Oregon's Communes and Intentional Communities PDF
Oregon's Communes and Intentional Communities PDF
by
BRIAN VANNEMAN
A THESIS
August 1997
11
Approved:
Professor Richard M. Brown
ACKNOWlEDGMENTS
IV
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Chapter Page
Appendix
A. Map of Oregon 57
B. An Inventory of Oregon's Utopian Communities, 58
Intentional Communities and Communes
Bibliography 61
I
Back to the Land
The United States' Communal Movement
in the 1960s and 1970s
IJohn Stickney, "The Commune Comes to America," Life, 18 July 1969, p. 16.
2
3 Ibid., p. 5.
t'""
4 Ibid., p. 6.
5
The communal movement of the late 1960s and 70s can be seen as a
sudden, sweeping social innovation, or a development rooted In a
time forgotten by those who took part in it. No matter the
interpretation, it is undeniable that the communes of the late
twentieth century were a radical departure from the society that
surrounded them.
8 Frances FitzGerald, Cities on a Hill (Simon and Schuster: New York, 1981) p.
23.
9
II
Oregon Bound!
Communes Migrate to the Pacific Northwest
The initial area of our choice was... a beautiful area characterized by its
moderate weather and good growing season; good multi-crop agricultural
land; West Coast location but away from earthquake prone zones; excellent
educational facilities; progressive government and relatively comfortable
political climate ("flexible within a structure"); and a social climate that
seemed to be as tolerant of new ideas as any area of the United States. After
much discussion we agreed that Oregon, especially the Eugene area, was the
most propitious in the country.!
3Ibid., p. 469.
4Ibid., from "Profile: Tom McCall of Oregon" and "The Politics of Anxiety
and Affluence."
12
14
III
From Breitenbush to Yellow Submarine
An Overview of Oregon's Intentional Communities
order to create a "lifestyle that reflects their shared core values. ,,2
Oregon's communal movement has been subdivided and
analyzed in various ways. Some judge that the movement is split
between communes that escaped from society into anarchy and those
that constructed new alternatives. Many within the movement feel
pigeonholing groups is artificial: "Intentional communities are like
people--you can categorize them based on certain distinguishing
characteristics, but no two are ever identical. ,,3 Others feel loose
descriptions are useful, and divide intentional communities into
categories and subcategories based on their size, amount of economIC
sharing, sexual norms, or social and ideological origins.
The last criterion seems to be the most accurate and most often
used, because of the distinct social and ideological traditions--from
Marxism to the psychedelic subculture--from which the generations
of the late twentieth century drew their inspiration. So, Oregon's
recent communities are best divided into five groups: rural
counterculture, urban counterculture, Christian radical, middle-class,
and Eastern mystic. Remember, however, that many middle-class
Oregonians followed Eastern mystic teachers, and rural hippie
communes often contained devoted Christians; communes, like
people, are not always easily defined.
19
20
Their dress (what there was of it), their manner, their hair all reflected
this new life style, yet they seemed as fanatically committed to Jesus as
any of their more conservative, straight-type brethren.... It was a mind-
blowing scene. Four uptight, tight-lipped, straightlaced, well-groomed,
conventionally dressed, knit-browned Oregon Okies talking with two
dusty clothed, freaky hatted, longhaired, land-loving, out-of-sight
12
Christian hippies.
middle-class stability and security. But even their lives were not
untouched by the social and political turmoil that shook the 1960s.
Across the country, middle-class citizens who dared not join Vietnam
protesters III youth rallies and marches agreed with many of the
principles of the student movement. They were troubled by the
with designing and imagining their new lifestyle, and not committed
enough to jump in and live it. The Cerro Gordo Town Forum
chronicles years of discussion, not action. Cerro Gordo's failure IS
IV
Magic Farm
A Country Commune
Institutional
Magic Farm's first rule: there are no rules--customs and
routines maybe, but no rules. After all, rules were something Magic
Farm's members were universally fleeing from: government, parents,
police, and society all regulating and judging their actions.
From this first premise, the institutional character of the
community followed. Situations were explored intuitively, and dealt
with one at a time through group meetings or personal interaction.
31
5S undancer, p. 92.
32
Economic
As one might expect from a community that did not reqUIre
regular work of its members and had no consistent income, Magic
Farm often scrambled for money at the beginning of each month. By
33
6Ibid., p. 115.
