Managerial Economics Trainer Manual
Managerial Economics Trainer Manual
Managerial Economics
Prepared by:
I. Course Objective:
Economics is a social science. “Economics is a Study of mankind in the ordinary business of
life” So writer Alfred Marshall, the great 19th century economist modern business Problems
are so complex that decision makers personal experience intuition, insight, foresight alone
are no longer adequate to provide an appropriate solution to complex business problems. It is
here that the subject managerial Economics or applied economics assumes great importance
for the future managers. It will help student , managers to Understand the economic
environment in which we live and work, what is good about it and what’s not so good, how
the policy makers are trying to make it better some times successfully, sometime not.
The course of Managerial economics have been framed in such a way that it will help
in understanding many of the most pressing issues facing the world today- free market versus
government intervention, resources exhaustion, pollution and environmental degradation,
government taxes and spending employment and unemployment, inflation, changing living
standards in advanced nations, growth and stagnation among many of the world’s poorest
nation. In addition, with increased globalization, the interdependencies among the economies
have become very glaring. This has increased the importance of assessing the impact of
domestic policy changes after taking into account these external influences
Thus, this subject will provide the students with a toolbox that will prove useful in the
world of work.
II. Learning action:
This course would enable the students to-
Visualize the linkages and interdependencies among the various segments within the
domestic economy as well as impact on the domestic economy policy changes in the
international economy.
The subject presents the foundation to understanding how the economy works,
covering microeconomic descriptions of business applications, including pricing for profit
maximization, price elasticity, market structures and modeling of business in varying
economic climates. The focus is on market economies, the organizations that operate in them
and their business strategies.
Learning objective:
At the end of the course students would be all to-
1. Quizzes- Quizzes would be taken after the completion of few chapters to test the
understanding of the concepts by the students. Objective type quizzes would also
prepare the students for the multiple type questions, thereby preparing them for the
examination.
2. Assignment-Topics for them would be prior given to the students during the course
tenure. Four assignments would have to be completed. These topics should be
comprehensively written covering all the possible aspects of it.
I. Chapter 1.
INTRODUCTION TO ECONOMICS
Economic issues and concepts
Definitions
Introduction to Managerial Concepts
Nature and Scope
Concept of Economic Analysis
II. Chapter2.
DEMAND AND SUPPLY ANALYSIS
1.1 Demand, Law of Demand and Demand Forecasting
1.2 Managerial Utility Analysis
1.3 Supply, Law of supply
1.4 Equilibrium and Determination of Price
1.5 Indifference Curve Analysis
1.6 Elasticity of Demand and supply
1.7 Demand and Revenue Curves
-Relationship between AR and MR
1.8 Concept of Consumer Surplus, Produce Surplus
III. Chapter3.
PRODUCTION AND COST ANALYSIS
1.1 Law of variable production
1.2 Law of Returns to scale
1.3 ISO- quant Curves
1.4 Cost structure of Firms –Long run and Short run
1.5 Break Even Point
1.6 Economics and Diseconomies of scale
IV. Chapter 4.
PROFIT ANALYSIS
1.1 Profit Theories – Accounting and Economic profit
1.2 Profit Planning and Forecasting
1.3 Profit Maximization
1.4 CVP Relation and Break-even Analyses
V. Chapter 5.
MARKETS AND COMPETITION
1.1 Classification of Markets
Characteristics, Perfect, Monopolistic, Oligopoly,
1.2 Price and Output determination in each market-Equilibrium conditions
1.3 Control and Regulation of Monopoly
1.4 Oligopoly Pricing –Price Leadership Concept of Cartels
Role of Advertising
VI. Chapter 6.
PRICING
1.1 Objectives of Pricing Policy, Pricing Methods
1.2 Role of Costs and demand factor in pricing
1.3 Pricing and Product life Cycles
VII. Chapter 7.
A well- known Mumbai- based firm manufacturing men ties found that the daily demand
for its ties is given by the equation
D = 400-4P
a) How many ties per day can the firm sell at a price of Rs 50, and
b) What price should it charge, if it wants to sell 300 ties a day?
From the following demand data, calculate the demand equation:
Unit price (Rs) 5432
Quantity Demand (units) 70 80 90 100
the linear demand function for a product is
D = 120 – 10p
(a) Calculate price elasticity of demand for prices of Rs 10, Rs 8, Rs 6, Rs 4, and Rs 2, per
unit.
(b) Is the demand at these prices elastic or inelastic?
