Value Chain and Competitive Strategy
Value Chain and Competitive Strategy
Presented to:
Dr. Reham Adel
Table of Contents
1. Introduction....................................................................................................................2
2. Porter’s Value Chain Analysis of Amazon.com............................................................3
2.1 Primary Activities.......................................................................................................4
2.1.1 Inbound Logistics....................................................................................................4
2.1.2 Operations...............................................................................................................4
2.1.3 Outbound Logistics.................................................................................................4
2.1.4 Marketing and Sales...............................................................................................5
2.1.5 Services....................................................................................................................5
2.2 Secondary Activities...................................................................................................5
2.2.1 Infrastructure..........................................................................................................6
2.2.2 Human Resource Management..............................................................................6
2.2.3 Technology Development.......................................................................................6
2.2.4 Procurement............................................................................................................6
3. Amazon Sustainable Competitive Advantage...............................................................7
4. Cost Advantage of Amazon com....................................................................................8
4.1 Cost advantage through Value Chain Analysis........................................................8
4.2 Cost drivers of Amazon com Inc Value Chain Analysis..........................................8
5. Company Differentiation Advantage............................................................................9
5.1 Differentiation through Initial Value Chain Activities............................................9
5.2 Differentiation through secondary value chain activities.......................................10
6. Recommendations Based on Value Chain Analysis...................................................10
7. Amazon Growth strategies...........................................................................................12
7.1 Application of Michael Porters Generic/Intensive Growth Strategies to Amazon
com 12
7.1.1 Streams for Porter’s generic strategies...............................................................13
7.1.1.1 Cost Leadership....................................................................................................13
7.1.1.1.1 How does Amazon com use the cost leadership strategy?..............................13
7.1.1.2 Differentiation.......................................................................................................14
7.1.1.2.1 How does Amazon com use a differentiation strategy?..................................14
7.1.1.2.2 Focus Strategy...................................................................................................14
7.1.2 Intensive growth strategies...................................................................................15
7.1.2.1 What are Intensive Growth Strategies?..............................................................15
7.1.2.2 Amazon aims to use intense growth strategies....................................................15
7.1.2.3 Market penetration (basic strategy)....................................................................15
Page 1
7.1.2.4 Product development (secondary strategy).........................................................16
7.1.2.5 Market Development (Supportive Strategy).......................................................17
7.1.2.6 Diversification (supportive strategy)...................................................................18
8. References.....................................................................................................................19
Page 2
1. Introduction
Amazon.com Inc can identify various internal and external links between
activities through the lens of the value chain. Internal links are the
interrelationships between activities within the same organizational units
and external links between the business units of the same or different
companies. Studying these mutual relationships can help the company
benefit from coordination and mutual improvement.
Page 3
unexpected outage in the flow of information can affect the
relationship between a customer and a supplier. Amazon com Inc
can analyze the value chain and implement highlighting and
eliminating bottlenecks in the flow of information.
The Porter Value Chain Model is very popular in the business world.
However, Amazon.com must not take it as a rigid and independent framework
by giving equal importance to all activities. Effective value chain analysis
requires Amazon com Inc to be aware that not all activities or functions
require the same level of audit. Thus, the first step to adapting the Porter value
chain framework is to determine the relevance of activities according to their
role in the product / service delivery process.
Page 4
2.1.1 Inbound Logistics
It is important to develop strong relationships with suppliers as
their support is necessary to receive, store and distribute the
product. Without analyzing internal logistics, Amazon com Inc
could face various challenges in the product development stages.
The internal logistics analysis requires the company to focus on
every aspect of the transition from raw materials to the final
product. Some examples of incoming logistics services are
recovery of raw materials, storage of inputs and distribution of raw
materials and components internally to start production.
2.1.2 Operations
Analysis of operational activities becomes more important when
raw materials arrive, and Amazon.com. is ready to process raw
materials in the final product and release it to the market. Some
examples of operational activities are machinery, packaging,
assembly, and testing. Equipment repair and maintenance also fall
into this category.