.....
T
34
know that 40 hours a week and foresight are the only way the bills
get paid.
But Magic Farm's resourceful members had ways beyond their
garden of supplementing the flow when its source seemed to dry up.
Some earned money locally, splitting fence posts or performing other
manual labor. The commune frequently traded its labor or crops to
neighboring farms in exchange for animals or tools. One month,
when Magic Farm's communal coffers were particularly empty, the
group paid its $100 mortgage with five cords of split wood. Many
members enjoyed month-long winter respites III West Coast cities,
where they earned money which would later be contributed to the
community.
The unfortunate truth, however, is that Magic Farm could not
have lasted so long without the Uncle Sam's generosity. The federal
government supported community members through welfare,
unemployment compensation, government surplus foods, and food
stamps. But the government provided for its alienated citizens in
much subtler ways, too. As Sundancer writes, using Norton as a
pseudonym for the town of Grants Pass:
Maybe we're cheating. It's easy for us. No matter what we say or do, the
hospital in Norton goes right on existing. I've often walked past a
hospital and thought, 'They'll never get me sucked into their
operations.... But when Alan was in a coma after his car accident I found
myself praying that the hospital would save him.?
7Ibid., p. 125.
35
Social
Those who called Magic Farm home were searching for some
kind of companionship or family, and most found it. Close
friendships grew rapidly through constant contact, and an
interconnected family unit followed. As in any intentional
community, the tight-knit group could not remain so without
disagreements and occasional personal clashes, but those were the
exception, not the rule.
Sexual promiscuity plays a very big role in the accepted image
of 1960s hippie communes, but there was little difference between
relationships at Magic Farm and those in the outside world. No "free
love" or group marriage ethos existed at the commune--the group's
harmony and its connection to the land were too important to
endanger with sexual experimentation. The community's core
membership was mostly single, complemented by several couples.
Short-term relationships between Magic Farm's members were rare
because they endangered the group's social stability. However,
36
8Ibid., p. 36.
37
9Ibid., p. 53.
lOIbid., p. 71.
38
Magic Farm's routines held the group together for most of the
year, but the summertime flood of visitors and drifters could not
help but unravel that relatively fragile social fabric. As was
emphasized above, newcomers disturbed many permanent residents,
not least because they could no longer follow their usual social
patterns: a quiet breakfast with several friends, solitary weeding III
Institutional
Alpha Farm's institutional framework is subtle and friendly,
yet strong and effective. The community strives to be an accepting
.....
encounter enables members to talk about their personal 42
Economic
3Ibid.
4Alpha Farm members, from interviews, 6-7 May, 1997.
While other intentional communities have counted on a 44
three goats, and the water of the stream which flows through their
land. The nourishment which the land provides is helpful, but it
could not possibly sustain all of Alpha's fifteen members without
outside income.
5Ibid.
Alpha-Bit cafe is a small pIece of the farm, transplanted arili5
seemingly out of place in its new-age nook between Mapleton's
modern general store and supermarket. The cafe is much more than
just a place to get a bite to eat--beyond Alpha-Bit's counter are
shelves of books and arts and crafts. Alpha-Bit is a source of mcome
for the community, as well as a social focal point. Locals who stop for
coffee meet and come to understand Alpha's members, while the cafe
prevents Alpha from becoming too isolated on their remote farm.
Each new member who officially joins the community after a
year of residency also makes a significant economic contribution.
Because new members have decided to make Alpha their permanent
home, they contribute their money and property to the farm's
communal fund. $5,000 is goes directly to the community's
spendable account, while any remaining assets are kept in a reserve
from which only the interest can be used by the farm. However, the
entire contribution is refundable should the member decide to leave
Alpha. The community only asks that it be allowed time to return
the money, as it is always invested in the farm itself or one of its
businesses.
Alpha's other sources of income are somewhat more mundane:
while few Americans grow more than weeds in their backyards, most
would not feel too out of place delivering mail or receiving a pension
check. Alpha-Farm took over two of western Lane County's mail
routes in the mid-1970s and has continued to operate and profit
from it ever since. Alpha's members rumble down hundreds of miles
of the coast range's bumpy back roads each week to deliver mail.
