Recycling Plastic Marine Litter Guide
Recycling Plastic Marine Litter Guide
NOWPAP
Northwest Pacific Action Plan
October 2007
Prepared in 2007
by the Special Monitoring and Coastal Environmental Assessment Regional Activity Centre
of the Northwest Pacific Action Plan
(NOWPAP CEARAC)
Established at the Northwest Pacific Region Environmental Cooperation Center (NPEC)
5-5 Tower111 6th floor, Ushijimashin-machi, Toyama City, Toyama 930-0856 JAPAN
TEL: +81-76-445-1571 FAX: +81-76-445-1581
Website:http://cearac.nowpap.org/
E-mail: [email protected]
Acknowledgments
This booklet was prepared by NOWPAP CEARAC within the framework of the Marine Litter Activity
th
(MALITA) project, which was approved by the 10 NOWPAP Intergovernmental Meeting in November
2005. This booklet is based on “Research Report of Marine Litter Recyclability 2007” published by
1. Introduction ...................................................................................... 1
Marine litter is a serious global problem, and is known to have significant environmental,
economic, health and aesthetic impacts. In many cases, plastics are one of the most
abundant components of marine litter, mainly due to its very slow rate of degradation and
ever-increasing uses in our society. Figure 1 summarizes the findings of the marine litter
survey conducted along the Japanese coast of the NOWPAP region in 2004.
Glass/ceramic
2.8% Metal
Cloth
0.2% 0.6%
Paper Other
0.3% 1.0%
Expanded
polystyrene
18.0%
Rubber
0.3%
Plastics
76.8%
The figure shows that almost 80% of the marine litter found was comprised of plastic
products, and if we include expanded polystyrene, the proportion of plastic products would
be almost 95%.
Although various countermeasures are now being implemented to remove plastic litter
from the sea coast, such as beach clean-up activities, installation of marine litter
containment booms and so on, significant problems still persist in treating/disposing of the
collected litter. Common approaches include landfill and incineration, but these methods
are not always ideal solutions due to limited landfill space and pollution risks.
One possible solution to the treatment of plastic marine litter is to apply the
technologies of plastic recycling, which is now commonly employed to treat industrial and
domestic waste plastics. For example, marine waste plastics can be recycled into plastic
raw material, fuel oil, chemical feedstock and other products (see Chapter 3).
This booklet has been prepared, in recognition of the benefits of plastic waste recycling,
to introduce the existing and developing plastic recycling technologies with the potential
application for managing plastic marine litter. The booklet also describes some issues
involved in recycling plastic marine litter, with some suggestions (see Chapter 4).
Although many types of plastic are currently manufactured for a variety of purposes, the
raw material of these plastics is mainly derived from petroleum products, such as naphtha,
which are extracted from crude-oil distillation.
Since these polymers are in powder or lump form, they are usually processed into
pellets for easier handling. The final plastic product is then manufactured by processing
(e.g. molding) the plastic pellets into various shapes and forms.
2.2 Types and characteristics of plastics
Plastics can be broadly classified into two groups: thermoplastics and thermosetting
plastics. Thermoplastics can be repeatedly softened by heating and hardened by cooling,
like candle wax. For this reason, thermoplastics can be remolded and reused almost
indefinitely. Many types of thermoplastic products are manufactured to suit a wide range of
purposes, such as for packaging, food containers and household products. More
heat-resistant and durable thermoplastics are used in machines, automobiles and
electrical goods.
Conversely, thermosetting plastics harden permanently after being heated. They are
mainly used for products that require high heat resistance, because these plastics can be
heated to high temperatures without melting. Table 1 shows some of the common
thermoplastics and thermosetting plastics, and their main uses.
Table 1 Thermoplastics and thermosetting plastics and their main uses
Plastic type Abbreviation Main uses
construction sheeting
resin
lens
resin
Plastic recycling technologies can be typically classified into three methods: material
recycling (or mechanical recycling), chemical recycling (or feedstock recycling) and
thermal recycling (or energy recovery) 1 . General descriptions of the three recycling
methods are provided in the following sections, and specific examples of each are given.
Table 2 shows the recycling examples introduced in this Booklet.
