2012/ 

          8 

 4 


    /
  
      
      
!"

The Effectiveness of the Financial Controlling System and Its Effect on
the Financial Corruption in Iraq- Applied study on Mosul University
)   * . 
% (' . $ 
%
& "' ..
!"
 
 /  " ) +) ,

-. 

 
   
           !  "

&

' # &'

!  ( 
# )
% *+ ,- 
#    # 
    $ $ %
 ./0 1
2   * !  
#  , 
% *+ ,- 
# 3
%

! 6  6$  .,7 ( #, !  8 % .2$  , (4 ($ (4

&# *9   .
 #,  !   ) , 
% .:,;  '

4 &$ < (4 
 .  
4 : =   
  % *+ ,- '
.
Abstract:
The current research aims to the appear the corruption especially the financial
and administrative corruption , Which many countries suffer from and one of these
countries is Iraq. This takes different factors on the activity of controlling system ,
therefore the research is depended on the evaluation of the controlling of systems of
Mosul University the research sample selected to reach t0 the diagnosis of gaps which
can be abridge to the effectiveness and spread of corruption . the research has come up
with a number of conclusion. The most important is that the deficiencies in the
controlling procedures of Mosul University as a research sample. The research
concludes to a set of recommendations including the need for legal support for the
financial controlling system to take the adequate accountability of means of financial
irregularities to be a deterrent to the perpetrators .




 
!  
4 42 > *$ *
? *6 1 42  &# 42 & ,

# 
 
#, 
% 0$ (    

' @! ( & # ?-  ) *
- A
)  )    *   Corruption  "
 6    & @2
6 Corruption Financial  ) (  42 ( 6
C .. ) 
 ) 7) %7
"  # ! # E  .F  (
 (
F G (
 2 047
@ H/ .0 6 
  ) I- 42- '  ( < 6  (

317
 2012/            8 
 4 

.
 (
' 4 
 @
$   H ( 
2 >  #2 
C @4 
'!
.3H7 @#H .7!  F  
 &4!;
&4! 
 .! # 
J &
 G/ ., 
 
4! .=
6 . , E6  '
E &+7  "   
% .
 - (
' >9   =$ # 
#  %
#   4 :0   #%  % :?7 "24 # #
 42 %H-  
 .7! # *?
  F
 -  @#H 3H7 K/ .7! (  !
!
 :, &

' H ( 
% & "9 (4$ ./0 E # :9 ?
 0! :, % ) 
1 <?'  = *+ ,   
 H ! (9
  !
! 
4  "%
.
  >
  &6$ &

'      >%  H ( !  

6$ M : /% 
(
#  
% *+ ,- 6  
% .
 .:,;  ' "9 6 

=
. !  
#  , # 
? E 
 = .F
G  (CPI )  .4 2F #   .2F 
' 4F : !  42
(# ' ?' ( O#, .+!$ 2F # ,  ( %75   ( 2010 & O
! N '!7
  ) &  *2 
'
'! 42 ,  
2
 ) ., ( 10 ) <, ( ., ( 5 )
 4  
7  %     (
'  (
 H >'
 ($ ,
!  *
      *6 2 6 !  42   6 ( ) , ( 1,1) # ! 
 6$ (  ;   !4  
4! 
% *+ ,$ , ( &C 
4 42
.6
C 
  % (

:  !  "
: /% &(
.     >% &

'  H (   # "%   &    -
H (   
 .F .!  
 
  % $ 
# 3
% &

' -
. !  
#  , # 
?
2 GC-  H/ (4
 
  % .:,; ( ./0 ) "9 ' @, 
! -
 
: (
, ( 
0!  .
9 C
 & !  "6$   , ( : /% 1 2
= .+ >
,   2  .$  @ $ # E6 :3 !4 5 
2 ( !
 42 *:4 *' " 4 
 
% .:,; ($   
4!
.  2

318
 2012/            8 
 4 

 7 =-  (+- (


  
=! 7 . %H# , 7 :    5 
, 
 
  % & 
# 3
%  
# #7 (4

% 2F  7 6 7
.

    3  6 : !4 /%

 6 )    
 >9 #  Q? &  

4- !  9' :    8
7 )
 , /
! ( .   IF "H . .
!  Q?  0! 
6 * ( 9
 '
 ) Q 
C ?% 6  '
4 )     
:2  ( 6
Ash , !H? . ( 261 ) 1994 ) + )  (235 ) 1405 )  (  ) ! "H

= $ 
2 Q # ! ? & *:   "
   6
forth &Anand
&
' 2  
2
 ( I
 Windsor  (Ashforth &Anand , 2003 , 2) 
 $
(Windsor , #2 
C 
?  >, ! #  ! 
9 
%H7 . #7
*24  @4 
'!  @ &$ M 
F
2 (4 2$ 2004 ,142 )
(  
2
 
#,7 & # "
  ?
6 ( 7 ) 1998 ) 

2  (4 ) ++ 7

2   ( 54 )2008 ) ! )  " $ R  
'! &  $ ? &
6 2
7  @4 "
! ! ? & *: M   
2 
 6+

C 
4! .=
 .F 9
 1 <?'    ?' & <?'  (
 "

)  * "
 E6 ( ,    ( Daniada , 2003, 46 ) 

 @+!7 
4!
 7 G  
2

 ) 3H7 %  
2
7 G  *2 Q? ( @
%  
. ? & *: <4 H7 
   : 
;     ( , )  " * ?  :    
 7 9  
:
( * 
 1 ,
1 &H  - 1
 (
=  4 

' .
2 &
' 0
 :  4-  .1
.  .' (   3$ (4
 .' ' &  I2 ' 3H7 E4
++ 7  *2 @?  ?  ' (

 / ( &
% !  !
: /-  .2
. * (
' S  R - 
'! .%  ' &  

( 56 ) 2005 ) ! ) :-4 .
 .:, <  ;    " ( E6
/
 .% 
 .!H O, @ > & <?' 
 ) & <?'   .1
7  $
  .42 .T2 "6M   %H# 7 "6$ 
'! 
; &  (=
U  
?/ * G
 # ' 
! E 6  .  42 $ *M2 * & 

%

319
 2012/            8 
 4 

I2 :?#V 1 <?'  #- , , &

' 0 6 1 <?'   .2
GC- &6
  
 .   &  :2 G/ & <?'  (
  (
F
  & (9  ' (
 U  :?#  6
C.. .
+  .%4 
=  ( + E  '     # *24   2 0 !


*
, 
C    #  .%  !

( 28 )2010) , #) 74 .4  
 !
 ! 
 ;    " 4
4 # ! &# / ? 
! / ? & : W ( : 
  .1
I #$ 
 (
>, / 


' 
C 
 . .
 4 0
 ?'  @, M
 6 :   .2
. 
2 > 
'! "  
&  HS  #M &
'4 (
 2 E  0
 6 : %H7  .3
.  .
%H
&! &4 *7 "#7 Q=  
' 
C #7 4 0
 : 7  .4
.6
C .. .   :2 6 @ "4  
M (# <7  & .%
# 3
 @, E 6 

 ( 7   42$  E6 ( ,   
?
  @4 
'!   ' 
% 
C * 
 . .
# &  -
: 7 
' 
C 
 . .
 E ! (4
 )   
#
(74N53 )2009 ) <4  )) ( 28 )2010) , #))( Windsor , 2004 ,145)
('  
# 1 
 &4!- #'  .1
 %  '! 7 . , 
44  

9 .:# Q &
'4 &  # :#7 "; .2
G/ H$  '!
7 12-  9! .%    ,! 7 - 
 .
 
