Reptile Diversity in Agusan Marsh Study
Reptile Diversity in Agusan Marsh Study
http://dx.doi.org/10.15242/IJACEBS.C914015 149
Int’l Journal of Advances in Chemical Engg., & Biological Sciences (IJACEBS) Vol. 1, Issue 2(2014) ISSN 2349-1507 EISSN 2349-1515
(Almeria, 2013). It covers a portion of eight municipalities The researcher, along with the local participants and
(Primavera and Tumanda as cited by Almeria & Nuñeza, experts of reptiles conducted two camping trip every day
2013) on which Bunawan was one of the municipalities. (morning and night on the marsh during the research period.
Bunawan, on the other hand, covers several barangays that Each camping trip for every site lasted 4 hours and multiple
includes Sitio Kaliluan where Sago swamp and Terminalia surveys transects (three on average) conducted on each trip
forest were found (Figure1). (Beukema, 2012). Surveys targeted higher elevations where
species endemism would potentially be higher and where
there was less human disturbance. Surveys at different sites
completed within the same time period as much as possible to
minimize differences arising from weather, seasonal, or other
changes and no surveys conducted during vey inclement
weather (Ward, 2012). Each survey quadrat lasted up to 1
hour. Weather permitting, and a day and a night survey done
on the same date, if possible.
Collected samples were identified right away by experts
and were tagged, photographed on the dorsal, lateral and
ventral sides to facilitate scale counts (Beukema, 2011) and
released back into the field. One to two voucher specimens
were prepared especially for species not identified in the field
Fig. 1 Map of Agusan del Sur showing the two sampling area in (Heyer et al, 1994). Those species with unsure identification
Bunawan. were verified using taxonomic keys of Alcala (1986) and
Diesmos et al. (2008) for turtles, Brown and Alcala (1978) as
B. Sampling Sites
modified by Brown et al. (2007,2008) and Zug et al (2007)
Two sampling sites were established as anchored in for gekkonid lizards, Brown and Alcala (1980) and Mausfeld
Almeria & Nuñeza (2013). Sampling site 1, Terminalia et al. (2002) for scincid lizards, Koch et al. (2007) for varanid
Forest was situated at 08° 09.825’ North latitude and 125° lizards. Taxonomy of snakes followed Leviton (1964a; 1964b;
58.044 East longitude. Most of the area was flooded with 1967; 1970b),Ota and Ross (1994) and Utiger et al., (2005).
water and a stream was found within the sampling area. Then, it was sent to experts in herpetofauna, Dr. Arvin
Terminalia forest was a flat primary forest dominated by Diesmos of National Museum of the Philippines and Dr. Rafe
Terminalia copelandii Elm. and Terminalia calamansanay Brown from University of Kansas for identification
Rolfe under Family Combretaceae. Canopy epiphytes, canopy confirmation. Regardless of collection method, if a specimen
vines, understory plants and rare patches of grasses or sedges represented a species previously collected, the specimen was
were found. Fruit trees and mosses of about 10% cover were released. If it is a species not previously collected in the study,
present. Depth of humus cover was about 4 inches with the specimen will be retained and later euthanized by an
alluvium and clay loam soil type. There were few logs; no injection of lidocaine. Specimens were preserved with a 10%
exposed rocks (Almeria & Nuñeza, 2013). formalin solution and later stored in 70% ethanol (Ward,
Sampling site 2, Sago swamp forest was situated at 08° 2012).
09.825’ North latitude and 125° 57.637’ East longitude. It A one-way Anova at 0.05 alpha levels was used to test
was about 300 hectares and has a relatively flat slope. The whether there is any significant difference in the means of
sampling area, constantly flooded with water, has series of diversity in the two habitat types of Agusan Marsh.
brooks and streams. Water level ranged from 9 to 15 inches.
The Sago swamp forest was a secondary growth of D. Microhabitat Analysis
Metroxylon sagu or “sago” under the Palm family Arecaceae. Sample specimens were collected either on a survey or
Pitcher plant was found; moss density was about 40%; leaf opportunistic collection. Notes were taken on the microhabitat
litter was 90% and the depth of humus cover was about one to help determine the conservation needs of each species.
