0% found this document useful (0 votes)
4 views8 pages

GEC 8 Final

The document outlines various ethical theories and concepts, including the Universalizability Test, Morality of Dying, and Justice, emphasizing their implications in real-world dilemmas. It categorizes ethical theories into Normative, Moral Development, and Applied Ethics, detailing perspectives from key thinkers like Kant, Aristotle, and Kohlberg. Additionally, it provides situational moral dilemmas illustrating how different ethical frameworks approach complex moral questions.

Uploaded by

Mohaemen Kambal
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
0% found this document useful (0 votes)
4 views8 pages

GEC 8 Final

The document outlines various ethical theories and concepts, including the Universalizability Test, Morality of Dying, and Justice, emphasizing their implications in real-world dilemmas. It categorizes ethical theories into Normative, Moral Development, and Applied Ethics, detailing perspectives from key thinkers like Kant, Aristotle, and Kohlberg. Additionally, it provides situational moral dilemmas illustrating how different ethical frameworks approach complex moral questions.

Uploaded by

Mohaemen Kambal
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd

1.

Universalizability Test

 A principle in ethics (especially from Immanuel Kant) that asks: “What


if everyone did this?”

 An action is morally right if the rule guiding it could be applied


universally without contradiction.

 Example: If lying were universal, trust would be impossible—so lying is


morally wrong.

2. Morality of Dying

 Refers to ethical questions about death and dying, including:

o Euthanasia and assisted suicide

o Palliative care and the right to die

o Withholding or withdrawing treatment

 Moral considerations often include dignity, autonomy, quality of life,


and religious or cultural views.

3. Lawrence Kohlberg's Moral Development Theory

 A theory describing how people develop moral reasoning through six


stages across three levels:

1. Pre-conventional: Obedience and self-interest

2. Conventional: Social approval and law/order

3. Post-conventional: Social contract and universal ethical


principles

 It’s not about what people think is right, but why they think it's right.

4. Ecological Challenges

 Ethical concerns related to the environment:

o Climate change
o Biodiversity loss

o Pollution and resource depletion

 Raises moral questions about human responsibility to future


generations, other species, and the planet itself.

5. Justice

 Broad concept about fairness, equality, and moral rightness.

 Types include:

o Distributive justice: Fair distribution of resources

o Retributive justice: Fair punishment

o Procedural justice: Fair processes and laws

 Central to political philosophy, law, and ethics.

Here’s a concise summary of all the main ethical theories—including ones


that relate to the topics you mentioned earlier. These are grouped into major
categories:

⚖️Normative Ethical Theories

These ask: "What is the right thing to do?"

1. Deontology (Duty-Based Ethics)

 Key thinker: Immanuel Kant

 Morality = Following rules/duties

 Universalizability is a key test

 Example: Telling the truth is right, even if it causes harm

2. Consequentialism (Result-Based Ethics)

 Key type: Utilitarianism (Jeremy Bentham, John Stuart Mill)

 Morality = Maximizing good consequences


 "The greatest good for the greatest number"

 Example: Lying may be okay if it saves lives

3. Virtue Ethics

 Key thinker: Aristotle

 Morality = Developing good character traits (virtues)

 Focuses on being rather than just doing

 Example: A courageous, honest, and kind person will naturally act


morally

4. Ethics of Care

 Key thinkers: Carol Gilligan, Nel Noddings

 Emphasizes relationships, empathy, and care over abstract principles

 Morality = Nurturing others and maintaining trust

 Often applied in family, nursing, and community contexts

5. Social Contract Theory

 Key thinkers: Thomas Hobbes, John Locke, Jean-Jacques Rousseau

 Morality = Agreement among individuals for mutual benefit

 Basis for modern ideas of justice, rights, and democracy

6. Natural Law Theory

 Key thinker: Thomas Aquinas

 Morality = Following the natural purpose or design in life (often with


religious basis)

 Life, reproduction, and reason are natural goods


7. Moral Relativism

 No universal standard of right or wrong

 Morality depends on culture, context, or individual choice

8. Postmodern Ethics

 Questions grand narratives and objective morality

 Focus on marginal voices, diversity, and power dynamics

 Influenced by Foucault, Derrida, etc.