. 2 @'  * ! 6  

 - " &  (

4! (
=  &'
 H  8  - @
  .3
. = 
; &  (# &6  &
! !    *7 G/ 

. 
  % .:,  , "9 ./0 H/ .4
.6+ =
6 
  % *+ , (# * .
  .5
!  ( 
M 7 # 
#2 :9 
 0  7 
C .
 &
' .6
&0 ( % 
#,  ' >
2 &
' H ( E % #2 
C 6 (4  #2
6   ) #2 

? *    7 
#2 
%7 * (9  
. ( 7 )2005 ) ! ) 
% 
#, 
% #2 
C - 
#2 :9
(36 )2009) *,  ??  )N: 6  (
! (
+
 (4
:   .7! 7O00
6
C ...  %  3H7 $ *2 
# ?
 *2  - G  ! .1

320
 2012/            8 
 4 

:%4  9'  ' 

# 1 
C 
#2 
C . (
M $ . &
' ! .2
6
C... 

9 .H
 &
' $ W  
C 1
 :?# $ 
 .
@!  
4   *  @  (
0!  @4  N: 
    5  N 9
 ( 256 )2010 )  , 3 # ) : 6 (

= (
    ( , )    IF
:  6 (   
?  >, @  .1
. =  %  "9    ,7 
 # #7 -
. O, 
? * 
 
7 ? +4  
/ & -
.(
  % ( 
 .'   42 R &# ?  *
2 
+4 -
:   7 
?  >, @  .2
E6 .
 <+ "9 )'0 % )
 # % )@ ,7  )
2 ' .7! -
) <4  ) ) (80 N52) 2008) ! ) : 7 0  G   % ( .!  I @ 
: (34 )2006 ) (
 ) ) (74N53 )2009
.&  H/  @, 

  (% *
 
=9' ? "9 .1
.+7    %   .7!  F
  ! R7 

 
2 &+7 &# .2
. 

H/ # & 0!
 : <9 ( 
'  "   
! (

4! (
F > .3
6
C .. "; &  6 $ I2  ' 
2 @4 
'! & 
. .42 4!  '7 .4
E  ? # 
#2 :9 
?  .4 .T2 ( =6 *0  ! .5
.0 @   E   *
4  ?
 1 <?'  .4 ($ ! .0
.   7
. :7 
?       % 
+4 
  % *+ , : " .6
  .7! "24 0! @
$ ?    6%   6+ .=
6 
+
! " .7
.  (
 (
=
 !  
' .:,; 
*=, !=% = 
    5  *
*%  5 , ,>
!, *  *  *,




7:  ?  *@
 *A
  . &
' )  ?
!  =
  4!  B >    
5  •
"9 / H- "9 / 
 # % / '0 # % / >? : @ - E &6 (
(
6
C ... / ' ,! / 
F 2 "9 / (? :7 3!;
"9 / @ - E &6 (   . &
'       +' *  . 5  •
.:,;  ! "9 / ?  / 
  % "9 / (' #   *
 / ('
6
C ... / (
! 12- .
F ? 4! / 
  % 6+ .=
6  % ( #

321
 2012/            8 
 4 

E  !4 (# F . , "

  (4
:    % ,
* C
 1 8 N 9
.
: 7 (H0 (
=  !  .
9' @!
 !4    
 . ,4 
 . , .! : 9=
     % ,
* C
 1 8 .1
( 
4 !) 2011) ! ):  . , E 0 #  ? #
   *?  
#   ! .' ( # .  : *! &7  -
&  ( 
04 
 .9 ' 2004 &#  !4 
% .$ . '7 
? (
.
  , #  *# G/ .
,
7 .? ( #, >9  :  E  -
. 
%7 
 
# # 
 W0$ ( !

 (4
 - 
 .# 
  ( !   M, :  '  -
. 
%7 
 =
6  =# 
37 42  ) 
4! 
C  6 1993 &#  W6 .M2 : 
 
2  -
6' .:,; ?
  .
2 R9 #  H (  !  !4 #
. 
7 
#,7 
%7 .
/ O' ) ?  #9   9 >  ,
&  #  %    
! . , 6 :
=     % ,
* C
 1 8 .2
: 7 0 )   ! ? #  7  !4
 !4 *! &7 
% ( (36)  (6) (
 &4! =
 W6 @
, : (D A( •
& .! 7
O  .2 ) 2007  (35) &% ('  
#   2004 &# *
.=
 !$ 2005 &# %  6# 2004  (55) &% -  6+ 
9
(4 )  (52 ) * @, 6+ =
6      @ 3,  % 9  , '
# +

 
 
! I2 
   '4 
 E42  .7! ( '!   
>9 H (  7 & F  
2 "6 
'! ? H/ =? %# 3$
.   >
,  % (  
 &+7 @,
 E !=7  * HS 

 3
.+  2004  (57) &% % @, ( (2 @4 .M2 : *
 *$
 •
.7! > .+ # "2; 6+ 
F .
 > 
% ,    ) 4
  .7! (# &'  
' H ( 6+ =
6 > ( ? & *: 
 
.  .+
 
4! = .F 
  % 
% (# F  , 6 : 
   * •
 , 
+   ) 2004  (77 ) &% - @, 6
4M & 1924 &# .M2$ ) 
H ( %7 +
+ G/ 
 <9- 
4! .
  '
% . 4!
.   !4 G/ :- &

'  
%  

322
 2012/            8 
 4 

4 !7 (  

# 
+ . '!   :
  
    E 7  
>9 ( 7 )  .,   # 42M   2
 '! 4  (4 ) O
! 


 42 W 4   
 I2$  2003 &# (  4
7 H!7  : +
  4  .2  % (  >, 6 
&  *
, @
 ? .  ! 

 . ,  % ( " ' ) , 6  *? '  (  C ! 
%
E (
( ) &  (
' .,  # ? #   !4 (# F 
#
O
# 00    )   O
# 
0    "  ) 
 
2  . ,
 .4 2F O' E ) 2010 &  7  2  
  
: (1),   
4 (CPI)
(1)  !
 ! 
 2010 \2009 
    1 ,
$C

2010 2009 
5   5    5   5    !
  10 *
  10 *

1 19 7.7 1 22 7.0 

2 29 6.3 2 30 6.5 1
)
3 41 5.3 3 39 5.5 *

4 48 4.9 4 46 5.1 *%
5 50 4.7 5 49 5.0 *)
6 50 4.7 6 63 4.3 
7 54 4.5 7 66 4.1 1,
8 59 4.3 8 65 4.2 ;
9 85 3.4 9 89 3.3 5I

10 91 3.2 10 111 2.8  
11 98 3.1 11 111 2.8 "

12 105 2.9 12 111 2.8 AD

13 127 2.5 13 126 2.6 
14 127 2.5 14 130 2.5 * 
15 143 2.3 15 130 2.5  

16 146 2.2 16 130 2.5 

17 146 2.2 17 154 2.1 *


323
 2012/            8 
 4 

18 172 1.5 18 176 1.5 *

19 175 1.5 18 176 1.5

20 178 1.1 20 180 1.1 !
"
2010 )  !4 
  .2:

 2009 

\ 0 (4 (
% * H 62 &  .! # WH#$ # 
:   =,M &%  
! .
# # O: .
 