foot with sandy loam soil; fallen logs were minimal caused by Microhabitat descriptions in the filed notes included specific
storm (Almeria & Nuñeza, 2013). details such as physical characteristics (grass, humus, bare
soil, stream banks, on the ground, etc.) and associated
C. Species Inventory
vegetation (Ward, 2012), including the species name when
To achieve the inventory of reptile species, specimens was possible. The descriptions were grouped into more general
collected in three ways: survey transects, pitfall trap method categories such as leaf litter, rotting log, tree trunk, tree
and opportunistic collection. These techniques employed branches/ leaves, ground cover vegetation and others (Neal,
intensive sampling of arboreal, surface and subterranean 2007). Because many specimens were opportunistic
strata in the chosen sites (Almeria & Nuñeza, 2013). Two collections, human-made objects (such as houses or
transect line (1km) with three quadrats of about 20x20 m was equipment in people’s yards) and human- maintained
laid down randomly in each sampling site with 20m away vegetation (such as farms, gardens and roadsides) were used
from each quadrat. It was conducted last September to as microhabitat categories (Kati, 2007).
December 2013.
http://dx.doi.org/10.15242/IJACEBS.C914015 150
Int’l Journal of Advances in Chemical Engg., & Biological Sciences (IJACEBS) Vol. 1, Issue 2(2014) ISSN 2349-1507 EISSN 2349-1515
III. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION in sampling station 1.1. Naja philippinensis shows its
The Sago Palm area was a secondary forest dominated by apparent association with environmental variable with road
Metroxylon sagu under the Palm family Arecaceae and it was kills, in sampling station 1.1
about 3 hectares with a vegetation type composed primarily of
tall grass, vines, shrubs, and epiphytes. There were other trees
spotted in the area like Lanipao, Wango, Manga Pajo,
Kabihid and Libas. While few of Baas, Panabog, Dagahit and
Ferns (Pako) were also noted. The observed bed floor of Sago
Palm was watery with the presence of rotten logs and leaf
litters while the soil type was peat lands (Figure 2). Peat lands
were wetlands with a thick water-logged organic soil layer
(peat) made up of dead and decaying plant material as
documented by Santillan et al (2012). The distance from the
sampling site to anthropogenic clearing of a large scale rice
plantation and human settlement was about 50 meters. An
abandoned slash and burn farm was observed at the periphery
of the sampling site as also noted by the study of Almeria &
Nuñeza (2013).
Terminalia Forest was a flat primary forest dominated by
Terminalia copelandii under Family Combretaceae. The
vegetation type of this area was composed of tall grass, vines,
shrubs, and epiphytes. Tree taxa of Terminalia forest were
primarily composed of Manga Pajo, Maymayan, Lanipao,
Katumbawon, Kapi-kapi, Salumbayan, Tayapok and
Hambabawod. Some of the trees produce fruits that were
eaten by endemic birds in the area. Dominate grasses found in
the area include Baas, Bagahit, Bakong, Tambo, Muti-muti
and Bangiba. While, ground cover plants such Fern and Fern-
allies, Pitcher plant, and Badyang were recorded. Most of the Fig. 2. Natural habitats on ground dwelling (A), leaf litter (B)
area was flooded with water and a small stream was found and rotten sago and log trunks (C)
within the sampling area. Rotten logs, left litters and tree
holes were documented but no exposed rocks. Soil type was
clay loam and presence of depth humus cover was also noted.
The distance from the sampling site to anthropogenic clearing
and human settlements was approximately 50 meters. Slash
and burn can be observed few meters away from the sampling
site.
Environmental parameters in the two vegetation types of
Agusan Marsh were recorded such as ambient temperature;
wet temperature was 31°C while dry temperature was 30°C.
The sky during the day was partly cloudy but varied every day
during the fieldworks. Relative humidity was 79% while Fig. 3. Ordination of species and environmental variables in the
vapour pressure (mmHg) 23.75 mm while the dew point first two canonical axis from CCA scores.
temperature was 42.6 dc. In addition, rainfall (mm) during
the sampling period was 376.7 and the average wind speed Moreover, the clustering of species and environmental
variables with swampy areas and small streams shows strong
(mps) was 002 (Data taken from Hinatuan Weather Station) .
association with Cuora amboinensis, this can be explained
Habitat quality was a measure of the importance of habitat
that this species prefers this specific environment. With
type in maintaining a particular species (Van Horne, 1983).
reference to study of Hofer et al., 2000, that response of
In the CCA ordination (Figure 3) sampling site 1.1 and
reptiles to streams shows pronounced preference as it gives
1.2 shows particular environmental patterns. The association large CCA score, thus its abundance affects stronger relation
of environmental variables with bushes, coconut trees, leaf to its environment. Species that negatively correlates small
litter and tree trunk, selectively logs shows stronger streams Tropidophorus misaminius and Broghammerus
correlation with reptilian species such as Eutropis cumingi, reticularus, this species were given small weight in the CCA.
