COMPUTER PROGRAM

GROUP
Version 2016

A Program for the Analysis

of a Group of Piles Subjected to
Vertical and Lateral Loading
(Examples Manual)
by

Lymon C. Reese
Shin Tower Wang
Jose A. Arrellaga
Joe Hendrix
Luis Vasquez

for

ENSOFT, INC
3003 W. Howard Lane
Austin, Texas 78728

May - 2016

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 ii

PROGRAM LICENSE AGREEMENT

IMPORTANT NOTICE: Please read the terms of the

following license agreement carefully. You signify acceptance
of the terms of this Agreement by using the product.

This software is licensed only to the user (company or

individual) whose name is registered with ENSOFT, INC., or to
users at the registered location, on only one computer at a time.
Additional installations of the software may be made by the
user, as long as the number of installations is equal to the
number of purchased and registered licenses.

Users that purchased a network version of this software product

are entitled to install the software on all computers in the
network at their registered location. However, the software can
only be used simultaneously by as many users as the total
number of purchased and registered licenses.

The user is not entitled to copy this software unless copying for
backup purposes. The user may not loan, rent, lease, or transfer
this software to any other person, company, or location. This
software and documentation are copyrighted materials and
should be treated like any other copyrighted material (e.g. a
book or musical recording). This software is protected by
United States copyright law and the International Copyright
Treaty.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 iii

Copyright ® 1987, 1994, 1996, 2000, 2003, 2006, 2010, 2012,

2013, 2014, 2015, 2016 by ENSOFT, INC. All rights reserved.

Printed in the Unites States of America. Except as permitted

under the United States Copyright Act of 1976, no part of this
publication may be reproduced, translated, or distributed
without the prior written approval of ENSOFT, INC.

Although the program has been used with apparent success in

many analyses, new information is developed continuously and
new or updated versions may be written from time to time. All
users are requested to inform ENSOFT, INC. immediately of
any possible errors that are found in the coding. As errors are
detected, revised versions will be available for all who have
purchased the program on the ENSOFT, INC website as a
download.

No warranty, expressed or implied, is offered on the accuracy

of the results from the program. The user relies on the program
at his or her own risk. The program should not be used for
design unless caution is exercised in interpreting the results and
independent calculations are available to verify the general
correctness of the results. The user is assumed to be
knowledgeable of the information that is distributed with the
digital media. The user is assumed to recognize that the input
parameters, eg., soil properties, increment length, tolerance on
solution convergence, and many others, can have a significant
effect on the solution and must be chosen carefully. The user
should have a thorough understanding of the relevant
theoretical criteria (appropriate references are suggested in the
software documentation). The information presented herein is
not intended or represented to be suitable for direct use in
engineering design without additional engineering evaluation.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 iv

FOREWORD

Analyzing a group of piles that support a cap or a structure in a system

subjected to axial and lateral loading is an important problem in soil-structure
interaction. The piles may be of different sizes and may be installed vertically or
on a batter. The piles are assumed to be far enough apart so that there is no
significant pile-soil-pile interaction or, if the piles are spaced closely together, such
interaction is reflected by an appropriate modification of soil resistance curves.

Computer program GROUP allows the user to analyze the behavior of pile
groups using either a 2-dimensional model or a 3-dimensional model.

The procedures for analyzing a single pile subjected to lateral loading are
included in GROUP and the user should be familiar with that technology. A
complete discussion of the method of analysis of a single pile under lateral loading
is given in the documentation for LPILE, another program distributed by ENSOFT,
Inc.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 v

Table of Contents

Table of Contents .......................................................................................................................................... v

List of Figures ................................................................................................................................................ x
List of Tables ...............................................................................................................................................xiii
CHAPTER 1. Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses .............................................. 1-1
1.1 Introduction ............................................................................................................................... 1-2
1.2 Example Problem 1 - 2D ............................................................................................................. 1-4
1.2.1 Model Description.............................................................................................................. 1-4
1.2.2 Input Data .......................................................................................................................... 1-6
1.2.3 Echo Print File .................................................................................................................... 1-9
1.2.4 Processor Run Notes ........................................................................................................ 1-14
1.2.5 Output Results File ........................................................................................................... 1-16
1.2.6 Summary Results File ....................................................................................................... 1-20
1.2.7 Graphs .............................................................................................................................. 1-24
1.3 Example Problem 2 - 2D ........................................................................................................... 1-26
1.3.1 Model Description............................................................................................................ 1-26
1.3.2 Input Data ........................................................................................................................ 1-29
1.3.3 Echo Print File .................................................................................................................. 1-31
1.3.4 Processor Run Notes ........................................................................................................ 1-38
1.3.5 Output Results File ........................................................................................................... 1-40
1.3.6 Summary Results File ....................................................................................................... 1-46
1.3.7 Graphs .............................................................................................................................. 1-50
1.4 Example Problem 3 - 2D ........................................................................................................... 1-53
1.4.1 Model Description............................................................................................................ 1-53
1.4.2 Input Data ........................................................................................................................ 1-54
1.4.3 Echo Print File .................................................................................................................. 1-56
1.4.4 Processor Run Notes ........................................................................................................ 1-61
1.4.5 Output Results File ........................................................................................................... 1-63

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 vi

1.4.6 Summary Results File ....................................................................................................... 1-69

1.4.7 Graphs .............................................................................................................................. 1-73
1.5 Example Problem 4 - 2D ........................................................................................................... 1-75
1.5.1 Model Description............................................................................................................ 1-75
1.5.2 Input Data ........................................................................................................................ 1-78
1.5.3 Echo Print File .................................................................................................................. 1-80
1.5.4 Processor Run Notes ........................................................................................................ 1-86
1.5.5 Output Results File ........................................................................................................... 1-88
1.5.6 Summary Results File ....................................................................................................... 1-92
1.5.7 Graphs .............................................................................................................................. 1-96
1.6 Example Problem 5 - 2D ......................................................................................................... 1-100
1.6.1 Model Description.......................................................................................................... 1-100
1.6.2 Input Data ...................................................................................................................... 1-102
1.6.3 Echo Print File ................................................................................................................ 1-104
1.6.4 Processor Run Notes ...................................................................................................... 1-108
1.6.5 Output Results File ......................................................................................................... 1-110
1.6.6 Summary Results File ..................................................................................................... 1-117
1.6.7 Graphs ............................................................................................................................ 1-121
1.7 Example Problem 6 - 2D ......................................................................................................... 1-123
1.7.1 Model Description.......................................................................................................... 1-123
1.7.2 Input Data ...................................................................................................................... 1-124
1.7.3 Echo Print File ................................................................................................................ 1-126
1.7.4 Processor Run Notes ...................................................................................................... 1-131
1.7.5 Output Results File ......................................................................................................... 1-133
1.7.6 Summary Results File ..................................................................................................... 1-137
1.7.7 Graphs ............................................................................................................................ 1-141
1.8 Example Problem 7 - 2D ......................................................................................................... 1-143
1.8.1 Model Description.......................................................................................................... 1-143
1.8.2 Input Data ...................................................................................................................... 1-145
1.8.3 Echo Print File ................................................................................................................ 1-147
1.8.4 Processor Run Notes ...................................................................................................... 1-153
1.8.5 Output Results File ......................................................................................................... 1-164

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 vii

1.8.6 Summary Results File ..................................................................................................... 1-171

1.8.7 Graphs ............................................................................................................................ 1-176
1.9 Example Problem 8 - 2D ......................................................................................................... 1-183
1.9.1 Model Description.......................................................................................................... 1-183
1.9.2 Input Data ...................................................................................................................... 1-185
1.9.3 Echo Print File ................................................................................................................ 1-187
1.9.4 Processor Run Notes ...................................................................................................... 1-194
1.9.5 Output Results File ......................................................................................................... 1-203
1.9.6 Summary Results File ..................................................................................................... 1-212
1.9.7 Graphs ............................................................................................................................ 1-218
CHAPTER 2. Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses ........................................... 2-1
2.1 Introduction ............................................................................................................................... 2-2
2.2 Example Problem 1 - 3D ............................................................................................................. 2-4
2.2.1 Model Description.............................................................................................................. 2-4
2.2.2 Input Data .......................................................................................................................... 2-7
2.2.3 Echo Print File .................................................................................................................. 2-10
2.2.4 Processor Run Notes ........................................................................................................ 2-18
2.2.5 Output Results File ........................................................................................................... 2-20
2.2.6 Summary Results File ....................................................................................................... 2-29
2.2.7 Graphs .............................................................................................................................. 2-34
2.3 Example Problem 2 - 3D ........................................................................................................... 2-36
2.3.1 Model Description............................................................................................................ 2-36
2.3.2 Input Data ........................................................................................................................ 2-38
2.3.3 Echo Print File .................................................................................................................. 2-40
2.3.4 Processor Run Notes ........................................................................................................ 2-46
2.3.5 Output Results File ........................................................................................................... 2-48
2.3.6 Summary Results File ....................................................................................................... 2-55
2.3.7 Graphs .............................................................................................................................. 2-59
2.4 Example Problem 3 - 3D ........................................................................................................... 2-61
2.4.1 Model Description............................................................................................................ 2-61
2.4.2 Input Data ........................................................................................................................ 2-62
2.4.3 Echo Print File .................................................................................................................. 2-64

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 viii

2.4.4 Processor Run Notes ........................................................................................................ 2-69

2.4.5 Output Results File ........................................................................................................... 2-71
2.4.6 Summary Results File ....................................................................................................... 2-77
2.4.7 Graphs .............................................................................................................................. 2-81
2.5 Example Problem 4 - 3D ........................................................................................................... 2-83
2.5.1 Model Description............................................................................................................ 2-83
2.5.2 Input Data ........................................................................................................................ 2-85
2.5.3 Echo Print File .................................................................................................................. 2-87
2.5.4 Processor Run Notes ........................................................................................................ 2-93
2.5.5 Output Results File ........................................................................................................... 2-94
2.5.6 Summary Results File ..................................................................................................... 2-109
2.5.7 Graphs ............................................................................................................................ 2-114
2.6 Example Problem 5 - 3D ......................................................................................................... 2-116
2.6.1 Model Description.......................................................................................................... 2-116
2.6.2 Input Data ...................................................................................................................... 2-118
2.6.3 Echo Print File ................................................................................................................ 2-120
2.6.4 Processor Run Notes ...................................................................................................... 2-125
2.6.5 Output Results File ......................................................................................................... 2-127
2.6.6 Summary Results File ..................................................................................................... 2-136
2.6.7 Graphs ............................................................................................................................ 2-141
2.7 Example Problem 6 - 3D ......................................................................................................... 2-143
2.7.1 Model Description.......................................................................................................... 2-143
2.7.2 Input Data ...................................................................................................................... 2-145
2.7.3 Echo Print File ................................................................................................................ 2-147
2.7.4 Processor Run Notes ...................................................................................................... 2-152
2.7.5 Output Results File ......................................................................................................... 2-154
2.7.6 Summary Results File ..................................................................................................... 2-167
2.7.7 Graphs ............................................................................................................................ 2-172
CHAPTER 3. Example Problems Based on Moment Curvature Calculations ..................................... 3-1
3.1 Introduction ............................................................................................................................... 3-2
3.2 Example Problem 1 - MC............................................................................................................ 3-3
3.2.1 Model Description.............................................................................................................. 3-3

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 ix

3.2.2 Graphs ................................................................................................................................ 3-4

3.3 Example Problem 2 - MC............................................................................................................ 3-6
3.3.1 Model Description.............................................................................................................. 3-6
3.3.2 Graphs ................................................................................................................................ 3-7
3.4 Example Problem 3 - MC............................................................................................................ 3-9
3.4.1 Model Description.............................................................................................................. 3-9
3.4.2 Graphs .............................................................................................................................. 3-10
3.5 Example Problem 4 - MC.......................................................................................................... 3-12
3.5.1 Model Description............................................................................................................ 3-12
3.5.2 Graphs .............................................................................................................................. 3-13
3.6 Example Problem 5 - MC.......................................................................................................... 3-15
3.6.1 Model Description............................................................................................................ 3-15
3.6.2 Graphs .............................................................................................................................. 3-16
CHAPTER 4. Example Models for Troubleshooting ............................................................................ 4-1
4.1 Introduction ............................................................................................................................... 4-2
4.2 Example Model 1 - TB ................................................................................................................ 4-3
4.2.1 Model Description.............................................................................................................. 4-3
4.2.2 Discussion........................................................................................................................... 4-4
4.3 Example Model 2 - TB ................................................................................................................ 4-7
4.3.1 Model Description.............................................................................................................. 4-7
4.3.2 Discussion........................................................................................................................... 4-8
4.4 Example Model 3 - TB .............................................................................................................. 4-12
4.4.1 Model Description............................................................................................................ 4-12
4.4.2 Discussion......................................................................................................................... 4-13
4.5 Example Model 4 - TB .............................................................................................................. 4-20
4.5.1 Model Description............................................................................................................ 4-20
4.5.2 Discussion......................................................................................................................... 4-21
CHAPTER 5. Example Models for Excel Import/Export ...................................................................... 5-1
5.1 Introduction ............................................................................................................................... 5-2

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 x

List of Figures

Figure 1.1 General Description of Example Problem 1 - 2D. .......................................................... 1-5

Figure 1.2 Curves Deflection vs. Distance for Example Problem 1 - 2D........................................ 1-24
Figure 1.3 Curves Moment vs. Distance for Example Problem 1 - 2D. ......................................... 1-25
Figure 1.4 General Description of Example Problem 2 - 2D. ........................................................ 1-27
Figure 1.5 Section of prestressed concrete pile............................................................................ 1-28
Figure 1.6 Axial load versus pile-top displacements ..................................................................... 1-28
Figure 1.7 Curves Deflection vs. Distance for Example Problem 2 - 2D........................................ 1-50
Figure 1.8 Curves Moment vs. Distance for Example Problem 2 - 2D. ......................................... 1-51
Figure 1.9 Internally Generated p-y Curves for Example Problem 2 - 2D..................................... 1-52
Figure 1.10 Curves Deflection vs. Distance for Example Problem 3 - 2D....................................... 1-73
Figure 1.11 Curves Moment vs. Distance for Example Problem 3 - 2D. ......................................... 1-74
Figure 1.12 General Description of Example Problem 4 - 2D. ........................................................ 1-76
Figure 1.13 Axial load versus pile-top displacements ..................................................................... 1-77
Figure 1.14 Pile Loading (in Kips) .................................................................................................... 1-77
Figure 1.15 Curves Deflection vs. Distance for Example Problem 4 - 2D........................................ 1-96
Figure 1.16 Curves Moment vs. Distance for Example Problem 4 - 2D. ......................................... 1-97
Figure 1.17 Curves Shear vs. Distance for Example Problem 4 - 2D. .............................................. 1-98
Figure 1.18 Internally Generated p-y Curves for Example Problem 4 - 2D..................................... 1-99
Figure 1.19 General Description of Example Problem 5 - 2D. ...................................................... 1-101
Figure 1.20 Curves Deflection vs. Distance for Example Problem 5 - 2D...................................... 1-121
Figure 1.21 Curves Moment vs. Distance for Example Problem 5 - 2D. ....................................... 1-122
Figure 1.22 General Description of Example Problem 6 - 2D. ...................................................... 1-123
Figure 1.23 Curves Deflection vs. Distance for Example Problem 6 - 2D...................................... 1-141
Figure 1.24 Internally Generated curves of Axial Load vs. Displacement for Example Problem 6 -
2D. .............................................................................................................................. 1-142
Figure 1.25 General Description of Example Problem 7 - 2D. ...................................................... 1-144
Figure 1.26 Curves Deflection vs. Distance for Example Problem 7 - 2D...................................... 1-176
Figure 1.27 Curves Moment vs. Distance for Example Problem 7 - 2D. ....................................... 1-177
Figure 1.28 Curve of Pile-Cap Load vs. Vertical Displacement for Example Problem 7 - 2D. ...... 1-178
Figure 1.29 Curve of Pile-Cap Load vs. Lateral Deflection for Example Problem 7 - 2D. ............. 1-179
Figure 1.30 Curve of Pile-Cap Load vs. Rotation for Example Problem 7 - 2D. ............................ 1-180
Figure 1.31 Curve of Pile-Cap Moment vs. Lateral Deflection for Example Problem 7 - 2D. ....... 1-181
Figure 1.32 Curve of Pile-Cap Moment vs. Rotation for Example Problem 7 - 2D. ..................... 1-182
Figure 1.33 General Description of Example Problem 8 - 2D. ...................................................... 1-184
Figure 1.34 Curves Deflection vs. Distance for Example Problem 8 - 2D...................................... 1-218

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 xi

Figure 1.35 Curves Moment vs. Distance for Example Problem 8 - 2D. ....................................... 1-219
Figure 1.36 Curves K11(KXX) vs. vertical displacement for Example Problem 8 - 2D. .................... 1-220
Figure 1.37 Curves K22(KYY) vs. lateral deflection for Example Problem 8 - 2D. ........................... 1-221
Figure 1.38 Curves K33(KrZrZ) vs. rotation for Example Problem 8 - 2D. ........................................ 1-222
Figure 2.1 General Description of Example Problem 1 - 3D. .......................................................... 2-5
Figure 2.2 Section of prestressed concrete pile.............................................................................. 2-6
Figure 2.3 Axial load versus pile-top displacements ....................................................................... 2-6
Figure 2.4 Curves Resultant Deflection vs. Distance for Example Problem 1 - 3D. ...................... 2-34
Figure 2.5 Curves Resultant Moment vs. Distance for Example Problem 1 - 3D. ......................... 2-35
Figure 2.6 General Description of Example Problem 2 - 3D. ........................................................ 2-37
Figure 2.7 Curves Resultant Deflection vs. Distance for Example Problem 2 - 3D. ...................... 2-59
Figure 2.8 Curves Resultant Moment vs. Distance for Example Problem 2 - 3D. ......................... 2-60
Figure 2.9 Equilibrium check for Example Problem 3 - 3D. .......................................................... 2-61
Figure 2.10 Curves Resultant Deflection vs. Distance for Example Problem 3 - 3D. ...................... 2-81
Figure 2.11 Curves Resultant Moment vs. Distance for Example Problem 3 - 3D. ......................... 2-82
Figure 2.12 General Description of Example Problem 4 - 3D. ........................................................ 2-84
Figure 2.13 Curves Resultant Deflection vs. Distance for Example Problem 4 - 3D. .................... 2-114
Figure 2.14 Curves Resultant Moment vs. Distance for Example Problem 4 - 3D. ....................... 2-115
Figure 2.15 General Description of Example Problem 5 - 3D. ...................................................... 2-117
Figure 2.16 Curves Resultant Deflection vs. Distance for Example Problem 5 - 3D. .................... 2-141
Figure 2.17 Internally Generated curves of Axial Load vs Displacement for Example Problem 5 - 3D.
.................................................................................................................................... 2-142
Figure 2.18 General Description of Example Problem 6 - 3D. ...................................................... 2-144
Figure 2.19 Curves Resultant Deflection vs. Distance for Example Problem 6 - 3D. .................... 2-172
Figure 2.20 Curves Resultant Moment vs. Distance for Example Problem 6 - 3D. ....................... 2-173
Figure 3.1 Cross Section of Example Problem 1 - MC. .................................................................... 3-3
Figure 3.2 Moment Curvature for Example Problem 1 - MC. ......................................................... 3-4
Figure 3.3 Interaction Diagram for Example Problem 1 - MC. ........................................................ 3-5
Figure 3.4 Cross Section of Example Problem 2 - MC. .................................................................... 3-6
Figure 3.5 Moment Curvature for Example Problem 2 –MC, Unconfined Section......................... 3-7
Figure 3.6 Moment Curvature for Example Problem 2 – MC, Confined Section. ........................... 3-8
Figure 3.7 Cross Section of Example Problem 3 - MC. .................................................................... 3-9
Figure 3.8 Moment Curvature for Example Problem 3 –MC. ....................................................... 3-10
Figure 3.9 Bending Stiffness for Example Problem 3 – MC........................................................... 3-11
Figure 3.10 Cross Section of Example Problem 4 - MC. .................................................................. 3-12
Figure 3.11 Moment Curvature for Example Problem 4 –MC with embedded steel section. ....... 3-13
Figure 3.12 Moment Curvature for Example Problem 4 –MC without embedded steel section. .. 3-14
Figure 3.13 Cross Section of Example Problem 5 - MC. .................................................................. 3-15
Figure 3.14 Moment Curvature for Example Problem 5 –MC. ....................................................... 3-16
Figure 3.15 Bending Stiffness for Example Problem 5 – MC........................................................... 3-17
Figure 4.1 View of Example Model 1a - TB. .................................................................................... 4-3
Figure 4.2 Error while running Example Model 1a - TB. ................................................................. 4-4

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 xii

Figure 4.3 Processor Run Notes file for Example Model 1a - TB. ................................................... 4-4
Figure 4.4 Lack of Rotational Stiffness for Example Model 1a - TB. ............................................... 4-5
Figure 4.5 Change the connection to Fixed for Example Model 1b - TB......................................... 4-6
Figure 4.6 Lateral displacements for Example Model 1b - TB. ....................................................... 4-6
Figure 4.7 View of Example Model 2a - TB. .................................................................................... 4-7
Figure 4.8 Error while running Example Model 2a - TB. ................................................................. 4-8
Figure 4.9 Processor Run Notes file for Example Model 2a - TB. ................................................... 4-8
Figure 4.10 Definition of Load at 80% for Example Model 2b - TB. .................................................. 4-9
Figure 4.11 Load-Displacement curve generated for Example Model 2b - TB. .............................. 4-10
Figure 4.12 Summary Results File for Example Model 2b - TB. ...................................................... 4-11
Figure 4.13 View of Example Model 3a - TB. .................................................................................. 4-12
Figure 4.14 Error while running Example Model 3a - TB. ............................................................... 4-13
Figure 4.15 Processor Run Notes file for Example Model 3a - TB. ................................................. 4-13
Figure 4.16 Definition of Load at 50% for Example Model 3b - TB. ................................................ 4-14
Figure 4.17 Load-Displacement curve generated for Example Model 3b - TB. .............................. 4-15
Figure 4.18 Summary Results File for Example Model 2b - TB. ...................................................... 4-16
Figure 4.19 Lateral Deflection for Example Model 3b - TB. ............................................................ 4-17
Figure 4.20 Lateral Soil Reaction for Example Model 3b - TB. ........................................................ 4-18
Figure 4.21 Generated p-y curves for Example Model 3b - TB. ...................................................... 4-19
Figure 4.22 View of Example Model 4a - TB. .................................................................................. 4-20
Figure 4.23 Error while running Example Model 4a - TB. ............................................................... 4-21
Figure 4.24 Processor Run Notes file for Example Model 4a - TB. ................................................. 4-21
Figure 4.25 Definition of 5 load cases for Example Model 4b - TB. ................................................ 4-22
Figure 4.26 Lateral displacements for Example Model 4b - TB. ..................................................... 4-23

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 xiii

List of Tables

Table 1.1 Main features of two-dimensional examples for GROUP 2016 ..................................... 1-3
Table 2.1 Main features of three-dimensional examples for GROUP 2016 .................................. 2-3
Table 3.1 Main features of moment curvature examples for GROUP 2016.................................. 3-2
Table 4.1 Main features of troubleshooting examples for GROUP 2016 ...................................... 4-2
Table 5.1 Main features of import from excel examples for GROUP 2016 ................................... 5-2

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
CHAPTER 1. Example Problems Based
on Two-Dimensional
Analyses

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-2

1.1 Introduction

Several problems are provided herein as examples of different applications that may be solved
using GROUP 2016. Each example focuses on a particular computational feature of the program. Input
files for each example are automatically copied to the GROUP 2016 directory (examples folder) during
installation. GROUP 2016 allows the user to analyze the pile group either using 2-dimensional model or
using 3-dimensional model. The data files are named 2DexampleN.gp10d, where N represents the
desired example number, for two-dimensional applications.

Example problems provide the user information on input and output of various cases, and
present a quick tutorial for real-world applications. The user is encouraged to study these examples
and, with modifications, may use them to solve similar problems. However, by no means can these
limited examples explore the full functions and features provided by GROUP 2016.

Main features of the examples for two-dimensional analysis included with GROUP 2016 are
summarized in the table below.

Additional application problems will become available electronically at our internet website,
which may be accessed with the following unified resource locator (url):

http://www.ensoftinc.com/

Users may also access ENSOFT, INC.'s website to observe responses to commonly asked
questions related to the GROUP 2016 program.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-3

Example Name Name of Input File Description

Application with curves of load-displacement
Example 1 - 2D 2Dexample1.gp10d
and soil resistance (p-y) specified by the user.
Pile group consists of vertical and battered
piles. Axial load vs. displacement curve
Example 2 - 2D 2Dexample2.gp10d
specified by the user. The program generates
the soil-resistance (p-y) curve internally.
Application for various boundary conditions
Example 3 - 2D 2Dexample3.gp10d
between the pile cap and the pile heads.
Example 4 - 2D 2Dexample4.gp10d Application for pile-supported retaining wall.
Piles arranged in a circular pattern for offshore
Example 5 - 2D 2Dexample5.gp10d
platforms..
Two different sizes of piles are used in the
Example 6 - 2D 2Dexample6.gp10d same pile group. The program generates
curves the soil-response curves internally.
Application of a 3 x 3 pile group with the pile
cap below the ground surface. The program
Example 7 - 2D 2Dexample7.gp10d
generates curves for computation of
foundation stiffness.
Includes the passive soil resistance on the
embedded pile cap. The program will
Example 8 - 2D 2Dexample8.gp10d
internally generate group reduction factors for
lateral loading.

Table 1.1 Main features of two-dimensional examples for GROUP 2016

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-4

1.2 Example Problem 1 - 2D

1.2.1 Model Description

The geometrical configuration of Example Problem 1 - 2D is shown in Figure 1.1. It consists of

four, steel-pipe piles of two inches in diameters that are arranged symmetrically with respect to the XY
plane. These piles are rigidly connected to the pile cap. The typical tube has a cross sectional area of
0.380 in2. The yield stress is 64 x 103 psi, and the Young's modulus of the steel is 29 x 106 psi. Each pile
subgroup consists of two identical piles of 108 inches in length. All piles are standing approximately 12
inches above the ground surface.

The group of piles is subjected to loads applied at the center of the pile cap and leveled with the
pile tops (Figure 1.1). The loads are applied at the global origin of coordinates.

The applied loads are:

Vertical load = 17,770 lbs,

Lateral load = 3,700 lbs,

Moment = -7800 lbs-in

The soil consists of submerged dense sand. Two sets of p-y curves are inputted. In the first set,
a modification factor of 0.73 was applied to consider the effect of the out-battered piles of subgroup #2.

The example model has a user-specified curve of axial load versus displacement that was
obtained from a previous experiment performed in a test tank. The input and output files for the
example problem are shown in the following pages.

The contents of the input and output files (for this and all the examples) are reproduced using
the courier font for distinction.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-5

Figure 1.1 General Description of Example Problem 1 - 2D.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-6

1.2.2 Input Data

EXAMPLE PROBLEM 1 - 2D, EXTERNAL P-Y CURVES

GROUP2016.10.8
* Analysis Parameters
1 2 0 0 1 1 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 1
* Pile Cap Dimensions
0 0 0 0 0 0
* Load Cases
1 0 0 1 0
0 1 1 1 1 20 20
0.0001 0.0001 1 1
Load Case 1
12 0 0 0 1 0 0 0
2 1 1 0 1E-7 1E-5 0 0 0
1
0 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 0 1 1 0 1 1 0 0 1 1 1 0 0 1 1
1
17770 3700 -7800 0 0 0 0 0 0
0
0
* Load Combinations
0 0 0 1 0
* Distributed Load Sets
0
* Pile Group Configuration
2
2 2 1 1 1 0 0
0 0 1 1 1
0 -1.0208333 -4.7612793 0
2 2 1 2 1 0 0
0 0 1 1 1
0 1.0208333 9.4595332 0
* Pile Properties
1
0 1
35 9 1
0 9 1
* Pile Cross Sections
1
0 0 0 0
Section 1
2 0 1 1 0 0 0.1 0.1
1 0.38 0.185 0.185 0 0 0 0 29000000 0 0
0 0 0 0 1
None
* Soil Layers
1
0 1
0 0
2 10
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
* User defined py curves
2
0 6
0
2
0 0
0 20
0.5
3
0 0
9.37 0.053
9.37 20
1

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-7

3
0 0
33.5 0.095
33.5 20
1.5
3
0 0
72.5 0.137
72.5 20
2
3
0 0
126.29 0.179
126.29 20
10
3
0 0
1542.49 0.547
1542.49 20
1 6
0
2
0 0
0 20
0.5
3
0 0
12.84 0.053
12.84 20
1
3
0 0
45.95 0.095
45.95 20
1.5
3
0 0
99.32 0.137
99.32 20
2
3
0 0
173 0.179
173 20
10
3
0 0
2113 0.547
2113 20
* Generated LD curves
0
* User defined LD curves
1
0 15
-5400 -20
-5400 -0.1
-5000 -0.072
-4000 -0.046
-3000 -0.028
-2000 -0.016
-1000 -0.004
0 0
1000 0.004
2000 0.016
3000 0.028
4000 0.046
5000 0.072
5400 0.1
5400 20
* User defined MC curves
1

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-8

1 1
0
1 1
0 0
* Internally Generated MC curves
1
1 1
0
0
1 1
0 0
* End of file

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-9

1.2.3 Echo Print File

=========================================================================

GROUP for Windows, Version 2016.10.8

Serial Number : 136089307

Analysis of A Group of Piles

Subjected to Axial and Lateral Loading

(c) Copyright ENSOFT, Inc., 1987-2015

All Rights Reserved

=========================================================================

This program is licensed to :

ENSOFT, INC
AUSTIN, TX

Path to file locations : C:\projects\GROUP2016\Group2016_1008\DXE\Examples_2016\

Name of input data file : 2Dexample1.gp10r
Name of output echo file : 2Dexample1.gp10e
Name of output results file : 2Dexample1.gp10o
Name of output summary file : 2Dexample1.gp10t
Name of plot output file : 2Dexample1.gp10p
Name of runtime file : 2Dexample1.gp10r

-------------------------------------------------------------------------
Time and Date of Analysis
-------------------------------------------------------------------------

Date: May 09, 2016 Time: 18:14:12

***** INPUT INFORMATION *****

EXAMPLE PROBLEM 1 - 2D, EXTERNAL P-Y CURVES

ANALYSIS TYPE = 2D ANALYSIS

ADJUST DEPTH FOR BATTER PILES

GENERATE LOAD-DISP (AND T-R) CURVES BASED ON SOIL PROFILE

EXTEND INTERPOLATION FOR L-DP (AND T-R) CURVES

UNITS SYSTEM = ENGL

* TABLE C * LOAD AND CONTROL PARAMETERS

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-10

** LOAD CASES **

NUMBER OF LOAD CASES : 1

LOAD CASE : 1
CASE NAME : Load Case 1
LOAD TYPE : Special, Sp
SCALE FACTOR : 1.0000

* CONCENTRATED LOADS *

NL VERT.LOAD HOR.LOAD MOMENT COORD X COORD Y

LBS LBS LBS-IN FT FT
1 17770.0 3700.00 -7800.00 0.00000 0.00000

* EQUIVALENT CONCENTRATED LOAD AT ORIGIN *

VER.LOAD X,LBS HOR.LOAD Y,LBS MOMENT,LBS-IN

17770.0 3700.00 -7800.00

* THE LOADING IS STATIC *

* CONTROL PARAMETERS *
TOLERANCE ON CONVERGENCE OF PILE CAP MOVEMENT = 1.00000E-04
TOLERANCE ON DETERMINATION OF PILE DEFLECTIONS = 1.00000E-04 IN
MAX NO OF ITERATIONS ALLOWED FOR FOUNDATION ANALYSIS = 20
MAXIMUM NO OF ITERATIONS ALLOWED FOR PILE ANALYSIS = 20
FACTOR TO APPLY THE LOAD IN INCREMENTS = 1.0000
MINIMUM FACTOR FOR LOAD INCREMENTS = 1.0000
PRINT RESULTS AT PILE CAP, PILE HEADS AND ALONG PILES
PRINT RESULTS EVERY 1 NODE(S)

* TABLE D * ARRANGEMENT OF PILE GROUPS

GROUP CONNECT NO OF PILE PILE PROP P-Y CURVE L-S CURVE R-F-L SET
1 FIX 2 1 1 1 U 0
2 FIX 2 1 2 1 U 0

GROUP VERT,FT HOR,FT SLOPE,IN/IN GROUND,FT SPRING,LBS-IN SPACING,FT

1 0.00000 -1.02083 -0.0832918 0.00000 0.00000 0.00000
2 0.00000 1.02083 0.16662 0.00000 0.00000 0.00000

* TABLE E * PILE GEOMETRY AND PROPERTIES

PILE TYPE = 1 - DRIVEN PILE
= 2 - DRILLED SHAFT

PROP SECTS INC PILE TYPE LENGTH, FT

1 1 35 1 9.0000

* PILE SECTIONS *

PROP SECT FROM,FT TO,FT CROSS SECT

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-11

1 1 0.00000 9.00000 1

* PILE CROSS SECTIONS *

CROSS SECTION : 1
SECTION NAME : Section

TYPE : ELASTIC
CROSS SECTION TYPE : GENERAL SECTION
EQUIVALENT DIAMETER : 2.00000 IN
YOUNG MODULUS : 2.90000E+07 LBS/IN**2

* PILE CROSS SECTIONS PROPERTIES *

ELASTIC SECTIONS

SECT DIAM,IN AREA,IN**2 I,IN**4 Mn,LBS-IN Vn,LBS

1 2.00000 0.38000 0.18500 0.00000 0.00000

* TABLE F * SOIL DATA

SOILS INFORMATION

GROUND SURFACE = 0.00000 FT

1 LAYER(S) OF SOIL

LAYER 1
THE SOIL IS A SOFT CLAY
TOP OF LAYER BOTTOM OF LAYER
X COORDINATE (FT) 0.00000 0.00000
EFFECTIVE UNIT WEIGHT (LBS/FT**3) 0.00000 0.00000
UNDRAINED COHESION, C (LBS/FT**2) 0.00000 0.00000
STRAIN AT 50% STRESS 0.0200000 (E) 0.0200000 (E)
ULTIMATE UNIT SIDE FRICTION (LBS/FT**2) 0.00000 0.00000
ULTIMATE UNIT TIP RESISTANCE (LBS/FT**2) 0.00000 0.00000

Notes : Program estimated values for listed parameters

if zero input values were entered:
(E) STRAIN AT 50% STRESS

* TABLE G * INPUT P-Y CURVES

NUM OF SETS : 2

SET 1 NUM OF CURVES 6

CURVE 1 DISTANCE FROM ORIGIN (X-COORD.) 0.00000 FT

POINT P LBS Y IN
1 0.00000 0.00000
2 0.00000 20.0000

CURVE 2 DISTANCE FROM ORIGIN (X-COORD.) 0.50000 FT

POINT P LBS Y IN

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-12

1 0.00000 0.00000
2 9.37000 0.0530000
3 9.37000 20.0000

CURVE 3 DISTANCE FROM ORIGIN (X-COORD.) 1.00000 FT

POINT P LBS Y IN
1 0.00000 0.00000
2 33.5000 0.0950000
3 33.5000 20.0000

CURVE 4 DISTANCE FROM ORIGIN (X-COORD.) 1.50000 FT

POINT P LBS Y IN
1 0.00000 0.00000
2 72.5000 0.13700
3 72.5000 20.0000

CURVE 5 DISTANCE FROM ORIGIN (X-COORD.) 2.00000 FT

POINT P LBS Y IN
1 0.00000 0.00000
2 126.290 0.17900
3 126.290 20.0000

CURVE 6 DISTANCE FROM ORIGIN (X-COORD.) 10.0000 FT

POINT P LBS Y IN
1 0.00000 0.00000
2 1542.49 0.54700
3 1542.49 20.0000

SET 2 NUM OF CURVES 6

CURVE 1 DISTANCE FROM ORIGIN (X-COORD.) 0.00000 FT

POINT P LBS Y IN
1 0.00000 0.00000
2 0.00000 20.0000

CURVE 2 DISTANCE FROM ORIGIN (X-COORD.) 0.50000 FT

POINT P LBS Y IN
1 0.00000 0.00000
2 12.8400 0.0530000
3 12.8400 20.0000

CURVE 3 DISTANCE FROM ORIGIN (X-COORD.) 1.00000 FT

POINT P LBS Y IN
1 0.00000 0.00000
2 45.9500 0.0950000
3 45.9500 20.0000

CURVE 4 DISTANCE FROM ORIGIN (X-COORD.) 1.50000 FT

POINT P LBS Y IN
1 0.00000 0.00000
2 99.3200 0.13700
3 99.3200 20.0000

CURVE 5 DISTANCE FROM ORIGIN (X-COORD.) 2.00000 FT

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-13

POINT P LBS Y IN
1 0.00000 0.00000
2 173.000 0.17900
3 173.000 20.0000

CURVE 6 DISTANCE FROM ORIGIN (X-COORD.) 10.0000 FT

POINT P LBS Y IN
1 0.00000 0.00000
2 2113.00 0.54700
3 2113.00 20.0000

* TABLE H * AXIAL LOAD VS DISPLACEMENT

USER DEFINED AXIAL LOAD-DISPLACEMENT CURVES

NUM OF CURVES 1

CURVE 1 NUM OF POINTS 15

DISPLACEMENT, IN AXIAL LOAD,LBS

-20.0000 -5400.00
-0.1000000 -5400.00
-0.0720000 -5000.00
-0.0460000 -4000.00
-0.0280000 -3000.00
-0.0160000 -2000.00
-4.00000E-03 -1000.00
0.00000 0.00000
4.00000E-03 1000.00
0.0160000 2000.00
0.0280000 3000.00
0.0460000 4000.00
0.0720000 5000.00
0.1000000 5400.00
20.0000 5400.00

* TABLE J * MOMENT CURVATURE SETS

USER DEFINED MOMENT CURVATURE

NUM OF SETS : 1

CURVE SET 1 NUM OF CURVES 1

CURVE 1 AXIAL LOAD 0.000E+00 LBS

POINT MOMENT CURVATURE

LBS-IN RADIAN/IN
1 0.00000 0.00000

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-14

1.2.4 Processor Run Notes

GROUP for Windows, Version 2016.10.8

-------------------------------------------------------------------------
Time and Date of Analysis
-------------------------------------------------------------------------

Date: May 09, 2016 Time: 18:14:12

EXAMPLE PROBLEM 1 - 2D, EXTERNAL P-Y CURVES

READING * TITLE AND VERSION

READING * Analysis Parameters
READING * Pile Cap Dimensions
READING * Load Cases
READING * Load Combinations
READING * Distributed Load Sets
READING * Pile Group Configuration
READING * Pile Properties
READING * Pile Cross Sections
READING * Soil Layers
READING * User defined py curves
READING * Generated LD curves
READING * User defined LD curves
READING * User defined MC curves
READING * Internally Generated MC curves

COMPUTATION IS PROCEEDING......

LOAD CASE : 1
CASE NAME : Load Case 1

GLOBAL ITERATIONS
STEP 1, TCUR 1.0000, DTCUR 1.0000
ITERATION 1
- ErrDsp 0.10000E+01, IncDsp 0.13712E+00, TotDsp 0.13712E+00
- ErrRot 0.10000E+01, IncRot 0.11117E-02, TotRot 0.11117E-02
ITERATION 2
- ErrDsp 0.26019E+00, IncDsp 0.46578E-01, TotDsp 0.17901E+00
- ErrRot 0.26983E+00, IncRot 0.23623E-03, TotRot 0.87551E-03
ITERATION 3
- ErrDsp 0.11543E+00, IncDsp 0.23107E-01, TotDsp 0.20018E+00
- ErrRot 0.49619E+01, IncRot 0.72866E-03, TotRot 0.14685E-03
ITERATION 4
- ErrDsp 0.66103E-01, IncDsp 0.14102E-01, TotDsp 0.21333E+00
- ErrRot 0.13138E+01, IncRot 0.61476E-03, TotRot 0.46791E-03
ITERATION 5
- ErrDsp 0.58251E-01, IncDsp 0.13144E-01, TotDsp 0.22564E+00
- ErrRot 0.55416E+00, IncRot 0.58160E-03, TotRot 0.10495E-02
ITERATION 6
- ErrDsp 0.15087E-04, IncDsp 0.34042E-05, TotDsp 0.22564E+00
- ErrRot 0.13159E-03, IncRot 0.13812E-06, TotRot 0.10496E-02
ITERATION 7
- ErrDsp 0.11353E-11, IncDsp 0.25618E-12, TotDsp 0.22564E+00
- ErrRot 0.10756E-10, IncRot 0.11290E-13, TotRot 0.10496E-02

NUMBER OF GLOBAL ITERATIONS = 7

ANALYSIS FOR LOAD CASE 1/ 1 FINISHED

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-15

Execution Time : 59 ms
Number Processors : 1/ 8
Serial processing : 0.047 sec
Paral. processing : 0.002 sec
Print. processing : 0.011 sec

ANALYSIS COMPLETED
Execution Time : 59 ms
Number Processors : 1/ 8

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-16

1.2.5 Output Results File

=========================================================================

GROUP for Windows, Version 2016.10.8

Serial Number : 136089307

Analysis of A Group of Piles

Subjected to Axial and Lateral Loading

(c) Copyright ENSOFT, Inc., 1987-2015

All Rights Reserved

=========================================================================

This program is licensed to :

ENSOFT, INC
AUSTIN, TX

Path to file locations : C:\projects\GROUP2016\Group2016_1008\DXE\Examples_2016\

Name of input data file : 2Dexample1.gp10d
Name of output echo file : 2Dexample1.gp10e
Name of output results file : 2Dexample1.gp10o
Name of output summary file : 2Dexample1.gp10t
Name of plot output file : 2Dexample1.gp10p
Name of runtime file : 2Dexample1.gp10r

-------------------------------------------------------------------------
Time and Date of Analysis
-------------------------------------------------------------------------

Date: May 09, 2016 Time: 18:14:12

***** COMPUTATION RESULTS *****

EXAMPLE PROBLEM 1 - 2D, EXTERNAL P-Y CURVES

***** LOAD CASES RESULTS *****

LOAD CASE : 1
CASE NAME : Load Case 1
LOAD TYPE : Special, Sp

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-17

* TABLE L * COMPUTATION ON PILE CAP

* EQUIVALENT CONCENTRATED LOAD AT ORIGIN *

VERT. LOAD, LBS HORI. LOAD, LBS MOMENT,LBS-IN

17770.0 3700.00 -7800.00

* DISPLACEMENT OF GROUPED PILE FOUNDATION AT ORIGIN *

VERTICAL,IN HORIZONTAL,IN ROTATION,RAD

0.0701967 0.21445 -1.04964E-03

NUMBER OF ITERATIONS = 7

* TABLE M * COMPUTATION ON INDIVIDUAL PILE

* PILE GROUP * 1

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS AND REACTIONS *

THE GLOBAL STRUCTURAL COORDINATE SYSTEM

---------------------------------------

DISP.X,IN DISP.Y,IN SLOPE FOR.X, LB FOR.Y, LB BM, LB-IN STRESS, LB/IN**2

0.057339 0.2144 -1.0496E-03 3668.0 304.84 7417.1 4.9645E+04

THE PILE COORDINATE SYSTEM (LOCAL AXES)

---------------------------------------

DISP.x,IN DISP.y,IN SLOPE AXIAL, LB LAT, LB BM, LB-IN STRESS,LBS/IN**2

0.039341 0.2185 -1.0496E-03 3630.0 608.25 7417.1 4.9645E+04

* EFFECTS FOR LATERALLY LOADED PILE *

x DISPL. BENDING SHEAR SOIL TOTAL FLEXURAL

y-DIR MOMENT FORCE REACTION STRESS RIGIDITY
FT IN LBS-IN LBS LBS/IN LBS-IN**2 LBS-IN**2
********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
0.0000 0.2185 -7417.1 615.99 0.0000 4.9645E+04 5.3650E+06
0.2571 0.2086 -5504.6 600.81 4.8188 3.9307E+04 5.3650E+06
0.5143 0.1891 -3602.5 577.86 10.059 2.9026E+04 5.3650E+06
0.7714 0.1631 -1772.9 527.67 22.468 1.9136E+04 5.3650E+06
1.0286 0.1339 -145.91 438.03 35.635 1.0341E+04 5.3650E+06
1.2857 0.1046 1142.8 312.12 45.972 1.5730E+04 5.3650E+06
1.5429 7.7191E-02 1986.3 176.37 42.016 2.0290E+04 5.3650E+06
1.8000 5.3355E-02 2417.0 59.270 33.880 2.2618E+04 5.3650E+06

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-18

2.0571 3.3809E-02 2509.6 -30.593 24.364 2.3118E+04 5.3650E+06

2.3143 1.8717E-02 2354.0 -90.955 14.760 2.2277E+04 5.3650E+06
2.5714 7.8026E-03 2042.7 -124.04 6.6834 2.0594E+04 5.3650E+06
2.8286 5.1351E-04 1654.5 -135.08 0.4747 1.8496E+04 5.3650E+06
3.0857 -3.8391E-03 1251.3 -129.94 -3.8103 1.6316E+04 5.3650E+06
3.3429 -5.9710E-03 876.19 -114.29 -6.3320 1.4289E+04 5.3650E+06
3.6000 -6.5479E-03 555.77 -93.120 -7.3887 1.2557E+04 5.3650E+06
3.8571 -6.1384E-03 302.12 -70.390 -7.3438 1.1186E+04 5.3650E+06
4.1143 -5.1928E-03 116.44 -48.930 -6.5654 1.0182E+04 5.3650E+06
4.3714 -4.0404E-03 -7.4660 -30.495 -5.3831 9593.1 5.3650E+06
4.6286 -2.9014E-03 -80.072 -15.922 -4.0627 9985.6 5.3650E+06
4.8857 -1.9044E-03 -113.48 -5.3396 -2.7961 1.0166E+04 5.3650E+06
5.1429 -1.1088E-03 -119.53 1.6024 -1.7034 1.0199E+04 5.3650E+06
5.4000 -5.2542E-04 -108.60 5.5309 -0.8428 1.0140E+04 5.3650E+06
5.6571 -1.3472E-04 -88.935 7.1788 -0.2253 1.0033E+04 5.3650E+06
5.9143 9.8129E-05 -66.556 7.2630 0.1708 9912.5 5.3650E+06
6.1714 2.1286E-04 -45.374 6.4057 0.3849 9798.0 5.3650E+06
6.4286 2.4706E-04 -27.564 5.0968 0.4635 9701.8 5.3650E+06
6.6857 2.3235E-04 -13.990 3.6849 0.4517 9628.4 5.3650E+06
6.9429 1.9281E-04 -4.6261 2.3895 0.3879 9577.8 5.3650E+06
7.2000 1.4505E-04 1.0739 1.3256 0.3017 9558.6 5.3650E+06
7.4571 9.9203E-05 3.8944 0.5314 0.2131 9573.8 5.3650E+06
7.7143 6.0266E-05 4.6610 -3.3993E-03 0.1335 9578.0 5.3650E+06
7.9714 2.9602E-05 4.1261 -0.3137 6.7603E-02 9575.1 5.3650E+06
8.2286 6.2600E-06 2.9209 -0.4407 1.4722E-02 9568.5 5.3650E+06
8.4857 -1.1898E-05 1.5567 -0.4190 -2.8789E-02 9561.2 5.3650E+06
8.7429 -2.7293E-05 0.4566 -0.2699 -6.7895E-02 9555.2 5.3650E+06
9.0000 -4.1878E-05 0.0000 9.0206E-17 -0.1070 9552.8 5.3650E+06

* PILE GROUP * 2

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS AND REACTIONS *

THE GLOBAL STRUCTURAL COORDINATE SYSTEM

---------------------------------------

DISP.X,IN DISP.Y,IN SLOPE FOR.X, LB FOR.Y, LB BM, LB-IN STRESS, LB/IN**2

0.083055 0.2144 -1.0496E-03 5217.0 1545.2 7658.0 5.5605E+04

THE PILE COORDINATE SYSTEM (LOCAL AXES)

---------------------------------------

DISP.x,IN DISP.y,IN SLOPE AXIAL, LB LAT, LB BM, LB-IN STRESS,LBS/IN**2

0.1172 0.1979 -1.0496E-03 5400.0 666.73 7658.0 5.5605E+04

* EFFECTS FOR LATERALLY LOADED PILE *

x DISPL. BENDING SHEAR SOIL TOTAL FLEXURAL

y-DIR MOMENT FORCE REACTION STRESS RIGIDITY
FT IN LBS-IN LBS LBS/IN LBS-IN**2 LBS-IN**2
********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
0.0000 0.1979 -7658.0 678.63 0.0000 5.5605E+04 5.3650E+06
0.2571 0.1878 -5546.4 656.54 6.6034 4.4191E+04 5.3650E+06
0.5143 0.1680 -3444.6 625.09 13.786 3.2830E+04 5.3650E+06
0.7714 0.1420 -1441.1 556.28 30.813 2.2000E+04 5.3650E+06
1.0286 0.1134 282.93 434.65 48.021 1.5740E+04 5.3650E+06
1.2857 8.5379E-02 1547.0 278.68 53.068 2.2572E+04 5.3650E+06
1.5429 6.0078E-02 2290.9 127.69 44.798 2.6594E+04 5.3650E+06

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-19

1.8000 3.8842E-02 2586.3 6.4414 33.788 2.8190E+04 5.3650E+06

2.0571 2.2197E-02 2535.2 -79.496 21.912 2.7914E+04 5.3650E+06
2.3143 1.0051E-02 2251.2 -130.05 10.857 2.6379E+04 5.3650E+06
2.5714 1.8996E-03 1842.2 -150.24 2.2289 2.4168E+04 5.3650E+06
2.8286 -2.9819E-03 1394.3 -147.86 -3.7765 2.1747E+04 5.3650E+06
3.0857 -5.3889E-03 969.05 -130.73 -7.3265 1.9449E+04 5.3650E+06
3.3429 -6.0760E-03 604.25 -105.80 -8.8264 1.7477E+04 5.3650E+06
3.6000 -5.6907E-03 317.71 -78.615 -8.7965 1.5928E+04 5.3650E+06
3.8571 -4.7415E-03 111.88 -53.054 -7.7707 1.4815E+04 5.3650E+06
4.1143 -3.5938E-03 -21.027 -31.462 -6.2243 1.4324E+04 5.3650E+06
4.3714 -2.4834E-03 -94.472 -14.866 -4.5323 1.4721E+04 5.3650E+06
4.6286 -1.5406E-03 -123.86 -3.3137 -2.9551 1.4880E+04 5.3650E+06
4.8857 -8.1767E-04 -123.92 3.7829 -1.6445 1.4880E+04 5.3650E+06
5.1429 -3.1466E-04 -107.13 7.3418 -0.6621 1.4790E+04 5.3650E+06
5.4000 -1.7767E-06 -83.014 8.3694 -3.9042E-03 1.4659E+04 5.3650E+06
5.6571 1.6377E-04 -58.064 7.7967 0.3751 1.4524E+04 5.3650E+06
5.9143 2.2627E-04 -36.129 6.3858 0.5393 1.4406E+04 5.3650E+06
6.1714 2.2465E-04 -18.983 4.6952 0.5564 1.4313E+04 5.3650E+06
6.4286 1.8934E-04 -6.9535 3.0860 0.4866 1.4248E+04 5.3650E+06
6.6857 1.4168E-04 0.5100 1.7532 0.3773 1.4213E+04 5.3650E+06
6.9429 9.4934E-05 4.3762 0.7674 0.2616 1.4234E+04 5.3650E+06
7.2000 5.5952E-05 5.7092 0.1178 0.1594 1.4241E+04 5.3650E+06
7.4571 2.7103E-05 5.4695 -0.2512 7.9744E-02 1.4240E+04 5.3650E+06
7.7143 7.9611E-06 4.4182 -0.4115 2.4165E-02 1.4234E+04 5.3650E+06
7.9714 -3.3395E-06 3.0944 -0.4327 -1.0447E-02 1.4227E+04 5.3650E+06
8.2286 -9.1482E-06 1.8405 -0.3711 -2.9471E-02 1.4220E+04 5.3650E+06
8.4857 -1.1691E-05 0.8495 -0.2658 -3.8750E-02 1.4215E+04 5.3650E+06
8.7429 -1.2725E-05 0.2194 -0.1391 -4.3364E-02 1.4212E+04 5.3650E+06
9.0000 -1.3370E-05 0.0000 5.1977E-16 -4.6808E-02 1.4211E+04 5.3650E+06

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-20

1.2.6 Summary Results File

=========================================================================

GROUP for Windows, Version 2016.10.8

Serial Number : 136089307

Analysis of A Group of Piles

Subjected to Axial and Lateral Loading

(c) Copyright ENSOFT, Inc., 1987-2015

All Rights Reserved

=========================================================================

-------------------------------------------------------------------------
Time and Date of Analysis
-------------------------------------------------------------------------

Date: May 09, 2016 Time: 18:14:12

***** COMPUTATION RESULTS *****

EXAMPLE PROBLEM 1 - 2D, EXTERNAL P-Y CURVES

***** LOAD CASES RESULTS *****

LOAD CASE : 1
CASE NAME : Load Case 1
LOAD TYPE : Special, Sp

* TABLE L * COMPUTATION ON PILE CAP

* EQUIVALENT CONCENTRATED LOAD AT ORIGIN *

VERT. LOAD, LBS HORI. LOAD, LBS MOMENT,LBS-IN

17770.0 3700.00 -7800.00

* DISPLACEMENT OF GROUPED PILE FOUNDATION AT ORIGIN *

VERTICAL,IN HORIZONTAL,IN ROTATION,RAD

0.0701967 0.21445 -1.04964E-03

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-21

* TABLE M * COMPUTATION ON INDIVIDUAL PILE

THE GLOBAL STRUCTURAL COORDINATE SYSTEM

---------------------------------------

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS *

PILE GROUP DISP. X,IN DISP. Y,IN ROT. Z,RAD

********** *********** *********** ***********
1 0.057339 0.2145 -1.0496E-03
2 0.083055 0.2145 -1.0496E-03

MINIMUM 0.057339 0.2145 -1.0496E-03

Pile G. 1 1 1
MAXIMUM 0.083055 0.2145 -1.0496E-03
Pile G. 2 1 1

* PILE TOP REACTIONS *

PILE GROUP FOR. X,LBS FOR. Y,LBS MOM Z,LBS-IN STRESS,LBS/IN**2

********** *********** *********** ************ ****************
1 3668.0 304.84 7417.1 4.9645E+04
2 5217.0 1545.2 7658.0 5.5605E+04

MINIMUM 3668.0 304.84 7417.1 4.9645E+04

Pile G. 1 1 1 1
MAXIMUM 5217.0 1545.2 7658.0 5.5605E+04
Pile G. 2 2 2 2

THE PILE COORDINATE SYSTEM (LOCAL AXES)

---------------------------------------

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS *

PILE GROUP DISP. x,IN DISP. y,IN ROT. z,RAD

********** *********** *********** ***********
1 0.039341 0.2185 -1.0496E-03
2 0.1172 0.1979 -1.0496E-03

MINIMUM 0.039341 0.1979 -1.0496E-03

Pile G. 1 2 1
MAXIMUM 0.1172 0.2185 -1.0496E-03
Pile G. 2 1 1

* PILE TOP REACTIONS *

PILE GROUP AXIAL,LBS LAT. y,LBS MOM z,LBS-IN STRESS,LBS/IN**2

********** *********** *********** ************ ****************
1 3630.0 608.25 7417.1 4.9645E+04
2 5400.0 666.73 7658.0 5.5605E+04

MINIMUM 3630.0 608.25 7417.1 4.9645E+04

Pile G. 1 1 1 1
MAXIMUM 5400.0 666.73 7658.0 5.5605E+04
Pile G. 2 2 2 2

* EFFECTS FOR LATERALLY LOADED PILE *

* MINIMUM VALUES AND LOCATIONS *

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-22

PILE DISPL. BENDING SHEAR SOIL TOTAL FLEXURAL

y-DIR MOMENT FORCE REACTION STRESS RIGIDITY
IN LBS-IN LBS LBS/IN LBS-IN**2 LBS-IN**2
****** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
1 -6.5479E-03 -7417.1 -135.08 -7.3887 9552.8 5.3650E+06
x(FT) 3.6000 0.0000 2.8286 3.6000 9.0000 0.0000
2 -6.0760E-03 -7658.0 -150.24 -8.8264 1.4211E+04 5.3650E+06
x(FT) 3.3429 0.0000 2.5714 3.3429 9.0000 0.0000

Min. -6.5479E-03 -7658.0 -150.24 -8.8264 9552.8 5.3650E+06

Pile N. 1 2 2 2 1 1

* MAXIMUM VALUES AND LOCATIONS *

PILE DISPL. BENDING SHEAR SOIL TOTAL FLEXURAL

y-DIR MOMENT FORCE REACTION STRESS RIGIDITY
IN LBS-IN LBS LBS/IN LBS-IN**2 LBS-IN**2
****** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
1 0.2185 2509.6 615.99 45.972 4.9645E+04 5.3650E+06
x(FT) 0.0000 2.0571 0.0000 1.2857 0.0000 0.0000
2 0.1979 2586.3 678.63 53.068 5.5605E+04 5.3650E+06
x(FT) 0.0000 1.8000 0.0000 1.2857 0.0000 0.0000

Max. 0.2185 2586.3 678.63 53.068 5.5605E+04 5.3650E+06

Pile N. 1 2 2 2 2 1

***** SUMMARY FOR LOAD CASES AND COMBINATIONS *****

***** LOAD CASES RESULTS *****

LOAD CASE : 1

* EQUIVALENT CONCENTRATED LOAD AT ORIGIN *

LOAD X,LBS LOAD Y,LBS MOM Z,LBS-IN
17770.0 3700.00 -7800.00

* DISPLACEMENT OF GROUPED PILE FOUNDATION AT ORIGIN *

DISP X,IN DISP Y,IN ROT Z,RAD
0.0701967 0.21445 -1.04964E-03

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS, GLOBAL *

DISP. X,IN DISP. Y,IN ROT. Z,RAD
*********** *********** ***********
MINIMUM 0.057339 0.2145 -1.0496E-03
Pile G. 1 1 1
MAXIMUM 0.083055 0.2145 -1.0496E-03
Pile G. 2 1 1

* PILE TOP REACTIONS, GLOBAL *

FOR. X,LBS FOR. Y,LBS MOM Z,LBS-IN STRESS,LBS/IN**2
*********** *********** ************ ****************
MINIMUM 3668.0 304.84 7417.1 4.9645E+04
Pile G. 1 1 1 1
MAXIMUM 5217.0 1545.2 7658.0 5.5605E+04
Pile G. 2 2 2 2

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS, LOCAL *

DISP. x,IN DISP. y,IN ROT. z,RAD
*********** *********** ***********
MINIMUM 0.039341 0.1979 -1.0496E-03
Pile G. 1 2 1

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-23

MAXIMUM 0.1172 0.2185 -1.0496E-03

Pile G. 2 1 1

* PILE TOP REACTIONS, LOCAL *

AXIAL,LBS LAT. y,LBS MOM z,LBS-IN STRESS,LBS/IN**2
*********** *********** ************ ****************
MINIMUM 3630.0 608.25 7417.1 4.9645E+04
Pile G. 1 1 1 1
MAXIMUM 5400.0 666.73 7658.0 5.5605E+04
Pile G. 2 2 2 2

* EFFECTS FOR LATERALLY LOADED PILE *

PILE DISPL. BENDING SHEAR SOIL TOTAL FLEXURAL

y-DIR MOMENT FORCE REACTION STRESS RIGIDITY
IN LBS-IN LBS LBS/IN LBS-IN**2 LBS-IN**2
****** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
Min. -6.5479E-03 -7658.0 -150.24 -8.8264 9552.8 5.3650E+06
Pile N. 1 2 2 2 1 1
Max. 0.2185 2586.3 678.63 53.068 5.5605E+04 5.3650E+06
Pile N. 1 2 2 2 2 1

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-24

1.2.7 Graphs

Figure 1.2 Curves Deflection vs. Distance for Example Problem 1 - 2D.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-25

Figure 1.3 Curves Moment vs. Distance for Example Problem 1 - 2D.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-26

1.3 Example Problem 2 - 2D

1.3.1 Model Description

The geometrical configuration of Example Problem 2 - 2D is shown in Figure 1.4. It consists of

six 18-inch square, prestressed concrete piles of 93 ft in lengths, which are assumed to be rigidly
connected to the pile cap. Subgroups 1 and 4 have only one pile battered 1:4 in the plane of loading (x-y
plane). Subgroups 2 and 3 have two piles battered 1:6 away from the plane of loading. However, the
pile subgroups 2 and 3 are regarded as composed of vertical piles, because the projection of these piles
on the plane of loading is vertical. Distance from the pile cap to the assumed scour line is approximately
10 ft.

The group of piles is subjected to loads applied at the center of the pile cap and at the top of a
bent which is located 38.5 ft (462 in) above the origin of global coordinates.

The applied loads are:

Vertical load = 844 kips (844,000 lbs),

Lateral load = 36.4 kips (36,400 lbs),

Moment = 0

The general section property of the prestressed concrete pile is shown in Figure 1.5. The
compressive strength of the concrete is assumed to be 6,000 psi. The moment of inertia of the section
is 8,600 in4. The Young's modulus of the concrete is 4.44 x 106 psi. In this case the pile is regarded as
linearly elastic throughout, with the assumption that maximum stress in the pile is always in the elastic
range.

Theoretical lateral soil-resistance curves are internally generated by the program. The soil is
submerged soft clay with properties shown in Figure 1.4. For the example, the contribution of the top 5
ft is neglected by defining a soft clay layer with very low resistance (c=0.001 psi). Note that no
modifications of the p-y curves has been made in this example for the pile-batter effect. The curve of
axial load versus pile-top displacement used in this example is shown in Figure 1.6.

This example problem includes a printout of p-y curves internally generated by the program for
pile subgroup 1 at the depths of 180 in, 252 in, 360 in and 1116 in below the origin of coordinates that
correspond to 60 in, 132 in, 240 in and 996 in below the ground line. This curves are printed out for
verification purposes. The input and output files for the example problem are shown in the following
pages.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-27

Figure 1.4 General Description of Example Problem 2 - 2D.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-28

Figure 1.5 Section of prestressed concrete pile

AXIAL LOAD, Kip

-400 -200 0 200 400
-1
AXIAL PILE-TOP DISPLACEMENT, in

-0.8
Upward

-0.6
-0.4
-0.2
0
0.2
Downward

0.4
0.6
0.8
1

Figure 1.6 Axial load versus pile-top displacements

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-29

1.3.2 Input Data

EXAMPLE PROBLEM 2 - 2D, P-Y CURVES GENERATED INTERNALLY

GROUP2016.10.8
* Analysis Parameters
1 2 0 0 0 1 0 0 1 0 1 0 0 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 1
* Pile Cap Dimensions
0 0 0 0 0 0
* Load Cases
1 0 0 1 0
0 1 1 1 1 20 20
0.001 0.001 1 1
Load Case 1
12 0 0 0 1 0 0 0
2 1 1 0 1E-7 1E-5 0 0 0
1
0 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 0 1 1 0 1 1 0 0 1 1 1 0 0 1 1
1
844000 36400 0 0 0 0 -38.5 0 0
0
0
* Load Combinations
0 0 0 1 0
* Distributed Load Sets
1
1
0 0
* Pile Group Configuration
4
2 1 1 0 1 0 0
0 0 1 1 1
0 -10.5 -14.037466 10
2 2 1 0 1 0 0
0 0 1 1 1
0 -7.5 0 10
2 2 1 0 1 0 0
0 0 1 1 1
0 7.5 0 10
2 1 1 0 1 0 0
0 0 1 1 1
0 10.5 14.037466 10
* Pile Properties
1
0 1
35 93 1
0 93 1
* Pile Cross Sections
1
0 0 0 0
Section 1
18 0 1 1 0 0 0.1 0.1
1 324 8600 8600 0 0 0 0 4440000 0 0
0 0 0 0 1
None
* Soil Layers
3
0 1
10 15
2 10
17.28 0.144 0 10 0 0.02 0 0.144 0 0
17.28 0.144 0 10 0 0.02 0 0.144 0 0
1 1
15 84.5
2 10
29.99808 547.2 0 40 0 0.02 0 432 0 0
29.99808 547.2 0 40 0 0.02 0 432 0 0

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-30

2 1
84.5 93.333333
2 10
29.99808 2160 0 500 0 0.02 0 720 0 0
29.99808 2160 0 500 0 0.02 0 720 0 0
* Print py curves
4
1 15
0
1 21
0
1 30
0
1 93
0
* Generated LD curves
0
* User defined LD curves
1
0 25
-360000 -10
-360000 -0.65
-354000 -0.58
-345000 -0.5
-330000 -0.4
-310000 -0.3
-280000 -0.19
-260000 -0.16
-240000 -0.14
-120000 -0.06
-80000 -0.04
-40000 -0.02
0 0
40000 0.02
80000 0.04
120000 0.06
240000 0.14
260000 0.16
280000 0.19
310000 0.3
330000 0.4
345000 0.5
354000 0.58
360000 0.65
360000 10
* User defined MC curves
1
1 1
0
1 1
0 0
* Internally Generated MC curves
1
1 1
0
0
1 1
0 0
* End of file

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-31

1.3.3 Echo Print File

=========================================================================

GROUP for Windows, Version 2016.10.8

Serial Number : 136089307

Analysis of A Group of Piles

Subjected to Axial and Lateral Loading

(c) Copyright ENSOFT, Inc., 1987-2015

All Rights Reserved

=========================================================================

This program is licensed to :

ENSOFT, INC
AUSTIN, TX

Path to file locations : C:\projects\GROUP2016\Group2016_1008\DXE\Examples_2016\

Name of input data file : 2Dexample2.gp10r
Name of output echo file : 2Dexample2.gp10e
Name of output results file : 2Dexample2.gp10o
Name of output summary file : 2Dexample2.gp10t
Name of plot output file : 2Dexample2.gp10p
Name of runtime file : 2Dexample2.gp10r

-------------------------------------------------------------------------
Time and Date of Analysis
-------------------------------------------------------------------------

Date: May 09, 2016 Time: 18:14:12

***** INPUT INFORMATION *****

EXAMPLE PROBLEM 2 - 2D, P-Y CURVES GENERATED INTERNALLY

ANALYSIS TYPE = 2D ANALYSIS

ADJUST DEPTH FOR BATTER PILES

GENERATE LOAD-DISP (AND T-R) CURVES BASED ON SOIL PROFILE

EXTEND INTERPOLATION FOR L-DP (AND T-R) CURVES

UNITS SYSTEM = ENGL

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-32

* TABLE C * LOAD AND CONTROL PARAMETERS

** LOAD CASES **

NUMBER OF LOAD CASES : 1

LOAD CASE : 1
CASE NAME : Load Case 1
LOAD TYPE : Special, Sp
SCALE FACTOR : 1.0000

* CONCENTRATED LOADS *

NL VERT.LOAD HOR.LOAD MOMENT COORD X COORD Y

LBS LBS LBS-IN FT FT
1 8.44000E+05 36400.0 0.00000 -38.5000 0.00000

* EQUIVALENT CONCENTRATED LOAD AT ORIGIN *

VER.LOAD X,LBS HOR.LOAD Y,LBS MOMENT,LBS-IN

8.44000E+05 36400.0 -1.68168E+07

* THE LOADING IS STATIC *

* CONTROL PARAMETERS *
TOLERANCE ON CONVERGENCE OF PILE CAP MOVEMENT = 1.00000E-03
TOLERANCE ON DETERMINATION OF PILE DEFLECTIONS = 1.00000E-03 IN
MAX NO OF ITERATIONS ALLOWED FOR FOUNDATION ANALYSIS = 20
MAXIMUM NO OF ITERATIONS ALLOWED FOR PILE ANALYSIS = 20
FACTOR TO APPLY THE LOAD IN INCREMENTS = 1.0000
MINIMUM FACTOR FOR LOAD INCREMENTS = 1.0000
PRINT RESULTS AT PILE CAP, PILE HEADS AND ALONG PILES
PRINT RESULTS EVERY 1 NODE(S)

** SETS OF DISTRIBUTED LOAD **

NUMBER OF SETS : 1

DIST. LOAD SET : 1

NL DEPTH LOAD
(FT) (LBS)
1 0.0000 0.0000

* TABLE D * ARRANGEMENT OF PILE GROUPS

GROUP CONNECT NO OF PILE PILE PROP P-Y CURVE L-S CURVE R-F-L SET
1 FIX 1 1 0 1 U 0
2 FIX 2 1 0 1 U 0
3 FIX 2 1 0 1 U 0
4 FIX 1 1 0 1 U 0

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-33

GROUP VERT,FT HOR,FT SLOPE,IN/IN GROUND,FT SPRING,LBS-IN SPACING,FT

1 0.00000 -10.5000 -0.25002 10.0000 0.00000 0.00000
2 0.00000 -7.50000 0.00000 10.0000 0.00000 0.00000
3 0.00000 7.50000 0.00000 10.0000 0.00000 0.00000
4 0.00000 10.5000 0.25002 10.0000 0.00000 0.00000

* TABLE E * PILE GEOMETRY AND PROPERTIES

PILE TYPE = 1 - DRIVEN PILE
= 2 - DRILLED SHAFT

PROP SECTS INC PILE TYPE LENGTH, FT

1 1 35 1 93.000

* PILE SECTIONS *

PROP SECT FROM,FT TO,FT CROSS SECT

1 1 0.00000 93.0000 1

* PILE CROSS SECTIONS *

CROSS SECTION : 1
SECTION NAME : Section

TYPE : ELASTIC
CROSS SECTION TYPE : GENERAL SECTION
EQUIVALENT DIAMETER : 18.0000 IN
YOUNG MODULUS : 4.44000E+06 LBS/IN**2

* PILE CROSS SECTIONS PROPERTIES *

ELASTIC SECTIONS

SECT DIAM,IN AREA,IN**2 I,IN**4 Mn,LBS-IN Vn,LBS

1 18.0000 324.000 8600.00 0.00000 0.00000

* TABLE F * SOIL DATA

SOILS INFORMATION

GROUND SURFACE = 10.0000 FT

3 LAYER(S) OF SOIL

LAYER 1
THE SOIL IS A SOFT CLAY
TOP OF LAYER BOTTOM OF LAYER
X COORDINATE (FT) 10.0000 15.0000
EFFECTIVE UNIT WEIGHT (LBS/FT**3) 17.2800 17.2800
UNDRAINED COHESION, C (LBS/FT**2) 0.14400 0.14400
STRAIN AT 50% STRESS 0.0200000 0.0200000
ULTIMATE UNIT SIDE FRICTION (LBS/FT**2) 0.14400 0.14400
ULTIMATE UNIT TIP RESISTANCE (LBS/FT**2) 0.00000 0.00000

LAYER 2
THE SOIL IS A SOFT CLAY
TOP OF LAYER BOTTOM OF LAYER
X COORDINATE (FT) 15.0000 84.5000
EFFECTIVE UNIT WEIGHT (LBS/FT**3) 29.9981 29.9981
UNDRAINED COHESION, C (LBS/FT**2) 547.200 547.200

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-34

STRAIN AT 50% STRESS 0.0200000 0.0200000

ULTIMATE UNIT SIDE FRICTION (LBS/FT**2) 432.000 432.000
ULTIMATE UNIT TIP RESISTANCE (LBS/FT**2) 0.00000 0.00000

LAYER 3
THE SOIL IS A SOFT CLAY
TOP OF LAYER BOTTOM OF LAYER
X COORDINATE (FT) 84.5000 93.3333
EFFECTIVE UNIT WEIGHT (LBS/FT**3) 29.9981 29.9981
UNDRAINED COHESION, C (LBS/FT**2) 2160.00 2160.00
STRAIN AT 50% STRESS 0.0200000 0.0200000
ULTIMATE UNIT SIDE FRICTION (LBS/FT**2) 720.000 720.000
ULTIMATE UNIT TIP RESISTANCE (LBS/FT**2) 0.00000 0.00000

* DATA TO PRINT GENERATED P-Y CURVES *

NUMBER OF CURVES TO PRINT : 4

CURVE NUMBER PILE GROUP DEPTH (FT)

1 1 15.0000
2 1 21.0000
3 1 30.0000
4 1 93.0000

* TABLE H * AXIAL LOAD VS DISPLACEMENT

USER DEFINED AXIAL LOAD-DISPLACEMENT CURVES

NUM OF CURVES 1

CURVE 1 NUM OF POINTS 25

DISPLACEMENT, IN AXIAL LOAD,LBS

-10.0000 -3.60000E+05
-0.65000 -3.60000E+05
-0.58000 -3.54000E+05
-0.50000 -3.45000E+05
-0.40000 -3.30000E+05
-0.30000 -3.10000E+05
-0.19000 -2.80000E+05
-0.16000 -2.60000E+05
-0.14000 -2.40000E+05
-0.0600000 -1.20000E+05
-0.0400000 -80000.0
-0.0200000 -40000.0
0.00000 0.00000
0.0200000 40000.0
0.0400000 80000.0
0.0600000 1.20000E+05
0.14000 2.40000E+05
0.16000 2.60000E+05
0.19000 2.80000E+05
0.30000 3.10000E+05
0.40000 3.30000E+05
0.50000 3.45000E+05
0.58000 3.54000E+05
0.65000 3.60000E+05
10.0000 3.60000E+05

* TABLE J * MOMENT CURVATURE SETS

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-35

USER DEFINED MOMENT CURVATURE

NUM OF SETS : 1

CURVE SET 1 NUM OF CURVES 1

CURVE 1 AXIAL LOAD 0.000E+00 LBS

POINT MOMENT CURVATURE

LBS-IN RADIAN/IN
1 0.00000 0.00000

* TABLE N * PRINTED P-Y CURVES

* GENERATED P-Y CURVES *

NUMBER OF CURVES : 4

CURVE NUMBER = 1

PILE GROUP NUMBER = 1

DEPTH BELOW ORIGIN = 15.00 FT

NUMBER OF POINTS ON CURVE = 17

P-Y CURVE COMPUTED USING SOFT CLAY CRITERIA

DEPTH BELOW GS DIAM C GAMMA E50

FT IN LBS/FT**2 LBS/FT**3
5.00 18.000 0.5472E+03 0.1728E+02 0.2000E-01
EQ. DEPTH = 5.00 FT

Y,IN P,LBS/IN
0.00000 0.00000
1.80000E-03 20.7887
0.0180000 44.7879
0.0540000 64.5953
0.14400 89.5758
0.28800 112.858
0.43200 129.191
0.72000 153.172
1.08000 175.339
1.62000 200.713
2.16000 220.913
2.88000 243.146
3.60000 261.921
4.68000 285.859
5.76000 306.345
7.20000 330.000
8.64000 330.000

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-36

CURVE NUMBER = 2

PILE GROUP NUMBER = 1

DEPTH BELOW ORIGIN = 21.00 FT

NUMBER OF POINTS ON CURVE = 17

P-Y CURVE COMPUTED USING SOFT CLAY CRITERIA

DEPTH BELOW GS DIAM C GAMMA E50

FT IN LBS/FT**2 LBS/FT**3
11.00 18.000 0.5472E+03 0.2422E+02 0.2000E-01
EQ. DEPTH = 11.00 FT

Y,IN P,LBS/IN
0.00000 0.00000
1.80000E-03 30.8239
0.0180000 66.4080
0.0540000 95.7770
0.14400 132.816
0.28800 167.338
0.43200 191.554
0.72000 227.112
1.08000 259.979
1.62000 297.601
2.16000 327.553
2.88000 360.518
3.60000 388.357
4.68000 423.850
5.76000 454.225
7.20000 489.299
8.64000 489.299

CURVE NUMBER = 3

PILE GROUP NUMBER = 1

DEPTH BELOW ORIGIN = 30.00 FT

NUMBER OF POINTS ON CURVE = 17

P-Y CURVE COMPUTED USING SOFT CLAY CRITERIA

DEPTH BELOW GS DIAM C GAMMA E50

FT IN LBS/FT**2 LBS/FT**3
20.00 18.000 0.5472E+03 0.2682E+02 0.2000E-01
EQ. DEPTH = 20.00 FT

Y,IN P,LBS/IN
0.00000 0.00000
1.80000E-03 38.7804
0.0180000 83.5498
0.0540000 120.500
0.14400 167.100
0.28800 210.532
0.43200 240.999
0.72000 285.736
1.08000 327.086
1.62000 374.420
2.16000 412.103
2.88000 453.578
3.60000 488.602
4.68000 533.257

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-37

5.76000 571.472
7.20000 615.600
8.64000 615.600

CURVE NUMBER = 4

PILE GROUP NUMBER = 1

DEPTH BELOW ORIGIN = 93.00 FT

NUMBER OF POINTS ON CURVE = 17

P-Y CURVE COMPUTED USING SOFT CLAY CRITERIA

DEPTH BELOW GS DIAM C GAMMA E50

FT IN LBS/FT**2 LBS/FT**3
83.00 18.000 0.2160E+04 0.2923E+02 0.2000E-01
EQ. DEPTH = 83.00 FT

Y,IN P,LBS/IN
0.00000 0.00000
1.80000E-03 153.080
0.0180000 329.802
0.0540000 475.656
0.14400 659.603
0.28800 831.048
0.43200 951.313
0.72000 1127.91
1.08000 1291.13
1.62000 1477.98
2.16000 1626.72
2.88000 1790.44
3.60000 1928.69
4.68000 2104.96
5.76000 2255.81
7.20000 2430.00
8.64000 2430.00

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-38

1.3.4 Processor Run Notes

GROUP for Windows, Version 2016.10.8

-------------------------------------------------------------------------
Time and Date of Analysis
-------------------------------------------------------------------------

Date: May 09, 2016 Time: 18:14:12

EXAMPLE PROBLEM 2 - 2D, P-Y CURVES GENERATED INTERNALLY

READING * TITLE AND VERSION

READING * Analysis Parameters
READING * Pile Cap Dimensions
READING * Load Cases
READING * Load Combinations
READING * Distributed Load Sets
READING * Pile Group Configuration
READING * Pile Properties
READING * Pile Cross Sections
READING * Soil Layers
READING * Print py curves
READING * Generated LD curves
READING * User defined LD curves
READING * User defined MC curves
READING * Internally Generated MC curves

COMPUTATION IS PROCEEDING......

LOAD CASE : 1
CASE NAME : Load Case 1

GLOBAL ITERATIONS
STEP 1, TCUR 1.0000, DTCUR 1.0000
ITERATION 1
- ErrDsp 0.10000E+01, IncDsp 0.89651E-01, TotDsp 0.89651E-01
- ErrRot 0.10000E+01, IncRot 0.98326E-04, TotRot 0.98326E-04
ITERATION 2
- ErrDsp 0.27010E+00, IncDsp 0.30713E-01, TotDsp 0.11371E+00
- ErrRot 0.37710E-01, IncRot 0.38532E-05, TotRot 0.10218E-03
ITERATION 3
- ErrDsp 0.34217E-02, IncDsp 0.39007E-03, TotDsp 0.11400E+00
- ErrRot 0.40468E-02, IncRot 0.41184E-06, TotRot 0.10177E-03
ITERATION 4
- ErrDsp 0.99698E-06, IncDsp 0.11365E-06, TotDsp 0.11400E+00
- ErrRot 0.97144E-06, IncRot 0.98862E-10, TotRot 0.10177E-03

NUMBER OF GLOBAL ITERATIONS = 4

ANALYSIS FOR LOAD CASE 1/ 1 FINISHED

Execution Time : 65 ms
Number Processors : 1/ 1
Serial processing : 0.042 sec
Paral. processing : 0.003 sec
Print. processing : 0.020 sec

ANALYSIS COMPLETED

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-39

Execution Time : 80 ms
Number Processors : 1/ 1

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-40

1.3.5 Output Results File

=========================================================================

GROUP for Windows, Version 2016.10.8

Serial Number : 136089307

Analysis of A Group of Piles

Subjected to Axial and Lateral Loading

(c) Copyright ENSOFT, Inc., 1987-2015

All Rights Reserved

=========================================================================

This program is licensed to :

ENSOFT, INC
AUSTIN, TX

Path to file locations : C:\projects\GROUP2016\Group2016_1008\DXE\Examples_2016\

Name of input data file : 2Dexample2.gp10d
Name of output echo file : 2Dexample2.gp10e
Name of output results file : 2Dexample2.gp10o
Name of output summary file : 2Dexample2.gp10t
Name of plot output file : 2Dexample2.gp10p
Name of runtime file : 2Dexample2.gp10r

-------------------------------------------------------------------------
Time and Date of Analysis
-------------------------------------------------------------------------

Date: May 09, 2016 Time: 18:14:12

***** COMPUTATION RESULTS *****

EXAMPLE PROBLEM 2 - 2D, P-Y CURVES GENERATED INTERNALLY

***** LOAD CASES RESULTS *****

LOAD CASE : 1
CASE NAME : Load Case 1
LOAD TYPE : Special, Sp

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-41

* TABLE L * COMPUTATION ON PILE CAP

* EQUIVALENT CONCENTRATED LOAD AT ORIGIN *

VERT. LOAD, LBS HORI. LOAD, LBS MOMENT,LBS-IN

8.44000E+05 36400.0 -1.68168E+07

* DISPLACEMENT OF GROUPED PILE FOUNDATION AT ORIGIN *

VERTICAL,IN HORIZONTAL,IN ROTATION,RAD

0.0764671 0.0845477 -1.01768E-04

NUMBER OF ITERATIONS = 4

* TABLE M * COMPUTATION ON INDIVIDUAL PILE

* PILE GROUP * 1

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS AND REACTIONS *

THE GLOBAL STRUCTURAL COORDINATE SYSTEM

---------------------------------------

DISP.X,IN DISP.Y,IN SLOPE FOR.X, LB FOR.Y, LB BM, LB-IN STRESS, LB/IN**2

0.063644 0.084548 -1.0177E-04 8.0495E+04 -1.8063E+04 2.4953E+05 515.68

THE PILE COORDINATE SYSTEM (LOCAL AXES)

---------------------------------------

DISP.x,IN DISP.y,IN SLOPE AXIAL, LB LAT, LB BM, LB-IN STRESS,LBS/IN**2

0.041236 0.097460 -1.0177E-04 8.2472E+04 2001.4 2.4953E+05 515.68

* EFFECTS FOR LATERALLY LOADED PILE *

x DISPL. BENDING SHEAR SOIL TOTAL FLEXURAL

y-DIR MOMENT FORCE REACTION STRESS RIGIDITY
FT IN LBS-IN LBS LBS/IN LBS-IN**2 LBS-IN**2
********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
0.0000 9.7460E-02 -2.4953E+05 2010.0 0.0000 515.68 3.8184E+10
2.6571 9.0893E-02 -1.8517E+05 2001.4 0.0000 448.33 3.8184E+10
5.3143 7.9396E-02 -1.2040E+05 2001.4 0.0000 380.55 3.8184E+10
7.9714 6.4693E-02 -5.5375E+04 2001.4 0.0000 312.50 3.8184E+10
10.629 4.8515E-02 9775.6 2000.9 3.0399E-02 264.77 3.8184E+10
13.286 3.2598E-02 7.4874E+04 2000.0 2.6477E-02 332.90 3.8184E+10
15.943 1.8674E-02 1.3978E+05 1266.6 45.978 400.83 3.8184E+10
18.600 8.4718E-03 1.5764E+05 -126.83 41.422 419.51 3.8184E+10

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-42

21.257 2.4671E-03 1.3303E+05 -1264.3 29.925 393.76 3.8184E+10

23.914 4.5231E-06 7.7707E+04 -1746.2 0.3028 335.87 3.8184E+10
26.571 -3.8900E-04 2.1906E+04 -1234.7 -32.389 277.47 3.8184E+10
29.229 -1.9924E-04 -1013.7 -416.10 -18.957 255.61 3.8184E+10
31.886 -3.6474E-05 -4658.0 -7.4025 -6.6783 259.42 3.8184E+10
34.543 2.2669E-06 -1502.3 73.250 1.6194 256.12 3.8184E+10
37.200 1.0064E-06 10.167 24.128 1.4617 254.55 3.8184E+10
39.857 1.6599E-08 36.538 -0.1506 6.1163E-02 254.58 3.8184E+10
42.514 -2.8824E-10 0.6444 -0.5731 -3.4663E-02 254.54 3.8184E+10
45.171 -1.7233E-11 -9.5296E-03 -1.0115E-02 -6.5191E-04 254.54 3.8184E+10
47.829 3.1982E-14 -6.4962E-04 1.4947E-04 8.0954E-06 254.54 3.8184E+10
50.486 1.6544E-16 1.1887E-06 1.0187E-05 6.4128E-07 254.54 3.8184E+10
53.143 -1.0609E-19 6.2214E-09 -1.8640E-08 -1.1570E-09 254.54 3.8184E+10
55.800 -8.9206E-24 -3.9836E-12 -9.7557E-11 -6.1270E-12 254.54 3.8184E+10
58.457 5.7037E-27 -3.3546E-16 6.2467E-14 3.9175E-15 254.54 3.8184E+10
61.114 4.8100E-31 2.1418E-19 5.2603E-18 3.3037E-19 254.54 3.8184E+10
63.771 -3.0666E-34 1.8088E-23 -3.3585E-21 -2.1062E-22 254.54 3.8184E+10
66.429 -2.5935E-38 -1.1515E-26 -2.8364E-25 -1.7813E-26 254.54 3.8184E+10
69.086 1.6487E-41 -9.7529E-31 1.8057E-28 1.1324E-29 254.54 3.8184E+10
71.743 1.3984E-45 6.1911E-34 1.5293E-32 9.6049E-34 254.54 3.8184E+10
74.400 -8.8643E-49 5.2587E-38 -9.7082E-36 -6.0883E-37 254.54 3.8184E+10
77.057 0.0000 -3.3286E-41 -8.2461E-40 -5.1788E-41 254.54 3.8184E+10
79.714 0.0000 -2.8354E-45 5.2196E-43 3.2734E-44 254.54 3.8184E+10
82.371 0.0000 1.7896E-48 4.4462E-47 2.7924E-48 254.54 3.8184E+10
85.029 0.0000 0.0000 -2.8063E-50 0.0000 254.54 3.8184E+10
87.686 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 254.54 3.8184E+10
90.343 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 254.54 3.8184E+10
93.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 254.54 3.8184E+10

* PILE GROUP * 2

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS AND REACTIONS *

THE GLOBAL STRUCTURAL COORDINATE SYSTEM

---------------------------------------

DISP.X,IN DISP.Y,IN SLOPE FOR.X, LB FOR.Y, LB BM, LB-IN STRESS, LB/IN**2

0.067308 0.084548 -1.0177E-04 1.3096E+05 1757.5 2.1604E+05 630.29

THE PILE COORDINATE SYSTEM (LOCAL AXES)

---------------------------------------

DISP.x,IN DISP.y,IN SLOPE AXIAL, LB LAT, LB BM, LB-IN STRESS,LBS/IN**2

0.067308 0.084548 -1.0177E-04 1.3096E+05 1757.5 2.1604E+05 630.29

* EFFECTS FOR LATERALLY LOADED PILE *

x DISPL. BENDING SHEAR SOIL TOTAL FLEXURAL

y-DIR MOMENT FORCE REACTION STRESS RIGIDITY
FT IN LBS-IN LBS LBS/IN LBS-IN**2 LBS-IN**2
********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
0.0000 8.4548E-02 -2.1604E+05 1769.3 0.0000 630.29 3.8184E+10
2.6571 7.8427E-02 -1.5920E+05 1757.5 0.0000 570.81 3.8184E+10
5.3143 6.8066E-02 -1.0181E+05 1757.5 0.0000 510.74 3.8184E+10
7.9714 5.4996E-02 -4.4055E+04 1757.5 0.0000 450.31 3.8184E+10
10.629 4.0752E-02 1.3849E+04 1757.0 2.8683E-02 418.70 3.8184E+10
13.286 2.6877E-02 7.1676E+04 1756.2 2.4832E-02 479.21 3.8184E+10
15.943 1.4910E-02 1.2923E+05 1050.0 44.267 539.44 3.8184E+10

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-43

18.600 6.3846E-03 1.4132E+05 -280.78 39.207 552.10 3.8184E+10

21.257 1.6218E-03 1.1306E+05 -1346.0 27.606 522.52 3.8184E+10
23.914 -1.3060E-04 5.6340E+04 -1515.0 -17.007 463.16 3.8184E+10
26.571 -3.8286E-04 1.6713E+04 -905.67 -21.211 421.69 3.8184E+10
29.229 -1.9011E-04 -1407.6 -331.51 -14.803 405.68 3.8184E+10
31.886 -3.4834E-05 -4473.4 0.9757 -6.0520 408.89 3.8184E+10
34.543 1.3287E-06 -1370.5 69.837 1.7327 405.64 3.8184E+10
37.200 1.0015E-06 -24.435 22.049 1.2648 404.23 3.8184E+10
39.857 2.3600E-08 35.787 0.3966 9.3335E-02 404.24 3.8184E+10
42.514 -1.3970E-09 0.9903 -0.5620 -3.3205E-02 404.20 3.8184E+10
45.171 -2.7582E-11 -5.0393E-02 -1.5542E-02 -1.0719E-03 404.20 3.8184E+10
47.829 7.3471E-14 -1.0414E-03 7.9031E-04 4.7517E-05 404.20 3.8184E+10
50.486 5.2813E-16 2.7197E-06 1.6330E-05 1.0296E-06 404.20 3.8184E+10
53.143 -1.1263E-19 1.9843E-08 -4.2648E-08 -2.6360E-09 404.20 3.8184E+10
55.800 -9.6323E-23 -4.2228E-12 -3.1117E-10 -1.9526E-11 404.20 3.8184E+10
58.457 6.0368E-27 -3.6180E-15 6.6217E-14 4.1463E-15 404.20 3.8184E+10
61.114 5.1818E-30 2.2633E-19 5.6734E-17 3.5591E-18 404.20 3.8184E+10
63.771 -3.2356E-34 1.9464E-22 -3.5491E-21 -2.2223E-22 404.20 3.8184E+10
66.429 -2.7876E-37 -1.2131E-26 -3.0521E-24 -1.9146E-25 404.20 3.8184E+10
69.086 1.7342E-41 -1.0471E-29 1.9023E-28 1.1911E-29 404.20 3.8184E+10
71.743 1.4996E-44 6.5019E-34 1.6419E-31 1.0300E-32 404.20 3.8184E+10
74.400 -9.2948E-49 5.6328E-37 -1.0196E-35 -6.3840E-37 404.20 3.8184E+10
77.057 0.0000 -3.4848E-41 -8.8328E-39 -5.5409E-40 404.20 3.8184E+10
79.714 0.0000 -3.0302E-44 5.4645E-43 3.4216E-44 404.20 3.8184E+10
82.371 0.0000 1.8677E-48 4.7517E-46 2.9808E-47 404.20 3.8184E+10
85.029 0.0000 0.0000 -2.9287E-50 0.0000 404.20 3.8184E+10
87.686 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 404.20 3.8184E+10
90.343 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 404.20 3.8184E+10
93.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 404.20 3.8184E+10

* PILE GROUP * 3

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS AND REACTIONS *

THE GLOBAL STRUCTURAL COORDINATE SYSTEM

---------------------------------------

DISP.X,IN DISP.Y,IN SLOPE FOR.X, LB FOR.Y, LB BM, LB-IN STRESS, LB/IN**2

0.085626 0.084548 -1.0177E-04 1.5844E+05 1748.1 2.1600E+05 715.06

THE PILE COORDINATE SYSTEM (LOCAL AXES)

---------------------------------------

DISP.x,IN DISP.y,IN SLOPE AXIAL, LB LAT, LB BM, LB-IN STRESS,LBS/IN**2

0.085626 0.084548 -1.0177E-04 1.5844E+05 1748.1 2.1600E+05 715.06

* EFFECTS FOR LATERALLY LOADED PILE *

x DISPL. BENDING SHEAR SOIL TOTAL FLEXURAL

y-DIR MOMENT FORCE REACTION STRESS RIGIDITY
FT IN LBS-IN LBS LBS/IN LBS-IN**2 LBS-IN**2
********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
0.0000 8.4548E-02 -2.1600E+05 1762.4 0.0000 715.06 3.8184E+10
2.6571 7.8427E-02 -1.5929E+05 1748.1 0.0000 655.71 3.8184E+10
5.3143 6.8065E-02 -1.0191E+05 1748.1 0.0000 595.66 3.8184E+10
7.9714 5.4990E-02 -4.4101E+04 1748.1 0.0000 535.16 3.8184E+10
10.629 4.0740E-02 1.3896E+04 1747.6 2.8680E-02 503.55 3.8184E+10
13.286 2.6860E-02 7.1804E+04 1746.8 2.4827E-02 564.15 3.8184E+10

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-44

15.943 1.4893E-02 1.2938E+05 1040.9 44.249 624.41 3.8184E+10

18.600 6.3698E-03 1.4143E+05 -289.05 39.172 637.02 3.8184E+10
21.257 1.6128E-03 1.1306E+05 -1352.5 27.533 607.32 3.8184E+10
23.914 -1.3387E-04 5.6210E+04 -1516.6 -17.238 547.83 3.8184E+10
26.571 -3.8392E-04 1.6654E+04 -903.86 -21.198 506.44 3.8184E+10
29.229 -1.9053E-04 -1421.1 -330.49 -14.767 490.50 3.8184E+10
31.886 -3.4985E-05 -4476.9 1.1531 -6.0351 493.70 3.8184E+10
34.543 1.3568E-06 -1378.0 69.917 1.7220 490.45 3.8184E+10
37.200 1.0086E-06 -23.903 22.170 1.2730 489.04 3.8184E+10
39.857 2.4002E-08 36.026 0.3880 9.3245E-02 489.05 3.8184E+10
42.514 -1.3557E-09 1.0022 -0.5658 -3.3419E-02 489.01 3.8184E+10
45.171 -2.8063E-11 -4.8807E-02 -1.5729E-02 -1.0805E-03 489.01 3.8184E+10
47.829 7.4619E-14 -1.0596E-03 7.6545E-04 4.5922E-05 489.01 3.8184E+10
50.486 5.5433E-16 2.7608E-06 1.6615E-05 1.0476E-06 489.01 3.8184E+10
53.143 -1.2036E-19 2.0828E-08 -4.3294E-08 -2.6746E-09 489.01 3.8184E+10
55.800 -1.0449E-22 -4.5125E-12 -3.2660E-10 -2.0495E-11 489.01 3.8184E+10
58.457 6.4508E-27 -3.9248E-15 7.0760E-14 4.4307E-15 489.01 3.8184E+10
61.114 5.6211E-30 2.4185E-19 6.1544E-17 3.8608E-18 489.01 3.8184E+10
63.771 -3.4573E-34 2.1114E-22 -3.7925E-21 -2.3746E-22 489.01 3.8184E+10
66.429 -3.0239E-37 -1.2962E-26 -3.3108E-24 -2.0769E-25 489.01 3.8184E+10
69.086 1.8529E-41 -1.1358E-29 2.0326E-28 1.2727E-29 489.01 3.8184E+10
71.743 1.6267E-44 6.9469E-34 1.7811E-31 1.1173E-32 489.01 3.8184E+10
74.400 -9.9307E-49 6.1102E-37 -1.0893E-35 -6.8208E-37 489.01 3.8184E+10
77.057 0.0000 -3.7231E-41 -9.5815E-39 -6.0106E-40 489.01 3.8184E+10
79.714 0.0000 -3.2870E-44 5.8382E-43 3.6555E-44 489.01 3.8184E+10
82.371 0.0000 1.9953E-48 5.1544E-46 3.2335E-47 489.01 3.8184E+10
85.029 0.0000 0.0000 -3.1288E-50 0.0000 489.01 3.8184E+10
87.686 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 489.01 3.8184E+10
90.343 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 489.01 3.8184E+10
93.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 489.01 3.8184E+10

* PILE GROUP * 4

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS AND REACTIONS *

THE GLOBAL STRUCTURAL COORDINATE SYSTEM

---------------------------------------

DISP.X,IN DISP.Y,IN SLOPE FOR.X, LB FOR.Y, LB BM, LB-IN STRESS, LB/IN**2

0.089290 0.084548 -1.0177E-04 1.8470E+05 4.7451E+04 1.4566E+05 741.01

THE PILE COORDINATE SYSTEM (LOCAL AXES)

---------------------------------------

DISP.x,IN DISP.y,IN SLOPE AXIAL, LB LAT, LB BM, LB-IN STRESS,LBS/IN**2

0.1071 0.060365 -1.0177E-04 1.9070E+05 1233.6 1.4566E+05 741.01

* EFFECTS FOR LATERALLY LOADED PILE *

x DISPL. BENDING SHEAR SOIL TOTAL FLEXURAL

y-DIR MOMENT FORCE REACTION STRESS RIGIDITY
FT IN LBS-IN LBS LBS/IN LBS-IN**2 LBS-IN**2
********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
0.0000 6.0365E-02 -1.4566E+05 1245.2 0.0000 741.01 3.8184E+10
2.6571 5.5181E-02 -1.0534E+05 1233.6 0.0000 698.81 3.8184E+10
5.3143 4.7192E-02 -6.4483E+04 1233.6 0.0000 656.05 3.8184E+10
7.9714 3.7486E-02 -2.3297E+04 1233.6 0.0000 612.95 3.8184E+10
10.629 2.7160E-02 1.8006E+04 1233.2 2.5038E-02 607.41 3.8184E+10

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-45

13.286 1.7313E-02 5.9193E+04 1232.5 2.1411E-02 650.52 3.8184E+10

15.943 9.0420E-03 1.0006E+05 658.70 35.967 693.28 3.8184E+10
18.600 3.4354E-03 1.0385E+05 -397.91 30.308 697.25 3.8184E+10
21.257 5.9384E-04 7.6293E+04 -1158.6 17.407 668.41 3.8184E+10
23.914 -2.1634E-04 3.0655E+04 -1117.3 -20.002 620.65 3.8184E+10
26.571 -2.1030E-04 5197.0 -528.18 -16.947 594.01 3.8184E+10
29.229 -6.5885E-05 -3056.7 -115.74 -8.9224 591.77 3.8184E+10
31.886 -2.8572E-06 -2223.5 45.341 -1.1813 590.90 3.8184E+10
34.543 9.6764E-07 -177.99 35.382 1.8059 588.76 3.8184E+10
37.200 5.3245E-08 32.332 2.8198 0.2365 588.60 3.8184E+10
39.857 -2.5916E-10 2.0178 -0.5073 -2.7835E-02 588.57 3.8184E+10
42.514 -3.7814E-11 -6.8927E-03 -3.1662E-02 -1.9967E-03 588.57 3.8184E+10
45.171 8.7137E-15 -1.4208E-03 1.0820E-04 3.9914E-06 588.57 3.8184E+10
47.829 2.4518E-16 3.0884E-07 2.2280E-05 1.3981E-06 588.57 3.8184E+10
50.486 -1.0331E-20 9.2088E-09 -4.8437E-09 -2.8570E-10 588.57 3.8184E+10
53.143 -1.3188E-23 -3.8699E-13 -1.4440E-10 -9.0584E-12 588.57 3.8184E+10
55.800 5.5277E-28 -4.9536E-16 6.0685E-15 3.7966E-16 588.57 3.8184E+10
58.457 7.0943E-31 2.0707E-20 7.7677E-18 4.8726E-19 588.57 3.8184E+10
61.114 -2.9577E-35 2.6646E-23 -3.2471E-22 -2.0315E-23 588.57 3.8184E+10
63.771 -3.8161E-38 -1.1080E-27 -4.1784E-25 -2.6211E-26 588.57 3.8184E+10
66.429 1.5825E-42 -1.4333E-30 1.7374E-29 1.0869E-30 588.57 3.8184E+10
69.086 2.0528E-45 5.9281E-35 2.2476E-32 1.4099E-33 588.57 3.8184E+10
71.743 -8.4672E-50 7.7101E-38 -9.2959E-37 -5.8156E-38 588.57 3.8184E+10
74.400 0.0000 -3.1717E-42 -1.2090E-39 -7.5841E-41 588.57 3.8184E+10
77.057 0.0000 -4.1474E-45 4.9736E-44 3.1115E-45 588.57 3.8184E+10
79.714 0.0000 1.6969E-49 6.5035E-47 4.0796E-48 588.57 3.8184E+10
82.371 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 588.57 3.8184E+10
85.029 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 588.57 3.8184E+10
87.686 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 588.57 3.8184E+10
90.343 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 588.57 3.8184E+10
93.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 588.57 3.8184E+10

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-46

1.3.6 Summary Results File

=========================================================================

GROUP for Windows, Version 2016.10.8

Serial Number : 136089307

Analysis of A Group of Piles

Subjected to Axial and Lateral Loading

(c) Copyright ENSOFT, Inc., 1987-2015

All Rights Reserved

=========================================================================

-------------------------------------------------------------------------
Time and Date of Analysis
-------------------------------------------------------------------------

Date: May 09, 2016 Time: 18:14:12

***** COMPUTATION RESULTS *****

EXAMPLE PROBLEM 2 - 2D, P-Y CURVES GENERATED INTERNALLY

***** LOAD CASES RESULTS *****

LOAD CASE : 1
CASE NAME : Load Case 1
LOAD TYPE : Special, Sp

* TABLE L * COMPUTATION ON PILE CAP

* EQUIVALENT CONCENTRATED LOAD AT ORIGIN *

VERT. LOAD, LBS HORI. LOAD, LBS MOMENT,LBS-IN

8.44000E+05 36400.0 -1.68168E+07

* DISPLACEMENT OF GROUPED PILE FOUNDATION AT ORIGIN *

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-47

VERTICAL,IN HORIZONTAL,IN ROTATION,RAD

0.0764671 0.0845477 -1.01768E-04

* TABLE M * COMPUTATION ON INDIVIDUAL PILE

THE GLOBAL STRUCTURAL COORDINATE SYSTEM

---------------------------------------

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS *

PILE GROUP DISP. X,IN DISP. Y,IN ROT. Z,RAD

********** *********** *********** ***********
1 0.063644 0.084548 -1.0177E-04
2 0.067308 0.084548 -1.0177E-04
3 0.085626 0.084548 -1.0177E-04
4 0.089290 0.084548 -1.0177E-04

MINIMUM 0.063644 0.084548 -1.0177E-04

Pile G. 1 1 1
MAXIMUM 0.089290 0.084548 -1.0177E-04
Pile G. 4 1 1

* PILE TOP REACTIONS *

PILE GROUP FOR. X,LBS FOR. Y,LBS MOM Z,LBS-IN STRESS,LBS/IN**2

********** *********** *********** ************ ****************
1 8.0495E+04 -1.8063E+04 2.4953E+05 515.68
2 1.3096E+05 1757.5 2.1604E+05 630.29
3 1.5844E+05 1748.1 2.1600E+05 715.06
4 1.8470E+05 4.7451E+04 1.4566E+05 741.01

MINIMUM 8.0495E+04 -1.8063E+04 1.4566E+05 515.68

Pile G. 1 1 4 1
MAXIMUM 1.8470E+05 4.7451E+04 2.4953E+05 741.01
Pile G. 4 4 1 4

THE PILE COORDINATE SYSTEM (LOCAL AXES)

---------------------------------------

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS *

PILE GROUP DISP. x,IN DISP. y,IN ROT. z,RAD

********** *********** *********** ***********
1 0.041236 0.097460 -1.0177E-04
2 0.067308 0.084548 -1.0177E-04
3 0.085626 0.084548 -1.0177E-04
4 0.1071 0.060365 -1.0177E-04

MINIMUM 0.041236 0.060365 -1.0177E-04

Pile G. 1 4 1
MAXIMUM 0.1071 0.097460 -1.0177E-04
Pile G. 4 1 1

* PILE TOP REACTIONS *

PILE GROUP AXIAL,LBS LAT. y,LBS MOM z,LBS-IN STRESS,LBS/IN**2

********** *********** *********** ************ ****************
1 8.2472E+04 2001.4 2.4953E+05 515.68
2 1.3096E+05 1757.5 2.1604E+05 630.29
3 1.5844E+05 1748.1 2.1600E+05 715.06
4 1.9070E+05 1233.6 1.4566E+05 741.01

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-48

MINIMUM 8.2472E+04 1233.6 1.4566E+05 515.68

Pile G. 1 4 4 1
MAXIMUM 1.9070E+05 2001.4 2.4953E+05 741.01
Pile G. 4 1 1 4

* EFFECTS FOR LATERALLY LOADED PILE *

* MINIMUM VALUES AND LOCATIONS *

PILE DISPL. BENDING SHEAR SOIL TOTAL FLEXURAL

y-DIR MOMENT FORCE REACTION STRESS RIGIDITY
IN LBS-IN LBS LBS/IN LBS-IN**2 LBS-IN**2
****** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
1 -3.8900E-04 -2.4953E+05 -1746.2 -32.389 254.54 3.8184E+10
x(FT) 26.571 0.0000 23.914 26.571 55.800 0.0000
2 -3.8286E-04 -2.1604E+05 -1515.0 -21.211 404.20 3.8184E+10
x(FT) 26.571 0.0000 23.914 26.571 55.800 0.0000
3 -3.8392E-04 -2.1600E+05 -1516.6 -21.198 489.01 3.8184E+10
x(FT) 26.571 0.0000 23.914 26.571 55.800 0.0000
4 -2.1634E-04 -1.4566E+05 -1158.6 -20.002 588.57 3.8184E+10
x(FT) 23.914 0.0000 21.257 23.914 53.143 0.0000

Min. -3.8900E-04 -2.4953E+05 -1746.2 -32.389 254.54 3.8184E+10

Pile N. 1 1 1 1 1 1

* MAXIMUM VALUES AND LOCATIONS *

PILE DISPL. BENDING SHEAR SOIL TOTAL FLEXURAL

y-DIR MOMENT FORCE REACTION STRESS RIGIDITY
IN LBS-IN LBS LBS/IN LBS-IN**2 LBS-IN**2
****** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
1 0.097460 1.5764E+05 2010.0 45.978 515.68 3.8184E+10
x(FT) 0.0000 18.600 0.0000 15.943 0.0000 0.0000
2 0.084548 1.4132E+05 1769.3 44.267 630.29 3.8184E+10
x(FT) 0.0000 18.600 0.0000 15.943 0.0000 0.0000
3 0.084548 1.4143E+05 1762.4 44.249 715.06 3.8184E+10
x(FT) 0.0000 18.600 0.0000 15.943 0.0000 0.0000
4 0.060365 1.0385E+05 1245.2 35.967 741.01 3.8184E+10
x(FT) 0.0000 18.600 0.0000 15.943 0.0000 0.0000

Max. 0.097460 1.5764E+05 2010.0 45.978 741.01 3.8184E+10

Pile N. 1 1 1 1 4 1

***** SUMMARY FOR LOAD CASES AND COMBINATIONS *****

***** LOAD CASES RESULTS *****

LOAD CASE : 1

* EQUIVALENT CONCENTRATED LOAD AT ORIGIN *

LOAD X,LBS LOAD Y,LBS MOM Z,LBS-IN
8.44000E+05 36400.0 -1.68168E+07

* DISPLACEMENT OF GROUPED PILE FOUNDATION AT ORIGIN *

DISP X,IN DISP Y,IN ROT Z,RAD
0.0764671 0.0845477 -1.01768E-04

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS, GLOBAL *

DISP. X,IN DISP. Y,IN ROT. Z,RAD
*********** *********** ***********

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-49

MINIMUM 0.063644 0.084548 -1.0177E-04

Pile G. 1 1 1
MAXIMUM 0.089290 0.084548 -1.0177E-04
Pile G. 4 1 1

* PILE TOP REACTIONS, GLOBAL *

FOR. X,LBS FOR. Y,LBS MOM Z,LBS-IN STRESS,LBS/IN**2
*********** *********** ************ ****************
MINIMUM 8.0495E+04 -1.8063E+04 1.4566E+05 515.68
Pile G. 1 1 4 1
MAXIMUM 1.8470E+05 4.7451E+04 2.4953E+05 741.01
Pile G. 4 4 1 4

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS, LOCAL *

DISP. x,IN DISP. y,IN ROT. z,RAD
*********** *********** ***********
MINIMUM 0.041236 0.060365 -1.0177E-04
Pile G. 1 4 1
MAXIMUM 0.1071 0.097460 -1.0177E-04
Pile G. 4 1 1

* PILE TOP REACTIONS, LOCAL *

AXIAL,LBS LAT. y,LBS MOM z,LBS-IN STRESS,LBS/IN**2
*********** *********** ************ ****************
MINIMUM 8.2472E+04 1233.6 1.4566E+05 515.68
Pile G. 1 4 4 1
MAXIMUM 1.9070E+05 2001.4 2.4953E+05 741.01
Pile G. 4 1 1 4

* EFFECTS FOR LATERALLY LOADED PILE *

PILE DISPL. BENDING SHEAR SOIL TOTAL FLEXURAL

y-DIR MOMENT FORCE REACTION STRESS RIGIDITY
IN LBS-IN LBS LBS/IN LBS-IN**2 LBS-IN**2
****** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
Min. -3.8900E-04 -2.4953E+05 -1746.2 -32.389 254.54 3.8184E+10
Pile N. 1 1 1 1 1 1
Max. 0.097460 1.5764E+05 2010.0 45.978 741.01 3.8184E+10
Pile N. 1 1 1 1 4 1

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-50

1.3.7 Graphs

Figure 1.7 Curves Deflection vs. Distance for Example Problem 2 - 2D.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-51

Figure 1.8 Curves Moment vs. Distance for Example Problem 2 - 2D.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-52

Figure 1.9 Internally Generated p-y Curves for Example Problem 2 - 2D.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-53

1.4 Example Problem 3 - 2D

1.4.1 Model Description

This example serves the purpose of demonstrating the various input/outputs in the program.
Users may find it helpful if there are uncertainties for the input parameters.

The loads and the geometric configuration of the foundation in this example are the same as
those in Example 2 - 2D. In this example, subgroups 1 and 4 have pile tops which are elastically
restrained instead of fixed to the pile cap. Rotational stiffness of the springs is assumed to be 5.5 x 106
lbs-in/rad. Two curves of axial versus displacement and two types of piles are used. Pile type 1 has the
same dimensions and properties as those in Example 2 - 2D. Pile type 2 has two uniform sections. From
0 to 500 in the pile has the same dimensions as pile type 1. From 500 to 1116 in, the diameter of pile is
reduced to 9 in, the moment of inertia is equal to 538 in4, and the area of the cross section is 81 in2.

A distributed load curve is used to represent loads applied along the piles.