   . , . ' ) 2010 
 \
 ) 
%7 . 7 *! ) ( F ) 
7 
 '
7 
 E ) : 6
( 4 )2011) 
!
) (  E  
 *
  F ) 
!
, (1,1 ) # !  )  O
2 
  04 =%   Q9
(1) , (
 # 6+ 
2
! ( O
 180   ! 2009 &#  ., (10) <, (
) @
 3  2010 &# , 3   ) 
  (
( 
7 ) (20)   ) 
. 
  (
( 
7
( ( >  
7  % ) 18  O
 176    , (1,5) # !  
. 
  (
@
  >,  7 2010 &# , 3  ) 2009 &# 
  (

(1) , (. (175)   # ! O
  (19)    
7    
   Q 

 6+ 
2 W, O
# 04 .4 (# .; ?%   $ #   Z
  (
5,5 ) 6,5 ) 7 ) ., # .! 
  . ' @ # .!    !
) 
 (4  # (# .7 ?% ( 4 2010 &# ( 5،3 ) 6,3 ) 7,7 )  2009 &# (
&# ( )41 )29 )19 ) @ 2009 &# O
 ( 39 )30 )22 ) @ O
#  # ( 3 )2 )1
&,! ' M (
'  (
  
2 6+ (#  2 (9 6+ =
6 
2 4. 2010
2009/2008 . $ 
 ( 7,5 ) ! .+   7  :, *  7
: W (2) , Q9 4 *=  *+ 4 @! #+
(2)  !
2009/2008 @  1D  36 
    J +8
 !
4 %
%    7  &,! *= \ *+ &$
.
53,33 
 4 < 1
13,33 
 1 :  4 2
7,16 (
 510 ? 3
2,95 (
 210 ' 4
2,81 (
 200 
 5

324
 2012/            8 
 4 

2,11 (
 150 *, 6
2,11 (
 150 +4 E  
 7
1,69 (
 120 (47 #7 8
98 (
 70 .77 9
77 (
 55 /  10
70 (
 50  !   &
 12
70 (
 50 @ 2 9
 12
70 (
 50 ! 13
56 (
 40  14
42 (
 30 #+ 15
44 (
 30 
=  16
28 (
 20 ( # 17
14 (
 10 . H 
 =
 18
14 (
 10 !
 =
6 19
7 (
 5 
 20
7 (
 5 
#,7 (F2  21

Palestine www.aman )     >% ) R  # :! : 

.    6+ =
6 34 # #7 @yahoo.com
2  I   
# !  
   , ,
 W6 
2
!
 !4 (# F . , O9
 W4F  6   *
!  >
, 
 (?4
 
W6 ( 04 '  
C       (9 >' (2) , Z= 
? :4 $   .=? 
,M .2 &
 $ .H7 ' ( 
M *! U 
. 6
C ..
.! @    ?2 (9     
4! .#?' >
, ( Q9
  
.+ (
 
 
C    ( 4F
6 )  - &,! ( %98 N %2,11 (

.+ >
,  
     ($ N 6 
9 G @,   
4! =
. ,  6  :  6$ (    *
04 .7F 0
% 6   
4! =
. , E .4 (
 \ (7 !  
M   # Z= 6  )    !4 (# F
I+ 6 \ . W6 (# (F W,    # .:,7 6 \  6 4 &

325
 2012/            8 
 4 

 6 6
C ... 
  %  @
7 .
 .:,7  %  
 &7 W6
.'!7 !? &

   *
%  
    :  /%


; *!   ?
? .
 R, I # "% *; "= ( &  #  %
  
 *; 
 ( :+, 
  % ($   ) 6$ 
'! .
 E 
 I
&# (9 .' E 
2     % ( R - >
+ 

 
07 .'
..
 (
'  
 ;   *6 2 
+ > $  

+ *
4 
6$ 
 W  Q $ '
 % .=
6 .! &%$ # . ? .+ =
 , 7 @?
  .F
?? (# .!7 . 7 

9 
4! 
C 
4! .4 # !  42$ 4
:
A @, %  <9 6 
6-

  % 
  
 
! - (
  & "
:
   8
7)
 
%  % 0
6! )(
, ! 
  % ($ I  .%  
,  %  4
  ,4 
  % (
 0 
,  % 0
- )(
  %) F
 % (
  ?  E6 ($ - '
'!  )  
4! = 4 
%  % 

, #  #  
,  %   ) ?2$  4 E6 ($ $ 
,  % 

 % ?2   4 +
4 E6 (4 4 *
4 
# W6 .4 4 F 
  % 
#
, 3
% ($ # ) , .% 
 (# H9    8!   .7,  
,
.
,  %   .=
  % ( 
  % & &

' #  

#
1
2 ('!)  :- (
 ?? (
* '  M 
  % .# '
)?? 
 # @  
!
! .:,;  &0 ).
 
4 
/ H ( . 7
)1992 )<2) *2 ?
! E 
 .
/ " ?   (
07 $  :-
 ,  % ( &  E"  M 
  %  

4 ! 4 
2
 (Acc4ksa.com) (153
>  % ' 
#2 ( 4M )
; 
! 
 . H (9 "  '
(4  #- Z= I 3
% #9 ?? 
 Z= ' * (
' &4!-
(89 )2008 )6+)  , .!7 @ $  :- .7  7 '
'! " 
?? 
? # * 

 *?
 .
# 6 
  % &  ( (') 
2



 
 .'   6 (  6$ 
'! (9
   *F4 * 
)')  !
! +H ., >9 .%; .7, ? 
! 
 6 )
2 
(6 )2008

326
 2012/            8 
 4 

# 34
 &  # ! 
6$ ( 
  % 
6$ +  :
   
(_  
  ,  
4! = .+ :$  % (   0 

   ! *#
   
, ( 4M 
 
! 
! ( ) # * (
' .'  + I

6$ , 4 )
  $ " ( 
 .
 " (9 .
; 
!  
E 1  ' " ,$ ( 4M >
2 
    
%7 
! ( 
  %
 4 
F &  # W
0M M? , !
 
' 
! ( ; *:4 >
2
Q= (
' ' :?- E # 9 . ' 
!7 K/ @#H $ :?-
..

'0 24 *
? 
#,7 G- ( !  &6- 
  V 
#,7 
! (  
6$ $
.(91N90 )2008 )6+) &  !  
*2  "9 *' ?' 
! &

' .
#   
6$ &# 42  % 
  % ($ 4
+,    
!    "9 ?'   ! R' 6  
 F $
!, @, E ' H ( .F E # ?2  *' ?' &
 (# H9 )?' E
. 4 # ! :- (! (9  F  = 4 
= ,    0  
 
,  =
>  "

4 ! 
  % 34
( *; 
 6 
 
 
, =
 .
/ > Z  .
 .:,; ??
N: 6# 
4 
/ H
.    (? "24 .
.

/2 *:4 (
! .@
.