Members of the community also make money by doing repair and
construction jobs in the area. Jim Estes is the only Alpha membcl<i
who worked for several years at a job outside the farm. As an editor
for the Salem Statesman-Journal, his salary and pension have helped
his companions significantly. Jim's wife Caroline also makes money
outside the farm through consensus and intentional community
workshops which she hosts around the country.
Anyone who has ever worked on a farm knows its not easy.
Add all of Alpha's other jobs and obligations, and you've got a heavy
load. Members usually work from eight until five, with a break for
lunch at noon. Its no idyllic life in the country, but as one member
said, "I'd rather work 40 hours out here than in a building.
To counter the strain of work, jobs rotate among members, so that
In order to make the daily grind somewhat interesting, jobs
rotate daily at Alpha. Nobody is forced to shovel dirt five days a
week. Instead, a member may work at Alpha-Bit cafe on Monday,
garden Tuesday, and drive the mail route Wednesday. Members
cook communal meals about once a week in two-person crews. Even
so, if there's a big project that must get done, such as building a new
house, everyone may pitch in for weeks or months. In addition to
avoiding monotony, job rotation keeps people from identifying
themselves with a single job. No Alpha member is "the cook" or "the
leader," and those on the farm like it that way. When every member
understands and contributes to the work of every other member,
work becomes a team effort, not the labor of some under the
direction of others.
At times, though, communal ideals must gIve way to practical
realities. Caroline Estes can no longer chop wood as well as some of
the younger members, which means she will rarely be seen splitiihg
a cord of Douglas Fir on a hot summer day. Another long-time
member was trained as an accountant, so she's far more qualified to
figure Alpha's taxes than others. Often, due to differing abilities or
preferences, some members find themselves performing similar jobs,
rather than rotating randomly. That doesn't mean the system is too
idealistic, but instead that Alpha's residents use common sense when
putting together their schedule.
While individual jobs keep Alpha's members busy most days,
the farm must also plan and complete big group projects which will
benefit the whole community. In the course of Alpha's 25 years, the
group has built two large structures, the "new house" and the office,
and repaired and improved many others. These buildings represent
major undertakings for Alpha, especially since many members didn't
know a wrench from a ratchet, and the farm must continue to focus
on its other sources of income. The new house, now more than ten
years old, is a two-story, five bedroom wood home which fits quietly
into Alpha's wooded hills. It took the community 13 years to
who have lived at the farm for more than a year, and $25 for otfl~rs
Social
Economic and institutional guidelines help to define Alpha
Farm, but its warm, hospitable spirit is the community's core.
"Socially, we envision a modified style of family life that overcomes
the isolation and rigid classifications of single persons, couples, and
separate families.... Community members of all ages will participate
together in the living and growing of each other." In Alpha's vision,
the divisions in American society are bridged, creating unity and
family. And the vision has become reality: three generations live,
work, and play together on the farm.?
Alpha's members, like those of other intentional communities,
experience and enJoy life together. Everything from their daily lives
to unique They work, eat, play, and hang out all in each others'
company
Its hard to draw the line at Alpha Farm between members'
social and professional lives. For most Americans, the separation
6Ibid.
7Alpha Farm Community, "Alpha: A Prospectus," Philadelphia,
Pennsylvania, 1971.
between business and pleasure is clear. Workers leave the officet;9
drive home and then make plans with family or friends to relax and
unwind. But at Alpha, the two worlds are inextricably intertwined:
members work with friends, and socialize with their fellow workers.
Communal meals are some of the most precious social times.
Breakfast and lunch are prepared by the rotating kitchen crew for
everyone, but members break for these meals at different times and
often eat in small groups. Dinner is especially valuable, for it's the
only time during the day when the entire community is sure to be
gathered together in the same room. Before the evening meal is
served, the members of Alpha join hands for a moment of silence,
and often a song.
While the community IS nearly always together, some residents
appreciate time by themselves, and Alpha ensures they can get it.
The community promises each member his or her own room--a
private space to retreat to or store personal belongings in.
Personal space can be very valuable, especially at Alpha Farm,
where human contact is virtually unavoidable. And while constant
companionship is pleasant, many members of intentional
communities say that living with 20 friends can be one of the
hardest transitions to make. Americans, after all, are notoriously
independent: we drive alone, and often live thousands of miles away
from our extended families. Learning the social skills necessary to
share possessions, resolve minor personal problems, and divide one
bathroom between six people can discourage less dedicated visitors.
