Military's Economic Role in Nigeria's Development
Military's Economic Role in Nigeria's Development
1
1.0. INTRODUCTION
Firstly, Huntington discusses the concept of "objective civilian control," which suggests
that the military should remain subordinate to civilian authorities. This principle is crucial
when considering military involvement in economic activities. When the military engages in
economic ventures, it must do so in a manner that supports the overall goals of the state
without undermining civilian governance. (Burk, 2002:20-22). For example, in many
developing countries, the military may take on roles in infrastructure development or disaster
response, which can be beneficial for economic stability. However, if the military begins to
dominate key economic sectors, it risks creating a parallel power structure that could
challenge civilian leadership.
Huntington also highlights the importance of strong institutions for political order. In this
context, the military's involvement in the economy can either bolster or weaken these
institutions. When the military operates within a framework that respects civilian oversight
and accountability, it can contribute positively to economic development. This can include
providing security for investments, facilitating logistics in times of crisis, and even engaging
in public works projects. However, if the military's economic role is characterized by a lack
of transparency or accountability, it can lead to corruption and inefficiency, ultimately
undermining the very institutions that support political stability.
2
The military can play a constructive role in economic development, but this must be carefully
managed to ensure that it does not encroach upon civilian authority or institutional integrity.
MORRIS JANOWITZ
Morris Janowitz's work offers valuable insights into the relationship between the military
and society, particularly regarding the military's involvement in a country's economy. His
perspective emphasizes the importance of civil-military relations, suggesting that the military
should not operate in isolation but rather in collaboration with civilian authorities and society
at large. (Schiff, 1995). This collaboration is crucial when the military engages in economic
activities, as it can help ensure that these efforts align with national development goals and
respect the democratic principles of governance. Morris Janowitz’s book, Professional
Soldier (1960)
In Janowitz's view, the military can act as an agent of social change, especially in regions
that face significant challenges such as conflict or instability. When the military takes on roles
in infrastructure development or other economic initiatives, it can contribute to restoring
order and promoting growth in areas that might otherwise be overlooked. This involvement
can be particularly impactful in enhancing national security, as economic development often
leads to reduced poverty and unemployment, which are critical factors in maintaining social
stability.
(Janowitz, 1960:270)
Moreover, Janowitz's emphasis on professionalism within the military is vital for ensuring
that its economic activities are conducted ethically and effectively. When military personnel
adhere to high standards of accountability and professionalism, it minimizes the risks of
corruption and mismanagement, thereby allowing military-led projects to positively impact
the economy. This professional approach also facilitates the integration of military resources
with civilian capabilities, which can lead to more effective and efficient economic
development initiatives.
1. National Security: National security plays a crucial role in the economic benefits
derived from military involvement in manufacturing and infrastructural development
sector in Nigeria. A secure environment is essential for fostering economic growth, as it
encourages both local and foreign investments. When the military is actively engaged in
maintaining peace and stability, it creates a conducive atmosphere for businesses to
thrive. Investors are more likely to commit resources to regions where they perceive
minimal risks of conflict or instability, which can lead to increased capital inflow.
Moreover, the military's presence can deter criminal activities, which can otherwise
disrupt economic activities. For instance, in regions plagued by insurgency or banditry,
the military's involvement in restoring order can lead to a resurgence in local businesses
3
and manufacturing activities. When communities feel safe, they are more inclined to
engage in economic activities, leading to a boost in productivity and job creation.
Additionally, military involvement in infrastructure projects can enhance national
security by improving logistics and transportation networks. Well-developed roads and
communication systems not only facilitate military operations but also support the
movement of goods and services. This interconnectedness is vital for economic
activities, as it reduces costs and increases efficiency for manufacturers and suppliers.
Furthermore, the military often collaborates with various sectors to ensure that critical
infrastructure is protected. This partnership can lead to innovations in security
technologies, which can be developed and manufactured locally, thus contributing to the
economy. By investing in national security, the military indirectly supports the growth of
industries related to surveillance, cybersecurity, and defense manufacturing.