Material recycling
1 Industrial PE and PP waste plastics Plastic pellets (used to produce other
plastic products)
2 Waste fishing nets Plastic pellets
3 Waste EPS floats Polystyrene ingots (used to produce
other plastic products)
4 Waste ABS floats New ABS floats
Chemical recycling
5 Waste EPS products Polystyrene pellets (new EPS products)
6 Waste PE and PP products Aromatics (raw material for chemical
and medical products) and lower olefin
(raw material of plastics)
7 Waste polyester products Dimethyl terephthalate and ethylene
glycol (raw material for plastics)
8 Tolylene diisocyanate (TDI) residues Toluenediamine (raw material for TDI)
(TDI: raw material of polyurethane)
9 Domestic waste plastics Fuel oil
10 Waste PE, PP, PS plastics Fuel oil
11 Low-grade oil produced from waste High-grade oil
plastic recycling
12 Domestic and industrial waste plastics Reducing agent of blast furnaces
13 Waste vinyl chloride products Hydrocarbons (reducing agents for blast
furnaces), hydrogen chloride (used by
1
These terms (material recycling, chemical recycling and thermal recycling) will be used in this
booklet, although other terms might be used elsewhere.
the steel and chemical industries)
14 Waste plastics except for vinyl chloride Coke (reducing agent for blast
plastics furnaces), hydrocarbon oil (chemical
feedstock for plastic manufacturing),
coke oven gas (power generation)
15 All types of waste plastics Synthetic gas (hydrogen, carbon
monoxide)
Thermal recycling
16 Various wastes, including plastics Fuel for power plants
17 Industrial and domestic waste plastics, Refuse Paper and Plastic Fuel (RPF)
wastepaper, wastewood used as fuel for power, paper, steel and
cement plants
18 Industrial waste plastics Fuel for cement manufacturing
19 Old or abandoned small FRP (Fiber Fuel for cement manufacturing
Reinforced Plastic) vessels
3.1 Material recycling
Material recycling is a method where waste plastics are reprocessed into a similar or
different plastic product without modifying the initial chemical structure. In this process,
waste plastics are initially processed into ingots or pellets through melting, shredding or
granulation. The ingots or pellets are then processed into new plastic products. Figure 3
shows some examples of plastic products generated through material recycling.
To produce high quality pellets or ingots, waste plastics must be sorted into the same
plastic type prior to the processing stage. Impurities, dirt and foreign objects must also be
removed. For these reasons, material recycling has mainly targeted industrial waste
plastics because they are clearly separated into plastic type, contain low levels of
impurities and are available in large quantities. On the other hand, more contaminated
plastics such as in the domestic waste are usually, hard to differentiate and the supplies
are unstable. However, the recycling rate of domestic plastic wastes such as PET bottles
and food trays are increasing due to the establishment of new laws/regulations and
advancements in recycling technology.
Contents
Recycling
Products
Recycled Products
Contents
Recycling Process
Contents
Contents
Recycling Process
Pellets mixed with virgin pellets at a 4:6 ratio
- ABS floats are collected when they become old and are recycled
into new ABS floats
- Virgin pellets are mixed to achieve the required float quality
- Attached marine organisms are removed by sun drying
Remarks - Fishermen often revert to other convenient disposal methods,
such as landfill, because they must bear the transportation cost
to the recycling plant
- Feasible only if the price of virgin pellet is higher than the
recycled pellets
3.2 Chemical recycling
In chemical recycling, waste plastics are recycled as, among other products, plastic raw
material, fuel oil and industrial feedstock, which is achieved by altering the chemical
structure through various chemical processes. Chemical recycling methods include
monomerization, liquefaction, blast furnace feedstock recycling, coke oven chemical
feedstock recycling and gasification.
Monomerization
With monomerization, waste plastics are initially broken down into their constituent
monomers by chemical reaction (depolymerization). These monomers are then extracted
for use as the raw material in new plastic products.
Monomerization produces higher quality plastic raw materials than material recycling,
which in turn enables the production of high-quality plastic products with the same (or
almost the same) quality as virgin raw material. Among other products, this enables the
recycling of waste PET bottles into new PET bottles, which is not possible with other
recycling technologies.
Liquefaction
Liquefaction is a recycling method where waste plastics are reverted to their original oil
form. Common liquefaction methods usually apply heat (ca. 400 ºC) and catalysis to break
down plastics into oil. With this method, chloride must be removed prior to liquefaction so
as to prevent dioxin emissions and furnace corrosion.
The quality of the oil produced from waste plastic liquefaction is usually dependant on
the properties of the waste plastics. Low-quality oil is usually used as fuel oil, which is
currently the most common option. High-quality oil can be used as raw material by the
petrochemical industry. Technologies to upgrade low-quality oil are also available.
In blast furnace feedstock recycling, waste plastics are used as a reducing agent in iron
ore processing. Although coke is usually used as a reducing agent, plastic can be used as
an alternative because its main constituents are carbon, which removes the oxygen from
iron oxide.
Coke oven chemical feedstock recycling utilizes waste plastics to make coke (usually
coal is used to produce coke). Hydrocarbon oil and coke oven gas are produced as
by-products, which are used as chemical feedstock and power generation, respectively.
Except for vinyl chloride plastics, both thermoplastics and thermosetting plastics can be
used for this recycling method.
Gasification
Gasification is a recycling method where waste plastics are processed into gases such
as carbon monoxide, hydrogen and hydrogen chloride. These gases are then used as the
chemical raw material for the production of chemicals such as methanol and ammonia.
