10 Chapter 4
10 Chapter 4
j
RADHAKRISHNAN :
HIS PHILOSOPHICAL STANDPOINT
Radhakrishnan surveyed Indian Philosophy and placed Indian
philosophy on the philosophical map of the world. He has given a touch of
reorientation and reconstruction to the traditional Indian thought. He
clearly and comparatively expounds all the Indian Philosophical schools.
IV. 1. Epistemology :
159
between the self and the not-self involved in knowledge is an object of
internal perception.
160
Radhakrishnan develops intuition as the third source of knowledge.
Intuition is the direct realization of its object. It is the source of the insight
of reality. Intuition is absolutely immediate knowledge. Here the knower
i
and the known are one: to know reality is here to be reality. Radhakrishnan
says, It is not fancy or make believe but a bonafied discovery of reality. 4
According to Radhakrishnan spiritual apprehension or the kind of
awareness of real values which are neither objects in space and time nor
universals of thought is called intuition.5 Intuition is also called
samyakjnana. For him, intuition is the inner most realization of the soul. He
says, Intuition is the ultimate vision of the profoundest being 6 From this
it is clear that intuition is the ultimate criterion of truth. Radhakrishnan
conceives the Absolute as indeterminate, pure consciousness, freedom and
possibility. According to him the Absolute can be known only by intuitive
knowledge not by discursive logical knowledge . He says, Intuition is self
established ( Svafhsiddha), self evidencing ( Svatahsamvedya), self
luminous (svayamprakash) , 7 It has the character of revelation. It is
spontaneous and immediate. It comes to us a vision. It is above reason.
According to Radhakrishnan, intuitive knowledge is the highest knowledge.
The innermost realization of the soul can be possible by perfect living,
leading a moral life. To realize reality one must be himself fully real.
Radhakrishnan says, Intuition is not only perfect knowledge, but also
perfect living. The consecration of the self and the knowledge of the reality
grow together. The fully real can be known only by one who himself fully
real. 8 In the epistemology of Radhakrishnan intellect has been
subordinated to intuition. Intellect is preserved here as a function of
intuition. Intuition is not antagonistic to intellect. The two are not only
incompatible but vitally united.9 Radhakrishnan regarded intuition as the
integral whole. In the integral whole all the aspects of mind properly
161
cultivated will develop and will also be merged. Intellect, emotion and will
are the fragmentary manifestation of the spiritual energy of man. Intuition
makes man one with the spirit. Intuition is the basis of every great religion.
Religious life consists in the culture of intuition through the harmonious
perfection of emotion, intellect and will. According to Radhakrishnan,
intuition is the root of all creative works. The root of all creative work is
not due to mechanical activity of reason. By this Radhakrishnan
emphasizes spirituality as the true basis of all our activities in life.
Radhakrishnan says, creative work is not blind imitation or mechanical
repitition. It is synthetic insight, which advances by leaps, A new truth
*
162
knowledge is valid in itself, and is not validated by any other knowledge.
According to Radhakrishnan validity is a property of knowledge. The self
evident character of knowledge merely restates the character of
apprehension and it is of its nature valid. All knowledge bears immediate
witness to its own validity. The reality of a thing depends on the thing
itself, not on human notions. According to Radhakrishnan the invalidity of
a conception is never inherent. For him the invalidity of conception is due
to extraneous means. Cognitions are externally invalidated either by the
discovery through other means of the real character of the object, or by the
discovery of the defects in the instruments of cognition. Every cognition
*
163
To emphasize the self evident character of knowledge,
Radhakrishnan says that all knowledge bears immediate witness to its own
validity. For him the self evident character is hidden by our psychological
prejudices. According to Radhakrishnan, true knowledge is that which is
not contradicted to other knowledge. Knowledge which is not
contradicted is truth. 14 For Radhakrishnan, insight into reality is the
highest knowledge since there is no other knowledge that can contradict it.
Hence the knower and the known are ultimately one real. It is the
immediate witness of reality to itself. In the empirical level this knowledge
is obscured by avidya, according to Radhakrishnan. Logical proofs enable
us to break down the obstructing veils. It helps us to reveal the self evident
character of truth. Logical rules are working tools . They serve as negative
checks by which we break down our prejudices.
VI.2. Metaphysics :
164
A c c o r d in g to R a d h a k r is h n a n , m e ta p h y s ic s c o n s tru c t a th e o ry o f
R e a lity . I t h a s lo g ic a l c o n s is te n c y a n d e m p iric a l a d e q u a c y . R a d h a k r is h n a n
B ra d le y . B r a d le y s a y s th a t w h a t m a y b e , i f it m u s t b e , it is . T h e
m e ta p h y s ic a l v ie w o f R a d h a k r is h n a n is m o n is tic . F o r h im r e a lity is o n e .