Calculation the difference between the ruling price P, (Rs 10 or Rs 8 etc) and the price at
which D is zero (Rs 12 in over example) we will have P1-p.
(a) Divide the ruling price (Rs 10 or Rs 8 etc) by the difference and find out the price
elasticity of demand.
The project and loss data of company for a particular year are given as follows:
Net Sales Rs
Cost of goods sold 1, 00 000
Variable cost 40,000
Fixed cost 10,000
Gross profit 50,000
Selling costs:
Variable cost 10,000
Fixed cost 5,000
Net profit 35,000
A firm has purchased a plant its manufacturing a new product cost data for the plant is
given below:
Estimated annual sales: 24,000 units
Estimated costs:
1. This paper is divided into four sections each section should be attempted
2. Section A - consist of objective-type questions each should be attempted. It
carries 20 marks.
3. Section B - consist of 6 questions out of which 4 should be compulsorarily written
in about 50 words. 4 ×5=20
4. Section C - is a short –essay type which should be written in about 100 words.
Here again 4 should be answered out of 6 4×10=40
5. Section D – it is a case study which has to be analyzed and answered thoughtfully
in full description 20 marks
Section A
2. For an elastic demand curve ( and assume that the supply curve is upward sloping ),
when income of consumers increase, equilibrium price of a good is likely to:
(a) Decrease
(b) Increase
(c) Stay the same
(d) None of the above
3. For an inelastic demand curve, when income of consumers decrease, equilibrium
priced of a good is likely to:
(a) Decrease
(b) Increase
(c) Stay the same
(d) None of the above
4. If you assume that the demand curve for garments is very elastic, then a price discount
offered by garment – manufacturers is likely to:
(a) Decrease the total revenue they earn
(b) Not change the total revenue they earn
(c) Cannot say what will happen to total revenue
(d) Likely to increase the total revenue they earn
.
5. Consumer surplus is the difference between;
(a) How much consumers think of paying and want to pay.
(b) How much consumers want to pay and think of paying.
(c) How much consumers are willing to pay and actually pay
(d) How much they should pay in different countries.
6. Suppose consumer income increase so that the demand curve shifts outward, then.
(a) Both equilibrium price and quantity are likely to increase
(b) Equilibrium price will increase but quantity will decrease
(c) Equilibrium price will decrease but quantity will increase
(d) Both equilibrium price and quantity are decrease
9. A monopolist can:
(a) charge as high a price as it wishes
(b) Choose quantity but is constrained by the demand curve to fix price.
(c) Always faces a horizontal demand curve
(d) Can neither fix price or quantity?
11. Man has unlimited wants but the resources to satisfy them are limited.
12. Profit maximization is the only motive of capitalist economy.
13. Indifference curves always interested each other.
14. The law of Diminishing Marginal Utility applies in case of money.
15. Firms are price-makers in perfect competition
16. M R curve is always above the A R curve
17. B E P is that volume of sales when total revenue of firm exceeds total cost.
18. Inflation in any given country can be controlled only by fiscal measures.
19. In the second stage of production M P curve is below the Average Product Curve.
20. Opportunity cost is also known as Transfer-cost
Section B
1. What is managerial economics? How does it different from traditional economics.
2. Explain the nature of problems studied in managerial economics.
3. State and explain law of demand
4. Explain the price elasticity of demand.
5. What are the main features of pure competition?
6. What are the two factors which lead to inflation in any given country?
Section C
1. Explain the concept of the break-even point with the help of profit-volume graph.
2. What is a production function? Show how a production function can be plotted in and
isoquant diagram.
3. Explain the cost-Volume profit relations.
4. Distinguish between perfect, Monopoly and Monopolistic competitions
5. Difference between penetration pricing and skimming pricing.
6. Calculate price elasticity of demand of:
Q = 4,000 P1= Rs 20
Q2= 5,000 P2= Rs 19
Section- D
Case study:
Textile Demand in India-
Shri Siddhartha Roy, an Economist, Hindustan lever Ltd, has estimated that if there is
one percent increase in the prices of textiles, the demand for it would come down by 1.4
percent similarly if the food prices go up by one percent the demand for textile would decline
by 0.98% Finally if there is one percent increase in the share of agriculture in the national
income, then the demand for textile would go up by 0.3 % price elasticity is an area where
active intervention by the mills can contribute to the expansion of demand.