Draco quadrasi, Emoia atrocostata. On the upper- right
quadrat, Hydrosaurus pustulatus, Tropidophorus davaoensis
shows its stronger relation in the human maintain vegetation
http://dx.doi.org/10.15242/IJACEBS.C914015 151
Int’l Journal of Advances in Chemical Engg., & Biological Sciences (IJACEBS) Vol. 1, Issue 2(2014) ISSN 2349-1507 EISSN 2349-1515
http://dx.doi.org/10.15242/IJACEBS.C914015 152
Int’l Journal of Advances in Chemical Engg., & Biological Sciences (IJACEBS) Vol. 1, Issue 2(2014) ISSN 2349-1507 EISSN 2349-1515
(2011), observed that the road-kills of reptile are a major Hence, extraction of forest resources by the villages of the
cause of mortality for a wide variety of taxa. Hydrosaurus forest perimeter was leading to overexploitation, and
pustulatus and Cuora amboinensis were identified as enhancing extent of disturbances (Surasinghe & Jayaratne,
vulnerable and likely decreasing. Raising of Cuora 2006). On the other hand, Kaingin or Slush and Burns
amboinensis for pet and food consumption were observed in (Figure 5C) in the area were noted during our field sampling.
the locality. Harvesting of herpetofauna through illegal trade This not only destroys the habitats but also directly kills the
and unsustainable consumption was probably the biggest reptile and amphibian species. Moreover, burning would
threat other than habitat destruction and alteration as cited by hinder the development of the secondary successions. In
Neal (2007). (Zug et al., 2001). certain situations, fire spreads even into the core-forest areas
Though, this study accounted only 11 (17.8%) species causing significant degree habitat destruction (Surasinghe &
with 2 (5.5%) were endemic (Tropidophorus davaoensis and Jayaratne, 2006). With the ongoing disturbances in the
Tropidophorus misaminius) this does not exactly indicate Agusan Marsh, it appears that the endemic species are more
reptile species decline in Agusan Marsh as the surveys were at risk (Almeria & Nuñeza, 2013). Poynton et al., (2007), as
encountered only for four months. This decrease could be due cited by Almeria & Nuñeza, 2013), reported that the
to either samples being missed, especially if individuals are uniqueness of the species combined with their evident
small in size and residing in the clumped leaf litter, species vulnerability to disturbance make them a subject for
being well camouflaged, or the ability of individuals to escape particular conservation.
even before they were noticed (Ates- Camino et al., 2010). In The researcher come up with these policies for
addition, the researcher supposes that the swifter nature of conservation management; first, a legal framework must be
reptiles compared to amphibians and their limited of absence established to prevent disturbances, especially encroachments
of vocalization may have account for their rarity of capture. and forest-resource overexploitation and the law enforcement
should be functional to take legal action against violation of
Environmental Threats and Conservation Management
rules; second, a pilot project was also need to carry out to
Despite the exceedingly small land coverage, the Sago monitor the population status of reptile species and the biotic
swamp and Terminalia forest was confronting threats due to and anthropogenic factors affecting those; third, the
unprecedented human activities. Today, the major threat of landowners of the nearby private agricultural lands must be
reptile species in Agusan Marsh was the on-going conversion encouraged to adopt agroforestry practices. This will allow
of Sago and Terminalia Forest into agricultural land (Figure establishment of small populations of herpetofauna that can
5A,B). Local residents such as the Manobo have cleared function as subpopulations. Later on, such small populations
portions for corn, vegetable and rice production. The will interbreed with the main populations in the reserve and
agricultural chemicals and pesticides used in corn, vegetable will create metapopulations; lastly, forest management should
and rice production results in secondary problems for target the maintenance of the open forest structure with low
herpetofaunal communities with the mass killing of insect bush under growth, to favor the diversity of terrestrial reptiles
communities, which was an integral component of their food (Surasinghe & Jayaratne, 2006).
