3 PB
3 PB
php/jcerp
Research Article
Received: 19th December 2024; Revised: 27th December 2024; Accepted: 27th December 2024
Available online: 8th January 2025; Published regularly: June 2025
Abstract
1,2-ethylenedichloride (EDC) is a chemical compound used widely in industry. This study aims to develop a modified
process for EDC production through direct chlorination and oxychlorination methods to improve mass efficiency,
establish an environmentally friendly plant, and produce high purity products. Conceptual process simulation was
conducted using Aspen HYSYS, with energy consumption and carbon emission analysis using Aspen Energy Analyzer.
Process modifications included a new separation system incorporating a flash drum separator, liquid-liquid extraction,
and reboiled absorber to achieve more high yield from 71796.84 kg/h to 71859.39 kg/h and purity from 94% to 99.05%
and. The results showed improved efficiency purity and yield with reduced carbon emissions from 67680 kg/h to 14170
kg/h, with the potential for industrial sustainability through feedstock optimization and reduced environmental
impact.
Copyright © 2025 by Authors, Published by Universitas Diponegoro and BCREC Publishing Group. This is an open
access article under the CC BY-SA License (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0).
How to Cite: Saputra, M.S.F., Azhar, R.F., Ramadhani, T., & Dodi, V. (2025). Improving 1,2-Ethylene Dichloride
Yield and Purity with Reducing Carbon Emissions from Ethylene through Waste Treatment Method Modification.
Journal of Chemical Engineering Research Progress, 2 (1), 14-18 (doi: 10.9767/jcerp.20297)
Permalink/DOI: https://doi.org/10.9767/jcerp.20297
making it suitable for integrated operations that industry standards [9]. Process information for
produce chlorine as a by-product [4]. While this ethylene dichloride was sourced from the
method is more environmentally friendly because literature.
it recycles HCl, it also requires more complex The conceptual process simulation model
reactions, higher energy usage, and increased was developed specifically for the production of
risks associated with inside oxygen and heat ethylene dichloride through direct chlorination
management. and oxychlorination. Furthermore, the Aspen
Ethylene dichloride (EDC) purification is Energy Analyzer tool was used to analyze the
critical to ensuring the quality and efficiency of energy consumption and total carbon emissions in
downstream processes. High-purity EDC reduces all plant processes [10]. Aspen HYSYS was used
operational disruptions, extends the service life of to minimize total carbon emissions, and a
industrial equipment, and ensures compliance conversion study of ethylene dichloride
with product quality standards [5]. Impurities in production. Detailed simulation by incorporating
EDC, such as water, organic chlorides, and other measurement operations that reflect the real-time
by-products, can cause catalyst poisoning, concept of the plant's industrial processes..
equipment corrosion, and reduced product yield in In this research, an iterative simulation
subsequent reactions [6]. By enabling recycling of method was used to investigate, study, and
by-products and reducing emissions of harmful compare the basic and advanced processes for
substances such as carbon emissions, an effective ethylene dichloride production. The iterative
purification process also helps to reduce waste simulation method entails repeated iterations
and environmental impact. As a result, EDC using the software to adjust process parameters
purification is essential for maintaining process and observe their impact on the simulation
efficiency and supporting responsible and results. The process begins by building a
sustainable industrial practices [7]. simulation model using Aspen HYSYS, analyzing
To improve the production of ethylene the results with Aspen Energy Analyzer, and
dichloride in terms of economics and good iteratively modifying the process parameters until
conversion, this study will examine the design for the desired performance or results are achieved.
ethylene dichloride plant using HYSYS The process modification carried out in this study
simulation. The research study shows that is to adjust the process parameters and tools using
overcoming this problem can be done by the principles of the iterative simulation method.
implementing sustainable design procedures at Further explanation of the modifications made
various stages of the process. Optimizing can be seen in the next chapter.
conversion and minimizing carbon emissions by In addition, this study involves a comparison
selecting purification methods are in line with key between the initial ethylene dichloride purity and
targets in the industrial sector [8]. The objective the purity after modification. The mass of
of this research is to develop a modified process ethylene dichloride mass was obtained using
for producing ethylene dichloride by direct Aspen HYSYS. Furthermore, the %Purity was
chlorination and oxychlorination methods, aiming calculated as the ratio between the mass of
to achieve mass efficiency, set up a plant that ethylene dichloride product (kg/h) and the total
follows environmentally friendly principles, and mass of product (kg/h). The calculation of %Purity
maximizing yield with high purity of ethylene is expressed in Equation (1) [11]:
dichlorination products.