The input and output files for the example problem are shown in the following pages.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-54

1.4.2 Input Data

EXAMPLE PROBLEM 3 - 2D , 2 PILE TYPES, DIST LOAD,2 L-S CURVES,RES HEAD

GROUP2016.10.8
* Analysis Parameters
1 2 0 0 0 1 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 1
* Pile Cap Dimensions
0 0 0 0 0 0
* Load Cases
1 0 0 1 0
0 1 1 1 1 50 50
0.001 0.001 1 1
Load Case 1
12 0 0 0 1 1 0 0
2 1 1 0 1E-7 1E-5 0 0 0
1
0 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 0 1 1 0 1 1 0 0 1 1 1 0 0 1 1
1
844000 36400 0 0 0 0 -38.5 0 0
1
1 0 1 4 1 1 1 0 0
0
* Load Combinations
0 0 0 1 0
* Distributed Load Sets
1
2
0 0
10 50
* Pile Group Configuration
4
3 1 2 0 2 0 0
550000 0 1 1 1
0 -10.5 -14.037466 10
2 2 1 0 1 0 0
0 0 1 1 1
0 -7.5 0 10
2 2 1 0 1 0 0
0 0 1 1 1
0 7.5 0 10
3 1 2 0 2 0 0
550000 0 1 1 1
0 10.5 14.037466 10
* Pile Properties
2
0 1
44 93 1
0 93 1
1 2
35 93 1
0 41.666667 3
41.666667 93 2
* Pile Cross Sections
3
0 0 0 0
Section 1
18 0 1 1 0 0 0.1 0.1
1 324 8600 8600 0 0 0 0 5440000 0 0
0 0 0 0 1
None
1 0 0 0
Section 2
9 0 1 1 0 0 0.1 0.1
1 81 538 538 0 0 0 0 4440000 0 0
0 0 0 0 1
None
2 2 0 0

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-55

Section 1
18 0 1 1 0 0 0.1 0.1
1 324 8600 8600 0 0 0 0 4440000 0 0
0 0 0 0 1
None
* Soil Layers
3
0 1
10 15
2 10
17.28 0.144 0 10 0 0.02 0 0.144 0 0
17.28 0.144 0 10 0 0.02 0 0.144 0 0
1 1
15 84.5
2 10
29.99808 547.2 0 40 0 0.02 0 432 0 0
29.99808 547.2 0 40 0 0.02 0 432 0 0
2 1
84.5 93.333333
2 10
29.99808 2160 0 500 0 0.02 0 720 0 0
29.99808 2160 0 500 0 0.02 0 720 0 0
* Generated LD curves
0
* User defined LD curves
2
0 12
0 -20
-13.333333 -1E-5
0 0
40000 0.03
80000 0.04
100000 0.05
120000 0.06
240000 0.14
260000 0.16
280000 0.19
360000 0.65
360000 10
1 6
0 -20
-8 -1E-5
0 0
40000 0.05
120000 0.12
250000 10
* User defined MC curves
1
1 1
0
1 1
0 0
* Internally Generated MC curves
3
1 1
0
0
1 1
0 0
2 1
0
0
1 1
0 0
3 1
0
0
1 1
0 0
* End of file

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-56

1.4.3 Echo Print File

=========================================================================

GROUP for Windows, Version 2016.10.8

Serial Number : 136089307

Analysis of A Group of Piles

Subjected to Axial and Lateral Loading

(c) Copyright ENSOFT, Inc., 1987-2015

All Rights Reserved

=========================================================================

This program is licensed to :

ENSOFT, INC
AUSTIN, TX

Path to file locations : C:\projects\GROUP2016\Group2016_1008\DXE\Examples_2016\

Name of input data file : 2Dexample3.gp10r
Name of output echo file : 2Dexample3.gp10e
Name of output results file : 2Dexample3.gp10o
Name of output summary file : 2Dexample3.gp10t
Name of plot output file : 2Dexample3.gp10p
Name of runtime file : 2Dexample3.gp10r

-------------------------------------------------------------------------
Time and Date of Analysis
-------------------------------------------------------------------------

Date: May 09, 2016 Time: 18:14:12

***** INPUT INFORMATION *****

EXAMPLE PROBLEM 3 - 2D , 2 PILE TYPES, DIST LOAD,2 L-S CURVES,RES HEAD

ANALYSIS TYPE = 2D ANALYSIS

ADJUST DEPTH FOR BATTER PILES

GENERATE LOAD-DISP (AND T-R) CURVES BASED ON SOIL PROFILE

EXTEND INTERPOLATION FOR L-DP (AND T-R) CURVES

UNITS SYSTEM = ENGL

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-57

* TABLE C * LOAD AND CONTROL PARAMETERS

** LOAD CASES **

NUMBER OF LOAD CASES : 1

LOAD CASE : 1
CASE NAME : Load Case 1
LOAD TYPE : Special, Sp
SCALE FACTOR : 1.0000

* CONCENTRATED LOADS *

NL VERT.LOAD HOR.LOAD MOMENT COORD X COORD Y

LBS LBS LBS-IN FT FT
1 8.44000E+05 36400.0 0.00000 -38.5000 0.00000

* EQUIVALENT CONCENTRATED LOAD AT ORIGIN *

VER.LOAD X,LBS HOR.LOAD Y,LBS MOMENT,LBS-IN

8.44000E+05 36400.0 -1.68168E+07

* DISTRIBUTED LOADS *

NL AXIS INI_PILE END_PILE INC_PILE SET_Y FACTOR_Y

1 LOCAL 1 4 1 1 1.0000

* THE LOADING IS STATIC *

* CONTROL PARAMETERS *
TOLERANCE ON CONVERGENCE OF PILE CAP MOVEMENT = 1.00000E-03
TOLERANCE ON DETERMINATION OF PILE DEFLECTIONS = 1.00000E-03 IN
MAX NO OF ITERATIONS ALLOWED FOR FOUNDATION ANALYSIS = 50
MAXIMUM NO OF ITERATIONS ALLOWED FOR PILE ANALYSIS = 50
FACTOR TO APPLY THE LOAD IN INCREMENTS = 1.0000
MINIMUM FACTOR FOR LOAD INCREMENTS = 1.0000
PRINT RESULTS AT PILE CAP, PILE HEADS AND ALONG PILES
PRINT RESULTS EVERY 1 NODE(S)

** SETS OF DISTRIBUTED LOAD **

NUMBER OF SETS : 1

DIST. LOAD SET : 1

NL DEPTH LOAD
(FT) (LBS)
1 0.0000 0.0000
2 10.000 50.000

* TABLE D * ARRANGEMENT OF PILE GROUPS

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-58

GROUP CONNECT NO OF PILE PILE PROP P-Y CURVE L-S CURVE R-F-L SET
1 RES 1 2 0 2 U 0
2 FIX 2 1 0 1 U 0
3 FIX 2 1 0 1 U 0
4 RES 1 2 0 2 U 0

GROUP VERT,FT HOR,FT SLOPE,IN/IN GROUND,FT SPRING,LBS-IN SPACING,FT

1 0.00000 -10.5000 -0.25002 10.0000 5.50000E+05 0.00000
2 0.00000 -7.50000 0.00000 10.0000 0.00000 0.00000
3 0.00000 7.50000 0.00000 10.0000 0.00000 0.00000
4 0.00000 10.5000 0.25002 10.0000 5.50000E+05 0.00000

* TABLE E * PILE GEOMETRY AND PROPERTIES

PILE TYPE = 1 - DRIVEN PILE
= 2 - DRILLED SHAFT

PROP SECTS INC PILE TYPE LENGTH, FT

1 1 44 1 93.000
2 2 35 1 93.000

* PILE SECTIONS *

PROP SECT FROM,FT TO,FT CROSS SECT

1 1 0.00000 93.0000 1
2 1 0.00000 41.6667 3
2 2 41.6667 93.0000 2

* PILE CROSS SECTIONS *

CROSS SECTION : 1
SECTION NAME : Section

TYPE : ELASTIC
CROSS SECTION TYPE : GENERAL SECTION
EQUIVALENT DIAMETER : 18.0000 IN
YOUNG MODULUS : 5.44000E+06 LBS/IN**2

CROSS SECTION : 2
SECTION NAME : Section

TYPE : ELASTIC
CROSS SECTION TYPE : GENERAL SECTION
EQUIVALENT DIAMETER : 9.00000 IN
YOUNG MODULUS : 4.44000E+06 LBS/IN**2

CROSS SECTION : 3
SECTION NAME : Section

TYPE : ELASTIC
CROSS SECTION TYPE : GENERAL SECTION
EQUIVALENT DIAMETER : 18.0000 IN
YOUNG MODULUS : 4.44000E+06 LBS/IN**2

* PILE CROSS SECTIONS PROPERTIES *

ELASTIC SECTIONS

SECT DIAM,IN AREA,IN**2 I,IN**4 Mn,LBS-IN Vn,LBS

1 18.0000 324.000 8600.00 0.00000 0.00000
2 9.00000 81.0000 538.000 0.00000 0.00000
3 18.0000 324.000 8600.00 0.00000 0.00000

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-59

* TABLE F * SOIL DATA

SOILS INFORMATION

GROUND SURFACE = 10.0000 FT

3 LAYER(S) OF SOIL

LAYER 1
THE SOIL IS A SOFT CLAY
TOP OF LAYER BOTTOM OF LAYER
X COORDINATE (FT) 10.0000 15.0000
EFFECTIVE UNIT WEIGHT (LBS/FT**3) 17.2800 17.2800
UNDRAINED COHESION, C (LBS/FT**2) 0.14400 0.14400
STRAIN AT 50% STRESS 0.0200000 0.0200000
ULTIMATE UNIT SIDE FRICTION (LBS/FT**2) 0.14400 0.14400
ULTIMATE UNIT TIP RESISTANCE (LBS/FT**2) 0.00000 0.00000

LAYER 2
THE SOIL IS A SOFT CLAY
TOP OF LAYER BOTTOM OF LAYER
X COORDINATE (FT) 15.0000 84.5000
EFFECTIVE UNIT WEIGHT (LBS/FT**3) 29.9981 29.9981
UNDRAINED COHESION, C (LBS/FT**2) 547.200 547.200
STRAIN AT 50% STRESS 0.0200000 0.0200000
ULTIMATE UNIT SIDE FRICTION (LBS/FT**2) 432.000 432.000
ULTIMATE UNIT TIP RESISTANCE (LBS/FT**2) 0.00000 0.00000

LAYER 3
THE SOIL IS A SOFT CLAY
TOP OF LAYER BOTTOM OF LAYER
X COORDINATE (FT) 84.5000 93.3333
EFFECTIVE UNIT WEIGHT (LBS/FT**3) 29.9981 29.9981
UNDRAINED COHESION, C (LBS/FT**2) 2160.00 2160.00
STRAIN AT 50% STRESS 0.0200000 0.0200000
ULTIMATE UNIT SIDE FRICTION (LBS/FT**2) 720.000 720.000
ULTIMATE UNIT TIP RESISTANCE (LBS/FT**2) 0.00000 0.00000

* TABLE H * AXIAL LOAD VS DISPLACEMENT

USER DEFINED AXIAL LOAD-DISPLACEMENT CURVES

NUM OF CURVES 2

CURVE 1 NUM OF POINTS 12

DISPLACEMENT, IN AXIAL LOAD,LBS

-20.0000 0.00000
-1.00000E-05 -13.3333
0.00000 0.00000
0.0300000 40000.0
0.0400000 80000.0
0.0500000 1.00000E+05
0.0600000 1.20000E+05
0.14000 2.40000E+05
0.16000 2.60000E+05
0.19000 2.80000E+05
0.65000 3.60000E+05
10.0000 3.60000E+05

CURVE 2 NUM OF POINTS 6

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-60

DISPLACEMENT, IN AXIAL LOAD,LBS

-20.0000 0.00000
-1.00000E-05 -8.00000
0.00000 0.00000
0.0500000 40000.0
0.12000 1.20000E+05
10.0000 2.50000E+05

* TABLE J * MOMENT CURVATURE SETS

USER DEFINED MOMENT CURVATURE

NUM OF SETS : 1

CURVE SET 1 NUM OF CURVES 1

CURVE 1 AXIAL LOAD 0.000E+00 LBS

POINT MOMENT CURVATURE

LBS-IN RADIAN/IN
1 0.00000 0.00000

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-61

1.4.4 Processor Run Notes

GROUP for Windows, Version 2016.10.8

-------------------------------------------------------------------------
Time and Date of Analysis
-------------------------------------------------------------------------

Date: May 09, 2016 Time: 18:14:12

EXAMPLE PROBLEM 3 - 2D , 2 PILE TYPES, DIST LOAD,2 L-S CURVES,RES HEAD

READING * TITLE AND VERSION

READING * Analysis Parameters
READING * Pile Cap Dimensions
READING * Load Cases
READING * Load Combinations
READING * Distributed Load Sets
READING * Pile Group Configuration
READING * Pile Properties
READING * Pile Cross Sections
READING * Soil Layers
READING * Generated LD curves
READING * User defined LD curves
READING * User defined MC curves
READING * Internally Generated MC curves

COMPUTATION IS PROCEEDING......

LOAD CASE : 1
CASE NAME : Load Case 1

GLOBAL ITERATIONS
STEP 1, TCUR 1.0000, DTCUR 1.0000
ITERATION 1
- ErrDsp 0.10000E+01, IncDsp 0.19748E+00, TotDsp 0.19748E+00
- ErrRot 0.10000E+01, IncRot 0.17776E-03, TotRot 0.17776E-03
ITERATION 2
- ErrDsp 0.14301E+00, IncDsp 0.26723E-01, TotDsp 0.18686E+00
- ErrRot 0.13456E+00, IncRot 0.21081E-04, TotRot 0.15667E-03
ITERATION 3
- ErrDsp 0.36889E+00, IncDsp 0.10378E+00, TotDsp 0.28133E+00
- ErrRot 0.24125E+00, IncRot 0.30451E-04, TotRot 0.12622E-03
ITERATION 4
- ErrDsp 0.19938E-01, IncDsp 0.57170E-02, TotDsp 0.28674E+00
- ErrRot 0.16677E-01, IncRot 0.20705E-05, TotRot 0.12415E-03
ITERATION 5
- ErrDsp 0.39793E-04, IncDsp 0.11410E-04, TotDsp 0.28675E+00
- ErrRot 0.39767E-04, IncRot 0.49370E-08, TotRot 0.12415E-03

NUMBER OF GLOBAL ITERATIONS = 5

ANALYSIS FOR LOAD CASE 1/ 1 FINISHED

Execution Time : 66 ms
Number Processors : 1/ 1
Serial processing : 0.039 sec
Paral. processing : 0.006 sec
Print. processing : 0.022 sec

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-62

ANALYSIS COMPLETED
Execution Time : 67 ms
Number Processors : 1/ 1

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-63

1.4.5 Output Results File

=========================================================================

GROUP for Windows, Version 2016.10.8

Serial Number : 136089307

Analysis of A Group of Piles

Subjected to Axial and Lateral Loading

(c) Copyright ENSOFT, Inc., 1987-2015

All Rights Reserved

=========================================================================

This program is licensed to :

ENSOFT, INC
AUSTIN, TX

Path to file locations : C:\projects\GROUP2016\Group2016_1008\DXE\Examples_2016\

Name of input data file : 2Dexample3.gp10d
Name of output echo file : 2Dexample3.gp10e
Name of output results file : 2Dexample3.gp10o
Name of output summary file : 2Dexample3.gp10t
Name of plot output file : 2Dexample3.gp10p
Name of runtime file : 2Dexample3.gp10r

-------------------------------------------------------------------------
Time and Date of Analysis
-------------------------------------------------------------------------

Date: May 09, 2016 Time: 18:14:12

***** COMPUTATION RESULTS *****

EXAMPLE PROBLEM 3 - 2D , 2 PILE TYPES, DIST LOAD,2 L-S CURVES,RES HEAD

***** LOAD CASES RESULTS *****

LOAD CASE : 1
CASE NAME : Load Case 1
LOAD TYPE : Special, Sp

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-64

* TABLE L * COMPUTATION ON PILE CAP

* EQUIVALENT CONCENTRATED LOAD AT ORIGIN *

VERT. LOAD, LBS HORI. LOAD, LBS MOMENT,LBS-IN

8.44000E+05 36400.0 -1.68168E+07

* DISPLACEMENT OF GROUPED PILE FOUNDATION AT ORIGIN *

VERTICAL,IN HORIZONTAL,IN ROTATION,RAD

0.0991002 0.26908 -1.24148E-04

NUMBER OF ITERATIONS = 5

* TABLE M * COMPUTATION ON INDIVIDUAL PILE

* PILE GROUP * 1

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS AND REACTIONS *

THE GLOBAL STRUCTURAL COORDINATE SYSTEM

---------------------------------------

DISP.X,IN DISP.Y,IN SLOPE FOR.X, LB FOR.Y, LB BM, LB-IN STRESS, LB/IN**2

0.083457 0.2691 -1.2415E-04 1.2188E+04 -3032.6 665.74 39.459

THE PILE COORDINATE SYSTEM (LOCAL AXES)

---------------------------------------

DISP.x,IN DISP.y,IN SLOPE AXIAL, LB LAT, LB BM, LB-IN STRESS,LBS/IN**2

0.015699 0.2813 -1.2415E-04 1.2559E+04 14.083 665.74 39.459

* EFFECTS FOR LATERALLY LOADED PILE *

x DISPL. BENDING SHEAR SOIL TOTAL FLEXURAL

y-DIR MOMENT FORCE REACTION STRESS RIGIDITY
FT IN LBS-IN LBS LBS/IN LBS-IN**2 LBS-IN**2
********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
0.0000 0.2813 -665.74 14.086 0.0000 39.459 3.8184E+10
2.6571 0.2387 317.85 225.89 0.0000 39.095 3.8184E+10
5.3143 0.1962 1.4809E+04 861.33 0.0000 54.260 3.8184E+10
7.9714 0.1540 5.6310E+04 1920.4 0.0000 97.692 3.8184E+10
10.629 0.1133 1.3832E+05 2555.2 4.0428E-02 183.51 3.8184E+10
13.286 7.6367E-02 2.2023E+05 2554.0 3.5346E-02 269.24 3.8184E+10
15.943 4.5253E-02 3.0204E+05 1557.9 62.445 354.85 3.8184E+10
18.600 2.2181E-02 3.2026E+05 -370.38 58.503 373.92 3.8184E+10
21.257 7.6360E-03 2.7889E+05 -2045.9 46.591 330.63 3.8184E+10
23.914 5.1729E-04 1.9006E+05 -3044.5 16.049 237.67 3.8184E+10

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-65

26.571 -1.5407E-03 8.4856E+04 -2668.7 -39.622 127.57 3.8184E+10

29.229 -1.3394E-03 1.9901E+04 -1477.3 -35.109 59.590 3.8184E+10
31.886 -6.0810E-04 -9363.8 -520.03 -24.932 48.562 3.8184E+10
34.543 -1.2615E-04 -1.3277E+04 73.512 -12.297 52.657 3.8184E+10
37.200 2.2741E-06 -4683.5 202.79 4.1882 43.664 3.8184E+10
39.857 5.9949E-06 -346.50 73.626 3.9135 39.125 3.8184E+10
42.514 4.8955E-07 11.784 5.4504 0.3628 155.15 2.3887E+09
45.171 -3.2657E-10 1.1517 -0.1849 -9.3300E-03 155.06 2.3887E+09
47.829 -8.5457E-12 -7.2711E-04 -1.8060E-02 -1.1342E-03 155.05 2.3887E+09
50.486 3.7571E-17 -2.0078E-05 1.1403E-05 6.7578E-07 155.05 2.3887E+09
53.143 4.5643E-20 8.8058E-11 3.1485E-07 1.9749E-08 155.05 2.3887E+09
55.800 -1.9969E-25 1.0724E-13 -1.3808E-12 -8.6401E-14 155.05 2.3887E+09
58.457 -2.4378E-28 -4.6802E-19 -1.6816E-15 -1.0548E-16 155.05 2.3887E+09
61.114 1.0613E-33 -5.7275E-22 7.3391E-21 4.5921E-22 155.05 2.3887E+09
63.771 1.3020E-36 2.4874E-27 8.9813E-24 5.6335E-25 155.05 2.3887E+09
66.429 -5.6406E-42 3.0591E-30 -3.9005E-29 -2.4406E-30 155.05 2.3887E+09
69.086 -6.9539E-45 -1.3220E-35 -4.7969E-32 -3.0088E-33 155.05 2.3887E+09
71.743 2.9977E-50 -1.6338E-38 2.0730E-37 1.2971E-38 155.05 2.3887E+09
74.400 0.0000 7.0256E-44 2.5620E-40 1.6070E-41 155.05 2.3887E+09
77.057 0.0000 8.7262E-47 -1.1017E-45 -6.8931E-47 155.05 2.3887E+09
79.714 0.0000 0.0000 -1.3684E-48 -8.5830E-50 155.05 2.3887E+09
82.371 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 155.05 2.3887E+09
85.029 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 155.05 2.3887E+09
87.686 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 155.05 2.3887E+09
90.343 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 155.05 2.3887E+09
93.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 155.05 2.3887E+09

* PILE GROUP * 2

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS AND REACTIONS *

THE GLOBAL STRUCTURAL COORDINATE SYSTEM

---------------------------------------

DISP.X,IN DISP.Y,IN SLOPE FOR.X, LB FOR.Y, LB BM, LB-IN STRESS, LB/IN**2

0.087927 0.2691 -1.2415E-04 1.6189E+05 2624.7 6.1238E+05 1140.5

THE PILE COORDINATE SYSTEM (LOCAL AXES)

---------------------------------------

DISP.x,IN DISP.y,IN SLOPE AXIAL, LB LAT, LB BM, LB-IN STRESS,LBS/IN**2

0.087927 0.2691 -1.2415E-04 1.6189E+05 2624.7 6.1238E+05 1140.5

* EFFECTS FOR LATERALLY LOADED PILE *

x DISPL. BENDING SHEAR SOIL TOTAL FLEXURAL

y-DIR MOMENT FORCE REACTION STRESS RIGIDITY
FT IN LBS-IN LBS LBS/IN LBS-IN**2 LBS-IN**2
********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
0.0000 0.2691 -6.1238E+05 2651.6 0.0000 1140.5 4.6784E+10
2.1136 0.2617 -5.4462E+05 2758.7 0.0000 1069.6 4.6784E+10
4.2273 0.2469 -4.6884E+05 3160.8 0.0000 990.31 4.6784E+10
6.3409 0.2256 -3.7843E+05 3830.9 0.0000 895.69 4.6784E+10
8.4545 0.1991 -2.6677E+05 4769.1 0.0000 778.84 4.6784E+10
10.568 0.1689 -1.2733E+05 5304.6 4.6296E-02 632.91 4.6784E+10
12.682 0.1370 1.2366E+04 5303.5 4.3134E-02 512.60 4.6784E+10
14.795 0.1052 1.5201E+05 5302.4 3.9451E-02 658.74 4.6784E+10
16.909 7.5586E-02 2.9128E+05 4251.2 82.852 804.49 4.6784E+10

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-66

19.023 4.9934E-02 3.7661E+05 2153.9 82.530 893.79 4.6784E+10

21.136 2.9460E-02 4.0801E+05 121.95 77.693 926.65 4.6784E+10
23.250 1.4597E-02 3.8852E+05 -1722.9 67.780 906.25 4.6784E+10
25.364 5.0766E-03 3.2456E+05 -3230.8 51.122 839.32 4.6784E+10
27.477 1.8999E-05 2.2699E+05 -3897.3 1.4326 737.21 4.6784E+10
29.591 -1.9173E-03 1.2799E+05 -3388.9 -41.516 633.61 4.6784E+10
31.705 -2.0937E-03 5.5422E+04 -2341.5 -41.077 557.66 4.6784E+10
33.818 -1.5079E-03 9150.2 -1368.1 -35.682 509.24 4.6784E+10
35.932 -7.9633E-04 -1.4187E+04 -566.76 -27.504 514.51 4.6784E+10
38.045 -2.7983E-04 -1.9799E+04 5.6059 -17.628 520.38 4.6784E+10
40.159 -3.5579E-05 -1.4026E+04 309.04 -6.2985 514.34 4.6784E+10
42.273 1.5807E-05 -4169.8 273.14 9.1299 504.02 4.6784E+10
44.386 9.8567E-06 -177.82 92.023 5.1513 499.85 4.6784E+10
46.500 1.4607E-06 500.63 5.6983 1.6557 500.19 4.6784E+10
48.614 -5.1260E-08 112.85 -9.9142 -0.4246 499.78 4.6784E+10
50.727 -1.1491E-08 -2.0557 -2.2409 -0.1805 499.66 4.6784E+10
52.841 1.0308E-11 -0.8369 4.0568E-02 5.9605E-04 499.66 4.6784E+10
54.955 3.0761E-12 3.0224E-04 1.6503E-02 1.3015E-03 499.66 4.6784E+10
57.068 1.4486E-16 2.2368E-04 -5.9677E-06 2.2480E-07 499.66 4.6784E+10
59.182 -3.8551E-18 1.1095E-08 -4.4095E-06 -3.4767E-07 499.66 4.6784E+10
61.295 -9.4414E-23 -2.8034E-10 -2.1871E-10 -1.8118E-11 499.66 4.6784E+10
63.409 6.3444E-25 -6.9584E-15 5.5265E-12 4.3576E-13 499.66 4.6784E+10
65.523 1.5957E-29 4.6136E-17 1.3717E-16 1.0960E-17 499.66 4.6784E+10
67.636 -1.0441E-31 1.1756E-21 -9.0950E-19 -7.1713E-20 499.66 4.6784E+10
69.750 -2.6950E-36 -7.5927E-24 -2.3175E-23 -1.8510E-24 499.66 4.6784E+10
71.864 1.7183E-38 -1.9849E-28 1.4968E-25 1.1802E-26 499.66 4.6784E+10
73.977 4.5487E-43 1.2495E-30 3.9128E-30 3.1242E-31 499.66 4.6784E+10
76.091 -2.8278E-45 3.3491E-35 -2.4632E-32 -1.9422E-33 499.66 4.6784E+10
78.205 -7.6726E-50 -2.0563E-37 -6.6020E-37 -5.2698E-38 499.66 4.6784E+10
80.318 0.0000 -5.6475E-42 4.0537E-39 3.1963E-40 499.66 4.6784E+10
82.432 0.0000 3.3841E-44 1.1133E-43 8.8838E-45 499.66 4.6784E+10
84.545 0.0000 9.4345E-49 -6.6712E-46 -5.2601E-47 499.66 4.6784E+10
86.659 0.0000 0.0000 -1.8598E-50 0.0000 499.66 4.6784E+10
88.773 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 499.66 4.6784E+10
90.886 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 499.66 4.6784E+10
93.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 499.66 4.6784E+10

* PILE GROUP * 3

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS AND REACTIONS *

THE GLOBAL STRUCTURAL COORDINATE SYSTEM

---------------------------------------

DISP.X,IN DISP.Y,IN SLOPE FOR.X, LB FOR.Y, LB BM, LB-IN STRESS, LB/IN**2

0.1103 0.2691 -1.2415E-04 1.9541E+05 2593.3 6.1193E+05 1243.5

THE PILE COORDINATE SYSTEM (LOCAL AXES)

---------------------------------------

DISP.x,IN DISP.y,IN SLOPE AXIAL, LB LAT, LB BM, LB-IN STRESS,LBS/IN**2

0.1103 0.2691 -1.2415E-04 1.9541E+05 2593.3 6.1193E+05 1243.5

* EFFECTS FOR LATERALLY LOADED PILE *

x DISPL. BENDING SHEAR SOIL TOTAL FLEXURAL

y-DIR MOMENT FORCE REACTION STRESS RIGIDITY
FT IN LBS-IN LBS LBS/IN LBS-IN**2 LBS-IN**2

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-67

********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********

0.0000 0.2691 -6.1193E+05 2625.7 0.0000 1243.5 4.6784E+10
2.1136 0.2617 -5.4472E+05 2727.3 0.0000 1173.2 4.6784E+10
4.2273 0.2469 -4.6924E+05 3129.4 0.0000 1094.2 4.6784E+10
6.3409 0.2256 -3.7891E+05 3799.5 0.0000 999.65 4.6784E+10
8.4545 0.1991 -2.6716E+05 4737.7 0.0000 882.70 4.6784E+10
10.568 0.1689 -1.2750E+05 5273.2 4.6295E-02 736.55 4.6784E+10
12.682 0.1369 1.2473E+04 5272.0 4.3131E-02 616.17 4.6784E+10
14.795 0.1052 1.5238E+05 5271.0 3.9446E-02 762.59 4.6784E+10
16.909 7.5515E-02 2.9186E+05 4220.0 82.833 908.55 4.6784E+10
19.023 4.9860E-02 3.7727E+05 2123.3 82.502 997.93 4.6784E+10
21.136 2.9392E-02 4.0858E+05 92.182 77.657 1030.7 4.6784E+10
23.250 1.4542E-02 3.8884E+05 -1751.8 67.744 1010.0 4.6784E+10
25.364 5.0394E-03 3.2448E+05 -3259.1 51.110 942.69 4.6784E+10
27.477 -1.5437E-06 2.2636E+05 -3905.6 -0.1302 840.01 4.6784E+10
29.591 -1.9298E-03 1.2772E+05 -3380.0 -41.310 736.78 4.6784E+10
31.705 -2.1018E-03 5.5313E+04 -2336.7 -40.956 661.00 4.6784E+10
33.818 -1.5132E-03 9103.3 -1365.8 -35.607 612.64 4.6784E+10
35.932 -7.9939E-04 -1.4224E+04 -565.90 -27.467 618.00 4.6784E+10
38.045 -2.8120E-04 -1.9844E+04 5.9230 -17.623 623.89 4.6784E+10
40.159 -3.5884E-05 -1.4073E+04 309.56 -6.3193 617.85 4.6784E+10
42.273 1.5917E-05 -4199.0 273.95 9.1271 607.51 4.6784E+10
44.386 9.9793E-06 -185.23 92.667 5.1677 603.31 4.6784E+10
46.500 1.4945E-06 504.56 5.8879 1.6751 603.65 4.6784E+10
48.614 -5.2169E-08 115.41 -9.9930 -0.4228 603.24 4.6784E+10
50.727 -1.1929E-08 -2.0583 -2.2920 -0.1844 603.12 4.6784E+10
52.841 8.8703E-12 -0.8686 4.0624E-02 5.0256E-04 603.12 4.6784E+10
54.955 3.2376E-12 1.7421E-04 1.7127E-02 1.3503E-03 603.12 4.6784E+10
57.068 3.0404E-16 2.3540E-04 -3.4463E-06 4.6002E-07 603.12 4.6784E+10
59.182 -4.0089E-18 2.2694E-08 -4.6405E-06 -3.6585E-07 603.12 4.6784E+10
61.295 -1.9685E-22 -2.9151E-10 -4.4736E-10 -3.6182E-11 603.12 4.6784E+10
63.409 6.5969E-25 -1.4411E-14 5.7467E-12 4.5310E-13 603.12 4.6784E+10
65.523 3.2833E-29 4.7970E-17 2.8409E-16 2.2551E-17 603.12 4.6784E+10
67.636 -1.0855E-31 2.4035E-21 -9.4564E-19 -7.4559E-20 603.12 4.6784E+10
69.750 -5.4752E-36 -7.8936E-24 -4.7380E-23 -3.7606E-24 603.12 4.6784E+10
71.864 1.7863E-38 -4.0078E-28 1.5561E-25 1.2269E-26 603.12 4.6784E+10
73.977 9.1291E-43 1.2989E-30 7.9005E-30 6.2702E-31 603.12 4.6784E+10
76.091 -2.9394E-45 6.6817E-35 -2.5606E-32 -2.0189E-33 603.12 4.6784E+10
78.205 -1.5219E-49 -2.1374E-37 -1.3172E-36 -1.0453E-37 603.12 4.6784E+10
80.318 0.0000 -1.1138E-41 4.2136E-39 3.3222E-40 603.12 4.6784E+10
82.432 0.0000 3.5172E-44 2.1956E-43 1.7422E-44 603.12 4.6784E+10
84.545 0.0000 1.8476E-48 -6.9336E-46 -5.4668E-47 603.12 4.6784E+10
86.659 0.0000 0.0000 -3.6423E-50 0.0000 603.12 4.6784E+10
88.773 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 603.12 4.6784E+10
90.886 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 603.12 4.6784E+10
93.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 603.12 4.6784E+10

* PILE GROUP * 4

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS AND REACTIONS *

THE GLOBAL STRUCTURAL COORDINATE SYSTEM

---------------------------------------

DISP.X,IN DISP.Y,IN SLOPE FOR.X, LB FOR.Y, LB BM, LB-IN STRESS, LB/IN**2

0.1147 0.2691 -1.2415E-04 1.1721E+05 2.8997E+04 536.40 373.23

THE PILE COORDINATE SYSTEM (LOCAL AXES)

---------------------------------------

DISP.x,IN DISP.y,IN SLOPE AXIAL, LB LAT, LB BM, LB-IN STRESS,LBS/IN**2

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-68

0.1766 0.2332 -1.2415E-04 1.2074E+05 -299.67 536.40 373.23

* EFFECTS FOR LATERALLY LOADED PILE *

x DISPL. BENDING SHEAR SOIL TOTAL FLEXURAL

y-DIR MOMENT FORCE REACTION STRESS RIGIDITY
FT IN LBS-IN LBS LBS/IN LBS-IN**2 LBS-IN**2
********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
0.0000 0.2332 -536.40 -299.64 0.0000 373.23 3.8184E+10
2.6571 0.1981 -5857.9 -87.856 0.0000 378.80 3.8184E+10
5.3143 0.1629 2347.1 547.58 0.0000 375.12 3.8184E+10
7.9714 0.1278 3.7560E+04 1606.6 0.0000 411.97 3.8184E+10
10.629 9.3614E-02 1.1317E+05 2241.5 3.7934E-02 491.11 3.8184E+10
13.286 6.2471E-02 1.8839E+05 2240.3 3.3063E-02 569.82 3.8184E+10
15.943 3.6344E-02 2.6296E+05 1314.0 58.070 647.86 3.8184E+10
18.600 1.7218E-02 2.7765E+05 -470.01 53.831 663.23 3.8184E+10
21.257 5.4852E-03 2.3671E+05 -1996.1 41.890 620.39 3.8184E+10
23.914 5.5070E-05 1.5243E+05 -2728.6 4.0590 532.18 3.8184E+10
26.571 -1.3165E-03 6.3525E+04 -2221.5 -35.867 439.15 3.8184E+10
29.229 -9.9659E-04 1.0885E+04 -1156.0 -30.966 384.06 3.8184E+10
31.886 -3.8688E-04 -1.0308E+04 -331.94 -20.723 383.46 3.8184E+10
34.543 -5.1619E-05 -1.0397E+04 125.57 -7.9736 383.55 3.8184E+10
37.200 6.7960E-06 -2347.1 163.94 5.5673 375.12 3.8184E+10
39.857 2.7175E-06 50.495 36.893 2.4013 372.72 3.8184E+10
42.514 -1.6556E-08 6.4622 -0.7976 -3.7242E-02 1490.7 2.3887E+09
45.171 -9.1344E-11 -3.8469E-02 -0.1013 -6.4296E-03 1490.7 2.3887E+09
47.829 5.7789E-14 -2.1488E-04 6.0341E-04 3.7425E-05 1490.7 2.3887E+09
50.486 1.9361E-18 1.3577E-07 3.3695E-06 2.1161E-07 1490.7 2.3887E+09
53.143 -3.0860E-22 4.5503E-12 -2.1289E-09 -1.3353E-10 1490.7 2.3887E+09
55.800 -1.0347E-26 -7.2501E-16 -7.1352E-14 -4.4769E-15 1490.7 2.3887E+09
58.457 1.6480E-30 -2.4318E-20 1.1369E-17 7.1305E-19 1490.7 2.3887E+09
61.114 5.5297E-35 3.8717E-24 3.8132E-22 2.3926E-23 1490.7 2.3887E+09
63.771 -8.8005E-39 1.2996E-28 -6.0712E-26 -3.8078E-27 1490.7 2.3887E+09
66.429 -2.9552E-43 -2.0675E-32 -2.0379E-30 -1.2787E-31 1490.7 2.3887E+09
69.086 4.6996E-47 -6.9454E-37 3.2421E-34 2.0334E-35 1490.7 2.3887E+09
71.743 0.0000 1.1041E-40 1.0891E-38 6.8334E-40 1490.7 2.3887E+09
74.400 0.0000 3.7118E-45 -1.7313E-42 -1.0859E-43 1490.7 2.3887E+09
77.057 0.0000 -5.8961E-49 -5.8204E-47 -3.6519E-48 1490.7 2.3887E+09
79.714 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 1490.7 2.3887E+09
82.371 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 1490.7 2.3887E+09
85.029 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 1490.7 2.3887E+09
87.686 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 1490.7 2.3887E+09
90.343 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 1490.7 2.3887E+09
93.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 1490.7 2.3887E+09

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-69

1.4.6 Summary Results File

=========================================================================

GROUP for Windows, Version 2016.10.8

Serial Number : 136089307

Analysis of A Group of Piles

Subjected to Axial and Lateral Loading

(c) Copyright ENSOFT, Inc., 1987-2015

All Rights Reserved

=========================================================================

-------------------------------------------------------------------------
Time and Date of Analysis
-------------------------------------------------------------------------

Date: May 09, 2016 Time: 18:14:12

***** COMPUTATION RESULTS *****

EXAMPLE PROBLEM 3 - 2D , 2 PILE TYPES, DIST LOAD,2 L-S CURVES,RES HEAD

***** LOAD CASES RESULTS *****

LOAD CASE : 1
CASE NAME : Load Case 1
LOAD TYPE : Special, Sp

* TABLE L * COMPUTATION ON PILE CAP

* EQUIVALENT CONCENTRATED LOAD AT ORIGIN *

VERT. LOAD, LBS HORI. LOAD, LBS MOMENT,LBS-IN

8.44000E+05 36400.0 -1.68168E+07

* DISPLACEMENT OF GROUPED PILE FOUNDATION AT ORIGIN *

VERTICAL,IN HORIZONTAL,IN ROTATION,RAD

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-70

0.0991002 0.26908 -1.24148E-04

* TABLE M * COMPUTATION ON INDIVIDUAL PILE

THE GLOBAL STRUCTURAL COORDINATE SYSTEM

---------------------------------------

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS *

PILE GROUP DISP. X,IN DISP. Y,IN ROT. Z,RAD

********** *********** *********** ***********
1 0.083458 0.2691 -1.2415E-04
2 0.087927 0.2691 -1.2415E-04
3 0.1103 0.2691 -1.2415E-04
4 0.1147 0.2691 -1.2415E-04

MINIMUM 0.083458 0.2691 -1.2415E-04

Pile G. 1 1 1
MAXIMUM 0.1147 0.2691 -1.2415E-04
Pile G. 4 1 1

* PILE TOP REACTIONS *

PILE GROUP FOR. X,LBS FOR. Y,LBS MOM Z,LBS-IN STRESS,LBS/IN**2

********** *********** *********** ************ ****************
1 1.2188E+04 -3032.6 665.74 39.459
2 1.6189E+05 2624.7 6.1238E+05 1140.5
3 1.9541E+05 2593.3 6.1193E+05 1243.5
4 1.1721E+05 2.8997E+04 536.40 373.23

MINIMUM 1.2188E+04 -3032.6 536.40 39.459

Pile G. 1 1 4 1
MAXIMUM 1.9541E+05 2.8997E+04 6.1238E+05 1243.5
Pile G. 3 4 2 3

THE PILE COORDINATE SYSTEM (LOCAL AXES)

---------------------------------------

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS *

PILE GROUP DISP. x,IN DISP. y,IN ROT. z,RAD

********** *********** *********** ***********
1 0.015699 0.2813 -1.2415E-04
2 0.087927 0.2691 -1.2415E-04
3 0.1103 0.2691 -1.2415E-04
4 0.1766 0.2332 -1.2415E-04

MINIMUM 0.015699 0.2332 -1.2415E-04

Pile G. 1 4 1
MAXIMUM 0.1766 0.2813 -1.2415E-04
Pile G. 4 1 1

* PILE TOP REACTIONS *

PILE GROUP AXIAL,LBS LAT. y,LBS MOM z,LBS-IN STRESS,LBS/IN**2

********** *********** *********** ************ ****************
1 1.2559E+04 14.083 665.74 39.459
2 1.6189E+05 2624.7 6.1238E+05 1140.5
3 1.9541E+05 2593.3 6.1193E+05 1243.5
4 1.2074E+05 -299.67 536.40 373.23

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-71

MINIMUM 1.2559E+04 -299.67 536.40 39.459

Pile G. 1 4 4 1
MAXIMUM 1.9541E+05 2624.7 6.1238E+05 1243.5
Pile G. 3 2 2 3

* EFFECTS FOR LATERALLY LOADED PILE *

* MINIMUM VALUES AND LOCATIONS *

PILE DISPL. BENDING SHEAR SOIL TOTAL FLEXURAL

y-DIR MOMENT FORCE REACTION STRESS RIGIDITY
IN LBS-IN LBS LBS/IN LBS-IN**2 LBS-IN**2
****** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
1 -1.5407E-03 -1.3277E+04 -3044.5 -39.622 39.095 2.3887E+09
x(FT) 26.571 34.543 23.914 26.571 2.6571 42.514
2 -2.0937E-03 -6.1238E+05 -3897.3 -41.516 499.66 4.6784E+10
x(FT) 31.704 0.0000 27.477 29.591 63.409 0.0000
3 -2.1018E-03 -6.1193E+05 -3905.6 -41.310 603.12 4.6784E+10
x(FT) 31.704 0.0000 27.477 29.591 63.409 0.0000
4 -1.3165E-03 -1.0397E+04 -2728.6 -35.867 372.72 2.3887E+09
x(FT) 26.571 34.543 23.914 26.571 39.857 42.514

Min. -2.1018E-03 -6.1238E+05 -3905.6 -41.516 39.095 2.3887E+09

Pile N. 3 2 3 2 1 1

* MAXIMUM VALUES AND LOCATIONS *

PILE DISPL. BENDING SHEAR SOIL TOTAL FLEXURAL

y-DIR MOMENT FORCE REACTION STRESS RIGIDITY
IN LBS-IN LBS LBS/IN LBS-IN**2 LBS-IN**2
****** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
1 0.2813 3.2026E+05 2555.2 62.445 373.92 3.8184E+10
x(FT) 0.0000 18.600 10.629 15.943 18.600 0.0000
2 0.2691 4.0801E+05 5304.6 82.852 1140.5 4.6784E+10
x(FT) 0.0000 21.136 10.568 16.909 0.0000 0.0000
3 0.2691 4.0858E+05 5273.2 82.833 1243.5 4.6784E+10
x(FT) 0.0000 21.136 10.568 16.909 0.0000 0.0000
4 0.2332 2.7765E+05 2241.5 58.070 1490.7 3.8184E+10
x(FT) 0.0000 18.600 10.629 15.943 42.514 0.0000

Max. 0.2813 4.0858E+05 5304.6 82.852 1490.7 4.6784E+10

Pile N. 1 3 2 2 4 2

***** SUMMARY FOR LOAD CASES AND COMBINATIONS *****

***** LOAD CASES RESULTS *****

LOAD CASE : 1

* EQUIVALENT CONCENTRATED LOAD AT ORIGIN *

LOAD X,LBS LOAD Y,LBS MOM Z,LBS-IN
8.44000E+05 36400.0 -1.68168E+07

* DISPLACEMENT OF GROUPED PILE FOUNDATION AT ORIGIN *

DISP X,IN DISP Y,IN ROT Z,RAD
0.0991002 0.26908 -1.24148E-04

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS, GLOBAL *

DISP. X,IN DISP. Y,IN ROT. Z,RAD
*********** *********** ***********
MINIMUM 0.083458 0.2691 -1.2415E-04
Pile G. 1 1 1

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-72

MAXIMUM 0.1147 0.2691 -1.2415E-04

Pile G. 4 1 1

* PILE TOP REACTIONS, GLOBAL *

FOR. X,LBS FOR. Y,LBS MOM Z,LBS-IN STRESS,LBS/IN**2
*********** *********** ************ ****************
MINIMUM 1.2188E+04 -3032.6 536.40 39.459
Pile G. 1 1 4 1
MAXIMUM 1.9541E+05 2.8997E+04 6.1238E+05 1243.5
Pile G. 3 4 2 3

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS, LOCAL *

DISP. x,IN DISP. y,IN ROT. z,RAD
*********** *********** ***********
MINIMUM 0.015699 0.2332 -1.2415E-04
Pile G. 1 4 1
MAXIMUM 0.1766 0.2813 -1.2415E-04
Pile G. 4 1 1

* PILE TOP REACTIONS, LOCAL *

AXIAL,LBS LAT. y,LBS MOM z,LBS-IN STRESS,LBS/IN**2
*********** *********** ************ ****************
MINIMUM 1.2559E+04 -299.67 536.40 39.459
Pile G. 1 4 4 1
MAXIMUM 1.9541E+05 2624.7 6.1238E+05 1243.5
Pile G. 3 2 2 3

* EFFECTS FOR LATERALLY LOADED PILE *

PILE DISPL. BENDING SHEAR SOIL TOTAL FLEXURAL

y-DIR MOMENT FORCE REACTION STRESS RIGIDITY
IN LBS-IN LBS LBS/IN LBS-IN**2 LBS-IN**2
****** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
Min. -2.1018E-03 -6.1238E+05 -3905.6 -41.516 39.095 2.3887E+09
Pile N. 3 2 3 2 1 1
Max. 0.2813 4.0858E+05 5304.6 82.852 1490.7 4.6784E+10
Pile N. 1 3 2 2 4 2

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-73

1.4.7 Graphs

Figure 1.10 Curves Deflection vs. Distance for Example Problem 3 - 2D.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-74

Figure 1.11 Curves Moment vs. Distance for Example Problem 3 - 2D.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-75

1.5 Example Problem 4 - 2D

1.5.1 Model Description

The geometrical configuration of Example Problem 4 - 2D, shown in Figure 1.12, shows a pile-
supported retaining wall with the piles spaced 3 feet apart. The piles are 14 inches in outside diameter
with 4-No 7 reinforcement-steel bars spaced equally. The center of the bars are on a 8-inch circle. The
yield strength of the reinforcing steel is 60 ksi and the compressive strength of the concrete is 2.67 ksi.
The length of the piles is 40 feet.

The backfill is a free-draining, granular soil without any fine particles. The surface of the backfill
is treated to facilitate a runoff, and weep holes are provided so that water will not collect behind the
wall.

The forces P1, P2, PS and PW (shown in Figure 1.12) were estimated as follows: 21.4, 4.6, 18.4 and
22.5 kips, respectively. The equivalent load at the origin of coordinates is FX=45.5 kips, FY=21.4 kips and
MZ=-33.5 ft-kips.

The subsurface soils at the site consist of silty clay. The water content averaged 20% in the top
10 feet. The water table was reported to be at depth of 10 feet. There was a considerable range in the
undrained shear strength of the clay and an average value of 3 ksf was used in the analysis. A value of
the submerged unit weight of 46 pcf was employed, and the value of 50 was estimated to be 0.005. The
axial load versus displacement curve is shown in Figure 1.13.

In making the computations, the assumption was made that all the load by the piles with none
of the load taken by passive earth pressure or by the base of the footing. It was further assumed that
the pile heads were free to rotate.

The computed load in the piles is shown in Figure 1.14. The following check is made to see that
the equilibrium equation are satisfied.

FX = 11.6 +33.9 = 45.5 kips

FY = 6.5 +14.9 = 21.4 kips

Z = 11.6 (1.5) -33.9 (1.5) = 33.5 ft-kips

The input and output files for the example problem are shown in the following pages.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-76

Figure 1.12 General Description of Example Problem 4 - 2D.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-77

AXIAL LOAD, Kip

-200 -100 0 100 200
-0.4
AXIAL PILE-TOP DISPLACEMENT, in
-0.3
Upward
-0.2

-0.1

0.1
Downward

0.2

0.3

0.4

Figure 1.13 Axial load versus pile-top displacements

Figure 1.14 Pile Loading (in Kips)

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-78

1.5.2 Input Data

EXAMPLE PROBLEM 4 - 2D, PILE-SUPPORTED RETAINING WALL

GROUP2016.10.8
* Analysis Parameters
1 2 0 0 0 1 0 0 1 0 1 0 0 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 1
* Pile Cap Dimensions
0 0 0 0 0 0
* Load Cases
1 0 0 1 0
0 1 1 1 1 100 100
1E-5 1E-5 1 1
Load Case 1
12 0 0 0 4 0 0 0
2 1 1 0 1E-7 1E-5 0 0 0
1
0 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 0 1 1 0 1 1 0 0 1 1 1 0 0 1 1
4
0 21400 0 0 0 0 -3.5 0 0
4600 0 0 0 0 0 0 -3 0
18400 0 0 0 0 0 0 -1.5 0
22500 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
0
0
* Load Combinations
0 0 0 1 0
* Distributed Load Sets
0
* Pile Group Configuration
2
1 1 1 0 1 0 0
0 0 1 1 1
0 -1.5 0 0
1 1 1 0 1 0 0
0 0 1 1 1
0 1.5 14.03624 0
* Pile Properties
1
0 1
50 40 1
0 40 1
* Pile Cross Sections
1
0 0 0 0
Section 1
14 0 1 1 0 0 0.1 0.1
1 154 1886 1886 0 0 0 0 2945000 0 0
0 0 0 0 1
None
* Soil Layers
2
0 3
0 10
2 10
110.592 1497.6 0 500 0 0.005 0 0 0 0
110.592 1497.6 0 500 0 0.005 0 0 0 0
1 2
10 41.666667
2 10
46.656 1497.6 0 500 0 0.005 0 0 0 0
46.656 1497.6 0 500 0 0.005 0 0 0 0
* Print py curves
2
1 7.5
0
1 15

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-79

0
* Generated LD curves
0
* User defined LD curves
1
0 13
-165517.24 -0.28333333
-162068.97 -0.2
-156896.55 -0.15555556
-151724.14 -0.12222222
-137931.03 -0.094444444
-68965.517 -0.038888889
0 0
68965.517 0.038888889
137931.03 0.094444444
151724.14 0.12222222
156896.55 0.15555556
162068.97 0.2
165517.24 0.28333333
* User defined MC curves
1
1 1
0
1 1
0 0
* Internally Generated MC curves
1
1 1
0
0
1 1
0 0
* End of file

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-80

1.5.3 Echo Print File

=========================================================================

GROUP for Windows, Version 2016.10.8

Serial Number : 136089307

Analysis of A Group of Piles

Subjected to Axial and Lateral Loading

(c) Copyright ENSOFT, Inc., 1987-2015

All Rights Reserved

=========================================================================

This program is licensed to :

ENSOFT, INC
AUSTIN, TX

Path to file locations : C:\projects\GROUP2016\Group2016_1008\DXE\Examples_2016\

Name of input data file : 2Dexample4.gp10r
Name of output echo file : 2Dexample4.gp10e
Name of output results file : 2Dexample4.gp10o
Name of output summary file : 2Dexample4.gp10t
Name of plot output file : 2Dexample4.gp10p
Name of runtime file : 2Dexample4.gp10r

-------------------------------------------------------------------------
Time and Date of Analysis
-------------------------------------------------------------------------

Date: May 09, 2016 Time: 18:14:12

***** INPUT INFORMATION *****

EXAMPLE PROBLEM 4 - 2D, PILE-SUPPORTED RETAINING WALL

ANALYSIS TYPE = 2D ANALYSIS

ADJUST DEPTH FOR BATTER PILES

GENERATE LOAD-DISP (AND T-R) CURVES BASED ON SOIL PROFILE

EXTEND INTERPOLATION FOR L-DP (AND T-R) CURVES

UNITS SYSTEM = ENGL

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-81

* TABLE C * LOAD AND CONTROL PARAMETERS

** LOAD CASES **

NUMBER OF LOAD CASES : 1

LOAD CASE : 1
CASE NAME : Load Case 1
LOAD TYPE : Special, Sp
SCALE FACTOR : 1.0000

* CONCENTRATED LOADS *

NL VERT.LOAD HOR.LOAD MOMENT COORD X COORD Y

LBS LBS LBS-IN FT FT
1 0.00000 21400.0 0.00000 -3.50000 0.00000
2 4600.00 0.00000 0.00000 0.00000 -3.00000
3 18400.0 0.00000 0.00000 0.00000 -1.50000
4 22500.0 0.00000 0.00000 0.00000 0.00000

* EQUIVALENT CONCENTRATED LOAD AT ORIGIN *

VER.LOAD X,LBS HOR.LOAD Y,LBS MOMENT,LBS-IN

45500.0 21400.0 -4.02000E+05

* THE LOADING IS STATIC *

* CONTROL PARAMETERS *
TOLERANCE ON CONVERGENCE OF PILE CAP MOVEMENT = 1.00000E-05
TOLERANCE ON DETERMINATION OF PILE DEFLECTIONS = 1.00000E-05 IN
MAX NO OF ITERATIONS ALLOWED FOR FOUNDATION ANALYSIS = 100
MAXIMUM NO OF ITERATIONS ALLOWED FOR PILE ANALYSIS = 100
FACTOR TO APPLY THE LOAD IN INCREMENTS = 1.0000
MINIMUM FACTOR FOR LOAD INCREMENTS = 1.0000
PRINT RESULTS AT PILE CAP, PILE HEADS AND ALONG PILES
PRINT RESULTS EVERY 1 NODE(S)

* TABLE D * ARRANGEMENT OF PILE GROUPS

GROUP CONNECT NO OF PILE PILE PROP P-Y CURVE L-S CURVE R-F-L SET
1 PIN 1 1 0 1 U 0
2 PIN 1 1 0 1 U 0

GROUP VERT,FT HOR,FT SLOPE,IN/IN GROUND,FT SPRING,LBS-IN SPACING,FT

1 0.00000 -1.50000 0.00000 0.00000 0.00000 0.00000
2 0.00000 1.50000 0.25000 0.00000 0.00000 0.00000

* TABLE E * PILE GEOMETRY AND PROPERTIES

PILE TYPE = 1 - DRIVEN PILE
= 2 - DRILLED SHAFT

PROP SECTS INC PILE TYPE LENGTH, FT

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-82

1 1 50 1 40.000

* PILE SECTIONS *

PROP SECT FROM,FT TO,FT CROSS SECT

1 1 0.00000 40.0000 1

* PILE CROSS SECTIONS *

CROSS SECTION : 1
SECTION NAME : Section

TYPE : ELASTIC
CROSS SECTION TYPE : GENERAL SECTION
EQUIVALENT DIAMETER : 14.0000 IN
YOUNG MODULUS : 2.94500E+06 LBS/IN**2

* PILE CROSS SECTIONS PROPERTIES *

ELASTIC SECTIONS

SECT DIAM,IN AREA,IN**2 I,IN**4 Mn,LBS-IN Vn,LBS

1 14.0000 154.000 1886.00 0.00000 0.00000

* TABLE F * SOIL DATA

SOILS INFORMATION

GROUND SURFACE = 0.00000 FT

2 LAYER(S) OF SOIL

LAYER 1
THE SOIL IS A STIFF CLAY WITHOUT FREE WATER
TOP OF LAYER BOTTOM OF LAYER
X COORDINATE (FT) 0.00000 10.0000
EFFECTIVE UNIT WEIGHT (LBS/FT**3) 110.592 110.592
UNDRAINED COHESION, C (LBS/FT**2) 1497.60 1497.60
STRAIN AT 50% STRESS 5.00000E-03 5.00000E-03
ULTIMATE UNIT SIDE FRICTION (LBS/FT**2) 0.00000 0.00000
ULTIMATE UNIT TIP RESISTANCE (LBS/FT**2) 0.00000 0.00000

LAYER 2
THE SOIL IS A STIFF CLAY WITH FREE WATER
TOP OF LAYER BOTTOM OF LAYER
X COORDINATE (FT) 10.0000 41.6667
EFFECTIVE UNIT WEIGHT (LBS/FT**3) 46.6560 46.6560
UNDRAINED COHESION, C (LBS/FT**2) 1497.60 1497.60
P-Y SUBGRADE MODULUS (LBS/IN**3) 500.000 500.000
STRAIN AT 50% STRESS 5.00000E-03 5.00000E-03
ULTIMATE UNIT SIDE FRICTION (LBS/FT**2) 0.00000 0.00000
ULTIMATE UNIT TIP RESISTANCE (LBS/FT**2) 0.00000 0.00000

* DATA TO PRINT GENERATED P-Y CURVES *

NUMBER OF CURVES TO PRINT : 2

CURVE NUMBER PILE GROUP DEPTH (FT)

1 1 7.50000
2 1 15.0000

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-83

* TABLE H * AXIAL LOAD VS DISPLACEMENT

USER DEFINED AXIAL LOAD-DISPLACEMENT CURVES

NUM OF CURVES 1

CURVE 1 NUM OF POINTS 13

DISPLACEMENT, IN AXIAL LOAD,LBS

-0.28333 -1.65517E+05
-0.20000 -1.62069E+05
-0.15556 -1.56897E+05
-0.12222 -1.51724E+05
-0.0944444 -1.37931E+05
-0.0388889 -68965.5
0.00000 0.00000
0.0388889 68965.5
0.0944444 1.37931E+05
0.12222 1.51724E+05
0.15556 1.56897E+05
0.20000 1.62069E+05
0.28333 1.65517E+05

* TABLE J * MOMENT CURVATURE SETS

USER DEFINED MOMENT CURVATURE

NUM OF SETS : 1

CURVE SET 1 NUM OF CURVES 1

CURVE 1 AXIAL LOAD 0.000E+00 LBS

POINT MOMENT CURVATURE

LBS-IN RADIAN/IN
1 0.00000 0.00000

* TABLE N * PRINTED P-Y CURVES

* GENERATED P-Y CURVES *

NUMBER OF CURVES : 2

CURVE NUMBER = 1

PILE GROUP NUMBER = 1

DEPTH BELOW ORIGIN = 7.50 FT

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-84

NUMBER OF POINTS ON CURVE = 17

P-Y CURVE COMPUTED USING STIFF CLAY WITHOUT FREE WATER CRITERIA

DEPTH BELOW GS DIAM C CAVG GAMMA E50

FT IN LBS/IN**2 LBS/IN**2 LBS/IN**3
7.50 14.000 0.15E+04 0.15E+04 0.11E+03 0.5000E-02
EQ. DEPTH = 7.50 FT

Y P
IN LBS/IN
0.00000 0.00000
7.00000E-04 123.913
7.00000E-03 220.351
0.0210000 289.998
0.0560000 370.585
0.11200 440.702
0.16800 487.717
0.28000 554.154
0.42000 613.272
0.63000 678.697
0.84000 729.307
1.12000 783.692
1.40000 828.653
1.82000 884.827
2.24000 931.972
2.80000 985.440
3.36000 985.440

CURVE NUMBER = 2

PILE GROUP NUMBER = 1

DEPTH BELOW ORIGIN = 15.00 FT

NUMBER OF POINTS ON CURVE = 17

P-Y CURVE COMPUTED USING STIFF CLAY WITH FREE WATER CRITERIA

DEPTH BELOW GS DIAM C CAVG GAMMA E50

FT IN LBS/FT**2 LBS/FT**2 LBS/FT**3
15.00 14.000 0.15E+04 0.15E+04 0.89E+02 0.5000E-02
AS = 0.60, AC = 0.30, EQ. DEPTH = 15.00 FT

Y,IN P,LBS/IN
0.00000 0.00000
0.0210000 438.616
0.0420000 620.297
0.0630000 722.669
0.0840000 789.144
0.10500 834.548
0.12600 864.876
0.14700 883.557
0.16800 892.803
0.18900 894.150
0.21000 888.725
0.23100 877.384
0.25200 860.800
0.42000 620.914
0.58800 380.674
0.75600 140.434
1.09200 140.434

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-85

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-86

1.5.4 Processor Run Notes

GROUP for Windows, Version 2016.10.8

-------------------------------------------------------------------------
Time and Date of Analysis
-------------------------------------------------------------------------

Date: May 09, 2016 Time: 18:14:12

EXAMPLE PROBLEM 4 - 2D, PILE-SUPPORTED RETAINING WALL

READING * TITLE AND VERSION

READING * Analysis Parameters
READING * Pile Cap Dimensions
READING * Load Cases
READING * Load Combinations
READING * Distributed Load Sets
READING * Pile Group Configuration
READING * Pile Properties
READING * Pile Cross Sections
READING * Soil Layers
READING * Print py curves
READING * Generated LD curves
READING * User defined LD curves
READING * User defined MC curves
READING * Internally Generated MC curves

COMPUTATION IS PROCEEDING......

LOAD CASE : 1
CASE NAME : Load Case 1

GLOBAL ITERATIONS
STEP 1, TCUR 1.0000, DTCUR 1.0000
ITERATION 1
- ErrDsp 0.10000E+01, IncDsp 0.13146E-01, TotDsp 0.13146E-01
- ErrRot 0.10000E+01, IncRot 0.33114E-03, TotRot 0.33114E-03
ITERATION 2
- ErrDsp 0.66891E+00, IncDsp 0.14837E-01, TotDsp 0.22181E-01
- ErrRot 0.16542E+00, IncRot 0.47001E-04, TotRot 0.28414E-03
ITERATION 3
- ErrDsp 0.60898E+00, IncDsp 0.29986E-01, TotDsp 0.49239E-01
- ErrRot 0.30100E+01, IncRot 0.21328E-03, TotRot 0.70857E-04
ITERATION 4
- ErrDsp 0.21356E+00, IncDsp 0.13257E-01, TotDsp 0.62076E-01
- ErrRot 0.44219E+01, IncRot 0.91564E-04, TotRot 0.20707E-04
ITERATION 5
- ErrDsp 0.14947E-01, IncDsp 0.94155E-03, TotDsp 0.62995E-01
- ErrRot 0.23812E+00, IncRot 0.64719E-05, TotRot 0.27179E-04
ITERATION 6
- ErrDsp 0.28162E-04, IncDsp 0.17740E-05, TotDsp 0.62993E-01
- ErrRot 0.49683E-03, IncRot 0.13497E-07, TotRot 0.27165E-04
ITERATION 7
- ErrDsp 0.28320E-09, IncDsp 0.17840E-10, TotDsp 0.62993E-01
- ErrRot 0.45340E-08, IncRot 0.12317E-12, TotRot 0.27165E-04

NUMBER OF GLOBAL ITERATIONS = 7

ANALYSIS FOR LOAD CASE 1/ 1 FINISHED

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-87

Execution Time : 60 ms
Number Processors : 1/ 1
Serial processing : 0.036 sec
Paral. processing : 0.010 sec
Print. processing : 0.015 sec

ANALYSIS COMPLETED
Execution Time : 67 ms
Number Processors : 1/ 1

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-88

1.5.5 Output Results File

=========================================================================

GROUP for Windows, Version 2016.10.8

Serial Number : 136089307

Analysis of A Group of Piles

Subjected to Axial and Lateral Loading

(c) Copyright ENSOFT, Inc., 1987-2015

All Rights Reserved

=========================================================================

This program is licensed to :

ENSOFT, INC
AUSTIN, TX

Path to file locations : C:\projects\GROUP2016\Group2016_1008\DXE\Examples_2016\

Name of input data file : 2Dexample4.gp10d
Name of output echo file : 2Dexample4.gp10e
Name of output results file : 2Dexample4.gp10o
Name of output summary file : 2Dexample4.gp10t
Name of plot output file : 2Dexample4.gp10p
Name of runtime file : 2Dexample4.gp10r

-------------------------------------------------------------------------
Time and Date of Analysis
-------------------------------------------------------------------------

Date: May 09, 2016 Time: 18:14:12

***** COMPUTATION RESULTS *****

EXAMPLE PROBLEM 4 - 2D, PILE-SUPPORTED RETAINING WALL

***** LOAD CASES RESULTS *****

LOAD CASE : 1
CASE NAME : Load Case 1
LOAD TYPE : Special, Sp

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-89

* TABLE L * COMPUTATION ON PILE CAP

* EQUIVALENT CONCENTRATED LOAD AT ORIGIN *

VERT. LOAD, LBS HORI. LOAD, LBS MOMENT,LBS-IN

45500.0 21400.0 -4.02000E+05

* DISPLACEMENT OF GROUPED PILE FOUNDATION AT ORIGIN *

VERTICAL,IN HORIZONTAL,IN ROTATION,RAD

6.04274E-03 0.0627023 2.71654E-05

NUMBER OF ITERATIONS = 7

* TABLE M * COMPUTATION ON INDIVIDUAL PILE

* PILE GROUP * 1

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS AND REACTIONS *

THE GLOBAL STRUCTURAL COORDINATE SYSTEM

---------------------------------------

DISP.X,IN DISP.Y,IN SLOPE FOR.X, LB FOR.Y, LB BM, LB-IN STRESS, LB/IN**2

6.5317E-03 0.062702 2.7165E-05 1.1583E+04 6474.4 0.0000 75.216

THE PILE COORDINATE SYSTEM (LOCAL AXES)

---------------------------------------

DISP.x,IN DISP.y,IN SLOPE AXIAL, LB LAT, LB BM, LB-IN STRESS,LBS/IN**2

6.5317E-03 0.062702 2.7165E-05 1.1583E+04 6474.4 0.0000 75.216

* EFFECTS FOR LATERALLY LOADED PILE *

x DISPL. BENDING SHEAR SOIL TOTAL FLEXURAL

y-DIR MOMENT FORCE REACTION STRESS RIGIDITY
FT IN LBS-IN LBS LBS/IN LBS-IN**2 LBS-IN**2
********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
0.0000 6.2702E-02 0.0000 6474.4 0.0000 75.216 5.5543E+09
0.8000 4.8291E-02 6.2321E+04 5612.8 179.49 306.53 5.5543E+09
1.6000 3.4914E-02 1.0809E+05 3863.0 185.06 476.39 5.5543E+09
2.4000 2.3330E-02 1.3678E+05 2086.8 184.98 582.88 5.5543E+09
3.2000 1.4016E-02 1.4840E+05 342.61 178.39 626.00 5.5543E+09
4.0000 7.1642E-03 1.4354E+05 -1300.5 163.92 607.99 5.5543E+09
4.8000 2.6941E-03 1.2356E+05 -2752.0 138.48 533.81 5.5543E+09
5.6000 2.7417E-04 9.0785E+04 -3813.3 82.612 412.17 5.5543E+09
6.4000 -6.3939E-04 5.0382E+04 -3672.1 -112.03 262.21 5.5543E+09
7.2000 -7.1699E-04 2.0293E+04 -2546.6 -122.45 150.54 5.5543E+09

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-90

8.0000 -4.5787E-04 1485.6 -1401.6 -116.08 80.730 5.5543E+09

8.8000 -1.7410E-04 -6624.3 -381.73 -96.397 99.803 5.5543E+09
9.6000 -2.4882E-07 -5848.9 156.53 -15.740 96.925 5.5543E+09
10.400 7.6557E-05 -3621.9 209.15 4.7771 88.659 5.5543E+09
11.200 9.3267E-05 -1834.4 156.13 6.2675 82.025 5.5543E+09
12.000 7.9539E-05 -624.13 98.560 5.7268 77.533 5.5543E+09
12.800 5.5456E-05 58.442 50.628 4.2590 75.433 5.5543E+09
13.600 3.2343E-05 348.49 17.517 2.6392 76.510 5.5543E+09
14.400 1.5012E-05 395.23 -1.3769 1.2970 76.683 5.5543E+09
15.200 4.2387E-06 322.37 -9.4581 0.3866 76.413 5.5543E+09
16.000 -1.1853E-06 213.83 -10.767 -0.1138 76.010 5.5543E+09
16.800 -3.0615E-06 115.72 -8.7400 -0.3086 75.646 5.5543E+09
17.600 -3.0175E-06 46.039 -5.7292 -0.3186 75.387 5.5543E+09
18.400 -2.2095E-06 5.7117 -3.0289 -0.2439 75.238 5.5543E+09
19.200 -1.3069E-06 -12.135 -1.1353 -0.1505 75.261 5.5543E+09
20.000 -6.0552E-07 -16.106 -6.3927E-02 -7.2663E-02 75.276 5.5543E+09
20.800 -1.7142E-07 -13.376 0.3875 -2.1394E-02 75.266 5.5543E+09
21.600 4.0733E-08 -8.6722 0.4649 5.2789E-03 75.249 5.5543E+09
22.400 1.0899E-07 -4.4533 0.3692 1.4649E-02 75.233 5.5543E+09
23.200 1.0336E-07 -1.5835 0.2299 1.4388E-02 75.222 5.5543E+09
24.000 7.1459E-08 -3.9466E-02 0.1114 1.0290E-02 75.217 5.5543E+09
24.800 3.8900E-08 0.5562 3.4230E-02 5.7883E-03 75.219 5.5543E+09
25.600 1.5570E-08 0.6184 -5.0328E-03 2.3915E-03 75.219 5.5543E+09
26.400 2.5008E-09 0.4600 -1.8413E-02 3.9612E-04 75.218 5.5543E+09
27.200 -2.9350E-09 0.2651 -1.8016E-02 -4.7899E-04 75.217 5.5543E+09
28.000 -3.9724E-09 0.1142 -1.2513E-02 -6.6737E-04 75.217 5.5543E+09
28.800 -3.1148E-09 2.4825E-02 -6.7263E-03 -5.3824E-04 75.217 5.5543E+09
29.600 -1.8453E-09 -1.4960E-02 -2.5697E-03 -3.2772E-04 75.217 5.5543E+09
30.400 -8.2398E-10 -2.4539E-02 -2.7521E-04 -1.5029E-04 75.217 5.5543E+09
31.200 -2.0984E-10 -2.0263E-02 6.3475E-04 -3.9282E-05 75.217 5.5543E+09
32.000 6.8088E-11 -1.2362E-02 7.6055E-04 1.3073E-05 75.216 5.5543E+09
32.800 1.4089E-10 -5.6643E-03 5.6471E-04 2.7727E-05 75.216 5.5543E+09
33.600 1.1971E-10 -1.5206E-03 3.1578E-04 2.4133E-05 75.216 5.5543E+09
34.400 7.3294E-11 3.9939E-04 1.2732E-04 1.5128E-05 75.216 5.5543E+09
35.200 3.3508E-11 9.2507E-04 2.0741E-05 7.0769E-06 75.216 5.5543E+09
36.000 9.0712E-12 7.9837E-04 -2.2633E-05 1.9594E-06 75.216 5.5543E+09
36.800 -2.1187E-12 4.9093E-04 -2.9792E-05 -4.6781E-07 75.216 5.5543E+09
37.600 -5.1627E-12 2.2652E-04 -2.1956E-05 -1.1647E-06 75.216 5.5543E+09
38.400 -4.4482E-12 6.9395E-05 -1.1447E-05 -1.0249E-06 75.216 5.5543E+09
39.200 -2.5822E-12 6.7123E-06 -3.6120E-06 -6.0734E-07 75.216 5.5543E+09
40.000 -6.0487E-13 0.0000 -1.1332E-22 -1.4517E-07 75.216 5.5543E+09

* PILE GROUP * 2

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS AND REACTIONS *

THE GLOBAL STRUCTURAL COORDINATE SYSTEM

---------------------------------------

DISP.X,IN DISP.Y,IN SLOPE FOR.X, LB FOR.Y, LB BM, LB-IN STRESS, LB/IN**2

5.5538E-03 0.062702 2.7165E-05 3.3917E+04 1.4926E+04 0.0000 237.17

THE PILE COORDINATE SYSTEM (LOCAL AXES)

---------------------------------------

DISP.x,IN DISP.y,IN SLOPE AXIAL, LB LAT, LB BM, LB-IN STRESS,LBS/IN**2

0.020595 0.059483 2.7165E-05 3.6524E+04 6254.0 0.0000 237.17

* EFFECTS FOR LATERALLY LOADED PILE *

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-91

x DISPL. BENDING SHEAR SOIL TOTAL FLEXURAL

y-DIR MOMENT FORCE REACTION STRESS RIGIDITY
FT IN LBS-IN LBS LBS/IN LBS-IN**2 LBS-IN**2
********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
0.0000 5.9483E-02 0.0000 6254.0 0.0000 237.17 5.5543E+09
0.8000 4.5702E-02 6.0541E+04 5407.2 176.41 461.87 5.5543E+09
1.6000 3.2925E-02 1.0479E+05 3690.6 181.22 626.09 5.5543E+09
2.4000 2.1886E-02 1.3227E+05 1954.4 180.49 728.10 5.5543E+09
3.2000 1.3043E-02 1.4304E+05 255.77 173.38 768.06 5.5543E+09
4.0000 6.5724E-03 1.3774E+05 -1337.3 158.51 748.40 5.5543E+09
4.8000 2.3876E-03 1.1775E+05 -2734.4 132.57 674.21 5.5543E+09
5.6000 1.5661E-04 8.5473E+04 -3706.6 69.979 554.41 5.5543E+09
6.4000 -6.5613E-04 4.6695E+04 -3510.0 -110.94 410.48 5.5543E+09
7.2000 -6.9409E-04 1.8112E+04 -2404.1 -119.46 304.39 5.5543E+09
8.0000 -4.3153E-04 527.27 -1291.1 -112.43 239.13 5.5543E+09
8.8000 -1.6022E-04 -6696.3 -306.08 -92.779 262.02 5.5543E+09
9.6000 -2.1141E-08 -5365.2 175.43 -7.5361 257.08 5.5543E+09
10.400 7.1157E-05 -3336.4 190.93 4.3076 249.55 5.5543E+09
11.200 8.6976E-05 -1702.6 143.03 5.6702 243.49 5.5543E+09
12.000 7.4543E-05 -590.30 90.824 5.2069 239.36 5.5543E+09
12.800 5.2316E-05 42.493 47.121 3.8979 237.33 5.5543E+09
13.600 3.0795E-05 316.02 16.709 2.4378 238.34 5.5543E+09
14.400 1.4517E-05 364.69 -0.8330 1.2168 238.52 5.5543E+09
15.200 4.2897E-06 301.00 -8.4953 0.3795 238.29 5.5543E+09
16.000 -9.4292E-07 202.14 -9.8956 -8.7817E-02 237.92 5.5543E+09
16.800 -2.8214E-06 111.26 -8.1497 -0.2759 237.58 5.5543E+09
17.600 -2.8538E-06 45.739 -5.4220 -0.2924 237.34 5.5543E+09
18.400 -2.1273E-06 7.1333 -2.9250 -0.2278 237.20 5.5543E+09
19.200 -1.2824E-06 -10.478 -1.1434 -0.1433 237.21 5.5543E+09
20.000 -6.1142E-07 -14.875 -0.1137 -7.1180E-02 237.22 5.5543E+09
20.800 -1.8722E-07 -12.702 0.3367 -2.2667E-02 237.22 5.5543E+09
21.600 2.6234E-08 -8.4326 0.4297 3.2984E-03 237.20 5.5543E+09
22.400 9.9764E-08 -4.4621 0.3514 1.3008E-02 237.19 5.5543E+09
23.200 9.9256E-08 -1.6878 0.2247 1.3404E-02 237.18 5.5543E+09
24.000 7.0743E-08 -0.1477 0.1129 9.8828E-03 237.17 5.5543E+09
24.800 3.9779E-08 0.4817 3.7878E-02 5.7425E-03 237.17 5.5543E+09
25.600 1.6809E-08 0.5815 -1.7083E-03 2.5047E-03 237.17 5.5543E+09
26.400 3.4870E-09 0.4502 -1.6303E-02 5.3585E-04 237.17 5.5543E+09
27.200 -2.3643E-09 0.2692 -1.7078E-02 -3.7433E-04 237.17 5.5543E+09
28.000 -3.7484E-09 0.1226 -1.2349E-02 -6.1094E-04 237.17 5.5543E+09
28.800 -3.0988E-09 3.2151E-02 -6.9231E-03 -5.1948E-04 237.17 5.5543E+09
29.600 -1.9156E-09 -1.0416E-02 -2.8453E-03 -3.3006E-04 237.17 5.5543E+09
30.400 -9.0533E-10 -2.2559E-02 -4.9205E-04 -1.6020E-04 237.17 5.5543E+09
31.200 -2.6935E-10 -1.9924E-02 5.1171E-04 -4.8917E-05 237.17 5.5543E+09
32.000 3.6042E-11 -1.2769E-02 7.1429E-04 6.7134E-06 237.17 5.5543E+09
32.800 1.2957E-10 -6.2243E-03 5.6333E-04 2.4737E-05 237.17 5.5543E+09
33.600 1.1981E-10 -1.9559E-03 3.3211E-04 2.3433E-05 237.17 5.5543E+09
34.400 7.7608E-11 1.5412E-04 1.4504E-04 1.5540E-05 237.17 5.5543E+09
35.200 3.7959E-11 8.3184E-04 3.3113E-05 7.7776E-06 237.17 5.5543E+09
36.000 1.2113E-11 7.9227E-04 -1.6404E-05 2.5383E-06 237.17 5.5543E+09
36.800 -5.8678E-13 5.1829E-04 -2.7985E-05 -1.2569E-07 237.17 5.5543E+09
37.600 -4.6870E-12 2.5558E-04 -2.2457E-05 -1.0258E-06 237.17 5.5543E+09
38.400 -4.5464E-12 8.7255E-05 -1.2656E-05 -1.0162E-06 237.17 5.5543E+09
39.200 -2.9580E-12 1.2530E-05 -4.5381E-06 -6.7495E-07 237.17 5.5543E+09
40.000 -1.1617E-12 0.0000 1.3648E-21 -2.7049E-07 237.17 5.5543E+09

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-92

1.5.6 Summary Results File

=========================================================================

GROUP for Windows, Version 2016.10.8

Serial Number : 136089307

Analysis of A Group of Piles

Subjected to Axial and Lateral Loading

(c) Copyright ENSOFT, Inc., 1987-2015

All Rights Reserved

=========================================================================

-------------------------------------------------------------------------
Time and Date of Analysis
-------------------------------------------------------------------------

Date: May 09, 2016 Time: 18:14:12

***** COMPUTATION RESULTS *****

EXAMPLE PROBLEM 4 - 2D, PILE-SUPPORTED RETAINING WALL

***** LOAD CASES RESULTS *****

LOAD CASE : 1
CASE NAME : Load Case 1
LOAD TYPE : Special, Sp

* TABLE L * COMPUTATION ON PILE CAP

* EQUIVALENT CONCENTRATED LOAD AT ORIGIN *

VERT. LOAD, LBS HORI. LOAD, LBS MOMENT,LBS-IN

45500.0 21400.0 -4.02000E+05

* DISPLACEMENT OF GROUPED PILE FOUNDATION AT ORIGIN *

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-93

VERTICAL,IN HORIZONTAL,IN ROTATION,RAD

6.04274E-03 0.0627023 2.71654E-05

* TABLE M * COMPUTATION ON INDIVIDUAL PILE

THE GLOBAL STRUCTURAL COORDINATE SYSTEM

---------------------------------------

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS *

PILE GROUP DISP. X,IN DISP. Y,IN ROT. Z,RAD

********** *********** *********** ***********
1 6.5317E-03 0.062702 2.7165E-05
2 5.5538E-03 0.062702 2.7165E-05

MINIMUM 5.5538E-03 0.062702 2.7165E-05

Pile G. 2 1 1
MAXIMUM 6.5317E-03 0.062702 2.7165E-05
Pile G. 1 1 1

* PILE TOP REACTIONS *

PILE GROUP FOR. X,LBS FOR. Y,LBS MOM Z,LBS-IN STRESS,LBS/IN**2

********** *********** *********** ************ ****************
1 1.1583E+04 6474.4 0.0000 75.216
2 3.3917E+04 1.4926E+04 0.0000 237.17

MINIMUM 1.1583E+04 6474.4 0.0000 75.216

Pile G. 1 1 1 1
MAXIMUM 3.3917E+04 1.4926E+04 0.0000 237.17
Pile G. 2 2 1 2

THE PILE COORDINATE SYSTEM (LOCAL AXES)

---------------------------------------

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS *

PILE GROUP DISP. x,IN DISP. y,IN ROT. z,RAD

********** *********** *********** ***********
1 6.5317E-03 0.062702 2.7165E-05
2 0.020595 0.059483 2.7165E-05

MINIMUM 6.5317E-03 0.059483 2.7165E-05

Pile G. 1 2 1
MAXIMUM 0.020595 0.062702 2.7165E-05
Pile G. 2 1 1

* PILE TOP REACTIONS *

PILE GROUP AXIAL,LBS LAT. y,LBS MOM z,LBS-IN STRESS,LBS/IN**2

********** *********** *********** ************ ****************
1 1.1583E+04 6474.4 0.0000 75.216
2 3.6524E+04 6254.0 0.0000 237.17

MINIMUM 1.1583E+04 6254.0 0.0000 75.216

Pile G. 1 2 1 1
MAXIMUM 3.6524E+04 6474.4 0.0000 237.17
Pile G. 2 1 1 2

* EFFECTS FOR LATERALLY LOADED PILE *

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-94

* MINIMUM VALUES AND LOCATIONS *

PILE DISPL. BENDING SHEAR SOIL TOTAL FLEXURAL

y-DIR MOMENT FORCE REACTION STRESS RIGIDITY
IN LBS-IN LBS LBS/IN LBS-IN**2 LBS-IN**2
****** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
1 -7.1699E-04 -6624.3 -3813.3 -122.45 75.216 5.5543E+09
x(FT) 7.2000 8.8000 5.6000 7.2000 0.0000 0.0000
2 -6.9409E-04 -6696.3 -3706.6 -119.46 237.17 5.5543E+09
x(FT) 7.2000 8.8000 5.6000 7.2000 0.0000 0.0000

Min. -7.1699E-04 -6696.3 -3813.3 -122.45 75.216 5.5543E+09

Pile N. 1 2 1 1 1 1

* MAXIMUM VALUES AND LOCATIONS *

PILE DISPL. BENDING SHEAR SOIL TOTAL FLEXURAL

y-DIR MOMENT FORCE REACTION STRESS RIGIDITY
IN LBS-IN LBS LBS/IN LBS-IN**2 LBS-IN**2
****** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
1 0.062702 1.4840E+05 6474.4 185.06 626.00 5.5543E+09
x(FT) 0.0000 3.2000 0.0000 1.6000 3.2000 0.0000
2 0.059483 1.4304E+05 6254.0 181.22 768.06 5.5543E+09
x(FT) 0.0000 3.2000 0.0000 1.6000 3.2000 0.0000

Max. 0.062702 1.4840E+05 6474.4 185.06 768.06 5.5543E+09

Pile N. 1 1 1 1 2 1

***** SUMMARY FOR LOAD CASES AND COMBINATIONS *****

***** LOAD CASES RESULTS *****

LOAD CASE : 1

* EQUIVALENT CONCENTRATED LOAD AT ORIGIN *

LOAD X,LBS LOAD Y,LBS MOM Z,LBS-IN
45500.0 21400.0 -4.02000E+05

* DISPLACEMENT OF GROUPED PILE FOUNDATION AT ORIGIN *

DISP X,IN DISP Y,IN ROT Z,RAD
6.04274E-03 0.0627023 2.71654E-05

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS, GLOBAL *

DISP. X,IN DISP. Y,IN ROT. Z,RAD
*********** *********** ***********
MINIMUM 5.5538E-03 0.062702 2.7165E-05
Pile G. 2 1 1
MAXIMUM 6.5317E-03 0.062702 2.7165E-05
Pile G. 1 1 1

* PILE TOP REACTIONS, GLOBAL *

FOR. X,LBS FOR. Y,LBS MOM Z,LBS-IN STRESS,LBS/IN**2
*********** *********** ************ ****************
MINIMUM 1.1583E+04 6474.4 0.0000 75.216
Pile G. 1 1 1 1
MAXIMUM 3.3917E+04 1.4926E+04 0.0000 237.17
Pile G. 2 2 1 2

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS, LOCAL *

DISP. x,IN DISP. y,IN ROT. z,RAD

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-95

*********** *********** ***********

MINIMUM 6.5317E-03 0.059483 2.7165E-05
Pile G. 1 2 1
MAXIMUM 0.020595 0.062702 2.7165E-05
Pile G. 2 1 1

* PILE TOP REACTIONS, LOCAL *

AXIAL,LBS LAT. y,LBS MOM z,LBS-IN STRESS,LBS/IN**2
*********** *********** ************ ****************
MINIMUM 1.1583E+04 6254.0 0.0000 75.216
Pile G. 1 2 1 1
MAXIMUM 3.6524E+04 6474.4 0.0000 237.17
Pile G. 2 1 1 2

* EFFECTS FOR LATERALLY LOADED PILE *

PILE DISPL. BENDING SHEAR SOIL TOTAL FLEXURAL

y-DIR MOMENT FORCE REACTION STRESS RIGIDITY
IN LBS-IN LBS LBS/IN LBS-IN**2 LBS-IN**2
****** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
Min. -7.1699E-04 -6696.3 -3813.3 -122.45 75.216 5.5543E+09
Pile N. 1 2 1 1 1 1
Max. 0.062702 1.4840E+05 6474.4 185.06 768.06 5.5543E+09
Pile N. 1 1 1 1 2 1

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-96

1.5.7 Graphs

Figure 1.15 Curves Deflection vs. Distance for Example Problem 4 - 2D.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-97

Figure 1.16 Curves Moment vs. Distance for Example Problem 4 - 2D.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-98

Figure 1.17 Curves Shear vs. Distance for Example Problem 4 - 2D.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-99

Figure 1.18 Internally Generated p-y Curves for Example Problem 4 - 2D.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-100

1.6 Example Problem 5 - 2D

1.6.1 Model Description

This example is included to show the use of the program for pile subgroups distributed in a
circular configuration (Figure 1.19). Circular pile groups are, in general, used for offshore structures.
There are 8 piles in each leg and 4-subgroups are employed for two-dimensional analysis. The pile
dimensions and geometry of each pile are given in Figure 1.19. Each steel pile is 150 meters in length,
and a total of 140 meters penetrates the seabed. The soil at the site is medium dense sand with an
internal friction angle of 38 to 40 degrees. The submerged soil density is approximately 9.5 kN/m3.

The input and output files for the example problem are shown in the following pages.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-101

Figure 1.19 General Description of Example Problem 5 - 2D.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-102

1.6.2 Input Data

EXAMPLE PROBLEM 5 - 2D, PILE GROUP IN A CIRCULAR CONFIGURATION

GROUP2016.10.8
* Analysis Parameters
2 2 0 0 0 1 0 2 1 0 0 0 0 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 1
* Pile Cap Dimensions
0 0 0 0 0 0
* Load Cases
1 0 0 1 0
0 1 1 0 100 100 100
1E-7 1E-7 1 1
Load Case 1
12 0 0 0 1 0 0 0
2 1 1 0 1E-7 1E-5 0 0 0
1
0 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 0 1 1 0 1 1 0 0 1 1 1 0 0 1 1
1
40000 1400 -150000 0 0 0 0 0 0
0
0
* Load Combinations
0 0 0 1 0
* Distributed Load Sets
0
* Pile Group Configuration
4
3 2 1 0 1 0 0
400000 0 0.85 1.15 1
0 -4.73 0 10
3 2 1 0 1 0 0
400000 0 0.9 1.1 1
0 -1.96 0 10
3 2 1 0 1 0 0
400000 0 0.9 1.1 1
0 1.96 0 10
3 2 1 0 1 0 0
400000 0 0.95 1.05 1
0 4.73 0 10
* Pile Properties
1
0 1
50 150 1
0 150 1
* Pile Cross Sections
1
0 0 0 0
Section 1
1500 0 1000 1000 0 0 100 100
1 820000 1.7E11 1.7E11 0 0 0 0 2E8 0 0
0 0 0 0 1
None
* Soil Layers
1
0 4
10 200
2 10
9.5 0 38 120 0 0 0 0 0 0
9.5 0 40 120 0 0 0 0 0 0
* Generated LD curves
0
* User defined LD curves
1
0 7
-100000 -0.402
-25000 -0.086
-10000 -0.032

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-103

0 0
10000 0.032
25000 0.086
100000 0.402
* User defined MC curves
1
1 1
0
1 1
0 0
* Internally Generated MC curves
1
1 1
0
0
1 1
0 0
* End of file

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-104

1.6.3 Echo Print File

=========================================================================

GROUP for Windows, Version 2016.10.8

Serial Number : 136089307

Analysis of A Group of Piles

Subjected to Axial and Lateral Loading

(c) Copyright ENSOFT, Inc., 1987-2015

All Rights Reserved

=========================================================================

This program is licensed to :

ENSOFT, INC
AUSTIN, TX

Path to file locations : C:\projects\GROUP2016\Group2016_1008\DXE\Examples_2016\

Name of input data file : 2Dexample5.gp10r
Name of output echo file : 2Dexample5.gp10e
Name of output results file : 2Dexample5.gp10o
Name of output summary file : 2Dexample5.gp10t
Name of plot output file : 2Dexample5.gp10p
Name of runtime file : 2Dexample5.gp10r

-------------------------------------------------------------------------
Time and Date of Analysis
-------------------------------------------------------------------------

Date: May 09, 2016 Time: 18:14:12

***** INPUT INFORMATION *****

EXAMPLE PROBLEM 5 - 2D, PILE GROUP IN A CIRCULAR CONFIGURATION

ANALYSIS TYPE = 2D ANALYSIS

ADJUST DEPTH FOR BATTER PILES

GENERATE LOAD-DISP (AND T-R) CURVES BASED ON SOIL PROFILE

EXTEND INTERPOLATION FOR L-DP (AND T-R) CURVES

UNITS SYSTEM = METR

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-105

* TABLE C * LOAD AND CONTROL PARAMETERS

** LOAD CASES **

NUMBER OF LOAD CASES : 1

LOAD CASE : 1
CASE NAME : Load Case 1
LOAD TYPE : Special, Sp
SCALE FACTOR : 1.0000

* CONCENTRATED LOADS *

NL VERT.LOAD HOR.LOAD MOMENT COORD X COORD Y

KN KN KN- M M M
1 40000.0 1400.00 -1.50000E+05 0.00000 0.00000

* EQUIVALENT CONCENTRATED LOAD AT ORIGIN *

VER.LOAD X, KN HOR.LOAD Y, KN MOMENT, KN- M

40000.0 1400.00 -1.50000E+05

* THE LOADING IS CYCLIC *

NO. OF CYCLES = 100.

* CONTROL PARAMETERS *
TOLERANCE ON CONVERGENCE OF PILE CAP MOVEMENT = 1.00000E-07
TOLERANCE ON DETERMINATION OF PILE DEFLECTIONS = 1.00000E-07 M
MAX NO OF ITERATIONS ALLOWED FOR FOUNDATION ANALYSIS = 100
MAXIMUM NO OF ITERATIONS ALLOWED FOR PILE ANALYSIS = 100
FACTOR TO APPLY THE LOAD IN INCREMENTS = 1.0000
MINIMUM FACTOR FOR LOAD INCREMENTS = 1.0000
PRINT RESULTS AT PILE CAP, PILE HEADS AND ALONG PILES
PRINT RESULTS EVERY 1 NODE(S)

* TABLE D * ARRANGEMENT OF PILE GROUPS

GROUP CONNECT NO OF PILE PILE PROP P-Y CURVE L-S CURVE R-F-L SET
1 RES 2 1 0 1 U 0
2 RES 2 1 0 1 U 0
3 RES 2 1 0 1 U 0
4 RES 2 1 0 1 U 0

GROUP VERT, M HOR, M SLOPE, M/ M GROUND, M SPRING, KN- M SPACING, M

1 0.00000 -4.73000 0.00000 10.0000 4.00000E+05 0.00000
2 0.00000 -1.96000 0.00000 10.0000 4.00000E+05 0.00000
3 0.00000 1.96000 0.00000 10.0000 4.00000E+05 0.00000
4 0.00000 4.73000 0.00000 10.0000 4.00000E+05 0.00000

* TABLE E * PILE GEOMETRY AND PROPERTIES

PILE TYPE = 1 - DRIVEN PILE

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-106

= 2 - DRILLED SHAFT

PROP SECTS INC PILE TYPE LENGTH, M

1 1 50 1 150.00

* PILE SECTIONS *

PROP SECT FROM, M TO, M CROSS SECT

1 1 0.00000 150.000 1

* PILE CROSS SECTIONS *

CROSS SECTION : 1
SECTION NAME : Section

TYPE : ELASTIC
CROSS SECTION TYPE : GENERAL SECTION
EQUIVALENT DIAMETER : 1500.00 MM
YOUNG MODULUS : 2.00000E+08 KN/ M**2

* PILE CROSS SECTIONS PROPERTIES *

ELASTIC SECTIONS

SECT DIAM,MM AREA,MM**2 I,MM**4 Mn, KN- M Vn, KN

1 1500.00 8.20000E+05 1.70000E+11 0.00000 0.00000

* TABLE F * SOIL DATA

SOILS INFORMATION

GROUND SURFACE = 10.0000 M

1 LAYER(S) OF SOIL

LAYER 1
THE SOIL IS A SAND
TOP OF LAYER BOTTOM OF LAYER
X COORDINATE ( M) 10.0000 200.000
EFFECTIVE UNIT WEIGHT ( KN/ M**3) 9.50000 9.50000
FRICTION ANGLE (DEGREES) 38.0000 40.0000
P-Y SUBGRADE MODULUS ( KN/ M**3) 120.000 120.000
ULTIMATE UNIT SIDE FRICTION ( KN/ M**2) 0.00000 0.00000
ULTIMATE UNIT TIP RESISTANCE ( KN/ M**2) 0.00000 0.00000

* TABLE H * AXIAL LOAD VS DISPLACEMENT

USER DEFINED AXIAL LOAD-DISPLACEMENT CURVES

NUM OF CURVES 1

CURVE 1 NUM OF POINTS 7

DISPLACEMENT, M AXIAL LOAD, KN

-0.40200 -1.00000E+05
-0.0860000 -25000.0
-0.0320000 -10000.0
0.00000 0.00000
0.0320000 10000.0

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-107

0.0860000 25000.0
0.40200 1.00000E+05

* TABLE J * MOMENT CURVATURE SETS

USER DEFINED MOMENT CURVATURE

NUM OF SETS : 1

CURVE SET 1 NUM OF CURVES 1

CURVE 1 AXIAL LOAD 0.000E+00 KN

POINT MOMENT CURVATURE

KN- M RADIAN/ M
1 0.00000 0.00000

* TABLE K * REDUCTION FACTORS

REDUCTION FACTORS FOR CLOSELY-SPACED PILE GROUPS

GROUP NO P-FACTOR Y-FACTOR

1 0.8500 1.1500
2 0.9000 1.1000
3 0.9000 1.1000
4 0.9500 1.0500

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-108

1.6.4 Processor Run Notes

GROUP for Windows, Version 2016.10.8

-------------------------------------------------------------------------
Time and Date of Analysis
-------------------------------------------------------------------------

Date: May 09, 2016 Time: 18:14:12

EXAMPLE PROBLEM 5 - 2D, PILE GROUP IN A CIRCULAR CONFIGURATION

READING * TITLE AND VERSION

READING * Analysis Parameters
READING * Pile Cap Dimensions
READING * Load Cases
READING * Load Combinations
READING * Distributed Load Sets
READING * Pile Group Configuration
READING * Pile Properties
READING * Pile Cross Sections
READING * Soil Layers
READING * Generated LD curves
READING * User defined LD curves
READING * User defined MC curves
READING * Internally Generated MC curves

COMPUTATION IS PROCEEDING......

LOAD CASE : 1
CASE NAME : Load Case 1

GLOBAL ITERATIONS
STEP 1, TCUR 1.0000, DTCUR 1.0000
ITERATION 1
- ErrDsp 0.10000E+01, IncDsp 0.76405E-01, TotDsp 0.76405E-01
- ErrRot 0.10000E+01, IncRot 0.44587E-02, TotRot 0.44587E-02
ITERATION 2
- ErrDsp 0.52328E-01, IncDsp 0.42156E-02, TotDsp 0.80560E-01
- ErrRot 0.14781E-01, IncRot 0.66891E-04, TotRot 0.45255E-02
ITERATION 3
- ErrDsp 0.24430E-04, IncDsp 0.19682E-05, TotDsp 0.80562E-01
- ErrRot 0.16824E-05, IncRot 0.76139E-08, TotRot 0.45256E-02
ITERATION 4
- ErrDsp 0.42528E-13, IncDsp 0.34261E-14, TotDsp 0.80562E-01
- ErrRot 0.21551E-13, IncRot 0.97528E-16, TotRot 0.45256E-02

NUMBER OF GLOBAL ITERATIONS = 4

ANALYSIS FOR LOAD CASE 1/ 1 FINISHED

Execution Time : 67 ms
Number Processors : 1/ 1
Serial processing : 0.036 sec
Paral. processing : 0.006 sec
Print. processing : 0.025 sec

ANALYSIS COMPLETED
Execution Time : 67 ms

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-109

Number Processors : 1/ 1

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-110

1.6.5 Output Results File

=========================================================================

GROUP for Windows, Version 2016.10.8

Serial Number : 136089307

Analysis of A Group of Piles

Subjected to Axial and Lateral Loading

(c) Copyright ENSOFT, Inc., 1987-2015

All Rights Reserved

=========================================================================

This program is licensed to :

ENSOFT, INC
AUSTIN, TX

Path to file locations : C:\projects\GROUP2016\Group2016_1008\DXE\Examples_2016\

Name of input data file : 2Dexample5.gp10d
Name of output echo file : 2Dexample5.gp10e
Name of output results file : 2Dexample5.gp10o
Name of output summary file : 2Dexample5.gp10t
Name of plot output file : 2Dexample5.gp10p
Name of runtime file : 2Dexample5.gp10r

-------------------------------------------------------------------------
Time and Date of Analysis
-------------------------------------------------------------------------

Date: May 09, 2016 Time: 18:14:12

***** COMPUTATION RESULTS *****

EXAMPLE PROBLEM 5 - 2D, PILE GROUP IN A CIRCULAR CONFIGURATION

***** LOAD CASES RESULTS *****

LOAD CASE : 1
CASE NAME : Load Case 1
LOAD TYPE : Special, Sp

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-111

REDUCTION FACTORS FOR CLOSELY-SPACED PILE GROUPS

ESTIMATED USING MOVEMENT IN THE DIRECTION OF PILE CAP DISPLACEMENTS

GROUP NO P-FACTOR Y-FACTOR

1 0.8500 1.1500
2 0.9000 1.1000
3 0.9000 1.1000
4 0.9500 1.0500

* TABLE L * COMPUTATION ON PILE CAP

* EQUIVALENT CONCENTRATED LOAD AT ORIGIN *

VERT. LOAD, KN HORI. LOAD, KN MOMENT, KN- M

40000.0 1400.00 -1.50000E+05

* DISPLACEMENT OF GROUPED PILE FOUNDATION AT ORIGIN *

VERTICAL, M HORIZONTAL, M ROTATION,RAD

0.0161545 0.0789259 -4.52555E-03

NUMBER OF ITERATIONS = 4

* TABLE M * COMPUTATION ON INDIVIDUAL PILE

* PILE GROUP * 1

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS AND REACTIONS *

THE GLOBAL STRUCTURAL COORDINATE SYSTEM

---------------------------------------

DISP.X, M DISP.Y, M SLOPE FOR.X, K FOR.Y, K BM, K- M STRESS, K/ M**2

-5.2514E-03 0.078926 -4.5256E-03 -1641.1 182.21 -468.46 4068.1

THE PILE COORDINATE SYSTEM (LOCAL AXES)

---------------------------------------

DISP.x, M DISP.y, M SLOPE AXIAL, K LAT, K BM, K- M STRESS, KN/ M**2

-5.2514E-03 0.078926 -4.5256E-03 -1641.1 182.21 -468.46 4068.1

* EFFECTS FOR LATERALLY LOADED PILE *

x DISPL. BENDING SHEAR SOIL TOTAL FLEXURAL

y-DIR MOMENT FORCE REACTION STRESS RIGIDITY

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-112

M M KN- M KN KN/ M KN- M**2 KN- M**2

********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
0.0000 7.8926E-02 468.46 182.24 0.0000 4068.1 3.4000E+07
3.0000 6.8925E-02 998.68 182.21 0.0000 6407.2 3.4000E+07
6.0000 5.9188E-02 1529.3 182.21 0.0000 8748.3 3.4000E+07
9.0000 4.9856E-02 2060.6 182.21 0.0000 1.1092E+04 3.4000E+07
12.000 4.1069E-02 2592.9 171.28 7.2853 1.3440E+04 3.4000E+07
15.000 3.2969E-02 3060.6 138.42 14.621 1.5504E+04 3.4000E+07
18.000 2.5679E-02 3398.1 89.158 18.221 1.6993E+04 3.4000E+07
21.000 1.9289E-02 3573.1 33.598 18.819 1.7765E+04 3.4000E+07
24.000 1.3844E-02 3580.3 -20.416 17.191 1.7797E+04 3.4000E+07
27.000 9.3470E-03 3434.3 -67.343 14.094 1.7153E+04 3.4000E+07
30.000 5.7591E-03 3163.0 -103.81 10.216 1.5956E+04 3.4000E+07
33.000 3.0085E-03 2801.1 -128.34 6.1373 1.4359E+04 3.4000E+07
36.000 9.9933E-04 2385.1 -141.00 2.3045 1.2524E+04 3.4000E+07
39.000 -3.7848E-04 1949.5 -143.00 -0.9735 1.0602E+04 3.4000E+07
42.000 -1.2402E-03 1523.5 -136.26 -3.5201 8722.5 3.4000E+07
45.000 -1.6987E-03 1129.8 -123.07 -5.2735 6985.7 3.4000E+07
48.000 -1.8582E-03 784.07 -105.76 -6.2628 5460.4 3.4000E+07
51.000 -1.8100E-03 495.04 -86.494 -6.5823 4185.3 3.4000E+07
54.000 -1.6309E-03 265.47 -67.074 -6.3647 3172.5 3.4000E+07
57.000 -1.3814E-03 93.304 -48.888 -5.7588 2412.9 3.4000E+07
60.000 -1.1073E-03 -26.996 -32.884 -4.9107 2120.4 3.4000E+07
63.000 -8.4033E-04 -103.11 -19.593 -3.9503 2456.2 3.4000E+07
66.000 -6.0064E-04 -143.72 -9.1920 -2.9834 2635.4 3.4000E+07
69.000 -3.9899E-04 -157.54 -1.5851 -2.0880 2696.3 3.4000E+07
72.000 -2.3905E-04 -152.64 3.5187 -1.3146 2674.7 3.4000E+07
75.000 -1.1951E-04 -135.97 6.5240 -0.6890 2601.2 3.4000E+07
78.000 -3.5955E-05 -113.16 7.8827 -0.2169 2500.5 3.4000E+07
81.000 1.7641E-05 -88.448 8.0414 0.1111 2391.5 3.4000E+07
84.000 4.7825E-05 -64.774 7.4039 0.3139 2287.1 3.4000E+07
87.000 6.0862E-05 -43.953 6.3095 0.4157 2195.2 3.4000E+07
90.000 6.2265E-05 -26.893 5.0233 0.4418 2119.9 3.4000E+07
93.000 5.6550E-05 -13.820 3.7362 0.4163 2062.3 3.4000E+07
96.000 4.7175E-05 -4.5007 2.5719 0.3598 2021.2 3.4000E+07
99.000 3.6610E-05 1.5784 1.5987 0.2890 2008.3 3.4000E+07
102.00 2.6462E-05 5.0573 0.8413 0.2159 2023.6 3.4000E+07
105.00 1.7653E-05 6.5950 0.2943 0.1487 2030.4 3.4000E+07
108.00 1.0590E-05 6.7969 -6.6936E-02 9.2051E-02 2031.3 3.4000E+07
111.00 5.3260E-06 6.1732 -0.2766 4.7712E-02 2028.5 3.4000E+07
114.00 1.6961E-06 5.1228 -0.3716 1.5645E-02 2023.9 3.4000E+07
117.00 -5.7785E-07 3.9338 -0.3869 -5.4840E-03 2018.7 3.4000E+07
120.00 -1.8105E-06 2.7959 -0.3521 -1.7664E-02 2013.6 3.4000E+07
123.00 -2.3030E-06 1.8181 -0.2910 -2.3082E-02 2009.3 3.4000E+07
126.00 -2.3143E-06 1.0489 -0.2207 -2.3811E-02 2005.9 3.4000E+07
129.00 -2.0479E-06 0.4945 -0.1525 -2.1615E-02 2003.5 3.4000E+07
132.00 -1.6506E-06 0.1348 -9.3322E-02 -1.7861E-02 2001.9 3.4000E+07
135.00 -1.2177E-06 -6.4063E-02 -4.6280E-02 -1.3500E-02 2001.6 3.4000E+07
138.00 -8.0164E-07 -0.1415 -1.2378E-02 -9.1011E-03 2001.9 3.4000E+07
141.00 -4.2308E-07 -0.1370 8.6475E-03 -4.9158E-03 2001.9 3.4000E+07
144.00 -8.0781E-08 -8.8401E-02 1.7461E-02 -9.6010E-04 2001.7 3.4000E+07
147.00 2.3811E-07 -3.1173E-02 1.4561E-02 2.8934E-03 2001.4 3.4000E+07
150.00 5.4876E-07 -3.9999E-16 -1.6884E-16 6.8141E-03 2001.3 3.4000E+07

* PILE GROUP * 2

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS AND REACTIONS *

THE GLOBAL STRUCTURAL COORDINATE SYSTEM

---------------------------------------

DISP.X, M DISP.Y, M SLOPE FOR.X, K FOR.Y, K BM, K- M STRESS, K/ M**2

7.2844E-03 0.078926 -4.5256E-03 2276.4 181.89 -445.49 4741.4

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-113

THE PILE COORDINATE SYSTEM (LOCAL AXES)

---------------------------------------

DISP.x, M DISP.y, M SLOPE AXIAL, K LAT, K BM, K- M STRESS, KN/ M**2

7.2844E-03 0.078926 -4.5256E-03 2276.4 181.89 -445.49 4741.4

* EFFECTS FOR LATERALLY LOADED PILE *

x DISPL. BENDING SHEAR SOIL TOTAL FLEXURAL

y-DIR MOMENT FORCE REACTION STRESS RIGIDITY
M M KN- M KN KN/ M KN- M**2 KN- M**2
********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
0.0000 7.8926E-02 445.49 181.84 0.0000 4741.4 3.4000E+07
3.0000 6.8749E-02 1014.3 181.89 0.0000 7251.0 3.4000E+07
6.0000 5.8841E-02 1582.5 181.89 0.0000 9757.8 3.4000E+07
9.0000 4.9352E-02 2149.8 181.89 0.0000 1.2260E+04 3.4000E+07
12.000 4.0432E-02 2715.8 169.98 7.9394 1.4757E+04 3.4000E+07
15.000 3.2231E-02 3208.6 134.34 15.822 1.6932E+04 3.4000E+07
18.000 2.4879E-02 3557.2 81.289 19.541 1.8469E+04 3.4000E+07
21.000 1.8469E-02 3727.7 22.058 19.946 1.9222E+04 3.4000E+07
24.000 1.3045E-02 3716.5 -34.759 17.931 1.9172E+04 3.4000E+07
27.000 8.6056E-03 3541.6 -83.202 14.364 1.8401E+04 3.4000E+07
30.000 5.1034E-03 3235.3 -119.78 10.021 1.7050E+04 3.4000E+07
33.000 2.4576E-03 2836.9 -143.14 5.5496 1.5292E+04 3.4000E+07
36.000 5.6266E-04 2386.9 -153.61 1.4363 1.3306E+04 3.4000E+07
39.000 -7.0041E-04 1922.4 -152.78 -1.9943 1.1257E+04 3.4000E+07
42.000 -1.4546E-03 1474.8 -142.93 -4.5701 9282.4 3.4000E+07
45.000 -1.8184E-03 1067.4 -126.70 -6.2488 7485.1 3.4000E+07
48.000 -1.8997E-03 715.58 -106.70 -7.0876 5933.0 3.4000E+07
51.000 -1.7916E-03 427.14 -85.248 -7.2118 4660.5 3.4000E+07
54.000 -1.5703E-03 203.34 -64.255 -6.7839 3673.1 3.4000E+07
57.000 -1.2953E-03 40.477 -45.113 -5.9773 2954.6 3.4000E+07
60.000 -1.0096E-03 -68.615 -28.713 -4.9560 3078.8 3.4000E+07
63.000 -7.4197E-04 -133.06 -15.488 -3.8609 3363.1 3.4000E+07
66.000 -5.0960E-04 -162.68 -5.4937 -2.8019 3493.8 3.4000E+07
69.000 -3.2030E-04 -166.98 1.4922 -1.8554 3512.8 3.4000E+07
72.000 -1.7520E-04 -154.49 5.8751 -1.0665 3457.6 3.4000E+07
75.000 -7.0991E-05 -132.30 8.1544 -0.4531 3359.7 3.4000E+07
78.000 -1.8053E-06 -105.96 8.8520 -1.2053E-02 3243.5 3.4000E+07
81.000 3.9333E-05 -79.440 8.4588 0.2742 3126.5 3.4000E+07
84.000 5.9444E-05 -55.343 7.3997 0.4319 3020.2 3.4000E+07
87.000 6.4904E-05 -35.100 6.0159 0.4907 2930.9 3.4000E+07
90.000 6.1074E-05 -19.252 4.5603 0.4797 2861.0 3.4000E+07
93.000 5.2147E-05 -7.7092 3.2033 0.4250 2810.1 3.4000E+07
96.000 4.1180E-05 1.3384E-02 2.0443 0.3477 2776.1 3.4000E+07
99.000 3.0216E-05 4.6066 1.1267 0.2640 2796.4 3.4000E+07
102.00 2.0472E-05 6.8208 0.4533 0.1849 2806.1 3.4000E+07
105.00 1.2533E-05 7.3666 5.6994E-04 0.1169 2808.6 3.4000E+07
108.00 6.5440E-06 6.8559 -0.2692 6.2965E-02 2806.3 3.4000E+07
111.00 2.3700E-06 5.7744 -0.3989 2.3501E-02 2801.5 3.4000E+07
114.00 -2.7559E-07 4.4779 -0.4300 -2.8140E-03 2795.8 3.4000E+07
117.00 -1.7358E-06 3.2040 -0.3984 -1.8235E-02 2790.2 3.4000E+07
120.00 -2.3479E-06 2.0923 -0.3330 -2.5357E-02 2785.3 3.4000E+07
123.00 -2.4061E-06 1.2076 -0.2549 -2.6695E-02 2781.4 3.4000E+07
126.00 -2.1447E-06 0.5624 -0.1782 -2.4426E-02 2778.5 3.4000E+07
129.00 -1.7344E-06 0.1367 -0.1112 -2.0264E-02 2776.7 3.4000E+07
132.00 -1.2879E-06 -0.1067 -5.7661E-02 -1.5427E-02 2776.5 3.4000E+07
135.00 -8.6970E-07 -0.2113 -1.8510E-02 -1.0674E-02 2777.0 3.4000E+07
138.00 -5.0740E-07 -0.2196 7.0652E-03 -6.3766E-03 2777.0 3.4000E+07
141.00 -2.0322E-07 -0.1704 2.0551E-02 -2.6137E-03 2776.8 3.4000E+07
144.00 5.5863E-08 -9.7555E-02 2.3369E-02 7.3495E-04 2776.5 3.4000E+07
147.00 2.8912E-07 -3.1287E-02 1.6433E-02 3.8889E-03 2776.2 3.4000E+07
150.00 5.1409E-07 3.9999E-16 2.5397E-17 7.0664E-03 2776.1 3.4000E+07

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-114

* PILE GROUP * 3

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS AND REACTIONS *

THE GLOBAL STRUCTURAL COORDINATE SYSTEM

---------------------------------------

DISP.X, M DISP.Y, M SLOPE FOR.X, K FOR.Y, K BM, K- M STRESS, K/ M**2

0.025025 0.078926 -4.5256E-03 7820.2 168.05 -437.44 1.1467E+04

THE PILE COORDINATE SYSTEM (LOCAL AXES)

---------------------------------------

DISP.x, M DISP.y, M SLOPE AXIAL, K LAT, K BM, K- M STRESS, KN/ M**2

0.025025 0.078926 -4.5256E-03 7820.2 168.05 -437.44 1.1467E+04

* EFFECTS FOR LATERALLY LOADED PILE *

x DISPL. BENDING SHEAR SOIL TOTAL FLEXURAL

y-DIR MOMENT FORCE REACTION STRESS RIGIDITY
M M KN- M KN KN/ M KN- M**2 KN- M**2
********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
0.0000 7.8926E-02 437.44 167.90 0.0000 1.1467E+04 3.4000E+07
3.0000 6.8688E-02 1021.6 168.05 0.0000 1.4044E+04 3.4000E+07
6.0000 5.8720E-02 1603.7 168.05 0.0000 1.6612E+04 3.4000E+07
9.0000 4.9177E-02 2182.5 168.05 0.0000 1.9166E+04 3.4000E+07
12.000 4.0212E-02 2756.8 156.20 7.8962 2.1699E+04 3.4000E+07
15.000 3.1977E-02 3254.3 120.81 15.698 2.3894E+04 3.4000E+07
18.000 2.4602E-02 3603.7 68.281 19.324 2.5436E+04 3.4000E+07
21.000 1.8182E-02 3771.8 9.8397 19.637 2.6177E+04 3.4000E+07
24.000 1.2760E-02 3755.4 -45.925 17.540 2.6105E+04 3.4000E+07
27.000 8.3327E-03 3573.3 -93.097 13.908 2.5301E+04 3.4000E+07
30.000 4.8508E-03 3258.6 -128.25 9.5253 2.3913E+04 3.4000E+07
33.000 2.2316E-03 2851.5 -150.09 5.0393 2.2117E+04 3.4000E+07
36.000 3.6711E-04 2393.1 -159.06 0.9371 2.0095E+04 3.4000E+07
39.000 -8.6387E-04 1921.4 -156.77 -2.4597 1.8013E+04 3.4000E+07
42.000 -1.5863E-03 1467.8 -145.61 -4.9837 1.6012E+04 3.4000E+07
45.000 -1.9201E-03 1056.0 -128.24 -6.5982 1.4196E+04 3.4000E+07
48.000 -1.9744E-03 701.39 -107.29 -7.3664 1.2631E+04 3.4000E+07
51.000 -1.8431E-03 411.64 -85.111 -7.4193 1.1353E+04 3.4000E+07
54.000 -1.6028E-03 187.82 -63.596 -6.9241 1.0365E+04 3.4000E+07
57.000 -1.3128E-03 25.920 -44.123 -6.0579 9651.1 3.4000E+07
60.000 -1.0159E-03 -81.509 -27.555 -4.9872 9896.4 3.4000E+07
63.000 -7.4061E-04 -143.89 -14.294 -3.8538 1.0172E+04 3.4000E+07
66.000 -5.0339E-04 -171.28 -4.3613 -2.7677 1.0292E+04 3.4000E+07
69.000 -3.1152E-04 -173.41 2.4971 -1.8045 1.0302E+04 3.4000E+07
72.000 -1.6555E-04 -158.94 6.7155 -1.0077 1.0238E+04 3.4000E+07
75.000 -6.1647E-05 -135.07 8.8172 -0.3934 1.0133E+04 3.4000E+07
78.000 6.4997E-06 -107.38 9.3423 4.3394E-02 1.0011E+04 3.4000E+07
81.000 4.6222E-05 -79.860 8.7939 0.3222 9889.1 3.4000E+07
84.000 6.4804E-05 -55.073 7.6043 0.4708 9779.8 3.4000E+07
87.000 6.8809E-05 -34.410 6.1178 0.5202 9688.6 3.4000E+07
90.000 6.3704E-05 -18.358 4.5869 0.5004 9617.8 3.4000E+07
93.000 5.3741E-05 -6.7710 3.1795 0.4379 9566.7 3.4000E+07
96.000 4.1985E-05 0.8886 1.9908 0.3545 9540.7 3.4000E+07
99.000 3.0464E-05 5.3559 1.0597 0.2662 9560.4 3.4000E+07
102.00 2.0361E-05 7.4162 0.3846 0.1839 9569.5 3.4000E+07
105.00 1.2221E-05 7.8060 -6.2278E-02 0.1140 9571.2 3.4000E+07

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-115

108.00 6.1473E-06 7.1537 -0.3220 5.9149E-02 9568.3 3.4000E+07

111.00 1.9673E-06 5.9543 -0.4400 1.9509E-02 9563.1 3.4000E+07
114.00 -6.3656E-07 4.5669 -0.4595 -6.4999E-03 9556.9 3.4000E+07
117.00 -2.0315E-06 3.2287 -0.4177 -2.1342E-02 9551.0 3.4000E+07
120.00 -2.5719E-06 2.0758 -0.3440 -2.7776E-02 9545.9 3.4000E+07
123.00 -2.5627E-06 1.1686 -0.2597 -2.8432E-02 9541.9 3.4000E+07
126.00 -2.2443E-06 0.5148 -0.1787 -2.5560E-02 9539.1 3.4000E+07
129.00 -1.7895E-06 9.0092E-02 -0.1090 -2.0908E-02 9537.2 3.4000E+07
132.00 -1.3110E-06 -0.1467 -5.4119E-02 -1.5703E-02 9537.4 3.4000E+07
135.00 -8.7119E-07 -0.2418 -1.4526E-02 -1.0692E-02 9537.9 3.4000E+07
138.00 -4.9543E-07 -0.2402 1.0851E-02 -6.2262E-03 9537.8 3.4000E+07
141.00 -1.8325E-07 -0.1821 2.3725E-02 -2.3570E-03 9537.6 3.4000E+07
144.00 8.0726E-08 -0.1024 2.5668E-02 1.0621E-03 9537.2 3.4000E+07
147.00 3.1761E-07 -3.1988E-02 1.7666E-02 4.2721E-03 9536.9 3.4000E+07
150.00 5.4603E-07 -3.9999E-16 -7.2642E-18 7.5054E-03 9536.8 3.4000E+07

* PILE GROUP * 4

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS AND REACTIONS *

THE GLOBAL STRUCTURAL COORDINATE SYSTEM

---------------------------------------

DISP.X, M DISP.Y, M SLOPE FOR.X, K FOR.Y, K BM, K- M STRESS, K/ M**2

0.037560 0.078926 -4.5256E-03 1.1545E+04 167.86 -414.88 1.5909E+04

THE PILE COORDINATE SYSTEM (LOCAL AXES)

---------------------------------------

DISP.x, M DISP.y, M SLOPE AXIAL, K LAT, K BM, K- M STRESS, KN/ M**2

0.037560 0.078926 -4.5256E-03 1.1545E+04 167.86 -414.88 1.5909E+04

* EFFECTS FOR LATERALLY LOADED PILE *

x DISPL. BENDING SHEAR SOIL TOTAL FLEXURAL

y-DIR MOMENT FORCE REACTION STRESS RIGIDITY
M M KN- M KN KN/ M KN- M**2 KN- M**2
********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
0.0000 7.8926E-02 414.88 167.64 0.0000 1.5909E+04 3.4000E+07
3.0000 6.8516E-02 1038.6 167.86 0.0000 1.8661E+04 3.4000E+07
6.0000 5.8381E-02 1659.2 167.86 0.0000 2.1399E+04 3.4000E+07
9.0000 4.8685E-02 2274.7 167.86 0.0000 2.4114E+04 3.4000E+07
12.000 3.9591E-02 2883.3 154.96 8.5968 2.6799E+04 3.4000E+07
15.000 3.1260E-02 3405.6 116.61 16.970 2.9103E+04 3.4000E+07
18.000 2.3831E-02 3764.9 60.107 20.699 3.0688E+04 3.4000E+07
21.000 1.7398E-02 3926.3 -2.1086 20.779 3.1401E+04 3.4000E+07
24.000 1.2005E-02 3888.7 -60.648 18.248 3.1235E+04 3.4000E+07
27.000 7.6411E-03 3675.0 -109.17 14.103 3.0292E+04 3.4000E+07
30.000 4.2500E-03 3323.2 -144.17 9.2286 2.8740E+04 3.4000E+07
33.000 1.7386E-03 2878.2 -164.53 4.3415 2.6776E+04 3.4000E+07
36.000 -1.0953E-05 2385.2 -170.99 -3.0919E-02 2.4602E+04 3.4000E+07
39.000 -1.1291E-03 1885.3 -165.61 -3.5551 2.2396E+04 3.4000E+07
42.000 -1.7482E-03 1411.6 -151.17 -6.0739 2.0306E+04 3.4000E+07
45.000 -1.9937E-03 988.26 -130.70 -7.5761 1.8439E+04 3.4000E+07
48.000 -1.9776E-03 630.08 -107.09 -8.1589 1.6858E+04 3.4000E+07
51.000 -1.7946E-03 343.40 -82.872 -7.9887 1.5594E+04 3.4000E+07
54.000 -1.5208E-03 127.57 -59.991 -7.2651 1.4642E+04 3.4000E+07
57.000 -1.2132E-03 -23.259 -39.807 -6.1909 1.4181E+04 3.4000E+07

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-116

60.000 -9.1178E-04 -118.30 -23.097 -4.9497 1.4601E+04 3.4000E+07

63.000 -6.4166E-04 -168.44 -10.134 -3.6923 1.4822E+04 3.4000E+07
66.000 -4.1612E-04 -184.83 -0.8001 -2.5300 1.4894E+04 3.4000E+07
69.000 -2.3951E-04 -177.88 5.2962 -1.5342 1.4863E+04 3.4000E+07
72.000 -1.0998E-04 -156.58 8.7081 -0.7403 1.4770E+04 3.4000E+07
75.000 -2.1905E-05 -128.14 10.050 -0.1546 1.4644E+04 3.4000E+07
78.000 3.2252E-05 -97.922 9.9252 0.2381 1.4511E+04 3.4000E+07
81.000 6.0490E-05 -69.543 8.8686 0.4663 1.4386E+04 3.4000E+07
84.000 7.0318E-05 -45.149 7.3217 0.5650 1.4278E+04 3.4000E+07
87.000 6.8196E-05 -25.702 5.6191 0.5701 1.4192E+04 3.4000E+07
90.000 5.9269E-05 -11.307 3.9917 0.5148 1.4129E+04 3.4000E+07
93.000 4.7350E-05 -1.5109 2.5795 0.4267 1.4085E+04 3.4000E+07
96.000 3.5031E-05 4.4497 1.4488 0.3271 1.4098E+04 3.4000E+07
99.000 2.3890E-05 7.4530 0.6119 0.2308 1.4112E+04 3.4000E+07
102.00 1.4721E-05 8.3558 4.5105E-02 0.1470 1.4116E+04 3.4000E+07
105.00 7.7648E-06 7.9098 -0.2956 8.0088E-02 1.4114E+04 3.4000E+07
108.00 2.9019E-06 6.7187 -0.4620 3.0876E-02 1.4108E+04 3.4000E+07
111.00 -1.8243E-07 5.2293 -0.5054 -2.0005E-03 1.4102E+04 3.4000E+07
114.00 -1.8826E-06 3.7418 -0.4705 -2.1257E-02 1.4095E+04 3.4000E+07
117.00 -2.5922E-06 2.4343 -0.3934 -3.0114E-02 1.4089E+04 3.4000E+07
120.00 -2.6575E-06 1.3903 -0.3006 -3.1738E-02 1.4085E+04 3.4000E+07
123.00 -2.3548E-06 0.6277 -0.2097 -2.8890E-02 1.4081E+04 3.4000E+07
126.00 -1.8859E-06 0.1232 -0.1307 -2.3752E-02 1.4079E+04 3.4000E+07
129.00 -1.3844E-06 -0.1679 -6.8273E-02 -1.7886E-02 1.4079E+04 3.4000E+07
132.00 -9.2733E-07 -0.2975 -2.3019E-02 -1.2283E-02 1.4080E+04 3.4000E+07
135.00 -5.4900E-07 -0.3156 6.5821E-03 -7.4507E-03 1.4080E+04 3.4000E+07
138.00 -2.5422E-07 -0.2658 2.3058E-02 -3.5330E-03 1.4080E+04 3.4000E+07
141.00 -2.9789E-08 -0.1833 2.8993E-02 -4.2369E-04 1.4080E+04 3.4000E+07
144.00 1.4613E-07 -9.6420E-02 2.6439E-02 2.1260E-03 1.4079E+04 3.4000E+07
147.00 2.9652E-07 -2.8406E-02 1.6634E-02 4.4106E-03 1.4079E+04 3.4000E+07
150.00 4.3940E-07 0.0000 9.1073E-18 6.6789E-03 1.4079E+04 3.4000E+07

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-117

1.6.6 Summary Results File

=========================================================================

GROUP for Windows, Version 2016.10.8

Serial Number : 136089307

Analysis of A Group of Piles

Subjected to Axial and Lateral Loading

(c) Copyright ENSOFT, Inc., 1987-2015

All Rights Reserved

=========================================================================

-------------------------------------------------------------------------
Time and Date of Analysis
-------------------------------------------------------------------------

Date: May 09, 2016 Time: 18:14:12

***** COMPUTATION RESULTS *****

EXAMPLE PROBLEM 5 - 2D, PILE GROUP IN A CIRCULAR CONFIGURATION

***** LOAD CASES RESULTS *****

LOAD CASE : 1
CASE NAME : Load Case 1
LOAD TYPE : Special, Sp

REDUCTION FACTORS FOR CLOSELY-SPACED PILE GROUPS

ESTIMATED USING MOVEMENT IN THE DIRECTION OF PILE CAP DISPLACEMENTS

GROUP NO P-FACTOR Y-FACTOR

1 0.8500 1.1500
2 0.9000 1.1000
3 0.9000 1.1000
4 0.9500 1.0500

* TABLE L * COMPUTATION ON PILE CAP

* EQUIVALENT CONCENTRATED LOAD AT ORIGIN *

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-118

VERT. LOAD, KN HORI. LOAD, KN MOMENT, KN- M

40000.0 1400.00 -1.50000E+05

* DISPLACEMENT OF GROUPED PILE FOUNDATION AT ORIGIN *

VERTICAL, M HORIZONTAL, M ROTATION,RAD

0.0161545 0.0789259 -4.52555E-03

* TABLE M * COMPUTATION ON INDIVIDUAL PILE

THE GLOBAL STRUCTURAL COORDINATE SYSTEM

---------------------------------------

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS *

PILE GROUP DISP. X, M DISP. Y, M ROT. Z,RAD

********** *********** *********** ***********
1 -5.2514E-03 0.078926 -4.5255E-03
2 7.2844E-03 0.078926 -4.5255E-03
3 0.025025 0.078926 -4.5255E-03
4 0.037560 0.078926 -4.5255E-03

MINIMUM -5.2514E-03 0.078926 -4.5255E-03

Pile G. 1 1 1
MAXIMUM 0.037560 0.078926 -4.5255E-03
Pile G. 4 1 1

* PILE TOP REACTIONS *

PILE GROUP FOR. X, KN FOR. Y, KN MOM Z, KN- M STRESS, KN/ M**2

********** *********** *********** ************ ****************
1 -1641.1 182.21 -468.46 4068.1
2 2276.4 181.89 -445.49 4741.4
3 7820.2 168.05 -437.44 1.1467E+04
4 1.1545E+04 167.86 -414.88 1.5909E+04

MINIMUM -1641.1 167.86 -468.46 4068.1

Pile G. 1 4 1 1
MAXIMUM 1.1545E+04 182.21 -414.88 1.5909E+04
Pile G. 4 1 4 4

THE PILE COORDINATE SYSTEM (LOCAL AXES)

---------------------------------------

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS *

PILE GROUP DISP. x, M DISP. y, M ROT. z,RAD

********** *********** *********** ***********
1 -5.2514E-03 0.078926 -4.5255E-03
2 7.2844E-03 0.078926 -4.5255E-03
3 0.025025 0.078926 -4.5255E-03
4 0.037560 0.078926 -4.5255E-03

MINIMUM -5.2514E-03 0.078926 -4.5255E-03

Pile G. 1 1 1
MAXIMUM 0.037560 0.078926 -4.5255E-03
Pile G. 4 1 1

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-119

* PILE TOP REACTIONS *

PILE GROUP AXIAL, KN LAT. y, KN MOM z, KN- M STRESS, KN/ M**2

********** *********** *********** ************ ****************
1 -1641.1 182.21 -468.46 4068.1
2 2276.4 181.89 -445.49 4741.4
3 7820.2 168.05 -437.44 1.1467E+04
4 1.1545E+04 167.86 -414.88 1.5909E+04

MINIMUM -1641.1 167.86 -468.46 4068.1

Pile G. 1 4 1 1
MAXIMUM 1.1545E+04 182.21 -414.88 1.5909E+04
Pile G. 4 1 4 4

* EFFECTS FOR LATERALLY LOADED PILE *

* MINIMUM VALUES AND LOCATIONS *

PILE DISPL. BENDING SHEAR SOIL TOTAL FLEXURAL

y-DIR MOMENT FORCE REACTION STRESS RIGIDITY
M KN- M KN KN/ M KN- M**2 KN- M**2
****** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
1 -1.8582E-03 -157.54 -143.00 -6.5823 2001.3 3.4000E+07
x( M) 48.000 69.000 39.000 51.000 150.00 0.0000
2 -1.8997E-03 -166.98 -153.61 -7.2118 2776.1 3.4000E+07
x( M) 48.000 69.000 36.000 51.000 150.00 0.0000
3 -1.9744E-03 -173.41 -159.06 -7.4193 9536.8 3.4000E+07
x( M) 48.000 69.000 36.000 51.000 150.00 0.0000
4 -1.9937E-03 -184.83 -170.99 -8.1589 1.4079E+04 3.4000E+07
x( M) 45.000 66.000 36.000 48.000 150.00 0.0000

Min. -1.9937E-03 -184.83 -170.99 -8.1589 2001.3 3.4000E+07

Pile N. 4 4 4 4 1 1

* MAXIMUM VALUES AND LOCATIONS *

PILE DISPL. BENDING SHEAR SOIL TOTAL FLEXURAL

y-DIR MOMENT FORCE REACTION STRESS RIGIDITY
M KN- M KN KN/ M KN- M**2 KN- M**2
****** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
1 0.078926 3580.3 182.24 18.819 1.7797E+04 3.4000E+07
x( M) 0.0000 24.000 0.0000 21.000 24.000 0.0000
2 0.078926 3727.7 181.89 19.946 1.9222E+04 3.4000E+07
x( M) 0.0000 21.000 3.0000 21.000 21.000 0.0000
3 0.078926 3771.8 168.05 19.637 2.6177E+04 3.4000E+07
x( M) 0.0000 21.000 9.0000 21.000 21.000 0.0000
4 0.078926 3926.3 167.86 20.779 3.1401E+04 3.4000E+07
x( M) 0.0000 21.000 9.0000 21.000 21.000 0.0000

Max. 0.078926 3926.3 182.24 20.779 3.1401E+04 3.4000E+07

Pile N. 1 4 1 4 4 1

***** SUMMARY FOR LOAD CASES AND COMBINATIONS *****

***** LOAD CASES RESULTS *****

LOAD CASE : 1

* EQUIVALENT CONCENTRATED LOAD AT ORIGIN *

LOAD X, KN LOAD Y, KN MOM Z, KN- M
40000.0 1400.00 -1.50000E+05

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-120

* DISPLACEMENT OF GROUPED PILE FOUNDATION AT ORIGIN *

DISP X, M DISP Y, M ROT Z,RAD
0.0161545 0.0789259 -4.52555E-03

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS, GLOBAL *

DISP. X, M DISP. Y, M ROT. Z,RAD
*********** *********** ***********
MINIMUM -5.2514E-03 0.078926 -4.5255E-03
Pile G. 1 1 1
MAXIMUM 0.037560 0.078926 -4.5255E-03
Pile G. 4 1 1

* PILE TOP REACTIONS, GLOBAL *

FOR. X, KN FOR. Y, KN MOM Z, KN- M STRESS, KN/ M**2
*********** *********** ************ ****************
MINIMUM -1641.1 167.86 -468.46 4068.1
Pile G. 1 4 1 1
MAXIMUM 1.1545E+04 182.21 -414.88 1.5909E+04
Pile G. 4 1 4 4

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS, LOCAL *

DISP. x, M DISP. y, M ROT. z,RAD
*********** *********** ***********
MINIMUM -5.2514E-03 0.078926 -4.5255E-03
Pile G. 1 1 1
MAXIMUM 0.037560 0.078926 -4.5255E-03
Pile G. 4 1 1

* PILE TOP REACTIONS, LOCAL *

AXIAL, KN LAT. y, KN MOM z, KN- M STRESS, KN/ M**2
*********** *********** ************ ****************
MINIMUM -1641.1 167.86 -468.46 4068.1
Pile G. 1 4 1 1
MAXIMUM 1.1545E+04 182.21 -414.88 1.5909E+04
Pile G. 4 1 4 4

* EFFECTS FOR LATERALLY LOADED PILE *

PILE DISPL. BENDING SHEAR SOIL TOTAL FLEXURAL

y-DIR MOMENT FORCE REACTION STRESS RIGIDITY
M KN- M KN KN/ M KN- M**2 KN- M**2
****** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
Min. -1.9937E-03 -184.83 -170.99 -8.1589 2001.3 3.4000E+07
Pile N. 4 4 4 4 1 1
Max. 0.078926 3926.3 182.24 20.779 3.1401E+04 3.4000E+07
Pile N. 1 4 1 4 4 1

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-121

1.6.7 Graphs

Figure 1.20 Curves Deflection vs. Distance for Example Problem 5 - 2D.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-122

Figure 1.21 Curves Moment vs. Distance for Example Problem 5 - 2D.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-123

1.7 Example Problem 6 - 2D

1.7.1 Model Description

This example problem is used to illustrate the feature of internal generation of curves of axial
load versus displacement. There are 3 piles with different dimensions as shown in Figure 1.22. The soil
at the site is stiff clay with a cohesive strength of 17.4 psi. The maximum load-transfer for axial loads is
estimated to be 8.7 psi. The curves of load versus displacement that were generated by the program
are presented in the output..

