Summary of Empirically-Tested Theoretical Perspectives In: Student Achieve Literature Review
Summary of Empirically-Tested Theoretical Perspectives In: Student Achieve Literature Review
)1.-.*arch 20072ntr$ducti$n )1.-. sta%% in su""$rt $% the w$rk $% the )tudent #chieve+ent #dvis$r! .$++ittee and)!ste+ -ask
3$rce %$r )tudent #chieve+ent 2ncentives c$nducted transcri"t asedanal!sis $% student "ersistence and success in the
4ashingt$n c$++unit! and technicalc$llege s!ste+. -his "a"er su++ari'es three the$retical "ersistence/success c$nstructsreviewed in "re"arati$n %$r
that anal!sis. -hese three "ers"ectives are atte+"ts t$ e5"lainthe relati$nshi" etween "ersistence/success and varia les descri ing students
$r their ehavi$rs $r c$llege acti$ns.-his su++ar! is %$cused $n the$ries tested thr$ugh nati$nal0 +eta( anal!sis $r $ther largescale
e+"irical research designed t$ e5a+ine the relati$nshi"s "redicted in each%ra+ew$rk. -his literature re"resents research $n c$++unit! and
technical c$llegestudents0 h$wever0 +$st $% the literature is %$cused $n $nl! a "$rti$n $% all students. )$+estudies e5a+ined students
wh$ started c$llege in their late 20s $r later in li%e0 ut +$st $% the literature e5a+ined "ersistence/success %$r students wh$ egan at a tw$(!ear c$llegewithin a
decade $% high sch$$l graduati$n. )$+e $% the research %$cused $n adult asiceducati$n $r ,)L students regardless $% age.2n this literature0
"ersistence is t!"icall! de%ined in ter+s $% students +$ving t$ the ne5tlevel in their studies 6
such as +$ving thr$ugh the levels in asic skills 6 $r sta!ing atc$llege %r$+ ter+ t$ ter+ $r !ear t$ !ear. )uccess is generall! de%ined
as c$+"letingcerti%ica tes $r degrees. )uccess in the student engage+ent research is als$ s$+eti+es ased $n student re"$rted
learning gains $r earning a high 7P#. -he$retical Pers"ectives $n Persistence and )uccess
#cade+ic +$+entu+
6
as students gain acade+ic skills and kn$wledge neededt$ succeed in their studies0
the! gain +$+entu+ that "r$"els the+ %$rwardt$ward "ersistence/success . 1ehavi$ral +easures identi%ia le in the transcri"trec$rd
)tudent engage+ent
student "ersistence/success . # c$ntr$vers! in thisliterature relates t$ whether the res"$nsi ilit! %$r integrati$n lies with the student$r the instituti$n.
6
ackgr$und characteristics such as %irstgenerati$n
2# se"arate $d! $% literature e5a+ines the e%%ectiveness $% the "ersistence/success strategies and "ractices that c$lleges e+"l$!. -his
Paths t$ Persistence:
-h$+as R. 1aile! and *ariana #l%$ns$ 0 .$++unit!.$lleg e Research .enter0 -eachers .$llege0 .$lu+ ia &niversit!
V$lu+e <0:u+ er 10 =anuar! 200>.htt"://www.lu +ina%$undati$n.$r g/"u licati$ns/Path st$Persistence."d% 2s there a reas$n %$r c$ncern regarding student
achieve+ent? :ati$nal studies $% asicskills students have %$und that hal% dr$" $ut e%$re the ter+ ends (in less than 10 weeks) (#la+"rese0 200>).
2n 4ashingt$n and nati$nwide a $ut 7> "ercent $% high sch$$lgraduates enr$ll in c$llege within three !ears $% graduati$n. @es"ite this high c$llege(g$ing rate0
the rate at which students c$+"lete en$ugh c$llege t$ earn a certi%icate $rdegree is l$w. # recent nati$nal anal!sis $% the high sch$$l class $% 1AA2 (#del+an0
1 $ut $% C wh$ had attended s$+e c$llege 8uit e%$re $r at the ti+e the!
6
L$$king at the .$llege -ranscri"t 1ehavi$rs $% students during
high sch$$l and c$llege are regarded as uilding0 +aintaining $r l$sing 9acade+ic +$+entu+
6 the acade+ic skills and kn$wledge needed t$ "r$"el%urther achieve+ent in studies. -his "ers"ective ste+s %r$+ decades $%
l$$king at$ serva le (in the transcri"t) acade+ic student ehavi$r in ter+s $% the c$urses taken0 theirintensit! $% enr$ll+ent (h$w
+an! credits earned within a s"eci%ied ti+e %ra+e) andc$ntinuit! $% enr$ll+ent %r$+ !ear(t$(!ear. -he chie% data s$urce is the student
transcri"tsas c$llected %$r several large nati$nal l$ngitudinal data ases. -he transcri"ts include th$se%r$+ students attending
c$++unit! and technical c$lleges0 including th$se wh$ dela!edc$llege g$ing until their +id 20s. .li%% #del+an0 veteran researcher %$r+erl!