The margins in textile business as shown by N CAER and Anubhai and Bijapurkar study
vary from 28 percent to 48 percent ( this includes margins of manufacturer, wholesaler, semi
wholesaler and retailer). If the Distribution system could be rationalized so as to bring down
the final price of cloth, then by exploiting price elasticity alone, demand can go up.
Questions:
1. Identify the various types of demand elasticities relevant to textile demand in India.
2. Clearly define these elasticities and state formula
3. What role has been visualized for price elasticity of demand for textile in India?
New Horizon Leadership Institute
PGDM- Post Graduate Diploma in Management
Course Title: Managerial Economics
Session : 35 Hrs.
Faculty : Geetanjali Sharma
Session
Topic Pedagogical Tools Remarks
No
1. Introduction to Micro Slides This session would be an
Managerial Economics- introductory class for students
Definitions, Applications. who would understand what
economics is all about – its uses
and applications in day-to-day
life.
2. Nature and Scope of Slides/blackboard This session would highlight the
Managerial Economics application to managerial
economic to future managers
3. Demand Analysis-Case study Slides/blackboard Case study on demand would
enable student to know what
market demand is and what are
the factors governing them.
4 Supply Analysis Determination Slides/Blackboard
of Equilibrium price and output
5 Indifference Curve Analysis of Student will be able to understand
Demand the nature of consumers through
this concept.
6 Quiz on demand and supply
concept
To conclude, the case method has large educational value as the class-room
discussion of case studies helps the management trainees in developing necessary skills for
successful decision-making in actual business situations.
Case study method has also been found useful in training programmes for working
executives. The realism of the case material makes many managers relate what they are
learning to their own situations. They use their own experience in analyzing the cases and
derive management principles from the discussion their analysis.
LIMITATIONS
The case study method takes getting used to. Trainees who have not had previous
experience with this method can become quite frustrated when they find that there is no
“right” answer to the case problem is and that there even may be a question as to just what
the problem is. “How can I learn to manage,” they ask, “if no one is sure of what is wrong or
what should be done about it?” Most trainees pass through this stage successfully; they learn
eventually that management situations often are ambiguous and that there frequently is no
single best solution.
CASES
CASE 1: ENERGY FOODS
The top management of Energy Foods (Private) Ltd. were considering a report
submitted by one of their executives in June, 1995. The report was a study of the implications
of the Government of Indian’s changed import policy. The problem facing the management
was whether to depend solely on imported basic raw material, as hitherto, for the preparation
of baby foods inside the country till its imports were totally banned and then try to switch on
to local substitutes or go out of production, or else to resort forthwith to a blend of
indigenous raw material land imported stocks to feed the company’s factory, thus stretching
the period of part-availability of the imported material for as long as possible.
Energy Foods is a subsidiary of Energy Foods, USA, which has branches all over
the world. In India it produces baby foods and also processes and repacks some other
commodities imported in bulk.
The principals in the USA produce the raw material on a larges scale. This is sold to bulk
purchasers throughout the world.
In India, the largest importers of the raw material are Baby Foods (Private) Ltd., and
Energy Foods (Private) Ltd. These two firms are also the largest sellers of quality baby foods
in the Indian market. Hence the effective competition for sale is between these two. The cost
of raw material imported by them is about the same.
Both these firms normally keep stocks of raw materials in hand sufficient to meet
their requirements for at least one year. And being competing firms, they sell at price parity.
The changed import policy of the Government, however, made some adjustments
necessary in the import programs of these companies. The executives of Energy Foods who
had made a careful study of the national import policy felt convinced that imports were going
to be slashed considerably and were likely to be stopped ultimately. So in order to see that
their company was not caught napping, the executives were considering reduction of reliance
on the imported raw material and as a first step towards this new policy were thinking of
establishing contact with indigenous manufactures of the same raw materials.
The quality of the indigenous raw material, however, compared unfavorably with the
imported material. Again the color of the final product became off grade with the use of the
indigenous raw material instead of the crystal white finished product which resulted from the
use of the imported material.
Moreover, the cost of the indigenous supply was considerably higher than that of the
imported raw material ranged between Rs. 3.75 and Rs. 4 a Ib. while the cost of the
indigenous material varied from Rs.4.50to Rs.5 per Ib.
The use of local raw material was likely to raise the cost of production and the hence
the price of the final product. It was estimated that the use of local raw material would
increase the price of baby foods by about 25%.
The executives of Energy Foods thought that instead of confronting the market with a
25% rise in price later, they would raise their price by 12.5 immediately and begin to mix
local raw material to the imported material gradually increasing the proportion of the former
to the latter.
