Army dismantles BCAP, a program that promoted merit-based leadership

View profile for Dave Prakash MD

AI Governance | Investor | Army Reservist | USAF Flight Test Veteran | Tillman Scholar

BCAP was helping the Army select the leaders that soldiers deserved. Now it’s gone. The Army’s decision to dismantle the Battalion Commanders Assessment Program (BCAP) is a setback for merit-based leadership. As a junior officer, I watched outstanding Air Force leaders get passed over while others advanced through connections, not character. That drove me to research I/O psychology, interview instructors from Delta Force and the Navy SEALs, and propose a system using psychometric assessments to screen out unfit commanders. The Air Force declined. The Army, however, embraced the pitch and launched BCAP in 2019. Over six years, it excluded about 15% of command candidates—a small minority, but one with outsized impact on morale, performance, and retention. Because people don’t quit jobs—they quit bosses. BCAP aligned with what Special Forces have done for years: assess character, judgment, and ethics—not just networks or physical ability. It wasn’t perfect, but it was progress. So why dismantle a program that was creating a meritocracy, excluding unfit commanders, and giving soldiers the leaders they deserve? https://lnkd.in/eKEAjc4V

Dr. Jim Coughlin

Senior Cybersecurity and Information Technology Executive | Board Member | Community Volunteer | Author | Veteran | Father of 9

3w

Dave Prakash MD, How do you address the fact that a GO used BCAP to work to assure a specific subordinate received command?

Like
Reply
Aaron Ullman

Director of Safety at USAF

3w

Thank you for your attempt to use data and analysis to pick the better leaders our military deserves. Unfortunately, the buddy system has a strong hold on our leader selection process. Breaking free will be tough because the system is firmly in place.

Jacob “Juice” Berry, MD, MPH, SFS

Military medical officer. Trustworthy Occupational Medical Director & Executive Staff Physician: Chief of Aerospace Med, Operational Med, Aeromedical Evacuation Specialist, Long Fighter Ops, Environmental Exposure SME.

2w

Sad

Like
Reply
See more comments

To view or add a comment, sign in

Explore content categories