Mass of EDC product
%Purity= ×100% (1)
Total product mass
2. Methods
The basic process model of ethylene After obtaining energy demand data through
dichloride production via direct chlorination and Aspen Energy Analyzer and product purity, the
oxychlorination was designed using Aspen results were analyzed and compared between the
HYSYS, and the corresponding process flow sheet basic process system for producing ethylene
is depicted in Figures 1 and 2. This simulation dichloride and the modified ethylene dichloride
model serves to predict the process response of the process to assess the efficiency of each process.
plant through the application of mass and energy
balances, phase considerations, and chemical 3. Result and Discussion
equilibrium relationships. The model
3.1 Process Description Before Modification
incorporates relevant thermodynamic data, real-
time operating conditions, and rigorous In the ethylene dichloride (EDC) production
equipment models to mimic actual plant process, the materials used as raw materials are
processes. Aspen HYSYS process simulation tool chloride, ethane, water, and chloride acid. At the
was used to design a conceptual simulation model initial stage, the ethane stream is split into two,
for ethylene dichloride production, following one stream will be reacted with chloride (Direct
Chlorination) and the other stream will be mixed before modification can be seen at Figure 1 and
with chloride acid and water (Oxychlorination). Figure 2.
Ethane and chloride will be reacted (Direct
Chlorination) which begins with mixing in a 3.2 Properties and Reaction During Process
mixer (MIX-100) with a pressure of 1.5 atm at a
The physical properties of the compounds
temperature of 25 °C. The mixture is flowed to the
involved, such as boiling point, vapor pressure,
heater (E-100) to be heated to a temperature of 60
density, and solubility, are very important in the
°C before being inserted into the reactor. The
ethylene dichloride (EDC) formation reaction
heater output temperature is adjusted using a
(Table 1). Understanding these characteristics
controller (SET-1) so that the reactor output
helps to control the reaction, separate the
temperature is 60 °C. The reactor used is a stirred
products, and implement safety procedures
tank reactor (CSTR) with kinetic reaction. On the
throughout the process [13].
other hand, the other ethane stream will be
Aside from the importance of understanding
reacted with air and chloride acid
the physical properties of the compounds
(Oxychlorination) in a flow pipe reactor (PFR).
involved, reviewing the enthalpy of formation in
Ethane, air, and hydrochloric acid are mixed in a
ethylene dichloride (EDC) production reactions is
mixer (MIX-101) at 25 °C and 1.5 atm pressure.
crucial to understanding the energy requirements
After that, the mixture is flowed to the
and thermodynamic efficiency of the process by
compressor (K-100) until the pressure becomes 4
knowing the nature of the reaction (endothermic
atm and the temperature increases to 137 °C.
or exothermic) [15]. Knowing the nature of the
Before entering the PFR reactor, the mixture is
reaction can help determine the amount of energy
passed through a heater (E-101) to increase the
required from outside, regulate the temperature,
temperature to 225 °C. The outputs of the CSTR
and make the right reactor design to achieve.
and PFR reactors are mixed using a mixer (M-
Chemical reaction of direct chlorination (DC)
102). Furthermore, it is cooled using a cooler with
and oxychlorination (OX) [12], calculation of
an output temperature of 15 °C. Next, the flash
kinetic reaction [17] and calculation of ∆H
drum separator produces vapor product and
reaction [18]:
liquid product. Liquid product is then put into
three-phase distillation and will produce
C2H(4) ((g)) + Cl(2) ((g))→ C2H4Cl(2) ((l))
nitrogen, water, and ethylene dichloride. Also, -r1 = k1 [C2H4] [Cl(2)]
heavy product is produced [12]. The simulation k1 = 11493 exp (-2156.8/T) m3.mol-1.s-1
Figure 1. Basic process flow diagram of EDC production using Aspen HYSYS
Figure 3. Modified process flow diagram of EDC production using Aspen HYSYS
Reboiled Absorber. The system as a whole is 3.4 Emission of Carbon Analysis of Separation
designed to improve the separation efficiency of Operating System
multicomponent mixtures in the process industry
Carbon emission analysis is carried out by
[23].
varying the separator, which initially before
In this separation system, the output
modification uses a flash drum separator and
product from the reboiled absorber (T-103)
three-phase distillation, while after modification
consisting of liquid product and vapor product will
uses a flash drum separator, liquid-liquid
undergo further processing before being recycled.
extraction, and reboiled absorber. This is done
The vapor product from T-103 will be cooled from
with the aim of minimizing the occurrence of
126.6 °C to 60 °C using a cooler (E-103) to reduce
carbon emissions by using the Case Study tool.
its temperature so that it is ready for use or
The case study was conducted by changing the
further processing. After cooling, this product is
type of separation device. Figure 5 presents a
flowed to the recycle system, which is then
comparison of carbon emissions using the system
returned to the mixer (MIX-103).
before modification with the system after
At the mixer (MIX-103), the recycle product
modification.
stream joins the new feed from the main process.