/ * 
 ..
.(TQM) 2 *, *V4 0
! *; ? 
?  *# .
.:$ *:4 04$  ,
   (4$   2 .8

 (  ! ) #)  :,$  
; .  *  >
+ *# .R
.
# .! .
 (# 2 .
 , % (4
 9M  6$ 
'!   
  = !
 .H42 .+- 
' .^
..%
."6- W, W+!  &' 3
% ( *; (4 3

' 

 
 .
 !  .
/ >   I  ?2- G  *  %  ?? &

' .
(7N6 )2006 )(J 
) .=

(
) (95N92 )2008 )6+) 
,% 1 C
  
    8
 &( 7  
(8 )2004 )
  %

327
 2012/            8 
 4 

(
' <  
 . H 
  % $ =H ( . 0 ) - 
! N
.- Q=
.;  %7 - & (! (9 N
.
+
   '    ! (# 
4! .
!H  8 &# (9 N
.
 #- .:, 
? (
! 9- :-  
4! *+ ,- 
, #  N
- (
' 
? H ( '!  % >9 4! + , . ! 
%  % N
..
; 
 , & ; 1 
 .

 % 9 . , 
 <9- #- Z= ' 
' .
 &='  $ :  N
+4 '
'! 34 * 
! - #' 
' . ?   .4   (

.?2 ,
 *' 07 =# 
.* (
' &4!- ' :- &
'  % N
.

 
 $ (  
 
! .7,   ( &
' N
.
% 
! 

 - #' 

? >9  6 N

!    
! 
4! *+ ,- ( ! . $ .! $ :?$ $ (# "24 N
. ,   $
   ($ (4

  % (  <$ E6 : (>  5 
   < 7 
 #)  
  % &
' (4

# ) % 4 
, . , 
%7 .F .!
: ( 39N2010،38)  

  %   6
 &'
 *! 
 . 4 
% 1! $ :    71
   @6  ?' 
 .H # @ 7 
  % ( 4 
, )*! E 
:, 
  % "
 4
  (

' (
!     E *! ?2 " E (

! 

 
 (   % .
# #, (9
&  
  % 
2" 

  ' (752 ) 2004)(
!  !7) "*M2   
 (! 9 *;  9
 K/ .7! @#H ";   .7! 

9 #   
  % ( "

  1! 
% ( )   
 +H . ? .' 4  ?2 (4 ! $ 
.
 (
' ' (4
"
 4 &
 
?   9
 *! :$ # ?

"
 ?    '
9 !  (4 "   
% (
,) I$ 
% . , &' % )*
+
, '# 4 
%   
  % (
 .=
6 &
% E 0 
+4 .
, $ !
( '! )
 
6S   $ 7 "$ (150)   /  (4  
 !;  % :2;
.!;  .
 ?2 .
- ' ? I

328
 2012/            8 
 4 

&
' &
7  % ( < 6  
  % $ 
   %  :%@   72

' > ? . '!H  % ,
  4 ( 12/31  $ H  0!  7 
 .
:  6 '  % W6 &
' (4
 
 . !  $ :  # +4
 !
! $
 :+,  2
 F  
 4
 ($ $  = 4 2 :.  7
& K @4 *
- .  .+ 4
6  "
9$ 4 
  % @2 &%$ .


 % (4 (# H9 . % <$ 4 3 
  % ( '  
 
2$ 4 )*+ 4 
(%100) 2 
% H ( E 
; .!  ?2 
 # 
 *; (
# 

.@#H K/ .7! :?S 4  "24  F
 ?2
 
% 9 
; *! ?  7 
, 
% .=
6 &  ( (4 : .  7
)6+ =
6 )
  % (
) .=
 W6 ( 

2 .?  6
' &' '  
 .F :$ ?2 #  % 9
$ &' 
 
C I$ . , E6 (
   %
6 . , W6 ( * .
 - (
'  
 4 &  6
 I # "%
+! 
,  %  
  % , ( - '
'!  ( >,  % )
2  %)
 (4 ($ # 1!  >,  % >  4  .:, ??   
4 &
 42  Z= 9$ 
'! 0  . % 
4! .! 
 # (4
. % ( <- W6 ( >
, (# 
7 )  H  2F
E 
%7 .#?'
# I . 
,  %  
+ 
  % E6 (4   $ - G   9 4

H &
" "9 ?' ./0 ., 4 (  >,  % , > 
  :- (
.. % E .?2 &+H
&=(4
% *
*,
, 6 
 @ ) ( 
 E

   D

( *'
: (2004،6 )
#)  <4 >( &A    &%) &2   %   
. !4 .$
.

 
#, - =2  6 .@
.
 &  # ! (9
   @
C !  _ ` .8
)?? Z  
  4!  E
24   . E  &'   2 
 .
Z (
! ? 9$ # " (! 4 +4 .
)   & &

'

? 4 .=
 # 
%   
 . 
!  .
 Z 
.(www.openbudgetindex.org)
.G  & 9 W, .#, - E ? 9 4! ? #  %4 ? 97 & 
'! .$
.(; '! 
! .@

329
 2012/            8 
 4 

  @! & #  % & # @!  %  : ,)   73
4 .%  ,  %7 '!
 G/   
  
! Z  
% 

. 4 %  ? ( (4
 %M  ? Z=   
?) :( :.4 1   
,% <     1J' &2  8   !
 7 
.
(ISSAI(400) )=7) (2010N2006 )

34
 
4! . ,  
2   .  .% 
? 
6M 

 Z  % .1
.    
,; :- #
> F?  *6 , Q
(
+
 *M4 +! %  .
 G .2
.(
+, (

& 
? . ? .
!  4 E 6 &C 
,4 ( *7 "9 
 
- .3
.
2   !
.. Q
! ?? 
    % #$ :-  ?
? "9 .4
(4
 !$  F
.
2 (
' G  
+4 .
, .
 
? &# .5
.    H (
.
!H G
  .
!H " *: Q9 42 
; 
 .
!H 
! &# .6
.4  # *  &
 3
 12$ 
F
 - .F &  
 .,
!H 

' + #  
 3- @
C .7
.  ,! 04$ I$ .F (! 9= 
 .
 H/ : 
?2 .H,  24 . (#    .!H 
, 
  %   "9 .8
..H, > *- ' ? &# 2F  .7!   
4! .!
.. 0 $ &
' .
- 4 # <H?7 H ( 
% 
#  +H 
  
  &# .9
' .'   0   (

4! (
 G I &# 42  # 1' .10
.
 -
.- (
' .
 &+7 &# !  # . ' G : @
C. 11
6 4$ %  % .:, @, G  % "9  . .,   W6 (
&
' 
'  6
2M &  .2F .!H H ( 
  % (
 ' "9
 ( 20082007)
  % (
 
') .  
  % (
  % (  = :-
( # 
 & ' 2008  2007 . .#?' " 
  % (
  % ( .
(7 ! Z & = E 
  % .:,  "9 E6 ( (
  .2F .!H
:6

?/ &' :$ *:4 &

' (9
 
  % &% .?2   4 ? , Q9
& .1
.*! .?2 4 2

% 4 Z ,
7 4 )
; *! .?2 4

330
 2012/            8 
 4 

 
%  % .:,; .+  .