T h e A b s o lu te is th e o n ly re a lity . T h e m e ta p h y s ic s o f R a d h a k r is h n a n
c o n ta in s in it th e e le m e n ts o f b o th th e A d v a ita V e d a n ta a n d th e H e g e lia n
,m e t a p h y s i c s o f R a d h a k r is h n a n . R a d h a k r is h n a n c o n c e iv e s s p ir it a s life . H e
s a y s , S p ir it is th e life , n o t th in g , e n e rg y , n o t im m o b ility , s o m e th in g re a l in
*
o b je c tiv e . 19 T h e s e lf, G o d , a n d A b s o lu te a re a ll n a m e s o f th e u n iv e rs a l
s p irit in h u m a n c e n tr e , th r o u g h th e b o d y a n d m in d o f m a n . G o d is th e s p irit
c o n c e iv e d a s th e r e a lity m a n if e s te d in th e w o rld a t la rg e . A b s o lu te is th e
o n e a c tu a l m a n ife s ta tio n . E v e r y th in g o f th e u n iv e r s e is th e e x p r e s s io n o f th e
A b s o lu te . H e s a y s th a t th e U ltim a te R e a lity s le e p s in th e s to n e , b re a th e s in
p la n ts , fe e ls in th e a n im a ls a n d a w a k e s to s e lf c o n c io u s n e s s in m a n .
F o r R a d h a k r is h n a n th e A b s o lu te is P u re c o n s c io u s n e s s , P u re
r e a lity , c o n s c io u s n e s s a n d f re e d o m - S a t, c it a n d a n a n d a . H e v ie w e d
th a t th e re a re f o u r p o is e s o f R e a lity ; th e A b s o lu te B ra h m a n , th e c re a tiv e
S v a ru p a . T h e s e a r e th e f o u r s id e s o f o n e w h o le .
T h e R e a lity is a p p r e h e n d e d in tw o w a y s - p e r s o n a l a n d im p e rs o n a l.
G o d is p e r s o n a l w h ile A b s o lu te is im p e rs o n a l. G o d is p e r c e iv e d re a lity
p r e s e n t in e a c h m a n . H e is th e g u id e a n d s a v io u r o f m a n k in d . G o d is
1 6 5
immanent in the world and He is transcendent to it. According to
Radhakrishnan, God is truth, love and justice. God is the perfect and the
highest moral being free from all evils. God helps us to resist the force of
evil and error and uplift human life by discarding sin and malicious
feelings. God pours fourth. Radhakrishnan writes, the whole wealth of
his love to actualize his intensions for us. He takes us the burden of
helping us to resist the forces of evil, error and ugliness and transmute
them into truth, beauty and goodness. 21 He says. God loves us, creates
us and rules us. Creation, redemption and judgment are different names for
the fact of God. God satisfies the religious sentiments of man.
166
from the past and moves into the future. It is not a never ending repition of
a limited number of situation. Radhakrishnan says, The present adds
significance to the character of the past and may pave the way for the
realization of unexpected possibilities of the future. 27
167
world process. The very effort of man is to know the secrets of nature. Man
is also capable of participating in the longer spirit. Mans participation in
the longer spirit is to be discovered in the whole process with its ordered
, and progressive character. This reminds us Samkara. Samkara tells us that
there is a fundamental principle behind and beyond the world process. He
inspires and informs the world process. He is manifesting new values.
168
the apex of the soul, which is divine and creative. Kant distinguishes the
synthetic principle from the merely empirical self. All their views refer to
the self as subject. The empirical self is finite, limited. According to
Radhakrishnan when the empirical self realizes himself as limited then he
has direct consciousness of something unlimited. Radhakrishnan says, the
consciousness of limit involves the action of the greater unlimited self in
us. 36 He says, ..... empirical self is the expression or focusing of
something beyond itself. Similar line of thought is found in Professor
IS . Haldane. He writes, Personality is not something confined and
completed in itself separately from an environment in space and time, but
extended over that environment. 38 Radharkishnan explains that the
empirical self belongs to the human world. It interacts with individuals. He
shares knowledge of one another. He has a social relation with one another.
There is an integral relationship between the organism and its environment
in the empirical self. Radhakrishnan says, Human individuals are not
unchanging substrata of change with accidental qualities and are related to
one another externally, but are elements in an interrelated system. 39
According to him human being is not absolutely individual. His world is
equally real with himself. His interaction with the world influence the
growth of his individuality. Radhakrishnan describes that the individual and
the world co-exist and subsist together.
169
Radhakrishnan, the thought of the self, the will of the self are themselves
the expression of a deeper whole which includes the self and its object.
