Primark's Operations Management Strategies
Primark's Operations Management Strategies
Primark's operations involve ensuring quality and value for money through robust
testing procedures and a lean operations system with a "state of the art
infrastructure" (Companies house, 2019). In implementing this strict strategy,
Primark ensures that cost savings can be passed onto customers (Companies
house, 2019). Therefore, increasing the value offered and competitiveness in the
market for Primark (Slack and Brandon-Jones, 2019).
When looking at the four V's of operations, volume, variety, visibility, and variation
(Slack and Brandon-Jones, 2019), Primark uses their scale quantities to purchase
high volumes to lower costs on products from suppliers (Companies house 2019).
This practice also relates to the value chain theory mentioned in Dudovskiy (2016),
as quantities of scale can be seen as Primark's central value creation. Concerning
the visibility of the four V's (Slack and Brandon-Jones, 2019), Primark's visibility is
low as they spend little on advertising to keep costs down (Primark, 2020a). When
referring to Mintzberg et al (2020) five P's, plan, pattern, position, perspective, and
ploy, the savings mentioned above allow Primark to position themselves as one the
cheapest sellers in the retail industry.
One negative for Primark of having this reliance on providing the lowest cost is that
they have had a substandard ethical reputation surrounding their past operations
(Jones et al, 2009). Primark is trying to combat this negative reputation with their
ethical training initiative, which means they are now selective about their suppliers
(Primark, 2020a). Baram (2019) states that of the individuals who took part, 57%
said that they try and make more ethical fashion purchases from the previous year.
To combat this growing change in attitudes, Primark has launched a new wellness
collection made purely from sustainable goods (Associated British Foods, 2020).
This launch relates to Mintzbergs et al (2020) five P's plan, pattern, position,
perspective, and ploy. Primark uses its wellness collection as a ploy to help address
H&M's change in strategy of only using sustainable goods by 2030 (Morgan, 2020).
Primark's business model is built around achieving high sales volumes (Companies
house, 2019). Primark needs to ensure customers buy in volume to achieve the
desired levels of profitability (Arriaga et al, 2017). Primark's facilities help ensure
that: they accommodate the need for high volumes, compete with rivals to win sales,
and create value for customers. Primark's stores are of a substantial size to allow for
larger volume deliveries and encourage shoppers to purchase more when visiting
(Arriaga et al, 2017). Primark entices customers to purchase in volume by creating a
positive in-store experience (Companies house, 2019). A recent opening that
highlights this successful strategy is the Birmingham city centre store (Hinsliff, 2019).
The store is 160,000 square foot (Associated British foods, 2019) and houses a
blow-dry bar, beauty salon, and a Disney themed café (Hinsliff, 2019). Primark's in-
store facilities mean that customers can spend longer at a store, increasing sales
volumes, and improving their overall experience (Companies house, 2019).
Kraaijenbrink (2019) refers to this as the "kid in a candy store feeling" and states that
this is essentially Primark's value proposition to customers. However, to keep
achieving this outcome, Primark needs to continuously update stores through
various methods to keep enticing and exciting customers (Companies house, 2019).
The continuous updating means that Primark will need to frequently invest time and
cash to ensure stores are new and trendy, which is costly.
Quality is a crucial objective for Primark. Slack and Brandon-Jones (2019 p.48)
explain quality as "consistent conformance to customer's expectations." Primark
achieves high-quality standards by having a continuous testing procedure at each
supply chain phase (Companies house, 2019). However, while Primark state they
offer quality (Primark, 2020b), according to Apeagyei et al (2013), to achieve their
low prices, they use cheaper materials and construction methods in their production
than rivals M&S and Zara resulting in lower product longevity. Having stated this,
Primark's customers are more concerned about buying fashion trends for minimal
prices and care less about the product's quality (Apeagyei et al, 2013).
