Scribd
Upload
559 views1 page

Villonez Convicted of Murder in Group Attack

Villonez et al were convicted of murdering Gerardo Longasa. Edgar Jimenez witnessed seven armed men, including Villonez, attack Longasa. Two men held Longasa's arms while others hit him with weapons and stabbed him multiple times, causing his death. The court rejected the alibi defense and found Villonez et al guilty of conspiracy and murder through treachery, as Longasa was overwhelmed and unable to defend himself against the attack.

Uploaded by

SophiaFrancescaEspinosa
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
559 views1 page

Villonez Convicted of Murder in Group Attack

Villonez et al were convicted of murdering Gerardo Longasa. Edgar Jimenez witnessed seven armed men, including Villonez, attack Longasa. Two men held Longasa's arms while others hit him with weapons and stabbed him multiple times, causing his death. The court rejected the alibi defense and found Villonez et al guilty of conspiracy and murder through treachery, as Longasa was overwhelmed and unable to defend himself against the attack.

Uploaded by

SophiaFrancescaEspinosa
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
  • Ruling: Discusses the legal ruling and reasoning applied by the court in this case.
  • Case Summary: Provides a brief overview of the case involving Villonez et al, outlining the facts and circumstances.
  • Facts: Details the facts of the case including events, timelines, and involved parties.

Villonez et al were convicted of murder.

Facts:

Edgar Jimenez 9:00 p.m., while he was resting inside his store, a certain Tonton informed him that his
close friend GERARDO LONGASA had a fistfight with one Rudy. Edgar proceeded to the area to mediate,
since LONGASA and Rudy were both his friends. At the street, a group of seven armed men, including
Villonez, attacked Edgar. RUEL hit Edgar on his forehead and back with a bottle. Edgar was able to escape
from his attackers. While fleeing, he ran past LONGASA, who seemed drunk. When Edgar called LONGASA,
the attackers were already upon LONGASA.

While he was about eight arms length away from LONGASA, Edgar saw EMERLITO hit LONGASA with a 2
x 2 inches piece of wood. Simultaneously, REGANDO and RUEL struck LONGASA with bottles. Rudy Santos
and Eddie Santos then stabbed LONGASA seven and eight times, respectively, even as two other persons
named Rey and Budda held LONGASAs arms. LONGASA fell to the ground. Edgar saw all these because
the scene of the incident was illuminated by a big fluorescent lamp located about three arms length
away. Edgar rushed to LONGASAs house and reported the incident to the latters parents.

Ruling:

The bromidic defense of alibi cannot benefit accused-appellants. In the face of the positive identification
of the accused by Edgar, such defense is worth nothing. Besides, accused-appellants were unable to prove
that it was physically impossible for them to be at the crime scene at the time the crime was committed.

There was conspiracy because the accused simultaneously attacked LONGASA, with two of them holding
the victims hands or arms. Some struck LONGASA with a piece of wood or bottles and two others stabbed
him. The attack continued until LONGASA fell dead. These acts clearly point to a joint purpose to
accomplish the desired end.

Treachery may still be appreciated even when the victim was forewarned of danger to his person. What
is decisive is that the execution of the attack made it impossible for the victim to defend himself or to
retaliate. The overwhelming number of the accused, their use of weapons against the unarmed victim,
and the fact that the victims hands were held behind him preclude the possibility of any defense by the
victim.

The other qualifying circumstance of abuse of superior strength, which the trial court appreciated, will no
longer be taken against accused-appellants, for it is absorbed in treachery.

Villonez et al were convicted of murder. Facts: Edgar Jimenez 9:00 p.m., while he was resting inside his store, a certain

You might also like