Otto C. Dreschmeyer lived what appears to be a small, provincial kind of life.
Born in New York in 1896 to German immigrant parents, he attended P.S. 81 on Cypress Avenue near the Brooklyn-Queens border. His father served as president of the Cigar Makers Union, and the family resided at 20-14 Stanhope Street in today’s Ridgewood.
What little is known about Dreschmeyer comes mostly from a handful of newspaper articles. His name appeared in his father’s 1935 obituary, and he served as executor of his $9000 estate.
While working as a timekeeper a year later, Dreschmeyer was identified as the driver who plowed into a man on a Glendale street corner, killing him. (He was acquitted of criminal negligence in 1938).
And in 1958, when he served as a manager at Krug’s Baking Company in Jamaica, three robbers broke into his office, held him up, and made off with the $3000 collected by the day’s delivery drivers.
A blog post from the Brooklyn Public Library fills in some blanks about his personal life. Dreschmeyer never married, and after his parents passed away he remained on Stanhope Street possibly for the rest of his days, sharing his childhood home with his widowed sister.
On the surface, he seems to be an ordinary, unremarkable man. But in the mid-1960s, something compelled Dreschmeyer to pick up a camera—likely a Hasselblad, per the Brooklyn Public Library—and capture more than one hundred images of a fading Coney Island.
This isn’t the dynamic Coney Island of the early 20th century. By the 1960s, population shifts put this legendary seaside escape in decline.
Dreschmeyer’s photos show beachgoers strolling the boardwalk and swimming in the water. But this Coney is a less visited, almost dreary place with its golden days behind it.
“The closing of Steeplechase Amusement Park in 1965 was a symbolic moment that illustrated the fall into economic decline by both the amusement parks and the neighborhood,” states the Brooklyn Public Library.
“Under urban renewal plans, middle class family homes were demolished by the city while high-rise, low-income public housing buildings were being constructed,” continued the Library blog post.
“Coney Island of the 1960s and 1970s became known for its crime and poverty, partially due to the city’s neglect.”
You wouldn’t necessarily realize this decline by viewing Dreschmeyer’s photos. He focused on beachgoers in colorful swimsuits, and the Wonder Wheel and parachute under blue skies.
In some images, fireworks illuminate the night, amusement rides await customers, and a kaleidoscopic of colorful lights give the impression of motion and magic.
Dreschmeyer brought his camera with him to other parts of the city. He took photos of Brooklyn’s Memorial Day parade, a trip on the Staten Island ferry, boats at Sheepshead Bay, and movingly, a memorial to John F. Kennedy at Grand Army Plaza, unveiled in 1965.
None of Dreschmeyer’s photos, available to view via the Brooklyn Public Library’s Center for Brooklyn History website, are closeups. People in his images are either part of crowds or caught unaware. There’s no known self portraits, either.
This distance between himself and human subjects might be a clue to the kind of man he was—perhaps introverted and uncomfortable approaching others.
Dreschmeyer passed away in 1983, and he took his reasons for chronicling Coney Island by camera to the grave. Yet it’s hard not to wonder about him and what his motives were.
Coney Island may have been a happy place for him as a child in the 1900s, and now in his 70s he hoped to recapture those memories. Maybe taking pictures was his way of sharing joyful emotions in a communal environment, yet still shielded and set apart by a camera.
Decades after his death, he’s still obscure and enigmatic.
“Whether intentional or accidental, Dreschmeyer took quieter, everyday images of this neighborhood in transition that captures the Coney Island sightseers, new construction sites, the old rides and attractions, the boardwalk strollers, and the evening sunsets,” notes the Brooklyn Public Library.
[All photos: Center for Brooklyn History/Brooklyn Public Library]