   
%  % &%   &# .2
."9 *' ?' # "%  42      <
  4 "9 (# Z 
4! = &  
%  % .:, "9 .3
. .7! 2  &6
%  -  % ,
4M 
 (, , &# " E  1

   0 ., # *?
 "9 .4
. 
!H I (
E 
 
C 
42 , .
# &
! .,  , .
#  
, @
C .5
. H .
2 9 > '  . , &=% # #7
 G  * 
0  
!  
+  (+ @
$ .:,; &67 % .6
.   
#  8!  


4
?' 
 . 1! 
% # 
4! = &  
  % &  +
4 .7
    % (# 
 
; *! @2 &%$ .?2 & ,
 -
.
2 . ,7  " $ .
 ? # >,2


?
!7 .- 
! ( 
  .:, 
 .! #  % .:, "9 .8
).7
! ( 
 4 < 
 &=H (4 
  
9 .+
.
 
, K # #7 &# 6+, @?  ? > .+ E '

' +H 
6- :H
 
  % &%$ .!H .
, 
 .; G &6 &# .9
*
' *=+ .'!  M " 
!$   
C  % .! .; W6   )  % ( #
+; # :@# 42 
6) !  
9 G @,
WH#$ 
  % (
 
'  "9 ' @, H (
  2 2 >
! % "9 
 ,
7 4 
  % .:, ($
% 
 +
7 4 
C 
  % .:, ( 6 
  
9  % (  
.  2 2 Q
 "9
  42$  #$ "  % *+ ,$  :
    *
% 
     ' 7  
 % &4!-   .$ =  8!    , ( .4  .
/ "6- 
'!
:    !4
7 (
' 
?   #  %  +
4 ($
!  
 #-  >
2 .1
..

.
  % *+ ,$ :$ (
!  &   
  % .2
.
,4 .? > &,
? 4 =
 ; 
? .3

; 
 . 4 .
 - (
' 
? H ( 
' 
9- 
 .4
.
2 . ,7 &,! '
 

331
 2012/            8 
 4 

.R9 
2 $  # .5
.

 .
 4 @#H 
 
C 
 :?- (# :  ! = 
 .6
.
, & 
 *0 
,4 .? > @
  % @
$ =
! .7
.0
! 
4 @
- 

!  % = 0
!

  % (
  % ( 
  % & 
# &

'  7 *9 # !  4F

 N8
"9 (? 
! &
 &

' 1! # 

 :9 # # $
6#  H?7 ?'  
  2 2  F  
4! .! 
  % *+ ,$  ./0 '
= & # &

'  #7 &
 
% .:, ? 
! % &'
 
# : 
 ) 
' )
4 1 ) (
7 6 
%  *  @
-
. ! & 1! )( ?=) 

 ?=
Z= ($ ,
! &

'  
#9 1' 6 
= @
#  >, = W6 >
, ($ ( &C
'
?   E 97 6 &

'  (
7 & ($ ,  7 )
=2 
  #  
&

'
) *! -  %  ! & 1= & +  (9
 =-  ) .! "
7 :H .! ( ) * 
% 
# 4 
, Z :2 (# % /

! .% 

?  
7  6 ) * 
% .:, ( :+,4 
 (

!  '
? # (9

  (
7   
  % & 
 # &4!  
#9 
'! (4
4 . I-
(179N175) 2010 ) a #)   1. <   L>    W &
% .
?#$


!  % ' E   <2  
  % & ! 4 2 (
 &
 N1
.
# % $ #7

 <% @, )  ( 4 &

' 
# 
 (7) $ (& ) =- >
, (#  ,; (4 ($ *# N2
. I$ 
! ( 2 ( ,7) &4!

&
' (4 6 ( . 
% .! <2 # 
?   .7,  (
7 &
' N 3
 I$ # R   (
7

.  
% 6:?# &!

 
6-
! ( 
  % .7, . N4

. 9
$  
% 6:?# &!

 , 4 (9 =S 
 
6- . N5

&' 6 

' &
' W6 . 44 
  % 

' &
'  #,  (4  , 4 
% &
% 
!
<2  
  % 
 , # &4! (
7 ,
 (? ) *? 
 &
' 
 @ 

4 
% .!

332
 2012/            8 
 4 

(&  ,7) *' ?' *7  ,

100× = % & 

 ,



' &
'
,  =- W6 .  ) F 4 *' 
' 
! 6 6 
= 42 '  6 >
(+- (

  % 2 &4!  <, 6 E  
 ) 
% 
! (  
6$
&
' ( 
 I 
($ % 9 ( ) (
7 # @
 6 (
7 =- 
1 ( I 6 (4
' . 
 
6$ > F 4 *' 
' @
! (
7 =- (?')
=S *
4 &
' ?
! 3  1 ( $ 5  1 ( 10  1 ( $ 50  1 ( $ 100 
.  % 
# 
 
 
6- .

  !% :/  /%

 >% # 60$ 
  % " 
 .'? #   ,   
E Z=      ( ?; 6  ) , # 
?   
 % 
# 3
% &0 ( :'7 * &  ,  % & &
' H ( .%H
.# 
C & , $  % & , &# G 
+ @#H K/ 
 &=' 
 %
    (  6+ =
6  % ( *2 .:!; 
' 
2 :/%  E


  
 :, E ) ,    6 ( %70 ) 42  !   &
 *+ 
 &
 *+   '
 ., (  ,  ) !   '
? @, (4
,  
4 (23) (
( 
4 (18)   , = 
 &)    ! 
(40)  ( (0!  (4 * (50) >
+ & !  
# ( (%82) 42  
,  (
! ( %30 . !  % ( %70 0 
 .! $ % %80   *
:- H ( E & .
9 ! ( '! " Z= > &, .  ,
 &0 (.
$ 6 $  :A 
? # " # ! 6 "
: 1I
-.$  &" :)
: 
A .' H ( E (
7 ! (9 "9 *% 42  .
/ (2  
#
,     .:,; I! 
! # &'  ( < 6 (9 $ I! 
! N1
Z=   H (  W (
 ! >%  .,   "  % , 
. % &  ' .:,; W6 I! 
! &0 ( !? =- $ .  
G/ 
 @,  

=  !   (
7 * # & :(
7 * N2
: 
A .'  !  G  7 
? 
 = (# # . (9
- (
$+,  7 .! : *  ) +
 B ,
&" .$
0 :+, $ ) 
! )
%  ! ,  *  . # (9 &
 .#+
 % 
 *:4 3
' - 1
(


= (
!  .:,  (
7 =$ ! (9


333
 2012/            8 
 4 

0 ! $  !  @, 7 @,  .%  % .:,; & ,
., . !  
 . # *?
 
