0 ratings 0% found this document useful (0 votes) 53 views 14 pages Chapter 7
The document outlines the importance of mineral exploitation in Zimbabwe, detailing various minerals, their economic significance, and the mining methods employed. It discusses factors influencing mining, environmental impacts, and the legislative framework governing the sector. Additionally, it highlights the role of small-scale mining and the challenges faced by miners, along with potential solutions to improve the industry.
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content,
claim it here .
Available Formats
Download as PDF or read online on Scribd
Go to previous items Go to next items
ae
Pnteata |
A Prailiced Approach to
Geography
‘O’ Level Revision
Sue
llabus objectives
eal IZIMSEC questions
and answersPret (ct 2 ID cy Vw O rm DT Ce)
Objectives
By the end of this topic, you should be able
to:
© identify minerals that are found in
Zimbabwe.
© listand explain the categories of
‘minerals in Zimbabwe.
© explain the factors influencing the
exploitation of minerals.
© explain the concept of mineralogy.
© describe the environmental impact of
‘mining.
© outline the legislative framework on
‘mining and mining rights.
© explain the processing of minerals in
Zimbabwe and other African countries
© describe the importance of beneficiation
ofminerals in Zimbabwe.
‘© explain the importance of health and
safety issues in mining.
‘© explain the concept of Environmemal
Impact Assessment (BLA).
Introduction
The extraction of minerals is a very important
primary activity in many countries which has led
to great economic developments
Mining refers to the extraction of valuable
minerals, liquids and gases from the earth which
are present as ores, seams, veins or liquids.
Even in ancient times, mining formed the basis
of economic activities from the onset of the Stone
Age.
Zimbabwe's economy is also hinged on mineral
exploitation with the country having more than,
sixty minerals of economic value,
Factors influencing mining
Capital
* Technology.
© Market
+ Labour.
© Transport,
* Quality of ore
* Size of seam,
Minerals and mines in Zimbabwe
Nickel - Bindura
+ Coal - Hwange
© Phosphates - Dorowa
* Tin -Kamativi
© Asbestos = Mashava
Diamonds —- Marange
© Gold = Mazowe
* Copper = Mhangura
© Emeralds -Mberengwa
© Platinum: ~ Ngezi
Distribution of minerals in Zimbabwe
* Most of Zimbabwe's minerals are found
along the Great Dyke which stretches
from West Nicholson in the Midlands
to Bindura in Mashonaland Central
Province.
© Dykes are intrusive volcanic extrusions
that cut across bedding planes ejecting
magma,
«The magma forms a ridge which will be
rich in different kinds of minerals,‘© The Great Dyke in Zimbabwe has
length of 550km and a width of
approximately 11km.
© The Dyke was discovered in 1925.
© Ithas minerals such as gold, chrome
and platinum.
sting
a
moe
Waowom tae
Cwm
. he pee
Fig. 71 Distribution of minerals in Zimbabwe
Precious minerals in Zimbabwe
Gold.
Platinum,
© Diamonds.
Chrome,
+ Copper
Minerals in Zimbabwe are ranked according to
‘heir economic value and the foreign currency
sefums they generate as well as contribution to
‘he national GDP.
‘Ores and mineral groups
* Chrome,
Copper.
Nickel.
Platinum,
‘Tungsten
Tron.
+ Lithium,
Mineral groups
Minerals can be grouped into:
© Ubiquitous minerals ~ These are
common minerals of low value such as
river sand, gravel and quarry stones that
are found everywhere,
© Non-ubiquitous minerals ~ These are
high value and rare minerals which
include gold, diamond, platinum, oil,
copper and chrome,
‘© Metallic minerals ~ These consist of
metals in their chemical composition.
‘They include manganese, iron ore and
bauxite
+ Non-metallic minerals ~ They shine
in their appearance and show a non-
metallic lustre, They include limestone,
‘gypsum and mica.
Uses of selected minerals in
Zimbabwe
Gold
Gold coins.
Jewellery.
© Gold plating.
+ Blectroplating
© Manufacture of electricity cables.
* Manufacture of cutlery.
Asbestos
* Manufacture of roofing sheets.
* — Manufacture of protective clothing,
Coal
© Manufacture of thermal electricity.