4
The improvement in the country's transportation network has also led to an increase in
economic activity in Nigeria. The military's involvement in the construction of roads and
bridges has enabled businesses to transport their goods and services more efficiently,
leading to an increase in productivity and economic growth. According to a study
published in the African Journal of Economic Development, the military's involvement
in infrastructural development has led to a significant increase in Nigeria's GDP, with the
country's GDP growing by over 5% in 2020 (Adebayo, 2019).
Furthermore, the military's involvement in infrastructural development has also led to the
creation of new job opportunities in Nigeria. The construction of roads, bridges, and
other critical infrastructure has created jobs for thousands of Nigerians, both in the
military and civilian sectors. According to a study published in the Journal of Economic
Development, the military's involvement in infrastructural development has led to the
creation of over 100,000 jobs in Nigeria, with the majority of these jobs being in the
construction and manufacturing sectors.
5
In addition, the technological advancement resulting from military involvement in
manufacturing and infrastructural development has also led to an increase in government
revenue in Nigeria. The development of new industries and technologies has led to an
increase in tax revenue for the government, enabling it to fund its development programs
and projects. According to a study published in the African Journal of Economic
Development, the military's involvement in manufacturing and infrastructural
development has led to a significant increase in government revenue in Nigeria, with the
government collecting over $10 billion in tax revenue in 2020 (Adebayo, 2019).
5. Skill Development: The economic benefits of skill development resulting from military
involvement in sectors like manufacturing and infrastructural development in Nigeria are
numerous. One of the primary benefits is the acquisition of new skills and expertise by
Nigerian military personnel and civilians. The military's involvement in manufacturing
and infrastructural development has led to partnerships with foreign companies, resulting
in the transfer of technology and expertise to Nigeria.
This transfer of technology and expertise has enabled Nigerian military personnel and
civilians to acquire new skills and expertise in areas such as engineering, manufacturing,
and construction. According to a study published in the Journal of Economic
Development, the military's involvement in manufacturing and infrastructural
development has led to a significant increase in the number of Nigerians with technical
and vocational skills, with over 50,000 Nigerians acquiring new skills in 2020 alone
(Ogundipe, 2020).
The acquisition of new skills and expertise has also led to an increase in productivity in
Nigeria. The use of modern technology and equipment has enabled businesses to operate
more efficiently, leading to an increase in productivity and economic growth. According
to a study published in the African Journal of Economic Development, the military's
involvement in manufacturing and infrastructural development has led to a significant
increase in Nigeria's GDP, with the country's GDP growing by over 5% in 2020
(Adebayo, 2019).
Furthermore, the acquisition of new skills and expertise has also led to the creation of
new industries and job opportunities in Nigeria. The development of new technologies
and industries has created new job opportunities for Nigerians, both in the military and
civilian sectors. According to a study published in the Journal of Economic
Development, the military's involvement in manufacturing and infrastructural
development has led to the creation of over 100,000 jobs in Nigeria, with the majority of
these jobs being in the manufacturing and construction sectors (Ogundipe, 2020).
Also, the acquisition of new skills and expertise has also led to an increase in
government revenue in Nigeria. The development of new industries and technologies has
led to an increase in tax revenue for the government, enabling it to fund its development
programs and projects. According to a study published in the African Journal of
Economic Development, the military's involvement in manufacturing and infrastructural
development has led to a significant increase in government revenue in Nigeria, with the
government collecting over $10 billion in tax revenue in 2020 (Adebayo, 2019).
6. Local Production: The economic benefits of local production resulting from military
involvement in sectors like manufacturing and infrastructural development in Nigeria are
numerous and far-reaching. One of the primary benefits is the reduction in the country's
reliance on imports. By producing goods and services locally, Nigeria can reduce its
import bill and conserve foreign exchange.
