Comp Gov Unit 1 Cheat Sheet
Comp Gov Unit 1 Cheat Sheet
Comparative Politics:
- The study of HOW internal and external forces affect a country’s domestic politics
- These studies are done to: a) test hypotheses; b) understand political processes; c) explain those
political processes
- Comparative politics is good for: a) explaining complex correlations; b) qualitative and quantitative
analysis; c) interpreting policy making in a global context; d) assessing policy alternatives
- Case study is the most common type of study (the “BIG 6” – United Kingdom, Russia, China, Mexico,
Iran, Nigeria [and the EU])
- Case Studies are: a) specific examples of developments, issues, and institutions; b) bounded by
geographic spaces OR c) over certain periods of time
- Comparisons are often based on democracy vs. authoritarianism and communism vs. capitalism
While case studies focus on empirical data, they are often done in efforts to answer normative
questions (ex. How can democracy best be poromoted? Does prosperity improve human rights?)
Classification:
- Classification systems are based on correlations, causations, and generalizations about groups of
countries organized around the “Three World Approach”
- Industrialized Democracies are established democracies, with the most resources for creating and
sustaining power. They are wealthy and have reasonably effective and popular political
institutions – usually have built in restraints of power (constitutions/legislation) – competitive
elections [United Kingdom]
- Communist and post-Communist States sought to create systems that limit individual freedom and
divide the wealth equally- Communist states were/are extremely strong and control/controlled
almost everything (schools, press, economy) – as Communism fell – countries began to
liberalize (individual and economic freedoms). China implemented liberal economic reform while
retaining tight control over political life. [Russia/China]
- Global South/Less Developed Countries generally fall into TWO categories: a) newly industrialized
experiencing rapid economic growth with a tendency toward democratization and political
stability; OR b) lack significant economic development and/or lean toward authoritarian state.
[a) Mexico and Iran – b) Nigeria]
Theoretical approaches:
- Theoretical approaches determine what similarities and differences are significant and what
strategies are appropriate
- Rational Choice Theory: People act rationally in their own self-interest. Understanding their
perceptions of their self-interest will explain their behavior. Therefore a comparative study should
focus on individual behavior and motivation.
- Structural Theory: Human actions are determined by underlying arrangements which guide
behavior. (ex. Marxism proposed economic relationships as such arguments.) Understanding the
structure will explain political behavior. Therefore a comparative study will focus on the
structures that determine relationships.
- Cultural Theory: Culture is a way of believing and acting shared by people with a common
identity. Culture varies and evolves over time. Understanding the culture will explain political
behavior. Therefore a comparative study will focus on context within which people act
politically.
- Systems Theory: Inputs to the state affect decision making which creates outputs of public policy.
The environments outside of the state and feedback from previous decisions influence policy
making. Therefore a comparative study will examine the system as a whole mechanism in
search of explanations for political behavior.
Major Ideas/Concepts/Terms
- Empirical – Factual, numbers, stats, data, objective
- Normative – Value judgment, subjective, explained
- Qualitative Data – Deals with descriptions, data that can be observed but not measured
- Quantitative Data – Deals with numbers, data which can be measured
- Causation – One variable causes an influence on another variable
- Correlation – When change in one variable coincides with a change in another variable
- Independent Variable – Is a variable that stands alone and isn't changed by the other variables
you are trying to measure (IV)
- Dependent Variable – It is something that depends on other factors (independent variables).
Usually when looking for a relationship between two things you are trying to find out what
makes the dependent variable change the way it does. (DV) (ex. Poverty (DV) is caused by a
lack of education (IV))
- Permeability: the ability of one substance, idea, object etc. to allow another substance, idea, object etc.
to pass through it – THINK: What is the general political and economic permeability of
national borders? PAY ATTENTION TO: what gets through national borders:
Refugees
Pollution
Drugs
Invasive species
Fundamentalism/extremism
NGO’s
Jobs
Olympics/World Cup
Political ideas (democratization
Political Institutions
Most political systems create and describe their regimes in a constitution (or some semblance of a
constitution). In the 21st century nearly every regime invokes a constitution as evidence of legitimacy
and rule of law. (Some constitutions are simply more powerful or more followed than others)
- Constitution – a supreme law that defines the structure of a nation-state’s regime and the legal
processes that the government must follow. (A constitution helps create: 1) Government
structure; 2) Citizenship aspects; 3) the electoral process)
Governmental Structure
The structure of a regime defined in a constitution is the general outline of the executive, legislative,
and judicial institutions and their powers.