  % 
 *:4 3
' 1

:7 #$ & ' *7 
!  :*  ) +
 !% 5  .5
& 
# , 3
%  
  % (
  % (  '
? &
 '
? # !  #$ 7
.64   
  %
&
' 
'  2  ,7 (#  7 
#9 
'! =!7 @7 # !  # N
:( /%   ? 14 & & % 

'

7  & E  % &  
 , 3
% .1
(&  ,7)* ?' *7  ,
100× NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN= % & 
 ,


' &
'
.. ,; <, ( (
 
/ . ,;   (
 :
= @ .2
.(
 
/ # . ,; ? G : ! ? .3
 7 =-  (+- (
  2 &4!  7 =!; (Z)@$ & .4

:  !"   @ 14 .   :1 2    . MA  !% :  

(# '  *  (
=   
' &  *  . (3) , Q9
:*  . # N1
*  &
 
 $ ( %70   ($ (
  15 (# 
+ *  . # 
0  15
 
  
 *   # 
6  %  ! ,   15 (# 
+
!  
# $
+. 1 (3)  !
15 * D +. 1 5% 15 * ! +. 8 *

 
<


  
%  %  % 
%30 5 %

12 66.7 8 33.3 4
5

%70 28 71.4 20 28.6 8



%100 40 %70 28 %30 12

 6F ' !  
# $ >
+ (4) &% , Q9
: 6F N2

334
 2012/            8 
 4 


# 
# H6F (4

 $ >
, ( Q9
  
! ' .= 0H0  
 >
+ &
  &  %90 
, * 2 %2,5 

4- * 2 ! 42
  %  ! , 
.
= 
,  ('! &6 %7,5 


 !(C
 (4)  !
A
   
 !(C

%2,5 1 
%  !
36
%90 3
4
3
%7,5    & 
%100 40
+
= . =  =. =       ;  :     
    ;  .3
:  ) O2  *  )
()  ! 7 
,  % .:,7 & - ! 4 F (24) *7 .! .$
. !  
 . # *?
 
  % 
 *:4 3
' 1
 0 ! $
.((+ ).7' ).9 ' )@ ).) 6 ,
=S  @- 
! 4 &

' 
# 
 (7)  (& ) =7 #  ,; *# &
.4 @- 
4 (9 !? =S 
 
6- . 
 
6-
! (  % .7, .  .@
4 

' 
' 0 (60) 6 &
' W6 <, (3N1) (
 >'  
% 6:?# & ' ,
.,

  .  * 4 
# , 3
% & .8

? 
=   @! (40) 6# U  * .7 # WH#$  
?  .

# , ./ ' 0 ! $ %48,433 6 & - ! 
# , ($ (
  !

% ? E6 ($ 
6  ,  % & "9  
2
 6 %36,375 6
& ( N ) 6 
9 G @,

6 W2$ # #
  #   0F
 , 

9  % (  ( ! H ( (4
 
# +
 , 
  %
. (,   2 2 >
! *
4 
# + 7 
  % & () 
 
1'  "9 H (
% 
7 @7 +
+ :(
7 =- (+7 (

   .4
6 
% 
%  %    # :/7 (4
7  2 &4! &# &

'  
#9
4! &
@% (  % 
 , &

'  = = 
#9 (4
($ (4
7 '
? &#

335
 2012/            8 
 4 

( 4M 4!  7  7 =7  (+- (

  , 

' 
' 
!  2
> (z) ,
 ' &  
?   =!7 (z)@$ & & 
#9 ( , 
% 
7 . %H# ,7)6 
9 G   
, (  4$  M Q9 ( 1.96 ) 
, 
'
= B 
) *,

 $C
  ) 6 7  7 =-  (+- (

  
=!
 (+S  
 &  

' &
' ( 6  2  !  (       ; 
"9 ! 1
2    (
7 * # (4

# 
#9 ( , 
%
(6) (5) (
,   
4  ,  
  % *+ ,- '
*(5)  !
*  ) +
)   .) MA  3 
 &%)  %  )  ,  1 D 



 &%)  
MA  Z 
 ,  1
 3 
   , 
1.6457898 1.96 3.60579 0.877 1.5 2 85 34 1
0.9147979 1.96 2.874798 0.77 1.65 2 80 32 2
3.7635795 1.96 5.72358 0.221 0.8 1 95 38 $3
1.1632372 1.96 3.123237 0.405 0.8 1 90 36 @3
3.7635795 1.96 5.72358 0.221 0.8 1 92.5 37 83
4.0473664 1.96 6.007366 1.316 0.75 2 32.5 13 4
6.6918865 1.96 8.651887 0.962 0.684 2 60 24 5
10.104915 1.96 12.06492 1.245 0.625 3 22.5 9 6
12.445615 1.96 14.40562 1.109 0.474 3 50 20 7
13.89713 1.96 15.85713 1.037 0.4 3 35 14 8
5.519088 1.96 7.479088 0.997 0.821 2 57.5 23 9
11.254524 1.96 13.21452 0.783 0.364 2 42.5 17 10
5.8519507 1.96 7.811951 1.012 0.75 2 95 38 11
8.587373 1.96 10.54737 0.981 0.364 2 77.5 31 12
4.6338186 1.96 6.593819 1.01 0.947 2 82.5 33 13
7.0544745 1.96 9.014475 0.877 0.75 2 55 22 14
3.7265519 1.96 5.686552 1.368 1.77 3 30 12 15
8.857369 1.96 10.81737 0.877 0.5 2 65 26 16
7.0084609 1.96 8.968461 1.519 0.846 3 17.5 7 17
8.12165 1.96 10.08165 0.941 0.5 2 30 12 18
4.2002264 1.96 6.160226 1.501 1.538 3 25 10 19
9.435638 1.96 11.39564 1.327 0.609 3 17.5 7 20
7.4860469 1.96 9.446047 1.163 1.263 3 30 12 21
11.071364 1.96 13.03136 1.092 0.75 3 20 8 22

336
 2012/            8 
 4 

11.99178 1.96 13.95178 0.67 0.522 2 55 22 23

N N
1.96 0.911 0.455 3 15 6 24
19.62849 17.6685
Excel Z & @! ., # #7 (
0!  # ( (8) (7) (6) (5), *
(6) !
*  ) +
)   .) MA  3 
 &%)  %  )  ,  1 D 
" .
MA  


 
  
 
 ,  1
  .) *D
   , 

14.332503 1.96 16.2925 0.677 0.256 2 30 12 1
8.479412 1.96 10.43941 0.893 0.526 2 62.5 25 2
14.559361 1.96 16.51936 1.005 0.375 3 52.5 21 3
9.041334 1.96 11.00133 1.305 0.73 3 60 24 4
9.430124 1.96 11.39012 0.854 0.462 2 55 22 5
3.9583339 1.96 5.918334 1.012 1.053 2 35 14 6
7.581355 1.96 9.541355 0.928 0.6 2 22.5 9 7
10.430966 1.96 12.39097 1.225 0.6 3 50 20 8
13.820982 1.96 15.78098 1.04 0.405 3 37.5 15 9
10.278092 1.96 12.23809 1.231 0.618 3 17.5 7 10
13.587365 1.96 15.54737 1.054 0.409 3 25 10 11
7.581355 1.96 9.541355 1.392 0.9 3 47.5 19 12
11.983023 1.96 13.94302 1.134 0.5 3 15 6 13
4.2588351 1.96 6.218835 1.017 1 2 60 24 14
8.666682 1.96 10.62668 0.885 0.513 2 42.5 17 15
8.449457 1.96 10.40946 0.898 0.522 2 52.5 21 16
7.6314839 1.96 9.591484 1.39 0.892 3 17.5 7 17
8.857369 1.96 10.81737 0.877 0.5 2 67.5 27 18
9.236371 1.96 11.19637 0.862 0.474 2 15 6 19
7.2448464 1.96 9.204846 0.942 0.629 2 37.5 15 20
14.559361 1.96 16.51936 1.005 0.375 3 22.5 9 21
7.9984007 1.96 9.958401 1.368 0.846 3 52.5 21 22
3.982955 1.96 5.942955 1.011 1.05 2 62.5 25 23
21.310374 1.96 23.27037 0.761 0.2 3 7.5 3 24
: ) MA   !"     !%  !@. *
: !%    75
,   % .:, ( (7) &% ,   
4 7 ! (
 Z= 
2 .$
Z= ./ '  !  @,  %56,767 6 e @, 7   (  

337
 2012/            8 
 4 

  7 =$  .!? &  @,  % ./0 

 ( 
6 ( %43,2336
;   ,   H ( ! &
!   +H ! >9   @,

3) %
 *D
  %  )  ,  1 D  (7 !)