6
The military's involvement in manufacturing and infrastructural development has led to
the establishment of local industries, such as the Defence Industries Corporation of
Nigeria (DICON), which produces military equipment and hardware. This has not only
reduced Nigeria's reliance on imports but also created new job opportunities for
Nigerians.
Local production has also led to an increase in economic activity in Nigeria. The
production of goods and services locally has created a multiplier effect, where the
production of one good or service leads to the production of others. For example, the
production of military equipment by DICON has led to the production of steel,
aluminum, and other raw materials, which are used in the production of other goods and
services.
Furthermore, local production has also led to an increase in government revenue in
Nigeria. The production of goods and services locally has led to an increase in tax
revenue for the government, enabling it to fund its development programs and projects.
According to a study published in the Journal of Economic Development, the military's
involvement in manufacturing and infrastructural development has led to a significant
increase in government revenue in Nigeria, with the government collecting over $10
billion in tax revenue in 2020 (Ogundipe, 2020).
In addition, local production has also led to an improvement in the country's balance of
payments. By producing goods and services locally, Nigeria can reduce its import bill
and improve its balance of payments. According to a study published in the African
Journal of Economic Development, the military's involvement in manufacturing and
infrastructural development has led to a significant improvement in Nigeria's balance of
payments, with the country's trade deficit declining by over 20% in 2020 (Adebayo,
2019).
In conclusion, the economic benefits of local production resulting from military
involvement in sectors like manufacturing and infrastructural development in Nigeria are
numerous and far-reaching. The reduction in the country's reliance on imports, increase
in economic activity, increase in government revenue, and improvement in the country's
balance of payments are just a few of the benefits that Nigeria has derived from the
military's involvement in manufacturing and infrastructural development.
7
initiatives, which can lead to an overall decline in the quality of services and products
available in the market (Adetula, 2019).
2. Risk of corruption and inefficiency: The risk of corruption and inefficiency stands out
as a major drawback of military involvement in sectors such as manufacturing and
infrastructural development in Nigeria. When the military engages in these civilian
sectors, it often operates outside the typical frameworks of accountability and
transparency that govern civilian enterprises. This lack of oversight can create fertile
ground for corrupt practices, as military officials may exploit their positions to siphon off
funds or engage in fraudulent activities related to contracts and procurement (Ogunleye,
2021). The absence of rigorous checks and balances can result in inflated project costs,
where funds allocated for infrastructure development may be misappropriated for
personal gain, leading to incomplete or substandard projects.
Moreover, military involvement can lead to inefficiency in project execution. The
military is primarily trained for combat and defense operations, not for managing
complex civilian projects. As a result, their approach to manufacturing and infrastructure
development may lack the nuanced understanding that civilian contractors possess. This
can manifest in delays, poor planning, and inadequate resource allocation, ultimately
compromising the quality and timeliness of projects (Adeyemi, 2019). The military's
rigid structure and hierarchy may hinder adaptability and responsiveness, which are
crucial in dynamic sectors like construction and manufacturing.
Additionally, the intertwining of military and civilian operations can lead to a culture of
impunity. When military personnel are involved in civilian projects, they may feel
insulated from the consequences of their actions, leading to a disregard for ethical
standards and regulations. This culture can perpetuate a cycle of corruption, where
individuals prioritize personal interests over the common good, further eroding public
trust in both the military and government institutions (Nwachukwu, 2022). The
perception that military involvement is synonymous with corruption can deter private
investment in these sectors, stifling economic growth and development.
8
Summarily, the risk of corruption and inefficiency associated with military involvement
in manufacturing and infrastructural development in Nigeria poses significant
challenges. The lack of accountability, combined with the military's operational focus,
can lead to mismanagement of resources and a decline in project quality. This not only
undermines public confidence but also hampers overall economic progress, highlighting
the need for a clear separation between military duties and civilian responsibilities.
