THE CLOTHING
RETAIL INDUSTRY:
SHEIN
Julia Leeming
PESTLE ANALYSIS
SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY – External Business Environment
FACTORS:
Social structures
Health consciousness
Lifestyle choices
Cultural trends
Societal ideals
Level of education within a society
POSITIVES:
Influence consumer behavior
Market demand
Industry norms
Innovation
Drive positive change
Uphold moral standards
NEGATIVES:
Decrease in sales
Decrease in profits
Negative brand reputation
SHEIN
SHEIN stands out for its significant
negative impact socially through:
Fast fashion model
Exploitation of forced labor
Human rights violations
Overproduction
Excessive consumption
Lack of sustainability practices
EVALUATION OF
ARTICLES
Article 1: Global Affairs
Shein and Temu's strategies for complying with US labor laws
Prohibiting products made from forced labor
The methods these companies use to navigate regulations (especially
concerning labor practices)
Article 2: Ethical Consumer
Fast fashion
Addressed issues:
Environmental degradation, labor exploitation, and consumerism
Article 3: LinkedIn
Social issues within the fast fashion industry
Focusing on: overproduction, overconsumption, and their contribution to
landfill waste
Article 4: Lawdit.co.uk
Legal aspects related to SHEIN
Controversies: allegations of racketeering
EVALUATION OF ARTICLES
CONT.
Article 5: Vox Article
SHEIN's environmental and human rights violations
Impact on workers and the environment.
Article 6: Quora
User-generated content discussing labor conditions in SHEIN's factories
The working conditions in said factories
Article 7: Sustainable Review
SHEIN's sustainability practices, or lack thereof
SHEIN's business model
Environmental footprint
SIMILARITIES &
DIFFERENCES
Labor Practices:
SHEIN’S labor conditions (use of forced labor.)
Labor issues within SHEIN’S supply chain
Labor violations and exploitation.
Environmental Impact:
The environmental consequences of Shein's fast fashion
model
Overproduction, overconsumption, and resource
exploitation
Pollution and landfill waste.
Ethical Concerns:
Broader ethical implications of fast fashion
Workers' rights, social inequalities, and consumer
behavior.
Legal Issues:
Legal troubles (copyright infringement and racketeering
allegations)
POSSIBLE STRATEGIES
1. Transition to sustainable practices:
- Strategy: SHEIN can adopt sustainable and ethical sourcing
practices, emphasizing fair labor conditions, environmentally-friendly
materials, and transparent supply chains.
- Counter-Argument: Transitioning to sustainable practices may
initially incur higher costs, leading to less consumers buying products,
potentially impacting SHEIN’S profit.
2. Introduce slow fashion:
- Strategy: Shift towards a "slow fashion" model, promoting
timeless designs and quality over quantity to reduce overconsumption.
- Counter-Argument: WIth SHEIN’S ability to always be trendy and
provide new products for their consumers may result in a loss of
valued customers. Also implementing a slow fashion model
successfully could be challenging due to the rapid pace of consumer
demand.
3. Invest in worker welfare:
- Strategy: Improve working conditions, provide fair
wages, and ensure workers' rights are respected,
addressing issues related to exploitation and human
rights violations which is largely seen in SHEIN’S
working force.
- Counter-Argument: Higher labor costs may lead to
POSSIBLE increased product prices, potentially affecting SHEIN’S
STRATEGIES competitive advantage.
CONT 4. Raise fast fashion awareness:
- Strategy: SHEIN could raise awareness among
consumers about the environmental and social impacts
of fast fashion, on all social media platforms,
encouraging conscious consumption.
- Counter-Argument: Changing consumer behavior
around fast fashion ideas may take a long time, and
immediate results might be challenging to achieve or
see.
EVALUATION
Significant impact on SHEIN's performance.
SHEIN's unethical practices may lead to a:
Damaged reputation
Decreased brand loyalty and trust.
Concerned consumers may choose to stop buying SHEIN products, and rather buy from brands with
better ethical and sustainability standards
Legal attention, leading to potential fines, legal action, ext.
Implementing sustainable practices:
Significant financial aid (impacting its financial department.)
Competitors may gain a competitive advantage
causing a loss of clients for SHEIN.
If SHEIN doesn't implement strategies to solve said social issue SHEIN will decline in:
Sales
Customer loyalty
Profit (bankruptcy.)
IN
CONCLUSION…
SHEIN's operations reveals a complex relationship with
social, ethical, and environmental challenges.
Urgency for action within the fast fashion industry.
SHEIN has raised significant concerns.
Strategies suggested are seen as potential solutions.
However, implementing these strategies requires a lot
of effort and time from SHEIN.
Failure to address these issues:
Irreparable damage to SHEIN's reputation
Declining sales
A negative brand image
Bankruptcy.
It is vital for SHEIN to change and embrace a more
ethical and sustainable approach