  

 ,  A4 1
*D
   , 
0.877 1.5 2 85 34 \, 

 ?
 ,
1
&%- (
.
F .7 
! &

0.77 1.65 2 80 32 2
\(

.
 Q
 
 N$ :(
 &
' &

0.221 0.8 1 95 38 3

# '
*  !7 
N@ :(
 &
' &

0.405 0.8 1 90 36 53
7
0.221 0.8 1 93 37  ! 
' 
N8 :(
 &
' &
Q3
 !  ('
(
 ( >,

1.316 0.75 2 33 13 4
\*!  $ *,!
-  E
7
!  (
 (
 ,

0.962 0.684 2 60 24 5
\ F ' 7 2 " "
&
  (
 (
.H' 4! :, &

1.245 0.625 3 23 9 . 3 ( 04$ '

7
! @2 F 6
\  
@2 F 
  (
 (

 & ,

1.109 0.474 3 50 20 
  
*+,V &  $ >
#
! 7
\*:4 3   * #
  2  04  (
0 (
 % .H ,
1.037 0.4 3 35 14 8
\ &'

 9 
# (F 
 * # @! 4
0.997 0.821 2 58 23 (
! (
'!
F " E6 7 9
\.
M W6 ( 7
 
4 
 .  : =
0.783 0.364 2 43 17 10
\
4 I <
1.012 0.75 2 95 38 . .
 
  (  ! &
 11

338
 2012/            8 
 4 

 %  ,   

% + ,
0.981 0.364 2 78 31 
% &  # "4 "2- 
% 12
\.
4 ,   %
, *  W
'  % >

1.01 0.947 2 83 33 13
\O
 2

  % . &   ?  ,
0.877 0.75 2 55 22 K/ "24 >  F

! 
, 14
\.!7
> . !  % (
( E6
1.368 1.77 3 30 12 15
\, 1 &    
 4  
H'7  % >

0.877 0.5 2 65 26 16
\*+
 
C  
  
!  %
F 
%  %  4 # %
1.519 0.846 3 18 7 "24 (# & /2
! &  , 
+  17
\.!7 @#H :?7

 
# .H6F 
%  % 4 >

0.941 0.5 2 30 12 18
\3H7 @#H :?7 "24 ( & 4
 .!7 . U
( " E6
1.501 1.538 3 25 10 19
\
 
%  Q 
( 
 . ,

; 
 .
 (
' 
1.327 0.609 3 18 7  F
7 42  '
? (4

! !9 20
\&  6
 !  ,  @! &
1.163 1.263 3 30 12 21
\
 . .!7 (# "24 4
.! $ +   
4 
 &=' 
'
1.092 0.75 3 20 8 22
\
!  .
 &%-  . '
H ( &  #  % ! &

0.67 0.522 2 55 22 # + .

 
 &+7 23
\.
:?- ! >   # 
 % &%
0.911 0.455 3 15 6 24
 M 7
O $  24 .!7 K/

339
 2012/            8 
 4 

\64 >  !
! +H .:,;

=" . =  5 
  3> (8)  ! 

,   %
 *  ) MA  $ .5
: 4 '   
  %
 1JR
> ,  % ( 6 &
 .:,7 (  
2
6 %33,5096 7   :&"71

F &$  9
 ) , *  % ( 
4 
C " 
#  3H7 @#H K/
7N1 ( !? =7 &$ "%  , #   , M 6M ( )   $ (# ! 
. (8) &% , 
 12N8( !? =7 ( .7' 
 @,   '   ./ :1) 
  " 72
 7   6  ( , * # @, , 
   6 %18,733 6 (8) &% ,
 

= .  ( 6 3H7 @#H K/ *2 
 >'
( (4
 @, 04$
. 
4! 
/ 
4! .! .F >
,   ?' ,  3
 
,  17N13( !? =7 ( , 
% .4 9
$ 7   ( :1 2
 5  73
E6 .4
! !? =7 % @ E %7,387  %12,4@ ./ $ (8) &%
  W6 ( (
7  I7 @,  .!? %  =M4  !? ! 7 

 .:,
.I7 @,  4  , 
# "% (4
@, W6  "9 $ % E6 7
=7 (  ! (4$ (+ # 
% .:,7 @,   '   ./ :*D.
74
#   &67 @,
, 
%   6 %27,968 6 (8) &% ,  24N18 ( !?
!$ 9
$  
 &   6 
 #
9 (7  H >  ! +H .:,7 
  

= ,-
(8)  !
  %
 *D
  %  )  ,  1 D 

  

 ,  A4 1
*D
   , 
0.677 0.256 2 30 12 .1! , * 2 '0 . 1

0.893 0.526 2 63 25  % .

 
 

M  
M 2
. 
   # 
 34
"
1.005 0.375 3 53 21 G/  2 H :2 =+, &
3
..
!H (9  
1.305 0.73 3 60 24 + .
' (
 ? &# 4
"  F
, .,
!

340
2012/            8 
 4 

@   
9 
C .,
!7
.&   6
0.854 0.462 2 55 22 "2H (

 
$ $  &
5
: 
! ( 
 .  ? #
.@? 4 # "27 : 
1.012 1.053 2 35 14 - ( .+  :2 &
6
* ' ( 8 ( 
!
.
 ,
0.928 0.6 2 23 9  (  2$ 6 4 :2 (, 42 7
*+ ,S   
 
  
C 
42 6 (4
 
 
8 ( 12  % ( :2 &
%
., :9#$
1.225 0.6 3 50 20 ! #  ! &
' &
8

 #- - %  %  
!; 4 > 
 : @! #
.& H ! 12 
 #-
1.04 0.405 3 38 15 
 (, (  %   &
9
> 
 #$  &H7 "2;
.&  <
9 K/
1.231 0.618 3 18 7 $  # 2 , &' 10
4 :2 ?
 ' # #7

 : #$ !
  ? 
.
9
1.054 0.409 3 25 10 
  &
(
' (  *: &H 11

 7 
1.392 0.9 3 48 19 .
 (
'  ' 
 12
"; F
 
% (  4 U  
&  # :#7
1.134 0.5 3 15 6 +
, #M 12- 3 &'
6 13
.@ >
+

341
2012/            8 
 4 

1.017 2 60 24 &  @ #  %   E6 14


    !$  
!   

.
0.885 0.513 2 43 17 @! $ 
 
/2 #  % 15
?' @! ., # & *!