© Domestic and industrial heating.Importance of minerals in Zimbabwe
Zimbabwe has a variety of minerals that
are valuable, The importance of minerals in
Zimbabwe is seen through:
* Foreign currency earnings for the
country,
* Creation of employment,
* Development of thriving mi
communities such as Hwange,
Zvishavane, Shamva, Mazowe to
mention a few.
© Substantial contribution to the country’s
Gross Domestic Product.
+ Empowerment of marginalised
communities such as Mutoko and
‘Marange through mining granite and
diamonds respectively.
* Improvement of people’s lives who
are directly and indirectly involved in
mining.
Infrastructural development,
Development of industries that rely on
‘minerals as raw material
Mining methods in Zimbabwe
Basically there are methods which are
1g
(a) Surface mining
(b) Underground mining
(@) Surface mining techniques
(i) Open cast mining
* A method used for extracting the
‘mineral from the earth by their removal
from an open pit.
* Overburden produced is removed using
excavators and draglines.
* Avery cheap mining technique
especially on seams that are near the
surface
* In Zimbabwe, the method was used
at Hwange for coal, Zvishavane and
‘Mashava for asbestos.
Fig. 22 An open cast mine
Advantages
* — Itis cheap.
+ Itis less risky,
* Itisa simple method.
‘+ Enables bulk exploitation
Disadvantages
© Causes sight pollution.
© Results in erosion.
© Causes deforestation
‘© Blasting destroys buildings and other
infrastructure and it can also harm
miners.
© Creates habitats for mosquitoes causing
malaria,
(li) Strip mining
Involves use of graders to scrape off ore
just below the top soil like chrome ore in
‘Mutorashanga in Zimbabwe. Steps followed when
extracting the ore is similar to that of open cast
mining.
Advantages of strip mining
‘© Cheap technique of extracting
‘© Simple technique.
+ Less risky.
© Shallow open pits ensures fast
accessibility to minerals,
Disadvantages
© Blasting of rocks damages
infrastructure,
© Causes land degradation,© Causes deforestation,
* — Destruction of arable lands for
agriculture
(ill) Quarrying
It is a surface mining technique mostly done for
onstruction purposes where small pits are dug
or cut. Quarrying can be done at a large or small
scale, Black granite explorations in Mutoko are an
example of quarrying activities, It also supplies
headstones, rocks, and dust and pit sand mostly
for the construction industry,
Advantages
Creates employment for local people.
| © Less risky.
| Does not require complex technology.
| * Can be done by unskilled and semi-
skilled miners,
Disadvantages
* Noise pollution,
Land degradation,
other infrastructure and even people's
health,
t
* Blasting effect damages buildings and
* Destruction of habitats for wildlife
| @) Altuvial/placer Mining
| Method used to extract minerals occurring in
| alluvial deposits, for example, gol, tin, diamonds
| ‘eed platinum
Advantages
is considered the most environmentally
| friendly method of gold mining as a result of the
|
‘duced environmental impact when compared to
| ‘Sderground mining,
Disadvantages
* Not very productive.
* Lack safety and tend to have a high
environmental impact.
(v) Panning
It involves;
* Digging a mixture of sand, gravel and
mineral from the river bed,
* Putting it in a pan and rotating the pan
while tilted.
* The lighter sand or gravel is washed
‘on the side leaving the heavier mineral
at the bottom of the pan for example
‘gold mining along Angwa and Mazowe
rivers,
(b) Underground mining
‘Method employed when the mineral lies very
deep below the surface and the overburden is too
thick to be removed by mechanical means,
Underground mining techniques
(i) Shaft method
Method is used when the mineral seam is deep
underground,
How it is carried out
* Vertical shafts are sunk into the
cearth’s crust to reach the layer with the
mineral.
* Horizontal tunnels are dug from the
vertical shaft to reach the mineral
* Props are erected to support the roof to
prevent it from collapsing,
+ The mineral bearing rock is blasted
loose by explosives
* The deposit is transported on light rail
‘oF conveyor belt to the bottom of the
shaft
* _Itis then brought to the surface ina
crane or a lft called cage,
(ii) Dritt or adit mining
* — Method employed when the mineral
deposit can be reached from the valley
sides‘© Horizontal tunnels (adits) are
constructed from the side of a
‘mountain,
‘© Railway line is constructed into
the mine to bring out the mineral,
for example, mining of asbestos in
‘Zvishavane and Mashava.
