Standardization Guide 2019 PDF
Standardization Guide 2019 PDF
S·O·S Services programs must be focused on providing high quality information and
recommendations by leveraging a large fluid analysis database, support of Caterpillar
scientists and engineers, and a strong global service support network. Having a
dedicated follow-up process to deliver the results and recommendations in a timely
manner enables the customer to make critical equipment management decisions. The
combination of these qualities is what sets Cat S·O·S Services programs apart from the
competition.
There is a tremendous opportunity for growth in S·O·S Services programs. To align with
Caterpillar’s brand, promote and sustain growth, provide globally consistent and quality
results and recommendations, Cat S·O·S Services has developed a program to
standardize Cat Dealer S·O·S Services programs worldwide. The S·O·S Services
Standardization program will provide the tools necessary for an exceptional and
consistent customer experience, regardless if the customer operates in one dealer
territory or multiple, resulting in increased dealer parts and service business.
The S·O·S Standardization Program was added to the Consistency of Delivery section
of the Process Orientation attribute of the Service Excellence Program (SEP) in
2019. S·O·S Services programs are a service offered by the dealers globally and the
Standardization program provides program consistency to help ensure a common
customer experience from dealer to dealer.
Caterpillar and Cat Dealers have increased their emphasis on rental units and
Customer Support Agreements (CSA). To provide the highest returns, CSAs and rental
units must be properly maintained. A high-quality S·O·S Services program continues to
be essential for managing and lowering owning and operating costs for CSA and rental
fleets.
The implementation of this strategy has been divided into four key areas of the S·O·S
Services program.
Test Results
All S·O·S Services laboratories will be required to provide a minimum number of
specific fluid tests and results. The required test categories include: Elemental Analysis,
FT-IR, Viscosity, Water Contamination, Fuel Dilution, Particle Count and Level 1
Coolant. The exact listing of tests will be covered in a later section. In addition,
providing a consistent set of test results will help large customers and Condition
Monitoring.
Standardized S·O·S Services laboratories will also be required to check the precision
and accuracy of their instruments based off of ASTM methods, instrument vendor
recommendations, or expected variance from instrument vetting and experience. Some
of these checks will be done very frequently; others will be done on a quarterly basis.
Laboratory Operations
This is a very large topic that begins with the operation and calibration of the test
equipment. While ISO9001 will be used to ensure high quality test results, each S·O·S
Services laboratory will be required to work with ISO to establish their individual ISO
certification, whether ISO 9001 or ISO 17025.
Laboratory safety and chemical hygiene are also included under Laboratory Operations.
Occupational safety and health organizations such as OSHA in the United States,
INSHT in Europe, COSHA in China, and JISHA in Japan, have developed guidelines for
laboratory safety that will be used in the S·O·S Services Standardization program.
The dealer is informed of the program status upon completion of the DSD S·O·S
Consultant's audit, and Standardization recognition is received with successful program
requirement compliance. If all requirements are not met, the consultant will provide
needed improvement steps. Dealer programs only receive Standardization recognition
with 100% compliance of the assessment.
Once deficiencies are corrected, the Dealer should notify the district, in writing, of what
was done to correct the deficiencies. Subsequent audits may be required by the DSD
S·O·S Consultant to validate the corrections and Standardization recognition is awarded
accordingly. One plaque is provided to recognize the Dealer’s Standardization
achievement.
Subsequent/Continuous Evaluations
The goal of Standardization and recertification is to provide motivation and means for
dealers to assess their current program versus where they need to be in providing
customer service that clearly separates the Cat Dealer S·O·S program from competitors
in the fluid analysis business. The process requires continuous improvement, and
updates to the Standardization program will be made with customer expectation
increases or with developed value-added program enhancements. The Standardization
certification process is not a one-time event through which a program receives a
permanent certification. A Standardized program, in apparent good standing, must be
reviewed every three years. Changes to Standardization requirements, customer
complaints, key personnel changes, frequent poor performance in performance testing
programs, etc. could be reason for a program's Standardization reevaluation.
