Decision Making
Decision Making
QUESTION 1
Diagram 1.1 shows a cooling system of a motorcycle engine.
You as a mechanical engineer are given a task to study characteristics of metal shown in the
Table 1.2 to be used as effective fins in the cooling system of the motorcycle engine.
[ 10 marks ]
Diagram 1.1
Types of metal
Specific Heat
Capacity
J kg-1C-1
Melting point
C
Heat Conductor
Rate of
expansion
P
Q
R
S
300
360
450
900
1020
700
1600
720
Good
Moderate
Good
Moderate
Moderate
High
Moderate
High
QUESTION 2
A student plans to fix a lamp in his room. Table 3 shows the features of 4 different
types of lamps.
Type of lamp
Power
Efficiency
Life Span
Price
Compact fluorescent
lamp
18 W
50 %
7000 hours
High
Filament lamp
75 W
12 %
1000 hours
Low
20 W
45 %
24 W
40 %
14000
hours
10000
hours
Medium
High
Explain the suitability of each feature in Table 3 and then determine the most suitable
lamp to be used. Give a reason for your choice.
[10 marks]
4
QUESTION 6
Table 6 shows the specifications of four water storage tanks, P, Q, R and S, that can be used
to store
Material used
metal
concrete
concrete
metal
Density
low
high
low
low
low
high
high
low
Shape
Bentuk
Table 6
You are required to determine the most suitable water storage tank. Study the specifications of
all the four water storage tanks based on the following aspects :
-
QUESTION 7
Table below shows the characteristics of four types of cables that have the same length.
Cable
Diameter/ cm
Density/ kgm-3
Rate of expansion
Melting point
P
Q
R
S
2
4
3
1
4.50 x 103
3.00 x 103
5.45 x 103
2.50 x 103
Medium
Low
High
Low
High
High
Low
Medium
You are to choose one of the cables to be used in the National Grid Network.
Explain the suitability of each of the characteristics of the cables. Choose the most suitable
cable and justify your choice.
[10 marks]
6
QUESTION 9
The transmission of electricity over the National Grid Network uses high voltage cables. You are
assigned to study the characteristics of cables which could be used as transmission cable. Table 12
shows the characteristics of four transmission cables.
Rate of thermal
expansion
High
Cable
Resistivity /m-1
Density / kg m-3
Cost
3.0 x l0-7
5 x l05
Low
1.8 x l0-8
2 x l03
Medium
7.5 x l0-7
8 x l02
High
7.0 x l0-8
4 x l03
Medium
Low
Medium
High
Table 10
Based on the table 10;
(i)
(ii)
QUESTION 10
You are required to build a hydrometer that can be used to measure densities of
concentrated acids.
Table 11 shows the characteristics of 4 types of hydrometers L, M, N and O.
Hydrometer
L
M
N
O
Type of
material of
hydrometer
Plastic
Plastic
Glass/
Glass
Diameter of
capillary tube/ cm
0.5
2.0
0.5
2.0
Table 11
Density of
shots/ kgm-3
Diameter of
bottom bulb/ cm
1000
1300
9800
8000
1.0
3.0
3.0
1.0
7
QUESTION 11
Heat generated in the car engine has to be removed effectively to avoid overheating. Diagram 12.1
shows the cooling system of a car engine
Heater core
thermostat
Upper radiator
hose
Heater
hoses
Coolant
recovery
system
Bypass
hose
Cooling
jackets
Water
pump
Down-flow radiator
Lower radiator hose
Diagram 12.1
Table 12.1 shows the characteristics of liquid that can be used in the cooling system of a car.
Liquid
J
K
L
M
N
Characteristics
Freezing point Boiling point
(C)
(C)
20
110
-15
120
15
95
5
95
-20
320
Rusting rate
of metal
High
Low
Medium
Medium
Low
You are asked to investigate the characteristic of the liquid in Table 12.1 which could
be used in cooling system of a car. Explain the suitability of each characteristic in Table
12.1 and hence, determine which liquid is most suitable to be used in the cooling
system.. Justify your choice.
[ 10 marks ]
QUESTION 12
As a sport officer, you are given the responsibility to design a high jump landing pad.
Table 12 shows four types of foam materials with different specifications.
Type of
material
P
Q
R
S
Density /
Elasticity /
kgm-3
1500
1700
1200
2000
N cm-1
15.2
13.5
13.7
16.0
Thickness /
cm
Rate of air
absorption
60.0
45.0
80.0
85.0
High
Low
High
moderate
Table 12
You are required to determine the most suitable material to be used to make
the landing pad. Study the specifications of all the four types of material from
the following aspects:
- The density of the material
- The elasticity of the material
- The thickness of the foam
- The ability to absorb water of the material
Explain the suitability of the aspects.
[10 marks]
9
QUESTION 14
Diagram 14 shows circuits P, Q, R, S and T each containing an ideal transformer.
Diodes in the circuits are used for the purpose of rectification.
Circuit
Specification of circuit
QUESTION 15
Q
T
You are asked to make a circuit that can be used to switch on 12 V d.c. radio. Study the
R, S and T in Diagram 12.1 and consider the following aspects:
-
circuits P, Q,
type of transformer
ratio of the number of turns in primary coil to secondary coil
type of rectification
characteristic of output current
Explain the suitability of the above aspects and hence, determine the most suitable circuit to switch on
12 V d.c. radio. Justify your choice.
[ 10 marks ]
10
Diagram 15.1 shows a pair of outdoor shoes suitable for mountain trekking.
Diagram 15.1
Table 15.2 shows the characteristics of five types of materials that can be used
the soles of the trekking shoes.
Type of
material
P
Q
R
S
T
Table 15.2
Density
(Kg/m -3)
820
700
720
750
880
Expansion
effect
Low
Low
Medium
High
High
for making
Ability to
stretch
Good
Good
Average
Poor
Poor
You are asked to study the characteristics of the materials shown in Table 15.2. Explain
the suitability of each characteristic in Table 11.1 and then determine the most suitable
material to be used. Give a reason for your choice.
[ 10 marks ]