Chapter 3 Risk and Return (Updated)
Chapter 3 Risk and Return (Updated)
Table of Contents
Chapter 3: Risk and Return ............................................................................................................ 1
Types of Risks in Investments ................................................................................................... 2
Detailed Types of Investment Risks ...................................................................................... 4
Measurement of Risk and Return .............................................................................................. 9
I. Measurement of Return ..................................................................................................... 10
II. Measurement of Risk ........................................................................................................ 12
III. Risk-Adjusted Return Measures ..................................................................................... 15
IV. Capital Asset Pricing Model (CAPM) ............................................................................. 16
I. Calculation of Return .............................................................................................................. 17
III. Calculation of Risk-Adjusted Return Measures ........................................................... 24
Risk is an inherent and unavoidable part of life, affecting everyone from individuals to
large organizations on a daily basis. For effective management and mitigation of potential
losses, it's crucial to understand the various types of risks and how they can impact
you or your organization. Risks can broadly include financial, operational, strategic, and
reputational risks, among others.
By understanding each type of risk and its potential effects, one can take proactive and
actionable steps to prevent negative consequences. Thoughtful planning and preventative
measures empower businesses to be prepared for the diverse range of risks that may
emerge. Let's delve into the various categories of risk.
What is Risk?
• Definition 1: Risk is any activity or investment that offers the potential for gain
but also carries the possibility of loss.
Risk is broadly associated with various aspects of life, including business operations,
financial investments, and even personal decisions. Generally, risks are categorized into:
• Physical Activities: Risks associated with tangible actions or events (e.g., driving,
natural disasters).
The risks associated with investments are diverse. They can be broadly classified and
understood in terms of their impact and whether they can be diversified away.
This breakdown highlights that the total risk of an investment is a sum of its systematic
and unsystematic components.
• Nature: Systematic risk represents the uncertainty that affects a large number
of investments across the entire market or a broad sector. It is inherent to
the overall market and economy.
o Wars, Structural Economic Changes, Tax Law Changes: Factors that affect
the entire economic landscape.
• Impact: The effect of these factors is to put pressure on all securities, causing
their prices to generally move in the same direction. For instance, during a boom
period, prices of most securities tend to rise, indicating overall economic
prosperity.
• Impact: These factors are independent of the broader market's price mechanisms.
• Control: While unavoidable for any single investment, unsystematic risk can be
managed through effective diversification strategies.
These risks generally affect the entire market or broad sectors and cannot be diversified
away.
1. Market Risk:
o Definition: Market risk refers to the variability in stock prices (or overall security
returns) due to changes in investors' collective attitudes, sentiments, and
expectations. It's often synonymous with systematic risk.
o Causes: It's primarily driven by investor reactions to tangible events (real economic,
political, social reasons) and intangible events (psychological factors, expectations,
or fear/overconfidence).
o Mitigation (limited): Investors can try to reduce market risk by being conservative
in their portfolio construction, timing their stock purchases, or choosing only "growth
stocks" (though even these are susceptible to market downturns). However, falling
markets will still bring down prices across the board, though the decline in some
stocks will be less than others.
o Impact on Security Prices: Interest rate changes generally affect security prices
inversely. This means that when interest rates rise, security prices (especially bond
prices) tend to fall, and vice versa. This inverse relationship is due to the valuation
of securities, as future cash flows are discounted at a higher rate when interest
rates rise.
o Primary Impact: Interest rate risk affects bonds more directly and significantly
than common stocks. It is a major risk for all bondholders.
o Example: If you hold a portfolio of long-term bonds with fixed interest rates and
prevailing interest rates suddenly rise, newly issued bonds will offer higher yields.
This makes your existing bonds, which offer lower fixed yields, less attractive.