$% the &.).@e"art+ent $% ,ducati$n0 devel$"ed the acade+ic +$+entu+ "ers"ective ased $n the@e"art+ent $% ,ducati$n sta%%
review $% the nati$nal data ases.)tudents wh$ gain acade+ic +$+entu+ have a higher likelih$$d $% re+aining in c$llege$r achieving a degree $r
certi%icate generall! irres"ective $% ackgr$und characteristics0and with$ut regard t$ issues $% s$cial $r acade+ic integrati$n.
)tr$ngl! ass$ciated with"ersistence/suc cess are increased credits c$+"leted0 higher grades earned in the %irst !ear0and %ewer withdrawn $r re"eated c$urses
thr$ugh$ut enr$ll+ent 6 all transcri"t( asedin%$r+ati$n. #+$ng the chie% %indings are (#del+an0 1AAA0 20030 200<):
-he acade+ic +$+entu+ students ring %$rward %r$+ high sch$$l has a greaterin%luence $n
degree c$+"leti$n than an! $ther "re( c$llegiate $r de+$gra"hic %act$r.#dditi$nall!0 +$+entu+ g$es ack even %urther than high sch$$l. 2% students d$ n$t
! the eighth grade0the! are +uch less likel! t$ ac8uire the needed skills in high sch$$l.
,arning
credits in c$llege( level +ath in the %irst tw$ !ears $% c$llege uilds+$+entu+.
enr$ll+ent "r$gra+ (R) %$r e5a+"le)0which the research c$unts as e%$re starting c$llege0 uilds +$+entu+.
)tudents entering c$llege right a%ter high sch$$l rather than dela!ing enr$ll+ent+$re
uilds +$+entu+.
hal%).:$te that these %indings "red$+inatel! relate t$ student ehavi$rs in the %irst !ear $% c$llege. #nal!si s t$ date indicates that acade+ic
+$+entu+ gained in a $ut the %irst !ear$% c$llege e5"lains the ulk $% the di%%erences in student "ersistence and success (#del+an0200<D
.hen0 200>). 4hen researchers %irst c$nsider these ehavi$ral +easures0 ackgr$u nd characteristics such as race0 ethnicit!0 and %irst generati$n c$llege(
g$ingt!"icall! are %$und t$ acc$unt %$r little $r n$ne $% the di%%erences in student"ersistence/ success.2+"licati$n s %$r #cti$n: -he e+"irical testing $% this c$nstruct has
een li+ited t$students at the "re(c$llege (re+edial) and c$llege(level $nl!0 and als$ li+ited t$ th$se wh$start c$llege within a decade $% last
attending high sch$$l. 3$r th$se students0 the researchsuggests that c$lleges %$cus $n increasing acade+ic +$+entu+ uilding ehavi$rs
a+$ngstudents. -he research als$ suggests that c$lleges sh$uld in%$r+ students a $ut success%ul acade+ic ehavi$rs (getting thr$ugh th$se
9+$+entu+ "$ints ). .$lleges and s!ste+ssh$uld create instituti$nal structures that rein%$rce acade+ic ehavi$rs that uild
acade+ic+$+entu +0 and structures that "reclude the ehavi$rs that result in l$ss $% +$+entu+. )tudent ,ngage+ent Literature
# large $d! $% the$r! and research underlies the c$nclusi$n that there is a "$sitiverelati$nshi" etween student engage+ent and student learning
and "ersistence (#stin01AC>D Pace0 1ACBD -int$0 1AA3D Pascarella G -eren'ini0 200>). -his "ers"ective generall!de%ines success as sel%( re"$rted student
is a %uncti$n $% a studentIs level $% acade+ic and s$cial inv$lve+ent with the instituti$nal envir$n+entD
2nstituti$ns can in%luence the 8ualit! $% e%%$rt students "ut int$ their inv$lve+ent andthus their "$tential %$r successD
-he e5tent t$ which students share values and n$r+s $% $ther individuals in theinstituti$n i+"acts "ersistence in c$llege.