Baby Foods, on the other hand, were thinking along the following lines-to carry on
production as long as possible with imported material and seek alternative source of supply
only when forced to do so. The policy was hardly likely to raise the cost of production
immediately because they would be operating from stocks in hand. And they had stocks
enough to last for a year.
As a result of the policy which Energy Foods were thinking of pursuing a rise in price
by 12.5% was inevitable. Baby foods, on the other hand, could maintain their present selling
price for some time more.
The sales executives of Energy Foods informed the management that the company
would lose 50% of its share of the national market during the coming year in case it decided
to use local raw material thus necessitating a 12.5% increase in price with immediate effect.
What should the company do?
During the pricing discussions, the controller and the sales manager had considered two other
aspects of the problem. The controller was concerned about the possibility that competitors
would reduce their prices below Rs. 15 if the simplex announced Rs.15.00 price for item 345.
The sales manager confident that competitors would not go below Rs.15 because they all had
higher costs and several of them were in tight financial straits. He believed that action taken
on items 345 would not have any substantial repercussion and other items in the line.
The controller prepared estimated costs of items 345 at various volumes of production
as given below:
Production cost per meter-
These estimated costs reflected current labour and material costs. They were based on past
experience except for the estimates of 75,000 and 100,000 meters.
Notice has been issued against the company for alleged unauthorized manufacture and sale of
cassettes for tape-recorders, it is learnt. The ministry of industry is believed to have made an
inquiry in to allegation made by some MP’s that Philips were engaged in such activities. The
government had assured parliament that the matter would be fully inquired into.
The unauthorized manufacture of cassettes for tape-recorders by the company violates not
only the industries (Development and Regulation) Act but also attracts actions under the
monopolies and restrictive Trade Practices Act.
The small-scale industries have been the pioneers in the field of cassettes for tape-recorders.
The small-scale manufacture of cassettes started as early as 1973. There are also in the
market foreign brand name cassettes which are claimed to be made in India. It is not known
whether the department concerned as inquired in to the matter.
Qualified observers say that there was no need for the country to support foreign brand
names in such a simple consumer item has cassettes.
Viewed in this light, the government action is stated to be significant in extending protection
to the small-scale sector. Though no official statistics of production of cassettes for tape-
recorders are readily available, it is stated that demand for the item would amount to one
million.
It is also pointed out that the item has large demand potential at home and in foreign markets.
Since it is rather skill-oriented and highly labour-intensive, the government has been wanting
as a matter of policy to encourage production the small-scale sector.
In India, the input materials are subject to very high customs duties. Because of the split up
of the licenses presumably with a view to avoiding a monopoly situation. The scales of
operation are far lower in India than in countries overseas. Small volume of production has
engendered the use of manual techniques of production which pushes up costs. Though
wages may be comparatively lower in India than in
Western countries, the industry in India is plagued with lower productivity, labour unrest and
power shortage. These factors push up the cost substantially.
The electronic components industry in general and the picture tube industry in
particular, will need protection by way of import duties. The protection being given to the
electronic component industry is in no way different from the treatment accorded to other
engineering industry.
It would be impossible to grow in India an indigenous electronic components industry
without protection unless all inputs are available at international prices and unless production
is geared to international levels of operations. As electronic components are the building
bricks of the electronics industry, such growth should be nurtured.
A 20-inch TV receiver is available in the Western markets at about US $90. The cost
of components in a set would be of the order of US $60, including the cost of the picture
tube. Balance of US $30 covers assembly, testing, marketing, financing and profit, in India,
the build-up of the cost is as follows: price of components including the picture tube (Rs.
1285+ Rs. 80 towards freight and mortality) = Rs. 1,365.00; Cost of manufacture and
marketing including profit Rs. 235.00; Dealers commission is Rs.200; Excise on Rs. 1,600 is
Rs. 84; sales tax (10%) is Rs. 184.40; Total Rs. 2,072.40. this represents cheapest model
available today.
In western countries the cost of assembly, testing, marketing, financing and profit,
including dealer’s commission, amount to only US $30 or 435 in spite of the so-called cheap
labour.
A cost comparison of components available to the television industry in India as
against what television manufacturers in Western countries are able to obtain is given in the
Table below:
Item Western prices Indian Difference
Picture tube $ 18.00 405.00 24.00
Tuner (Rs.162.00) 125.00 89.00
Cabinet $ 4.00 (Rs. 125.00 80.00
Deflection 36.00)
components $ 5.00 (Rs. 100.00 68.50
Semi-conductors 45.00) 250.00 195.00
Passive components 180.00 -
Other components $ 3.50 (Rs. 100.00 28.00
31.50)
$ 6.00 (Rs.