- Executive Institutions – the people and agencies, which implement and execute public policy;
people or groups in charge of the executive institution (branch) are the government
- Legislative Institutions – the public body (or bodies) with the authority to make, amend, and repeal
statutory laws as well as impose taxes and authorize public spending for a political
unit/bureaucracy
- Judicial Institutions – the collection of courts in a regime with the authority to interpret laws (statute
and common)
- Judicial Review – in common law systems, courts have the authority to modify or nullify the
actions of legislatures, executives, and lower courts; these decisions create precedents that
are preserved through stare decisis
- Stare Decisis – the legal principal that judges should respect and follow precedents whenever possible.
- In code law (civil or statutory law systems), laws are enacted by legislative or regulatory bodies
and higher courts can reverse or modify lower court decisions without creating precedents for
future cases
CITIZENSHIP
Constitutions and basic laws create things other than structures of a regime. They can also:
Define citizenship
Outline the limits of government authority
Identify the obligations of government to the citizens
Describe the rights and obligations of citizens
- Citizen – a member of a nation-state who is legally entitled to full civil rights and is legally obliged
to perform defined public duties
- Civil Rights AND Civil Liberties – freedoms protected by the state from unwarranted infringement
by governments and private organizations; they ensure (in liberal states) citizens ability to
participate in the civil and political life of the society and the state.
Electoral Process
The third aspect created by constitutions are electoral systems; the institutions and procedures within
the nation-state which votes are cast and counted in a representative regime.
- Universal Suffrage – the right to vote of every adult citizen except those who are individually
excluded from voting (ex. dependents and incarcerated criminals)
- Limited Suffrage – A system in which only a subset of citizens is granted the right to vote
- Plurality Elections – an electoral system that declares a candidate receiving the most votes as the
winner (also known as First-Past-The Post/FPTP)
- Majority Elections – an electoral system that requires winners to receive the majority of the votes
cast (sometimes a majority of eligible voters) NOTE: This often requires a secondary voting
between the top candidates who did not receive a majority
- Proportional Elections – an electoral system in which a party’s candidates win office in proportion
to the percentages of votes won by the party (there is usually a minimum percentage a
party is required to receive before any of it candidates are elected)
- Ranked Choice Voting – voters rank all candidates by their preferences; NOTE: If a voter’s first choice
is not elected, his or her second choice gets the vote, etc.
Separation/Fusion of Powers
John Locke and Baron de La Brède et de Montesquieu both wrote that every political system must
legislate, administer, and adjudicate; and many (but not all) liberal, representative regimes create
separate institutions for each function.
- Separation of Powers – the system of governance in which government power is divided into
several bodies with the ability to check (minimize/stop) the power of the other
- Fusion of Powers – a system of governance in which the authority of government is concentrated
in one institutional body
- Division of Powers – the concept that branches of government (executive, legislative, judicial) have
different responsibilities and powers
- Checks and Balances – a system of governance in which divisions (branches) of government can
restrain the political power of other divisions (branches)
ILLIBERAL DEMOCRACIES
Illiberal states are those that have the trappings of a constitution, elections, and rule of law but in
fact have only a symbolic constitution, non-competitive elections, and a façade that appears to be
rule of law. The government regularly ignores human rights and treats citizens as subjects
Systems
- Parliamentary System – the head of government is chosen by a majority in the legislature and
holds BOTH legislative and executive power
- Presidential System – the head of government is chosen independently of the legislature (by direct
election) and holds executive power BUT NOT legislative power
NOTE: The head of government is usually the executive leading a cabinet of ministers each charged with
a specific area of responsibility (ex. Foreign affairs, military, justice, health, education etc.)
- Cabinet – the group of ministers who direct administrative bureaucracies, which are accountable to
the head of government; NOTE: In a parliamentary system, the head of government and the
cabinet are reffered to as the government.
- Bureaucracy – a hierarchal structured organization charged with carrying out the policies determined
by those with political authority.
Bureaucrats are civil servants who have been hired for their technical expertise, specialized knowledge,
and special skills and/or in some cases because they performed well on objectively fair assessments of
their abilities and knowledge (civil servant exams). They are often referred to as technocrats because
of their specialized NON-POLITICAL knowledge and skills; their jobs are to carry out or implement public
policy made by people with political authority. They are supposed to be separated from making policy by
their positions in an organization where policy and directions come from the top policy making leaders.
NOTE: Bureaucrats often weild great influence over policies adopted by governments and legislatures –
they ARE NOT ELCTED!
Judiciary – Courts/Judges
- judiciary – The set of institutions that are created to: (If it is functioning ideally, the judiciary plays a
large role in maintaining a rule of law).
Interpret the application of public laws and ploicies
Settle public disputes in the nation-state
Enforce criminal law
A major responsibility of an effective judiciary is to interpret statute law (Code Law) or administrative
regulations as they are applied. In some legal systems the judiciary is to interpret the application of
common law and precedent.