4.3. Communication
4.3.1. Laboratory Information Management System Requirements
4.3.2 Dealer Training Events
4.3.3 Customer Training Events
For Dealers who utilize Caterpillar or another Cat Dealer laboratory for their fluid
analysis services, it should be noted that the laboratory being utilized must meet all the
requirements for test results and laboratory operations included in the S·O·S Services
Standardization Program.
Elemental analysis is used to determine the weight percent of the listed elements in the
used oil sample. Elemental analysis must be reported for all samples and the results
must be posted as parts per million (ppm). The required instrument for measuring the
elemental concentration is an Inductively Coupled Plasma Optical Emission
Spectrometer (ICP-OES). This type of instrument has proven accuracy, repeatability,
and durability in the measurement of used oil samples. The ICP must be capable of
producing an accuracy of +/- 10% for concentrations of 20 ppm or higher. For
concentrations lower than 20 ppm, the ICP must have an accuracy of +/- 2 ppm. The
method currently recommended is based on processes ASTM D5185.
Laboratories are required to report a minimum of 15 elements including: Fe, Cr, Al, Pb,
Mo, Cu, Sn, Si, Na, K, P, Ca, Mg, Zn, and Ni. Elements such as Fe, Cr, Al, Pb, Cu, Sn,
Si, Na, K and Ni are commonly seen within most oil-lubricated compartments. Most of
these elements help to identify wear in the compartment, while the others are indicators
of contaminants such as antifreeze or dirt. Elements Mo, P, Ca, Mg and Zn are oil
additive elements and are used to help identify the type of oil.
The use of an internal standard is required for elemental analysis. An internal standard
is used to assist in identifying a sample dilution problem and for stabilizing the results of
the high-concentration additive elements. Internal standards must be applied to all
samples.
FT-IR Analysis
Fourier Transform Infrared Spectroscopy (FT-IR) must be used for the measurement of
oxidation, nitration, sulfation, and soot. The FT-IR must be configured to produce
results in accordance with the ASTM E2412-04 Direct Trending procedure. S·O·S
Services uses the term Un-subtracted FT-IR Method (UFM) to identify this procedure.
Additional information on the UFM can be found on the Dealer.cat.com page for S·O·S
Services.
Oil oxidation can take place in all oil-lubricated compartments due to the presence of
oxygen resulting in premature oil degradation and wear. Oxidation must be measured
and reported for all samples.
In natural gas/gaseous fuels engines, the nitration measurement helps identify if the air
to fuel ratio is too lean or too rich. Nitration must be measured and reported for all
gaseous fuel engine samples.
While viscosity values at both 100oC and 40oC are acceptable for standardization,
Kinematic Viscosity at 100oC is the most useful viscosity measurement for new and
used oil analysis. Viscosity results must be posted in centistokes (cSt). A capillary tube
type viscometer must be used for this measurement and the viscometer must be
capable of measuring viscosity within +/- 0.5 cSt according to ASTM D445.
The kinematic viscosity of an oil is essential for identifying if the correct oil is being used
in a compartment. Viscosity analysis also is an indicator of contamination within an oil
compartment. Viscosity results must be reported for all samples.
Water
The reporting of Water on the S·O·S Services report must follow the guidelines listed in
the chart below.
S·O·S
Report Water
Result % Water Water Result Definition
N <0.1% Negative
Glycol
Particle Analysis
Particle analysis may be performed using multiple different methods. The optical particle
counter, PQ Analyzer, visual inspection, Laser Net Fines, filter patch analysis, and
ferrography are all acceptable methods for particle analysis.
GC Fuel Dilution
Gas Chromatography (GC) must be used for the measurement of fuel dilution. The GC
test can be done by ASTM D7593 or by the Perkin Elmer modified method on the PE
Clarus 500 with PreVent ModeTM. The PE method has been submitted for approval to
ASTM, and is a much quicker alternative to the standard ASTM method. For more
information please visit the Dealer.cat.com page for S·O·S Services.
A positive or negative fuel dilution analysis result must be reported for all diesel engine
samples. This can be satisfied by the viscosity screen business rule in S·O·S Services
Manager. Samples with a positive result must also include the % volume value reported
from the GC analysis.
