0% found this document useful (0 votes)
229 views32 pages

Ruth vs. Esther: Biblical Comparisons

The document provides background information on the book of Esther in the Bible. It discusses themes like God's providence, contrasts between Esther and Ruth, the historical context during the Persian period, and debates around Esther's spiritual nature.

Uploaded by

Luis Melendez
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
0% found this document useful (0 votes)
229 views32 pages

Ruth vs. Esther: Biblical Comparisons

The document provides background information on the book of Esther in the Bible. It discusses themes like God's providence, contrasts between Esther and Ruth, the historical context during the Persian period, and debates around Esther's spiritual nature.

Uploaded by

Luis Melendez
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
  • Introduction to Esther
  • Comparison of Ruth and Esther
  • Historical Background
  • Title and Authorship
  • Canon and Date
  • Major Themes
  • Purpose of Esther
  • Book Structure
  • Nature of Esther

OT SURVEY, PT 24:

ESTHER
A COMPARISON OF THE BOOKS OF RUTH AND ESTHER

Ruth and Esther are the only two books in the Bible named for women.

The providence of God is an important theme in both books.


Ruth is read by Jews at the feast of Pentecost; Esther is read at the Feast of Purim.
Relatives play an important role in each book.
Death is essential to the plot of both stories.

There are many contrasts between the two women:


Ruth was a Gentile woman from a pagan country who married a Hebrew
Esther was a young Jewish girl who married a pagan Gentile King

Ruth was a widow; Esther an orphan


Ruth came to Israel; Esther was an exile from Israel
Ruth was a Gentile living among Jews; Esther a Jew living among Gentiles
Ruth was a proselyte; Esther influenced many proselytes
Ruth gleaned in a field; Esther ruled in a palace
Ruth was poor; Esther was rich
Ruth was the grandmother of a king; Esther married a king (and was related to King Saul)
Ruth gave life; Esther ordered death

Both were foreigners living in a land other than their own


Both found favor in the eyes of those who saw them
Both were taken into the homes of relatives

God redeemed Ruth to perpetuate the line of the Redeemer, the Lord Jesus Christ
God saved Esther to protect the nation through whom the Redeemer would be born
(From, Esther: A Story of the Providence of God in a Pagan Land, 17).
Historical Background

Esther occurred during the Persian period of world


history, ca. 539 B.C. to ca. 331 B.C.
Ahasuerus ruled from ca. 486 to 465 B.C.
Esther covers the 483473 B.C. portion of his reign
Ahasuerus represents the Hebrew transliteration of
his Persian name
Xerxes is his Greek name.
Historical Background

Artaxerxes

1043 110 Years 931 605


B.C. B.C. B.C.
Historical Background

Esther and Exodus parallels


God was faithful to His covenant to Abraham ca.
21002075 B.C. (Genesis 12:1-3)
As a result, Esther 9-10 records the beginning of
Purim
Still celebrated along with Hanukkah (John 10:22)
Title

Esther in Hebrew and Septuagint


Like Song of Solomon, Obadiah, and Nahum, the NT
does not quote or allude to Esther
Hadassah (2:7), meaning myrtle, Hebrew Name
Esther means star
But Mordecai is the main character and the main
plot is Mordecai vs. Haman
The summary of the book is all about Mordecai
Author

Unknown
Mordecai, Ezra, and Nehemiah have been suggested
Possibly a Persian Jew
Canonicity

All 167 verses of Esther have been recognized as


canonical
Lack of Gods mention cast doubt initially
Greek Septuagint (LXX) added an extra 107
apocryphal verses
Date of Events

From c. 483 BC (1:3) to c. 473 BC


Only Ezra 710, Nehemiah, and Malachi report later
OT history than Esther
5 major Persian kings
Cyrus-539-510,
Cambyses (not mentioned OT)
Darius 522-486,
Xerxes (in Ezra)/Ahasuerus (in Esther) 486-465
Artaxerxes464-424
Canonical Position

Between Lamentations and Daniel


Major Themes

The Providence of God.


In Esther, there is no Mention of Gods Name
MacArthur says, Esther is the classic illustration
of Gods providence as He, the unseen power,
controls everything for His purpose. There are no
miracles in Esther, but the preservation of Israel
through providential control of every event and
person reveals the omniscience and omnipotence of
Jehovah. Whether He is named is not the issue. He is
clearly the main character in the drama.
Major Themes

No mention of Israel, Jerusalem, Temple, Torah (the


life of Jews outside the land?)
Major Themes

Reversal of Human plans


Chapter 2, Esther is safe as QueenChapter 4, Esther is not
safe because shes a Jew
Chapter 6: Hamans means to get honored is how Mordecai
gets honored
Chapter 5: Haman is honored to come to a banquet, Chapter 7:
a Banquet is Hamans downfall
Chapter 3: A decree to kill the Jews, Chapter 8: A decree to kill
Jewish enemies
Chapter 2: Mordecai is no one, Chapter 8: Mordecai is honored
Chapter 9: When Jews were to be put to deathdestruction of
Jewish enemies
Major Themes