The input and output files for the example problem are shown in the following pages.

Figure 1.22 General Description of Example Problem 6 - 2D.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-124

1.7.2 Input Data

EXAMPLE PROBLEM 6 - 2D, INTERNAL LOAD-DISPLACEMENT

GROUP2016.10.8
* Analysis Parameters
1 2 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 1
* Pile Cap Dimensions
0 0 0 0 0 0
* Load Cases
1 0 0 1 0
0 1 1 1 1 75 75
0.0001 0.0001 1 1
Load Case 1
12 0 0 0 1 0 0 0
2 1 1 0 1E-7 1E-5 0 0 0
1
0 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 0 1 1 0 1 1 0 0 1 1 1 0 0 1 1
1
227600 45000 -2700000 0 0 0 0 0 0
0
0
* Load Combinations
0 0 0 1 0
* Distributed Load Sets
0
* Pile Group Configuration
2
1 1 1 0 0 0 1
0 0 1 1 1
0 -9 0 16
1 2 2 0 0 0 2
0 0 1 1 1
0 9 0 16
* Pile Properties
2
0 1
50 55 1
0 55 1
1 1
50 55 1
0 55 2
* Pile Cross Sections
2
0 0 0 0
Section 1
72 0 1 1 0 0 0.1 0.1
1 4072 1319170 1319170 0 0 0 0 4030000 0 0
0 0 0 0 1
None
1 0 0 0
Section 2
66 0 1 1 0 0 0.1 0.1
1 3421 931422 931422 0 0 0 0 4030000 0 0
0 0 0 0 1
None
* Soil Layers
1
0 3
16 58.333333
2 10
124.416 2505.6 0 500 0 0.005 0 1252.8 0 0
124.416 2505.6 0 500 0 0.005 0 1252.8 0 0
* Generated LD curves
2
1
2
* User defined MC curves

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-125

1
1 1
0
1 1
0 0
* Internally Generated MC curves
2
1 1
0
0
1 1
0 0
2 1
0
0
1 1
0 0
* End of file

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-126

1.7.3 Echo Print File

=========================================================================

GROUP for Windows, Version 2016.10.8

Serial Number : 136089307

Analysis of A Group of Piles

Subjected to Axial and Lateral Loading

(c) Copyright ENSOFT, Inc., 1987-2015

All Rights Reserved

=========================================================================

This program is licensed to :

ENSOFT, INC
AUSTIN, TX

Path to file locations : C:\projects\GROUP2016\Group2016_1008\DXE\Examples_2016\

Name of input data file : 2Dexample6.gp10r
Name of output echo file : 2Dexample6.gp10e
Name of output results file : 2Dexample6.gp10o
Name of output summary file : 2Dexample6.gp10t
Name of plot output file : 2Dexample6.gp10p
Name of runtime file : 2Dexample6.gp10r

-------------------------------------------------------------------------
Time and Date of Analysis
-------------------------------------------------------------------------

Date: May 09, 2016 Time: 18:14:13

***** INPUT INFORMATION *****

EXAMPLE PROBLEM 6 - 2D, INTERNAL LOAD-DISPLACEMENT

ANALYSIS TYPE = 2D ANALYSIS

ADJUST DEPTH FOR BATTER PILES

GENERATE LOAD-DISP (AND T-R) CURVES BASED ON SOIL PROFILE

EXTEND INTERPOLATION FOR L-DP (AND T-R) CURVES

UNITS SYSTEM = ENGL

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-127

* TABLE C * LOAD AND CONTROL PARAMETERS

** LOAD CASES **

NUMBER OF LOAD CASES : 1

LOAD CASE : 1
CASE NAME : Load Case 1
LOAD TYPE : Special, Sp
SCALE FACTOR : 1.0000

* CONCENTRATED LOADS *

NL VERT.LOAD HOR.LOAD MOMENT COORD X COORD Y

LBS LBS LBS-IN FT FT
1 2.27600E+05 45000.0 -2.70000E+06 0.00000 0.00000

* EQUIVALENT CONCENTRATED LOAD AT ORIGIN *

VER.LOAD X,LBS HOR.LOAD Y,LBS MOMENT,LBS-IN

2.27600E+05 45000.0 -2.70000E+06

* THE LOADING IS STATIC *

* CONTROL PARAMETERS *
TOLERANCE ON CONVERGENCE OF PILE CAP MOVEMENT = 1.00000E-04
TOLERANCE ON DETERMINATION OF PILE DEFLECTIONS = 1.00000E-04 IN
MAX NO OF ITERATIONS ALLOWED FOR FOUNDATION ANALYSIS = 75
MAXIMUM NO OF ITERATIONS ALLOWED FOR PILE ANALYSIS = 75
FACTOR TO APPLY THE LOAD IN INCREMENTS = 1.0000
MINIMUM FACTOR FOR LOAD INCREMENTS = 1.0000
PRINT RESULTS AT PILE CAP, PILE HEADS AND ALONG PILES
PRINT RESULTS EVERY 1 NODE(S)

* TABLE D * ARRANGEMENT OF PILE GROUPS

GROUP CONNECT NO OF PILE PILE PROP P-Y CURVE L-S CURVE R-F-L SET
1 PIN 1 1 0 1 G 0
2 PIN 2 2 0 2 G 0

GROUP VERT,FT HOR,FT SLOPE,IN/IN GROUND,FT SPRING,LBS-IN SPACING,FT

1 0.00000 -9.00000 0.00000 16.0000 0.00000 0.00000
2 0.00000 9.00000 0.00000 16.0000 0.00000 0.00000

* TABLE E * PILE GEOMETRY AND PROPERTIES

PILE TYPE = 1 - DRIVEN PILE
= 2 - DRILLED SHAFT

PROP SECTS INC PILE TYPE LENGTH, FT

1 1 50 1 55.000
2 1 50 1 55.000

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-128

* PILE SECTIONS *

PROP SECT FROM,FT TO,FT CROSS SECT

1 1 0.00000 55.0000 1
2 1 0.00000 55.0000 2

* PILE CROSS SECTIONS *

CROSS SECTION : 1
SECTION NAME : Section

TYPE : ELASTIC
CROSS SECTION TYPE : GENERAL SECTION
EQUIVALENT DIAMETER : 72.0000 IN
YOUNG MODULUS : 4.03000E+06 LBS/IN**2

CROSS SECTION : 2
SECTION NAME : Section

TYPE : ELASTIC
CROSS SECTION TYPE : GENERAL SECTION
EQUIVALENT DIAMETER : 66.0000 IN
YOUNG MODULUS : 4.03000E+06 LBS/IN**2

* PILE CROSS SECTIONS PROPERTIES *

ELASTIC SECTIONS

SECT DIAM,IN AREA,IN**2 I,IN**4 Mn,LBS-IN Vn,LBS

1 72.0000 4072.00 1.31917E+06 0.00000 0.00000
2 66.0000 3421.00 9.31422E+05 0.00000 0.00000

* TABLE F * SOIL DATA

SOILS INFORMATION

GROUND SURFACE = 16.0000 FT

1 LAYER(S) OF SOIL

LAYER 1
THE SOIL IS A STIFF CLAY WITHOUT FREE WATER
TOP OF LAYER BOTTOM OF LAYER
X COORDINATE (FT) 16.0000 58.3333
EFFECTIVE UNIT WEIGHT (LBS/FT**3) 124.416 124.416
UNDRAINED COHESION, C (LBS/FT**2) 2505.60 2505.60
STRAIN AT 50% STRESS 5.00000E-03 5.00000E-03
ULTIMATE UNIT SIDE FRICTION (LBS/FT**2) 1252.80 1252.80
ULTIMATE UNIT TIP RESISTANCE (LBS/FT**2) 22550.4 (R) 22550.4 (R)

Notes : Program estimated values for listed parameters

if zero input values were entered:
(R) ULTIMATE UNIT TIP RESISTANCE for Driven Piles

* TABLE H * AXIAL LOAD VS DISPLACEMENT

AXIAL LOAD-DISPLACEMENT CURVES GENERATED INTERNALLY

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-129

NUM OF CURVES 2

CURVE 1 NUM OF POINTS 19

DISPLACEMENT, IN AXIAL LOAD,LBS

-3.62210 -8.45527E+05
-1.02210 -8.45527E+05
-0.52210 -8.45527E+05
-0.12336 -8.92679E+05
-0.0715000 -8.30683E+05
-0.0145375 -1.77333E+05
-7.25556E-03 -87968.1
-1.45111E-03 -17593.6
-1.45111E-04 -1759.36
0.00000 0.00000
1.47938E-04 1836.50
1.47938E-03 18365.0
7.39688E-03 91825.1
0.0148237 1.85214E+05
0.0728309 8.65162E+05
0.12586 9.54705E+05
0.53263 1.10730E+06
1.03717 1.22010E+06
3.64775 1.48320E+06

CURVE 2 NUM OF POINTS 19

DISPLACEMENT, IN AXIAL LOAD,LBS

-3.32412 -7.75067E+05
-1.02412 -7.75067E+05
-0.52412 -7.75067E+05
-0.12548 -8.18049E+05
-0.0735105 -7.63576E+05
-0.0149773 -1.63727E+05
-7.47286E-03 -81162.1
-1.49457E-03 -16232.4
-1.49457E-04 -1623.24
0.00000 0.00000
1.52572E-04 1695.20
1.52572E-03 16952.0
7.62860E-03 84759.9
0.0152930 1.71091E+05
0.0749655 7.95216E+05
0.12821 8.74846E+05
0.53512 1.00489E+06
1.03990 1.10467E+06
3.34976 1.31080E+06

* TABLE J * MOMENT CURVATURE SETS

USER DEFINED MOMENT CURVATURE

NUM OF SETS : 1

CURVE SET 1 NUM OF CURVES 1

CURVE 1 AXIAL LOAD 0.000E+00 LBS

POINT MOMENT CURVATURE

LBS-IN RADIAN/IN
1 0.00000 0.00000

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-130

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-131

1.7.4 Processor Run Notes

GROUP for Windows, Version 2016.10.8

-------------------------------------------------------------------------
Time and Date of Analysis
-------------------------------------------------------------------------

Date: May 09, 2016 Time: 18:14:13

EXAMPLE PROBLEM 6 - 2D, INTERNAL LOAD-DISPLACEMENT

READING * TITLE AND VERSION

READING * Analysis Parameters
READING * Pile Cap Dimensions
READING * Load Cases
READING * Load Combinations
READING * Distributed Load Sets
READING * Pile Group Configuration
READING * Pile Properties
READING * Pile Cross Sections
READING * Soil Layers
READING * Generated LD curves
READING * User defined MC curves
READING * Internally Generated MC curves

COMPUTATION IS PROCEEDING......

LOAD CASE : 1
CASE NAME : Load Case 1

GLOBAL ITERATIONS
STEP 1, TCUR 1.0000, DTCUR 1.0000
ITERATION 1
- ErrDsp 0.10000E+01, IncDsp 0.12992E-01, TotDsp 0.12992E-01
- ErrRot 0.10000E+01, IncRot 0.11612E-04, TotRot 0.11612E-04
ITERATION 2
- ErrDsp 0.58430E+00, IncDsp 0.16584E-01, TotDsp 0.28383E-01
- ErrRot 0.16814E-01, IncRot 0.19202E-06, TotRot 0.11420E-04
ITERATION 3
- ErrDsp 0.63370E-01, IncDsp 0.19167E-02, TotDsp 0.30246E-01
- ErrRot 0.31033E-14, IncRot 0.35440E-19, TotRot 0.11420E-04
ITERATION 4
- ErrDsp 0.11346E-02, IncDsp 0.34355E-04, TotDsp 0.30279E-01
- ErrRot 0.66567E-13, IncRot 0.76019E-18, TotRot 0.11420E-04
ITERATION 5
- ErrDsp 0.22322E-04, IncDsp 0.67587E-06, TotDsp 0.30279E-01
- ErrRot 0.91313E-13, IncRot 0.10428E-17, TotRot 0.11420E-04

NUMBER OF GLOBAL ITERATIONS = 5

ANALYSIS FOR LOAD CASE 1/ 1 FINISHED

Execution Time : 82 ms
Number Processors : 1/ 1
Serial processing : 0.066 sec
Paral. processing : 0.003 sec
Print. processing : 0.014 sec

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-132

ANALYSIS COMPLETED
Execution Time : 83 ms
Number Processors : 1/ 1

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-133

1.7.5 Output Results File

=========================================================================

GROUP for Windows, Version 2016.10.8

Serial Number : 136089307

Analysis of A Group of Piles

Subjected to Axial and Lateral Loading

(c) Copyright ENSOFT, Inc., 1987-2015

All Rights Reserved

=========================================================================

This program is licensed to :

ENSOFT, INC
AUSTIN, TX

Path to file locations : C:\projects\GROUP2016\Group2016_1008\DXE\Examples_2016\

Name of input data file : 2Dexample6.gp10d
Name of output echo file : 2Dexample6.gp10e
Name of output results file : 2Dexample6.gp10o
Name of output summary file : 2Dexample6.gp10t
Name of plot output file : 2Dexample6.gp10p
Name of runtime file : 2Dexample6.gp10r

-------------------------------------------------------------------------
Time and Date of Analysis
-------------------------------------------------------------------------

Date: May 09, 2016 Time: 18:14:13

***** COMPUTATION RESULTS *****

EXAMPLE PROBLEM 6 - 2D, INTERNAL LOAD-DISPLACEMENT

***** LOAD CASES RESULTS *****

LOAD CASE : 1
CASE NAME : Load Case 1
LOAD TYPE : Special, Sp

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-134

* TABLE L * COMPUTATION ON PILE CAP

* EQUIVALENT CONCENTRATED LOAD AT ORIGIN *

VERT. LOAD, LBS HORI. LOAD, LBS MOMENT,LBS-IN

2.27600E+05 45000.0 -2.70000E+06

* DISPLACEMENT OF GROUPED PILE FOUNDATION AT ORIGIN *

VERTICAL,IN HORIZONTAL,IN ROTATION,RAD

6.91701E-03 0.0294778 1.14200E-05

NUMBER OF ITERATIONS = 5

* TABLE M * COMPUTATION ON INDIVIDUAL PILE

* PILE GROUP * 1

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS AND REACTIONS *

THE GLOBAL STRUCTURAL COORDINATE SYSTEM

---------------------------------------

DISP.X,IN DISP.Y,IN SLOPE FOR.X, LB FOR.Y, LB BM, LB-IN STRESS, LB/IN**2

8.1504E-03 0.029478 1.1420E-05 1.0130E+05 1.7593E+04 0.0000 24.877

THE PILE COORDINATE SYSTEM (LOCAL AXES)

---------------------------------------

DISP.x,IN DISP.y,IN SLOPE AXIAL, LB LAT, LB BM, LB-IN STRESS,LBS/IN**2

8.1504E-03 0.029478 1.1420E-05 1.0130E+05 1.7593E+04 0.0000 24.877

* EFFECTS FOR LATERALLY LOADED PILE *

x DISPL. BENDING SHEAR SOIL TOTAL FLEXURAL

y-DIR MOMENT FORCE REACTION STRESS RIGIDITY
FT IN LBS-IN LBS LBS/IN LBS-IN**2 LBS-IN**2
********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
0.0000 2.9478E-02 0.0000 1.7593E+04 0.0000 24.877 5.3163E+12
1.1000 2.7561E-02 2.3242E+05 1.7593E+04 0.0000 31.220 5.3163E+12
2.2000 2.5651E-02 4.6485E+05 1.7593E+04 0.0000 37.563 5.3163E+12
3.3000 2.3757E-02 6.9727E+05 1.7593E+04 0.0000 43.906 5.3163E+12
4.4000 2.1886E-02 9.2969E+05 1.7593E+04 0.0000 50.248 5.3163E+12
5.5000 2.0045E-02 1.1621E+06 1.7593E+04 0.0000 56.591 5.3163E+12
6.6000 1.8242E-02 1.3945E+06 1.7593E+04 0.0000 62.933 5.3163E+12
7.7000 1.6485E-02 1.6269E+06 1.7593E+04 0.0000 69.276 5.3163E+12
8.8000 1.4781E-02 1.8593E+06 1.7593E+04 0.0000 75.618 5.3163E+12
9.9000 1.3138E-02 2.0917E+06 1.7593E+04 0.0000 81.960 5.3163E+12

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-135

11.000 1.1564E-02 2.3241E+06 1.7593E+04 0.0000 88.302 5.3163E+12

12.100 1.0066E-02 2.5565E+06 1.7593E+04 0.0000 94.644 5.3163E+12
13.200 8.6513E-03 2.7889E+06 1.7593E+04 0.0000 100.99 5.3163E+12
14.300 7.3283E-03 3.0212E+06 1.7593E+04 0.0000 107.33 5.3163E+12
15.400 6.1044E-03 3.2536E+06 1.7593E+04 0.0000 113.67 5.3163E+12
16.500 4.9871E-03 3.4859E+06 1.4174E+04 518.05 120.01 5.3163E+12
17.600 3.9841E-03 3.6280E+06 7377.7 511.70 123.88 5.3163E+12
18.700 3.1000E-03 3.6809E+06 696.37 500.62 125.33 5.3163E+12
19.800 2.3365E-03 3.6465E+06 -5804.5 484.36 124.39 5.3163E+12
20.900 1.6925E-03 3.5278E+06 -1.2052E+04 462.24 121.15 5.3163E+12
22.000 1.1641E-03 3.3285E+06 -1.7963E+04 433.30 115.71 5.3163E+12
23.100 7.4488E-04 3.0537E+06 -2.3435E+04 395.83 108.21 5.3163E+12
24.200 4.2571E-04 2.7099E+06 -2.8333E+04 346.33 98.830 5.3163E+12
25.300 1.9535E-04 2.3057E+06 -3.2436E+04 275.33 87.800 5.3163E+12
26.400 4.0561E-05 1.8536E+06 -3.5158E+04 137.03 75.462 5.3163E+12
27.500 -5.3475E-05 1.3776E+06 -3.3009E+04 -462.63 62.472 5.3163E+12
28.600 -1.0236E-04 9.8219E+05 -2.7576E+04 -360.43 51.681 5.3163E+12
29.700 -1.1906E-04 6.4958E+05 -2.2867E+04 -353.08 42.604 5.3163E+12
30.800 -1.1446E-04 3.7849E+05 -1.8273E+04 -343.00 35.206 5.3163E+12
31.900 -9.7460E-05 1.6717E+05 -1.3858E+04 -325.95 29.439 5.3163E+12
33.000 -7.4981E-05 1.2634E+04 -9717.2 -301.48 25.222 5.3163E+12
34.100 -5.2087E-05 -8.9371E+04 -5948.4 -269.56 27.316 5.3163E+12
35.200 -3.2123E-05 -1.4441E+05 -2650.1 -230.17 28.818 5.3163E+12
36.300 -1.6891E-05 -1.5934E+05 77.784 -183.14 29.226 5.3163E+12
37.400 -6.8822E-06 -1.4236E+05 2130.2 -127.83 28.762 5.3163E+12
38.500 -1.5387E-06 -1.0310E+05 3373.8 -60.593 27.691 5.3163E+12
39.600 4.2556E-07 -5.3289E+04 3330.3 67.184 26.331 5.3163E+12
40.700 6.4330E-07 -1.5183E+04 2048.7 127.00 25.292 5.3163E+12
41.800 3.6343E-07 796.25 748.60 69.988 24.899 5.3163E+12
42.900 1.0965E-07 4580.5 77.135 31.750 25.002 5.3163E+12
44.000 6.0044E-09 2832.7 -156.04 3.5799 24.955 5.3163E+12
45.100 -4.8037E-09 461.01 -111.66 -10.305 24.890 5.3163E+12
46.200 -5.0217E-10 -115.17 -18.099 -3.8713 24.880 5.3163E+12
47.300 2.4632E-11 -16.810 4.3898 0.4639 24.878 5.3163E+12
48.400 5.0206E-13 0.7201 0.6374 0.1046 24.877 5.3163E+12
49.500 -2.7454E-14 1.6985E-02 -2.7307E-02 -3.9331E-03 24.877 5.3163E+12
50.600 -2.8723E-16 -8.2012E-04 -6.4370E-04 -1.0684E-04 24.877 5.3163E+12
51.700 6.0610E-19 -8.8004E-06 3.1066E-05 4.6057E-06 24.877 5.3163E+12
52.800 5.7132E-21 1.8144E-08 3.3335E-07 5.0715E-08 24.877 5.3163E+12
53.900 -6.2460E-25 1.7435E-10 -6.8728E-10 -1.0213E-10 24.877 5.3163E+12
55.000 -1.2020E-26 -5.6040E-30 4.4708E-28 -2.0013E-12 24.877 5.3163E+12

* PILE GROUP * 2

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS AND REACTIONS *

THE GLOBAL STRUCTURAL COORDINATE SYSTEM

---------------------------------------

DISP.X,IN DISP.Y,IN SLOPE FOR.X, LB FOR.Y, LB BM, LB-IN STRESS, LB/IN**2

5.6837E-03 0.029478 1.1420E-05 6.3150E+04 1.3703E+04 7.4742E-08 18.460

THE PILE COORDINATE SYSTEM (LOCAL AXES)

---------------------------------------

DISP.x,IN DISP.y,IN SLOPE AXIAL, LB LAT, LB BM, LB-IN STRESS,LBS/IN**2

5.6837E-03 0.029478 1.1420E-05 6.3150E+04 1.3703E+04 7.4742E-08 18.460

* EFFECTS FOR LATERALLY LOADED PILE *

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-136

x DISPL. BENDING SHEAR SOIL TOTAL FLEXURAL

y-DIR MOMENT FORCE REACTION STRESS RIGIDITY
FT IN LBS-IN LBS LBS/IN LBS-IN**2 LBS-IN**2
********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
0.0000 2.9478E-02 -7.4742E-08 1.3703E+04 0.0000 18.460 3.7536E+12
1.1000 2.7494E-02 1.8101E+05 1.3703E+04 0.0000 24.873 3.7536E+12
2.2000 2.5518E-02 3.6202E+05 1.3703E+04 0.0000 31.286 3.7536E+12
3.3000 2.3559E-02 5.4303E+05 1.3703E+04 0.0000 37.699 3.7536E+12
4.4000 2.1626E-02 7.2404E+05 1.3703E+04 0.0000 44.112 3.7536E+12
5.5000 1.9726E-02 9.0504E+05 1.3703E+04 0.0000 50.525 3.7536E+12
6.6000 1.7868E-02 1.0860E+06 1.3703E+04 0.0000 56.938 3.7536E+12
7.7000 1.6060E-02 1.2670E+06 1.3703E+04 0.0000 63.350 3.7536E+12
8.8000 1.4312E-02 1.4480E+06 1.3703E+04 0.0000 69.763 3.7536E+12
9.9000 1.2630E-02 1.6290E+06 1.3703E+04 0.0000 76.176 3.7536E+12
11.000 1.1024E-02 1.8100E+06 1.3703E+04 0.0000 82.588 3.7536E+12
12.100 9.5024E-03 1.9910E+06 1.3703E+04 0.0000 89.000 3.7536E+12
13.200 8.0729E-03 2.1720E+06 1.3703E+04 0.0000 95.412 3.7536E+12
14.300 6.7443E-03 2.3529E+06 1.3703E+04 0.0000 101.82 3.7536E+12
15.400 5.5249E-03 2.5339E+06 1.3703E+04 0.0000 108.24 3.7536E+12
16.500 4.4231E-03 2.7149E+06 1.0591E+04 471.60 114.65 3.7536E+12
17.600 3.4473E-03 2.8136E+06 4415.3 464.09 118.15 3.7536E+12
18.700 2.6021E-03 2.8315E+06 -1628.2 451.59 118.78 3.7536E+12
19.800 1.8884E-03 2.7707E+06 -7470.4 433.60 116.63 3.7536E+12
20.900 1.3033E-03 2.6344E+06 -1.3034E+04 409.40 111.80 3.7536E+12
22.000 8.4047E-04 2.4267E+06 -1.8230E+04 377.88 104.44 3.7536E+12
23.100 4.9028E-04 2.1532E+06 -2.2948E+04 336.90 94.746 3.7536E+12
24.200 2.4005E-04 1.8209E+06 -2.7028E+04 281.26 82.974 3.7536E+12
25.300 7.4344E-05 1.4397E+06 -3.0142E+04 190.62 69.467 3.7536E+12
26.400 -2.4535E-05 1.0252E+06 -2.7348E+04 -613.95 54.782 3.7536E+12
27.500 -7.5826E-05 7.1769E+05 -2.1363E+04 -292.82 43.887 3.7536E+12
28.600 -9.3802E-05 4.6121E+05 -1.7503E+04 -292.10 34.800 3.7536E+12
29.700 -9.0369E-05 2.5562E+05 -1.3696E+04 -284.77 27.516 3.7536E+12
30.800 -7.5071E-05 9.9643E+04 -1.0041E+04 -268.93 21.990 3.7536E+12
31.900 -5.5148E-05 -9470.5 -6649.2 -244.99 18.795 3.7536E+12
33.000 -3.5664E-05 -7.5898E+04 -3624.9 -213.24 21.149 3.7536E+12
34.100 -1.9704E-05 -1.0517E+05 -1070.2 -173.84 22.186 3.7536E+12
35.200 -8.6251E-06 -1.0415E+05 912.96 -126.64 22.150 3.7536E+12
36.300 -2.3811E-06 -8.1069E+04 2213.1 -70.354 21.332 3.7536E+12
37.400 9.9860E-08 -4.5726E+04 2616.6 9.2201 20.080 3.7536E+12
38.500 4.5822E-07 -1.1990E+04 1737.6 123.97 18.884 3.7536E+12
39.600 2.6000E-07 145.75 554.83 55.238 18.465 3.7536E+12
40.700 6.8542E-08 2657.2 47.793 21.586 18.554 3.7536E+12
41.800 4.3043E-10 1407.5 -96.588 0.2900 18.509 3.7536E+12
42.900 -2.3464E-09 107.27 -54.988 -6.5932 18.463 3.7536E+12
44.000 -1.4409E-10 -44.172 -4.1934 -1.1029 18.461 3.7536E+12
45.100 7.8432E-12 -3.4390 1.6793 0.2131 18.460 3.7536E+12
46.200 1.4192E-13 0.1627 0.1304 2.1586E-02 18.460 3.7536E+12
47.300 -5.0028E-15 3.2724E-03 -6.1686E-03 -8.9584E-04 18.460 3.7536E+12
48.400 -2.1403E-17 -1.0685E-04 -1.2397E-04 -2.0005E-05 18.460 3.7536E+12
49.500 1.1187E-19 -4.6590E-07 4.0474E-06 6.0787E-07 18.460 3.7536E+12
50.600 4.6090E-23 2.4079E-09 1.7648E-08 2.7015E-09 18.460 3.7536E+12
51.700 -9.0388E-26 9.9680E-13 -9.1209E-11 -1.3808E-11 18.460 3.7536E+12
52.800 -3.6884E-29 -1.9456E-15 -3.7758E-14 -5.7432E-15 18.460 3.7536E+12
53.900 7.0323E-32 -7.9761E-19 7.3698E-17 1.1157E-17 18.460 3.7536E+12
55.000 5.6653E-35 0.0000 2.2421E-36 9.1553E-21 18.460 3.7536E+12

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-137

1.7.6 Summary Results File

=========================================================================

GROUP for Windows, Version 2016.10.8

Serial Number : 136089307

Analysis of A Group of Piles

Subjected to Axial and Lateral Loading

(c) Copyright ENSOFT, Inc., 1987-2015

All Rights Reserved

=========================================================================

-------------------------------------------------------------------------
Time and Date of Analysis
-------------------------------------------------------------------------

Date: May 09, 2016 Time: 18:14:13

***** COMPUTATION RESULTS *****

EXAMPLE PROBLEM 6 - 2D, INTERNAL LOAD-DISPLACEMENT

***** LOAD CASES RESULTS *****

LOAD CASE : 1
CASE NAME : Load Case 1
LOAD TYPE : Special, Sp

* TABLE L * COMPUTATION ON PILE CAP

* EQUIVALENT CONCENTRATED LOAD AT ORIGIN *

VERT. LOAD, LBS HORI. LOAD, LBS MOMENT,LBS-IN

2.27600E+05 45000.0 -2.70000E+06

* DISPLACEMENT OF GROUPED PILE FOUNDATION AT ORIGIN *

VERTICAL,IN HORIZONTAL,IN ROTATION,RAD

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-138

6.91701E-03 0.0294778 1.14200E-05

* TABLE M * COMPUTATION ON INDIVIDUAL PILE

THE GLOBAL STRUCTURAL COORDINATE SYSTEM

---------------------------------------

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS *

PILE GROUP DISP. X,IN DISP. Y,IN ROT. Z,RAD

********** *********** *********** ***********
1 8.1504E-03 0.029478 1.1420E-05
2 5.6837E-03 0.029478 1.1420E-05

MINIMUM 5.6837E-03 0.029478 1.1420E-05

Pile G. 2 1 1
MAXIMUM 8.1504E-03 0.029478 1.1420E-05
Pile G. 1 1 1

* PILE TOP REACTIONS *

PILE GROUP FOR. X,LBS FOR. Y,LBS MOM Z,LBS-IN STRESS,LBS/IN**2

********** *********** *********** ************ ****************
1 1.0130E+05 1.7593E+04 0.0000 24.877
2 6.3150E+04 1.3703E+04 7.4742E-08 18.460

MINIMUM 6.3150E+04 1.3703E+04 0.0000 18.460

Pile G. 2 2 1 2
MAXIMUM 1.0130E+05 1.7593E+04 7.4742E-08 24.877
Pile G. 1 1 2 1

THE PILE COORDINATE SYSTEM (LOCAL AXES)

---------------------------------------

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS *

PILE GROUP DISP. x,IN DISP. y,IN ROT. z,RAD

********** *********** *********** ***********
1 8.1504E-03 0.029478 1.1420E-05
2 5.6837E-03 0.029478 1.1420E-05

MINIMUM 5.6837E-03 0.029478 1.1420E-05

Pile G. 2 1 1
MAXIMUM 8.1504E-03 0.029478 1.1420E-05
Pile G. 1 1 1

* PILE TOP REACTIONS *

PILE GROUP AXIAL,LBS LAT. y,LBS MOM z,LBS-IN STRESS,LBS/IN**2

********** *********** *********** ************ ****************
1 1.0130E+05 1.7593E+04 0.0000 24.877
2 6.3150E+04 1.3703E+04 7.4742E-08 18.460

MINIMUM 6.3150E+04 1.3703E+04 0.0000 18.460

Pile G. 2 2 1 2
MAXIMUM 1.0130E+05 1.7593E+04 7.4742E-08 24.877
Pile G. 1 1 2 1

* EFFECTS FOR LATERALLY LOADED PILE *

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-139

* MINIMUM VALUES AND LOCATIONS *

PILE DISPL. BENDING SHEAR SOIL TOTAL FLEXURAL

y-DIR MOMENT FORCE REACTION STRESS RIGIDITY
IN LBS-IN LBS LBS/IN LBS-IN**2 LBS-IN**2
****** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
1 -1.1906E-04 -1.5934E+05 -3.5158E+04 -462.63 24.877 5.3163E+12
x(FT) 29.700 36.300 26.400 27.500 0.0000 0.0000
2 -9.3802E-05 -1.0517E+05 -3.0142E+04 -613.95 18.460 3.7536E+12
x(FT) 28.600 34.100 25.300 26.400 51.700 0.0000

Min. -1.1906E-04 -1.5934E+05 -3.5158E+04 -613.95 18.460 3.7536E+12

Pile N. 1 1 1 2 2 2

* MAXIMUM VALUES AND LOCATIONS *

PILE DISPL. BENDING SHEAR SOIL TOTAL FLEXURAL

y-DIR MOMENT FORCE REACTION STRESS RIGIDITY
IN LBS-IN LBS LBS/IN LBS-IN**2 LBS-IN**2
****** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
1 0.029478 3.6809E+06 1.7593E+04 518.05 125.33 5.3163E+12
x(FT) 0.0000 18.700 7.7000 16.500 18.700 0.0000
2 0.029478 2.8315E+06 1.3703E+04 471.60 118.78 3.7536E+12
x(FT) 0.0000 18.700 13.200 16.500 18.700 0.0000

Max. 0.029478 3.6809E+06 1.7593E+04 518.05 125.33 5.3163E+12

Pile N. 1 1 1 1 1 1

***** SUMMARY FOR LOAD CASES AND COMBINATIONS *****

***** LOAD CASES RESULTS *****

LOAD CASE : 1

* EQUIVALENT CONCENTRATED LOAD AT ORIGIN *

LOAD X,LBS LOAD Y,LBS MOM Z,LBS-IN
2.27600E+05 45000.0 -2.70000E+06

* DISPLACEMENT OF GROUPED PILE FOUNDATION AT ORIGIN *

DISP X,IN DISP Y,IN ROT Z,RAD
6.91701E-03 0.0294778 1.14200E-05

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS, GLOBAL *

DISP. X,IN DISP. Y,IN ROT. Z,RAD
*********** *********** ***********
MINIMUM 5.6837E-03 0.029478 1.1420E-05
Pile G. 2 1 1
MAXIMUM 8.1504E-03 0.029478 1.1420E-05
Pile G. 1 1 1

* PILE TOP REACTIONS, GLOBAL *

FOR. X,LBS FOR. Y,LBS MOM Z,LBS-IN STRESS,LBS/IN**2
*********** *********** ************ ****************
MINIMUM 6.3150E+04 1.3703E+04 0.0000 18.460
Pile G. 2 2 1 2
MAXIMUM 1.0130E+05 1.7593E+04 7.4742E-08 24.877
Pile G. 1 1 2 1

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS, LOCAL *

DISP. x,IN DISP. y,IN ROT. z,RAD
*********** *********** ***********
MINIMUM 5.6837E-03 0.029478 1.1420E-05

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-140

Pile G. 2 1 1
MAXIMUM 8.1504E-03 0.029478 1.1420E-05
Pile G. 1 1 1

* PILE TOP REACTIONS, LOCAL *

AXIAL,LBS LAT. y,LBS MOM z,LBS-IN STRESS,LBS/IN**2
*********** *********** ************ ****************
MINIMUM 6.3150E+04 1.3703E+04 0.0000 18.460
Pile G. 2 2 1 2
MAXIMUM 1.0130E+05 1.7593E+04 7.4742E-08 24.877
Pile G. 1 1 2 1

* EFFECTS FOR LATERALLY LOADED PILE *

PILE DISPL. BENDING SHEAR SOIL TOTAL FLEXURAL

y-DIR MOMENT FORCE REACTION STRESS RIGIDITY
IN LBS-IN LBS LBS/IN LBS-IN**2 LBS-IN**2
****** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
Min. -1.1906E-04 -1.5934E+05 -3.5158E+04 -613.95 18.460 3.7536E+12
Pile N. 1 1 1 2 2 2
Max. 0.029478 3.6809E+06 1.7593E+04 518.05 125.33 5.3163E+12
Pile N. 1 1 1 1 1 1

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-141

1.7.7 Graphs

Figure 1.23 Curves Deflection vs. Distance for Example Problem 6 - 2D.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-142

Figure 1.24 Internally Generated curves of Axial Load vs. Displacement for Example Problem 6 - 2D.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-143

1.8 Example Problem 7 - 2D

1.8.1 Model Description

This example is included to show the use of the program to compute the data for foundation
stiffness (flexibility matrix components) of the pile foundation, which may be needed for the
superstructure analysis. Figure 1.25 shows a 3 by 3 pile group with the pile cap, which is below the
existing ground surface. The piles are 30 inches in diameter and 50 feet in length. The piles are closely
spaced with the center to center spacing equal to 3 pile diameters. The soil is stiff clay, and group
reduction factors on piles are generated internally by the program.

It should be noted that the origin (0,0) is set 5 feet below the ground surface(Figure 1.25 );
therefore, the top of the ground surface has the coordinate of -60 inches for the input. The program
divides the loadings into 10 increments and computes the pile cap response for each individual loading
to estimate the data for foundation stiffness. The different components of the foundation stiffness
matrix can be estimated from the flexibility components.

The input and output files for the example problem are shown in the following pages.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-144

Figure 1.25 General Description of Example Problem 7 - 2D.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-145

1.8.2 Input Data

EXAMPLE PROBLEM 7 - 2D, 3x3 group, data for foundation stiffness

GROUP2016.10.8
* Analysis Parameters
1 2 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 1 0 0 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 1
* Pile Cap Dimensions
0 0 0 0 0 0
* Load Cases
1 0 0 1 0
0 1 1 1 1 100 100
1E-5 1E-5 1 1
Load Case 1
12 10 0 0 1 0 0 0
2 1 1 0 1E-7 1E-5 0 0 0
1
0 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 0 1 1 0 1 1 0 0 1 1 1 0 0 1 1
1
1000000 400000 20000000 0 0 0 0 0 0
0
10
0.1
0.30102999
0.47712125
0.60205999
0.69897
0.77815125
0.84509804
0.90308998
0.9542425
1
* Load Combinations
0 0 0 1 0
* Distributed Load Sets
0
* Pile Group Configuration
3
2 3 1 0 0 0 1
0 0 1 1 1
0 -7.5 0 -5
2 3 1 0 0 0 1
0 0 1 1 1
0 0 0 -5
2 3 1 0 0 0 1
0 0 1 1 1
0 7.5 0 -5
* Pile Properties
1
0 1
50 50 1
0 50 1
* Pile Cross Sections
1
0 0 0 0
Section 1
30 0 1 1 0 0 0.1 0.1
1 707 39700 39700 0 0 0 0 3600000 0 0
0 0 0 0 1
None
* Soil Layers
1
0 3
-5 70
2 10
103.68 1440 0 1000 0 0.005 0 720 0 0
103.68 2880 0 1000 0 0.005 0 1440 0 0

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-146

* Print py curves
2
1 10
0
1 30
0
* Generated LD curves
1
1
* User defined MC curves
1
1 1
0
1 1
0 0
* Internally Generated MC curves
1
1 1
0
0
1 1
0 0
* End of file

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-147

1.8.3 Echo Print File

=========================================================================

GROUP for Windows, Version 2016.10.8

Serial Number : 136089307

Analysis of A Group of Piles

Subjected to Axial and Lateral Loading

(c) Copyright ENSOFT, Inc., 1987-2015

All Rights Reserved

=========================================================================

This program is licensed to :

ENSOFT, INC
AUSTIN, TX

Path to file locations : C:\projects\GROUP2016\Group2016_1008\DXE\Examples_2016\

Name of input data file : 2Dexample7.gp10r
Name of output echo file : 2Dexample7.gp10e
Name of output results file : 2Dexample7.gp10o
Name of output summary file : 2Dexample7.gp10t
Name of plot output file : 2Dexample7.gp10p
Name of runtime file : 2Dexample7.gp10r

-------------------------------------------------------------------------
Time and Date of Analysis
-------------------------------------------------------------------------

Date: May 09, 2016 Time: 18:14:13

***** INPUT INFORMATION *****

EXAMPLE PROBLEM 7 - 2D, 3x3 group, data for foundation stiffness

ANALYSIS TYPE = 2D ANALYSIS

ADJUST DEPTH FOR BATTER PILES

GENERATE LOAD-DISP (AND T-R) CURVES BASED ON SOIL PROFILE

EXTEND INTERPOLATION FOR L-DP (AND T-R) CURVES

UNITS SYSTEM = ENGL

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-148

* TABLE C * LOAD AND CONTROL PARAMETERS

** LOAD CASES **

NUMBER OF LOAD CASES : 1

LOAD CASE : 1
CASE NAME : Load Case 1
LOAD TYPE : Special, Sp
SCALE FACTOR : 1.0000

* CONCENTRATED LOADS *

NL VERT.LOAD HOR.LOAD MOMENT COORD X COORD Y

LBS LBS LBS-IN FT FT
1 1.00000E+06 4.00000E+05 2.00000E+07 0.00000 0.00000

* EQUIVALENT CONCENTRATED LOAD AT ORIGIN *

VER.LOAD X,LBS HOR.LOAD Y,LBS MOMENT,LBS-IN

1.00000E+06 4.00000E+05 2.00000E+07

* DATA FOR FOUNDATION STIFFNESS *

COMPUTED FOR EQUIVALENT CONCENTRATED LOAD AT ORIGIN

* FOUNDATION STIFFNESS LOAD LEVELS *

NL LOAD LEVEL
1 0.1000000
2 0.30103
3 0.47712
4 0.60206
5 0.69897
6 0.77815
7 0.84510
8 0.90309
9 0.95424
10 1.00000

* THE LOADING IS STATIC *

* CONTROL PARAMETERS *
TOLERANCE ON CONVERGENCE OF PILE CAP MOVEMENT = 1.00000E-05
TOLERANCE ON DETERMINATION OF PILE DEFLECTIONS = 1.00000E-05 IN
MAX NO OF ITERATIONS ALLOWED FOR FOUNDATION ANALYSIS = 100
MAXIMUM NO OF ITERATIONS ALLOWED FOR PILE ANALYSIS = 100
FACTOR TO APPLY THE LOAD IN INCREMENTS = 1.0000
MINIMUM FACTOR FOR LOAD INCREMENTS = 1.0000
PRINT RESULTS AT PILE CAP, PILE HEADS AND ALONG PILES
PRINT RESULTS EVERY 1 NODE(S)

* TABLE D * ARRANGEMENT OF PILE GROUPS

GROUP CONNECT NO OF PILE PILE PROP P-Y CURVE L-S CURVE R-F-L SET
1 FIX 3 1 0 1 G 0

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-149

2 FIX 3 1 0 1 G 0
3 FIX 3 1 0 1 G 0

GROUP VERT,FT HOR,FT SLOPE,IN/IN GROUND,FT SPRING,LBS-IN SPACING,FT

1 0.00000 -7.50000 0.00000 -5.00000 0.00000 0.00000
2 0.00000 0.00000 0.00000 -5.00000 0.00000 0.00000
3 0.00000 7.50000 0.00000 -5.00000 0.00000 0.00000

* TABLE E * PILE GEOMETRY AND PROPERTIES

PILE TYPE = 1 - DRIVEN PILE
= 2 - DRILLED SHAFT

PROP SECTS INC PILE TYPE LENGTH, FT

1 1 50 1 50.000

* PILE SECTIONS *

PROP SECT FROM,FT TO,FT CROSS SECT

1 1 0.00000 50.0000 1

* PILE CROSS SECTIONS *

CROSS SECTION : 1
SECTION NAME : Section

TYPE : ELASTIC
CROSS SECTION TYPE : GENERAL SECTION
EQUIVALENT DIAMETER : 30.0000 IN
YOUNG MODULUS : 3.60000E+06 LBS/IN**2

* PILE CROSS SECTIONS PROPERTIES *

ELASTIC SECTIONS

SECT DIAM,IN AREA,IN**2 I,IN**4 Mn,LBS-IN Vn,LBS

1 30.0000 707.000 39700.0 0.00000 0.00000

* TABLE F * SOIL DATA

SOILS INFORMATION

GROUND SURFACE = -5.00000 FT

1 LAYER(S) OF SOIL

LAYER 1
THE SOIL IS A STIFF CLAY WITHOUT FREE WATER
TOP OF LAYER BOTTOM OF LAYER
X COORDINATE (FT) -5.00000 70.0000
EFFECTIVE UNIT WEIGHT (LBS/FT**3) 103.680 103.680
UNDRAINED COHESION, C (LBS/FT**2) 1440.00 2880.00
STRAIN AT 50% STRESS 5.00000E-03 5.00000E-03
ULTIMATE UNIT SIDE FRICTION (LBS/FT**2) 720.000 1440.00
ULTIMATE UNIT TIP RESISTANCE (LBS/FT**2) 12960.0 (R) 25920.0 (R)

Notes : Program estimated values for listed parameters

if zero input values were entered:
(R) ULTIMATE UNIT TIP RESISTANCE for Driven Piles

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-150

* DATA TO PRINT GENERATED P-Y CURVES *

NUMBER OF CURVES TO PRINT : 2

CURVE NUMBER PILE GROUP DEPTH (FT)

1 1 10.0000
2 1 30.0000

* TABLE H * AXIAL LOAD VS DISPLACEMENT

AXIAL LOAD-DISPLACEMENT CURVES GENERATED INTERNALLY

NUM OF CURVES 1

CURVE 1 NUM OF POINTS 19

DISPLACEMENT, IN AXIAL LOAD,LBS

-2.04683 -3.68133E+05
-1.04683 -3.68133E+05
-0.54683 -3.68133E+05
-0.14930 -3.85001E+05
-0.0965698 -3.74821E+05
-0.0205437 -94984.2
-0.0101808 -45993.3
-2.03611E-03 -9191.59
-2.03611E-04 -919.159
0.00000 0.00000
2.11533E-04 967.479
2.11533E-03 9674.79
0.0105774 48442.7
0.0213640 1.00180E+05
0.0998575 3.89193E+05
0.15535 4.09997E+05
0.56358 4.39155E+05
1.07055 4.68750E+05
2.07283 4.78425E+05

* TABLE J * MOMENT CURVATURE SETS

USER DEFINED MOMENT CURVATURE

NUM OF SETS : 1

CURVE SET 1 NUM OF CURVES 1

CURVE 1 AXIAL LOAD 0.000E+00 LBS

POINT MOMENT CURVATURE

LBS-IN RADIAN/IN
1 0.00000 0.00000

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-151

* TABLE N * PRINTED P-Y CURVES

* GENERATED P-Y CURVES *

NUMBER OF CURVES : 2

CURVE NUMBER = 1

PILE GROUP NUMBER = 1

DEPTH BELOW ORIGIN = 10.00 FT

NUMBER OF POINTS ON CURVE = 17

P-Y CURVE COMPUTED USING STIFF CLAY WITHOUT FREE WATER CRITERIA

DEPTH BELOW GS DIAM C CAVG GAMMA E50

FT IN LBS/IN**2 LBS/IN**2 LBS/IN**3
15.00 30.000 0.17E+04 0.16E+04 0.10E+03 0.5000E-02
EQ. DEPTH = 15.00 FT

Y P
IN LBS/IN
0.00000 0.00000
1.50000E-03 289.713
0.0150000 515.190
0.0450000 678.028
0.12000 866.443
0.24000 1030.38
0.36000 1140.30
0.60000 1295.63
0.90000 1433.86
1.35000 1586.82
1.80000 1705.15
2.40000 1832.30
3.00000 1937.43
3.90000 2068.76
4.80000 2178.99
6.00000 2304.00
7.20000 2304.00

CURVE NUMBER = 2

PILE GROUP NUMBER = 1

DEPTH BELOW ORIGIN = 30.00 FT

NUMBER OF POINTS ON CURVE = 17

P-Y CURVE COMPUTED USING STIFF CLAY WITHOUT FREE WATER CRITERIA

DEPTH BELOW GS DIAM C CAVG GAMMA E50

FT IN LBS/IN**2 LBS/IN**2 LBS/IN**3
35.00 30.000 0.21E+04 0.18E+04 0.10E+03 0.5000E-02
EQ. DEPTH = 35.00 FT

Y P
IN LBS/IN
0.00000 0.00000
1.50000E-03 497.944
0.0150000 885.483
0.0450000 1165.36

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-152

0.12000 1489.20
0.24000 1770.97
0.36000 1959.90
0.60000 2226.87
0.90000 2464.44
1.35000 2727.35
1.80000 2930.73
2.40000 3149.27
3.00000 3329.95
3.90000 3555.69
4.80000 3745.14
6.00000 3960.00
7.20000 3960.00

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-153

1.8.4 Processor Run Notes

GROUP for Windows, Version 2016.10.8

-------------------------------------------------------------------------
Time and Date of Analysis
-------------------------------------------------------------------------

Date: May 09, 2016 Time: 18:14:13

EXAMPLE PROBLEM 7 - 2D, 3x3 group, data for foundation stiffness

READING * TITLE AND VERSION

READING * Analysis Parameters
READING * Pile Cap Dimensions
READING * Load Cases
READING * Load Combinations
READING * Distributed Load Sets
READING * Pile Group Configuration
READING * Pile Properties
READING * Pile Cross Sections
READING * Soil Layers
READING * Print py curves
READING * Generated LD curves
READING * User defined MC curves
READING * Internally Generated MC curves

COMPUTATION IS PROCEEDING......

LOAD CASE : 1
CASE NAME : Load Case 1
* PILE CAP FLEXIBILITY ESTIMATION *
DOF : 1 POINT : 1

GLOBAL ITERATIONS
STEP 1, TCUR 1.0000, DTCUR 1.0000
ITERATION 1
- ErrDsp 0.10000E+01, IncDsp 0.24452E-02, TotDsp 0.24452E-02
- ErrRot 0.00000E+00, IncRot 0.00000E+00, TotRot 0.00000E+00
ITERATION 2
- ErrDsp 0.67503E-02, IncDsp 0.16395E-04, TotDsp 0.24288E-02
- ErrRot 0.00000E+00, IncRot 0.00000E+00, TotRot 0.00000E+00
ITERATION 3
- ErrDsp 0.00000E+00, IncDsp 0.00000E+00, TotDsp 0.24288E-02
- ErrRot 0.00000E+00, IncRot 0.00000E+00, TotRot 0.00000E+00
DOF : 1 POINT : 2

GLOBAL ITERATIONS
STEP 1, TCUR 1.0000, DTCUR 1.0000
ITERATION 1
- ErrDsp 0.10000E+01, IncDsp 0.73609E-02, TotDsp 0.73609E-02
- ErrRot 0.00000E+00, IncRot 0.00000E+00, TotRot 0.00000E+00
ITERATION 2
- ErrDsp 0.77389E-02, IncDsp 0.56528E-04, TotDsp 0.73044E-02
- ErrRot 0.00000E+00, IncRot 0.00000E+00, TotRot 0.00000E+00
ITERATION 3
- ErrDsp 0.00000E+00, IncDsp 0.00000E+00, TotDsp 0.73044E-02
- ErrRot 0.00000E+00, IncRot 0.00000E+00, TotRot 0.00000E+00
DOF : 1 POINT : 3

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-154

GLOBAL ITERATIONS
STEP 1, TCUR 1.0000, DTCUR 1.0000
ITERATION 1
- ErrDsp 0.10000E+01, IncDsp 0.11667E-01, TotDsp 0.11667E-01
- ErrRot 0.00000E+00, IncRot 0.00000E+00, TotRot 0.00000E+00
ITERATION 2
- ErrDsp 0.11831E-01, IncDsp 0.13641E-03, TotDsp 0.11530E-01
- ErrRot 0.00000E+00, IncRot 0.00000E+00, TotRot 0.00000E+00
ITERATION 3
- ErrDsp 0.11694E-14, IncDsp 0.13484E-16, TotDsp 0.11530E-01
- ErrRot 0.00000E+00, IncRot 0.00000E+00, TotRot 0.00000E+00
DOF : 1 POINT : 4

GLOBAL ITERATIONS
STEP 1, TCUR 1.0000, DTCUR 1.0000
ITERATION 1
- ErrDsp 0.10000E+01, IncDsp 0.14722E-01, TotDsp 0.14722E-01
- ErrRot 0.00000E+00, IncRot 0.00000E+00, TotRot 0.00000E+00
ITERATION 2
- ErrDsp 0.20605E-01, IncDsp 0.29721E-03, TotDsp 0.14425E-01
- ErrRot 0.00000E+00, IncRot 0.00000E+00, TotRot 0.00000E+00
ITERATION 3
- ErrDsp 0.74783E-15, IncDsp 0.10787E-16, TotDsp 0.14425E-01
- ErrRot 0.00000E+00, IncRot 0.00000E+00, TotRot 0.00000E+00
DOF : 1 POINT : 5

GLOBAL ITERATIONS
STEP 1, TCUR 1.0000, DTCUR 1.0000
ITERATION 1
- ErrDsp 0.10000E+01, IncDsp 0.17092E-01, TotDsp 0.17092E-01
- ErrRot 0.00000E+00, IncRot 0.00000E+00, TotRot 0.00000E+00
ITERATION 2
- ErrDsp 0.25312E-01, IncDsp 0.42194E-03, TotDsp 0.16670E-01
- ErrRot 0.00000E+00, IncRot 0.00000E+00, TotRot 0.00000E+00
ITERATION 3
- ErrDsp 0.64712E-15, IncDsp 0.10787E-16, TotDsp 0.16670E-01
- ErrRot 0.00000E+00, IncRot 0.00000E+00, TotRot 0.00000E+00
DOF : 1 POINT : 6

GLOBAL ITERATIONS
STEP 1, TCUR 1.0000, DTCUR 1.0000
ITERATION 1
- ErrDsp 0.10000E+01, IncDsp 0.19028E-01, TotDsp 0.19028E-01
- ErrRot 0.00000E+00, IncRot 0.00000E+00, TotRot 0.00000E+00
ITERATION 2
- ErrDsp 0.28310E-01, IncDsp 0.52385E-03, TotDsp 0.18504E-01
- ErrRot 0.00000E+00, IncRot 0.00000E+00, TotRot 0.00000E+00
ITERATION 3
- ErrDsp 0.87446E-15, IncDsp 0.16181E-16, TotDsp 0.18504E-01
- ErrRot 0.00000E+00, IncRot 0.00000E+00, TotRot 0.00000E+00
DOF : 1 POINT : 7

GLOBAL ITERATIONS
STEP 1, TCUR 1.0000, DTCUR 1.0000
ITERATION 1
- ErrDsp 0.10000E+01, IncDsp 0.20665E-01, TotDsp 0.20665E-01
- ErrRot 0.00000E+00, IncRot 0.00000E+00, TotRot 0.00000E+00
ITERATION 2
- ErrDsp 0.30417E-01, IncDsp 0.61001E-03, TotDsp 0.20055E-01
- ErrRot 0.00000E+00, IncRot 0.00000E+00, TotRot 0.00000E+00
ITERATION 3
- ErrDsp 0.72615E-14, IncDsp 0.14563E-15, TotDsp 0.20055E-01
- ErrRot 0.00000E+00, IncRot 0.00000E+00, TotRot 0.00000E+00
DOF : 1 POINT : 8

GLOBAL ITERATIONS
STEP 1, TCUR 1.0000, DTCUR 1.0000
ITERATION 1

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-155

- ErrDsp 0.10000E+01, IncDsp 0.22083E-01, TotDsp 0.22083E-01

- ErrRot 0.00000E+00, IncRot 0.00000E+00, TotRot 0.00000E+00
ITERATION 2
- ErrDsp 0.31498E-01, IncDsp 0.67433E-03, TotDsp 0.21408E-01
- ErrRot 0.00000E+00, IncRot 0.00000E+00, TotRot 0.00000E+00
ITERATION 3
- ErrDsp 0.39383E-14, IncDsp 0.84313E-16, TotDsp 0.21408E-01
- ErrRot 0.00000E+00, IncRot 0.00000E+00, TotRot 0.00000E+00
DOF : 1 POINT : 9

GLOBAL ITERATIONS
STEP 1, TCUR 1.0000, DTCUR 1.0000
ITERATION 1
- ErrDsp 0.10000E+01, IncDsp 0.23334E-01, TotDsp 0.23334E-01
- ErrRot 0.00000E+00, IncRot 0.00000E+00, TotRot 0.00000E+00
ITERATION 2
- ErrDsp 0.16622E-01, IncDsp 0.38151E-03, TotDsp 0.22952E-01
- ErrRot 0.00000E+00, IncRot 0.00000E+00, TotRot 0.00000E+00
ITERATION 3
- ErrDsp 0.19898E-14, IncDsp 0.45670E-16, TotDsp 0.22952E-01
- ErrRot 0.00000E+00, IncRot 0.00000E+00, TotRot 0.00000E+00
DOF : 1 POINT : 10

GLOBAL ITERATIONS
STEP 1, TCUR 1.0000, DTCUR 1.0000
ITERATION 1
- ErrDsp 0.10000E+01, IncDsp 0.24452E-01, TotDsp 0.24452E-01
- ErrRot 0.00000E+00, IncRot 0.00000E+00, TotRot 0.00000E+00
ITERATION 2
- ErrDsp 0.49141E-02, IncDsp 0.11957E-03, TotDsp 0.24333E-01
- ErrRot 0.00000E+00, IncRot 0.00000E+00, TotRot 0.00000E+00
ITERATION 3
- ErrDsp 0.57750E-15, IncDsp 0.14052E-16, TotDsp 0.24333E-01
- ErrRot 0.00000E+00, IncRot 0.00000E+00, TotRot 0.00000E+00
DOF : 2 POINT : 1

GLOBAL ITERATIONS
STEP 1, TCUR 1.0000, DTCUR 1.0000
ITERATION 1
- ErrDsp 0.10000E+01, IncDsp 0.76316E-04, TotDsp 0.76316E-04
- ErrRot 0.10000E+01, IncRot 0.22270E-05, TotRot 0.22270E-05
ITERATION 2
- ErrDsp 0.63890E+00, IncDsp 0.13503E-03, TotDsp 0.21134E-03
- ErrRot 0.47116E-01, IncRot 0.11012E-06, TotRot 0.23372E-05
ITERATION 3
- ErrDsp 0.25165E+00, IncDsp 0.71069E-04, TotDsp 0.28241E-03
- ErrRot 0.98644E-01, IncRot 0.25578E-06, TotRot 0.25929E-05
ITERATION 4
- ErrDsp 0.22944E-01, IncDsp 0.66318E-05, TotDsp 0.28904E-03
- ErrRot 0.36811E-02, IncRot 0.95800E-08, TotRot 0.26025E-05
ITERATION 5
- ErrDsp 0.93369E-03, IncDsp 0.27013E-06, TotDsp 0.28931E-03
- ErrRot 0.89362E-03, IncRot 0.23277E-08, TotRot 0.26048E-05
ITERATION 6
- ErrDsp 0.46764E-05, IncDsp 0.13529E-08, TotDsp 0.28931E-03
- ErrRot 0.72263E-05, IncRot 0.18823E-10, TotRot 0.26049E-05
DOF : 2 POINT : 2

GLOBAL ITERATIONS
STEP 1, TCUR 1.0000, DTCUR 1.0000
ITERATION 1
- ErrDsp 0.10000E+01, IncDsp 0.22974E-03, TotDsp 0.22974E-03
- ErrRot 0.10000E+01, IncRot 0.67041E-05, TotRot 0.67041E-05
ITERATION 2
- ErrDsp 0.79902E+00, IncDsp 0.91334E-03, TotDsp 0.11431E-02
- ErrRot 0.30591E+00, IncRot 0.29547E-05, TotRot 0.96588E-05
ITERATION 3
- ErrDsp 0.53560E+00, IncDsp 0.13183E-02, TotDsp 0.24614E-02
- ErrRot 0.20506E+00, IncRot 0.24915E-05, TotRot 0.12150E-04
ITERATION 4

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-156

- ErrDsp 0.14187E+00, IncDsp 0.40693E-03, TotDsp 0.28683E-02

- ErrRot 0.63544E-01, IncRot 0.82447E-06, TotRot 0.12975E-04
ITERATION 5
- ErrDsp 0.15018E-02, IncDsp 0.43142E-05, TotDsp 0.28726E-02
- ErrRot 0.68419E-03, IncRot 0.88712E-08, TotRot 0.12966E-04
ITERATION 6
- ErrDsp 0.80271E-06, IncDsp 0.23059E-08, TotDsp 0.28726E-02
- ErrRot 0.59185E-07, IncRot 0.76738E-12, TotRot 0.12966E-04
DOF : 2 POINT : 3

GLOBAL ITERATIONS
STEP 1, TCUR 1.0000, DTCUR 1.0000
ITERATION 1
- ErrDsp 0.10000E+01, IncDsp 0.36412E-03, TotDsp 0.36412E-03
- ErrRot 0.10000E+01, IncRot 0.10626E-04, TotRot 0.10626E-04
ITERATION 2
- ErrDsp 0.84664E+00, IncDsp 0.20101E-02, TotDsp 0.23742E-02
- ErrRot 0.37337E+00, IncRot 0.63312E-05, TotRot 0.16957E-04
ITERATION 3
- ErrDsp 0.59465E+00, IncDsp 0.34830E-02, TotDsp 0.58572E-02
- ErrRot 0.27967E+00, IncRot 0.65834E-05, TotRot 0.23540E-04
ITERATION 4
- ErrDsp 0.21302E+00, IncDsp 0.15855E-02, TotDsp 0.74426E-02
- ErrRot 0.60341E-01, IncRot 0.15117E-05, TotRot 0.25052E-04
ITERATION 5
- ErrDsp 0.18271E-01, IncDsp 0.13852E-03, TotDsp 0.75812E-02
- ErrRot 0.30994E-02, IncRot 0.77888E-07, TotRot 0.25130E-04
ITERATION 6
- ErrDsp 0.22548E-03, IncDsp 0.17098E-05, TotDsp 0.75829E-02
- ErrRot 0.23601E-04, IncRot 0.59308E-09, TotRot 0.25129E-04
ITERATION 7
- ErrDsp 0.24817E-07, IncDsp 0.18819E-09, TotDsp 0.75829E-02
- ErrRot 0.52465E-09, IncRot 0.13184E-13, TotRot 0.25129E-04
DOF : 2 POINT : 4

GLOBAL ITERATIONS
STEP 1, TCUR 1.0000, DTCUR 1.0000
ITERATION 1
- ErrDsp 0.10000E+01, IncDsp 0.45947E-03, TotDsp 0.45947E-03
- ErrRot 0.10000E+01, IncRot 0.13408E-04, TotRot 0.13408E-04
ITERATION 2
- ErrDsp 0.86594E+00, IncDsp 0.29679E-02, TotDsp 0.34273E-02
- ErrRot 0.40613E+00, IncRot 0.91694E-05, TotRot 0.22577E-04
ITERATION 3
- ErrDsp 0.63037E+00, IncDsp 0.58449E-02, TotDsp 0.92723E-02
- ErrRot 0.30105E+00, IncRot 0.97247E-05, TotRot 0.32302E-04
ITERATION 4
- ErrDsp 0.23514E+00, IncDsp 0.28505E-02, TotDsp 0.12123E-01
- ErrRot 0.73477E-01, IncRot 0.25617E-05, TotRot 0.34864E-04
ITERATION 5
- ErrDsp 0.18338E-01, IncDsp 0.22646E-03, TotDsp 0.12349E-01
- ErrRot 0.50427E-02, IncRot 0.17670E-06, TotRot 0.35041E-04
ITERATION 6
- ErrDsp 0.99894E-03, IncDsp 0.12349E-04, TotDsp 0.12362E-01
- ErrRot 0.43630E-04, IncRot 0.15289E-08, TotRot 0.35042E-04
ITERATION 7
- ErrDsp 0.37641E-06, IncDsp 0.46531E-08, TotDsp 0.12362E-01
- ErrRot 0.52899E-07, IncRot 0.18537E-11, TotRot 0.35042E-04
DOF : 2 POINT : 5

GLOBAL ITERATIONS
STEP 1, TCUR 1.0000, DTCUR 1.0000
ITERATION 1
- ErrDsp 0.10000E+01, IncDsp 0.53343E-03, TotDsp 0.53343E-03
- ErrRot 0.10000E+01, IncRot 0.15566E-04, TotRot 0.15566E-04
ITERATION 2
- ErrDsp 0.87667E+00, IncDsp 0.37919E-02, TotDsp 0.43253E-02
- ErrRot 0.42660E+00, IncRot 0.11581E-04, TotRot 0.27148E-04
ITERATION 3
- ErrDsp 0.67020E+00, IncDsp 0.87896E-02, TotDsp 0.13115E-01

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-157

- ErrRot 0.29446E+00, IncRot 0.11330E-04, TotRot 0.38478E-04

ITERATION 4
- ErrDsp 0.21502E+00, IncDsp 0.35924E-02, TotDsp 0.16707E-01
- ErrRot 0.10803E+00, IncRot 0.46603E-05, TotRot 0.43138E-04
ITERATION 5
- ErrDsp 0.12266E-01, IncDsp 0.20747E-03, TotDsp 0.16915E-01
- ErrRot 0.49544E-02, IncRot 0.21479E-06, TotRot 0.43353E-04
ITERATION 6
- ErrDsp 0.16793E-03, IncDsp 0.28410E-05, TotDsp 0.16918E-01
- ErrRot 0.46201E-05, IncRot 0.20029E-09, TotRot 0.43353E-04
ITERATION 7
- ErrDsp 0.22140E-04, IncDsp 0.37454E-06, TotDsp 0.16917E-01
- ErrRot 0.16545E-05, IncRot 0.71729E-10, TotRot 0.43353E-04
ITERATION 8
- ErrDsp 0.36571E-07, IncDsp 0.61869E-09, TotDsp 0.16917E-01
- ErrRot 0.28900E-08, IncRot 0.12529E-12, TotRot 0.43353E-04
DOF : 2 POINT : 6

GLOBAL ITERATIONS
STEP 1, TCUR 1.0000, DTCUR 1.0000
ITERATION 1
- ErrDsp 0.10000E+01, IncDsp 0.59386E-03, TotDsp 0.59386E-03
- ErrRot 0.10000E+01, IncRot 0.17330E-04, TotRot 0.17330E-04
ITERATION 2
- ErrDsp 0.88360E+00, IncDsp 0.45079E-02, TotDsp 0.51017E-02
- ErrRot 0.44098E+00, IncRot 0.13670E-04, TotRot 0.31000E-04
ITERATION 3
- ErrDsp 0.66083E+00, IncDsp 0.99402E-02, TotDsp 0.15042E-01
- ErrRot 0.30636E+00, IncRot 0.13692E-04, TotRot 0.44692E-04
ITERATION 4
- ErrDsp 0.27152E+00, IncDsp 0.56064E-02, TotDsp 0.20648E-01
- ErrRot 0.10823E+00, IncRot 0.54240E-05, TotRot 0.50116E-04
ITERATION 5
- ErrDsp 0.26419E-01, IncDsp 0.56031E-03, TotDsp 0.21209E-01
- ErrRot 0.73862E-02, IncRot 0.37292E-06, TotRot 0.50489E-04
ITERATION 6
- ErrDsp 0.23831E-03, IncDsp 0.50555E-05, TotDsp 0.21214E-01
- ErrRot 0.44381E-04, IncRot 0.22408E-08, TotRot 0.50491E-04
ITERATION 7
- ErrDsp 0.20076E-07, IncDsp 0.42588E-09, TotDsp 0.21214E-01
- ErrRot 0.35389E-08, IncRot 0.17868E-12, TotRot 0.50491E-04
DOF : 2 POINT : 7

GLOBAL ITERATIONS
STEP 1, TCUR 1.0000, DTCUR 1.0000
ITERATION 1
- ErrDsp 0.10000E+01, IncDsp 0.64495E-03, TotDsp 0.64495E-03
- ErrRot 0.10000E+01, IncRot 0.18821E-04, TotRot 0.18821E-04
ITERATION 2
- ErrDsp 0.88848E+00, IncDsp 0.51382E-02, TotDsp 0.57831E-02
- ErrRot 0.45181E+00, IncRot 0.15512E-04, TotRot 0.34332E-04
ITERATION 3
- ErrDsp 0.67185E+00, IncDsp 0.11841E-01, TotDsp 0.17624E-01
- ErrRot 0.32900E+00, IncRot 0.16834E-04, TotRot 0.51166E-04
ITERATION 4
- ErrDsp 0.27626E+00, IncDsp 0.67270E-02, TotDsp 0.24351E-01
- ErrRot 0.92620E-01, IncRot 0.52227E-05, TotRot 0.56388E-04
ITERATION 5
- ErrDsp 0.36687E-01, IncDsp 0.92738E-03, TotDsp 0.25278E-01
- ErrRot 0.60507E-02, IncRot 0.34327E-06, TotRot 0.56732E-04
ITERATION 6
- ErrDsp 0.81468E-03, IncDsp 0.20577E-04, TotDsp 0.25257E-01
- ErrRot 0.63929E-03, IncRot 0.36291E-07, TotRot 0.56768E-04
ITERATION 7
- ErrDsp 0.14348E-05, IncDsp 0.36238E-07, TotDsp 0.25258E-01
- ErrRot 0.63589E-06, IncRot 0.36098E-10, TotRot 0.56768E-04
DOF : 2 POINT : 8

GLOBAL ITERATIONS
STEP 1, TCUR 1.0000, DTCUR 1.0000

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-158

ITERATION 1
- ErrDsp 0.10000E+01, IncDsp 0.68921E-03, TotDsp 0.68921E-03
- ErrRot 0.10000E+01, IncRot 0.20112E-04, TotRot 0.20112E-04
ITERATION 2
- ErrDsp 0.89213E+00, IncDsp 0.56997E-02, TotDsp 0.63889E-02
- ErrRot 0.46035E+00, IncRot 0.17157E-04, TotRot 0.37269E-04
ITERATION 3
- ErrDsp 0.67855E+00, IncDsp 0.13486E-01, TotDsp 0.19875E-01
- ErrRot 0.33702E+00, IncRot 0.18945E-04, TotRot 0.56215E-04
ITERATION 4
- ErrDsp 0.29173E+00, IncDsp 0.81866E-02, TotDsp 0.28062E-01
- ErrRot 0.90517E-01, IncRot 0.55948E-05, TotRot 0.61809E-04
ITERATION 5
- ErrDsp 0.31115E-01, IncDsp 0.90118E-03, TotDsp 0.28963E-01
- ErrRot 0.93857E-02, IncRot 0.58562E-06, TotRot 0.62395E-04
ITERATION 6
- ErrDsp 0.54557E-03, IncDsp 0.15810E-04, TotDsp 0.28979E-01
- ErrRot 0.16580E-04, IncRot 0.10345E-08, TotRot 0.62396E-04
ITERATION 7
- ErrDsp 0.82467E-07, IncDsp 0.23898E-08, TotDsp 0.28979E-01
- ErrRot 0.42936E-07, IncRot 0.26790E-11, TotRot 0.62396E-04
DOF : 2 POINT : 9

GLOBAL ITERATIONS
STEP 1, TCUR 1.0000, DTCUR 1.0000
ITERATION 1
- ErrDsp 0.10000E+01, IncDsp 0.72824E-03, TotDsp 0.72824E-03
- ErrRot 0.10000E+01, IncRot 0.21251E-04, TotRot 0.21251E-04
ITERATION 2
- ErrDsp 0.89497E+00, IncDsp 0.62051E-02, TotDsp 0.69334E-02
- ErrRot 0.46733E+00, IncRot 0.18645E-04, TotRot 0.39896E-04
ITERATION 3
- ErrDsp 0.68774E+00, IncDsp 0.15270E-01, TotDsp 0.22204E-01
- ErrRot 0.33756E+00, IncRot 0.20330E-04, TotRot 0.60226E-04
ITERATION 4
- ErrDsp 0.29808E+00, IncDsp 0.94290E-02, TotDsp 0.31633E-01
- ErrRot 0.98036E-01, IncRot 0.65460E-05, TotRot 0.66772E-04
ITERATION 5
- ErrDsp 0.28055E-01, IncDsp 0.91306E-03, TotDsp 0.32546E-01
- ErrRot 0.10034E-01, IncRot 0.67676E-06, TotRot 0.67449E-04
ITERATION 6
- ErrDsp 0.26404E-03, IncDsp 0.85957E-05, TotDsp 0.32554E-01
- ErrRot 0.47708E-04, IncRot 0.32180E-08, TotRot 0.67452E-04
ITERATION 7
- ErrDsp 0.24286E-07, IncDsp 0.79062E-09, TotDsp 0.32554E-01
- ErrRot 0.42087E-08, IncRot 0.28389E-12, TotRot 0.67452E-04
DOF : 2 POINT : 10

GLOBAL ITERATIONS
STEP 1, TCUR 1.0000, DTCUR 1.0000
ITERATION 1
- ErrDsp 0.10000E+01, IncDsp 0.76316E-03, TotDsp 0.76316E-03
- ErrRot 0.10000E+01, IncRot 0.22270E-04, TotRot 0.22270E-04
ITERATION 2
- ErrDsp 0.89725E+00, IncDsp 0.66640E-02, TotDsp 0.74272E-02
- ErrRot 0.47317E+00, IncRot 0.20002E-04, TotRot 0.42272E-04
ITERATION 3
- ErrDsp 0.69584E+00, IncDsp 0.16992E-01, TotDsp 0.24419E-01
- ErrRot 0.33881E+00, IncRot 0.21661E-04, TotRot 0.63933E-04
ITERATION 4
- ErrDsp 0.29814E+00, IncDsp 0.10373E-01, TotDsp 0.34792E-01
- ErrRot 0.10446E+00, IncRot 0.74571E-05, TotRot 0.71390E-04
ITERATION 5
- ErrDsp 0.30795E-01, IncDsp 0.11055E-02, TotDsp 0.35897E-01
- ErrRot 0.93596E-02, IncRot 0.67450E-06, TotRot 0.72065E-04
ITERATION 6
- ErrDsp 0.19302E-02, IncDsp 0.69422E-04, TotDsp 0.35967E-01
- ErrRot 0.74255E-05, IncRot 0.53511E-09, TotRot 0.72064E-04
ITERATION 7
- ErrDsp 0.18011E-05, IncDsp 0.64781E-07, TotDsp 0.35967E-01

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-159

- ErrRot 0.21693E-06, IncRot 0.15633E-10, TotRot 0.72064E-04

DOF : 3 POINT : 1

GLOBAL ITERATIONS
STEP 1, TCUR 1.0000, DTCUR 1.0000
ITERATION 1
- ErrDsp 0.10000E+01, IncDsp 0.11135E-03, TotDsp 0.11135E-03
- ErrRot 0.10000E+01, IncRot 0.78449E-05, TotRot 0.78449E-05
ITERATION 2
- ErrDsp 0.25478E+00, IncDsp 0.22656E-04, TotDsp 0.88922E-04
- ErrRot 0.78883E-01, IncRot 0.57358E-06, TotRot 0.72713E-05
ITERATION 3
- ErrDsp 0.41758E-01, IncDsp 0.38750E-05, TotDsp 0.92795E-04
- ErrRot 0.18345E-02, IncRot 0.13364E-07, TotRot 0.72846E-05
ITERATION 4
- ErrDsp 0.68047E-02, IncDsp 0.62718E-06, TotDsp 0.92168E-04
- ErrRot 0.31544E-03, IncRot 0.22971E-08, TotRot 0.72823E-05
ITERATION 5
- ErrDsp 0.35402E-03, IncDsp 0.32641E-07, TotDsp 0.92201E-04
- ErrRot 0.87541E-04, IncRot 0.63756E-09, TotRot 0.72830E-05
ITERATION 6
- ErrDsp 0.56026E-04, IncDsp 0.51654E-08, TotDsp 0.92196E-04
- ErrRot 0.28893E-05, IncRot 0.21042E-10, TotRot 0.72830E-05
ITERATION 7
- ErrDsp 0.25927E-05, IncDsp 0.23904E-09, TotDsp 0.92196E-04
- ErrRot 0.72587E-06, IncRot 0.52865E-11, TotRot 0.72830E-05
DOF : 3 POINT : 2

GLOBAL ITERATIONS
STEP 1, TCUR 1.0000, DTCUR 1.0000
ITERATION 1
- ErrDsp 0.10000E+01, IncDsp 0.33520E-03, TotDsp 0.33520E-03
- ErrRot 0.10000E+01, IncRot 0.23615E-04, TotRot 0.23615E-04
ITERATION 2
- ErrDsp 0.35942E-01, IncDsp 0.12360E-04, TotDsp 0.34389E-03
- ErrRot 0.33908E-01, IncRot 0.77448E-06, TotRot 0.22841E-04
ITERATION 3
- ErrDsp 0.43321E-01, IncDsp 0.15572E-04, TotDsp 0.35946E-03
- ErrRot 0.21901E-02, IncRot 0.50133E-07, TotRot 0.22891E-04
ITERATION 4
- ErrDsp 0.26404E-01, IncDsp 0.97484E-05, TotDsp 0.36921E-03
- ErrRot 0.11271E-02, IncRot 0.25830E-07, TotRot 0.22917E-04
ITERATION 5
- ErrDsp 0.71811E-02, IncDsp 0.26324E-05, TotDsp 0.36658E-03
- ErrRot 0.31855E-03, IncRot 0.72977E-08, TotRot 0.22910E-04
ITERATION 6
- ErrDsp 0.19195E-03, IncDsp 0.70377E-07, TotDsp 0.36665E-03
- ErrRot 0.91154E-05, IncRot 0.20883E-09, TotRot 0.22910E-04
ITERATION 7
- ErrDsp 0.16554E-04, IncDsp 0.60695E-08, TotDsp 0.36664E-03
- ErrRot 0.69954E-06, IncRot 0.16026E-10, TotRot 0.22910E-04
ITERATION 8
- ErrDsp 0.13892E-05, IncDsp 0.50933E-09, TotDsp 0.36664E-03
- ErrRot 0.58760E-07, IncRot 0.13462E-11, TotRot 0.22910E-04
DOF : 3 POINT : 3

GLOBAL ITERATIONS
STEP 1, TCUR 1.0000, DTCUR 1.0000
ITERATION 1
- ErrDsp 0.10000E+01, IncDsp 0.53128E-03, TotDsp 0.53128E-03
- ErrRot 0.10000E+01, IncRot 0.37429E-04, TotRot 0.37429E-04
ITERATION 2
- ErrDsp 0.91208E-01, IncDsp 0.53133E-04, TotDsp 0.58255E-03
- ErrRot 0.21375E-01, IncRot 0.78332E-06, TotRot 0.36646E-04
ITERATION 3
- ErrDsp 0.20659E+00, IncDsp 0.15168E-03, TotDsp 0.73419E-03
- ErrRot 0.99000E-02, IncRot 0.36642E-06, TotRot 0.37013E-04
ITERATION 4
- ErrDsp 0.58944E-01, IncDsp 0.40868E-04, TotDsp 0.69333E-03
- ErrRot 0.12505E-02, IncRot 0.46225E-07, TotRot 0.36966E-04

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-160

ITERATION 5
- ErrDsp 0.12056E-01, IncDsp 0.82595E-05, TotDsp 0.68507E-03
- ErrRot 0.31824E-03, IncRot 0.11760E-07, TotRot 0.36955E-04
ITERATION 6
- ErrDsp 0.41974E-03, IncDsp 0.28743E-06, TotDsp 0.68478E-03
- ErrRot 0.10062E-04, IncRot 0.37182E-09, TotRot 0.36954E-04
ITERATION 7
- ErrDsp 0.18984E-05, IncDsp 0.13000E-08, TotDsp 0.68478E-03
- ErrRot 0.53819E-07, IncRot 0.19888E-11, TotRot 0.36954E-04
DOF : 3 POINT : 4

GLOBAL ITERATIONS
STEP 1, TCUR 1.0000, DTCUR 1.0000
ITERATION 1
- ErrDsp 0.10000E+01, IncDsp 0.67041E-03, TotDsp 0.67041E-03
- ErrRot 0.10000E+01, IncRot 0.47231E-04, TotRot 0.47231E-04
ITERATION 2
- ErrDsp 0.13606E+00, IncDsp 0.10535E-03, TotDsp 0.77431E-03
- ErrRot 0.15227E-01, IncRot 0.70839E-06, TotRot 0.46522E-04
ITERATION 3
- ErrDsp 0.18446E+00, IncDsp 0.17512E-03, TotDsp 0.94939E-03
- ErrRot 0.99702E-02, IncRot 0.46851E-06, TotRot 0.46991E-04
ITERATION 4
- ErrDsp 0.39737E-01, IncDsp 0.36284E-04, TotDsp 0.91311E-03
- ErrRot 0.25592E-03, IncRot 0.12023E-07, TotRot 0.46979E-04
ITERATION 5
- ErrDsp 0.43761E-02, IncDsp 0.40134E-05, TotDsp 0.91713E-03
- ErrRot 0.15692E-03, IncRot 0.73706E-08, TotRot 0.46971E-04
ITERATION 6
- ErrDsp 0.11368E-03, IncDsp 0.10425E-06, TotDsp 0.91702E-03
- ErrRot 0.33523E-05, IncRot 0.15746E-09, TotRot 0.46971E-04
ITERATION 7
- ErrDsp 0.27094E-05, IncDsp 0.24846E-08, TotDsp 0.91703E-03
- ErrRot 0.91264E-07, IncRot 0.42868E-11, TotRot 0.46971E-04
DOF : 3 POINT : 5

GLOBAL ITERATIONS
STEP 1, TCUR 1.0000, DTCUR 1.0000
ITERATION 1
- ErrDsp 0.10000E+01, IncDsp 0.77832E-03, TotDsp 0.77832E-03
- ErrRot 0.10000E+01, IncRot 0.54833E-04, TotRot 0.54833E-04
ITERATION 2
- ErrDsp 0.20745E+00, IncDsp 0.20348E-03, TotDsp 0.98085E-03
- ErrRot 0.88272E-02, IncRot 0.47979E-06, TotRot 0.54353E-04
ITERATION 3
- ErrDsp 0.14035E+00, IncDsp 0.16014E-03, TotDsp 0.11410E-02
- ErrRot 0.86031E-02, IncRot 0.47167E-06, TotRot 0.54825E-04
ITERATION 4
- ErrDsp 0.60067E-01, IncDsp 0.64651E-04, TotDsp 0.10763E-02
- ErrRot 0.16491E-02, IncRot 0.90264E-07, TotRot 0.54735E-04
ITERATION 5
- ErrDsp 0.15791E-01, IncDsp 0.17269E-04, TotDsp 0.10936E-02
- ErrRot 0.53035E-03, IncRot 0.29044E-07, TotRot 0.54764E-04
ITERATION 6
- ErrDsp 0.42288E-03, IncDsp 0.46226E-06, TotDsp 0.10931E-02
- ErrRot 0.59314E-05, IncRot 0.32482E-09, TotRot 0.54763E-04
ITERATION 7
- ErrDsp 0.59922E-05, IncDsp 0.65502E-08, TotDsp 0.10931E-02
- ErrRot 0.22512E-06, IncRot 0.12329E-10, TotRot 0.54763E-04
DOF : 3 POINT : 6

GLOBAL ITERATIONS
STEP 1, TCUR 1.0000, DTCUR 1.0000
ITERATION 1
- ErrDsp 0.10000E+01, IncDsp 0.86649E-03, TotDsp 0.86649E-03
- ErrRot 0.10000E+01, IncRot 0.61045E-04, TotRot 0.61045E-04
ITERATION 2
- ErrDsp 0.25611E+00, IncDsp 0.29806E-03, TotDsp 0.11638E-02
- ErrRot 0.42648E-02, IncRot 0.25924E-06, TotRot 0.60786E-04
ITERATION 3

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-161

- ErrDsp 0.84380E-01, IncDsp 0.10725E-03, TotDsp 0.12710E-02

- ErrRot 0.66195E-02, IncRot 0.40505E-06, TotRot 0.61191E-04
ITERATION 4
- ErrDsp 0.21734E-01, IncDsp 0.27037E-04, TotDsp 0.12440E-02
- ErrRot 0.64393E-03, IncRot 0.39377E-07, TotRot 0.61151E-04
ITERATION 5
- ErrDsp 0.29617E-02, IncDsp 0.36735E-05, TotDsp 0.12403E-02
- ErrRot 0.73368E-04, IncRot 0.44862E-08, TotRot 0.61147E-04
ITERATION 6
- ErrDsp 0.24557E-03, IncDsp 0.30451E-06, TotDsp 0.12400E-02
- ErrRot 0.74879E-05, IncRot 0.45786E-09, TotRot 0.61146E-04
ITERATION 7
- ErrDsp 0.66194E-04, IncDsp 0.82076E-07, TotDsp 0.12399E-02
- ErrRot 0.21448E-05, IncRot 0.13115E-09, TotRot 0.61146E-04
ITERATION 8
- ErrDsp 0.18807E-04, IncDsp 0.23318E-07, TotDsp 0.12399E-02
- ErrRot 0.61015E-06, IncRot 0.37308E-10, TotRot 0.61146E-04
ITERATION 9
- ErrDsp 0.54180E-05, IncDsp 0.67177E-08, TotDsp 0.12399E-02
- ErrRot 0.17583E-06, IncRot 0.10752E-10, TotRot 0.61146E-04
DOF : 3 POINT : 7

GLOBAL ITERATIONS
STEP 1, TCUR 1.0000, DTCUR 1.0000
ITERATION 1
- ErrDsp 0.10000E+01, IncDsp 0.94103E-03, TotDsp 0.94103E-03
- ErrRot 0.10000E+01, IncRot 0.66297E-04, TotRot 0.66297E-04
ITERATION 2
- ErrDsp 0.29089E+00, IncDsp 0.38575E-03, TotDsp 0.13261E-02
- ErrRot 0.86573E-03, IncRot 0.57345E-07, TotRot 0.66239E-04
ITERATION 3
- ErrDsp 0.26735E-01, IncDsp 0.36427E-04, TotDsp 0.13625E-02
- ErrRot 0.45910E-02, IncRot 0.30550E-06, TotRot 0.66545E-04
ITERATION 4
- ErrDsp 0.75994E-02, IncDsp 0.10434E-04, TotDsp 0.13730E-02
- ErrRot 0.28521E-03, IncRot 0.18985E-07, TotRot 0.66564E-04
ITERATION 5
- ErrDsp 0.32009E-03, IncDsp 0.43933E-06, TotDsp 0.13725E-02
- ErrRot 0.85123E-05, IncRot 0.56660E-09, TotRot 0.66563E-04
ITERATION 6
- ErrDsp 0.91013E-05, IncDsp 0.12492E-07, TotDsp 0.13725E-02
- ErrRot 0.26688E-06, IncRot 0.17765E-10, TotRot 0.66563E-04
DOF : 3 POINT : 8

GLOBAL ITERATIONS
STEP 1, TCUR 1.0000, DTCUR 1.0000
ITERATION 1
- ErrDsp 0.10000E+01, IncDsp 0.10056E-02, TotDsp 0.10056E-02
- ErrRot 0.10000E+01, IncRot 0.70846E-04, TotRot 0.70846E-04
ITERATION 2
- ErrDsp 0.31665E+00, IncDsp 0.46569E-03, TotDsp 0.14707E-02
- ErrRot 0.14743E-02, IncRot 0.10461E-06, TotRot 0.70951E-04
ITERATION 3
- ErrDsp 0.11056E-01, IncDsp 0.16441E-04, TotDsp 0.14871E-02
- ErrRot 0.43470E-02, IncRot 0.30977E-06, TotRot 0.71260E-04
ITERATION 4
- ErrDsp 0.21164E-03, IncDsp 0.31466E-06, TotDsp 0.14868E-02
- ErrRot 0.35306E-05, IncRot 0.25159E-09, TotRot 0.71260E-04
ITERATION 5
- ErrDsp 0.49132E-04, IncDsp 0.73047E-07, TotDsp 0.14867E-02
- ErrRot 0.17897E-05, IncRot 0.12753E-09, TotRot 0.71260E-04
ITERATION 6
- ErrDsp 0.15822E-04, IncDsp 0.23522E-07, TotDsp 0.14867E-02
- ErrRot 0.57598E-06, IncRot 0.41044E-10, TotRot 0.71260E-04
ITERATION 7
- ErrDsp 0.55217E-05, IncDsp 0.82092E-08, TotDsp 0.14867E-02
- ErrRot 0.20128E-06, IncRot 0.14343E-10, TotRot 0.71260E-04
DOF : 3 POINT : 9

GLOBAL ITERATIONS

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-162

STEP 1, TCUR 1.0000, DTCUR 1.0000

ITERATION 1
- ErrDsp 0.10000E+01, IncDsp 0.10626E-02, TotDsp 0.10626E-02
- ErrRot 0.10000E+01, IncRot 0.74859E-04, TotRot 0.74859E-04
ITERATION 2
- ErrDsp 0.33874E+00, IncDsp 0.54403E-03, TotDsp 0.16060E-02
- ErrRot 0.37333E-02, IncRot 0.28052E-06, TotRot 0.75139E-04
ITERATION 3
- ErrDsp 0.12966E-02, IncDsp 0.20851E-05, TotDsp 0.16081E-02
- ErrRot 0.37954E-02, IncRot 0.28627E-06, TotRot 0.75426E-04
ITERATION 4
- ErrDsp 0.84392E-04, IncDsp 0.13570E-06, TotDsp 0.16080E-02
- ErrRot 0.21717E-05, IncRot 0.16380E-09, TotRot 0.75426E-04
ITERATION 5
- ErrDsp 0.29006E-05, IncDsp 0.46641E-08, TotDsp 0.16080E-02
- ErrRot 0.84024E-07, IncRot 0.63376E-11, TotRot 0.75426E-04
DOF : 3 POINT : 10

GLOBAL ITERATIONS
STEP 1, TCUR 1.0000, DTCUR 1.0000
ITERATION 1
- ErrDsp 0.10000E+01, IncDsp 0.11135E-02, TotDsp 0.11135E-02
- ErrRot 0.10000E+01, IncRot 0.78449E-04, TotRot 0.78449E-04
ITERATION 2
- ErrDsp 0.35645E+00, IncDsp 0.61646E-03, TotDsp 0.17294E-02
- ErrRot 0.56045E-02, IncRot 0.44214E-06, TotRot 0.78891E-04
ITERATION 3
- ErrDsp 0.95739E-02, IncDsp 0.16401E-04, TotDsp 0.17130E-02
- ErrRot 0.33558E-02, IncRot 0.26563E-06, TotRot 0.79156E-04
ITERATION 4
- ErrDsp 0.25460E-03, IncDsp 0.43603E-06, TotDsp 0.17126E-02
- ErrRot 0.39183E-06, IncRot 0.31016E-10, TotRot 0.79156E-04
ITERATION 5
- ErrDsp 0.29670E-06, IncDsp 0.50813E-09, TotDsp 0.17126E-02
- ErrRot 0.12160E-07, IncRot 0.96258E-12, TotRot 0.79156E-04

ANALYSIS DUE TO TOTAL LOAD

GLOBAL ITERATIONS
STEP 1, TCUR 1.0000, DTCUR 1.0000
ITERATION 1
- ErrDsp 0.10000E+01, IncDsp 0.24455E-01, TotDsp 0.24455E-01
- ErrRot 0.10000E+01, IncRot 0.56178E-04, TotRot 0.56178E-04
ITERATION 2
- ErrDsp 0.22226E+00, IncDsp 0.55603E-02, TotDsp 0.25017E-01
- ErrRot 0.13512E+00, IncRot 0.66871E-05, TotRot 0.49491E-04
ITERATION 3
- ErrDsp 0.48674E+00, IncDsp 0.15546E-01, TotDsp 0.31939E-01
- ErrRot 0.89790E+00, IncRot 0.23414E-04, TotRot 0.26077E-04
ITERATION 4
- ErrDsp 0.23301E+00, IncDsp 0.89467E-02, TotDsp 0.38396E-01
- ErrRot 0.53106E+00, IncRot 0.90449E-05, TotRot 0.17032E-04
ITERATION 5
- ErrDsp 0.27311E-01, IncDsp 0.10714E-02, TotDsp 0.39231E-01
- ErrRot 0.31094E-01, IncRot 0.51361E-06, TotRot 0.16518E-04
ITERATION 6
- ErrDsp 0.48631E-04, IncDsp 0.19077E-05, TotDsp 0.39229E-01
- ErrRot 0.63455E-03, IncRot 0.10475E-07, TotRot 0.16508E-04
ITERATION 7
- ErrDsp 0.44063E-08, IncDsp 0.17285E-09, TotDsp 0.39229E-01
- ErrRot 0.12961E-08, IncRot 0.21396E-13, TotRot 0.16508E-04

NUMBER OF GLOBAL ITERATIONS = 7

ANALYSIS FOR LOAD CASE 1/ 1 FINISHED

Execution Time : 446 ms

Number Processors : 1/ 1
Serial processing : 0.221 sec

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-163

Paral. processing : 0.206 sec

Print. processing : 0.020 sec

ANALYSIS COMPLETED
Execution Time : 452 ms
Number Processors : 1/ 1

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-164

1.8.5 Output Results File

=========================================================================

GROUP for Windows, Version 2016.10.8

Serial Number : 136089307

Analysis of A Group of Piles

Subjected to Axial and Lateral Loading

(c) Copyright ENSOFT, Inc., 1987-2015

All Rights Reserved

=========================================================================

This program is licensed to :

ENSOFT, INC
AUSTIN, TX

Path to file locations : C:\projects\GROUP2016\Group2016_1008\DXE\Examples_2016\

Name of input data file : 2Dexample7.gp10d
Name of output echo file : 2Dexample7.gp10e
Name of output results file : 2Dexample7.gp10o
Name of output summary file : 2Dexample7.gp10t
Name of plot output file : 2Dexample7.gp10p
Name of runtime file : 2Dexample7.gp10r

-------------------------------------------------------------------------
Time and Date of Analysis
-------------------------------------------------------------------------

Date: May 09, 2016 Time: 18:14:13

***** COMPUTATION RESULTS *****

EXAMPLE PROBLEM 7 - 2D, 3x3 group, data for foundation stiffness

***** LOAD CASES RESULTS *****

LOAD CASE : 1
CASE NAME : Load Case 1
LOAD TYPE : Special, Sp

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-165

* PILE CAP FLEXIBILITY ESTIMATION *

DOF : 1 (FORCE X)

N FORCE, LB VERT. DISP,IN HOR. DISP Y,IN ROTATION Z,RAD

1 1.00000E+05
2.42885E-03 0.00000 0.00000
2 3.01030E+05
7.30438E-03 0.00000 0.00000
3 4.77121E+05
0.0115304 0.00000 0.00000
4 6.02060E+05
0.0144246 0.00000 0.00000
5 6.98970E+05
0.0166696 0.00000 0.00000
6 7.78151E+05
0.0185038 0.00000 0.00000
7 8.45098E+05
0.0200547 0.00000 0.00000
8 9.03090E+05
0.0214084 0.00000 0.00000
9 9.54242E+05
0.0229520 0.00000 0.00000
10 1.00000E+06
0.0243328 0.00000 0.00000

N S11 S21 S31

IN/LBS IN/LBS RAD/LBS
1 2.42885E-08 0.00000 0.00000
2 2.42646E-08 0.00000 0.00000
3 2.41665E-08 0.00000 0.00000
4 2.39587E-08 0.00000 0.00000
5 2.38487E-08 0.00000 0.00000
6 2.37792E-08 0.00000 0.00000
7 2.37306E-08 0.00000 0.00000
8 2.37057E-08 0.00000 0.00000
9 2.40526E-08 0.00000 0.00000
10 2.43328E-08 0.00000 0.00000

DOF : 2 (FORCE Y)

N FORCE, LB VERT. DISP,IN HOR. DISP Y,IN ROTATION Z,RAD

1 40000.0
-1.02294E-06 2.89310E-04 -2.60486E-06
2 1.20412E+05
-5.09174E-06 2.87264E-03 -1.29659E-05
3 1.90848E+05
-9.87305E-06 7.58287E-03 -2.51293E-05
4 2.40824E+05
-1.39931E-05 0.0123616 -3.50421E-05
5 2.79588E+05
-1.74472E-05 0.0169173 -4.33526E-05
6 3.11260E+05
-2.04141E-05 0.0212137 -5.04909E-05
7 3.38039E+05
-2.30230E-05 0.0252575 -5.67680E-05
8 3.61236E+05
-2.53622E-05 0.0289787 -6.23959E-05
9 3.81697E+05
-2.74636E-05 0.0325544 -6.74520E-05
10 4.00000E+05
-2.93807E-05 0.0359669 -7.20644E-05

N S12 S22 S32

IN/LBS IN/LBS RAD/LBS
1 -2.55734E-11 7.23276E-09 -6.51215E-11
2 -4.22860E-11 2.38567E-08 -1.07679E-10

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-166

3 -5.17324E-11 3.97324E-08 -1.31671E-10

4 -5.81052E-11 5.13305E-08 -1.45509E-10
5 -6.24032E-11 6.05080E-08 -1.55059E-10
6 -6.55852E-11 6.81540E-08 -1.62214E-10
7 -6.81076E-11 7.47176E-08 -1.67933E-10
8 -7.02094E-11 8.02209E-08 -1.72729E-10
9 -7.19514E-11 8.52885E-08 -1.76716E-10
10 -7.34517E-11 8.99172E-08 -1.80161E-10

DOF : 3 (MOMENT Z)

N MOMENT,LBS-IN VERT. DISP,IN HOR. DISP Y,IN ROTATION Z,RAD

1 2.00000E+06
-2.86004E-06 -9.21516E-05 7.28296E-06
2 6.02060E+06
-8.98598E-06 -3.66530E-04 2.29097E-05
3 9.54242E+06
-1.47878E-05 -6.84623E-04 3.69542E-05
4 1.20412E+07
-1.89512E-05 -9.16829E-04 4.69713E-05
5 1.39794E+07
-2.21899E-05 -1.09289E-03 5.47635E-05
6 1.55630E+07
-2.48427E-05 -1.23964E-03 6.11461E-05
7 1.69020E+07
-2.70942E-05 -1.37225E-03 6.65632E-05
8 1.80618E+07
-2.90463E-05 -1.48643E-03 7.12600E-05
9 1.90848E+07
-3.07777E-05 -1.60769E-03 7.54255E-05
10 2.00000E+07
-3.23283E-05 -1.71230E-03 7.91563E-05

N S13 S23 S33

IN/IN-LBS IN/IN-LBS RAD/IN-LBS
1 -1.43002E-12 -4.60758E-11 3.64148E-12
2 -1.49254E-12 -6.08794E-11 3.80522E-12
3 -1.54969E-12 -7.17452E-11 3.87262E-12
4 -1.57387E-12 -7.61410E-11 3.90088E-12
5 -1.58733E-12 -7.81788E-11 3.91744E-12
6 -1.59627E-12 -7.96531E-11 3.92894E-12
7 -1.60302E-12 -8.11890E-11 3.93820E-12
8 -1.60816E-12 -8.22967E-11 3.94534E-12
9 -1.61268E-12 -8.42390E-11 3.95212E-12
10 -1.61641E-12 -8.56152E-11 3.95781E-12

* ANALYSIS DUE TO TOTAL LOAD *

* TABLE L * COMPUTATION ON PILE CAP

* EQUIVALENT CONCENTRATED LOAD AT ORIGIN *

VERT. LOAD, LBS HORI. LOAD, LBS MOMENT,LBS-IN

1.00000E+06 4.00000E+05 2.00000E+07

* DISPLACEMENT OF GROUPED PILE FOUNDATION AT ORIGIN *

VERTICAL,IN HORIZONTAL,IN ROTATION,RAD

0.0243328 0.0307706 1.65077E-05

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-167

NUMBER OF ITERATIONS = 7

* TABLE M * COMPUTATION ON INDIVIDUAL PILE

* PILE GROUP * 1

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS AND REACTIONS *

THE GLOBAL STRUCTURAL COORDINATE SYSTEM

---------------------------------------

DISP.X,IN DISP.Y,IN SLOPE FOR.X, LB FOR.Y, LB BM, LB-IN STRESS, LB/IN**2

0.025819 0.030771 1.6508E-05 1.1658E+05 4.4443E+04 1.8940E+06 880.51

THE PILE COORDINATE SYSTEM (LOCAL AXES)

---------------------------------------

DISP.x,IN DISP.y,IN SLOPE AXIAL, LB LAT, LB BM, LB-IN STRESS,LBS/IN**2

0.025819 0.030771 1.6508E-05 1.1658E+05 4.4443E+04 1.8940E+06 880.51

* EFFECTS FOR LATERALLY LOADED PILE *

x DISPL. BENDING SHEAR SOIL TOTAL FLEXURAL

y-DIR MOMENT FORCE REACTION STRESS RIGIDITY
FT IN LBS-IN LBS LBS/IN LBS-IN**2 LBS-IN**2
********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
0.0000 3.0771E-02 -1.8940E+06 4.2288E+04 360.73 880.51 1.4292E+11
1.0000 3.0015E-02 -1.3866E+06 3.9981E+04 382.96 688.79 1.4292E+11
2.0000 2.7861E-02 -9.3412E+05 3.5283E+04 400.12 517.84 1.4292E+11
3.0000 2.4767E-02 -5.3917E+05 3.0408E+04 412.23 368.61 1.4292E+11
4.0000 2.1130E-02 -2.0353E+05 2.5420E+04 419.16 241.80 1.4292E+11
5.0000 1.7287E-02 7.1783E+04 2.0381E+04 420.67 192.02 1.4292E+11
6.0000 1.3517E-02 2.8651E+05 1.5359E+04 416.45 273.15 1.4292E+11
7.0000 1.0035E-02 4.4123E+05 1.0423E+04 406.08 331.61 1.4292E+11
8.0000 6.9981E-03 5.3743E+05 5652.6 389.04 367.95 1.4292E+11
9.0000 4.5026E-03 5.7754E+05 1130.9 364.58 383.11 1.4292E+11
10.000 2.5890E-03 5.6509E+05 -3045.9 331.56 378.40 1.4292E+11
11.000 1.2447E-03 5.0482E+05 -6761.5 287.71 355.63 1.4292E+11
12.000 4.0905E-04 4.0307E+05 -9844.3 226.10 317.19 1.4292E+11
13.000 -2.0477E-05 2.6871E+05 -1.0462E+04 -123.17 266.42 1.4292E+11
14.000 -1.7927E-04 1.5205E+05 -8515.4 -201.24 222.35 1.4292E+11
15.000 -1.8486E-04 6.4355E+04 -6050.6 -209.57 189.21 1.4292E+11
16.000 -1.2561E-04 6829.1 -3613.9 -196.55 167.48 1.4292E+11
17.000 -5.9484E-05 -2.2394E+04 -1427.3 -167.88 173.36 1.4292E+11
18.000 -1.5918E-05 -2.7440E+04 319.52 -123.26 175.26 1.4292E+11
19.000 4.0254E-10 -1.4732E+04 1057.2 0.3141 170.46 1.4292E+11
20.000 1.0754E-06 -2068.3 652.82 67.087 165.68 1.4292E+11
21.000 6.6406E-08 935.35 88.934 26.894 165.25 1.4292E+11
22.000 -1.4860E-10 66.203 -38.979 -5.5751 164.92 1.4292E+11
23.000 -6.6732E-13 -0.1462 -2.7585 -0.4618 164.90 1.4292E+11
24.000 1.3296E-17 -6.6234E-04 6.0900E-03 1.0058E-03 164.90 1.4292E+11
25.000 6.0226E-20 1.3077E-08 2.7597E-05 4.5998E-06 164.90 1.4292E+11
26.000 -1.1670E-24 5.9776E-11 -5.4486E-10 -8.9980E-11 164.90 1.4292E+11
27.000 -5.3338E-27 -1.1477E-15 -2.4907E-12 -4.1513E-13 164.90 1.4292E+11

