Qualification Exam: Statistical Mechanics

Name:

, QEID#60661227:
April, 2014

Qualification Exam

QEID#60661227

Undergraduate level

Problem 1. 1983-Fall-SM-U-1
ID:SM-U-2
1. Two containers of equal volume are filled with an equal number of moles of
two different ideal classical gasses. The containers are in thermal contact. The
molecules of one of the gasses are diatomic, the other monoatomic. Which
container has greater
(a) pressure
(b) internal energy
(c) heat capacity at constant volume
(d) entropy
2. Discuss and criticize, using examples, the following statement: In equilibrium,
nature seeks the equipartition of energy, in which each degree of freedom contains an average amount of energy 12 kB T .
Problem 2. 1983-Fall-SM-U-2
ID:SM-U-16
1. Two containers of equal volume are filled with an equal number of moles of
two different ideal monoatomic classical gasses. The containers are in thermal contact. The molecules of one of the gasses obey classical (Maxwellian,
Boltzmann) statistics, while the molecules of the other gas obey Fermi-Dirac
statistics. Which container has greater
(a) pressure
(b) internal energy
(c) heat capacity at constant volume
(d) entropy
2. Answer the same questions as for previous part, but comparing classical statistics and Bose-Einstein statistics. Do any of your answers depend on the temperature?
Problem 3. 1983-Fall-SM-U-3
ID:SM-U-31
An engine with one mole of a monoatomic gas as the working fluid undergoes the
following cycle:
An adiabatic expansion from pressure P0 , volume V0 to a volume 2V0 ;
An isothermal compression from 2V0 to V0 ;
At constant pressure to the original state.
1. Find the efficiency of the engine
Statistical Mechanics

QEID#60661227

April, 2014

Qualification Exam

QEID#60661227

2. What is the change in the entropy of the gas during the second leg of the cycle?
3. What is the change in internal energy of the gas in the first leg of the cycle?
Problem 4. 1983-Spring-SM-U-1
ID:SM-U-45
1. Define the thermodynamic energy function H (enthalpy), G (Gibbs free energy),
and F (Helmholtz free energy) for a homogeneous system in term of U (internal
energy) and the thermodynamic variables (S, T, P, V ). What are the natural
variables for each function?
2. Derive the Maxwell relations between the partial derivatives of the thermodynamic variables. Justify each step in words.
Problem 5. 1983-Spring-SM-U-2
ID:SM-U-54
An engine with one mole of a monoatomic ideal gas as a working substance undergoes
the following process:
1 2 isobaric expansion V0 2V0
2 3 isothermal expansion P0 P0 /2
3 4 isobaric compression at P0 /2
4 1 isothermal compression at T0
1. Find the net work done in the process in terms of P0 , V0 .
2. Find the net heat absorbed in the total process in terms of P0 , V0 .
3. Find the entropy change in going from 1 to 2 in terms of R.
4. Find the entropy change in going from 2 to 3 in terms of R.
5. What is the net entropy change in the total process?
Problem 6. 1983-Spring-SM-U-3
ID:SM-U-72
The heat capacity of a normal metal Cn at low temperatures is given by Cn = T ,
where is a constant. If the metal is superconducting below Tc , then the heat capacity
CS in the temperature range 0 < T < Tc is given by the relation CS = T 3 , where
is a constant. The entropy Sn , SS of the normal metal and superconducting metal
are equal at Tc , also Sn = SS as T 0.
1. Find the relation between CS and Cn at Tc .
2. Is the transition first or second order?

Statistical Mechanics

QEID#60661227

April, 2014

Qualification Exam

QEID#60661227

Problem 7. 1984-Fall-SM-U-1
ID:SM-U-81
A cylinder closed at both ends equipped with insulating (adiabatic) walls, and is
divided into two parts with a frictionless, insulating, movable piston. The gases on
both sides are initially at equilibrium with identical pressure, volume, and temperature (P0 , V0 , T0 ). The gas is ideal with CV = 3R/2 and CP /CV = 1.5. By means of
a heating coil in the gas on the left hand side, heat is slowly supplied to the gas on
the left until the pressure reaches 27P0 /8. In terms of nR, P0 , V0 , and T0
1. What is the final right hand volume?
2. What is the final right hand temperature?
3. What is the final left hand temperature?
4. How much heat must be supplied to the gas on the left?
5. How much work is done on the gas on the right?
6. What is entropy change of the gas on the right?
7. Shaw that the entropy change of the gas on the left is nCV log(21/4)+nR log(14/9).
Problem 8. 1984-Fall-SM-U-2
ID:SM-U-96
This problem refers to a classical monoatomic gas.
1. On a T S diagram, draw an isothermal expansion, an isobaric expansion, and
a constant volume process.
2. Draw a Carnot cycle on a T S diagram. Assume that the Carnot cycle operates
between T1 and T2 , with T1 > T2 .
3. Derive the expression for the efficiency of a Carnot cycle using this T S
diagram.
Problem 9. 1984-Fall-SM-U-3
ID:SM-U-107
The van der Waals equation of state for a mole of gas is given by (P + a/V 2 )(V b) =
RT , where V is the molar volume of the gas.
1. Define the critical point Tc , Vc , and Pc in terms of (p/v)T and ( 2 P/V 2 )T .
2. Express a and b in terms of Tc and Vc .
3. Express Pc in terms of Tc and Vc .
4. Calculate the compressibility T = V 1 (V /P )T and the thermal expansion coefficient = V 1 (V /T )P for the van der Waals gas. What do these
quantities do at the critical point?

Statistical Mechanics

QEID#60661227

April, 2014

Qualification Exam

QEID#60661227

Problem 10. 1984-Spring-SM-U-1

ID:SM-U-118
1. If lS is latent heat of sublimation per mole, and the vapor phase can be considered to be an ideal gas, show by using Clausius-Clapeyron equation that
dP
lS
=
dT,
P
RT 2

lS = R

and

d(log P )
,
d(1/T )

where the volume occupied by the solid can be neglected compared to that
occupied by the vapor.
2. Iodine vapor can be assumed to be an ideal diatomic gas with constant CP . At
301K, the vapor pressure is 51.5N/m2 and at 299K it is 43.5N/m2 . Compute
the latent heat of sublimation at 300K.
3. Assuming constant latent heat, calculate the vapor pressure at 305K, assuming
no phase transition exist in the intervening temperature range.
Problem 11. 1984-Spring-SM-U-2
ID:SM-U-132
1. A body of finite, temperature independent, heat capacity is originally at temperature T1 which is higher than the temperature of a heat reservoir T2 . Suppose
that a heat engine operates in infinitesimal cycles between the body and the
reservoir, until it lowers the temperature of the body from T1 to T2 extracting Q
(heat) and does work W during the process. Prove that the maximum amount
of work obtainable is
Wmax = Q T2 (S1 S2 ),
where S1 S2 is the entropy decrease of the body.
2. Two identical bodies, each of constant heat capacity C are at the same initial
temperature Ti . A refrigerator operates between these two bodies until one
of them is cooled to T2 . Calculate using the same principle as the one in the
previous question the final temperature of the high temperature body in terms
of Ti and T2 . Show that the minimum amount of work needed is

 2
Ti
+ T2 2Ti .
W =C
T2
Problem 12. 1984-Spring-SM-U-3
ID:SM-U-147
1. Write down differential equations for the internal energy U , the enthalpy H,
the Helmholtz free energy F , and the Gibbs function G.
2. Derive, showing your reasoning the four Maxwells Relations.
3. Show that

Statistical Mechanics

U
V


=T

P
T

QEID#60661227

P.
V

April, 2014

Qualification Exam

QEID#60661227

4. For a van der Waals gas, show that the internal energy increases as the volume
increases. The van der Waals equation of state is
P =

a
RT
2.
V b V

Problem 13. 1985-Fall-SM-U-1

ID:SM-U-163
1. A membrane separates two chambers of equal volume. Only one side contains
gas, the other is a vacuum. The system as a whole is thermally isolated from
the world, and its walls are rigid. If the membrane is burst (neglect the energy
associated with the membrane) which of the following quantities will remain
unchanged after the system adjusts to the doubled volume?
(a) total entropy S
(b) total particle number N
(c) total energy E
(d) temperature T
(e) pressure P
(f) chemical potential
2. During which periods of time can one describe the entropy of the system as
a unique function of energy, volume, and particle number? Comment on your
answers for each part.
(a) Initially.
(b) During the expansion.
(c) After the adjustment to the doubled volume.
Problem 14. 1985-Fall-SM-U-2
ID:SM-U-184
What is the thermal efficiency of an engine that operates by taking an ideal gas the
following cycle?
1. Start with n moles at P0 , V0 , T0 .
2. Change to 2P0 , V0 , at constant volume.
3. Change 2P0 , 2V0 , at constant pressure.
4. Change to P0 , 2V0 , at constant volume.
5. Change P0 , V0 , at constant pressure.

Statistical Mechanics

QEID#60661227

April, 2014

Qualification Exam

QEID#60661227

Problem 15. 1985-Fall-SM-U-3

ID:SM-U-195

Heat is added to 0.5kg of ice at 0 C until it is all melted. If you dont know the heat
of melting, call it l.
1. What is the change in entropy of the water?
2. If the source of heat is a very massive body at a temperature of 20 C, what is
the change in entropy of this body?
3. What is the total change in entropy of the water and the heat source?
Problem 16. 1985-Spring-SM-U-1
ID:SM-U-204
A system possesses three energy levels E1 = , E2 = 2, E3 = 3 with degeneracies
g(E1 ) = g(E2 ) = 1 and g(E3 ) = 2. Write down
1. The partition function for the system
2. The energy of the system
3. The heat capacity of the system
4. What is the low temperature temperature dependence of the heat capacity?
5. What is the high temperature temperature dependence of the heat capacity?
Problem 17. 1985-Spring-SM-U-2
ID:SM-U-225
For a ferromagnetic solid at low temperatures, the quantized waves of magnetization
(spin waves) have their frequency related to their wave number k according to
= Ak 2 where A is a constant.
1. For a 3-dimensional solid, write down the density of states D() for such an
excitation.
2. Write an expression for the energy density for the spin waves.
3. Determine an expression for the heat capacity, and what is its temperature
dependence at low temperatures?
4. At sufficiently low temperatures, which terms should give the largest contribution to the specific heat: phonons, electrons, or spin waves? Which would give
the smallest contribution?

Statistical Mechanics

QEID#60661227

April, 2014

Qualification Exam

QEID#60661227

Problem 18. 1985-Spring-SM-U-3

ID:SM-U-244
According to quantum mechanics, the molecules of a diatomic gas possess rotational
energy levels
er = ~2 r(r + 1)/2I, where r = 0, 1, 2, . . .
and I is a constant, the level r being (2r + 1)-fold degenerate.
1. Write down the expression for the partition function of the rotational motion.
2. Using the previous part find the molar rotational heat capacity of the gas at
low and at high temperatures.
3. For CO, the constant, I has a value 1.3 1039 gmcm2 . What is the molar
rotational heat capacity for CO at room temperature?
Problem 19. 1986-Spring-SM-U-1
Consider an ideal gas.

ID:SM-U-265

1. Show that the heat transferred during an inflniteslsal quasi-static process c an

be written as
CP
CV
V dP +
P dV
dQ =
R
R
2. Apply the above equation to show that P V = const. far an adiabatic process.
What is ?
Problem 20. 1986-Spring-SM-U-2
ID:SM-U-281
3
A vessel contains 10 cubic meters of helium gas at 3K and 103 Pa. Take the zero of
internal energy of helium to be at this point. You may assume that helium acts as a
monoatomic ideal gas. R = 8.31 J/mole-K.
1. The temperature is raised to 300K at constant volume. Hou much heat Q is
absorbed, and what is the internal energy of helium?
2. The helium is now expanded adiabatically to 3K. What ls the final volume? H
ow much work W is done by the gas and what is the new internal energy of the
gas?
3. The helium is now compressed isothermally to its original volume. What are
Q, W , and U during this process?
4. Sketch the process on a P V diagram. What is the efficiency of the cycle?
Compare this efficiency to that of an ideal Carnot cycle operating between the
two temperature extremes.

Statistical Mechanics

QEID#60661227

April, 2014

Qualification Exam

QEID#60661227

Problem 21. 1986-Spring-SM-U-3

ID:SM-U-303
On a mountainside, air is enclosed in a limp, massless, plastic bag and then is carried
down 100m, in a time too short for heat to flow across the plastic bag, but slow
enough that the pressure inside the bag is in equilibrium with its surroundings at
all times. If air weights 29.3g/mole, and has CP = 29.3J/K, by how much does the
temperature in the air change? Give a brief explanation for the sign of the rise or fall
in temperature.
Problem 22. 1987-Fall-SM-U-1
ID:SM-U-309
1. Find the Fermi energy at T = 0, F , of a gas of N noninteracting spin one-half
particles constrained to move in two dimensions within an area A.
2. Recall that the surface tension, , in two dimensions is analogous to pressure
in three dimensions so that the surface tension contribution from a particle in
state n is given by n /A. Show that the surface tension at T = 0 is given
by N F /2A.
Problem 23. 1987-Fall-SM-U-2
ID:SM-U-323
Derive the general expression for CP CV in terms of T , KT where T is the
isothermal expansion coefficient and KT is the isothermal compressibility coefficient
of the material. Prove that (CP CV )/T must approach zero as T approaches zero.
Problem 24. 1987-Fall-SM-U-3
ID:SM-U-327
The work done by a long solenoid in magnetizing a thin rod shaped magnetic sample
inside it is
Wsol = 0 V Ha dM,
where 0 is the permeability of free space, V the sample volume, Ha , the applied field
and M the magnetization of the sample (magnetic moment per unit volume), The
magnetic induction inside the sample is given by
B = 0 (Ha + M ) = 0 (1 + )Ha ,
where is the magnetic susceptibility of the material. For most ordinary metals in
the normal state, is rather small. (For this problem it can be set equal to zero.)
If the metal goes into the superconducting state, however, it would usually exhibit a
Meissner effect which means that B = 0 inside the superconductor, i.e. = 1. At
temperatures below the superconducting transition temperature, T < Tc , an applied
field Ha = Hc , (the critical field) is sufficient to destroy superconductivity. The
phase boundary between the superconducting state and the normal state can be
approximated by


Hc = H0 1 (T /Tc )2
1. For this phase boundary in the Ha , T plane. Write the defining expression for
the magnetic Gibbs free energy G(T, P, Ha ) and its differential.

Statistical Mechanics

QEID#60661227

April, 2014

Qualification Exam

QEID#60661227

10

2. What is the relationship between GN (T, P0 , Hc ) and Gs (T, P0 , Hc ), the Gibbs

free energies for the normal and superconducting phases along this phase boundary. P0 is an arbitrary, fixed pressure at which the relation for Hc , given above
was determined. Find the relationship between GN (T, P0 , Ha ) and GN (T, P0 , 0)
and between GS (T, P0 , Ha ) and GS (T, P0 , 0).
3. Use the results of the previous parts to show that
(a) there must be a jump discontinuity in the heat capacity of a metal when
it undergoes the superconducting transition at T = Tc . (Relate this jump
to dHc /dT at T = Tc , Ha = 0);
(b) there must be a latent heat of transformation when the superconductor is
driven from the superconducting state to the normal state by a magnetic
field applied at a constant temperature T . (Relate this latent heat to the
slope of the phase boundary as a function of temperature.)
Problem 25. 1988-Fall-SM-U-1
ID:SM-U-361
Starting from ideal gas law and the first law of thermodynamocs, derive the relation
between pressure P and volume V for an adiabatic process in terms of (cV +
R)/cV = cP /cV .
Problem 26. 1988-Fall-SM-U-2
ID:SM-U-366
1. Assuming that water is incompressible, estimate the change in Gibbs energy
G in joules of 100cm3 of water at 25o when the pressure is changed from 1atm
to 100atm. (Note that 1atm = 1.013 105 N/m2 .)
2. In fact the volume of a sample does change when it is subjected to pressure, and
so we ought to see how to take the effect into account, and then judge whether it
is significant. The volume varies in a way that can be determined by specifying
the isothermal compressibility = V 1 (V /P )T , and we may assume that
this is virtually constant over a pressure range of interest. Deduce an expression
for the Gibbs energy Gf at the pressure pf in terms of its value Gi at the initial
pressure pi , the original volume of the sample Vi , and the compressibility .
Take the limit of 0 in your expression for G Gf Gi , and show that
it reduces to the expression used in the first part.
Problem 27. 1988-Fall-SM-U-3
ID:SM-U-376
A hydrogen atom in equilibrium with a radiation field at temperature T can be in its
ground state orbital level (the 1 s level, which is two-fold spin degenerate with
energy 0 ), or it can be in its first excited state energy level (the 2 p level, which is
six-fold degenerate with energy 1 ). For the purpose of this problem we shall assume
that theis atom does not have any other excited states (i.e., no 2s level and no levels
with the principal quantum number n > 2).
1. (a) What is the probability that the atom will be in an orbital sstate?
Statistical Mechanics

QEID#60661227

April, 2014

Qualification Exam

QEID#60661227

11

(b) What is the probability that the atom will be in an orbital pstate?
(c) What is the probability that the atom will be in an orbital slevel?
(d) What is the probability that the atom will be in an orbital plevel?
2. If the temperature is such that kB T = 1 0 , then show and state which of the
two orbital levels is occupied more.
3. Derive an expression for the mean energy of the atom at temperature T and
obtain the limiting value of this mean energy as T .
4. Derive an expression for the entropy of the atom at temperature T and also,
from the definition of entropy, state what should be the values of the entropy for
this atom in the limits of T 0 and T . (If you do not know the answer
for the last question, you may obtain the limits from your general expression of
entropy.)
Problem 28. 1989-Fall-SM-U-1
ID:SM-U-393
Consider a single component system with two phases 1 and 2
1. Starting from the condition of equilibrium for the two phases that the Gibbs
free energies g1 and g2 are the same, i.e. g1 = g2 , derive the Clausius-Clapeyron
equation:
dP
l1,2
=
dT
T v
where l1,2 is the heat absorbed when one mole of phase 1 is transformed to
phase 2, v = v2 v1 is the corresponding volume change, and P and T are,
respectively, the pressure and temperature of the system.
2. Using the above equation show that the slope of any vapor pressure curve (liquid
or solid) is positive.
3. Show that the melting curve for water has a negative slope.
4. The slope of a vapor pressure curve near the critical point is finite. Using the
above equation find the expected numerical value for l1,2 at the critical point.
Problem 29. 1989-Fall-SM-U-2
ID:SM-U-415
Consider a cylinder of length l and area S shown in the figure. The piston is semipermeable, allowing gas A only to pass through. The cylinder contains ideal gases A,
B and C (which are classical gases), so that B is contained on the left, and C on the
right, as shown. The cylinder and piston have small heat capacity compared to the
gases.
1. Find the equilibrium piston position, x0 , given the mole amounts of the three
gases, NA , NB , NC .