Consequently, their market value will decrease, potentially leading to a capital loss
if you sell them before maturity.
o Maturity and Yield: Generally, the longer the maturity period of a security, the
higher its potential yield, but also the higher its sensitivity to interest rate changes
(and thus greater price fluctuations). Short-term interest rates tend to fluctuate
more rapidly than long-term rates.
o Definition: This is the possibility that the purchasing power of your invested money
will decline over time, even if the nominal return is stable. It arises from changes
in the prices of goods and services, covering both inflation (rising prices) and
deflation (falling prices).
o Relationship with Interest Rate Risk: This risk is closely related to interest rate
risk because interest rates generally rise as inflation increases. Lenders demand
additional "inflation premiums" to compensate for the anticipated loss of purchasing
power.
o Indian Context: In India, purchasing power risk is typically associated with inflation
and rising prices, often driven by "cost-push" (rising production costs) or "demand-
pull" (excess demand over supply) inflation. Rising Wholesale Price Index (WPI) and
Consumer Price Index (CPI) reflect this price spiral. Consumers who save for future
consumption find their budgets affected by rising prices and reduced purchasing
power.
o Definition: The risk that changes in government regulations, tax laws, or policies
could adversely affect the attractiveness, value, or fundamental nature of an
investment.
o Example (1987 Tax Law Changes): In 1987, changes in US tax laws reduced the
attractiveness of many existing limited partnerships that relied on special tax
considerations. This led to a dramatic fall in their prices, leaving investors with
"different securities" than what they originally bought. Due to a lack of a robust
secondary market, many investors couldn't sell these illiquid securities except at
"firesale" prices.
o Definition: This risk specifically refers to the variability in market returns that
results from the alternating forces of bull (rising) and bear (falling) markets.
o Bull Market: An upward trend where the market index rises fairly consistently
from a low point (trough) over a period of time.
o Bear Market: A downward trend that begins when the market index reaches a
peak and declines to the next trough.
o Impact: Investors face the risk of purchasing assets at the peak of a bull market
and seeing their value decline significantly during a subsequent bear market, or
missing out on gains during a bull market.
These risks are specific to a particular company or industry and can be reduced through
diversification.
o Causes: Fluctuations in operating revenue and expenses (both variable and fixed).
A higher proportion of fixed operating expenses in a firm's total expenses means
greater operating risk (higher operating leverage).
o Impact: High fluctuations in operating income over time lead to uncertainty and
increased business risk. Conversely, an increase in stable operating income lowers
business risk.
▪ If DOL > 1, it indicates the existence of operating risk, meaning a small change
in sales leads to a larger change in operating income due to fixed costs.
o Examples: U.S. Steel faces unique problems as a large steel producer (e.g.,
commodity price volatility). General Motors faces challenges related to global oil
prices and competition from imports.
2. Financial Risk:
o Impact: A higher financial risk means that the amount of profit remaining for
equity shareholders (and thus Earnings Per Share - EPS) becomes more volatile
and can significantly decrease if the company's operating income is not sufficient
to cover fixed interest charges.
▪ If DFL > 1, it indicates the existence of financial risk, meaning a small change
in EBIT leads to a larger change in EPS due to fixed interest costs.
3. Management Risk:
o Definition: The risk that poor decisions, errors, or ethical lapses by a company's
management can harm investors.
o Causes: Managers are fallible and can make mistakes (e.g., forecasting errors, poor
strategic choices, inefficient operations) or engage in unethical behavior.
o Mitigation: Research suggests investors can reduce losses from management errors
by investing in companies where executives have significant equity investments,
aligning their interests more closely with shareholders. Examples like Enron,
WorldCom, and Arthur Andersen demonstrate how "creative accounting" practices
by management can erode net worth while maintaining false stock prices, leading
to significant investor losses.
o Definition: The portion of an investment's total risk that results from changes in
the financial integrity or creditworthiness of the issuer. It is the risk that the
issuer of a debt security (bond) will fail to make timely interest payments or
repay the principal.
o Actual vs. Perceived Loss: Most losses suffered by investors due to default risk
are not from actual bankruptcy, but rather from the decline in security prices
as the firm's financial integrity weakens. By the time a company actually defaults
or goes bankrupt, its security prices will have often already fallen to near zero.