Elemental Analysis
Elemental analysis is used to determine the volume percent of the listed elements in the
used coolant sample. Elemental analysis must be reported for all samples and the
results must be posted as parts per million (ppm). The required instrument for
measuring the elemental concentration is an Inductively Coupled Plasma Optical
Emission Spectrometer (ICP-OES). This type of instrument has proven accuracy,
repeatability, and durability in the measurement of used coolant samples. The ICP
must be capable of producing an accuracy of +/- 10% for concentrations of 20 ppm or
higher. For concentrations lower than 20 ppm, the ICP must have an accuracy of +/- 2
ppm. The method currently recommended is based on processes ASTM D6130.
Laboratories are required to report a minimum of 13 elements including: Al, Fe, Cu, Zn,
Pb, Sn, Mo, K, Na, BO3, PO4, SiO3, MoO4. Elements such as Al, Fe, Cu, Zn, Pb, Sn
help to identify corrosive wear in the cooling system. Other elements are coolant
The use of an internal standard is required for elemental analysis. An internal standard
is used to assist in identifying a sample dilution problem and for stabilizing the results of
the high-concentration additive elements. Internal standards must be applied to all
samples.
% Glycol
Glycol measurements must be done with a refractometer that has been calibrated for
ethylene glycol and propylene glycol. Common refractometers provide freeze or boiling
point results. Results must be reported in percent (%). It is recommended that a
refractometer with a percent concentration scale be used. However, freeze and boiling
point results can be converted to percent if necessary. Additional information on using a
refractometer can be found the Dealer.cat.com page for S·O·S Services in the
recommended instrument listing.
pH
pH measurements must be done with a pH meter. The pH meter used must be capable
of a linear calibration between the pH values of 4.0 and 10.0. The meter must be
capable of producing accurate results within +/- 0.1. Additional information on pH
meters can be found on the Dealer.cat.com page for S·O·S Services in the
recommended instrument listing.
Conductivity
Conductivity is measured with a conductivity meter. The conductivity meter used must
be capable of a linear calibration range of 2,000-10,000. The results are reported in
µS/cm. The meter must be capable of producing accurate results within +/- 5%.
Additional information on conductivity meters can be found on the Dealer.cat.com page
for S·O·S Services in the recommended instrument listing.
Nitrite
Caterpillar recommends a titration method that aligns more accurately with Inorganic
Chromatography (IC) nitrite analysis. Please see the Instrument listing on the
Dealer.cat.com page for S·O·S Services.
Coolant Physical tests include magnetic solids, odor, color, appearance, precipitate, oil,
fuel, and foam. S·O·S Services considers this group of tests as sensory tests. The
laboratory technician carries out these tests. Descriptions of these test procedures and
appropriate test results are available in the S·O·S Services Basic Interpretation Help
Sheet Guide on the Dealer.cat.com page for S·O·S Services.
A list of laboratory equipment that Caterpillar has tested and approved in Caterpillar
fluid analysis laboratories is available on the Dealer.cat.com page for S·O·S Services.
Note that this list is not all inclusive and instruments should be reviewed prior to use by
the Dealer.
Introduction
A laboratory’s primary function is to produce quality data. As in any production
environment, the product that is built with the highest quality standards will likely be the
most successful. With analysis data, data quality is not only a competitive differentiator,
but also a critical success factor. Laboratories must produce accurate and precise data
to satisfy key customer requirements.
The following section discusses specific minimum quality laboratory activities needed to
demonstrate that accurate and precise results are being produced and delivered to the
customer. The activities will consist of daily measuring and monitoring activities as well
as quarterly verification by a third-party verification standard. Some or all of the
elements of quality assurance should be integrated in the ISO process. This section
intends to specify, with exactness, the measures and goals that should be met.
Definitions
Precision: The extent to which the results from a given set of measurements on the
same sample agree with their mean
Accuracy: The extent to which a given measurement agrees with the standard value for
that measurement
Procedures
Quarterly Verification Standards
Acceptance Criteria
Percent differences of the analytical results from the certified value are automatically
calculated if you are using VHG’s PTP service. If another vendor is chosen, percent
differences from the certified value will need to be calculated using the following formula:
To represent the degree of tolerances permitted for percent differences, the common
scheme of red, yellow and green will be utilized. The table below delineates how
percent differences are interpreted into the color-coding schemes.