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-168

28.000 1.0052E-31 -5.2940E-18 4.7820E-17 7.8964E-18 164.90 1.4292E+11

29.000 4.6371E-34 9.8843E-23 2.2058E-19 3.6765E-20 164.90 1.4292E+11
30.000 -8.4989E-39 4.6025E-25 -4.1185E-24 -6.8002E-25 164.90 1.4292E+11
31.000 -3.9587E-41 -8.3566E-30 -1.9177E-26 -3.1963E-27 164.90 1.4292E+11
32.000 7.0563E-46 -3.9292E-32 3.4819E-31 5.7486E-32 164.90 1.4292E+11
33.000 3.3198E-48 6.9375E-37 1.6372E-33 2.7287E-34 164.90 1.4292E+11
34.000 0.0000 3.2950E-39 -2.8906E-38 -4.7720E-39 164.90 1.4292E+11
35.000 0.0000 -5.6573E-44 -1.3729E-40 -2.2883E-41 164.90 1.4292E+11
36.000 0.0000 -2.7151E-46 2.3572E-45 3.8910E-46 164.90 1.4292E+11
37.000 0.0000 0.0000 1.1313E-47 1.8856E-48 164.90 1.4292E+11
38.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 164.90 1.4292E+11
39.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 164.90 1.4292E+11
40.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 164.90 1.4292E+11
41.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 164.90 1.4292E+11
42.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 164.90 1.4292E+11
43.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 164.90 1.4292E+11
44.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 164.90 1.4292E+11
45.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 164.90 1.4292E+11
46.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 164.90 1.4292E+11
47.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 164.90 1.4292E+11
48.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 164.90 1.4292E+11
49.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 164.90 1.4292E+11
50.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 164.90 1.4292E+11

* PILE GROUP * 2

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS AND REACTIONS *

THE GLOBAL STRUCTURAL COORDINATE SYSTEM

---------------------------------------

DISP.X,IN DISP.Y,IN SLOPE FOR.X, LB FOR.Y, LB BM, LB-IN STRESS, LB/IN**2

0.024333 0.030771 1.6508E-05 1.1111E+05 4.4444E+04 1.8940E+06 872.78

THE PILE COORDINATE SYSTEM (LOCAL AXES)

---------------------------------------

DISP.x,IN DISP.y,IN SLOPE AXIAL, LB LAT, LB BM, LB-IN STRESS,LBS/IN**2

0.024333 0.030771 1.6508E-05 1.1111E+05 4.4444E+04 1.8940E+06 872.78

* EFFECTS FOR LATERALLY LOADED PILE *

x DISPL. BENDING SHEAR SOIL TOTAL FLEXURAL

y-DIR MOMENT FORCE REACTION STRESS RIGIDITY
FT IN LBS-IN LBS LBS/IN LBS-IN**2 LBS-IN**2
********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
0.0000 3.0771E-02 -1.8940E+06 4.2289E+04 360.73 872.78 1.4292E+11
1.0000 3.0015E-02 -1.3866E+06 3.9982E+04 382.96 681.05 1.4292E+11
2.0000 2.7861E-02 -9.3410E+05 3.5284E+04 400.12 510.09 1.4292E+11
3.0000 2.4767E-02 -5.3916E+05 3.0410E+04 412.23 360.87 1.4292E+11
4.0000 2.1130E-02 -2.0352E+05 2.5421E+04 419.16 234.06 1.4292E+11
5.0000 1.7287E-02 7.1782E+04 2.0382E+04 420.67 184.28 1.4292E+11
6.0000 1.3517E-02 2.8650E+05 1.5360E+04 416.45 265.41 1.4292E+11
7.0000 1.0035E-02 4.4122E+05 1.0425E+04 406.08 323.87 1.4292E+11
8.0000 6.9983E-03 5.3742E+05 5653.8 389.04 360.21 1.4292E+11
9.0000 4.5027E-03 5.7753E+05 1132.1 364.58 375.37 1.4292E+11
10.000 2.5891E-03 5.6508E+05 -3044.8 331.56 370.66 1.4292E+11

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-169

11.000 1.2448E-03 5.0482E+05 -6760.4 287.72 347.90 1.4292E+11

12.000 4.0911E-04 4.0307E+05 -9843.4 226.11 309.45 1.4292E+11
13.000 -2.0441E-05 2.6872E+05 -1.0461E+04 -123.09 258.69 1.4292E+11
14.000 -1.7925E-04 1.5206E+05 -8515.6 -201.23 214.61 1.4292E+11
15.000 -1.8485E-04 6.4360E+04 -6050.8 -209.56 181.48 1.4292E+11
16.000 -1.2561E-04 6832.1 -3614.1 -196.55 159.74 1.4292E+11
17.000 -5.9482E-05 -2.2393E+04 -1427.5 -167.89 165.62 1.4292E+11
18.000 -1.5917E-05 -2.7440E+04 319.50 -123.28 167.53 1.4292E+11
19.000 4.0779E-10 -1.4732E+04 1057.2 0.3209 162.72 1.4292E+11
20.000 1.0752E-06 -2068.0 652.79 67.088 157.94 1.4292E+11
21.000 6.6317E-08 935.31 88.915 26.892 157.51 1.4292E+11
22.000 -1.4765E-10 66.112 -38.978 -5.5760 157.18 1.4292E+11
23.000 -6.6523E-13 -0.1452 -2.7547 -0.4611 157.16 1.4292E+11
24.000 1.3210E-17 -6.6027E-04 6.0508E-03 9.9929E-04 157.16 1.4292E+11
25.000 6.0037E-20 1.2992E-08 2.7511E-05 4.5854E-06 157.16 1.4292E+11
26.000 -1.1594E-24 5.9589E-11 -5.4131E-10 -8.9391E-11 157.16 1.4292E+11
27.000 -5.3171E-27 -1.1401E-15 -2.4829E-12 -4.1383E-13 157.16 1.4292E+11
28.000 9.9853E-32 -5.2774E-18 4.7505E-17 7.8443E-18 157.16 1.4292E+11
29.000 4.6226E-34 9.8187E-23 2.1989E-19 3.6650E-20 157.16 1.4292E+11
30.000 -8.4422E-39 4.5881E-25 -4.0911E-24 -6.7548E-25 157.16 1.4292E+11
31.000 -3.9463E-41 -8.3006E-30 -1.9117E-26 -3.1863E-27 157.16 1.4292E+11
32.000 7.0088E-46 -3.9169E-32 3.4586E-31 5.7099E-32 157.16 1.4292E+11
33.000 3.3094E-48 6.8906E-37 1.6320E-33 2.7202E-34 157.16 1.4292E+11
34.000 0.0000 3.2847E-39 -2.8711E-38 -4.7395E-39 157.16 1.4292E+11
35.000 0.0000 -5.6186E-44 -1.3686E-40 -2.2811E-41 157.16 1.4292E+11
36.000 0.0000 -2.7066E-46 2.3411E-45 3.8642E-46 157.16 1.4292E+11
37.000 0.0000 0.0000 1.1278E-47 1.8797E-48 157.16 1.4292E+11
38.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 157.16 1.4292E+11
39.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 157.16 1.4292E+11
40.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 157.16 1.4292E+11
41.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 157.16 1.4292E+11
42.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 157.16 1.4292E+11
43.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 157.16 1.4292E+11
44.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 157.16 1.4292E+11
45.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 157.16 1.4292E+11
46.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 157.16 1.4292E+11
47.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 157.16 1.4292E+11
48.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 157.16 1.4292E+11
49.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 157.16 1.4292E+11
50.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 157.16 1.4292E+11

* PILE GROUP * 3

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS AND REACTIONS *

THE GLOBAL STRUCTURAL COORDINATE SYSTEM

---------------------------------------

DISP.X,IN DISP.Y,IN SLOPE FOR.X, LB FOR.Y, LB BM, LB-IN STRESS, LB/IN**2

0.022847 0.030771 1.6508E-05 1.0564E+05 4.4446E+04 1.8940E+06 865.04

THE PILE COORDINATE SYSTEM (LOCAL AXES)

---------------------------------------

DISP.x,IN DISP.y,IN SLOPE AXIAL, LB LAT, LB BM, LB-IN STRESS,LBS/IN**2

0.022847 0.030771 1.6508E-05 1.0564E+05 4.4446E+04 1.8940E+06 865.04

* EFFECTS FOR LATERALLY LOADED PILE *

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-170

x DISPL. BENDING SHEAR SOIL TOTAL FLEXURAL

y-DIR MOMENT FORCE REACTION STRESS RIGIDITY
FT IN LBS-IN LBS LBS/IN LBS-IN**2 LBS-IN**2
********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
0.0000 3.0771E-02 -1.8940E+06 4.2290E+04 360.73 865.04 1.4292E+11
1.0000 3.0015E-02 -1.3866E+06 3.9984E+04 382.96 673.31 1.4292E+11
2.0000 2.7861E-02 -9.3409E+05 3.5285E+04 400.12 502.35 1.4292E+11
3.0000 2.4767E-02 -5.3915E+05 3.0411E+04 412.23 353.13 1.4292E+11
4.0000 2.1130E-02 -2.0352E+05 2.5423E+04 419.16 226.32 1.4292E+11
5.0000 1.7287E-02 7.1780E+04 2.0384E+04 420.67 176.54 1.4292E+11
6.0000 1.3517E-02 2.8649E+05 1.5361E+04 416.45 257.67 1.4292E+11
7.0000 1.0035E-02 4.4121E+05 1.0426E+04 406.08 316.13 1.4292E+11
8.0000 6.9984E-03 5.3740E+05 5655.0 389.04 352.47 1.4292E+11
9.0000 4.5029E-03 5.7752E+05 1133.3 364.59 367.63 1.4292E+11
10.000 2.5892E-03 5.6507E+05 -3043.7 331.57 362.92 1.4292E+11
11.000 1.2449E-03 5.0481E+05 -6759.4 287.72 340.16 1.4292E+11
12.000 4.0918E-04 4.0307E+05 -9842.5 226.12 301.71 1.4292E+11
13.000 -2.0405E-05 2.6873E+05 -1.0461E+04 -123.01 250.95 1.4292E+11
14.000 -1.7923E-04 1.5207E+05 -8515.7 -201.22 206.88 1.4292E+11
15.000 -1.8485E-04 6.4365E+04 -6051.1 -209.56 173.74 1.4292E+11
16.000 -1.2561E-04 6835.0 -3614.3 -196.56 152.00 1.4292E+11
17.000 -5.9481E-05 -2.2392E+04 -1427.6 -167.89 157.88 1.4292E+11
18.000 -1.5916E-05 -2.7440E+04 319.48 -123.29 159.79 1.4292E+11
19.000 4.1326E-10 -1.4731E+04 1057.3 0.3280 154.99 1.4292E+11
20.000 1.0749E-06 -2067.6 652.76 67.089 150.20 1.4292E+11
21.000 6.6226E-08 935.26 88.896 26.889 149.77 1.4292E+11
22.000 -1.4668E-10 66.020 -38.976 -5.5770 149.45 1.4292E+11
23.000 -6.6310E-13 -0.1443 -2.7509 -0.4605 149.42 1.4292E+11
24.000 1.3122E-17 -6.5815E-04 6.0108E-03 9.9266E-04 149.42 1.4292E+11
25.000 5.9845E-20 1.2905E-08 2.7423E-05 4.5707E-06 149.42 1.4292E+11
26.000 -1.1516E-24 5.9399E-11 -5.3770E-10 -8.8792E-11 149.42 1.4292E+11
27.000 -5.3001E-27 -1.1324E-15 -2.4749E-12 -4.1251E-13 149.42 1.4292E+11
28.000 9.9178E-32 -5.2605E-18 4.7185E-17 7.7912E-18 149.42 1.4292E+11
29.000 4.6078E-34 9.7519E-23 2.1919E-19 3.6533E-20 149.42 1.4292E+11
30.000 -8.3845E-39 4.5734E-25 -4.0633E-24 -6.7086E-25 149.42 1.4292E+11
31.000 -3.9337E-41 -8.2435E-30 -1.9056E-26 -3.1761E-27 149.42 1.4292E+11
32.000 6.9604E-46 -3.9043E-32 3.4348E-31 5.6705E-32 149.42 1.4292E+11
33.000 3.2988E-48 6.8427E-37 1.6268E-33 2.7114E-34 149.42 1.4292E+11
34.000 0.0000 3.2742E-39 -2.8511E-38 -4.7064E-39 149.42 1.4292E+11
35.000 0.0000 -5.5792E-44 -1.3642E-40 -2.2738E-41 149.42 1.4292E+11
36.000 0.0000 -2.6980E-46 2.3247E-45 3.8370E-46 149.42 1.4292E+11
37.000 0.0000 0.0000 1.1242E-47 1.8737E-48 149.42 1.4292E+11
38.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 149.42 1.4292E+11
39.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 149.42 1.4292E+11
40.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 149.42 1.4292E+11
41.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 149.42 1.4292E+11
42.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 149.42 1.4292E+11
43.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 149.42 1.4292E+11
44.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 149.42 1.4292E+11
45.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 149.42 1.4292E+11
46.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 149.42 1.4292E+11
47.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 149.42 1.4292E+11
48.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 149.42 1.4292E+11
49.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 149.42 1.4292E+11
50.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 149.42 1.4292E+11

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-171

1.8.6 Summary Results File

=========================================================================

GROUP for Windows, Version 2016.10.8

Serial Number : 136089307

Analysis of A Group of Piles

Subjected to Axial and Lateral Loading

(c) Copyright ENSOFT, Inc., 1987-2015

All Rights Reserved

=========================================================================

-------------------------------------------------------------------------
Time and Date of Analysis
-------------------------------------------------------------------------

Date: May 09, 2016 Time: 18:14:13

***** COMPUTATION RESULTS *****

EXAMPLE PROBLEM 7 - 2D, 3x3 group, data for foundation stiffness

***** LOAD CASES RESULTS *****

LOAD CASE : 1
CASE NAME : Load Case 1
LOAD TYPE : Special, Sp

* PILE CAP FLEXIBILITY ESTIMATION *

DOF : 1 (FORCE X)

N S11 S21 S31

IN/LBS IN/LBS RAD/LBS
1 2.42885E-08 0.00000 0.00000
2 2.42646E-08 0.00000 0.00000
3 2.41665E-08 0.00000 0.00000
4 2.39587E-08 0.00000 0.00000
5 2.38487E-08 0.00000 0.00000
6 2.37792E-08 0.00000 0.00000
7 2.37306E-08 0.00000 0.00000

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-172

8 2.37057E-08 0.00000 0.00000

9 2.40526E-08 0.00000 0.00000
10 2.43328E-08 0.00000 0.00000

DOF : 2 (FORCE Y)

N S12 S22 S32

IN/LBS IN/LBS RAD/LBS
1 -2.55734E-11 7.23276E-09 -6.51215E-11
2 -4.22860E-11 2.38567E-08 -1.07679E-10
3 -5.17324E-11 3.97324E-08 -1.31671E-10
4 -5.81052E-11 5.13305E-08 -1.45509E-10
5 -6.24032E-11 6.05080E-08 -1.55059E-10
6 -6.55852E-11 6.81540E-08 -1.62214E-10
7 -6.81076E-11 7.47176E-08 -1.67933E-10
8 -7.02094E-11 8.02209E-08 -1.72729E-10
9 -7.19514E-11 8.52885E-08 -1.76716E-10
10 -7.34517E-11 8.99172E-08 -1.80161E-10

DOF : 3 (MOMENT Z)

N S13 S23 S33

IN/IN-LBS IN/IN-LBS RAD/IN-LBS
1 -1.43002E-12 -4.60758E-11 3.64148E-12
2 -1.49254E-12 -6.08794E-11 3.80522E-12
3 -1.54969E-12 -7.17452E-11 3.87262E-12
4 -1.57387E-12 -7.61410E-11 3.90088E-12
5 -1.58733E-12 -7.81788E-11 3.91744E-12
6 -1.59627E-12 -7.96531E-11 3.92894E-12
7 -1.60302E-12 -8.11890E-11 3.93820E-12
8 -1.60816E-12 -8.22967E-11 3.94534E-12
9 -1.61268E-12 -8.42390E-11 3.95212E-12
10 -1.61641E-12 -8.56152E-11 3.95781E-12

* ANALYSIS DUE TO TOTAL LOAD *

* TABLE L * COMPUTATION ON PILE CAP

* EQUIVALENT CONCENTRATED LOAD AT ORIGIN *

VERT. LOAD, LBS HORI. LOAD, LBS MOMENT,LBS-IN

1.00000E+06 4.00000E+05 2.00000E+07

* DISPLACEMENT OF GROUPED PILE FOUNDATION AT ORIGIN *

VERTICAL,IN HORIZONTAL,IN ROTATION,RAD

0.0243328 0.0307706 1.65077E-05

* TABLE M * COMPUTATION ON INDIVIDUAL PILE

THE GLOBAL STRUCTURAL COORDINATE SYSTEM

---------------------------------------

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS *

PILE GROUP DISP. X,IN DISP. Y,IN ROT. Z,RAD

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-173

********** *********** *********** ***********

1 0.025819 0.030771 1.6508E-05
2 0.024333 0.030771 1.6508E-05
3 0.022847 0.030771 1.6508E-05

MINIMUM 0.022847 0.030771 1.6508E-05

Pile G. 3 1 1
MAXIMUM 0.025819 0.030771 1.6508E-05
Pile G. 1 1 1

* PILE TOP REACTIONS *

PILE GROUP FOR. X,LBS FOR. Y,LBS MOM Z,LBS-IN STRESS,LBS/IN**2

********** *********** *********** ************ ****************
1 1.1658E+05 4.4443E+04 1.8940E+06 880.51
2 1.1111E+05 4.4444E+04 1.8940E+06 872.78
3 1.0564E+05 4.4446E+04 1.8940E+06 865.04

MINIMUM 1.0564E+05 4.4443E+04 1.8940E+06 865.04

Pile G. 3 1 1 3
MAXIMUM 1.1658E+05 4.4446E+04 1.8940E+06 880.51
Pile G. 1 3 3 1

THE PILE COORDINATE SYSTEM (LOCAL AXES)

---------------------------------------

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS *

PILE GROUP DISP. x,IN DISP. y,IN ROT. z,RAD

********** *********** *********** ***********
1 0.025819 0.030771 1.6508E-05
2 0.024333 0.030771 1.6508E-05
3 0.022847 0.030771 1.6508E-05

MINIMUM 0.022847 0.030771 1.6508E-05

Pile G. 3 1 1
MAXIMUM 0.025819 0.030771 1.6508E-05
Pile G. 1 1 1

* PILE TOP REACTIONS *

PILE GROUP AXIAL,LBS LAT. y,LBS MOM z,LBS-IN STRESS,LBS/IN**2

********** *********** *********** ************ ****************
1 1.1658E+05 4.4443E+04 1.8940E+06 880.51
2 1.1111E+05 4.4444E+04 1.8940E+06 872.78
3 1.0564E+05 4.4446E+04 1.8940E+06 865.04

MINIMUM 1.0564E+05 4.4443E+04 1.8940E+06 865.04

Pile G. 3 1 1 3
MAXIMUM 1.1658E+05 4.4446E+04 1.8940E+06 880.51
Pile G. 1 3 3 1

* EFFECTS FOR LATERALLY LOADED PILE *

* MINIMUM VALUES AND LOCATIONS *

PILE DISPL. BENDING SHEAR SOIL TOTAL FLEXURAL

y-DIR MOMENT FORCE REACTION STRESS RIGIDITY
IN LBS-IN LBS LBS/IN LBS-IN**2 LBS-IN**2
****** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
1 -1.8486E-04 -1.8940E+06 -1.0462E+04 -209.57 164.90 1.4292E+11
x(FT) 15.000 0.0000 13.000 15.000 27.000 0.0000
2 -1.8485E-04 -1.8940E+06 -1.0461E+04 -209.56 157.16 1.4292E+11
x(FT) 15.000 0.0000 13.000 15.000 27.000 0.0000
3 -1.8485E-04 -1.8940E+06 -1.0461E+04 -209.56 149.42 1.4292E+11

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-174

x(FT) 15.000 0.0000 13.000 15.000 27.000 0.0000

Min. -1.8486E-04 -1.8940E+06 -1.0462E+04 -209.57 149.42 1.4292E+11

Pile N. 1 1 1 1 3 1

* MAXIMUM VALUES AND LOCATIONS *

PILE DISPL. BENDING SHEAR SOIL TOTAL FLEXURAL

y-DIR MOMENT FORCE REACTION STRESS RIGIDITY
IN LBS-IN LBS LBS/IN LBS-IN**2 LBS-IN**2
****** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
1 0.030771 5.7754E+05 4.2288E+04 420.67 880.51 1.4292E+11
x(FT) 0.0000 9.0000 0.0000 5.0000 0.0000 0.0000
2 0.030771 5.7753E+05 4.2289E+04 420.67 872.78 1.4292E+11
x(FT) 0.0000 9.0000 0.0000 5.0000 0.0000 0.0000
3 0.030771 5.7752E+05 4.2290E+04 420.67 865.04 1.4292E+11
x(FT) 0.0000 9.0000 0.0000 5.0000 0.0000 0.0000

Max. 0.030771 5.7754E+05 4.2290E+04 420.67 880.51 1.4292E+11

Pile N. 1 1 3 1 1 1

***** SUMMARY FOR LOAD CASES AND COMBINATIONS *****

***** LOAD CASES RESULTS *****

LOAD CASE : 1

* EQUIVALENT CONCENTRATED LOAD AT ORIGIN *

LOAD X,LBS LOAD Y,LBS MOM Z,LBS-IN
1.00000E+06 4.00000E+05 2.00000E+07

* DISPLACEMENT OF GROUPED PILE FOUNDATION AT ORIGIN *

DISP X,IN DISP Y,IN ROT Z,RAD
0.0243328 0.0307706 1.65077E-05

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS, GLOBAL *

DISP. X,IN DISP. Y,IN ROT. Z,RAD
*********** *********** ***********
MINIMUM 0.022847 0.030771 1.6508E-05
Pile G. 3 1 1
MAXIMUM 0.025819 0.030771 1.6508E-05
Pile G. 1 1 1

* PILE TOP REACTIONS, GLOBAL *

FOR. X,LBS FOR. Y,LBS MOM Z,LBS-IN STRESS,LBS/IN**2
*********** *********** ************ ****************
MINIMUM 1.0564E+05 4.4443E+04 1.8940E+06 865.04
Pile G. 3 1 1 3
MAXIMUM 1.1658E+05 4.4446E+04 1.8940E+06 880.51
Pile G. 1 3 3 1

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS, LOCAL *

DISP. x,IN DISP. y,IN ROT. z,RAD
*********** *********** ***********
MINIMUM 0.022847 0.030771 1.6508E-05
Pile G. 3 1 1
MAXIMUM 0.025819 0.030771 1.6508E-05
Pile G. 1 1 1

* PILE TOP REACTIONS, LOCAL *

AXIAL,LBS LAT. y,LBS MOM z,LBS-IN STRESS,LBS/IN**2
*********** *********** ************ ****************

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-175

MINIMUM 1.0564E+05 4.4443E+04 1.8940E+06 865.04

Pile G. 3 1 1 3
MAXIMUM 1.1658E+05 4.4446E+04 1.8940E+06 880.51
Pile G. 1 3 3 1

* EFFECTS FOR LATERALLY LOADED PILE *

PILE DISPL. BENDING SHEAR SOIL TOTAL FLEXURAL

y-DIR MOMENT FORCE REACTION STRESS RIGIDITY
IN LBS-IN LBS LBS/IN LBS-IN**2 LBS-IN**2
****** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
Min. -1.8486E-04 -1.8940E+06 -1.0462E+04 -209.57 149.42 1.4292E+11
Pile N. 1 1 1 1 3 1
Max. 0.030771 5.7754E+05 4.2290E+04 420.67 880.51 1.4292E+11
Pile N. 1 1 3 1 1 1

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-176

1.8.7 Graphs

Figure 1.26 Curves Deflection vs. Distance for Example Problem 7 - 2D.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-177

Figure 1.27 Curves Moment vs. Distance for Example Problem 7 - 2D.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-178

Figure 1.28 Curve of Pile-Cap Load vs. Vertical Displacement for Example Problem 7 - 2D.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-179

Figure 1.29 Curve of Pile-Cap Load vs. Lateral Deflection for Example Problem 7 - 2D.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-180

Figure 1.30 Curve of Pile-Cap Load vs. Rotation for Example Problem 7 - 2D.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-181

Figure 1.31 Curve of Pile-Cap Moment vs. Lateral Deflection for Example Problem 7 - 2D.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-182

Figure 1.32 Curve of Pile-Cap Moment vs. Rotation for Example Problem 7 - 2D.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-183

1.9 Example Problem 8 - 2D

1.9.1 Model Description

For an embedded pile cap, the lateral soil resistance on the pile cap may be considered in the
analysis, as discussed in Chapter 8 of the Technical Manual. This example is included to illustrate the
use of the program to compute the resistance of the embedded pile cap. Figure 1.33 shows a 3 by 2 pile
group with the pile cap, which is 1 foot below the existing ground surface. The user must specify the
dimensions of the pile cap when soil resistance is considered.

The pile cap for this example is 16 feet by 10 feet by 2 feet, as shown in Figure 1.33. The piles
are 24 inches in diameter and 37 feet in length. The piles are closely spaced with the center to center
spacing equal to 3 pile diameters. The subsurface consists of a layer of stiff clay underlain by soft clay
and medium dense sand. The group reduction factors on closely spaced piles are generated internally
by the program.

It should be noted that the origin of coordinates (0,0) is set at the top of the pile cap (1 foot
below the ground surface), therefore, the top of the ground surface has the coordinate of -12 inches.
The vertical coordinate at the pile head is 24 inches below the origin (downward is positive).

Also, this example shows the use of the program to compute the foundation stiffness matrix of
the pile foundation, which may be needed for the superstructure analysis

The input and output files for the example problem are shown in the following pages.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-184

Figure 1.33 General Description of Example Problem 8 - 2D.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-185

1.9.2 Input Data

EXAMPLE PROBLEM 8 - 3D, EMBEDDED PILE CAP

GROUP2016.10.8
* Analysis Parameters
1 2 1 0 0 0 0 1 1 0 1 0 0 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 1
* Pile Cap Dimensions
16 10 2 0 0 0
* Load Cases
1 0 0 1 0
0 7 1 1 1 50 50
0.0001 0.0001 1 1
Load Case 1
12 10 1 0 1 0 0 0
2 2 1 0 0.0001 1E-5 0 0 0
1
0 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 0 1 1 0 1 1 0 0 1 1 1 0 0 1 1
1
340000 92000 -49600000 0 0 0 0 0 0
0
10
0.1
0.30102999
0.47712125
0.60205999
0.69897
0.77815125
0.84509804
0.90308998
0.9542425
1
* Load Combinations
0 0 0 1 0
* Distributed Load Sets
0
* Pile Group Configuration
3
2 2 1 0 0 0 1
0 6 1 1 1
2 -6 0 -3
2 2 1 0 0 0 1
0 6 1 1 1
2 0 0 -3
2 2 1 0 0 0 1
0 6 1 1 1
2 6 0 -3
* Pile Properties
1
0 1
100 37 1
0 37 1
* Pile Cross Sections
1
0 0 0 0
Section 1
24 0 1 1 0 0 0.1 0.1
1 452 16286 16286 0 0 0 0 3100000 0 0
0 0 0 0 1
None
* Soil Layers
4
0 2
-1 10
2 10
60.48 2995.2 0 2000 0 0.005 0 1641.6 0 0
60.48 2995.2 0 2000 0 0.005 0 1641.6 0 0
1 1

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-186

10 30
2 10
60.48 748.8 0 300 0 0.02 0 432 0 0
60.48 748.8 0 300 0 0.02 0 432 0 0
2 4
30 35
2 10
60.48 0 38 120 0 0 0 1296 0 0
60.48 0 38 120 0 0 0 1512 0 0
3 3
35 50
2 10
69.12 7920 0 3000 0 0.003 0 2880 0 0
69.12 7920 0 3000 0 0.003 0 2880 0 0
* Print py curves
2
1 6
0
1 12
0
* Generated LD curves
1
1
* User defined MC curves
1
1 1
0
1 1
0 0
* Internally Generated MC curves
1
1 1
0
0
1 1
0 0
* End of file

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-187

1.9.3 Echo Print File

=========================================================================

GROUP for Windows, Version 2016.10.8

Serial Number : 136089307

Analysis of A Group of Piles

Subjected to Axial and Lateral Loading

(c) Copyright ENSOFT, Inc., 1987-2015

All Rights Reserved

=========================================================================

This program is licensed to :

ENSOFT, INC
AUSTIN, TX

Path to file locations : C:\projects\GROUP2016\Group2016_1008\DXE\Examples_2016\

Name of input data file : 2Dexample8.gp10r
Name of output echo file : 2Dexample8.gp10e
Name of output results file : 2Dexample8.gp10o
Name of output summary file : 2Dexample8.gp10t
Name of plot output file : 2Dexample8.gp10p
Name of runtime file : 2Dexample8.gp10r

-------------------------------------------------------------------------
Time and Date of Analysis
-------------------------------------------------------------------------

Date: May 09, 2016 Time: 18:14:13

***** INPUT INFORMATION *****

EXAMPLE PROBLEM 8 - 3D, EMBEDDED PILE CAP

ANALYSIS TYPE = 2D ANALYSIS

ADJUST DEPTH FOR BATTER PILES

GENERATE LOAD-DISP (AND T-R) CURVES BASED ON SOIL PROFILE

EXTEND INTERPOLATION FOR L-DP (AND T-R) CURVES

UNITS SYSTEM = ENGL

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-188

* TABLE B * PILE CAP OPTIONS

LENGTH,YY ( FT ) = 16.00
WIDTH, ZZ ( FT ) = 10.00
THICKNESS,XX ( FT ) = 2.000

* PILE CAP IS EMBEDDED AND PASSIVE EARTH

RESISTANCE IN FRONT OF PILE CAP WILL BE CONSIDERED

* TABLE C * LOAD AND CONTROL PARAMETERS

** LOAD CASES **

NUMBER OF LOAD CASES : 1

LOAD CASE : 1
CASE NAME : Load Case 1
LOAD TYPE : Special, Sp
SCALE FACTOR : 1.0000

* CONCENTRATED LOADS *

NL VERT.LOAD HOR.LOAD MOMENT COORD X COORD Y

LBS LBS LBS-IN FT FT
1 3.40000E+05 92000.0 -4.96000E+07 0.00000 0.00000

* EQUIVALENT CONCENTRATED LOAD AT ORIGIN *

VER.LOAD X,LBS HOR.LOAD Y,LBS MOMENT,LBS-IN

3.40000E+05 92000.0 -4.96000E+07

* DATA FOR FOUNDATION STIFFNESS *

COMPUTED FOR EQUIVALENT CONCENTRATED LOAD AT ORIGIN

* FOUNDATION STIFFNESS LOAD LEVELS *

NL LOAD LEVEL
1 0.1000000
2 0.30103
3 0.47712
4 0.60206
5 0.69897
6 0.77815
7 0.84510
8 0.90309
9 0.95424
10 1.00000

* THE LOADING IS STATIC *

* CONTROL PARAMETERS *
TOLERANCE ON CONVERGENCE OF PILE CAP MOVEMENT = 1.00000E-04

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-189

TOLERANCE ON DETERMINATION OF PILE DEFLECTIONS = 1.00000E-04 IN

MAX NO OF ITERATIONS ALLOWED FOR FOUNDATION ANALYSIS = 50
MAXIMUM NO OF ITERATIONS ALLOWED FOR PILE ANALYSIS = 50
FACTOR TO APPLY THE LOAD IN INCREMENTS = 1.0000
MINIMUM FACTOR FOR LOAD INCREMENTS = 1.0000
PRINT RESULTS AT PILE CAP, PILE HEADS AND ALONG PILES
PRINT RESULTS EVERY 2 NODE(S)

* TABLE D * ARRANGEMENT OF PILE GROUPS

GROUP CONNECT NO OF PILE PILE PROP P-Y CURVE L-S CURVE R-F-L SET
1 FIX 2 1 0 1 G 0
2 FIX 2 1 0 1 G 0
3 FIX 2 1 0 1 G 0

GROUP VERT,FT HOR,FT SLOPE,IN/IN GROUND,FT SPRING,LBS-IN SPACING,FT

1 2.00000 -6.00000 0.00000 -3.00000 0.00000 6.00000
2 2.00000 0.00000 0.00000 -3.00000 0.00000 6.00000
3 2.00000 6.00000 0.00000 -3.00000 0.00000 6.00000

* TABLE E * PILE GEOMETRY AND PROPERTIES

PILE TYPE = 1 - DRIVEN PILE
= 2 - DRILLED SHAFT

PROP SECTS INC PILE TYPE LENGTH, FT

1 1 100 1 37.000

* PILE SECTIONS *

PROP SECT FROM,FT TO,FT CROSS SECT

1 1 0.00000 37.0000 1

* PILE CROSS SECTIONS *

CROSS SECTION : 1
SECTION NAME : Section

TYPE : ELASTIC
CROSS SECTION TYPE : GENERAL SECTION
EQUIVALENT DIAMETER : 24.0000 IN
YOUNG MODULUS : 3.10000E+06 LBS/IN**2

* PILE CROSS SECTIONS PROPERTIES *

ELASTIC SECTIONS

SECT DIAM,IN AREA,IN**2 I,IN**4 Mn,LBS-IN Vn,LBS

1 24.0000 452.000 16286.0 0.00000 0.00000

* TABLE F * SOIL DATA

SOILS INFORMATION

GROUND SURFACE = -1.00000 FT

4 LAYER(S) OF SOIL

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-190

LAYER 1
THE SOIL IS A STIFF CLAY WITH FREE WATER
TOP OF LAYER BOTTOM OF LAYER
X COORDINATE (FT) -1.00000 10.0000
EFFECTIVE UNIT WEIGHT (LBS/FT**3) 60.4800 60.4800
UNDRAINED COHESION, C (LBS/FT**2) 2995.20 2995.20
P-Y SUBGRADE MODULUS (LBS/IN**3) 2000.00 2000.00
STRAIN AT 50% STRESS 5.00000E-03 5.00000E-03
ULTIMATE UNIT SIDE FRICTION (LBS/FT**2) 1641.60 1641.60
ULTIMATE UNIT TIP RESISTANCE (LBS/FT**2) 0.00000 0.00000

LAYER 2
THE SOIL IS A SOFT CLAY
TOP OF LAYER BOTTOM OF LAYER
X COORDINATE (FT) 10.0000 30.0000
EFFECTIVE UNIT WEIGHT (LBS/FT**3) 60.4800 60.4800
UNDRAINED COHESION, C (LBS/FT**2) 748.800 748.800
STRAIN AT 50% STRESS 0.0200000 0.0200000
ULTIMATE UNIT SIDE FRICTION (LBS/FT**2) 432.000 432.000
ULTIMATE UNIT TIP RESISTANCE (LBS/FT**2) 0.00000 0.00000

LAYER 3
THE SOIL IS A SAND
TOP OF LAYER BOTTOM OF LAYER
X COORDINATE (FT) 30.0000 35.0000
EFFECTIVE UNIT WEIGHT (LBS/FT**3) 60.4800 60.4800
FRICTION ANGLE (DEGREES) 38.0000 38.0000
P-Y SUBGRADE MODULUS (LBS/IN**3) 120.000 120.000
ULTIMATE UNIT SIDE FRICTION (LBS/FT**2) 1296.00 1512.00
ULTIMATE UNIT TIP RESISTANCE (LBS/FT**2) 0.00000 0.00000

LAYER 4
THE SOIL IS A STIFF CLAY WITHOUT FREE WATER
TOP OF LAYER BOTTOM OF LAYER
X COORDINATE (FT) 35.0000 50.0000
EFFECTIVE UNIT WEIGHT (LBS/FT**3) 69.1200 69.1200
UNDRAINED COHESION, C (LBS/FT**2) 7920.00 7920.00
STRAIN AT 50% STRESS 3.00000E-03 3.00000E-03
ULTIMATE UNIT SIDE FRICTION (LBS/FT**2) 2880.00 2880.00
ULTIMATE UNIT TIP RESISTANCE (LBS/FT**2) 71280.0 (R) 71280.0 (R)

Notes : Program estimated values for listed parameters

if zero input values were entered:
(R) ULTIMATE UNIT TIP RESISTANCE for Driven Piles

* DATA TO PRINT GENERATED P-Y CURVES *

NUMBER OF CURVES TO PRINT : 2

CURVE NUMBER PILE GROUP DEPTH (FT)

1 1 6.00000
2 1 12.0000

* TABLE H * AXIAL LOAD VS DISPLACEMENT

AXIAL LOAD-DISPLACEMENT CURVES GENERATED INTERNALLY

NUM OF CURVES 1

CURVE 1 NUM OF POINTS 19

DISPLACEMENT, IN AXIAL LOAD,LBS

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-191

-2.04155 -2.37080E+05
-1.04097 -2.34852E+05
-0.54067 -2.33737E+05
-0.13899 -2.29683E+05
-0.0848794 -2.17901E+05
-0.0180924 -56899.4
-9.01367E-03 -27763.9
-1.80273E-03 -5552.78
-1.80273E-04 -555.278
0.00000 0.00000
2.20670E-04 740.239
2.20670E-03 7402.39
0.0110338 37045.2
0.0221733 76261.7
0.10279 2.74665E+05
0.16799 3.19188E+05
0.60663 4.42189E+05
1.11177 4.58618E+05
2.11236 4.60847E+05

* TABLE J * MOMENT CURVATURE SETS

USER DEFINED MOMENT CURVATURE

NUM OF SETS : 1

CURVE SET 1 NUM OF CURVES 1

CURVE 1 AXIAL LOAD 0.000E+00 LBS

POINT MOMENT CURVATURE

LBS-IN RADIAN/IN
1 0.00000 0.00000

* TABLE K * REDUCTION FACTORS

PILE DIAMETER = 24.000 IN

REDUCTION FACTORS FOR CLOSELY-SPACED PILE GROUPS

GROUP NO P-FACTOR Y-FACTOR

1 0.5858 1.0000
2 0.5803 1.0000
3 0.8661 1.0000

* TABLE N * PRINTED P-Y CURVES

* GENERATED P-Y CURVES *

NUMBER OF CURVES : 2

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-192

CURVE NUMBER = 1

PILE GROUP NUMBER = 1

DEPTH BELOW ORIGIN = 6.00 FT

NUMBER OF POINTS ON CURVE = 17

P-Y CURVE COMPUTED USING STIFF CLAY WITH FREE WATER CRITERIA

DEPTH BELOW GS DIAM C CAVG GAMMA E50

FT IN LBS/FT**2 LBS/FT**2 LBS/FT**3
7.00 24.000 0.30E+04 0.30E+04 0.60E+02 0.5000E-02
AS = 0.59, AC = 0.30, EQ. DEPTH = 7.00 FT

Y,IN P,LBS/IN
0.00000 0.00000
0.0357000 877.234
0.0714000 1240.60
0.10710 1445.03
0.14280 1577.55
0.17850 1667.87
0.21420 1728.00
0.24990 1764.80
0.28560 1782.69
0.32130 1784.77
0.35700 1773.28
0.39270 1749.93
0.42840 1716.79
0.71400 1238.32
0.99960 759.841
1.28520 281.366
1.85640 281.366

CURVE NUMBER = 2

PILE GROUP NUMBER = 1

DEPTH BELOW ORIGIN = 12.00 FT

NUMBER OF POINTS ON CURVE = 17

P-Y CURVE COMPUTED USING SOFT CLAY CRITERIA

DEPTH BELOW GS DIAM C GAMMA E50

FT IN LBS/FT**2 LBS/FT**3
13.00 24.000 0.7488E+03 0.6048E+02 0.2000E-01
EQ. DEPTH = 8.86 FT

Y,IN P,LBS/IN
0.00000 0.00000
2.40000E-03 28.8525
0.0240000 62.1609
0.0720000 89.6515
0.19200 124.322
0.38400 156.636
0.57600 179.303
0.96000 212.587
1.44000 243.352
2.16000 278.568
2.88000 306.604
3.84000 337.461
4.80000 363.519

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-193

6.24000 396.742
7.68000 425.174
9.60000 458.005
11.5200 458.005

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-194

1.9.4 Processor Run Notes

GROUP for Windows, Version 2016.10.8

-------------------------------------------------------------------------
Time and Date of Analysis
-------------------------------------------------------------------------

Date: May 09, 2016 Time: 18:14:13

EXAMPLE PROBLEM 8 - 3D, EMBEDDED PILE CAP

READING * TITLE AND VERSION

READING * Analysis Parameters
READING * Pile Cap Dimensions
READING * Load Cases
READING * Load Combinations
READING * Distributed Load Sets
READING * Pile Group Configuration
READING * Pile Properties
READING * Pile Cross Sections
READING * Soil Layers
READING * Print py curves
READING * Generated LD curves
READING * User defined MC curves
READING * Internally Generated MC curves

COMPUTATION IS PROCEEDING......

LOAD CASE : 1
CASE NAME : Load Case 1
* PILE CAP FLEXIBILITY ESTIMATION *
DOF : 1 POINT : 1

GLOBAL ITERATIONS
STEP 1, TCUR 1.0000, DTCUR 1.0000
ITERATION 1
- ErrDsp 0.10000E+01, IncDsp 0.17613E-02, TotDsp 0.17613E-02
- ErrRot 0.00000E+00, IncRot 0.00000E+00, TotRot 0.00000E+00
ITERATION 2
- ErrDsp 0.42630E-01, IncDsp 0.72014E-04, TotDsp 0.16893E-02
- ErrRot 0.00000E+00, IncRot 0.00000E+00, TotRot 0.00000E+00
ITERATION 3
- ErrDsp 0.42800E-15, IncDsp 0.72300E-18, TotDsp 0.16893E-02
- ErrRot 0.00000E+00, IncRot 0.00000E+00, TotRot 0.00000E+00
DOF : 1 POINT : 2

GLOBAL ITERATIONS
STEP 1, TCUR 1.0000, DTCUR 1.0000
ITERATION 1
- ErrDsp 0.10000E+01, IncDsp 0.53020E-02, TotDsp 0.53020E-02
- ErrRot 0.00000E+00, IncRot 0.00000E+00, TotRot 0.00000E+00
ITERATION 2
- ErrDsp 0.43272E-01, IncDsp 0.21991E-03, TotDsp 0.50821E-02
- ErrRot 0.00000E+00, IncRot 0.00000E+00, TotRot 0.00000E+00
ITERATION 3
- ErrDsp 0.99477E-15, IncDsp 0.50555E-17, TotDsp 0.50821E-02
- ErrRot 0.00000E+00, IncRot 0.00000E+00, TotRot 0.00000E+00
DOF : 1 POINT : 3

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-195

GLOBAL ITERATIONS
STEP 1, TCUR 1.0000, DTCUR 1.0000
ITERATION 1
- ErrDsp 0.10000E+01, IncDsp 0.84035E-02, TotDsp 0.84035E-02
- ErrRot 0.00000E+00, IncRot 0.00000E+00, TotRot 0.00000E+00
ITERATION 2
- ErrDsp 0.43454E-01, IncDsp 0.34996E-03, TotDsp 0.80535E-02
- ErrRot 0.00000E+00, IncRot 0.00000E+00, TotRot 0.00000E+00
ITERATION 3
- ErrDsp 0.41252E-14, IncDsp 0.33222E-16, TotDsp 0.80535E-02
- ErrRot 0.00000E+00, IncRot 0.00000E+00, TotRot 0.00000E+00
DOF : 1 POINT : 4

GLOBAL ITERATIONS
STEP 1, TCUR 1.0000, DTCUR 1.0000
ITERATION 1
- ErrDsp 0.10000E+01, IncDsp 0.10604E-01, TotDsp 0.10604E-01
- ErrRot 0.00000E+00, IncRot 0.00000E+00, TotRot 0.00000E+00
ITERATION 2
- ErrDsp 0.43518E-01, IncDsp 0.44222E-03, TotDsp 0.10162E-01
- ErrRot 0.00000E+00, IncRot 0.00000E+00, TotRot 0.00000E+00
ITERATION 3
- ErrDsp 0.24165E-14, IncDsp 0.24555E-16, TotDsp 0.10162E-01
- ErrRot 0.00000E+00, IncRot 0.00000E+00, TotRot 0.00000E+00
DOF : 1 POINT : 5

GLOBAL ITERATIONS
STEP 1, TCUR 1.0000, DTCUR 1.0000
ITERATION 1
- ErrDsp 0.10000E+01, IncDsp 0.12311E-01, TotDsp 0.12311E-01
- ErrRot 0.00000E+00, IncRot 0.00000E+00, TotRot 0.00000E+00
ITERATION 2
- ErrDsp 0.46675E-01, IncDsp 0.54899E-03, TotDsp 0.11762E-01
- ErrRot 0.00000E+00, IncRot 0.00000E+00, TotRot 0.00000E+00
ITERATION 3
- ErrDsp 0.58572E-15, IncDsp 0.68891E-17, TotDsp 0.11762E-01
- ErrRot 0.00000E+00, IncRot 0.00000E+00, TotRot 0.00000E+00
DOF : 1 POINT : 6

GLOBAL ITERATIONS
STEP 1, TCUR 1.0000, DTCUR 1.0000
ITERATION 1
- ErrDsp 0.10000E+01, IncDsp 0.13705E-01, TotDsp 0.13705E-01
- ErrRot 0.00000E+00, IncRot 0.00000E+00, TotRot 0.00000E+00
ITERATION 2
- ErrDsp 0.51324E-01, IncDsp 0.66907E-03, TotDsp 0.13036E-01
- ErrRot 0.00000E+00, IncRot 0.00000E+00, TotRot 0.00000E+00
ITERATION 3
- ErrDsp 0.65528E-14, IncDsp 0.85425E-16, TotDsp 0.13036E-01
- ErrRot 0.00000E+00, IncRot 0.00000E+00, TotRot 0.00000E+00
DOF : 1 POINT : 7

GLOBAL ITERATIONS
STEP 1, TCUR 1.0000, DTCUR 1.0000
ITERATION 1
- ErrDsp 0.10000E+01, IncDsp 0.14885E-01, TotDsp 0.14885E-01
- ErrRot 0.00000E+00, IncRot 0.00000E+00, TotRot 0.00000E+00
ITERATION 2
- ErrDsp 0.54599E-01, IncDsp 0.77061E-03, TotDsp 0.14114E-01
- ErrRot 0.00000E+00, IncRot 0.00000E+00, TotRot 0.00000E+00
ITERATION 3
- ErrDsp 0.78097E-15, IncDsp 0.11023E-16, TotDsp 0.14114E-01
- ErrRot 0.00000E+00, IncRot 0.00000E+00, TotRot 0.00000E+00
DOF : 1 POINT : 8

GLOBAL ITERATIONS
STEP 1, TCUR 1.0000, DTCUR 1.0000
ITERATION 1
- ErrDsp 0.10000E+01, IncDsp 0.15906E-01, TotDsp 0.15906E-01

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-196

- ErrRot 0.00000E+00, IncRot 0.00000E+00, TotRot 0.00000E+00

ITERATION 2
- ErrDsp 0.57057E-01, IncDsp 0.85856E-03, TotDsp 0.15047E-01
- ErrRot 0.00000E+00, IncRot 0.00000E+00, TotRot 0.00000E+00
ITERATION 3
- ErrDsp 0.73253E-15, IncDsp 0.11023E-16, TotDsp 0.15047E-01
- ErrRot 0.00000E+00, IncRot 0.00000E+00, TotRot 0.00000E+00
DOF : 1 POINT : 9

GLOBAL ITERATIONS
STEP 1, TCUR 1.0000, DTCUR 1.0000
ITERATION 1
- ErrDsp 0.10000E+01, IncDsp 0.16807E-01, TotDsp 0.16807E-01
- ErrRot 0.00000E+00, IncRot 0.00000E+00, TotRot 0.00000E+00
ITERATION 2
- ErrDsp 0.58985E-01, IncDsp 0.93614E-03, TotDsp 0.15871E-01
- ErrRot 0.00000E+00, IncRot 0.00000E+00, TotRot 0.00000E+00
ITERATION 3
- ErrDsp 0.86815E-15, IncDsp 0.13778E-16, TotDsp 0.15871E-01
- ErrRot 0.00000E+00, IncRot 0.00000E+00, TotRot 0.00000E+00
DOF : 1 POINT : 10

GLOBAL ITERATIONS
STEP 1, TCUR 1.0000, DTCUR 1.0000
ITERATION 1
- ErrDsp 0.10000E+01, IncDsp 0.17613E-01, TotDsp 0.17613E-01
- ErrRot 0.00000E+00, IncRot 0.00000E+00, TotRot 0.00000E+00
ITERATION 2
- ErrDsp 0.60548E-01, IncDsp 0.10055E-02, TotDsp 0.16607E-01
- ErrRot 0.00000E+00, IncRot 0.00000E+00, TotRot 0.00000E+00
ITERATION 3
- ErrDsp 0.66372E-15, IncDsp 0.11023E-16, TotDsp 0.16607E-01
- ErrRot 0.00000E+00, IncRot 0.00000E+00, TotRot 0.00000E+00
DOF : 2 POINT : 1

GLOBAL ITERATIONS
STEP 1, TCUR 1.0000, DTCUR 1.0000
ITERATION 1
- ErrDsp 0.10000E+01, IncDsp 0.76738E-03, TotDsp 0.76738E-03
- ErrRot 0.10000E+01, IncRot 0.56812E-05, TotRot 0.56812E-05
ITERATION 2
- ErrDsp 0.74043E-01, IncDsp 0.52988E-04, TotDsp 0.71563E-03
- ErrRot 0.54745E-01, IncRot 0.29488E-06, TotRot 0.53864E-05
ITERATION 3
- ErrDsp 0.54059E-02, IncDsp 0.38897E-05, TotDsp 0.71952E-03
- ErrRot 0.41238E-02, IncRot 0.22304E-07, TotRot 0.54087E-05
ITERATION 4
- ErrDsp 0.40325E-03, IncDsp 0.29003E-06, TotDsp 0.71923E-03
- ErrRot 0.30730E-03, IncRot 0.16616E-08, TotRot 0.54070E-05
ITERATION 5
- ErrDsp 0.30120E-04, IncDsp 0.21664E-07, TotDsp 0.71925E-
03
- ErrRot 0.22953E-04, IncRot 0.12411E-09, TotRot
0.54071E-05
DOF : 2 POINT : 2

GLOBAL ITERATIONS
STEP 1, TCUR 1.0000, DTCUR 1.0000
ITERATION 1
- ErrDsp 0.10000E+01, IncDsp 0.23100E-02, TotDsp 0.23100E-02
- ErrRot 0.10000E+01, IncRot 0.17102E-04, TotRot 0.17102E-04
ITERATION 2
- ErrDsp 0.71588E-01, IncDsp 0.15458E-03, TotDsp 0.21593E-02
- ErrRot 0.53585E-01, IncRot 0.86982E-06, TotRot 0.16232E-04
ITERATION 3
- ErrDsp 0.52259E-02, IncDsp 0.11344E-04, TotDsp 0.21707E-02
- ErrRot 0.39846E-02, IncRot 0.64938E-07, TotRot 0.16297E-04
ITERATION 4

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-197

- ErrDsp 0.39115E-03, IncDsp 0.84871E-06, TotDsp 0.21698E-02

- ErrRot 0.29796E-03, IncRot 0.48545E-08, TotRot 0.16293E-04
ITERATION 5
- ErrDsp 0.29319E-04, IncDsp 0.63618E-07, TotDsp 0.21699E-
02
- ErrRot 0.22332E-04, IncRot 0.36386E-09, TotRot
0.16293E-04
DOF : 2 POINT : 3

GLOBAL ITERATIONS
STEP 1, TCUR 1.0000, DTCUR 1.0000
ITERATION 1
- ErrDsp 0.10000E+01, IncDsp 0.36613E-02, TotDsp 0.36613E-02
- ErrRot 0.10000E+01, IncRot 0.27106E-04, TotRot 0.27106E-04
ITERATION 2
- ErrDsp 0.71756E-01, IncDsp 0.24554E-03, TotDsp 0.34219E-02
- ErrRot 0.53584E-01, IncRot 0.13786E-05, TotRot 0.25728E-04
ITERATION 3
- ErrDsp 0.52429E-02, IncDsp 0.18035E-04, TotDsp 0.34399E-02
- ErrRot 0.39963E-02, IncRot 0.10323E-06, TotRot 0.25831E-04
ITERATION 4
- ErrDsp 0.39242E-03, IncDsp 0.13494E-05, TotDsp 0.34386E-02
- ErrRot 0.29892E-03, IncRot 0.77190E-08, TotRot 0.25823E-04
ITERATION 5
- ErrDsp 0.29410E-04, IncDsp 0.10113E-06, TotDsp 0.34387E-
02
- ErrRot 0.22402E-04, IncRot 0.57851E-09, TotRot
0.25824E-04
DOF : 2 POINT : 4

GLOBAL ITERATIONS
STEP 1, TCUR 1.0000, DTCUR 1.0000
ITERATION 1
- ErrDsp 0.10000E+01, IncDsp 0.46201E-02, TotDsp 0.46201E-02
- ErrRot 0.10000E+01, IncRot 0.34205E-04, TotRot 0.34205E-04
ITERATION 2
- ErrDsp 0.71131E-01, IncDsp 0.30732E-03, TotDsp 0.43205E-02
- ErrRot 0.53339E-01, IncRot 0.17320E-05, TotRot 0.32472E-04
ITERATION 3
- ErrDsp 0.51951E-02, IncDsp 0.22563E-04, TotDsp 0.43431E-02
- ErrRot 0.39581E-02, IncRot 0.12904E-06, TotRot 0.32602E-04
ITERATION 4
- ErrDsp 0.38935E-03, IncDsp 0.16903E-05, TotDsp 0.43414E-02
- ErrRot 0.29637E-03, IncRot 0.96591E-08, TotRot 0.32592E-04
ITERATION 5
- ErrDsp 0.29205E-04, IncDsp 0.12679E-06, TotDsp 0.43415E-
02
- ErrRot 0.22235E-04, IncRot 0.72470E-09, TotRot
0.32593E-04
DOF : 2 POINT : 5

GLOBAL ITERATIONS
STEP 1, TCUR 1.0000, DTCUR 1.0000
ITERATION 1
- ErrDsp 0.10000E+01, IncDsp 0.53637E-02, TotDsp 0.53637E-02
- ErrRot 0.10000E+01, IncRot 0.39710E-04, TotRot 0.39710E-04
ITERATION 2
- ErrDsp 0.64868E-01, IncDsp 0.32735E-03, TotDsp 0.50463E-02
- ErrRot 0.49863E-01, IncRot 0.18860E-05, TotRot 0.37824E-04
ITERATION 3
- ErrDsp 0.52114E-02, IncDsp 0.26436E-04, TotDsp 0.50727E-02
- ErrRot 0.31485E-02, IncRot 0.11947E-06, TotRot 0.37944E-04
ITERATION 4
- ErrDsp 0.46859E-03, IncDsp 0.23759E-05, TotDsp 0.50704E-02

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-198

- ErrRot 0.33664E-03, IncRot 0.12769E-07, TotRot 0.37931E-04

ITERATION 5
- ErrDsp 0.41302E-04, IncDsp 0.20942E-06, TotDsp 0.50706E-
02
- ErrRot 0.29643E-04, IncRot 0.11244E-08, TotRot
0.37932E-04
DOF : 2 POINT : 6

GLOBAL ITERATIONS
STEP 1, TCUR 1.0000, DTCUR 1.0000
ITERATION 1
- ErrDsp 0.10000E+01, IncDsp 0.59714E-02, TotDsp 0.59714E-02
- ErrRot 0.10000E+01, IncRot 0.44209E-04, TotRot 0.44209E-04
ITERATION 2
- ErrDsp 0.38484E-01, IncDsp 0.22198E-03, TotDsp 0.57680E-02
- ErrRot 0.37474E-01, IncRot 0.15968E-05, TotRot 0.42612E-04
ITERATION 3
- ErrDsp 0.15924E-02, IncDsp 0.91996E-05, TotDsp 0.57771E-02
- ErrRot 0.10727E-02, IncRot 0.45760E-07, TotRot 0.42658E-04
ITERATION 4
- ErrDsp 0.72700E-04, IncDsp 0.41997E-06, TotDsp 0.57767E-02
- ErrRot 0.50066E-04, IncRot 0.21356E-08, TotRot 0.42655E-04
DOF : 2 POINT : 7

GLOBAL ITERATIONS
STEP 1, TCUR 1.0000, DTCUR 1.0000
ITERATION 1
- ErrDsp 0.10000E+01, IncDsp 0.64851E-02, TotDsp 0.64851E-02
- ErrRot 0.10000E+01, IncRot 0.48012E-04, TotRot 0.48012E-04
ITERATION 2
- ErrDsp 0.18462E-01, IncDsp 0.11846E-03, TotDsp 0.64165E-02
- ErrRot 0.27219E-01, IncRot 0.12722E-05, TotRot 0.46740E-04
ITERATION 3
- ErrDsp 0.39208E-03, IncDsp 0.25166E-05, TotDsp 0.64186E-02
- ErrRot 0.23108E-03, IncRot 0.10803E-07, TotRot 0.46751E-04
ITERATION 4
- ErrDsp 0.14947E-04, IncDsp 0.95937E-07, TotDsp 0.64185E-02
- ErrRot 0.10090E-04, IncRot 0.47172E-09, TotRot 0.46750E-04
DOF : 2 POINT : 8

GLOBAL ITERATIONS
STEP 1, TCUR 1.0000, DTCUR 1.0000
ITERATION 1
- ErrDsp 0.10000E+01, IncDsp 0.69301E-02, TotDsp 0.69301E-02
- ErrRot 0.10000E+01, IncRot 0.51307E-04, TotRot 0.51307E-04
ITERATION 2
- ErrDsp 0.18162E-01, IncDsp 0.12722E-03, TotDsp 0.70048E-02
- ErrRot 0.18695E-01, IncRot 0.94159E-06, TotRot 0.50365E-04
ITERATION 3
- ErrDsp 0.70272E-03, IncDsp 0.49191E-05, TotDsp 0.70001E-02
- ErrRot 0.45161E-03, IncRot 0.22735E-07, TotRot 0.50342E-04
ITERATION 4
- ErrDsp 0.30978E-04, IncDsp 0.21686E-06, TotDsp 0.70003E-02
- ErrRot 0.20667E-04, IncRot 0.10404E-08, TotRot 0.50343E-04
DOF : 2 POINT : 9

GLOBAL ITERATIONS
STEP 1, TCUR 1.0000, DTCUR 1.0000
ITERATION 1
- ErrDsp 0.10000E+01, IncDsp 0.73226E-02, TotDsp 0.73226E-02
- ErrRot 0.10000E+01, IncRot 0.54213E-04, TotRot 0.54213E-04
ITERATION 2
- ErrDsp 0.32228E-01, IncDsp 0.24300E-03, TotDsp 0.75400E-02
- ErrRot 0.11560E-01, IncRot 0.61954E-06, TotRot 0.53593E-04
ITERATION 3
- ErrDsp 0.99830E-03, IncDsp 0.75198E-05, TotDsp 0.75327E-02
- ErrRot 0.93466E-03, IncRot 0.50045E-07, TotRot 0.53543E-04
ITERATION 4

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-199

- ErrDsp 0.43106E-04, IncDsp 0.32472E-06, TotDsp 0.75330E-02

- ErrRot 0.28190E-04, IncRot 0.15094E-08, TotRot 0.53545E-04
DOF : 2 POINT : 10

GLOBAL ITERATIONS
STEP 1, TCUR 1.0000, DTCUR 1.0000
ITERATION 1
- ErrDsp 0.10000E+01, IncDsp 0.76738E-02, TotDsp 0.76738E-02
- ErrRot 0.10000E+01, IncRot 0.56812E-04, TotRot 0.56812E-04
ITERATION 2
- ErrDsp 0.47278E-01, IncDsp 0.37994E-03, TotDsp 0.80363E-02
- ErrRot 0.54108E-02, IncRot 0.30575E-06, TotRot 0.56507E-04
ITERATION 3
- ErrDsp 0.18830E-02, IncDsp 0.15104E-04, TotDsp 0.80213E-02
- ErrRot 0.14244E-02, IncRot 0.80372E-07, TotRot 0.56426E-04
ITERATION 4
- ErrDsp 0.85334E-04, IncDsp 0.68455E-06, TotDsp 0.80220E-02
- ErrRot 0.55490E-04, IncRot 0.31313E-08, TotRot 0.56429E-04
DOF : 3 POINT : 1

GLOBAL ITERATIONS
STEP 1, TCUR 1.0000, DTCUR 1.0000
ITERATION 1
- ErrDsp 0.10000E+01, IncDsp 0.30629E-02, TotDsp 0.30629E-02
- ErrRot 0.10000E+01, IncRot 0.66855E-04, TotRot 0.66855E-04
ITERATION 2
- ErrDsp 0.60574E-01, IncDsp 0.17875E-03, TotDsp 0.29509E-02
- ErrRot 0.76066E-02, IncRot 0.50470E-06, TotRot 0.66350E-04
ITERATION 3
- ErrDsp 0.31255E-02, IncDsp 0.92517E-05, TotDsp 0.29600E-02
- ErrRot 0.78980E-03, IncRot 0.52445E-07, TotRot 0.66403E-04
ITERATION 4
- ErrDsp 0.22683E-03, IncDsp 0.67128E-06, TotDsp 0.29593E-02
- ErrRot 0.58191E-04, IncRot 0.38638E-08, TotRot 0.66399E-04
ITERATION 5
- ErrDsp 0.16941E-04, IncDsp 0.50134E-07, TotDsp 0.29594E-
02
- ErrRot 0.43317E-05, IncRot 0.28762E-09, TotRot
0.66399E-04
DOF : 3 POINT : 2

GLOBAL ITERATIONS
STEP 1, TCUR 1.0000, DTCUR 1.0000
ITERATION 1
- ErrDsp 0.10000E+01, IncDsp 0.92203E-02, TotDsp 0.92203E-02
- ErrRot 0.10000E+01, IncRot 0.20125E-03, TotRot 0.20125E-03
ITERATION 2
- ErrDsp 0.66258E-01, IncDsp 0.58229E-03, TotDsp 0.87882E-02
- ErrRot 0.19150E-01, IncRot 0.37816E-05, TotRot 0.19747E-03
ITERATION 3
- ErrDsp 0.28360E-02, IncDsp 0.24994E-04, TotDsp 0.88128E-02
- ErrRot 0.69142E-03, IncRot 0.13663E-06, TotRot 0.19761E-03
ITERATION 4
- ErrDsp 0.20719E-03, IncDsp 0.18256E-05, TotDsp 0.88110E-02
- ErrRot 0.51778E-04, IncRot 0.10231E-07, TotRot 0.19760E-03
ITERATION 5
- ErrDsp 0.15488E-04, IncDsp 0.13647E-06, TotDsp 0.88111E-
02
- ErrRot 0.38715E-05, IncRot 0.76501E-09, TotRot
0.19760E-03
DOF : 3 POINT : 3

GLOBAL ITERATIONS
STEP 1, TCUR 1.0000, DTCUR 1.0000
ITERATION 1
- ErrDsp 0.10000E+01, IncDsp 0.14614E-01, TotDsp 0.14614E-01

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-200

- ErrRot 0.10000E+01, IncRot 0.31898E-03, TotRot 0.31898E-03

ITERATION 2
- ErrDsp 0.81696E-01, IncDsp 0.11885E-02, TotDsp 0.14547E-01
- ErrRot 0.32844E-02, IncRot 0.10511E-05, TotRot 0.32003E-03
ITERATION 3
- ErrDsp 0.31259E-02, IncDsp 0.45607E-04, TotDsp 0.14590E-01
- ErrRot 0.22428E-02, IncRot 0.71938E-06, TotRot 0.32075E-03
ITERATION 4
- ErrDsp 0.14294E-03, IncDsp 0.20851E-05, TotDsp 0.14588E-01
- ErrRot 0.16319E-04, IncRot 0.52341E-08, TotRot 0.32074E-03
ITERATION 5
- ErrDsp 0.49975E-05, IncDsp 0.72903E-07, TotDsp 0.14588E-
01
- ErrRot 0.14597E-05, IncRot 0.46821E-09, TotRot
0.32075E-03
DOF : 3 POINT : 4

GLOBAL ITERATIONS
STEP 1, TCUR 1.0000, DTCUR 1.0000
ITERATION 1
- ErrDsp 0.10000E+01, IncDsp 0.18441E-01, TotDsp 0.18441E-01
- ErrRot 0.10000E+01, IncRot 0.40251E-03, TotRot 0.40251E-03
ITERATION 2
- ErrDsp 0.91686E-01, IncDsp 0.18167E-02, TotDsp 0.19815E-01
- ErrRot 0.60968E-01, IncRot 0.26133E-04, TotRot 0.42864E-03
ITERATION 3
- ErrDsp 0.12347E-02, IncDsp 0.24452E-04, TotDsp 0.19804E-01
- ErrRot 0.29796E-03, IncRot 0.12768E-06, TotRot 0.42851E-03
ITERATION 4
- ErrDsp 0.18290E-04, IncDsp 0.36222E-06, TotDsp 0.19804E-01
- ErrRot 0.52207E-05, IncRot 0.22372E-08, TotRot 0.42852E-03
DOF : 3 POINT : 5

GLOBAL ITERATIONS
STEP 1, TCUR 1.0000, DTCUR 1.0000
ITERATION 1
- ErrDsp 0.10000E+01, IncDsp 0.21409E-01, TotDsp 0.21409E-01
- ErrRot 0.10000E+01, IncRot 0.46730E-03, TotRot 0.46730E-03
ITERATION 2
- ErrDsp 0.11945E+00, IncDsp 0.28687E-02, TotDsp 0.24015E-01
- ErrRot 0.89673E-01, IncRot 0.46032E-04, TotRot 0.51333E-03
ITERATION 3
- ErrDsp 0.20928E-02, IncDsp 0.50167E-04, TotDsp 0.23971E-01
- ErrRot 0.56675E-03, IncRot 0.29077E-06, TotRot 0.51304E-03
ITERATION 4
- ErrDsp 0.60584E-04, IncDsp 0.14524E-05, TotDsp 0.23973E-01
- ErrRot 0.16939E-04, IncRot 0.86904E-08, TotRot 0.51305E-03
DOF : 3 POINT : 6

GLOBAL ITERATIONS
STEP 1, TCUR 1.0000, DTCUR 1.0000
ITERATION 1
- ErrDsp 0.10000E+01, IncDsp 0.23834E-01, TotDsp 0.23834E-01
- ErrRot 0.10000E+01, IncRot 0.52023E-03, TotRot 0.52023E-03
ITERATION 2
- ErrDsp 0.13882E+00, IncDsp 0.38102E-02, TotDsp 0.27446E-01
- ErrRot 0.10716E+00, IncRot 0.62442E-04, TotRot 0.58268E-03
ITERATION 3
- ErrDsp 0.81540E-03, IncDsp 0.22382E-04, TotDsp 0.27449E-01
- ErrRot 0.45511E-03, IncRot 0.26506E-06, TotRot 0.58241E-03
ITERATION 4
- ErrDsp 0.10499E-04, IncDsp 0.28820E-06, TotDsp 0.27449E-01
- ErrRot 0.29878E-05, IncRot 0.17401E-08, TotRot 0.58241E-03
DOF : 3 POINT : 7

GLOBAL ITERATIONS
STEP 1, TCUR 1.0000, DTCUR 1.0000
ITERATION 1

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-201

- ErrDsp 0.10000E+01, IncDsp 0.25885E-01, TotDsp 0.25885E-01

- ErrRot 0.10000E+01, IncRot 0.56499E-03, TotRot 0.56499E-03
ITERATION 2
- ErrDsp 0.15202E+00, IncDsp 0.46108E-02, TotDsp 0.30330E-01
- ErrRot 0.11918E+00, IncRot 0.76449E-04, TotRot 0.64144E-03
ITERATION 3
- ErrDsp 0.28175E-02, IncDsp 0.85689E-04, TotDsp 0.30413E-01
- ErrRot 0.36538E-03, IncRot 0.23428E-06, TotRot 0.64121E-03
ITERATION 4
- ErrDsp 0.10005E-03, IncDsp 0.30427E-05, TotDsp 0.30410E-01
- ErrRot 0.27435E-04, IncRot 0.17591E-07, TotRot 0.64119E-03
ITERATION 5
- ErrDsp 0.28014E-05, IncDsp 0.85192E-07, TotDsp 0.30410E-
01
- ErrRot 0.90634E-06, IncRot 0.58114E-09, TotRot
0.64119E-03
DOF : 3 POINT : 8
GLOBAL ITERATIONS
STEP 1, TCUR 1.0000, DTCUR 1.0000
ITERATION 1
- ErrDsp 0.10000E+01, IncDsp 0.27661E-01, TotDsp 0.27661E-01
- ErrRot 0.10000E+01, IncRot 0.60376E-03, TotRot 0.60376E-03
ITERATION 2
- ErrDsp 0.16735E+00, IncDsp 0.55314E-02, TotDsp 0.33053E-01
- ErrRot 0.12832E+00, IncRot 0.88883E-04, TotRot 0.69264E-03
ITERATION 3
- ErrDsp 0.17317E-02, IncDsp 0.57149E-04, TotDsp 0.33002E-01
- ErrRot 0.64107E-03, IncRot 0.44375E-06, TotRot 0.69220E-03
ITERATION 4
- ErrDsp 0.44011E-04, IncDsp 0.14525E-05, TotDsp 0.33003E-01
- ErrRot 0.11662E-04, IncRot 0.80728E-08, TotRot 0.69221E-03
DOF : 3 POINT : 9

GLOBAL ITERATIONS
STEP 1, TCUR 1.0000, DTCUR 1.0000
ITERATION 1
- ErrDsp 0.10000E+01, IncDsp 0.29228E-01, TotDsp 0.29228E-01
- ErrRot 0.10000E+01, IncRot 0.63796E-03, TotRot 0.63796E-03
ITERATION 2
- ErrDsp 0.18030E+00, IncDsp 0.64023E-02, TotDsp 0.35508E-01
- ErrRot 0.13479E+00, IncRot 0.99389E-04, TotRot 0.73735E-03
ITERATION 3
- ErrDsp 0.58576E-02, IncDsp 0.20680E-03, TotDsp 0.35304E-01
- ErrRot 0.14262E-03, IncRot 0.10514E-06, TotRot 0.73724E-03
ITERATION 4
- ErrDsp 0.20028E-03, IncDsp 0.70722E-05, TotDsp 0.35311E-01
- ErrRot 0.55338E-04, IncRot 0.40800E-07, TotRot 0.73728E-03
ITERATION 5
- ErrDsp 0.58691E-05, IncDsp 0.20724E-06, TotDsp 0.35311E-
01
- ErrRot 0.15861E-05, IncRot 0.11694E-08, TotRot
0.73728E-03
DOF : 3 POINT : 10

GLOBAL ITERATIONS
STEP 1, TCUR 1.0000, DTCUR 1.0000
ITERATION 1
- ErrDsp 0.10000E+01, IncDsp 0.30629E-01, TotDsp 0.30629E-01
- ErrRot 0.10000E+01, IncRot 0.66855E-03, TotRot 0.66855E-03
ITERATION 2
- ErrDsp 0.18494E+00, IncDsp 0.69236E-02, TotDsp 0.37438E-01
- ErrRot 0.14040E+00, IncRot 0.10920E-03, TotRot 0.77775E-03
ITERATION 3
- ErrDsp 0.16626E-02, IncDsp 0.62152E-04, TotDsp 0.37382E-01
- ErrRot 0.17218E-03, IncRot 0.13389E-06, TotRot 0.77761E-03
ITERATION 4

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-202

- ErrDsp 0.45268E-04, IncDsp 0.16923E-05, TotDsp 0.37383E-01

- ErrRot 0.13244E-04, IncRot 0.10299E-07, TotRot 0.77763E-03
* PILE CAP STIFFNESS ESTIMATION *

ANALYSIS DUE TO TOTAL LOAD

GLOBAL ITERATIONS
STEP 1, TCUR 1.0000, DTCUR 1.0000
ITERATION 1
- ErrDsp 0.10000E+01, IncDsp 0.42159E-01, TotDsp 0.42159E-01
- ErrRot 0.10000E+01, IncRot 0.72536E-03, TotRot 0.72536E-03
ITERATION 2
- ErrDsp 0.22956E+00, IncDsp 0.12424E-01, TotDsp 0.54119E-01
- ErrRot 0.15930E+00, IncRot 0.13744E-03, TotRot 0.86281E-03
ITERATION 3
- ErrDsp 0.80207E-02, IncDsp 0.43736E-03, TotDsp 0.54529E-01
- ErrRot 0.26976E-03, IncRot 0.23269E-06, TotRot 0.86257E-03
ITERATION 4
- ErrDsp 0.11068E-03, IncDsp 0.60347E-05, TotDsp 0.54523E-01
- ErrRot 0.75289E-04, IncRot 0.64938E-07, TotRot 0.86251E-03
ITERATION 5
- ErrDsp 0.28388E-05, IncDsp 0.15478E-06, TotDsp0.54523E-01
- ErrRot 0.90067E-06, IncRot 0.77684E-09, TotRot
0.86251E-03

NUMBER OF GLOBAL ITERATIONS = 5

ANALYSIS FOR LOAD CASE 1/ 1 FINISHED

Execution Time : 792 ms

Number Processors : 1/ 1
Serial processing : 0.301 sec
Paral. processing : 0.466 sec
Print. processing : 0.025 sec

ANALYSIS COMPLETED
Execution Time : 799 ms
Number Processors : 1/ 1

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-203

1.9.5 Output Results File

=========================================================================

GROUP for Windows, Version 2016.10.8

Serial Number : 136089307

Analysis of A Group of Piles

Subjected to Axial and Lateral Loading

(c) Copyright ENSOFT, Inc., 1987-2015

All Rights Reserved

=========================================================================

This program is licensed to :

ENSOFT, INC
AUSTIN, TX

Path to file locations : C:\projects\GROUP2016\Group2016_1008\DXE\Examples_2016\

Name of input data file : 2Dexample8.gp10d
Name of output echo file : 2Dexample8.gp10e
Name of output results file : 2Dexample8.gp10o
Name of output summary file : 2Dexample8.gp10t
Name of plot output file : 2Dexample8.gp10p
Name of runtime file : 2Dexample8.gp10r

-------------------------------------------------------------------------
Time and Date of Analysis
-------------------------------------------------------------------------

Date: May 09, 2016 Time: 18:14:13

***** COMPUTATION RESULTS *****

EXAMPLE PROBLEM 8 - 3D, EMBEDDED PILE CAP

***** LOAD CASES RESULTS *****

LOAD CASE : 1
CASE NAME : Load Case 1
LOAD TYPE : Special, Sp

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-204

* PILE CAP FLEXIBILITY ESTIMATION *

DOF : 1 (FORCE X)

N FORCE, LB VERT. DISP,IN HOR. DISP Y,IN ROTATION Z,RAD

1 34000.0
1.68927E-03 0.00000 0.00000
2 1.02350E+05
5.08208E-03 0.00000 0.00000
3 1.62221E+05
8.05350E-03 0.00000 0.00000
4 2.04700E+05
0.0101618 0.00000 0.00000
5 2.37650E+05
0.0117618 0.00000 0.00000
6 2.64571E+05
0.0130364 0.00000 0.00000
7 2.87333E+05
0.0141140 0.00000 0.00000
8 3.07051E+05
0.0150474 0.00000 0.00000
9 3.24442E+05
0.0158708 0.00000 0.00000
10 3.40000E+05
0.0166073 0.00000 0.00000

N S11 S21 S31

IN/LBS IN/LBS RAD/LBS
1 4.96844E-08 0.00000 0.00000
2 4.96538E-08 0.00000 0.00000
3 4.96451E-08 0.00000 0.00000
4 4.96421E-08 0.00000 0.00000
5 4.94924E-08 0.00000 0.00000
6 4.92735E-08 0.00000 0.00000
7 4.91205E-08 0.00000 0.00000
8 4.90063E-08 0.00000 0.00000
9 4.89170E-08 0.00000 0.00000
10 4.88450E-08 0.00000 0.00000

DOF : 2 (FORCE Y)

N FORCE, LB VERT. DISP,IN HOR. DISP Y,IN ROTATION Z,RAD

1 9200.00
-1.12239E-05 7.19165E-04 -5.40714E-06
2 27694.8
-3.38200E-05 2.16961E-03 -1.62929E-05
3 43895.2
-5.36041E-05 3.43825E-03 -2.58239E-05
4 55389.5
-6.76819E-05 4.34099E-03 -3.25926E-05
5 64305.2
-7.89083E-05 5.06995E-03 -3.79320E-05
6 71589.9
-8.88397E-05 5.77603E-03 -4.26555E-05
7 77749.0
-9.74492E-05 6.41774E-03 -4.67502E-05
8 83084.3
-1.05004E-04 6.99952E-03 -5.03435E-05
9 87790.3
-1.11735E-04 7.53215E-03 -5.35448E-05
10 92000.0
-1.17800E-04 8.02115E-03 -5.64295E-05

N S12 S22 S32

IN/LBS IN/LBS RAD/LBS
1 -1.21999E-09 7.81702E-08 -5.87732E-10
2 -1.22117E-09 7.83401E-08 -5.88302E-10
3 -1.22118E-09 7.83288E-08 -5.88309E-10

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-205

4 -1.22193E-09 7.83721E-08 -5.88425E-10

5 -1.22709E-09 7.88420E-08 -5.89874E-10
6 -1.24095E-09 8.06822E-08 -5.95831E-10
7 -1.25338E-09 8.25444E-08 -6.01297E-10
8 -1.26383E-09 8.42460E-08 -6.05933E-10
9 -1.27275E-09 8.57970E-08 -6.09917E-10
10 -1.28044E-09 8.71864E-08 -6.13364E-10

DOF : 3 (MOMENT Z)

N MOMENT,LBS-IN VERT. DISP,IN HOR. DISP Y,IN ROTATION Z,RAD

1 -4.96000E+06
-1.38762E-04 2.95614E-03 -6.63992E-05
2 -1.49311E+07
-3.86598E-04 8.80264E-03 -1.97599E-04
3 -2.36652E+07
-1.17033E-03 0.0145409 -3.20745E-04
4 -2.98622E+07
-1.25268E-03 0.0197645 -4.28515E-04
5 -3.46689E+07
-1.29116E-03 0.0239378 -5.13046E-04
6 -3.85963E+07
-1.32273E-03 0.0274172 -5.82408E-04
7 -4.19169E+07
-1.34948E-03 0.0303802 -6.41189E-04
8 -4.47933E+07
-1.37270E-03 0.0329744 -6.92209E-04
9 -4.73304E+07
-1.39322E-03 0.0352833 -7.37283E-04
10 -4.96000E+07
-1.41158E-03 0.0373568 -7.77625E-04

N S13 S23 S33

IN/IN-LBS IN/IN-LBS RAD/IN-LBS
1 2.79763E-11 -5.95997E-10 1.33869E-11
2 2.58922E-11 -5.89551E-10 1.32341E-11
3 4.94536E-11 -6.14444E-10 1.35535E-11
4 4.19488E-11 -6.61856E-10 1.43498E-11
5 3.72425E-11 -6.90469E-10 1.47985E-11
6 3.42708E-11 -7.10357E-10 1.50897E-11
7 3.21942E-11 -7.24773E-10 1.52967E-11
8 3.06453E-11 -7.36147E-10 1.54534E-11
9 2.94359E-11 -7.45467E-10 1.55774E-11
10 2.84592E-11 -7.53161E-10 1.56779E-11

* PILE CAP STIFFNESS ESTIMATION *

UNITS
DOF 1 2 3
1 LBS/IN LBS/IN LBS/RAD
2 LBS/IN LBS/IN LBS/RAD
3 LBS LBS LBS-IN/RAD

N: 1 FACTOR : 0.1000
DOF 1 2 3
1 2.01271E+07 -3200.02 -4.22044E+07
2 0.00000 1.92293E+07 8.56105E+08
3 0.00000 8.44233E+08 1.12286E+11

N: 2 FACTOR : 0.3010
DOF 1 2 3
1 2.01394E+07 27108.4 -3.81947E+07
2 0.00000 1.91819E+07 8.54515E+08
3 0.00000 8.52704E+08 1.13549E+11

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-206

N: 3 FACTOR : 0.4771
DOF 1 2 3
1 2.01430E+07 -3.60852E+05 -8.98565E+07
2 0.00000 1.93581E+07 8.77598E+08
3 0.00000 8.40270E+08 1.11875E+11

N: 4 FACTOR : 0.6021
DOF 1 2 3
1 2.01442E+07 -1.95899E+05 -6.79232E+07
2 0.00000 1.95190E+07 9.00278E+08
3 0.00000 8.00394E+08 1.06604E+11

N: 5 FACTOR : 0.6990
DOF 1 2 3
1 2.02051E+07 -1.01347E+05 -5.55779E+07
2 0.00000 1.94857E+07 9.09169E+08
3 0.00000 7.76712E+08 1.03815E+11

N: 6 FACTOR : 0.7782
DOF 1 2 3
1 2.02949E+07 -43285.2 -4.81300E+07
2 0.00000 1.89994E+07 8.94406E+08
3 0.00000 7.50207E+08 1.01587E+11

N: 7 FACTOR : 0.8451
DOF 1 2 3
1 2.03581E+07 -4571.66 -4.30633E+07
2 0.00000 1.84999E+07 8.76546E+08
3 0.00000 7.27213E+08 9.98298E+10

N: 8 FACTOR : 0.9031
DOF 1 2 3
1 2.04056E+07 22924.9 -3.93736E+07
2 0.00000 1.80566E+07 8.60153E+08
3 0.00000 7.08003E+08 9.84375E+10

N: 9 FACTOR : 0.9542
DOF 1 2 3
1 2.04428E+07 43412.2 -3.65524E+07
2 0.00000 1.76650E+07 8.45375E+08
3 0.00000 6.91658E+08 9.72956E+10

N: 10 FACTOR : 1.0000
DOF 1 2 3
1 2.04729E+07 59246.2 -3.43172E+07
2 0.00000 1.73248E+07 8.32277E+08
3 0.00000 6.77795E+08 9.63449E+10

* ANALYSIS DUE TO TOTAL LOAD *

REDUCTION FACTORS FOR CLOSELY-SPACED PILE GROUPS

ESTIMATED USING MOVEMENT IN THE DIRECTION OF PILE CAP DISPLACEMENTS

GROUP NO P-FACTOR Y-FACTOR

1 0.5858 1.0000
2 0.5803 1.0000
3 0.8661 1.0000

* TABLE L * COMPUTATION ON PILE CAP

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-207

* EQUIVALENT CONCENTRATED LOAD AT ORIGIN *

VERT. LOAD, LBS HORI. LOAD, LBS MOMENT,LBS-IN

3.40000E+05 92000.0 -4.96000E+07

* DISPLACEMENT OF GROUPED PILE FOUNDATION AT ORIGIN *

VERTICAL,IN HORIZONTAL,IN ROTATION,RAD

0.0190974 0.0510693 -8.62509E-04

NUMBER OF ITERATIONS = 5

* PASSIVE RESISTANCE IN PILE CAP *

HORI. LOAD,LBS POSITION, FT EQ. DIAM, FT

13070.8 1.16667 10.0000

* TABLE M * COMPUTATION ON INDIVIDUAL PILE

* PILE GROUP * 1

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS AND REACTIONS *

THE GLOBAL STRUCTURAL COORDINATE SYSTEM

---------------------------------------

DISP.X,IN DISP.Y,IN SLOPE FOR.X, LB FOR.Y, LB BM, LB-IN STRESS, LB/IN**2

-0.043003 0.030369 -8.6251E-04 -1.1695E+05 1.0678E+04 -5.1943E+05 641.47

THE PILE COORDINATE SYSTEM (LOCAL AXES)

---------------------------------------

DISP.x,IN DISP.y,IN SLOPE AXIAL, LB LAT, LB BM, LB-IN STRESS,LBS/IN**2

-0.043003 0.030369 -8.6251E-04 -1.1695E+05 1.0678E+04 -5.1943E+05 641.47

* EFFECTS FOR LATERALLY LOADED PILE *

x DISPL. BENDING SHEAR SOIL TOTAL FLEXURAL

y-DIR MOMENT FORCE REACTION STRESS RIGIDITY
FT IN LBS-IN LBS LBS/IN LBS-IN**2 LBS-IN**2
********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
0.0000 3.0369E-02 5.1943E+05 9650.7 463.80 641.47 5.0487E+10
0.7400 2.3132E-02 5.9497E+05 6506.9 472.96 697.14 5.0487E+10
1.4800 1.6821E-02 6.3343E+05 2346.7 461.47 725.47 5.0487E+10
2.2200 1.1496E-02 6.3572E+05 -1620.9 429.59 727.16 5.0487E+10

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-208

2.9600 7.1598E-03 6.0435E+05 -5214.2 377.06 704.04 5.0487E+10

3.7000 3.7650E-03 5.4351E+05 -8193.2 285.21 659.22 5.0487E+10
4.4400 1.2170E-03 4.6035E+05 -1.0119E+04 127.29 597.94 5.0487E+10
5.1800 -6.1300E-04 3.6729E+05 -1.0353E+04 -70.496 529.37 5.0487E+10
5.9200 -1.8688E-03 2.7968E+05 -9058.2 -199.50 464.82 5.0487E+10
6.6600 -2.6862E-03 2.0747E+05 -7095.4 -239.36 411.61 5.0487E+10
7.4000 -3.1777E-03 1.5408E+05 -4869.3 -260.31 372.28 5.0487E+10
8.1400 -3.4266E-03 1.2120E+05 -3044.2 -29.071 348.04 5.0487E+10
8.8800 -3.4859E-03 9.5320E+04 -2779.5 -30.479 328.98 5.0487E+10
9.6200 -3.3961E-03 7.1861E+04 -2504.4 -31.434 311.69 5.0487E+10
10.360 -3.1938E-03 5.0892E+04 -2222.6 -31.981 296.24 5.0487E+10
11.100 -2.9118E-03 3.2451E+04 -1937.7 -32.145 282.65 5.0487E+10
11.840 -2.5789E-03 1.6550E+04 -1652.9 -31.944 270.94 5.0487E+10
12.580 -2.2198E-03 3169.1 -1371.5 -31.391 261.08 5.0487E+10
13.320 -1.8556E-03 -7737.7 -1096.6 -30.493 264.44 5.0487E+10
14.060 -1.5032E-03 -1.6243E+04 -831.07 -29.260 270.71 5.0487E+10
14.800 -1.1760E-03 -2.2446E+04 -578.01 -27.695 275.28 5.0487E+10
15.540 -8.8361E-04 -2.6470E+04 -340.30 -25.803 278.25 5.0487E+10
16.280 -6.3237E-04 -2.8466E+04 -120.84 -23.584 279.72 5.0487E+10
17.020 -4.2541E-04 -2.8610E+04 77.443 -21.031 279.82 5.0487E+10
17.760 -2.6297E-04 -2.7102E+04 251.48 -18.118 278.71 5.0487E+10
18.500 -1.4272E-04 -2.4172E+04 397.48 -14.637 276.55 5.0487E+10
19.240 -6.0118E-05 -2.0096E+04 508.61 -10.292 273.55 5.0487E+10
19.980 -8.8209E-06 -1.5221E+04 573.42 -3.6990 269.96 5.0487E+10
20.720 1.8731E-05 -1.0397E+04 479.12 11.238 266.40 5.0487E+10
21.460 2.9957E-05 -6574.0 383.14 10.581 263.59 5.0487E+10
22.200 3.0833E-05 -3585.1 291.05 10.110 261.38 5.0487E+10
22.940 2.6032E-05 -1392.1 204.91 9.2480 259.77 5.0487E+10
23.680 1.8986E-05 72.851 127.81 8.0853 258.80 5.0487E+10
24.420 1.1990E-05 901.31 62.022 6.7093 259.41 5.0487E+10
25.160 6.3516E-06 1201.6 9.1186 5.1920 259.63 5.0487E+10
25.900 2.5494E-06 1093.1 -29.861 3.5740 259.55 5.0487E+10
26.640 4.2702E-07 704.08 -53.285 1.5891 259.26 5.0487E+10
27.380 -6.0790E-07 316.99 -24.408 -2.6734 258.98 5.0487E+10
28.120 -1.1271E-06 208.67 -5.8786 -1.4478E-02 258.90 5.0487E+10
28.860 -1.3203E-06 157.06 -5.7334 -1.7783E-02 258.86 5.0487E+10
29.600 -1.2681E-06 106.86 -5.5735 -1.7871E-02 258.82 5.0487E+10
30.340 -1.0488E-06 58.079 -5.4244 -1.5435E-02 258.78 5.0487E+10
31.080 -7.3867E-07 10.518 -5.3049 -1.1332E-02 258.75 5.0487E+10
31.820 -4.1204E-07 -36.151 -5.2253 -6.5785E-03 258.77 5.0487E+10
32.560 -1.4181E-07 -82.306 -5.1863 -2.3527E-03 258.80 5.0487E+10
33.300 -1.2428E-10 -128.28 11.780 -7.6385 258.84 5.0487E+10
34.040 3.5779E-15 0.1837 7.7212E-02 5.3411E-02 258.74 5.0487E+10
34.780 -1.6700E-21 -8.2716E-08 -1.0505E-06 -4.8159E-07 258.74 5.0487E+10
35.520 7.7850E-28 3.7254E-14 4.9001E-13 2.2451E-13 258.74 5.0487E+10
36.260 -3.6250E-34 -1.6778E-20 -2.2830E-19 -1.0454E-19 258.74 5.0487E+10
37.000 3.3192E-40 8.5562E-43 -2.1662E-41 9.5720E-26 258.74 5.0487E+10

* PILE GROUP * 2

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS AND REACTIONS *

THE GLOBAL STRUCTURAL COORDINATE SYSTEM

---------------------------------------

DISP.X,IN DISP.Y,IN SLOPE FOR.X, LB FOR.Y, LB BM, LB-IN STRESS, LB/IN**2

0.019097 0.030369 -8.6251E-04 6.5433E+04 1.0459E+04 -5.1940E+05 527.48

THE PILE COORDINATE SYSTEM (LOCAL AXES)

---------------------------------------

DISP.x,IN DISP.y,IN SLOPE AXIAL, LB LAT, LB BM, LB-IN STRESS,LBS/IN**2

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-209

0.019097 0.030369 -8.6251E-04 6.5433E+04 1.0459E+04 -5.1940E+05 527.48

* EFFECTS FOR LATERALLY LOADED PILE *

x DISPL. BENDING SHEAR SOIL TOTAL FLEXURAL

y-DIR MOMENT FORCE REACTION STRESS RIGIDITY
FT IN LBS-IN LBS LBS/IN LBS-IN**2 LBS-IN**2
********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
0.0000 3.0369E-02 5.1940E+05 9437.8 459.46 527.48 5.0487E+10
0.7400 2.3132E-02 5.9450E+05 6327.5 468.54 582.81 5.0487E+10
1.4800 1.6820E-02 6.3269E+05 2206.2 457.14 610.95 5.0487E+10
2.2200 1.1493E-02 6.3487E+05 -1724.1 425.52 612.55 5.0487E+10
2.9600 7.1536E-03 6.0353E+05 -5282.9 373.38 589.46 5.0487E+10
3.7000 3.7542E-03 5.4285E+05 -8231.7 282.15 544.75 5.0487E+10
4.4400 1.2006E-03 4.5992E+05 -1.0133E+04 124.40 483.65 5.0487E+10
5.1800 -6.3566E-04 3.6718E+05 -1.0345E+04 -72.418 415.31 5.0487E+10
5.9200 -1.8979E-03 2.7994E+05 -9039.4 -199.17 351.03 5.0487E+10
6.6600 -2.7213E-03 2.0803E+05 -7081.5 -238.67 298.05 5.0487E+10
7.4000 -3.2180E-03 1.5483E+05 -4862.0 -259.51 258.85 5.0487E+10
8.1400 -3.4708E-03 1.2202E+05 -3042.7 -28.923 234.67 5.0487E+10
8.8800 -3.5329E-03 9.6162E+04 -2779.3 -30.329 215.62 5.0487E+10
9.6200 -3.4445E-03 7.2682E+04 -2505.5 -31.287 198.32 5.0487E+10
10.360 -3.2424E-03 5.1660E+04 -2225.0 -31.841 182.83 5.0487E+10
11.100 -2.9593E-03 3.3141E+04 -1941.3 -32.017 169.18 5.0487E+10
11.840 -2.6242E-03 1.7142E+04 -1657.6 -31.830 157.39 5.0487E+10
12.580 -2.2621E-03 3649.2 -1377.2 -31.293 147.45 5.0487E+10
13.320 -1.8941E-03 -7378.2 -1103.0 -30.414 150.20 5.0487E+10
14.060 -1.5373E-03 -1.6008E+04 -838.13 -29.200 156.56 5.0487E+10
14.800 -1.2054E-03 -2.2336E+04 -585.50 -27.656 161.22 5.0487E+10
15.540 -9.0806E-04 -2.6482E+04 -348.06 -25.783 164.28 5.0487E+10
16.280 -6.5192E-04 -2.8593E+04 -128.71 -23.579 165.83 5.0487E+10
17.020 -4.4026E-04 -2.8845E+04 69.576 -21.035 166.02 5.0487E+10
17.760 -2.7349E-04 -2.7436E+04 243.63 -18.117 164.98 5.0487E+10
18.500 -1.4944E-04 -2.4599E+04 389.50 -14.605 162.89 5.0487E+10
19.240 -6.3688E-05 -2.0611E+04 500.08 -10.193 159.95 5.0487E+10
19.980 -1.0053E-05 -1.5826E+04 563.88 -3.6271 156.42 5.0487E+10
20.720 1.8892E-05 -1.0887E+04 510.05 13.831 152.79 5.0487E+10
21.460 3.0726E-05 -6865.2 401.47 11.385 149.82 5.0487E+10
22.200 3.1749E-05 -3742.4 303.48 10.662 147.52 5.0487E+10
22.940 2.6846E-05 -1458.6 213.03 9.6729 145.84 5.0487E+10
23.680 1.9589E-05 64.026 132.58 8.4146 144.81 5.0487E+10
24.420 1.2368E-05 924.08 64.262 6.9518 145.44 5.0487E+10
25.160 6.5372E-06 1236.6 9.6078 5.3422 145.67 5.0487E+10
25.900 2.5963E-06 1128.3 -30.191 3.6016 145.59 5.0487E+10
26.640 3.8992E-07 737.57 -52.854 1.3553 145.31 5.0487E+10
27.380 -6.7491E-07 331.59 -28.110 -3.3691 145.01 5.0487E+10
28.120 -1.1959E-06 213.10 -6.0324 -1.5217E-02 144.92 5.0487E+10
28.860 -1.3839E-06 160.18 -5.8808 -1.8466E-02 144.88 5.0487E+10
29.600 -1.3216E-06 108.69 -5.7153 -1.8452E-02 144.84 5.0487E+10
30.340 -1.0894E-06 58.631 -5.5616 -1.5884E-02 144.81 5.0487E+10
31.080 -7.6556E-07 9.8101 -5.4388 -1.1635E-02 144.77 5.0487E+10
31.820 -4.2626E-07 -38.098 -5.3572 -6.7419E-03 144.79 5.0487E+10
32.560 -1.4641E-07 -85.468 -5.3172 -2.4062E-03 144.83 5.0487E+10
33.300 -3.1225E-11 -132.63 12.228 -7.8992 144.86 5.0487E+10
34.040 2.1534E-15 0.1977 5.3541E-02 4.4177E-02 144.76 5.0487E+10
34.780 -1.0327E-21 -8.9063E-08 -6.4111E-07 -2.9782E-07 144.76 5.0487E+10
35.520 4.9345E-28 4.0116E-14 3.0688E-13 1.4230E-13 144.76 5.0487E+10
36.260 -2.3500E-34 -1.8069E-20 -1.4638E-19 -6.7771E-20 144.76 5.0487E+10
37.000 2.1746E-40 1.7112E-42 -8.2446E-42 6.2710E-26 144.76 5.0487E+10

* PILE GROUP * 3

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS AND REACTIONS *

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-210

THE GLOBAL STRUCTURAL COORDINATE SYSTEM

---------------------------------------

DISP.X,IN DISP.Y,IN SLOPE FOR.X, LB FOR.Y, LB BM, LB-IN STRESS, LB/IN**2

0.081198 0.030369 -8.6251E-04 2.2152E+05 1.8328E+04 -4.3001E+05 806.93

THE PILE COORDINATE SYSTEM (LOCAL AXES)

---------------------------------------

DISP.x,IN DISP.y,IN SLOPE AXIAL, LB LAT, LB BM, LB-IN STRESS,LBS/IN**2

0.081198 0.030369 -8.6251E-04 2.2152E+05 1.8328E+04 -4.3001E+05 806.93

* EFFECTS FOR LATERALLY LOADED PILE *

x DISPL. BENDING SHEAR SOIL TOTAL FLEXURAL

y-DIR MOMENT FORCE REACTION STRESS RIGIDITY
FT IN LBS-IN LBS LBS/IN LBS-IN**2 LBS-IN**2
********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
0.0000 3.0369E-02 4.3001E+05 1.6801E+04 685.72 806.93 5.0487E+10
0.7400 2.3075E-02 5.6714E+05 1.2164E+04 698.41 907.97 5.0487E+10
1.4800 1.6662E-02 6.4915E+05 6030.7 679.03 968.40 5.0487E+10
2.2200 1.1257E-02 6.7755E+05 208.26 628.51 989.32 5.0487E+10
2.9600 6.9058E-03 6.5631E+05 -5030.0 547.46 973.67 5.0487E+10
3.7000 3.5753E-03 5.9190E+05 -9339.0 410.85 926.21 5.0487E+10
4.4400 1.1661E-03 4.9495E+05 -1.2104E+04 180.33 854.78 5.0487E+10
5.1800 -4.7149E-04 3.8344E+05 -1.2515E+04 -80.166 772.61 5.0487E+10
5.9200 -1.5096E-03 2.7781E+05 -1.0917E+04 -264.97 694.78 5.0487E+10
6.6600 -2.1117E-03 1.9202E+05 -8327.3 -313.57 631.57 5.0487E+10
7.4000 -2.4115E-03 1.3076E+05 -5437.1 -334.96 586.43 5.0487E+10
8.1400 -2.5045E-03 9.5795E+04 -3100.2 -38.653 560.67 5.0487E+10
8.8800 -2.4476E-03 6.9792E+04 -2750.7 -39.964 541.51 5.0487E+10
9.6200 -2.2814E-03 4.6912E+04 -2392.7 -40.586 524.65 5.0487E+10
10.360 -2.0416E-03 2.7214E+04 -2032.0 -40.579 510.14 5.0487E+10
11.100 -1.7590E-03 1.0702E+04 -1674.0 -39.980 497.97 5.0487E+10
11.840 -1.4593E-03 -2662.7 -1323.8 -38.816 492.05 5.0487E+10
12.580 -1.1635E-03 -1.2969E+04 -986.44 -37.104 499.64 5.0487E+10
13.320 -8.8772E-04 -2.0347E+04 -666.62 -34.861 505.08 5.0487E+10
14.060 -6.4341E-04 -2.4973E+04 -369.05 -32.094 508.49 5.0487E+10
14.800 -4.3787E-04 -2.7061E+04 -98.359 -28.807 510.02 5.0487E+10
15.540 -2.7437E-04 -2.6871E+04 140.78 -24.985 509.88 5.0487E+10
16.280 -1.5264E-04 -2.4705E+04 343.39 -20.565 508.29 5.0487E+10
17.020 -6.9342E-05 -2.0912E+04 503.32 -15.327 505.49 5.0487E+10
17.760 -1.8588E-05 -1.5912E+04 609.84 -8.2877 501.81 5.0487E+10
18.500 7.3788E-06 -1.0292E+04 588.16 22.777 497.67 5.0487E+10
19.240 1.7095E-05 -5884.5 421.06 15.559 494.42 5.0487E+10
19.980 1.7501E-05 -2736.1 292.76 13.438 492.10 5.0487E+10
20.720 1.3530E-05 -645.97 182.31 11.405 490.56 5.0487E+10
21.460 8.4618E-06 546.48 91.133 9.0977 490.49 5.0487E+10
22.200 4.1775E-06 1022.4 21.404 6.5887 490.84 5.0487E+10
22.940 1.4392E-06 978.80 -25.580 3.9885 490.81 5.0487E+10
23.680 1.9894E-07 620.45 -49.326 1.3463 490.54 5.0487E+10
24.420 -8.2618E-08 161.04 -36.473 -6.6203 490.20 5.0487E+10
25.160 -6.1702E-08 9.5069 -9.1051 -1.4622 490.09 5.0487E+10
25.900 -1.4682E-08 -23.180 -0.2229 -0.5755 490.10 5.0487E+10
26.640 5.6451E-10 -9.2208 1.8368 0.1140 490.09 5.0487E+10
27.380 5.3118E-10 -9.4551E-03 0.2760 9.6862E-02 490.08 5.0487E+10
28.120 -2.6252E-10 0.2349 -5.9405E-03 -4.9854E-06 490.08 5.0487E+10
28.860 -6.8927E-10 0.1826 -5.8544E-03 -1.3726E-05 490.08 5.0487E+10
29.600 -8.3079E-10 0.1312 -5.7139E-03 -1.7311E-05 490.08 5.0487E+10
30.340 -7.6727E-10 8.1123E-02 -5.5609E-03 -1.6695E-05 490.08 5.0487E+10

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-211

31.080 -5.7692E-10 3.2328E-02 -5.4274E-03 -1.3086E-05 490.08 5.0487E+10

31.820 -3.3598E-10 -1.5453E-02 -5.3337E-03 -7.9308E-06 490.08 5.0487E+10
32.560 -1.1911E-10 -6.2604E-02 -5.2861E-03 -2.9216E-06 490.08 5.0487E+10
33.300 -2.3379E-17 -0.1095 9.6927E-03 -6.7422E-03 490.08 5.0487E+10
34.040 4.5235E-23 4.9324E-08 1.7851E-08 1.3045E-08 490.08 5.0487E+10
34.780 -3.6011E-29 -2.2219E-14 -1.8050E-14 -1.0385E-14 490.08 5.0487E+10
35.520 2.3264E-35 1.0009E-20 1.2640E-20 6.7090E-21 490.08 5.0487E+10
36.260 -1.3652E-41 -4.5087E-27 -7.7249E-27 -3.9371E-27 490.08 5.0487E+10
37.000 1.3729E-47 0.0000 -1.5465E-48 3.9593E-33 490.08 5.0487E+10

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-212

1.9.6 Summary Results File

=========================================================================

GROUP for Windows, Version 2016.10.8

Serial Number : 136089307

Analysis of A Group of Piles

Subjected to Axial and Lateral Loading

(c) Copyright ENSOFT, Inc., 1987-2015

All Rights Reserved

=========================================================================

-------------------------------------------------------------------------
Time and Date of Analysis
-------------------------------------------------------------------------

Date: May 09, 2016 Time: 18:14:13

***** COMPUTATION RESULTS *****

EXAMPLE PROBLEM 8 - 3D, EMBEDDED PILE CAP

***** LOAD CASES RESULTS *****

LOAD CASE : 1
CASE NAME : Load Case 1
LOAD TYPE : Special, Sp

* PILE CAP FLEXIBILITY ESTIMATION *

DOF : 1 (FORCE X)

N S11 S21 S31

IN/LBS IN/LBS RAD/LBS
1 4.96844E-08 0.00000 0.00000
2 4.96538E-08 0.00000 0.00000
3 4.96451E-08 0.00000 0.00000
4 4.96421E-08 0.00000 0.00000
5 4.94924E-08 0.00000 0.00000
6 4.92735E-08 0.00000 0.00000
7 4.91205E-08 0.00000 0.00000
8 4.90063E-08 0.00000 0.00000

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-213

9 4.89170E-08 0.00000 0.00000

10 4.88450E-08 0.00000 0.00000

DOF : 2 (FORCE Y)

N S12 S22 S32

IN/LBS IN/LBS RAD/LBS
1 -1.21999E-09 7.81702E-08 -5.87732E-10
2 -1.22117E-09 7.83401E-08 -5.88302E-10
3 -1.22118E-09 7.83288E-08 -5.88309E-10
4 -1.22193E-09 7.83721E-08 -5.88425E-10
5 -1.22709E-09 7.88420E-08 -5.89874E-10
6 -1.24095E-09 8.06822E-08 -5.95831E-10
7 -1.25338E-09 8.25444E-08 -6.01297E-10
8 -1.26383E-09 8.42460E-08 -6.05933E-10
9 -1.27275E-09 8.57970E-08 -6.09917E-10
10 -1.28044E-09 8.71864E-08 -6.13364E-10

DOF : 3 (MOMENT Z)

N S13 S23 S33

IN/IN-LBS IN/IN-LBS RAD/IN-LBS
1 2.79763E-11 -5.95997E-10 1.33869E-11
2 2.58922E-11 -5.89551E-10 1.32341E-11
3 4.94536E-11 -6.14444E-10 1.35535E-11
4 4.19488E-11 -6.61856E-10 1.43498E-11
5 3.72425E-11 -6.90469E-10 1.47985E-11
6 3.42708E-11 -7.10357E-10 1.50897E-11
7 3.21942E-11 -7.24773E-10 1.52967E-11
8 3.06453E-11 -7.36147E-10 1.54534E-11
9 2.94359E-11 -7.45467E-10 1.55774E-11
10 2.84592E-11 -7.53161E-10 1.56779E-11

* PILE CAP STIFFNESS ESTIMATION *

UNITS
DOF 1 2 3
1 LBS/IN LBS/IN LBS/RAD
2 LBS/IN LBS/IN LBS/RAD
3 LBS LBS LBS-IN/RAD

N: 1 FACTOR : 0.1000
DOF 1 2 3
1 2.01271E+07 -3200.02 -4.22044E+07
2 0.00000 1.92293E+07 8.56105E+08
3 0.00000 8.44233E+08 1.12286E+11

N: 2 FACTOR : 0.3010
DOF 1 2 3
1 2.01394E+07 27108.4 -3.81947E+07
2 0.00000 1.91819E+07 8.54515E+08
3 0.00000 8.52704E+08 1.13549E+11

N: 3 FACTOR : 0.4771
DOF 1 2 3
1 2.01430E+07 -3.60852E+05 -8.98565E+07
2 0.00000 1.93581E+07 8.77598E+08
3 0.00000 8.40270E+08 1.11875E+11

N: 4 FACTOR : 0.6021
DOF 1 2 3
1 2.01442E+07 -1.95899E+05 -6.79232E+07
2 0.00000 1.95190E+07 9.00278E+08
3 0.00000 8.00394E+08 1.06604E+11

N: 5 FACTOR : 0.6990

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-214

DOF 1 2 3
1 2.02051E+07 -1.01347E+05 -5.55779E+07
2 0.00000 1.94857E+07 9.09169E+08
3 0.00000 7.76712E+08 1.03815E+11

N: 6 FACTOR : 0.7782
DOF 1 2 3
1 2.02949E+07 -43285.2 -4.81300E+07
2 0.00000 1.89994E+07 8.94406E+08
3 0.00000 7.50207E+08 1.01587E+11

N: 7 FACTOR : 0.8451
DOF 1 2 3
1 2.03581E+07 -4571.66 -4.30633E+07
2 0.00000 1.84999E+07 8.76546E+08
3 0.00000 7.27213E+08 9.98298E+10

N: 8 FACTOR : 0.9031
DOF 1 2 3
1 2.04056E+07 22924.9 -3.93736E+07
2 0.00000 1.80566E+07 8.60153E+08
3 0.00000 7.08003E+08 9.84375E+10

N: 9 FACTOR : 0.9542
DOF 1 2 3
1 2.04428E+07 43412.2 -3.65524E+07
2 0.00000 1.76650E+07 8.45375E+08
3 0.00000 6.91658E+08 9.72956E+10

N: 10 FACTOR : 1.0000
DOF 1 2 3
1 2.04729E+07 59246.2 -3.43172E+07
2 0.00000 1.73248E+07 8.32277E+08
3 0.00000 6.77795E+08 9.63449E+10

* ANALYSIS DUE TO TOTAL LOAD *

REDUCTION FACTORS FOR CLOSELY-SPACED PILE GROUPS

ESTIMATED USING MOVEMENT IN THE DIRECTION OF PILE CAP DISPLACEMENTS

GROUP NO P-FACTOR Y-FACTOR

1 0.5858 1.0000
2 0.5803 1.0000
3 0.8661 1.0000

* TABLE L * COMPUTATION ON PILE CAP

* EQUIVALENT CONCENTRATED LOAD AT ORIGIN *

VERT. LOAD, LBS HORI. LOAD, LBS MOMENT,LBS-IN

3.40000E+05 92000.0 -4.96000E+07

* DISPLACEMENT OF GROUPED PILE FOUNDATION AT ORIGIN *

VERTICAL,IN HORIZONTAL,IN ROTATION,RAD

0.0190974 0.0510693 -8.62509E-04

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-215

* PASSIVE RESISTANCE IN PILE CAP *

HORI. LOAD,LBS POSITION, FT EQ. DIAM, FT

13070.8 1.16667 10.0000

* TABLE M * COMPUTATION ON INDIVIDUAL PILE

THE GLOBAL STRUCTURAL COORDINATE SYSTEM

---------------------------------------

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS *

PILE GROUP DISP. X,IN DISP. Y,IN ROT. Z,RAD

********** *********** *********** ***********
1 -0.043003 0.030369 -8.6251E-04
2 0.019097 0.030369 -8.6251E-04
3 0.081198 0.030369 -8.6251E-04

MINIMUM -0.043003 0.030369 -8.6251E-04

Pile G. 1 1 1
MAXIMUM 0.081198 0.030369 -8.6251E-04
Pile G. 3 1 1

* PILE TOP REACTIONS *

PILE GROUP FOR. X,LBS FOR. Y,LBS MOM Z,LBS-IN STRESS,LBS/IN**2

********** *********** *********** ************ ****************
1 -1.1695E+05 1.0678E+04 -5.1943E+05 641.47
2 6.5433E+04 1.0459E+04 -5.1940E+05 527.48
3 2.2152E+05 1.8328E+04 -4.3001E+05 806.93

MINIMUM -1.1695E+05 1.0459E+04 -5.1943E+05 527.48

Pile G. 1 2 1 2
MAXIMUM 2.2152E+05 1.8328E+04 -4.3001E+05 806.93
Pile G. 3 3 3 3

THE PILE COORDINATE SYSTEM (LOCAL AXES)

---------------------------------------

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS *

PILE GROUP DISP. x,IN DISP. y,IN ROT. z,RAD

********** *********** *********** ***********
1 -0.043003 0.030369 -8.6251E-04
2 0.019097 0.030369 -8.6251E-04
3 0.081198 0.030369 -8.6251E-04

MINIMUM -0.043003 0.030369 -8.6251E-04

Pile G. 1 1 1
MAXIMUM 0.081198 0.030369 -8.6251E-04
Pile G. 3 1 1

* PILE TOP REACTIONS *

PILE GROUP AXIAL,LBS LAT. y,LBS MOM z,LBS-IN STRESS,LBS/IN**2

********** *********** *********** ************ ****************
1 -1.1695E+05 1.0678E+04 -5.1943E+05 641.47
2 6.5433E+04 1.0459E+04 -5.1940E+05 527.48
3 2.2152E+05 1.8328E+04 -4.3001E+05 806.93

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-216

MINIMUM -1.1695E+05 1.0459E+04 -5.1943E+05 527.48

Pile G. 1 2 1 2
MAXIMUM 2.2152E+05 1.8328E+04 -4.3001E+05 806.93
Pile G. 3 3 3 3

* EFFECTS FOR LATERALLY LOADED PILE *

* MINIMUM VALUES AND LOCATIONS *

PILE DISPL. BENDING SHEAR SOIL TOTAL FLEXURAL

y-DIR MOMENT FORCE REACTION STRESS RIGIDITY
IN LBS-IN LBS LBS/IN LBS-IN**2 LBS-IN**2
****** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
1 -3.4859E-03 -2.8758E+04 -1.0456E+04 -266.37 258.74 5.0487E+10
x(FT) 8.8800 16.650 4.8100 7.7700 35.150 0.0000
2 -3.5329E-03 -2.8940E+04 -1.0457E+04 -265.55 144.76 5.0487E+10
x(FT) 8.8800 16.650 4.8100 7.7700 35.150 0.0000
3 -2.5045E-03 -2.7233E+04 -1.2599E+04 -339.54 490.08 5.0487E+10
x(FT) 8.1400 15.170 4.8100 7.7700 34.410 0.0000

Min. -3.5329E-03 -2.8940E+04 -1.2599E+04 -339.54 144.76 5.0487E+10

Pile N. 2 2 3 3 2 1

* MAXIMUM VALUES AND LOCATIONS *

PILE DISPL. BENDING SHEAR SOIL TOTAL FLEXURAL

y-DIR MOMENT FORCE REACTION STRESS RIGIDITY
IN LBS-IN LBS LBS/IN LBS-IN**2 LBS-IN**2
****** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
1 0.030369 6.3898E+05 9650.7 472.96 729.56 5.0487E+10
x(FT) 0.0000 1.8500 0.0000 0.7400 1.8500 0.0000
2 0.030369 6.3816E+05 9437.8 468.54 614.98 5.0487E+10
x(FT) 0.0000 1.8500 0.0000 0.7400 1.8500 0.0000
3 0.030369 6.7755E+05 1.6801E+04 698.41 989.32 5.0487E+10
x(FT) 0.0000 2.2200 0.0000 0.7400 2.2200 0.0000

Max. 0.030369 6.7755E+05 1.6801E+04 698.41 989.32 5.0487E+10

Pile N. 1 3 3 3 3 1

***** SUMMARY FOR LOAD CASES AND COMBINATIONS *****

***** LOAD CASES RESULTS *****

LOAD CASE : 1

* EQUIVALENT CONCENTRATED LOAD AT ORIGIN *

LOAD X,LBS LOAD Y,LBS MOM Z,LBS-IN
3.40000E+05 92000.0 -4.96000E+07

* DISPLACEMENT OF GROUPED PILE FOUNDATION AT ORIGIN *

DISP X,IN DISP Y,IN ROT Z,RAD
0.0190974 0.0510693 -8.62509E-04

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS, GLOBAL *

DISP. X,IN DISP. Y,IN ROT. Z,RAD
*********** *********** ***********
MINIMUM -0.043003 0.030369 -8.6251E-04
Pile G. 1 1 1
MAXIMUM 0.081198 0.030369 -8.6251E-04
Pile G. 3 1 1

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-217

* PILE TOP REACTIONS, GLOBAL *

FOR. X,LBS FOR. Y,LBS MOM Z,LBS-IN STRESS,LBS/IN**2
*********** *********** ************ ****************
MINIMUM -1.1695E+05 1.0459E+04 -5.1943E+05 527.48
Pile G. 1 2 1 2
MAXIMUM 2.2152E+05 1.8328E+04 -4.3001E+05 806.93
Pile G. 3 3 3 3

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS, LOCAL *

DISP. x,IN DISP. y,IN ROT. z,RAD
*********** *********** ***********
MINIMUM -0.043003 0.030369 -8.6251E-04
Pile G. 1 1 1
MAXIMUM 0.081198 0.030369 -8.6251E-04
Pile G. 3 1 1

* PILE TOP REACTIONS, LOCAL *

AXIAL,LBS LAT. y,LBS MOM z,LBS-IN STRESS,LBS/IN**2
*********** *********** ************ ****************
MINIMUM -1.1695E+05 1.0459E+04 -5.1943E+05 527.48
Pile G. 1 2 1 2
MAXIMUM 2.2152E+05 1.8328E+04 -4.3001E+05 806.93
Pile G. 3 3 3 3

* EFFECTS FOR LATERALLY LOADED PILE *

PILE DISPL. BENDING SHEAR SOIL TOTAL FLEXURAL

y-DIR MOMENT FORCE REACTION STRESS RIGIDITY
IN LBS-IN LBS LBS/IN LBS-IN**2 LBS-IN**2
****** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
Min. -3.5329E-03 -2.8940E+04 -1.2599E+04 -339.54 144.76 5.0487E+10
Pile N. 2 2 3 3 2 1
Max. 0.030369 6.7755E+05 1.6801E+04 698.41 989.32 5.0487E+10
Pile N. 1 3 3 3 3 1

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-218

1.9.7 Graphs

Figure 1.34 Curves Deflection vs. Distance for Example Problem 8 - 2D.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-219

Figure 1.35 Curves Moment vs. Distance for Example Problem 8 - 2D.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-220

Figure 1.36 Curves K11(KXX) vs. vertical displacement for Example Problem 8 - 2D.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-221

Figure 1.37 Curves K22(KYY) vs. lateral deflection for Example Problem 8 - 2D.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 1 Example Problems Based on Two-Dimensional Analyses 1-222

Figure 1.38 Curves K33(KrZrZ) vs. rotation for Example Problem 8 - 2D.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
CHAPTER 2. Example Problems Based
on Three-Dimensional
Analyses

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-2

2.1 Introduction

Main features of the examples for two-dimensional analysis included with GROUP are
summarized in the table below.