niche (Bishop and Gendron, 1998; Somaweera, 2001;
Bambaradeniya, 2001 as cited by Surasinghe & Jayaratne IV. CONCLUSION
,2006). Besides, there was a tendency for bioaccumulation
Sago plam and Terminalia forest still harbour unique
and biomagnification of the pesticides to occur through food
community of reptilian species regardless of the on-going
webs (Moriarty, 1975; Feleers et al., 2004 as cited by
anthropogenic activities in the area like Kaingin, conversion
Surasinghe & Jayaratne , 2006 )
of lands to agriculture and harvesting of species for pet trade,
medicine, and food consumption in the rest of Agusan Marsh
are any indication that the clock was ticking on this unique
and valuable ecological refuge. Data from this study suggest
that reptiles in Terminalia Forest and Sago Palm need urgent
protective measures and management including other wildlife
faunal species in the area. Protection and conservation
Fig. 5On-going anthropogenic activities inside Sago Palm and priorities of the reptilian species and long-term monitoring
Terminalia Forest of Agusan Marsh. programmes within the Sago palm and Terminalia forest of
Agusan Marsh will be closely monitored by our local and
Cutting and clearing of Terminalia trees for charcoal provincial government and some non-government
making and firewood production as well as harvesting organizations (NGOs) in the country.
(hunting/gathering) of wildlife vertebrates for food
consumption (wild pig capture) were the present livelihood of ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
some local residents in the area. Like the species Cuora
amboinensis on the study of Brown et al., 2012, it was heavily The author wishes to express her sincere thanks to all
hunted for food, curiosities, pet trade and traditional medicine individuals who contributed their valuable assistance in the
which were also observed in the locality of Agusan Marsh. preparation and completion of this study, especially to Dr.
http://dx.doi.org/10.15242/IJACEBS.C914015 153
Int’l Journal of Advances in Chemical Engg., & Biological Sciences (IJACEBS) Vol. 1, Issue 2(2014) ISSN 2349-1507 EISSN 2349-1515
Arvin Diesmos of National Museum of the Philippines and [24] Newmark, W. D., 1998. Forest area, Fragmentation and loss in the Eastern
Arc mountains: implications for the conservation of biological diversity.
Dr. Rafe Brown from University of Kansas for identification [25] Nguku J.K., 2009. Distribution, diversity and population status of
confirmation. To the St. Paul University- Surigao especially herpetofauna in Lower Tanariver forests, Kenya.
to Sr. Rosanne Mallillin, SPC for providing her with moral [26] Oliveros C.H., Ota H., Crombie R.I., Brown R.M., 2011. The
Herpetofauna of the Babuyan Islands, northern Philippines.
and financial support during her study and for the chance and [27] Petrov B., 2007. Amphibian and reptiles of Bulgaria: Fauna, vertical
effort in sending her in the IICBE conference. distribution, zoogeography and conservation.
[28] Poynton, J. C., Loader S. P., Sherratt E., Clarke, B. T., 2007. Amphibian
diversity in East African biodiversity hotspots: altitudinal and latitudinal
REFERENCES patterns.
[1] Agusan del Sur Map of Bunawan. Retrieved from July 27, 2013. [29] Primavera, J. H., Tumanda, M. I., 2006. The Agusan Marsh: proceedings
<http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Ph_locator_agusan_del_sur_bunawan.p of the 2nd workshop of MAB- Ecotone Phase II and 14th Meeting of
ng> Southeast Asian biosphere Reserve network UNESCO Jakarta Office
[2] Agusan Marsh Management Plan, Executive Summary (2010). [30] Siler C. D., Swab J. C., Oliveros C. H., Diesmos A. C., Averia L., Alcala
[3] Alcala, A. (1986). Guide to Philippine flora and fauna. Amphibians and A. C., Brown R. M., Amphibians and Reptiles, Romblon Island Group,
Reptiles. Natural Resources Management Center, Ministry of Natural Central Philippines: Comprehensive herpetofaunal inventory.
Resources and University of the Philippines. [31] Sharma, H. B., and Warman, M., 2011. Diversity, ecological structure and
[4] Alcala, A.C., and Brown, W.C. (1998). Philippine Amphibians Illustrated conservation of herpetofauna in trans yamunatic region of Mathura
field guide. Bookmark, Inc, Makati City, Philippines. [32] Surasinghe, T. D. and Jayaratne, R. L., 2006. Diversity, threats and
[5] Almeria M.L., Olga M. N., 2013 Amphibian Diversity and Endemism in conservation of herpetofauna in and around Eastern Sinharaja
the Swamp Forests of Agusan Marsh, Agusan del Sur, Philippines. [33] Ward A. C., 2006 Composition, Distribution, and Conservation of the
[6] Ates- Camino, F. B., Leano., E. P., and Relox, R. E., 2010. Herpetofaunal Herpetofauna of Santa Barbara Mountain, Honduras.