Living communally is not easy, Alpha's members say; it's not for
everyone. When serious personal problems arise within the
community, they are dealt with at Third Meeting. If they still cahOt
be resolved, the farm's members may make a consensus decision
that one or more people must leave. Fortunately, disagreements
rarely progress that far
Few rules are placed on interpersonal relationships at Alpha
Farm. Lovers, friends, families, and singles of all sexual orientations
are welcome. As their prospectus states, the group seeks to join
together groups who are traditionally separated. The community
only asks that its members are respectful of others' wishes and
prIvacy. If the group's harmony remains, Alpha is content to allow
any lifestyle or relationships.
Children at Alpha are raised not by one or two biological
parents, but by 15 adoptive ones. There's always a mom or pop
around to teach the young ones a new skill or keep them out of
trouble. Sally, mother of three of the farm's children, has enjoyed
Alpha Farm's extended family child rearing. The help she receives
from other members removes the burden of constant surveillance
from her shoulders, and she feels her kids have gotten more
perspectives and experiences from a farm full of parents than a
traditional nuclear family could have provided. 8
Though Alpha's members feel that communal child rearIng IS a
great benefit for both parents and kids, most children are schooled III
Mapleton, 15 miles south of the farm. Alpha does not want its
smallest residents to grow up insulated and sheltered from the
outside world. Apparently, parents at the farm acknowledge that
there may be some lessons which cannot be taught by a small
..
ya
I
52
VI
In Retrospect
Oregon's Intentional Communities
in Historical Perspective
Oregon and across the country fell into a slump, which discouraged
52
53
others from joining the movement. "The flow," as Magic Farm called
it, began to dry up. 1
Some communities, like Alpha Farm, Breitenbush, and
Mountain Grove, pulled together to ride out the hard times, and still
exist today. As we evaluate the success of the late twentieth
century's communal movement, it is valuable to put the groups III
historical context, and remember that while they were unique, they
do not stand alone in American history.
The United States' first communal movement of note was the
Millenarian sects of the east coast who, in the 1820s, believed that
God would soon end civilization on Earth, select his "chosen," and
bring them to his heavenly kingdom. The Shakers and Harmonists
were two such groups. Both practiced celibacy as there seemed to be
no sense in having children when judgement day was so near. The
Harmonists began several communal towns which excelled in
agriculture and craftsmanship. The Shakers settled in both rural as
well as urban areas, when they often owned blocks of homes. Both
were highly successful--economically and socially--and despite
obvious obstacles to propagation, they lasted until the late 19th
century.2
America's next rush of new Utopias came in the 1840s, when
Owenism and Fourierism offered· people new alternatives. These
new social theories reached people as industrialization rapidly
changed the 19th century world. Factories, unemployment, and
53
54
1855, very much fit the mold of successful communities of its time:
a charismatic religious leader united his followers communal village.
Like George Rapp and his Harmonists, Aurora's members were
devoted to Wilhelm Keil and his plans for self sufficiency through
agriculture and industry. Keil encouraged close study of the bible,
and was said to possess remarkable healing powers. The community
prospered, sold its high quality handicrafts in Portland, and
eventually operated a well-known hotel on the route to San
54
'1"
55
55
56
56
~> 111()1j>·,j~/~J ~' - .. ·~>c, cU"~..
1~,pto,~~;,~',
~ ."".'J °:@~1
0_~'(j ~"~f "~'oc1"~:.' ' selaQ~I~O;( "'''~ ~I'~(I""", --~Colj
, ',',llkl' T"0rntor' _
'\~"~Ik
'lJlk\lI~,rl ,Jl((lI.JlI~1 .1~'))~epl'lv ~ ~J'S ~
,/RiUoill" Ewan'",,'. '(
, --... ur J(.1\\lt?S 'Georg" p"'i,,,I,., n',er"", ""ongo, St
\IT UXiF.!71'/'
IMfl..,:"-/,"";." ,-P'''''' , Ell,·, sl, 'tJ'Il'
v""" V"nl.So OS"I/;"nOu,,- ,WMd,'n ,'[ :Ralston E d,cott,St
Hills?'.p,aI0
" '",,"".,,1
- Grayland ..", l P II :" .. I "
I Tl'r'I') j]e'IJe.CrlY1_r-,-- Benge-
a
""J9,"
I .""" .. \ , ; .. 'c c".. " ';
I " '.....":""""
Oystcrvtll
So. i b
c,c,~
c,,, ",.,.\,+-0""oe",•r\..01".';'0,'1/
~o ~IRa _0 -
''''0': ...",,,",
~, Y k
, ..",,,,.,
I
c ,w,,""', "'0.':
~i ) . ' . _ 'hlotus
__
.3,"''''
\C'-
Hamm~to
~ I".."..,"~" ~,~ ..,~. ,c,. ,.. . ;<:.,.~I .. ""~ . ~'m
"";";;;.,;,,,."1\.... •..