Haman begins the book as the empowered destroyer


of the Jews, but ends up as a powerless man killed by
the Jews.
Mordecai begins as a nameless victim of Hamans
attack, but ends up as an honored protector of Israel.
The day appointed for Jewish genocide ironically
ends up as the day of victory for the Jews and the
defeat of Israels enemies.
Esther begins as a selfish, unspiritual woman but
ends as a courageously selfless and spiritual Jew
Major Themes

The Jews
Haman represents Gentiles who hate and fear Jews
But Esther is just an outworking of Genesis 12:3:
And I will bless those who bless you and the one
who curses you I will curse.
Major Themes

Historical Conflict between Mordecai (a Benjamite


descendant of Saul) and Haman (an Agagite)
Began when the Jews exited from Egypt (ca. 1445
B.C.) and were attacked by the Amalekites
God pronounced His curse on the Amalekites (Ex.
17)
Saul (ca. 1030 B.C.) received orders to kill all the
Amalekites, including their king Agag but he
disobeyed (1 Sam 15)
Because of his lineage from Agag, Haman carried
deep hostility toward the Jews.
Major Themes

Explains why Mordecai refused to bow down to


Haman (3:2, 3) and why Haman so tried to
exterminate the Jewish race
But Gods prophecy to eliminate the Amalekites and
preserve the Jews prevailed
Major Themes

The Feast of Purim


Because of Gods faithfulness to save His people
named after the Akkadian word for lot
Celebrated by Jews since this day
Purpose

Purpose: While the physical seed of Abraham was


not faithful to Yahweh, they were still protected by
God from Gentile attack, an event commemorated by
the Feast of Purim.
The Nature of Esther

Five major positions on the spiritual and moral


state of Esther. These views include:
1. Esther was a spiritual woman,
2. Esther was an unspiritual woman,
3. Esther was both a spiritual and unspiritual
woman,
4. Esther started as an unspiritual woman but
became a spiritual woman,
5. Esthers moral state cannot be deciphered.
The Nature of Esther

Omission of Spirituality
Esthers Concealment of Jewishness (2:10,20) 2:10,
Esther did not make known her people or her
kindred, for Mordecai had instructed her that she
should not make them known.
The Nature of Esther

Winning the Favor and Love of the King (2:15-20)


Swindoll: no driving ambition to be queen. Her life
did not revolve around her physical appearance or
making a king happy. She was there for one reason:
because she knew that the hand of God was on her
life.
But Esther a part of the harem
She went into the king for a night
Esther becomes a part of the concubines after the
night
The Nature of Esther

Reluctance about Approaching the King


The news of the Genocide initially gets no reaction
from the Queen
She does not want to jeopardize her safety until
Mordecai says in 4:13: Do not imagine that you in
the kings palace can escape any more than all the
Jewsand who knows whether you have not attained
royalty for such a time as this?
The Nature of Esther

The turning point: if I perish, I perish (4:16)


4:16-17: Go assemble all the Jews who are found in
Susa and fast for me; do not eat or drink for three
days, night or day. I and my maidens also will fast in
the same way. And thus I will go in to the king,
which is not according to the law; and if I perish, I
perish.
The Nature of Esther

The Second Banquet (7:1-4)Esther finally reveals her Jewish


nature, identifies with her people, and identifies with their
fate
Esthers Vengeance upon Her enemies
Esther 9:1: Now in the twelfth month (that is, the month
Adar), on the thirteenth day when the kings command and
edict were about to be executed, on the day when the enemies
of the Jews hoped to gain the mastery over them, it was
turned to the contrary so that the Jews themselves gained the
mastery over those who hated them. Esther 9:16: Now the
rest of the Jews who were in the kings provinces assembled,
to defend their lives and rid themselves of their enemies, and
kill 75,000 of those who hated them; but they did not lay their
hands on the plunder.
Esther fulfills Gods original decree for the blotting out of all
the Amalekites
The Nature of Esther

Esthers Establishment of the Feast of Purim


(9:29-32)9:32: The command of Esther
established these customs for Purim, and it was
written in the book.
Esther was never intended to be held up as a paragon
of virtue
Esther is not a supreme example of virtue, but rather
a supreme example of redemption

OT SURVEY, PT 24:  
ESTHER
A COMPARISON OF THE BOOKS OF RUTH AND ESTHER 
 
Ruth and Esther are the only two books in the Bible named for women. 
  
Th
Historical Background 
Esther occurred during the Persian period of world 
history, ca. 539 B.C. to ca. 331 B.C.  
Ahasueru
Historical Background 
 
1043 
B.C. 
931  
B.C. 
110 Years 
605  
B.C. 
Artaxerxes
Historical Background 
Esther and Exodus parallels  
God was faithful to His covenant to Abraham ca. 
2100–2075 B.C. (Genes
Title  
“Esther” in Hebrew and Septuagint  
Like Song of Solomon, Obadiah, and Nahum, the NT 
does not quote or allude to E
Author  
Unknown  
Mordecai, Ezra, and Nehemiah have been suggested 
Possibly a Persian Jew
Canonicity  
All 167 verses of Esther have been recognized as 
canonical 
Lack of God’s mention cast doubt initially 
Gree
Date of Events  
From c. 483 BC (1:3) to c. 473 BC  
Only Ezra 7–10, Nehemiah, and Malachi report later 
OT history than Es

You might also like