endemism and diversity in tropical forests in Mt. Hamaguitan in the
Philippines
[7] Beukema W., 2011. Herpetofauna of disturbed forest fragments on the
lower Mt. Kitanglad Range, Mindanao Island, Philippines. Meconcepcion M. Ngilangil was born on
[8] Brown R.M., Oliveros C.H., Siler C.D., Fernandez J.B., Welton L.J., December 7, 1987 in Cabadbaran City, Agusan
Buenavente P.A.C., Diesmos M.L.L., Diesmos A.C., 2012. Amphibians del Norte, Philippines. She was a graduate of
and reptiles of Luzon Island (Philippines), VII: herpetofauna of Ilocos Bachelor of Science in Biology in Mindanao
Norte Province, northern Cordillera Mountain Range. State University- Main Campus, Marawi City,
[9] Brown, W.C., Alcala, A.C. (1978). Philippine Lizards of the family Philippines last November 2008. She also
Gekkonidae. Siliman University. Nat Sci Monogr Ser 1, Dumaguete City, finished her Master of Science in Biology major
Philippines, 131. in Physiology at Caraga State University,
[10] Brown, W.C., Alcala, A.C. (1980). Philippine Lizards of the family Ampayon, Butuan City, Philippines last Nov.
Scincidae. Siliman University. Nat Sci Monogr Ser 1, Dumaguete City, 2014. She was a member of Philippine Society
Philippines, 263. of the Study of Nature (PSSN). Now, she is
[11] Buckland, S.T., Anderson, D.R., Burnham, K.P., and Laake, J.L. (1993). currently employed at St. Paul University- Surigao, Surigao City, Philippines as
Distance Sampling. Estimating the abundance of ecological populations. Research Coordinator.
Champman and Hall.
[12] Brown R.M., Siler C.D., Oliveros C.H., Welton L.J., Rock A., Swab J.,
Weerd M.V., Beijnen J.V., Jose E., Rodriguez D., Jose E., Diesmos A.C.,
2013. The Amphibians and Reptiles of Luzon Island, Philippines VIII: the
herpetofauna of Cagayan and Isabela Provinces, northern Sierra Madre
Mountain Range.
[13] DENR- IPAS, 2003. Agusan Marsh wildlife sanctuary protected area
report. Agusan del Sur, Philippines
[14] Diesmos A.C., Brown R.M., Alcala A.C., Sison R.V., Afuang L.E.,
Genevieve V.A. 2002. Philippine Amphibians and Reptiles: An Overview
of Species Diversity, Biogeography and Conservation.
[15] Devan-song A., Brown R.M., 2012. Amphibians and reptiles of Luzon
island, Philippines VI: the herpetofauna of the Subic bay area.
[16] Ferner J.W., Brown R.M., Sison R.V., Kennedy R.S., 2000.The
Amphibians and Reptiles of Panay Island, Philippines.
[17] Gomes M. A., Vrcibradic D., Siqueira C. C., Kiefer M. C., Klaion T.,
Santos P. A., Nascimento D., Ariani C. V., Vitor N. T., Junior B., Freitas-
Filho R. F., Sluys M. V., Carlos F.D Rocha 2008. Herpetofauna of an
Atlantic rainforest (Morro Sao Joao) in Rio de Janiero State, Brazil.
[18] Hilario B.A., 2012. Saving Biodiversity.
[19] Inger R. F., Stuebing R. B., 1989. The frogs of Sabah Kota Kinabalu,
Sabah Malaysia. Sabah Parks Publication.
[20] IUCN Redlist of Threatened Species, 2007. International union for
conservation of nature and natural resources. Rio, Brasil Kati V.,
Foufopoulos J., Ioannidis Y., Papaioannou H., Poirazidis K., Lebrun P.,
2007. Diversity, ecological structure and conservation of herpetofauna in a
Mediterranean area (Dadia National Park, Greece).
[21] Nuneza O.M., Fabricante K.M.B., Alicante A.A., Sucaldito M.O., Ponce
A.G., 2012.The Herpetofauna of Mounts Sambilikan, Ararat and Berseba
of the Diwata Range, Agusan del Sur, Philippines.
[22] Nuneza O. M., Ates F. B., Alicante A. A., 2010. Distribution of endemic
and threatened herpetofauna in Mt. Malindang, Mindanao, Philippines.
Biodiversity Conservation
[23] Neal S., 2007. An assessment of the herpetofaunal biological diversity of
the Hydrological Reserve on Isla Del Rey, Las Perlas Archipelago,
Panama.
http://dx.doi.org/10.15242/IJACEBS.C914015 154