5. Liquidity Risk:
o Definition: The risk associated with the ease and speed at which a security can
be bought or sold in its secondary market without significantly affecting its price.
o Examples: A Treasury bill has very low liquidity risk because it can be easily
traded with minimal price impact. A small Over-The-Counter (OTC) stock, however,
might have substantial liquidity risk due to limited buyers and sellers.
o Liquid Assets Risk: This refers specifically to the risk of needing to accept price
discounts or pay high sales commissions to sell an asset without delay. Perfectly
liquid assets are highly marketable with no liquidation costs. Illiquid assets are
not readily marketable and incur larger price discounts or commissions to find a
buyer.
▪ Impact: Investors who invest internationally face the prospect that even if
their foreign investment performs well in the local currency, their returns
might be significantly reduced (or even turn into losses) when converted back
to their home currency due to unfavorable exchange rate movements.
▪ Definition: The risk associated with the political, and by extension, the
economic stability and viability of a specific country's economy. This is crucial
for investors investing directly or indirectly in foreign countries.
7. Industry Risk:
I. Measurement of Return
Return on an investment represents the gain or loss generated over a specific period,
typically expressed as a percentage of the initial investment. Returns can come from
various sources, including capital gains (change in price) and income (dividends or
interest).
Components of Return:
1. Yield (Income Component): This refers to the periodic cash flows generated by
the investment.
o If the selling price is higher than the purchase price, it's a capital gain.
o If the selling price is lower than the purchase price, it's a capital loss.
o Definition: This measures the total return earned from holding an asset for
a specific period, regardless of whether it's one day, one month, or multiple
years. It does not annualize the return.
o Formula:
Where:
o Example: If you buy a stock for ₹100, receive ₹5 in dividends, and sell it for
₹110 after one year:
o Usefulness: Primarily used for short-term periods (less than a year) or when
simply showing the total gain/loss over a specific, non-annualized period.
2. Expected Return:
o Formula:
E(R)=i=1∑n(Pi×Ri)
Where:
o Example:
o Definition: This is the actual return an investor has obtained from their
investment at the end of the holding period. It is based on past performance.
o Calculation: Uses historical price data and income received over past periods
to calculate actual returns.
o Definition: When an investment is held for more than one year, simply using
the HPR doesn't account for the compounding effect. Annualized return or
CAGR provides an average annual rate of return over a multi-year period,
CAGR=(₹1,00,000₹1,50,000)(31)−1=(1.5)0.3333−1≈1.1447−1=0.1447 or 14.47%
• Probability Distribution: The set of all possible returns and their associated
probabilities.
1. Range:
o Definition: The simplest measure of risk. It is the difference between the highest
possible return and the lowest possible return from an investment.
o Formula:
o Example: If an investment can yield returns of 25% (best case), 10% (most likely),
and -10% (worst case):
Range=25%−(−10%)=35%
o Limitations: It only considers the extreme values and ignores the distribution of
returns in between. It doesn't tell us about the likelihood of those extremes.
o Definition: The most common and statistically robust measure of total risk or
total variability of an investment's returns. It quantifies the dispersion of actual
returns around the expected (or average) return. A higher standard deviation
indicates greater risk (more volatile returns), while a lower standard deviation
indicates lower risk (more stable returns).
σ=n−1∑i=1n(Ri−Rˉ)2
Where:
▪ σ = Standard Deviation
▪ Ri = Individual historical return for period i
▪ Rˉ = Average (Mean) of historical returns
▪ n = Number of historical periods
σ=i=1∑nPi(Ri−E(R))2
Where:
3. Variance (σ2):
o Definition: The square of the standard deviation. It measures the average squared
deviation of individual returns from the mean return. While mathematically
important, it's less intuitive than standard deviation because its units are squared
(e.g., % squared).
o Formula:
5. Beta (β):
o Interpretation:
▪ β=1.0: The security's price moves exactly in line with the market. If the
market goes up by 10%, the security is expected to go up by 10%.
▪ β>1.0: The security is more volatile than the market (aggressive). If the
market goes up by 10%, a stock with β=1.5 is expected to go up by 15%.
▪ β<1.0: The security is less volatile than the market (defensive). If the market
goes up by 10%, a stock with β=0.8 is expected to go up by 8%.