The results of the case study show that the
This mixture is then cooled in the cooler (E-102)
process before modification produces greater
before entering the separator flash drum (V-100).
carbon emissions than those produced by the
The process is designed to improve separation
process after modification. The resulting process
efficiency and ensure the reuse of valuable
before modification produces carbon emissions of
components, while reducing waste and operating
67680 kg/h of carbon emissions. This amount is
costs. With this recycle system, the separation
more than the process after modification which
process becomes more economical and sustainable
only produces carbon emissions of 14170 kg/h
as it maximizes the utilization of materials that
carbon emissions. The results of the modification
have not been fully separated in the previous
process can produce products that have higher
cycle. This process will continue to repeat,
purity and produce smaller carbon emissions, this
starting from separation in the flash drum,
can be seen at Figure 5 and Table 3.
extraction in T-101, to absorption in T-103,
The post-modification process produces less
resulting in an efficient and optimized separation
carbon emissions than the pre-modification
cycle.
process due to improved flow circulation and
Basic 71796.8362 94
Modified 71859.3916 99.05
[12] Dry, J., Lawson, B., Le, P., Osisanya, I., Patel, D., [20] Lavado, G.J., Pighizzini, G., & Prigioniero, L.
& Shelton, A. (2003). Vinyl Chloride Production. (2017). Weakly and strongly irreversible regular
University of Oklahoma. languages. arXiv preprint, arXiv:1708.06465.
DOI: 10.4204/EPTCS.252.15
[13] Stoessel, F. (2021). Thermal safety of chemical
processes: risk assessment and process design. [21] Affandy, S.A., Kurniawan, A., Handogo, R.,
John Wiley & Sons. ISBN: 978-3-527-69692-5 Sutikno, J.P., & Chien, I.L. (2020). Technical and
economic evaluation of triethylene glycol
[14] Dimian, A.C., & Bildea, C.S. (2008). Chemical
regeneration process using flash gas as stripping
process design: Computer-aided case studies.
gas in a domestic natural gas dehydration unit.
John Wiley & Sons. DOI: 10.1002/9783527621583
Engineering Reports, 2(5), e1215. DOI:
[15] Ritchie, M.E. (2018). Reaction and diffusion 10.1002/eng2.12153
thermodynamics explain optimal temperatures of
biochemical reactions. Scientific Reports, 8 (1),
[22] Zhang, Y., & Ray, A. K. (2023). Liquid–liquid
extraction. In Coulson and Richardson's Chemical
11105. DOI: 10.1038/s41598-018-28833-9
Engineering (pp. 257-312). Butterworth-
[16] Salehi, M.S., Askarishahi, M., Godini, H.R., Heinemann. DOI: 10.1016/B978-0-08-101097-
Schomäcker, R., & Wozny, G. (2016). CFD 6.00004-3
simulation of oxidative coupling of methane in
[23] Sorsamäki, L., & Nappa, M. (2015). Design and
fluidized-bed reactors: a detailed analysis of flow-
selection of separation processes. Finland: VTT
reaction characteristics and operating conditions.
Technical Research Centre of Finland Ltd
Industrial & Engineering Chemistry Research, 55
(5), 1149-1163. DOI: 10.1021/acs.iecr.5b02433 [24] Tonini, D., Albizzati, P.F., Caro, D., De Meester,
S., Garbarino, E., & Blengini, G.A. (2022). Quality
[17] Sai Prasad, P.S., Prasad, K.B., & Ananth, M.S.
of recycling: Urgent and undefined. Waste
(2001). Parameter estimation in a fixed-bed
Management, 146, 11-19. DOI:
reactor operating under unsteady state:
10.1016/j.wasman.2022.04.037
Oxychlorination of ethylene. Industrial &
Engineering Chemistry Research, 40 (23), 5487- [25] Unegg, M.C., Steininger, K.W., Ramsauer, C., &
5495. DOI: 10.1021/ie010031i Rivera-Aguilar, M. (2023). Assessing the
environmental impact of waste management: A
[18] Yaws, C.L. (1999). Chemical Properties
comparative study of CO2 emissions with a focus
Handbook. New York: McGraw Hill Company,
on recycling and incineration. Journal of Cleaner
Inc. ISBN: 9780070734012
Production, 415, 13774. DOI:
[19] Shen, Z., Zhao, H., Liu, Y., Kan, Z., Xing, P., 10.1016/j.jclepro.2023.137745
Zhong, J., & Jiang, B. (2018). Mercury-free
nitrogen-doped activated carbon catalyst: an
efficient catalyst for the catalytic coupling
reaction of acetylene and ethylene dichloride to
synthesize the vinyl chloride monomer. Reaction
Chemistry & Engineering, 3 (1), 34-40. DOI:
10.1039/C7RE00201G