170
loves and hates, with its wars and battles, with its jealousies and
competitions as well as its masked helpfulness, sustained intellectual effort,
intense moral struggle seems to be no more than an unsubstantive dreams, a
phantasmagoria dancing on the fabric of pure being. 43 Vivekananda adopts
a similar line of thought when he says, when the Hindu says the world is
Maya, at once people get the idea that the world is an illusion. This
interpretation has some basis - But the maya of the Vedanta, in its last
developed form, is neither Idealism nor realism, nor is it a theory. It is a
simple statement of facts - what we are and what we see around us. 44
Radhakrishnan finds out many difficulties of logical positivists
denial of metaphysics.45 He shows that metaphysical theory can be verified
indirectly. It can be verified by its adequacy to account for the observed
fact. Speculative metaphysics is a tenable enquiry with a field of its own.46
need in man for adoration. The Religious man submits his will to the
transcendent. By his submission his soul becomes both acting and acted.
His activities have religious significance. His whole activities is directed
towards an end. The end is the union of all human beings. According to
171
Radhakrishnan metaphysics is not the enemy of faith. It alone can restore to
man the spiritual wholeness. Radhakrishnan says, No culture can last
unless it supports this effort and encourage the confidence that man is
capable of insight into the nature of the process in which he participates.49
VI.3. Ethics
Radhakrishnan revives the ethical principles and moral values in the
present context and he reestablished the foundation of enduring human
civilization. He pointed out that ethical principles are the rules for the
guidance of human conduct. Radhakrishnan says that there is a necessity of
deep synthetic unity for giving man proper meaning of life. This unity can
be attained by the realization of the moral and spiritual values.
Radhakrishnan states that moral life is the precondition for the attainment
of the spiritual goal. He says, moral life is essential condition for the
pursuit of wisdom. 50 Ethics disciplines human nature and leads him
towards perfection. Radhakrishnan lays emphasis on ethical values. Ethical
values enrich mans life. For him, human beings strives for truth, beauty
and goodness as human mind is value seeking. He interprets the ethical
discipline which are the means to attain the spiritual goal.
172
of Rta. It is antecedent to all objects. Rta in the cosmos corresponds to that
of Karma in human life. The theory of Rta is applied to moral system. Then
the Rta is regarded as the law of Karma. The world follows the course of
Rta. Hence Radhakrishnan says that whole universe depends on Rta and
moves with it. He also says It is law which pervades the whole world,
which all gods and men must obey. 51 According to Radhakrishnan, human
growth is an ordered one and its orderedness is governed by the law of
Karma. What ever you sow that you will also reap . 52 All acts produce
their effects and their moral effects are worked into the character of the
self. Good produces good, evil produces evil. The law of karma says that
is
each individual will get the return according to the energy he puts forth.
Brhadaranyaka Upanishad also states that As is his desires, such is his
purpose, such is the action he performs, what action he performs that he
4*-5
173
is possible for man to do that. Because man is not a mere animal. Man has
the power and freedom to take decisions, this power to make a choice
makes him a man and distinguishes him from the animal and lends
sacredness to human life. 57 Morality is inherent in all beings.
Radhakrishnans concept of freedom is spiritual. It distinguishes man from
lower animals. It is the test of higher beings. Man has an aspiration for
freedom or mukti as he is a spiritual being. He has an ever longing for the
attainment of the state of liberation which transcends morality, suffering
and attachment to worldly objects. Radhakrishnan says that mans
existence includes the power, the determination to stand out of existence
*
and the truth of beingrffuman life is based on certain idealSvHPhe ideals are
invariably the ideals of Truth,^Goodness and Beauty.-Radhakrishnans
concept of freedom is depicted in his line of thought, when he says, the
very effort of man to know the secrets of nature, to sit in judgment on it,
indicates his participation in the creative process. 58 Here the view of
Vivekananda is worth mentioning. Vivekananda also holds that the goal of
human being is to reach freedom. He says, one conscious fact present in
the midst of all our joys and sorrows, difficulties and struggles is that we
are surely journeying towards freedom. 59 Vivekanandas replies of some
metaphysical question is also relevant here. The metaphysical questions are
- what is this universe? From what does it arise? Into what does it go?
Vevekananda replied, In freedom it rises, in freedom it rests and into
freedom it melts away. 60
174
redemption, but universl redemption - Sarvamukti as Radhakrishnans calls
it.
[Link] :
175
gives a purpose to life. Religion speaks to the profound realities of our
nature and satisfy the whole of our being.