Statistical Mechanics

QEID#60661227

April, 2014

Qualification Exam

QEID#60661227

12

2. If the piston is moved adiabatically from its equilibrium position (x0 ), find the
temperature vs. x, in terms of the initial temperature T0 , and the constant volume
molar heat capacities of the three gases CA , CB , and CC . (Assume that the three
gases attain a mutual temperature.)
3. What is the total entropy change in the process (S vs. x)?
4. For the system of B molecules only, what is the entropy change (SB vs. x)?

Problem 30. 1989-Fall-SM-U-3

ID:SM-U-439
Consider a system of N non-interacting fermions for which the single-particle density
of states N () is a sum of delta functions:
N () = N0

( n0 ),

n=0

where 0 is a constant of the dimension of energy, and N0 is proportional to the total

volume V of the system and is otherwise a dimensionless constant.
1. What is the relation which determines the chemical potential of this system
as a function of N , V , and the temperature T ?
2. Sketch the dependence of on N at fixed V and T assuming that T  0 , so
one is in the low temperature regime (but not exactly at T = 0). You may
sketch the inverse function N () if you so choose to do so.
3. What is the relation which determines the total energy E of the system as a
function of T , V , and ?
4. Use the above relations to show that the total heat capacity at constant volume
of the system is given by:


2
P

n=0 cosh2 [ 1 (n0 )]

2
2 X
n
N0 0
2


P

CV =

4kB T
cosh2 21 (n0 )

n=0 cosh2 [ 1 (n0 )]

n=0

[Note: cosh x 21 [ex + ex ].]

Statistical Mechanics

QEID#60661227

April, 2014

Qualification Exam

QEID#60661227

13

Problem 31. 1989-Spring-SM-U-1

ID:SM-U-458
Imagine a set of N independent spins, with fixed positions and J = 1. In a uniform
magnetic field, the spin energies are E = Hs, where s = (1, 0, 1) labels the spin
component along the magnetic field, H is the applied field, and is the magnetic
moment. N is a very large number.
1. Find a general form for n+ , n0 , and n , the expectation values for the numbers
of spins with each of the three spin components, at a given temperature and
field. Do not assume the high-temperature limit here.
2. What is hEi, the total energy expectation value, in the high temperature limit
(first temperature-dependent term)?
3. Find an expression for the entropy S, in the high-temperature limit. Here we
are looking for two terms, the temperature-independent T term and the
first temperature-dependent term. (You may need Stirlings approximation,
log N ! N log N N , although one can do the problem without needing this
formula.)
4. From the previous result, find the temperature dependence on the field H, as H
is varied in an adiabatic process. For decreasing H, what is the process called?
Problem 32. 1989-Spring-SM-U-2
ID:SM-U-484
A particular system obeys the following relations: For internal energy;
U = PV
and for the pressure,
P = BT 2
where V is volume, T absolute temperature, and B is a constant.
1. Find the fundamental equation of this system, that is how the entropy S depends
on U and T and an arbitrary constant Sc .
2. Discuss and show whether S obeys the Third Law of Thermodynamics.
3. Calculate how much heat is transferred into the system when the volume changes
from V0 to 2V0 during an isobaric process (P = P0 ).
4. Calculate the amount of work done by the system when V changes from V0 to
2V0 under isobaric condition (P = P0 ).
5. Show that your results from the previous two parts obey the First Law of
Thermodynamics.

Statistical Mechanics

QEID#60661227

April, 2014

Qualification Exam

QEID#60661227

14

Problem 33. 1989-Spring-SM-U-3

ID:SM-U-514
Consider an extremely relativistic gas consisting of weakly interacting N identical
monoatomic molecules with energy momentum relationship E = cp, where c is the
speed of light. The gas is confined to a volume V and is in thermal equilibrium at
temperature T .
1. Calculate the partition function ZN (V, T ) for the gas.
2. Calculate the Helmholz free energy F .
3. Derive an equation of state of the gas.
Problem 34. 1990-Fall-SM-U-1
ID:SM-U-524
Consider the properties of a rubber band with tension (x, T ), extension x, entropy
S, and temperature T .
1. Find the work done by the rubber band when stretched from x to x + dx.
2. Formulate the first law of thermodynamics for the system.
3. Show that

4. Show that

x
S

S
x


=


=
T

 
T


.
x

T
x


.

5. If now the rubber band obeys Hookss law as an ideal spring, with the force
constant K independent of temperature, what is implied about the functional
form of S = S(x, T )?
Problem 35. 1990-Fall-SM-U-2
ID:SM-U-549
A horizontal insulating cylinder contains a frictionless, thermally insulating piston.
On each side of the piston there are V0 cubic meters of a monoatomic ideal gas at
a pressure P0 and absolute temperature T0 . The gas on the left hand side is heated
slowly until the piston has compressed the right hand side to a pressure of 32P0 .
1. How much work is done on the gas on the right hand side? Express the answer
in units of P0 V0 .
2. What is the final temperature of the gas on the right hand side in units of T0 ?
3. What is the change in entropy for the gas on the right hand side in units of the
number of moles times the gas constant, nR?
4. What is the final temperature of the gas on the left hand side in units of T0 ?

Statistical Mechanics

QEID#60661227

April, 2014

Qualification Exam

QEID#60661227

15

5. How much heat is added to the gas on the left hand side? Express the answer
in units of P0 V0 .
Problem 36. 1990-Fall-SM-U-3
ID:SM-U-568
The relation between the frequency and the wavelength for surface tension waves
on the surface of a liquid of density and surface tension is
2 =

2
.
3

Use a method analogous to the Debye theory of specific heats to find a formula,
analogous to the Debye T 3 law, for the temperature dependence of the surface energy
E of a liquid at low temperatures. The surface tension of liquid helium at 0K is 0.352
103 N/m and its density is 0.145gcm3 . From these data estimate the temperature
range over which your formula for E(T ) is valid for liquid helium, assuming that each
helium atom in the surface of the liquid possesses one degree of freedom.
You may assume
Z 4/3
x
dx = 1.68.
ex 1
0
Bohzmanns constant kB = 1.38 1016 ergK1
Avogadros number N = 6.02 1023 mole1
Plancks constant ~ = 1.05 1027 ergsec
Problem 37. 1990-Spring-SM-U-1
ID:SM-U-587
One liter of an ideal gas under a pressure of 1 atm is expanded isothermally until its
volume is doubled. It is then compressed to its original volume at constant pressure
and further compressed isothermally to its original pressure. Plot the process on a
P V diagram and calculate the total work done on the gas. If 50J of heat, were
removed during the constant- pressure process, what would be the total change in
internal energy? (1 atm = 1.013 105 N/m2 )
Problem 38. 1990-Spring-SM-U-2
ID:SM-U-593
1. For a general (non-ideal) gas, derive the formula


 
P
dE = nCV dT + T
P dV.
T V
CV is the constant-volume specific heat, assumed here to be a constant, and n
denotes the number of moles of gas. You may want to use the Maxwell relation,




S
P
=
.
V T
T V
2. For the van-der-Waals equation of state,


n2 a
P + 2 (V b) = nRT,
V
Statistical Mechanics

QEID#60661227

April, 2014

Qualification Exam

QEID#60661227

16

derive a specific form for dE given above. CV is again a constant (valid, presumably, over a limited temperature range).
3. Find, for the van-der-Waals gas, the constant-pressure specific heat CP (T, V ),
using your result from the previous part. Note that CP is not a constant, but
show that it reduces to the expected form for the ideal gas case.
Problem 39. 1990-Spring-SM-U-3
ID:SM-U-618
In an isolated system of N identical particles (N large) each particle can be in two
energy states: 1 = 0 and 2 =  > 0. The total energy of the system is E. Find, as
a function of E,
1. The entropy of the system.
2. The tmnperature of the system.
Note that log n! = n log n n.
Problem 40. 1991-Fall-SM-U-1
ID:SM-U-630
A substance is found to have two phases N and S. In the normal state, the N phase,
the magnetization M is negligible. At a fixed temperature T < Tc , as the external
magnetic field H is lowered below the critical field
"
 2 #
T
Hc (T ) = H0 1
Tc
the normal state undergoes a phase transition to a new state, the S phase. In the S
state, it is found that B = 0 inside the material. The phase diagram is shown below.
1. Show that the difference in Gibbs free energies (in cgs units) between the two
phases at temperature T Tc , is given by
GS (T, H) GN (T, H) =


1  2
H Hc2 (T ) .
8

(You may express your answer in another system of units. The Gibbs free
energy in a magnetic field is given by G = U T S HM .)
2. Compute the latent heat of transition L from the N to the S phase.
[Hint: one approach is to consider a vClausius-Clapeyron type of analys is.]
3. At H = 0, compute the discontinuity in the specific heat as the material transforms from the N to the S phase.
4. Is the phase transition first or second order at H = 0? What is the basis of
your conclusion?

Statistical Mechanics

QEID#60661227

April, 2014

Qualification Exam

QEID#60661227

17

Problem 41. 1991-Fall-SM-U-2

ID:SM-U-656
A thermally conducting, uniform and homogeneous bar of length L, cross section A,
density and specific heat at constant pressure cP is brought to a steady state by
contact at one end with a hot reservoir at a temperature TH and at the other end
with a cold reservoir at a temperature TC . The bar is removed from the reservoirs,
thermally insulated and kept at constant pressure.
1. Find the equilibrium temperature Tf of the bar.
2. Show that the change in entropy of the bar is


TH
TC
log TC
log TH ,
S = CP 1 + log Tf +
TH TC
TH TC
where CP = cP AL. Assume cP and thermal conductivity are constants.
Problem 42. 1991-Fall-SM-U-3
ID:SM-U-671
1. Show that the Hamiltonian of an LC circuit is that of a harmonic oscillator.
Identify the resonance frequency, and obtain the discrete energy levels of this
system if it is quantized.
2. Calculate the mean energy of this system if it is at thermodynamic equilibrium
with its surroundings which are at an absolute temperature T .
3. Show how the root-mean-square voltage Vrms , across the capacitor of this circuit
can be used as a thermometer to measure the absolute temperature T of its
surroundings, by showing that Vrms is a monotonically increasing function of
Statistical Mechanics

QEID#60661227

April, 2014

Qualification Exam

QEID#60661227

18

T , and therefore Vrms can uniquely determine T . Neglect any temperature

dependence of L or C.
Problem 43. 1991-Spring-SM-U-1
ID:SM-U-686
Find the change of temperature of a quantity of water carried by a downward current
to a depth of 1km in a lake at 27o C. For water at this temperature


1 V
= 0.00013 deg1
V T P
and you may assume: no heat exchange (S = 0).
Given: g = 980 cm/s2 , and = 1 gm/cm3 , cP 1 cal/gdeg for water, and
1cal = 4.18 107 erg.
Problem 44. 1991-Spring-SM-U-2
ID:SM-U-697
Measuring the tension J of a rubber band stretched at a constant length l, it is found
that J = AT , where A is a positive constant depending only on l; T is the absolute
temperature.
1. Show that the internal energy U is a function of the temperature only.
2. Show that the entropy S decreases with increasing length at constant temperature.
3. When the rubber band is stretched adiabatically, does the temperature increase,
decrease or stay unchanged, and why?
Problem 45. 1991-Spring-SM-U-3
ID:SM-U-710
The molecuies of one mole of a certain gas consist of two different atoms, each of zero
nuclear spin, bound together. Measurements of the specific heat of this material, over
a wide range of temperatures, give the graph shown below. (The values marked on
the vertical scale correspond to the height of the curve in each of the plateau regions.)

Statistical Mechanics

QEID#60661227

April, 2014

Qualification Exam

QEID#60661227

19

1. Describe the physical reason for each of the three difierent plateaus in the figure.
2. At temperature T0 , the gas undergoes a phase transition directly to an ideal
classical solid. Sketch the typical behavior of CV below T0 , down to 0K, including the magnitude just below T0 and the temperature dependence just above
the absolute zero temperature, and give physical justifications.
3. Given the first excited state of the rotational spectrum of this molecule is at
the energy kTe above the ground rotational state, and Te = 64K, calculate
from basic theory the rotational contribution to the specific heat capacity per
molecule (in units of the Boltzmann constant kB ) at T = 10K and T = 500K.
~2
is the rotational temperature, and you
(Note that Te = 2r , where r 2Ik
B
may make reasonable approximations in answering this part. If you dont have
a calculator for the explicit evaluations, indicate what numerical expressions
you would have to compute with a calculator.)
Problem 46. 1992-Fall-SM-U-1
ID:SM-U-726
A gas is described by the following equations of state
P =

U
,
3V

U = bV T 4

where b is a constant and P , U , V , and T are the thermodynamic pressure, internal

energy, volume and temperature.
1. Determine the entropy S as a function of U and V .
Statistical Mechanics

QEID#60661227

April, 2014

Qualification Exam

QEID#60661227

20

2. Determine the functional relationship between P and V along an adiabatic path.

3. Determine the functional relationship between P and V along an isothermal
path.
4. Determine the work done by the system as it expands from an initial volume
V0 to a final volume 2V0 along an isothermal path with temperature T0 .
5. Determine the heat added to the system as it expands from an initial volume
V0 to a final volume 2V0 along an isothermal path with temperature T0 .
Problem 47. 1992-Fall-SM-U-2
ID:SM-U-748
Consider a gas of non-interacting Bose particles with spin S = 0 and mass m. In the
ultrarelativistic limit, one can approximate the dispersion relation by E(p) = cp.
1. Write down a general integral expression for the statistical average of the total
number of particles not in the zero-energy ground state.
2. Determine the Bose-Einstein condensation temperature T0 of the gas as a function of the gas density = N/V .
3. Determine the fraction N0 /N of the particles in the zero-energy ground state
as a function of temperature T and density .
You may gnd the following formula useful:
Z x1
z
dz = (x)(x)
ez 1
0
x

3/2

/2
2.612

5/2

3 /4
1.341

3
2
1.202

5
24
1.037

Problem 48. 1992-Fall-SM-U-3

ID:SM-U-779
A chamber, that is adiabatically isolated from the outside universe, is partitioned
into two volumes V0 and V . Initially the volume V0 is filled with N particles of a
gas and the volume V is completely empty. The partition between the volumes V0
and V is punctured so that the gas freely expands into the additional volume V
so that its final volume is V0 + V .
1. Assuming V is small, calculate a general expression for the change in temperature T . Express your answer in terms of the following thermodynamic
quantities which you can assume to be known.

Statistical Mechanics

QEID#60661227

April, 2014

Qualification Exam

QEID#60661227

21

Temperature

Volume

Pressure

Thermal Expansion
Isothermal Compressibility

=
T =

1
V

V1

V
T

P

V
P

T

2. Evaluate your expression for T in the previous part for a monoatomic ideal
gas.
Problem 49. 1992-Spring-SM-U-1
ID:SM-U-808
An ensemble of non-interacting pairs of Ising spins is in a magnetic field h and at
temperature T . Each spin variable szi can only take on values sz = 1. The two spins
within each pair interact according to the Hamiltonian
H = Jsz1 sz2 B h (sz1 + sz2 ) ,

with J > 0

1. Enumerate the possible states of a single pair and compute their corresponding
energies.
2. Derive an expression for the average value of a spin, hszi i, (i = 1, 2) as a function
of J, T and h.
3. Given the above model, determine whether there exists a temperature Tc for
which hszi i can be non-zero at h = 0. Evaluate Tc .
Problem 50. 1992-Spring-SM-U-2
ID:SM-U-825
1. Show that the number of photons, N , in equilibrium at temperature T in a
cavity of volume V is proportional to

3
kB T
V
~c
2. Show that the heat capacity for this system is proportional to T 3 .
Problem 51. 1992-Spring-SM-U-3
ID:SM-U-840
Consider a system of non-interacting spin 1/2 fermion particles, electrons, adsorbed
on a surface with specific adsorption sites. At each site, an electron can occupy any
one of three distinct orbital states corresponding to energies 1 , 2 , and 3 (1 > 0,
2 > 0, and 3 > 0). The surface is in contact with a gas of electrons that acts as a
thermal and particle reservoir.
1. Determine a general expression for the average number of particles adsorbed
per site if the reservoir is at a temperature T and has a chemical potential .
Statistical Mechanics

QEID#60661227

April, 2014

Qualification Exam

QEID#60661227

22

2. If 1 < 2 and 2 = 3 within what range of values must (T = 0) lie if at T = 0

the average number of electrons adsorbed per site is 2.
3. If the average number of electrons adsorbed per site is maintained at 2 for small
nonzero temperatures, determine the precise limiting value of as T approaches
zero.
Problem 52. 1993-Fall-SM-U-1
ID:SM-U-855
Consider the following equations of state for an ideal gas:
U = cN kB T,

P V = N kB T,

where c is a constant.
1. Determine the entropy as a function of U , V , and N . Let S = 0 when U =
N u0 , and V = N v0 , where constants u0 and v0 are the energy/particle and
volume/particle respectively.
2. Determine the entropy as a function of P , T , and N . Let S = 0 when T = T0
and P = P0 .
3. If the number of particles N varies, then calculate the chemical potential in
terms of P , T , P0 , T0 , and constants c and kB .
Problem 53. 1993-Fall-SM-U-2
ID:SM-U-873
When we apply a magnetic field H to a solid body, it is permissible under many
circumstances to neglect the P dV term in comparison to the HdM term in the
fundamental thermodynamic equation. Hence for a magnetizable solid body we can
simply write
dU = T dS + HdM
where the magnetization M = H is related to H through the susceptibility =
(H, T ). Let CH denote the heat capacity at constant field H, CM the heat capacity
at constant M , and define the differential isothermal susceptibility as = (M/H)T .
1. Find an expression for CH CM in terms of T , H, , and .
2. Show for a paramagnetic material, where = /T with a = constant, that the
expression in the first part reduces to CH CM = M H/T .
Problem 54. 1993-Fall-SM-U-3
ID:SM-U-889
1. Shown in the figure below is a set of available single-particle states and their
energies. By properly filling these single-particle states, find the energies and
degeneracies for a system of four identical non-interacting particles in the systems lowest energy level and in its first excited energy level, assuming that
these particles are:
Statistical Mechanics

QEID#60661227

April, 2014

Qualification Exam

QEID#60661227

23

(a) identical spinless bosons,

(b) identical spinless fermions.
2. At a finite temperature T, calculate the ratio r = P1 /P0 , again for the two cases
defined above. P1 is the probability for finding the four-particle system in the
first excited energy level, and P0 is the probability for finding the same system
in the lowest energy level.