🧠 Moral Development Theories

These describe how people develop moral reasoning rather than define
right/wrong:

1. Kohlberg’s Stages of Moral Development

 6 stages across 3 levels: pre-conventional, conventional, post-


conventional

 Moves from obedience to universal principles

2. Gilligan’s Ethics of Care (in contrast to Kohlberg)

 Emphasizes compassion, connection, and care rather than abstract


justice

🌍 Applied Ethics

Focused on specific real-world issues, using the theories above:

 Bioethics (e.g., morality of dying, abortion)

 Environmental ethics (e.g., ecological challenges, sustainability)

 Business ethics

 Justice and political ethics (e.g., fairness, equality)


Examples:

Here are 20 situational moral dilemmas or examples, each matched


with how different ethical theories might approach them:

1. Lying to Protect a Friend

 Deontology: Wrong (lying breaks a moral rule)

 Utilitarianism: Right if it prevents harm

 Virtue Ethics: Depends—was it done with compassion or cowardice?

2. Stealing to Feed a Starving Child

 Deontology: Wrong (stealing is always wrong)

 Utilitarianism: Right if it saves a life

 Natural Law: May be justified to preserve life

3. Abortion in Case of Rape

 Kantian Ethics: Difficult—depends on autonomy vs. duty

 Utilitarianism: Allowed if it prevents more suffering

 Natural Law: Often opposed (life begins at conception)

4. Euthanasia of a Terminally Ill Patient

 Deontology: Usually wrong (killing is wrong)

 Ethics of Care: May be acceptable to reduce suffering

 Utilitarianism: Right if it reduces pain for all involved

5. Cheating on an Exam to Avoid Failing

 Virtue Ethics: Wrong (dishonest character)

 Utilitarianism: Might justify it if consequences are minimal


 Deontology: Wrong regardless of outcome

6. Donating to Charity vs. Buying Luxury

 Utilitarianism: Charity is more ethical

 Virtue Ethics: Generosity is a virtue

 Moral Relativism: Depends on personal/cultural values

7. Free Speech vs. Hate Speech

 Social Contract: Limit harmful speech to protect society

 Postmodern Ethics: Analyze power behind the speech

 Kantian Ethics: Uphold dignity of all people

8. Using Animals for Medical Testing

 Utilitarianism: Justified if many lives are saved

 Ethics of Care: Concern for suffering of animals

 Natural Law: Humans may be prioritized but with responsibility

9. Whistleblowing Against Corruption

 Deontology: Duty to tell the truth

 Virtue Ethics: Courageous and just

 Utilitarianism: Good if it benefits the greater public

10. Breaking the Law for Civil Disobedience

 Social Contract: Laws should be challenged when unjust

 Kohlberg (Stage 6): Moral principles > legal rules

 Deontology: Conflict between legal and moral duties


11. Choosing to Have Children During Climate Crisis

 Ecological Ethics: Consider sustainability

 Utilitarianism: Consider long-term impacts

 Virtue Ethics: Is the choice responsible and hopeful?

12. Surveillance for National Security

 Social Contract: May be allowed for safety

 Postmodern Ethics: Question who holds power and why

 Deontology: Invasion of privacy may be wrong

13. Helping a Stranger in Need

 Virtue Ethics: Compassion is virtuous

 Utilitarianism: Good consequences expected

 Ethics of Care: Caring builds community bonds

14. Downloading Movies Illegally

 Deontology: Wrong (theft of property)

 Utilitarianism: Depends—harm to creators?

 Moral Relativism: Might vary by culture/view

15. Physician Breaking Confidentiality to Prevent Harm

 Deontology: Conflict between duties

 Utilitarianism: Justified if harm is prevented

 Kohlberg: Advanced reasoning required

16. Robots Replacing Humans in Jobs

 Social Justice: Raises questions of fairness


 Utilitarianism: Net benefit?

 Postmodern: Who profits and who is silenced?

17. Choosing Between Two Lives in a Trolley Problem

 Utilitarianism: Save the most people

 Deontology: Wrong to intentionally harm

 Virtue Ethics: Focus on the actor’s integrity

18. Refusing Vaccination on Personal Grounds

 Social Contract: Duty to community health

 Natural Law: Preserve life

 Relativism: Depends on beliefs

19. Genetic Engineering of Embryos

 Natural Law: Opposed (tampering with life)

 Utilitarianism: Support if benefits are great

 Postmodern: Who controls the tech?

20. Releasing Prisoners for Overcrowding

 Justice Theory: Balance fairness with public safety

 Utilitarianism: May reduce systemic harm

 Deontology: Punishment must fit crime regardless

You might also like