LoRa and IoT Based Monitoring System For Detecting
LoRa and IoT Based Monitoring System For Detecting
1. INTRODUCTION
West Kalimantan can produce 5,742,925 tons of palm plantation yields with a planting area of 2,109,890
hectares. However, despite these abundant plantation yields, the productivity of palm plantations in West
Kalimantan is still below average, i.e., 3,282 Kg/Ha compared to the national average of 3,339 Kg/Ha [1].
Disease is one of the factors affecting oil palm productivity. Even with good soil nutrient factors, crop
productivity will still decrease if it is infected with diseases.
The type of disease that often and most damages oil palm plants is stem rot disease (Ganoderma) caused
by the fungus Ganoderma boninense [2]. The mortality rate of plants due to ganoderma disease, which reaches
80%, causes a significant decrease in oil palm productivity by up to 50% per hectare area, with potential losses
estimated to exceed USD 250 million [3].
Control of plant diseases is carried out by spraying pesticides, but excessive use of pesticides apart from
causing financial losses also has a bad impact on the environment in the form of a buildup of chemical residues
which can have a bad impact on the lives of living creatures in the surroundings[4], so information on the risk
of plants being attacked by disease is needed so that pesticide use can be carried out wiser and more precise.
The difficulty in detecting infected plants is the cause of the high risk of plant mortality due to disease.
Many oil palm plants are only known to have been diseased after it becomes severe, resulting in delayed
handling and eventually being cut down [5]. Therefore, an early detection system is needed that can know as
early as possible the condition and risk of oil palm plants being infected with diseases. In addition to assisting
in decision-making time and target pesticide use, it also assists in the palm plantation process to be more
efficient because it can be monitored in real-time on smartphone applications.
The system uses Long Range (LoRa) technology that utilizes radio frequency as signal transmission
between the transmitter and receiver devices. The transmitter contains an early ganoderma disease detection
sensor, while the receiver serves as a data recipient that has been transmitted by the LoRa transmitter and will
be forwarded to the Blynk Apps through the internet network, thus forming an IoT (Internet of Things) system.
159
Journal of Electrical Engineering, Energy, and Information Technology (J3EIT)
2. LITERATURE REVIEW
2.1. Previous Research
This research refers to several previous studies as references. In 2021, Agustin Sri Mulyatni and
colleagues from Gadjah Mada University conducted research by testing the electronic nose 118 system in
detecting basal stem rot disease in oil palm based on volatile organic compounds (VOC) parameters, using
TGS sensors with Arduino Uno as the microcontroller [6].
Muhammad Muzakky Al Maududy, Koko Mardianto, and Agus Susanto, in 2021 discussed sensors that
can be used in oil palm plantation management, including temperature sensors as an early warning system for
pest attacks of oil palm leaf-eating caterpillars such as fire caterpillars and bag caterpillars. This journal also
discusses gas sensors that can be used for early detection of ganoderma disease (basal stem rot) [7].
Mhd Feri Desfri, Minarni, Dewi Laila Sari, Dewi Anjarwati Mahmudah, Ihsan Okta Harmaili, and Irfan
Cahyadi, in 2022 conducted a study comparing the sensitivity of several types of TGS sensors in identifying
ganoderma disease in oil palm plants. Volatile organic compounds (VOC) emitted by G.Boninensis will be
read by 6 different types of TGS sensors, until it was concluded that the TGS 2611 sensor has the highest
sensitivity[8].
Moh. Nadhif Muttaqin from Maulana Malik Ibrahim Islamic State University of Malang conducted
research on an electronic nose device in the form of a space made of copper pipes to select beef and pork using
an LM35 temperature sensor and MQ-138 as a gas sensor sensitive to Volatile Organic Compunds (VOC) gas
compounds which were then processed by Arduino Uno as a microcontroller in the system [9].
Siska Wati, Joseph Dedy Irawan, and Yosep Agus Pranoto in 2022 designed a tool for remote monitoring
and control of oil palm seedlings in the IoT system. Arduino Uno and NodeMCU ESP8266 are used in series
so that sensors and components in the system can connect to the internet and can be monitored and controlled
remotely [10].