Additional application problems will become available electronically at our internet website,
which may be accessed with the following unified resource locator (url):

http://www.ensoftinc.com/

Users may also access ENSOFT, INC.'s website to observe responses to commonly asked
questions related to the GROUP program.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-3

Example Name Name of Input File Description

Pile group consists of vertical and battered
piles. The user enters the curve for Axial load
vs. displacement. The program generates the
soil-resistance (p-y) curve internally. This
Example 1 - 3D 3Dexample1.gp10d
example is similar to Example 2 - 2D in Chapter
5, where the analysis has been changed from a
2-dimensional model to a 3-dimensional
model.
Application of a 2 x 2 pile group with 3-
Example 2 - 3D 3Dexample2.gp10d dimensional analysis. Loading applied at the
top of the pile cap has 5 components.
Application of a 2 x 2 pile group with 3-
dimensional analysis. Loading has only
Example 3 - 3D 3Dexample3.gp10d
torsional moment applied at the top of the pile
cap.
Application of a 9 pile group with 3-
dimensional analysis. The piles are divided into
Example 4 - 3D 3Dexample4.gp10d
the front row and the back row. The piles in
the front row are also battered.
Application of a 5 pile group with 3-
dimensional analysis. Four piles are installed at
Example 5 - 3D 3Dexample5.gp10d
each corner and the fifth pile is installed at the
center of the pile cap.
Application of piles in a circular group with 3-
dimensional analysis. This example is similar to
Example 6 - 3D 3Dexample6.gp10d Example 5 - 2D in Chapter 5, where the
analysis has been changed from a 2-
dimensional model to a 3-dimensional model..

Table 2.1 Main features of three-dimensional examples for GROUP 2016

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-4

2.2 Example Problem 1 - 3D

2.2.1 Model Description

The geometrical configuration of Example Problem 1 - 3D is shown in Figure 2.1. It consists of

six 18-inch square, prestressed concrete piles of 93 ft in length, which are assumed to be rigidly
connected to the pile cap. Subgroups 1 and 4 have only one pile battered 1:4 in the plane of loading (x-y
plane). Subgroups 2 and 3 have two piles battered 1:6 away from the plane of loading. However, the
pile subgroups 2 and 3 are regarded as composed of vertical piles, because the projection of these piles
on the plane of loading is vertical. Distance from the pile cap to the assumed scour line is approximately
10 ft.

The group of piles is subjected to loads applied at the center of the pile cap and at the top of a
bent which is located 38.5 ft (462 in) above the origin of global coordinates.

The applied loads are:

Vertical load = 844 kips (844,000 lbs),

Lateral load = 36.4 kips (36,400 lbs),

Moment = 0

The general section properties of the prestressed concrete pile is shown in Figure 2.2. The
compressive strength of the concrete is assumed to be 6,000 psi. The moment of inertia of the section
is 8,600 in4. The Young's modulus of the concrete is 4.44 x 106 psi. In this case the pile is regarded as
linearly elastic throughout, with the assumption that maximum stress in the pile is always in the elastic
range.

Theoretical lateral soil-resistance curves are internally generated by the program. The soil is
submerged soft clay with properties shown in Figure 2.3. For the example, the contribution of the top 5
ft is neglected by defining a soft clay layer with very low resistance (c=0.001 psi). Note that no
modifications of the p-y curves has been made in this example for the pile-batter effect. The curve of
axial load versus pile-top displacement used in this example is shown in Figure 1.6.

This example problem includes a printout of p-y curves internally generated by the program for
pile subgroup 1 at the depths of 180 in, 252 in, 360 in and 1116 in below the origin of coordinates that
correspond to 60 in, 132 in, 240 in and 996 in below the ground line. These curves are printed out for
verification purposes. The input and output files for the example problem are shown in the following
pages.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-5

Figure 2.1 General Description of Example Problem 1 - 3D.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-6

Figure 2.2 Section of prestressed concrete pile

AXIAL LOAD, Kip

-400 -200 0 200 400
-1
AXIAL PILE-TOP DISPLACEMENT, in

-0.8
Upward

-0.6
-0.4
-0.2
0
0.2
Downward

0.4
0.6
0.8
1

Figure 2.3 Axial load versus pile-top displacements

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-7

2.2.2 Input Data

EXAMPLE PROBLEM 1 - 3D, P-Y CURVES GENERATED INTERNALLY

GROUP2016.10.8
* Analysis Parameters
1 3 0 0 0 1 0 0 1 0 1 0 0 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 1
* Pile Cap Dimensions
0 0 0 0 0 0
* Load Cases
1 0 0 1 0
0 1 1 1 1 20 20
1E-5 1E-5 1 1
Load Case 1
12 0 0 0 1 0 0 0
2 1 1 0 1E-7 1E-5 0 0 0
1
0 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 0 0 0 1 0 0 1 0 1 0 0 0 0 1 1
1
844000 36400 0 0 0 0 -38.5 0 0
0
0
* Load Combinations
0 0 0 1 0
* Distributed Load Sets
1
1
0 0
* Pile Group Configuration
6
2 2 1 0 1 0 0 0 0 1
0 0 1 1 1 1 1
0 -10.5 0 0 104.03623 0 10
2 2 1 0 1 0 0 0 0 2
0 0 1 1 1 1 1
0 -7.5 -3.3333333 270 80.53768 0 10
2 2 1 0 1 0 0 0 0 2
0 0 1 1 1 1 1
0 7.5 -3.3333333 270 80.53768 0 10
2 2 1 0 1 0 0 0 0 2
0 0 1 1 1 1 1
0 -7.5 3.3333333 90 80.53768 0 10
2 2 1 0 1 0 0 0 0 2
0 0 1 1 1 1 1
0 7.5 3.3333333 90 80.53768 0 10
2 2 1 0 1 0 0 0 0 3
0 0 1 1 1 1 1
0 10.5 0 0 75.96237 0 10
* Pile Properties
1
0 1
35 93 1
0 93 1
* Pile Cross Sections
1
0 0 0 0
Section 1
18 0 1 1 0 0 0.1 0.1
1 324 8600 8600 17200 3.05472E10 0 0 4440000 0 0
0 0 0 0 1
None
* Soil Layers
3
0 1
10 15
2 10
17.28 0.144 0 10 0 0.02 0 0.144 0 0
17.28 0.144 0 10 0 0.02 0 0.144 0 0

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-8

1 1
15 84.5
2 10
29.99808 547.2 0 40 0 0.02 0 432 0 0
29.99808 547.2 0 40 0 0.02 0 432 0 0
2 1
84.5 93.333333
2 10
29.99808 2160 0 500 0 0.02 0 720 0 0
29.99808 2160 0 500 0 0.02 0 720 0 0
* Print py curves
4
1 15
0
1 21
0
1 30
0
1 93
0
* Generated LD curves
0
* Generated TR curves
3
1
2
6
* User defined LD curves
1
0 25
-360000 -10
-360000 -0.65
-354000 -0.58
-345000 -0.5
-330000 -0.4
-310000 -0.3
-280000 -0.19
-260000 -0.16
-240000 -0.14
-120000 -0.06
-80000 -0.04
-40000 -0.02
0 0
40000 0.02
80000 0.04
120000 0.06
240000 0.14
260000 0.16
280000 0.19
310000 0.3
330000 0.4
345000 0.5
354000 0.58
360000 0.65
360000 10
* User defined MC curves
1
1 1
0
1 1
0 0
* Internally Generated MC curves
1
1 1
0
0
1 1
0 0
1 1
0
0

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-9

1 1
0 0
* End of file

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-10

2.2.3 Echo Print File

=========================================================================

GROUP for Windows, Version 2016.10.8

Serial Number : 136089307

Analysis of A Group of Piles

Subjected to Axial and Lateral Loading

(c) Copyright ENSOFT, Inc., 1987-2015

All Rights Reserved

=========================================================================

This program is licensed to :

ENSOFT, INC
AUSTIN, TX

Path to file locations : C:\projects\GROUP2016\Group2016_1008\DXE\Examples_2016\

Name of input data file : 3Dexample1.gp10r
Name of output echo file : 3Dexample1.gp10e
Name of output results file : 3Dexample1.gp10o
Name of output summary file : 3Dexample1.gp10t
Name of plot output file : 3Dexample1.gp10p
Name of runtime file : 3Dexample1.gp10r

-------------------------------------------------------------------------
Time and Date of Analysis
-------------------------------------------------------------------------

Date: May 09, 2016 Time: 18:14:30

***** INPUT INFORMATION *****

EXAMPLE PROBLEM 1 - 3D, P-Y CURVES GENERATED INTERNALLY

ANALYSIS TYPE = 3D ANALYSIS

ADJUST DEPTH FOR BATTER PILES

GENERATE LOAD-DISP (AND T-R) CURVES BASED ON SOIL PROFILE

EXTEND INTERPOLATION FOR L-DP (AND T-R) CURVES

UNITS SYSTEM = ENGL

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-11

* TABLE C * LOAD AND CONTROL PARAMETERS

** LOAD CASES **

NUMBER OF LOAD CASES : 1

LOAD CASE : 1
CASE NAME : Load Case 1
LOAD TYPE : Special, Sp
SCALE FACTOR : 1.0000

* CONCENTRATED LOADS *

NL VERT.LOAD HR.LOAD Y HR.LOAD Z MOMENT X MOMENT Y MOMENT Z COORD X COORD Y COORD Z

LBS LBS LBS LBS-IN LBS-IN LBS-IN FT FT FT
1 8.44E+05 3.64E+04 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 -38.5 0.00 0.00

* EQUIVALENT CONCENTRATED LOAD AT ORIGIN *

VER.LOAD X,LBS HOR.LOAD Y,LBS HOR.LOAD Z,LBS

8.44000E+05 36400.0 0.00000

MOMENT X,LBS-IN MOMENT Y,LBS-IN MOMENT Z,LBS-IN

0.00000 0.00000 -1.68168E+07

* THE LOADING IS STATIC *

* CONTROL PARAMETERS *
TOLERANCE ON CONVERGENCE OF PILE CAP MOVEMENT = 1.00000E-05
TOLERANCE ON DETERMINATION OF PILE DEFLECTIONS = 1.00000E-05 IN
MAX NO OF ITERATIONS ALLOWED FOR FOUNDATION ANALYSIS = 20
MAXIMUM NO OF ITERATIONS ALLOWED FOR PILE ANALYSIS = 20
FACTOR TO APPLY THE LOAD IN INCREMENTS = 1.0000
MINIMUM FACTOR FOR LOAD INCREMENTS = 1.0000
PRINT RESULTS AT PILE CAP, PILE HEADS AND ALONG PILES
PRINT RESULTS EVERY 1 NODE(S)

** SETS OF DISTRIBUTED LOAD **

NUMBER OF SETS : 1

DIST. LOAD SET : 1

NL DEPTH LOAD
(FT) (LBS)
1 0.0000 0.0000

* TABLE D * ARRANGEMENT OF PILE GROUPS

GROUP CONN.Z-Z CONN.Y-Y PILE PROP P-Y CURVE L-S CURVE T-R CURVE R-F-L SET
1 FIX FIX 1 0 1 U 1 G 0

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-12

2 FIX FIX 1 0 1 U 2 G 0
3 FIX FIX 1 0 1 U 2 G 0
4 FIX FIX 1 0 1 U 2 G 0
5 FIX FIX 1 0 1 U 2 G 0
6 FIX FIX 1 0 1 U 3 G 0

GROUP CorX,FT CorY,FT CorZ,FT ALPHA,DEG BETA,DEG THETA,DEG GROUND,FT SPz,LBS-IN

SPy,LBS-IN
1 0.000 -10.50 0.000 0.000 104.0 0.000 10.00 0.000
0.000
2 0.000 -7.500 -3.333 270.0 80.54 0.000 10.00 0.000
0.000
3 0.000 7.500 -3.333 270.0 80.54 0.000 10.00 0.000
0.000
4 0.000 -7.500 3.333 90.00 80.54 0.000 10.00 0.000
0.000
5 0.000 7.500 3.333 90.00 80.54 0.000 10.00 0.000
0.000
6 0.000 10.50 0.000 0.000 75.96 0.000 10.00 0.000
0.000

* TABLE E * PILE GEOMETRY AND PROPERTIES

PILE TYPE = 1 - DRIVEN PILE
= 2 - DRILLED SHAFT

PROP SECTS INC PILE TYPE LENGTH, FT

1 1 35 1 93.000

* PILE SECTIONS *

PROP SECT FROM,FT TO,FT CROSS SECT

1 1 0.00000 93.0000 1

* PILE CROSS SECTIONS *

CROSS SECTION : 1
SECTION NAME : Section

TYPE : ELASTIC
CROSS SECTION TYPE : GENERAL SECTION
EQUIVALENT DIAMETER : 18.0000 IN
YOUNG MODULUS : 4.44000E+06 LBS/IN**2

* PILE CROSS SECTIONS PROPERTIES *

ELASTIC SECTIONS

SECT DIAM,IN AREA,IN**2 Iz,IN**4 Iy,IN**4 GJ,LBS-IN**2 Mn,LBS-IN Vn,LBS

1 18.000 324.00 8600.0 8600.0 3.0547E+10 0.0000 0.0000

* TABLE F * SOIL DATA

SOILS INFORMATION

GROUND SURFACE = 10.0000 FT

3 LAYER(S) OF SOIL

LAYER 1

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-13

THE SOIL IS A SOFT CLAY

TOP OF LAYER BOTTOM OF LAYER
X COORDINATE (FT) 10.0000 15.0000
EFFECTIVE UNIT WEIGHT (LBS/FT**3) 17.2800 17.2800
UNDRAINED COHESION, C (LBS/FT**2) 0.14400 0.14400
STRAIN AT 50% STRESS 0.0200000 0.0200000
ULTIMATE UNIT SIDE FRICTION (LBS/FT**2) 0.14400 0.14400
ULTIMATE UNIT TIP RESISTANCE (LBS/FT**2) 0.00000 0.00000

LAYER 2
THE SOIL IS A SOFT CLAY
TOP OF LAYER BOTTOM OF LAYER
X COORDINATE (FT) 15.0000 84.5000
EFFECTIVE UNIT WEIGHT (LBS/FT**3) 29.9981 29.9981
UNDRAINED COHESION, C (LBS/FT**2) 547.200 547.200
STRAIN AT 50% STRESS 0.0200000 0.0200000
ULTIMATE UNIT SIDE FRICTION (LBS/FT**2) 432.000 432.000
ULTIMATE UNIT TIP RESISTANCE (LBS/FT**2) 0.00000 0.00000

LAYER 3
THE SOIL IS A SOFT CLAY
TOP OF LAYER BOTTOM OF LAYER
X COORDINATE (FT) 84.5000 93.3333
EFFECTIVE UNIT WEIGHT (LBS/FT**3) 29.9981 29.9981
UNDRAINED COHESION, C (LBS/FT**2) 2160.00 2160.00
STRAIN AT 50% STRESS 0.0200000 0.0200000
ULTIMATE UNIT SIDE FRICTION (LBS/FT**2) 720.000 720.000
ULTIMATE UNIT TIP RESISTANCE (LBS/FT**2) 0.00000 0.00000

* DATA TO PRINT GENERATED P-Y CURVES *

NUMBER OF CURVES TO PRINT : 4

CURVE NUMBER PILE GROUP DEPTH (FT)

1 1 15.0000
2 1 21.0000
3 1 30.0000
4 1 93.0000

* TABLE H * AXIAL LOAD VS DISPLACEMENT

USER DEFINED AXIAL LOAD-DISPLACEMENT CURVES

NUM OF CURVES 1

CURVE 1 NUM OF POINTS 25

DISPLACEMENT, IN AXIAL LOAD,LBS

-10.0000 -3.60000E+05
-0.65000 -3.60000E+05
-0.58000 -3.54000E+05
-0.50000 -3.45000E+05
-0.40000 -3.30000E+05
-0.30000 -3.10000E+05
-0.19000 -2.80000E+05
-0.16000 -2.60000E+05
-0.14000 -2.40000E+05
-0.0600000 -1.20000E+05
-0.0400000 -80000.0
-0.0200000 -40000.0
0.00000 0.00000
0.0200000 40000.0
0.0400000 80000.0
0.0600000 1.20000E+05

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-14

0.14000 2.40000E+05
0.16000 2.60000E+05
0.19000 2.80000E+05
0.30000 3.10000E+05
0.40000 3.30000E+05
0.50000 3.45000E+05
0.58000 3.54000E+05
0.65000 3.60000E+05
10.0000 3.60000E+05

* TABLE I * TORS. MOM. VS ANGLE ROT.

TORQUE-ROTATION CURVES GENERATED INTERNALLY

NUM OF CURVES 3

CURVE 1 NUM OF POINTS 19

ROT. ANGLE,Rad. TORS.MOMEN,LBS-IN

-0.25348 -1.40358E+06
-0.14237 -1.40358E+06
-0.0868180 -1.40358E+06
-0.0433703 -1.43524E+06
-0.0372596 -1.42677E+06
-0.0137697 -7.45679E+05
-6.90998E-03 -3.94153E+05
-1.32301E-03 -73049.8
-1.32301E-04 -7304.98
0.00000 0.00000
1.32301E-04 7304.98
1.32301E-03 73049.8
6.90998E-03 3.94153E+05
0.0137697 7.45679E+05
0.0372596 1.42677E+06
0.0433703 1.43524E+06
0.0868180 1.40358E+06
0.14237 1.40358E+06
0.25348 1.40358E+06

CURVE 2 NUM OF POINTS 19

ROT. ANGLE,Rad. TORS.MOMEN,LBS-IN

-0.25348 -1.40358E+06
-0.14237 -1.40358E+06
-0.0868180 -1.40358E+06
-0.0433703 -1.43524E+06
-0.0372596 -1.42677E+06
-0.0137697 -7.45679E+05
-6.90998E-03 -3.94153E+05
-1.32301E-03 -73049.8
-1.32301E-04 -7304.98
0.00000 0.00000
1.32301E-04 7304.98
1.32301E-03 73049.8
6.90998E-03 3.94153E+05
0.0137697 7.45679E+05
0.0372596 1.42677E+06
0.0433703 1.43524E+06
0.0868180 1.40358E+06
0.14237 1.40358E+06
0.25348 1.40358E+06

CURVE 3 NUM OF POINTS 19

ROT. ANGLE,Rad. TORS.MOMEN,LBS-IN

-0.25348 -1.40358E+06

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-15

-0.14237 -1.40358E+06
-0.0868180 -1.40358E+06
-0.0433703 -1.43524E+06
-0.0372596 -1.42677E+06
-0.0137697 -7.45679E+05
-6.90998E-03 -3.94153E+05
-1.32301E-03 -73049.8
-1.32301E-04 -7304.98
0.00000 0.00000
1.32301E-04 7304.98
1.32301E-03 73049.8
6.90998E-03 3.94153E+05
0.0137697 7.45679E+05
0.0372596 1.42677E+06
0.0433703 1.43524E+06
0.0868180 1.40358E+06
0.14237 1.40358E+06
0.25348 1.40358E+06

* TABLE J * MOMENT CURVATURE SETS

USER DEFINED MOMENT CURVATURE

NUM OF SETS : 1

CURVE SET 1 NUM OF CURVES 1

CURVE 1 AXIAL LOAD 0.000E+00 LBS

POINT MOMENT CURVATURE

LBS-IN RADIAN/IN
1 0.00000 0.00000

* TABLE N * PRINTED P-Y CURVES

* GENERATED P-Y CURVES *

NUMBER OF CURVES : 4

CURVE NUMBER = 1

PILE GROUP NUMBER = 1

DEPTH BELOW ORIGIN = 15.00 FT

NUMBER OF POINTS ON CURVE = 17

P-Y CURVE COMPUTED USING SOFT CLAY CRITERIA

DEPTH BELOW GS DIAM C GAMMA E50

FT IN LBS/FT**2 LBS/FT**3
5.00 18.000 0.5472E+03 0.1728E+02 0.2000E-01

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-16

EQ. DEPTH = 5.00 FT

Y,IN P,LBS/IN
0.00000 0.00000
1.80000E-03 20.7887
0.0180000 44.7879
0.0540000 64.5953
0.14400 89.5758
0.28800 112.858
0.43200 129.191
0.72000 153.172
1.08000 175.339
1.62000 200.713
2.16000 220.913
2.88000 243.146
3.60000 261.921
4.68000 285.859
5.76000 306.345
7.20000 330.000
8.64000 330.000

CURVE NUMBER = 2

PILE GROUP NUMBER = 1

DEPTH BELOW ORIGIN = 21.00 FT

NUMBER OF POINTS ON CURVE = 17

P-Y CURVE COMPUTED USING SOFT CLAY CRITERIA

DEPTH BELOW GS DIAM C GAMMA E50

FT IN LBS/FT**2 LBS/FT**3
11.00 18.000 0.5472E+03 0.2422E+02 0.2000E-01
EQ. DEPTH = 11.00 FT

Y,IN P,LBS/IN
0.00000 0.00000
1.80000E-03 30.8239
0.0180000 66.4080
0.0540000 95.7770
0.14400 132.816
0.28800 167.338
0.43200 191.554
0.72000 227.112
1.08000 259.979
1.62000 297.601
2.16000 327.553
2.88000 360.518
3.60000 388.357
4.68000 423.850
5.76000 454.225
7.20000 489.299
8.64000 489.299

CURVE NUMBER = 3

PILE GROUP NUMBER = 1

DEPTH BELOW ORIGIN = 30.00 FT

NUMBER OF POINTS ON CURVE = 17

P-Y CURVE COMPUTED USING SOFT CLAY CRITERIA

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-17

DEPTH BELOW GS DIAM C GAMMA E50

FT IN LBS/FT**2 LBS/FT**3
20.00 18.000 0.5472E+03 0.2682E+02 0.2000E-01
EQ. DEPTH = 20.00 FT

Y,IN P,LBS/IN
0.00000 0.00000
1.80000E-03 38.7804
0.0180000 83.5498
0.0540000 120.500
0.14400 167.100
0.28800 210.532
0.43200 240.999
0.72000 285.736
1.08000 327.086
1.62000 374.420
2.16000 412.103
2.88000 453.578
3.60000 488.602
4.68000 533.257
5.76000 571.472
7.20000 615.600
8.64000 615.600

CURVE NUMBER = 4

PILE GROUP NUMBER = 1

DEPTH BELOW ORIGIN = 93.00 FT

NUMBER OF POINTS ON CURVE = 17

P-Y CURVE COMPUTED USING SOFT CLAY CRITERIA

DEPTH BELOW GS DIAM C GAMMA E50

FT IN LBS/FT**2 LBS/FT**3
83.00 18.000 0.2160E+04 0.2923E+02 0.2000E-01
EQ. DEPTH = 83.00 FT

Y,IN P,LBS/IN
0.00000 0.00000
1.80000E-03 153.080
0.0180000 329.802
0.0540000 475.656
0.14400 659.603
0.28800 831.048
0.43200 951.313
0.72000 1127.91
1.08000 1291.13
1.62000 1477.98
2.16000 1626.72
2.88000 1790.44
3.60000 1928.69
4.68000 2104.96
5.76000 2255.81
7.20000 2430.00
8.64000 2430.00

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-18

2.2.4 Processor Run Notes

GROUP for Windows, Version 2016.10.8

-------------------------------------------------------------------------
Time and Date of Analysis
-------------------------------------------------------------------------

Date: May 09, 2016 Time: 18:14:30

EXAMPLE PROBLEM 1 - 3D, P-Y CURVES GENERATED INTERNALLY

READING * TITLE AND VERSION

READING * Analysis Parameters
READING * Pile Cap Dimensions
READING * Load Cases
READING * Load Combinations
READING * Distributed Load Sets
READING * Pile Group Configuration
READING * Pile Properties
READING * Pile Cross Sections
READING * Soil Layers
READING * Print py curves
READING * Generated LD curves
READING * Generated TR curves
READING * User defined LD curves
READING * User defined MC curves
READING * Internally Generated MC curves

COMPUTATION IS PROCEEDING......

LOAD CASE : 1
CASE NAME : Load Case 1

GLOBAL ITERATIONS
STEP 1, TCUR 1.0000, DTCUR 1.0000
ITERATION 1
- ErrDsp 0.10000E+01, IncDsp 0.77840E-01, TotDsp 0.77840E-01
- ErrRot 0.10000E+01, IncRot 0.11865E-03, TotRot 0.11865E-03
ITERATION 2
- ErrDsp 0.46204E+00, IncDsp 0.50989E-01, TotDsp 0.11036E+00
- ErrRot 0.72749E-01, IncRot 0.80464E-05, TotRot 0.11061E-03
ITERATION 3
- ErrDsp 0.52731E-01, IncDsp 0.60502E-02, TotDsp 0.11474E+00
- ErrRot 0.60966E-01, IncRot 0.63557E-05, TotRot 0.10425E-03
ITERATION 4
- ErrDsp 0.36388E-03, IncDsp 0.41762E-04, TotDsp 0.11477E+00
- ErrRot 0.42603E-03, IncRot 0.44394E-07, TotRot 0.10420E-03
ITERATION 5
- ErrDsp 0.16620E-07, IncDsp 0.19074E-08, TotDsp 0.11477E+00
- ErrRot 0.19516E-07, IncRot 0.20337E-11, TotRot 0.10420E-03

NUMBER OF GLOBAL ITERATIONS = 5

ANALYSIS FOR LOAD CASE 1/ 1 FINISHED

Execution Time : 169 ms

Number Processors : 1/ 1
Serial processing : 0.109 sec

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-19

Paral. processing : 0.031 sec

Print. processing : 0.029 sec

ANALYSIS COMPLETED
Execution Time : 202 ms
Number Processors : 1/ 1

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-20

2.2.5 Output Results File

=========================================================================

GROUP for Windows, Version 2016.10.8

Serial Number : 136089307

Analysis of A Group of Piles

Subjected to Axial and Lateral Loading

(c) Copyright ENSOFT, Inc., 1987-2015

All Rights Reserved

=========================================================================

This program is licensed to :

ENSOFT, INC
AUSTIN, TX

Path to file locations : C:\projects\GROUP2016\Group2016_1008\DXE\Examples_2016\

Name of input data file : 3Dexample1.gp10d
Name of output echo file : 3Dexample1.gp10e
Name of output results file : 3Dexample1.gp10o
Name of output summary file : 3Dexample1.gp10t
Name of plot output file : 3Dexample1.gp10p
Name of runtime file : 3Dexample1.gp10r

-------------------------------------------------------------------------
Time and Date of Analysis
-------------------------------------------------------------------------

Date: May 09, 2016 Time: 18:14:30

***** COMPUTATION RESULTS *****

EXAMPLE PROBLEM 1 - 3D, P-Y CURVES GENERATED INTERNALLY

***** LOAD CASES RESULTS *****

LOAD CASE : 1
CASE NAME : Load Case 1
LOAD TYPE : Special, Sp

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-21

* TABLE L * COMPUTATION ON PILE CAP

* EQUIVALENT CONCENTRATED LOAD AT ORIGIN *

VERT. LOAD, LBS HOR. LOAD Y, LBS HOR. LOAD Z, LBS

8.44000E+05 36400.0 0.00000

MOMENT X ,LBS-IN MOMENT Y,LBS-IN MOMENT Z,LBS-IN

0.00000 0.00000 -1.68168E+07

* DISPLACEMENT OF GROUPED PILE FOUNDATION AT ORIGIN *

VERTICAL ,IN HORIZONTAL Y,IN HORIZONTAL Z,IN

0.0779912 0.0841969 4.65529E-18

ANGLE ROT. X,RAD ANGLE ROT. Y,RAD ANGLE ROT. Z,RAD

5.94148E-19 1.51212E-19 -1.04205E-04

NUMBER OF GLOBAL ITERATIONS = 5

* TABLE M * COMPUTATION ON INDIVIDUAL PILE

* PILE GROUP * 1

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS AND REACTIONS *

THE GLOBAL STRUCTURAL COORDINATE SYSTEM

---------------------------------------

DISP. X,IN DISP. Y,IN DISP. Z,IN ROT. X,RAD ROT. Y,RAD ROT. Z,RAD
0.064861 0.084197 -7.0207E-17 5.9415E-19 1.5121E-19 -1.0420E-04

FOR. X,LBS FOR. Y,LBS FOR. Z,LBS MOM X,LBS-IN MOM Y,LBS-IN MOM Z,LBS-IN
8.2959E+04 -1.8663E+04 -2.6095E-12 1.2208E-10 3.6543E-10 2.5013E+05

STR,LBS/IN**2
524.14

THE PILE COORDINATE SYSTEM (LOCAL AXES)

---------------------------------------

DISP. x,IN DISP. y,IN DISP. z,IN ROT. x,RAD ROT. y,RAD ROT. z,RAD
0.042504 0.097414 -7.0207E-17 5.3973E-19 2.9080E-19 -1.0420E-04

AXIAL,LBS LAT. y,LBS LAT. z,LBS MOM x,LBS-IN MOM y,LBS-IN MOM z,LBS-IN

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-22

8.5008E+04 2014.6 -2.6095E-12 2.9801E-11 3.8413E-10 2.5013E+05

STR,LBS/IN**2
524.14

* EFFECTS FOR LATERALLY LOADED PILE *

x DISPL. DISPL. MOMENT MOMENT SHEAR SOIL REACT TOTAL

y-DIR z-DIR z-DIR y-DIR y-z-DIR y-z-DIR STRESS
FT IN IN LBS-IN LBS-IN LBS LBS/IN LBS/IN**2
********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
0.0000 9.7414E-02 -7.0207E-17 -2.5013E+05 3.8413E-10 2023.4 0.0000 524.14
2.6571 9.0761E-02 -7.4366E-17 -1.8533E+05 3.0127E-10 2014.6 0.0000 456.32
5.3143 7.9174E-02 -7.0502E-17 -1.2011E+05 2.1774E-10 2014.6 0.0000 388.07
7.9714 6.4389E-02 -6.0841E-17 -5.4615E+04 1.3371E-10 2014.6 0.0000 319.53
10.629 4.8149E-02 -4.7620E-17 1.1001E+04 4.9382E-11 2014.1 3.0523E-02 273.88
13.286 3.2203E-02 -3.3084E-17 7.6562E+04 -3.5029E-11 2013.2 2.6694E-02 342.49
15.943 1.8295E-02 -1.9480E-17 1.4192E+05 -1.1933E-10 1267.7 46.733 410.89
18.600 8.1654E-03 -9.0545E-18 1.5945E+05 -1.5277E-10 160.81 42.867 429.23
21.257 2.2817E-03 -2.6962E-18 1.3303E+05 -1.3754E-10 1366.2 32.737 401.59
23.914 -5.9999E-05 -1.4126E-22 7.3024E+04 -8.2662E-11 1720.7 10.498 338.79
26.571 -4.5729E-04 4.9497E-19 2.3528E+04 -2.7572E-11 1163.9 24.427 286.99
29.229 -2.2811E-04 2.5594E-19 -1187.3 6.9901E-13 465.87 19.359 263.61
31.886 -3.0549E-05 3.5528E-20 -6217.4 6.8846E-12 0.7383 9.8157 268.88
34.543 1.4661E-06 -1.5762E-21 -1253.9 1.4486E-12 98.287 3.6045 263.68
37.200 9.5506E-08 -1.0972E-22 47.888 -5.0954E-14 19.716 1.3238 262.42
39.857 -1.9083E-12 2.0020E-27 3.5871 -4.1209E-15 0.7511 4.0053E-02 262.37
42.514 -6.7691E-15 7.7765E-30 -7.1160E-05 7.4604E-20 5.6249E-02 3.5283E-03 262.37
45.171 1.0118E-19 -1.0600E-34 -2.5423E-07 2.9207E-22 1.1159E-06 6.9492E-08 262.37
47.829 3.6408E-22 -4.1826E-37 3.7725E-12 -3.9496E-27 3.9867E-09 2.5007E-10 262.37
50.486 -5.3633E-27 5.6110E-42 1.3674E-14 -1.5709E-29 5.9157E-14 3.6837E-15 262.37
53.143 -1.9583E-29 2.2496E-44 -1.9996E-19 2.0904E-34 2.1443E-16 1.3450E-17 262.37
55.800 2.8424E-34 -2.9694E-49 -7.3548E-22 8.4492E-37 3.1355E-21 1.9523E-22 262.37
58.457 1.0533E-36 0.0000 1.0596E-26 -1.1061E-41 1.1533E-23 0.0000 262.37
61.114 -1.5061E-41 0.0000 3.9558E-29 -4.5444E-44 0.0000 0.0000 262.37
63.771 -5.6650E-44 0.0000 -5.6138E-34 5.8513E-49 0.0000 0.0000 262.37
66.429 7.9782E-49 0.0000 -2.1277E-36 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 262.37
69.086 0.0000 0.0000 2.9735E-41 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 262.37
71.743 0.0000 0.0000 1.1444E-43 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 262.37
74.400 0.0000 0.0000 -1.5746E-48 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 262.37
77.057 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 262.37
79.714 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 262.37
82.371 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 262.37
85.029 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 262.37
87.686 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 262.37
90.343 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 262.37
93.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 262.37

* PILE GROUP * 2

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS AND REACTIONS *

THE GLOBAL STRUCTURAL COORDINATE SYSTEM

---------------------------------------

DISP. X,IN DISP. Y,IN DISP. Z,IN ROT. X,RAD ROT. Y,RAD ROT. Z,RAD
0.068613 0.084197 -5.0161E-17 5.9292E-19 1.5121E-19 -1.0420E-04

FOR. X,LBS FOR. Y,LBS FOR. Z,LBS MOM X,LBS-IN MOM Y,LBS-IN MOM Z,LBS-IN
1.2978E+05 1756.1 -2.1345E+04 3.6349E+04 -3.6618E+04 2.1234E+05

STR,LBS/IN**2

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-23

634.60

THE PILE COORDINATE SYSTEM (LOCAL AXES)

---------------------------------------

DISP. x,IN DISP. y,IN DISP. z,IN ROT. x,RAD ROT. y,RAD ROT. z,RAD
0.067679 -0.011280 0.084197 1.7131E-05 1.0279E-04 1.7035E-19

AXIAL,LBS LAT. y,LBS LAT. z,LBS MOM x,LBS-IN MOM y,LBS-IN MOM z,LBS-IN
1.3152E+05 -279.97 1756.1 945.90 -2.1543E+05 -3.6618E+04

STR,LBS/IN**2
634.60

* EFFECTS FOR LATERALLY LOADED PILE *

x DISPL. DISPL. MOMENT MOMENT SHEAR SOIL REACT TOTAL

y-DIR z-DIR z-DIR y-DIR y-z-DIR y-z-DIR STRESS
FT IN IN LBS-IN LBS-IN LBS LBS/IN LBS/IN**2
********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
0.0000 -1.1280E-02 8.4197E-02 3.6618E+04 -2.1543E+05 1790.3 0.0000 634.60
2.6571 -1.0792E-02 7.8051E-02 2.7626E+04 -1.5862E+05 1778.3 0.0000 574.42
5.3143 -9.5693E-03 6.7682E-02 1.8538E+04 -1.0126E+05 1778.3 0.0000 513.66
7.9714 -7.8526E-03 5.4617E-02 9385.5 -4.3550E+04 1778.3 0.0000 452.54
10.629 -5.8860E-03 4.0392E-02 199.77 1.4317E+04 1777.9 2.8889E-02 420.91
13.286 -3.9141E-03 2.6549E-02 -8982.5 7.2104E+04 1777.0 2.5122E-02 481.96
15.943 -2.1813E-03 1.4625E-02 -1.8130E+04 1.2961E+05 1068.6 44.414 542.89
18.600 -9.3131E-04 6.1523E-03 -2.0552E+04 1.4201E+05 276.85 39.937 556.08
21.257 -2.2850E-04 1.4609E-03 -1.6825E+04 1.1376E+05 1374.3 28.930 526.27
23.914 2.6318E-05 -2.0160E-04 -8494.1 5.6052E+04 1570.6 16.621 465.25
26.571 5.4971E-05 -3.7164E-04 -2320.7 1.4905E+04 941.77 22.822 421.71
29.229 2.1832E-05 -1.4481E-04 465.55 -3341.9 312.56 16.646 409.45
31.886 1.0881E-06 -6.9700E-06 727.31 -4842.2 46.756 5.8917 411.05
34.543 -2.9011E-07 1.9407E-06 62.611 -407.25 77.944 3.9351 406.35
37.200 -1.1919E-09 7.8093E-09 -10.806 72.300 6.4618 0.5485 406.00
39.857 2.2757E-12 -1.5229E-11 -4.4934E-02 0.2944 1.1464 7.1317E-02 405.92
42.514 6.4591E-17 -4.2328E-16 8.5465E-05 -5.7192E-04 4.6705E-03 2.9409E-04 405.92
45.171 -1.2238E-19 8.1896E-19 2.4350E-09 -1.5958E-08 9.0678E-06 5.6874E-07 405.92
47.829 -3.5002E-24 2.2941E-23 -4.5960E-12 3.0756E-11 2.5314E-10 1.5939E-11 405.92
50.486 6.5813E-27 -4.4041E-26 -1.3195E-16 8.6490E-16 4.8764E-13 3.0585E-14 405.92
53.143 1.8966E-31 -1.2433E-30 2.4716E-19 -1.6539E-18 1.3719E-17 8.6382E-19 405.92
55.800 -3.5392E-34 2.3684E-33 7.1497E-24 -4.6872E-23 2.6223E-20 1.6447E-21 405.92
58.457 -1.0277E-38 6.7377E-38 -1.3291E-26 8.8943E-26 0.0000 0.0000 405.92
61.114 1.9032E-41 -1.2736E-40 -3.8739E-31 2.5400E-30 0.0000 0.0000 405.92
63.771 5.5679E-46 -3.6511E-45 7.1475E-34 -4.7831E-33 0.0000 0.0000 405.92
66.429 -1.0235E-48 6.8491E-48 2.0988E-38 -1.3764E-37 0.0000 0.0000 405.92
69.086 0.0000 0.0000 -3.8437E-41 2.5722E-40 0.0000 0.0000 405.92
71.743 0.0000 0.0000 -1.1371E-45 7.4578E-45 0.0000 0.0000 405.92
74.400 0.0000 0.0000 2.0670E-48 -1.3832E-47 0.0000 0.0000 405.92
77.057 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 405.92
79.714 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 405.92
82.371 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 405.92
85.029 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 405.92
87.686 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 405.92
90.343 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 405.92
93.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 405.92

* PILE GROUP * 3

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS AND REACTIONS *

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-24

THE GLOBAL STRUCTURAL COORDINATE SYSTEM

---------------------------------------

DISP. X,IN DISP. Y,IN DISP. Z,IN ROT. X,RAD ROT. Y,RAD ROT. Z,RAD
0.087370 0.084197 5.9126E-17 5.9292E-19 1.5121E-19 -1.0420E-04

FOR. X,LBS FOR. Y,LBS FOR. Z,LBS MOM X,LBS-IN MOM Y,LBS-IN MOM Z,LBS-IN
1.5716E+05 1744.0 -2.5835E+04 3.6304E+04 -4.6561E+04 2.1207E+05

STR,LBS/IN**2
721.95

THE PILE COORDINATE SYSTEM (LOCAL AXES)

---------------------------------------

DISP. x,IN DISP. y,IN DISP. z,IN ROT. x,RAD ROT. y,RAD ROT. z,RAD
0.086181 -0.014363 0.084197 1.7131E-05 1.0279E-04 1.7035E-19

AXIAL,LBS LAT. y,LBS LAT. z,LBS MOM x,LBS-IN MOM y,LBS-IN MOM z,LBS-IN
1.5927E+05 -354.36 1744.0 945.90 -2.1515E+05 -4.6561E+04

STR,LBS/IN**2
721.95

* EFFECTS FOR LATERALLY LOADED PILE *

x DISPL. DISPL. MOMENT MOMENT SHEAR SOIL REACT TOTAL

y-DIR z-DIR z-DIR y-DIR y-z-DIR y-z-DIR STRESS
FT IN IN LBS-IN LBS-IN LBS LBS/IN LBS/IN**2
********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
0.0000 -1.4363E-02 8.4197E-02 4.6561E+04 -2.1515E+05 1794.3 0.0000 721.95
2.6571 -1.3744E-02 7.8055E-02 3.5163E+04 -1.5856E+05 1779.7 0.0000 661.55
5.3143 -1.2187E-02 6.7691E-02 2.3616E+04 -1.0130E+05 1779.7 0.0000 600.44
7.9714 -1.0003E-02 5.4630E-02 1.1969E+04 -4.3615E+04 1779.7 0.0000 538.91
10.629 -7.4989E-03 4.0408E-02 271.47 1.4260E+04 1779.2 2.8955E-02 506.50
13.286 -4.9880E-03 2.6565E-02 -1.1422E+04 7.2045E+04 1778.3 2.5182E-02 567.92
15.943 -2.7812E-03 1.4641E-02 -2.3063E+04 1.2950E+05 1068.1 44.529 629.23
18.600 -1.1885E-03 6.1642E-03 -2.6156E+04 1.4193E+05 281.42 40.055 642.61
21.257 -2.9227E-04 1.4669E-03 -2.1429E+04 1.1377E+05 1382.3 29.040 612.73
23.914 3.3405E-05 -2.0122E-04 -1.0841E+04 5.6167E+04 1580.0 16.636 551.44
26.571 7.0423E-05 -3.7383E-04 -2977.7 1.5015E+04 949.47 22.917 507.60
29.229 2.8156E-05 -1.4664E-04 585.05 -3302.9 317.00 16.754 495.09
31.886 1.4675E-06 -7.3842E-06 933.20 -4878.8 46.195 6.0264 496.78
34.543 -3.7370E-07 1.9635E-06 83.120 -424.49 79.077 3.9634 492.03
37.200 -1.6816E-09 8.6503E-09 -13.909 73.092 6.7830 0.5712 491.66
39.857 2.9808E-12 -1.5668E-11 -6.3380E-02 0.3261 1.1668 7.2529E-02 491.58
42.514 9.1083E-17 -4.6860E-16 1.1194E-04 -5.8840E-04 5.2085E-03 3.2788E-04 491.58
45.171 -1.6030E-19 8.4256E-19 3.4328E-09 -1.7663E-08 9.3922E-06 5.8908E-07 491.58
47.829 -4.9331E-24 2.5384E-23 -6.0199E-12 3.1642E-11 2.8215E-10 1.7761E-11 491.58
50.486 8.6202E-27 -4.5310E-26 -1.8592E-16 9.5674E-16 5.0508E-13 3.1679E-14 491.58
53.143 2.6717E-31 -1.3749E-30 3.2373E-19 -1.7016E-18 1.5283E-17 9.6203E-19 491.58
55.800 -4.6356E-34 2.4366E-33 1.0069E-23 -5.1822E-23 2.7161E-20 1.7036E-21 491.58
58.457 -1.4469E-38 7.4472E-38 -1.7409E-26 9.1505E-26 0.0000 0.0000 491.58
61.114 2.4928E-41 -1.3103E-40 -5.4527E-31 2.8068E-30 0.0000 0.0000 491.58
63.771 7.8352E-46 -4.0334E-45 9.3617E-34 -4.9208E-33 0.0000 0.0000 491.58
66.429 -1.3405E-48 7.0462E-48 2.9527E-38 -1.5201E-37 0.0000 0.0000 491.58
69.086 0.0000 0.0000 -5.0343E-41 2.6462E-40 0.0000 0.0000 491.58
71.743 0.0000 0.0000 -1.5989E-45 8.2325E-45 0.0000 0.0000 491.58
74.400 0.0000 0.0000 2.7072E-48 -1.4230E-47 0.0000 0.0000 491.58
77.057 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 491.58
79.714 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 491.58
82.371 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 491.58

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-25

85.029 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 491.58

87.686 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 491.58
90.343 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 491.58
93.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 491.58

* PILE GROUP * 4

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS AND REACTIONS *

THE GLOBAL STRUCTURAL COORDINATE SYSTEM

---------------------------------------

DISP. X,IN DISP. Y,IN DISP. Z,IN ROT. X,RAD ROT. Y,RAD ROT. Z,RAD
0.068613 0.084197 -5.0258E-17 5.9292E-19 1.5121E-19 -1.0420E-04

FOR. X,LBS FOR. Y,LBS FOR. Z,LBS MOM X,LBS-IN MOM Y,LBS-IN MOM Z,LBS-IN
1.2978E+05 1756.1 2.1345E+04 -3.6349E+04 3.6618E+04 2.1234E+05

STR,LBS/IN**2
634.60

THE PILE COORDINATE SYSTEM (LOCAL AXES)

---------------------------------------

DISP. x,IN DISP. y,IN DISP. z,IN ROT. x,RAD ROT. y,RAD ROT. z,RAD
0.067679 -0.011280 -0.084197 -1.7131E-05 -1.0279E-04 -1.5759E-19

AXIAL,LBS LAT. y,LBS LAT. z,LBS MOM x,LBS-IN MOM y,LBS-IN MOM z,LBS-IN
1.3152E+05 -279.97 -1756.1 -945.90 2.1543E+05 -3.6618E+04

STR,LBS/IN**2
634.60

* EFFECTS FOR LATERALLY LOADED PILE *

x DISPL. DISPL. MOMENT MOMENT SHEAR SOIL REACT TOTAL

y-DIR z-DIR z-DIR y-DIR y-z-DIR y-z-DIR STRESS
FT IN IN LBS-IN LBS-IN LBS LBS/IN LBS/IN**2
********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
0.0000 -1.1280E-02 -8.4197E-02 3.6618E+04 2.1543E+05 1790.3 0.0000 634.60
2.6571 -1.0792E-02 -7.8051E-02 2.7626E+04 1.5862E+05 1778.3 0.0000 574.42
5.3143 -9.5693E-03 -6.7682E-02 1.8538E+04 1.0126E+05 1778.3 0.0000 513.66
7.9714 -7.8526E-03 -5.4617E-02 9385.5 4.3550E+04 1778.3 0.0000 452.54
10.629 -5.8860E-03 -4.0392E-02 199.77 -1.4317E+04 1777.9 2.8889E-02 420.91
13.286 -3.9141E-03 -2.6549E-02 -8982.5 -7.2104E+04 1777.0 2.5122E-02 481.96
15.943 -2.1813E-03 -1.4625E-02 -1.8130E+04 -1.2961E+05 1068.6 44.414 542.89
18.600 -9.3131E-04 -6.1523E-03 -2.0552E+04 -1.4201E+05 276.85 39.937 556.08
21.257 -2.2850E-04 -1.4609E-03 -1.6825E+04 -1.1376E+05 1374.3 28.930 526.27
23.914 2.6318E-05 2.0160E-04 -8494.1 -5.6052E+04 1570.6 16.621 465.25
26.571 5.4971E-05 3.7164E-04 -2320.7 -1.4905E+04 941.77 22.822 421.71
29.229 2.1832E-05 1.4481E-04 465.55 3341.9 312.56 16.646 409.45
31.886 1.0881E-06 6.9700E-06 727.31 4842.2 46.756 5.8917 411.05
34.543 -2.9011E-07 -1.9407E-06 62.611 407.25 77.944 3.9351 406.35
37.200 -1.1919E-09 -7.8093E-09 -10.806 -72.300 6.4618 0.5485 406.00
39.857 2.2757E-12 1.5229E-11 -4.4934E-02 -0.2944 1.1464 7.1317E-02 405.92
42.514 6.4591E-17 4.2328E-16 8.5465E-05 5.7192E-04 4.6705E-03 2.9409E-04 405.92
45.171 -1.2238E-19 -8.1896E-19 2.4350E-09 1.5958E-08 9.0678E-06 5.6874E-07 405.92
47.829 -3.5002E-24 -2.2941E-23 -4.5960E-12 -3.0756E-11 2.5314E-10 1.5939E-11 405.92

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-26

50.486 6.5813E-27 4.4041E-26 -1.3195E-16 -8.6490E-16 4.8764E-13 3.0585E-14 405.92

53.143 1.8966E-31 1.2433E-30 2.4716E-19 1.6539E-18 1.3719E-17 8.6382E-19 405.92
55.800 -3.5392E-34 -2.3684E-33 7.1497E-24 4.6872E-23 2.6223E-20 1.6447E-21 405.92
58.457 -1.0277E-38 -6.7377E-38 -1.3291E-26 -8.8943E-26 0.0000 0.0000 405.92
61.114 1.9032E-41 1.2736E-40 -3.8739E-31 -2.5400E-30 0.0000 0.0000 405.92
63.771 5.5679E-46 3.6511E-45 7.1475E-34 4.7831E-33 0.0000 0.0000 405.92
66.429 -1.0235E-48 -6.8491E-48 2.0988E-38 1.3764E-37 0.0000 0.0000 405.92
69.086 0.0000 0.0000 -3.8437E-41 -2.5722E-40 0.0000 0.0000 405.92
71.743 0.0000 0.0000 -1.1371E-45 -7.4578E-45 0.0000 0.0000 405.92
74.400 0.0000 0.0000 2.0670E-48 1.3832E-47 0.0000 0.0000 405.92
77.057 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 405.92
79.714 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 405.92
82.371 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 405.92
85.029 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 405.92
87.686 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 405.92
90.343 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 405.92
93.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 405.92

* PILE GROUP * 5

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS AND REACTIONS *

THE GLOBAL STRUCTURAL COORDINATE SYSTEM

---------------------------------------

DISP. X,IN DISP. Y,IN DISP. Z,IN ROT. X,RAD ROT. Y,RAD ROT. Z,RAD
0.087370 0.084197 5.9029E-17 5.9292E-19 1.5121E-19 -1.0420E-04

FOR. X,LBS FOR. Y,LBS FOR. Z,LBS MOM X,LBS-IN MOM Y,LBS-IN MOM Z,LBS-IN
1.5716E+05 1744.0 2.5835E+04 -3.6304E+04 4.6561E+04 2.1207E+05

STR,LBS/IN**2
721.95

THE PILE COORDINATE SYSTEM (LOCAL AXES)

---------------------------------------

DISP. x,IN DISP. y,IN DISP. z,IN ROT. x,RAD ROT. y,RAD ROT. z,RAD
0.086181 -0.014363 -0.084197 -1.7131E-05 -1.0279E-04 -1.5759E-19

AXIAL,LBS LAT. y,LBS LAT. z,LBS MOM x,LBS-IN MOM y,LBS-IN MOM z,LBS-IN
1.5927E+05 -354.36 -1744.0 -945.90 2.1515E+05 -4.6561E+04

STR,LBS/IN**2
721.95

* EFFECTS FOR LATERALLY LOADED PILE *

x DISPL. DISPL. MOMENT MOMENT SHEAR SOIL REACT TOTAL

y-DIR z-DIR z-DIR y-DIR y-z-DIR y-z-DIR STRESS
FT IN IN LBS-IN LBS-IN LBS LBS/IN LBS/IN**2
********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
0.0000 -1.4363E-02 -8.4197E-02 4.6561E+04 2.1515E+05 1794.3 0.0000 721.95
2.6571 -1.3744E-02 -7.8055E-02 3.5163E+04 1.5856E+05 1779.7 0.0000 661.55
5.3143 -1.2187E-02 -6.7691E-02 2.3616E+04 1.0130E+05 1779.7 0.0000 600.44
7.9714 -1.0003E-02 -5.4630E-02 1.1969E+04 4.3615E+04 1779.7 0.0000 538.91
10.629 -7.4989E-03 -4.0408E-02 271.47 -1.4260E+04 1779.2 2.8955E-02 506.50
13.286 -4.9880E-03 -2.6565E-02 -1.1422E+04 -7.2045E+04 1778.3 2.5182E-02 567.92

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-27

15.943 -2.7812E-03 -1.4641E-02 -2.3063E+04 -1.2950E+05 1068.1 44.529 629.23

18.600 -1.1885E-03 -6.1642E-03 -2.6156E+04 -1.4193E+05 281.42 40.055 642.61
21.257 -2.9227E-04 -1.4669E-03 -2.1429E+04 -1.1377E+05 1382.3 29.040 612.73
23.914 3.3405E-05 2.0122E-04 -1.0841E+04 -5.6167E+04 1580.0 16.636 551.44
26.571 7.0423E-05 3.7383E-04 -2977.7 -1.5015E+04 949.47 22.917 507.60
29.229 2.8156E-05 1.4664E-04 585.05 3302.9 317.00 16.754 495.09
31.886 1.4675E-06 7.3842E-06 933.20 4878.8 46.195 6.0264 496.78
34.543 -3.7370E-07 -1.9635E-06 83.120 424.49 79.077 3.9634 492.03
37.200 -1.6816E-09 -8.6503E-09 -13.909 -73.092 6.7830 0.5712 491.66
39.857 2.9808E-12 1.5668E-11 -6.3380E-02 -0.3261 1.1668 7.2529E-02 491.58
42.514 9.1083E-17 4.6860E-16 1.1194E-04 5.8840E-04 5.2085E-03 3.2788E-04 491.58
45.171 -1.6030E-19 -8.4256E-19 3.4328E-09 1.7663E-08 9.3922E-06 5.8908E-07 491.58
47.829 -4.9331E-24 -2.5384E-23 -6.0199E-12 -3.1642E-11 2.8215E-10 1.7761E-11 491.58
50.486 8.6202E-27 4.5310E-26 -1.8592E-16 -9.5674E-16 5.0508E-13 3.1679E-14 491.58
53.143 2.6717E-31 1.3749E-30 3.2373E-19 1.7016E-18 1.5283E-17 9.6203E-19 491.58
55.800 -4.6356E-34 -2.4366E-33 1.0069E-23 5.1822E-23 2.7161E-20 1.7036E-21 491.58
58.457 -1.4469E-38 -7.4472E-38 -1.7409E-26 -9.1505E-26 0.0000 0.0000 491.58
61.114 2.4928E-41 1.3103E-40 -5.4527E-31 -2.8068E-30 0.0000 0.0000 491.58
63.771 7.8352E-46 4.0334E-45 9.3617E-34 4.9208E-33 0.0000 0.0000 491.58
66.429 -1.3405E-48 -7.0462E-48 2.9527E-38 1.5201E-37 0.0000 0.0000 491.58
69.086 0.0000 0.0000 -5.0343E-41 -2.6462E-40 0.0000 0.0000 491.58
71.743 0.0000 0.0000 -1.5989E-45 -8.2325E-45 0.0000 0.0000 491.58
74.400 0.0000 0.0000 2.7072E-48 1.4230E-47 0.0000 0.0000 491.58
77.057 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 491.58
79.714 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 491.58
82.371 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 491.58
85.029 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 491.58
87.686 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 491.58
90.343 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 491.58
93.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 491.58

* PILE GROUP * 6

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS AND REACTIONS *

THE GLOBAL STRUCTURAL COORDINATE SYSTEM

---------------------------------------

DISP. X,IN DISP. Y,IN DISP. Z,IN ROT. X,RAD ROT. Y,RAD ROT. Z,RAD
0.091121 0.084197 7.9518E-17 5.9415E-19 1.5121E-19 -1.0420E-04

FOR. X,LBS FOR. Y,LBS FOR. Z,LBS MOM X,LBS-IN MOM Y,LBS-IN MOM Z,LBS-IN
1.8717E+05 4.8063E+04 2.1079E-12 9.8592E-11 -2.5477E-10 1.4396E+05

STR,LBS/IN**2
747.06

THE PILE COORDINATE SYSTEM (LOCAL AXES)

---------------------------------------

DISP. x,IN DISP. y,IN DISP. z,IN ROT. x,RAD ROT. y,RAD ROT. z,RAD
0.1088 0.059580 7.9518E-17 6.1308E-19 2.5806E-21 -1.0420E-04

AXIAL,LBS LAT. y,LBS LAT. z,LBS MOM x,LBS-IN MOM y,LBS-IN MOM z,LBS-IN
1.9323E+05 1228.8 2.1079E-12 3.3851E-11 -2.7107E-10 1.4396E+05

STR,LBS/IN**2
747.06

* EFFECTS FOR LATERALLY LOADED PILE *

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-28

x DISPL. DISPL. MOMENT MOMENT SHEAR SOIL REACT TOTAL

y-DIR z-DIR z-DIR y-DIR y-z-DIR y-z-DIR STRESS
FT IN IN LBS-IN LBS-IN LBS LBS/IN LBS/IN**2
********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
0.0000 5.9580E-02 7.9518E-17 -1.4396E+05 -2.7107E-10 1240.4 0.0000 747.06
2.6571 5.4341E-02 7.5827E-17 -1.0377E+05 -2.0315E-10 1228.8 0.0000 705.00
5.3143 4.6339E-02 6.6727E-17 -6.3040E+04 -1.3418E-10 1228.8 0.0000 662.37
7.9714 3.6658E-02 5.4054E-17 -2.1988E+04 -6.4518E-11 1228.8 0.0000 619.41
10.629 2.6392E-02 3.9663E-17 1.9178E+04 5.4749E-12 1228.4 2.4981E-02 616.47
13.286 1.6636E-02 2.5418E-17 6.0219E+04 7.5401E-11 1227.7 2.1422E-02 659.42
15.943 8.4842E-03 1.3181E-17 1.0093E+05 1.4491E-10 650.45 36.185 702.02
18.600 3.0194E-03 4.8017E-18 1.0433E+05 1.5651E-10 417.51 30.802 705.58
21.257 3.3262E-04 5.8996E-19 7.5879E+04 1.1751E-10 1186.5 17.433 675.81
23.914 -3.3381E-04 -4.9284E-19 2.9314E+04 4.6471E-11 1153.8 19.483 627.08
26.571 -2.1973E-04 -3.3829E-19 2406.1 4.4361E-12 539.10 19.074 598.92
29.229 -4.1574E-05 -6.5631E-20 -5121.8 -7.7647E-12 61.699 10.871 601.76
31.886 2.0184E-07 2.8671E-22 -1571.0 -2.4777E-12 80.387 1.9586 598.05
34.543 1.4719E-07 2.3193E-22 -3.4757 -6.6527E-15 24.721 1.5330 596.40
37.200 6.6236E-13 1.0974E-27 5.5281 8.7103E-15 5.4057E-02 1.4265E-02 596.41
39.857 -2.5670E-14 -4.0446E-29 2.6804E-05 4.4251E-20 8.6687E-02 5.4373E-03 596.40
42.514 -4.1139E-20 -6.7709E-35 -9.6407E-07 -1.5190E-21 4.2024E-07 2.8256E-08 596.40
45.171 1.3806E-21 2.1753E-36 -1.6487E-12 -2.7063E-27 1.5118E-08 9.4823E-10 596.40
47.829 2.5092E-27 4.1089E-42 5.1850E-14 8.1697E-29 2.5850E-14 1.7234E-15 596.40
50.486 -7.4250E-29 -1.1699E-43 9.9814E-20 1.6311E-34 8.1306E-16 5.0998E-17 596.40
53.143 -1.5090E-34 -2.4612E-49 -2.7886E-21 -4.3938E-36 1.5650E-21 1.0365E-22 596.40
55.800 3.9934E-36 0.0000 -5.9674E-27 -9.7163E-42 4.3728E-23 2.7428E-24 596.40
58.457 8.9739E-42 0.0000 1.4998E-28 2.3631E-43 0.0000 0.0000 596.40
61.114 -2.1477E-43 0.0000 3.5316E-34 5.7334E-49 0.0000 0.0000 596.40
63.771 -5.2879E-49 0.0000 -8.0661E-36 -1.2709E-50 0.0000 0.0000 596.40
66.429 1.1551E-50 0.0000 -2.0727E-41 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 596.40
69.086 0.0000 0.0000 4.3381E-43 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 596.40
71.743 0.0000 0.0000 1.2080E-48 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 596.40
74.400 0.0000 0.0000 -2.3331E-50 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 596.40
77.057 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 596.40
79.714 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 596.40
82.371 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 596.40
85.029 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 596.40
87.686 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 596.40
90.343 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 596.40
93.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 596.40

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-29

2.2.6 Summary Results File

=========================================================================

GROUP for Windows, Version 2016.10.8

Serial Number : 136089307

Analysis of A Group of Piles

Subjected to Axial and Lateral Loading

(c) Copyright ENSOFT, Inc., 1987-2015

All Rights Reserved

=========================================================================

-------------------------------------------------------------------------
Time and Date of Analysis
-------------------------------------------------------------------------

Date: May 09, 2016 Time: 18:14:30

***** COMPUTATION RESULTS *****

EXAMPLE PROBLEM 1 - 3D, P-Y CURVES GENERATED INTERNALLY

***** LOAD CASES RESULTS *****

LOAD CASE : 1
CASE NAME : Load Case 1
LOAD TYPE : Special, Sp

* TABLE L * COMPUTATION ON PILE CAP

* EQUIVALENT CONCENTRATED LOAD AT ORIGIN *

VERT. LOAD, LBS HOR. LOAD Y, LBS HOR. LOAD Z, LBS

8.44000E+05 36400.0 0.00000

MOMENT X ,LBS-IN MOMENT Y,LBS-IN MOMENT Z,LBS-IN

0.00000 0.00000 -1.68168E+07

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-30

* DISPLACEMENT OF GROUPED PILE FOUNDATION AT ORIGIN *

VERTICAL ,IN HORIZONTAL Y,IN HORIZONTAL Z,IN

0.0779912 0.0841969 4.65529E-18

ANGLE ROT. X,RAD ANGLE ROT. Y,RAD ANGLE ROT. Z,RAD

5.94148E-19 1.51212E-19 -1.04205E-04

* TABLE M * COMPUTATION ON INDIVIDUAL PILE

THE GLOBAL STRUCTURAL COORDINATE SYSTEM

---------------------------------------

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS *

PILE GROUP DISP. X,IN DISP. Y,IN DISP. Z,IN ROT. X,RAD ROT. Y,RAD ROT. Z,RAD
********** *********** *********** *********** *********** *********** ***********
1 0.064861 0.084197 -7.0207E-17 5.9415E-19 1.5121E-19 -1.0420E-04
2 0.068613 0.084197 -5.0161E-17 5.9292E-19 1.5121E-19 -1.0420E-04
3 0.087370 0.084197 5.9126E-17 5.9292E-19 1.5121E-19 -1.0420E-04
4 0.068613 0.084197 -5.0258E-17 5.9292E-19 1.5121E-19 -1.0420E-04
5 0.087370 0.084197 5.9029E-17 5.9292E-19 1.5121E-19 -1.0420E-04
6 0.091121 0.084197 7.9518E-17 5.9415E-19 1.5121E-19 -1.0420E-04

MINIMUM 0.064861 0.084197 -7.0207E-17 5.9292E-19 1.5121E-19 -1.0420E-04

Pile N. 1 1 1 2 1 1
MAXIMUM 0.091121 0.084197 7.9518E-17 5.9415E-19 1.5121E-19 -1.0420E-04
Pile N. 6 1 6 1 1 1

* PILE TOP REACTIONS *

PILE GROUP FOR. X,LBS FOR. Y,LBS FOR. Z,LBS MOM X,LBS-IN MOM Y,LBS-IN MOM Z,LBS-IN
********** *********** *********** *********** *********** *********** ***********
1 8.2959E+04 -1.8663E+04 -2.6095E-12 1.2208E-10 3.6543E-10 2.5013E+05
2 1.2978E+05 1756.1 -2.1345E+04 3.6349E+04 -3.6618E+04 2.1234E+05
3 1.5716E+05 1744.0 -2.5835E+04 3.6304E+04 -4.6561E+04 2.1207E+05
4 1.2978E+05 1756.1 2.1345E+04 -3.6349E+04 3.6618E+04 2.1234E+05
5 1.5716E+05 1744.0 2.5835E+04 -3.6304E+04 4.6561E+04 2.1207E+05
6 1.8716E+05 4.8063E+04 2.1079E-12 9.8592E-11 -2.5477E-10 1.4396E+05

MINIMUM 8.2959E+04 -1.8663E+04 -2.5835E+04 -3.6349E+04 -4.6561E+04 1.4396E+05

Pile N. 1 1 3 4 3 6
MAXIMUM 1.8716E+05 4.8063E+04 2.5835E+04 3.6349E+04 4.6561E+04 2.5013E+05
Pile N. 6 6 5 2 5 1

THE PILE COORDINATE SYSTEM (LOCAL AXES)

---------------------------------------

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS *

PILE GROUP DISP. x,IN DISP. y,IN DISP. z,IN ROT. x,RAD ROT. y,RAD ROT. z,RAD
********** *********** *********** *********** *********** *********** ***********
1 0.042504 0.097414 -7.0207E-17 5.3973E-19 2.9080E-19 -1.0420E-04
2 0.067679 -0.011280 0.084197 1.7131E-05 1.0279E-04 1.7035E-19
3 0.086181 -0.014363 0.084197 1.7131E-05 1.0279E-04 1.7035E-19
4 0.067679 -0.011280 -0.084197 -1.7131E-05 -1.0279E-04 -1.5759E-19
5 0.086181 -0.014363 -0.084197 -1.7131E-05 -1.0279E-04 -1.5759E-19
6 0.1088 0.059580 7.9518E-17 6.1308E-19 2.5806E-21 -1.0420E-04

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-31

MINIMUM 0.042504 -0.014363 -0.084197 -1.7131E-05 -1.0279E-04 -1.0420E-04

Pile N. 1 3 4 4 4 1
MAXIMUM 0.1088 0.097414 0.084197 1.7131E-05 1.0279E-04 1.7035E-19
Pile N. 6 1 2 2 2 2

* PILE TOP REACTIONS *

PILE GROUP AXIAL,LBS LAT. y,LBS LAT. z,LBS MOM x,LBS-IN MOM y,LBS-IN MOM z,LBS-IN
********** *********** *********** *********** *********** *********** ***********
1 8.5008E+04 2014.6 -2.6095E-12 2.9801E-11 3.8413E-10 2.5013E+05
2 1.3152E+05 -279.97 1756.1 945.90 -2.1543E+05 -3.6618E+04
3 1.5927E+05 -354.36 1744.0 945.90 -2.1515E+05 -4.6561E+04
4 1.3152E+05 -279.97 -1756.1 -945.90 2.1543E+05 -3.6618E+04
5 1.5927E+05 -354.36 -1744.0 -945.90 2.1515E+05 -4.6561E+04
6 1.9323E+05 1228.8 2.1079E-12 3.3851E-11 -2.7107E-10 1.4396E+05

MINIMUM 8.5008E+04 -354.36 -1756.1 -945.90 -2.1543E+05 -4.6561E+04

Pile N. 1 3 4 4 2 3
MAXIMUM 1.9323E+05 2014.6 1756.1 945.90 2.1543E+05 2.5013E+05
Pile N. 6 1 2 2 4 1

PILE GROUP STRESS,LBS/IN**2

********** ****************
1 524.14
2 634.60
3 721.95
4 634.60
5 721.95
6 747.06

MINIMUM 524.14
Pile N. 1
MAXIMUM 747.06
Pile N. 6

* EFFECTS FOR LATERALLY LOADED PILE *

* MINIMUM VALUES AND LOCATIONS *

PILE DISPL. DISPL. MOMENT MOMENT SHEAR SOIL REACT TOTAL

y-DIR z-DIR z-DIR y-DIR y-z-DIR y-z-DIR STRESS
IN IN LBS-IN LBS-IN LBS LBS/IN LBS/IN**2
****** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
1 -4.5729E-04 -7.4366E-17 -2.5013E+05 -1.5277E-10 0.0000 0.0000 262.37
x(FT) 26.571 2.6571 0.0000 18.600 61.114 0.0000 47.829
2 -0.011280 -3.7164E-04 -2.0552E+04 -2.1543E+05 0.0000 0.0000 405.92
x(FT) 0.0000 26.571 18.600 0.0000 58.457 0.0000 50.486
3 -0.014363 -3.7383E-04 -2.6156E+04 -2.1515E+05 0.0000 0.0000 491.58
x(FT) 0.0000 26.571 18.600 0.0000 58.457 0.0000 50.486
4 -0.011280 -0.084197 -2.0552E+04 -1.4201E+05 0.0000 0.0000 405.92
x(FT) 0.0000 0.0000 18.600 18.600 58.457 0.0000 50.486
5 -0.014363 -0.084197 -2.6156E+04 -1.4193E+05 0.0000 0.0000 491.58
x(FT) 0.0000 0.0000 18.600 18.600 58.457 0.0000 50.486
6 -3.3381E-04 -4.9284E-19 -1.4396E+05 -2.7107E-10 0.0000 0.0000 596.40
x(FT) 23.914 23.914 0.0000 0.0000 58.457 0.0000 45.171

Min. -0.014363 -0.084197 -2.5013E+05 -2.1543E+05 0.0000 0.0000 262.37

Pile N. 3 4 1 2 1 1 1

* MAXIMUM VALUES AND LOCATIONS *

PILE DISPL. DISPL. MOMENT MOMENT SHEAR SOIL REACT TOTAL

y-DIR z-DIR z-DIR y-DIR y-z-DIR y-z-DIR STRESS
IN IN LBS-IN LBS-IN LBS LBS/IN LBS/IN**2
****** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
1 0.097414 4.9497E-19 1.5945E+05 3.8413E-10 2023.4 46.733 524.14

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-32

x(FT) 0.0000 26.571 18.600 0.0000 0.0000 15.943 0.0000

2 5.4971E-05 0.084197 3.6618E+04 1.4201E+05 1790.3 44.414 634.60
x(FT) 26.571 0.0000 0.0000 18.600 0.0000 15.943 0.0000
3 7.0423E-05 0.084197 4.6561E+04 1.4193E+05 1794.3 44.529 721.95
x(FT) 26.571 0.0000 0.0000 18.600 0.0000 15.943 0.0000
4 5.4971E-05 3.7164E-04 3.6618E+04 2.1543E+05 1790.3 44.414 634.60
x(FT) 26.571 26.571 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 15.943 0.0000
5 7.0423E-05 3.7383E-04 4.6561E+04 2.1515E+05 1794.3 44.529 721.95
x(FT) 26.571 26.571 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 15.943 0.0000
6 0.059580 7.9518E-17 1.0433E+05 1.5651E-10 1240.4 36.185 747.06
x(FT) 0.0000 0.0000 18.600 18.600 0.0000 15.943 0.0000

Max. 0.097414 0.084197 1.5945E+05 2.1543E+05 2023.4 46.733 747.06

Pile N. 1 2 1 4 1 1 6

***** SUMMARY FOR LOAD CASES AND COMBINATIONS *****

***** LOAD CASES RESULTS *****

LOAD CASE : 1

* TABLE L * COMPUTATION ON PILE CAP

* EQUIVALENT CONCENTRATED LOAD AT ORIGIN *

LOAD X,LBS LOAD Y,LBS LOAD Z,LBS MOM X,LBS-IN MOM Y,LBS-IN MOM Z,LBS-IN
8.44000E+05 36400.0 0.00000 0.00000 0.00000 -1.68168E+07

* DISPLACEMENT OF GROUPED PILE FOUNDATION AT ORIGIN *

DISP X,IN DISP Y,IN DISP Z,IN ROT X,RAD ROT Y,RAD ROT Z,RAD
0.0779912 0.0841969 4.65529E-18 5.94148E-19 1.51212E-19 -1.04205E-04

* TABLE M * COMPUTATION ON INDIVIDUAL PILE

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS, GLOBAL *

DISP. X,IN DISP. Y,IN DISP. Z,IN ROT. X,RAD ROT. Y,RAD ROT. Z,RAD
*********** *********** *********** *********** *********** ***********
MINIMUM 0.064861 0.084197 -7.0207E-17 5.9292E-19 1.5121E-19 -1.0420E-04
Pile N. 1 1 1 2 1 1
MAXIMUM 0.091121 0.084197 7.9518E-17 5.9415E-19 1.5121E-19 -1.0420E-04
Pile N. 6 1 6 1 1 1

* PILE TOP REACTIONS, GLOBAL *

FOR. X,LBS FOR. Y,LBS FOR. Z,LBS MOM X,LBS-IN MOM Y,LBS-IN MOM Z,LBS-IN
*********** *********** *********** *********** *********** ***********
MINIMUM 8.2959E+04 -1.8663E+04 -2.5835E+04 -3.6349E+04 -4.6561E+04 1.4396E+05
Pile N. 1 1 3 4 3 6
MAXIMUM 1.8716E+05 4.8063E+04 2.5835E+04 3.6349E+04 4.6561E+04 2.5013E+05
Pile N. 6 6 5 2 5 1

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS, LOCAL *

DISP. x,IN DISP. y,IN DISP. z,IN ROT. x,RAD ROT. y,RAD ROT. z,RAD
*********** *********** *********** *********** *********** ***********
MINIMUM 0.042504 -0.014363 -0.084197 -1.7131E-05 -1.0279E-04 -1.0420E-04
Pile N. 1 3 4 4 4 1
MAXIMUM 0.1088 0.097414 0.084197 1.7131E-05 1.0279E-04 1.7035E-19
Pile N. 6 1 2 2 2 2

* PILE TOP REACTIONS, LOCAL *

AXIAL,LBS LAT. y,LBS LAT. z,LBS MOM x,LBS-IN MOM y,LBS-IN MOM z,LBS-IN
*********** *********** *********** *********** *********** ***********
MINIMUM 8.5008E+04 -354.36 -1756.1 -945.90 -2.1543E+05 -4.6561E+04
Pile N. 1 3 4 4 2 3

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-33

MAXIMUM 1.9323E+05 2014.6 1756.1 945.90 2.1543E+05 2.5013E+05

Pile N. 6 1 2 2 4 1

* EFFECTS FOR LATERALLY LOADED PILE *

PILE DISPL. DISPL. MOMENT MOMENT SHEAR SOIL REACT TOTAL

y-DIR z-DIR z-DIR y-DIR y-z-DIR y-z-DIR STRESS
IN IN LBS-IN LBS-IN LBS LBS/IN LBS/IN**2
****** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
Min. -0.014363 -0.084197 -2.5013E+05 -2.1543E+05 0.0000 0.0000 262.37
Pile N. 3 4 1 2 1 1 1
Max. 0.097414 0.084197 1.5945E+05 2.1543E+05 2023.4 46.733 747.06
Pile N. 1 2 1 4 1 1 6

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-34

2.2.7 Graphs

Figure 2.4 Curves Resultant Deflection vs. Distance for Example Problem 1 - 3D.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-35

Figure 2.5 Curves Resultant Moment vs. Distance for Example Problem 1 - 3D.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-36

2.3 Example Problem 2 - 3D

2.3.1 Model Description

This example serves the purpose of demonstrating the pile group subjected to lateral forces
from both longitudinal and transverse directions. The pile group consists of four drilled shafts of 36
inches in diameter that are arranged un-symmetrically with respect to the pile cap because one pile was
installed with a batter angle accidentally. The center to center spacing is 3 pile diameters. These piles
are rigidly connected to the pile cap. The group of piles is subjected to loads applied at the bottom of
the pile cap.The global origin of coordinates is set at the point of application of loads.

The subsurface layers consist of 15 ft of soft clay (c = 4 psi, 50 = 0.02) underlain by 20 ft stiff clay
(c = 16 psi, 50 = 0.005) A layer of dense sand with an internal friction angle of 38 degrees is encountered
at depths of 35 ft to 70 ft below the ground surface. This example asks the program to generate the
curves of axial load versus displacement, torque versus rotation, and p-y curves internally.

The Y-direction is defined as longitudinal direction and the Z-direction is defined as the
transversed direction. The component forces on the pile cap are: 600 kips at the X direction
(downward), 75 kips at the Y direction (lateral), 50 kips at the Z direction (lateral), a moment of 2000 ft-
kips on the XY plane, and moment of 1000 ft-kips on the XZ plane.

The input and output files for the example problem are shown in the following pages.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-37

Figure 2.6 General Description of Example Problem 2 - 3D.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-38

2.3.2 Input Data

EXAMPLE PROBLEM 2 - 3D, Pile group subjected to both longl and transverse loads
GROUP2016.10.8
* Analysis Parameters
1 3 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 1
* Pile Cap Dimensions
0 0 0 0 0 0
* Load Cases
1 0 0 1 0
0 1 1 1 1 100 100
1E-5 1E-5 1 1
Load Case 1
12 0 0 0 1 0 0 0
2 2 1 0 1E-7 1E-5 0 0 0
1
0 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 0 0 0 1 0 0 1 0 1 0 0 0 0 1 1
1
600000 75000 24000000 50000 12000000 0 0 0 0
0
0
* Load Combinations
0 0 0 1 0
* Distributed Load Sets
1
1
0 0
* Pile Group Configuration
4
2 2 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 1
0 0 1 1 1 1 1
0 -4.5 -4.5 0 90 0 0
2 2 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 1
0 0 1 1 1 1 1
0 -4.5 4.5 0 90 0 0
2 2 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 1
0 0 1 1 1 1 1
0 4.5 -4.5 0 90 0 0
2 2 1 0 0 0 0 0 2 2
0 0 1 1 1 1 1
0 4.5 4.5 90 80.5 0 0
* Pile Properties
1
0 1
60 60 1
0 60 1
* Pile Cross Sections
1
0 0 0 0
Section 1
36 0 1 1 0 0 0.1 0.1
1 1018 82448 82448 0 1.48E11 0 0 3600000 0 0
0 0 0 0 1
None
* Soil Layers
3
0 1
0 15
2 10
52.46208 576 0 500 0 0.02 0 576 0 0
52.46208 576 0 500 0 0.02 0 576 0 0
1 3
15 35
2 10
52.46208 2304 0 1000 0 0.005 0 1728 0 0
52.46208 2304 0 1000 0 0.005 0 1728 0 0
2 4

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-39

35 70
2 10
52.46208 0 38 150 0 0 0 2880 0 0
52.46208 0 38 150 0 0 0 2880 0 0
* Generated LD curves
2
1
4
* Generated TR curves
2
1
4
* User defined MC curves
1
1 1
0
1 1
0 0
* Internally Generated MC curves
1
1 1
0
0
1 1
0 0
1 1
0
0
1 1
0 0
* End of file

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-40

2.3.3 Echo Print File

=========================================================================

GROUP for Windows, Version 2016.10.8

Serial Number : 136089307

Analysis of A Group of Piles

Subjected to Axial and Lateral Loading

(c) Copyright ENSOFT, Inc., 1987-2015

All Rights Reserved

=========================================================================

This program is licensed to :

ENSOFT, INC
AUSTIN, TX

Path to file locations : C:\projects\GROUP2016\Group2016_1008\DXE\Examples_2016\

Name of input data file : 3Dexample2.gp10r
Name of output echo file : 3Dexample2.gp10e
Name of output results file : 3Dexample2.gp10o
Name of output summary file : 3Dexample2.gp10t
Name of plot output file : 3Dexample2.gp10p
Name of runtime file : 3Dexample2.gp10r

-------------------------------------------------------------------------
Time and Date of Analysis
-------------------------------------------------------------------------

Date: May 09, 2016 Time: 18:14:30

***** INPUT INFORMATION *****

EXAMPLE PROBLEM 2 - 3D, Pile group subjected to both longl and transverse loads

ANALYSIS TYPE = 3D ANALYSIS

ADJUST DEPTH FOR BATTER PILES

GENERATE LOAD-DISP (AND T-R) CURVES BASED ON SOIL PROFILE

EXTEND INTERPOLATION FOR L-DP (AND T-R) CURVES

UNITS SYSTEM = ENGL

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-41

* TABLE C * LOAD AND CONTROL PARAMETERS

** LOAD CASES **

NUMBER OF LOAD CASES : 1

LOAD CASE : 1
CASE NAME : Load Case 1
LOAD TYPE : Special, Sp
SCALE FACTOR : 1.0000

* CONCENTRATED LOADS *

NL VERT.LOAD HR.LOAD Y HR.LOAD Z MOMENT X MOMENT Y MOMENT Z COORD X COORD Y COORD Z

LBS LBS LBS LBS-IN LBS-IN LBS-IN FT FT FT
1 6.00E+05 7.50E+04 5.00E+04 0.00 1.20E+07 2.40E+07 0.00 0.00 0.00

* EQUIVALENT CONCENTRATED LOAD AT ORIGIN *

VER.LOAD X,LBS HOR.LOAD Y,LBS HOR.LOAD Z,LBS

6.00000E+05 75000.0 50000.0

MOMENT X,LBS-IN MOMENT Y,LBS-IN MOMENT Z,LBS-IN

0.00000 1.20000E+07 2.40000E+07

* THE LOADING IS STATIC *

* CONTROL PARAMETERS *
TOLERANCE ON CONVERGENCE OF PILE CAP MOVEMENT = 1.00000E-05
TOLERANCE ON DETERMINATION OF PILE DEFLECTIONS = 1.00000E-05 IN
MAX NO OF ITERATIONS ALLOWED FOR FOUNDATION ANALYSIS = 100
MAXIMUM NO OF ITERATIONS ALLOWED FOR PILE ANALYSIS = 100
FACTOR TO APPLY THE LOAD IN INCREMENTS = 1.0000
MINIMUM FACTOR FOR LOAD INCREMENTS = 1.0000
PRINT RESULTS AT PILE CAP, PILE HEADS AND ALONG PILES
PRINT RESULTS EVERY 2 NODE(S)

** SETS OF DISTRIBUTED LOAD **

NUMBER OF SETS : 1

DIST. LOAD SET : 1

NL DEPTH LOAD
(FT) (LBS)
1 0.0000 0.0000

* TABLE D * ARRANGEMENT OF PILE GROUPS

GROUP CONN.Z-Z CONN.Y-Y PILE PROP P-Y CURVE L-S CURVE T-R CURVE R-F-L SET

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-42

1 FIX FIX 1 0 1 G 1 G 0
2 FIX FIX 1 0 1 G 1 G 0
3 FIX FIX 1 0 1 G 1 G 0
4 FIX FIX 1 0 2 G 2 G 0

GROUP CorX,FT CorY,FT CorZ,FT ALPHA,DEG BETA,DEG THETA,DEG GROUND,FT SPz,LBS-IN

SPy,LBS-IN
1 0.000 -4.500 -4.500 0.000 90.00 0.000 0.000 0.000
0.000
2 0.000 -4.500 4.500 0.000 90.00 0.000 0.000 0.000
0.000
3 0.000 4.500 -4.500 0.000 90.00 0.000 0.000 0.000
0.000
4 0.000 4.500 4.500 90.00 80.50 0.000 0.000 0.000
0.000

* TABLE E * PILE GEOMETRY AND PROPERTIES

PILE TYPE = 1 - DRIVEN PILE
= 2 - DRILLED SHAFT

PROP SECTS INC PILE TYPE LENGTH, FT

1 1 60 1 60.000

* PILE SECTIONS *

PROP SECT FROM,FT TO,FT CROSS SECT

1 1 0.00000 60.0000 1

* PILE CROSS SECTIONS *

CROSS SECTION : 1
SECTION NAME : Section

TYPE : ELASTIC
CROSS SECTION TYPE : GENERAL SECTION
EQUIVALENT DIAMETER : 36.0000 IN
YOUNG MODULUS : 3.60000E+06 LBS/IN**2

* PILE CROSS SECTIONS PROPERTIES *

ELASTIC SECTIONS

SECT DIAM,IN AREA,IN**2 Iz,IN**4 Iy,IN**4 GJ,LBS-IN**2 Mn,LBS-IN Vn,LBS

1 36.000 1018.0 8.2448E+04 8.2448E+04 1.4800E+11 0.0000 0.0000

* TABLE F * SOIL DATA

SOILS INFORMATION

GROUND SURFACE = 0.00000 FT

3 LAYER(S) OF SOIL

LAYER 1
THE SOIL IS A SOFT CLAY
TOP OF LAYER BOTTOM OF LAYER
X COORDINATE (FT) 0.00000 15.0000
EFFECTIVE UNIT WEIGHT (LBS/FT**3) 52.4621 52.4621
UNDRAINED COHESION, C (LBS/FT**2) 576.000 576.000

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-43

STRAIN AT 50% STRESS 0.0200000 0.0200000

ULTIMATE UNIT SIDE FRICTION (LBS/FT**2) 576.000 576.000
ULTIMATE UNIT TIP RESISTANCE (LBS/FT**2) 0.00000 0.00000

LAYER 2
THE SOIL IS A STIFF CLAY WITHOUT FREE WATER
TOP OF LAYER BOTTOM OF LAYER
X COORDINATE (FT) 15.0000 35.0000
EFFECTIVE UNIT WEIGHT (LBS/FT**3) 52.4621 52.4621
UNDRAINED COHESION, C (LBS/FT**2) 2304.00 2304.00
STRAIN AT 50% STRESS 5.00000E-03 5.00000E-03
ULTIMATE UNIT SIDE FRICTION (LBS/FT**2) 1728.00 1728.00
ULTIMATE UNIT TIP RESISTANCE (LBS/FT**2) 0.00000 0.00000

LAYER 3
THE SOIL IS A SAND
TOP OF LAYER BOTTOM OF LAYER
X COORDINATE (FT) 35.0000 70.0000
EFFECTIVE UNIT WEIGHT (LBS/FT**3) 52.4621 52.4621
FRICTION ANGLE (DEGREES) 38.0000 38.0000
P-Y SUBGRADE MODULUS (LBS/IN**3) 150.000 150.000
ULTIMATE UNIT SIDE FRICTION (LBS/FT**2) 2880.00 2880.00
ULTIMATE UNIT TIP RESISTANCE (LBS/FT**2) 84464.5 (R) 1.68929E+05 (R)

Notes : Program estimated values for listed parameters

if zero input values were entered:
(R) ULTIMATE UNIT TIP RESISTANCE for Driven Piles

* TABLE H * AXIAL LOAD VS DISPLACEMENT

AXIAL LOAD-DISPLACEMENT CURVES GENERATED INTERNALLY

NUM OF CURVES 2

CURVE 1 NUM OF POINTS 19

DISPLACEMENT, IN AXIAL LOAD,LBS

-2.12111 -9.86008E+05
-1.11148 -9.24111E+05
-0.60667 -8.93163E+05
-0.16868 -6.55465E+05
-0.10357 -5.64143E+05
-0.0238350 -1.56770E+05
-0.0117984 -76040.3
-2.35879E-03 -15160.5
-2.35880E-04 -1516.06
0.00000 0.00000
0.0114398 90212.6
0.0192099 1.49748E+05
0.0542049 4.18806E+05
0.0763110 5.62596E+05
0.16895 9.02082E+05
0.24798 1.05881E+06
0.73669 1.55543E+06
1.27144 1.73884E+06
2.31186 1.95758E+06

CURVE 2 NUM OF POINTS 19

DISPLACEMENT, IN AXIAL LOAD,LBS

-2.12111 -9.86008E+05
-1.11148 -9.24111E+05
-0.60667 -8.93163E+05
-0.16868 -6.55465E+05
-0.10357 -5.64143E+05

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-44

-0.0238350 -1.56770E+05
-0.0117984 -76040.3
-2.35879E-03 -15160.5
-2.35880E-04 -1516.06
0.00000 0.00000
0.0112839 88956.7
0.0189700 1.47800E+05
0.0536272 4.14352E+05
0.0756308 5.57944E+05
0.16808 8.97643E+05
0.24690 1.05322E+06
0.73491 1.54635E+06
1.26924 1.72767E+06
2.30924 1.94426E+06

* TABLE I * TORS. MOM. VS ANGLE ROT.

TORQUE-ROTATION CURVES GENERATED INTERNALLY

NUM OF CURVES 2

CURVE 1 NUM OF POINTS 19

ROT. ANGLE,Rad. TORS.MOMEN,LBS-IN

-0.16524 -1.74729E+07
-0.10537 -1.63521E+07
-0.0754371 -1.57917E+07
-0.0376416 -1.18271E+07
-0.0281931 -1.01178E+07
-0.0144981 -6.92056E+06
-8.91777E-03 -4.83741E+06
-1.81805E-03 -1.10882E+06
-1.80485E-04 -1.08704E+05
0.00000 0.00000
1.80485E-04 1.08704E+05
1.81805E-03 1.10882E+06
8.91777E-03 4.83741E+06
0.0144981 6.92056E+06
0.0281931 1.01178E+07
0.0376416 1.18271E+07
0.0754371 1.57917E+07
0.10537 1.63521E+07
0.16524 1.74729E+07

CURVE 2 NUM OF POINTS 19

ROT. ANGLE,Rad. TORS.MOMEN,LBS-IN

-0.16524 -1.74729E+07
-0.10537 -1.63521E+07
-0.0754371 -1.57917E+07
-0.0376416 -1.18271E+07
-0.0281931 -1.01178E+07
-0.0144981 -6.92056E+06
-8.91777E-03 -4.83741E+06
-1.81805E-03 -1.10882E+06
-1.80485E-04 -1.08704E+05
0.00000 0.00000
1.80485E-04 1.08704E+05
1.81805E-03 1.10882E+06
8.91777E-03 4.83741E+06
0.0144981 6.92056E+06
0.0281931 1.01178E+07
0.0376416 1.18271E+07
0.0754371 1.57917E+07
0.10537 1.63521E+07
0.16524 1.74729E+07

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-45

* TABLE J * MOMENT CURVATURE SETS

USER DEFINED MOMENT CURVATURE

NUM OF SETS : 1

CURVE SET 1 NUM OF CURVES 1

CURVE 1 AXIAL LOAD 0.000E+00 LBS

POINT MOMENT CURVATURE

LBS-IN RADIAN/IN
1 0.00000 0.00000

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-46

2.3.4 Processor Run Notes

GROUP for Windows, Version 2016.10.8

-------------------------------------------------------------------------
Time and Date of Analysis
-------------------------------------------------------------------------

Date: May 09, 2016 Time: 18:14:30

EXAMPLE PROBLEM 2 - 3D, Pile group subjected to both longl and transverse loads

READING * TITLE AND VERSION

READING * Analysis Parameters
READING * Pile Cap Dimensions
READING * Load Cases
READING * Load Combinations
READING * Distributed Load Sets
READING * Pile Group Configuration
READING * Pile Properties
READING * Pile Cross Sections
READING * Soil Layers
READING * Generated LD curves
READING * Generated TR curves
READING * User defined MC curves
READING * Internally Generated MC curves

COMPUTATION IS PROCEEDING......

LOAD CASE : 1
CASE NAME : Load Case 1

GLOBAL ITERATIONS
STEP 1, TCUR 1.0000, DTCUR 1.0000
ITERATION 1
- ErrDsp 0.10000E+01, IncDsp 0.17915E-01, TotDsp 0.17915E-01
- ErrRot 0.10000E+01, IncRot 0.19457E-03, TotRot 0.19457E-03
ITERATION 2
- ErrDsp 0.64735E+00, IncDsp 0.15838E-01, TotDsp 0.24466E-01
- ErrRot 0.33230E+00, IncRot 0.78007E-04, TotRot 0.23475E-03
ITERATION 3
- ErrDsp 0.41281E+00, IncDsp 0.14592E-01, TotDsp 0.35348E-01
- ErrRot 0.21243E+00, IncRot 0.51506E-04, TotRot 0.24246E-03
ITERATION 4
- ErrDsp 0.59078E-01, IncDsp 0.21979E-02, TotDsp 0.37204E-01
- ErrRot 0.35120E-01, IncRot 0.86081E-05, TotRot 0.24511E-03
ITERATION 5
- ErrDsp 0.97848E-03, IncDsp 0.36433E-04, TotDsp 0.37234E-01
- ErrRot 0.72638E-03, IncRot 0.17808E-06, TotRot 0.24517E-03
ITERATION 6
- ErrDsp 0.23554E-06, IncDsp 0.87703E-08, TotDsp 0.37234E-01
- ErrRot 0.17782E-06, IncRot 0.43594E-10, TotRot 0.24517E-03

NUMBER OF GLOBAL ITERATIONS = 6

ANALYSIS FOR LOAD CASE 1/ 1 FINISHED

Execution Time : 170 ms

Number Processors : 1/ 1

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-47

Serial processing : 0.099 sec

Paral. processing : 0.052 sec
Print. processing : 0.020 sec

ANALYSIS COMPLETED
Execution Time : 171 ms
Number Processors : 1/ 1

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-48

2.3.5 Output Results File

=========================================================================

GROUP for Windows, Version 2016.10.8

Serial Number : 136089307

Analysis of A Group of Piles

Subjected to Axial and Lateral Loading

(c) Copyright ENSOFT, Inc., 1987-2015

All Rights Reserved

=========================================================================

This program is licensed to :

ENSOFT, INC
AUSTIN, TX

Path to file locations : C:\projects\GROUP2016\Group2016_1008\DXE\Examples_2016\

Name of input data file : 3Dexample2.gp10d
Name of output echo file : 3Dexample2.gp10e
Name of output results file : 3Dexample2.gp10o
Name of output summary file : 3Dexample2.gp10t
Name of plot output file : 3Dexample2.gp10p
Name of runtime file : 3Dexample2.gp10r

-------------------------------------------------------------------------
Time and Date of Analysis
-------------------------------------------------------------------------

Date: May 09, 2016 Time: 18:14:30

***** COMPUTATION RESULTS *****

EXAMPLE PROBLEM 2 - 3D, Pile group subjected to both longl and transverse loads

***** LOAD CASES RESULTS *****

LOAD CASE : 1
CASE NAME : Load Case 1

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-49

LOAD TYPE : Special, Sp

* TABLE L * COMPUTATION ON PILE CAP

* EQUIVALENT CONCENTRATED LOAD AT ORIGIN *

VERT. LOAD, LBS HOR. LOAD Y, LBS HOR. LOAD Z, LBS

6.00000E+05 75000.0 50000.0

MOMENT X ,LBS-IN MOMENT Y,LBS-IN MOMENT Z,LBS-IN

0.00000 1.20000E+07 2.40000E+07

* DISPLACEMENT OF GROUPED PILE FOUNDATION AT ORIGIN *

VERTICAL ,IN HORIZONTAL Y,IN HORIZONTAL Z,IN

0.0185937 0.0210203 0.0244710

ANGLE ROT. X,RAD ANGLE ROT. Y,RAD ANGLE ROT. Z,RAD

-7.33220E-05 1.31612E-04 1.93413E-04

NUMBER OF GLOBAL ITERATIONS = 6

* TABLE M * COMPUTATION ON INDIVIDUAL PILE

* PILE GROUP * 1

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS AND REACTIONS *

THE GLOBAL STRUCTURAL COORDINATE SYSTEM

---------------------------------------

DISP. X,IN DISP. Y,IN DISP. Z,IN ROT. X,RAD ROT. Y,RAD ROT. Z,RAD
0.021931 0.017061 0.028430 -7.3322E-05 1.3161E-04 1.9341E-04

FOR. X,LBS FOR. Y,LBS FOR. Z,LBS MOM X,LBS-IN MOM Y,LBS-IN MOM Z,LBS-IN
1.7067E+05 1.6967E+04 9104.3 -4.4161E+04 -4.7472E+05 1.7873E+06

STR,LBS/IN**2
571.39

THE PILE COORDINATE SYSTEM (LOCAL AXES)

---------------------------------------

DISP. x,IN DISP. y,IN DISP. z,IN ROT. x,RAD ROT. y,RAD ROT. z,RAD
0.021931 0.017061 0.028430 -7.3322E-05 1.3161E-04 1.9341E-04

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-50

AXIAL,LBS LAT. y,LBS LAT. z,LBS MOM x,LBS-IN MOM y,LBS-IN MOM z,LBS-IN
1.7067E+05 1.6967E+04 9104.3 -4.4161E+04 -4.7472E+05 1.7873E+06

STR,LBS/IN**2
571.39

* EFFECTS FOR LATERALLY LOADED PILE *

x DISPL. DISPL. MOMENT MOMENT SHEAR SOIL REACT TOTAL

y-DIR z-DIR z-DIR y-DIR y-z-DIR y-z-DIR STRESS
FT IN IN LBS-IN LBS-IN LBS LBS/IN LBS/IN**2
********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
0.0000 1.7061E-02 2.8430E-02 -1.7873E+06 -4.7472E+05 1.9262E+04 0.0000 571.39
2.0000 2.0067E-02 2.4864E-02 -1.3858E+06 -2.6286E+05 1.8234E+04 66.028 475.59
4.0000 2.0381E-02 2.0784E-02 -1.0076E+06 -8.0453E+04 1.6686E+04 73.398 388.32
6.0000 1.8737E-02 1.6545E-02 -6.5854E+05 7.1843E+04 1.4967E+04 78.688 312.28
8.0000 1.5810E-02 1.2441E-02 -3.4317E+05 1.9416E+05 1.3143E+04 81.500 253.73
10.000 1.2213E-02 8.7103E-03 -6.4487E+04 2.8744E+05 1.1283E+04 81.440 231.96
12.000 8.4859E-03 5.5342E-03 1.7614E+05 3.5344E+05 9469.0 78.073 253.87
14.000 5.0962E-03 3.0410E-03 3.7918E+05 3.9482E+05 7789.8 70.878 287.16
16.000 2.4381E-03 1.3114E-03 5.1818E+05 3.9873E+05 2927.8 352.32 310.39
18.000 7.6388E-04 3.4400E-04 4.8881E+05 3.1241E+05 6874.9 284.76 294.30
20.000 2.0103E-05 -2.5338E-05 3.1137E+05 1.6056E+05 1.1078E+04 133.04 244.14
22.000 -1.2521E-04 -7.5822E-05 1.0091E+05 4.4257E+04 7616.8 209.48 191.71
24.000 -6.2178E-05 -3.2840E-05 -9888.0 -9981.8 2808.9 184.93 170.72
26.000 -6.9133E-06 -3.1953E-06 -2.8151E+04 -1.5121E+04 807.36 108.73 174.63
28.000 6.1803E-07 2.9370E-07 -2271.8 -1033.2 649.55 59.286 168.20
30.000 -6.4237E-11 -3.1254E-11 172.27 80.213 42.953 4.5183 167.69
32.000 4.9285E-18 2.5286E-18 -1.8520E-02 -8.6238E-03 4.4332E-03 4.5525E-04 167.65
34.000 -2.2465E-25 -1.4332E-25 9.2004E-10 4.2842E-10 1.5219E-10 2.3022E-11 167.65
36.000 -1.7871E-18 -8.3219E-19 6.1879E-10 2.8814E-10 1.3033E-11 8.7242E-14 167.65
38.000 -2.3680E-18 -1.1026E-18 3.6127E-10 1.6823E-10 1.0422E-11 1.2500E-13 167.65
40.000 -2.2398E-18 -1.0429E-18 1.6774E-10 7.8108E-11 7.3541E-12 1.2713E-13 167.65
42.000 -1.7780E-18 -8.2793E-19 3.9838E-11 1.8551E-11 4.5109E-12 1.0798E-13 167.65
44.000 -1.2321E-18 -5.7373E-19 -3.1985E-11 -1.4894E-11 2.2524E-12 7.9719E-14 167.65
46.000 -7.4323E-19 -3.4609E-19 -6.2178E-11 -2.8953E-11 6.8747E-13 5.1039E-14 167.65
48.000 -3.7178E-19 -1.7312E-19 -6.5542E-11 -3.0520E-11 2.3986E-13 2.7007E-14 167.65
50.000 -1.2581E-19 -5.8582E-20 -5.4561E-11 -2.5406E-11 6.6925E-13 9.6386E-15 167.65
52.000 1.4897E-20 6.9368E-21 -3.8313E-11 -1.7840E-11 7.6151E-13 1.2005E-15 167.65
54.000 8.1175E-20 3.7799E-20 -2.2509E-11 -1.0482E-11 6.5829E-13 6.8639E-15 167.65
56.000 1.0334E-19 4.8119E-20 -1.0172E-11 -4.7368E-12 4.6243E-13 9.1482E-15 167.65
58.000 1.0518E-19 4.8977E-20 -2.5544E-12 -1.1895E-12 2.3441E-13 9.7290E-15 167.65
60.000 1.0145E-19 4.7239E-20 2.4811E-26 2.4811E-26 0.0000 9.7867E-15 167.65

* PILE GROUP * 2

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS AND REACTIONS *

THE GLOBAL STRUCTURAL COORDINATE SYSTEM

---------------------------------------

DISP. X,IN DISP. Y,IN DISP. Z,IN ROT. X,RAD ROT. Y,RAD ROT. Z,RAD
0.036145 0.024980 0.028430 -7.3322E-05 1.3161E-04 1.9341E-04

FOR. X,LBS FOR. Y,LBS FOR. Z,LBS MOM X,LBS-IN MOM Y,LBS-IN MOM Z,LBS-IN
2.7995E+05 1.9936E+04 8405.8 -4.4161E+04 -4.4223E+05 2.0612E+06

STR,LBS/IN**2
735.25

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-51

THE PILE COORDINATE SYSTEM (LOCAL AXES)

---------------------------------------

DISP. x,IN DISP. y,IN DISP. z,IN ROT. x,RAD ROT. y,RAD ROT. z,RAD
0.036145 0.024980 0.028430 -7.3322E-05 1.3161E-04 1.9341E-04

AXIAL,LBS LAT. y,LBS LAT. z,LBS MOM x,LBS-IN MOM y,LBS-IN MOM z,LBS-IN
2.7995E+05 1.9936E+04 8405.8 -4.4161E+04 -4.4223E+05 2.0612E+06

STR,LBS/IN**2
735.25

* EFFECTS FOR LATERALLY LOADED PILE *

x DISPL. DISPL. MOMENT MOMENT SHEAR SOIL REACT TOTAL

y-DIR z-DIR z-DIR y-DIR y-z-DIR y-z-DIR STRESS
FT IN IN LBS-IN LBS-IN LBS LBS/IN LBS/IN**2
********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
0.0000 2.4980E-02 2.8430E-02 -2.0612E+06 -4.4223E+05 2.1648E+04 0.0000 735.25
2.0000 2.7737E-02 2.4892E-02 -1.5901E+06 -2.4608E+05 2.0526E+04 69.504 626.29
4.0000 2.7406E-02 2.0872E-02 -1.1479E+06 -7.6507E+04 1.8850E+04 77.635 526.17
6.0000 2.4842E-02 1.6701E-02 -7.4051E+05 6.6056E+04 1.6991E+04 83.561 437.31
8.0000 2.0837E-02 1.2655E-02 -3.7256E+05 1.8177E+05 1.5013E+04 86.887 365.51
10.000 1.6103E-02 8.9584E-03 -4.7088E+04 2.7145E+05 1.2989E+04 87.217 335.15
12.000 1.1273E-02 5.7855E-03 2.3463E+05 3.3660E+05 1.1000E+04 84.111 364.58
14.000 6.8930E-03 3.2632E-03 4.7326E+05 3.7951E+05 9137.1 77.052 407.44
16.000 3.4264E-03 1.4750E-03 6.3937E+05 3.8864E+05 3326.7 379.60 438.36
18.000 1.1761E-03 4.3054E-04 6.1602E+05 3.1648E+05 6502.0 315.12 426.20
20.000 1.0064E-04 -7.3563E-06 4.2340E+05 1.8317E+05 1.2238E+04 190.08 375.72
22.000 -1.6647E-04 -8.8830E-05 1.6132E+05 5.9412E+04 9626.8 222.24 312.53
24.000 -1.0683E-04 -4.7702E-05 6876.8 -3821.5 4342.8 211.12 276.72
26.000 -2.0386E-05 -7.9767E-06 -3.8336E+04 -1.7990E+04 165.79 145.23 284.25
28.000 1.1155E-06 5.3487E-07 -8864.7 -3324.5 1336.7 85.861 277.07
30.000 5.4163E-09 1.7118E-09 973.49 401.61 17.443 11.776 275.23
32.000 -6.6910E-15 -2.1668E-15 -0.2390 -9.9150E-02 0.5093 8.8471E-02 275.00
34.000 1.1162E-21 3.6214E-22 1.1870E-08 4.9240E-09 6.0812E-07 1.0138E-07 275.00
36.000 -2.3062E-17 -9.5673E-18 7.9849E-09 3.3125E-09 1.6506E-10 1.1049E-12 275.00
38.000 -3.0559E-17 -1.2677E-17 4.6627E-09 1.9343E-09 1.3198E-10 1.5832E-12 275.00
40.000 -2.8906E-17 -1.1991E-17 2.1653E-09 8.9826E-10 9.3126E-11 1.6102E-12 275.00
42.000 -2.2947E-17 -9.5192E-18 5.1451E-10 2.1344E-10 5.7114E-11 1.3677E-12 275.00
44.000 -1.5901E-17 -6.5963E-18 -4.1269E-10 -1.7121E-10 2.8508E-11 1.0097E-12 275.00
46.000 -9.5905E-18 -3.9785E-18 -8.0257E-10 -3.3294E-10 8.6871E-12 6.4638E-13 275.00
48.000 -4.7960E-18 -1.9896E-18 -8.4608E-10 -3.5099E-10 3.0558E-12 3.4193E-13 275.00
50.000 -1.6213E-18 -6.7256E-19 -7.0435E-10 -2.9220E-10 8.4906E-12 1.2191E-13 275.00
52.000 1.9448E-19 8.0683E-20 -4.9461E-10 -2.0518E-10 9.6548E-12 1.5382E-14 275.00
54.000 1.0494E-18 4.3535E-19 -2.9058E-10 -1.2055E-10 8.3435E-12 8.7089E-14 275.00
56.000 1.3348E-18 5.5375E-19 -1.3131E-10 -5.4475E-11 5.8595E-12 1.1598E-13 275.00
58.000 1.3580E-18 5.6334E-19 -3.2973E-11 -1.3679E-11 2.9696E-12 1.2328E-13 275.00
60.000 1.3091E-18 5.4309E-19 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 1.2395E-13 275.00

* PILE GROUP * 3

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS AND REACTIONS *

THE GLOBAL STRUCTURAL COORDINATE SYSTEM

---------------------------------------

DISP. X,IN DISP. Y,IN DISP. Z,IN ROT. X,RAD ROT. Y,RAD ROT. Z,RAD
1.0423E-03 0.017061 0.020512 -7.3322E-05 1.3161E-04 1.9341E-04

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-52

FOR. X,LBS FOR. Y,LBS FOR. Z,LBS MOM X,LBS-IN MOM Y,LBS-IN MOM Z,LBS-IN
8219.6 1.7695E+04 5453.8 -4.4161E+04 -1.5601E+05 1.8214E+06

STR,LBS/IN**2
407.19

THE PILE COORDINATE SYSTEM (LOCAL AXES)

---------------------------------------

DISP. x,IN DISP. y,IN DISP. z,IN ROT. x,RAD ROT. y,RAD ROT. z,RAD
1.0423E-03 0.017061 0.020512 -7.3322E-05 1.3161E-04 1.9341E-04

AXIAL,LBS LAT. y,LBS LAT. z,LBS MOM x,LBS-IN MOM y,LBS-IN MOM z,LBS-IN
8219.6 1.7695E+04 5453.8 -4.4161E+04 -1.5601E+05 1.8214E+06

STR,LBS/IN**2
407.19

* EFFECTS FOR LATERALLY LOADED PILE *

x DISPL. DISPL. MOMENT MOMENT SHEAR SOIL REACT TOTAL

y-DIR z-DIR z-DIR y-DIR y-z-DIR y-z-DIR STRESS
FT IN IN LBS-IN LBS-IN LBS LBS/IN LBS/IN**2
********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
0.0000 1.7061E-02 2.0512E-02 -1.8214E+06 -1.5601E+05 1.8516E+04 0.0000 407.19
2.0000 2.0038E-02 1.7233E-02 -1.4027E+06 -3.0959E+04 1.7569E+04 61.982 314.38
4.0000 2.0291E-02 1.3892E-02 -1.0109E+06 7.0843E+04 1.6114E+04 69.384 229.31
6.0000 1.8577E-02 1.0686E-02 -6.5190E+05 1.5009E+05 1.4482E+04 74.755 154.12
8.0000 1.5594E-02 7.7678E-03 -3.3016E+05 2.0790E+05 1.2738E+04 77.685 93.253
10.000 1.1966E-02 5.2510E-03 -4.8349E+04 2.4577E+05 1.0954E+04 77.781 62.759
12.000 8.2381E-03 3.2090E-03 1.9255E+05 2.6567E+05 9207.3 74.612 79.707
14.000 4.8795E-03 1.6807E-03 3.9355E+05 2.6999E+05 7586.8 67.661 112.27
16.000 2.2801E-03 6.7474E-04 5.2710E+05 2.5178E+05 2713.9 339.30 135.60
18.000 6.8092E-04 1.5067E-04 4.8440E+05 1.8173E+05 6390.9 272.34 121.02
20.000 3.1681E-06 -2.4837E-05 2.9050E+05 7.9318E+04 1.0184E+04 118.30 73.817
22.000 -1.1188E-04 -3.8223E-05 8.5302E+04 1.7314E+04 6646.8 197.75 27.077
24.000 -4.8322E-05 -1.3543E-05 -1.5391E+04 -7712.0 2173.4 168.76 11.833
26.000 -3.2773E-06 -6.4732E-07 -2.4320E+04 -6857.3 958.02 83.066 13.591
28.000 2.6590E-07 6.5772E-08 -354.68 -3.5560 349.69 46.018 8.1517
30.000 -4.2173E-11 -1.0699E-11 13.664 2.5981 22.382 3.5363 8.0773
32.000 7.3188E-18 1.8584E-18 -7.7742E-05 -1.4846E-05 3.7301E-03 6.2059E-04 8.0742
34.000 -1.2101E-24 -3.0742E-25 3.8655E-12 7.3832E-13 6.4726E-10 1.0787E-10 8.0742
36.000 -7.5061E-21 -1.4337E-21 2.5990E-12 4.9641E-13 5.0523E-14 3.3818E-16 8.0742
38.000 -9.9442E-21 -1.8994E-21 1.5169E-12 2.8974E-13 4.0401E-14 4.8447E-16 8.0742
40.000 -9.4053E-21 -1.7965E-21 7.0409E-13 1.3448E-13 2.8511E-14 4.9269E-16 8.0742
42.000 -7.4662E-21 -1.4261E-21 1.6709E-13 3.1912E-14 1.7492E-14 4.1847E-16 8.0742
44.000 -5.1741E-21 -9.8827E-22 -1.3437E-13 -2.5667E-14 8.7392E-15 3.0897E-16 8.0742
46.000 -3.1216E-21 -5.9624E-22 -2.6105E-13 -4.9863E-14 2.6735E-15 1.9785E-16 8.0742
48.000 -1.5621E-21 -2.9837E-22 -2.7513E-13 -5.2551E-14 9.2175E-16 1.0473E-16 8.0742
50.000 -5.2939E-22 -1.0111E-22 -2.2901E-13 -4.3742E-14 2.5876E-15 3.7433E-17 8.0742
52.000 6.1502E-23 1.1750E-23 -1.6081E-13 -3.0715E-14 2.9470E-15 4.5742E-18 8.0742
54.000 3.4001E-22 6.4945E-23 -9.4481E-14 -1.8046E-14 2.5488E-15 2.6535E-17 8.0742
56.000 4.3335E-22 8.2772E-23 -4.2700E-14 -8.1559E-15 1.7911E-15 3.5407E-17 8.0742
58.000 4.4140E-22 8.4308E-23 -1.0723E-14 -2.0481E-15 9.0823E-16 3.7682E-17 8.0742
60.000 4.2605E-22 8.1375E-23 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 3.7933E-17 8.0742

* PILE GROUP * 4

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS AND REACTIONS *

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-53

THE GLOBAL STRUCTURAL COORDINATE SYSTEM

---------------------------------------

DISP. X,IN DISP. Y,IN DISP. Z,IN ROT. X,RAD ROT. Y,RAD ROT. Z,RAD
0.015256 0.024980 0.020512 -7.3322E-05 1.3161E-04 1.9341E-04

FOR. X,LBS FOR. Y,LBS FOR. Z,LBS MOM X,LBS-IN MOM Y,LBS-IN MOM Z,LBS-IN
1.4116E+05 2.0402E+04 2.7036E+04 -3.6987E+05 -7127.1 2.0629E+06

STR,LBS/IN**2
598.66

THE PILE COORDINATE SYSTEM (LOCAL AXES)

---------------------------------------

DISP. x,IN DISP. y,IN DISP. z,IN ROT. x,RAD ROT. y,RAD ROT. z,RAD
0.018433 0.017712 -0.024980 -4.0394E-05 2.0286E-04 -1.3161E-04

AXIAL,LBS LAT. y,LBS LAT. z,LBS MOM x,LBS-IN MOM y,LBS-IN MOM z,LBS-IN
1.4369E+05 3367.4 -2.0402E+04 -2.4329E+04 2.0956E+06 7127.1

STR,LBS/IN**2
598.66

* EFFECTS FOR LATERALLY LOADED PILE *

x DISPL. DISPL. MOMENT MOMENT SHEAR SOIL REACT TOTAL

y-DIR z-DIR z-DIR y-DIR y-z-DIR y-z-DIR STRESS
FT IN IN LBS-IN LBS-IN LBS LBS/IN LBS/IN**2
********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
0.0000 1.7712E-02 -2.4980E-02 -7127.1 2.0956E+06 2.0684E+04 0.0000 598.66
2.0000 1.4566E-02 -2.7934E-02 6.9643E+04 1.6139E+06 1.9630E+04 65.586 493.82
4.0000 1.1554E-02 -2.7752E-02 1.2893E+05 1.1651E+06 1.8031E+04 73.927 397.07
6.0000 8.7889E-03 -2.5304E-02 1.7182E+05 7.5523E+05 1.6241E+04 80.146 310.24
8.0000 6.3558E-03 -2.1385E-02 1.9953E+05 3.8864E+05 1.4323E+04 83.882 236.52
10.000 4.3083E-03 -1.6707E-02 2.1343E+05 6.8148E+04 1.2347E+04 84.778 190.06
12.000 2.6736E-03 -1.1890E-02 2.1509E+05 -2.0520E+05 1.0389E+04 82.439 206.05
14.000 1.4549E-03 -7.4662E-03 2.0629E+05 -4.3230E+05 8535.3 76.391 245.72
16.000 6.3558E-04 -3.8760E-03 1.8903E+05 -6.1625E+05 5073.8 385.60 281.87
18.000 1.7872E-04 -1.4551E-03 1.4443E+05 -6.2889E+05 4317.7 327.70 282.02
20.000 -6.6545E-07 -2.3188E-04 7.7216E+04 -4.5544E+05 1.0703E+04 225.47 241.99
22.000 -3.0158E-05 1.2328E-04 2.0910E+04 -1.8854E+05 9544.0 201.12 182.56
24.000 -1.5735E-05 9.8906E-05 -1769.7 -2.0370E+04 4580.1 203.31 145.61
26.000 -2.5144E-06 2.0976E-05 -6074.2 3.4199E+04 348.38 144.46 148.73
28.000 1.1998E-07 -6.0766E-07 -905.03 8829.5 1172.2 73.739 143.08
30.000 1.8443E-10 -3.0040E-09 84.058 -675.26 6.0603 10.164 141.29
32.000 -3.5116E-17 5.4799E-16 -8.4870E-03 6.7538E-02 0.2641 4.4968E-02 141.14
34.000 6.3087E-24 -9.4876E-23 1.4467E-09 -1.1512E-08 4.8125E-08 8.1817E-09 141.14
36.000 -4.6437E-24 6.8499E-23 3.2431E-15 -4.8310E-14 8.0116E-16 3.0027E-18 141.14
38.000 -9.2885E-24 1.3791E-22 2.0331E-15 -3.0305E-14 6.8227E-16 6.5362E-18 141.14
40.000 -9.9571E-24 1.4806E-22 1.0694E-15 -1.5957E-14 5.1018E-16 7.5440E-18 141.14
42.000 -8.5151E-24 1.2672E-22 3.9310E-16 -5.8813E-15 3.3494E-16 6.9075E-18 141.14
44.000 -6.2778E-24 9.3482E-23 -1.8605E-17 2.5648E-16 1.8617E-16 5.4284E-18 141.14
46.000 -4.0513E-24 6.0364E-23 -2.2132E-16 3.2822E-15 7.6397E-17 3.7201E-18 141.14
48.000 -2.2368E-24 3.3356E-23 -2.8006E-16 4.1628E-15 6.1015E-18 2.1743E-18 141.14
50.000 -9.5568E-25 1.4275E-23 -2.5405E-16 3.7797E-15 3.1174E-17 9.8129E-19 141.14
52.000 -1.6294E-25 2.4597E-24 -1.8925E-16 2.8173E-15 4.4525E-17 1.7783E-19 141.14
54.000 2.6336E-25 -3.9004E-24 -1.1683E-16 1.7401E-15 4.2686E-17 2.9590E-19 141.14
56.000 4.6154E-25 -6.8631E-24 -5.5321E-17 8.2426E-16 3.2343E-17 5.4508E-19 141.14
58.000 5.4982E-25 -8.1884E-24 -1.4586E-17 2.1742E-16 1.7550E-17 6.7946E-19 141.14
60.000 6.0661E-25 -9.0443E-24 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 7.8266E-19 141.14

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-54

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-55

2.3.6 Summary Results File

=========================================================================

GROUP for Windows, Version 2016.10.8

Serial Number : 136089307

Analysis of A Group of Piles

Subjected to Axial and Lateral Loading

(c) Copyright ENSOFT, Inc., 1987-2015

All Rights Reserved

=========================================================================

-------------------------------------------------------------------------
Time and Date of Analysis
-------------------------------------------------------------------------

Date: May 09, 2016 Time: 18:14:30

***** COMPUTATION RESULTS *****

EXAMPLE PROBLEM 2 - 3D, Pile group subjected to both longl and transverse loads

***** LOAD CASES RESULTS *****

LOAD CASE : 1
CASE NAME : Load Case 1
LOAD TYPE : Special, Sp

* TABLE L * COMPUTATION ON PILE CAP

* EQUIVALENT CONCENTRATED LOAD AT ORIGIN *

VERT. LOAD, LBS HOR. LOAD Y, LBS HOR. LOAD Z, LBS

6.00000E+05 75000.0 50000.0

MOMENT X ,LBS-IN MOMENT Y,LBS-IN MOMENT Z,LBS-IN

0.00000 1.20000E+07 2.40000E+07

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-56

* DISPLACEMENT OF GROUPED PILE FOUNDATION AT ORIGIN *

VERTICAL ,IN HORIZONTAL Y,IN HORIZONTAL Z,IN

0.0185937 0.0210203 0.0244710

ANGLE ROT. X,RAD ANGLE ROT. Y,RAD ANGLE ROT. Z,RAD

-7.33220E-05 1.31612E-04 1.93413E-04

* TABLE M * COMPUTATION ON INDIVIDUAL PILE

THE GLOBAL STRUCTURAL COORDINATE SYSTEM

---------------------------------------

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS *

PILE GROUP DISP. X,IN DISP. Y,IN DISP. Z,IN ROT. X,RAD ROT. Y,RAD ROT. Z,RAD
********** *********** *********** *********** *********** *********** ***********
1 0.021931 0.017061 0.028430 -7.3322E-05 1.3161E-04 1.9341E-04
2 0.036145 0.024980 0.028430 -7.3322E-05 1.3161E-04 1.9341E-04
3 1.0423E-03 0.017061 0.020512 -7.3322E-05 1.3161E-04 1.9341E-04
4 0.015256 0.024980 0.020512 -7.3322E-05 1.3161E-04 1.9341E-04

MINIMUM 1.0423E-03 0.017061 0.020512 -7.3322E-05 1.3161E-04 1.9341E-04

Pile N. 3 1 3 1 1 1
MAXIMUM 0.036145 0.024980 0.028430 -7.3322E-05 1.3161E-04 1.9341E-04
Pile N. 2 2 1 1 1 1

* PILE TOP REACTIONS *

PILE GROUP FOR. X,LBS FOR. Y,LBS FOR. Z,LBS MOM X,LBS-IN MOM Y,LBS-IN MOM Z,LBS-IN
********** *********** *********** *********** *********** *********** ***********
1 1.7067E+05 1.6967E+04 9104.3 -4.4161E+04 -4.7472E+05 1.7873E+06
2 2.7995E+05 1.9936E+04 8405.8 -4.4161E+04 -4.4223E+05 2.0612E+06
3 8219.6 1.7695E+04 5453.8 -4.4161E+04 -1.5601E+05 1.8214E+06
4 1.4116E+05 2.0402E+04 2.7036E+04 -3.6987E+05 -7127.1 2.0629E+06

MINIMUM 8219.6 1.6967E+04 5453.8 -3.6987E+05 -4.7472E+05 1.7873E+06

Pile N. 3 1 3 4 1 1
MAXIMUM 2.7995E+05 2.0402E+04 2.7036E+04 -4.4161E+04 -7127.1 2.0629E+06
Pile N. 2 4 4 1 4 4

THE PILE COORDINATE SYSTEM (LOCAL AXES)

---------------------------------------

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS *

PILE GROUP DISP. x,IN DISP. y,IN DISP. z,IN ROT. x,RAD ROT. y,RAD ROT. z,RAD
********** *********** *********** *********** *********** *********** ***********
1 0.021931 0.017061 0.028430 -7.3322E-05 1.3161E-04 1.9341E-04
2 0.036145 0.024980 0.028430 -7.3322E-05 1.3161E-04 1.9341E-04
3 1.0423E-03 0.017061 0.020512 -7.3322E-05 1.3161E-04 1.9341E-04
4 0.018433 0.017712 -0.024980 -4.0394E-05 2.0286E-04 -1.3161E-04

MINIMUM 1.0423E-03 0.017061 -0.024980 -7.3322E-05 1.3161E-04 -1.3161E-04

Pile N. 3 1 4 1 1 4
MAXIMUM 0.036145 0.024980 0.028430 -4.0394E-05 2.0286E-04 1.9341E-04
Pile N. 2 2 1 4 4 1

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-57

* PILE TOP REACTIONS *

PILE GROUP AXIAL,LBS LAT. y,LBS LAT. z,LBS MOM x,LBS-IN MOM y,LBS-IN MOM z,LBS-IN
********** *********** *********** *********** *********** *********** ***********
1 1.7067E+05 1.6967E+04 9104.3 -4.4161E+04 -4.7472E+05 1.7873E+06
2 2.7995E+05 1.9936E+04 8405.8 -4.4161E+04 -4.4223E+05 2.0612E+06
3 8219.6 1.7695E+04 5453.8 -4.4161E+04 -1.5601E+05 1.8214E+06
4 1.4368E+05 3367.4 -2.0402E+04 -2.4329E+04 2.0956E+06 7127.1

MINIMUM 8219.6 3367.4 -2.0402E+04 -4.4161E+04 -4.7472E+05 7127.1

Pile N. 3 4 4 1 1 4
MAXIMUM 2.7995E+05 1.9936E+04 9104.3 -2.4329E+04 2.0956E+06 2.0612E+06
Pile N. 2 2 1 4 4 2

PILE GROUP STRESS,LBS/IN**2

********** ****************
1 571.39
2 735.25
3 407.19
4 598.66

MINIMUM 407.19
Pile N. 3
MAXIMUM 735.25
Pile N. 2

* EFFECTS FOR LATERALLY LOADED PILE *

* MINIMUM VALUES AND LOCATIONS *

PILE DISPL. DISPL. MOMENT MOMENT SHEAR SOIL REACT TOTAL

y-DIR z-DIR z-DIR y-DIR y-z-DIR y-z-DIR STRESS
IN IN LBS-IN LBS-IN LBS LBS/IN LBS/IN**2
****** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
1 -1.2521E-04 -7.5822E-05 -1.7873E+06 -4.7472E+05 0.0000 0.0000 167.65
x(FT) 22.000 22.000 0.0000 0.0000 60.000 0.0000 42.000
2 -1.6647E-04 -8.8830E-05 -2.0612E+06 -4.4223E+05 0.0000 0.0000 275.00
x(FT) 22.000 22.000 0.0000 0.0000 60.000 0.0000 43.000
3 -1.1188E-04 -4.1969E-05 -1.8214E+06 -1.5601E+05 0.0000 0.0000 8.0742
x(FT) 22.000 21.000 0.0000 0.0000 60.000 0.0000 34.000
4 -3.0158E-05 -0.028179 -7127.1 -6.4828E+05 0.0000 0.0000 141.14
x(FT) 22.000 3.0000 0.0000 17.000 60.000 0.0000 35.000

Min. -1.6647E-04 -0.028179 -2.0612E+06 -6.4828E+05 0.0000 0.0000 8.0742

Pile N. 2 4 2 4 1 1 3

* MAXIMUM VALUES AND LOCATIONS *

PILE DISPL. DISPL. MOMENT MOMENT SHEAR SOIL REACT TOTAL

y-DIR z-DIR z-DIR y-DIR y-z-DIR y-z-DIR STRESS
IN IN LBS-IN LBS-IN LBS LBS/IN LBS/IN**2
****** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
1 0.020514 0.028430 5.2432E+05 4.0737E+05 1.9262E+04 352.32 571.39
x(FT) 3.0000 0.0000 17.000 15.000 0.0000 16.000 0.0000
2 0.027903 0.028430 6.5123E+05 3.9356E+05 2.1648E+04 379.60 735.25
x(FT) 3.0000 0.0000 17.000 15.000 0.0000 16.000 0.0000
3 0.020456 0.020512 5.2735E+05 2.6999E+05 1.8516E+04 339.30 407.19
x(FT) 3.0000 0.0000 17.000 14.000 0.0000 16.000 0.0000
4 0.017712 1.3279E-04 2.1569E+05 2.0956E+06 2.0684E+04 385.60 598.66
x(FT) 0.0000 23.000 11.000 0.0000 0.0000 16.000 0.0000

Max. 0.027903 0.028430 6.5123E+05 2.0956E+06 2.1648E+04 385.60 735.25

Pile N. 2 1 2 4 2 4 2

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-58

***** SUMMARY FOR LOAD CASES AND COMBINATIONS *****

***** LOAD CASES RESULTS *****

LOAD CASE : 1

* TABLE L * COMPUTATION ON PILE CAP

* EQUIVALENT CONCENTRATED LOAD AT ORIGIN *

LOAD X,LBS LOAD Y,LBS LOAD Z,LBS MOM X,LBS-IN MOM Y,LBS-IN MOM Z,LBS-IN
6.00000E+05 75000.0 50000.0 0.00000 1.20000E+07 2.40000E+07

* DISPLACEMENT OF GROUPED PILE FOUNDATION AT ORIGIN *

DISP X,IN DISP Y,IN DISP Z,IN ROT X,RAD ROT Y,RAD ROT Z,RAD
0.0185937 0.0210203 0.0244710 -7.33220E-05 1.31612E-04 1.93413E-04

* TABLE M * COMPUTATION ON INDIVIDUAL PILE

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS, GLOBAL *

DISP. X,IN DISP. Y,IN DISP. Z,IN ROT. X,RAD ROT. Y,RAD ROT. Z,RAD
*********** *********** *********** *********** *********** ***********
MINIMUM 1.0423E-03 0.017061 0.020512 -7.3322E-05 1.3161E-04 1.9341E-04
Pile N. 3 1 3 1 1 1
MAXIMUM 0.036145 0.024980 0.028430 -7.3322E-05 1.3161E-04 1.9341E-04
Pile N. 2 2 1 1 1 1

* PILE TOP REACTIONS, GLOBAL *

FOR. X,LBS FOR. Y,LBS FOR. Z,LBS MOM X,LBS-IN MOM Y,LBS-IN MOM Z,LBS-IN
*********** *********** *********** *********** *********** ***********
MINIMUM 8219.6 1.6967E+04 5453.8 -3.6987E+05 -4.7472E+05 1.7873E+06
Pile N. 3 1 3 4 1 1
MAXIMUM 2.7995E+05 2.0402E+04 2.7036E+04 -4.4161E+04 -7127.1 2.0629E+06
Pile N. 2 4 4 1 4 4

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS, LOCAL *

DISP. x,IN DISP. y,IN DISP. z,IN ROT. x,RAD ROT. y,RAD ROT. z,RAD
*********** *********** *********** *********** *********** ***********
MINIMUM 1.0423E-03 0.017061 -0.024980 -7.3322E-05 1.3161E-04 -1.3161E-04
Pile N. 3 1 4 1 1 4
MAXIMUM 0.036145 0.024980 0.028430 -4.0394E-05 2.0286E-04 1.9341E-04
Pile N. 2 2 1 4 4 1

* PILE TOP REACTIONS, LOCAL *

AXIAL,LBS LAT. y,LBS LAT. z,LBS MOM x,LBS-IN MOM y,LBS-IN MOM z,LBS-IN
*********** *********** *********** *********** *********** ***********
MINIMUM 8219.6 3367.4 -2.0402E+04 -4.4161E+04 -4.7472E+05 7127.1
Pile N. 3 4 4 1 1 4
MAXIMUM 2.7995E+05 1.9936E+04 9104.3 -2.4329E+04 2.0956E+06 2.0612E+06
Pile N. 2 2 1 4 4 2

* EFFECTS FOR LATERALLY LOADED PILE *

PILE DISPL. DISPL. MOMENT MOMENT SHEAR SOIL REACT TOTAL

y-DIR z-DIR z-DIR y-DIR y-z-DIR y-z-DIR STRESS
IN IN LBS-IN LBS-IN LBS LBS/IN LBS/IN**2
****** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
Min. -1.6647E-04 -0.028179 -2.0612E+06 -6.4828E+05 0.0000 0.0000 8.0742
Pile N. 2 4 2 4 1 1 3
Max. 0.027903 0.028430 6.5123E+05 2.0956E+06 2.1648E+04 385.60 735.25
Pile N. 2 1 2 4 2 4 2

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-59

2.3.7 Graphs

Figure 2.7 Curves Resultant Deflection vs. Distance for Example Problem 2 - 3D.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-60

Figure 2.8 Curves Resultant Moment vs. Distance for Example Problem 2 - 3D.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-61

2.4 Example Problem 3 - 3D

2.4.1 Model Description

This example uses the same pile properties and soil data presented in Example Problem 2 - 3D,
except that the model has only torsional force applied at the top of the pile cap. The local axis y for the
piles is oriented tangentially and the local axis z is oriented toward the center of the pile cap. The
torque of 9000 in-kips is applied at the center of the pile cap.