Problem 55. 1993-Spring-SM-U-1

ID:SM-U-906
One is given two containers. Each contains N moles of water at the same pressure.
Initially the temperature of the water in each container is T1 , and T2 (T2 T1 ).
The entire system is kept at a constant pressure and is thermally isolated from the
surroundings. The heat capacity of water per mole, CP , can be taken to be a constant
for T1 T T2 .
First, consider a process when the two bodies of water are brought into thermal
contact so they can exchange heat between themselves.
1. Calculate the final temperature of the resulting mixture.
2. Calculate the change in the total entropy of the two bodies of water.
3. Now, determine the theoretical maximum amount of total work that could have
been obtained from this system.
Statistical Mechanics

QEID#60661227

April, 2014

Qualification Exam

QEID#60661227

24

Problem 56. 1993-Spring-SM-U-2

ID:SM-U-925
During a process in which the volume of a system of N molecules is expanded from
V1 to V2 , the temperature is observed to decrease linearly with the volume from T1
to T2 , that is,
T = T1 + A(V V1 )
T1
.
where A = VT22 V
1
Express the heat transfer during this process in terms of definite integrals of

T
CP =
N

S
T


,
P,N

1
=
V

V
T


,
P,N

1
T =
V

V
P


,
T,N

which are assumed to be known functions of T and V .

Problem 57. 1993-Spring-SM-U-3
ID:SM-U-945
A simple statistical mechanical model can be used to describe thermal denaturation
(strand separation) of DNA molecules. The DNA molecule is represented as a chain
of two kinds of base pairs, NA pairs of type A and NB pairs of type B, in a given
sequence. Each pair can be in two states (n = 0, 1), ether bound (n = 0) or unbound
(n = 1), as shown in the figure. The average fraction of unbound pairs (f ) can be
easily measured experimentally.

1. Sketch qualitatively, using only physical arguments, f as a function of temperature T for a pure A (NB = 0) and a pure B (NA = 0) DNA. Be sure to state
the limiting values at T = 0 and explicitly.
2. Derive the partition function for a single DNA molecule assuming that the
energy n of each base pair is independent of the state of other pairs, and that
the unbinding energy depends only on whether the base is of type A or B,

0,
if n = 0
n =
.
A or B , if n = 1
In this model, does the partition function (and the other physical properties)
depend on the particular sequence of the bases?
3. Derive a closed analytical expression for f as a function of T and c NA /N ,
where N = NA + NB .
[Hint: You may find the following identity useful: ex /(1 + ex ) = 1/(1 + ex ) =
1
(1 tanh(x/2))].
2
Statistical Mechanics

QEID#60661227

April, 2014

Qualification Exam

QEID#60661227

25

4. Using the result in the previous part and the phenomenological form A =
aA (TA T ) and B = aB (TB T ), indicate the phenomenological parameters
aA , aB , TA and TB in your figures in the first part, and sketch f (T ) assuming
1
c = 1/4, TB = 1.5TA , a1
A = 0.1TA , and aB = 0.1TB .
Problem 58. 1993-Spring-SM-U-4
ID:SM-U-976
Consider a classical system of N point particles of mass m in a volume V at temperature T . The particles interact through a two-body repulsive central potential
 r n
0
,
(r) = 0
r
where 0 > 0, r0 > 0, and n > 0.
1. Calculate the partition function Z(T, V ) for this system and show explicitly
that Z(T, V ) = Z0 (T, V )q(T V n/3 ), where Z0 is the ideal gas partition function
and the function q(x) (which you can not express in a closed form!) depends
on T and V only through x = T V n/3 .
2. Given the result of the previous part, show that the internal energy U and the
pressure P are related as U = U0 + n3 (P P0 )V , where the subscript 0 refers to
the ideal gas.
3. What is the potential (r) as n ? Explain the result obtained in the
previous part in this limit. Is it correct?
Problem 59. 1994-Fall-SM-U-1
ID:SM-U-994
A material, in a certain range of temperature T and pressure P , has a volume expansivity (or thermal expansion coefficient) given by
= (R/P v) + (a/RvT 2 ),
and an isothermal compressibility given by
T = [T f (P ) + (b/P )]/v,
where R, a, and b are (non-dimensionless) constants independent of pressure P the
specific volume v V /N , and the absolute temperature T , and f (P ) f(P) is an
unknown function of P .
1. Determine f (P ).
2. Determine v(P, T ).

Statistical Mechanics

QEID#60661227

April, 2014

Qualification Exam

QEID#60661227

26

Problem 60. 1994-Fall-SM-U-2

ID:SM-U-1013
The ground state density of a free-electron Fermi gas is conveniently parametrised by
specifying the volume per conduction electron according to
4 3
V
rs
3
N
1. Find the Fermi wavevector, kF in terms of the electron density parameter rs .
2. Find expressions for the following quantities, in terms of the dimensionless density parameter (rs /a0 ), where a0 is the Bohr radius, and with the units indicated:
(a) the Fermi momentum kF (in
A), [Given: 1a0 = 0.529
A.]
(b) the Fermi energy F (in eV ), [Given: 1Rydberg = 13.6eV .j
(c) the Fermi temperature TF (in K). [Given: 1eV = kB x1.16 104 K.]
In each case, a detailed expression for the coefficient involved should be found
so that if you had a calculator you would be able to evaluate the coefficient
numerically.
3. Starting from the equation of state
2
P V = hEi,
3
where hEi is the total internal energy of the gas, express the T = 0value of the
bulk modulus


P
,
B V
V T,N
which is the inverse of the isothermal compressibility T V1 (V /P )T,N , in
terms of the Fermi energy F and the density parameter rs .
Problem 61. 1994-Fall-SM-U-3
ID:SM-U-1048
Using some simple reasoning, obtain the functional dependencies of the low- and hightemperature behaviors (i.e., for T  F and T  F ) of the following quantities for
a three-dimensional ideal Fermi gas, in terms of N (the total number of particles), T
(the absolute temperature), F (the Fermi energy), and kB (the Boltzmann constant):
1. the total specific heat at a constant volume CV ,
2. the total entropy S,
3. the total internal energy E.
In each expression, you may introduce any number of un-determined numerical constants, but not any un-determined dimensional quantities. For each of the three
physical quantities listed above, drew also a qualitative sketch of its T -dependence
Statistical Mechanics

QEID#60661227

April, 2014

Qualification Exam

QEID#60661227

27

from T = 0 up to a temperature T  F , based on the low- and high-temperature

behaviors of it you have deduced.
Problem 62. 1994-Spring-SM-U-1
ID:SM-U-1062
Over some range of parameters a system is described by the following fundamental
equation:
s = Au1/3 v 1/3 ,
where s, u, and v are the molar entropy, molar energy, and molar volume, respectively
and A is a constant. N moles of this fluid is initially confined to a volume Vi at pressure
Pi . It then expands reversibly at consonant temperature T0 to a final volume Vf > Vi .
1. Determine the final pressure Pf in terms of Vi , Vf , and Pi .
2. Determine an expression for either the chemical potential or an expression
for the change in chemical potential, d, and explain whether the chemical
potential of this system increases or decreases for this process?
Problem 63. 1994-Spring-SM-U-2
ID:SM-U-1079
For a system in an electric field E the differential of the internal energy is
dU = T dS + Ed
where is the electric polarization of the system. Define the generalized Helmholtz
free energy F (T, ), the generalized enthalpy H(S, E) and the generalized Gibbs free
energy G(T, E) for this system in terms of the variables T , S, E, and . Write the
differentials for these thermodynamic functions and use these to find the four Maxwell
relations between derivatives of these variables. (Note: for this particular system the
pressure P and volume V are not relevant variables, so dont include them in your
work.)
Problem 64. 1994-Spring-SM-U-3
ID:SM-U-1089
For an isotropic three-dimensional solid whose velocity of sound c is the same for all
three modes, find the expression for the Debye temperature D (where ~max = kB D ).
Show that the number of phonons exceed in this solid is proportional to T 3 for T  D
and proportional to T for T  D .
Problem 65. 1995-Fall-SM-U-1
ID:SM-U-1095
The figure shows the pressure versus molar volume isotherms for the Van der Waals
gas
RT
a
P =
2
vb v
1. Which of the isotherms in the figure contains regions that do not satisfy the
thermodynamic stability conditions?
2. Which isotherm represents the critical temperature?

Statistical Mechanics

QEID#60661227

April, 2014

Qualification Exam

QEID#60661227

28

3. Sketch on the graph the region in which the system is unstable to local perturbations (spinodal line).
4. Sketch on the graph the region in which the system is globally unstable.
5. What is physically occurring within this region of global instabilities?
6. Sketch the qualitative behavior of the molar volume against temperature for an
isobar at P = 0.02 and P = 0.06.

Problem 66. 1995-Fall-SM-U-2

ID:SM-U-1114
An ideal gas is expanded adiabatically from (P1 , V1 ) to (P2 , V2 ) [AB in figure below].
Then it is compressed at constant pressure to (P2 , V1 ) [BC]. Finally the pressure is
increased to P1 at constant volume V1 [CA].

Statistical Mechanics

QEID#60661227

April, 2014

Qualification Exam

QEID#60661227

29

1. Calculate WBC , the work done in going from B to C.

2. Calculate W CA, the work done in going from C to A.
3. For an ideal gas, show that CP = CV + N k, and hence that CV = N k/( l),
where CP /CV . (Here N is the number of molecules and k is the Boltzmann
constant. )
4. Calculate WAB the work done in going from A to B, in terms of , P2 , V2 , P1 ,
and V1 .
5. Calculate Q, the heat absorbed in going from C to A, in terms of , V1 , V2 , P2
and P1 .
6. Calculate the efficiency W/Q, and show that it is given by
=1

1 V2 /V1
1 P1 /P2

Problem 67. 1995-Fall-SM-U-3

ID:SM-U-1141
Molecules do not all pile up at the bottom of the atmosphere, but rather have a
density n that decreases as one moves higher in the atmosphere The pull of gravity
is countered by upward diffusion.
Consider a monoatomic gas of molecules of mass m, in a uniform downward gravitational field g. Take the y-direction to be upward.
1. Using N as the number of molecules in a gas, V as its volume, and kB as the
Boltzmann constant, write down the ideal gas law.
2. Find the differential equation for the pressure P (y) under gravity by finding the
equilibrium condition for the matter in a slab of area A and thickness dy.
3. For an isothermal atmosphere if P = P0 at y = 0, find P (y).
4. Find the density n(y).
Statistical Mechanics

QEID#60661227

April, 2014

Qualification Exam

QEID#60661227

30

5. If the drift velocity due to gravity is v = mg, where is called the mobility,
write down the number current density Jg due to the pull of gravity, including
its direction.
6. The number current density due to diffusion is Jdif f = Dy n, where D is
called the diffusion constant. Setting to zero the sum of the number current
densities due to gravity and due to diffusion, find a relationship between D and
.
Problem 68. 1995-Spring-SM-U-1
ID:SM-U-1163
Consider a set of N indistinguishable spin-1 objects, each with energy
E = ASz + BSz2 ,
where S, is given in units where ~ = 1. Thus A and B are energies.
1. With (n1 , n0 , n1 ) the numbers of spins in the states with Sz = 1, 0, 1 respectively, find the number of arrangements W of the spins that will produce these
numbers.
2. Write down the free energy F for this system, in terms of n1 , n0 , n1 the temperature T , and N . Use log(m!) = m log(m) m for large m. Set kB = 1.
3. Using ni and n0 as independent variables, minimize F to find n1 , n0 , and n1 ,
in equilibrium at a given temperature T .
Problem 69. 1995-Spring-SM-U-2
ID:SM-U-1179
Consider a one-dimensional (non-harmonic) oscillator with energy given by
p2
+ bx4 ,
2m
where p is the momentum and b is some constant. Suppose this oscillator is in thermal
equilibrium with a heat bath at a sufficiently high temperature T so that classical
mechanics is valid.
E=

1. Compute its mean kinetic energy as a fraction of kT .

2. Compute its mean potential energy as a fraction of kT .
3. Consider a collection of such non-interacting oscillators all at thermal equilibrium in one-dimension. What is the specific heat (per particle) of this system?
[Hint: You might use
Z

xn1 ex dx = (n),

n 6= 1, 2, . . .

or an integration by parts in solving this problem.]

Statistical Mechanics

QEID#60661227

April, 2014

Qualification Exam

QEID#60661227

31

Problem 70. 1995-Spring-SM-U-3

ID:SM-U-1203
The equation of state for an ideal gas is P V = nRT .
1. Prove that the internal energy U (V, T ) is s function of T only.
2. If the entropy at T0 , V0 is S0 , find the entropy at any other T , V assuming
the molar specific heat CV is a given constant. (Express the answer for S as a
function of the variables T , V .)
3. Show that the reversible work done in an isothermal expansion is equal to the
negative of the change in free energy.
Problem 71. 1996-Fall-SM-U-1
ID:SM-U-1217
1. Determine the chemical potential, at temperature T = 0 and at number density
n for a non-interactmg, non-relativistic Fermi gas of spin-1/2 and mass m ( =
p2 /2m).
2. Repeat the previous part for the relativistic case ( = cp).
3. Show that, at some critical density n, and T = 0, the proton-electron plasma
starts a transition into the degenerate neutron gas. Neglect any interaction
between the particles and consider the electron and proton systems as Fermigases. Take into account the mass difference M between the neutron and
proton. Since me  M , the electrons must be treated relativistically. Assume
that neutrons created in the course of this transformation leave the system.
Neglect gravity.
4. Consider such a system in a box of volume V , with n < nc . Determine the
number of electrons Ne and their pressure as the volume is decreased somewhat
below the volume where the transition occurs. Do not consider compression so
high that complete conversion occurs.
Problem 72. 1996-Fall-SM-U-2
ID:SM-U-1233
The 1-dimensional Ising model is defined as a chain with spins n , on each site n
(n = 1, 2 . . . N ) independently taking one of two values n = 1. The energy of this
system can be written as follows:
H = J

N
1
X

n n+1 ,

n=1

where J is a positive constant.

1. Introduce spins on a bond n = n n+1 as new variables. Explain why the
s are independent. Find the partition function.
2. Find the free energy and the heat capacity per site.
Statistical Mechanics

QEID#60661227

April, 2014

Qualification Exam

QEID#60661227

32

3. Find the asymptotic behavior of the heat capacity at T  J and at T  J.

Give a physical explanation for the dominant behavior at T  J.
Problem 73. 1996-Fall-SM-U-3
ID:SM-U-1251
The total entropy S for a system of N particles in a container of volume V , with total
energy E, is
S = aE 1/3 V 1/3 N 1/3 ,
where a is a constant.
1. Compute the temperature, pressure, and chemical potential as functions of S,
V , and N .
2. Stability, the Third Law, and the extensivity property provide some constraints
on allowable thermodynamic quantities (Extensivity refers to how various quantities scale when two identical systems am combined.) Discuss how the results
from the previous part satisfy or do not satisfy these constraints.
3. Compute the Helmholtz free energy F (T, V, N ), and from F compute S(T, V, N ).
Show that this is consistent with the entropy S(E, V, N ) given initially.
Problem 74. 1996-Spring-SM-U-1
ID:SM-U-1270
Consider a cylinder of water that undergoes a slow adiabatic compression
1. What thermodynamic property of the water will be constant during an adiabatic
compression? Use this to write a simple equation connecting small temperature
changes, T , to pressure changes, P , to first order.
2. The temperature change in an adiabatic compression can be related to the waters compressibility, V1 (V /T )P , and its specific heat at constant pressure,
CP . To do so, first find a Maxwell relation which will connect the compressibility
to a derivative of the entropy.
3. Now transform your equation from the first part, in order to express small
temperature changes, T , to adiabatic pressure changes, P , in terms of the
temperature, volume, CP , and the compressibility. Consider , and CP , to be
essentially constant during the process.
Problem 75. 1996-Spring-SM-U-2
Specific heat of a gas-liquid system:

ID:SM-U-1284

1. What general expression relates pressure and temperature changes for condensation and evaporation along an equilibrium liquid-gas coexistent curve?
2. Consider a liquid and its vapor, and assume that the vapor behaves as an
ideal gas. Express the slope (P/T ) along the coexistence curve, in terms of
the latent heat of vaporization (Lv ) of the system, plus other thermodynamic
quantities.
Statistical Mechanics

QEID#60661227

April, 2014

Qualification Exam

QEID#60661227

33

3. Now find an expression for the specific heat of the gas, following the coexistence
curve (that is, the specific heat calculated from the heat into the gas only, as
it contacts the liquid), in terms of T , Lv , and the specific heat at constant
pressure (CP ). CP , (assumed to apply only to the gas) and Lv may be taken to
be constant.
[Hint: a Maxwell relation may be used to obtain the final answer.]
4. Show from your result that there is a temperature regime in which the specific
heat of the gas is negative. Does this mean that the gas is thermodynamically
unstable?
Problem 76. 1996-Spring-SM-U-3
ID:SM-U-1302
Consider a classical gas, in equilibrium at temperature T , with no interactions between gas particles. Each particle has mass m.
1. Write down the general form of the velocity (not speed) distribution function
for such a gas. This should be a probability function per unit volume, per d3~v .
Assume the gas as a whole is at rest in your coordinate system. Determine the
normalizing constant.
2. Obtain vrms , which is the root-mean-square velocity for this gas, using your
distribution function (You get credit for demonstrating the method, not for
recalling the result.)
3. Find the probability that a gas particle will have a positive x velocity component
that exceeds vrms . (There is a table of values in the CRC tables that can be
used to evaluate the integral.)
Problem 77. 1997-Fall-SM-U-1
ID:SM-U-1316
In so-called intrinsic semiconductors at T = 0, electrons fill the lower (valence) band,
whereas the upper (conducting) band is empty. Let the maximal energy of the valence
band and the minimal energy of the conducting band correspond to the momentum
p~ = 0 and be separated by the energy gap Eg . Assume that near the minimum
(maximum) the energy (p) can be represented approximately by an expansion:
c =

p2
Eg
+
;
2
2mc

v =

Eg
p2

,
2
2mv

where Eg , is the gap in the electron spectrum and mc,v , are effective masses of electrons
and holes respectively.
1. Using the electro-neutrality condition, (i.e., the number of thermally excited
holes in the valence band equals the number of thermally excited electrons in
the conduction band.), calculate the chemical potential for electrons as a
function of temperature at a temperature T  Eg .