54.00)
$ 20.00 (Rs.
180.00)
$ 8.00 (Rs.
72.00)
$ 64.50 (Rs.
Total 1,285.50 704.50
580.50)
Notes: 1. Assumed US $ 1 = 9
2. Accessories like antenna and installation are extra and cost nearly Rs 200 in
Indian.
It will be seen that apart from the picture tube the other components are as expensive
A mass produced plastic cabinet will be available in Western countries to the TV receivers
industry at about US $ 5 whereas a wooden cabinet produced in India costs as much as Rs.
125. There is a feeling that as that as the wooden cabinets are made by the small-scale
industry, it would be advisable to stick to his approach. Cost reduction would be difficult
with such approaches. Again, in the case of tuners and deflection components, the Indian
price is nearly 3 to 4 times the price of similar components available overseas. Semi-
conductors are expensive.
Therefore, it is stated that it would not be appropriate to single out the picture tube as the
main culprit leading to the high cost of components for a television set. It would be necessary
to look at the cost structure of the electronic components industry in general for the answer.
It should be possible to produce a molded cabinet in Indian provided all the manufacturers
join together as a consortium and set up the necessary facilities or and MNC who has
considerable experience in the field is asked to produce the cabinet, it may protect the small-
scale industry at the expense of the consumers.
Unless the scales of operation for the other components increase and unless input raw
material are made available at international prices. It would be difficult for the electronic
components industry to bring down the prices t international level.
One may argue why a high cost electronic components industry should be supported
in India, and take the view that it may be advisable to import the components. The suggestion
may be valid when we are flush with foreign exchange. The situation was quite different a
few years back. In any case, for the healthy growth of the electronics industry it is essential
that the building bricks-electronic components-are made in the country. Industry’s attempt
should be towards policy which enables components to be made economically and it is
essential that all steps are taken no look into the difficulties of the electronic components
industry and remedy the same.
The glass shell for the picture tube is being imported and current c.i.f. price is about
Rs.80. An import duty of 75 per cent pushes up the cost to Rs. 140. Taking damage in transit
into account, the price per glass shell comes to Rs. 150. There is a freight element of Rs. 23
in the c.i.f. cost of Rs. 80. Duty is payable on freight and the element of freight cost plus duty
amounts to Rs.40 out of the total cost of Rs.150.
Question Bank
Introduction to Economics
Topic-1
7. The output, total cost data for a firm are given below .work out the following costs:
TFC, TVC, AFC, AVC, ATC, MC at various levels of ‘output’
Units of output: 0, 1, 2, 4, 5, 6,
TC : 120, 180, 200, 210, 225, 260, 330
8. Discuss briefly different cost concepts relevant to managerial decisions of planning
and control.
9. Discuss the various cost concepts relevant for decision-making at the
Firm level. Do you feel that ‘break-even analysis could be a useful tool to Indian
managers?
10. Define short run costs and long-run costs what is the practical usefulness of
distinguishing between them.
IV Profit analysis
1. Distinguish between risk and uncertainty.
2. Contrast briefly the various theories of profit regarding their explanation of the source
of profit.
3. Distinguish between economic profit and accounting profit with suitable examples.
4. Profit is the reward for risk-learning function of the enterprenuer.Examine critically.
V Pricing Markets and Competition
1. What are the main features of pure competition? How does a firm adjust its policies
to a purely competitive situation?
2. How does the equilibrium of the firm under perfect competition differ from that of a
monopolist?
3. Explain the following propositions?
If demand rises, prices goes up.
If supply rises, prices goes down.
If both demand and supply increase increase sales are bound to increase, but
price may or may not.
VI Pricing
1. How does consumer behavior affect. Pricing policies.
2. Critically examine price as a weapon of competition.
3. What is the most important group or individual factors which influence the price of a
product?
4. Discuss the different methods of pricing products and state the method that would be
adopted by a firm under monopolistic completion.
5. Would you prefer a low penetration price to a high & initial price for a new product?
6. What is meant by price discrimination? What are its objectives? Is price discrimination
anti-docial?
7. What are the advantages and limitations of marginal pricing?
8. Explain the method of cost plus pricing and state its limitations.
The reason for this change in strategy is not very difficult to understand. Though
there were only three major players in the Indian aviation market, namely Jet Airways (JA),
Air Sahara (Sahara), and the state-owned Indian Airlines (IA), competition was getting
fiercer by the day. To counter the competition, the companies had to resort to pricing wars.