Almost all types of plastics, including those containing chlorine, can be recycled under
the gasification method. This method is therefore suitable for miscellaneous plastics or
plastics that are hard to sort. Slag is produced as a by-product, which can be utilized as
raw material for civil engineering works and construction materials.
Table 5 summarizes the chemical recycling examples introduced in the following section.
Each example is introduced in Tables 6.1-6.11.
Contents
Recycled Product
Polystyrene pellets
1) Waste EPS products are put into a limonene containing tank
2) Waste EPS products are dissolved by limonene and turned
into a polystyrene-limonene solution
3) Foreign objects in the polystyrene-limonene solution are
removed by filtering
4) The polystyrene-limonene solution is heated inside a vacuum
chamber to approximately 180 °C, the boiling point of
Recycling Process limonene.
5) The vaporized limonene is extracted from the chamber,
leaving behind only polystyrene
6) The extracted limonene is reused for the above processes
7) The remaining polystyrene is transformed to a cooling
chamber, and converted back to a solid form
8) The solid polystyrene is then cut into small pellets (ca. 3 mm)
for processing into new EPS products
- Limonene is extracted from orange peel, and so the recycling
process is safe and environmentally friendly
- Limonene dissolves EPS at room temperature, and so the
recycling process is less energy intensive than other methods
- With this method, new EPS can be manufactured with 100%
Remarks
recycled polystyrene, whereas around 70% virgin polystyrene is
required for other methods
- High-quality recycled EPS can be produced with this method―
no change in heat resistance and durability
- The capital cost of the recycling facility is relatively high
Table 6.2 Examples of chemical recycling (2)
Contents
Contents
Contents
Contents
Recycling Process
Contents
Recycling Process
Contents
Contents
Contents
Contents
Recycling Process
Contents
Thermal recycling utilizes the heat energy produced from combustion of waste plastic.
The heat energy can be used for various purposes, including power generation and
cement manufacturing.
Although power plants often rely on fossil fuels (coal and oil) for their energy source,
power plants that use waste as an energy source are becoming a popular alternative.
Waste plastics are good energy sources for these plants because they have a high
calorific value, similar to that of coal and oil.
Waste plastic can also be mixed with wastepaper and wastewood to produce fuel pellets
called RPF (Refuse Paper & Plastic Fuel). RPF has a high calorific value and thus can be
used as an alternative energy source to fossil fuels. RPF can also be produced at a low
cost and is currently in high demand by the paper, steel and cement industries.
Although coal has traditionally been used as a fuel in the cement manufacturing process,
waste plastics can be used as an alternative energy source due to their high calorific value.
The process sludge can also be utilized as cement raw material.
Table 7 summarizes the thermal recycling examples introduced in the following section.
Each example is introduced in Table 8.1-8.4.
Contents
Type of Recycling Utilization of waste plastics as fuel for re-powering power plants
Recycling Product Various wastes including plastics
Recycled Product Electricity
- Re-powering power plants generate electricity using both gas
and waste
- Re-powering power plants utilize the waste heat (ca. 500 ºC)
generated from the gas turbine to superheat the steam
generated from the waste incinerator boiler
- As a result, the power generation efficiency of the steam turbine
increases significantly
Recycling Process
Contents
Contents
Contents
Technical issues
z Since marine litter includes various plastic types, the collected litter must be sorted
into the same plastic types for recycling
z Even for the same plastic types, the composition or quantity of additives used may
differ among plastic manufacturers. In this case, recycling must be conducted
separately
z Materials of some plastic marine litter are difficult to identify, making it hard to select
the appropriate recycling method
z Painted and specially coated plastic must be pretreated (i.e. removal of painting and
coating) prior to recycling
z Foreign objects, such as sand, dirt and marine organisms, must be removed prior to
recycling
z The quality of some plastic marine litter may be unsuitable for recycling due to
degradation by marine environment exposure, including ultraviolet radiation
Economic issues
Contrary to material and chemical recycling, thermal recycling of plastic marine litter
does not require rigorous sorting, and plastics can be mixed with other wastes. However,
some general issues still remain such as:
z Plastics with high moisture and salt content are unsuitable for incineration because of
possible damage to the furnace
z Some plastics (e.g. plastics coated with flame retardant) may emit harmful chemical
substances when incinerated
z Further treatment of incineration ash is required in some cases
As described above, various technical and economic issues arise when recycling plastic
marine litter. Although some of these issues may be solved by technical advancements,
other issues are harder to solve because they are influenced by less controllable factors,
such as fluctuation of raw material prices, lack of demand for recycled material, lack of
recycling plants, high recycling costs and so on.
However, in spite of these technical and economic issues, recycling of plastic marine
litter should be encouraged because it is the only environmentally-sound alternative to
landfill or incineration. Recycling should also become a more feasible option, as our
society shift towards a more recycling-oriented structure.