▪ β<0 (Negative Beta): The security moves inversely to the market (very rare
for common stocks). If the market goes up, the security is expected to go
down.
o Formula:
o Usefulness: Beta is a crucial input in the Capital Asset Pricing Model (CAPM)
for determining the expected return for an asset given its systematic risk. It
helps investors understand how a particular stock will behave relative to the
overall market.
o Definition: Measures the degree to which two assets' returns move in relation
to each other. It ranges from -1 to +1.
o Interpretation:
1. Sharpe Ratio:
o Definition: Measures the excess return (return above the risk-free rate)
per unit of total risk (standard deviation).
o Formula:
Where:
2. Treynor Ratio:
o Definition: Measures the excess return per unit of systematic risk (Beta).
It is similar to the Sharpe ratio but uses beta in the denominator, making
it suitable for evaluating diversified portfolios (where unsystematic risk has
been largely eliminated).
o Formula:
3. Alpha (α):
Where Expected Return (as per CAPM) = Risk-Free Rate + β * (Market Return - Risk-
Free Rate)
o Interpretation:
• Core Principle: Investors are compensated for taking on systematic risk, not
unsystematic risk. Therefore, the expected return of an asset should be linearly
related to its beta.
• Formula:
E(Ri)=Rf+βi×(Rm−Rf)
Where:
• Security Market Line (SML): The CAPM formula can be graphically represented
by the Security Market Line. The SML plots the expected return against beta. It
shows the relationship between risk (beta) and expected return for all assets in
the market. Assets that plot above the SML are considered undervalued (offering
higher return for their risk), while those below are overvalued.
Conclusion
I. Calculation of Return
Return calculations quantify the income and capital appreciation (or depreciation) of an
investment.1 We'll look at historical (realized) and expected returns.
When we have past data, we can calculate the actual return achieved.2
o Concept: Measures the total return over a specific period, including both price
changes and any income received.3 It's a simple, direct measure for any length
of holding period.4
o Formula:
You bought a share of XYZ Ltd. for ₹250. After one year, you received a dividend of
₹15, and the share's market price is now ₹280.
HPR=₹250(₹280−₹250)+₹15=₹250₹30+₹15=₹250₹45=0.18 or 18%
You purchased a bond for ₹980. Over the year, it paid ₹70 in interest. At the end of
the year, the bond's market value is ₹995.
HPR=₹980(₹995−₹980)+₹70=₹980₹15+₹70=₹980₹85≈0.0867 or 8.67%
o Concept: Used when an investment is held for more than one year to calculate
the average annual growth rate, assuming compounding. It provides a
standardized measure for comparing investments of different durations.5
o Formula:
(Note: This formula assumes all intermediate income is reinvested to contribute to the
Ending Value. If income is taken out, more complex Time-Weighted Rate of Return
calculations are needed, but for basic [Link], CAGR as presented is usually sufficient for
multi-year price appreciation)
o Example:
▪ Number of Years = 4
CAGR=(₹50,000₹75,000)(41)−1CAGR=(1.5)0.25−1CAGR≈1.10668−1≈0.10668 or 10.67%
o Concept: A weighted average of all possible returns, where the weights are
the probabilities of those returns occurring. It's the most likely return an
investor anticipates.
o Formula:
E(R)=i=1∑n(Pi×Ri)
Where:
o Example:
E(R)=0.1025 or 10.25%
Risk measures the variability or uncertainty of returns. We'll cover several key measures.
1. Range:
o Concept: The simplest measure of risk, indicating the spread between the
best and worst possible outcomes.
o Formula:
o Example:
Range=25%−(−8%)=25%+8%=33%
o Concept: The most widely used measure of total risk. It quantifies how
much the returns typically deviate from the average or expected return. A
higher standard deviation means higher risk.7
σ=i=1∑nPi(Ri−E(R))2
(We use this formula when given probabilities for different outcomes.)
We know E(R)=10.25%.
| | | | | Sum = | 0.01391875 |
σ=n−1∑i=1n(Ri−Rˉ)2
(We use this formula when given a series of past returns and need to calculate historical
risk. Using n−1 in the denominator provides an unbiased estimate for a sample.)