Mineralogy
Methods of prospecting for gold
Gold is one of the major foreign currency earners
cof Zimbabwe. There are various methods used for
‘gold prospecting.
‘These are:
* Geochemical prospecting ~ Based on
systematic measurement of one or more
of the chemical properties of rock,
soil, glacial debris, stream sediment,
‘water or plants, The chemical mostly
measured is the content of key trace
element.
© Geophysical prospecting - Combines
the sciences of physies and geology to
locate ore deposits. For example, the
use of Geiger counters for detecting
radioactive uranium deposits and
‘magnetic surveys to find iron deposits.
Geophysical methods
© Magnetic,
© Gravimetric,
© Electrical
© Radiometric.
© Seismic,
Indicator plants ~ these are used in prospecting
for deeply embedded mineral seams using the
root system,
Activity 7.1
(a) Embark on a visit o a mine in your locality
and study the mining method that is used
there.
(b) Record the advantages and disadvantages of
the method being used at the mine,
Physio-chemical properties of alluvial
minerals
Most alluvial mineral deposits are mainly
constituted by soils such as sand and clay in
river beds, Several alluvial minerals such as gold
and tin are found in the river beds mainly on
the lower course where deposition takes place.
Some of them are found on flood plains which are
areas mostly prone to flooding and deposition. In
Zimbabwe, the major mineral found in river beds
{s gold on rivers such as Angwa, Save, Mazowe,
dzi, Shashe and Shangani. These minerals found
in rivers appear in very small quantities. These
minerals are mostly mined by artisanal miners on
asmall scale,
Methods of gold panning
© Dredging.
© Placer mining.
© Shuicing
Problems of gold mining
River siltation.
‘Water pollution due to use of chemicals.
Land degradation as open pits are left
Reduction in tourism potential for
example Umzingwane.
Deforestation.
Loss of life due to mine collapse.
Crime.
Social ills such as prostitution
Money laundering,Measures to increase gold panning
contributions to the economy
‘Reducing procedures and paperwork
requirements needed for one to venture
into gold panning.
Assisting youths to access loans from
banks so as to venture into regularised
gold panning so as to contribute to the
national gold output
Carrying out educational campaigns for
youth to venture into mining so as to
create empowerment.
Organising youths into cooperatives for
maximum capacity utilisation
Fostering partnerships with
international investors to ensure
maximum output.
Opening schools of mining so as to
empower locals who venture into
‘mining, For example, the school of
mines
Environmental impact of mining
The exploitation of mineral
resources can have negative impacts
‘on the environment, Some of the
environmental impacts include:
= Widespread siltation along rivers
affecting river capacity, Rivers
such as Angwa in Mashonaland
West is heavily silted due to
mining activities
= Use of chemicals in cleaning
and purifying minerals can
have negative impacts on the
environment, For example, the use
of mercury in gold panning.
= Deforestation is a major
characteristic of major mining
areas and hence trees are a major
‘component of the environment
which should be protected.
= Water pollution is also widespread
in mining areas due to disposal of
chemicals which eventually affect
aquatic life, for example, fish,
= Mining produces a lot of dust
which causes air pollution and
disturbes pollination, for example,
trees surrounding Dorowa mines
are affected by air pollution.
= Processes such as smelting at
‘mines result in the emission of
‘gases into the air damaging the
‘ozone layer and contributing to
‘ozone depletion as well as acid
rain which destroys the vegetation
resources,
= Big pits that are left by mining
companies cause sight pollution
as well as becoming breeding
grounds of mosquitos
Mitigation measures
Before any mining takes place, there
is need for an (EIA) Environmental
Impact Assessment which a
document outlining the road map
of a mining venture in terms of
how the environment is going to be
rehabilitated.
Legislative frameworks need to be in
place so that underhand dealings are
climinated and mining laws are being
religiously followed. For example,
the Minerals and Mines Act has to be
valued and followed very seriously.
‘The Environmental Management Act is
another one to be followed in earnest.
Rehabilitation efforts need to be stepped
up so that the environment is restored to
its former self after exploitation
Education efforts also need to be
stepped up so that the general people
become aware of the importance of the
environment, Education can be in form
of awareness campaigns,‘+ There is need for mineral substitution in
order to scale down exploitation which
threatens the environment. For example,
recycled material can be used instead of
exploiting mineral reserves.