Statistical Mechanics

QEID#60661227

April, 2014

Qualification Exam

QEID#60661227

34

2. Calculate the density of electrons in the conducting band and the density of
holes in the valence band at a temperature T  Eg .
Problem 78. 1997-Fall-SM-U-2
ID:SM-U-1332
Calculate the efficiency of a Stirling engine using a classical ideal gas. In the Stirling
engine the gas is compressed isothermally from a volume V1 , to a smaller volume V2
at a temperature T2 then it is heated at a fixed volume V2 to a higher temperature T2 ;
then it performs work, expanding isothermally to the initial volume V1 , and finally it
returns to the initial temperature T1 by cooling at fixed volume V1 .
Problem 79. 1997-Fall-SM-U-3
ID:SM-U-1338
A 2-dimensional classical ideal gas of N particles at a temperature T , is contained to
an area A in the x y plane.
1. Find the partition function and the free energy for this system.
2. Determine the surface tension as a function of temperature and density (numbe
r of particles per unit area) n = N/A.
3. If the same gas is placed in a field of constant force per particle, F , directed
along the x-axis, determine the density n as a function of x.
4. Find how the surface tension varies with x.
Problem 80. 1997-Spring-SM-U-1
ID:SM-U-1356
Consider a solid with N , atoms each having a mass m. Assume that each atom has
three independent modes of oscillation, each at the same frequency 0 . This is known
as the Einstein model. Let the solid be in equilibrium with a vapor of the same type
of atom, and let 0 > 0 be the sublimation energy per atom, i.e. the energy which
is necessary to remove an atom from the solid to the vapor with zero final kinetic
energy.
The vapor can be treated as an ideal gas. Its free energy is



 
2~
Vg

+
1
,

=
Fg = kB T Ng log
,
T
Ng 3T
mT
where we have assumed that the vapor contains Ng particles occupying a volume Vg .
1. Find the free energy Fs of the solid.
2. Find the equilibrium vapor pressure as a function of temperature if the volume
Vg is maintained constant. Neglect any volume changes in the solid, due to
evaporation.

Statistical Mechanics

QEID#60661227

April, 2014

Qualification Exam

QEID#60661227

35

Problem 81. 1997-Spring-SM-U-2

ID:SM-U-1373
The surface of the sun has the temperature 6000K. The suns radius is R 106 km.
1. Assuming that the sun is a black body, what is the emitted power per cycle
dP/df at a wavelength of 3cm? (Please give a simple approximate expression.)
2. What is the emitted power per cycle dP/df at the wave-length 3 106 cm?
3. Indicate how you would determine the power P integrated over all frequencies.
Problem 82. 1997-Spring-SM-U-3
ID:SM-U-1388
One mole of an ideal gas, with internal energy U = 52 nRT (n = 1mole), is taken from
an initial state i, with pressure P0 and volume V0 to a final state f with Pf = 2P0
and Vf = 2V0 by two different paths:
Path 1: The gas undergoes an isothermal expansion from V0 to 2V0 , and then the pressure is increased to its final value Pf at constant volume.
Path 2: The gas undergoes an isothermal compression to Pf , and then is expanded at
constant pressure to its final volume Vf .
1. Sketch P V diagrams for each case.
2. Find the heat Q added to the system in each step of the above two processes in
terms of P0 , V0 , and other constants.
3. Find the change in entropy of the gas in going from the initial to the final state.
Problem 83. 1998-Fall-SM-U-1
ID:SM-U-1408
The cycle of a highly idealized gasoline engine can be approximated by the Otto
cycle. Steps 1 2 and 3 4 are adiabatic compression and expansion, respectively.
Steps 2 3 and 4 1 are isochoric (constant volume) processes. Treat the working
medium as an ideal gas with constant = CP /CV = 5/3 and take V1 = 3liters,
P1 = 1atm (105 N/m2 ), and P3 = 2P2 .
1. Sketch the cycle on a P V diagram.
2. Compute the efficiency of this cycle for compression ratio r = V1 /V2 = 4.
3. Calculate the work done on the gas during the two steps 1 2 and 2 3.
4. Calculate the entropy changes of the gas during the two step 1 2 and 2 3.

Statistical Mechanics

QEID#60661227

April, 2014

Qualification Exam

QEID#60661227

36

Problem 84. 1998-Fall-SM-U-2

ID:SM-U-1424
A cylindrical container of height L and radius R contains many identical non-interacting
particles of mass m at temperature T . If the container rotates about its axis at angular velocity , the single-particle Hamiltonian in the rotating frame is given by
H=

m 2 r2
p2

,
2m
2

where r is the radial coordinate, and p is the total momentum.

1. The earths atmosphere thins out with increasing height, because of gravity. A
similar effect occurs for the gas within this rotating container. Determine how
the pressure and density vary with radial coordinate r.
2. If the system has N particles, obtain the density as a function of r.
3. Obtain an approximate expression for the density distribution at high rates of
rotation, i.e, m 2 R2 /2  kB T . In this case, essentially all of the gas is compressed into a region of characteristic thickness d  R close to the wall. How
does d scale with m, , and T ? For hydrogen molecules at room temperature,
in a container with R = 5cm, estimate the numerical value of where d equals
0.1R.
Boltzmann constant kB = 1.38 1023 J/K
Speed of light c = 3.0 108 m/s
Proton mass mp = 1.67 1027 kg
Problem 85. 1998-Fall-SM-U-3
ID:SM-U-1449
A horizontal wire of length L is fixed at both ends and tightened to a tension F . It
is in equilibrium with a heat bath at temperature T .
1. Because of thermal fluctuation, the midpoint of the wire is sometimes displaced
vertically by a distance y (y  L). Find the work done by the heat bath to the
wire.
2. Find the probability for such displacement to happen.
3. Find the root-mean-square displacement of the midpoint of the wire.
Problem 86. 1998-Spring-SM-U-1
ID:SM-U-1463
In a hot quark-gluon plasma, the gluons are massless spin-1 particles (energymomentum relation  = cp), with eight degenerate colors, and quarks are relativistic
spin-1/2 particles with three degenerate colors and two degenerate flavors.
1. Determine the degeneracy factors dG and dC for the gluons and the quarks.
In what follows, consider only the gluons, and take volume V.

Statistical Mechanics

QEID#60661227

April, 2014

Qualification Exam

QEID#60661227

37

2. Determine the thermal average for the total energy E for the gluons. (Gluons
are not conserved; from this one can show that their chemical potential G = 0.)
Leave any integrals in dimensionless form; do not evaluate them.
3. Determine the heat capacity CV , and the entropy S.
4. Determine the free energy F and the pressure P associated with the gluons.
Show that P = 13 E/V
Problem 87. 1998-Spring-SM-U-2
ID:SM-U-1484
Consider a crystal with p identical hydrogen atoms distributed over J identical bulk
sites and K identical surface sites. Let p  J. The atoms do not interact, but they
have an energy B at the bulk sites, and an energy S at the surface sites. Let b be
the number of atoms at bulk sites, and let r be the number of atoms at surface sites
, so p = b + s.
1. If B = S , what is the ratio b/s at all temperatures? Explain your reasoning.
In what follows, do not assume that B = S .
2. Find the number of ways W (J, b) that b atoms can be distributed over the J
bulk sites. Find the bulk entropy SB (J, b), the bulk energy EB (J, b), and the
bulk free energy FB (T, J, b).
3. Find the number of ways W (K, s) that s atoms can be distributed over the K
surface sites. Find the surface entropy SS (K, s), the surface energy ES (K, s)
and the surface free energy FS (T, K, s).
4. Minimize the total free energy FB (T, J, b) + FS (T, K, s) with respect to b at
fixed b + s = p. Find b/s for p  J, K. Note that, for large integer z, ln(n!) =
z ln(z) z.
5. Find b/s in the following limits: at high T ; at low T if S  B ; at low T if
S  B .
Problem 88. 1998-Spring-SM-U-3
ID:SM-U-1507
A set of N non-interacting molecules are fixed in space. Each has a permanent electric
dipole moment of magnitude p0 that is free to rotate in three dimensions. They are
~ = E0 z.
in a uniform electric field E
1. Find the thermal average, at temperature T , of their total electric dipole moment P~ .
2. Evaluate P~ at low T , and explain your result physically. Define low T in
terms of the parameters of the problem.
3. Evaluate P~ at high T .

Statistical Mechanics

QEID#60661227

April, 2014

Qualification Exam

QEID#60661227

38

~ along
4. At high T find the electric polarizability = P/E, taking P~ and E
z.
Problem 89. 1999-Fall-SM-U-1
ID:SM-U-1524
Find the entropy rise S of a monoatomic ideal gas of N molecules occupying the
volume V1 when it expands to a volume V2 under constant pressure.
Problem 90. 1999-Fall-SM-U-2
ID:SM-U-1529
1. Using the extensivity/intensivity properties of the thermodynamic quantities,
show that U = ST P V + N .
2. Using this result, prove the following thermodynamic identity:
 


1 n
1 V
=
,
n2 T
V P N,T
where V 1 (V /P )T,N is the isothermal compressibility and n = N/V is the
particle number density. Here P denotes the pressure, T the absolute temperature, and the chemical potential.
Problem 91. 1999-Fall-SM-U-3
ID:SM-U-1541
Consider a two-dimensional ideal neutron gas with areal umber density ( i.e., number
per unit area) n at temperature T and zero magnetic field. Each neutron has a mass
m.
1. Derive a closed-form expression for the chemical potential as a function of T
and n.
2. A magnetic field H is now applied to the system. Each neutron has a magnetic moment N whose direction is opposite to its spin. Derive a relation
which gives implicitly the function (T, n, H). Use this relation to show that
(/H)T,n|H=0 = 0.
3. Derive a closed-form expression for the zero-fold spin-susceptibility S (M/H)T,n|H=0
of the system as a function of T and n. Note, that the definition of S has n
kept constant and not , so you must properly use the result of the previous
part to do this part correctly.
Problem 92. 1999-Spring-SM-U-1
ID:SM-U-1556
You should express your answers for this problem in terms of any of the following
Temperature
Volume
Pressure
Heat capacity at constant volume
Isothermal Compressibility
Thermal Expansion
Statistical Mechanics

QEID#60661227

T
V
P
CV


T = V1 V
P

T
= V1 V
T P
April, 2014

Qualification Exam

QEID#60661227

39

1. Express the incremental heat Q absorbed by a gas if the pressure of the gas is
increased incrementally from P to P + P while maintaining a fixed volume.
2. For the same process, determine the incremental change in the enthalpy of the
gas, H where H = U + P V .
3. Evaluate your answers in for the first and the second parts for the case of an
ideal monoatomic gas.
Problem 93. 1999-Spring-SM-U-2
ID:SM-U-1590
It is given that the equation of state of a certain photon-like gas is given by
P = a(T ),
where P denotes pressure, a > 0 is a constant, and (T ) is the internal energy per
unit volume of the photon gas at temperature T .
1. Calculate the temperature dependence of the total internal energy U for the
whole gas using the equation




P
U
=T
P.
V T
T V
One unknown constant is allowed to appear in your answer, but no unknown
functions of either T or V or both are allowed to appear.
2. Calculate the entropy S of the system as a function of T and V .
[Hint: Start from the equation
1
1
dS = (dU + P dV ) =
T
T

U
T


V



 
1
U
dT +
P+
dV,
T
V T

evaluate (S/T )V , and (S/V )T , and then integrate them to obtain S. Use
the third law of thermodynamics to fix any unknown integration constant(s) of
this step.]
Problem 94. 1999-Spring-SM-U-3
ID:SM-U-1618
1
2
A molecule has energy E = 2 mv + j, where v is the velocity, is a constant with
the dimension of energy, and j is an internal quantum number which can take all
odd integer values (no degeneracy). It is in a cubic box of volume V with its walls
maintained at the absolute temperature T .
1. Calculate the average energy of the molecule as a function of T assuming that
it is in thermodynamic equilibrium with the walls of the box.
2. Calculate the free energy of the molecule as a function of T .
Statistical Mechanics

QEID#60661227

April, 2014

Qualification Exam

QEID#60661227

40

3. Calculate the entropy S of the molecule as a function of T .

Problem 95. 2000-Fall-SM-U-1
ID:SM-U-1632
In thermodynamics, all physical properties can be calculated once one of the thermodynamic potentials is known as a function of appropriate variables (e.g. U (S, V, N )).
Unfortunately, the thermodynamic potentials can not be directly measured but need
to be calculated from experimentally accessible quantities, such as the specific heat at
a constant volume cv = T (s/T )v , the isothermal compressibility T = v 1 (v/P )T
and the thermal expansion coefficient at constant pressure = v 1 (v/T )P , where
N is the particle number, P is the pressure, T is the temperature, s = S/N is the
specific entropy and v = V /N is the specific volume.
Given the following values for these quantities:
 1/2
4
2
4v0 P0 T v
=
,
T = ,
cv =
2
T0
v0
P
T
and that the pressure, specific volume and temperature are all known at a particular
reference state (i.e., P0 , v0 , and T0 ), determine
1. The specific volume as a function of T and P and the constants of the reference
state, P0 , v0 , and T0 .
2. The specific entropy as a function of T and P and the constants of the reference
state, P0 , v0 , and T0 . (You may assume that the third law of thermodynamics
is valid for this system, and use it to fix an integration constant.)
[Hint: First obtain S(T, v) and then convert it to S(T, P )].
3. The specific Gibbs free energy g as a function of T and P and the constants of
the reference state, P0 , v0 , T0 , and g0 .
Problem 96. 2000-Fall-SM-U-2
ID:SM-U-1654
The fundamental thermodynamic relation for a rubber band is
dU = T dS + dl
where U is the internal energy, T is the absolute temperature, S is the entropy, is
the tension and l is the length of the rubber band.
1. What is dH, where the generalized enthalpy for this system is H = U l.
2. Derive the Maxwell relation that is associated with the expression for dH. State
clearly what variable is held constant in each partial derivative.
3. Using the known fact that a rubber band contracts when it is heated at constant
tension, deduce from the Maxwell relation obtained in the previous part that a
rubber band warms when it is stretched adiabatically.

Statistical Mechanics

QEID#60661227

April, 2014

Qualification Exam

QEID#60661227

41

Problem 97. 2000-Fall-SM-U-3

ID:SM-U-1672
Consider a classical ideal monoatomic gas at temperature T in a uniform gravitational
field (i.e, an isothermal atmosphere). Assume that the gas atoms have mass, m, and
that their distribution overall all possible heights from z = 0 (the surface of the
earth) to z = is an equilibrium one. Denote the magnitude of the gravitational
acceleration by g and assume that it can be taken to be a constant for all values of z.
1. Find the probability density governing the fraction of atoms per unit height at
a height z.
2. Find the mean potential energy per atom.
3. Find the total internal energy and total heat capacity of the gas (i.e., the total
amount of heat energy required to increase the temperature of the entire gas
column by 1K).
Problem 98. 2000-Spring-SM-U-1
ID:SM-U-1686
The intersection of two Gibbs free energy surfaces is a line where G = G , along
which two phases and coexist. Let the phases and be the liquid phase and
the gas phase, respectively.
Along the liquid-gas coexistence line in the P T plane, show that, to a vary
good approximation,


 
1
Lvap 1
P

=
,
log
P0
R
Tb T
where P is the vapor pressure of the liquid present, P0 , is the atmospheric pressure
(1atm), R is the ideal gas constant, T is the absolute temperature, Tb is the boiling
point of the system (at atmospheric pressure), and Lvap , is the heat of vaporization
per mole (whose dependence on T and P may be neglected). You may assume that
the gas phase obeys the ideal gas law.
Problem 99. 2000-Spring-SM-U-2
ID:SM-U-1698
You are given two objects with the same total heat capacity, C0 which is temperature
independent. (These objects are finite and should not be treated as thermal reservoirs.) The two objects are initially at temperatures T1 and T2 (T1 > T2 ) respectively.
1. What type of heat engine would you operate between these two objects so that
the maximum total amount of useable work ts extracted?
2. Using this type of heat engine, determine the final temperatures of the two
objects.
3. Using this type of heat engine, determine the total amount of useable work
extracted.

Statistical Mechanics

QEID#60661227

April, 2014

Qualification Exam

QEID#60661227

42

Problem 100. 2000-Spring-SM-U-3

ID:SM-U-1712
According to the principles of quantum statistical mechanics, the pressure of blackbody radiation inside a volume V may be calculated by treating the radiation as a
photon gas, and using the relation
p =

1 log Z
,
V

where p is the mean pressure, Z the partition function, and = 1/kB T is kept
constant. You may assume that the volume V is a cubic box of edge length L = V 1/3 ,
with walls maintained at temperature T .
1. Express the partition function Z in terms of the energies s , of a set of independent photon states (i.e., normal modes) in the volume, and use it to show
that
X s
n
s,
p =
V
s
where ns is the mean population of the state s with energy s .
2. Using the above result, obtain an explicit relation between the mean pressure
) of the photon gas.
p and the mean energy density u (= E/V
Problem 101. 2001-Fall-SM-U-1
ID:SM-U-1732
Let
1 N3
N2
F = A T B 2 T 2 CN
V
2 V
describe the Helmholtz free energy of a system of N particles in a volume V at
temperature T , for a finite interval of temperature not including absolute zero. Here
A, B, and C are positive constants.
1. Find S, P , and in terms of N , V , and T , where S is the total entropy, P is
pressure, and is the chemical potential.
2. Find the energy U in terms of N , V , and S.
3. Find T in terms of N , V , and S, and verify that it is consistent with the results
of the first part.
4. Find the isothermal compressibility T = V 1 (V /P )T,N .
5. Find the total heat capacity CV .