176
Upanishads and it is the root concept of humanism also. But the speciality
of Radhakrishnan is that he conceives the spirit as life.68 In explaining
intution Radhakrishnan supports the different views propounded by the
Western thinkers like Plato, Descartes, Spinoza, Bradley, Bergson and
ancient Indian thinker like Samkara. But Radhakrishnan adds something
more by conceiving that intution is not antagonistic to the intellect. The
brief schetch of Radhakrishnan ethical standpoint would be sufficient to
show how ethics plays significant role in human life to attain spiritual
freedom. With an ardent appreciation of eternal values, Radhakrishnan
considers that the Hindu ideal is sufficiently ethical and it requires us to
is
integrate oureslves, to maintain a constant fight with the passions which
impede the growth of soul.
177
\
References:
1. C.E.M. load, Counter attacks from the East, Page,38 .
2. S. Radhakrishnan, the Principal Upanishads, Page-96.
3. S. Radhakrishnan, An Idealist View of Life, Page-134.
4. [Link], An Idealist view of Life, page -143.
5. S. Radhakrishnan and J.H. Muirhead Eds. Contemporary Indian
Philosophy, Page-485.
6. [Link], An Idealist view of Life, page-114.
7. [Link], An Idealist View of Life, page 93
8. [Link] and J.H. Muirhead, Eds. Contemporary Indian
p,
Philosophy page-487.
9. D.M. Datta, The Chief currents of Contemporary Philosophy, page-146.
10. S. RadhaKrihsnan, An Idealist View of Life, Page-175.
11. Slokavartika .... ii, 53.
12. S. Radhakrishnan, Indian Philosophy, [Link]-500.
13. S. Radhakrishnan, Indian Philosophy, [Link], Page-500.
14. S. Radhakrishnan, Indian Philosophy, [Link] page-501.
15. D.M. Datta, the Chief Currents of Contemporary Philosophy, Page-
136.
16.5. Radhakrishnan, Religion and Culture, Page-90.
17. S. Radhakrishnan, Religion and Culture, Page-96.
18. S. Radhakrishnan, Religion and Culture, Page-95
19. Contemporary Indian Philosophy, his personal statement,. P.P.492,
(2ndEd.)
20. [Link], An Idealist view of Life, Page-11.
21. S. Radhakrishnan, An Idealist View of Life, Page-335.
22.5. Radhakrishnan, An Idealist View of Life, Page-268.
1 7 8
23. D.M. Datta, the Chief Currents of Contemporary Philosophy, page-
142-143.
24. S. Radhakrishnan, Brahma Sutra, Page-103.
25. [Link], Recovery of Faith page-84.
26. [Link], Religion and Culture page-95.
27. S. Radhakrishnan, Religion and Culture, Page 96.
28. S. Radkharishnan, An Idealist View of Life, page-313.
29. [Link], An Idealist View of Life, Page-313.
30. [Link] Autobiography, in PSRpage-30.
31. [Link], The Brahmp Sutra, The Philosophy of spiritual
life, page-103.
32. [Link], Riligion and Culture, Page-97
33. S. Radhakrishnan, Indian Philosophy. [Link]-595.
34. Brh. Up. 1.4.7; 1.5.15; 2.4,6.7, Chand Up.[Link].
35. [Link], An Idealist View of Life, pageO-215.
36. [Link], An Idealist View of Life, Page-215.
37. [Link], An Idealist View of Life, Page-216
38. The science and Philosophy, 1929, page-30.
39. [Link] An Idealist View of Life, 216.
40. S. Radhakrishnan, An Idealist View of Life, page-217.
41. S. Radhakrishnan, the Principal Upanisads, Page-734.
42. S. Radhakrishnan, the Bhagavad Gita, Page-13.
43. [Link], the Principal Upanisads -page-78.
44. C. W. S. [Link], Page-89. (45. Radhakrishnan, Religion and Cultures -
page-93
45. [Link], Religion and Cultures -page-93.
46. [Link], Religion and Culture, Page-95.
179
47. S. Radhakrishnan, Religion and culture, page-98.
48. S. Radhakrishnan, Religion and Culture, Page-101.
49. S. Radhakrishnan, religion and Cultures - Page-108.
50. S. Radhakrishnan, Brahma sutra, Page- 155.
51. S. Radhakrishnan, Indian Philosophy, Vo.I Page-109.
52. [Link], our Heritage, Page-40.
53. Brhad Upanishad, IV.4.5.
54. [Link], the Bhagavadgita, Page-69.
55. [Link], A n Idealist View o f Life, Page-287.
56. [Link], True Knowledge, Page-42.
57. S. Radhakrishnan, Religion and Society page-55.
58. S. Radhakrishnan, occasional Speeches and Writings, 1952-1959,
page-391.
59. C.W.S. VoLH, Page-125.
60. C.W.S. [Link],page,125.
61. R.A. Medermott. Ed. Basic writings o f Sarvepalli Radhakrishnan,
page,191).
180