Introduction to Arc Flash
Protection
What is arc protection
What is arc flash protection - PPE
Arc flash protection can be understood in many ways
Does this protect user in case of arc flash hazard? Yes, maybe, no.
Use of PPE gives protection against heat and flying objects but PPE may not
give protection against toxic gases, pressure shock, high sound pressure, falling
or slipping, etc...
Does PPE protect switchgear against damages? No
Schneider Electric - End User Business Group – Cities Business - Energy Division – Vamp Ltd – 09/2014 20
What is arc flash protection –
Arc resistant switchgear
International standards, like IEC 62271-200, gives test specification
and acceptance criteria for an arc resistant switchgear
IAC 1 class switchgear is qualified if following criteria are fulfilled :
• Correctly secured doors, covers do not open. Deformations are accepted (with
restrictions).
It is admitted that the switchgear does not comply anymore with its IP code
• No fragmentation of the enclosure. No projection of parts above 60g.
• Arcing does not cause holes in the accessible sides upto a height of 2 m
• Indicators don't ignite due to the effect of hot gases
• All earthing connections are still effective
Schneider Electric - End User Business Group – Cities Business - Energy Division – Vamp Ltd – 09/2014 21
What is arc flash protection –
International standards
Schneider Electric - End User Business Group – Cities Business - Energy Division – Vamp Ltd – 09/2014 22
What is arc flash protection –
International standards (MV)
Two out of two -> not light only
Schneider Electric - End User Business Group – Cities Business - Energy Division – Vamp Ltd – 09/2014 23
What is arc flash protection –
“Other measures” (IEC62271-200)
Arc flash protection recognizes simultaneous over current and arc
flash and initiates trip command for CB in order to isolate fault from
the supply
Conventional O/C protection
Trip Command
Current 1
• Current value is measured over one or
few cycles > 40 ms
• Typical operation time more than 40 ms
Arc flash protection
• Regocnizes o/c and arc flash light Current Trip Command
&
• Typical operation time 2 ... 7 ms Light
7 ms
2 ms
Schneider Electric - End User Business Group – Cities Business - Energy Division – Vamp Ltd – 09/2014 24
Dual sensing principle: Light & Current
Operation based on I > (I0>)
• Light & Current & Trip
L>
• Light only
L>
Trip
Light & Current based principle preferred
• Because of the light condition, the current condition can be set
very sensitively Early detection, detection of earth faults
• Light only condition may be applied when no external light sources
are present and low cost is essential, e.g. wind power plant
• Detection time ca. 1ms
Schneider Electric - End User Business Group – Cities Business - Energy Division – Vamp Ltd – 09/2014 25
Tripping based on dual sensing
• Optical sensors
CB
• Arc light
Trip
• Location (address)
• Current measurement (CT’s of the
Relay
normal protection system)
• General overcurrent information
Schneider Electric - End User Business Group – Cities Business - Energy Division – Vamp Ltd – 09/2014 26
Tripping time and arcing time
Relay trip time: 1ms...1 cycle
Typical arcing time
= Relay trip time + CB operation time
e.g. 7ms + 50ms = 57ms
CB time
Schneider Electric - End User Business Group – Cities Business - Energy Division – Vamp Ltd – 09/2014 27
Tripping time and arcing time
Arcing time
= Relay trip time + CB operation time
Light and overcurrent based protection
CB time
Fast conventional overcurrent protection
Relay time CB time
Schneider Electric - End User Business Group – Cities Business - Energy Division – Vamp Ltd – 09/2014 28