Statistical Mechanics

QEID#60661227

April, 2014

Qualification Exam

QEID#60661227

43

Problem 102. 2001-Fall-SM-U-2

ID:SM-U-1754
It is given that
N (T, V, z) = V T 3 f1 (z)
and
U (T, V, z) = V T 4 f2 (z),
where N is the total particle number, U is the total internal energy, T is the absolute
temperature, V is the total volume of the system, and z e is the fugacity, with
1/kB T , and the chemical potential. Let CV (U/T )V,N denote the total
heat capacity of the system at constant volume, find CV in terms of T , V , f1 (z),
f2 (z), and the derivatives of f1 (z) and f2 (z).
Problem 103. 2001-Fall-SM-U-3
ID:SM-U-1769
Consider a system of N independent harmonic oscillators with the same frequency .
The system is at, temperature T .
1. Show that the partition function of the system is


N
~
.
QN = 2 sinh
2kB T
2. Using this result, obtain the internal energy U of the system as a function of T
and N .
3. Show that the heat capacity is
C = N kB

e~/kB T
(e~/kB T 1)


2

~
kB T

2

and it approaches to 0 as T 0.
4. Determine its Helmholtz free energy F .
5. Determine its entropy S.
Problem 104. 2001-Spring-SM-U-1
ID:SM-U-1794
An unknown substance ts experimentally found to satisfy the following equations of
state:
T (u, v) = au2/3 v 1/2
and
P (u, v) = buv 1 ,
where a and b are some constants, T and P are the substances temperature and
pressure as functions of its internal energy per particle, u, and volume per particle,
v, respectively.
1. Find the condition(s) under which the above two equations of state are consistent with each other, and then determine the entropy per particle of the
substance, s(u, v), to within an additive constant.
Statistical Mechanics

QEID#60661227

April, 2014

Qualification Exam

QEID#60661227

44

2. Fix the constant in your answer to the previous part by invoking some law in
thermodynamics.
Problem 105. 2001-Spring-SM-U-2
ID:SM-U-1811
A non-ideal gas has a fundamental relation given by
1 2 1/2 1/2
S V
N
,
2A
where U is the total internal energy, S is the total entropy V is the volume, N is the
number of molecules, and A is a constant.
U (S, V, N ) =

1. Determine the following equations of state

U (T, V, N )

and

P (T, V, N ).

2. Consider a rigid chamber of volume V0 which is subdivided by an impermeable

membrane into volumes V0 /3 and 2V0 /3. The chamber is isolated from the rest
of the universe so that no heat or work can be transferred between them. (You
may assume that the walls of the chamber have negligible heat capacity) A
number N0 of molecules of the gas of the previous part is placed in the smaller
section (volume V0 /3), and the larger section is evacuated. Initially, the gas
has internal energy U0 , temperature T0 and entropy S0 . Solve the following two
parts of this problem under these conditions.
(a) If the membrane separating the two sections is broken, so that the gas
can freely expand to fill the entire chamber, what is the final values of
the internal energy Uf , temperature Tf , and entropy Sf of the gas after
equilibrium has been reached? Express your answer in terms of U0 , T0 ,
and S0 .
(b) If the gas is then slowly compressed isothermally back to its original volume, how much work is done by the piston compressing the gas? Express
your answer in terms of U0 , T0 , and S0 .
Problem 106. 2001-Spring-SM-U-3
ID:SM-U-1836
1. A gas of N inert atoms (such as N e or Ar) is contained in a volume V which
may be taken as a cube of side L = V 1/3 with periodic boundary conditions.
The gas is in thermal equilibrium with the walls of the container which are
maintained at (absolute) temperature T . Calculate the number of atoms in
this gas with atomic kinetic energy larger than rkB T , where r is some positive rational number (such as 2.0). Your answer may contain a dimensionless,
unevaluated integral. You may neglect any interaction between the gas atoms,
and treat the gas with Boltzmann statistics.
2. Will your answer change if the gas is made of N diatomic molecules (such as
N2 or CO), if by kinetic energy we now mean the center-of-mass kinetic energy
of a molecule? Briefly justify your answer.
Statistical Mechanics

QEID#60661227

April, 2014

Qualification Exam

QEID#60661227

45

Problem 107. Quantum oscillator

ID:SM-U-1840
2
x2 in 1D at temperature
A quantum particle of charge q is in the potential V (x) = m
2
T.
a. Find the heat capacity of this system.
b. Find the electric dipole susceptibility of the system. (d = (F/E)V,N,T , =
(d/E)V,N,T , where E is the electric field.)
c. For the oscillator state n in the presence ofPelectric field E calculate xn =
hn |
x|n i, and then average displacement x = n xn wn .

Statistical Mechanics

QEID#60661227

April, 2014

Qualification Exam

QEID#60661227

46

Graduate level

Problem 108. 1983-Fall-SM-G-4.

a. Show that


ID:SM-G-3

S
P


= V,
T

where is the coefficient of thermal expansion.

b. Show that for an isothermal compression
dE = (T V + P V T )dP,
where T is the isothermal compressibility. To get the full credit for this problem
you must start with dE = T dS P dV .
Problem 109. 1983-Fall-SM-G-5
ID:SM-G-20
a. What is the average energy of a system at temperature T with two quantum states,
with an energy difference  separating the levels?
b. In a highly disordered solid it is believed that a large number of two-level tunneling systems are present with a distribution of energy differences. If the number
of these two level systems per unit volume of the solid with energy separations
between  and  + d, D(), is a constant, show that their contribution to the heat
capacity of the solid will be linear in temperature.
Problem 110. Distribution function. 1983-Fall-SM-G-6
ID:SM-G-27
A classical one dimensional particle, confined to the region y y0 is in a potential
V (y) = V0 log (y/y0 )
The statistical distribution is given by %(p, q) = AeE(p,q)/T , where A is a normalization parameter, T is a parameter which is called temperature, and E(p, q) is the
particles energy.
a. Find the normalization constant A. Determine the critical temperature Tc above
which the particle escapes to infinity (You need to figure out what it means.).
b. Write down the normalized positional distribution function f (y) (i.e. the probability per unit distance to find the particle between y and y + dy) for this particle
for T < Tc .
c. Find the average distance hyi for the particle. What happens if 0 < Tc /2 T 
Tc /2

Statistical Mechanics

QEID#60661227

April, 2014

Qualification Exam

QEID#60661227

47

Problem 111. 1983-Spring-SM-G-4

ID:SM-G-44
A thermodynamic system consists of N spatially separated noninteracting subsystems. Each subsystem has non-degenerate energy levels 0, , 2, and 3. The system
is in thermal equilibrium with a heat reservoir of absolute temperature T = /kB .
Calculate the partition function, the mean energy, and the entropy of the thermodynamic system.
Problem 112. 1983-Spring-SM-G-5.
ID:SM-G-48
At T = 0, all the N atoms in a crystal occupy a lattice site of a simple cubic lattice
with no vacancies. At higher temperature, it is possible for an atom to move from a
lattice site to an interstitial site in the center of a cube (the interstitial atom does not
have to end up close to vacancy). An atom needs energy  to make this transition.
a. Compute the number of different ways of making n vacancies (and correspondingly
fill n interstitial sites) in the lattice.
b. Calculate the entropy of a state with energy E = n.
c. Calculate the average hni in equilibrium at temperature T .
d. Calculate the free energy of the lattice at temperature T .
Problem 113. 1983-Spring-SM-G-6
ID:SM-G-58
24
A paramagnetic salt contains a total of 10 non-interacting magnetic ions, each with
a magnetic moment of 1 Bohr magneton (9.273 1024 Am2 ) which can be aligned
either parallel or anti-parallel to a magnetic field. A magnetic field of magnetic
induction 1T is applied at a temperature 3K.
a. Calculate the partition function.
b. Compute the magnetic energy.
c. Compute the heat capacity.
[Hint: You will be given more credit for this problem if you can also give numerical
values for the last two parts.]
Problem 114. 1983-Spring-SM-G-7.
ID:SM-G-68
a. Find the mean speed of the fermions in an ideal D-dimensional fermi gas at T = 0
(the dispersion is p = p2 /2m) in terms of vF Fermi velocity (velocity at F ).
b. Find the average kinetic energy of a fermion in terms of vF .

Statistical Mechanics

QEID#60661227

April, 2014

Qualification Exam

QEID#60661227

48

Problem 115. 1983-Spring-SM-G-8.

ID:SM-G-75
The single particles energy levels for a particular Hamiltonian are n = n. where
n = 1, 2, 3 . . . . For a system of three non-interacting identical particles in the
same spin state, find the energy and the degeneracy of the ground state and the
first four excited states if the particles are:
a. Bosons.
b. Fermions.
c. What is the energy and degeneracy of the ground state and the first four excited
states if the system consists of spin 1/2 particles which are not constrained to be
in the same spin state?
Problem 116. 1984-Fall-SM-G-4
ID:SM-G-84
Remembering that the free energy F will be minimized in a given phase, and that the
order parameter is defined to be zero above a phase transition, consider a system
whose free energy F depends on an order parameter according to
F (, T ) = F0 + a(T Tc )2 + b4 ,
where F0 , a, and b are all positive constants. Show that there is a phase transition
at a temperature Tc and deduce the temperature dependence of the order parameter.
Calculate the jump in the heat capacity at T = Tc .
[Hint: C = T ( 2 F/T 2 ).]
Problem 117. 1984-Fall-SM-G-5
ID:SM-G-93
A system consists of N weakly interacting particles each of which can be in either of
the two states with respective energies 1 and 2 , with 1 < 2 .
1. Make a qualitative plot of the mean energy  of the system as a function of
the temperature T . What is  in the limit of very low and very high temperatures? Roughly at what temperature does  changes from its low to its high
temperature value?
2. Using the result of the previous part make qualitative plot of the heat capacity
CV as a function of the temperature T .
3. Calculate explicitly an expression for the mean energy (T ) and heat capacity CV (T ) for this system. Verify that your expression exhibit the qualitative
features discussed in the previous parts.

Statistical Mechanics

QEID#60661227

April, 2014

Qualification Exam

QEID#60661227

49

Problem 118. 1984-Fall-SM-G-6

ID:SM-G-103
1. For a photon gas, show that the average number of photons in a particular
state, s, is given by
1
ns = s
,
e 1
where s is the energy of the state s, and = 1/kB T .
2. Calculate the density of modes i.e. the number of modes per unit volume
between and + d for a three dimensional photon gas.
3. Show that the average energy density u of the gas can be written as
u(, T )d =

h 3 d
2 c3 (eh 1)

4. Show that hmax /kB T 3, where max represents the peak in the energy
density functional.
5. Show that the energy density functional is proportional to T 4 .
[Hint: Change the energy h to a dimensionless variable.]
Problem 119. 1984-Fall-SM-G-7
ID:SM-G-123
Suppose we have some type of wavelike excitation in a solid which is characterized by
a free quasiparticle of spin 3. The total number of quasiparticles in the system is not
conserved. Furthermore, the excitation (quasiparticle) obeys the dispersion relation
= Ak 3 , where is the angular frequency of the excitation, k is its wave number,
and A is a constant of proportionality. If the solid has a volume V and is macroscopic
in size, then determine the temperature dependence of both the internal energy and
heat capacity in the limit of very low temperatures.
Problem 120. 1984-Spring-SM-G-4.
ID:SM-G-128
There are three quantum states of energies 0, , and 2. Consider a system of two
indistinguishable non-interacting particles which can occupy these states. The system
is coupled with the heat bath at temperature T .
a. Calculate the free energy of the system in case the particles are Bosons.
b. Calculate the free energy of the system in case the particles are Fermions.
c. What is the ration of occupation probability of the highest energy state of the
system to the lowest energy state in each of these cases?

Statistical Mechanics

QEID#60661227

April, 2014

Qualification Exam

QEID#60661227

50

Problem 121. 1984-Spring-SM-G-5

ID:SM-G-138
A sample of water is placed in an external magnetic field B. Each proton has a spin
1/2 and a magnetic moment . An applied radio-frequency field can induce transitions
between the magnetic (Zeeman) energy levels, (How many possible energy levels per
proton are there?), if the frequency satisfies the Larmor condition h = 2B. The
power absorbed from the radiation field is then proportional to the difference in the
number of protons in the energy levels. Assume that the protons in the water are in
thermal equilibrium at temperature T such that B  kB T .
1. Give an expression for the partition function.
2. How does the absorbed power depend on the temperature of the water?
Problem 122. 1984-Spring-SM-G-6
ID:SM-G-148
If D() is a density of states function, find an expression for the heat capacity of a
fermion gas at kB T  0F , even if D() is a complicated function of energy .
[Hint: The expression for the heat capacity should contain D(), T , and some
constants. 0F is the chemical potential at absolute zero. You may need the integral
Z
2
x2 ex
dx
=
.
x
2
3
(e + 1)
]
Problem 123. 1985-Fall-SM-G-4
ID:SM-G-157
In one-dimension, a mass m is attached to a spring of spring constant k. The system
is in thermal equilibrium at a temperature T .
1. Assuming the classical statistics hold, what is the rms displacement of the
mass from equilibrium, if T = 70o F , m = 2g, and k = 50g/s2 ? Take kB
1.4 1016 cgs. and ~ 1027 cgs.
2. Treating this system using quantum statistics, where the energy of the system
is E = ~(n + 1/2) for n = 0, 1, . . . , and there is only one state at each energy,
calculate the partition function of this system. ( is the oscillation frequency
of the mass on the spring.)
3. What is the average energy E of the system? Does this come close to the
classical value for the system in the first part?
4. From the previous part, find the average occupation number n
. Must n
be large
or small for E to be close to its classical value?
5. Give an approximate criterion for the validity of the classical result.

Statistical Mechanics

QEID#60661227

April, 2014

Qualification Exam

QEID#60661227

51

Problem 124. 1985-Fall-SM-G-5

ID:SM-G-169
A 3D harmonic oscillator has mass m and the same spring constant k for all three
directions. Thus, its quantum-mechanical energy levels are given by
E = ~(n1 + n2 + n3 + 3/2)
Neglect the zero point energy in what follows.
1. What are the energy E0 and degeneracy g0 of the ground sate? Of the first
excited state? Of the second excited state?
2. What is the partition function for this system if only the lowest two (ground
and the first exited) energy levels are important? When this approximation
valid?
3. What is the free energy in this case?
4. What is the entropy in this case?
2 )1/2 in the energy in this case?
5. What is the rms fluctuation E (E 2 (E)
Problem 125. 1985-Fall-SM-G-6
ID:SM-G-185
Consider a large number N of identical non-interacting particles, each of which can be
in only one of two states, with energies 0 and 1 . Denote by n0 and n1 the occupation
numbers of each of these states.
1. Find the total energy E as a function of n0 .
2. Find the number of states N available to the system, as a function of n0 .
3. Find S, the entropy, as a function of E.
4. Find the temperature T as a function of E.
5. Using E0 = N 0 and  = (1 0 ), show that
E = E0 +

N 
1 + exp[/kB T ]

[Hint: log n! n log n n, for large n.]

Problem 126. 1985-Spring-SM-G-4
ID:SM-G-202
1. Find the Fermi energy at T = 0, f , of a gas of N non-interacting spin one-half
particles constrained to move in two dimensions.
2. Recall that the surface tension, , in two dimensions is analogous to pressure
in three dimensions so that the surface tension contribution from a particle in
a state n is given by n /A. Shaw that the surface tension at T = 0 is given
by N f /2A, where A is the area that the particles occupy.
Statistical Mechanics

QEID#60661227

April, 2014

Qualification Exam

QEID#60661227

52

Problem 127. 1985-Spring-SM-G-5

ID:SM-G-210
1. Show that for an ideal gas, for a quasistatic adiabatic process
dP
P
= ,
dV
V
where = CP /CV .
2. Write down the expression for the work done by one mole of a monoatomic ideal
gas during an adiabatic expansion from a state (P1 , V1 ) to a state with volume
V2 .
3. The molar energy of a monoatomic gas which obeys van der Waals equation of
state is given by
a
3
E = RT ,
2
V
where V is the molar volume at a temperature T and a is a constant of the gas.
If initially, one mole of the gas is at the temperature T1 and occupies volume
V1 , and the gas is allowed to expand irreversibly into a vacuum in an isolated
container, so that it occupies a total volume V2 , what is the final temperature
T2 of the gas?
4. Calculate the change of the temperature in this process for the ideal gas. Give
the reason for your answer explaining concisely the origin of the differences (In
one short(!!!!) sentence.).
Problem 128. 1985-Spring-SM-G-6.
ID:SM-G-228
For a vapor in equilibrium with its solid phase, find the relation between the pressure
P and the temperature T , if the molar latent heat q is constant. The vapor is close
to the ideal gas, and the molar volume of the gas is much larger than that of solid.
Problem 129. 1985-Spring-SM-G-7.
ID:SM-G-232
A thermally isolated container is divided by a partition into two compartments, the
right hand compartment having a volume b times larger than the left one. The left
compartment contains moles of an ideal gas at temperature T , and pressure P .
The right compartment also contains moles of an ideal gas at temperature T . The
partition is now removed. Calculate:
a. The final pressure
b. The total change in the entropy if the gases are different.
c. The total change in the entropy if the gases are the same.
d. What is the total change in the entropy if the gases are the same and b = 1? Can
you explain the result?

Statistical Mechanics

QEID#60661227

April, 2014

Qualification Exam

QEID#60661227

53

Problem 130. 1986-Spring-SM-G-4

ID:SM-G-242
N Classical particles are constrained to move on a frictionless flat surface of area A.
1. What is the partition function for the system at the temperature T , assuming
that the particles are distinguishable?
2. Same as above, if the particles are indistinguishable.
3. For indistinguishable particles, compute the free energy F .
4. For indistinguishable particles, compute the entropy S.
5. Verify that, if N 2N and A 2A, then S 2S. What role indistinguishability have to play in this result?
6. Let represent the two-dimensional pressure, or surface tension, of this system.
Find as a function of N , T , and A.
Problem 131. 1986-Spring-SM-G-5
ID:SM-G-256
Consider a system of N  1 noninteracting bosons of spin zero, with quantum states
at the single particle energies 0 and . The thermal average population of the lowest
state is twice the population of the state with energy . Find approximate values of
the chemical potential and the temperature T .
Problem 132. 1986-Spring-SM-G-6
ID:SM-G-260
A model for a vacancy formation in an otherwise perfect crystal is as follows. An
energy Es is required to produce a vacancy by taking an atom from the interior and
putting it on the surface. Let the number of lattice sites in the bulk N greatly exceed
the number of vacancies n, and let n  1.
1. In how many ways can one take n atoms from the interior? Treat the atoms as
indistinguishable.
2. What is the entropy S associated with this?
3. What is the energy of the system, assuming that E = 0 in the absence of
vacancies?
4. For a given temperature T , what is the thermal average value of n?
Problem 133. 1987-Fall-SM-G-5.
ID:SM-G-290
Write down the partition function for an ideal gas of N monoatomic molecules in a
volume V in a classical limit where you have treated the particles as distinguishable.
What is the partition function in the classical limit if the particles are indistinguishable? Use both partition functions to calculate the entropy of the ideal gas in each
case. Why is the result for the distinguishable particles physically unacceptable?