Hazia Rifka Maulida, Fikra Titan Syifa, and Mas Aly Affandi from the Telkom Institute of Technology
conducted research on the creation of a tool for monitoring temperature and humidity of tea plantation land. In
the system, two devices were made, a transmitter equipped with a sensor and placed on tea plantation land, and
a receiver whose job is to receive data and forward it to the internet network. Both devices are each paired with
a LoRa module to be able to communicate with each other [11].
LoRa and IoT Based Monitoring System for Detecting… (Ahmad Dzakiyuddin Muhaimin)
160
Journal of Electrical Engineering, Energy, and Information Technology (J3EIT)
3. RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
3.1. Research Procedure
The flow in the research process on the design of the LoRa and IoT based monitoring system to detect
ganoderma disease refers to the flow diagram shown in the Figure 1.
LoRa and IoT Based Monitoring System for Detecting … (Ahmad Dzakiyuddin Muhaimin)
161
Journal of Electrical Engineering, Energy, and Information Technology (J3EIT)
(a) (b)
Figure 4. Receiver device appearance design: (a) Front, (b) Back
LoRa and IoT Based Monitoring System for Detecting… (Ahmad Dzakiyuddin Muhaimin)
162
Journal of Electrical Engineering, Energy, and Information Technology (J3EIT)
The receiver hardware is used as a receiving device for the data sent by the transmitter device via the
LoRa communication network. This device consists of a LoRa RFM95 module, ESP32 DevKit, I2C 2004 LCD,
battery indicator, and 18650 battery. This device uses a clear acrylic material as an outer casing to protect the
components. The assembled receiver hardware is shown in Figure 6.
LoRa and IoT Based Monitoring System for Detecting … (Ahmad Dzakiyuddin Muhaimin)
163
Journal of Electrical Engineering, Energy, and Information Technology (J3EIT)
LoRa and IoT Based Monitoring System for Detecting… (Ahmad Dzakiyuddin Muhaimin)
164
Journal of Electrical Engineering, Energy, and Information Technology (J3EIT)
(hydroxylmethyl)-, which is included in the aldehyde group; Thiophene, 2-propyl- with an odor resembling
benzene; and other organic compounds namely 4H-Pyran-4-one [18]. Sensors used include:
1. MQ-138 sensor for VOC, Aldehyde, benzene, alcohol, and other gas readings.
2. The TGS2611 sensor is sensitive to VOC gases, methane, and other natural gases.
Tests were also conducted on samples of palm trunks known to be infected with ganoderma disease to
understand and calibrate the severity level of ganoderma attacks on oil palm trees. The samples were taken
from the trunk of the oil palm tree from field tests. Testing was done by taking sensor reading data from the
samples placed at a certain distance, then calibration adjustments were made to the palm health category based
on ADC sensor data. The recapitulation of the total ADC values of the results of target testing by the sensor at
an ideal distance of 1 cm to 4 cm is shown in Table 1.
LoRa and IoT Based Monitoring System for Detecting … (Ahmad Dzakiyuddin Muhaimin)
165
Journal of Electrical Engineering, Energy, and Information Technology (J3EIT)
The increase in sensor values is inversely proportional to the increase in reading distance, which can be
seen from the sensor reading graph visualization. The closer the reading distance, the higher the sensor reading
value, and the further the reading distance, the lower the sensor reading value. This is because the reading gas
does not reach the sensor's sensing element at a far distance, resulting in a reduction in value. Even though
there is a decrease in value, at a distance of 1 cm - 4 cm, the sensor can still read the increase in values that
occur in oil palm plants. However, when the reading is set 5 cm from the oil palm plant, the reading starts to
show a significant decrease and unstable readings, so it can be inferred from this data that the limitation of the
sensor is only at a maximum reading distance of 4 cm.
The highest reading value occurred in the sample of sick plants. Besides reading volatile gas at the base
of the diseased plant, the emergence of ganoderma sp fruit bodies at the base of the plant increases the
sensitivity of the sensor in data reading. In the Ganoderma sp. Sample, were found aliphatic compounds with
8 carbon atoms such as 1-octen-3-ol (69.43%), also known as mushroom alcohol, 3-octanone (10.34%), and
1-octanol and (E)-2-octenal (20.23%) [19]. Thus, with the presence of the ganoderma sp fruit body on the outer
part of the palm base, it can increase the reading value of both sensors.