 .H, G  <, (
(8) ! & 

 , 
0.898 0.522 2 53 21  (
$ . , (
H' E6 16


 
, <
; (
='
. 
1.39 0.892 3 18 7 `,  ,  % &'
17
>
, ($ ( 4M  
'

M ( E  

< .9 '
0.877 0.5 2 68 27 (
$ (
&
 & H 9! ,
18
(
$ * # 
  0 !H   (+
.(+
0.862 0.474 2 15 6 +  * 2 
9! &
19
,  % (  ! 
+ .,
 H ( 4M 
+  &H
(+ (
$ &'
 .  ' ?
. . ! &H#V
0.942 0.629 2 38 15 , (+ F (

 ,
20
( *! .,
! 
! .
2
# 6
 9 
 .+
. 
1.005 0.375 3 23 9  
+  ! !
! (4$ ,
21
@ 
7     
 '
?
.&  6
1.368 0.846 3 53 21 
 * (+ * .H, & 22
&
 
M ( 
 
! &
 
. , ' ?  6#

342
 2012/            8 
 4 

1.011 1.05 2 63 25 :  # ' ? I$ , , 42 23


F   $ .% 
!  4
 + > +H .
 :,  #
., :  
#
0.761 0.2 3 7.5 3 &
 4! =
?     &
24
&        *7
  
 
' #$  
(# 9= % *9 
.(+ F  % ( ,!
(+- (

  
=! 7 . %H# , 7) 1  !  
9 G Q9
  
 % & 
# 3
%  
# #7 (4

% 2F   7 6 7  7 =- 
(+- (

  
=! 7 . %H# ,)6  
  
9  % ( , 


  % & 
# 3
%  
# #7 (4

% 2F   6 7  7 =- 

C  , 
  % & .
# .:,; ($ . 0$ 
'
? Z= (7 ( ,
.  ! # *M4  7 6
?  
! #  @,
  ( ! # 
4

1 "  1   )
: 1   )
$ )  =
  4!     7 (


= (
4 !  @   .1
"9  6$ (          * (# , @ M 0
 0
.
  %
&
 *+   
% 
4! = .+ >
, (M 6+ =
6 .2  :,  4F .2
.  (  +7 
*' ?' 
! &
 :'7 
4! .F 
  % & &

' 
  % .=
6 &
% .3
"24 7   .7, 12
W  
  % & &  ?2  "9
.    (?
< 
42 H ( (4 &  # ! 
4! .F "6 
'! Q
! 
, .4
 % 47 
%  
 !4 .!7 :?7 "247 ? = ) 
  %
( 
# ! 
9  "
! @#H 
 (4
  % = ( 
 9 
47
. *6 ( !
 
 6?

343
 2012/            8 
 4 

' 

 . H ( 
  % 
  % ,  
 
 4 
? .5
.7! ! 47 
%  % I  'H 
 ! 
 @! , 
.@#H
 @,  E (4 :  ( !  4 .:,e ' ,  
  % ( .6
)@ ) ") 
! .
    .:,; $ 
! 
7  %
.((+ ) .7' )

4! = .+ 
% 7 *:4 &

' 
  % (
   
% .=
 &' .7
(+7 
'  2 &4! 
@7 6 ( 7 
6$ ( &C (
7 @$ &
. ! ( 4M 
=!7 . 7 :, ( F 4 

'

:1 " 
? <?' 
4! .F 
  % & *:4 &

' 
  % .=
6 &
% *9 .1
 4!$  
#9 (4 
=!7 @
7 

7 *7 & 6 .42
..!7 :?7 ! (   ?27 4 # *?
 &4!   7

! 
7 @2 .!  (
 4 # .
F .
!H >
+ #  .2
.(
 (

  % ,
 &0 (  ? 9 '!
2 ( 

4! F   %  
  % ?2 
,  % &  (
4 E6 (4
($ @,
.3
  F %  ./0  
 .H 4 # *?
 
4$ 4 6 '!
4
7  
.
# # 
% .:,7   # $ &
 @
7   *# , *$ # @,
.4
27  (4 ($ (4
 ./0 # :9' (+ .7' @  "
 '
? @,   
'   &  @,  <, H ( E .,  
. ! 
  4  # &
>
2  #
( @,
 !,  6 
'! ( 
% . , (4 4 .5
.
 
,4 .? > "
4 *   @
"9  0 
  % 
  % I   &6   , *9 .6
. 2    (4 ( (4
  : @
C  % .:,;  ?
?

344
 2012/            8 
 4 

  "

: 5 ,: )
.@ ( : 61405)(
 , 9  $)  (  .1
..
)R!  : 1994)4  $ ( ! )+ .2
*= )% ('   + 
 #  % :2008 )+
 (# (
 )6+ .3
./ /-  ? )@ 3,  
H#;
. ),  );   , ).42 4! :2006 )? ! )(
 .4
. (-) (# ) 2 &++ ) 
  % : 2010 ) !$ ! )    # .5
.(-)2 =  )
 
 
!/ . ! 
% &#: 2010) (
$ ) a  # .6
: 

A :  
./ /
  % (
 )2004 ) @
% 
 .1
 !  % 
 *+ ,S 
  (#  !  % 
 *+ ,S 
 

 .2
www.Issai.org
4!  %  
' C
 / ISSAI (400) (7)

, :- 2010N2006 *2 
 ? N ?
? =
6 N
 
 4 .3
. 
  (? '! F 
?
: / %4:  

! 
2  )2009 )&
6  (H :- 
,   :   # :!
 )<4  .1
: ! 
4 )25 < )
 ' ! , )  ( !    ! R; 


. ) ),
F ) - 
C .
#  60$ 
 
,4 ) 2005 ) &
6   ) ! .2
. (- ) 
H
 ,  

#,7 
%7 0$  ;  )2010 )(
! !  , &4 3 # )# .3
, )%7 *; 
4 )26 < )7 & )
; & 
% , ) # +
4 >
.  ):H 4
) ( !  
47  %  )2005)  (
! ! )
 &26 ! )' .4
..& K @4 )*, *+
. +4.   *6   
2  %  ) 2009 ) ! &% ) 
# .5
.  ) (
  , /

 
'
. 79  )
 , ) *6 "
 )2008). )# .6
,  0
! .
'  )!  )<%  $ +
+  # 
 )(0# "

 )@H4 .7

  % 
 *+ ,S 
 #,    :' ) K/ (# "24

345
 2012/            8 
 4 

– 2006/5/7 ( * 
  
 , . ! +4 + , / !
.

? 
? ? /
; 
  % (
 /
0! % )2006/5/10
,  
'
?  –  ;  4 
! 3
% :2008 )(0# +C )! .8
. ) ), : ! 
4 ) 22 < )
 ' ! , )(
 RH
. !4 
  ) .4 2F , :2010 )&26) 
!
.9
: 1 ): 
. www.openbudghtindex.org 
#,7  % .1
. www.aman-palestine.orgl )2011 )R  #  )! . .2
. www.Acc4ksa.com )   @%.. .3
[email protected] ) 
2 +
+  !4 ) 6+ =
6 .4
4  "

1.- Ashford ,B.E., & Anan d1v.2003, the normalization of corruption in organization
,new York.
2.windssor, 2004, Theory of limits on corruption, N.Y
3.danida Action plan to fight corruption, 2003, ministry foreign www.danida-
publication .dk .

346