The input and output files for the example problem are shown in the following pages.

The results indicates that each pile takes 29.5 kips on shear on the tangential direction (local y
axes) and 0 kips on the radial direction (z axis). The following check is made to see that the equilibrium
equation is satisfied for pile heads with the pin connection.

SM = 4 * 29.46 * 54 *1.4141 = 8999 in - kips

(that is very close to the applied 9000 in-kips, OK)

Figure 2.9 Equilibrium check for Example Problem 3 - 3D.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-62

2.4.2 Input Data

EXAMPLE PROBLEM 3 - 3D, A pile group subjected to torsional load only

GROUP2016.10.8
* Analysis Parameters
1 3 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 1
* Pile Cap Dimensions
0 0 0 0 0 0
* Load Cases
1 0 0 1 0
0 1 1 1 1 100 100
0.0001 0.0001 1 1
Load Case 1
12 0 0 0 1 0 0 0
2 2 1 0 1E-7 1E-5 0 0 0
1
0 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 0 0 0 1 0 0 1 0 1 0 0 0 0 1 1
1
0 0 0 0 0 9000000 0 0 0
0
0
* Load Combinations
0 0 0 0 0
* Distributed Load Sets
1
1
0 0
* Pile Group Configuration
4
1 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 1
0 0 1 1 1 1 1
0 -4.5 -4.5 315 90 0 0
1 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 1
0 0 1 1 1 1 1
0 -4.5 4.5 225 90 0 0
1 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 1
0 0 1 1 1 1 1
0 4.5 -4.5 45 90 0 0
1 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 1
0 0 1 1 1 1 1
0 4.5 4.5 135 90 0 0
* Pile Properties
1
0 1
60 60 1
0 60 1
* Pile Cross Sections
1
0 0 0 0
Section 1
36 0 1 1 0 0 0.1 0.1
1 1018 82448 82448 0 1.48E11 0 0 3600000 0 0
0 0 0 0 1
None
* Soil Layers
3
0 1
0 15
2 10
52.46208 576 0 500 0 0.02 0 576 0 0
52.46208 576 0 500 0 0.02 0 576 0 0
1 3
15 35
2 10
52.46208 2304 0 1000 0 0.005 0 1728 0 0
52.46208 2304 0 1000 0 0.005 0 1728 0 0
2 4

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-63

35 70
2 10
52.46208 0 38 150 0 0 0 2880 0 0
52.46208 0 38 150 0 0 0 2880 0 0
* Generated LD curves
1
1
* Generated TR curves
1
1
* User defined MC curves
1
1 1
0
1 1
0 0
* Internally Generated MC curves
1
1 1
0
0
1 1
0 0
1 1
0
0
1 1
0 0
* End of file

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-64

2.4.3 Echo Print File

=========================================================================

GROUP for Windows, Version 2016.10.8

Serial Number : 136089307

Analysis of A Group of Piles

Subjected to Axial and Lateral Loading

(c) Copyright ENSOFT, Inc., 1987-2015

All Rights Reserved

=========================================================================

This program is licensed to :

ENSOFT, INC
AUSTIN, TX

Path to file locations : C:\projects\GROUP2016\Group2016_1008\DXE\Examples_2016\

Name of input data file : 3Dexample3.gp10r
Name of output echo file : 3Dexample3.gp10e
Name of output results file : 3Dexample3.gp10o
Name of output summary file : 3Dexample3.gp10t
Name of plot output file : 3Dexample3.gp10p
Name of runtime file : 3Dexample3.gp10r

-------------------------------------------------------------------------
Time and Date of Analysis
-------------------------------------------------------------------------

Date: May 09, 2016 Time: 18:14:30

***** INPUT INFORMATION *****

EXAMPLE PROBLEM 3 - 3D, A pile group subjected to torsional load only

ANALYSIS TYPE = 3D ANALYSIS

ADJUST DEPTH FOR BATTER PILES

GENERATE LOAD-DISP (AND T-R) CURVES BASED ON SOIL PROFILE

EXTEND INTERPOLATION FOR L-DP (AND T-R) CURVES

UNITS SYSTEM = ENGL

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-65

* TABLE C * LOAD AND CONTROL PARAMETERS

** LOAD CASES **

NUMBER OF LOAD CASES : 1

LOAD CASE : 1
CASE NAME : Load Case 1
LOAD TYPE : Special, Sp
SCALE FACTOR : 1.0000

* CONCENTRATED LOADS *

NL VERT.LOAD HR.LOAD Y HR.LOAD Z MOMENT X MOMENT Y MOMENT Z COORD X COORD Y COORD Z

LBS LBS LBS LBS-IN LBS-IN LBS-IN FT FT FT
1 0.00 0.00 0.00 9.00E+06 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00

* EQUIVALENT CONCENTRATED LOAD AT ORIGIN *

VER.LOAD X,LBS HOR.LOAD Y,LBS HOR.LOAD Z,LBS

0.00000 0.00000 0.00000

MOMENT X,LBS-IN MOMENT Y,LBS-IN MOMENT Z,LBS-IN

9.00000E+06 0.00000 0.00000

* THE LOADING IS STATIC *

* CONTROL PARAMETERS *
TOLERANCE ON CONVERGENCE OF PILE CAP MOVEMENT = 1.00000E-04
TOLERANCE ON DETERMINATION OF PILE DEFLECTIONS = 1.00000E-04 IN
MAX NO OF ITERATIONS ALLOWED FOR FOUNDATION ANALYSIS = 100
MAXIMUM NO OF ITERATIONS ALLOWED FOR PILE ANALYSIS = 100
FACTOR TO APPLY THE LOAD IN INCREMENTS = 1.0000
MINIMUM FACTOR FOR LOAD INCREMENTS = 1.0000
PRINT RESULTS AT PILE CAP, PILE HEADS AND ALONG PILES
PRINT RESULTS EVERY 2 NODE(S)

** SETS OF DISTRIBUTED LOAD **

NUMBER OF SETS : 1

DIST. LOAD SET : 1

NL DEPTH LOAD
(FT) (LBS)
1 0.0000 0.0000

* TABLE D * ARRANGEMENT OF PILE GROUPS

GROUP CONN.Z-Z CONN.Y-Y PILE PROP P-Y CURVE L-S CURVE T-R CURVE R-F-L SET

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-66

1 PIN PIN 1 0 1 G 1 G 0
2 PIN PIN 1 0 1 G 1 G 0
3 PIN PIN 1 0 1 G 1 G 0
4 PIN PIN 1 0 1 G 1 G 0

GROUP CorX,FT CorY,FT CorZ,FT ALPHA,DEG BETA,DEG THETA,DEG GROUND,FT SPz,LBS-IN

SPy,LBS-IN
1 0.000 -4.500 -4.500 315.0 90.00 0.000 0.000 0.000
0.000
2 0.000 -4.500 4.500 225.0 90.00 0.000 0.000 0.000
0.000
3 0.000 4.500 -4.500 45.00 90.00 0.000 0.000 0.000
0.000
4 0.000 4.500 4.500 135.0 90.00 0.000 0.000 0.000
0.000

* TABLE E * PILE GEOMETRY AND PROPERTIES

PILE TYPE = 1 - DRIVEN PILE
= 2 - DRILLED SHAFT

PROP SECTS INC PILE TYPE LENGTH, FT

1 1 60 1 60.000

* PILE SECTIONS *

PROP SECT FROM,FT TO,FT CROSS SECT

1 1 0.00000 60.0000 1

* PILE CROSS SECTIONS *

CROSS SECTION : 1
SECTION NAME : Section

TYPE : ELASTIC
CROSS SECTION TYPE : GENERAL SECTION
EQUIVALENT DIAMETER : 36.0000 IN
YOUNG MODULUS : 3.60000E+06 LBS/IN**2

* PILE CROSS SECTIONS PROPERTIES *

ELASTIC SECTIONS

SECT DIAM,IN AREA,IN**2 Iz,IN**4 Iy,IN**4 GJ,LBS-IN**2 Mn,LBS-IN Vn,LBS

1 36.000 1018.0 8.2448E+04 8.2448E+04 1.4800E+11 0.0000 0.0000

* TABLE F * SOIL DATA

SOILS INFORMATION

GROUND SURFACE = 0.00000 FT

3 LAYER(S) OF SOIL

LAYER 1
THE SOIL IS A SOFT CLAY
TOP OF LAYER BOTTOM OF LAYER
X COORDINATE (FT) 0.00000 15.0000
EFFECTIVE UNIT WEIGHT (LBS/FT**3) 52.4621 52.4621
UNDRAINED COHESION, C (LBS/FT**2) 576.000 576.000

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-67

STRAIN AT 50% STRESS 0.0200000 0.0200000

ULTIMATE UNIT SIDE FRICTION (LBS/FT**2) 576.000 576.000
ULTIMATE UNIT TIP RESISTANCE (LBS/FT**2) 0.00000 0.00000

LAYER 2
THE SOIL IS A STIFF CLAY WITHOUT FREE WATER
TOP OF LAYER BOTTOM OF LAYER
X COORDINATE (FT) 15.0000 35.0000
EFFECTIVE UNIT WEIGHT (LBS/FT**3) 52.4621 52.4621
UNDRAINED COHESION, C (LBS/FT**2) 2304.00 2304.00
STRAIN AT 50% STRESS 5.00000E-03 5.00000E-03
ULTIMATE UNIT SIDE FRICTION (LBS/FT**2) 1728.00 1728.00
ULTIMATE UNIT TIP RESISTANCE (LBS/FT**2) 0.00000 0.00000

LAYER 3
THE SOIL IS A SAND
TOP OF LAYER BOTTOM OF LAYER
X COORDINATE (FT) 35.0000 70.0000
EFFECTIVE UNIT WEIGHT (LBS/FT**3) 52.4621 52.4621
FRICTION ANGLE (DEGREES) 38.0000 38.0000
P-Y SUBGRADE MODULUS (LBS/IN**3) 150.000 150.000
ULTIMATE UNIT SIDE FRICTION (LBS/FT**2) 2880.00 2880.00
ULTIMATE UNIT TIP RESISTANCE (LBS/FT**2) 84464.5 (R) 1.68929E+05 (R)

Notes : Program estimated values for listed parameters

if zero input values were entered:
(R) ULTIMATE UNIT TIP RESISTANCE for Driven Piles

* TABLE H * AXIAL LOAD VS DISPLACEMENT

AXIAL LOAD-DISPLACEMENT CURVES GENERATED INTERNALLY

NUM OF CURVES 1

CURVE 1 NUM OF POINTS 19

DISPLACEMENT, IN AXIAL LOAD,LBS

-2.12111 -9.86008E+05
-1.11148 -9.24111E+05
-0.60667 -8.93163E+05
-0.16868 -6.55465E+05
-0.10357 -5.64143E+05
-0.0238350 -1.56770E+05
-0.0117984 -76040.3
-2.35879E-03 -15160.5
-2.35880E-04 -1516.06
0.00000 0.00000
0.0114398 90212.6
0.0192099 1.49748E+05
0.0542049 4.18806E+05
0.0763110 5.62596E+05
0.16895 9.02082E+05
0.24798 1.05881E+06
0.73669 1.55543E+06
1.27144 1.73884E+06
2.31186 1.95758E+06

* TABLE I * TORS. MOM. VS ANGLE ROT.

TORQUE-ROTATION CURVES GENERATED INTERNALLY

NUM OF CURVES 1

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-68

CURVE 1 NUM OF POINTS 19

ROT. ANGLE,Rad. TORS.MOMEN,LBS-IN

-0.16524 -1.74729E+07
-0.10537 -1.63521E+07
-0.0754371 -1.57917E+07
-0.0376416 -1.18271E+07
-0.0281931 -1.01178E+07
-0.0144981 -6.92056E+06
-8.91777E-03 -4.83741E+06
-1.81805E-03 -1.10882E+06
-1.80485E-04 -1.08704E+05
0.00000 0.00000
1.80485E-04 1.08704E+05
1.81805E-03 1.10882E+06
8.91777E-03 4.83741E+06
0.0144981 6.92056E+06
0.0281931 1.01178E+07
0.0376416 1.18271E+07
0.0754371 1.57917E+07
0.10537 1.63521E+07
0.16524 1.74729E+07

* TABLE J * MOMENT CURVATURE SETS

USER DEFINED MOMENT CURVATURE

NUM OF SETS : 1

CURVE SET 1 NUM OF CURVES 1

CURVE 1 AXIAL LOAD 0.000E+00 LBS

POINT MOMENT CURVATURE

LBS-IN RADIAN/IN
1 0.00000 0.00000

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-69

2.4.4 Processor Run Notes

GROUP for Windows, Version 2016.10.8

-------------------------------------------------------------------------
Time and Date of Analysis
-------------------------------------------------------------------------

Date: May 09, 2016 Time: 18:14:30

EXAMPLE PROBLEM 3 - 3D, A pile group subjected to torsional load only

READING * TITLE AND VERSION

READING * Analysis Parameters
READING * Pile Cap Dimensions
READING * Load Cases
READING * Load Combinations
READING * Distributed Load Sets
READING * Pile Group Configuration
READING * Pile Properties
READING * Pile Cross Sections
READING * Soil Layers
READING * Generated LD curves
READING * Generated TR curves
READING * User defined MC curves
READING * Internally Generated MC curves

COMPUTATION IS PROCEEDING......

LOAD CASE : 1
CASE NAME : Load Case 1

GLOBAL ITERATIONS
STEP 1, TCUR 1.0000, DTCUR 1.0000
ITERATION 1
- ErrDsp 0.10000E+01, IncDsp 0.24708E-18, TotDsp 0.24708E-18
- ErrRot 0.10000E+01, IncRot 0.22807E-05, TotRot 0.22807E-05
ITERATION 2
- ErrDsp 0.10000E+01, IncDsp 0.20170E-09, TotDsp 0.20170E-09
- ErrRot 0.99305E+00, IncRot 0.32586E-03, TotRot 0.32814E-03
ITERATION 3
- ErrDsp 0.10000E+01, IncDsp 0.24336E-04, TotDsp 0.24335E-04
- ErrRot 0.85899E+00, IncRot 0.19989E-02, TotRot 0.23270E-02
ITERATION 4
- ErrDsp 0.22911E+01, IncDsp 0.43185E-04, TotDsp 0.18849E-04
- ErrRot 0.39636E+00, IncRot 0.15280E-02, TotRot 0.38550E-02
ITERATION 5
- ErrDsp 0.69049E+01, IncDsp 0.22041E-04, TotDsp 0.31921E-05
- ErrRot 0.67110E-01, IncRot 0.27732E-03, TotRot 0.41323E-02
ITERATION 6
- ErrDsp 0.12042E+05, IncDsp 0.31924E-05, TotDsp 0.26510E-09
- ErrRot 0.49372E-03, IncRot 0.20392E-05, TotRot 0.41303E-02
ITERATION 7
- ErrDsp 0.34284E+01, IncDsp 0.24830E-09, TotDsp 0.72423E-10
- ErrRot 0.11458E-07, IncRot 0.47326E-10, TotRot 0.41303E-02
ITERATION 8
- ErrDsp 0.66906E+02, IncDsp 0.73245E-10, TotDsp 0.10947E-11
- ErrRot 0.72597E-10, IncRot 0.29985E-12, TotRot
0.41303E-02

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-70

ITERATION 9
- ErrDsp 0.79789E+01, IncDsp 0.12291E-11,TotDsp 0.15404E-12
- ErrRot 0.14442E-11, IncRot 0.59652E-14, TotRot
0.41303E-02
NUMBER OF GLOBAL ITERATIONS = 9
ANALYSIS FOR LOAD CASE 1/ 1 FINISHED
Execution Time : 185 ms
Number Processors : 1/ 1
Serial processing : 0.076 sec
Paral. processing : 0.089 sec
Print. processing : 0.020 sec
ANALYSIS COMPLETED
Execution Time : 185 ms
Number Processors : 1/ 1

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-71

2.4.5 Output Results File

=========================================================================

GROUP for Windows, Version 2016.10.8

Serial Number : 136089307

Analysis of A Group of Piles

Subjected to Axial and Lateral Loading

(c) Copyright ENSOFT, Inc., 1987-2015

All Rights Reserved

=========================================================================

This program is licensed to :

ENSOFT, INC
AUSTIN, TX

Path to file locations : C:\projects\GROUP2016\Group2016_1008\DXE\Examples_2016\

Name of input data file : 3Dexample3.gp10d
Name of output echo file : 3Dexample3.gp10e
Name of output results file : 3Dexample3.gp10o
Name of output summary file : 3Dexample3.gp10t
Name of plot output file : 3Dexample3.gp10p
Name of runtime file : 3Dexample3.gp10r

-------------------------------------------------------------------------
Time and Date of Analysis
-------------------------------------------------------------------------

Date: May 09, 2016 Time: 18:14:30

***** COMPUTATION RESULTS *****

EXAMPLE PROBLEM 3 - 3D, A pile group subjected to torsional load only

***** LOAD CASES RESULTS *****

LOAD CASE : 1
CASE NAME : Load Case 1
LOAD TYPE : Special, Sp

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-72

* TABLE L * COMPUTATION ON PILE CAP

* EQUIVALENT CONCENTRATED LOAD AT ORIGIN *

VERT. LOAD, LBS HOR. LOAD Y, LBS HOR. LOAD Z, LBS

0.00000 0.00000 0.00000

MOMENT X ,LBS-IN MOMENT Y,LBS-IN MOMENT Z,LBS-IN

9.00000E+06 0.00000 0.00000

* DISPLACEMENT OF GROUPED PILE FOUNDATION AT ORIGIN *

VERTICAL ,IN HORIZONTAL Y,IN HORIZONTAL Z,IN

-1.90447E-17 -1.49366E-13 -3.76639E-14

ANGLE ROT. X,RAD ANGLE ROT. Y,RAD ANGLE ROT. Z,RAD

4.13028E-03 1.55269E-22 -8.12379E-23

NUMBER OF GLOBAL ITERATIONS = 9

* TABLE M * COMPUTATION ON INDIVIDUAL PILE

* PILE GROUP * 1

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS AND REACTIONS *

THE GLOBAL STRUCTURAL COORDINATE SYSTEM

---------------------------------------

DISP. X,IN DISP. Y,IN DISP. Z,IN ROT. X,RAD ROT. Y,RAD ROT. Z,RAD
-1.9058E-17 0.2230 -0.2230 4.1303E-03 1.5527E-22 -8.1238E-23

FOR. X,LBS FOR. Y,LBS FOR. Z,LBS MOM X,LBS-IN MOM Y,LBS-IN MOM Z,LBS-IN
2.1764E-13 2.0833E+04 -2.0833E+04 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000

STR,LBS/IN**2
1.9860E-15

THE PILE COORDINATE SYSTEM (LOCAL AXES)

---------------------------------------

DISP. x,IN DISP. y,IN DISP. z,IN ROT. x,RAD ROT. y,RAD ROT. z,RAD
2.5637E-19 0.3154 -1.3217E-13 4.1303E-03 -2.5274E-19 5.2348E-23

AXIAL,LBS LAT. y,LBS LAT. z,LBS MOM x,LBS-IN MOM y,LBS-IN MOM z,LBS-IN

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-73

2.0217E-12 2.9463E+04 -1.2346E-08 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000

STR,LBS/IN**2
1.9860E-15

* EFFECTS FOR LATERALLY LOADED PILE *

x DISPL. DISPL. MOMENT MOMENT SHEAR SOIL REACT TOTAL

y-DIR z-DIR z-DIR y-DIR y-z-DIR y-z-DIR STRESS
FT IN IN LBS-IN LBS-IN LBS LBS/IN LBS/IN**2
********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
0.0000 0.3154 -1.3217E-13 0.0000 0.0000 2.9463E+04 0.0000 1.9860E-15
2.0000 0.2676 -1.1211E-13 6.8870E+05 -2.8859E-07 2.7124E+04 134.08 150.36
4.0000 0.2210 -9.2612E-14 1.3003E+06 -5.4486E-07 2.3779E+04 144.27 283.87
6.0000 0.1770 -7.4164E-14 1.8289E+06 -7.6636E-07 2.0229E+04 151.11 399.28
8.0000 0.1365 -5.7198E-14 2.2706E+06 -9.5144E-07 1.6559E+04 154.31 495.71
10.000 0.1004 -4.2074E-14 2.6235E+06 -1.0993E-06 1.2859E+04 153.50 572.76
12.000 6.9394E-02 -2.9079E-14 2.8882E+06 -1.2103E-06 9230.3 148.30 630.55
14.000 4.3977E-02 -1.8428E-14 3.0677E+06 -1.2855E-06 5784.5 138.21 669.73
16.000 2.4503E-02 -1.0268E-14 3.1146E+06 -1.3051E-06 4688.3 607.88 679.98
18.000 1.1031E-02 -4.6224E-15 2.8311E+06 -1.1863E-06 1.8547E+04 542.47 618.08
20.000 3.0151E-03 -1.2634E-15 2.2368E+06 -9.3728E-07 3.0293E+04 427.77 488.33
22.000 -6.8992E-04 2.8910E-16 1.4017E+06 -5.8735E-07 3.4936E+04 299.12 306.01
24.000 -1.6540E-03 6.9307E-16 6.6108E+05 -2.7702E-07 2.6107E+04 411.38 144.33
26.000 -1.3064E-03 5.4741E-16 1.5431E+05 -6.4662E-08 1.6103E+04 414.88 33.689
28.000 -6.3030E-04 2.6412E-16 -1.1522E+05 4.8282E-08 6636.2 368.53 25.155
30.000 -1.5211E-04 6.3738E-17 -1.7404E+05 7.2928E-08 1192.4 278.14 37.996
32.000 7.7791E-06 -3.2597E-18 -7.4538E+04 3.1234E-08 4763.2 111.22 16.273
34.000 1.5244E-05 -6.3880E-18 -76.191 3.1927E-11 1065.5 173.96 1.6634E-02
36.000 1.0408E-05 -4.3615E-18 366.16 -1.5343E-10 12.412 0.4606 7.9939E-02
38.000 6.2506E-06 -2.6192E-18 543.24 -2.2764E-10 3.3146 0.2991 0.1186
40.000 3.1263E-06 -1.3100E-18 547.17 -2.2928E-10 2.1576 0.1609 0.1195
42.000 1.0525E-06 -4.4103E-19 457.15 -1.9156E-10 4.7266 5.7944E-02 9.9805E-02
44.000 -1.3815E-07 5.7891E-20 332.41 -1.3929E-10 5.2720 8.1033E-03 7.2572E-02
46.000 -6.8315E-07 2.8626E-19 211.20 -8.8498E-11 4.6228 4.2529E-02 4.6108E-02
48.000 -8.1533E-07 3.4165E-19 113.64 -4.7618E-11 3.4400 5.3693E-02 2.4809E-02
50.000 -7.2323E-07 3.0306E-19 46.483 -1.9478E-11 2.1769 5.0231E-02 1.0148E-02
52.000 -5.3741E-07 2.2520E-19 7.9975 -3.3512E-12 1.0960 3.9260E-02 1.7460E-03
54.000 -3.3333E-07 1.3968E-19 -7.9674 3.3386E-12 0.3166 2.5551E-02 1.7394E-03
56.000 -1.4293E-07 5.9894E-20 -9.2236 3.8650E-12 0.1274 1.1471E-02 2.0137E-03
58.000 3.0372E-08 -1.2727E-20 -3.8679 1.6208E-12 0.2348 2.5468E-03 8.4443E-04
60.000 1.9599E-07 -8.2127E-20 0.0000 0.0000 2.2759E-15 1.7140E-02 1.9860E-15

* PILE GROUP * 2

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS AND REACTIONS *

THE GLOBAL STRUCTURAL COORDINATE SYSTEM

---------------------------------------

DISP. X,IN DISP. Y,IN DISP. Z,IN ROT. X,RAD ROT. Y,RAD ROT. Z,RAD
-1.9041E-17 -0.2230 -0.2230 4.1303E-03 1.5527E-22 -8.1238E-23

FOR. X,LBS FOR. Y,LBS FOR. Z,LBS MOM X,LBS-IN MOM Y,LBS-IN MOM Z,LBS-IN
3.4988E-13 -2.0833E+04 -2.0833E+04 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000

STR,LBS/IN**2
2.1159E-15

THE PILE COORDINATE SYSTEM (LOCAL AXES)

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-74

---------------------------------------

DISP. x,IN DISP. y,IN DISP. z,IN ROT. x,RAD ROT. y,RAD ROT. z,RAD
2.7314E-19 0.3154 -7.8909E-14 4.1303E-03 -2.5296E-19 1.6724E-22

AXIAL,LBS LAT. y,LBS LAT. z,LBS MOM x,LBS-IN MOM y,LBS-IN MOM z,LBS-IN
2.1540E-12 2.9463E+04 -7.3708E-09 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000

STR,LBS/IN**2
2.1159E-15

* EFFECTS FOR LATERALLY LOADED PILE *

x DISPL. DISPL. MOMENT MOMENT SHEAR SOIL REACT TOTAL

y-DIR z-DIR z-DIR y-DIR y-z-DIR y-z-DIR STRESS
FT IN IN LBS-IN LBS-IN LBS LBS/IN LBS/IN**2
********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
0.0000 0.3154 -7.8909E-14 0.0000 0.0000 2.9463E+04 0.0000 2.1159E-15
2.0000 0.2676 -6.6934E-14 6.8870E+05 -1.7229E-07 2.7124E+04 134.08 150.36
4.0000 0.2210 -5.5291E-14 1.3003E+06 -3.2529E-07 2.3779E+04 144.27 283.87
6.0000 0.1770 -4.4277E-14 1.8289E+06 -4.5753E-07 2.0229E+04 151.11 399.28
8.0000 0.1365 -3.4148E-14 2.2706E+06 -5.6803E-07 1.6559E+04 154.31 495.71
10.000 0.1004 -2.5119E-14 2.6235E+06 -6.5633E-07 1.2859E+04 153.50 572.76
12.000 6.9394E-02 -1.7360E-14 2.8882E+06 -7.2255E-07 9230.3 148.30 630.55
14.000 4.3977E-02 -1.1002E-14 3.0677E+06 -7.6744E-07 5784.5 138.21 669.73
16.000 2.4503E-02 -6.1300E-15 3.1146E+06 -7.7919E-07 4688.3 607.88 679.98
18.000 1.1031E-02 -2.7596E-15 2.8311E+06 -7.0826E-07 1.8547E+04 542.47 618.08
20.000 3.0151E-03 -7.5430E-16 2.2368E+06 -5.5957E-07 3.0293E+04 427.77 488.33
22.000 -6.8992E-04 1.7260E-16 1.4017E+06 -3.5066E-07 3.4936E+04 299.12 306.01
24.000 -1.6540E-03 4.1377E-16 6.6108E+05 -1.6538E-07 2.6107E+04 411.38 144.33
26.000 -1.3064E-03 3.2681E-16 1.5431E+05 -3.8605E-08 1.6103E+04 414.88 33.689
28.000 -6.3030E-04 1.5768E-16 -1.1522E+05 2.8825E-08 6636.2 368.53 25.155
30.000 -1.5211E-04 3.8053E-17 -1.7404E+05 4.3540E-08 1192.4 278.14 37.996
32.000 7.7791E-06 -1.9461E-18 -7.4538E+04 1.8647E-08 4763.2 111.22 16.273
34.000 1.5244E-05 -3.8137E-18 -76.191 1.9061E-11 1065.5 173.96 1.6634E-02
36.000 1.0408E-05 -2.6039E-18 366.16 -9.1602E-11 12.412 0.4606 7.9939E-02
38.000 6.2506E-06 -1.5637E-18 543.24 -1.3590E-10 3.3146 0.2991 0.1186
40.000 3.1263E-06 -7.8210E-19 547.17 -1.3689E-10 2.1576 0.1609 0.1195
42.000 1.0525E-06 -2.6330E-19 457.15 -1.1437E-10 4.7266 5.7944E-02 9.9805E-02
44.000 -1.3815E-07 3.4562E-20 332.41 -8.3160E-11 5.2720 8.1033E-03 7.2572E-02
46.000 -6.8315E-07 1.7091E-19 211.20 -5.2835E-11 4.6228 4.2529E-02 4.6108E-02
48.000 -8.1533E-07 2.0397E-19 113.64 -2.8429E-11 3.4400 5.3693E-02 2.4809E-02
50.000 -7.2323E-07 1.8093E-19 46.483 -1.1629E-11 2.1769 5.0231E-02 1.0148E-02
52.000 -5.3741E-07 1.3445E-19 7.9975 -2.0008E-12 1.0960 3.9260E-02 1.7460E-03
54.000 -3.3333E-07 8.3391E-20 -7.9674 1.9932E-12 0.3166 2.5551E-02 1.7394E-03
56.000 -1.4293E-07 3.5758E-20 -9.2236 2.3075E-12 0.1274 1.1471E-02 2.0137E-03
58.000 3.0372E-08 -7.5981E-21 -3.8679 9.6764E-13 0.2348 2.5468E-03 8.4443E-04
60.000 1.9599E-07 -4.9032E-20 0.0000 0.0000 2.2760E-15 1.7140E-02 2.1159E-15

* PILE GROUP * 3

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS AND REACTIONS *

THE GLOBAL STRUCTURAL COORDINATE SYSTEM

---------------------------------------

DISP. X,IN DISP. Y,IN DISP. Z,IN ROT. X,RAD ROT. Y,RAD ROT. Z,RAD
-1.9049E-17 0.2230 0.2230 4.1303E-03 1.5527E-22 -8.1238E-23

FOR. X,LBS FOR. Y,LBS FOR. Z,LBS MOM X,LBS-IN MOM Y,LBS-IN MOM Z,LBS-IN

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-75

2.8683E-13 2.0833E+04 2.0833E+04 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000

STR,LBS/IN**2
2.0539E-15

THE PILE COORDINATE SYSTEM (LOCAL AXES)

---------------------------------------

DISP. x,IN DISP. y,IN DISP. z,IN ROT. x,RAD ROT. y,RAD ROT. z,RAD
2.6515E-19 0.3154 7.9020E-14 4.1303E-03 -2.5285E-19 -1.6724E-22

AXIAL,LBS LAT. y,LBS LAT. z,LBS MOM x,LBS-IN MOM y,LBS-IN MOM z,LBS-IN
2.0909E-12 2.9463E+04 7.3811E-09 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000

STR,LBS/IN**2
2.0539E-15

* EFFECTS FOR LATERALLY LOADED PILE *

x DISPL. DISPL. MOMENT MOMENT SHEAR SOIL REACT TOTAL

y-DIR z-DIR z-DIR y-DIR y-z-DIR y-z-DIR STRESS
FT IN IN LBS-IN LBS-IN LBS LBS/IN LBS/IN**2
********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
0.0000 0.3154 7.9020E-14 0.0000 0.0000 2.9463E+04 0.0000 2.0539E-15
2.0000 0.2676 6.7028E-14 6.8870E+05 1.7254E-07 2.7124E+04 134.08 150.36
4.0000 0.2210 5.5369E-14 1.3003E+06 3.2575E-07 2.3779E+04 144.27 283.87
6.0000 0.1770 4.4339E-14 1.8289E+06 4.5818E-07 2.0229E+04 151.11 399.28
8.0000 0.1365 3.4196E-14 2.2706E+06 5.6883E-07 1.6559E+04 154.31 495.71
10.000 0.1004 2.5154E-14 2.6235E+06 6.5725E-07 1.2859E+04 153.50 572.76
12.000 6.9394E-02 1.7385E-14 2.8882E+06 7.2356E-07 9230.3 148.30 630.55
14.000 4.3977E-02 1.1017E-14 3.0677E+06 7.6852E-07 5784.5 138.21 669.73
16.000 2.4503E-02 6.1386E-15 3.1146E+06 7.8029E-07 4688.3 607.88 679.98
18.000 1.1031E-02 2.7635E-15 2.8311E+06 7.0926E-07 1.8547E+04 542.47 618.08
20.000 3.0151E-03 7.5536E-16 2.2368E+06 5.6036E-07 3.0293E+04 427.77 488.33
22.000 -6.8992E-04 -1.7284E-16 1.4017E+06 3.5115E-07 3.4936E+04 299.12 306.01
24.000 -1.6540E-03 -4.1436E-16 6.6108E+05 1.6562E-07 2.6107E+04 411.38 144.33
26.000 -1.3064E-03 -3.2727E-16 1.5431E+05 3.8659E-08 1.6103E+04 414.88 33.689
28.000 -6.3030E-04 -1.5791E-16 -1.1522E+05 -2.8866E-08 6636.2 368.53 25.155
30.000 -1.5211E-04 -3.8106E-17 -1.7404E+05 -4.3601E-08 1192.4 278.14 37.996
32.000 7.7791E-06 1.9489E-18 -7.4538E+04 -1.8673E-08 4763.2 111.22 16.273
34.000 1.5244E-05 3.8191E-18 -76.191 -1.9088E-11 1065.5 173.96 1.6634E-02
36.000 1.0408E-05 2.6075E-18 366.16 9.1731E-11 12.412 0.4606 7.9939E-02
38.000 6.2506E-06 1.5659E-18 543.24 1.3610E-10 3.3146 0.2991 0.1186
40.000 3.1263E-06 7.8320E-19 547.17 1.3708E-10 2.1576 0.1609 0.1195
42.000 1.0525E-06 2.6367E-19 457.15 1.1453E-10 4.7266 5.7944E-02 9.9805E-02
44.000 -1.3815E-07 -3.4611E-20 332.41 8.3277E-11 5.2720 8.1033E-03 7.2572E-02
46.000 -6.8315E-07 -1.7115E-19 211.20 5.2909E-11 4.6228 4.2529E-02 4.6108E-02
48.000 -8.1533E-07 -2.0426E-19 113.64 2.8469E-11 3.4400 5.3693E-02 2.4809E-02
50.000 -7.2323E-07 -1.8119E-19 46.483 1.1645E-11 2.1769 5.0231E-02 1.0148E-02
52.000 -5.3741E-07 -1.3463E-19 7.9975 2.0036E-12 1.0960 3.9260E-02 1.7460E-03
54.000 -3.3333E-07 -8.3508E-20 -7.9674 -1.9960E-12 0.3166 2.5551E-02 1.7394E-03
56.000 -1.4293E-07 -3.5808E-20 -9.2236 -2.3107E-12 0.1274 1.1471E-02 2.0137E-03
58.000 3.0372E-08 7.6088E-21 -3.8679 -9.6900E-13 0.2348 2.5468E-03 8.4443E-04
60.000 1.9599E-07 4.9101E-20 0.0000 2.4811E-26 2.2760E-15 1.7140E-02 2.0539E-15

* PILE GROUP * 4

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS AND REACTIONS *

THE GLOBAL STRUCTURAL COORDINATE SYSTEM

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-76

---------------------------------------

DISP. X,IN DISP. Y,IN DISP. Z,IN ROT. X,RAD ROT. Y,RAD ROT. Z,RAD
-1.9032E-17 -0.2230 0.2230 4.1303E-03 1.5527E-22 -8.1238E-23

FOR. X,LBS FOR. Y,LBS FOR. Z,LBS MOM X,LBS-IN MOM Y,LBS-IN MOM Z,LBS-IN
4.1906E-13 -2.0833E+04 2.0833E+04 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000

STR,LBS/IN**2
2.1838E-15

THE PILE COORDINATE SYSTEM (LOCAL AXES)

---------------------------------------

DISP. x,IN DISP. y,IN DISP. z,IN ROT. x,RAD ROT. y,RAD ROT. z,RAD
2.8192E-19 0.3154 1.3226E-13 4.1303E-03 -2.5307E-19 -5.2348E-23

AXIAL,LBS LAT. y,LBS LAT. z,LBS MOM x,LBS-IN MOM y,LBS-IN MOM z,LBS-IN
2.2231E-12 2.9463E+04 1.2354E-08 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000

STR,LBS/IN**2
2.1838E-15

* EFFECTS FOR LATERALLY LOADED PILE *

x DISPL. DISPL. MOMENT MOMENT SHEAR SOIL REACT TOTAL

y-DIR z-DIR z-DIR y-DIR y-z-DIR y-z-DIR STRESS
FT IN IN LBS-IN LBS-IN LBS LBS/IN LBS/IN**2
********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
0.0000 0.3154 1.3226E-13 0.0000 0.0000 2.9463E+04 0.0000 2.1838E-15
2.0000 0.2676 1.1218E-13 6.8870E+05 2.8877E-07 2.7124E+04 134.08 150.36
4.0000 0.2210 9.2671E-14 1.3003E+06 5.4520E-07 2.3779E+04 144.27 283.87
6.0000 0.1770 7.4210E-14 1.8289E+06 7.6684E-07 2.0229E+04 151.11 399.28
8.0000 0.1365 5.7234E-14 2.2706E+06 9.5204E-07 1.6559E+04 154.31 495.71
10.000 0.1004 4.2100E-14 2.6235E+06 1.1000E-06 1.2859E+04 153.50 572.76
12.000 6.9394E-02 2.9097E-14 2.8882E+06 1.2110E-06 9230.3 148.30 630.55
14.000 4.3977E-02 1.8439E-14 3.0677E+06 1.2863E-06 5784.5 138.21 669.73
16.000 2.4503E-02 1.0274E-14 3.1146E+06 1.3060E-06 4688.3 607.88 679.98
18.000 1.1031E-02 4.6253E-15 2.8311E+06 1.1871E-06 1.8547E+04 542.47 618.08
20.000 3.0151E-03 1.2642E-15 2.2368E+06 9.3787E-07 3.0293E+04 427.77 488.33
22.000 -6.8992E-04 -2.8928E-16 1.4017E+06 5.8772E-07 3.4936E+04 299.12 306.01
24.000 -1.6540E-03 -6.9350E-16 6.6108E+05 2.7719E-07 2.6107E+04 411.38 144.33
26.000 -1.3064E-03 -5.4775E-16 1.5431E+05 6.4703E-08 1.6103E+04 414.88 33.689
28.000 -6.3030E-04 -2.6429E-16 -1.1522E+05 -4.8312E-08 6636.2 368.53 25.155
30.000 -1.5211E-04 -6.3778E-17 -1.7404E+05 -7.2974E-08 1192.4 278.14 37.996
32.000 7.7791E-06 3.2618E-18 -7.4538E+04 -3.1254E-08 4763.2 111.22 16.273
34.000 1.5244E-05 6.3920E-18 -76.191 -3.1947E-11 1065.5 173.96 1.6634E-02
36.000 1.0408E-05 4.3642E-18 366.16 1.5353E-10 12.412 0.4606 7.9939E-02
38.000 6.2506E-06 2.6209E-18 543.24 2.2778E-10 3.3146 0.2991 0.1186
40.000 3.1263E-06 1.3108E-18 547.17 2.2943E-10 2.1576 0.1609 0.1195
42.000 1.0525E-06 4.4131E-19 457.15 1.9168E-10 4.7266 5.7944E-02 9.9805E-02
44.000 -1.3815E-07 -5.7928E-20 332.41 1.3938E-10 5.2720 8.1033E-03 7.2572E-02
46.000 -6.8315E-07 -2.8645E-19 211.20 8.8554E-11 4.6228 4.2529E-02 4.6108E-02
48.000 -8.1533E-07 -3.4187E-19 113.64 4.7648E-11 3.4400 5.3693E-02 2.4809E-02
50.000 -7.2323E-07 -3.0325E-19 46.483 1.9490E-11 2.1769 5.0231E-02 1.0148E-02
52.000 -5.3741E-07 -2.2534E-19 7.9975 3.3534E-12 1.0960 3.9260E-02 1.7460E-03
54.000 -3.3333E-07 -1.3977E-19 -7.9674 -3.3407E-12 0.3166 2.5551E-02 1.7394E-03
56.000 -1.4293E-07 -5.9931E-20 -9.2236 -3.8675E-12 0.1274 1.1471E-02 2.0137E-03
58.000 3.0372E-08 1.2735E-20 -3.8679 -1.6218E-12 0.2348 2.5468E-03 8.4443E-04
60.000 1.9599E-07 8.2179E-20 -1.0912E-13 0.0000 4.5519E-15 1.7140E-02 2.2077E-15

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-77

2.4.6 Summary Results File

=========================================================================

GROUP for Windows, Version 2016.10.8

Serial Number : 136089307

Analysis of A Group of Piles

Subjected to Axial and Lateral Loading

(c) Copyright ENSOFT, Inc., 1987-2015

All Rights Reserved

=========================================================================

-------------------------------------------------------------------------
Time and Date of Analysis
-------------------------------------------------------------------------

Date: May 09, 2016 Time: 18:14:30

***** COMPUTATION RESULTS *****

EXAMPLE PROBLEM 3 - 3D, A pile group subjected to torsional load only

***** LOAD CASES RESULTS *****

LOAD CASE : 1
CASE NAME : Load Case 1
LOAD TYPE : Special, Sp

* TABLE L * COMPUTATION ON PILE CAP

* EQUIVALENT CONCENTRATED LOAD AT ORIGIN *

VERT. LOAD, LBS HOR. LOAD Y, LBS HOR. LOAD Z, LBS

0.00000 0.00000 0.00000

MOMENT X ,LBS-IN MOMENT Y,LBS-IN MOMENT Z,LBS-IN

9.00000E+06 0.00000 0.00000

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-78

* DISPLACEMENT OF GROUPED PILE FOUNDATION AT ORIGIN *

VERTICAL ,IN HORIZONTAL Y,IN HORIZONTAL Z,IN

-1.90447E-17 -1.49366E-13 -3.76639E-14

ANGLE ROT. X,RAD ANGLE ROT. Y,RAD ANGLE ROT. Z,RAD

4.13028E-03 1.55269E-22 -8.12379E-23

* TABLE M * COMPUTATION ON INDIVIDUAL PILE

THE GLOBAL STRUCTURAL COORDINATE SYSTEM

---------------------------------------

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS *

PILE GROUP DISP. X,IN DISP. Y,IN DISP. Z,IN ROT. X,RAD ROT. Y,RAD ROT. Z,RAD
********** *********** *********** *********** *********** *********** ***********
1 -1.9057E-17 0.2230 -0.2230 4.1303E-03 1.5527E-22 -8.1238E-23
2 -1.9041E-17 -0.2230 -0.2230 4.1303E-03 1.5527E-22 -8.1238E-23
3 -1.9049E-17 0.2230 0.2230 4.1303E-03 1.5527E-22 -8.1238E-23
4 -1.9032E-17 -0.2230 0.2230 4.1303E-03 1.5527E-22 -8.1238E-23

MINIMUM -1.9057E-17 -0.2230 -0.2230 4.1303E-03 1.5527E-22 -8.1238E-23

Pile N. 1 2 1 1 1 1
MAXIMUM -1.9032E-17 0.2230 0.2230 4.1303E-03 1.5527E-22 -8.1238E-23
Pile N. 4 1 3 1 1 1

* PILE TOP REACTIONS *

PILE GROUP FOR. X,LBS FOR. Y,LBS FOR. Z,LBS MOM X,LBS-IN MOM Y,LBS-IN MOM Z,LBS-IN
********** *********** *********** *********** *********** *********** ***********
1 2.1764E-13 2.0833E+04 -2.0833E+04 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000
2 3.4988E-13 -2.0833E+04 -2.0833E+04 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000
3 2.8683E-13 2.0833E+04 2.0833E+04 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000
4 4.1906E-13 -2.0833E+04 2.0833E+04 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000

MINIMUM 2.1764E-13 -2.0833E+04 -2.0833E+04 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000

Pile N. 1 2 1 1 1 1
MAXIMUM 4.1906E-13 2.0833E+04 2.0833E+04 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000
Pile N. 4 1 3 1 1 1

THE PILE COORDINATE SYSTEM (LOCAL AXES)

---------------------------------------

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS *

PILE GROUP DISP. x,IN DISP. y,IN DISP. z,IN ROT. x,RAD ROT. y,RAD ROT. z,RAD
********** *********** *********** *********** *********** *********** ***********
1 2.5637E-19 0.3154 -1.3217E-13 4.1303E-03 -2.5274E-19 5.2348E-23
2 2.7314E-19 0.3154 -7.8909E-14 4.1303E-03 -2.5296E-19 1.6724E-22
3 2.6515E-19 0.3154 7.9020E-14 4.1303E-03 -2.5285E-19 -1.6724E-22
4 2.8192E-19 0.3154 1.3226E-13 4.1303E-03 -2.5307E-19 -5.2348E-23

MINIMUM 2.5637E-19 0.3154 -1.3217E-13 4.1303E-03 -2.5307E-19 -1.6724E-22

Pile N. 1 1 1 1 4 3
MAXIMUM 2.8192E-19 0.3154 1.3226E-13 4.1303E-03 -2.5274E-19 1.6724E-22
Pile N. 4 1 4 1 1 2

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-79

* PILE TOP REACTIONS *

PILE GROUP AXIAL,LBS LAT. y,LBS LAT. z,LBS MOM x,LBS-IN MOM y,LBS-IN MOM z,LBS-IN
********** *********** *********** *********** *********** *********** ***********
1 2.0217E-12 2.9463E+04 -1.2346E-08 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000
2 2.1540E-12 2.9463E+04 -7.3708E-09 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000
3 2.0909E-12 2.9463E+04 7.3811E-09 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000
4 2.2231E-12 2.9463E+04 1.2354E-08 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000

MINIMUM 2.0217E-12 2.9463E+04 -1.2346E-08 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000

Pile N. 1 1 1 1 1 1
MAXIMUM 2.2231E-12 2.9463E+04 1.2354E-08 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000
Pile N. 4 1 4 1 1 1

PILE GROUP STRESS,LBS/IN**2

********** ****************
1 1.9860E-15
2 2.1159E-15
3 2.0539E-15
4 2.1838E-15

MINIMUM 1.9860E-15
Pile N. 1
MAXIMUM 2.1838E-15
Pile N. 4

* EFFECTS FOR LATERALLY LOADED PILE *

* MINIMUM VALUES AND LOCATIONS *

PILE DISPL. DISPL. MOMENT MOMENT SHEAR SOIL REACT TOTAL

y-DIR z-DIR z-DIR y-DIR y-z-DIR y-z-DIR STRESS
IN IN LBS-IN LBS-IN LBS LBS/IN LBS/IN**2
****** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
1 -1.6540E-03 -1.3217E-13 -1.7404E+05 -1.3104E-06 2.2759E-15 0.0000 1.9860E-15
x(FT) 24.000 0.0000 30.000 15.000 60.000 0.0000 0.0000
2 -1.6540E-03 -7.8909E-14 -1.7404E+05 -7.8232E-07 2.2760E-15 0.0000 2.1159E-15
x(FT) 24.000 0.0000 30.000 15.000 60.000 0.0000 0.0000
3 -1.6540E-03 -4.1436E-16 -1.7404E+05 -4.3601E-08 2.2760E-15 0.0000 2.0539E-15
x(FT) 24.000 24.000 30.000 30.000 60.000 0.0000 0.0000
4 -1.6540E-03 -6.9350E-16 -1.7404E+05 -7.2974E-08 4.5519E-15 0.0000 2.1838E-15
x(FT) 24.000 24.000 30.000 30.000 60.000 0.0000 0.0000

Min. -1.6540E-03 -1.3217E-13 -1.7404E+05 -1.3104E-06 2.2759E-15 0.0000 1.9860E-15

Pile N. 1 1 1 1 1 1 1

* MAXIMUM VALUES AND LOCATIONS *

PILE DISPL. DISPL. MOMENT MOMENT SHEAR SOIL REACT TOTAL

y-DIR z-DIR z-DIR y-DIR y-z-DIR y-z-DIR STRESS
IN IN LBS-IN LBS-IN LBS LBS/IN LBS/IN**2
****** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
1 0.3154 6.9307E-16 3.1271E+06 7.2928E-08 3.4936E+04 607.88 682.71
x(FT) 0.0000 24.000 15.000 30.000 22.000 16.000 15.000
2 0.3154 4.1377E-16 3.1271E+06 4.3540E-08 3.4936E+04 607.88 682.71
x(FT) 0.0000 24.000 15.000 30.000 22.000 16.000 15.000
3 0.3154 7.9020E-14 3.1271E+06 7.8342E-07 3.4936E+04 607.88 682.71
x(FT) 0.0000 0.0000 15.000 15.000 22.000 16.000 15.000
4 0.3154 1.3226E-13 3.1271E+06 1.3112E-06 3.4936E+04 607.88 682.71
x(FT) 0.0000 0.0000 15.000 15.000 22.000 16.000 15.000

Max. 0.3154 1.3226E-13 3.1271E+06 1.3112E-06 3.4936E+04 607.88 682.71

Pile N. 1 4 1 4 1 1 1

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-80

***** SUMMARY FOR LOAD CASES AND COMBINATIONS *****

***** LOAD CASES RESULTS *****

LOAD CASE : 1

* TABLE L * COMPUTATION ON PILE CAP

* EQUIVALENT CONCENTRATED LOAD AT ORIGIN *

LOAD X,LBS LOAD Y,LBS LOAD Z,LBS MOM X,LBS-IN MOM Y,LBS-IN MOM Z,LBS-IN
0.00000 0.00000 0.00000 9.00000E+06 0.00000 0.00000

* DISPLACEMENT OF GROUPED PILE FOUNDATION AT ORIGIN *

DISP X,IN DISP Y,IN DISP Z,IN ROT X,RAD ROT Y,RAD ROT Z,RAD
-1.90447E-17 -1.49366E-13 -3.76639E-14 4.13028E-03 1.55269E-22 -8.12379E-23

* TABLE M * COMPUTATION ON INDIVIDUAL PILE

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS, GLOBAL *

DISP. X,IN DISP. Y,IN DISP. Z,IN ROT. X,RAD ROT. Y,RAD ROT. Z,RAD
*********** *********** *********** *********** *********** ***********
MINIMUM -1.9057E-17 -0.2230 -0.2230 4.1303E-03 1.5527E-22 -8.1238E-23
Pile N. 1 2 1 1 1 1
MAXIMUM -1.9032E-17 0.2230 0.2230 4.1303E-03 1.5527E-22 -8.1238E-23
Pile N. 4 1 3 1 1 1

* PILE TOP REACTIONS, GLOBAL *

FOR. X,LBS FOR. Y,LBS FOR. Z,LBS MOM X,LBS-IN MOM Y,LBS-IN MOM Z,LBS-IN
*********** *********** *********** *********** *********** ***********
MINIMUM 2.1764E-13 -2.0833E+04 -2.0833E+04 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000
Pile N. 1 2 1 1 1 1
MAXIMUM 4.1906E-13 2.0833E+04 2.0833E+04 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000
Pile N. 4 1 3 1 1 1

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS, LOCAL *

DISP. x,IN DISP. y,IN DISP. z,IN ROT. x,RAD ROT. y,RAD ROT. z,RAD
*********** *********** *********** *********** *********** ***********
MINIMUM 2.5637E-19 0.3154 -1.3217E-13 4.1303E-03 -2.5307E-19 -1.6724E-22
Pile N. 1 1 1 1 4 3
MAXIMUM 2.8192E-19 0.3154 1.3226E-13 4.1303E-03 -2.5274E-19 1.6724E-22
Pile N. 4 1 4 1 1 2

* PILE TOP REACTIONS, LOCAL *

AXIAL,LBS LAT. y,LBS LAT. z,LBS MOM x,LBS-IN MOM y,LBS-IN MOM z,LBS-IN
*********** *********** *********** *********** *********** ***********
MINIMUM 2.0217E-12 2.9463E+04 -1.2346E-08 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000
Pile N. 1 1 1 1 1 1
MAXIMUM 2.2231E-12 2.9463E+04 1.2354E-08 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000
Pile N. 4 1 4 1 1 1

* EFFECTS FOR LATERALLY LOADED PILE *

PILE DISPL. DISPL. MOMENT MOMENT SHEAR SOIL REACT TOTAL

y-DIR z-DIR z-DIR y-DIR y-z-DIR y-z-DIR STRESS
IN IN LBS-IN LBS-IN LBS LBS/IN LBS/IN**2
****** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
Min. -1.6540E-03 -1.3217E-13 -1.7404E+05 -1.3104E-06 2.2759E-15 0.0000 1.9860E-15
Pile N. 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
Max. 0.3154 1.3226E-13 3.1271E+06 1.3112E-06 3.4936E+04 607.88 682.71
Pile N. 1 4 1 4 1 1 1

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-81

2.4.7 Graphs

Figure 2.10 Curves Resultant Deflection vs. Distance for Example Problem 3 - 3D.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-82

Figure 2.11 Curves Resultant Moment vs. Distance for Example Problem 3 - 3D.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-83

2.5 Example Problem 4 - 3D

2.5.1 Model Description

This example is used to demonstrate an application of employing a pile group to be part of

breasting structures (Figure 2.12). Two rows of steel piles are, in general, used for breasting structures.
The front row consists of 5 batter piles (batter angle= 10 degrees) and the back row consists of 4
battered piles (batter angle= 20 degrees ). Each steel pile is 96 feet in length with an outside diameter
of 24 inches. The thickness of the steel pile is 0.5 inches. The pile head is 53 feet above the mud line.

The soil at the site is medium to medium dense sand underlain by a layer of stiff clay. The
internal friction angle vary from 25 degree near the top to 35 degree at the bottom of the sand layer.
The stiff clay has an averaged shear strength of 48 psi at depths of 85 feet to 100 feet from the origin
which is set at the bottom of the pile cap.

The input and output files for the example problem are shown in the following pages.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-84

Figure 2.12 General Description of Example Problem 4 - 3D.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-85

2.5.2 Input Data

EXAMPLE PROBLEM 4 - 3D, Pile Group for Breasting Structure

GROUP2016.10.8
* Analysis Parameters
1 3 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 1
* Pile Cap Dimensions
0 0 0 0 0 0
* Load Cases
1 0 0 1 0
0 1 1 1 1 300 300
0.0001 0.0001 1 1
Load Case 1
12 0 0 0 1 0 0 0
2 1 1 0 1E-7 1E-5 0 0 0
1
0 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 0 0 0 1 0 0 1 0 1 0 0 0 0 1 1
1
513228 485000 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
0
0
* Load Combinations
0 0 0 0 0
* Distributed Load Sets
0
* Pile Group Configuration
9
2 2 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 1
0 0 1 1 1 1 1
0 -1 -8 180 80 0 53
2 2 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 1
0 0 1 1 1 1 1
0 -1 -4 180 80 0 53
2 2 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 1
0 0 1 1 1 1 1
0 -1 0 180 80 0 53
2 2 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 1
0 0 1 1 1 1 1
0 -1 4 180 80 0 53
2 2 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 1
0 0 1 1 1 1 1
0 -1 8 180 80 0 53
2 2 1 0 0 0 0 0 2 2
0 0 1 1 1 1 1
0 5 -8 360 70 0 53
2 2 1 0 0 0 0 0 2 2
0 0 1 1 1 1 1
0 5 -4 360 70 0 53
2 2 1 0 0 0 0 0 2 2
0 0 1 1 1 1 1
0 5 4 360 70 0 53
2 2 1 0 0 0 0 0 2 2
0 0 1 1 1 1 1
0 5 8 360 70 0 53
* Pile Properties
1
0 1
50 96 1
0 96 1
* Pile Cross Sections
1
0 0 0 0
Section 1
24 0 1 1 0 0 0.1 0.1
1 36.92 2549 2549 0 3.7E10 0 0 29000000 0 0
0 0 0 0 1
None

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-86

* Soil Layers
3
0 4
53 60
2 10
92.999992 0 25 40 0 0 0 9360 0 0
96.000008 0 28 40 0 0 0 21312 0 0
1 4
60 85
2 10
99.999999 0 32 60 0 0 0 21312 0 0
105 0 35 60 0 0 0 81792 0 0
2 2
85 100
2 10
99.999999 6912 0 1750 0 0.004 0 3456 0 0
99.999999 6912 0 1750 0 0.004 0 3456 0 0
* Generated LD curves
2
1
6
* Generated TR curves
2
1
6
* User defined MC curves
1
1 1
0
1 1
0 0
* Internally Generated MC curves
1
1 1
0
0
1 1
0 0
1 1
0
0
1 1
0 0
* End of file

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-87

2.5.3 Echo Print File

=========================================================================

GROUP for Windows, Version 2016.10.8

Serial Number : 136089307

Analysis of A Group of Piles

Subjected to Axial and Lateral Loading

(c) Copyright ENSOFT, Inc., 1987-2015

All Rights Reserved

=========================================================================

This program is licensed to :

ENSOFT, INC
AUSTIN, TX

Path to file locations : C:\projects\GROUP2016\Group2016_1008\DXE\Examples_2016\

Name of input data file : 3Dexample4.gp10r
Name of output echo file : 3Dexample4.gp10e
Name of output results file : 3Dexample4.gp10o
Name of output summary file : 3Dexample4.gp10t
Name of plot output file : 3Dexample4.gp10p
Name of runtime file : 3Dexample4.gp10r

-------------------------------------------------------------------------
Time and Date of Analysis
-------------------------------------------------------------------------

Date: May 09, 2016 Time: 18:14:30

***** INPUT INFORMATION *****

EXAMPLE PROBLEM 4 - 3D, Pile Group for Breasting Structure

ANALYSIS TYPE = 3D ANALYSIS

ADJUST DEPTH FOR BATTER PILES

GENERATE LOAD-DISP (AND T-R) CURVES BASED ON SOIL PROFILE

EXTEND INTERPOLATION FOR L-DP (AND T-R) CURVES

UNITS SYSTEM = ENGL

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-88

* TABLE C * LOAD AND CONTROL PARAMETERS

** LOAD CASES **

NUMBER OF LOAD CASES : 1

LOAD CASE : 1
CASE NAME : Load Case 1
LOAD TYPE : Special, Sp
SCALE FACTOR : 1.0000

* CONCENTRATED LOADS *

NL VERT.LOAD HR.LOAD Y HR.LOAD Z MOMENT X MOMENT Y MOMENT Z COORD X COORD Y COORD Z

LBS LBS LBS LBS-IN LBS-IN LBS-IN FT FT FT
1 5.13E+05 4.85E+05 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00

* EQUIVALENT CONCENTRATED LOAD AT ORIGIN *

VER.LOAD X,LBS HOR.LOAD Y,LBS HOR.LOAD Z,LBS

5.13228E+05 4.85000E+05 0.00000

MOMENT X,LBS-IN MOMENT Y,LBS-IN MOMENT Z,LBS-IN

0.00000 0.00000 0.00000

* THE LOADING IS STATIC *

* CONTROL PARAMETERS *
TOLERANCE ON CONVERGENCE OF PILE CAP MOVEMENT = 1.00000E-04
TOLERANCE ON DETERMINATION OF PILE DEFLECTIONS = 1.00000E-04 IN
MAX NO OF ITERATIONS ALLOWED FOR FOUNDATION ANALYSIS = 300
MAXIMUM NO OF ITERATIONS ALLOWED FOR PILE ANALYSIS = 300
FACTOR TO APPLY THE LOAD IN INCREMENTS = 1.0000
MINIMUM FACTOR FOR LOAD INCREMENTS = 1.0000
PRINT RESULTS AT PILE CAP, PILE HEADS AND ALONG PILES
PRINT RESULTS EVERY 1 NODE(S)

* TABLE D * ARRANGEMENT OF PILE GROUPS

GROUP CONN.Z-Z CONN.Y-Y PILE PROP P-Y CURVE L-S CURVE T-R CURVE R-F-L SET
1 FIX FIX 1 0 1 G 1 G 0
2 FIX FIX 1 0 1 G 1 G 0
3 FIX FIX 1 0 1 G 1 G 0
4 FIX FIX 1 0 1 G 1 G 0
5 FIX FIX 1 0 1 G 1 G 0
6 FIX FIX 1 0 2 G 2 G 0
7 FIX FIX 1 0 2 G 2 G 0
8 FIX FIX 1 0 2 G 2 G 0
9 FIX FIX 1 0 2 G 2 G 0

GROUP CorX,FT CorY,FT CorZ,FT ALPHA,DEG BETA,DEG THETA,DEG GROUND,FT SPz,LBS-IN

SPy,LBS-IN
1 0.000 -1.000 -8.000 180.0 80.00 0.000 53.00 0.000
0.000

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-89

2 0.000 -1.000 -4.000 180.0 80.00 0.000 53.00 0.000

0.000
3 0.000 -1.000 0.000 180.0 80.00 0.000 53.00 0.000
0.000
4 0.000 -1.000 4.000 180.0 80.00 0.000 53.00 0.000
0.000
5 0.000 -1.000 8.000 180.0 80.00 0.000 53.00 0.000
0.000
6 0.000 5.000 -8.000 360.0 70.00 0.000 53.00 0.000
0.000
7 0.000 5.000 -4.000 360.0 70.00 0.000 53.00 0.000
0.000
8 0.000 5.000 4.000 360.0 70.00 0.000 53.00 0.000
0.000
9 0.000 5.000 8.000 360.0 70.00 0.000 53.00 0.000
0.000

* TABLE E * PILE GEOMETRY AND PROPERTIES

PILE TYPE = 1 - DRIVEN PILE
= 2 - DRILLED SHAFT

PROP SECTS INC PILE TYPE LENGTH, FT

1 1 50 1 96.000

* PILE SECTIONS *

PROP SECT FROM,FT TO,FT CROSS SECT

1 1 0.00000 96.0000 1

* PILE CROSS SECTIONS *

CROSS SECTION : 1
SECTION NAME : Section

TYPE : ELASTIC
CROSS SECTION TYPE : GENERAL SECTION
EQUIVALENT DIAMETER : 24.0000 IN
YOUNG MODULUS : 2.90000E+07 LBS/IN**2

* PILE CROSS SECTIONS PROPERTIES *

ELASTIC SECTIONS

SECT DIAM,IN AREA,IN**2 Iz,IN**4 Iy,IN**4 GJ,LBS-IN**2 Mn,LBS-IN Vn,LBS

1 24.000 36.920 2549.0 2549.0 3.7000E+10 0.0000 0.0000

* TABLE F * SOIL DATA

SOILS INFORMATION

GROUND SURFACE = 53.0000 FT

3 LAYER(S) OF SOIL

LAYER 1
THE SOIL IS A SAND
TOP OF LAYER BOTTOM OF LAYER
X COORDINATE (FT) 53.0000 60.0000
EFFECTIVE UNIT WEIGHT (LBS/FT**3) 93.0000 96.0000
FRICTION ANGLE (DEGREES) 25.0000 28.0000

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-90

P-Y SUBGRADE MODULUS (LBS/IN**3) 40.0000 40.0000

ULTIMATE UNIT SIDE FRICTION (LBS/FT**2) 9360.00 21312.0
ULTIMATE UNIT TIP RESISTANCE (LBS/FT**2) 0.00000 0.00000

LAYER 2
THE SOIL IS A SAND
TOP OF LAYER BOTTOM OF LAYER
X COORDINATE (FT) 60.0000 85.0000
EFFECTIVE UNIT WEIGHT (LBS/FT**3) 100.0000 105.000
FRICTION ANGLE (DEGREES) 32.0000 35.0000
P-Y SUBGRADE MODULUS (LBS/IN**3) 60.0000 60.0000
ULTIMATE UNIT SIDE FRICTION (LBS/FT**2) 21312.0 81792.0
ULTIMATE UNIT TIP RESISTANCE (LBS/FT**2) 0.00000 0.00000

LAYER 3
THE SOIL IS A STIFF CLAY WITH FREE WATER
TOP OF LAYER BOTTOM OF LAYER
X COORDINATE (FT) 85.0000 100.000
EFFECTIVE UNIT WEIGHT (LBS/FT**3) 100.0000 100.0000
UNDRAINED COHESION, C (LBS/FT**2) 6912.00 6912.00
P-Y SUBGRADE MODULUS (LBS/IN**3) 1750.00 1750.00
STRAIN AT 50% STRESS 4.00000E-03 4.00000E-03
ULTIMATE UNIT SIDE FRICTION (LBS/FT**2) 3456.00 3456.00
ULTIMATE UNIT TIP RESISTANCE (LBS/FT**2) 62208.0 (R) 62208.0 (R)

Notes : Program estimated values for listed parameters

if zero input values were entered:
(R) ULTIMATE UNIT TIP RESISTANCE for Driven Piles

* TABLE H * AXIAL LOAD VS DISPLACEMENT

AXIAL LOAD-DISPLACEMENT CURVES GENERATED INTERNALLY

NUM OF CURVES 2

CURVE 1 NUM OF POINTS 19

DISPLACEMENT, IN AXIAL LOAD,LBS

-4.57614 -3.10686E+06
-2.56421 -1.87490E+06
-1.55560 -1.25470E+06
-0.56795 -5.31331E+05
-0.40759 -3.98607E+05
-0.0856763 -84469.1
-0.0425534 -41948.7
-8.33853E-03 -8181.97
-8.33853E-04 -818.197
0.00000 0.00000
8.44124E-04 828.937
8.44125E-03 8289.37
0.0430814 42502.8
0.0867622 85608.1
0.41252 4.03730E+05
0.57643 5.40059E+05
1.57252 1.27148E+06
2.58519 1.89571E+06
4.59670 3.12701E+06

CURVE 2 NUM OF POINTS 19

DISPLACEMENT, IN AXIAL LOAD,LBS

-4.71049 -3.15931E+06
-2.60538 -1.86906E+06
-1.54929 -1.21852E+06
-0.48309 -4.31488E+05

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-91

-0.31516 -2.93269E+05
-0.0648844 -60782.3
-0.0322971 -30251.7
-6.37585E-03 -5947.06
-6.37584E-04 -594.706
0.00000 0.00000
6.46842E-04 604.217
6.46842E-03 6042.17
0.0327679 30736.8
0.0658430 61769.8
0.31980 2.98019E+05
0.49153 4.40061E+05
1.56597 1.23488E+06
2.62607 1.88935E+06
4.73063 3.17879E+06

* TABLE I * TORS. MOM. VS ANGLE ROT.

TORQUE-ROTATION CURVES GENERATED INTERNALLY

NUM OF CURVES 2

CURVE 1 NUM OF POINTS 19

ROT. ANGLE,Rad. TORS.MOMEN,LBS-IN

-1.07219 -3.81677E+07
-0.72041 -2.71638E+07
-0.49188 -1.90589E+07
-0.28285 -1.14491E+07
-0.24675 -1.00822E+07
-0.0677094 -2.81902E+06
-0.0322957 -1.34795E+06
-6.16861E-03 -2.56429E+05
-6.17202E-04 -25660.8
0.00000 0.00000
6.17202E-04 25660.8
6.16861E-03 2.56429E+05
0.0322957 1.34795E+06
0.0677094 2.81902E+06
0.24675 1.00822E+07
0.28285 1.14491E+07
0.49188 1.90589E+07
0.72041 2.71638E+07
1.07219 3.81677E+07

CURVE 2 NUM OF POINTS 19

ROT. ANGLE,Rad. TORS.MOMEN,LBS-IN

-1.07219 -3.81677E+07
-0.72041 -2.71638E+07
-0.49188 -1.90589E+07
-0.28285 -1.14491E+07
-0.24675 -1.00822E+07
-0.0677094 -2.81902E+06
-0.0322957 -1.34795E+06
-6.16861E-03 -2.56429E+05
-6.17202E-04 -25660.8
0.00000 0.00000
6.17202E-04 25660.8
6.16861E-03 2.56429E+05
0.0322957 1.34795E+06
0.0677094 2.81902E+06
0.24675 1.00822E+07
0.28285 1.14491E+07
0.49188 1.90589E+07
0.72041 2.71638E+07

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-92

1.07219 3.81677E+07

* TABLE J * MOMENT CURVATURE SETS

USER DEFINED MOMENT CURVATURE

NUM OF SETS : 1

CURVE SET 1 NUM OF CURVES 1

CURVE 1 AXIAL LOAD 0.000E+00 LBS

POINT MOMENT CURVATURE

LBS-IN RADIAN/IN
1 0.00000 0.00000

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-93

2.5.4 Processor Run Notes

GROUP for Windows, Version 2016.10.8

-------------------------------------------------------------------------
Time and Date of Analysis
-------------------------------------------------------------------------

Date: May 09, 2016 Time: 18:14:30

EXAMPLE PROBLEM 4 - 3D, Pile Group for Breasting Structure

READING * TITLE AND VERSION

READING * Analysis Parameters
READING * Pile Cap Dimensions
READING * Load Cases
READING * Load Combinations
READING * Distributed Load Sets
READING * Pile Group Configuration
READING * Pile Properties
READING * Pile Cross Sections
READING * Soil Layers
READING * Generated LD curves
READING * Generated TR curves
READING * User defined MC curves
READING * Internally Generated MC curves

COMPUTATION IS PROCEEDING......

LOAD CASE : 1
CASE NAME : Load Case 1

GLOBAL ITERATIONS
STEP 1, TCUR 1.0000, DTCUR 1.0000
ITERATION 1
- ErrDsp 0.10000E+01, IncDsp 0.22242E+01, TotDsp 0.22242E+01
- ErrRot 0.10000E+01, IncRot 0.11994E-01, TotRot 0.11994E-01
ITERATION 2
- ErrDsp 0.32744E-01, IncDsp 0.75295E-01, TotDsp 0.22995E+01
- ErrRot 0.42054E-01, IncRot 0.52656E-03, TotRot 0.12521E-01
ITERATION 3
- ErrDsp 0.80669E-03, IncDsp 0.18565E-02, TotDsp 0.23014E+01
- ErrRot 0.21281E-02, IncRot 0.26702E-04, TotRot 0.12547E-01
ITERATION 4
- ErrDsp 0.39831E-07, IncDsp 0.91667E-07, TotDsp0.23014E+01
- ErrRot 0.17570E-07, IncRot 0.22046E-09, TotRot
0.12547E-01
NUMBER OF GLOBAL ITERATIONS = 4

ANALYSIS FOR LOAD CASE 1/ 1 FINISHED

Execution Time : 210 ms
Number Processors : 1/ 1
Serial processing : 0.108 sec
Paral. processing : 0.047 sec
Print. processing : 0.055 sec

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-94

ANALYSIS COMPLETED
Execution Time : 210 ms
Number Processors : 1/ 1

2.5.5 Output Results File

=========================================================================

GROUP for Windows, Version 2016.10.8

Serial Number : 136089307

Analysis of A Group of Piles

Subjected to Axial and Lateral Loading

(c) Copyright ENSOFT, Inc., 1987-2015

All Rights Reserved

=========================================================================

This program is licensed to :

ENSOFT, INC
AUSTIN, TX

Path to file locations : C:\projects\GROUP2016\Group2016_1008\DXE\Examples_2016\

Name of input data file : 3Dexample4.gp10d
Name of output echo file : 3Dexample4.gp10e
Name of output results file : 3Dexample4.gp10o
Name of output summary file : 3Dexample4.gp10t
Name of plot output file : 3Dexample4.gp10p
Name of runtime file : 3Dexample4.gp10r

-------------------------------------------------------------------------
Time and Date of Analysis
-------------------------------------------------------------------------

Date: May 09, 2016 Time: 18:14:30

***** COMPUTATION RESULTS *****

EXAMPLE PROBLEM 4 - 3D, Pile Group for Breasting Structure

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-95

***** LOAD CASES RESULTS *****

LOAD CASE : 1
CASE NAME : Load Case 1
LOAD TYPE : Special, Sp

* TABLE L * COMPUTATION ON PILE CAP

* EQUIVALENT CONCENTRATED LOAD AT ORIGIN *

VERT. LOAD, LBS HOR. LOAD Y, LBS HOR. LOAD Z, LBS

5.13228E+05 4.85000E+05 0.00000

MOMENT X ,LBS-IN MOMENT Y,LBS-IN MOMENT Z,LBS-IN

0.00000 0.00000 0.00000

* DISPLACEMENT OF GROUPED PILE FOUNDATION AT ORIGIN *

VERTICAL ,IN HORIZONTAL Y,IN HORIZONTAL Z,IN

0.18083 2.29425 -2.04278E-14

ANGLE ROT. X,RAD ANGLE ROT. Y,RAD ANGLE ROT. Z,RAD

-1.34787E-16 -7.46304E-17 0.0125472

NUMBER OF GLOBAL ITERATIONS = 4

* TABLE M * COMPUTATION ON INDIVIDUAL PILE

* PILE GROUP * 1

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS AND REACTIONS *

THE GLOBAL STRUCTURAL COORDINATE SYSTEM

---------------------------------------

DISP. X,IN DISP. Y,IN DISP. Z,IN ROT. X,RAD ROT. Y,RAD ROT. Z,RAD
0.3314 2.2942 -1.8810E-14 -1.3479E-16 -7.4630E-17 0.012547

FOR. X,LBS FOR. Y,LBS FOR. Z,LBS MOM X,LBS-IN MOM Y,LBS-IN MOM Z,LBS-IN
-6.7587E+04 2.5654E+04 3.2118E-11 -9.0979E-09 -2.2208E-08 6.4664E+06

STR,LBS/IN**2
3.2365E+04

THE PILE COORDINATE SYSTEM (LOCAL AXES)

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-96

---------------------------------------

DISP. x,IN DISP. y,IN DISP. z,IN ROT. x,RAD ROT. y,RAD ROT. z,RAD
-0.072031 -2.3169 1.8529E-14 -1.1951E-16 9.8415E-17 -0.012547

AXIAL,LBS LAT. y,LBS LAT. z,LBS MOM x,LBS-IN MOM y,LBS-IN MOM z,LBS-IN
-7.1015E+04 -1.3528E+04 -3.5260E-11 -4.9658E-09 2.4230E-08 -6.4664E+06

STR,LBS/IN**2
3.2365E+04

* EFFECTS FOR LATERALLY LOADED PILE *

x DISPL. DISPL. MOMENT MOMENT SHEAR SOIL REACT TOTAL

y-DIR z-DIR z-DIR y-DIR y-z-DIR y-z-DIR STRESS
FT IN IN LBS-IN LBS-IN LBS LBS/IN LBS/IN**2
********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
0.0000 -2.3169 1.8529E-14 6.4664E+06 2.4230E-08 1.3457E+04 0.0000 3.2365E+04
1.9200 -2.5828 1.6349E-14 6.1358E+06 2.3263E-08 1.3528E+04 0.0000 3.0809E+04
3.8400 -2.8046 1.4336E-14 5.8083E+06 2.2308E-08 1.3528E+04 0.0000 2.9268E+04
5.7600 -2.9847 1.2482E-14 5.4839E+06 2.1364E-08 1.3528E+04 0.0000 2.7740E+04
7.6800 -3.1254 1.0782E-14 5.1622E+06 2.0431E-08 1.3528E+04 0.0000 2.6226E+04
9.6000 -3.2291 9.2294E-15 4.8431E+06 1.9508E-08 1.3528E+04 0.0000 2.4724E+04
11.520 -3.2979 7.8163E-15 4.5265E+06 1.8595E-08 1.3528E+04 0.0000 2.3233E+04
13.440 -3.3343 6.5369E-15 4.2123E+06 1.7692E-08 1.3528E+04 0.0000 2.1754E+04
15.360 -3.3404 5.3844E-15 3.9001E+06 1.6798E-08 1.3528E+04 0.0000 2.0284E+04
17.280 -3.3185 4.3526E-15 3.5900E+06 1.5912E-08 1.3528E+04 0.0000 1.8824E+04
19.200 -3.2708 3.4351E-15 3.2817E+06 1.5034E-08 1.3528E+04 0.0000 1.7373E+04
21.120 -3.1996 2.6255E-15 2.9751E+06 1.4165E-08 1.3528E+04 0.0000 1.5929E+04
23.040 -3.1070 1.9177E-15 2.6699E+06 1.3302E-08 1.3528E+04 0.0000 1.4493E+04
24.960 -2.9952 1.3054E-15 2.3662E+06 1.2446E-08 1.3528E+04 0.0000 1.3063E+04
26.880 -2.8664 7.8242E-16 2.0636E+06 1.1597E-08 1.3528E+04 0.0000 1.1639E+04
28.800 -2.7228 3.4275E-16 1.7621E+06 1.0753E-08 1.3528E+04 0.0000 1.0219E+04
30.720 -2.5666 -1.9702E-17 1.4615E+06 9.9148E-09 1.3528E+04 0.0000 8804.0
32.640 -2.3998 -3.1095E-16 1.1617E+06 9.0817E-09 1.3528E+04 0.0000 7392.4
34.560 -2.2247 -5.3699E-16 8.6244E+05 8.2533E-09 1.3528E+04 0.0000 5983.6
36.480 -2.0435 -7.0375E-16 5.6362E+05 7.4291E-09 1.3528E+04 0.0000 4576.8
38.400 -1.8581 -8.1717E-16 2.6508E+05 6.6086E-09 1.3528E+04 0.0000 3171.4
40.320 -1.6709 -8.8313E-16 -3.3312E+04 5.7915E-09 1.3528E+04 0.0000 2080.3
42.240 -1.4839 -9.0749E-16 -3.3173E+05 4.9774E-09 1.3528E+04 0.0000 3485.2
44.160 -1.2993 -8.9612E-16 -6.3031E+05 4.1658E-09 1.3528E+04 0.0000 4890.8
46.080 -1.1192 -8.5482E-16 -9.2921E+05 3.3564E-09 1.3528E+04 0.0000 6298.0
48.000 -0.9458 -7.8943E-16 -1.2286E+06 2.5486E-09 1.3528E+04 0.0000 7707.4
49.920 -0.7812 -7.0573E-16 -1.5286E+06 1.7422E-09 1.3528E+04 0.0000 9119.7
51.840 -0.6276 -6.0952E-16 -1.8294E+06 9.3664E-10 1.3528E+04 0.0000 1.0536E+04
53.760 -0.4871 -5.0659E-16 -2.1311E+06 1.3157E-10 1.3528E+04 0.0000 1.1956E+04
55.680 -0.3620 -4.0271E-16 -2.4339E+06 -6.7344E-10 1.1831E+04 147.36 1.3382E+04
57.600 -0.2543 -3.0367E-16 -2.6597E+06 -1.3918E-09 7000.3 271.95 1.4445E+04
59.520 -0.1657 -2.1462E-16 -2.7425E+06 -1.9384E-09 165.29 321.37 1.4835E+04
61.440 -9.6791E-02 -1.3949E-16 -2.6562E+06 -2.2651E-09 7952.6 383.30 1.4428E+04
63.360 -4.6969E-02 -8.0626E-17 -2.3677E+06 -2.2996E-09 1.5834E+04 300.81 1.3070E+04
65.280 -1.4150E-02 -3.8278E-17 -1.9207E+06 -2.0613E-09 2.0624E+04 115.00 1.0966E+04
67.200 4.8768E-03 -1.0731E-17 -1.4136E+06 -1.6588E-09 2.1415E+04 46.275 8578.5
69.120 1.3752E-02 4.9034E-18 -9.3188E+05 -1.2031E-09 1.9163E+04 149.21 6310.5
71.040 1.5935E-02 1.1898E-17 -5.2980E+05 -7.7630E-10 1.5203E+04 194.59 4417.6
72.960 1.4313E-02 1.3318E-17 -2.3129E+05 -4.2701E-10 1.0723E+04 194.27 3012.3
74.880 1.1030E-02 1.1671E-17 -3.6024E+04 -1.7390E-10 6587.4 164.73 2093.1
76.800 7.4891E-03 8.7758E-18 7.1774E+04 -1.3406E-11 3283.7 122.04 2261.4
78.720 4.4633E-03 5.7841E-18 1.1482E+05 7.1167E-11 969.91 78.810 2464.0
80.640 2.2620E-03 3.3034E-18 1.1610E+05 1.0156E-10 433.58 43.021 2470.0
82.560 8.9444E-04 1.5521E-18 9.4591E+04 9.8656E-11 1139.2 18.229 2368.8
84.480 2.0614E-04 5.0925E-19 6.3457E+04 7.9009E-11 1400.8 4.4817 2222.2
86.400 -2.6465E-05 3.3767E-20 2.9977E+04 5.3524E-11 1247.0 17.833 2064.6
88.320 -4.3800E-05 -5.7348E-20 5978.2 1.5989E-11 681.51 31.253 1951.6
90.240 -1.8203E-05 -3.3642E-20 -1426.8 1.8438E-13 163.52 13.712 1930.2
92.160 -2.8528E-06 -8.6124E-21 -1553.9 -2.1681E-12 20.497 2.2621 1930.8
94.080 1.3388E-06 8.4788E-22 -480.93 -8.9645E-13 33.714 1.1148 1925.7

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-97

96.000 2.0768E-06 3.8706E-21 1.1795E-13 2.0952E-28 3.3133E-15 1.8117 1923.5

* PILE GROUP * 2

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS AND REACTIONS *

THE GLOBAL STRUCTURAL COORDINATE SYSTEM

---------------------------------------

DISP. X,IN DISP. Y,IN DISP. Z,IN ROT. X,RAD ROT. Y,RAD ROT. Z,RAD
0.3314 2.2942 -1.8810E-14 -1.3479E-16 -7.4630E-17 0.012547

FOR. X,LBS FOR. Y,LBS FOR. Z,LBS MOM X,LBS-IN MOM Y,LBS-IN MOM Z,LBS-IN
-6.7587E+04 2.5654E+04 3.2118E-11 -9.0979E-09 -2.2208E-08 6.4664E+06

STR,LBS/IN**2
3.2365E+04

THE PILE COORDINATE SYSTEM (LOCAL AXES)

---------------------------------------

DISP. x,IN DISP. y,IN DISP. z,IN ROT. x,RAD ROT. y,RAD ROT. z,RAD
-0.072031 -2.3169 1.8529E-14 -1.1951E-16 9.8415E-17 -0.012547

AXIAL,LBS LAT. y,LBS LAT. z,LBS MOM x,LBS-IN MOM y,LBS-IN MOM z,LBS-IN
-7.1015E+04 -1.3528E+04 -3.5260E-11 -4.9658E-09 2.4230E-08 -6.4664E+06

STR,LBS/IN**2
3.2365E+04

* EFFECTS FOR LATERALLY LOADED PILE *

x DISPL. DISPL. MOMENT MOMENT SHEAR SOIL REACT TOTAL

y-DIR z-DIR z-DIR y-DIR y-z-DIR y-z-DIR STRESS
FT IN IN LBS-IN LBS-IN LBS LBS/IN LBS/IN**2
********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
0.0000 -2.3169 1.8529E-14 6.4664E+06 2.4230E-08 1.3457E+04 0.0000 3.2365E+04
1.9200 -2.5828 1.6349E-14 6.1358E+06 2.3263E-08 1.3528E+04 0.0000 3.0809E+04
3.8400 -2.8046 1.4336E-14 5.8083E+06 2.2308E-08 1.3528E+04 0.0000 2.9268E+04
5.7600 -2.9847 1.2482E-14 5.4839E+06 2.1364E-08 1.3528E+04 0.0000 2.7740E+04
7.6800 -3.1254 1.0782E-14 5.1622E+06 2.0431E-08 1.3528E+04 0.0000 2.6226E+04
9.6000 -3.2291 9.2294E-15 4.8431E+06 1.9508E-08 1.3528E+04 0.0000 2.4724E+04
11.520 -3.2979 7.8163E-15 4.5265E+06 1.8595E-08 1.3528E+04 0.0000 2.3233E+04
13.440 -3.3343 6.5369E-15 4.2123E+06 1.7692E-08 1.3528E+04 0.0000 2.1754E+04
15.360 -3.3404 5.3844E-15 3.9001E+06 1.6798E-08 1.3528E+04 0.0000 2.0284E+04
17.280 -3.3185 4.3526E-15 3.5900E+06 1.5912E-08 1.3528E+04 0.0000 1.8824E+04
19.200 -3.2708 3.4351E-15 3.2817E+06 1.5034E-08 1.3528E+04 0.0000 1.7373E+04
21.120 -3.1996 2.6255E-15 2.9751E+06 1.4165E-08 1.3528E+04 0.0000 1.5929E+04
23.040 -3.1070 1.9177E-15 2.6699E+06 1.3302E-08 1.3528E+04 0.0000 1.4493E+04
24.960 -2.9952 1.3054E-15 2.3662E+06 1.2446E-08 1.3528E+04 0.0000 1.3063E+04
26.880 -2.8664 7.8242E-16 2.0636E+06 1.1597E-08 1.3528E+04 0.0000 1.1639E+04
28.800 -2.7228 3.4275E-16 1.7621E+06 1.0753E-08 1.3528E+04 0.0000 1.0219E+04
30.720 -2.5666 -1.9702E-17 1.4615E+06 9.9148E-09 1.3528E+04 0.0000 8804.0
32.640 -2.3998 -3.1095E-16 1.1617E+06 9.0817E-09 1.3528E+04 0.0000 7392.4
34.560 -2.2247 -5.3699E-16 8.6244E+05 8.2533E-09 1.3528E+04 0.0000 5983.6
36.480 -2.0435 -7.0375E-16 5.6362E+05 7.4291E-09 1.3528E+04 0.0000 4576.8
38.400 -1.8581 -8.1717E-16 2.6508E+05 6.6086E-09 1.3528E+04 0.0000 3171.4
40.320 -1.6709 -8.8313E-16 -3.3312E+04 5.7915E-09 1.3528E+04 0.0000 2080.3

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-98

42.240 -1.4839 -9.0749E-16 -3.3173E+05 4.9774E-09 1.3528E+04 0.0000 3485.2

44.160 -1.2993 -8.9612E-16 -6.3031E+05 4.1658E-09 1.3528E+04 0.0000 4890.8
46.080 -1.1192 -8.5482E-16 -9.2921E+05 3.3564E-09 1.3528E+04 0.0000 6298.0
48.000 -0.9458 -7.8943E-16 -1.2286E+06 2.5486E-09 1.3528E+04 0.0000 7707.4
49.920 -0.7812 -7.0573E-16 -1.5286E+06 1.7422E-09 1.3528E+04 0.0000 9119.7
51.840 -0.6276 -6.0952E-16 -1.8294E+06 9.3664E-10 1.3528E+04 0.0000 1.0536E+04
53.760 -0.4871 -5.0659E-16 -2.1311E+06 1.3157E-10 1.3528E+04 0.0000 1.1956E+04
55.680 -0.3620 -4.0271E-16 -2.4339E+06 -6.7344E-10 1.1831E+04 147.36 1.3382E+04
57.600 -0.2543 -3.0367E-16 -2.6597E+06 -1.3918E-09 7000.3 271.95 1.4445E+04
59.520 -0.1657 -2.1462E-16 -2.7425E+06 -1.9384E-09 165.29 321.37 1.4835E+04
61.440 -9.6791E-02 -1.3949E-16 -2.6562E+06 -2.2651E-09 7952.6 383.30 1.4428E+04
63.360 -4.6969E-02 -8.0626E-17 -2.3677E+06 -2.2996E-09 1.5834E+04 300.81 1.3070E+04
65.280 -1.4150E-02 -3.8278E-17 -1.9207E+06 -2.0613E-09 2.0624E+04 115.00 1.0966E+04
67.200 4.8768E-03 -1.0731E-17 -1.4136E+06 -1.6588E-09 2.1415E+04 46.275 8578.5
69.120 1.3752E-02 4.9034E-18 -9.3188E+05 -1.2031E-09 1.9163E+04 149.21 6310.5
71.040 1.5935E-02 1.1898E-17 -5.2980E+05 -7.7630E-10 1.5203E+04 194.59 4417.6
72.960 1.4313E-02 1.3318E-17 -2.3129E+05 -4.2701E-10 1.0723E+04 194.27 3012.3
74.880 1.1030E-02 1.1671E-17 -3.6024E+04 -1.7390E-10 6587.4 164.73 2093.1
76.800 7.4891E-03 8.7758E-18 7.1774E+04 -1.3406E-11 3283.7 122.04 2261.4
78.720 4.4633E-03 5.7841E-18 1.1482E+05 7.1167E-11 969.91 78.810 2464.0
80.640 2.2620E-03 3.3034E-18 1.1610E+05 1.0156E-10 433.58 43.021 2470.0
82.560 8.9444E-04 1.5521E-18 9.4591E+04 9.8656E-11 1139.2 18.229 2368.8
84.480 2.0614E-04 5.0925E-19 6.3457E+04 7.9009E-11 1400.8 4.4817 2222.2
86.400 -2.6465E-05 3.3767E-20 2.9977E+04 5.3524E-11 1247.0 17.833 2064.6
88.320 -4.3800E-05 -5.7348E-20 5978.2 1.5989E-11 681.51 31.253 1951.6
90.240 -1.8203E-05 -3.3642E-20 -1426.8 1.8438E-13 163.52 13.712 1930.2
92.160 -2.8528E-06 -8.6124E-21 -1553.9 -2.1681E-12 20.497 2.2621 1930.8
94.080 1.3388E-06 8.4788E-22 -480.93 -8.9645E-13 33.714 1.1148 1925.7
96.000 2.0768E-06 3.8706E-21 0.0000 0.0000 3.9235E-15 1.8117 1923.5

* PILE GROUP * 3

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS AND REACTIONS *

THE GLOBAL STRUCTURAL COORDINATE SYSTEM

---------------------------------------

DISP. X,IN DISP. Y,IN DISP. Z,IN ROT. X,RAD ROT. Y,RAD ROT. Z,RAD
0.3314 2.2942 -1.8810E-14 -1.3479E-16 -7.4630E-17 0.012547

FOR. X,LBS FOR. Y,LBS FOR. Z,LBS MOM X,LBS-IN MOM Y,LBS-IN MOM Z,LBS-IN
-6.7587E+04 2.5654E+04 3.2118E-11 -9.0979E-09 -2.2208E-08 6.4664E+06

STR,LBS/IN**2
3.2365E+04

THE PILE COORDINATE SYSTEM (LOCAL AXES)

---------------------------------------

DISP. x,IN DISP. y,IN DISP. z,IN ROT. x,RAD ROT. y,RAD ROT. z,RAD
-0.072031 -2.3169 1.8529E-14 -1.1951E-16 9.8415E-17 -0.012547

AXIAL,LBS LAT. y,LBS LAT. z,LBS MOM x,LBS-IN MOM y,LBS-IN MOM z,LBS-IN
-7.1015E+04 -1.3528E+04 -3.5260E-11 -4.9658E-09 2.4230E-08 -6.4664E+06

STR,LBS/IN**2
3.2365E+04

* EFFECTS FOR LATERALLY LOADED PILE *

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-99

x DISPL. DISPL. MOMENT MOMENT SHEAR SOIL REACT TOTAL

y-DIR z-DIR z-DIR y-DIR y-z-DIR y-z-DIR STRESS
FT IN IN LBS-IN LBS-IN LBS LBS/IN LBS/IN**2
********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
0.0000 -2.3169 1.8529E-14 6.4664E+06 2.4230E-08 1.3457E+04 0.0000 3.2365E+04
1.9200 -2.5828 1.6349E-14 6.1358E+06 2.3263E-08 1.3528E+04 0.0000 3.0809E+04
3.8400 -2.8046 1.4336E-14 5.8083E+06 2.2308E-08 1.3528E+04 0.0000 2.9268E+04
5.7600 -2.9847 1.2482E-14 5.4839E+06 2.1364E-08 1.3528E+04 0.0000 2.7740E+04
7.6800 -3.1254 1.0782E-14 5.1622E+06 2.0431E-08 1.3528E+04 0.0000 2.6226E+04
9.6000 -3.2291 9.2294E-15 4.8431E+06 1.9508E-08 1.3528E+04 0.0000 2.4724E+04
11.520 -3.2979 7.8163E-15 4.5265E+06 1.8595E-08 1.3528E+04 0.0000 2.3233E+04
13.440 -3.3343 6.5369E-15 4.2123E+06 1.7692E-08 1.3528E+04 0.0000 2.1754E+04
15.360 -3.3404 5.3844E-15 3.9001E+06 1.6798E-08 1.3528E+04 0.0000 2.0284E+04
17.280 -3.3185 4.3526E-15 3.5900E+06 1.5912E-08 1.3528E+04 0.0000 1.8824E+04
19.200 -3.2708 3.4351E-15 3.2817E+06 1.5034E-08 1.3528E+04 0.0000 1.7373E+04
21.120 -3.1996 2.6255E-15 2.9751E+06 1.4165E-08 1.3528E+04 0.0000 1.5929E+04
23.040 -3.1070 1.9177E-15 2.6699E+06 1.3302E-08 1.3528E+04 0.0000 1.4493E+04
24.960 -2.9952 1.3054E-15 2.3662E+06 1.2446E-08 1.3528E+04 0.0000 1.3063E+04
26.880 -2.8664 7.8242E-16 2.0636E+06 1.1597E-08 1.3528E+04 0.0000 1.1639E+04
28.800 -2.7228 3.4275E-16 1.7621E+06 1.0753E-08 1.3528E+04 0.0000 1.0219E+04
30.720 -2.5666 -1.9702E-17 1.4615E+06 9.9148E-09 1.3528E+04 0.0000 8804.0
32.640 -2.3998 -3.1095E-16 1.1617E+06 9.0817E-09 1.3528E+04 0.0000 7392.4
34.560 -2.2247 -5.3699E-16 8.6244E+05 8.2533E-09 1.3528E+04 0.0000 5983.6
36.480 -2.0435 -7.0375E-16 5.6362E+05 7.4291E-09 1.3528E+04 0.0000 4576.8
38.400 -1.8581 -8.1717E-16 2.6508E+05 6.6086E-09 1.3528E+04 0.0000 3171.4
40.320 -1.6709 -8.8313E-16 -3.3312E+04 5.7915E-09 1.3528E+04 0.0000 2080.3
42.240 -1.4839 -9.0749E-16 -3.3173E+05 4.9774E-09 1.3528E+04 0.0000 3485.2
44.160 -1.2993 -8.9612E-16 -6.3031E+05 4.1658E-09 1.3528E+04 0.0000 4890.8
46.080 -1.1192 -8.5482E-16 -9.2921E+05 3.3564E-09 1.3528E+04 0.0000 6298.0
48.000 -0.9458 -7.8943E-16 -1.2286E+06 2.5486E-09 1.3528E+04 0.0000 7707.4
49.920 -0.7812 -7.0573E-16 -1.5286E+06 1.7422E-09 1.3528E+04 0.0000 9119.7
51.840 -0.6276 -6.0952E-16 -1.8294E+06 9.3664E-10 1.3528E+04 0.0000 1.0536E+04
53.760 -0.4871 -5.0659E-16 -2.1311E+06 1.3157E-10 1.3528E+04 0.0000 1.1956E+04
55.680 -0.3620 -4.0271E-16 -2.4339E+06 -6.7344E-10 1.1831E+04 147.36 1.3382E+04
57.600 -0.2543 -3.0367E-16 -2.6597E+06 -1.3918E-09 7000.3 271.95 1.4445E+04
59.520 -0.1657 -2.1462E-16 -2.7425E+06 -1.9384E-09 165.29 321.37 1.4835E+04
61.440 -9.6791E-02 -1.3949E-16 -2.6562E+06 -2.2651E-09 7952.6 383.30 1.4428E+04
63.360 -4.6969E-02 -8.0626E-17 -2.3677E+06 -2.2996E-09 1.5834E+04 300.81 1.3070E+04
65.280 -1.4150E-02 -3.8278E-17 -1.9207E+06 -2.0613E-09 2.0624E+04 115.00 1.0966E+04
67.200 4.8768E-03 -1.0731E-17 -1.4136E+06 -1.6588E-09 2.1415E+04 46.275 8578.5
69.120 1.3752E-02 4.9034E-18 -9.3188E+05 -1.2031E-09 1.9163E+04 149.21 6310.5
71.040 1.5935E-02 1.1898E-17 -5.2980E+05 -7.7630E-10 1.5203E+04 194.59 4417.6
72.960 1.4313E-02 1.3318E-17 -2.3129E+05 -4.2701E-10 1.0723E+04 194.27 3012.3
74.880 1.1030E-02 1.1671E-17 -3.6024E+04 -1.7390E-10 6587.4 164.73 2093.1
76.800 7.4891E-03 8.7758E-18 7.1774E+04 -1.3406E-11 3283.7 122.04 2261.4
78.720 4.4633E-03 5.7841E-18 1.1482E+05 7.1167E-11 969.91 78.810 2464.0
80.640 2.2620E-03 3.3034E-18 1.1610E+05 1.0156E-10 433.58 43.021 2470.0
82.560 8.9444E-04 1.5521E-18 9.4591E+04 9.8656E-11 1139.2 18.229 2368.8
84.480 2.0614E-04 5.0925E-19 6.3457E+04 7.9009E-11 1400.8 4.4817 2222.2
86.400 -2.6465E-05 3.3767E-20 2.9977E+04 5.3524E-11 1247.0 17.833 2064.6
88.320 -4.3800E-05 -5.7348E-20 5978.2 1.5989E-11 681.51 31.253 1951.6
90.240 -1.8203E-05 -3.3642E-20 -1426.8 1.8438E-13 163.52 13.712 1930.2
92.160 -2.8528E-06 -8.6124E-21 -1553.9 -2.1681E-12 20.497 2.2621 1930.8
94.080 1.3388E-06 8.4788E-22 -480.93 -8.9645E-13 33.714 1.1148 1925.7
96.000 2.0768E-06 3.8706E-21 -5.8976E-14 0.0000 1.4077E-15 1.8117 1923.5

* PILE GROUP * 4

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS AND REACTIONS *

THE GLOBAL STRUCTURAL COORDINATE SYSTEM

---------------------------------------

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-100

DISP. X,IN DISP. Y,IN DISP. Z,IN ROT. X,RAD ROT. Y,RAD ROT. Z,RAD
0.3314 2.2942 -1.8810E-14 -1.3479E-16 -7.4630E-17 0.012547

FOR. X,LBS FOR. Y,LBS FOR. Z,LBS MOM X,LBS-IN MOM Y,LBS-IN MOM Z,LBS-IN
-6.7587E+04 2.5654E+04 3.2118E-11 -9.0979E-09 -2.2208E-08 6.4664E+06

STR,LBS/IN**2
3.2365E+04

THE PILE COORDINATE SYSTEM (LOCAL AXES)

---------------------------------------

DISP. x,IN DISP. y,IN DISP. z,IN ROT. x,RAD ROT. y,RAD ROT. z,RAD
-0.072031 -2.3169 1.8529E-14 -1.1951E-16 9.8415E-17 -0.012547

AXIAL,LBS LAT. y,LBS LAT. z,LBS MOM x,LBS-IN MOM y,LBS-IN MOM z,LBS-IN
-7.1015E+04 -1.3528E+04 -3.5260E-11 -4.9658E-09 2.4230E-08 -6.4664E+06