Small scale mining
This is the extraction of mineral ore by
individuals and groups not formally employed
by large mining conglomerates, In Zimbabwe, it
accounts for a significant percentage of mining
activities in the country.
‘The characteristics of small scale mining are:
‘* Miners use simple technology such as
hoes, mattocks and shovels
Miners use less capital
Workers are semi-skilled and unskilled.
Mining is done at a subsistence level
The mining activities are haphazard and
not organised.
* Mining is seasonal and mostly done
during the winter and dry season.
* There are poor health and safety
‘measures in the mines,
+ Miners usually employ minors which is
against the law.
‘* Most of their output is sold through
informal markets.
* The miners are always against law
enforcement agencies,
Contribution of small scale mining to
Zimbabwe
‘+ Simall scale mining creates employment
in various capacities.
‘© Small scale mining contributes
significantly to the country’s Gross
Domestic Product (GDP).
© Small scale mining brings the much
needed foreign currency in the country
through sale of mineral output.
© They act as a source of revenue for the
government through payment of tax.
* The mines also raise the standard of
living for the people either directly or
indirectly.
‘+ Small scale mines provide raw
materials for other industries
* They necessitate more output from the
large established mining companies
through competition
Challenges faced by small scale mining
industry
Small scale mining industry faces a plethora of
challenges and these include:
failing to harness appropriate
technology.
* failing to access financial resources
from banks due to lack of collateral
security,
‘+ facing a lot of accidents due to the
hiring of unskilled labour, small scale
mines face a lot of accidents.
* — working conditions are very poor in
small scale mines,
* falling prey to unscrupulous dealers
resulting in heavy losses,
‘* suffering from serious competition from
large established mining companies.
Solutions to challenges faced by small scale
mining
‘Small scale mines can be assisted by both the
public and the private sector,
Some of the measures that can be done to solve
the challenges faced by small scale miners
include:
* Organising small scale miners into
‘cooperatives so that they pull resources
together.
© Government funded mechanisation
programmes that can help small players
to harness technology.|
|
|
Provision of cheap loans so that small
mining players can have access to
finance,
Organisation of safety health workshops
for small scale mining concerns so that
accidents can be reduced,
Providing a framework for small scale
‘miners to sell their produce at formal
markets,
Speeding up the registration process so
that small players can get into regulated
mining,
Legislative framework in mining
Zimbabwe has a variety of legislative guidelines
that control the mining sector so as to have order
and sanity in the sector. Some of the legislative
instruments include:
1. The Mine
and Minerals Act
The Mines and Minerals Act was
enacted in 1961 and governs mining
activities, processing of minerals and
mining rights.
The Act has been amended several
times, The Act also governs the
registration of miners and prospectors
as well as licensing of mines.
The Act sets out rules and obligations
observed when carrying out mining
activities. Payment of license fees to
local authorities is also governed by the
Act,
2 Environmental Management Act
Mining destroys the environment,
hence the need to have legislation
which governs how actors in the
mining industry ought to protect the
environment.
The Act seeks to protect the
environment from the negative effects
‘of mining on the environment.
Mining causes land, air, water and sight
pollution.
The Act henceforth acts as the police
for the environment, Violators of the
Act are prosecuted,
3. The National Social Security Authority Act
The Act was put into action in 1989 for
the purpose of protecting workers and
employers from work related hazards
and risks,
Both employers and employees need
protection from work related accidents
and risks
At mines, miners are exposed to great
risks as they work with chemicals and
‘other hazardous substances hence the
need fo have an Act which protects
against losses,
The Act compels mine owners to invest
in safety in order to prevent mishaps
at work. Protective clothing, proper
ventilation and sound machinery are
some of the requirements of a proper
working environment.
The Act therefore provides parameters
that should not be violated as
prosecution or fine may result
4. Precious Minerals Act
The Act was enacted to govern the sale
of precious minerals such as gold.
‘Mines involved in the mining and sale
of those precious minerals have to
strictly comply with the Act to avoid
violation which lead to prosecution,
The Act is there to ensure that the
country benefits from the exploitation
of the precious minerals.Zimbabwe
Processing of minerals
© Due to improvements in technology,
alot of countries in Africa are now
practising beneficiation and value
addition of their minerals 50 as to
improve their revenue.