".C..",,,,,;,, .' )"\ .", .. C.... ' ;, .... .... ..••
'"', ...rot.....
""'¥,.., " "'"''
'v,11,mook~·aSld Cli~~i1~Co ,. " ,2. alarna?-~, Glenwo~tTsc~ ·~".c"lIli' !r'~l ';"' l'ol1'I! !'Ir.C'f(p;
n ,,,,,',",, , ,." ,., " , ;
,.",,'.., 'p )
, 1':lt' M,
'
M.;C.... ,,","'"' " ' "
. , '
no
\ ~ ~ernonla.S~Helel'1 ~ ~
_ _ P/rV"N) L If< __
~ '~"",
FT.CL '1001< l; "o,.Rock. Bickleton
'"
"~".,,,
iC""" ,
"'~''''
'86'<
0,... ,J ,
·A M, ,,""- ar/;;'Pass ? L ''''!' "'''''. M, I ", .', , , ..A>'", " ""'''' , ..
~ Cascade~:e
" d" WillanV~g~o.'/
\ ,,' ....'''·1"Am;ty/,WoOdb'u~,;'lalia ':~ , I..... '",.~ +,."'••'"
00
"'j , , '", ' , "'''''',.. """", ',", <0 ,
f A() 11
, 0..., '''' bler
r 'r'. "'"
)v-o.r, ~,_."
, .. Jo,~l.n. ~ '.,M,.Pov.M~':~t~ ~
"I nc G'.....C'
I . ,\.. , " M aup,n
. , ..
"" 'Kent' ar man Ukiah, '-,
\"1"~.\n .
....
\C\'t.~ ,
"',sCi/!,. / I f. ""', .
. . ",0"
leoSilve'ton
.. D., . '
T1 .
~
'6n+ "-tMt
_.~
~ q~;:_~~,., \'I;,m asho,
Shaniko.
'''' .•"
F 'I" W.
J
, l.'k .•
Ritter"
D(I;'088 J. i-
,,~
",/ 'P Ouweather.' , .' ,J fSt"'.i. ' '1-1\1\ ".eo:. . i.t [......2199 :261 \·1· ll /I". "I nt 1 '\ \ .. ray .,MonumelltJ G 't. "'Cree1< __
/' Sto,""'"
neWR/I.:~. ., W""'" ....'I ~ " ... .n '"-~'/ ..C........ " , ~N , ~'.."
q;, ,,,c ,"" ",,' J ,,",,"" l'f\~ kYJ"...
CI
U / '''' " , ",,' ' " ..." .
,,,,;://,, "'l
W . . . c . . ., . . , . . ... , ""', " 1" ""
V7 .,,:,.;;", '0......"" ." . ,. . , """"
rC,....... rd",;•",,' '"" ","" """
b ny
....."'" '"" m,;""... ,... I """. .C..., C"., "'" "'''"
eo , '"" I ,o:l"""" .., ., "'" ",' ,.."" ">i;~i;,. :. ""'~ r
/ ... N.. M., ,
~ .~
R 'tgt rt~ ~,. C~ GI~." fJ{~IJ!l /1 ~
1
"e- pi /8 It
'------..--, 0 ,,,.orcene:die
'M ,-<-·onota
"d' R" ", .. pn 9 .."
'Jasper 'e__ . - .. cM--, , ""... 8('nd.
- __ ......U l M,/u"y Mt.s._. I__ uair . C"tf,(ock.. - Bu.ll/'Cree
. : ". w.....