STR,LBS/IN**2
3.2365E+04

* EFFECTS FOR LATERALLY LOADED PILE *

x DISPL. DISPL. MOMENT MOMENT SHEAR SOIL REACT TOTAL

y-DIR z-DIR z-DIR y-DIR y-z-DIR y-z-DIR STRESS
FT IN IN LBS-IN LBS-IN LBS LBS/IN LBS/IN**2
********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
0.0000 -2.3169 1.8529E-14 6.4664E+06 2.4230E-08 1.3457E+04 0.0000 3.2365E+04
1.9200 -2.5828 1.6349E-14 6.1358E+06 2.3263E-08 1.3528E+04 0.0000 3.0809E+04
3.8400 -2.8046 1.4336E-14 5.8083E+06 2.2308E-08 1.3528E+04 0.0000 2.9268E+04
5.7600 -2.9847 1.2482E-14 5.4839E+06 2.1364E-08 1.3528E+04 0.0000 2.7740E+04
7.6800 -3.1254 1.0782E-14 5.1622E+06 2.0431E-08 1.3528E+04 0.0000 2.6226E+04
9.6000 -3.2291 9.2294E-15 4.8431E+06 1.9508E-08 1.3528E+04 0.0000 2.4724E+04
11.520 -3.2979 7.8163E-15 4.5265E+06 1.8595E-08 1.3528E+04 0.0000 2.3233E+04
13.440 -3.3343 6.5369E-15 4.2123E+06 1.7692E-08 1.3528E+04 0.0000 2.1754E+04
15.360 -3.3404 5.3844E-15 3.9001E+06 1.6798E-08 1.3528E+04 0.0000 2.0284E+04
17.280 -3.3185 4.3526E-15 3.5900E+06 1.5912E-08 1.3528E+04 0.0000 1.8824E+04
19.200 -3.2708 3.4351E-15 3.2817E+06 1.5034E-08 1.3528E+04 0.0000 1.7373E+04
21.120 -3.1996 2.6255E-15 2.9751E+06 1.4165E-08 1.3528E+04 0.0000 1.5929E+04
23.040 -3.1070 1.9177E-15 2.6699E+06 1.3302E-08 1.3528E+04 0.0000 1.4493E+04
24.960 -2.9952 1.3054E-15 2.3662E+06 1.2446E-08 1.3528E+04 0.0000 1.3063E+04
26.880 -2.8664 7.8242E-16 2.0636E+06 1.1597E-08 1.3528E+04 0.0000 1.1639E+04
28.800 -2.7228 3.4275E-16 1.7621E+06 1.0753E-08 1.3528E+04 0.0000 1.0219E+04
30.720 -2.5666 -1.9702E-17 1.4615E+06 9.9148E-09 1.3528E+04 0.0000 8804.0
32.640 -2.3998 -3.1095E-16 1.1617E+06 9.0817E-09 1.3528E+04 0.0000 7392.4
34.560 -2.2247 -5.3699E-16 8.6244E+05 8.2533E-09 1.3528E+04 0.0000 5983.6
36.480 -2.0435 -7.0375E-16 5.6362E+05 7.4291E-09 1.3528E+04 0.0000 4576.8
38.400 -1.8581 -8.1717E-16 2.6508E+05 6.6086E-09 1.3528E+04 0.0000 3171.4
40.320 -1.6709 -8.8313E-16 -3.3312E+04 5.7915E-09 1.3528E+04 0.0000 2080.3
42.240 -1.4839 -9.0749E-16 -3.3173E+05 4.9774E-09 1.3528E+04 0.0000 3485.2
44.160 -1.2993 -8.9612E-16 -6.3031E+05 4.1658E-09 1.3528E+04 0.0000 4890.8
46.080 -1.1192 -8.5482E-16 -9.2921E+05 3.3564E-09 1.3528E+04 0.0000 6298.0
48.000 -0.9458 -7.8943E-16 -1.2286E+06 2.5486E-09 1.3528E+04 0.0000 7707.4
49.920 -0.7812 -7.0573E-16 -1.5286E+06 1.7422E-09 1.3528E+04 0.0000 9119.7
51.840 -0.6276 -6.0952E-16 -1.8294E+06 9.3664E-10 1.3528E+04 0.0000 1.0536E+04
53.760 -0.4871 -5.0659E-16 -2.1311E+06 1.3157E-10 1.3528E+04 0.0000 1.1956E+04
55.680 -0.3620 -4.0271E-16 -2.4339E+06 -6.7344E-10 1.1831E+04 147.36 1.3382E+04
57.600 -0.2543 -3.0367E-16 -2.6597E+06 -1.3918E-09 7000.3 271.95 1.4445E+04
59.520 -0.1657 -2.1462E-16 -2.7425E+06 -1.9384E-09 165.29 321.37 1.4835E+04
61.440 -9.6791E-02 -1.3949E-16 -2.6562E+06 -2.2651E-09 7952.6 383.30 1.4428E+04
63.360 -4.6969E-02 -8.0626E-17 -2.3677E+06 -2.2996E-09 1.5834E+04 300.81 1.3070E+04
65.280 -1.4150E-02 -3.8278E-17 -1.9207E+06 -2.0613E-09 2.0624E+04 115.00 1.0966E+04
67.200 4.8768E-03 -1.0731E-17 -1.4136E+06 -1.6588E-09 2.1415E+04 46.275 8578.5

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-101

69.120 1.3752E-02 4.9034E-18 -9.3188E+05 -1.2031E-09 1.9163E+04 149.21 6310.5

71.040 1.5935E-02 1.1898E-17 -5.2980E+05 -7.7630E-10 1.5203E+04 194.59 4417.6
72.960 1.4313E-02 1.3318E-17 -2.3129E+05 -4.2701E-10 1.0723E+04 194.27 3012.3
74.880 1.1030E-02 1.1671E-17 -3.6024E+04 -1.7390E-10 6587.4 164.73 2093.1
76.800 7.4891E-03 8.7758E-18 7.1774E+04 -1.3406E-11 3283.7 122.04 2261.4
78.720 4.4633E-03 5.7841E-18 1.1482E+05 7.1167E-11 969.91 78.810 2464.0
80.640 2.2620E-03 3.3034E-18 1.1610E+05 1.0156E-10 433.58 43.021 2470.0
82.560 8.9444E-04 1.5521E-18 9.4591E+04 9.8656E-11 1139.2 18.229 2368.8
84.480 2.0614E-04 5.0925E-19 6.3457E+04 7.9009E-11 1400.8 4.4817 2222.2
86.400 -2.6465E-05 3.3767E-20 2.9977E+04 5.3524E-11 1247.0 17.833 2064.6
88.320 -4.3800E-05 -5.7348E-20 5978.2 1.5989E-11 681.51 31.253 1951.6
90.240 -1.8203E-05 -3.3642E-20 -1426.8 1.8438E-13 163.52 13.712 1930.2
92.160 -2.8528E-06 -8.6124E-21 -1553.9 -2.1681E-12 20.497 2.2621 1930.8
94.080 1.3388E-06 8.4788E-22 -480.93 -8.9645E-13 33.714 1.1148 1925.7
96.000 2.0768E-06 3.8706E-21 5.8976E-14 0.0000 2.5114E-15 1.8117 1923.5

* PILE GROUP * 5

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS AND REACTIONS *

THE GLOBAL STRUCTURAL COORDINATE SYSTEM

---------------------------------------

DISP. X,IN DISP. Y,IN DISP. Z,IN ROT. X,RAD ROT. Y,RAD ROT. Z,RAD
0.3314 2.2942 -1.8810E-14 -1.3479E-16 -7.4630E-17 0.012547

FOR. X,LBS FOR. Y,LBS FOR. Z,LBS MOM X,LBS-IN MOM Y,LBS-IN MOM Z,LBS-IN
-6.7587E+04 2.5654E+04 3.2118E-11 -9.0979E-09 -2.2208E-08 6.4664E+06

STR,LBS/IN**2
3.2365E+04

THE PILE COORDINATE SYSTEM (LOCAL AXES)

---------------------------------------

DISP. x,IN DISP. y,IN DISP. z,IN ROT. x,RAD ROT. y,RAD ROT. z,RAD
-0.072031 -2.3169 1.8529E-14 -1.1951E-16 9.8415E-17 -0.012547

AXIAL,LBS LAT. y,LBS LAT. z,LBS MOM x,LBS-IN MOM y,LBS-IN MOM z,LBS-IN
-7.1015E+04 -1.3528E+04 -3.5260E-11 -4.9658E-09 2.4230E-08 -6.4664E+06

STR,LBS/IN**2
3.2365E+04

* EFFECTS FOR LATERALLY LOADED PILE *

x DISPL. DISPL. MOMENT MOMENT SHEAR SOIL REACT TOTAL

y-DIR z-DIR z-DIR y-DIR y-z-DIR y-z-DIR STRESS
FT IN IN LBS-IN LBS-IN LBS LBS/IN LBS/IN**2
********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
0.0000 -2.3169 1.8529E-14 6.4664E+06 2.4230E-08 1.3457E+04 0.0000 3.2365E+04
1.9200 -2.5828 1.6349E-14 6.1358E+06 2.3263E-08 1.3528E+04 0.0000 3.0809E+04
3.8400 -2.8046 1.4336E-14 5.8083E+06 2.2308E-08 1.3528E+04 0.0000 2.9268E+04
5.7600 -2.9847 1.2482E-14 5.4839E+06 2.1364E-08 1.3528E+04 0.0000 2.7740E+04
7.6800 -3.1254 1.0782E-14 5.1622E+06 2.0431E-08 1.3528E+04 0.0000 2.6226E+04
9.6000 -3.2291 9.2294E-15 4.8431E+06 1.9508E-08 1.3528E+04 0.0000 2.4724E+04
11.520 -3.2979 7.8163E-15 4.5265E+06 1.8595E-08 1.3528E+04 0.0000 2.3233E+04
13.440 -3.3343 6.5369E-15 4.2123E+06 1.7692E-08 1.3528E+04 0.0000 2.1754E+04

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-102

15.360 -3.3404 5.3844E-15 3.9001E+06 1.6798E-08 1.3528E+04 0.0000 2.0284E+04

17.280 -3.3185 4.3526E-15 3.5900E+06 1.5912E-08 1.3528E+04 0.0000 1.8824E+04
19.200 -3.2708 3.4351E-15 3.2817E+06 1.5034E-08 1.3528E+04 0.0000 1.7373E+04
21.120 -3.1996 2.6255E-15 2.9751E+06 1.4165E-08 1.3528E+04 0.0000 1.5929E+04
23.040 -3.1070 1.9177E-15 2.6699E+06 1.3302E-08 1.3528E+04 0.0000 1.4493E+04
24.960 -2.9952 1.3054E-15 2.3662E+06 1.2446E-08 1.3528E+04 0.0000 1.3063E+04
26.880 -2.8664 7.8242E-16 2.0636E+06 1.1597E-08 1.3528E+04 0.0000 1.1639E+04
28.800 -2.7228 3.4275E-16 1.7621E+06 1.0753E-08 1.3528E+04 0.0000 1.0219E+04
30.720 -2.5666 -1.9702E-17 1.4615E+06 9.9148E-09 1.3528E+04 0.0000 8804.0
32.640 -2.3998 -3.1095E-16 1.1617E+06 9.0817E-09 1.3528E+04 0.0000 7392.4
34.560 -2.2247 -5.3699E-16 8.6244E+05 8.2533E-09 1.3528E+04 0.0000 5983.6
36.480 -2.0435 -7.0375E-16 5.6362E+05 7.4291E-09 1.3528E+04 0.0000 4576.8
38.400 -1.8581 -8.1717E-16 2.6508E+05 6.6086E-09 1.3528E+04 0.0000 3171.4
40.320 -1.6709 -8.8313E-16 -3.3312E+04 5.7915E-09 1.3528E+04 0.0000 2080.3
42.240 -1.4839 -9.0749E-16 -3.3173E+05 4.9774E-09 1.3528E+04 0.0000 3485.2
44.160 -1.2993 -8.9612E-16 -6.3031E+05 4.1658E-09 1.3528E+04 0.0000 4890.8
46.080 -1.1192 -8.5482E-16 -9.2921E+05 3.3564E-09 1.3528E+04 0.0000 6298.0
48.000 -0.9458 -7.8943E-16 -1.2286E+06 2.5486E-09 1.3528E+04 0.0000 7707.4
49.920 -0.7812 -7.0573E-16 -1.5286E+06 1.7422E-09 1.3528E+04 0.0000 9119.7
51.840 -0.6276 -6.0952E-16 -1.8294E+06 9.3664E-10 1.3528E+04 0.0000 1.0536E+04
53.760 -0.4871 -5.0659E-16 -2.1311E+06 1.3157E-10 1.3528E+04 0.0000 1.1956E+04
55.680 -0.3620 -4.0271E-16 -2.4339E+06 -6.7344E-10 1.1831E+04 147.36 1.3382E+04
57.600 -0.2543 -3.0367E-16 -2.6597E+06 -1.3918E-09 7000.3 271.95 1.4445E+04
59.520 -0.1657 -2.1462E-16 -2.7425E+06 -1.9384E-09 165.29 321.37 1.4835E+04
61.440 -9.6791E-02 -1.3949E-16 -2.6562E+06 -2.2651E-09 7952.6 383.30 1.4428E+04
63.360 -4.6969E-02 -8.0626E-17 -2.3677E+06 -2.2996E-09 1.5834E+04 300.81 1.3070E+04
65.280 -1.4150E-02 -3.8278E-17 -1.9207E+06 -2.0613E-09 2.0624E+04 115.00 1.0966E+04
67.200 4.8768E-03 -1.0731E-17 -1.4136E+06 -1.6588E-09 2.1415E+04 46.275 8578.5
69.120 1.3752E-02 4.9034E-18 -9.3188E+05 -1.2031E-09 1.9163E+04 149.21 6310.5
71.040 1.5935E-02 1.1898E-17 -5.2980E+05 -7.7630E-10 1.5203E+04 194.59 4417.6
72.960 1.4313E-02 1.3318E-17 -2.3129E+05 -4.2701E-10 1.0723E+04 194.27 3012.3
74.880 1.1030E-02 1.1671E-17 -3.6024E+04 -1.7390E-10 6587.4 164.73 2093.1
76.800 7.4891E-03 8.7758E-18 7.1774E+04 -1.3406E-11 3283.7 122.04 2261.4
78.720 4.4633E-03 5.7841E-18 1.1482E+05 7.1167E-11 969.91 78.810 2464.0
80.640 2.2620E-03 3.3034E-18 1.1610E+05 1.0156E-10 433.58 43.021 2470.0
82.560 8.9444E-04 1.5521E-18 9.4591E+04 9.8656E-11 1139.2 18.229 2368.8
84.480 2.0614E-04 5.0925E-19 6.3457E+04 7.9009E-11 1400.8 4.4817 2222.2
86.400 -2.6465E-05 3.3767E-20 2.9977E+04 5.3524E-11 1247.0 17.833 2064.6
88.320 -4.3800E-05 -5.7348E-20 5978.2 1.5989E-11 681.51 31.253 1951.6
90.240 -1.8203E-05 -3.3642E-20 -1426.8 1.8438E-13 163.52 13.712 1930.2
92.160 -2.8528E-06 -8.6124E-21 -1553.9 -2.1681E-12 20.497 2.2621 1930.8
94.080 1.3388E-06 8.4788E-22 -480.93 -8.9645E-13 33.714 1.1148 1925.7
96.000 2.0768E-06 3.8706E-21 -5.8976E-14 0.0000 1.1172E-15 1.8117 1923.5

* PILE GROUP * 6

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS AND REACTIONS *

THE GLOBAL STRUCTURAL COORDINATE SYSTEM

---------------------------------------

DISP. X,IN DISP. Y,IN DISP. Z,IN ROT. X,RAD ROT. Y,RAD ROT. Z,RAD
-0.5720 2.2942 -2.8515E-14 -1.3479E-16 -7.4630E-17 0.012547

FOR. X,LBS FOR. Y,LBS FOR. Z,LBS MOM X,LBS-IN MOM Y,LBS-IN MOM Z,LBS-IN
2.1279E+05 8.9182E+04 -4.0551E-11 -9.0065E-09 7.5158E-09 5.6983E+06

STR,LBS/IN**2
3.3068E+04

THE PILE COORDINATE SYSTEM (LOCAL AXES)

---------------------------------------

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-103

DISP. x,IN DISP. y,IN DISP. z,IN ROT. x,RAD ROT. y,RAD ROT. z,RAD
0.2472 2.3515 -2.7953E-14 -1.5323E-16 -2.6918E-17 0.012547

AXIAL,LBS LAT. y,LBS LAT. z,LBS MOM x,LBS-IN MOM y,LBS-IN MOM z,LBS-IN
2.3046E+05 1.1025E+04 -1.8708E-11 -6.3701E-09 8.8314E-09 5.6983E+06

STR,LBS/IN**2
3.3068E+04

* EFFECTS FOR LATERALLY LOADED PILE *

x DISPL. DISPL. MOMENT MOMENT SHEAR SOIL REACT TOTAL

y-DIR z-DIR z-DIR y-DIR y-z-DIR y-z-DIR STRESS
FT IN IN LBS-IN LBS-IN LBS LBS/IN LBS/IN**2
********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
0.0000 2.3515 -2.7953E-14 -5.6983E+06 8.8314E-09 1.1230E+04 0.0000 3.3068E+04
1.9200 2.6202 -2.7301E-14 -5.5062E+06 8.2502E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 3.2164E+04
3.8400 2.8492 -2.6590E-14 -5.3049E+06 7.6553E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 3.1216E+04
5.7600 3.0402 -2.5824E-14 -5.0949E+06 7.0477E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 3.0228E+04
7.6800 3.1946 -2.5007E-14 -4.8765E+06 6.4284E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 2.9199E+04
9.6000 3.3140 -2.4144E-14 -4.6500E+06 5.7985E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 2.8133E+04
11.520 3.4000 -2.3240E-14 -4.4158E+06 5.1591E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 2.7031E+04
13.440 3.4543 -2.2298E-14 -4.1743E+06 4.5110E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 2.5894E+04
15.360 3.4786 -2.1324E-14 -3.9259E+06 3.8556E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 2.4724E+04
17.280 3.4747 -2.0323E-14 -3.6710E+06 3.1937E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 2.3524E+04
19.200 3.4444 -1.9298E-14 -3.4100E+06 2.5265E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 2.2295E+04
21.120 3.3897 -1.8255E-14 -3.1433E+06 1.8552E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 2.1040E+04
23.040 3.3124 -1.7199E-14 -2.8715E+06 1.1808E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 1.9760E+04
24.960 3.2145 -1.6135E-14 -2.5949E+06 5.0444E-10 1.1025E+04 0.0000 1.8458E+04
26.880 3.0979 -1.5067E-14 -2.3140E+06 -1.7275E-10 1.1025E+04 0.0000 1.7136E+04
28.800 2.9647 -1.4000E-14 -2.0293E+06 -8.4965E-10 1.1025E+04 0.0000 1.5796E+04
30.720 2.8170 -1.2939E-14 -1.7413E+06 -1.5252E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 1.4439E+04
32.640 2.6567 -1.1889E-14 -1.4503E+06 -2.1981E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 1.3070E+04
34.560 2.4860 -1.0855E-14 -1.1570E+06 -2.8675E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 1.1689E+04
36.480 2.3070 -9.8414E-15 -8.6169E+05 -3.5321E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 1.0299E+04
38.400 2.1219 -8.8533E-15 -5.6499E+05 -4.1908E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 8902.0
40.320 1.9326 -7.8952E-15 -2.6737E+05 -4.8426E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 7500.8
42.240 1.7415 -6.9720E-15 3.0704E+04 -5.4864E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 6386.7
44.160 1.5506 -6.0881E-15 3.2872E+05 -6.1211E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 7789.7
46.080 1.3620 -5.2482E-15 6.2620E+05 -6.7457E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 9190.1
48.000 1.1779 -4.4568E-15 9.2264E+05 -7.3591E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 1.0586E+04
49.920 1.0005 -3.7182E-15 1.2175E+06 -7.9604E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 1.1974E+04
51.840 0.8318 -3.0367E-15 1.5104E+06 -8.5485E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 1.3353E+04
53.760 0.6739 -2.4167E-15 1.8008E+06 -9.1224E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 1.4720E+04
55.680 0.5290 -1.8621E-15 2.0883E+06 -9.6812E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 1.6073E+04
57.600 0.3991 -1.3771E-15 2.3722E+06 -1.0224E-08 1.0003E+04 88.745 1.7410E+04
59.520 0.2862 -9.6549E-16 2.6051E+06 -1.0587E-08 6406.4 223.44 1.8506E+04
61.440 0.1920 -6.2991E-16 2.7151E+06 -1.0533E-08 337.58 303.37 1.9024E+04
63.360 0.1173 -3.6998E-16 2.6596E+06 -9.9327E-09 6638.2 302.17 1.8763E+04
65.280 6.1701E-02 -1.8138E-16 2.4393E+06 -8.8100E-09 1.3631E+04 304.88 1.7726E+04
67.200 2.3631E-02 -5.6038E-17 2.0531E+06 -7.1970E-09 1.9133E+04 172.65 1.5907E+04
69.120 3.0404E-04 1.7617E-17 1.5718E+06 -5.3548E-09 2.1152E+04 2.6163 1.3642E+04
71.040 -1.1735E-02 5.2819E-17 1.0866E+06 -3.5842E-09 1.9843E+04 116.23 1.1357E+04
72.960 -1.5972E-02 6.2281E-17 6.6120E+05 -2.0853E-09 1.6442E+04 178.94 9354.9
74.880 -1.5460E-02 5.6769E-17 3.2974E+05 -9.5338E-10 1.2154E+04 193.29 7794.5
76.800 -1.2581E-02 4.4410E-17 1.0034E+05 -1.9664E-10 7927.6 173.63 6714.5
78.720 -8.9804E-03 3.0639E-17 -3.7056E+04 2.3507E-10 4365.3 135.61 6416.6
80.640 -5.6463E-03 1.8557E-17 -1.0241E+05 4.2078E-10 1736.4 92.595 6724.2
82.560 -3.0476E-03 9.4956E-18 -1.1843E+05 4.4425E-10 48.309 53.938 6799.7
84.480 -1.2994E-03 3.6248E-18 -1.0563E+05 3.7778E-10 857.44 24.686 6739.4
86.400 -3.0984E-04 4.6694E-19 -7.9555E+04 2.7413E-10 1214.3 6.2887 6616.7
88.320 1.0845E-04 -7.2231E-19 -5.0006E+04 1.6500E-10 1259.7 2.3421 6477.5
90.240 1.6765E-04 -7.2670E-19 -2.1617E+04 6.3867E-11 1188.5 3.8382 6343.9
92.160 7.1606E-05 -2.7244E-19 4770.2 -2.8535E-11 562.22 50.529 6264.6
94.080 9.8203E-06 -2.3090E-20 4326.7 -1.8840E-11 103.98 7.3017 6262.5
96.000 -2.0895E-05 9.0963E-20 9.4361E-13 -3.3524E-27 6.2783E-14 16.328 6242.1

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-104

* PILE GROUP * 7

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS AND REACTIONS *

THE GLOBAL STRUCTURAL COORDINATE SYSTEM

---------------------------------------

DISP. X,IN DISP. Y,IN DISP. Z,IN ROT. X,RAD ROT. Y,RAD ROT. Z,RAD
-0.5720 2.2942 -2.8515E-14 -1.3479E-16 -7.4630E-17 0.012547

FOR. X,LBS FOR. Y,LBS FOR. Z,LBS MOM X,LBS-IN MOM Y,LBS-IN MOM Z,LBS-IN
2.1279E+05 8.9182E+04 -4.0551E-11 -9.0065E-09 7.5158E-09 5.6983E+06

STR,LBS/IN**2
3.3068E+04

THE PILE COORDINATE SYSTEM (LOCAL AXES)

---------------------------------------

DISP. x,IN DISP. y,IN DISP. z,IN ROT. x,RAD ROT. y,RAD ROT. z,RAD
0.2472 2.3515 -2.7953E-14 -1.5323E-16 -2.6918E-17 0.012547

AXIAL,LBS LAT. y,LBS LAT. z,LBS MOM x,LBS-IN MOM y,LBS-IN MOM z,LBS-IN
2.3046E+05 1.1025E+04 -1.8708E-11 -6.3701E-09 8.8314E-09 5.6983E+06

STR,LBS/IN**2
3.3068E+04

* EFFECTS FOR LATERALLY LOADED PILE *

x DISPL. DISPL. MOMENT MOMENT SHEAR SOIL REACT TOTAL

y-DIR z-DIR z-DIR y-DIR y-z-DIR y-z-DIR STRESS
FT IN IN LBS-IN LBS-IN LBS LBS/IN LBS/IN**2
********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
0.0000 2.3515 -2.7953E-14 -5.6983E+06 8.8314E-09 1.1230E+04 0.0000 3.3068E+04
1.9200 2.6202 -2.7301E-14 -5.5062E+06 8.2502E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 3.2164E+04
3.8400 2.8492 -2.6590E-14 -5.3049E+06 7.6553E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 3.1216E+04
5.7600 3.0402 -2.5824E-14 -5.0949E+06 7.0477E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 3.0228E+04
7.6800 3.1946 -2.5007E-14 -4.8765E+06 6.4284E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 2.9199E+04
9.6000 3.3140 -2.4144E-14 -4.6500E+06 5.7985E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 2.8133E+04
11.520 3.4000 -2.3240E-14 -4.4158E+06 5.1591E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 2.7031E+04
13.440 3.4543 -2.2298E-14 -4.1743E+06 4.5110E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 2.5894E+04
15.360 3.4786 -2.1324E-14 -3.9259E+06 3.8556E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 2.4724E+04
17.280 3.4747 -2.0323E-14 -3.6710E+06 3.1937E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 2.3524E+04
19.200 3.4444 -1.9298E-14 -3.4100E+06 2.5265E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 2.2295E+04
21.120 3.3897 -1.8255E-14 -3.1433E+06 1.8552E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 2.1040E+04
23.040 3.3124 -1.7199E-14 -2.8715E+06 1.1808E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 1.9760E+04
24.960 3.2145 -1.6135E-14 -2.5949E+06 5.0444E-10 1.1025E+04 0.0000 1.8458E+04
26.880 3.0979 -1.5067E-14 -2.3140E+06 -1.7275E-10 1.1025E+04 0.0000 1.7136E+04
28.800 2.9647 -1.4000E-14 -2.0293E+06 -8.4965E-10 1.1025E+04 0.0000 1.5796E+04
30.720 2.8170 -1.2939E-14 -1.7413E+06 -1.5252E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 1.4439E+04
32.640 2.6567 -1.1889E-14 -1.4503E+06 -2.1981E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 1.3070E+04
34.560 2.4860 -1.0855E-14 -1.1570E+06 -2.8675E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 1.1689E+04
36.480 2.3070 -9.8414E-15 -8.6169E+05 -3.5321E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 1.0299E+04
38.400 2.1219 -8.8533E-15 -5.6499E+05 -4.1908E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 8902.0
40.320 1.9326 -7.8952E-15 -2.6737E+05 -4.8426E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 7500.8
42.240 1.7415 -6.9720E-15 3.0704E+04 -5.4864E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 6386.7

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-105

44.160 1.5506 -6.0881E-15 3.2872E+05 -6.1211E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 7789.7

46.080 1.3620 -5.2482E-15 6.2620E+05 -6.7457E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 9190.1
48.000 1.1779 -4.4568E-15 9.2264E+05 -7.3591E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 1.0586E+04
49.920 1.0005 -3.7182E-15 1.2175E+06 -7.9604E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 1.1974E+04
51.840 0.8318 -3.0367E-15 1.5104E+06 -8.5485E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 1.3353E+04
53.760 0.6739 -2.4167E-15 1.8008E+06 -9.1224E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 1.4720E+04
55.680 0.5290 -1.8621E-15 2.0883E+06 -9.6812E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 1.6073E+04
57.600 0.3991 -1.3771E-15 2.3722E+06 -1.0224E-08 1.0003E+04 88.745 1.7410E+04
59.520 0.2862 -9.6549E-16 2.6051E+06 -1.0587E-08 6406.4 223.44 1.8506E+04
61.440 0.1920 -6.2991E-16 2.7151E+06 -1.0533E-08 337.58 303.37 1.9024E+04
63.360 0.1173 -3.6998E-16 2.6596E+06 -9.9327E-09 6638.2 302.17 1.8763E+04
65.280 6.1701E-02 -1.8138E-16 2.4393E+06 -8.8100E-09 1.3631E+04 304.88 1.7726E+04
67.200 2.3631E-02 -5.6038E-17 2.0531E+06 -7.1970E-09 1.9133E+04 172.65 1.5907E+04
69.120 3.0404E-04 1.7617E-17 1.5718E+06 -5.3548E-09 2.1152E+04 2.6163 1.3642E+04
71.040 -1.1735E-02 5.2819E-17 1.0866E+06 -3.5842E-09 1.9843E+04 116.23 1.1357E+04
72.960 -1.5972E-02 6.2281E-17 6.6120E+05 -2.0853E-09 1.6442E+04 178.94 9354.9
74.880 -1.5460E-02 5.6769E-17 3.2974E+05 -9.5338E-10 1.2154E+04 193.29 7794.5
76.800 -1.2581E-02 4.4410E-17 1.0034E+05 -1.9664E-10 7927.6 173.63 6714.5
78.720 -8.9804E-03 3.0639E-17 -3.7056E+04 2.3507E-10 4365.3 135.61 6416.6
80.640 -5.6463E-03 1.8557E-17 -1.0241E+05 4.2078E-10 1736.4 92.595 6724.2
82.560 -3.0476E-03 9.4956E-18 -1.1843E+05 4.4425E-10 48.309 53.938 6799.7
84.480 -1.2994E-03 3.6248E-18 -1.0563E+05 3.7778E-10 857.44 24.686 6739.4
86.400 -3.0984E-04 4.6694E-19 -7.9555E+04 2.7413E-10 1214.3 6.2887 6616.7
88.320 1.0845E-04 -7.2231E-19 -5.0006E+04 1.6500E-10 1259.7 2.3421 6477.5
90.240 1.6765E-04 -7.2670E-19 -2.1617E+04 6.3867E-11 1188.5 3.8382 6343.9
92.160 7.1606E-05 -2.7244E-19 4770.2 -2.8535E-11 562.22 50.529 6264.6
94.080 9.8203E-06 -2.3090E-20 4326.7 -1.8840E-11 103.98 7.3017 6262.5
96.000 -2.0895E-05 9.0963E-20 0.0000 -3.3524E-27 7.7938E-14 16.328 6242.1

* PILE GROUP * 8

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS AND REACTIONS *

THE GLOBAL STRUCTURAL COORDINATE SYSTEM

---------------------------------------

DISP. X,IN DISP. Y,IN DISP. Z,IN ROT. X,RAD ROT. Y,RAD ROT. Z,RAD
-0.5720 2.2942 -2.8515E-14 -1.3479E-16 -7.4630E-17 0.012547

FOR. X,LBS FOR. Y,LBS FOR. Z,LBS MOM X,LBS-IN MOM Y,LBS-IN MOM Z,LBS-IN
2.1279E+05 8.9182E+04 -4.0551E-11 -9.0065E-09 7.5158E-09 5.6983E+06

STR,LBS/IN**2
3.3068E+04

THE PILE COORDINATE SYSTEM (LOCAL AXES)

---------------------------------------

DISP. x,IN DISP. y,IN DISP. z,IN ROT. x,RAD ROT. y,RAD ROT. z,RAD
0.2472 2.3515 -2.7953E-14 -1.5323E-16 -2.6918E-17 0.012547

AXIAL,LBS LAT. y,LBS LAT. z,LBS MOM x,LBS-IN MOM y,LBS-IN MOM z,LBS-IN
2.3046E+05 1.1025E+04 -1.8708E-11 -6.3701E-09 8.8314E-09 5.6983E+06

STR,LBS/IN**2
3.3068E+04

* EFFECTS FOR LATERALLY LOADED PILE *

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-106

x DISPL. DISPL. MOMENT MOMENT SHEAR SOIL REACT TOTAL

y-DIR z-DIR z-DIR y-DIR y-z-DIR y-z-DIR STRESS
FT IN IN LBS-IN LBS-IN LBS LBS/IN LBS/IN**2
********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
0.0000 2.3515 -2.7953E-14 -5.6983E+06 8.8314E-09 1.1230E+04 0.0000 3.3068E+04
1.9200 2.6202 -2.7301E-14 -5.5062E+06 8.2502E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 3.2164E+04
3.8400 2.8492 -2.6590E-14 -5.3049E+06 7.6553E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 3.1216E+04
5.7600 3.0402 -2.5824E-14 -5.0949E+06 7.0477E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 3.0228E+04
7.6800 3.1946 -2.5007E-14 -4.8765E+06 6.4284E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 2.9199E+04
9.6000 3.3140 -2.4144E-14 -4.6500E+06 5.7985E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 2.8133E+04
11.520 3.4000 -2.3240E-14 -4.4158E+06 5.1591E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 2.7031E+04
13.440 3.4543 -2.2298E-14 -4.1743E+06 4.5110E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 2.5894E+04
15.360 3.4786 -2.1324E-14 -3.9259E+06 3.8556E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 2.4724E+04
17.280 3.4747 -2.0323E-14 -3.6710E+06 3.1937E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 2.3524E+04
19.200 3.4444 -1.9298E-14 -3.4100E+06 2.5265E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 2.2295E+04
21.120 3.3897 -1.8255E-14 -3.1433E+06 1.8552E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 2.1040E+04
23.040 3.3124 -1.7199E-14 -2.8715E+06 1.1808E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 1.9760E+04
24.960 3.2145 -1.6135E-14 -2.5949E+06 5.0444E-10 1.1025E+04 0.0000 1.8458E+04
26.880 3.0979 -1.5067E-14 -2.3140E+06 -1.7275E-10 1.1025E+04 0.0000 1.7136E+04
28.800 2.9647 -1.4000E-14 -2.0293E+06 -8.4965E-10 1.1025E+04 0.0000 1.5796E+04
30.720 2.8170 -1.2939E-14 -1.7413E+06 -1.5252E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 1.4439E+04
32.640 2.6567 -1.1889E-14 -1.4503E+06 -2.1981E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 1.3070E+04
34.560 2.4860 -1.0855E-14 -1.1570E+06 -2.8675E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 1.1689E+04
36.480 2.3070 -9.8414E-15 -8.6169E+05 -3.5321E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 1.0299E+04
38.400 2.1219 -8.8533E-15 -5.6499E+05 -4.1908E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 8902.0
40.320 1.9326 -7.8952E-15 -2.6737E+05 -4.8426E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 7500.8
42.240 1.7415 -6.9720E-15 3.0704E+04 -5.4864E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 6386.7
44.160 1.5506 -6.0881E-15 3.2872E+05 -6.1211E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 7789.7
46.080 1.3620 -5.2482E-15 6.2620E+05 -6.7457E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 9190.1
48.000 1.1779 -4.4568E-15 9.2264E+05 -7.3591E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 1.0586E+04
49.920 1.0005 -3.7182E-15 1.2175E+06 -7.9604E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 1.1974E+04
51.840 0.8318 -3.0367E-15 1.5104E+06 -8.5485E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 1.3353E+04
53.760 0.6739 -2.4167E-15 1.8008E+06 -9.1224E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 1.4720E+04
55.680 0.5290 -1.8621E-15 2.0883E+06 -9.6812E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 1.6073E+04
57.600 0.3991 -1.3771E-15 2.3722E+06 -1.0224E-08 1.0003E+04 88.745 1.7410E+04
59.520 0.2862 -9.6549E-16 2.6051E+06 -1.0587E-08 6406.4 223.44 1.8506E+04
61.440 0.1920 -6.2991E-16 2.7151E+06 -1.0533E-08 337.58 303.37 1.9024E+04
63.360 0.1173 -3.6998E-16 2.6596E+06 -9.9327E-09 6638.2 302.17 1.8763E+04
65.280 6.1701E-02 -1.8138E-16 2.4393E+06 -8.8100E-09 1.3631E+04 304.88 1.7726E+04
67.200 2.3631E-02 -5.6038E-17 2.0531E+06 -7.1970E-09 1.9133E+04 172.65 1.5907E+04
69.120 3.0404E-04 1.7617E-17 1.5718E+06 -5.3548E-09 2.1152E+04 2.6163 1.3642E+04
71.040 -1.1735E-02 5.2819E-17 1.0866E+06 -3.5842E-09 1.9843E+04 116.23 1.1357E+04
72.960 -1.5972E-02 6.2281E-17 6.6120E+05 -2.0853E-09 1.6442E+04 178.94 9354.9
74.880 -1.5460E-02 5.6769E-17 3.2974E+05 -9.5338E-10 1.2154E+04 193.29 7794.5
76.800 -1.2581E-02 4.4410E-17 1.0034E+05 -1.9664E-10 7927.6 173.63 6714.5
78.720 -8.9804E-03 3.0639E-17 -3.7056E+04 2.3507E-10 4365.3 135.61 6416.6
80.640 -5.6463E-03 1.8557E-17 -1.0241E+05 4.2078E-10 1736.4 92.595 6724.2
82.560 -3.0476E-03 9.4956E-18 -1.1843E+05 4.4425E-10 48.309 53.938 6799.7
84.480 -1.2994E-03 3.6248E-18 -1.0563E+05 3.7778E-10 857.44 24.686 6739.4
86.400 -3.0984E-04 4.6694E-19 -7.9555E+04 2.7413E-10 1214.3 6.2887 6616.7
88.320 1.0845E-04 -7.2231E-19 -5.0006E+04 1.6500E-10 1259.7 2.3421 6477.5
90.240 1.6765E-04 -7.2670E-19 -2.1617E+04 6.3867E-11 1188.5 3.8382 6343.9
92.160 7.1606E-05 -2.7244E-19 4770.2 -2.8535E-11 562.22 50.529 6264.6
94.080 9.8203E-06 -2.3090E-20 4326.7 -1.8840E-11 103.98 7.3017 6262.5
96.000 -2.0895E-05 9.0963E-20 9.4361E-13 -3.3524E-27 4.3132E-14 16.328 6242.1

* PILE GROUP * 9

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS AND REACTIONS *

THE GLOBAL STRUCTURAL COORDINATE SYSTEM

---------------------------------------

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-107

DISP. X,IN DISP. Y,IN DISP. Z,IN ROT. X,RAD ROT. Y,RAD ROT. Z,RAD
-0.5720 2.2942 -2.8515E-14 -1.3479E-16 -7.4630E-17 0.012547

FOR. X,LBS FOR. Y,LBS FOR. Z,LBS MOM X,LBS-IN MOM Y,LBS-IN MOM Z,LBS-IN
2.1279E+05 8.9182E+04 -4.0551E-11 -9.0065E-09 7.5158E-09 5.6983E+06

STR,LBS/IN**2
3.3068E+04

THE PILE COORDINATE SYSTEM (LOCAL AXES)

---------------------------------------

DISP. x,IN DISP. y,IN DISP. z,IN ROT. x,RAD ROT. y,RAD ROT. z,RAD
0.2472 2.3515 -2.7953E-14 -1.5323E-16 -2.6918E-17 0.012547

AXIAL,LBS LAT. y,LBS LAT. z,LBS MOM x,LBS-IN MOM y,LBS-IN MOM z,LBS-IN
2.3046E+05 1.1025E+04 -1.8708E-11 -6.3701E-09 8.8314E-09 5.6983E+06

STR,LBS/IN**2
3.3068E+04

* EFFECTS FOR LATERALLY LOADED PILE *

x DISPL. DISPL. MOMENT MOMENT SHEAR SOIL REACT TOTAL

y-DIR z-DIR z-DIR y-DIR y-z-DIR y-z-DIR STRESS
FT IN IN LBS-IN LBS-IN LBS LBS/IN LBS/IN**2
********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
0.0000 2.3515 -2.7953E-14 -5.6983E+06 8.8314E-09 1.1230E+04 0.0000 3.3068E+04
1.9200 2.6202 -2.7301E-14 -5.5062E+06 8.2502E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 3.2164E+04
3.8400 2.8492 -2.6590E-14 -5.3049E+06 7.6553E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 3.1216E+04
5.7600 3.0402 -2.5824E-14 -5.0949E+06 7.0477E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 3.0228E+04
7.6800 3.1946 -2.5007E-14 -4.8765E+06 6.4284E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 2.9199E+04
9.6000 3.3140 -2.4144E-14 -4.6500E+06 5.7985E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 2.8133E+04
11.520 3.4000 -2.3240E-14 -4.4158E+06 5.1591E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 2.7031E+04
13.440 3.4543 -2.2298E-14 -4.1743E+06 4.5110E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 2.5894E+04
15.360 3.4786 -2.1324E-14 -3.9259E+06 3.8556E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 2.4724E+04
17.280 3.4747 -2.0323E-14 -3.6710E+06 3.1937E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 2.3524E+04
19.200 3.4444 -1.9298E-14 -3.4100E+06 2.5265E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 2.2295E+04
21.120 3.3897 -1.8255E-14 -3.1433E+06 1.8552E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 2.1040E+04
23.040 3.3124 -1.7199E-14 -2.8715E+06 1.1808E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 1.9760E+04
24.960 3.2145 -1.6135E-14 -2.5949E+06 5.0444E-10 1.1025E+04 0.0000 1.8458E+04
26.880 3.0979 -1.5067E-14 -2.3140E+06 -1.7275E-10 1.1025E+04 0.0000 1.7136E+04
28.800 2.9647 -1.4000E-14 -2.0293E+06 -8.4965E-10 1.1025E+04 0.0000 1.5796E+04
30.720 2.8170 -1.2939E-14 -1.7413E+06 -1.5252E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 1.4439E+04
32.640 2.6567 -1.1889E-14 -1.4503E+06 -2.1981E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 1.3070E+04
34.560 2.4860 -1.0855E-14 -1.1570E+06 -2.8675E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 1.1689E+04
36.480 2.3070 -9.8414E-15 -8.6169E+05 -3.5321E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 1.0299E+04
38.400 2.1219 -8.8533E-15 -5.6499E+05 -4.1908E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 8902.0
40.320 1.9326 -7.8952E-15 -2.6737E+05 -4.8426E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 7500.8
42.240 1.7415 -6.9720E-15 3.0704E+04 -5.4864E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 6386.7
44.160 1.5506 -6.0881E-15 3.2872E+05 -6.1211E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 7789.7
46.080 1.3620 -5.2482E-15 6.2620E+05 -6.7457E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 9190.1
48.000 1.1779 -4.4568E-15 9.2264E+05 -7.3591E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 1.0586E+04
49.920 1.0005 -3.7182E-15 1.2175E+06 -7.9604E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 1.1974E+04
51.840 0.8318 -3.0367E-15 1.5104E+06 -8.5485E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 1.3353E+04
53.760 0.6739 -2.4167E-15 1.8008E+06 -9.1224E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 1.4720E+04
55.680 0.5290 -1.8621E-15 2.0883E+06 -9.6812E-09 1.1025E+04 0.0000 1.6073E+04
57.600 0.3991 -1.3771E-15 2.3722E+06 -1.0224E-08 1.0003E+04 88.745 1.7410E+04
59.520 0.2862 -9.6549E-16 2.6051E+06 -1.0587E-08 6406.4 223.44 1.8506E+04
61.440 0.1920 -6.2991E-16 2.7151E+06 -1.0533E-08 337.58 303.37 1.9024E+04
63.360 0.1173 -3.6998E-16 2.6596E+06 -9.9327E-09 6638.2 302.17 1.8763E+04
65.280 6.1701E-02 -1.8138E-16 2.4393E+06 -8.8100E-09 1.3631E+04 304.88 1.7726E+04
67.200 2.3631E-02 -5.6038E-17 2.0531E+06 -7.1970E-09 1.9133E+04 172.65 1.5907E+04
69.120 3.0404E-04 1.7617E-17 1.5718E+06 -5.3548E-09 2.1152E+04 2.6163 1.3642E+04
71.040 -1.1735E-02 5.2819E-17 1.0866E+06 -3.5842E-09 1.9843E+04 116.23 1.1357E+04

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-108

72.960 -1.5972E-02 6.2281E-17 6.6120E+05 -2.0853E-09 1.6442E+04 178.94 9354.9

74.880 -1.5460E-02 5.6769E-17 3.2974E+05 -9.5338E-10 1.2154E+04 193.29 7794.5
76.800 -1.2581E-02 4.4410E-17 1.0034E+05 -1.9664E-10 7927.6 173.63 6714.5
78.720 -8.9804E-03 3.0639E-17 -3.7056E+04 2.3507E-10 4365.3 135.61 6416.6
80.640 -5.6463E-03 1.8557E-17 -1.0241E+05 4.2078E-10 1736.4 92.595 6724.2
82.560 -3.0476E-03 9.4956E-18 -1.1843E+05 4.4425E-10 48.309 53.938 6799.7
84.480 -1.2994E-03 3.6248E-18 -1.0563E+05 3.7778E-10 857.44 24.686 6739.4
86.400 -3.0984E-04 4.6694E-19 -7.9555E+04 2.7413E-10 1214.3 6.2887 6616.7
88.320 1.0845E-04 -7.2231E-19 -5.0006E+04 1.6500E-10 1259.7 2.3421 6477.5
90.240 1.6765E-04 -7.2670E-19 -2.1617E+04 6.3867E-11 1188.5 3.8382 6343.9
92.160 7.1606E-05 -2.7244E-19 4770.2 -2.8535E-11 562.22 50.529 6264.6
94.080 9.8203E-06 -2.3090E-20 4326.7 -1.8840E-11 103.98 7.3017 6262.5
96.000 -2.0895E-05 9.0963E-20 0.0000 -3.3524E-27 7.7882E-14 16.328 6242.1

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-109

2.5.6 Summary Results File

=========================================================================

GROUP for Windows, Version 2016.10.8

Serial Number : 136089307

Analysis of A Group of Piles

Subjected to Axial and Lateral Loading

(c) Copyright ENSOFT, Inc., 1987-2015

All Rights Reserved

=========================================================================

-------------------------------------------------------------------------
Time and Date of Analysis
-------------------------------------------------------------------------

Date: May 09, 2016 Time: 18:14:30

***** COMPUTATION RESULTS *****

EXAMPLE PROBLEM 4 - 3D, Pile Group for Breasting Structure

***** LOAD CASES RESULTS *****

LOAD CASE : 1
CASE NAME : Load Case 1
LOAD TYPE : Special, Sp

* TABLE L * COMPUTATION ON PILE CAP

* EQUIVALENT CONCENTRATED LOAD AT ORIGIN *

VERT. LOAD, LBS HOR. LOAD Y, LBS HOR. LOAD Z, LBS

5.13228E+05 4.85000E+05 0.00000

MOMENT X ,LBS-IN MOMENT Y,LBS-IN MOMENT Z,LBS-IN

0.00000 0.00000 0.00000

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-110

* DISPLACEMENT OF GROUPED PILE FOUNDATION AT ORIGIN *

VERTICAL ,IN HORIZONTAL Y,IN HORIZONTAL Z,IN

0.18083 2.29425 -2.04278E-14

ANGLE ROT. X,RAD ANGLE ROT. Y,RAD ANGLE ROT. Z,RAD

-1.34787E-16 -7.46304E-17 0.0125472

* TABLE M * COMPUTATION ON INDIVIDUAL PILE

THE GLOBAL STRUCTURAL COORDINATE SYSTEM

---------------------------------------

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS *

PILE GROUP DISP. X,IN DISP. Y,IN DISP. Z,IN ROT. X,RAD ROT. Y,RAD ROT. Z,RAD
********** *********** *********** *********** *********** *********** ***********
1 0.3314 2.2942 -1.8810E-14 -1.3479E-16 -7.4630E-17 0.012547
2 0.3314 2.2942 -1.8810E-14 -1.3479E-16 -7.4630E-17 0.012547
3 0.3314 2.2942 -1.8810E-14 -1.3479E-16 -7.4630E-17 0.012547
4 0.3314 2.2942 -1.8810E-14 -1.3479E-16 -7.4630E-17 0.012547
5 0.3314 2.2942 -1.8810E-14 -1.3479E-16 -7.4630E-17 0.012547
6 -0.5720 2.2942 -2.8515E-14 -1.3479E-16 -7.4630E-17 0.012547
7 -0.5720 2.2942 -2.8515E-14 -1.3479E-16 -7.4630E-17 0.012547
8 -0.5720 2.2942 -2.8515E-14 -1.3479E-16 -7.4630E-17 0.012547
9 -0.5720 2.2942 -2.8515E-14 -1.3479E-16 -7.4630E-17 0.012547

MINIMUM -0.5720 2.2942 -2.8515E-14 -1.3479E-16 -7.4630E-17 0.012547

Pile N. 6 1 6 1 1 1
MAXIMUM 0.3314 2.2942 -1.8810E-14 -1.3479E-16 -7.4630E-17 0.012547
Pile N. 1 1 1 1 1 1

* PILE TOP REACTIONS *

PILE GROUP FOR. X,LBS FOR. Y,LBS FOR. Z,LBS MOM X,LBS-IN MOM Y,LBS-IN MOM Z,LBS-IN
********** *********** *********** *********** *********** *********** ***********
1 -6.7587E+04 2.5654E+04 3.2118E-11 -9.0979E-09 -2.2208E-08 6.4664E+06
2 -6.7587E+04 2.5654E+04 3.2118E-11 -9.0979E-09 -2.2208E-08 6.4664E+06
3 -6.7587E+04 2.5654E+04 3.2118E-11 -9.0979E-09 -2.2208E-08 6.4664E+06
4 -6.7587E+04 2.5654E+04 3.2118E-11 -9.0979E-09 -2.2208E-08 6.4664E+06
5 -6.7587E+04 2.5654E+04 3.2118E-11 -9.0979E-09 -2.2208E-08 6.4664E+06
6 2.1279E+05 8.9182E+04 -4.0551E-11 -9.0065E-09 7.5158E-09 5.6983E+06
7 2.1279E+05 8.9182E+04 -4.0551E-11 -9.0065E-09 7.5158E-09 5.6983E+06
8 2.1279E+05 8.9182E+04 -4.0551E-11 -9.0065E-09 7.5158E-09 5.6983E+06
9 2.1279E+05 8.9182E+04 -4.0551E-11 -9.0065E-09 7.5158E-09 5.6983E+06

MINIMUM -6.7587E+04 2.5654E+04 -4.0551E-11 -9.0979E-09 -2.2208E-08 5.6983E+06

Pile N. 1 1 6 1 1 6
MAXIMUM 2.1279E+05 8.9182E+04 3.2118E-11 -9.0065E-09 7.5158E-09 6.4664E+06
Pile N. 6 6 1 6 6 1

THE PILE COORDINATE SYSTEM (LOCAL AXES)

---------------------------------------

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS *

PILE GROUP DISP. x,IN DISP. y,IN DISP. z,IN ROT. x,RAD ROT. y,RAD ROT. z,RAD
********** *********** *********** *********** *********** *********** ***********

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-111

1 -0.072031 -2.3169 1.8529E-14 -1.1951E-16 9.8415E-17 -0.012547

2 -0.072031 -2.3169 1.8529E-14 -1.1951E-16 9.8415E-17 -0.012547
3 -0.072031 -2.3169 1.8529E-14 -1.1951E-16 9.8415E-17 -0.012547
4 -0.072031 -2.3169 1.8529E-14 -1.1951E-16 9.8415E-17 -0.012547
5 -0.072031 -2.3169 1.8529E-14 -1.1951E-16 9.8415E-17 -0.012547
6 0.2472 2.3515 -2.7953E-14 -1.5323E-16 -2.6918E-17 0.012547
7 0.2472 2.3515 -2.7953E-14 -1.5323E-16 -2.6918E-17 0.012547
8 0.2472 2.3515 -2.7953E-14 -1.5323E-16 -2.6918E-17 0.012547
9 0.2472 2.3515 -2.7953E-14 -1.5323E-16 -2.6918E-17 0.012547

MINIMUM -0.072031 -2.3169 -2.7953E-14 -1.5323E-16 -2.6918E-17 -0.012547

Pile N. 1 1 6 6 6 1
MAXIMUM 0.2472 2.3515 1.8529E-14 -1.1951E-16 9.8415E-17 0.012547
Pile N. 6 6 1 1 1 6

* PILE TOP REACTIONS *

PILE GROUP AXIAL,LBS LAT. y,LBS LAT. z,LBS MOM x,LBS-IN MOM y,LBS-IN MOM z,LBS-IN
********** *********** *********** *********** *********** *********** ***********
1 -7.1015E+04 -1.3528E+04 -3.5260E-11 -4.9658E-09 2.4230E-08 -6.4664E+06
2 -7.1015E+04 -1.3528E+04 -3.5260E-11 -4.9658E-09 2.4230E-08 -6.4664E+06
3 -7.1015E+04 -1.3528E+04 -3.5260E-11 -4.9658E-09 2.4230E-08 -6.4664E+06
4 -7.1015E+04 -1.3528E+04 -3.5260E-11 -4.9658E-09 2.4230E-08 -6.4664E+06
5 -7.1015E+04 -1.3528E+04 -3.5260E-11 -4.9658E-09 2.4230E-08 -6.4664E+06
6 2.3046E+05 1.1025E+04 -1.8708E-11 -6.3701E-09 8.8314E-09 5.6983E+06
7 2.3046E+05 1.1025E+04 -1.8708E-11 -6.3701E-09 8.8314E-09 5.6983E+06
8 2.3046E+05 1.1025E+04 -1.8708E-11 -6.3701E-09 8.8314E-09 5.6983E+06
9 2.3046E+05 1.1025E+04 -1.8708E-11 -6.3701E-09 8.8314E-09 5.6983E+06

MINIMUM -7.1015E+04 -1.3528E+04 -3.5260E-11 -6.3701E-09 8.8314E-09 -6.4664E+06

Pile N. 1 1 1 6 6 1
MAXIMUM 2.3046E+05 1.1025E+04 -1.8708E-11 -4.9658E-09 2.4230E-08 5.6983E+06
Pile N. 6 6 6 1 1 6

PILE GROUP STRESS,LBS/IN**2

********** ****************
1 3.2365E+04
2 3.2365E+04
3 3.2365E+04
4 3.2365E+04
5 3.2365E+04
6 3.3068E+04
7 3.3068E+04
8 3.3068E+04
9 3.3068E+04

MINIMUM 3.2365E+04
Pile N. 1
MAXIMUM 3.3068E+04
Pile N. 6

* EFFECTS FOR LATERALLY LOADED PILE *

* MINIMUM VALUES AND LOCATIONS *

PILE DISPL. DISPL. MOMENT MOMENT SHEAR SOIL REACT TOTAL

y-DIR z-DIR z-DIR y-DIR y-z-DIR y-z-DIR STRESS
IN IN LBS-IN LBS-IN LBS LBS/IN LBS/IN**2
****** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
1 -3.3404 -9.0749E-16 -2.7425E+06 -2.2996E-09 3.3133E-15 0.0000 1923.5
x(FT) 15.360 42.240 59.520 63.360 96.000 0.0000 96.000
2 -3.3404 -9.0749E-16 -2.7425E+06 -2.2996E-09 3.9235E-15 0.0000 1923.5
x(FT) 15.360 42.240 59.520 63.360 96.000 0.0000 96.000
3 -3.3404 -9.0749E-16 -2.7425E+06 -2.2996E-09 1.4077E-15 0.0000 1923.5
x(FT) 15.360 42.240 59.520 63.360 96.000 0.0000 96.000
4 -3.3404 -9.0749E-16 -2.7425E+06 -2.2996E-09 2.5114E-15 0.0000 1923.5
x(FT) 15.360 42.240 59.520 63.360 96.000 0.0000 96.000
5 -3.3404 -9.0749E-16 -2.7425E+06 -2.2996E-09 1.1172E-15 0.0000 1923.5

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-112

x(FT) 15.360 42.240 59.520 63.360 96.000 0.0000 96.000

6 -0.015972 -2.7953E-14 -5.6983E+06 -1.0587E-08 6.2783E-14 0.0000 6242.1
x(FT) 72.960 0.0000 0.0000 59.520 96.000 0.0000 96.000
7 -0.015972 -2.7953E-14 -5.6983E+06 -1.0587E-08 7.7938E-14 0.0000 6242.1
x(FT) 72.960 0.0000 0.0000 59.520 96.000 0.0000 96.000
8 -0.015972 -2.7953E-14 -5.6983E+06 -1.0587E-08 4.3132E-14 0.0000 6242.1
x(FT) 72.960 0.0000 0.0000 59.520 96.000 0.0000 96.000
9 -0.015972 -2.7953E-14 -5.6983E+06 -1.0587E-08 7.7882E-14 0.0000 6242.1
x(FT) 72.960 0.0000 0.0000 59.520 96.000 0.0000 96.000

Min. -3.3404 -2.7953E-14 -5.6983E+06 -1.0587E-08 1.1172E-15 0.0000 1923.5

Pile N. 1 6 6 6 5 1 1

* MAXIMUM VALUES AND LOCATIONS *

PILE DISPL. DISPL. MOMENT MOMENT SHEAR SOIL REACT TOTAL

y-DIR z-DIR z-DIR y-DIR y-z-DIR y-z-DIR STRESS
IN IN LBS-IN LBS-IN LBS LBS/IN LBS/IN**2
****** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
1 0.015935 1.8529E-14 6.4664E+06 2.4230E-08 2.1415E+04 383.30 3.2365E+04
x(FT) 71.040 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 67.200 61.440 0.0000
2 0.015935 1.8529E-14 6.4664E+06 2.4230E-08 2.1415E+04 383.30 3.2365E+04
x(FT) 71.040 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 67.200 61.440 0.0000
3 0.015935 1.8529E-14 6.4664E+06 2.4230E-08 2.1415E+04 383.30 3.2365E+04
x(FT) 71.040 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 67.200 61.440 0.0000
4 0.015935 1.8529E-14 6.4664E+06 2.4230E-08 2.1415E+04 383.30 3.2365E+04
x(FT) 71.040 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 67.200 61.440 0.0000
5 0.015935 1.8529E-14 6.4664E+06 2.4230E-08 2.1415E+04 383.30 3.2365E+04
x(FT) 71.040 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 67.200 61.440 0.0000
6 3.4786 6.2281E-17 2.7151E+06 8.8314E-09 2.1152E+04 304.88 3.3068E+04
x(FT) 15.360 72.960 61.440 0.0000 69.120 65.280 0.0000
7 3.4786 6.2281E-17 2.7151E+06 8.8314E-09 2.1152E+04 304.88 3.3068E+04
x(FT) 15.360 72.960 61.440 0.0000 69.120 65.280 0.0000
8 3.4786 6.2281E-17 2.7151E+06 8.8314E-09 2.1152E+04 304.88 3.3068E+04
x(FT) 15.360 72.960 61.440 0.0000 69.120 65.280 0.0000
9 3.4786 6.2281E-17 2.7151E+06 8.8314E-09 2.1152E+04 304.88 3.3068E+04
x(FT) 15.360 72.960 61.440 0.0000 69.120 65.280 0.0000

Max. 3.4786 1.8529E-14 6.4664E+06 2.4230E-08 2.1415E+04 383.30 3.3068E+04

Pile N. 6 1 1 1 1 1 6

***** SUMMARY FOR LOAD CASES AND COMBINATIONS *****

***** LOAD CASES RESULTS *****

LOAD CASE : 1

* TABLE L * COMPUTATION ON PILE CAP

* EQUIVALENT CONCENTRATED LOAD AT ORIGIN *

LOAD X,LBS LOAD Y,LBS LOAD Z,LBS MOM X,LBS-IN MOM Y,LBS-IN MOM Z,LBS-IN
5.13228E+05 4.85000E+05 0.00000 0.00000 0.00000 0.00000

* DISPLACEMENT OF GROUPED PILE FOUNDATION AT ORIGIN *

DISP X,IN DISP Y,IN DISP Z,IN ROT X,RAD ROT Y,RAD ROT Z,RAD
0.18083 2.29425 -2.04278E-14 -1.34787E-16 -7.46304E-17 0.0125472

* TABLE M * COMPUTATION ON INDIVIDUAL PILE

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS, GLOBAL *

DISP. X,IN DISP. Y,IN DISP. Z,IN ROT. X,RAD ROT. Y,RAD ROT. Z,RAD
*********** *********** *********** *********** *********** ***********

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-113

MINIMUM -0.5720 2.2942 -2.8515E-14 -1.3479E-16 -7.4630E-17 0.012547

Pile N. 6 1 6 1 1 1
MAXIMUM 0.3314 2.2942 -1.8810E-14 -1.3479E-16 -7.4630E-17 0.012547
Pile N. 1 1 1 1 1 1

* PILE TOP REACTIONS, GLOBAL *

FOR. X,LBS FOR. Y,LBS FOR. Z,LBS MOM X,LBS-IN MOM Y,LBS-IN MOM Z,LBS-IN
*********** *********** *********** *********** *********** ***********
MINIMUM -6.7587E+04 2.5654E+04 -4.0551E-11 -9.0979E-09 -2.2208E-08 5.6983E+06
Pile N. 1 1 6 1 1 6
MAXIMUM 2.1279E+05 8.9182E+04 3.2118E-11 -9.0065E-09 7.5158E-09 6.4664E+06
Pile N. 6 6 1 6 6 1

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS, LOCAL *

DISP. x,IN DISP. y,IN DISP. z,IN ROT. x,RAD ROT. y,RAD ROT. z,RAD
*********** *********** *********** *********** *********** ***********
MINIMUM -0.072031 -2.3169 -2.7953E-14 -1.5323E-16 -2.6918E-17 -0.012547
Pile N. 1 1 6 6 6 1
MAXIMUM 0.2472 2.3515 1.8529E-14 -1.1951E-16 9.8415E-17 0.012547
Pile N. 6 6 1 1 1 6

* PILE TOP REACTIONS, LOCAL *

AXIAL,LBS LAT. y,LBS LAT. z,LBS MOM x,LBS-IN MOM y,LBS-IN MOM z,LBS-IN
*********** *********** *********** *********** *********** ***********
MINIMUM -7.1015E+04 -1.3528E+04 -3.5260E-11 -6.3701E-09 8.8314E-09 -6.4664E+06
Pile N. 1 1 1 6 6 1
MAXIMUM 2.3046E+05 1.1025E+04 -1.8708E-11 -4.9658E-09 2.4230E-08 5.6983E+06
Pile N. 6 6 6 1 1 6

* EFFECTS FOR LATERALLY LOADED PILE *

PILE DISPL. DISPL. MOMENT MOMENT SHEAR SOIL REACT TOTAL

y-DIR z-DIR z-DIR y-DIR y-z-DIR y-z-DIR STRESS
IN IN LBS-IN LBS-IN LBS LBS/IN LBS/IN**2
****** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
Min. -3.3404 -2.7953E-14 -5.6983E+06 -1.0587E-08 1.1172E-15 0.0000 1923.5
Pile N. 1 6 6 6 5 1 1
Max. 3.4786 1.8529E-14 6.4664E+06 2.4230E-08 2.1415E+04 383.30 3.3068E+04
Pile N. 6 1 1 1 1 1 6

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-114

2.5.7 Graphs

Figure 2.13 Curves Resultant Deflection vs. Distance for Example Problem 4 - 3D.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-115

Figure 2.14 Curves Resultant Moment vs. Distance for Example Problem 4 - 3D.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-116

2.6 Example Problem 5 - 3D

2.6.1 Model Description

This example problem is used to illustrate a pile group with 5 piles arranged in a diamond shape
as shown in Figure 2.15. The soil at the site is soft clay with a cohesive strength that increases linearly
from 5.2 psi at the ground surface to 10.4 psi at 100 feet. The maximum load-transfer in skin friction for
axial loads is estimated to be 5.2 psi at the top and 8 psi near the pile tip. All piles are steel pipe piles
with 10.75 inches outer diameter and 10.,02 inches inner diameter. The connection between the pile
and the pile cap is rigid for all the piles.

The input and output files for the example problem are shown in the following pages.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-117

Figure 2.15 General Description of Example Problem 5 - 3D.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-118

2.6.2 Input Data

EXAMPLE PROBLEM 5 - 3D, Pile group arranged in a diamond shape

GROUP2016.10.8
* Analysis Parameters
1 3 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 1
* Pile Cap Dimensions
0 0 0 0 0 0
* Load Cases
1 0 0 1 0
0 1 1 1 1 100 100
0.0001 0.0001 1 1
Load Case 1
12 0 0 0 1 0 0 0
2 1 1 0 0.0001 1E-6 0 0 0
1
0 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 0 0 0 1 0 0 1 0 1 0 0 0 0 1 1
1
0 100000 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
0
0
* Load Combinations
0 0 0 0 0
* Distributed Load Sets
0
* Pile Group Configuration
5
2 2 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 1
0 0 1 1 1 1 1
0 -2.5 0 0 90 0 0
2 2 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 1
0 0 1 1 1 1 1
0 0 2.5 0 90 0 0
2 2 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 1
0 0 1 1 1 1 1
0 2.5 0 0 90 0 0
2 2 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 1
0 0 1 1 1 1 1
0 0 -2.5 0 90 0 0
2 2 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 1
0 0 1 1 1 1 1
0 0 0 0 90 0 0
* Pile Properties
1
0 1
50 76 1
0 76 1
* Pile Cross Sections
1
0 0 0 0
Section 1
10.75 0 1 1 0 0 0.1 0.1
1 11.91 160.73 160.73 0 2.4E9 0 0 30000000 0 0
0 0 0 0 1
None
* Soil Layers
1
0 1
0 100
2 10
58.752 748.8 0 100 0 0.01 0 748.8 0 0
58.752 1497.6 0 100 0 0.01 0 1152 0 0
* Generated LD curves
1
1
* Generated TR curves
1

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-119

1
* User defined MC curves
1
1 1
0
1 1
0 0
* Internally Generated MC curves
1
1 1
0
0
1 1
0 0
1 1
0
0
1 1
0 0
* End of file

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-120

2.6.3 Echo Print File

=========================================================================

GROUP for Windows, Version 2016.10.8

Serial Number : 136089307

Analysis of A Group of Piles

Subjected to Axial and Lateral Loading

(c) Copyright ENSOFT, Inc., 1987-2015

All Rights Reserved

=========================================================================

This program is licensed to :

ENSOFT, INC
AUSTIN, TX

Path to file locations : C:\projects\GROUP2016\Group2016_1008\DXE\Examples_2016\

Name of input data file : 3Dexample5.gp10r
Name of output echo file : 3Dexample5.gp10e
Name of output results file : 3Dexample5.gp10o
Name of output summary file : 3Dexample5.gp10t
Name of plot output file : 3Dexample5.gp10p
Name of runtime file : 3Dexample5.gp10r

-------------------------------------------------------------------------
Time and Date of Analysis
-------------------------------------------------------------------------

Date: May 09, 2016 Time: 18:14:31

***** INPUT INFORMATION *****

EXAMPLE PROBLEM 5 - 3D, Pile group arranged in a diamond shape

ANALYSIS TYPE = 3D ANALYSIS

ADJUST DEPTH FOR BATTER PILES

GENERATE LOAD-DISP (AND T-R) CURVES BASED ON SOIL PROFILE

EXTEND INTERPOLATION FOR L-DP (AND T-R) CURVES

UNITS SYSTEM = ENGL

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-121

* TABLE C * LOAD AND CONTROL PARAMETERS

** LOAD CASES **

NUMBER OF LOAD CASES : 1

LOAD CASE : 1
CASE NAME : Load Case 1
LOAD TYPE : Special, Sp
SCALE FACTOR : 1.0000

* CONCENTRATED LOADS *

NL VERT.LOAD HR.LOAD Y HR.LOAD Z MOMENT X MOMENT Y MOMENT Z COORD X COORD Y COORD Z

LBS LBS LBS LBS-IN LBS-IN LBS-IN FT FT FT
1 0.00 1.00E+05 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00

* EQUIVALENT CONCENTRATED LOAD AT ORIGIN *

VER.LOAD X,LBS HOR.LOAD Y,LBS HOR.LOAD Z,LBS

0.00000 1.00000E+05 0.00000

MOMENT X,LBS-IN MOMENT Y,LBS-IN MOMENT Z,LBS-IN

0.00000 0.00000 0.00000

* THE LOADING IS STATIC *

* CONTROL PARAMETERS *
TOLERANCE ON CONVERGENCE OF PILE CAP MOVEMENT = 1.00000E-04
TOLERANCE ON DETERMINATION OF PILE DEFLECTIONS = 1.00000E-04 IN
MAX NO OF ITERATIONS ALLOWED FOR FOUNDATION ANALYSIS = 100
MAXIMUM NO OF ITERATIONS ALLOWED FOR PILE ANALYSIS = 100
FACTOR TO APPLY THE LOAD IN INCREMENTS = 1.0000
MINIMUM FACTOR FOR LOAD INCREMENTS = 1.0000
PRINT RESULTS AT PILE CAP, PILE HEADS AND ALONG PILES
PRINT RESULTS EVERY 1 NODE(S)

* TABLE D * ARRANGEMENT OF PILE GROUPS

GROUP CONN.Z-Z CONN.Y-Y PILE PROP P-Y CURVE L-S CURVE T-R CURVE R-F-L SET
1 FIX FIX 1 0 1 G 1 G 0
2 FIX FIX 1 0 1 G 1 G 0
3 FIX FIX 1 0 1 G 1 G 0
4 FIX FIX 1 0 1 G 1 G 0
5 FIX FIX 1 0 1 G 1 G 0

GROUP CorX,FT CorY,FT CorZ,FT ALPHA,DEG BETA,DEG THETA,DEG GROUND,FT SPz,LBS-IN

SPy,LBS-IN
1 0.000 -2.500 0.000 0.000 90.00 0.000 0.000 0.000
0.000
2 0.000 0.000 2.500 0.000 90.00 0.000 0.000 0.000
0.000
3 0.000 2.500 0.000 0.000 90.00 0.000 0.000 0.000
0.000

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-122

4 0.000 0.000 -2.500 0.000 90.00 0.000 0.000 0.000

0.000
5 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 90.00 0.000 0.000 0.000
0.000

* TABLE E * PILE GEOMETRY AND PROPERTIES

PILE TYPE = 1 - DRIVEN PILE
= 2 - DRILLED SHAFT

PROP SECTS INC PILE TYPE LENGTH, FT

1 1 50 1 76.000

* PILE SECTIONS *

PROP SECT FROM,FT TO,FT CROSS SECT

1 1 0.00000 76.0000 1

* PILE CROSS SECTIONS *

CROSS SECTION : 1
SECTION NAME : Section

TYPE : ELASTIC
CROSS SECTION TYPE : GENERAL SECTION
EQUIVALENT DIAMETER : 10.7500 IN
YOUNG MODULUS : 3.00000E+07 LBS/IN**2

* PILE CROSS SECTIONS PROPERTIES *

ELASTIC SECTIONS

SECT DIAM,IN AREA,IN**2 Iz,IN**4 Iy,IN**4 GJ,LBS-IN**2 Mn,LBS-IN Vn,LBS

1 10.750 11.910 160.73 160.73 2.4000E+09 0.0000 0.0000

* TABLE F * SOIL DATA

SOILS INFORMATION

GROUND SURFACE = 0.00000 FT

1 LAYER(S) OF SOIL

LAYER 1
THE SOIL IS A SOFT CLAY
TOP OF LAYER BOTTOM OF LAYER
X COORDINATE (FT) 0.00000 100.000
EFFECTIVE UNIT WEIGHT (LBS/FT**3) 58.7520 58.7520
UNDRAINED COHESION, C (LBS/FT**2) 748.800 1497.60
STRAIN AT 50% STRESS 1.00000E-02 1.00000E-02
ULTIMATE UNIT SIDE FRICTION (LBS/FT**2) 748.800 1152.00
ULTIMATE UNIT TIP RESISTANCE (LBS/FT**2) 6739.20 (R) 13478.4 (R)

Notes : Program estimated values for listed parameters

if zero input values were entered:
(R) ULTIMATE UNIT TIP RESISTANCE for Driven Piles

* TABLE H * AXIAL LOAD VS DISPLACEMENT

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-123

AXIAL LOAD-DISPLACEMENT CURVES GENERATED INTERNALLY

NUM OF CURVES 1

CURVE 1 NUM OF POINTS 19

DISPLACEMENT, IN AXIAL LOAD,LBS

-2.24195 -1.79427E+05
-1.24195 -1.79427E+05
-0.74195 -1.79427E+05
-0.34999 -1.83249E+05
-0.29620 -1.82656E+05
-0.10508 -1.02191E+05
-0.0532479 -59514.8
-0.0101702 -11102.2
-1.00876E-03 -1088.18
0.00000 0.00000
1.01135E-03 1091.00
0.0101963 11130.9
0.0533881 59659.2
0.10532 1.02356E+05
0.29664 1.82827E+05
0.35078 1.83554E+05
0.74386 1.80174E+05
1.24446 1.80408E+05
2.24446 1.80408E+05

* TABLE I * TORS. MOM. VS ANGLE ROT.

TORQUE-ROTATION CURVES GENERATED INTERNALLY

NUM OF CURVES 1

CURVE 1 NUM OF POINTS 19

ROT. ANGLE,Rad. TORS.MOMEN,LBS-IN

-0.54374 -7.00990E+05
-0.35769 -7.00990E+05
-0.26467 -7.00990E+05
-0.19376 -7.11092E+05
-0.18352 -7.09782E+05
-0.10466 -4.94973E+05
-0.0718896 -3.81673E+05
-0.0211408 -1.52169E+05
-2.00222E-03 -14911.5
0.00000 0.00000
2.00222E-03 14911.5
0.0211408 1.52169E+05
0.0718896 3.81673E+05
0.10466 4.94973E+05
0.18352 7.09782E+05
0.19376 7.11092E+05
0.26467 7.00990E+05
0.35769 7.00990E+05
0.54374 7.00990E+05

* TABLE J * MOMENT CURVATURE SETS

USER DEFINED MOMENT CURVATURE

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-124

NUM OF SETS : 1

CURVE SET 1 NUM OF CURVES 1

CURVE 1 AXIAL LOAD 0.000E+00 LBS

POINT MOMENT CURVATURE

LBS-IN RADIAN/IN
1 0.00000 0.00000

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-125

2.6.4 Processor Run Notes

GROUP for Windows, Version 2016.10.8

-------------------------------------------------------------------------
Time and Date of Analysis
-------------------------------------------------------------------------

Date: May 09, 2016 Time: 18:14:31

EXAMPLE PROBLEM 5 - 3D, Pile group arranged in a diamond shape

READING * TITLE AND VERSION

READING * Analysis Parameters
READING * Pile Cap Dimensions
READING * Load Cases
READING * Load Combinations
READING * Distributed Load Sets
READING * Pile Group Configuration
READING * Pile Properties
READING * Pile Cross Sections
READING * Soil Layers
READING * Generated LD curves
READING * Generated TR curves
READING * User defined MC curves
READING * Internally Generated MC curves

COMPUTATION IS PROCEEDING......

LOAD CASE : 1
CASE NAME : Load Case 1

GLOBAL ITERATIONS
STEP 1, TCUR 1.0000, DTCUR 1.0000
ITERATION 1
- ErrDsp 0.10000E+01, IncDsp 0.13628E-01, TotDsp 0.13628E-01
- ErrRot 0.10000E+01, IncRot 0.43071E-03, TotRot 0.43071E-03
ITERATION 2
- ErrDsp 0.91584E+00, IncDsp 0.14829E+00, TotDsp 0.16192E+00
- ErrRot 0.66844E+00, IncRot 0.86834E-03, TotRot 0.12990E-02
ITERATION 3
- ErrDsp 0.69536E+00, IncDsp 0.36958E+00, TotDsp 0.53150E+00
- ErrRot 0.35759E+00, IncRot 0.72311E-03, TotRot 0.20222E-02
ITERATION 4
- ErrDsp 0.27034E+00, IncDsp 0.19692E+00, TotDsp 0.72843E+00
- ErrRot 0.15299E+00, IncRot 0.36526E-03, TotRot 0.23874E-02
ITERATION 5
- ErrDsp 0.26083E-01, IncDsp 0.19508E-01, TotDsp 0.74793E+00
- ErrRot 0.74690E-02, IncRot 0.17966E-04, TotRot 0.24054E-02
ITERATION 6
- ErrDsp 0.16493E-03, IncDsp 0.12338E-03, TotDsp 0.74806E+00
- ErrRot 0.62549E-04, IncRot 0.15046E-06, TotRot 0.24055E-02
ITERATION 7
- ErrDsp 0.53565E-08, IncDsp 0.40070E-08, TotDsp 0.74806E+00
- ErrRot 0.22063E-08, IncRot 0.53074E-11, TotRot 0.24055E-02

NUMBER OF GLOBAL ITERATIONS = 7

ANALYSIS FOR LOAD CASE 1/ 1 FINISHED

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-126

Execution Time : 147 ms

Number Processors : 1/ 1
Serial processing : 0.068 sec
Paral. processing : 0.050 sec
Print. processing : 0.030 sec

ANALYSIS COMPLETED
Execution Time : 148 ms
Number Processors : 1/ 1

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-127

2.6.5 Output Results File

=========================================================================

GROUP for Windows, Version 2016.10.8

Serial Number : 136089307

Analysis of A Group of Piles

Subjected to Axial and Lateral Loading

(c) Copyright ENSOFT, Inc., 1987-2015

All Rights Reserved

=========================================================================

This program is licensed to :

ENSOFT, INC
AUSTIN, TX

Path to file locations : C:\projects\GROUP2016\Group2016_1008\DXE\Examples_2016\

Name of input data file : 3Dexample5.gp10d
Name of output echo file : 3Dexample5.gp10e
Name of output results file : 3Dexample5.gp10o
Name of output summary file : 3Dexample5.gp10t
Name of plot output file : 3Dexample5.gp10p
Name of runtime file : 3Dexample5.gp10r

-------------------------------------------------------------------------
Time and Date of Analysis
-------------------------------------------------------------------------

Date: May 09, 2016 Time: 18:14:31

***** COMPUTATION RESULTS *****

EXAMPLE PROBLEM 5 - 3D, Pile group arranged in a diamond shape

***** LOAD CASES RESULTS *****

LOAD CASE : 1
CASE NAME : Load Case 1

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-128

LOAD TYPE : Special, Sp

* TABLE L * COMPUTATION ON PILE CAP

* EQUIVALENT CONCENTRATED LOAD AT ORIGIN *

VERT. LOAD, LBS HOR. LOAD Y, LBS HOR. LOAD Z, LBS

0.00000 1.00000E+05 0.00000

MOMENT X ,LBS-IN MOMENT Y,LBS-IN MOMENT Z,LBS-IN

0.00000 0.00000 0.00000

* DISPLACEMENT OF GROUPED PILE FOUNDATION AT ORIGIN *

VERTICAL ,IN HORIZONTAL Y,IN HORIZONTAL Z,IN

-1.20284E-06 0.74806 0.00000

ANGLE ROT. X,RAD ANGLE ROT. Y,RAD ANGLE ROT. Z,RAD

0.00000 0.00000 -2.40553E-03

NUMBER OF GLOBAL ITERATIONS = 7

* TABLE M * COMPUTATION ON INDIVIDUAL PILE

* PILE GROUP * 1

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS AND REACTIONS *

THE GLOBAL STRUCTURAL COORDINATE SYSTEM

---------------------------------------

DISP. X,IN DISP. Y,IN DISP. Z,IN ROT. X,RAD ROT. Y,RAD ROT. Z,RAD
-0.072167 0.7481 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 -2.4055E-03

FOR. X,LBS FOR. Y,LBS FOR. Z,LBS MOM X,LBS-IN MOM Y,LBS-IN MOM Z,LBS-IN
-7.5093E+04 2.0370E+04 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 8.9784E+05

STR,LBS/IN**2
3.6330E+04

THE PILE COORDINATE SYSTEM (LOCAL AXES)

---------------------------------------

DISP. x,IN DISP. y,IN DISP. z,IN ROT. x,RAD ROT. y,RAD ROT. z,RAD
-0.072167 0.7481 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 -2.4055E-03

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-129

AXIAL,LBS LAT. y,LBS LAT. z,LBS MOM x,LBS-IN MOM y,LBS-IN MOM z,LBS-IN
-7.5093E+04 2.0370E+04 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 8.9784E+05

STR,LBS/IN**2
3.6330E+04

* EFFECTS FOR LATERALLY LOADED PILE *

x DISPL. DISPL. MOMENT MOMENT SHEAR SOIL REACT TOTAL

y-DIR z-DIR z-DIR y-DIR y-z-DIR y-z-DIR STRESS
FT IN IN LBS-IN LBS-IN LBS LBS/IN LBS/IN**2
********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
0.0000 0.7481 0.0000 -8.9784E+05 0.0000 2.0242E+04 0.0000 3.6330E+04
1.5200 0.6732 0.0000 -5.3192E+05 0.0000 1.8976E+04 152.83 2.4093E+04
3.0400 0.5617 0.0000 -2.1960E+05 0.0000 1.5927E+04 181.46 1.3649E+04
4.5600 0.4349 0.0000 3.1206E+04 0.0000 1.2430E+04 202.01 7348.6
6.0800 0.3104 0.0000 2.1497E+05 0.0000 8645.8 212.90 1.3494E+04
7.6000 0.2007 0.0000 3.2901E+05 0.0000 4763.9 212.75 1.7308E+04
9.1200 0.1137 0.0000 3.7398E+05 0.0000 996.84 200.30 1.8811E+04
10.640 5.2446E-02 0.0000 3.5425E+05 0.0000 2303.6 161.59 1.8151E+04
12.160 1.5673E-02 0.0000 2.8259E+05 0.0000 4778.4 109.77 1.5755E+04
13.680 -1.6013E-03 0.0000 1.7587E+05 0.0000 5319.7 50.405 1.2186E+04
15.200 -6.7413E-03 0.0000 8.6840E+04 0.0000 4090.7 84.361 9209.1
16.720 -5.8896E-03 0.0000 2.6324E+04 0.0000 2575.3 81.799 7185.4
18.240 -3.2215E-03 0.0000 -6841.7 0.0000 1211.3 67.760 6533.8
19.760 -1.0256E-03 0.0000 -1.7499E+04 0.0000 166.16 46.838 6890.2
21.280 -3.7001E-05 0.0000 -1.2664E+04 0.0000 406.24 15.925 6728.6
22.800 7.7782E-05 0.0000 -2596.7 0.0000 367.29 20.195 6391.9
24.320 1.3402E-05 0.0000 738.50 0.0000 76.685 11.670 6329.7
25.840 -2.4515E-08 0.0000 194.93 0.0000 20.225 1.0439 6311.6
27.360 -9.2998E-10 0.0000 -0.3283 0.0000 5.3439 0.5878 6305.1
28.880 8.3678E-16 0.0000 -1.3479E-02 0.0000 8.9987E-03 9.0567E-04 6305.1
30.400 3.6995E-17 0.0000 1.1055E-08 0.0000 3.6948E-04 4.0513E-05 6305.1
31.920 -2.7077E-23 0.0000 5.3618E-10 0.0000 3.0298E-10 2.9998E-11 6305.1
33.440 -1.4381E-24 0.0000 -3.5075E-16 0.0000 1.4698E-11 1.6116E-12 6305.1
34.960 8.1935E-31 0.0000 -2.0844E-17 0.0000 9.6120E-18 9.2865E-19 6305.1
36.480 5.4661E-32 0.0000 1.0291E-23 0.0000 5.7137E-19 6.2650E-20 6305.1
38.000 -2.2570E-38 0.0000 7.9222E-25 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 6305.1
39.520 -2.0323E-39 0.0000 -2.6820E-31 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 6305.1
41.040 5.3072E-46 0.0000 -2.9455E-32 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 6305.1
42.560 7.3949E-47 0.0000 5.5483E-39 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 6305.1
44.080 0.0000 0.0000 1.0718E-39 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 6305.1
45.600 0.0000 0.0000 -4.6015E-47 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 6305.1
47.120 0.0000 0.0000 -3.8184E-47 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 6305.1
48.640 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 6305.1
50.160 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 6305.1
51.680 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 6305.1
53.200 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 6305.1
54.720 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 6305.1
56.240 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 6305.1
57.760 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 6305.1
59.280 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 6305.1
60.800 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 6305.1
62.320 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 6305.1
63.840 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 6305.1
65.360 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 6305.1
66.880 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 6305.1
68.400 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 6305.1
69.920 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 6305.1
71.440 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 6305.1
72.960 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 6305.1
74.480 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 6305.1
76.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 6305.1

* PILE GROUP * 2

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-130

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS AND REACTIONS *

THE GLOBAL STRUCTURAL COORDINATE SYSTEM

---------------------------------------

DISP. X,IN DISP. Y,IN DISP. Z,IN ROT. X,RAD ROT. Y,RAD ROT. Z,RAD
-1.2028E-06 0.7481 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 -2.4055E-03

FOR. X,LBS FOR. Y,LBS FOR. Z,LBS MOM X,LBS-IN MOM Y,LBS-IN MOM Z,LBS-IN
-1.2975 2.0000E+04 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 9.0111E+05

STR,LBS/IN**2
3.0134E+04

THE PILE COORDINATE SYSTEM (LOCAL AXES)

---------------------------------------

DISP. x,IN DISP. y,IN DISP. z,IN ROT. x,RAD ROT. y,RAD ROT. z,RAD
-1.2028E-06 0.7481 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 -2.4055E-03

AXIAL,LBS LAT. y,LBS LAT. z,LBS MOM x,LBS-IN MOM y,LBS-IN MOM z,LBS-IN
-1.2975 2.0000E+04 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 9.0111E+05

STR,LBS/IN**2
3.0134E+04

* EFFECTS FOR LATERALLY LOADED PILE *

x DISPL. DISPL. MOMENT MOMENT SHEAR SOIL REACT TOTAL

y-DIR z-DIR z-DIR y-DIR y-z-DIR y-z-DIR STRESS
FT IN IN LBS-IN LBS-IN LBS LBS/IN LBS/IN**2
********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
0.0000 0.7481 0.0000 -9.0111E+05 0.0000 2.0000E+04 0.0000 3.0134E+04
1.5200 0.6731 0.0000 -5.3631E+05 0.0000 1.8607E+04 152.82 1.7935E+04
3.0400 0.5611 0.0000 -2.2235E+05 0.0000 1.5558E+04 181.41 7435.6
4.5600 0.4338 0.0000 3.1262E+04 0.0000 1.2063E+04 201.84 1045.5
6.0800 0.3087 0.0000 2.1772E+05 0.0000 8284.4 212.50 7280.9
7.6000 0.1985 0.0000 3.3348E+05 0.0000 4413.0 211.99 1.1152E+04
9.1200 0.1114 0.0000 3.7870E+05 0.0000 664.91 198.98 1.2664E+04
10.640 5.0422E-02 0.0000 3.5773E+05 0.0000 2604.4 159.50 1.1963E+04
12.160 1.4113E-02 0.0000 2.8369E+05 0.0000 5026.2 106.05 9487.2
13.680 -2.6216E-03 0.0000 1.7437E+05 0.0000 5446.2 60.003 5831.4
15.200 -7.3252E-03 0.0000 8.5016E+04 0.0000 4107.8 86.751 2843.2
16.720 -6.1628E-03 0.0000 2.4520E+04 0.0000 2559.2 83.053 820.10
18.240 -3.3087E-03 0.0000 -8344.2 0.0000 1178.2 68.376 279.15
19.760 -1.0302E-03 0.0000 -1.8460E+04 0.0000 126.55 46.937 617.44
21.280 -2.5500E-05 0.0000 -1.2961E+04 0.0000 434.19 14.547 433.52
22.800 8.4993E-05 0.0000 -2621.0 0.0000 377.40 20.774 87.759
24.320 1.4643E-05 0.0000 806.89 0.0000 77.692 12.088 27.092
25.840 -3.3217E-08 0.0000 213.18 0.0000 22.131 1.1424 7.2378
27.360 -1.1295E-09 0.0000 -0.4487 0.0000 5.8441 0.6434 0.1240
28.880 1.1551E-15 0.0000 -1.6370E-02 0.0000 1.2300E-02 1.2502E-03 0.1095
30.400 4.4932E-17 0.0000 1.5439E-08 0.0000 4.4875E-04 4.9205E-05 0.1089
31.920 -3.8355E-23 0.0000 6.5122E-10 0.0000 4.2323E-10 4.2492E-11 0.1089
33.440 -1.7467E-24 0.0000 -5.0525E-16 0.0000 1.7851E-11 1.9574E-12 0.1089
34.960 1.2057E-30 0.0000 -2.5315E-17 0.0000 1.3850E-17 1.3665E-18 0.1089
36.480 6.6388E-32 0.0000 1.5550E-23 0.0000 6.9395E-19 7.6091E-20 0.1089
38.000 -3.5338E-38 0.0000 9.6219E-25 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.1089
39.520 -2.4683E-39 0.0000 -4.4061E-31 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.1089
41.040 9.3656E-46 0.0000 -3.5774E-32 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.1089
42.560 8.9814E-47 0.0000 1.0971E-38 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.1089

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-131

44.080 0.0000 0.0000 1.3017E-39 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.1089

45.600 0.0000 0.0000 -2.0849E-46 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.1089
47.120 0.0000 0.0000 -4.6376E-47 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.1089
48.640 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.1089
50.160 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.1089
51.680 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.1089
53.200 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.1089
54.720 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.1089
56.240 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.1089
57.760 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.1089
59.280 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.1089
60.800 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.1089
62.320 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.1089
63.840 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.1089
65.360 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.1089
66.880 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.1089
68.400 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.1089
69.920 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.1089
71.440 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.1089
72.960 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.1089
74.480 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.1089
76.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.1089

* PILE GROUP * 3

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS AND REACTIONS *

THE GLOBAL STRUCTURAL COORDINATE SYSTEM

---------------------------------------

DISP. X,IN DISP. Y,IN DISP. Z,IN ROT. X,RAD ROT. Y,RAD ROT. Z,RAD
0.072165 0.7481 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 -2.4055E-03

FOR. X,LBS FOR. Y,LBS FOR. Z,LBS MOM X,LBS-IN MOM Y,LBS-IN MOM Z,LBS-IN
7.5097E+04 1.9630E+04 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 9.0453E+05

STR,LBS/IN**2
3.6554E+04

THE PILE COORDINATE SYSTEM (LOCAL AXES)

---------------------------------------

DISP. x,IN DISP. y,IN DISP. z,IN ROT. x,RAD ROT. y,RAD ROT. z,RAD
0.072165 0.7481 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 -2.4055E-03

AXIAL,LBS LAT. y,LBS LAT. z,LBS MOM x,LBS-IN MOM y,LBS-IN MOM z,LBS-IN
7.5097E+04 1.9630E+04 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 9.0453E+05

STR,LBS/IN**2
3.6554E+04

* EFFECTS FOR LATERALLY LOADED PILE *

x DISPL. DISPL. MOMENT MOMENT SHEAR SOIL REACT TOTAL

y-DIR z-DIR z-DIR y-DIR y-z-DIR y-z-DIR STRESS
FT IN IN LBS-IN LBS-IN LBS LBS/IN LBS/IN**2
********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
0.0000 0.7481 0.0000 -9.0453E+05 0.0000 1.9758E+04 0.0000 3.6554E+04

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-132

1.5200 0.6730 0.0000 -5.4084E+05 0.0000 1.8236E+04 152.81 2.4392E+04

3.0400 0.5606 0.0000 -2.2520E+05 0.0000 1.5188E+04 181.35 1.3836E+04
4.5600 0.4326 0.0000 3.1277E+04 0.0000 1.1695E+04 201.66 7351.3
6.0800 0.3069 0.0000 2.2050E+05 0.0000 7922.1 212.09 1.3679E+04
7.6000 0.1963 0.0000 3.3802E+05 0.0000 4061.7 211.19 1.7609E+04
9.1200 0.1091 0.0000 3.8353E+05 0.0000 333.80 197.57 1.9131E+04
10.640 4.8275E-02 0.0000 3.6132E+05 0.0000 2901.8 157.21 1.8388E+04
12.160 1.2425E-02 0.0000 2.8493E+05 0.0000 5263.1 101.70 1.5834E+04
13.680 -3.7661E-03 0.0000 1.7323E+05 0.0000 5569.8 68.068 1.2098E+04
15.200 -8.0046E-03 0.0000 8.3276E+04 0.0000 4133.8 89.391 9090.2
16.720 -6.4973E-03 0.0000 2.2633E+04 0.0000 2547.5 84.546 7062.3
18.240 -3.4284E-03 0.0000 -9999.1 0.0000 1145.4 69.193 6639.8
19.760 -1.0495E-03 0.0000 -1.9559E+04 0.0000 83.871 47.198 6959.5
21.280 -2.0006E-05 0.0000 -1.3315E+04 0.0000 464.82 12.966 6750.6
22.800 9.0775E-05 0.0000 -2687.9 0.0000 388.32 21.354 6395.3
24.320 1.6102E-05 0.0000 848.45 0.0000 79.915 12.462 6333.8
25.840 -3.1070E-08 0.0000 234.25 0.0000 23.302 1.1445 6313.2
27.360 -1.5821E-09 0.0000 -0.4045 0.0000 6.4218 0.7064 6305.4
28.880 9.9617E-16 0.0000 -2.2931E-02 0.0000 1.1090E-02 1.0782E-03 6305.4
30.400 6.2938E-17 0.0000 1.2614E-08 0.0000 6.2858E-04 6.8923E-05 6305.4
31.920 -2.9285E-23 0.0000 9.1218E-10 0.0000 3.4589E-10 3.2444E-11 6305.4
33.440 -2.4467E-24 0.0000 -3.5351E-16 0.0000 2.5005E-11 2.7418E-12 6305.4
34.960 7.4992E-31 0.0000 -3.5460E-17 0.0000 9.6957E-18 8.4995E-19 6305.4
36.480 9.2992E-32 0.0000 8.1733E-24 0.0000 9.7204E-19 1.0658E-19 6305.4
38.000 -1.4225E-38 0.0000 1.3478E-24 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 6305.4
39.520 -3.4574E-39 0.0000 -1.0595E-31 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 6305.4
41.040 1.5197E-47 0.0000 -5.0110E-32 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 6305.4
42.560 1.2581E-46 0.0000 -3.4264E-39 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 6305.4
44.080 0.0000 0.0000 1.8233E-39 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 6305.4
45.600 0.0000 0.0000 3.8424E-46 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 6305.4
47.120 0.0000 0.0000 -6.4961E-47 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 6305.4
48.640 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 6305.4
50.160 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 6305.4
51.680 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 6305.4
53.200 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 6305.4
54.720 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 6305.4
56.240 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 6305.4
57.760 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 6305.4
59.280 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 6305.4
60.800 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 6305.4
62.320 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 6305.4
63.840 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 6305.4
65.360 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 6305.4
66.880 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 6305.4
68.400 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 6305.4
69.920 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 6305.4
71.440 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 6305.4
72.960 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 6305.4
74.480 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 6305.4
76.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 6305.4

* PILE GROUP * 4

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS AND REACTIONS *

THE GLOBAL STRUCTURAL COORDINATE SYSTEM

---------------------------------------

DISP. X,IN DISP. Y,IN DISP. Z,IN ROT. X,RAD ROT. Y,RAD ROT. Z,RAD
-1.2028E-06 0.7481 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 -2.4055E-03

FOR. X,LBS FOR. Y,LBS FOR. Z,LBS MOM X,LBS-IN MOM Y,LBS-IN MOM Z,LBS-IN
-1.2975 2.0000E+04 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 9.0111E+05

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-133

STR,LBS/IN**2
3.0134E+04

THE PILE COORDINATE SYSTEM (LOCAL AXES)

---------------------------------------

DISP. x,IN DISP. y,IN DISP. z,IN ROT. x,RAD ROT. y,RAD ROT. z,RAD
-1.2028E-06 0.7481 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 -2.4055E-03

AXIAL,LBS LAT. y,LBS LAT. z,LBS MOM x,LBS-IN MOM y,LBS-IN MOM z,LBS-IN
-1.2975 2.0000E+04 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 9.0111E+05

STR,LBS/IN**2
3.0134E+04

* EFFECTS FOR LATERALLY LOADED PILE *

x DISPL. DISPL. MOMENT MOMENT SHEAR SOIL REACT TOTAL

y-DIR z-DIR z-DIR y-DIR y-z-DIR y-z-DIR STRESS
FT IN IN LBS-IN LBS-IN LBS LBS/IN LBS/IN**2
********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
0.0000 0.7481 0.0000 -9.0111E+05 0.0000 2.0000E+04 0.0000 3.0134E+04
1.5200 0.6731 0.0000 -5.3631E+05 0.0000 1.8607E+04 152.82 1.7935E+04
3.0400 0.5611 0.0000 -2.2235E+05 0.0000 1.5558E+04 181.41 7435.6
4.5600 0.4338 0.0000 3.1262E+04 0.0000 1.2063E+04 201.84 1045.5
6.0800 0.3087 0.0000 2.1772E+05 0.0000 8284.4 212.50 7280.9
7.6000 0.1985 0.0000 3.3348E+05 0.0000 4413.0 211.99 1.1152E+04
9.1200 0.1114 0.0000 3.7870E+05 0.0000 664.91 198.98 1.2664E+04
10.640 5.0422E-02 0.0000 3.5773E+05 0.0000 2604.4 159.50 1.1963E+04
12.160 1.4113E-02 0.0000 2.8369E+05 0.0000 5026.2 106.05 9487.2
13.680 -2.6216E-03 0.0000 1.7437E+05 0.0000 5446.2 60.003 5831.4
15.200 -7.3252E-03 0.0000 8.5016E+04 0.0000 4107.8 86.751 2843.2
16.720 -6.1628E-03 0.0000 2.4520E+04 0.0000 2559.2 83.053 820.10
18.240 -3.3087E-03 0.0000 -8344.2 0.0000 1178.2 68.376 279.15
19.760 -1.0302E-03 0.0000 -1.8460E+04 0.0000 126.55 46.937 617.44
21.280 -2.5500E-05 0.0000 -1.2961E+04 0.0000 434.19 14.547 433.52
22.800 8.4993E-05 0.0000 -2621.0 0.0000 377.40 20.774 87.759
24.320 1.4643E-05 0.0000 806.89 0.0000 77.692 12.088 27.092
25.840 -3.3217E-08 0.0000 213.18 0.0000 22.131 1.1424 7.2378
27.360 -1.1295E-09 0.0000 -0.4487 0.0000 5.8441 0.6434 0.1240
28.880 1.1551E-15 0.0000 -1.6370E-02 0.0000 1.2300E-02 1.2502E-03 0.1095
30.400 4.4932E-17 0.0000 1.5439E-08 0.0000 4.4875E-04 4.9205E-05 0.1089
31.920 -3.8355E-23 0.0000 6.5122E-10 0.0000 4.2323E-10 4.2492E-11 0.1089
33.440 -1.7467E-24 0.0000 -5.0525E-16 0.0000 1.7851E-11 1.9574E-12 0.1089
34.960 1.2057E-30 0.0000 -2.5315E-17 0.0000 1.3850E-17 1.3665E-18 0.1089
36.480 6.6388E-32 0.0000 1.5550E-23 0.0000 6.9395E-19 7.6091E-20 0.1089
38.000 -3.5338E-38 0.0000 9.6219E-25 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.1089
39.520 -2.4683E-39 0.0000 -4.4061E-31 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.1089
41.040 9.3656E-46 0.0000 -3.5774E-32 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.1089
42.560 8.9814E-47 0.0000 1.0971E-38 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.1089
44.080 0.0000 0.0000 1.3017E-39 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.1089
45.600 0.0000 0.0000 -2.0849E-46 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.1089
47.120 0.0000 0.0000 -4.6376E-47 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.1089
48.640 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.1089
50.160 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.1089
51.680 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.1089
53.200 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.1089
54.720 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.1089
56.240 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.1089
57.760 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.1089
59.280 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.1089
60.800 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.1089
62.320 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.1089
63.840 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.1089
65.360 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.1089

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-134

66.880 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.1089

68.400 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.1089
69.920 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.1089
71.440 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.1089
72.960 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.1089
74.480 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.1089
76.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.1089

* PILE GROUP * 5

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS AND REACTIONS *

THE GLOBAL STRUCTURAL COORDINATE SYSTEM

---------------------------------------

DISP. X,IN DISP. Y,IN DISP. Z,IN ROT. X,RAD ROT. Y,RAD ROT. Z,RAD
-1.2028E-06 0.7481 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 -2.4055E-03

FOR. X,LBS FOR. Y,LBS FOR. Z,LBS MOM X,LBS-IN MOM Y,LBS-IN MOM Z,LBS-IN
-1.2975 2.0000E+04 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 9.0111E+05

STR,LBS/IN**2
3.0134E+04

THE PILE COORDINATE SYSTEM (LOCAL AXES)

---------------------------------------

DISP. x,IN DISP. y,IN DISP. z,IN ROT. x,RAD ROT. y,RAD ROT. z,RAD
-1.2028E-06 0.7481 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 -2.4055E-03

AXIAL,LBS LAT. y,LBS LAT. z,LBS MOM x,LBS-IN MOM y,LBS-IN MOM z,LBS-IN
-1.2975 2.0000E+04 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 9.0111E+05

STR,LBS/IN**2
3.0134E+04

* EFFECTS FOR LATERALLY LOADED PILE *

x DISPL. DISPL. MOMENT MOMENT SHEAR SOIL REACT TOTAL

y-DIR z-DIR z-DIR y-DIR y-z-DIR y-z-DIR STRESS
FT IN IN LBS-IN LBS-IN LBS LBS/IN LBS/IN**2
********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
0.0000 0.7481 0.0000 -9.0111E+05 0.0000 2.0000E+04 0.0000 3.0134E+04
1.5200 0.6731 0.0000 -5.3631E+05 0.0000 1.8607E+04 152.82 1.7935E+04
3.0400 0.5611 0.0000 -2.2235E+05 0.0000 1.5558E+04 181.41 7435.6
4.5600 0.4338 0.0000 3.1262E+04 0.0000 1.2063E+04 201.84 1045.5
6.0800 0.3087 0.0000 2.1772E+05 0.0000 8284.4 212.50 7280.9
7.6000 0.1985 0.0000 3.3348E+05 0.0000 4413.0 211.99 1.1152E+04
9.1200 0.1114 0.0000 3.7870E+05 0.0000 664.91 198.98 1.2664E+04
10.640 5.0422E-02 0.0000 3.5773E+05 0.0000 2604.4 159.50 1.1963E+04
12.160 1.4113E-02 0.0000 2.8369E+05 0.0000 5026.2 106.05 9487.2
13.680 -2.6216E-03 0.0000 1.7437E+05 0.0000 5446.2 60.003 5831.4
15.200 -7.3252E-03 0.0000 8.5016E+04 0.0000 4107.8 86.751 2843.2
16.720 -6.1628E-03 0.0000 2.4520E+04 0.0000 2559.2 83.053 820.10
18.240 -3.3087E-03 0.0000 -8344.2 0.0000 1178.2 68.376 279.15
19.760 -1.0302E-03 0.0000 -1.8460E+04 0.0000 126.55 46.937 617.44
21.280 -2.5500E-05 0.0000 -1.2961E+04 0.0000 434.19 14.547 433.52
22.800 8.4993E-05 0.0000 -2621.0 0.0000 377.40 20.774 87.759

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-135

24.320 1.4643E-05 0.0000 806.89 0.0000 77.692 12.088 27.092

25.840 -3.3217E-08 0.0000 213.18 0.0000 22.131 1.1424 7.2378
27.360 -1.1295E-09 0.0000 -0.4487 0.0000 5.8441 0.6434 0.1240
28.880 1.1551E-15 0.0000 -1.6370E-02 0.0000 1.2300E-02 1.2502E-03 0.1095
30.400 4.4932E-17 0.0000 1.5439E-08 0.0000 4.4875E-04 4.9205E-05 0.1089
31.920 -3.8355E-23 0.0000 6.5122E-10 0.0000 4.2323E-10 4.2492E-11 0.1089
33.440 -1.7467E-24 0.0000 -5.0525E-16 0.0000 1.7851E-11 1.9574E-12 0.1089
34.960 1.2057E-30 0.0000 -2.5315E-17 0.0000 1.3850E-17 1.3665E-18 0.1089
36.480 6.6388E-32 0.0000 1.5550E-23 0.0000 6.9395E-19 7.6091E-20 0.1089
38.000 -3.5338E-38 0.0000 9.6219E-25 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.1089
39.520 -2.4683E-39 0.0000 -4.4061E-31 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.1089
41.040 9.3656E-46 0.0000 -3.5774E-32 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.1089
42.560 8.9814E-47 0.0000 1.0971E-38 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.1089
44.080 0.0000 0.0000 1.3017E-39 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.1089
45.600 0.0000 0.0000 -2.0849E-46 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.1089
47.120 0.0000 0.0000 -4.6376E-47 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.1089
48.640 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.1089
50.160 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.1089
51.680 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.1089
53.200 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.1089
54.720 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.1089
56.240 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.1089
57.760 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.1089
59.280 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.1089
60.800 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.1089
62.320 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.1089
63.840 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.1089
65.360 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.1089
66.880 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.1089
68.400 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.1089
69.920 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.1089
71.440 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.1089
72.960 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.1089
74.480 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.1089
76.000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.1089

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-136

2.6.6 Summary Results File

=========================================================================

GROUP for Windows, Version 2016.10.8

Serial Number : 136089307

Analysis of A Group of Piles

Subjected to Axial and Lateral Loading

(c) Copyright ENSOFT, Inc., 1987-2015

All Rights Reserved

=========================================================================

-------------------------------------------------------------------------
Time and Date of Analysis
-------------------------------------------------------------------------

Date: May 09, 2016 Time: 18:14:31

***** COMPUTATION RESULTS *****

EXAMPLE PROBLEM 5 - 3D, Pile group arranged in a diamond shape

***** LOAD CASES RESULTS *****

LOAD CASE : 1
CASE NAME : Load Case 1
LOAD TYPE : Special, Sp

* TABLE L * COMPUTATION ON PILE CAP

* EQUIVALENT CONCENTRATED LOAD AT ORIGIN *

VERT. LOAD, LBS HOR. LOAD Y, LBS HOR. LOAD Z, LBS

0.00000 1.00000E+05 0.00000

MOMENT X ,LBS-IN MOMENT Y,LBS-IN MOMENT Z,LBS-IN

0.00000 0.00000 0.00000

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-137

* DISPLACEMENT OF GROUPED PILE FOUNDATION AT ORIGIN *

VERTICAL ,IN HORIZONTAL Y,IN HORIZONTAL Z,IN

-1.20284E-06 0.74806 0.00000

ANGLE ROT. X,RAD ANGLE ROT. Y,RAD ANGLE ROT. Z,RAD

0.00000 0.00000 -2.40553E-03

* TABLE M * COMPUTATION ON INDIVIDUAL PILE

THE GLOBAL STRUCTURAL COORDINATE SYSTEM

---------------------------------------

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS *

PILE GROUP DISP. X,IN DISP. Y,IN DISP. Z,IN ROT. X,RAD ROT. Y,RAD ROT. Z,RAD
********** *********** *********** *********** *********** *********** ***********
1 -0.072167 0.7481 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 -2.4055E-03
2 -1.2028E-06 0.7481 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 -2.4055E-03
3 0.072165 0.7481 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 -2.4055E-03
4 -1.2028E-06 0.7481 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 -2.4055E-03
5 -1.2028E-06 0.7481 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 -2.4055E-03

MINIMUM -0.072167 0.7481 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 -2.4055E-03

Pile N. 1 1 1 1 1 1
MAXIMUM 0.072165 0.7481 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 -2.4055E-03
Pile N. 3 1 1 1 1 1

* PILE TOP REACTIONS *

PILE GROUP FOR. X,LBS FOR. Y,LBS FOR. Z,LBS MOM X,LBS-IN MOM Y,LBS-IN MOM Z,LBS-IN
********** *********** *********** *********** *********** *********** ***********
1 -7.5093E+04 2.0370E+04 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 8.9784E+05
2 -1.2975 2.0000E+04 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 9.0111E+05
3 7.5097E+04 1.9630E+04 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 9.0453E+05
4 -1.2975 2.0000E+04 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 9.0111E+05
5 -1.2975 2.0000E+04 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 9.0111E+05

MINIMUM -7.5093E+04 1.9630E+04 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 8.9784E+05

Pile N. 1 3 1 1 1 1
MAXIMUM 7.5097E+04 2.0370E+04 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 9.0453E+05
Pile N. 3 1 1 1 1 3

THE PILE COORDINATE SYSTEM (LOCAL AXES)

---------------------------------------

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS *

PILE GROUP DISP. x,IN DISP. y,IN DISP. z,IN ROT. x,RAD ROT. y,RAD ROT. z,RAD
********** *********** *********** *********** *********** *********** ***********
1 -0.072167 0.7481 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 -2.4055E-03
2 -1.2028E-06 0.7481 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 -2.4055E-03
3 0.072165 0.7481 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 -2.4055E-03
4 -1.2028E-06 0.7481 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 -2.4055E-03
5 -1.2028E-06 0.7481 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 -2.4055E-03

MINIMUM -0.072167 0.7481 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 -2.4055E-03

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-138

Pile N. 1 1 1 1 1 1
MAXIMUM 0.072165 0.7481 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 -2.4055E-03
Pile N. 3 1 1 1 1 1

* PILE TOP REACTIONS *

PILE GROUP AXIAL,LBS LAT. y,LBS LAT. z,LBS MOM x,LBS-IN MOM y,LBS-IN MOM z,LBS-IN
********** *********** *********** *********** *********** *********** ***********
1 -7.5093E+04 2.0370E+04 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 8.9784E+05
2 -1.2975 2.0000E+04 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 9.0111E+05
3 7.5097E+04 1.9630E+04 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 9.0453E+05
4 -1.2975 2.0000E+04 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 9.0111E+05
5 -1.2975 2.0000E+04 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 9.0111E+05

MINIMUM -7.5093E+04 1.9630E+04 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 8.9784E+05

Pile N. 1 3 1 1 1 1
MAXIMUM 7.5097E+04 2.0370E+04 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 9.0453E+05
Pile N. 3 1 1 1 1 3

PILE GROUP STRESS,LBS/IN**2

********** ****************
1 3.6330E+04
2 3.0134E+04
3 3.6554E+04
4 3.0134E+04
5 3.0134E+04

MINIMUM 3.0134E+04
Pile N. 2
MAXIMUM 3.6554E+04
Pile N. 3

* EFFECTS FOR LATERALLY LOADED PILE *

* MINIMUM VALUES AND LOCATIONS *

PILE DISPL. DISPL. MOMENT MOMENT SHEAR SOIL REACT TOTAL

y-DIR z-DIR z-DIR y-DIR y-z-DIR y-z-DIR STRESS
IN IN LBS-IN LBS-IN LBS LBS/IN LBS/IN**2
****** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
1 -6.7413E-03 0.0000 -8.9784E+05 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 6305.1
x(FT) 15.200 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 38.000 0.0000 33.440
2 -7.3252E-03 0.0000 -9.0111E+05 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.1090
x(FT) 15.200 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 38.000 0.0000 34.960
3 -8.0046E-03 0.0000 -9.0453E+05 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 6305.4
x(FT) 15.200 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 38.000 0.0000 33.440
4 -7.3252E-03 0.0000 -9.0111E+05 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.1090
x(FT) 15.200 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 38.000 0.0000 34.960
5 -7.3252E-03 0.0000 -9.0111E+05 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.1090
x(FT) 15.200 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 38.000 0.0000 34.960

Min. -8.0046E-03 0.0000 -9.0453E+05 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.1090

Pile N. 3 1 3 1 1 1 2

* MAXIMUM VALUES AND LOCATIONS *

PILE DISPL. DISPL. MOMENT MOMENT SHEAR SOIL REACT TOTAL

y-DIR z-DIR z-DIR y-DIR y-z-DIR y-z-DIR STRESS
IN IN LBS-IN LBS-IN LBS LBS/IN LBS/IN**2
****** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
1 0.7481 0.0000 3.7398E+05 0.0000 2.0242E+04 212.90 3.6330E+04
x(FT) 0.0000 0.0000 9.1200 0.0000 0.0000 6.0800 0.0000
2 0.7481 0.0000 3.7870E+05 0.0000 2.0000E+04 212.50 3.0134E+04
x(FT) 0.0000 0.0000 9.1200 0.0000 0.0000 6.0800 0.0000
3 0.7481 0.0000 3.8353E+05 0.0000 1.9758E+04 212.09 3.6554E+04
x(FT) 0.0000 0.0000 9.1200 0.0000 0.0000 6.0800 0.0000
4 0.7481 0.0000 3.7870E+05 0.0000 2.0000E+04 212.50 3.0134E+04
x(FT) 0.0000 0.0000 9.1200 0.0000 0.0000 6.0800 0.0000

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-139

5 0.7481 0.0000 3.7870E+05 0.0000 2.0000E+04 212.50 3.0134E+04

x(FT) 0.0000 0.0000 9.1200 0.0000 0.0000 6.0800 0.0000

Max. 0.7481 0.0000 3.8353E+05 0.0000 2.0242E+04 212.90 3.6554E+04

Pile N. 1 1 3 1 1 1 3

***** SUMMARY FOR LOAD CASES AND COMBINATIONS *****

***** LOAD CASES RESULTS *****

LOAD CASE : 1

* TABLE L * COMPUTATION ON PILE CAP

* EQUIVALENT CONCENTRATED LOAD AT ORIGIN *

LOAD X,LBS LOAD Y,LBS LOAD Z,LBS MOM X,LBS-IN MOM Y,LBS-IN MOM Z,LBS-IN
0.00000 1.00000E+05 0.00000 0.00000 0.00000 0.00000

* DISPLACEMENT OF GROUPED PILE FOUNDATION AT ORIGIN *

DISP X,IN DISP Y,IN DISP Z,IN ROT X,RAD ROT Y,RAD ROT Z,RAD
-1.20284E-06 0.74806 0.00000 0.00000 0.00000 -2.40553E-03

* TABLE M * COMPUTATION ON INDIVIDUAL PILE

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS, GLOBAL *

DISP. X,IN DISP. Y,IN DISP. Z,IN ROT. X,RAD ROT. Y,RAD ROT. Z,RAD
*********** *********** *********** *********** *********** ***********
MINIMUM -0.072167 0.7481 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 -2.4055E-03
Pile N. 1 1 1 1 1 1
MAXIMUM 0.072165 0.7481 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 -2.4055E-03
Pile N. 3 1 1 1 1 1

* PILE TOP REACTIONS, GLOBAL *

FOR. X,LBS FOR. Y,LBS FOR. Z,LBS MOM X,LBS-IN MOM Y,LBS-IN MOM Z,LBS-IN
*********** *********** *********** *********** *********** ***********
MINIMUM -7.5093E+04 1.9630E+04 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 8.9784E+05
Pile N. 1 3 1 1 1 1
MAXIMUM 7.5097E+04 2.0370E+04 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 9.0453E+05
Pile N. 3 1 1 1 1 3

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS, LOCAL *

DISP. x,IN DISP. y,IN DISP. z,IN ROT. x,RAD ROT. y,RAD ROT. z,RAD
*********** *********** *********** *********** *********** ***********
MINIMUM -0.072167 0.7481 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 -2.4055E-03
Pile N. 1 1 1 1 1 1
MAXIMUM 0.072165 0.7481 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 -2.4055E-03
Pile N. 3 1 1 1 1 1

* PILE TOP REACTIONS, LOCAL *

AXIAL,LBS LAT. y,LBS LAT. z,LBS MOM x,LBS-IN MOM y,LBS-IN MOM z,LBS-IN
*********** *********** *********** *********** *********** ***********
MINIMUM -7.5093E+04 1.9630E+04 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 8.9784E+05
Pile N. 1 3 1 1 1 1
MAXIMUM 7.5097E+04 2.0370E+04 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 9.0453E+05
Pile N. 3 1 1 1 1 3

* EFFECTS FOR LATERALLY LOADED PILE *

PILE DISPL. DISPL. MOMENT MOMENT SHEAR SOIL REACT TOTAL

y-DIR z-DIR z-DIR y-DIR y-z-DIR y-z-DIR STRESS
IN IN LBS-IN LBS-IN LBS LBS/IN LBS/IN**2

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-140

****** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********

Min. -8.0046E-03 0.0000 -9.0453E+05 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.1090
Pile N. 3 1 3 1 1 1 2
Max. 0.7481 0.0000 3.8353E+05 0.0000 2.0242E+04 212.90 3.6554E+04
Pile N. 1 1 3 1 1 1 3

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-141

2.6.7 Graphs

Figure 2.16 Curves Resultant Deflection vs. Distance for Example Problem 5 - 3D.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-142

Figure 2.17 Internally Generated curves of Axial Load vs Displacement for Example Problem 5 - 3D.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-143

2.7 Example Problem 6 - 3D

2.7.1 Model Description

This example is included to show the use of 3-dimensional analysis for a pile group distributed in
a circular configuration (Figure 2.18). The same problem was also presented in Chapter 5 based on 2
dimensional analysis.