Corrective Actions
Inevitably laboratories will encounter instances when analytical results will disagree with
the certified values. When this occurs, a root cause analysis of the result discrepancy
must be done. Depending on the root cause analysis, appropriate remediation efforts
should be taken. In all situations, documentation of the corrective procedure as well as
a final re-test of the PTP sample.
Instruments with red results should be taken out of service and not be used to produce
S·O·S results. Once the instrument has been analyzed and corrected, and green or
yellow results are obtained, the instrument can be returned to service.
Although yellow results allow the instrument to be utilized, the laboratory personnel
should make reasonable efforts to have all results within green parameters.
Website: https://www.lgcgroup.com
Website: www.vhglabs.com
Email address: [email protected]
(+1) 888 622 7660 Toll free in the USA
(+1) 603 622 7660 Outside the USA
(+1) 603 622 5180 (fax)
VHG Labs
276 Abby Road
Manchester, New Hampshire, 03103, USA
Name Description Part No.
Elements included are: Ag, Al, B,
Ba, Ca, Cd, Cr, Cu, Fe, K, Mg, Mn,
Elemental Analysis VPTPMO-25G
Mo, Na, Ni, P, Pb, Sb, Si, Sn, V,
and Zn. 25 grams
Includes VPTPMO-25G,
Complete Set VPTSET1
VPTPVISC-50, and VPTPPC-125
Instrument Calibration
Elemental Analysis
For elemental analysis, the calibration range must span the area of interest for each
element. The recommended calibration range for Fe, Cr, Al, Pb, Mo, Cu, Sn, Si, Na, K,
Mg, Ni is 0 – 500 ppm. The recommended calibration range for Zn and P is 0 – 1,600
ppm. The recommended calibration range for Ca is 0 – 5,000 ppm.
FT-IR
Viscosity Analysis
Particle Count
Optical particle count instruments have sensors that should be calibrated externally in
accordance with ISO 11171:2016 on an annual basis. For other types of particle
analysis, refer to the manufacturer’s recommendations for calibration.
Glycol
Gas Chromatograph
pH Meter
Conductivity Meter
The table above describes which data to track to determine if the instrument or process
is under control. The daily checks should be maintained for periodic review to ensure
that processes continue to remain in control. Data can be tracked in the form of
electronic files, i.e. results files, or a spreadsheet; or through the instrument’s software.
Some tests may best be tracked using a laboratory notebook.
In some cases, it may require statistical treatment of the data to determine if the
process is in control. It is highly advisable for the data that requires statistical analysis
to use electronic spreadsheet files for tracking. Statistical analysis is recommended for
FT-IR, Viscosity, and Gas Chromatography data.
The S·O·S Standardization Program requires certified Cat Dealer programs to utilize a
laboratory that has an appropriate quality management system. The recommended
quality management systems are the ISO 9001 and ISO 17025 programs. When
evaluating a quality management system, Dealers will be asked to provide documented
work instructions, standard operating procedures, and/or standard work documents for
all analysis processes. Additionally, Dealer programs will need to identify their
customer satisfaction and demonstrate continuous improvement measurements.
Dealers can provide written documentation in their own template, or those developed by
Caterpillar, to allow a degree of flexibility corresponding to individual Dealer philosophy
and organizational structure. To help Dealers develop written documentation,
documentation templates, sample quality log forms, and sample process flow charts are
available on the Dealer.cat.com page for S·O·S Services.
Dealers that source data from recognized Cat certified laboratories may use the
documentation templates as needed and combine their written documentation with
documentation from the laboratory supplying analytical data to meet Cat S·O·S
Services Standardization. DSD S·O·S Consultant's review of the Dealer’s non-
laboratory program utilization, interpretation, communications, and key performance
indicators metrics is required.
Registrar
ISO certifies Accrediting Bodies in each region of the world. The Accrediting Bodies
then certify Registrars. Registrars are companies with trained and certified personnel
that will audit for conformity to the chosen ISO standard. The Registrar itself is certified
to the ISO standard defining how to conduct conformance audits.
For more information please visit the Dealer.cat.com page for S·O·S Services.