Statistical Mechanics

QEID#60661227

April, 2014

Qualification Exam

QEID#60661227

54

Problem 134. 1987-Fall-SM-G-6

ID:SM-G-294
1. Consider a particle which can take one of only two energy levels (E = 0 or E =

). Find and sketch as a function of T the average energy E(N,

T ) and the heat
capacity CV (N, T ) for a system of N particle. The particles are distinguishable.
2. Suppose that the value of the excited state energy  varies for different particles
in a system of N particles. Furthermore, assume that the number of particles
with a particular value of the excited state energy between  and  + d is n()d
and suppose that n() is a constant for all energies between 0 and 0 , and that
there is no states with  > 0 , i.e.

n0 , for 0 <  0
n() =
0, for  > 0
R
and N = 0 n()d = n0 0 . Find the temperature dependence of the specific
heat of these N particles at low temperature, T  0 /kB .
Problem 135. 1987-Fall-SM-G-7
ID:SM-G-309
Consider a system of N noninteracting particles in a volume V at an absolute temperature T . The single particle energy states are described by i = ~2 ki2 /2m. For
convenience, assume that the ki are determined by periodic boundary conditions.
1. Show that the mean pressure P of the system is given quite generally in terms
of the average kinetic energy E by
2E
.
P =
3V
independent of whether the particles obey classical, Fermi-Dirac, or Bose-Einstein
statistics.
2. Show that the dispersion in pressure of this system, (P )2 = (P P )2 , is given
by


2kB T 2 P
2
(P ) =
.
3V
T N,V
Problem 136. 1988-Fall-SM-G-4
ID:SM-G-325
Consider N identical and independent particles of spin 1/2 in a magnetic field so that
the energy of each particle is either + or  depending upon the orientation of the
spin: down or up respectively. The probability of the energy  is p and of + is
q = 1 p.
1. Find the probability that N1 spins are up and N2 are down, with N1 + N2 = N .
2. From this probability find the average or expected value of the energy in terms
of p, , and N .
Statistical Mechanics

QEID#60661227

April, 2014

Qualification Exam

QEID#60661227

55

3. By considering that N1 and N2 are continuous rather than discrete variables,

find the most likely (i.e., maximal probability) for the values N1 and N2 using
the approximation that log(x!) x log(x) x.
4. Write down a partition function for this system at a temperature T .
5. Find the free energy, the entropy, and the total energy from this partition
function. For what value of p will your result in the second part agree with
your result for the total energy in this part?
Problem 137. 1989-Fall-SM-G-4
ID:SM-G-340
Consider a classical system of N weakly interacting particles. Each isolated particle
can be in n states. Assume the ground state degeneracy of the system is aN , where
1 a < n. The excited energy levels are on the average evenly distributed around
a characteristic energy E1 . there are no phase changes in the phase diagram for the
system.
1. Sketch entropy per particle (N ) as function of temperature in the entire
temperature range. Write and denote on the graph the values of entropies and
of characteristic temperature you can determine from the given information.
2. Sketch the specific heat CV as function of temperature using CV /T and T as
coordinate axes. What is the total area under the curve?
3. Answer the first part now assuming that the levels are not all evenly distributed,
but rather m out of n states have characteristic energy E2 at least an order of
magnitude larger than the characteristic energy E1 of the remaining states.
Problem 138. 1989-Fall-SM-G-5
ID:SM-G-349
An incompressible fluid of density f is confined to a very long (infinite) cylinder
of cross section A with which it rotates at a constant angular velocity around
a perpendicular axis through the middle-point of the cylinder. Small number of
microscopic spheres each of volume v and density s < f are immersed in the rotating
fluid at temperature T. Neglect any interaction between the spheres, find the average
distance of a sphere from the rotation axis.

Statistical Mechanics

QEID#60661227

April, 2014

Qualification Exam

QEID#60661227

56

Problem 139. 1989-Spring-SM-G-4

ID:SM-G-356
A certain solid material has an isothermal compressibility


1 V
T =
V P T
Prove that adiabatic volume and pressure changes are related by
CV
dV
= T
dP,
V
CP
where CV and CP are the specific heats of the material at constant volume and
pressure respectively.
Problem 140. 1989-Spring-SM-G-5
ID:SM-G-369
Consider a monoatomic van der Waals gas whose equation of state is
P =

a
RT
+
.
V2 V b

If this gas undergoes free expansion,

1. What is the change in temperature in terms of the initial volume V1 and final
volume V2 ?
2. Determine the change in entropy.
[Hint: CV for a monoatomic van der Waals gas is a temperature and volume independent constant.]

Statistical Mechanics

QEID#60661227

April, 2014

Qualification Exam

QEID#60661227

57

Problem 141. 1990-Fall-SM-G-4

ID:SM-G-382
Let ~k = ~(|kx | + |ky | + |kz |) be the energy-momentum relation of a conducting
electrons in a certain (fictitious) metal, where is a constant with the dimensions of
velocity, and |x| denotes the absolute value of x.
1. Draw a picture of a typical constant-energy surface ~k = , for the above ~k .
2. Express the Fermi energy F as a function of the electron density n for this
metal. (Note, that electrons have spin 1/2.)
3. Calculate the electronic density of states (per unit volume) as a function of 
for this metal. Denote it as D(E).
4. Calculate the total energy of N electrons at T = 0 in this metal. Express E0 /N
in terms of F .
5. Now let the temperature T be finite. Express N and the total energy E as functions of T and the chemical potential . The expressions can involve integrals
which you do not have to evaluate.
Problem 142. 1990-Fall-SM-G-5
ID:SM-G-397
Show that the van der Waals equation of state can be derived from a mean field
theory: Assume that the potential felt by each particle in a gas is

, for r < r0
,
u(r) =

u, otherwise
where
u = cN/V.
Here N/V is the number of particles per unit volume, and c is a constant. (First
evaluate the classical partition function Z, and then use it to find pressure P .) Give
physical interpretation of your finite answer (the van der Waals equation), and show
that it reduces to the correct result when u(r) = 0.
Problem 143. 1990-Spring-SM-G-4
ID:SM-G-415
A system of ideal Boltzmann gas containing N monoatomic molecules (of mass
m each) is trapped in a three-dimensional harmonic potential well V (x, y, z) =
1
K (x2 + y 2 + z 2 ), so it will form a spherical cloud whose room-mean-square radius
2
1/2
rrms (hx2 + y 2 + z 2 i) will be the function of temperature. Calculate:
1. The (quantum) canonical partition function, (which no longer has volume V as
an independent variable due to the trapping potential).
2. The free energy F (N, T );
3. The total entropy of the cloud S(N, T );

Statistical Mechanics

QEID#60661227

April, 2014

Qualification Exam

QEID#60661227

58

4. Take the high-temperature approximation of S(N, T ) to the leading order in

some small parameter, and use it to obtain the specific heat C(N, T ) in this
limit to the same order. (Note: the specific heat is not of constant volume,
nor of constant pressure, but of constant K, the force constant, and, of course,
constant N .)
5. Interpret your result from the previous part in light of the equipartition theorem.
6. Given that hn|x2 |yi = (n + 1/2)~0 /K for a quantum mechanical harmonic
oscillator of mass m and force constant K, calculate rrms , and hence the mean
r3 , of the above cloud as a function of N and T . What is the
volume V 4
3 rms
smallest V at any temperature, and what is the behavior of V with respect to
T in the high-temperature limit?
Problem 144. 1990-Spring-SM-G-5
ID:SM-G-429
Show that in two dimensions, the heat capacity CV at low temperatures is the same
for fermions and bosons.
[Hint:
Z 2 x
Z 2 x
x e dx
x e dx
2
=
=
x
2
(ex 1)2
3
0
(e + 1)
]
Problem 145. 1991-Fall-SM-G-4
ID:SM-G-441
A system has only two energy levels. The lower energy level with energy E = E0 is
non-degenerate, and the higher energy level with energy +2E0 is three-fold degenerate.
1. Assuming that the system is in thermodynamic equilibrium with its surroundings which are maintained at an absolute temperature T , what are the probabilities that the system is found in each of the two energy levels?
2. If the volume of this system is V0 when it is in the lower energy state, but it
increases to 1.2V0 when it is in the higher energy state, calculate the mean volume hV i of this system as a function of temperature, and its thermal expansion
coefficient as a function of temperature.
3. What is expected limiting value of as T ? What about hV i itself? Use
these limiting behaviors to check your results of the previous part.
Problem 146. 1991-Fall-SM-G-5
ID:SM-G-452
A system contains two different types of excitations whose numbers are not conserved.
One type consists of bosons such that the number of excitation modes with energy
between  and  + d is
V 2
d.
2 2 c3
Statistical Mechanics

QEID#60661227

April, 2014

Qualification Exam

QEID#60661227

59

The other consists of fermions such that the number of excitation modes with energy
between  and  + d is

0
for  < 0
2V
d
for
 > 0
3 2 b
V is the volume of the system and b and c are constants.
1. Calculate the average energy of the system as a function of temperature T .
2. Calculate the specific heat per unit volume of the system as a function of temperature.
[Hint: One of the integrals can only be done after a series expansion, using
Z

X
1
1
1
n+1 nx
xeax dx = x0 eax0 + 2 eax0 .
=
(1) e ,
x
e + 1 n=1
a
a
x0
Also you might need some of the following definite integrals:
Z
Z 2
Z 3
2
4
xdx
x dx
x dx
=
,
=
2(3),
=
,
ex 1
6
ex 1
ex 1
15
0
0
0

Z
0

x4 dx
= 24(5)
ex 1

where (x) is the Riemann zeta function. ]

Problem 147. 1991-Spring-SM-G-4
ID:SM-G-487
Consider a system of N non-interacting nuclei with a spin quantum number I. Find an
expression for the magnetization M and the entropy S of these nuclei at a temperature
T in a magnetic field B. Express your answer in terms of g, the Laude g-factor for
this nucleus, and B , the Bohr magneton. Indicate the high temperature and low
temperature limits for M and S. How could the nuclear magnetic moments be used
to cool the material?
[Hint: Useful relations:
1 + x + x2 + + xn = (1 xn+1 )/(1 x),
sinh x (ex ex )/2,
d sinh x
= cosh x (ex + ex )/2.
dx
]
Problem 148. 1991-Spring-SM-G-5
ID:SM-G-505
Consider N spin-1/2 (fermionic) atoms of a monoatomic gas that might be physically
adsorbed on a homogeneous surface of area A. Assume that the atoms are noninteracting and that the energy of a single such atom would be described quantum
mechanically by
 = (p2x + p2y )/2m 0 ,
where 0 is the binding energy of the atom to the surface and is same for all of the
atoms.
Statistical Mechanics

QEID#60661227

April, 2014

Qualification Exam

QEID#60661227

60

1. Calculate the T = 0 value of the chemical potential for these atoms as a

function of the area density N/A, binding energy 0 , and mass m.
2. At temperatures very close to T = 0 (i.e., so that you can ignore any temperature dependence of the quantities you might calculate for the adsorbed
fermions,) find the areal coverage N/A of adsorbed atoms as a function of the
density N 0 /V 0 and temperature T of a dilute (three-dimensional) gas of
the same atoms that is in thermal equilibrium with the adsorbed gas. Assume
that the dilute gas can be treated classically at the given temperature with the
partition function

3N 0 /2
0
m
1
0 N
(2V
)
Z= 0
N ! 2~2
and 1/kB T .
Problem 149. 1992-Fall-SM-G-4.
ID:SM-G-524
Consider an ideal classical gas of rigid dipolar molecules in an electric field E. The
dipole moment of each molecule is . Calculate the linear dielectric constant  of the
gas as a function of temperature T and density = N/V .
Problem 150. 1992-Fall-SM-G-5
ID:SM-G-528
In experiments on the absorption spectrum of gases at finite temperature, atoms
are always moving either towards or away from the light source with distribution of
velocities vx . As a consequences the frequency of the photon seen by an electron in a
Bohr atom is Doppler shifted to a value D according to the classical formula
D = 0 (1 + vx /c).
1. Write down the normalized Maxwell distribution for vx .
2. Determine the distribution function g(D ) for the fraction of gas atoms that
will absorb light at frequency D .
3. Determine the fractional linewidth


0 rms

s


(D 0 )2
.
02

4. Estimate the fractional linewidth for a gas of hydrogen (M 938M eV /c2 ,

1eV /kB 11600K) atoms at room temperature.

Statistical Mechanics

QEID#60661227

April, 2014

Qualification Exam

QEID#60661227

61

Problem 151. 1992-Spring-SM-G-4

ID:SM-G-547
A system obeys the van der Waals equation of state,
P =

RT
a
2,
vb v

where P is pressure, v is the molar volume, T is the absolute temperature, and R, a,

and b are all constants. The molar heat capacity at constant volume cV is given as a
constant independent of P , T , and v.
1. One mole of this system is expanded isothermally at temperature T from an
initial volume vi to a final volume vf . Find heat transfer to the system in this
process.
2. One mole of this system is expanded from an initial volume vi to a final volume
vf in a process that conserves the enthalpy H = U +P V . Such a process is often
referred to a Joule-Thomson expansion, or a throttling process. Determine
the change in the temperature T if the change in the volume is small vf vi  vf .
Problem 152. 1992-Spring-SM-G-5

ID:SM-G-561

The He3 melting curve (solid-liquid coexistence curve) is shown above, left.. The
general shape of the melting curve is well understood in term of the physical properties
of solid and liquid He3 and the Clausius-Clapeyron equation
dP
s
=
,
dT
v
where s and v are the molar entropy and molar volume differences between the
two phases.
At low temperatures the molar volumes of the solid and liquid do not vary substantially along the coexistence curve such that below 40mK vl vs is essentially a
constant at 1.3cm3 /mole.
The thermal properties of the solid can be modeled by a system of N independent
2-level systems with the energy gap of 1mK, where N corresponds to the number of
He3 atoms.
Statistical Mechanics

QEID#60661227

April, 2014

Qualification Exam

QEID#60661227

62

The thermal properties of the liquid at low temperatures are well described by a
degenerate Fermi gas. In particular, the heat capacity of the liquid at temperatures
below 40mK is known to be linear in temperature, i.e. cv T .
You are given that the slope of the melting curve at P0 = 33.66 bar and T0 =
20mK is
dP/dT = 38.43bar/K
1. Estimate the molar entropy of the solid ss at P0 and T0 .
2. Using your result and the Clausius-Clapeyron equation, estimate the molar
entropy sl of the liquid at P0 and T0 .
3. Draw entropy as a function of the temperature along the P0 isobar from T = 0K
to T = 0.1K. Important features in your graph should be labeled with the
numerical values. Please use the graph provided.
Problem 153. 1993-Fall-SM-G-4
ID:SM-G-594
The energy-momentum dispersion relation for electrons in the extreme relativistic
limit (  m0 c2 ) is well approximated by
 = pc.
Assuming this relation is valid at all energies of interest, find:
1. The Fermi energy F at absolute zero in terms of the gas density, n = N/V .
2. The average energy per electron in the ground state of the gas at T = 0 as a
function of F .
3. Derive the equation of state for an electron gas in the extreme relativistic limit
which is valid at any temperature when the dispersion relation given above
applies.
Problem 154. 1993-Fall-SM-G-5
ID:SM-G-608
A gas consists of two molecular types, A and B, which are intermixed in a volume V
at a constant temperature T . This is a non-ideal gas, but each molecular type acts
as an independent indistinguishable particle system so that the energy for each type
A molecule is given by
p2
A =
+ nA
2mA
and for each type B molecule as
B =

p2
+ nB + 0 .
2mB

Here is a constant and 0 is a constant energy for a B-type molecule. The number
densities of molecules A and B are nA = NA /V , and nB = NB /V respectively.
Statistical Mechanics

QEID#60661227

April, 2014

Qualification Exam

QEID#60661227

63

1. Determine the N -particle classical canonical partition function for this mixed
gas. Since the partition function is to be determined classically, you can assume
that there is only one state per volume of the phase space h3 for each of the
two types of molecules.
2. Determine the Helmholtz free energy of this gas form the partition function.
3. Now, allow A and B type molecules to interconvert by simple reaction A  B
(e.g. B might be excited state of A and vice verse). Also assume A and B
have equal masses. Given that A and B are in equilibrium (at fixed V , T , and
total number of molecules, N = NA + NB ), determine the equilibrium ratio,
R = NA /NB .
[Hint: Stirlings approximation, ln N ! = N ln N N . ]
Problem 155. 1993-Spring-SM-G-1

ID:SM-G-628

A particular ideal gas is characterized by the following equations of state:

P V = N kB T

and

U = cN kB T,

where c is a constant. The gas is used as a medium in a heat engine/refrigerator

whose cycle an be represented on a P V diagram as shown in the figure.
1. Determine the change in the internal energy of the gas for one complete cycle
(A B C D A).
2. Determine the equation of the adiabats.
3. Determine the thermodynamic efficiency of the above heat engine. Express your
answer in terms of c, P1 , and P2 .