Circular pile groups are, in general, used for offshore structures. There are 8 piles in each leg
that are employed for three-dimensional analysis. The pile dimensions and geometry of each pile are
given in Figure 2.18. Each steel pile is 150 meters in length, and a total of 140 meters penetrates the
seabed. The soil at the site is medium dense sand with an internal friction angle of 38 to 40 degrees.
The submerged soil density is approximately 9.5 kN/m3.

The input and output files for the example problem are shown in the following pages.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-144

Figure 2.18 General Description of Example Problem 6 - 3D.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-145

2.7.2 Input Data

EXAMPLE PROBLEM 6 - 3D, PILE GROUP IN A CIRCULAR CONFIGURATION

GROUP2016.10.8
* Analysis Parameters
2 3 0 0 0 1 0 1 1 0 0 0 0 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 1
* Pile Cap Dimensions
0 0 0 0 0 0
* Load Cases
1 0 0 1 0
0 1 1 0 100 100 100
1E-7 1E-7 1 1
Load Case 1
12 0 0 0 1 0 0 0
2 1 1 0 0.0001 1E-6 0 0 0
1
0 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 0 0 0 1 0 0 1 0 1 0 0 0 0 1 1
1
40000 1400 -150000 0 0 0 0 0 0
0
0
* Load Combinations
0 0 0 0 0
* Distributed Load Sets
0
* Pile Group Configuration
8
3 3 1 0 1 0 0 0 0 1
400000 0 0 0 0 0 1
0 4.7 2 0 90 0 10
3 3 1 0 1 0 0 0 0 1
400000 0 0 0 0 0 1
0 2 4.7 0 90 0 10
3 3 1 0 1 0 0 0 0 1
400000 0 0 0 0 0 1
0 -2 4.7 0 90 0 10
3 3 1 0 1 0 0 0 0 1
400000 0 0 0 0 0 1
0 -4.7 2 0 90 0 10
3 3 1 0 1 0 0 0 0 1
400000 0 0 0 0 0 1
0 -4.7 -2 0 90 0 10
3 3 1 0 1 0 0 0 0 1
400000 0 0 0 0 0 1
0 -2 -4.7 0 90 0 10
3 3 1 0 1 0 0 0 0 1
400000 0 0 0 0 0 1
0 2 -4.7 0 90 0 10
3 3 1 0 1 0 0 0 0 1
400000 0 0 0 0 0 1
0 4.7 -2 0 90 0 10
* Pile Properties
1
0 1
50 150 1
0 150 1
* Pile Cross Sections
1
0 0 0 0
Section 1
1500 0 1000 1000 0 0 100 100
1 820000 1.7E11 1.7E11 0 17000000 0 0 2E8 0 0
0 0 0 0 1
None
* Soil Layers
1
0 4

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-146

10 200
2 10
9.5 0 38 120 0 0 0 0 0 0
9.5 0 40 120 0 0 0 0 0 0
* Generated LD curves
0
* Generated TR curves
1
1
* User defined LD curves
1
0 7
-100000 -0.402
-250000 -0.086
-10000 -0.032
0 0
10000 0.032
25000 0.086
100000 0.402
* User defined MC curves
1
1 1
0
1 1
0 0
* Internally Generated MC curves
1
1 1
0
0
1 1
0 0
1 1
0
0
1 1
0 0
* End of file

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-147

2.7.3 Echo Print File

=========================================================================

GROUP for Windows, Version 2016.10.8

Serial Number : 136089307

Analysis of A Group of Piles

Subjected to Axial and Lateral Loading

(c) Copyright ENSOFT, Inc., 1987-2015

All Rights Reserved

=========================================================================

This program is licensed to :

ENSOFT, INC
AUSTIN, TX

Path to file locations : C:\projects\GROUP2016\Group2016_1008\DXE\Examples_2016\

Name of input data file : 3Dexample6.gp10r
Name of output echo file : 3Dexample6.gp10e
Name of output results file : 3Dexample6.gp10o
Name of output summary file : 3Dexample6.gp10t
Name of plot output file : 3Dexample6.gp10p
Name of runtime file : 3Dexample6.gp10r

-------------------------------------------------------------------------
Time and Date of Analysis
-------------------------------------------------------------------------

Date: May 09, 2016 Time: 18:14:31

***** INPUT INFORMATION *****

EXAMPLE PROBLEM 6 - 3D, PILE GROUP IN A CIRCULAR CONFIGURATION

ANALYSIS TYPE = 3D ANALYSIS

ADJUST DEPTH FOR BATTER PILES

GENERATE LOAD-DISP (AND T-R) CURVES BASED ON SOIL PROFILE

EXTEND INTERPOLATION FOR L-DP (AND T-R) CURVES

UNITS SYSTEM = METR

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-148

* TABLE C * LOAD AND CONTROL PARAMETERS

** LOAD CASES **

NUMBER OF LOAD CASES : 1

LOAD CASE : 1
CASE NAME : Load Case 1
LOAD TYPE : Special, Sp
SCALE FACTOR : 1.0000

* CONCENTRATED LOADS *

NL VERT.LOAD HR.LOAD Y HR.LOAD Z MOMENT X MOMENT Y MOMENT Z COORD X COORD Y COORD Z

KN KN KN KN- M KN- M KN- M M M M
1 4.00E+04 1.40E+03 0.00 0.00 0.00 -1.50E+05 0.00 0.00 0.00

* EQUIVALENT CONCENTRATED LOAD AT ORIGIN *

VER.LOAD X, KN HOR.LOAD Y, KN HOR.LOAD Z, KN

40000.0 1400.00 0.00000

MOMENT X, KN- M MOMENT Y, KN- M MOMENT Z, KN- M

0.00000 0.00000 -1.50000E+05

* THE LOADING IS CYCLIC *

NO. OF CYCLES = 100.

* CONTROL PARAMETERS *
TOLERANCE ON CONVERGENCE OF PILE CAP MOVEMENT = 1.00000E-07
TOLERANCE ON DETERMINATION OF PILE DEFLECTIONS = 1.00000E-07 M
MAX NO OF ITERATIONS ALLOWED FOR FOUNDATION ANALYSIS = 100
MAXIMUM NO OF ITERATIONS ALLOWED FOR PILE ANALYSIS = 100
FACTOR TO APPLY THE LOAD IN INCREMENTS = 1.0000
MINIMUM FACTOR FOR LOAD INCREMENTS = 1.0000
PRINT RESULTS AT PILE CAP, PILE HEADS AND ALONG PILES
PRINT RESULTS EVERY 1 NODE(S)

* TABLE D * ARRANGEMENT OF PILE GROUPS

GROUP CONN.Z-Z CONN.Y-Y PILE PROP P-Y CURVE L-S CURVE T-R CURVE R-F-L SET
1 RES RES 1 0 1 U 1 G 0
2 RES RES 1 0 1 U 1 G 0
3 RES RES 1 0 1 U 1 G 0
4 RES RES 1 0 1 U 1 G 0
5 RES RES 1 0 1 U 1 G 0
6 RES RES 1 0 1 U 1 G 0
7 RES RES 1 0 1 U 1 G 0
8 RES RES 1 0 1 U 1 G 0

GROUP CorX, M CorY, M CorZ, M ALPHA,DEG BETA,DEG THETA,DEG GROUND, M SPz, KN- M
SPy, KN- M
1 0.000 4.700 2.000 0.000 90.00 0.000 10.00 4.000E+05
0.000

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-149

2 0.000 2.000 4.700 0.000 90.00 0.000 10.00 4.000E+05

0.000
3 0.000 -2.000 4.700 0.000 90.00 0.000 10.00 4.000E+05
0.000
4 0.000 -4.700 2.000 0.000 90.00 0.000 10.00 4.000E+05
0.000
5 0.000 -4.700 -2.000 0.000 90.00 0.000 10.00 4.000E+05
0.000
6 0.000 -2.000 -4.700 0.000 90.00 0.000 10.00 4.000E+05
0.000
7 0.000 2.000 -4.700 0.000 90.00 0.000 10.00 4.000E+05
0.000
8 0.000 4.700 -2.000 0.000 90.00 0.000 10.00 4.000E+05
0.000

* TABLE E * PILE GEOMETRY AND PROPERTIES

PILE TYPE = 1 - DRIVEN PILE
= 2 - DRILLED SHAFT

PROP SECTS INC PILE TYPE LENGTH, M

1 1 50 1 150.00

* PILE SECTIONS *

PROP SECT FROM, M TO, M CROSS SECT

1 1 0.00000 150.000 1

* PILE CROSS SECTIONS *

CROSS SECTION : 1
SECTION NAME : Section

TYPE : ELASTIC
CROSS SECTION TYPE : GENERAL SECTION
EQUIVALENT DIAMETER : 1500.00 MM
YOUNG MODULUS : 2.00000E+08 KN/ M**2

* PILE CROSS SECTIONS PROPERTIES *

ELASTIC SECTIONS

SECT DIAM,MM AREA,MM**2 Iz,MM**4 Iy,MM**4 GJ, KN- M**2 Mn, KN- M Vn, KN
1 1500.0 8.2000E+05 1.7000E+11 1.7000E+11 1.7000E+07 0.0000 0.0000

* TABLE F * SOIL DATA

SOILS INFORMATION

GROUND SURFACE = 10.0000 M

1 LAYER(S) OF SOIL

LAYER 1
THE SOIL IS A SAND
TOP OF LAYER BOTTOM OF LAYER
X COORDINATE ( M) 10.0000 200.000
EFFECTIVE UNIT WEIGHT ( KN/ M**3) 9.50000 9.50000
FRICTION ANGLE (DEGREES) 38.0000 40.0000
P-Y SUBGRADE MODULUS ( KN/ M**3) 120.000 120.000
ULTIMATE UNIT SIDE FRICTION ( KN/ M**2) 0.00000 0.00000

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-150

ULTIMATE UNIT TIP RESISTANCE ( KN/ M**2) 0.00000 0.00000

* TABLE H * AXIAL LOAD VS DISPLACEMENT

USER DEFINED AXIAL LOAD-DISPLACEMENT CURVES

NUM OF CURVES 1

CURVE 1 NUM OF POINTS 7

DISPLACEMENT, M AXIAL LOAD, KN

-0.40200 -1.00000E+05
-0.0860000 -2.50000E+05
-0.0320000 -10000.0
0.00000 0.00000
0.0320000 10000.0
0.0860000 25000.0
0.40200 1.00000E+05

* TABLE I * TORS. MOM. VS ANGLE ROT.

TORQUE-ROTATION CURVES GENERATED INTERNALLY

NUM OF CURVES 1

CURVE 1 NUM OF POINTS 19

ROT. ANGLE,Rad. TORS.MOMEN, KN- M

-0.89275 -1.38051E+05
-0.75323 -1.24761E+05
-0.65883 -1.14467E+05
-0.43135 -84831.8
-0.34523 -72024.5
-0.18050 -43831.4
-0.12769 -33143.3
-0.0473367 -14450.0
-6.56958E-03 -2342.29
0.00000 0.00000
6.56958E-03 2342.29
0.0473367 14450.0
0.12769 33143.3
0.18050 43831.4
0.34523 72024.5
0.43135 84831.8
0.65883 1.14467E+05
0.75323 1.24761E+05
0.89275 1.38051E+05

* TABLE J * MOMENT CURVATURE SETS

USER DEFINED MOMENT CURVATURE

NUM OF SETS : 1

CURVE SET 1 NUM OF CURVES 1

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-151

CURVE 1 AXIAL LOAD 0.000E+00 KN

POINT MOMENT CURVATURE

KN- M RADIAN/ M
1 0.00000 0.00000

* TABLE K * REDUCTION FACTORS

PILE DIAMETER = 1500.000 MM

REDUCTION FACTORS FOR CLOSELY-SPACED PILE GROUPS ALONG Y-DIRECTION

ESTIMATED ASSUMING MOVEMENT IN THE DIRECTION OF Y-FORCE (+)

GROUP NO P-FACTOR Y-FACTOR

1 0.7914 1.0000
2 0.6998 1.0000
3 0.5408 1.0000
4 0.5825 1.0000
5 0.5825 1.0000
6 0.5408 1.0000
7 0.6998 1.0000
8 0.7914 1.0000

REDUCTION FACTORS FOR CLOSELY-SPACED PILE GROUPS ALONG Z-DIRECTION

ESTIMATED ASSUMING MOVEMENT IN THE DIRECTION OF Z-FORCE (+)

GROUP NO P-FACTOR Y-FACTOR

1 0.6998 1.0000
2 0.7914 1.0000
3 0.7914 1.0000
4 0.6998 1.0000
5 0.5408 1.0000
6 0.5825 1.0000
7 0.5825 1.0000
8 0.5408 1.0000

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-152

2.7.4 Processor Run Notes

GROUP for Windows, Version 2016.10.8

-------------------------------------------------------------------------
Time and Date of Analysis
-------------------------------------------------------------------------

Date: May 09, 2016 Time: 18:14:31

EXAMPLE PROBLEM 6 - 3D, PILE GROUP IN A CIRCULAR CONFIGURATION

READING * TITLE AND VERSION

READING * Analysis Parameters
READING * Pile Cap Dimensions
READING * Load Cases
READING * Load Combinations
READING * Distributed Load Sets
READING * Pile Group Configuration
READING * Pile Properties
READING * Pile Cross Sections
READING * Soil Layers
READING * Generated LD curves
READING * Generated TR curves
READING * User defined LD curves
READING * User defined MC curves
READING * Internally Generated MC curves

COMPUTATION IS PROCEEDING......

LOAD CASE : 1
CASE NAME : Load Case 1

GLOBAL ITERATIONS
STEP 1, TCUR 1.0000, DTCUR 1.0000
ITERATION 1
- ErrDsp 0.10000E+01, IncDsp 0.82417E-01, TotDsp 0.82417E-01
- ErrRot 0.10000E+01, IncRot 0.44903E-02, TotRot 0.44903E-02
ITERATION 2
- ErrDsp 0.64126E-01, IncDsp 0.56421E-02, TotDsp 0.87985E-01
- ErrRot 0.15508E-01, IncRot 0.70731E-04, TotRot 0.45610E-02
ITERATION 3
- ErrDsp 0.15394E-03, IncDsp 0.13542E-04, TotDsp 0.87972E-01
- ErrRot 0.27031E-04, IncRot 0.12328E-06, TotRot 0.45609E-02
ITERATION 4
- ErrDsp 0.94545E-10, IncDsp 0.83173E-11, TotDsp 0.87972E-01
- ErrRot 0.24892E-10, IncRot 0.11353E-12, TotRot 0.45609E-02

NUMBER OF GLOBAL ITERATIONS = 4

ANALYSIS FOR LOAD CASE 1/ 1 FINISHED

Execution Time : 140 ms

Number Processors : 1/ 1
Serial processing : 0.062 sec
Paral. processing : 0.028 sec
Print. processing : 0.050 sec

ANALYSIS COMPLETED

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-153

Execution Time : 140 ms

Number Processors : 1/ 1

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-154

2.7.5 Output Results File

=========================================================================

GROUP for Windows, Version 2016.10.8

Serial Number : 136089307

Analysis of A Group of Piles

Subjected to Axial and Lateral Loading

(c) Copyright ENSOFT, Inc., 1987-2015

All Rights Reserved

=========================================================================

This program is licensed to :

ENSOFT, INC
AUSTIN, TX

Path to file locations : C:\projects\GROUP2016\Group2016_1008\DXE\Examples_2016\

Name of input data file : 3Dexample6.gp10d
Name of output echo file : 3Dexample6.gp10e
Name of output results file : 3Dexample6.gp10o
Name of output summary file : 3Dexample6.gp10t
Name of plot output file : 3Dexample6.gp10p
Name of runtime file : 3Dexample6.gp10r

-------------------------------------------------------------------------
Time and Date of Analysis
-------------------------------------------------------------------------

Date: May 09, 2016 Time: 18:14:31

***** COMPUTATION RESULTS *****

EXAMPLE PROBLEM 6 - 3D, PILE GROUP IN A CIRCULAR CONFIGURATION

***** LOAD CASES RESULTS *****

LOAD CASE : 1
CASE NAME : Load Case 1
LOAD TYPE : Special, Sp

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-155

REDUCTION FACTORS FOR CLOSELY-SPACED PILE GROUPS, COMBINED Y AND Z DIRECTIONS

ESTIMATED USING MOVEMENT IN THE DIRECTION OF PILE CAP DISPLACEMENTS

GROUP NO P-FACTOR Y-FACTOR

1 0.7914 1.0000
2 0.6998 1.0000
3 0.5408 1.0000
4 0.5825 1.0000
5 0.5825 1.0000
6 0.5408 1.0000
7 0.6998 1.0000
8 0.7914 1.0000

* TABLE L * COMPUTATION ON PILE CAP

* EQUIVALENT CONCENTRATED LOAD AT ORIGIN *

VERT. LOAD, KN HOR. LOAD Y, KN HOR. LOAD Z, KN

40000.0 1400.00 0.00000

MOMENT X , KN- M MOMENT Y, KN- M MOMENT Z, KN- M

0.00000 0.00000 -1.50000E+05

* DISPLACEMENT OF GROUPED PILE FOUNDATION AT ORIGIN *

VERTICAL , M HORIZONTAL Y, M HORIZONTAL Z, M

0.0161553 0.0864756 -1.43584E-18

ANGLE ROT. X,RAD ANGLE ROT. Y,RAD ANGLE ROT. Z,RAD

-4.39844E-17 1.12409E-19 -4.56089E-03

NUMBER OF GLOBAL ITERATIONS = 4

* TABLE M * COMPUTATION ON INDIVIDUAL PILE

* PILE GROUP * 1

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS AND REACTIONS *

THE GLOBAL STRUCTURAL COORDINATE SYSTEM

---------------------------------------

DISP. X, M DISP. Y, M DISP. Z, M ROT. X,RAD ROT. Y,RAD ROT. Z,RAD

0.037592 0.086476 -2.0816E-16 -4.3984E-17 1.1241E-19 -4.5609E-03

FOR. X, KN FOR. Y, KN FOR. Z, KN MOM X, KN- M MOM Y, KN- M MOM Z, KN- M

1.1553E+04 176.55 -4.5896E-13 -1.5916E-11 -9.4104E-26 -337.45

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-156

STR, KN/ M**2

1.5578E+04

THE PILE COORDINATE SYSTEM (LOCAL AXES)

---------------------------------------

DISP. x, M DISP. y, M DISP. z, M ROT. x,RAD ROT. y,RAD ROT. z,RAD

0.037592 0.086476 -2.0816E-16 -4.3984E-17 1.1241E-19 -4.5609E-03

AXIAL, KN LAT. y, KN LAT. z, KN MOM x, KN- M MOM y, KN- M MOM z, KN- M

1.1553E+04 176.55 -4.5896E-13 -1.5916E-11 -9.3129E-26 -337.45

STR, KN/ M**2

1.5578E+04

* EFFECTS FOR LATERALLY LOADED PILE *

x DISPL. DISPL. MOMENT MOMENT SHEAR SOIL REACT TOTAL

y-DIR z-DIR z-DIR y-DIR y-z-DIR y-z-DIR STRESS
M M M KN- M KN- M KN KN/ M KN/ M**2
********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
0.0000 8.6476E-02 -2.0816E-16 337.45 -9.3129E-26 176.38 0.0000 1.5578E+04
3.0000 7.5369E-02 -1.8205E-16 995.44 -1.6785E-12 176.55 0.0000 1.8481E+04
6.0000 6.4525E-02 -1.5639E-16 1650.4 -3.3519E-12 176.55 0.0000 2.1370E+04
9.0000 5.4118E-02 -1.3161E-16 2300.3 -5.0150E-12 176.55 0.0000 2.4238E+04
12.000 4.4320E-02 -1.0816E-16 2943.1 -6.6628E-12 163.93 8.4183 2.7074E+04
15.000 3.5301E-02 -8.6477E-17 3501.2 -8.1054E-12 126.16 16.763 2.9536E+04
18.000 2.7209E-02 -6.6936E-17 3897.7 -9.1535E-12 70.001 20.673 3.1285E+04
21.000 2.0149E-02 -4.9819E-17 4096.3 -9.7160E-12 7.4178 21.049 3.2161E+04
24.000 1.4173E-02 -3.5273E-17 4092.9 -9.7803E-12 52.423 18.845 3.2146E+04
27.000 9.2808E-03 -2.3317E-17 3907.3 -9.3927E-12 103.17 14.984 3.1327E+04
30.000 5.4226E-03 -1.3846E-17 3575.0 -8.6375E-12 141.09 10.300 2.9861E+04
33.000 2.5106E-03 -6.6625E-18 3139.0 -7.6192E-12 164.77 5.4841 2.7938E+04
36.000 4.2964E-04 -1.4954E-18 2644.0 -6.4466E-12 174.58 1.0609 2.5754E+04
39.000 -9.5147E-04 1.9652E-18 2131.5 -5.2211E-12 172.25 2.6205 2.3493E+04
42.000 -1.7684E-03 4.0438E-18 1636.0 -4.0283E-12 160.25 5.3742 2.1307E+04
45.000 -2.1522E-03 5.0561E-18 1183.8 -2.9338E-12 141.46 7.1539 1.9312E+04
48.000 -2.2227E-03 5.2918E-18 792.45 -1.9816E-12 118.70 8.0215 1.7585E+04
51.000 -2.0834E-03 5.0030E-18 470.84 -1.1952E-12 94.497 8.1124 1.6167E+04
54.000 -1.8195E-03 4.3979E-18 220.81 -5.8043E-13 70.924 7.6032 1.5063E+04
57.000 -1.4971E-03 3.6390E-18 38.526 -1.2933E-13 49.495 6.6826 1.4259E+04
60.000 -1.1646E-03 2.8460E-18 -83.730 1.7598E-13 31.176 5.5300 1.4459E+04
63.000 -8.5416E-04 2.0995E-18 -155.96 3.5912E-13 16.432 4.2994 1.4777E+04
66.000 -5.8504E-04 1.4481E-18 -189.02 4.4606E-13 5.3161 3.1115 1.4923E+04
69.000 -3.6596E-04 9.1480E-19 -193.50 4.6231E-13 2.4270 2.0506 1.4943E+04
72.000 -1.9809E-04 5.0384E-19 -178.93 4.3102E-13 7.2524 1.1664 1.4879E+04
75.000 -7.7591E-05 2.0698E-19 -153.31 3.7171E-13 9.7205 0.4790 1.4766E+04
78.000 2.3277E-06 8.5136E-21 -122.92 2.9976E-13 10.416 1.5032E-02 1.4632E+04
81.000 4.9709E-05 -1.1061E-19 -92.286 2.2640E-13 9.8911 0.3352 1.4496E+04
84.000 7.2661E-05 -1.6980E-19 -64.386 1.5906E-13 8.6223 0.5106 1.4373E+04
87.000 7.8570E-05 -1.8688E-19 -40.885 1.0197E-13 6.9945 0.5746 1.4270E+04
90.000 7.3656E-05 -1.7698E-19 -22.431 5.6875E-14 5.2933 0.5596 1.4188E+04
93.000 6.2804E-05 -1.5202E-19 -8.9437 2.3705E-14 3.7113 0.4951 1.4129E+04
96.000 4.9585E-05 -1.2078E-19 0.1151 1.2459E-15 2.3612 0.4050 1.4090E+04
99.000 3.6397E-05 -8.9213E-20 5.5286 -1.2338E-14 1.2923 0.3076 1.4114E+04
102.00 2.4672E-05 -6.0913E-20 8.1564 -1.9099E-14 0.5074 0.2156 1.4125E+04
105.00 1.5106E-05 -3.7669E-20 8.8192 -2.1010E-14 2.0354E-02 0.1363 1.4128E+04
108.00 7.8750E-06 -1.9986E-20 8.2284 -1.9799E-14 0.3347 7.3294E-02 1.4126E+04
111.00 2.8217E-06 -7.5434E-21 6.9527 -1.6853E-14 0.4853 2.7066E-02 1.4120E+04
114.00 -3.9107E-07 4.3764E-22 5.4122 -1.3204E-14 0.5201 3.8626E-03 1.4113E+04
117.00 -2.1712E-06 4.9235E-21 3.8900 -9.5542E-15 0.4812 2.2064E-02 1.4106E+04
120.00 -2.9217E-06 6.8802E-21 2.5543 -6.3251E-15 0.4023 3.0522E-02 1.4101E+04
123.00 -2.9960E-06 7.1627E-21 1.4856 -3.7236E-15 0.3083 3.2152E-02 1.4096E+04
126.00 -2.6771E-06 6.4595E-21 0.7017 -1.8025E-15 0.2158 2.9492E-02 1.4092E+04
129.00 -2.1724E-06 5.2792E-21 0.1811 -5.1631E-16 0.1348 2.4551E-02 1.4090E+04

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-157

132.00 -1.6197E-06 3.9622E-21 -0.1191 2.3446E-16 6.9789E-02 1.8767E-02 1.4090E+04

135.00 -1.0986E-06 2.7073E-21 -0.2500 5.7135E-16 2.2075E-02 1.3042E-02 1.4090E+04
138.00 -6.4370E-07 1.6036E-21 -0.2628 6.1724E-16 9.2264E-03 7.8250E-03 1.4090E+04
141.00 -2.5834E-07 6.6332E-22 -0.2044 4.8580E-16 2.5785E-02 3.2140E-03 1.4090E+04
144.00 7.2929E-08 -1.4838E-22 -0.1164 2.7860E-16 2.9214E-02 9.2810E-04 1.4090E+04
147.00 3.7339E-07 -8.8633E-22 -3.6382E-02 8.7539E-17 2.0534E-02 4.8582E-03 1.4089E+04
150.00 6.6422E-07 -1.6011E-21 7.9998E-16 0.0000 1.1883E-16 8.8315E-03 1.4089E+04

* PILE GROUP * 2

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS AND REACTIONS *

THE GLOBAL STRUCTURAL COORDINATE SYSTEM

---------------------------------------

DISP. X, M DISP. Y, M DISP. Z, M ROT. X,RAD ROT. Y,RAD ROT. Z,RAD

0.025277 0.086476 -8.9405E-17 -4.3984E-17 1.1241E-19 -4.5609E-03

FOR. X, KN FOR. Y, KN FOR. Z, KN MOM X, KN- M MOM Y, KN- M MOM Z, KN- M

7899.1 174.66 -1.9604E-13 -1.5916E-11 -9.7458E-28 -366.15

STR, KN/ M**2

1.1248E+04

THE PILE COORDINATE SYSTEM (LOCAL AXES)

---------------------------------------

DISP. x, M DISP. y, M DISP. z, M ROT. x,RAD ROT. y,RAD ROT. z,RAD

0.025277 0.086476 -8.9405E-17 -4.3984E-17 1.1241E-19 -4.5609E-03

AXIAL, KN LAT. y, KN LAT. z, KN MOM x, KN- M MOM y, KN- M MOM z, KN- M

7899.1 174.66 -1.9604E-13 -1.5916E-11 0.0000 -366.15

STR, KN/ M**2

1.1248E+04

* EFFECTS FOR LATERALLY LOADED PILE *

x DISPL. DISPL. MOMENT MOMENT SHEAR SOIL REACT TOTAL

y-DIR z-DIR z-DIR y-DIR y-z-DIR y-z-DIR STRESS
M M M KN- M KN- M KN KN/ M KN/ M**2
********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
0.0000 8.6476E-02 -8.9405E-17 366.15 0.0000 174.53 0.0000 1.1248E+04
3.0000 7.5588E-02 -7.8446E-17 976.12 -6.7468E-13 174.66 0.0000 1.3939E+04
6.0000 6.4958E-02 -6.7666E-17 1584.1 -1.3479E-12 174.66 0.0000 1.6622E+04
9.0000 5.4748E-02 -5.7242E-17 2188.7 -2.0184E-12 174.66 0.0000 1.9289E+04
12.000 4.5117E-02 -4.7353E-17 2788.7 -2.6846E-12 163.29 7.5778 2.1936E+04
15.000 3.6224E-02 -3.8174E-17 3314.7 -3.2737E-12 129.11 15.210 2.4257E+04
18.000 2.8208E-02 -2.9863E-17 3696.9 -3.7116E-12 77.863 18.952 2.5943E+04
21.000 2.1171E-02 -2.2533E-17 3900.8 -3.9612E-12 20.099 19.558 2.6842E+04
24.000 1.5167E-02 -1.6252E-17 3920.5 -4.0152E-12 35.987 17.833 2.6929E+04
27.000 1.0201E-02 -1.1034E-17 3771.5 -3.8888E-12 84.581 14.563 2.6272E+04
30.000 6.2327E-03 -6.8452E-18 3483.6 -3.6125E-12 122.13 10.468 2.5002E+04
33.000 3.1867E-03 -3.6128E-18 3094.2 -3.2251E-12 147.06 6.1553 2.3284E+04
36.000 9.5977E-04 -1.2340E-18 2642.9 -2.7683E-12 159.44 2.0957 2.1293E+04
39.000 -5.6758E-04 4.1202E-19 2167.2 -2.2813E-12 160.51 1.3823 1.9194E+04
42.000 -1.5213E-03 1.4541E-18 1699.4 -1.7987E-12 152.31 4.0882 1.7130E+04
45.000 -2.0251E-03 2.0201E-18 1264.9 -1.3474E-12 137.24 5.9525 1.5213E+04

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-158

48.000 -2.1941E-03 2.2295E-18 881.25 -9.4681E-13 117.81 7.0021 1.3521E+04

51.000 -2.1299E-03 2.1882E-18 558.82 -6.0824E-13 96.309 7.3337 1.2098E+04
54.000 -1.9177E-03 1.9859E-18 301.21 -3.3621E-13 74.679 7.0863 1.0962E+04
57.000 -1.6258E-03 1.6946E-18 106.76 -1.2951E-13 54.423 6.4173 1.0104E+04
60.000 -1.3057E-03 1.3690E-18 -30.159 1.7254E-14 36.573 5.4826 9766.1
63.000 -9.9350E-04 1.0479E-18 -117.67 1.1225E-13 21.716 4.4220 1.0152E+04
66.000 -7.1248E-04 7.5664E-19 -165.14 1.6503E-13 10.057 3.3507 1.0362E+04
69.000 -4.7516E-04 5.0902E-19 -182.11 1.8544E-13 1.4997 2.3544 1.0436E+04
72.000 -2.8606E-04 3.1049E-19 -177.51 1.8277E-13 4.2661 1.4894 1.0416E+04
75.000 -1.4394E-04 1.6034E-19 -159.13 1.6516E-13 7.6788 0.7857 1.0335E+04
78.000 -4.3943E-05 5.3908E-20 -133.35 1.3933E-13 9.2338 0.2509 1.0221E+04
81.000 2.0754E-05 -1.5644E-20 -105.03 1.1044E-13 9.4246 0.1238 1.0096E+04
84.000 5.7650E-05 -5.5962E-20 -77.604 8.2153E-14 8.7016 0.3583 9975.4
87.000 7.4003E-05 -7.4535E-20 -53.241 5.6827E-14 7.4463 0.4785 9867.9
90.000 7.6263E-05 -7.8064E-20 -33.073 3.5720E-14 5.9600 0.5124 9779.0
93.000 6.9768E-05 -7.2139E-20 -17.447 1.9259E-14 4.4620 0.4863 9710.0
96.000 5.8655E-05 -6.1115E-20 -6.1620 7.2829E-15 3.0971 0.4236 9660.2
99.000 4.5911E-05 -4.8163E-20 1.3236 -7.3577E-16 1.9469 0.3431 9638.9
102.00 3.3517E-05 -3.5407E-20 5.7180 -5.5131E-15 1.0438 0.2590 9658.3
105.00 2.2636E-05 -2.4109E-20 7.7699 -7.8168E-15 0.3844 0.1806 9667.3
108.00 1.3813E-05 -1.4881E-20 8.1802 -8.3730E-15 5.7001E-02 0.1137 9669.1
111.00 7.1548E-06 -7.8693E-21 7.5502 -7.8095E-15 0.3186 6.0687E-02 9666.4
114.00 2.4952E-06 -2.9247E-21 6.3582 -6.6290E-15 0.4423 2.1793E-02 9661.1
117.00 -4.8138E-07 2.6518E-22 4.9569 -5.2046E-15 0.4685 4.3257E-03 9654.9
120.00 -2.1458E-06 2.0774E-21 3.5840 -3.7909E-15 0.4323 1.9823E-02 9648.9
123.00 -2.8615E-06 2.8861E-21 2.3821 -2.5419E-15 0.3618 2.7155E-02 9643.6
126.00 -2.9467E-06 3.0219E-21 1.4197 -1.5341E-15 0.2780 2.8706E-02 9639.3
129.00 -2.6561E-06 2.7517E-21 0.7126 -7.8802E-16 0.1951 2.6544E-02 9636.2
132.00 -2.1768E-06 2.2729E-21 0.2429 -2.8782E-16 0.1218 2.2303E-02 9634.1
135.00 -1.6332E-06 1.7179E-21 -2.6608E-02 3.4062E-18 6.2677E-02 1.7145E-02 9633.2
138.00 -1.0967E-06 1.1638E-21 -0.1417 1.3232E-16 1.9276E-02 1.1789E-02 9633.7
141.00 -5.9774E-07 6.4473E-22 -0.1504 1.4836E-16 8.2725E-03 6.5760E-03 9633.7
144.00 -1.3857E-07 1.6493E-22 -9.9659E-02 1.0025E-16 2.0476E-02 1.5594E-03 9633.5
147.00 2.9421E-07 -2.8833E-22 -3.4633E-02 3.5236E-17 1.7737E-02 3.3850E-03 9633.2
150.00 7.1784E-07 -7.3227E-22 0.0000 7.1052E-31 5.6379E-17 8.4398E-03 9633.0

* PILE GROUP * 3

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS AND REACTIONS *

THE GLOBAL STRUCTURAL COORDINATE SYSTEM

---------------------------------------

DISP. X, M DISP. Y, M DISP. Z, M ROT. X,RAD ROT. Y,RAD ROT. Z,RAD

7.0335E-03 0.086476 8.6533E-17 -4.3984E-17 1.1241E-19 -4.5609E-03

FOR. X, KN FOR. Y, KN FOR. Z, KN MOM X, KN- M MOM Y, KN- M MOM Z, KN- M

2198.0 166.16 1.8275E-13 -1.5916E-11 -9.7458E-28 -422.41

STR, KN/ M**2

4544.0

THE PILE COORDINATE SYSTEM (LOCAL AXES)

---------------------------------------

DISP. x, M DISP. y, M DISP. z, M ROT. x,RAD ROT. y,RAD ROT. z,RAD

7.0335E-03 0.086476 8.6533E-17 -4.3984E-17 1.1241E-19 -4.5609E-03

AXIAL, KN LAT. y, KN LAT. z, KN MOM x, KN- M MOM y, KN- M MOM z, KN- M

2198.0 166.16 1.8275E-13 -1.5916E-11 0.0000 -422.41

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-159

STR, KN/ M**2

4544.0

* EFFECTS FOR LATERALLY LOADED PILE *

x DISPL. DISPL. MOMENT MOMENT SHEAR SOIL REACT TOTAL

y-DIR z-DIR z-DIR y-DIR y-z-DIR y-z-DIR STRESS
M M M KN- M KN- M KN KN/ M KN/ M**2
********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
0.0000 8.6476E-02 8.6533E-17 422.41 0.0000 166.12 0.0000 4544.0
3.0000 7.6017E-02 7.6414E-17 943.89 5.7049E-13 166.16 0.0000 6844.7
6.0000 6.5808E-02 6.6446E-17 1464.8 1.1407E-12 166.16 0.0000 9142.9
9.0000 5.5987E-02 5.6779E-17 1984.9 1.7102E-12 166.16 0.0000 1.1437E+04
12.000 4.6691E-02 4.7566E-17 2503.8 2.2787E-12 157.07 6.0597 1.3727E+04
15.000 3.8058E-02 3.8955E-17 2966.7 2.7903E-12 129.46 12.348 1.5769E+04
18.000 3.0211E-02 3.1083E-17 3316.8 3.1865E-12 87.415 15.683 1.7313E+04
21.000 2.3241E-02 2.4055E-17 3523.8 3.4357E-12 39.006 16.590 1.8227E+04
24.000 1.7204E-02 1.7936E-17 3579.4 3.5283E-12 9.3234 15.630 1.8472E+04
27.000 1.2115E-02 1.2751E-17 3492.3 3.4722E-12 52.815 13.365 1.8088E+04
30.000 7.9503E-03 8.4852E-18 3282.9 3.2876E-12 88.339 10.318 1.7164E+04
33.000 4.6544E-03 5.0896E-18 2978.7 3.0018E-12 114.24 6.9466 1.5822E+04
36.000 2.1470E-03 2.4887E-18 2610.2 2.6460E-12 130.09 3.6223 1.4196E+04
39.000 3.3050E-04 5.8810E-19 2207.7 2.2509E-12 136.46 0.6219 1.2420E+04
42.000 -9.0159E-04 -7.1664E-19 1798.2 1.8445E-12 134.58 1.8722 1.0614E+04
45.000 -1.6577E-03 -1.5331E-18 1404.5 1.4504E-12 126.12 3.7649 8877.0
48.000 -2.0420E-03 -1.9657E-18 1043.9 1.0867E-12 112.92 5.0353 7286.1
51.000 -2.1500E-03 -2.1106E-18 728.07 7.6613E-13 96.792 5.7201 5892.5
54.000 -2.0652E-03 -2.0528E-18 463.25 4.9561E-13 79.367 5.8966 4724.2
57.000 -1.8578E-03 -1.8637E-18 251.23 2.7755E-13 62.022 5.6662 3788.8
60.000 -1.5840E-03 -1.6012E-18 90.060 1.1049E-13 45.814 5.1392 3077.8
63.000 -1.2862E-03 -1.3094E-18 -24.910 -9.8869E-15 31.470 4.4237 2790.4
66.000 -9.9512E-04 -1.0202E-18 -100.05 -8.9727E-14 19.410 3.6161 3121.9
69.000 -7.3047E-04 -7.5477E-19 -142.59 -1.3615E-13 9.7910 2.7967 3309.5
72.000 -5.0358E-04 -5.2539E-19 -159.88 -1.5649E-13 2.5570 2.0260 3385.8
75.000 -3.1900E-04 -3.3743E-19 -158.84 -1.5771E-13 2.5003 1.3455 3381.2
78.000 -1.7647E-04 -1.9121E-19 -145.60 -1.4603E-13 5.6866 0.7787 3322.8
81.000 -7.2480E-05 -8.3658E-20 -125.26 -1.2667E-13 7.3555 0.3339 3233.1
84.000 -1.6481E-06 -9.6314E-21 -101.85 -1.0377E-13 7.8683 7.9143E-03 3129.8
87.000 4.2224E-05 3.6926E-20 -78.304 -8.0396E-14 7.5637 0.2110 3025.9
90.000 6.5369E-05 6.2201E-20 -56.613 -5.8633E-14 6.7382 0.3393 2930.2
93.000 7.3528E-05 7.1957E-20 -37.944 -3.9742E-14 5.6351 0.3960 2847.9
96.000 7.1643E-05 7.1192E-20 -22.816 -2.4315E-14 4.4414 0.3998 2781.1
99.000 6.3719E-05 6.3992E-20 -11.274 -1.2451E-14 3.2897 0.3680 2730.2
102.00 5.2810E-05 5.3495E-20 -3.0368 -3.9052E-15 2.2648 0.3153 2693.9
105.00 4.1097E-05 4.1965E-20 2.3645 1.7686E-15 1.4118 0.2534 2690.9
108.00 3.0011E-05 3.0902E-20 5.4843 5.1130E-15 0.7455 0.1908 2704.7
111.00 2.0376E-05 2.1194E-20 6.8834 6.6858E-15 0.2590 0.1335 2710.8
114.00 1.2563E-05 1.3255E-20 7.0765 7.0046E-15 6.8517E-02 8.4781E-02 2711.7
117.00 6.6230E-06 7.1697E-21 6.5025 6.5143E-15 0.2647 4.5985E-02 2709.2
120.00 2.4044E-06 2.8093E-21 5.5108 5.5722E-15 0.3594 1.7163E-02 2704.8
123.00 -3.5532E-07 -7.6211E-23 4.3615 4.4463E-15 0.3812 2.6055E-03 2699.7
126.00 -1.9606E-06 -1.7847E-21 3.2331 3.3229E-15 0.3552 1.4758E-02 2694.7
129.00 -2.7100E-06 -2.6137E-21 2.2356 2.3184E-15 0.3017 2.0927E-02 2690.3
132.00 -2.8677E-06 -2.8289E-21 1.4251 1.4943E-15 0.2362 2.2703E-02 2686.8
135.00 -2.6481E-06 -2.6486E-21 0.8182 8.7081E-16 0.1699 2.1480E-02 2684.1
138.00 -2.2120E-06 -2.2378E-21 0.4041 4.4019E-16 0.1102 1.8373E-02 2682.2
141.00 -1.6689E-06 -1.7105E-21 0.1551 1.7661E-16 6.1316E-02 1.4187E-02 2681.1
144.00 -1.0847E-06 -1.1364E-21 3.3709E-02 4.3781E-17 2.5888E-02 9.4321E-03 2680.6
147.00 -4.9164E-07 -5.5071E-22 -2.8148E-03 -1.4061E-19 5.1838E-03 4.3707E-03 2680.5
150.00 1.0070E-07 3.4926E-23 3.9999E-16 0.0000 2.0502E-16 9.1482E-04 2680.5

* PILE GROUP * 4

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS AND REACTIONS *

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-160

THE GLOBAL STRUCTURAL COORDINATE SYSTEM

---------------------------------------

DISP. X, M DISP. Y, M DISP. Z, M ROT. X,RAD ROT. Y,RAD ROT. Z,RAD

-5.2809E-03 0.086476 2.0529E-16 -4.3984E-17 1.1241E-19 -4.5609E-03

FOR. X, KN FOR. Y, KN FOR. Z, KN MOM X, KN- M MOM Y, KN- M MOM Z, KN- M

-1650.3 182.63 4.7225E-13 -1.5916E-11 -9.7458E-28 -415.44

STR, KN/ M**2

3845.3

THE PILE COORDINATE SYSTEM (LOCAL AXES)

---------------------------------------

DISP. x, M DISP. y, M DISP. z, M ROT. x,RAD ROT. y,RAD ROT. z,RAD

-5.2809E-03 0.086476 2.0529E-16 -4.3984E-17 1.1241E-19 -4.5609E-03

AXIAL, KN LAT. y, KN LAT. z, KN MOM x, KN- M MOM y, KN- M MOM z, KN- M

-1650.3 182.63 4.7225E-13 -1.5916E-11 0.0000 -415.44

STR, KN/ M**2

3845.3

* EFFECTS FOR LATERALLY LOADED PILE *

x DISPL. DISPL. MOMENT MOMENT SHEAR SOIL REACT TOTAL

y-DIR z-DIR z-DIR y-DIR y-z-DIR y-z-DIR STRESS
M M M KN- M KN- M KN KN/ M KN/ M**2
********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
0.0000 8.6476E-02 2.0529E-16 415.44 0.0000 182.66 0.0000 3845.3
3.0000 7.5964E-02 1.8113E-16 945.97 1.3769E-12 182.63 0.0000 6185.9
6.0000 6.5702E-02 1.5733E-16 1476.9 2.7543E-12 182.63 0.0000 8528.3
9.0000 5.5832E-02 1.3426E-16 2008.5 4.1330E-12 182.63 0.0000 1.0874E+04
12.000 4.6493E-02 1.1228E-16 2541.0 5.5135E-12 172.88 6.4993 1.3223E+04
15.000 3.7826E-02 9.1762E-17 3016.1 6.7551E-12 143.30 13.220 1.5319E+04
18.000 2.9959E-02 7.3033E-17 3373.5 7.7111E-12 98.342 16.752 1.6896E+04
21.000 2.2984E-02 5.6345E-17 3581.6 8.3028E-12 46.708 17.671 1.7814E+04
24.000 1.6957E-02 4.1855E-17 3632.3 8.5083E-12 4.6887 16.593 1.8037E+04
27.000 1.1891E-02 2.9617E-17 3535.2 8.3489E-12 50.773 14.130 1.7609E+04
30.000 7.7618E-03 1.9589E-17 3312.5 7.8765E-12 88.243 10.850 1.6626E+04
33.000 4.5090E-03 1.1646E-17 2993.5 7.1610E-12 115.39 7.2487 1.5219E+04
36.000 2.0486E-03 5.5990E-18 2610.7 6.2801E-12 131.85 3.7230 1.3530E+04
39.000 2.7935E-04 1.2139E-18 2195.5 5.3104E-12 138.28 0.5662 1.1698E+04
42.000 -9.0879E-04 -1.7654E-18 1776.1 4.3208E-12 136.08 2.0327 9848.3
45.000 -1.6268E-03 -3.6010E-18 1375.8 3.3687E-12 127.06 3.9797 8082.3
48.000 -1.9806E-03 -4.5449E-18 1012.0 2.4974E-12 113.20 5.2605 6477.0
51.000 -2.0665E-03 -4.8277E-18 695.87 1.7358E-12 96.431 5.9221 5082.5
54.000 -1.9682E-03 -4.6510E-18 433.39 1.0994E-12 78.468 6.0532 3924.5
57.000 -1.7552E-03 -4.1833E-18 225.58 5.9231E-13 60.739 5.7662 3007.7
60.000 -1.4825E-03 -3.5589E-18 69.760 2.0912E-13 44.318 5.1811 2320.3
63.000 -1.1914E-03 -2.8790E-18 -39.398 -6.2030E-14 29.926 4.4134 2186.3
66.000 -9.1061E-04 -2.2156E-18 -108.85 -2.3722E-13 17.960 3.5643 2492.8
69.000 -6.5868E-04 -1.6150E-18 -146.28 -3.3447E-13 8.5387 2.7163 2657.9
72.000 -4.4547E-04 -1.1029E-18 -159.32 -3.7192E-13 1.5685 1.9305 2715.4
75.000 -2.7443E-04 -6.8926E-19 -155.05 -3.6651E-13 3.1975 1.2468 2696.6
78.000 -1.4444E-04 -3.7264E-19 -139.64 -3.3309E-13 6.0975 0.6865 2628.6
81.000 -5.1409E-05 -1.4418E-19 -118.10 -2.8387E-13 7.5099 0.2551 2533.6
84.000 1.0359E-05 9.1261E-21 -94.321 -2.2833E-13 7.8122 5.3582E-02 2428.6
87.000 4.7161E-05 1.0200E-19 -71.065 -1.7332E-13 7.3511 0.2538 2326.0

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-161

90.000 6.5151E-05 1.4899E-19 -50.124 -1.2332E-13 6.4240 0.3643 2233.7

93.000 6.9873E-05 1.6333E-19 -32.483 -8.0881E-14 5.2695 0.4054 2155.8
96.000 6.5996E-05 1.5627E-19 -18.506 -4.7001E-14 4.0663 0.3967 2094.2
99.000 5.7221E-05 1.3676E-19 -8.1062 -2.1595E-14 2.9373 0.3560 2048.3
102.00 4.6301E-05 1.1154E-19 -0.9140 -3.8553E-15 1.9568 0.2977 2016.6
105.00 3.5138E-05 8.5298E-20 3.5981 7.4272E-15 1.1602 0.2333 2028.4
108.00 2.4927E-05 6.1022E-20 6.0120 1.3616E-14 0.5541 0.1707 2039.1
111.00 1.6309E-05 4.0349E-20 6.8918 1.6048E-14 0.1253 0.1151 2042.9
114.00 9.5140E-06 2.3925E-20 6.7384 1.5924E-14 0.1511 6.9159E-02 2042.3
117.00 4.5031E-06 1.1716E-20 5.9655 1.4241E-14 0.3054 3.3678E-02 2038.8
120.00 1.0713E-06 3.2768E-21 4.8921 1.1776E-14 0.3683 8.2365E-03 2034.1
123.00 -1.0656E-06 -2.0454E-21 3.7467 9.0894E-15 0.3680 8.4163E-03 2029.1
126.00 -2.2107E-06 -4.9616E-21 2.6787 6.5522E-15 0.3285 1.7924E-02 2024.3
129.00 -2.6467E-06 -6.1434E-21 1.7732 4.3799E-15 0.2686 2.2014E-02 2020.4
132.00 -2.6134E-06 -6.1658E-21 1.0665 2.6694E-15 0.2021 2.2285E-02 2017.2
135.00 -2.2977E-06 -5.4816E-21 0.5610 1.4332E-15 0.1386 2.0075E-02 2015.0
138.00 -1.8336E-06 -4.4181E-21 0.2363 6.2872E-16 8.3870E-02 1.6404E-02 2013.6
141.00 -1.3069E-06 -3.1881E-21 5.9369E-02 1.8026E-16 4.1314E-02 1.1966E-02 2012.8
144.00 -7.6446E-07 -1.9104E-21 -9.8292E-03 -5.3968E-18 1.2625E-02 7.1600E-03 2012.6
147.00 -2.2465E-07 -6.3415E-22 -1.4592E-02 -3.0018E-17 1.3423E-03 2.1512E-03 2012.6
150.00 3.1129E-07 6.3416E-22 3.9999E-16 0.0000 3.1182E-16 3.0461E-03 2012.5

* PILE GROUP * 5

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS AND REACTIONS *

THE GLOBAL STRUCTURAL COORDINATE SYSTEM

---------------------------------------

DISP. X, M DISP. Y, M DISP. Z, M ROT. X,RAD ROT. Y,RAD ROT. Z,RAD

-5.2809E-03 0.086476 2.0529E-16 -4.3984E-17 1.1241E-19 -4.5609E-03

FOR. X, KN FOR. Y, KN FOR. Z, KN MOM X, KN- M MOM Y, KN- M MOM Z, KN- M

-1650.3 182.63 4.7225E-13 -1.5916E-11 -9.7458E-28 -415.44

STR, KN/ M**2

3845.3

THE PILE COORDINATE SYSTEM (LOCAL AXES)

---------------------------------------

DISP. x, M DISP. y, M DISP. z, M ROT. x,RAD ROT. y,RAD ROT. z,RAD

-5.2809E-03 0.086476 2.0529E-16 -4.3984E-17 1.1241E-19 -4.5609E-03

AXIAL, KN LAT. y, KN LAT. z, KN MOM x, KN- M MOM y, KN- M MOM z, KN- M

-1650.3 182.63 4.7225E-13 -1.5916E-11 0.0000 -415.44

STR, KN/ M**2

3845.3

* EFFECTS FOR LATERALLY LOADED PILE *

x DISPL. DISPL. MOMENT MOMENT SHEAR SOIL REACT TOTAL

y-DIR z-DIR z-DIR y-DIR y-z-DIR y-z-DIR STRESS
M M M KN- M KN- M KN KN/ M KN/ M**2
********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
0.0000 8.6476E-02 2.0529E-16 415.44 0.0000 182.66 0.0000 3845.3
3.0000 7.5964E-02 1.8113E-16 945.97 1.3769E-12 182.63 0.0000 6185.9

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-162

6.0000 6.5702E-02 1.5733E-16 1476.9 2.7543E-12 182.63 0.0000 8528.3

9.0000 5.5832E-02 1.3426E-16 2008.5 4.1330E-12 182.63 0.0000 1.0874E+04
12.000 4.6493E-02 1.1228E-16 2541.0 5.5135E-12 172.88 6.4993 1.3223E+04
15.000 3.7826E-02 9.1762E-17 3016.1 6.7551E-12 143.30 13.220 1.5319E+04
18.000 2.9959E-02 7.3033E-17 3373.5 7.7111E-12 98.342 16.752 1.6896E+04
21.000 2.2984E-02 5.6345E-17 3581.6 8.3028E-12 46.708 17.671 1.7814E+04
24.000 1.6957E-02 4.1855E-17 3632.3 8.5083E-12 4.6887 16.593 1.8037E+04
27.000 1.1891E-02 2.9617E-17 3535.2 8.3489E-12 50.773 14.130 1.7609E+04
30.000 7.7618E-03 1.9589E-17 3312.5 7.8765E-12 88.243 10.850 1.6626E+04
33.000 4.5090E-03 1.1646E-17 2993.5 7.1610E-12 115.39 7.2487 1.5219E+04
36.000 2.0486E-03 5.5990E-18 2610.7 6.2801E-12 131.85 3.7230 1.3530E+04
39.000 2.7935E-04 1.2139E-18 2195.5 5.3104E-12 138.28 0.5662 1.1698E+04
42.000 -9.0879E-04 -1.7654E-18 1776.1 4.3208E-12 136.08 2.0327 9848.3
45.000 -1.6268E-03 -3.6010E-18 1375.8 3.3687E-12 127.06 3.9797 8082.3
48.000 -1.9806E-03 -4.5449E-18 1012.0 2.4974E-12 113.20 5.2605 6477.0
51.000 -2.0665E-03 -4.8277E-18 695.87 1.7358E-12 96.431 5.9221 5082.5
54.000 -1.9682E-03 -4.6510E-18 433.39 1.0994E-12 78.468 6.0532 3924.5
57.000 -1.7552E-03 -4.1833E-18 225.58 5.9231E-13 60.739 5.7662 3007.7
60.000 -1.4825E-03 -3.5589E-18 69.760 2.0912E-13 44.318 5.1811 2320.3
63.000 -1.1914E-03 -2.8790E-18 -39.398 -6.2030E-14 29.926 4.4134 2186.3
66.000 -9.1061E-04 -2.2156E-18 -108.85 -2.3722E-13 17.960 3.5643 2492.8
69.000 -6.5868E-04 -1.6150E-18 -146.28 -3.3447E-13 8.5387 2.7163 2657.9
72.000 -4.4547E-04 -1.1029E-18 -159.32 -3.7192E-13 1.5685 1.9305 2715.4
75.000 -2.7443E-04 -6.8926E-19 -155.05 -3.6651E-13 3.1975 1.2468 2696.6
78.000 -1.4444E-04 -3.7264E-19 -139.64 -3.3309E-13 6.0975 0.6865 2628.6
81.000 -5.1409E-05 -1.4418E-19 -118.10 -2.8387E-13 7.5099 0.2551 2533.6
84.000 1.0359E-05 9.1261E-21 -94.321 -2.2833E-13 7.8122 5.3582E-02 2428.6
87.000 4.7161E-05 1.0200E-19 -71.065 -1.7332E-13 7.3511 0.2538 2326.0
90.000 6.5151E-05 1.4899E-19 -50.124 -1.2332E-13 6.4240 0.3643 2233.7
93.000 6.9873E-05 1.6333E-19 -32.483 -8.0881E-14 5.2695 0.4054 2155.8
96.000 6.5996E-05 1.5627E-19 -18.506 -4.7001E-14 4.0663 0.3967 2094.2
99.000 5.7221E-05 1.3676E-19 -8.1062 -2.1595E-14 2.9373 0.3560 2048.3
102.00 4.6301E-05 1.1154E-19 -0.9140 -3.8553E-15 1.9568 0.2977 2016.6
105.00 3.5138E-05 8.5298E-20 3.5981 7.4272E-15 1.1602 0.2333 2028.4
108.00 2.4927E-05 6.1022E-20 6.0120 1.3616E-14 0.5541 0.1707 2039.1
111.00 1.6309E-05 4.0349E-20 6.8918 1.6048E-14 0.1253 0.1151 2042.9
114.00 9.5140E-06 2.3925E-20 6.7384 1.5924E-14 0.1511 6.9159E-02 2042.3
117.00 4.5031E-06 1.1716E-20 5.9655 1.4241E-14 0.3054 3.3678E-02 2038.8
120.00 1.0713E-06 3.2768E-21 4.8921 1.1776E-14 0.3683 8.2365E-03 2034.1
123.00 -1.0656E-06 -2.0454E-21 3.7467 9.0894E-15 0.3680 8.4163E-03 2029.1
126.00 -2.2107E-06 -4.9616E-21 2.6787 6.5522E-15 0.3285 1.7924E-02 2024.3
129.00 -2.6467E-06 -6.1434E-21 1.7732 4.3799E-15 0.2686 2.2014E-02 2020.4
132.00 -2.6134E-06 -6.1658E-21 1.0665 2.6694E-15 0.2021 2.2285E-02 2017.2
135.00 -2.2977E-06 -5.4816E-21 0.5610 1.4332E-15 0.1386 2.0075E-02 2015.0
138.00 -1.8336E-06 -4.4181E-21 0.2363 6.2872E-16 8.3870E-02 1.6404E-02 2013.6
141.00 -1.3069E-06 -3.1881E-21 5.9369E-02 1.8026E-16 4.1314E-02 1.1966E-02 2012.8
144.00 -7.6446E-07 -1.9104E-21 -9.8292E-03 -5.3968E-18 1.2625E-02 7.1600E-03 2012.6
147.00 -2.2465E-07 -6.3415E-22 -1.4592E-02 -3.0018E-17 1.3423E-03 2.1512E-03 2012.6
150.00 3.1129E-07 6.3416E-22 0.0000 0.0000 4.6621E-17 3.0461E-03 2012.5

* PILE GROUP * 6

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS AND REACTIONS *

THE GLOBAL STRUCTURAL COORDINATE SYSTEM

---------------------------------------

DISP. X, M DISP. Y, M DISP. Z, M ROT. X,RAD ROT. Y,RAD ROT. Z,RAD

7.0335E-03 0.086476 8.6533E-17 -4.3984E-17 1.1241E-19 -4.5609E-03

FOR. X, KN FOR. Y, KN FOR. Z, KN MOM X, KN- M MOM Y, KN- M MOM Z, KN- M

2198.0 166.16 1.8275E-13 -1.5916E-11 -9.7458E-28 -422.41

STR, KN/ M**2

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-163

4544.0

THE PILE COORDINATE SYSTEM (LOCAL AXES)

---------------------------------------

DISP. x, M DISP. y, M DISP. z, M ROT. x,RAD ROT. y,RAD ROT. z,RAD

7.0335E-03 0.086476 8.6533E-17 -4.3984E-17 1.1241E-19 -4.5609E-03

AXIAL, KN LAT. y, KN LAT. z, KN MOM x, KN- M MOM y, KN- M MOM z, KN- M

2198.0 166.16 1.8275E-13 -1.5916E-11 0.0000 -422.41

STR, KN/ M**2

4544.0

* EFFECTS FOR LATERALLY LOADED PILE *

x DISPL. DISPL. MOMENT MOMENT SHEAR SOIL REACT TOTAL

y-DIR z-DIR z-DIR y-DIR y-z-DIR y-z-DIR STRESS
M M M KN- M KN- M KN KN/ M KN/ M**2
********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
0.0000 8.6476E-02 8.6533E-17 422.41 0.0000 166.12 0.0000 4544.0
3.0000 7.6017E-02 7.6414E-17 943.89 5.7049E-13 166.16 0.0000 6844.7
6.0000 6.5808E-02 6.6446E-17 1464.8 1.1407E-12 166.16 0.0000 9142.9
9.0000 5.5987E-02 5.6779E-17 1984.9 1.7102E-12 166.16 0.0000 1.1437E+04
12.000 4.6691E-02 4.7566E-17 2503.8 2.2787E-12 157.07 6.0597 1.3727E+04
15.000 3.8058E-02 3.8955E-17 2966.7 2.7903E-12 129.46 12.348 1.5769E+04
18.000 3.0211E-02 3.1083E-17 3316.8 3.1865E-12 87.415 15.683 1.7313E+04
21.000 2.3241E-02 2.4055E-17 3523.8 3.4357E-12 39.006 16.590 1.8227E+04
24.000 1.7204E-02 1.7936E-17 3579.4 3.5283E-12 9.3234 15.630 1.8472E+04
27.000 1.2115E-02 1.2751E-17 3492.3 3.4722E-12 52.815 13.365 1.8088E+04
30.000 7.9503E-03 8.4852E-18 3282.9 3.2876E-12 88.339 10.318 1.7164E+04
33.000 4.6544E-03 5.0896E-18 2978.7 3.0018E-12 114.24 6.9466 1.5822E+04
36.000 2.1470E-03 2.4887E-18 2610.2 2.6460E-12 130.09 3.6223 1.4196E+04
39.000 3.3050E-04 5.8810E-19 2207.7 2.2509E-12 136.46 0.6219 1.2420E+04
42.000 -9.0159E-04 -7.1664E-19 1798.2 1.8445E-12 134.58 1.8722 1.0614E+04
45.000 -1.6577E-03 -1.5331E-18 1404.5 1.4504E-12 126.12 3.7649 8877.0
48.000 -2.0420E-03 -1.9657E-18 1043.9 1.0867E-12 112.92 5.0353 7286.1
51.000 -2.1500E-03 -2.1106E-18 728.07 7.6613E-13 96.792 5.7201 5892.5
54.000 -2.0652E-03 -2.0528E-18 463.25 4.9561E-13 79.367 5.8966 4724.2
57.000 -1.8578E-03 -1.8637E-18 251.23 2.7755E-13 62.022 5.6662 3788.8
60.000 -1.5840E-03 -1.6012E-18 90.060 1.1049E-13 45.814 5.1392 3077.8
63.000 -1.2862E-03 -1.3094E-18 -24.910 -9.8869E-15 31.470 4.4237 2790.4
66.000 -9.9512E-04 -1.0202E-18 -100.05 -8.9727E-14 19.410 3.6161 3121.9
69.000 -7.3047E-04 -7.5477E-19 -142.59 -1.3615E-13 9.7910 2.7967 3309.5
72.000 -5.0358E-04 -5.2539E-19 -159.88 -1.5649E-13 2.5570 2.0260 3385.8
75.000 -3.1900E-04 -3.3743E-19 -158.84 -1.5771E-13 2.5003 1.3455 3381.2
78.000 -1.7647E-04 -1.9121E-19 -145.60 -1.4603E-13 5.6866 0.7787 3322.8
81.000 -7.2480E-05 -8.3658E-20 -125.26 -1.2667E-13 7.3555 0.3339 3233.1
84.000 -1.6481E-06 -9.6314E-21 -101.85 -1.0377E-13 7.8683 7.9143E-03 3129.8
87.000 4.2224E-05 3.6926E-20 -78.304 -8.0396E-14 7.5637 0.2110 3025.9
90.000 6.5369E-05 6.2201E-20 -56.613 -5.8633E-14 6.7382 0.3393 2930.2
93.000 7.3528E-05 7.1957E-20 -37.944 -3.9742E-14 5.6351 0.3960 2847.9
96.000 7.1643E-05 7.1192E-20 -22.816 -2.4315E-14 4.4414 0.3998 2781.1
99.000 6.3719E-05 6.3992E-20 -11.274 -1.2451E-14 3.2897 0.3680 2730.2
102.00 5.2810E-05 5.3495E-20 -3.0368 -3.9052E-15 2.2648 0.3153 2693.9
105.00 4.1097E-05 4.1965E-20 2.3645 1.7686E-15 1.4118 0.2534 2690.9
108.00 3.0011E-05 3.0902E-20 5.4843 5.1130E-15 0.7455 0.1908 2704.7
111.00 2.0376E-05 2.1194E-20 6.8834 6.6858E-15 0.2590 0.1335 2710.8
114.00 1.2563E-05 1.3255E-20 7.0765 7.0046E-15 6.8517E-02 8.4781E-02 2711.7
117.00 6.6230E-06 7.1697E-21 6.5025 6.5143E-15 0.2647 4.5985E-02 2709.2
120.00 2.4044E-06 2.8093E-21 5.5108 5.5722E-15 0.3594 1.7163E-02 2704.8
123.00 -3.5532E-07 -7.6211E-23 4.3615 4.4463E-15 0.3812 2.6055E-03 2699.7
126.00 -1.9606E-06 -1.7847E-21 3.2331 3.3229E-15 0.3552 1.4758E-02 2694.7
129.00 -2.7100E-06 -2.6137E-21 2.2356 2.3184E-15 0.3017 2.0927E-02 2690.3
132.00 -2.8677E-06 -2.8289E-21 1.4251 1.4943E-15 0.2362 2.2703E-02 2686.8

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-164

135.00 -2.6481E-06 -2.6486E-21 0.8182 8.7081E-16 0.1699 2.1480E-02 2684.1

138.00 -2.2120E-06 -2.2378E-21 0.4041 4.4019E-16 0.1102 1.8373E-02 2682.2
141.00 -1.6689E-06 -1.7105E-21 0.1551 1.7661E-16 6.1316E-02 1.4187E-02 2681.1
144.00 -1.0847E-06 -1.1364E-21 3.3709E-02 4.3781E-17 2.5888E-02 9.4321E-03 2680.6
147.00 -4.9164E-07 -5.5071E-22 -2.8148E-03 -1.4061E-19 5.1838E-03 4.3707E-03 2680.5
150.00 1.0070E-07 3.4926E-23 -3.9999E-16 3.5526E-31 6.5486E-17 9.1482E-04 2680.5

* PILE GROUP * 7

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS AND REACTIONS *

THE GLOBAL STRUCTURAL COORDINATE SYSTEM

---------------------------------------

DISP. X, M DISP. Y, M DISP. Z, M ROT. X,RAD ROT. Y,RAD ROT. Z,RAD

0.025277 0.086476 -8.9405E-17 -4.3984E-17 1.1241E-19 -4.5609E-03

FOR. X, KN FOR. Y, KN FOR. Z, KN MOM X, KN- M MOM Y, KN- M MOM Z, KN- M

7899.1 174.66 -1.9604E-13 -1.5916E-11 -9.7458E-28 -366.15

STR, KN/ M**2

1.1248E+04

THE PILE COORDINATE SYSTEM (LOCAL AXES)

---------------------------------------

DISP. x, M DISP. y, M DISP. z, M ROT. x,RAD ROT. y,RAD ROT. z,RAD

0.025277 0.086476 -8.9405E-17 -4.3984E-17 1.1241E-19 -4.5609E-03

AXIAL, KN LAT. y, KN LAT. z, KN MOM x, KN- M MOM y, KN- M MOM z, KN- M

7899.1 174.66 -1.9604E-13 -1.5916E-11 0.0000 -366.15

STR, KN/ M**2

1.1248E+04

* EFFECTS FOR LATERALLY LOADED PILE *

x DISPL. DISPL. MOMENT MOMENT SHEAR SOIL REACT TOTAL

y-DIR z-DIR z-DIR y-DIR y-z-DIR y-z-DIR STRESS
M M M KN- M KN- M KN KN/ M KN/ M**2
********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
0.0000 8.6476E-02 -8.9405E-17 366.15 0.0000 174.53 0.0000 1.1248E+04
3.0000 7.5588E-02 -7.8446E-17 976.12 -6.7468E-13 174.66 0.0000 1.3939E+04
6.0000 6.4958E-02 -6.7666E-17 1584.1 -1.3479E-12 174.66 0.0000 1.6622E+04
9.0000 5.4748E-02 -5.7242E-17 2188.7 -2.0184E-12 174.66 0.0000 1.9289E+04
12.000 4.5117E-02 -4.7353E-17 2788.7 -2.6846E-12 163.29 7.5778 2.1936E+04
15.000 3.6224E-02 -3.8174E-17 3314.7 -3.2737E-12 129.11 15.210 2.4257E+04
18.000 2.8208E-02 -2.9863E-17 3696.9 -3.7116E-12 77.863 18.952 2.5943E+04
21.000 2.1171E-02 -2.2533E-17 3900.8 -3.9612E-12 20.099 19.558 2.6842E+04
24.000 1.5167E-02 -1.6252E-17 3920.5 -4.0152E-12 35.987 17.833 2.6929E+04
27.000 1.0201E-02 -1.1034E-17 3771.5 -3.8888E-12 84.581 14.563 2.6272E+04
30.000 6.2327E-03 -6.8452E-18 3483.6 -3.6125E-12 122.13 10.468 2.5002E+04
33.000 3.1867E-03 -3.6128E-18 3094.2 -3.2251E-12 147.06 6.1553 2.3284E+04
36.000 9.5977E-04 -1.2340E-18 2642.9 -2.7683E-12 159.44 2.0957 2.1293E+04
39.000 -5.6758E-04 4.1202E-19 2167.2 -2.2813E-12 160.51 1.3823 1.9194E+04
42.000 -1.5213E-03 1.4541E-18 1699.4 -1.7987E-12 152.31 4.0882 1.7130E+04
45.000 -2.0251E-03 2.0201E-18 1264.9 -1.3474E-12 137.24 5.9525 1.5213E+04
48.000 -2.1941E-03 2.2295E-18 881.25 -9.4681E-13 117.81 7.0021 1.3521E+04

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-165

51.000 -2.1299E-03 2.1882E-18 558.82 -6.0824E-13 96.309 7.3337 1.2098E+04

54.000 -1.9177E-03 1.9859E-18 301.21 -3.3621E-13 74.679 7.0863 1.0962E+04
57.000 -1.6258E-03 1.6946E-18 106.76 -1.2951E-13 54.423 6.4173 1.0104E+04
60.000 -1.3057E-03 1.3690E-18 -30.159 1.7254E-14 36.573 5.4826 9766.1
63.000 -9.9350E-04 1.0479E-18 -117.67 1.1225E-13 21.716 4.4220 1.0152E+04
66.000 -7.1248E-04 7.5664E-19 -165.14 1.6503E-13 10.057 3.3507 1.0362E+04
69.000 -4.7516E-04 5.0902E-19 -182.11 1.8544E-13 1.4997 2.3544 1.0436E+04
72.000 -2.8606E-04 3.1049E-19 -177.51 1.8277E-13 4.2661 1.4894 1.0416E+04
75.000 -1.4394E-04 1.6034E-19 -159.13 1.6516E-13 7.6788 0.7857 1.0335E+04
78.000 -4.3943E-05 5.3908E-20 -133.35 1.3933E-13 9.2338 0.2509 1.0221E+04
81.000 2.0754E-05 -1.5644E-20 -105.03 1.1044E-13 9.4246 0.1238 1.0096E+04
84.000 5.7650E-05 -5.5962E-20 -77.604 8.2153E-14 8.7016 0.3583 9975.4
87.000 7.4003E-05 -7.4535E-20 -53.241 5.6827E-14 7.4463 0.4785 9867.9
90.000 7.6263E-05 -7.8064E-20 -33.073 3.5720E-14 5.9600 0.5124 9779.0
93.000 6.9768E-05 -7.2139E-20 -17.447 1.9259E-14 4.4620 0.4863 9710.0
96.000 5.8655E-05 -6.1115E-20 -6.1620 7.2829E-15 3.0971 0.4236 9660.2
99.000 4.5911E-05 -4.8163E-20 1.3236 -7.3577E-16 1.9469 0.3431 9638.9
102.00 3.3517E-05 -3.5407E-20 5.7180 -5.5131E-15 1.0438 0.2590 9658.3
105.00 2.2636E-05 -2.4109E-20 7.7699 -7.8168E-15 0.3844 0.1806 9667.3
108.00 1.3813E-05 -1.4881E-20 8.1802 -8.3730E-15 5.7001E-02 0.1137 9669.1
111.00 7.1548E-06 -7.8693E-21 7.5502 -7.8095E-15 0.3186 6.0687E-02 9666.4
114.00 2.4952E-06 -2.9247E-21 6.3582 -6.6290E-15 0.4423 2.1793E-02 9661.1
117.00 -4.8138E-07 2.6518E-22 4.9569 -5.2046E-15 0.4685 4.3257E-03 9654.9
120.00 -2.1458E-06 2.0774E-21 3.5840 -3.7909E-15 0.4323 1.9823E-02 9648.9
123.00 -2.8615E-06 2.8861E-21 2.3821 -2.5419E-15 0.3618 2.7155E-02 9643.6
126.00 -2.9467E-06 3.0219E-21 1.4197 -1.5341E-15 0.2780 2.8706E-02 9639.3
129.00 -2.6561E-06 2.7517E-21 0.7126 -7.8802E-16 0.1951 2.6544E-02 9636.2
132.00 -2.1768E-06 2.2729E-21 0.2429 -2.8782E-16 0.1218 2.2303E-02 9634.1
135.00 -1.6332E-06 1.7179E-21 -2.6608E-02 3.4062E-18 6.2677E-02 1.7145E-02 9633.2
138.00 -1.0967E-06 1.1638E-21 -0.1417 1.3232E-16 1.9276E-02 1.1789E-02 9633.7
141.00 -5.9774E-07 6.4473E-22 -0.1504 1.4836E-16 8.2725E-03 6.5760E-03 9633.7
144.00 -1.3857E-07 1.6493E-22 -9.9659E-02 1.0025E-16 2.0476E-02 1.5594E-03 9633.5
147.00 2.9421E-07 -2.8833E-22 -3.4633E-02 3.5236E-17 1.7737E-02 3.3850E-03 9633.2
150.00 7.1784E-07 -7.3227E-22 -7.9998E-16 7.1052E-31 6.0715E-18 8.4398E-03 9633.0

* PILE GROUP * 8

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS AND REACTIONS *

THE GLOBAL STRUCTURAL COORDINATE SYSTEM

---------------------------------------

DISP. X, M DISP. Y, M DISP. Z, M ROT. X,RAD ROT. Y,RAD ROT. Z,RAD

0.037592 0.086476 -2.0816E-16 -4.3984E-17 1.1241E-19 -4.5609E-03

FOR. X, KN FOR. Y, KN FOR. Z, KN MOM X, KN- M MOM Y, KN- M MOM Z, KN- M

1.1553E+04 176.55 -4.5896E-13 -1.5916E-11 -9.4104E-26 -337.45

STR, KN/ M**2

1.5578E+04

THE PILE COORDINATE SYSTEM (LOCAL AXES)

---------------------------------------

DISP. x, M DISP. y, M DISP. z, M ROT. x,RAD ROT. y,RAD ROT. z,RAD

0.037592 0.086476 -2.0816E-16 -4.3984E-17 1.1241E-19 -4.5609E-03

AXIAL, KN LAT. y, KN LAT. z, KN MOM x, KN- M MOM y, KN- M MOM z, KN- M

1.1553E+04 176.55 -4.5896E-13 -1.5916E-11 -9.3129E-26 -337.45

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-166

STR, KN/ M**2

1.5578E+04

* EFFECTS FOR LATERALLY LOADED PILE *

x DISPL. DISPL. MOMENT MOMENT SHEAR SOIL REACT TOTAL

y-DIR z-DIR z-DIR y-DIR y-z-DIR y-z-DIR STRESS
M M M KN- M KN- M KN KN/ M KN/ M**2
********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
0.0000 8.6476E-02 -2.0816E-16 337.45 -9.3129E-26 176.38 0.0000 1.5578E+04
3.0000 7.5369E-02 -1.8205E-16 995.44 -1.6785E-12 176.55 0.0000 1.8481E+04
6.0000 6.4525E-02 -1.5639E-16 1650.4 -3.3519E-12 176.55 0.0000 2.1370E+04
9.0000 5.4118E-02 -1.3161E-16 2300.3 -5.0150E-12 176.55 0.0000 2.4238E+04
12.000 4.4320E-02 -1.0816E-16 2943.1 -6.6628E-12 163.93 8.4183 2.7074E+04
15.000 3.5301E-02 -8.6477E-17 3501.2 -8.1054E-12 126.16 16.763 2.9536E+04
18.000 2.7209E-02 -6.6936E-17 3897.7 -9.1535E-12 70.001 20.673 3.1285E+04
21.000 2.0149E-02 -4.9819E-17 4096.3 -9.7160E-12 7.4178 21.049 3.2161E+04
24.000 1.4173E-02 -3.5273E-17 4092.9 -9.7803E-12 52.423 18.845 3.2146E+04
27.000 9.2808E-03 -2.3317E-17 3907.3 -9.3927E-12 103.17 14.984 3.1327E+04
30.000 5.4226E-03 -1.3846E-17 3575.0 -8.6375E-12 141.09 10.300 2.9861E+04
33.000 2.5106E-03 -6.6625E-18 3139.0 -7.6192E-12 164.77 5.4841 2.7938E+04
36.000 4.2964E-04 -1.4954E-18 2644.0 -6.4466E-12 174.58 1.0609 2.5754E+04
39.000 -9.5147E-04 1.9652E-18 2131.5 -5.2211E-12 172.25 2.6205 2.3493E+04
42.000 -1.7684E-03 4.0438E-18 1636.0 -4.0283E-12 160.25 5.3742 2.1307E+04
45.000 -2.1522E-03 5.0561E-18 1183.8 -2.9338E-12 141.46 7.1539 1.9312E+04
48.000 -2.2227E-03 5.2918E-18 792.45 -1.9816E-12 118.70 8.0215 1.7585E+04
51.000 -2.0834E-03 5.0030E-18 470.84 -1.1952E-12 94.497 8.1124 1.6167E+04
54.000 -1.8195E-03 4.3979E-18 220.81 -5.8043E-13 70.924 7.6032 1.5063E+04
57.000 -1.4971E-03 3.6390E-18 38.526 -1.2933E-13 49.495 6.6826 1.4259E+04
60.000 -1.1646E-03 2.8460E-18 -83.730 1.7598E-13 31.176 5.5300 1.4459E+04
63.000 -8.5416E-04 2.0995E-18 -155.96 3.5912E-13 16.432 4.2994 1.4777E+04
66.000 -5.8504E-04 1.4481E-18 -189.02 4.4606E-13 5.3161 3.1115 1.4923E+04
69.000 -3.6596E-04 9.1480E-19 -193.50 4.6231E-13 2.4270 2.0506 1.4943E+04
72.000 -1.9809E-04 5.0384E-19 -178.93 4.3102E-13 7.2524 1.1664 1.4879E+04
75.000 -7.7591E-05 2.0698E-19 -153.31 3.7171E-13 9.7205 0.4790 1.4766E+04
78.000 2.3277E-06 8.5136E-21 -122.92 2.9976E-13 10.416 1.5032E-02 1.4632E+04
81.000 4.9709E-05 -1.1061E-19 -92.286 2.2640E-13 9.8911 0.3352 1.4496E+04
84.000 7.2661E-05 -1.6980E-19 -64.386 1.5906E-13 8.6223 0.5106 1.4373E+04
87.000 7.8570E-05 -1.8688E-19 -40.885 1.0197E-13 6.9945 0.5746 1.4270E+04
90.000 7.3656E-05 -1.7698E-19 -22.431 5.6875E-14 5.2933 0.5596 1.4188E+04
93.000 6.2804E-05 -1.5202E-19 -8.9437 2.3705E-14 3.7113 0.4951 1.4129E+04
96.000 4.9585E-05 -1.2078E-19 0.1151 1.2459E-15 2.3612 0.4050 1.4090E+04
99.000 3.6397E-05 -8.9213E-20 5.5286 -1.2338E-14 1.2923 0.3076 1.4114E+04
102.00 2.4672E-05 -6.0913E-20 8.1564 -1.9099E-14 0.5074 0.2156 1.4125E+04
105.00 1.5106E-05 -3.7669E-20 8.8192 -2.1010E-14 2.0354E-02 0.1363 1.4128E+04
108.00 7.8750E-06 -1.9986E-20 8.2284 -1.9799E-14 0.3347 7.3294E-02 1.4126E+04
111.00 2.8217E-06 -7.5434E-21 6.9527 -1.6853E-14 0.4853 2.7066E-02 1.4120E+04
114.00 -3.9107E-07 4.3764E-22 5.4122 -1.3204E-14 0.5201 3.8626E-03 1.4113E+04
117.00 -2.1712E-06 4.9235E-21 3.8900 -9.5542E-15 0.4812 2.2064E-02 1.4106E+04
120.00 -2.9217E-06 6.8802E-21 2.5543 -6.3251E-15 0.4023 3.0522E-02 1.4101E+04
123.00 -2.9960E-06 7.1627E-21 1.4856 -3.7236E-15 0.3083 3.2152E-02 1.4096E+04
126.00 -2.6771E-06 6.4595E-21 0.7017 -1.8025E-15 0.2158 2.9492E-02 1.4092E+04
129.00 -2.1724E-06 5.2792E-21 0.1811 -5.1631E-16 0.1348 2.4551E-02 1.4090E+04
132.00 -1.6197E-06 3.9622E-21 -0.1191 2.3446E-16 6.9789E-02 1.8767E-02 1.4090E+04
135.00 -1.0986E-06 2.7073E-21 -0.2500 5.7135E-16 2.2075E-02 1.3042E-02 1.4090E+04
138.00 -6.4370E-07 1.6036E-21 -0.2628 6.1724E-16 9.2264E-03 7.8250E-03 1.4090E+04
141.00 -2.5834E-07 6.6332E-22 -0.2044 4.8580E-16 2.5785E-02 3.2140E-03 1.4090E+04
144.00 7.2929E-08 -1.4838E-22 -0.1164 2.7860E-16 2.9214E-02 9.2810E-04 1.4090E+04
147.00 3.7339E-07 -8.8633E-22 -3.6382E-02 8.7539E-17 2.0534E-02 4.8582E-03 1.4089E+04
150.00 6.6422E-07 -1.6011E-21 -7.9998E-16 0.0000 1.0734E-16 8.8315E-03 1.4089E+04

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-167

2.7.6 Summary Results File

=========================================================================

GROUP for Windows, Version 2016.10.8

Serial Number : 136089307

Analysis of A Group of Piles

Subjected to Axial and Lateral Loading

(c) Copyright ENSOFT, Inc., 1987-2015

All Rights Reserved

=========================================================================

-------------------------------------------------------------------------
Time and Date of Analysis
-------------------------------------------------------------------------

Date: May 09, 2016 Time: 18:14:31

***** COMPUTATION RESULTS *****

EXAMPLE PROBLEM 6 - 3D, PILE GROUP IN A CIRCULAR CONFIGURATION

***** LOAD CASES RESULTS *****

LOAD CASE : 1
CASE NAME : Load Case 1
LOAD TYPE : Special, Sp

REDUCTION FACTORS FOR CLOSELY-SPACED PILE GROUPS, COMBINED Y AND Z DIRECTIONS

ESTIMATED USING MOVEMENT IN THE DIRECTION OF PILE CAP DISPLACEMENTS

GROUP NO P-FACTOR Y-FACTOR

1 0.7914 1.0000
2 0.6998 1.0000
3 0.5408 1.0000
4 0.5825 1.0000
5 0.5825 1.0000
6 0.5408 1.0000
7 0.6998 1.0000
8 0.7914 1.0000

* TABLE L * COMPUTATION ON PILE CAP

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-168

* EQUIVALENT CONCENTRATED LOAD AT ORIGIN *

VERT. LOAD, KN HOR. LOAD Y, KN HOR. LOAD Z, KN

40000.0 1400.00 0.00000

MOMENT X , KN- M MOMENT Y, KN- M MOMENT Z, KN- M

0.00000 0.00000 -1.50000E+05

* DISPLACEMENT OF GROUPED PILE FOUNDATION AT ORIGIN *

VERTICAL , M HORIZONTAL Y, M HORIZONTAL Z, M

0.0161553 0.0864756 -1.43584E-18

ANGLE ROT. X,RAD ANGLE ROT. Y,RAD ANGLE ROT. Z,RAD

-4.39844E-17 1.12409E-19 -4.56089E-03

* TABLE M * COMPUTATION ON INDIVIDUAL PILE

THE GLOBAL STRUCTURAL COORDINATE SYSTEM

---------------------------------------

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS *

PILE GROUP DISP. X, M DISP. Y, M DISP. Z, M ROT. X,RAD ROT. Y,RAD ROT. Z,RAD
********** *********** *********** *********** *********** *********** ***********
1 0.037591 0.086476 -2.0816E-16 -4.3984E-17 1.1241E-19 -4.5609E-03
2 0.025277 0.086476 -8.9405E-17 -4.3984E-17 1.1241E-19 -4.5609E-03
3 7.0335E-03 0.086476 8.6533E-17 -4.3984E-17 1.1241E-19 -4.5609E-03
4 -5.2809E-03 0.086476 2.0529E-16 -4.3984E-17 1.1241E-19 -4.5609E-03
5 -5.2809E-03 0.086476 2.0529E-16 -4.3984E-17 1.1241E-19 -4.5609E-03
6 7.0335E-03 0.086476 8.6533E-17 -4.3984E-17 1.1241E-19 -4.5609E-03
7 0.025277 0.086476 -8.9405E-17 -4.3984E-17 1.1241E-19 -4.5609E-03
8 0.037591 0.086476 -2.0816E-16 -4.3984E-17 1.1241E-19 -4.5609E-03

MINIMUM -5.2809E-03 0.086476 -2.0816E-16 -4.3984E-17 1.1241E-19 -4.5609E-03

Pile N. 4 1 1 1 1 1
MAXIMUM 0.037591 0.086476 2.0529E-16 -4.3984E-17 1.1241E-19 -4.5609E-03
Pile N. 1 1 4 1 1 1

* PILE TOP REACTIONS *

PILE GROUP FOR. X, KN FOR. Y, KN FOR. Z, KN MOM X, KN- M MOM Y, KN- M MOM Z, KN- M
********** *********** *********** *********** *********** *********** ***********
1 1.1553E+04 176.55 -4.5896E-13 -1.5916E-11 -9.4104E-26 -337.45
2 7899.1 174.66 -1.9604E-13 -1.5916E-11 -9.7458E-28 -366.15
3 2198.0 166.16 1.8275E-13 -1.5916E-11 -9.7458E-28 -422.41
4 -1650.3 182.63 4.7225E-13 -1.5916E-11 -9.7458E-28 -415.44
5 -1650.3 182.63 4.7225E-13 -1.5916E-11 -9.7458E-28 -415.44
6 2198.0 166.16 1.8275E-13 -1.5916E-11 -9.7458E-28 -422.41
7 7899.1 174.66 -1.9604E-13 -1.5916E-11 -9.7458E-28 -366.15
8 1.1553E+04 176.55 -4.5896E-13 -1.5916E-11 -9.4104E-26 -337.45

MINIMUM -1650.3 166.16 -4.5896E-13 -1.5916E-11 -9.4104E-26 -422.41

Pile N. 4 3 1 1 1 3
MAXIMUM 1.1553E+04 182.63 4.7225E-13 -1.5916E-11 -9.7458E-28 -337.45
Pile N. 1 4 4 1 2 1

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-169

THE PILE COORDINATE SYSTEM (LOCAL AXES)

---------------------------------------

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS *

PILE GROUP DISP. x, M DISP. y, M DISP. z, M ROT. x,RAD ROT. y,RAD ROT. z,RAD
********** *********** *********** *********** *********** *********** ***********
1 0.037591 0.086476 -2.0816E-16 -4.3984E-17 1.1241E-19 -4.5609E-03
2 0.025277 0.086476 -8.9405E-17 -4.3984E-17 1.1241E-19 -4.5609E-03
3 7.0335E-03 0.086476 8.6533E-17 -4.3984E-17 1.1241E-19 -4.5609E-03
4 -5.2809E-03 0.086476 2.0529E-16 -4.3984E-17 1.1241E-19 -4.5609E-03
5 -5.2809E-03 0.086476 2.0529E-16 -4.3984E-17 1.1241E-19 -4.5609E-03
6 7.0335E-03 0.086476 8.6533E-17 -4.3984E-17 1.1241E-19 -4.5609E-03
7 0.025277 0.086476 -8.9405E-17 -4.3984E-17 1.1241E-19 -4.5609E-03
8 0.037591 0.086476 -2.0816E-16 -4.3984E-17 1.1241E-19 -4.5609E-03

MINIMUM -5.2809E-03 0.086476 -2.0816E-16 -4.3984E-17 1.1241E-19 -4.5609E-03

Pile N. 4 1 1 1 1 1
MAXIMUM 0.037591 0.086476 2.0529E-16 -4.3984E-17 1.1241E-19 -4.5609E-03
Pile N. 1 1 4 1 1 1

* PILE TOP REACTIONS *

PILE GROUP AXIAL, KN LAT. y, KN LAT. z, KN MOM x, KN- M MOM y, KN- M MOM z, KN- M
********** *********** *********** *********** *********** *********** ***********
1 1.1553E+04 176.55 -4.5896E-13 -1.5916E-11 -9.3129E-26 -337.45
2 7899.1 174.66 -1.9604E-13 -1.5916E-11 0.0000 -366.15
3 2198.0 166.16 1.8275E-13 -1.5916E-11 0.0000 -422.41
4 -1650.3 182.63 4.7225E-13 -1.5916E-11 0.0000 -415.44
5 -1650.3 182.63 4.7225E-13 -1.5916E-11 0.0000 -415.44
6 2198.0 166.16 1.8275E-13 -1.5916E-11 0.0000 -422.41
7 7899.1 174.66 -1.9604E-13 -1.5916E-11 0.0000 -366.15
8 1.1553E+04 176.55 -4.5896E-13 -1.5916E-11 -9.3129E-26 -337.45

MINIMUM -1650.3 166.16 -4.5896E-13 -1.5916E-11 -9.3129E-26 -422.41

Pile N. 4 3 1 1 1 3
MAXIMUM 1.1553E+04 182.63 4.7225E-13 -1.5916E-11 0.0000 -337.45
Pile N. 1 4 4 1 2 1

PILE GROUP STRESS, KN/ M**2

********** ****************
1 1.5578E+04
2 1.1248E+04
3 4544.0
4 3845.3
5 3845.3
6 4544.0
7 1.1248E+04
8 1.5578E+04

MINIMUM 3845.3
Pile N. 4
MAXIMUM 1.5578E+04
Pile N. 1

* EFFECTS FOR LATERALLY LOADED PILE *

* MINIMUM VALUES AND LOCATIONS *

PILE DISPL. DISPL. MOMENT MOMENT SHEAR SOIL REACT TOTAL

y-DIR z-DIR z-DIR y-DIR y-z-DIR y-z-DIR STRESS
M M KN- M KN- M KN KN/ M KN/ M**2
****** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
1 -2.2227E-03 -2.0816E-16 -193.50 -9.7803E-12 1.1883E-16 0.0000 1.4089E+04
x( M) 48.000 0.0000 69.000 24.000 150.00 0.0000 150.00

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-170

2 -2.1941E-03 -8.9405E-17 -182.11 -4.0152E-12 5.6379E-17 0.0000 9633.0

x( M) 48.000 0.0000 69.000 24.000 150.00 0.0000 150.00
3 -2.1500E-03 -2.1106E-18 -159.88 -1.5771E-13 2.0502E-16 0.0000 2680.5
x( M) 51.000 51.000 72.000 75.000 150.00 0.0000 150.00
4 -2.0665E-03 -4.8277E-18 -159.32 -3.7192E-13 3.1182E-16 0.0000 2012.5
x( M) 51.000 51.000 72.000 72.000 150.00 0.0000 150.00
5 -2.0665E-03 -4.8277E-18 -159.32 -3.7192E-13 4.6621E-17 0.0000 2012.5
x( M) 51.000 51.000 72.000 72.000 150.00 0.0000 150.00
6 -2.1500E-03 -2.1106E-18 -159.88 -1.5771E-13 6.5486E-17 0.0000 2680.5
x( M) 51.000 51.000 72.000 75.000 150.00 0.0000 150.00
7 -2.1941E-03 -8.9405E-17 -182.11 -4.0152E-12 6.0715E-18 0.0000 9633.0
x( M) 48.000 0.0000 69.000 24.000 150.00 0.0000 150.00
8 -2.2227E-03 -2.0816E-16 -193.50 -9.7803E-12 1.0734E-16 0.0000 1.4089E+04
x( M) 48.000 0.0000 69.000 24.000 150.00 0.0000 150.00

Min. -2.2227E-03 -2.0816E-16 -193.50 -9.7803E-12 6.0715E-18 0.0000 2012.5

Pile N. 1 1 1 1 7 1 4

* MAXIMUM VALUES AND LOCATIONS *

PILE DISPL. DISPL. MOMENT MOMENT SHEAR SOIL REACT TOTAL

y-DIR z-DIR z-DIR y-DIR y-z-DIR y-z-DIR STRESS
M M KN- M KN- M KN KN/ M KN/ M**2
****** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
1 0.086476 5.2918E-18 4096.3 4.6231E-13 176.55 21.049 3.2161E+04
x( M) 0.0000 48.000 21.000 69.000 9.0000 21.000 21.000
2 0.086476 2.2295E-18 3920.5 1.8544E-13 174.66 19.558 2.6929E+04
x( M) 0.0000 48.000 24.000 69.000 6.0000 21.000 24.000
3 0.086476 8.6533E-17 3579.4 3.5283E-12 166.16 16.590 1.8472E+04
x( M) 0.0000 0.0000 24.000 24.000 6.0000 21.000 24.000
4 0.086476 2.0529E-16 3632.3 8.5083E-12 182.66 17.671 1.8037E+04
x( M) 0.0000 0.0000 24.000 24.000 0.0000 21.000 24.000
5 0.086476 2.0529E-16 3632.3 8.5083E-12 182.66 17.671 1.8037E+04
x( M) 0.0000 0.0000 24.000 24.000 0.0000 21.000 24.000
6 0.086476 8.6533E-17 3579.4 3.5283E-12 166.16 16.590 1.8472E+04
x( M) 0.0000 0.0000 24.000 24.000 3.0000 21.000 24.000
7 0.086476 2.2295E-18 3920.5 1.8544E-13 174.66 19.558 2.6929E+04
x( M) 0.0000 48.000 24.000 69.000 9.0000 21.000 24.000
8 0.086476 5.2918E-18 4096.3 4.6231E-13 176.55 21.049 3.2161E+04
x( M) 0.0000 48.000 21.000 69.000 9.0000 21.000 21.000

Max. 0.086476 2.0529E-16 4096.3 8.5083E-12 182.66 21.049 3.2161E+04

Pile N. 1 4 1 4 4 1 1

***** SUMMARY FOR LOAD CASES AND COMBINATIONS *****

***** LOAD CASES RESULTS *****

LOAD CASE : 1

* TABLE L * COMPUTATION ON PILE CAP

* EQUIVALENT CONCENTRATED LOAD AT ORIGIN *

LOAD X, KN LOAD Y, KN LOAD Z, KN MOM X, KN- M MOM Y, KN- M MOM Z, KN- M
40000.0 1400.00 0.00000 0.00000 0.00000 -1.50000E+05

* DISPLACEMENT OF GROUPED PILE FOUNDATION AT ORIGIN *

DISP X, M DISP Y, M DISP Z, M ROT X,RAD ROT Y,RAD ROT Z,RAD
0.0161553 0.0864756 -1.43584E-18 -4.39844E-17 1.12409E-19 -4.56089E-03

* TABLE M * COMPUTATION ON INDIVIDUAL PILE

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-171

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS, GLOBAL *

DISP. X, M DISP. Y, M DISP. Z, M ROT. X,RAD ROT. Y,RAD ROT. Z,RAD
*********** *********** *********** *********** *********** ***********
MINIMUM -5.2809E-03 0.086476 -2.0816E-16 -4.3984E-17 1.1241E-19 -4.5609E-03
Pile N. 4 1 1 1 1 1
MAXIMUM 0.037591 0.086476 2.0529E-16 -4.3984E-17 1.1241E-19 -4.5609E-03
Pile N. 1 1 4 1 1 1

* PILE TOP REACTIONS, GLOBAL *

FOR. X, KN FOR. Y, KN FOR. Z, KN MOM X, KN- M MOM Y, KN- M MOM Z, KN- M
*********** *********** *********** *********** *********** ***********
MINIMUM -1650.3 166.16 -4.5896E-13 -1.5916E-11 -9.4104E-26 -422.41
Pile N. 4 3 1 1 1 3
MAXIMUM 1.1553E+04 182.63 4.7225E-13 -1.5916E-11 -9.7458E-28 -337.45
Pile N. 1 4 4 1 2 1

* PILE TOP DISPLACEMENTS, LOCAL *

DISP. x, M DISP. y, M DISP. z, M ROT. x,RAD ROT. y,RAD ROT. z,RAD
*********** *********** *********** *********** *********** ***********
MINIMUM -5.2809E-03 0.086476 -2.0816E-16 -4.3984E-17 1.1241E-19 -4.5609E-03
Pile N. 4 1 1 1 1 1
MAXIMUM 0.037591 0.086476 2.0529E-16 -4.3984E-17 1.1241E-19 -4.5609E-03
Pile N. 1 1 4 1 1 1

* PILE TOP REACTIONS, LOCAL *

AXIAL, KN LAT. y, KN LAT. z, KN MOM x, KN- M MOM y, KN- M MOM z, KN- M
*********** *********** *********** *********** *********** ***********
MINIMUM -1650.3 166.16 -4.5896E-13 -1.5916E-11 -9.3129E-26 -422.41
Pile N. 4 3 1 1 1 3
MAXIMUM 1.1553E+04 182.63 4.7225E-13 -1.5916E-11 0.0000 -337.45
Pile N. 1 4 4 1 2 1

* EFFECTS FOR LATERALLY LOADED PILE *

PILE DISPL. DISPL. MOMENT MOMENT SHEAR SOIL REACT TOTAL

y-DIR z-DIR z-DIR y-DIR y-z-DIR y-z-DIR STRESS
M M KN- M KN- M KN KN/ M KN/ M**2
****** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** ********** **********
Min. -2.2227E-03 -2.0816E-16 -193.50 -9.7803E-12 6.0715E-18 0.0000 2012.5
Pile N. 1 1 1 1 7 1 4
Max. 0.086476 2.0529E-16 4096.3 8.5083E-12 182.66 21.049 3.2161E+04
Pile N. 1 4 1 4 4 1 1

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-172

2.7.7 Graphs

Figure 2.19 Curves Resultant Deflection vs. Distance for Example Problem 6 - 3D.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 2 Example Problems Based on Three-Dimensional Analyses 2-173

Figure 2.20 Curves Resultant Moment vs. Distance for Example Problem 6 - 3D.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
CHAPTER 3. Example Problems Based
on Moment Curvature
Calculations

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 3 Example Problems Based on Moment Curvature Calculations 3-2

3.1 Introduction

Main features of the examples for moment curvature calculations included with GROUP are
summarized in the table below.

Additional application problems will become available electronically at our internet website,
which may be accessed with the following unified resource locator (url):

http://www.ensoftinc.com/

Users may also access ENSOFT, INC.'s website to observe responses to commonly asked
questions related to the GROUP program.

Example Name Name of Input File Description

Circular Drilled Shaft.
Example 1 - MC MCexample1.gp10d
Rectangular Concrete Pile.
Example 2 - MC MCexample2.gp10d
Unconfined and Confined Sections
Square Prestressed Pile.
Example 3 - MC MCexample3.gp10d
Round Concrete Shaft with Casing.
Example 4 - MC MCexample4.gp10d
Include an embedded steel section
Steel Pipe Pile.
Example 5 - MC MCexample5.gp10d

Table 3.1 Main features of moment curvature examples for GROUP 2016

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 3 Example Problems Based on Moment Curvature Calculations 3-3

3.2 Example Problem 1 - MC

3.2.1 Model Description

A drilled shaft with an outside diameter of 760 mm is used in this example. The reinforcing steel
consists of 12 bars #8 bars spaced equally around the center of the shaft. The geometric configuration is
presented in Figure 3.1. The ultimate strengths of the reinforcing steel is 414 MPa and 27.6 MPa for
concrete.

Figure 3.1 Cross Section of Example Problem 1 - MC.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 3 Example Problems Based on Moment Curvature Calculations 3-4

3.2.2 Graphs

Figure 3.2 Moment Curvature for Example Problem 1 - MC.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 3 Example Problems Based on Moment Curvature Calculations 3-5

Figure 3.3 Interaction Diagram for Example Problem 1 - MC.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 3 Example Problems Based on Moment Curvature Calculations 3-6

3.3 Example Problem 2 - MC

3.3.1 Model Description

A rectangular concrete pile with a height of 400 mm and a width of 500 mm is used in this
example. The reinforcing steel consists of 10 bars #8 bars spaced equally around the height and width of
the pile. The geometric configurationis presented in Figure 3.4. The ultimate strengths of the reinforcing
steel is 300 MPa and 30 MPa for concrete.

The effect of confinement is considered in a second section using #3 transverse rebars spaced
90 mm.

Figure 3.4 Cross Section of Example Problem 2 - MC.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 3 Example Problems Based on Moment Curvature Calculations 3-7

3.3.2 Graphs

Figure 3.5 Moment Curvature for Example Problem 2 –MC, Unconfined Section.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 3 Example Problems Based on Moment Curvature Calculations 3-8

Figure 3.6 Moment Curvature for Example Problem 2 – MC, Confined Section.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 3 Example Problems Based on Moment Curvature Calculations 3-9

3.4 Example Problem 3 - MC

3.4.1 Model Description

A square prestressed pile with a width of 355 mm is used in this example. A corner chamfer of
25.4 mm is consiedred. The prestressing strands consists of 8 bars, ½” Grade 270. Being the initial
presstresing force of 986 kN. The geometric configurationis presented in Figure 3.7. The ultimate
strength of the concrete is 41.4 MPa.

Figure 3.7 Cross Section of Example Problem 3 - MC.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 3 Example Problems Based on Moment Curvature Calculations 3-10

3.4.2 Graphs

Figure 3.8 Moment Curvature for Example Problem 3 –MC.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 3 Example Problems Based on Moment Curvature Calculations 3-11

Figure 3.9 Bending Stiffness for Example Problem 3 – MC.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 3 Example Problems Based on Moment Curvature Calculations 3-12

3.5 Example Problem 4 - MC

3.5.1 Model Description

A round concrete shaft of 41 in of diameter is used in this example. The reinforcing steel consists
of 14 bars #9 bars spaced equally around the center of the shaft. The geometric configuration is
presented in Figure 3.10. An exterior casing of 42 in of diameter and 0,5 in of thickness is considered. A
W12x72 steel section is considered embedded into the shaft. The ultimate strengths of the reinforcing
steel is 60 ksi, 4 ksi for concrete and 36 ksi for the casing and steel section.

A second section without the embedded steel section is considered for comparison

Figure 3.10 Cross Section of Example Problem 4 - MC.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 3 Example Problems Based on Moment Curvature Calculations 3-13

3.5.2 Graphs

Figure 3.11 Moment Curvature for Example Problem 4 –MC with embedded steel section.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 3 Example Problems Based on Moment Curvature Calculations 3-14

Figure 3.12 Moment Curvature for Example Problem 4 –MC without embedded steel section.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 3 Example Problems Based on Moment Curvature Calculations 3-15

3.6 Example Problem 5 - MC

3.6.1 Model Description

A steel pipe pile of ft of 48 in of diameter and 1 in thickness is used in this example. The
geometric configuration is presented in Figure 3.13. The ultimate strengths of the reinforcing steel is 36
ksi.

Figure 3.13 Cross Section of Example Problem 5 - MC.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 3 Example Problems Based on Moment Curvature Calculations 3-16

3.6.2 Graphs

Figure 3.14 Moment Curvature for Example Problem 5 –MC.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 3 Example Problems Based on Moment Curvature Calculations 3-17

Figure 3.15 Bending Stiffness for Example Problem 5 – MC.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
CHAPTER 4. Example Models for
Troubleshooting

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 4 Example Models for Troubleshooting 4-2

4.1 Introduction

The analyses performed in GROUP involve iterations because of the nonlinearities of the
formulation. In general, we recommend to check the solution obtained by the program, so the results
are consistent with the input provided.

Sometimes the program may get a numerical error or lack of convergence; however, there is no a
unique solution to avoid that issue, each case is a different story. In general, we recommend to check
the consistency of the input data. Also, you can take a look at the Echo Print File, Output File and
Processor Run Notes File, which may include some Warning or Error Messages that may help the user to
figure out what is the reason of the lack of solution.

In order to provide some ideas for troubleshooting of models we are including a set of examples.
This set does not include all the possible cases, but provide a good idea on how to troubleshoot a model.
Main features of the sample models for troubleshooting included with GROUP are summarized in the
table below.

Example Name Name of Input File Description

Piles aligned with pinned connections.
Example 1a – TB TBexample1a.gp10d
Unstable Structure. Singular Stiffness Matrix
Piles aligned with fixed connections. Stable
Example 1b - TB TBexample1b.gp10d
Structure
Excessive load, some piles may fail in bearing,
Example 2a – TB TBexample2a.gp10d
pullout
Reduced load to verify demand in piles
Example 2b – TB TBexample2b.gp10d
Excessive load, large displacements generated.
Example 3a – TB TBexample3a.gp10d
Reduced load to verify level of displacements.
Example 3b – TB TBexample3b.gp10d
Excessive load, possible failure in buckling.
Example 4a – TB TBexample4a.gp10d
Analysis under various loads to check possible
Example 4b – TB TBexample4b.gp10d
buckling failure.

Table 4.1 Main features of troubleshooting examples for GROUP 2016

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 4 Example Models for Troubleshooting 4-3

4.2 Example Model 1 - TB

4.2.1 Model Description

A pile group consisting of three piles aligned, that is subjected to a vertical load and a lateral
load in the direction of the alignment. The geometric configuration is presented in Figure 4.1 Figure 3.1.
The connection between the piles heads and the piles are defined as pinned.

Figure 4.1 View of Example Model 1a - TB.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 4 Example Models for Troubleshooting 4-4

4.2.2 Discussion

Running the analysis, the program found a numerical error and looking at the Processors Run
Notes the warning message DETERMINANT OF STIFFNESS MATRIX IS ZERO shows up.

Figure 4.2 Error while running Example Model 1a - TB.

Figure 4.3 Processor Run Notes file for Example Model 1a - TB.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 4 Example Models for Troubleshooting 4-5

The error indicates that the structure is unstable. For this model the lack of stability is due to
the fact that the model does not have any rotational stiffness along the alignment of the piles because
all the piles are aligned and all of them have pinned connection, so the pile cap can rotate freely without
any restriction. Even though there is no acting load in the rotational direction along the alignments (My)
the system is unstable and cannot get solution.

Kryry=0

Figure 4.4 Lack of Rotational Stiffness for Example Model 1a - TB.

So, in order to analyze this model the structure needs to be stable. So, in order to maintain the
alignment of the piles, the connection between the pile cap can the pile heads must be fixed. After
making the correction the model is stable and the program can get a solution.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 4 Example Models for Troubleshooting 4-6

Figure 4.5 Change the connection to Fixed for Example Model 1b - TB.

Figure 4.6 Lateral displacements for Example Model 1b - TB.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 4 Example Models for Troubleshooting 4-7

4.3 Example Model 2 - TB

4.3.1 Model Description

A pile group consisting of four piles, which is subjected to a lateral load. The geometric
configuration is presented in Figure 4.7Figure 3.1.

Figure 4.7 View of Example Model 2a - TB.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 4 Example Models for Troubleshooting 4-8

4.3.2 Discussion

Running the analysis, the program found a numerical error and looking at the Processors Run
Notes the warning message SOME PILES REACHED MAXIMUM IN PULLOUT shows up.

Figure 4.8 Error while running Example Model 2a - TB.

Figure 4.9 Processor Run Notes file for Example Model 2a - TB.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 4 Example Models for Troubleshooting 4-9

The error indicates that axial load in bearing (and pullout) for some piles have reached the
maximum defined in the load settlement curve. This warning message can be displayed not only for the
load displacement curve generated by the program but also for the user-defined load displacement
curve. To verify if this is the case a new analysis with a reduced load must be performed. The level of
axial produced by the program is not known, so a trial an error procedure may be needed to verify this
behavior.

So, a new model with a scale factor of 0.8 is considered.

Figure 4.10 Definition of Load at 80% for Example Model 2b - TB.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 4 Example Models for Troubleshooting 4-10

Looking at the load displacement curve generated by the program, it can be noticed that the
capacity (both compression and pullout) is in the order of 150000 lbs.

Figure 4.11 Load-Displacement curve generated for Example Model 2b - TB.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 4 Example Models for Troubleshooting 4-11

The demand for axial forces can be extracted from the Summary Results file. At 80% of the load
the axial load demanded is 133000 lbs. So at 100% of the load the demand could be 166000 lbs. that
exceed the axial capacity of the pile.

If the user consider that the program is under estimating the axial capacity, the user can enter
its own load displacement capacity to be used for the analysis.

In any case to overcome this issue, the user may need to increase the section dimensions of the
piles, the pile length, increase the number of piles or change the pile configuration to have a system
capable to resist the original loads applied.

Figure 4.12 Summary Results File for Example Model 2b - TB.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 4 Example Models for Troubleshooting 4-12

4.4 Example Model 3 - TB

4.4.1 Model Description

A pile group consisting of four piles, which is subjected to a lateral load. The geometric
configuration is presented in Figure 4.7Figure 3.1.

Figure 4.13 View of Example Model 3a - TB.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 4 Example Models for Troubleshooting 4-13

4.4.2 Discussion

Running the analysis, the program found a numerical error and looking at the Processors Run
Notes the warning message SOME PILES REACHED MAXIMUM IN PULLOUT shows up.

Figure 4.14 Error while running Example Model 3a - TB.

Figure 4.15 Processor Run Notes file for Example Model 3a - TB.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 4 Example Models for Troubleshooting 4-14

The error indicates that axial load in bearing (and pullout) for some piles have reached the
maximum defined in the load settlement curve. This warning message can be generated also due to a
large displacements of the pile group, so the axial displacements become very large and trigger the
warning message. To verify the source of the error a new analysis with a reduced load must be
performed. The level of load needed to trigger the error is not known, so a trial an error procedure may
be needed to verify this behavior.

So, a new model with a scale factor of 0.5 is considered.

Figure 4.16 Definition of Load at 50% for Example Model 3b - TB.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 4 Example Models for Troubleshooting 4-15

Looking at the load displacement curve generated by the program, it can be noticed that the
capacity (both compression and pullout) is in the order of 850000 lbs.

Figure 4.17 Load-Displacement curve generated for Example Model 3b - TB.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 4 Example Models for Troubleshooting 4-16

The demand for axial forces can be extracted using the Pile Cap Response Option from the Show
3D-View Window. At 50% of the load the axial load demanded is 199500 lbs. So at 100% of the load the
demand could be 399000 lbs. that is below the axial capacity of the piles.

Figure 4.18 Summary Results File for Example Model 2b - TB.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 4 Example Models for Troubleshooting 4-17

Now, looking at the lateral deflection, we can notice that at 50% of the load the displacement is
getting large, about 14 in, so at 100% of the load the displacement could be higher than 28 in..

Figure 4.19 Lateral Deflection for Example Model 3b - TB.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 4 Example Models for Troubleshooting 4-18

Now, looking at the lateral soil reaction, we can notice that at 50% of the load the maximum
reaction is about 580 lbs/in at 15 ft.

Figure 4.20 Lateral Soil Reaction for Example Model 3b - TB.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 4 Example Models for Troubleshooting 4-19

Now, looking at the lateral p-y curves we can notice that the maximum soil reaction at 15ft is
about 580 lbs/in that is closer to the demanded soil reaction at 50% of the load. So, it can be inferred
that the pile group is not capable to take 100% of the load because it would exceed its lateral capacity.

In any case to overcome this issue, the user may need to increase the section dimensions of the
piles, increase the number of piles or change the pile configuration to have a system capable to resist
the original loads applied.

Figure 4.21 Generated p-y curves for Example Model 3b - TB.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 4 Example Models for Troubleshooting 4-20

4.5 Example Model 4 - TB

4.5.1 Model Description

A pile group consisting of 10 piles, which is subjected to a vertical load, a lateral load and a
moment. The geometric configuration is presented in Figure 4.22Figure 3.1.

Figure 4.22 View of Example Model 4a - TB.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 4 Example Models for Troubleshooting 4-21

4.5.2 Discussion

Running the analysis, the program cannot get convergence and looking at the Processors Run
Notes the warning message NO CLOSURE OF LLP AFTER 200 ITERATIONS.

Figure 4.23 Error while running Example Model 4a - TB.

Figure 4.24 Processor Run Notes file for Example Model 4a - TB.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 4 Example Models for Troubleshooting 4-22

The error indicates that the lateral analysis of some piles cannot achieve convergence, so the
program quits and stops the analysis. One of the reasons of not achieving convergence under lateral
loading is that buckling may be occurring in some piles. Actually, the program does not have an option
to compute the buckling load; however buckling may be infer by a series of analysis increasing the load
and looking at the results.

So, in order to check if the lack of convergence in this model may be due to buckling 5 load cases
are considered. Each load case is scaled using a factor. For the new model, the scaled factor are: 0.20,
0.3, 0.35, 0.36 and 0.364. Please note that this values were obtained from a trial and error procedure.

Figure 4.25 Definition of 5 load cases for Example Model 4b - TB.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 4 Example Models for Troubleshooting 4-23

As we can note in the displacements versus depth graph, the increase in displacements is
significant compared with the increase on the load. So, it can be inferred that buckling may be occurring
in some of the piles for this model.

To overcome this issue, the user may need to increase the section dimensions of the piles or
increase the number of piles in order to have a system capable to resist the original loads applied.

Figure 4.26 Lateral displacements for Example Model 4b - TB.

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
CHAPTER 5. Example Models for Excel
Import/Export

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC
 CHAPTER 5 Example Models for Excel Import/Export 5-2

5.1 Introduction

GROUP allows importing a pile group layout and loading from an excel file. Also the program can
export the pile layout and loading to an excel file. In order to help the users understand the process, a
couple of models are included with the corresponding excel templates. There is no further explanation
provided regarding the importing from excel procedure. The user is encouraged to look over the
templates before importing more complicated layouts and loading

Main features of the sample models for import/export to excel included in GROUP are
summarized in the table below.

Example Name Name of Input File Description

A two group pile in 2 dimensions with 3 load
cases and 2 load combinations
Layout excel template:
Example 2D – ET ETexample2D.gp10d
template_layout_2D.xlxs
Loading excel template:
template_loading_2D.xlxs
A nine group pile in 3 dimensions with 3 load
cases and 2 load combinations
Layout excel template:
Example 3D - ET ETexample3D.gp10d
template_layout_3D.xlxs
Loading excel template:
template_loading_3D.xlxs

Table 5.1 Main features of import from excel examples for GROUP 2016

GROUP 2016 for Windows Examples Manual

COPYRIGHT © ENSOFT, INC 2016

NO REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT AUTHORIZATION FROM ENSOFT, INC