It includes both manufacturing and service operations. An analysis
of operational activities is important to improve productivity,
increase efficiency, and ensure competitive success for
Amazon.com. Increased productivity can help Amazon.com
achieve consistent economic growth, increase profitability, and
establish a strong foundation for competitive advantage.
Page 5
sales activities. Sales agents and marketers play an important role
here.
Some examples of Amazon com Inc marketing and sales activities
are - sales force, advertising, promotional activities, pricing,
channel selection, quotation, and building relationships with
channel members. The company can use the marketing suppression
approach to structure its marketing and sales activities. Marketing
strategies can be either push or pull in nature, depending on
Amazon com Inc business goals, brand image, competitive
dynamics, and current market position.
Effective and wisely integrated marketing activities can develop
Amazon com Inc brand ownership and help them differentiate from
competition. However, Amazon com Inc should avoid making false
commitments about product features that the production
department cannot achieve. Indicates the need to ensure
coordination between different value chain activities
2.1.5 Services
Amazon.com's pre-sale and aftersales services will play an
important role in developing customer loyalty. Modern customers
consider after-sales services as important as marketing and
promotional activities. The negative power of electronic women
cannot be undermined due to the weak support service of today's
technologically advanced era. The company should analyze its
support activities to avoid damaging the brand's reputation, and
instead use it as a tool for spreading positive word of mouth due to
the prompt, timely and effective support services.
2.2.1 Infrastructure
The company's infrastructure refers to a set of activities, such as:
quality management, legal issues handling, accounting, financing,
planning and strategic management. Effective infrastructure
management can allow Amazon com Inc to improve the value of
the entire value chain. Amazon com Inc can control infrastructure
activities (or commonly called overhead costs) to enhance the
competitive position in the market.
Page 6
2.2.2 Human Resource Management
Amazon com Inc can analyze human resource management by
evaluating various aspects of human resources, including -
recruitment, selection, training, reward, performance management,
and other personnel management activities. Effective human
resource management can allow Amazon com Inc to reduce
competitive pressure based on motivation, commitment and
workforce skills. The company can also achieve cost-cutting
targets by analyzing recruitment and training costs with their
relative return. Amazon com Inc.'s heavy dependence on employee
talent will increase the importance of this activity to support the
value chain.
2.2.4 Procurement
Purchase in the value chain refers to the processes involved in
purchasing inputs that may range from equipment, machinery, raw
materials, supplies, raw materials, and other elements needed to
produce the final product. Linked to multiple value chain activities,
Amazon com Inc must carefully consider procurement activities to
improve incoming, operational, and outbound value chain
activities.
As mentioned above, the Porter Value Chain Model
implementation relies on an understanding of the importance of all
activities. After understanding the relative importance of specific
value chain activities, Amazon com Inc should highlight areas in
which value can be added, achieve cost efficiency, establish a basis
for differentiation, or improve operations.
Below is a graphic portrait of the Porter value chain model:
Page 7
3. Amazon Sustainable Competitive Advantage
It is important for Amazon com Inc to base its competitive advantage on
activities where it can access scarce or frightening resources. It may include -
intellectual capital, assets, skills or a distribution network. The value chain
analysis can help Amazon com Inc in identifying these activities and
developing those areas to obtain a strong competitive advantage over the
competitors. There are many examples (such as Toshiba and Sharp) that value
chain analysis is a tool to gain a competitive advantage and invest heavily in
research and development activities within their value chain network. Porter's
general strategies to achieve competitive advantage and the value chain model
can be used together to lay the foundation for a strong competitive advantage.
The following diagram illustrates Porter's competitive advantage model:
Page 8
differentiation. Amazon com Inc can get a competitive advantage from one or
both sources, depending on the depth and breadth of the value chain analysis.
The following parts of the article provide in detail how Amazon com Inc can
create core and / or secondary value chain activities to achieve the desired cost
and differentiation goals.