_" " <lIe
OR GONDUNES "'Is'lilwa, 10),,' 0 I"" ,'oen'lookoutPo;nt Bachelor
M . 0 ,\".. /(I.S .... +NHafPer. ;"... __ NYS.s i
C(
{If'( . 'N. Cv • orth'Bend Yel 0 ,Oakland cresccnll.,e! .,Gtichr",t leSS I H a e Y La:;n.
.f:l~"""I"""""~
'harJesto IdleYld Park 233'. C'escen. ,nl'" lO,,,,, " .' :lln""n"" . lerane , La/.:e.,\( ri
F <J f..Y""'........
f113'
. ' ..,. "C." .
\ ,.,7 ,11.-1 ",,,.',".
W.".
,W,."""",
•. .. "'" ,.." ''''''''m M'.
.r,:T"'d.. H'
., .
" ,...,....
".....,,...
,""..,...
,...., •••• I "'",..."
,,'"
B "'..... ""'''.,
"'".1..""'M',,
". .c"
~dderb'" ~',.~
<::I \ 1:2<12+- I (':
>"" 0'' ",',,.... '""", .. ,
'I'
.
"SO,' ' . I, ...... ,.... e,,,," ,....." "" ".
. p~ss r, ~~~'-'.."" .. ',. ~o>~.. ..~ D_s,,~
C"''''';''" .. "' M, " • ""'" . . . . . . ",,- ...
',1I .'/.
' .
1
Beach
0" ,,"', ."....
' ..
"c 1'.'':'1',(1
.(,0\ 1/
111l~rJ.;:L
. '.
.~',~iys
Butte Falls J.{ J II Chdoquln
",..
POint +-Nlt McLollg!JJm
.. " .J
S,?I as 8
o,er? -G
' '" '" ,
",,,0:
W....
Vall" F"II,.,
I ::; 'r:, Campbell r
I \444 'gSlltfT I.
0,,- c AI'or" c
;, V; •
'"
t
~.4 ~ .
, lnt ,
'"°1 ,~""", ~,
~ ~ 2~ ~
S~,~ R~~~- ~'""'0'.., ..'~
-,'1, \ Ir..,.
h'.,..." , " ....,," , ..."
I -;';-Al • ..".... I.r} "S01
.. . "", ,. "0' " .. I I
C,pef,e",ro 0
",',; Ca'eJunct,on! , .'"n Ash/an ,'1(,.'1111"., K / "hAlt" ' L"ko'i,w. I' .. 'Adel 'i." :
26 . ;:;.' :1,
"~K:L"'J¥;£ii" .,0",
,"",.. C.,,, ,,_...9"o'.4~", ~Mali/-'":~., _(j~Y.d'.lnnrCr"k'.}Sl"l~12:'=~~~ '0._..'"'""'" :' ".' ''"'l:; ':'~'"'"~:.J'l'~;:.iCD~ili
i
BrOOking v 892/ B n ":'.. ;{',o " 0)°"1" II"x. I,,,,,,,,, I "A, C. " £. ,1
M.o':M:..,, ", .
LJ L \
• ,"t'",.""
·il:: --"'''''''''''''':<''-Rffi ....
,! r..,f
"'""j1i"PPy~::''':1r MacdO~('t .~~eMt
Pr , " Isldnd ........ ..
" "." D" , .. ":5i.. ° ' C _ " ,",,, I
~I C~c::;ccnt (r~'V ,'~'. D<l.Vi~
"0'
Po 'i- \ tPrestonlfy/f).., J{JwlIllth 7111'\,1" I!. ,'1,,(11(1'. oFl.,,-i{(dlvell CatnrpMt r- "",.
jj
~ c""r ,.'f~ •:lS~I<Il..
II
In t iO,!,t -i_)1 \' all"1';;
g I"i,,, ", ./,;;: UpRer wi "Sold In" __
Appendix II
An Inventory of Oregon's Utopian Communities,
Intentional Communities and Communes
Bibliography
Bates, Doug. "A day in the life of a commune dweller." The Register-
Guard (Eugene, Oregon), 29 August 1971, page lB.
Colt, George H., "For the Forseeable Future." Life, December 1991, page
76.
Houriet, Robert. Getting Back Together. New York: Avon Books, 1969.
Interviews
65