Phase Change Materials for Thermal Storage
Phase Change Materials for Thermal Storage
Indian Journal of Science and Technology, Vol 10(13), DOI: 10.17485/ijst/2017/v10i13/112365, April 2017 ISSN (Online) : 0974-5645
Abstract
Objective: The purpose of this review leads to use of Energy conservation technologies. Methods: There are so many
systems which are used for energy saving among them thermal storage system with Phase Change Material (PCM) is well
known. In this review majority focuses on the human comforts. It was observed that maintaining the human comfort is
the challenging task for living spaces like room, offices etc. such type of required energy which is satisfied by thermal
storage PCM based system. If the Phase change materials are applied to building applications they can be used for peak
load shifting in cool storage system. Findings: Development of the new techniques for getting thermal comfort for building
(lowering the heating and cooling demand is required. Also it includes the expenses behind development, maintenance
and installation. Moreover this review finds the effective phase change materials. Improvements: Such thermal storage
system has a potential to replace the conventional methods but the effectiveness or efficiency of that system is less. So it is
required improvement in the selection of thermal storage system and phase change material. Also this review presents the
potential of the phase change material system.
Keywords: Energy Conservation Technologies, Phase Change Materials, Space Heating and Cooling, Thermal Energy
Storage System
1. Introduction energy. As there is always need to find new methods for
storing or saving the energy. One of the important and
Energy has played an important role in advancing tech- best methods for storing the energy is use of thermal
nology. It has also helped in conserving the many natural storage by Phase Change Material (PCM). Latent Heat
resources. But as time has passed the use of energy has Storage (LHS) is one of the most effective methods for
become more. There has been developing many methods storing the energy and reusing it whenever needed2.
of saving the energy which is wasted in lots of propor- PCM are materials which has ability to store the heat
tion1. Many methods such as solar energy storage, hydro energy and release them. It absorbs the latent heat from
energy storage etc. are been developed for conserving the surrounding and releases it when temperature falls3.
2 Vol 10 (13) | April 2017 | www.indjst.org Indian Journal of Science and Technology
Jaykumar H. Patel, P. H. Darji and M. N. Qureshi
In Figure 3 the PCM (passive) is installed inside the basically for free heating and cooling because this tech-
wall of the buildings. These types of technologies contain nology has renewable sources devices for generating the
PCM insulated in it. heating and cooling in the building. Such system has the
drawback of high initial cost of installation.
1.2 Active Technology Finally thermal energy storage system with phase
change material is the best technology to save the energy
This technology is most appropriate and unique solution
and free heating and cooling of building space. Also
for free heating and cooling application of building. This
system can meet the requirement of energy supply and
active system can basically working based on renewable
demand. Also this paper explores the literature survey,
sources like Photovoltaic system, solar panels etc. In this
classification, properties and its applications etc.
technology the insulation of TES in building can be done
in crux of the building for example, floor and walls. With
the help of TES in active technology we can achieve free 2. A Systematic Survey of Phase
cooling, when the building the charged with low tempera- Change Material based System
tures at night and this stored energy is discharged when
there is necessary. However this active system is not lim- for Energy Conservation
ited to new building but it can be installed with existing
To save the energy and to meet the supply and demand of
buildings which is also giving the most efficient results in
required energy for heating and cooling of the building or
energy saving9. This system can help to save the energy
space such PCM based technologies are most appropriate
during pick load period so heating and cooling of build-
as dissected in previous section. Such technology develop-
ing space should be achieved up to sufficient level.
ment is continuously growing to protect the environment
and convection energy sources. As briefly discussed in the
Table 1 PCM based system is one of the optimum solu-
tion among the energy conservation system2. Also recent
development in thermal energy storage systems are the
most promising and user-friendly technology for space
heating and cooling. Table 1 show an extensive review
of PCM based system integrated with buildings. However
this literature survey includes PCMs are installed into the
various building components and shows its effectiveness.