Page 9
5. Company Differentiation Advantage
Amazon com Inc can get the advantage of differentiation by analyzing
different value chain activities. For example, a company can purchase unique
and valuable inputs that are not readily available to competitors. Amazon com
Inc can either reconfigure the entire value chain or change individual entities
to set the basis for differentiation. Cost factors (such as timing, relationships,
links, scaling, and integration) can also be modified to develop uniqueness.
Some examples of differentiation through value chain analysis are:
Page 10
o Effective coordination between product, research and marketing
departments.
o Broader coverage of the sales force.
Services: the basis for the potential differentiation of Amazon com Inc
is:
o Excellent quality of service
o High-quality technical assistance
o Fast and reliable repair / maintenance service
Page 11
Amazon com Inc can also achieve competitive differentiation by speeding
up the delivery process for the products offered to end customers.
Pizza Hut provides another successful example of value chain analysis as
the organization outperforms competitors by reconfiguring value chain
activities to ensure rapid delivery.
Value Chain Analysis by Amazon com Inc can also be used to improve
HR practices.
FedEx is a good example of a value chain analysis to understand how
Amazon com Inc can achieve a competitive advantage by analyzing HR
activities.
FedEx emphasized value chain support activities, invested heavily in
employee development, took excellent HR initiatives, and made visible
infrastructure improvements, resulting in a marked increase in brand
loyalty and market share.
Amazon com Inc can analyze value chain activities to reduce costs, create
better deals with suppliers, and provide quality products at reasonable
prices.
An example provided for the relevant value chain analysis is provided by
Walmart who continuously analyzes value chain activities to stay
innovative, reduce operating costs and provide low-cost and reliable
services.
Amazon com Inc can analyze support value chain activities to provide
superior customer support. It can also analyze operational activities to
expand its presence in geographically dispersed areas.
It can be understood with the help of another example of value chain
analysis. Starbucks attaches great importance to the analysis of value chain
activities and has succeeded in opening direct stores in more than 50
countries.
Amazon com Inc can also use value chain analysis as a tool for reverse
integration. This can be done by merging or purchasing suppliers to ensure
that raw materials are available in a timely manner.
Apple provides a relevant example of value chain analysis in this regard.
The company is known for its effective value chain and successful control
of product and parts.
Amazon com Inc can also analyze the value chain to maximize operational
efficiency, reduce waste and integrate sustainability into business
operations.
Intel is a good example of value chain analysis that reduced waste and
negative impact on the environment by analyzing value chain operational
activities. The company received recognition for its waste reduction
efforts.
Amazon com Inc can learn from value chain practices in Dow
AgroSciences. Dow used value chain analysis to explore unique marketing
opportunities and extract value from the general commodity market. The
company also used the value chain to manage risks in the different product
life phases.
The examples above demonstrate how Amazon com Inc can benefit from carrying out
a detailed value chain analysis. However, it is also important to note that the
implementation of the Porter value chain model depends on the unique contextual
Page 12
variables that must be taken into account when assigning weight to primary and
secondary value chain activities
Page 13
7.1.1 Streams for Porter’s generic strategies
There are three main tracks to the generic Porter strategies that
multinationals like Amazon com use to achieve their growth
goals.
7.1.1.1.1 How does Amazon com use the cost leadership strategy?
The primary objective of using this strategy is to maintain a
leading position in the market by efficiently managing the
value chain.
This strategy allows Amazon.com to expand its market share
by targeting the middle class, making the largest proportion of
the total consumer market mix in most countries. Middle-class
consumers generally place great importance on the pricing
factor and cost leadership is the best strategy to meet the needs
of this consumer segment.
Amazon com focuses on affordability and ease of access to
its products worldwide, which increases brand awareness,
high sales growth and provides a solid competitive
foundation.
Unlike charging lower prices by lowering production costs
and increasing supply chain efficiency, Amazon com
frequently offers discounts and coupons to achieve sales
targets and deal with competitive pressure from its closest
competitors. The intended result of these promotional and
promotional campaigns is to increase the brand’s popularity
and encourage consumption.