Nevertheless, with Primark's low prices, their value proposition to the customer is
that their goods are value for money (Kraaijenbrink, 2019). Therefore, this
proposition satisfies their customer's expectations and ensures the quality objective
mentioned in Slack and Brandon-Jones (2019) is met. As mentioned previously,
Primark keeps product labelling and security to a minimum (Arriaga et al, 2017). This
choice results in fewer stages that a product has to go through before it is on a shop
floor. A benefit of having a reduced number of production stages is that there is a
lower chance of mistakes, which results in overall higher quality and efficiency (Slack
and Brandon-Jones, 2019).
Primark keeps up to date with fashion trends in the retail industry; this is done by
having high flexibility and speed (Slack and Brandon-Jones, 2019). Primark keeps
flexibility high by employing experienced teams to examine seasonal trends and
working with trusted suppliers (Associated British Foods, 2020). An example of
Primark's speed and flexibility is their six-week design to shop floor lead time
(Associated British Foods, 2019). This short lead time ensures that Primark can
satisfy desired volume levels and adapt to trends (Associated British foods, 2020).
Also, Primark's partnerships with brands such as Netflix and Disney ensure that they
have access to licensed merchandise to keep up with trends (Associated British
Foods, 2020). As stated in MacCarthy and Jayarathne (2010), Primark's inventory
management and receptive global supply chain have been key enablers for
Primark's high speed and flexibility, with Primark being able to monitor all stock in
stores hourly and alter production mid-season. Primark's supply chain speed is seen
as their suppliers package their items so that they are ready to go straight onto the
shop floor, thus improving efficiency and keep in line with their lean operations model
(Primark 2020a).
While Primark mainly focuses on a lean operation (companies house, 2019), rivals
Zara is using a more agile supply chain method (Madhani, 2015). This method does
not just focus on having nominal costs, like the lean counterpart, but incorporates the
need for reacting quickly to market trends and demands (Madhani, 2015).
Primark has eight warehouse distribution centres in the United Kingdom that ensure
that stock can be coordinated, stored, and moved around effectively (Primark,
2020c). Suppose a business such as Primark was not flexible. In that case, it could
result in a missed trend/ selling opportunity, leading to forced price reductions and
higher inventory costs resulting in less profitability (Madhani, 2015). However,
Primark is not entirely flexible as they ordered stock for summer 2020 equating to
£370 million and could not sell it due to covid-19 and not having an e-commerce side
(Associated British Foods, 2020).
Primark's significant gaps are: the business not being hybrid and being viewed as
unethical/unsustainable by the public. In recent months, Primark not being hybrid
has affected them more significantly, as the Coivd-19 pandemic has meant that, for
months, Primark could not sell any products, resulting in a sales loss of £2 billion
worldwide (Associated British Foods, 2020). Primark's competitors, such as Next and
Zara, are prominent in the online market, with Next being the leader with online
annual sales of £1.2 billion in 2018 (Sabanoglu, 2020a). Sender (2020) states that
the online clothing and accessories market has increased by 26% in 2020, making
the total online market in the UK worth £24.5 billion. Lord Wolfson, chief executive of
Primark's rival Next, believes there has been a permanent shift to online shopping in
the retail industry due to the covid-19 pandemic (Jack, 2020). Primark's need for
hybrid operations can also be supported by data from the office for national statistics
(2020), which shows that internet sales as a percentage of total retail sales have
continually increased since 2007.
Primark could offer online delivery exclusively on their new wellness collection
(Associated British Foods, 2020). While these products are still at lower price points
(Associated British Foods, 2020), Primark could gradually increase the range of
goods offered in the collection to allow for a gradual price increase. This increase in
variety could be achieved through collaborating with recognized ethical fashion
brands such as Lucy & Yak and House of Sunny (Wilkinson, 2020). As stated in
Slack and Brandon-Jones (2019), the increase in variety would allow a business
such as Primark to more successfully match customer needs and, therefore, satisfy
them, potentially increasing sales and profitability. This strategy would also negate
the previously mentioned price point issue in Andrews and Forsey (2020). The
increased prices would potentially not be an issue, as customers are becoming more
aware of purchasing sustainable goods and are willing to pay a higher fee for them
(Shahbandeh, 2020). This method would also enhance the previously mentioned
ploy adapted from Mintzberg et al (2020) and allow Primark to more successfully
combat H&M's pledge of only using sustainable goods by 2030 (Morgan, 2020).
However, Baram (2020) states that due to covid-19 pandemic, consumers are
temporarily buying cheaper/less sustainable clothing.
Consequently, Primark may want to utilize this strategy more in 2-4 years because
sustainable attitudes will potentially rebound by 2022 and continue to grow (Baram,
2020). Moreover, offering delivery exclusively on the wellness collection would help
reduce the new system's risk of overloading and improve customer experience. By
adopting this method, Primark would be moving towards a strategy similar to H&M
(Morgan, 2020); while keeping their USP of low prices on the less sustainable goods
(Companies house, 2019). Also, by implementing this method, Primark would
improve their damaged ethical reputation mentioned in Jones et al (2009).
On the other hand, Primark could offer their lower-priced goods online with a
minimum purchase price or delivery fee, as seen on Zara (2020). This specific
delivery fee would ensure that it is profitable for Primark to offer deliveries. This
policy would help negate the effects of having a low price point mentioned by John
Bason in Andrews and Forsey (2020).
Primark could offer customers a free click and collect scheme, as seen on the Zara
(2020) website. This scheme would ensure that delivery fees are negated as
customers have to collect an order from Primark in person. Using this method,
Primark would have a chance to entice customers to browse stores, and therefore,
they can utilize the previously mentioned "kid and candy store feeling," which is a
part of their USP. (Kraaijenbrink, 2019). One negative of using this method is that
most of Primark's large stores are located in city centres (Associated British Foods,
2020). So, customers would have to travel into highly congested areas to collect
orders, which could cause stress and leave them dissatisfied. Also, if another
pandemic occurred, the click and collect system would potentially be forced to close,
thus making the new process void.
Eventually, Primark will need to adopt a delivery system as more customers are
continuing to order items to their house due to aspects such as covid-19 (Carroll,
2020). Ultimately, Primark should own the delivery system to exclusively offer online
delivery on sustainable items, with a delivery fee similar to Zara and H&M of £3.95
and above (Zara, 2020; H&M, 2020). Primark will also have to consider the "parcel
conundrum" mentioned in Bomford (2012). Bomford (2012) states the problems with
delivering to doors are: missed deliveries and customers wanting increased visibility
with their orders, which both incur costs. Primark may have to consider partnerships
with delivery companies such as DPD, known for their sustainable delivery methods,
such as using electric cars (DPD, 2020). This partnership will increase costs to
Primark as DPD will not deliver for free. However, Primark could use their scale
quantities mentioned in Companies house (2019) to potentially reduce the cost
incurred and, therefore, make a beneficial partnership. The alliance would bridge the
gap in sustainable delivery operations. This report will take the home delivery
method into part two, where the report will use soft systems methodology to re-
design the process.
Part two
Rich picture
Root definition
A Primark owned system to deliver products from their wellness collection. By means
of suitable transport. In order to improve market share through having a hybrid
method of retailing.
CATWOE table
To be
This is Primark's proposed to be process. This involves no traveling for the customer
as they can order online products exclusively from the wellness collection that will be
delivered to their addresses. The Administration Department handles the order
request, while the warehouse distribution centres load the transports and compose
orders.
Part three
Primark's key performance objectives for the new process are sales revenue, market
share, amount of returns, and employee turnover. These objectives will help Primark
understand if the new process is performing effectively and efficiently. Primark
managers should consider the five performance objectives cost, quality, speed,
dependability, and flexibility explained in Slack and Brandon-Jones (2019) when
implementing the new hybrid process.
When looking at the cost, the new process will see an increase in Primark's
expenses. This increase is due to the cost of implementing the new system and
training employees to execute the new process competently. A similar initiative from
Morrison's in 2014 saw expenditure, at its peak, increase by 50%, which was £550
million (Morrisons, 2014). As Primark will be exclusively offering delivery on the
wellness collection outlined in Associated British Foods (2020), peak expenditure will
be relatively lower than Morrison's amount. So, Primark's estimated peak
expenditure will be estimated to be around the figure of £300-400 million. Offering
delivery will permanently increase Primark's overall operating cost as they have
expanded into the online marketplace. However, the expenses that occur will be
negated by an increased market share from operating online.
Quality will need to be consistently high as prices will be more than the usual amount
when customers shop in-store. Managers will ensure a rigorous checking procedure
takes place before items are sent out to customers. The rigorous checking procedure
should be adapting from the current testing procedure mentioned in Companies
house (2019). This procedure will help reduce the risk of faulty items and therefore
keep return levels low.
Managers at Primark will need to allow the customer to choose a delivery day and a
time slot, as seen with rivals H&M (2020). Therefore, the new process will have to
have a considerable amount of flexibility and speed to ensure deadlines are met.
Bomford (2012) states a common criticism with deliveries is the vague delivery
times. So, Primark managers have to ensure that offered time slots are relatively
precise to ensure customer satisfaction is not negatively affected. A method that
effectively improves visibility for customers is a delivery notification system (Bomford,
2012). This system involves sending a text or email when the order is close to the
customer (Bomford, 2012). Thus, Primark managers have to establish a notification
system similar enhance customer satisfaction.
Primark should develop an in-house management system for the new process rather
than outsource. While outsourcing management can allow a business to focus on
other strategic aspects and free up time, it can lead to decreased employee morale
and autonomy (Belcourt, 2006). So, ultimately the needed investment in
infrastructure is a necessary expense when implementing an in-house management
system.
Primark's managers could see an opposition to change when trying to implement the
new hybrid process. Employees in an organization often resist change due to
cynicism, fear, preconceptions, and assumptions surrounding the new process
(Sohmen, 2016). Employees are often scared of the unfamiliar and of failing
(Sohmen, 2016). This reluctance might see potential job losses. As Bhatt (2020)
stated, resistances can be minimized through an effective change management
system. Bhatt (2020) concludes that to successfully manage and continue a change,
the change management system must have proper effective communication with
employees and constant evaluation. So, Primark managers will have to establish a
change management system is in place with these qualities to ensure that the hybrid
process is effective.
Primark balanced scorecard
Financial perspective
The 12% revenue increase figure is contrived from Sabanoglu (2020b), which shows
next online sales on launching in 2009 was £873 million. The figure is lower than the
Next amount because Primark will be launching exclusively with the wellness
collection and therefore not have a wide variety of choices at the start of the new
hybrid process. Primark's gross profit figure for 2019 was 19.8% (Companies house,
2019). Therefore, Primark should aim for a gross profit margin of 20% for online
sales.
Customer perspective
To have an
increase in the
previous figure of
6952 supplier
training hours
(Associated British
Foods, 2020).
Increase the Check products To have an Rewarding the
variety of online created and increase of 100 design team when
products offered offered on products after one they have created
Primark's online year. a successful
selling platforms. product line.
To reduce the To analyse the To reduce the Investing and
number of number of number of defects reviewing
defective defective products by 5% after one production/
products monthly. year. delivery methods
and continually
discussing how to
improve them.
In terms of the internal business perspective goals, as stated in Slack and Brandon-
Jones (2019), increasing the variety of products and offering quality items and
service allows a business to meet customer needs more successfully. Meeting
customer needs will allow Primark to improve the customer experience and meet the
financial perspective's sales goals. By reducing the defect rate by 5%, Primark would
help reduce costs and help meet the financial perspective's gross margin.
Primark employees' learning and growth are vital as employees are crucial in the
new system's success. The training initiative will help reduce employee fears and
reduce the change's impact on employee satisfaction (Bhatt, 2020). The initiative will
help reduce the employee turnover rate and reduce the cost incurred from training
new employees in the basics. Overall, meeting the learning and growth goals will
help employees implement and run the new process successfully, which will help
Primark meet financial goals and gain market share.
Reference list
Adams, M (2019) What can online businesses learn from asos' though new returns
policy? Available at: [Link]
new-returns-policy/ [Accessed 16th December 2020]
Andrews, J and Forsey, Z (2020) Why Primark doesn't do online shopping and
secrets from inside the budget chain, The Mirror. 16th April. Available at:
[Link]
[Accessed 8th December 2020]
Associated British Foods (2019) Associated British foods plc annual report and
accounts 2019. Available at:
[Link] [Accessed 2nd
December 2020]
Associated British Foods (2020) Associated British foods plc annual report and
accounts 2020. Available at:
[Link] [Accessed 30th
November 2020]
Baram, C (2020) Fashion and sustainability: inc the impact of covid-19- UK-
September 2020. Available at: [Link]
[Accessed 9th December 2020]
BBC News (2019) Asos threatens to block serial returners. 4th April. Available at:
[Link]
%20Asos%20has,if%20it%20notices%20anything%20unusual [Accessed 16th
December 2020]
Bomford, A (2012) The parcel conundrum, BBC News. 6th July. Available at:
[Link] [Accessed: 9th December 2020]
Carroll, N (2020) The impact of covid-19 on retail and e-commerce- UK- June 2020.
Available: [Link] [Accessed 9th
December 2020]
Dudovskiy, J (2016) Gap inc. Value chain analysis. Available at: [Link]
[Link]/gap-inc-value-chain-analysis/ [Accessed 10th December 2020].
Hinsliff, G (2019) Cheap and cheerful: why there's more to Primark's success than
you thought. The Guardian. 28th May. Available at:
[Link]
you-thought [Accessed 19th October 2020]
Hope, K (2018) The people who return most of what they buy, BBC News. 28th
November. Available at: [Link] [Accessed
16th December 2020]
Jack, S (2020) Thousands of traditional retail jobs' unviable', next boss warns, BBC
News. 24th September. Available at: [Link]
[Accessed 10th December 2020]
Jones, B., Temperley, J and Lima, A (2009) Corporate reputation in the era of Web
2.0: the case of Primark. Journal of marketing management, 25(9-10). Available at:
[Link]
Kraaijenbrink, J (2019) Why is Primark so successful? The power of alignment.
Forbes. 22nd January. Available at:
[Link]
successful-the-power-of-alignment/?sh=810f5d769d38 [ Accessed 29th November
2020]
Lamé, G., Jouini, O and Stal-Le Cardinal, J (2019) Combining Soft Systems
Methodology, ethnographic observation, and discrete-event simulation: A case study
in cancer care. Journal of the Operational Research Society, 71(10). Available at:
[Link]
Madhani, P.M (2015) Enhancing customer lifetime value in fast fashion retailing with
RFID initiatives. International Journal of Business and Globalisation, 15(2). Available
at: [Link]
Mintzberg, H., Ahlstrand, B. and Lampel, J.B (2020) Strategy safari. 2nd edition.
United Kingdom: Pearson.
Office for national statistics (2020) Internet sales as a percentage of total retail sales
(ratio) (%). Available at:
[Link]
[Accessed 18th December 2020].
Primark (2020a) Primark cares. Available at: [Link]
cares [Accessed 25th November 2020]
Sabanoglu, T (2020a) online clothing market in the UK – statistics & facts. Available
at: [Link] [ Accessed
8th December 2020]
Sabanoglu, T (2020b) Retail and online sales of Next plc from financial years
2009/10 to 2019/20. Available at: [Link]
and-online-sales-next-plc/ [Accessed 17th December 2020]
Shahbandeh, M (2020) How much more are you willing to pay for sustainable
fashion than normal fashion? Available at:
[Link]
sustainable-fashion-products-by-amount-worldwide/ [Accessed 9th December 2020]
Wilkinson, M (2020) Planet fashion: the 10 coolest ethical fashion brands, The
Guardian. 21st April. Available at:
[Link]
coolest-ethical-fashion-brands [Accessed 19th December 2020]
Zara (2020) Delivery methods and costs. Available at:
[Link] [Accessed:
9th December 2020]