From the many different studies and experiments it has
been concluded that the PCM installed buildings has good
thermal conditioning than other technologies. Moreover
it is also observed that the selection of PCM plays major
role in system efficiency. So classification, characteristics
Figure 4. Schematic Diagram of Active Technology. and its properties are discussed in next section.
Figure 4 is an example of active technology. This tech- 3. Energy Storage Methods
nique uses solar energy and helps in heating applications.
These are also common type of setup used now a day. Looking towards the global energy scenario, day by day
However, both technologies have merits and demerits demands of convection energy sources leads the high cost
based on their characteristics. Passive based technologies and shortage and greenhouse effect problems advice to
have good capacity of thermal stability and also reduced find out some alternate of the limited energy sources. To
the utilization of cooling and heating devices. But this sys- resolve such kind of problem renewable energy resources
tem has required high volume for PCM storage so for this are the vital source. However, these types of renewable
system gets leakage and other problems. Furthermore, to sources are intermittent in nature. Also these sources have
overcome such problems active system can be more suit- intensity variations characteristics for working in differ-
able for shifting peak load duration. Active system is used ent climate conditions and environment. Therefore such
Vol 10 (13) | April 2017 | www.indjst.org Indian Journal of Science and Technology 3
Phase Change Material with Thermal Energy Storage System and its Applications: A Systematic Review
4 Vol 10 (13) | April 2017 | www.indjst.org Indian Journal of Science and Technology
Jaykumar H. Patel, P. H. Darji and M. N. Qureshi
the energy is possible when the off pick hours or day. In Basically Thermal energy storage is divided in to three
this type of storage power can be easily discharge during parts, Sensible heat, latent heat and chemical energy.
pick hours because inadequate supply from the base- Where Sensible heat storage and Latent heat storage are
load plant. two parts in which thermal energy is stored by changing
the internal energy of the material used10. Sensible heat is
3.2 Electrical Energy Storage related to change in temperature. Energy can be stored by
increasing the temperature of a solid or liquid in Sensible
Electrical energy storage systems are most common stor-
heat storage. Specific heat, temperature change and quan-
age phenomenon. In this storage systems energy stored
tity of the material are the important factor that affects the
in to the batteries and supply. Battery is charge during
quantity of storage of heat in the material. But in compare
directly connected to the electrical sources. Also during
to sensible heat, chemical energy and latent heat, latent is
discharge the stored chemical energy is transformed in to
applicable in PCM11.
electrical energy. Electrical energy storage through bat-
teries is widely used in load levelling, off-peak power and
photovoltaic plants. Ni–Cd and lead acid batteries are the
most common types for electrical storage. CPdT=mCap(Tf-Ti)(1)
Vol 10 (13) | April 2017 | www.indjst.org Indian Journal of Science and Technology 5
Phase Change Material with Thermal Energy Storage System and its Applications: A Systematic Review
storage system is used with phase change materials will 4.1 Classification of Phase Change Material
satisfy the domestic energy requirements.
Basically there are three types of phase change materi-
Normally design and construction of latent heat stor-
als which includes; 1. Organic Materials, 2. Inorganic
age is of PCM, working fluid and an appropriate well
Materials and 3. Eutectic Materials. The brief descrip-
designed heat exchanger. These systems process consist
tion of the each classification is mention in below
of thermodynamic cycle in which progressive melting
section10. Figure 6 indicates the types of Phase change
(charging) and solidification (discharging) is to be done.
material.
Several studies have been carried out on phase change
materials characteristics, selection, classification, its
design and construction, its applications and appropriate 4.1.1 Organic Phase Change Materials
techniques for heat exchange. This type of PCM classify in to paraffin and non-paraffin.