4. Public perception and trust: Public perception and trust significantly impact the
effectiveness of military involvement in sectors such as manufacturing and
infrastructural development in Nigeria. When the military engages in these sectors, it
often faces skepticism from the public, stemming from historical experiences where
military rule was associated with corruption, human rights abuses, and a lack of
accountability. This historical context creates a backdrop of mistrust that can hinder
collaboration between military entities and local communities.
The perception that military involvement is primarily driven by self-interest rather than
genuine development can lead to resistance from local populations. Communities may
view military-led projects as top-down initiatives that do not consider their needs or
aspirations. This disconnect can foster a sense of alienation among the populace, as they
9
may feel that their voices are not being heard in the decision-making processes related to
development projects (Ibrahim, 2020). Consequently, this lack of trust can result in
reduced community engagement and participation in initiatives that could benefit them,
ultimately undermining the potential success of military-led development efforts.
Moreover, the military's history of using force to maintain order can further exacerbate
public distrust. When the military is perceived as an enforcer rather than a partner in
development, it can create an environment of fear and apprehension. This perception can
deter local entrepreneurs and businesses from collaborating with military entities, as they
may fear repercussions or lack of support if their interests conflict with military
objectives. As a result, the military's involvement in manufacturing and infrastructure
may not yield the intended economic benefits, as local stakeholders remain hesitant to
engage fully.
In summary, public perception and trust are crucial factors that limit the effectiveness of
military involvement in Nigeria's manufacturing and infrastructural development sectors.
The historical context of military governance, coupled with a perception of self-interest
and a lack of accountability, can lead to skepticism and resistance from local
communities. This mistrust not only hampers collaboration but also undermines the
potential for successful development outcomes, highlighting the need for the military to
foster transparency and build genuine partnerships with the communities they aim to
serve.
4.0. CONCLUSION
In conclusion, military involvement in Nigeria's manufacturing and infrastructural
development can offer significant benefits, such as improved security and efficient
project execution, which are essential for economic growth. However, these advantages
10
come with drawbacks, including potential corruption, lack of accountability, and the risk
of prioritizing military interests over civilian needs. Therefore, it is important to strike a
balance that ensures military support contributes positively to the economy without
undermining the principles of good governance and sustainable development.
5.0. RECOMMENDATIONS
Here are some recommendations for improving the economic impact of military involvement
in manufacturing and infrastructural development in Nigeria:
1. Create transparent guidelines that govern military participation in economic activities to
ensure accountability and reduce corruption.
2. Encourage partnerships between military and civilian sectors to leverage each other's
strengths, ensuring that projects align with national development goals.
3. Invest in training military personnel in project management and economic development
principles to enhance their effectiveness in these roles.
4. Encourage private sector investment in infrastructure projects by reducing barriers to entry
and ensuring a competitive environment that complements military efforts.
5. Implement regular assessments of military-led projects to measure their economic impact
and make necessary adjustments to improve efficiency and effectiveness.
By focusing on these strategies, Nigeria can maximize the benefits of military involvement
while minimizing potential drawbacks.
11
REFERENCE:
Akinyemi, J. (2022). Resource Allocation and Development: The Challenges of Military
Involvement in Nigeria. African Journal of Development Studies.
Cohen, Eliot A. (2002), Supreme Command: Soldiers, Statesmen, and Leadership in Wartime,
New York, CA: Free Press.
Feaver, Peter (1996), “The Civil-Military Problematique: Huntington, Janowitz, and the
Question of Civilian Control,” Armed Forces and Society, vol. 23, no. 2, pp. 149–
178.
Ibrahim, M. (2020). Community Engagement in Military-Led Development: Challenges and
Opportunities. Nigerian Journal of Social Sciences.
Ibrahim, M. (2020). Economic Militarization and Its Effects on Civilian Enterprises.
Nigerian Journal of Social Sciences.
Ogunleye, A. (2021). The Impact of Militarization on Economic Development in Nigeria.
Journal of African Studies.
Ogunleye, A. (2021). Trust and Skepticism: The Public Perception of Military Involvement in
Development. Journal of African Studies.
12