Statistical Mechanics

QEID#60661227

April, 2014

Qualification Exam

QEID#60661227

64

Problem 156. 1993-Spring-SM-G-2

ID:SM-G-646
3
Consider a monolayer He (spin= 1/2) film of a large area A, and assume that it
behaves like a two-dimensional ideal gas.
1. Determine the Fermi energy (T = 0) as a function of the coverage density
= N/A.
2. Determine the chemical potential (T 6= 0) as a function of the coverage density
= N/A.
3. Determine how the heat capacity scales with temperature as T 0 using the
fact that the derivative of the Fermi function is sharply peaked around F in
this limit.
Problem 157. 1993-Spring-SM-G-3
ID:SM-G-656
4
Consider a non interacting gas of He (spin= 0) confined to a film (i.e., confined in z
direction, but infinite in the x and y directions). Because of the confinement, the pz
component of the momentum is quantized into discrete levels, n = 0, 1, . . . , so that
the energy spectrum is
p2
+ n ,
n (p) =
2m
where p is the two-dimensional (px , py ) momentum, and 0 = 0 < 1 < . . . n < . . . .
a. Write down the density of states for the system.
b. Write down the expression which determines the density of He4 atoms n as a
function of a chemical potential and temperature T . Evaluate integrals explicitly.
c. As T 0, i.e. T  1 find the limiting value of and how the specific heat
depends on T in this limit.
d. Determine (N, V, T ) in the limit ||  T (classical limit) assuming n = n.
Problem 158. 1994-Fall-SM-G-1

Statistical Mechanics

ID:SM-G-670

QEID#60661227

April, 2014

Qualification Exam

QEID#60661227

65

A two dimensional fictitious polymer is constructed as follows: It consists of N

identical monomers of length a each, joined into a chain. (See figure.) Starting from
the left end of the polymer, which corresponds to the coordinates x = 0, y = 0,
each new monomer added prefers to extend the polymer to the right (i.e., to the
+x direction) with energy  = 0, or upward (i.e., to the +y direction), with energy
 = J > 0. It is given that no monomer added will extend the polymer to the left or
downward.
1. A macro state of this polymer is characterized by N and m, where m denotes
the number of monomers which extend the polymer upward. Find the entropy
of this macro state as a function of N and m. Assume that both N and m are
 1, and use Stirlings formula ln N ! N (ln N 1) to simplify your result.
2. Write down the free energy of this macro-state of the polymer, as a function
of N , m, and the temperature T .
3. From minimizing this free energy, calculate the equilibrium value of m as a
function of N and T .
4. Calculate the equilibrium value of the free energy as a function of N and T , and
from which, calculate the specific heat of this polymer as a function of N and
T . (Note: Simplify your expression for the free energy to something quite simple
before calculating specific heat! Make sure your result has the right dimension,
or else you get no credit for this point.)
5. Show that in the limit kB T  J, the specific heat of this polymer is inversely
proportional to T 2 , and obtain the coefficient of proportionality.
Problem 159. 1994-Fall-SM-G-2
ID:SM-G-684
1. Explain why a three dimensional ideal Bose gas exhibit Bose-Einstein condensation at finite temperature, and yet in two or one dimension, an ideal Bose gas
cannot undergo a Bose-Einstein condensation at any finite temperature. (Or, to
put it in another way, they can only undergo the transition at T = 0, which is of
course, meaningless, since the absolute zero temperature can never be reached.)
2. Show that in two-dimensions, the relation between the chemical potential ,
the total number of particles N , and the absolute temperature T , of an ideal
gas, can be evaluated in close form (i.e., with the momentum or energy integral
doable in close form).
Problem 160. 1994-Spring-SM-G-4
ID:SM-G-693
Consider a system of fixed volume V in thermal equilibrium with a reservoir at temperature T .
1. Evaluate the mean-squared fluctuations in the systems energy
h(E)2 i = h(E hEi)2 i
in terms of its partition function Z(T, V ).
Statistical Mechanics

QEID#60661227

April, 2014

Qualification Exam

QEID#60661227

66

2. Show that these mean-squared fluctuations may be expressed in terms of the

systems heat capacity as
h(E)2 i = kB T 2 CV .
3. How does the ration of the RMS fluctuation to the mean energy depend on the
number of particles if the system is a classical ideal gas?
4. By expanding S(E, V ) in a Taylor series around the mean energy hEi, find the
expression for the mean-squared entropy fluctuation h(S)2 i in terms of the
heat capacity CV and the Boltzmann constant kB .
Problem 161. 1994-Spring-SM-G-5
ID:SM-G-710
1. Find an expression for the chemical potential g of an ideal gas as function of
P and T .
2. Consider an absorbent surface having N sites, each of which can adsorb one gas
molecule. This surface is in contact with an ideal gas with chemical potential
g (determined by the pressure P and temperature T ). Assuming that the
absorbed molecule has energy 0 compared to one in a free state, find the gran
partition function (sometimes called the grand canonical sum) that describes
the absorbing surface in terms of T , N , 0 , and a , the chemical potential of
the absorbed molecules.
3. Calculate the covering ration R(P, T ), i.e., the ration of the absorbed molecules
to the total number N of absorbing sites on the surface.
[Hint: What is the relation between the chemical potential of the molecules in
the gas g and these absorbed a ?
A useful expression:
N

(1 + x) =

N
X
n=0

N!
xn .
n!(N n)!

]
Problem 162. 1995-Fall-SM-G-1
ID:SM-G-726
Consider a system of n classical noninteracting identical homonuclear diatomic molecules
enclosed in a box of volume V , and held at temperature T . The Hamiltonian of a
single molecule is taken to be:
H(~p1 , p~2 , ~r1 , ~r2 ) =

1
1
p~21 + p~22 + |~r1 ~r2 |2 ,
2m
2

where p~1 , p~2 , and ~r1 , ~r2 are the momenta and positions, respectively, for the two
indistinguishable atoms comprising a molecule, and is an effective spring constant.
Determine the following:
Statistical Mechanics

QEID#60661227

April, 2014

Qualification Exam

QEID#60661227

67

1. The classical partition function for a single

molecule. Express your answer in
terms of the thermal wavelength, th = h/ 2mkB T .
p
R
[Hint: 0 dx exp (ax2 ) = /4a]
2. The mean square molecule diameter h|~r1 ~r2 |2 i.
3. The Helmholtz free energy for N molecule system.
Problem 163. 1995-Fall-SM-G-2
ID:SM-G-742
n
2
There are approximately (N M ) /(n!) ways of removing n atoms from a crystal
lattice with N sites and distribute them over M interstitial sites to obtain n Frenkel
defects. The energy of an atom at an interstitial site is + relative to the energy at
the lattice site, taken as zero.
1. Obtain an expression for the (Boltzmann) entropy SB (E) of the system in the
microcanonical ensemble.
2. Calculate the temperature T as a function of E, and find the most probable
excitation energy E and defect number n as a function of T .
[Hint: You may need to use: ln(n!) n ln(n) n.]
Problem 164. 1995-Fall-SM-G-3
ID:SM-G-753
Consider a system of noninteracting electrons constrained to have following density
of states:
() = constant D,  0;
() = 0,
<0
where  is the one particle energy, and () is the density of states for either spin.
1. Calculate the Fermi energy F at temperature T = 0, in terms of D and the
number of electrons, N .
2. Find U0 , the total energy of this electron system at T = 0.
3. Calculate the chemical potential at arbitrary temperature T , assuming N and
D are fixed. Find an expression in terms of D, N , and T (an exact solution,
rather than an expansion). Show also that your expression reduces to the result
of the first part in the limit T 0.
4. Find CV , the heat capacity at constant volume, in the small-T limit (kT 
N/D) and show that CV is proportional to T in this regime. Assume that
constant volume means D does not change.
[Hint: solve first for U U0 in this limit.]

Statistical Mechanics

QEID#60661227

April, 2014

Qualification Exam

QEID#60661227

68

Problem 165. 1995-Spring-SM-G-1

ID:SM-G-772
The gas of N identical particles is in a volume V at temperature T . The particles
interact weakly through two-body potentials
2 /a2

Uij = De(~ri ~rj )

where D and a are constants, and ~ri s are particles coordinates. Determine the leading
correction in D to the (Helmholtz) Free energy F of the system at high temperatures,
and the resulting change in the pressure of the gas.
Problem 166. 1995-Spring-SM-G-2
ID:SM-G-780
Consider a chemical reaction AB A + B. Treating the system as a multicomponent ideal gas, show that
nAB
V zAB
=
,
nA nB
zA zB
where nAB , nA , nB are the concentrations (number of molecules per volume) for each
molecule respectively, ZAB , ZA , ZB are the
P partition functions per molecule and V is
the volume. Note, that for equilibrium, i i dNi = 0 where the i are the chemical
potentials of the various species and the Ni are their numbers.
Problem 167. 1995-Spring-SM-G-3
ID:SM-G-789
1. Sketch the temperature dependence of the chemical potential (at fixed N and
V ) i the whole temperature range from T = 0 to T = , fro a three dimensional
non-relativistic ideal Fermi gas (spin 12 ), and a three-dimensional ideal Bose gas
(spin 0).
2. Derive, using statistical mechanics, a formula describing the high temperature
limiting behavior of each of these two curves (to leading order in the expansion
only); the independent variables should be T , N , and V , and no unknown
constants should appear in your result.
3. Find the zero temperature (T = 0) limiting values of these two curves as function of N and V , and state the qualitative initial T -dependence of these two
curves as T is increased from zero.
[Hint:
Z

ex dx =

ln N ! N (ln N 1),

for N  1.

Statistical Mechanics

QEID#60661227

April, 2014

Qualification Exam

QEID#60661227

69

Problem 168. 1996-Fall-SM-G-4

ID:SM-G-806
Consider a molecular clock that can take on four angular positions = n(/2), for
n = 0, 1, 2, 3. Its energy is given by
E = A cos .
It is subject to thermal fluctuations at a temperature T .
1. Determine the value of hcos i. Give the high-temperature and low-temperature
limits. Interpret your results physically.
2. Determine the value of hcos2 i. Give the high-temperature and low-temperature
limits. Interpret your results physically.
Problem 169. 1996-Fall-SM-G-5
ID:SM-G-820
A system of N non-interacting Fermi particles with spin 1/2 and mass m, is confined
to a volume V . It is at temperature T = 0. The particles have an energy-momentum
dispersion given by  = p2 /2m.
1. Determine the chemical potential.
2. Determine the internal energy.
3. The original volume V adjoins a vacuum region with volume V  V . Both
chambers are thermally isolated from the environment. The Fermi gas now
freely expands into the vacuum region. Assume that the internal energy as a
function of the temperature can be parametrized at low temperatures by
U = (V ) + (V )T 2 ,
where (V ) and (V ) are functions of volume. Determine the final temperature
of the gas after the expansion. Your answer should be expressed in terms of the
functions (V ) and (V ).
4. Determine (V ).
5. Determine (V ).
[Hint: The following integral expressions may prove useful:

Z
 2k1
X
2
1
7
(x)dx
=
(2k)(2k) (ln z) (ln z)+(2)(2) (ln z)+ (4)(4) (ln z),
x
1
2k2
e z + 1 k=0
2
4
0
where () =

R
0

(2n)

(x)dx, and
Z
0

Statistical Mechanics

() =

2n (x) 
x2n 

.
x=

k
X
xn1 dx
k+1 z
=
(n)
(1)
ex z 1 + 1
kn
k=1

QEID#60661227

April, 2014

Qualification Exam
Z

QEID#60661227

Z
0

2
xdx
=
,
ex + 1
12
"

Z
0

70

X
xn1 dx
zk
=
(n)
ex z 1 1
kn
k=1

X
xn1 dx
[ ln z]k z k
n1
k
=
(n)
(1

n)[
ln
z]
+
(1)
(n

k)
ex z 1 1
(k + 1) k n
k=0

]
Problem 170. 1996-Spring-SM-G-1
ID:SM-G-853
Consider a relativistic quantum Fermi gas, in three dimensions, with spin 1/2. The
energy of a relativistic fermion is  = cp, where p is the momentum.
1. Find an integral expression for the internal energy U of such a gas.
2. Find the equation of state relating volume, pressure and internal energy of this
gas.
[Hint: Find an expression for the thermodynamic potential for the grand
canonical ensemble, and relate this to U .]
Problem 171. 1996-Spring-SM-G-2
ID:SM-G-863
The Joule-Thomson process is the flow of a gas through a porous membrane separating two chambers, in which constant pressure p1 and p2 is maintained by external
conditions. In such a process the enthalpy H = U + P V is conserved.
1. Given that a change
of temperature and pressure is small, it is regulated by the


T
.
Show
that this derivative is:
derivative P
H

 



1
V
T
=
T
V .
P H
CP
T P
2. Calculate

T
P H

for the Van-der Waals gas with the equation of state:

(P + an2 )(1 bn) = T n,

where n = N/V is the density, and a and b are positive constants (also 1 nb
is supposed to be positive). In this part assume CP is given, and leave your
answer in terms of this parameter.
Problem 172. 1996-Spring-SM-G-3
ID:SM-G-879
0
Find the final temperature T of a Van-der Waals gas expanding to the vacuum when
it changes its volume from V to V 0 > V , if the initial temperature was T . Assume
that no heat is exchanged with the container. You may assume that CV is a given
constant.
For Van-der Waals gas the equation of state is
(P + an2 )(1 bn) = T n,
Statistical Mechanics

QEID#60661227

April, 2014

Qualification Exam

QEID#60661227

71

where n = N/V is the density, and a and b are positive constants (also 1 nb is
supposed to be positive).
Problem 173. 1997-Fall-SM-G-4
ID:SM-G-890
In the Debye model of the phonons (sound quanta) in a solid it is assumed that
there exist two degenerate transverse branches and one longitudinal branch of sound
oscillations. The oscillation frequencies t , l are linear isotropic functions of the wave
vector l,t (~q) = cl,t q, where cl and ct are the velocities of longitudinal and transverse
sound, respectively. The frequencies of each branch are assumed to be limited by a
maximal frequency D (Debye frequency). The value of D is determined by equating
the total number of degrees of freedom 3N j (j is the number of particles per unit
cell) to the number of phonon states.
1. Find the total number of states for transverse and longitudinal phonons, Nt and
Nl .
2. Find D .
3. Find the density of phonon states as a function of energy .
4. Find the integral form for the energy and specific heat CV of the phonons at
very low temperatures and at high temperature.
Problem 174. 1997-Fall-SM-G-5
ID:SM-G-901
Consider a system described by energy states with energies En . Using the canonical
ensemble at temperature T,
1. Derive an expression
for the root-mean-square fluctuation of the internal energy,
p
2
E|rms h(E) i in terms of En , where E = En hEi.
2. Determine the relationship between the specific heat at constant volume and
E|rms .
3. How does the relative fluctuation in energy, E|rms /hEi depend on volume for
large system?
4. Under what conditions might you expect the relative fluctuation in energy to
be large?
Problem 175. 1997-Spring-SM-G-4
ID:SM-G-912
Consider N particles of a non-interacting spin-1 Bose gas of mass m. They are
confined in three dimensions to a volume V . Take  = p2 /2m.
1. In the high-temperature, low-density limit, determine the partition function,
the free energy, and the entropy.

Statistical Mechanics

QEID#60661227

April, 2014

Qualification Exam

QEID#60661227

72

2. In 1926, Einstein predicted that, at sufficiently low temperatures, a non-interacting

Bose gas can undergo condensation in which the occupation number N0 of the
p = 0 state is macroscopic: i.e. N0 /N is finite as N . Taking the chemical
potential to be zero, derive N0 /N as a function T . Determine TE , the Einstein
condensation temperature, from the condition that N0 (TE ) = 0.
Any integrals that arise should be put in dimensionless form, but need not be
evaluated.
Problem 176. 1997-Spring-SM-G-5
ID:SM-G-924
Consider N particles of a non-interacting spin-1/2 Fermi gas of mass m confined to
a two dimensional plane of area A. Take  = 0 (p/p0 )3/2 .
1. Determine the T = 0 energy of this Fermi gas.
2. Determine the T = 0 surface pressure, , of the Fermi gas. This surface pressure
is the force per unit length acting on the confining boundary of the gas.
Problem 177. 1998-Fall-SM-G-4
ID:SM-G-934
Consider an atom trap containing two electrons, where such a large magnetic field
is applied, so that only spin-up states are occupied. The spin-down states are inaccessibly high in energy, so they need not be considered in this problem. The lowest
energy one-electron state of the trap has energy E0 and is doubly degenerate. The
first excited one-electron state has energy E1 and is four-fold degenerate. To simplify
the math set E0 = 0.
1. Find the thermal average energy of the two electrons.
2. Obtain an approximate expression for the previous result in the high temperature limit, i.e., |E1 E0 |  kB T . Find the heat capacity of the electrons in
this limit.
3. Find the thermal average energy and heat capacity of the two electrons also in
the low temperature limit, i.e., |E1 E0 |  kB T .
Problem 178. 1998-Fall-SM-G-5
ID:SM-G-945
Consider a spin-1 Bose gas with energy-momentum relation  = v|p| in a space of
dimensionality D = 1 and D = 2.
1. In one of these spaces Bose-Einstein condensation will occur, and in the other
case it wont. Determine which is which, and why. Note: For this part, you
need not explicitly evaluate the integrals involved, but merely verify if they are
well-behaved.
2. For the space in which Bose-Einstein condensation occurs, find the Bose-Einstein
transition temperature TBE . Express your results in terms of a dimensionless
integral, which you need not evaluate.
Statistical Mechanics

QEID#60661227

April, 2014

Qualification Exam

QEID#60661227

73

3. Find the fraction of Bose-Einstein particles as a function of temperature T , for

T < TBE .
Problem 179. 1998-Spring-SM-G-4
ID:SM-G-955
Consider a soap film supported by a wire frame of fixed length l along one direction
and of varying length x along the other direction. Because of surface tension , there
is a force 2l tending to contract the film. Take (T, x) = 0 T , where 0 and
are independent of T and x.
1. In one sentence, explain why the force is 2l, rather than l.
2. Express the energy change dE of the film due to work W associated with the
surface tension and heat Q absorbed by the film through the atmosphere.
3. Calculate the work W done on the film when it is stretched at a constant
temperature T0 from length 0 to x.
4. Calculate the entropy change of the film when it is stretched at constant temperature T0 from length 0 to x.
5. Calculate the change in energy E = E(x) E(0) when the film is stretched
at constant temperature T0 from length 0 to x.
Problem 180. 1998-Spring-SM-G-5
ID:SM-G-967
Consider a cyclic engine operating with one mole of an ideal monoatomic gas in the
following reversible cycle:
a b: expansion at constant pressure, the temperature going from Ta to 3Ta .
b c: expansion at constant temperature 3Ta , the volume going to 4Va .
c d: cooling at constant volume 4Va , the temperature going to Ta .
d a: compression at constant temperature, the volume going from 4Va to Va .
1. Sketch the cycle on a P V diagram.
2. Find the entropy change and the change in internal energy of the gas for each
part of the cycle. Find the net entropy change and the net change in internal
energy over the full cycle.
3. Calculate the thermodynamic efficiency of this engine and compare it to the
ideal efficiency of an engine operating between Ta and 3Ta .
4. What is the net change of the entropy of the hot thermal bath during one cycle?
5. What is the net change of the entropy of the cold thermal bath during one
cycle?
Statistical Mechanics

QEID#60661227

April, 2014

Qualification Exam

QEID#60661227

74

Problem 181. 1999-Fall-SM-G-4

ID:SM-G-983
An ideal monoatomic gas is composed of N atoms each of which has additional degrees
of freedom that must be taken into account when calculating the thermodynamics
properties of the gas. (For example, the atoms might have electronic excited states.)
For the following questions, use Zint (T ) to denote the partition function of the
internal degrees of freedom of a single atom and Z0 (T, V, N ) to denote the canonical
partition function of an ideal monoatomic gas composed of N atoms with no internal
degrees of freedom.
1. Determine the difference between the Helmholtz free energy of the gas composed
of atoms with internal degrees of freedom, F (T, V, N ) = U T S, and the
Helmholtz free energy of an ideal monoatomic gas composed of atoms with no
internal degrees of freedom, F0 (T, V, N ); i.e. determine
F = F (T, V, N ) F0 (T, V, N )
in terms of Z0 (T, V, N ) and Zint (T ).
2. Similarly, determine the corresponding difference in the entropies
S = S(T, V, N ) S0 (T, V, N )
3. Determine the corresponding difference in the chemical potentials
= (T, V, N ) 0 (T, V, N )
4. Determine the corresponding difference in the pressures
P = P (T, V, N ) P0 (T, V, N )
5. Evaluate Zint (T ) for an atom with two internal energy states separated by
energy E.
Problem 182. 1999-Fall-SM-G-5.
ID:SM-G-1012
N spin 1/2 fermions with positive charge +e placed in a magnetic field with field
strength B in the z-direction. The single particle energy levels are Landau levels, are
characterized by two quantum numbers and can be written as
n (pz ) = (n + 1/2)~c +

p2z
2m

where pz ( pz ) is the continuous projection of the momentum on the

z direction and non-negative integer n = 0, 1, 2 . . . is associated with the motion in
x y plane. Here m is the mass of the particle and c = eB/mc is the cyclotron
frequency.