Discussion of Amazon com's cost leadership strategy outlines
the many advantages that this generic strategy offers, such as
obtaining rapid brand recognition, expanding the customer
base, encouraging consumption and achieving sales targets by
emphasizing affordability and accessibility. Although
analyzing the competitive advantage strategies of Amazon
com Amazon com highlights cost leadership as a key strategy,
the company also uses a differentiation strategy along with
cost leadership to lay the groundwork for sustainable
competitive advantage in the highly competitive global
consumer market.
Page 14
7.1.1.2 Differentiation
Differentiation is another common strategy used to build a
competitive advantage. Amazon com uses differentiation along
with a cost leadership strategy to achieve growth goals.
Moreover, the company offers a variety of flavors to suit the unique taste
needs of consumers. Innovation is used as a tool to provide differentiated
additional services that may delight customers and increase their preference
for Amazon com over other brands.
Page 15
companies adopt a focus strategy, they serve specific sectors of the market and
base their competitive advantage on specialized marketing.
How does Amazon.com use the focus strategy?
Amazon.com adopts low cost focus strategy and best value. The low-cost
focus strategy is adopted by serving the needs of a specialized market segment
at the lowest possible price. While adopting a strategy to focus on the best
value by emphasizing the taste, size and design of the product, which can best
suit the needs and requirements of customers.
By focusing on product attributes, Amazon com reviews its branding
strategies and brings continuous changes to product design and packaging to
meet customers' psychological expectations and maximize value for money.
Page 16
The adoption of this strategy requires Amazon.com to reduce prices
and to use different marketing and promotion strategies to drive sales
in the current customer market. The organization offers various
discounts and quotations, often runs promotional campaigns and
presents the product in attractive new packages to achieve the goal of
sales growth while remaining in the same market. Aggressive
marketing tactics are required when using this strategy in a
competitive consumer market.
Amazon com's strategic goal linked to the market penetration
strategy is to increase sales by lowering prices by driving cost.
Assuming an association between low cost and low price leadership
in this case. Another way to achieve this growth goal is to integrate
innovation to lay a clear foundation for differentiation. It helps
Amazon.com to expand its customer base even though the market is
becoming saturated. However, it is also important to note that market
penetration becomes more expensive when the market reaches its
saturation point. In this case, investing in various marketing and
promotional activities yields a low return, which encourages the
company to consider other intense growth strategies.
Page 17
of competing products offered worldwide. Product development is an
important tool to attract more customers.
The strategic objective associated with the use of this intensive growth
strategy is to increase R&D investment for innovation and new product
development. Amazon com's ability to use the general growth strategy to
differentiate supports product development and enhances the organization's
ability to deliver new or new products for growth in existing consumer
markets.
Amazon com's cost leadership strategy also supports this intensive growth
strategy because it allows the organization to reduce costs and use existing
infrastructure to launch new products. Although the company can use the same
resources to expand product lines, developing a successful new product
requires Amazon com to focus on research and development and use the new
technologies required to pursue this strategy.
Regarding new product development, three major ways are available for
Amazon com.
First, it is to introduce new products that are closely associated with existing
production lines.
Second, introducing new products that resonate with existing customers.
The third strategy is to develop new products that update or reinvent existing
products. Amazon com managed to successfully introduce new products
through continuous evaluation of customer needs.
Page 18
strategy. Cost reduction supports the additional investment that Amazon com
has made to enter new consumer markets.
Multinationals like Amazon com have four ways available to implement this
intensive growth strategy - developing new distribution channels, creating new
market segments by imposing varying prices, developing new product
dimensions or thinking about new geographic areas. Geographical expansion
requires a significant commitment of resources, and it is also necessary for the
organization to assess whether the existing distribution network and other
resources support the decision to enter into that specific geographical area.
Access to culturally distant markets is more dangerous because it requires the
organization to be culturally smart and to build effective knowledge
management mechanisms.