Phase-change heat transfer problems are relevant Majority Phase change materials (PCMs) are character-
both to the storage of thermal energy from intermittent ized by their capability to freeze and melt under the
source such as the sun and to various processes in geo- different temperature condition. Paraffin is saturated
physics and technology. hydrocarbons from CnH2n+2 groups12. It has very simi-
lar properties in which C5 and C15 paraffin are in liquid
state and others are in wax solid state. The paraffin wax
4. PCM Classification, contains the straight chain hydrocarbons and it has low
melting temperature in the range of 23°C to 70°C. So
Characteristics, Its Selection
paraffin wax is most effective PCM for domestic appli-
for Efficient System and cations. Similarly non paraffin organic phase change
Applications materials have various properties. The review states that
it includes alcohols, glycols are used for thermal energy
There are several types of materials are invented storage13.
among them few has characteristics of change in its
phase according to the different temperature. Every
material has own properties to change its phase dur-
ing change in temperature. Furthermore latent heat
and thermal conductivity is various for different
materials. It is found that the main demerit of the
phase change material is their low thermal conductiv-
ity. Due to this reason heat transfer rate goes down.
As described in previous section selected PCMs have
suitable temperature range for particular application. Figure 6. Classification of Phase Change Material.
In reality there is no standard material to be utilised
for PCM systems because each material has its own 4.1.2 Inorganic Phase Change Materials
merits and demerits. Salt hydrates and metallic are the classification of inorganic
Moreover phase change materials are used for ther- Phase change materials. In salt hydrates contain the water
mal energy storage purpose so more attention is required and salt. This combination of water and salt create the crys-
due to large capacity of storage. Metallic alloys, inorganic talline matrix after getting the solidification. Salt hydrates
salts undergo reversible phase transformation, organic are available in different types of melting temperature ranges
paraffin are the significant parameters of phase change between 15°C to 117°C. Salt hydrates have unique charac-
materials. Such system can be used for building or space teristics of latent heat thermal storage so it is used in PCMs.
heating because of its isothermal behaviour during pro- Due to segregation in hydrates and dehydrates salts reduces
cess. The efficient system latent heat storage is desirable its volume for thermal energy storage. In thermal energy
when the small temperature changes. This is only hap- storage metallic containers are used for storage purpose
pened because of its phase change enthalpy, high storage but corrosion caused due to salt hydrates. Likewise metal
density etc. eutectics and low melting metals are the parts of metallic14.
6 Vol 10 (13) | April 2017 | www.indjst.org Indian Journal of Science and Technology
Jaykumar H. Patel, P. H. Darji and M. N. Qureshi
Metallic materials as a PCM survey are limited due to its Table 2. Different types of PCMs
high melting temperature and heavy weight. However such Name Type Melting
materials are used where weight is not a major parameter Temperature
and only focuses on the volume. Also these materials have in ºC
Low specific heat and High heat of fusion per unit volume. Lauric Acid Organic 44.2
Paraffin carbons Organic 5.5 to 75.9
4.1.2 Eutectics
Formic Acid Organic 7.5
The eutectics comprise of at least two segments where
Caprilic acid Organic 16.3
each of them melts and stops consistently framing a blend
Glycerin Organic 17.9
of a segment that precious stone amid crystallization
prepare. For the most part, eutectics liquefy and solidify Paraffin 18 carbons Organic 28
without isolation. Amid dissolving process, both parts p-Lattic acid Organic 26
melt in the meantime without probability of partition. Methyl palmitate Organic 29
Finally it would be concluded that organic materials Paraffin 19 carbons Organic 32
are not super cool and are chemically stable, also they are Methyl eicosanate Organic 45
non-acidic. The latent heat fusion is very high. Inorganic Methyl fumarate Organic 59.5
compounds are corrosive and are not easily available. They
Diphenyl amine Organic 102
also undergo super cooling and decomposition rate is
NaNO3 Inorganic 310
very high. Most of inorganic materials are salt hydrated15.
From discussed in previous section materials organic NaNO2 Inorganic 282
materials are selected as these materials are cheap in cost, Na2SO 10H2O
4
.