Suppose a stock had the following returns over the last 5 years: 10%, 15%, 5%, 20%,
8%.
Rˉ=(10%+15%+5%+20%+8%)/5=58%/5=11.6% (0.116)
| | | Sum = | 0.014120 |
These measures help compare the risk of investments with different characteristics.
o Concept: Measures risk per unit of expected return. It's useful for
comparing investments when their expected returns are significantly
different. A lower CV indicates a more favorable risk-return trade-off.8
o Formula:
o Example:
▪ For Investment A:
CVA=10%5%=0.50
▪ For Investment B:
CVB=15%8%≈0.533
Even though Investment B has a higher standard deviation (higher absolute risk), its
Coefficient of Variation (0.533) is slightly higher than Investment A's (0.50). This suggests
that Investment A offers a slightly better return for each unit of risk taken compared
to Investment B.
1. Beta (β):
Beta=Variance(Rmarket)Covariance(Rasset,Rmarket)
Alternatively:
βstock=0.8×0.120.18=0.8×1.5=1.2
Stock X has a Beta of 1.2, meaning it is 20% more volatile than the market.10 If the
market moves up/down by 10%, Stock X is expected to move up/down by 12%.
2. Portfolio Beta:
o Formula:
βPortfolio=j=1∑m(wj×βj)
Where:
▪ βj = Beta of asset j
o Example:
βPortfolio=(0.40×1.1)+(0.30×0.9)+(0.30×1.4)βPortfolio=0.44+0.27+0.42βPortfolio=1.13
The portfolio's overall Beta is 1.13, indicating it's slightly more volatile than the market.
rXY=σX×σYCovariance(RX,RY)
Where:
o Interpretation:
o Use in Diversification:
These ratios help evaluate how much return is generated for the level of risk taken.18
1. Sharpe Ratio:
o Concept: Measures excess return (return above the risk-free rate) per unit
of total risk (standard deviation). Useful for comparing investments where
total risk is relevant.
o Formula:
o Example:
▪ Risk-Free Rate = 5%
SharpeP=0.120.15−0.05=0.120.10≈0.833
SharpeQ=0.080.12−0.05=0.080.07=0.875
Portfolio Q has a higher Sharpe Ratio (0.875 vs. 0.833), indicating it provides a better
return per unit of total risk.
2. Treynor Ratio:
o Concept: Measures excess return per unit of systematic risk (Beta). More
appropriate for well-diversified portfolios where unsystematic risk is
negligible.
o Formula:
o Example:
▪ Risk-Free Rate = 6%
TreynorX=1.30.18−0.06=1.30.12≈0.0923
TreynorY=0.90.14−0.06=0.90.08≈0.0889
Portfolio X has a higher Treynor Ratio (0.0923 vs. 0.0889), indicating it provides a better
return for each unit of systematic risk.
3. Alpha (α):
o Formula:
Alpha=Actual Return−[Rf+β×(Rm−Rf)]
(The term in the square brackets is the Expected Return according to CAPM)
o Example:
E(RZ)=0.04+1.2×(0.10−0.04)E(RZ)=0.04+1.2×0.06E(RZ)=0.04+0.072=0.112 or 11.2%
AlphaZ=0.16−0.112=0.048 or 4.8%
Stock Z generated a positive alpha of 4.8%, meaning it outperformed its expected return
(given its systematic risk) by 4.8%.
• Formula:
E(Ri)=Rf+βi×(Rm−Rf)
Where:
o βi = Beta of Security 21
i
• Example:
Consider a stock with a Beta of 0.9. The current risk-free rate is 5%, and the expected
market return is 13%.
o Rf=0.05
o β=0.9
o Rm=0.13
E(Rstock)=0.05+0.9×(0.13−0.05)E(Rstock)=0.05+0.9×0.08E(Rstock)=0.05+0.072E(Rstock
)=0.122 or 12.2%
Based on CAPM, the expected (or required) return for this stock is 12.2%. This is the
minimum return an investor should expect for taking on the systematic risk associated
with this stock.