Autonomous Vehicles
Autonomous Vehicles
AUTONOMOUS VEHICLES
Executive Summary
Since the early 1960s the insurance industry has been a major force behind
the most significant advances in highway and vehicle safety including
electronic stability control requirements, seat belt use and automobile crash
worthiness. Now, autonomous vehicle (AV) technologies offer an opportunity
for us to advance another milestone in vehicle safety, going beyond keeping
people safe in a crash to avoiding the crash altogether.
According to the National Highway Transportation Safety Administration
(NHTSA) more than 32,000 fatalities occurred in the United States as a result
of vehicle crashes in 2014, with human error as a primary cause. Analysts
agree that Autonomous Vehicles (AVs) have the potential to dramatically
reduce human error and, therefore, the frequency of vehicle crashes. Savings
related to economic costs, including accident-related, fuel and productivity,
vary widely. McKinsey estimates savings at US$ 200bn US$ 1.9tr by 2025,
while Morgan Stanley puts savings at US$ 1.3tr.
In October 2010 Google publicly announced plans to develop automated
vehicle (AV) technology with the aim of preventing traffic accidents, reducing
carbon emissions and helping people make better use of time spent
commuting. Since then much has been written and reported with regard
to AVs, resulting in a wide range of estimates attempting to predict the timing
of their widespread adoption and quantify their impact.
AUTONOMOUS VEHICLES
AUTONOMOUS VEHICLES
Source: iStock
AUTONOMOUS VEHICLES
AUTONOMOUS VEHICLES
D.C.
AUTONOMOUS VEHICLES
Liability comparison
Level 1 Level 2 Level 3
As long as AV systems
and operator share
control, liability hinges
on determining which
was in control at the
time of an accident
Increased
reputational risk
New cyber liability
exposures
Level 4
Downstream
vendors and
contractors
liability emerges
AUTONOMOUS VEHICLES
AUTONOMOUS VEHICLES
AUTONOMOUS VEHICLES
Miles driven
More time on the road indicates higher
risk of loss. A subset of this may be
miles driven in AV mode versus
miles in operator mode. Fewer miles
driven in AV mode may require the
insurer to revert to more traditional
rating of the operator.
Time of day
Regular driving in heavy (or light)
traffic could impact a risks rating.
Location
Analysis of location data may be
blocked by regulators concerned about
privacy. Location might also include
the percentage of driving time spent
on mapped vs. non-mapped roads.
Speed
Instances of excessive speed could
be recorded via GPS information.
Driver identification
Even with telematics it is difficult to
know who is really driving the vehicle
and it matters to insurers whether
parents or their young drivers are
behind the wheel.
Hazards/Near-misses
Validation of how well the AV avoids
hazards that a human would not avoid
could support claims that AVs are safer
and lead to lower insurance rates.
Weather data
Knowing what driving conditions were
like at the time of an accident could
help with claims handling.
10
AUTONOMOUS VEHICLES
Shared vehicles
The future of autonomous vehicles goes beyond
individual vehicle owners to shared vehicles, and to
fleets of autonomous vehicles that include cars, trucks,
and public transportation. Shared AVs, for example,
could be available for rental on an as-needed basis.
Insurance might be included as part of the price of rental,
thereby easing consumers into the idea of the
autonomous functionality in a more economically feasible
manner than purchasing a fully autonomous vehicle.
Source: US DOT
11
AUTONOMOUS VEHICLES
Social acceptance
Active safety technologies
will ease acceptance of fully
autonomous vehicles.
Level 4
Acceptance
Economic disruption
Personal lines insurers, professional
drivers and accident economies will
be affected.
12
AUTONOMOUS VEHICLES
Sources
Gorzelany, James. 2013. Most consumers say theyll steer clear
of self-driving cars, survey says.
February 23.
Insurance Institute for Highway Safety/Highway Loss Data
Institute. 2015. Which states regulate testing on public roads?
November.
McKinsey & Company. 2013. Disruptive technologies: Advances
that will transform life, business, and the global economy.
May.
Morgan Stanley. 2013. Autonomous cars: Self-driving the new
auto industry paradigm.
November 6.
National Center for Statistics and Analysis. 2015. Early estimate of
motor vehicle traffic fatalities in 2014. DOT HS 812 160.
Washington, D.C.: NHTSAs National Center for Statistics and
Analysis.
13
Copyright 2015
Munich Reinsurance America, Inc.
All rights reserved.
555 College Road East
P.O. Box 5241
Princeton, NJ 08543-5241
Tel: (609) 243-4200
www.munichreamerica.com
Munich RE and the Munich Re logo
are internationally protected registered trademarks.