Inorganic 32.4
are more corrosion resistance, are easily available and KOH Inorganic 360
have low thermal conductivity. So it is better to select the NaCl Inorganic 284
organic material than inorganic. Zinc Inorganic 420
KNO3 Inorganic 337
4.2 Characteristics and its Selection for Titanium Inorganic 1500
Efficient System Na2SiO3·5H2O Inorganic 72.2
Selections of Phase change materials are important part to Silver Inorganic 961.78
developed efficient thermal storage systems. There are dif-
ferent types of PCMs available in Organic and Inorganic 4.2.2 Chemical Properties
form. Some of them are listed in Table 2. Chemical properties are the important due to their chemi-
Different types of PCM with their melting points are cal reaction with different material and atmosphere
shown in Table 2. Generally Organic PCMs have low condition. Among all such properties like non-corrosive,
melting points and Inorganic PCMs have high melting on-flammable, No phase separation or chemical decom-
point. Organic PCMs are less corrosive then that of inor- position, Chemical stability after many cycles of operation,
ganic due less proportion of water content. Following are No degradation after many cycles of operation and non-
the desirable characteristics and properties. toxic are to be considered during selection. As discussed
in above section selection of PCMs are the vital factor for
4.2.1 Thermo Physical Properties the thermal storage system. Also it is observed that the cost
and availability of material should be Abundant and Cheap.
This characteristic includes high thermal conductivity in
both liquid and solid phases, high density, No sub cooling
during freezing, Phase change temperature fitted to the
4.3 Applications of PCMs
application, Low volume change during the phase change, PCMs help in storage of thermal energy, solar cook-
Low density variation during phase change, High latent ing, cold energy battery, ice storage i.e. conditioning of
heat of fusion per unit mass, High value of specific heat to buildings, keeping the heat and electrical engines cool
give additional benefits of sensible heat storage. also in Medical such as blood transportation, hot-cold
Vol 10 (13) | April 2017 | www.indjst.org Indian Journal of Science and Technology 7
Phase Change Material with Thermal Energy Storage System and its Applications: A Systematic Review
therapies15. They can be applicable in spacecraft ther- was easy and economic with sufficient heat transfer. Portable
mal systems, protection of electrical devices from heat, heat storage system was possible with micro-encapsulation18.
Computer cooling, turbine inlet chilling with thermal In this method PCM were placed in a protective coating.
energy storage, Shelter for telecom in various tropical System was also known as phase change slurry (PCS). Figure
regions16. Figure 7 shows comparison of rock water and 8 shows the micro-encapsulation.
reinforce concrete cement storage capacity.
8 Vol 10 (13) | April 2017 | www.indjst.org Indian Journal of Science and Technology
Jaykumar H. Patel, P. H. Darji and M. N. Qureshi
Vol 10 (13) | April 2017 | www.indjst.org Indian Journal of Science and Technology 9
Phase Change Material with Thermal Energy Storage System and its Applications: A Systematic Review
17. Moreno P, Sole C, Castell A, Cabeza LF. The use of 20. Heinz A, Streicher W, editors. Application of phase change
phase change materials in domestic heat pump and air- materials and PCM-slurries for thermal energy storage.
conditioning systems for short term storage: A review. New Jersey: Proceedings of the ECOSTOC Conference,
Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews. 2014; 39:1–13. Session 12B-Transportation of Energy. 2006; p. 1–8.
Crossref 21. Demirbas MF. Thermal energy storage and phase
18. Abedin AH, Rosen MA. A critical review of thermochemi- change materials: an overview. Energy Sources, Part
cal energy storage systems. The Open Renewable Energy B: Economics, Planning, and Policy. 2006; 1(1):85–95.
Journal. 2011; 4(1):42–46. Crossref Crossref
19. Ravikumar M, Srinivasan P. Natural Cooling of Building
using Phase Change Material. International Journal of
Engineering and Technology. 2008; 5(1):1–10.
10 Vol 10 (13) | April 2017 | www.indjst.org Indian Journal of Science and Technology