B,5tensive research ties student engage+ent t$ student success when de%ined as sel%(re"$rted student learning0 higher 7P#s $r
c$+"leti$n $% degrees $r certi%icates. 4hile+uch $% the e+"irical student engage+ent research has een c$nducted in accalaureateinstit
uti$ns0 a recent large scale stud! %$und that r$ad +easures $% student engage+ent are"redictive $% "ersistence and success at
c$++unit! and technical c$lleges (*c.lenne! and*arti0 200<). -he stud! %$und that that the .$++unit! .$llege )urve! $% )tudent,ngage+en
9 )u""$rt %$rLearning were the +$st c$nsistent "redict$rs $% %irst t$ sec$nd ter+ and %irst t$ sec$nd!ear
"ersistence. 2n regard t$ student success (sel%( re"$rted learning gains) the ..)), ench+ark s 9
were +$st"redictive. 7P# was %$und t$ e c$nsistentl! related t$ higher levels $% engage+ent in 9
9 #cade+ic .hallenge. Jther acade+ic gains were si+ilarl! related t$ the ench+arks that %$cus directl!
$nc$ursew$rk.7ive n the u i8uit! $% the c$nnecti$n etween 9 #cade+ic and .$lla $rative Learning
t$"ersistence/succe ss it is hel"%ul t$ l$$k +$re cl$sel! at this c$nstruct. -he #ctive and.$lla $rative Learning ench+ark is c$+"$sed $% seven
surve! ite+s each +easured $n a%$ur ite+ res"$nse scale ( :ever0 )$+eti+es0 J%ten0 Ver! J%ten ):
$utside $% class (students0 %a+il!+e+ ers0 c$(w$rkers0 etc.).-he research in adult asic educati$n als$ included this student
engage+ent "ers"ective0es"ecia ll! the active and c$lla $rative learning "ers"ective which has een %$und t$i+"r$ve student "ersistence and
skill gain in asic skills "r$gra+s $r ,)L "r$gra+s.2ndividua l Res"$nsi ilit! as J""$sed t$ 2nstituti$nal Res"$nsi ilit!: Jne $% the
c$n%lictsa+$ng th$se wh$ e5a+ine issues $% student engage+ent relates t$ whether +$re $% theres"$nsi ilit! %$r student/instituti$n integrati$n $r %it
sh$uld %all t$ the instituti$n than t$the student (Rend$n0 =al$+$0 and :$ra0 2000). Recent studies have %$und greater success%$r students at s$+e %$r "r$%it
instituti$ns kn$wn %$r strea+lining the "r$cess %$r thestudent as c$nsu+ers (@eil( #+en and R$sen au+0 2003)0 than at "u lic c$++unit!c$lleges
. -his anal!sis calls int$ 8u esti$n whether itIs the student wh$ need s t$ eintegrated int$ c$llege0 $r the instituti$n that needs
trans%$r+ati$n t$ %it t$da!Is student. .all %$r instituti$nal trans%$r+ati$n: R ead$n (200<) argues that understanding 9success
%$r underserved students re8uires a dee"ened c$nsci$usness $% educati$nal and s$cial ine8ualities and s"eci%icall! the assu+"ti$n that
s$+e students d$ n$t 9%it the c$llege envir$n+ent. Rather0 she calls $n c$lleges t$ 9 e engaged in
k0001BC a"tureinc
!000031 a"tureinc
!000031 a"tureinc
!000031 a"tureinc
!000033 a"tureinc
!000033 a"tureinc
!000033 a"tureinc
!0000<2 a"tureinc
!0000<2 a"tureinc
w0007CB a"tureinc
w0007CB a"tureinc
w0007CB
a"tureinc
w00077A a"tureinc
w00077A a"tureinc
w0007A3 a"tureinc
w0007A3 a"tureinc
w0007A3 a"tureinc
w00073C a"tureinc
w00073C a"tureinc
w00073C a"tureinc
w000<72 a"tureinc
w000<72 a"tureinc
w000<72 a"tureinc
w000C0B a"tureinc
Read and "rint with$ut ads @$wnl$ad t$ kee" !$ur versi$n ,dit0 e+ail $r read $%%line
Choose a format:
.P@3 @$wnl$ad .-L-
Recommended
1lue 4hite Red: # :$vel 2ndiana &niversit! Press -his tale $% wild adventure reveals the dashed h$"es $% #%ricans living etwe...
-he 3uture $% L$ve: # :$vel 4$rk+an e1$$ks )et in :ew M$rk in 20010 # $ttNs de ut n$vel invites us int$ the lives $% g$...
*rs. @arc! and the 1lue(,!ed )tranger 4$rk+an e1$$ks Lee )+ith is a Oteller $% tales %$r tale tellers t$ ad+ire and env! . . . Pan...
# new editi$n $% l$ngti+e %ar+er Heith )tewartIs dee"l! "ers$nal and highl! ... Page 1 $% 3
Read and "rint with$ut ads @$wnl$ad t$ kee" !$ur versi$n ,dit0 e+ail $r read $%%line
Choose a format:
.P@3 @$wnl$ad About
.-L-
1r$wse # $ut )cri d -ea+ 1l$g =$in $ur tea+Q .$ntact &s
7i%t cards
*$ ile )ite