Costs
Annual certification cost will vary on several factors, most which are associated with the
current state of the Dealer program.
Initial certification
Initial certification will take one to two years of training, documentation, and process
changes. If a Dealership has ISO 9001 certification in another area, it is recommended
to collaborate and consult with that person or department to expedite the process for the
S·O·S Services laboratory.
If the Dealership does not have any other areas ISO 9001 certified, a Management
Representative (MR) will be needed. As a minimum, the MR should complete Lead
Auditor training. Lead Auditor training provides the MR with the information needed to
understand what the Certifying Auditor will be auditing.
Internal auditors will also need to be trained. The internal auditor(s) should be laboratory
technicians and laboratory managers. There are discounts for paying early and sending
more than one person per training event. Also, some ISO trainers offer frequent
customer programs. Investigate local choices and take advantage of special offers.
2. If resources are not available, determine if an external consultant will be used, and
employ as needed.
3. Identify the Dealership MR and send this person to Lead Auditor training.
4. Identify at least one person from the S·O·S Services laboratory for Internal Auditor
training.
5. The MR and other selected personnel will document current program processes.
7. Review documented procedures for conformity to the ISO 9001 standard. The
consultant may want to review the processes as the documentation is completed.
Note: Consultant fees may be reduced if the MR and the Internal Auditors create all the
process documentation. If this occurs, consultant time can be minimized to a final
check before Registrar audit.
Occupational safety and health organizations, such as OSHA in the United States,
INSHT in Europe, COSHA in China, and JISHA in Japan, have developed programs for
employees who work with chemicals. Please contact the appropriate national agency
for employee health and safety for details concerning rules and regulations.
Knowledge is the first step of safety. Reading and following recommended work
practices and procedures presented in the Chemical Hygiene / Safety Plan can greatly
minimize the risk of exposure to hazardous chemicals. Following the policies and
procedures set forth in the Chemical Hygiene / Safety Plan becomes the responsibility
of each employee.
The purpose of the Chemical Hygiene / Safety Plan is to provide chemical safety
information as well as recommended laboratory practices and procedures for working
with chemicals. The Chemical Hygiene / Safety Plan must protect employees from
health hazards associated with hazardous chemicals in the laboratory and keep
exposures below the limits specified in the standard. The Chemical Hygiene / Safety
Plan should indicate specific measures that the employer will take to ensure laboratory
employee protection. Some areas to address in the Chemical Hygiene / Safety Plan
include, but are not limited to:
Process Control
The Chemical Hygiene / Safety Plan should be readily accessible to all employees,
employee representatives, and, upon request, to a government safety representative.
Laboratory Safety
Safety Data Sheet
A Safety Data Sheet (SDS) document contains chemical hazard and safe handling
information designed to inform of potential hazards when working with certain chemicals.
The SDS for every chemical in the laboratory should always be readily accessible to
each employee and should be consulted before handling any chemicals.
At the time of initial assignment to the fluids analysis laboratory, employees must
receive training and information regarding hazardous chemicals present in the
laboratory. The information shall include, but is not limited to:
1. Methods and observations that may be used to detect the presence or release of a
hazardous chemical
2. The physical and health hazards of the chemicals in the work area
3. The measure employees can take to protect themselves from these hazards
To minimize the risk of injury to the employees, it is important that laboratories comply
with the following general laboratory safety requirements.
3. Emergency shower
Minimum Requirements
The following section discusses the different requirements in education and training
needed according to job type and description.
At least one member of the staff should have a Bachelor of Arts or Science in a
scientific discipline or equivalency thereof. Acceptable scientific disciplines include
chemistry, physics, biology, and environmental sciences. Chemistry is the most
desirable.
Laboratory Manager
The Laboratory Manager is directly responsible for the day-to-day operation of the
laboratory. This person may or may not be the overall S·O·S program manager.
Minimum requirements for the Laboratory Manager role are as follows:
Annually participate in at least one training course per year pertaining to laboratory
processes, instrumentation, oil chemistries, or machinery advances.
Achieve S·O·S Interpretation I Certification from Caterpillar Inc. For more information
on the training curriculum for S·O·S Interpretation Certification please visit the
Dealer.cat.com page for S·O·S Services.