It started in June 2002 when IA announced a 3-15% cut in fares for all classes on the
western sector and on Delhi-Srinagar, Delhi-Jammu, and Delhi-Khajuraho route. The next
day, JA reduced its prices by Rs.635 for the economy class on the Mumbai-Nagpur route and
the Mumbai-Goa route.
One of the most innovative offers (following the global aviation industry’s footsteps)
was the advanced Purchase Excursion (APEX) fares scheme. Under which passengers who
booked their tickets at least three weeks in advance, got a huge discount in fares. IA
introduced the APEX fares under its ‘U can Fly’ scheme and JA under the ‘Everyone Can
Fly’ scheme.
However, passengers had to face two disadvantages under the APEX scheme.
Planning air travel three weeks in advance was not very convenient. Cancellation charges
were also high. Passengers had to lose 50% of the ticket price if the ticket was canceled less
than 21 days before the travel date. Despite these disadvantages, the scheme proved very
successful for IA. Around 1,600 passengers fly every day under the scheme. Revenue
generation and passenger load factor have also increased.
JA also reported an increase in the number of passengers flying after the introduction
of APEX fares. Saroj Dutt, Executive Director, JA, said, “The average number of passengers
flying out on advance purchase tickets is around 1,500 per day. That means we are selling
most of the 1,850-2,000 seats offered every day under the concessional window. The
response is very encouraging for a scheme which has been introduced only recently”.
In March 2002, Sahara launched a unique ‘Wings & Wheels’ scheme in the metros-
Delhi, Mumbai, Kolkata, and Chennai. The scheme offered complementary air-conditioned
coach services for picking up passengers at designated points in the cities and dropping them
at the airport, the coaches also dropped passengers from the airport at certain locations within
the city, the coach with attended on board, offered add-ons like magazines, newspapers,
mineral water, soft drinks, and other refreshments.
During July-August, Sahara launched the ‘Sixer’ offer, a limited scheme for all
passengers, which enabled the passengers to buy a six-flight coupon ticket and fly any six
sectors on the carrier’s network for Rs. 25,000. The validity of the ticket was till December
2002. Analysts felt that the scheme was successful became of the flexibility it offered. If one
planned properly, the price of the tickets would work out to less than the APEX fares offered
by IA and JA.
However, what attracted the most attention from industry observes was Sahara’s
‘steal a seat’ online bid scheme in August 2002, Under the scheme, the base price for the
tickets was kept at Re 1, and the scheme was open to passengers flying 25 days later, For
unsuccessful bidders, there was another scheme called the ‘Steal Buys’ scheme under which
they could bid 24 -15 days in advance at a reserve price, which could work out much cheaper
than the APEX fares offered by IA and JA. Sahara also offered the Delhi-Mumbai tickets for
Rs.4,000 if it was bought between 15-19 days in advance, whereas IA and JA charged at Rs.
5,535 and Rs.5, 405 respectively for the same time period.
On August 15, 2002, IA launched the scheme ‘wings of Freedom,’ valid from August
15 to March 31, 2003. This scheme offered unlimited travel on the domestic network for
seven days for Rs. 15,000 (economy class) and Rs. 20,000 (business class. The airline also
planned to increase the commission of its agents and offer incentives for the most productive
agents. At the same time, it also launched the ‘Bharat Darshan,’ (India tour) which allowed
unlimited travel for passengers who bought tickets worth more than Rs. 80,000.
Industry observers remarked that the most interesting feature of the price war in 2002
was that Sahara, the smallest of the Big Three, was the most aggressive. Apart from
launching the novel bid schemes, it also offered the highest agent commission to increase
volumes of the tickets sold, while maintaining the lowest fares. Moreover, while IA and JA
were expected to revert to the original prices at the end of the learn season, i.e., October,
many of Sahara’s schemes would stretch till the year-end.
Though the fare war is not expected to end very soon. Analysts feel it will affect the
financial stability of the private carriers in the long run. While IA owns the aircraft and is
funded by the government, both the private carriers survive on leased aircraft. This lowers
their margins and makes it difficult for them to sustain these costs in the long run.
Some analysts feel that it is too early to predict the impact of the price war. Though
the number of passengers increased in 2002 as compared to 2001, it was mainly attributed to
school holidays and increase in the number of business travelers.