Amazon.com recognizes the importance of understanding culture and
integrating local standards and values into marketing campaigns when
entering new geographic regions. The high cultural intelligence has helped
Amazon.com gain acceptance in the culturally diverse consumer markets.
Effective implementation of this strategy also requires companies to conduct
detailed competitor and market intelligence. Well-thought out operational,
financial and market data are needed to make the right market entry decisions.
However, implementing this strategy runs the risk of isolating existing
customers.
Page 19
The relevant diversification strategy is applied by obtaining profitable
business after analyzing market trends and changing customer
expectations. For example, in response to the growing criticism from
environmental protection groups, the company attempted to offset the loss
from lower sales by investing in green business practices and making
business partners with a positive brand image.
The strategically wise implementation of the relevant diversification
growth strategy enhances business sustainability and helps the
organization achieve long-term growth goals despite high market turmoil.
A well-managed product group with related diversification also provides
the ability to hedge risk as decreasing trends in some product areas can be
balanced by emerging trends in related product areas.
8. References
Page 20
[11] Riasi, A. (2015). Competitive advantages of the shadow banking
industry: An analysis using Porter diamond model. Business Management and
Strategy, 6(2), 15-27.
[12] Rieple, A., & Singh, R. (2010). A Value Chain Analysis of the organic
cotton industry: The case of UK retailers and Indian suppliers. Ecological
Economics, 69(11), 2292-2302.
[13] Wiengarten, F., Humphreys, P., Gimenez, C., & McIvor, R. (2016).
Risk, risk management practices, and the success of supply chain integration.
International Journal of Production Economics, 171, 361-370.
[14] Yoo, S. H., & Seo, Y. W. (2017). Effect of supply chain structure and
power dynamics on R&D and market performances. Journal of Business
Economics and Management, 18(3), 487-504.
[15] Andersen, O., & Kheam, L. S. (1998). Resource-based theory and
international growth strategies: an exploratory study. International Business
Review, 7(2), 163-184.
[16] Ansoff, H. I. (1980). Strategic issue management. Strategic
management journal, 1(2), 131-148.
[17] Baker, M. J. (2010). Growth Strategies. Wiley International
Encyclopedia of Marketing.
[18] Galpin, T. J. (2019). Strategy beyond the business unit level: corporate
parenting in focus. Journal of Business Strategy.
[19] Hussain, S., Khattak, J., Rizwan, A., & Latif, M. A. (2013). ANSOFF
matrix, environment, and growth-an interactive triangle. Management and
Administrative Sciences Review, 2(2), 196-206.
[20] Meissner, P., & Wulf, T. (2015). The development of strategy
scenarios based on prospective hindsight: an approach to strategic decision
making. Journal of Strategy and Management, 8(2), 176-190.
[21] Morrison, A., & Wensley, R. (1991). Boxing up or boxed in? A short
history of the Boston Consulting Group share/growth matrix. Journal of
Marketing Management, 7(2), 105-129.
[22] Rahman, K. M. (2016). Strategic Planning and Marketing Models. In
Strategic Marketing Management in Asia: Case Studies and Lessons across
Industries (pp. 59-110). Emerald Group Publishing Limited.
[23] Reed, R., & Luffman, G. A. (1986). Diversification: The growing
confusion. Strategic Management Journal, 7(1), 29-35.
[24] Taylor, E. C. (2012). Competitive improvement planning: using
Ansoff's matrix with Abell's model to inform the strategic management
process. In Allied Academies International Conference. Academy of Strategic
Management. Proceedings (Vol. 11, No. 1, p. 21). Jordan Whitney Enterprises,
Inc.
[25] Varadarajan, P. (1983). Intensive growth opportunities: An extended
classification. California Management Review, 25(3), 118-132.
[26] Vrontis, D., & Sharp, I. (2003). The strategic positioning of Amazon
com in their global marketing operation. The Marketing Review, 3(3), 289-
309.
Page 21