Refinery Materials and Corrosion
High Temperature H2/H2S Corrosion
2011
H2/H2S corrosion
description of damage and affected materials
Description of damage
presence of hydrogen in streams containing H2S influences
sulfidation corrosion at temperatures over 500F (260C)
Low Cr alloys are much less resistant to H2/H2S corrosion than for
H2-free sulfidation
generally uniform loss of thickness
corrosion rates in gas oil streams are higher than in naphtha streams
Affected materials (in order of increasing resistance)
carbon steel
Cr-Mo steels (i.e. 5Cr-1/2Mo and 9Cr-1Mo)
4xx series SS (i.e. 405 and 410)
3xx series SS (i.e. 304, 316, 321 and 347)
H2/H2S corrosion
critical factors
Carbon Steel Corrosion
in H2-Containing Naphtha
Couper-Gorman correlations were
developed to predict corrosion in
H2/H2S vapor streams from 400 1100F (205 - 593C) for different
alloys
Above specific temperatures and
below specific H2S concentrations the
reaction Fe + H2S FeS + H2 reverses
and corrosion should not occur
The equation for the No Corrosion
boundary is approximately
ln(mol%H2S) = 6.212ln(T(F)) 46.658
Cr-Mo alloys with up to 9 wt% Cr
provide only slightly better corrosion
resistance than CS
Partial condensation can increase
corrosion rates due to droplet
impingement
H2/H2S corrosion
critical factors
Equation for carbon and Cr-Mo steels
CR(mpy) FCrFG 2.681 10 5 e
10720
T 460
CH2S
0.15400.05891logCH2S
where:
CR = corrosion rate in mpy
FCr = alloy Cr content factor = 10-0.01900(%Cr)
FG = diluent factor (naphtha = 1.000, gas oil = 1.896)
T = temperature in F
CH2S = mol% H2S in process stream
H2/H2S corrosion
critical factors
Equation for 4xx and 3xx SS
CR(mpy) FT 2.8145 10 4 e
9644
T 460
CH2S
0.14645
where:
CR = corrosion rate in mpy
FT = alloy factor (4xx SS = 1.000, 3xx SS = 0.166)
T = temperature in F
CH2S = mol% H2S in process stream
H2/H2S corrosion
affected units or equipment
Piping and equipment in high temperature H2/H2S service in
hydroprocessing units such as hydrotreaters and hydrocracker units
Corrosion may be more severe downstream of hydrogen injection
points
H2/H2S corrosion
prevention/mitigation
Use Couper-Gorman curves to select resistant materials
Cr-Mo steels with up to 9 wt% Cr provide only slightly better corrosion
resistance than carbon steel
3xx SS alloys are highly resistant
use solid SS in feed/effluent heat exchanger tubes and piping
clad or weld overlay pressure vessels and heat exchanger shells,
channels, and tubesheets
H2/H2S corrosion
references
API RP 571, Damage Mechanisms Affecting Fixed Equipment in the
Refining Industry, Section 5.1.1.5
A.S. Couper and J.W. Gorman, Computer Correlations to Estimate
High Temperature H2S Corrosion in Refinery Streams, Materials
Performance, Vol 10, No 1, Jan 1971, pp. 31-37
NACE Pub 34103, Overview of Sulfidic Corrosion in Petroleum
Refining
API RP 939-C, Guidelines for Avoiding Sulfidation (Sulfidic) Corrosion
Failures in Oil Refineries
Check your understanding
F CR versus % Cr
The FCR as shown to the left varies
with Cr content. This shows minimal
reduction in corrosion rate as Cr
increases from 0 (carbon steel) to 9 %
(9Cr-1Mo).
This factor suggests that if the
corrosion rate of carbon steel is 10
mpy (0.25 mm/y) then 9Cr-1Mo would
corrode at about 7 mpy (0.18 mm/y).
Explain how this influences materials
selection for H2 + H2S environments
such as in Hydroprocessing.
1.2
1
F CR
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
0
0
6
% Cr
10