Interpreters
Interpreters are responsible for interpreting S·O·S data and making the evaluations and
recommendations for the customer. Minimum requirements for the Interpreter role are
as follows:
• Interpreters must be recertified by Caterpillar every three years. This would also
apply to Laboratory Manager if they provide interpretation support.
Laboratory Technicians
The Laboratory Technicians are responsible for analyzing the samples and producing
quality S·O·S data. Minimum requirements for the Laboratory Technician role are as
follows:
Every customer should be associated to at least one Dealer employee. Dealer sales or
technical personnel such as PSSR’s, TC’s, ISR’s or Condition Monitoring Specialists
should have access to customer data via reports or the web tool.
Additional actions beyond the basic customer report should be performed with
customers to demonstrate further value of the program. Examples of such activities
include: volume reports, red alerts reports for the last month, late sample activity reports,
etc.
4.3.2 Communications – Red Alert Follow Up
Red alert follow up by a dealer representative demonstrates a commitment to customer
success as well as a differentiator from fluid analysis providers in which the report is the
final product. The dealer must have a documented follow up process which indicates
that the customer was notified of the red alert and is aware of possible
recommendations. Some red alerts, such as shop jobs, customers with external PM
processes, or other examples may fall under a pre-arranged business process. In these
cases, description of the business process may be acceptable.
Calculation Instructions
The formula for calculating DCAL is shown below:
The annual number of Cat product fluid samples processed from CAT prime product
machines (not engines and not competitive equipment) is provided by S·O·S Services
Manager. This information is available in the Cat Prime Product Report.
The source used by Cat S∙O∙S Services for machine population and estimated sample
volume is Corporate PTOS or OLGA. The total estimated sample volume for use in the
DCAL calculation is based upon Cat machines identified in PTOS/ OLGA in a Dealer’s
territory and the annual hours generated per each machine. Please contact the
respective Cat DSD PSOR for specific Dealer’s current total estimated sample volume
for use in this calculation.
Example Calculation
Dealership “A” processed 23,750 oil samples from Cat machines in the previous 12-
month period. According to Cat PTOS/OLGA, the total estimated samples equals
58,356.
To calculate S·O·S DCAL, divide the actual number of Cat machine samples by the
total estimated number of Cat machine samples, and then multiply by 100.
There are a variety of CSA products available on the market. During the coverage
period of the CSA it is critical to control maintenance and repair costs. It is also critical
that the dealer meet the commitment of the contract requiring S·O·S sampling. The
measure of CSA participation was updated to reflect the Caterpillar strategic emphasis
and importance of CSAs.
The definition of the CSA Participation metric has also been updated. The dealer will
need the ability to identify all machine models under CSA contract that includes S·O·S
Sampling. Units with CSAs that do not include S·O·S Sampling should not be included
in this calculation.
Dealers should be able to query the business system software to determine CSAs that
include S·O·S Services to generate an upload file for S·O·S Services Manager or utilize
the EM Tracking Tool process
Standard Requirement
The minimum CSA Participation Rate for Standardization is 60%.
Example Calculation
Shown in the chart below are the CSA machine models by sample volume according to
S·O·S Services Manager and or the EM Tracking Tool.
All machine models by sample volume
model D6R 325C 950G 430D D5M total
total machine count 300 252 208 185 98 1043
CSA machines 32 22 19 15 7 95
The chart below shows the calculations for one of the example machines.
model D6R
serial number AAX12345
average daily usage 4 hrs
hours in previous 12 months 1460
potential samples per 1000 hours 12
potential samples 13
Based on a 365-day year, the average usage for the example D6R is 4 hours per day.
At 4 hours per day, the machine operated for an average of 1460 hours during the
previous 12 months. This machine has the potential to produce 12 oil samples every
1000 hours. Therefore, the potential annual number of samples for this machine is 13.
PEBJ0149 © 2019 Caterpillar. All Rights Reserved. CAT, CATERPILLAR, LET’S DO THE WORK, their respective
logos, "Caterpillar Yellow", the "Power Edge" and Cat “Modern Hex” trade dress as well as corporate and product
identity used herein, are trademarks of Caterpillar and may not be used without permission.