Jonmichael Moy

Shopify's Sprint vs. Commerce's Strategic Pivot After analyzing both Q2 2025 earnings reports, we see two companies at different strategic moments. Shopify accelerates with 31% growth and $2.7B revenue Commerce (formerly BigCommerce) makes a bold strategic pivot with its fresh rebrand. Growth Trajectories: Speed vs. Foundation Shopify's Current Momentum: Revenue: $2.7B (+31% YoY) accelerating from 27% in Q1 GMV: $88B (+31% YoY) up from 23% in Q1 Nine consecutive quarters of 25%+ growth Commerce's Strategic Reset: Revenue: $84.4M (+3% YoY) - steady during transformation ARR: $355M (+3% YoY) maintaining stability ARPA +9% YoY showing improving customer value The numbers reflect different execution stages. Shopify operates from strength while Commerce rebuilds for future acceleration. Present vs. Future Shopify's AI Leadership: Catalog API for real-time product access Universal Cart for cross-merchant shopping Checkout Kit deployed with Microsoft Copilot Sidekick delivering business insights Commerce's Unified Vision: The rebrand integrates BigCommerce + Feedonomics + Makeswift, positioning for agentic commerce where data optimization becomes critical. Smart partnerships with Perplexity, PROS, and Google Cloud expand capabilities. Scale vs. Specialization Shopify's Broad Dominance: Europe GMV +42% outpacing local markets 4-5x Enterprise wins: Starbucks, Canada Goose Triple-digit B2B growth Commerce's Focused Strategy: Dedicated B2B, B2C, SMB sales teams Feedonomics creating unique data advantages Self-serve products launching 4Q25/1H26 The Timeline Challenge Commerce explicitly targets growth acceleration in 1H26 as transformation takes effect. Key catalysts include self-serve Feedonomics, Makeswift integration, and AI-optimized features. Critical Assessment Commerce's rebrand shows genuine strategic thinking about AI commerce futures. Their data-centric approach could prove prescient as AI agents need sophisticated product optimization. The challenge? Executing while maintaining momentum. At 3% growth, they have limited transformation runway. The Bottom Line Commerce deserves credit for bold strategic moves recognizing market shifts. They're betting data orchestration becomes more valuable than platform breadth A reasonable thesis worth monitoring. However, timing matters. Shopify's acceleration creates pressure making Commerce's timeline critical. Can they execute fast enough to reclaim growth momentum? Commerce tackles complexity but needs simple solutions driving measurable growth. The next four quarters determine whether their strategic bet pays off or Shopify extends its lead. This isn't failure vs. success it's different approaches in evolving markets. Commerce deserves time to prove their thesis, but the clock is ticking. I am off to eTail™ today and it will be interesting to get on the ground perspectives

30

5 Comments