- Electoral Systems
- Plurality elections – also known as “first-past-the post/FPTP” systems because the candidate with
the most votes (not always a majority) is elected from a member district; voters choose
ONE candidate from those offered; does not necessarily represent minority interest
- Single-member districts – voting constituencies from which only one candidate is selected in each
election
- multi-member districts – voting constituencies from which more than one candidate is selected in each
election
- majority elections – also known as “second ballot” systems because if no candidate wins a
majority in the original balloting, a second round of voting is required in which voters choose
from among the more successful candidates from the first round; (voters choose ONE candidate
from those offered in each round)
- Proportional elections – elections in which groups of voters are represented in the elected body in
proportion to the number of votes in a multi-member constituency
Party list system – voters indicate party preference; parties then select ranked lists of
candidates
Ranked choice system – also known as “single transferable vote” – voters indicate their 1st,
2nd, 3rd, etc. choices. If the voter’s first choice candidate is unsuccessful that vote is awarded to
the voter’s second choice etc.
Political Action
- Political Participation – the action taken by citizens that involve them in the process of selecting
leaders, making policies, or influencing public actions; in most political systems few people
do more to participate in government than vote
NOTE: Political parties are the most visible way for participation – advocacy for political preference is a
common incentive. Self-protection or the protection of the group also motivates political participation.
Coerced participation is not intended to influence policy BUT to support the government or regime.
- Media – the ways and means of communicating political information like books, newspapers,
magazines, radio, film television, and social media differ widely from one political culture to
another. Wealth, technology, censorship, language, and infrastructure are among the causes for
difference.
Types of Change
- Revolution – widespread and often rapid change of regime, government, leadership, politics,
institutions, social relations and economics
- Civil War – an armed uprising against a government or a regime by citizens of the state with the goal
of replacing the existing political system
- Coup d’etat – a rapid overthrow of a governing elite by another organized elite (often the military
elite)
- Reform – a usually gradual process of change to improve a regime or a society in ways generally
agreeable to most citizens and/or most people with political power
- Democratization – The spread of civil liberties, the rule of law, competitive elections, and independent
civil society to more nation-states; observers have attributed the rise in democratization to such
factors as growing wealth, a general rise in education levels, the spread of market economies,
growing social equality and the middle classes
- Illiberal democratization – an illiberal democracy is a regime in which elections are held, but citizens
are not a decisive factor in governing or policy making. Restrictions on civil society and civil
liberties exist, there is a lack of governmental transparency along-side the absence of
authentic rule of law
Political Economics
Political stability is inherently linked to economic stability
- Fiscal Policy – governmental decisions about total public spending and revenue that result in
budgetary deficits or surpluses
- Monetary Policy – policies that affect interest rates and supply of money available within an
economy
Government spending includes:
Cost of government
National defense
Social welfare programs
Government revenues include
Taxes and license fees
Income from public enterprise
Aid from other countries or international organizations (IMF/World Bank_
- Public spending contributes (and in some countries dominates) the economy
- Public saving – government revenues are more than government spending (slows the economy =
reduce inflation and increase stability over a fast growing economy/reduce national debt)
- Deficit spending occurs when the government spends more than incoming revenue (pro = can
stabilize economy/promote growth if in a recession/con = can increase inflation if economy
growing too fast)
Measuring Economies
- GDP (Gross Domestic Product) – the market value of goods and services produced IN a nation-state
in a specific time period
- HDI (Human Development Index) – a statistic based on the life expectancy, education, and income
data from most of the world’s countries; argued that combining social welfare AND economic
data makes for more meaningful comparisons the GDP does
- GDP per capita – takes into account the population of the countries being compared – suggests that
it better measures the social value of a countries production
- Gini coefficient – accounts for income distribution (higher numbers indicate greater economic
inequality)
Types of Economies
Basic economic questions:
What to produce?
How to produce?
For whom to produce?
How to distribute production?
- Market economy – an economic system in which supply, demand, investment, production, distribution,
and prices of goods and services are primarily determined by voluntary exchanges in
transparent markets
- Command economy – an economic system in which public and private policy decisions
substantially substitute for markets in determining prices, production, and distribution of economic
goods and services
- Mixed economy – an economic system in which markets, public policy, and powerful forces all play
important roles in answering the basic economic questions
- Agricultural economy – a system in which the agricultural sector employs the most people and
produces most of the economic goods
- Industrial economy – a system in which the manufacturing of material goods employs the most people
and produces most of the systems profits
Sectors of Economies
% of total GDP
(CIA World Factbook 2012 estimates)
A: Agriculture; M: Manufacturing; S: Services
A M S
UK .07 21 78
Russia 4 36 60
China 10 45 45
Mexico 4 34 62
Iran 11 38 51
Nigeria 31 43 26