LoRa and IoT Based Monitoring System for Detecting… (Ahmad Dzakiyuddin Muhaimin)
166
Journal of Electrical Engineering, Energy, and Information Technology (J3EIT)
Difference in ADC
Components Samples Initial ADC Final ADC
Values
Ganoderma 3 111 132 21
Ganoderma 4 112 135 23
Ganoderma 5 112 142 30
BPPSDMP data, Ministry of Agriculture states thatin the process of soil aeration, the atmosphere above
the soil contains 21% O2, 0.03% CO2, and almost 79% N2 [20]. These three compounds are not included in
group of compounds in ganoderma and are not included in the target gas sensor reading compounds. Hence the
sensor readings on the soil sample did not show a significant increase.
Figure 11. Graph of RSSI Value Against the Distance Between LoRa
Based on the data from the graph in Figure 11, it is known that the further the distance between the LoRa
devices, the smaller the RSSI value becomes. The smaller the RSSI value, the worse the signal quality received
by the transmission system. The RSSI value at the maximum distance recorded is -105 dBm at a distance of
757.92 meters.
Testing of the LoRa transmitter and receiver was also carried out in the oil palm plantation area on
Dermaga Kuala Mandor Street, Central Java Village, Sungai Ambawang Subdistrict, Kubu Raya Regency.
From the field testing, the farthest distance between the LoRa transmitter and receiver obtained was 469.13
meters. The maximum distance obtained is not as far as the distance in testing with minimal obstacle conditions
because the destination oil palm plantation area has obstacle conditions in the form of oil palm plants and
residential buildings, thus affecting the ability of radio signal transmission between the transmitter and receiver.
LoRa and IoT Based Monitoring System for Detecting … (Ahmad Dzakiyuddin Muhaimin)
167
Journal of Electrical Engineering, Energy, and Information Technology (J3EIT)
Figure 12. Range of RFM95 LoRa Communication Test on Oil Palm Plantations
4.6. Testing of Transmission and Reception Time of LoRa RFM95 Data from Transmitter to Receiver-
Blynk IoT
The data for the transmission and reception times between LoRa RFM95 devices are shown in Table 3.
Table 3. Comparison of Transmission and Reception Times Between LoRa RFM95 Devices
LoRa Transmitter Data LoRa Receiver Data
Data
Transmission Time Reception Time Time Difference (seconds)
Number
(hours:minutes:seconds) (hours:minutes:seconds)
1 10:48:31.586 10:48:32.302 0.716
2 10:48:36.737 10:48:37.465 0.728
3 10:48:41.935 10:48:42.636 0.701
4 10:48:47.101 10:48:47.793 0.692
5 10:48:52.267 10:48:52.984 0.717
6 10:48:57.433 10:48:58.037 0.604
7 10:49:02.569 10:49:03.296 0.727
8 10:49:07.736 10:49:08.493 0.757
9 10:49:12.919 10:49:13.580 0.661
10 10:49:18.086 10:49:18.776 0.690
11 10:49:23.270 10:49:23.960 0.690
12 10:49:28.421 10:49:29.074 0.653
Average 0.695
Based on the data in Table 3, it is known that there is a time difference between the transmission and
reception of data between LoRa devices. The average time difference is 0.695 seconds. Therefore, with an
average time of 0.695 seconds, the RFM95 LoRa module can transmit data between two LoRa transmitter and
receiver devices.
Table 4. Comparison of Data Transmission and Reception Time between LoRa Receiver Devices and Blynk
IoT
Data Receiver Data Transmission Blynk IoT Data Receipt Time
Time Difference (seconds)
Number Time (hours:minutes:seconds) (hours:minutes:seconds)
1 10:48:32.968 10:48:34 1.032
2 10:48:38.154 10:48:39 0.846
3 10:48:43.213 10:48:44 0.787
4 10:48:48.461 10:48:49 0.539
5 10:48:53.526 10:48:54 0.474
LoRa and IoT Based Monitoring System for Detecting… (Ahmad Dzakiyuddin Muhaimin)
168
Journal of Electrical Engineering, Energy, and Information Technology (J3EIT)
Based on the data in Table 4, it is known that there is a difference in precision in the time format between
the receiver device and Blynk IoT. The receiver device can obtain data up to an accuracy of 0.000 seconds that
can be displayed on the serial monitor, while on Blynk IoT, data can only be obtained up to an accuracy of 0
seconds. The average time difference that occurs in the process of sending and receiving data between the
receiver device and Blynk IoT is 0.701 seconds.
5. CONCLUSION
Based on the testing results of the LoRa and IoT based monitoring system to detect ganoderma disease
attacks on oil palm plants, the following conclusions can be drawn:
The ganoderma disease detection system with MQ-138 sensor and TGS2611 sensor can detect the level
of ganoderma volatile organic compounds, with the following results: The optimal sensor reading distance for
oil palm plants is in the range of 1 cm to 4 cm. Sensor testing on non-target components such as soil and dead
palm not due to ganoderma results in a minimum total ADC difference of 0 - 2 values. Meanwhile, the
ganoderma mushroom produces a total ADC difference between 7 - 30 values according to the maturity level
of the ganoderma mushroom body.
The LoRa and IoT-based monitoring system for detecting ganoderma disease attacks on oil palm plants
can transmit data from the transmitter to the receiver with a range of up to 757.92 meters and an RSSI value of
-105 dBm in conditions with minimal obstacles.
The system can send and receive information from LoRa devices to Blynk IoT with the following time
differences: The time difference for sending and receiving data between the RFM95 LoRa transmitter and
receiver devices averages 0.695 seconds. The time difference for sending and receiving data between the
receiver device and Blynk IoT averages 0.701 seconds.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
The author would like to thank the lecturers who have provided support and support, as well as
colleagues who have helped in the writing and research process. Hopefully this research can have a positive
impact on both writers and readers.
REFERENCES
[1] Directorate of Food Crops, Horticulture, and Estate Crops Statistics, “Production of Crude Palm Oil (CPO) Government Estates by
Province and Month (Tons), 2020” in Indonesian Oil Palm Statistics 2020, BPS-Statistics Indonesia, Jakarta, Indonesia, pp. 55.
[2] R. Evizal and F.E. Prasmatiwi, “Penyakit Busuk Pangkal Batang dan Performa Produktivitas Kelapa Sawit”, Jurnal Agrotropika,
vol. 21, no. 1, pp. 47-54, May.2022.
[3] H. Priwiratama and A. Susanto, “Kejadian Penyakit Busuk Pangkal Batang Pada Tanaman Belum Menghasilkan Varietas Toleran
Ganoderma Dengan Sistem Lubang Tanam Standar”, Warta Pusat Penelitian Kelapa Sawit, vol. 25, no. 3, pp. 115-122, Oct.2020,
doi:10.22302/iopri.war.warta.v25i3.20.
[4] E. Amelia, B. Joy, Sunardi, “Residu Pestisida pada Tanaman Hortikultura (Studi Kasus di Desa Cihanjuang Rahayu Kecamatan
Parongpong Kabupaten Bandung Barat)”, Jurnal Agrikultura, vol 27, no.1, pp 23-39, 2016.
[5] M. Wahyuni, T. Sabrina, Mukhlis, H. Santoso, “Aplikasi Support Vector Machine pada Deteksi Penyakit Busuk Pangkal Batang
Ganoderma Tanaman Kelapa Sawit”, Prosiding Seminar Nasional INSTIPER, vol. 1, no.1, July.2022, doi: 10.55180/pro.v1i1.247.
[6] A.S. Mulyatni, I. Kresnawaty, D.D. Eris, T. Panji, W. Kimberly, H. Widiastuti, Priyono, Chotimah, K. Triyana, “Potensi electronic
nose 118 untuk mendeteksi penyakit busuk pangkal batang pada kelapa sawit”, Menara Perkebunan, vol. 90, no. 1, pp. 1-10,
April.2022, doi: 10.22302/iribb.jur.mp.v90i1.472.
[7] M. M. Al Maududy, K. Mardianto, A. Susanto, “Pemanfaatan Berbagai Sensor dalam Manajemen Perkebunan Kelapa Sawit”,
Warta Pusat Penelitian Kelapa Sawit, vol. 26, no. 2, pp. 117-123, June.2021, doi: 10.22302/iopri.war.warta.v26i2.61.
[8] M. F. Desfri, et.al, “Analisa Sensitivitas Sensor TGS pada Hidung Elektronik untuk Identifikasi Ganoderma di Bagian Akar Kelapa
Sawit”, Jurnal Komunikasi Fisika Indonesia, vol. 19, no. 1, pp. 1-6, March.2022.
LoRa and IoT Based Monitoring System for Detecting … (Ahmad Dzakiyuddin Muhaimin)
169
Journal of Electrical Engineering, Energy, and Information Technology (J3EIT)
[9] M.N. Muttaqin, “Pengaruh Suhu pada Chamber Volatile Organic Compounds (Daging Sapi dan Babi) Berbasis Electronic Nose
dengan Menggunakan Metode Linear Discriminant Analysis (LDA)”, Thesis, Dept. science and technology, Universitas Islam
Negeri Maulana Malik Ibrahim Malang. 2018.
[10] R. Wati, J.D. Irawan, Y.A. Pranoto, “Rancang Bangun Pembibitan Kelapa Sawit Berbasis IoT (Internet of Things)”, Jurnal
Mahasiswa Teknik Informatika, vol. 6, no. 1, pp. 145-153. March.2022, doi: 10.36040/jati.v6i1.4509.
[11] H.R. Maulida, F.T. Syifa, M.A. Affandi, “RSSI System Testing toward Prototype of Tea Plantation Monitoring Design based on
LoRa”, JTECE. vol. 4, no. 2, pp. 117-127, July.2022, doi: 10.20895/JTECE.V4I2.538.
[12] A. Adriansyah, O. Hidyatama, “Rancang Bangun Prototipe Elevator Menggunakan Microcontroller Arduino ATmega 328P”, Jurnal
Teknologi Elektro, vol. 4, no. 3, pp 100-112, Sept.2013.
[13] M. Nizam, H. Yuana, Z. Wulansari, “Mikrokontroler ESP 32 sebagai Alat Monitoring Pintu Berbasis Web”, Jurnal Mahasiswa
Teknik Informatika (JATI), vol. 6, no. 2, pp. 767-722, Sept. 2022.
[14] M. P. S. Simbolon, H. Wijanarko, F. Nakul, R. Mahdaliza, “Penerapan Komunikasi Nirkabel LoRa pada Sistem Pencatat Kehadiran
Portabel”, Journal Of Applied Electrical Engineering, vol. 5, no. 2, pp. 30-35. 2021.
[15] S. Rahman, A. S. Alwadie, M. Irfan, R. Nawaz, M. Raza, E. Javed, M. Awais, “Wireless E-Nose Sensors to Detect Volatile Organic
Gases through Multivariate Analysis”, Micromachines, vol. 11, no. 6, pp. 597, June.2020, doi: 10.3390/mi11060597.
[16] A. Sudarmaji, A. Margiwiyatno, S.B Sulistyo , P.H. Kuncoro , N.S. Wahyuningsih, “Characteristic Of Array Mos Gas Sensors On
Patchouli Alcohol Identification In Patchouli Oil Using Artificial Neural Network”, Jurnal Keteknikan Pertanian Tropis dan
Biosistem, vol. 7, no. 2, pp. 148-160, August. 2019.
[17] Sugiyono, “Research and Development” in Metode Penelitian Pendidikan (Pendekatan Kuantitatif, Kualitatif dan R&D), Bandung,
ALFABETA, August.2015, pp. 407-408.
[18] S. Sundram, I.A. Seman, N.D. Roslan, L.P. Lee Angel, et.al, “Ganoderma: Research Advances, Management and Future
Challenges” in International Oil Palm Conference 19th, 28 September 2018, Colombia, pp. 35-36.
[19] N.H.Z. Hilmi, A.S. Idris, M.N.M. Azmil, “Headspace solid‐phase microextraction gas chromatography–mass spectrometry for the
detection of volatile organic compounds released from Ganoderma boninense and oil palm wood”, Forest Pathology, vol. 49, no. 4,
pp. 1-4. May.2019, doi: 10.1111/efp.12531.
[20] Badan Penyuluhan dan Pengembangan Sumber Daya Manusia Pertanian, Kementerian Pertanian, 2019, “Aerasi Tanah".[Online].
Available: http://cybex.pertanian.go.id/mobile/artikel/81298/AERASI-TANAH/.
LoRa and IoT Based Monitoring System for Detecting… (Ahmad Dzakiyuddin Muhaimin)