© Zimbabwe has quiet a number of
minerals that bring a lot of foreign
‘currency to the country. Some of the
minerals that the country boast of are
Gold
© — Gold in Zimbabwe is mined by both
mining conglomerates and artisanal
miners. It is mined at mines such
‘as Penhalonga, Redwing, Renco
‘Sandawana and Turk Mine. Gold
undergoes a lot of beneficiation to
separate it from the gold bearing rocks.
'* Companies use shaft mining. For
artisanal miners, the gold will be found
con the river banks though they follow
processes until they get the pure gold
‘ore, The processes include:
Extraction from river bank or gold
seam.
- Crushing.
= Processing using mercury and
cyanide.
Melting gold
= Moulding into gold bars
Diamond
Zimbabwe has diamond fields in Marange and
Mberengwa. Diamonds are also found in alluvial
deposits and are also mined by panners‘The
processing of diamonds involves:
Crushing ~ This reduces large run of
‘mine lumps into smaller pieces making,
them easier to handle.
‘© Screening ~ Ore is sized using vibrating
screens after each crushing stage
+ Scrubbing This is used to wash and
break down clay lumps present in the
ore
* Concentration ~ Ore is mixed into
a ferrosilicon slurry, then fed to a
dense media cyclone, where the heavy
minerals are separated from the waste.
* Collection - Diamonds are recovered
in various ways such as on belts or
vibrating tables coated with a specially
formulated grease that only the
diamonds stick to or by an x-ray sorting
‘which identifies diamonds as they
fluoresce or by their atomic mass.
‘Maia Go minerals
"eases
Nickel
© Copper
eLiun
on
PPhosciate
Kiron gee
oat
1m Micaand Beri
elds
APrrite
Ocoat Fit
(O Gicsasone Bat
(9 wu ye
—Rallvay
Fig. 7.3 Minerals distribution in Zimbabwe
Coal
Fig. 74 CoalZimbabwe has big coal fields in
Hwange and Mberengwa. Currently
coal exploitation is being done at
‘Hwange using underground mining
methods.
Coal is a high energy and flammable
fossil fuel used in the energy sector.
Coal processing is done in Zimbabwe.
Processing is done through crushing,
washing and grading In Zimbabwe,
coal is mainly used for generating
thermal energy as well as for domestic
usage in cooking and heating, Itis
also used in the agricultural sector for
‘curing tobacco.
Tron and steel industries also use coal to
smelt iron ore. Coal also produces coke
Tar and Benzol are also obtained from
coal and they constitute 1% of blend
fuel.
Chrome in Zimbabwe is mined at mines
such as Shurugwi and Kildonan
Chrome ore is screened and loaded
into trucks for further processing.
Processing of chrome is done at
ZIMASCO in Kwekwe and Gweru.
The chrome ore is checked for quality,
weighed and heated in furnaces and
mixed with iron, Chrome is mixed with
iron to produce ferro-chrome which is
exported,
Fig. 75 Chrome
Beneficiation
Beneficiation is the process of converting ores
into concentrated metals, for example, conversion
of iron ore into alloys, Beneficiation has a lot of
advantages to the economy. These include:
* More foreign currency from exporting
processed minerals.
* Creation of employment when factories
engaged in processing of mineral ores
are set up.
+ Communities share ownership schemes
which can result in the development of
infrastructure mainly in rural areas that
were previously marginalised.
* — More local people can get into
mining related businesses through
subcontracting by big conglomerates.
+ Beneficiation results in more benefits
for the local communities as minerals
are sold with a high value,
+ Beneficiation results in reduced brain
drain,
Safety and health in mining
Mining is a very hazardous and dangerous
‘occupation which can lead to health related
problems and death in case of disasters. Health
issues tend to take centre stage in the mining
industry. Mine workers deal with explosives,
chemicals and dangerous environments.
Mining companies should ensure the following:
‘+ Assound health policy,
‘* A funetional clinic at the mine
‘= Acompensation framework in case of
accidents,
* A functional first aid team,
‘+ Periodical health coaching clinics.
* Adequate protective clothing.Importance of health in mining
Guarantees continuity of operations.
Ensures maximum capacity utilisation
Ensures a competitive advantage for a
mining concern,
Guarantees mining growth.
Reduces staff turnover.