Statistical Mechanics

QEID#60661227

April, 2014

Qualification Exam

QEID#60661227

75

The degeneracy of each level is given by

g [n (pz )] =

mc
A,
2~

where A = V /L is the area of the system in the x y plane, V is the volume of the
system, and L is the length of the system in the z direction.
Assuming the BOLTZMANN statistics in canonical ensemble is valid, determine
a. The equation of state.
b. The magnetization of the gas.
c. What condition on the chemical potential must be true so that the use of the
Boltzmann statistics is justified?
Problem 183. 1999-Spring-SM-G-4
ID:SM-G-1033
A polymer is a molecule composed of a long chain of identical molecular units, called
monomers. For simplicity, assume the polymer consists of a long chain of N rodlike monomers, each of length l, attached end to end. Assume that the connectors
between the monomers are completely flexible so that each monomer can make any
angle with respect to its neighbors. One end of the polymer is fixed while the other
end is attached to a weight (mg) providing a constant force in the negative z direction.
Except for an arbitrary constant which can be ignored, the potential energy of any
configuration of the polymer can be written as,
E(1 , 1 , 2 , 2 , . . . N , N ) =

N
X

mgl(1 cos(i )),

i=1

where i , i represent angles in the spherical coordinates that the ith monomer makes
with the negative z direction. Each angle can take all possible values 0 < i < and
0 < i < 2.
1. Determine the classical canonical partition function Z(T, N ) for this polymer
in contact with a temperature bath at temperature T .
2. Determine the thermodynamic energy U (T, N ) and entropy S(T, N ) of the system. Find the temperature dependence of U and S for very small and very
large temperatures.
3. If the polymer is isolated from the temperature bath and the mass at the end
of the polymer is increased adiabatically from its initial value of m to a final
value of 2m, determine the final temperature of the polymer.

Statistical Mechanics

QEID#60661227

April, 2014

Qualification Exam

QEID#60661227

76

Problem 184. 1999-Spring-SM-G-5

ID:SM-G-1052
A gas of N identical non-interacting, spin-1/2 fermions in three dimensions obey the
dispersion relation  = Ap , where p is the magnitude of the momentum, A and
are positive constants. assuming that these particles are in a box of volume V with
periodic boundary conditions.
1. Calculate the density of states of this gas as a function of .
2. Calculate the Fermi energy of this gas as a function of n N/V , which is the
density of the gas.
3. Write down as many integral expressions as needed which can, together and
implicitly, give the internal energy U of this system as a function of N , V ,
and the temperature T . You are not required to evaluate these expressions in
the order to find U (N, V, T ) explicitly.
4. Take the high temperature limit of the expressions you gave in the previous
part, and then evaluate them in order to obtain U (N, T, V ) explicitly in this
limit only.
R
[Hint: (s) = 0 xs1 es ds = (s 1)(s 1)]
Problem 185. 2000-Fall-SM-G-4
ID:SM-G-1065
~ = B z with
Consider a dipole with a fixed magnitude = |~|, in a magnetic field B
~
interaction energy U = ~ B. Assume the dipole is in equilibrium with a thermal
reservoir at temperature, T .
1. Without doing any calculations but using only simple physical reasoning, describe in words the behavior of h~i, the thermal average value of
~ , in the limit
as the temperature approaches zero, T 0.
Statistical Mechanics

QEID#60661227

April, 2014

Qualification Exam

QEID#60661227

77

2. If
~ is treated classically and can point in any direction in 3-dimensional space,
find h~i as a function of temperature. In particular, what are the values of hx i,
hy i, hz i? Show that as T 0,
~ has the behavior predicted in the previous
part.
3. Now assume that magnetic moment is that of a spin-1/2 particle with nonvanishing gyromagnetic ratio , so it can only point parallel or anti-parallel to
~ Find h~i as a function of temperature and show that it has the expected
B.
behavior as T 0. Also show that


~
h~i B
hz i

=
~ 2
B T
|B|
as T . (Keep the leading non-trivial term.)
Problem 186. 2000-Fall-SM-G-5
ID:SM-G-1082
Consider a box of volume V containing electron-positron pairs and photons at temperature T = 1/kB . Assume that the equilibrium is established by the process
 e+ + e
This process does not occur in free space, but could be considered to be catalyzed
by the walls of the box. Ignore the walls except insofar as they allow this process to
occur and answer the following questions in sequence:
1. By minimizing the appropriate potential at fixed T and V give the thermodynamic proof to show that
= e+ + e ,
which relates the chemical potentials of the three types of particles.
2. What should be the value of in view of the fact that there is no number
conservation for photons?
3. What should be the values of e+ and e be if all the positrons and electrons
in the box are due to pair creation? (Remember that a positron and an electron
have the same rest mass me .)
4. Using the relativistic energy of the particles, write down the integral expression
for the number of e+ in term of T , V , and e+ and for the number of e in term
of T , V , and e .
5. Using the values of e+ and e from the third part and the integral expressions
from the fourth part, calculate the mean number of electron-positron pairs, in
the two limits kB T  me c2 and kB T  me c2 . (You may leave your answers in
terms of dimensionless definite integrals.

Statistical Mechanics

QEID#60661227

April, 2014

Qualification Exam

QEID#60661227

78

Problem 187. 2000-Spring-SM-G-4

ID:SM-G-1104
A box of volume V contains N molecules of a classical gas. The molecules can either
be bound to the walls of the box with binding energy b and dispersion relation of
a 2D gas (p) = (p2x + p2y )/2m, or move freely within the volume of the box with
dispersion relation of a 3D gas (p) = (p2x + p2y + p2z )/2m.
Find what portion of the molecules are stuck to the surface. Obtain an explicit
results in two limiting cases of low and high temperature.
Problem 188. 2000-Spring-SM-G-5
ID:SM-G-1110
A system consists of 2 single particle states with energies 0 and 1 (0 < 1 ) that can
be independently occupied by spin-1/2 (non-interacting) fermions.
1. Determine the grand partition function for this system.
2. Determine the average number of fermions in the system as a function of the
temperature, T , and the chemical potential, .
3. Assume that the average number of particles in the system is two. Determine the
limiting value of the chemical potential in the low temperature limit (T 0).
[Hint: Convince yourself that based on the low temperature behavior of the
Fermi function, the value of should lie between 0 and 1 . Then determine its
precise value. ]
4. Assume that the average number of particles in the system is three, determine
the limiting value of the chemical potential in the high temperature limit.
[Hint: Knowing that at the high temperatures, the particle occupancy should
be described by a classical probability, determine the precise value of .]
Problem 189. 2001-Fall-SM-G-4
ID:SM-G-1122
A single-particle Hamiltonian has six degenerate eigenstates at energy 1 , and another
six degenerate eigenstates at energy 2 > 1 . All other eigenstates are of very high
energy relative to kB T . Eight non-interacting identical fermions are described by this
Hamiltonian. (The spin degeneracy is already included in the given degeneracies.)
1. Compute the ground state energy and degeneracy for this eight-fermion system.
2. Repeat for the first excited state of this system.
3. Repeat for the second excited state of this system.
4. At low temperatures, where kB T < 0.1(2 1 ), write down an approximate
expression for the canonical partition function of this system, which can give
the leading non-trivial-order contribution to the specific heat.
5. Repeat for the average total energy of the system.

Statistical Mechanics

QEID#60661227

April, 2014

Qualification Exam

QEID#60661227

79

Problem 190. 2001-Fall-SM-G-5

ID:SM-G-1135
1. Derive the grand thermodynamic potential G (T, V, ) for an ideal non-relativistic
Maxwell-Boltzmann gas in three dimensions, assuming that the particles have
no internal degrees of freedom. From the result, obtain S(T, V, ) and N (T, V, ),
and show that they obey the relation


5kB

S=N

.
2
T
2. Begin with the entropy expression for an ideal gas:
X
S = kB
[hnj i loghnj i + (1 hnj i) log (1 hnj i)] .
j

Show that in the high temperature limit it reduces to the Maxwell-Boltzmann

result obtained in the first part.
Problem 191. 2001-Spring-SM-G-4
ID:SM-G-1151
A solid thin rectangular parallelepiped has dimensions abb, where a  b. Assume
that it has three types of acoustic vibrations (phonons), all having velocity v. Thus
~
= vk for all displacements of the form ~u = ~u0 ei(k~rt) , with ~u0 along ~k for the
longitudinal mode and ~u0 normal to ~k for the two transverse modes.
1. Compute the total density of states dN /d (number of modes per unit angularfrequency range).
R
2. Define the Debye frequency D by 0 D (dN /d)d = 3N , where N is the
number of atoms. Find D . (Note, that N and N have different meaning here!)
3. Assuming that dN /d = 0 for > D , find the internal energy U (T ) due to the
phonons in this solid. You may express your answer in terms of a dimensionless
unevaluated integral.
4. Find the specific heat CV (T ) due to the phonons in the solid. You may express
your answer in terms of a dimensionless unevaluated integral.
5. Evaluate the cross-over temperature Tx below which the system must be treated
as two dimensional.
Problem 192. 2001-Spring-SM-G-5.
ID:SM-G-1164
N electrons in a box of dimensions L L L obey the energy-momentum relation
 = p2 /2m, where m is the electron mass. The system is at absolute zero temperature.
a. Find the maximum occupied momentum pF in terms of N and V = L3 .
b. Find the internal energy U of the system as function of N and V .
Statistical Mechanics

QEID#60661227

April, 2014

Qualification Exam

QEID#60661227

80

c. Find the pressure P from U .

d. Calculate the rate at which x component of momentum px crosses a surface area
A = L2 perpendicular to x in the +
x direction due to all N electrons.
e. How does pressure relate to the rate calculated in the previous part? Give physical
explanation.
Problem 193. Rotating gas.
ID:SM-G-1175
The canonical partition function of a classical, monoatomic, ideal gas in a cylinder
rotating with angular velocity is given by (see Kubo chapter 2, problem 4)
"
#N

3/2 x
2mT
e

1
1
R2 L
Z=
N!
h2
x
where x =

m 2 R2
.
2T

a. Find the angular momentum M of the rotating gas as a function of temperature

and angular velocity.
b. Consider the limits of the obtained expression for M corresponding to very high
and very low temperatures. Give the physical interpretation of obtained results.
What is the criterion of high and low in this case?
c. How much energy one should supply to heat the gas from a very low temperature
T0 to a very high temperature Tf ? Denote the initial angular velocity of the
cylinder as 0 . Neglect the moment of inertia of the cylinder (vessel) itself.
Problem 194. Quantum oscillator
ID:SM-G-1195
A quantum particle of charge q is in the oscillator potential V (x) =
temperature T .

m 2 2
x
2

in 1D at

a. Find the heat capacity of this system.

b. Find the electric dipole susceptibility of the system. (d = (F/E)V,N,T , =
(d/E)V,N,T ).
c. For the oscillator state n in the presence ofPelectric field E calculate xn =
hn |
x|n i, and then average displacement x = n xn wn .

Statistical Mechanics

QEID#60661227

April, 2014

Qualification Exam

QEID#60661227

81

Problem 195. Bricks

ID:SM-G-1203
1. There are three identical bricks with temperatures T1 , T2 , and T3 . You are
allowed to use any number of ideal engines, but you cannot supply external
heat or work to the system. What is the highest temperature you can give to
one of the bricks. Give answer as a root of a single algebraic equation. (You do
not need to sole the equation.)
2. Now you have N identical bricks with temperatures Ti , i = 1 . . . N . What is the
highest temperature you can give to one of the bricks. Give answer as a root of
a single algebraic equation. (You do not need to solve the equation.)
3. If all of the initial temperatures are in a small interval T0 < Ti < T0 + T ,
where T  T0 , find the highest temperature of previous part for N .
Problem 196. String.
ID:SM-G-1212
A 3D string of length L has a temperature dependent tension f (T ).
a. What is the average value of the amplitude ak of the kth harmonic of a small
deformation of the string?
b. What is hak ak0 i for two harmonics k and k 0 ?


c. Calculate e~n~ak .
Problem 197. Membrane
ID:SM-G-1220
A circular membrane has a temperature dependent surface tension (T ). How does
the heat capacity of the membrane depend on the small displacement h of the center
of the membrane perpendicular to the membrane?
Problem 198. Membrane
ID:SM-G-1224
A circular membrane has a temperature dependent surface tension (T ). How does
the heat capacity of the membrane depend on the small displacement h of the center
of the membrane perpendicular to the membrane?
Problem 199. Circle.
ID:SM-G-1225
A body undergoes a thermodynamic reversible cycle along the path given by
(P P0 )2 (V V0 )2
+
= r2 ,
2
2
P0
V0
where r  1. The adiabatic compressibility S , the heat capacity at constant pressure
CP , and the coefficient of thermal expansion of the body at P0 , V0 are known.
a. What is the total change of the energy of the body after a full cycle?
b. What is the total change of the entropy of the body after a full cycle?

Statistical Mechanics

QEID#60661227

April, 2014

Qualification Exam

QEID#60661227

82

c. What is the total work done by the body during the full cycle?
d. On the path ABC the body receives heat. On the path CDA it gives up heat.
What is the angle between the line AC and the axis V ?
e. What is the efficiency of this engine?
f. What would the efficiency of this engine be if the body were a monoatomic ideal
gas?

Problem 200. Gas and vacuum

ID:SM-G-1230
A cylinder of volume V0 + V1 is divided by a partition into two parts of volume V0 and
V1 , where V1  V0 . The volume V0 contains 1 mole of a gas at temperature T0 and
pressure P0 . The volume V1 has vacuum. You know the gass coefficient of thermal
expansion (P0 , T0 ), its T (P0 , T0 ), and its heat capacity CV (T, V ). At some moment
the partition disappears.
1. What will be the temperature of the gas after it equilibrates?
2. A piston now adiabatically returns the gas back to the volume V0 , what will be
its temperature?
3. What are these results for the ideal gas?

Statistical Mechanics

QEID#60661227

April, 2014

Qualification Exam

QEID#60661227

83

Problem 201. Distribution, average, and fluctuations

ID:SM-G-1235
You through a dice N times count the number of times you have a 3. You repeat
this activity many many times.
a. With what probability the number of 3s is n?
b. What is the average number of 3s?
c. What is the standard deviation (r.m.s. fluctuation)?
Problem 202. Distribution function of an oscillator.
ID:SM-G-1240
m 2 x2
A classical one dimensional oscillator (V (x) = 2 ) has a statistical distribution
function %(p, q) = AeE(p,q)/T , where A is a normalization parameter, T is a parameter
which is called temperature, and E(p, q) is the oscillators energy.
a. Find the normalization constant A.
b. Find the average coordinate of the particle.
c. Find the average momentum of the particle.
d. Find the r.m.s. fluctuations of the particle coordinate and momentum.
e. Find the average energy of the particle. Find the heat capacity.
f. Find the distribution function for a quantity f = f (p, x), where f (p, x) = pmx.
Problem 203. Traveling frog.
ID:SM-G-1245
Consider a one dimensional frog. After every seconds it hops with probability 1/2
one meter to the left and with probability 1/2 one meter to the right. At t = 0 the
frog is at x = 0.
1. Consider a function p(x, t) the probability for the frog to be at point x at time
t. Find p(x, t + ).
2. Consider a limit of large distances and long times. Find a differential equation
for p(x, t).
3. What is the initial condition for this equation?
4. Solve the equation.
5. What is the average coordinate of the frog? How does it change with time?
6. What is the average deviation of the frogs coordinate? How does it change
with time?
7. Repeat all the steps for the situation when the frog hops with probability q to
the left and probability 1 q to the right.
Statistical Mechanics

QEID#60661227

April, 2014

Qualification Exam

QEID#60661227

84

Problem 204. Electrons in wire

ID:SM-G-1250
A current I flows in the wire. Treat electrons as point like classical particles.
1. What is the probability that exactly n electrons cross through a wire crosssection in time T .
2. What is the average number of electrons which crossed a wire cross-section in
time T ?
3. What is the standard deviation of that number?

Statistical Mechanics

QEID#60661227

April, 2014