Sustainable use of minerals
Mining ventures destroy the
environment especially with regards to
the future,
‘When carrying out mining activities,
due care needs to be done so that the
environment remains in its natural state
as ever.
Sustainable exploitation and use of
minerals guarantees an ever intact
environment.
To develop sustainably, there will be
need to consider the environment for
the purposes of the future
For the purpose of sustainable
utilisation of mineral resources, the
following can be done:
~ — Reuse ~ This can result in
resources lasting longer as the
same resource can be used over
and over again.
= Recycling - Waste materials
can be used for developing other
products.
= Miiltiple usage of the same
resource,
Sustainable use of mineral resources
is necessary as minerals are non-
renewable resources but if utilised in a
sustainable way long term benefits cane
be realised.
Environmental Impact Assessment
(EIA)
‘© Mining is an activity that destroys the
environment
‘+ _Ittherefore needs to be undertaken
with the environment in mind. An
environmental impact assessment needs
to be done before any mining venture.
© The EIA is a document outlining
how the environment is going to
be rehabilitated due to the mining
activities being done,
* _ EIAis compulsory especially in
developed nations while a number of
developing countries are now taking it
seriously
Purpose of EIA
‘© Potentially screens out environmentally
unsound projects
‘© Proposes modified designs to reduce
environmental impacts.
© Identifies feasible alternatives.
+ Predicts feasible alternatives.
* Identifies mitigation measures.
© Influences decision making and the
development of terms and conditions
EIA steps
Screening
This is the step of evaluating proposals to find out
which ones should be subjected to an EIA or not
Scoping
‘© This is the process of finding out issues
that are likely to be important during
the detailed EIA phase,
+ Italso involves an interaction between
the affected, interested parties,
government and proponents for
identifying issues with respect to a
proposed project.Baseline study
* — Itinvolves collection of all the
information about the environment.
* Itprovides a baseline against which
possible impacts and change as a result
of the project can be measured.
Impact prediction
It involves predictions about the change that can
be brought as a result of undertaking the project.
Impact assessment
Assessment requires careful, expert interpretation
and understanding of impacts so as to influence
decision making.
Mitigation
Itinvolves taking measures to reduce or remove
‘environmental impacts,
Producing environment impact statement
‘tis a formal document released and outlining all.
‘the information about the project that would have
been gathered.
EIA Review
A team from EMA assesses the adequacy of an
IA report, taking into consideration impacts
‘es the environment, rehabilitation plans and
‘comments from the public.
| Monitoring and auditing
* _Itis carried out to provide relevant
information about impacts that can be
used by the entity seeking to do mining
activities.
+ Monitoring is done to test the accuracy
of impact predictions,
Importance of EIA to the mining
industry
Carrying out an EIA is very important in the
mining industry as it ensures a lot of advantages,
EIA helps in the following parameters:
+ Ithelps to eliminate environmental
degradation.
+ Ensures maximum capacity utilisation.
* — Maintains environmental originality.
* Helps a miner to have indepth
knowledge of the area helshe seeks to
do business
* Promotes sustainable utilisation of
mineral resources,
‘© Encourages serious investment
Cost benefit analysis
* tis process of weighing up benefits
and costs for decision making purposes
‘+ Itis a means of securing the best
position when intending to get into a
mining venture.
+ The aim is to avoid positions that give a
disadvantage to a miner,
* — When doing business there are cost
and benefits associated. Benefits should
outweigh costs.
+ A scenario will be when opening a
mining venture in a rugged area, alot
of cost will be incurred in rehabilitating
the area and if the value of the mineral
falls short of the cost of rehabilitation,
mining will not be permissible there,
Procedure in cost benefit analysis
‘© Making a comprehensive list of the cost
and benefits, This includes costs such as
direct, indirect and unseen costs of risk.
+ A monetary unit of all the cost is drawn
up. No overstating and understating is
permissible,Importance of cost benefit analysis in mining
‘Comparison of the values of costs and
benefits.
Decision making.
Ithelps in making proper decisions in
mining.
Tis very expensive to set up and start
‘mining operations especially in bulky
mining.
Mining can have huge environmental
impacts, some of which might be
unforeseen and could add more cost in
the future
Carrying out cost benefit analysis
helps to maintain a culture of being
responsible by carrying out a proper
cost benefit analy: