Mcdonalds India PDF
Mcdonalds India PDF
Case Study
Please note: This case study was compiled from published sources, and is intended to be used as a basis for class
discussion and for information purposes only. While care has been taken to ensure correctness of the facts, accuracy of
information cannot be guaranteed and the content should not be taken as a substitute for professional advice.
Unauthorized distribution of this document electronically or otherwise is prohibited.
Please contact [email protected] for any queries.
1. Introduction ............................................................................................................................. 3
3. Localization Strategy............................................................................................................... 5
3.1. McDonald's JV in India ....................................................................................................... 5
3.2. Initial Challenges - 'Culturally Sensitive' Food.................................................................... 5
3.2.1. Understanding Indian Customs and Culture ...................................................................... 5
3.2.2. An Indianized Menu, Re-engineered operations and no beef burger ................................ 6
8. Pricing Strategy - The Rs-20 trap and ‘Purchasing Power Pricing’ ...................................... 10
11. Out-of-home Breakfast - International McDonald’s format with local taste .......................... 11
“Having created a strong brand, McDonald’s can now monetize the time and footfalls
from its stores by increasing both the value purchase and incidence of purchase.”
- Purnendu Kumar, Associate Vice-President, Retail consultancy Technopak.
1. Introduction
Year 2008 and early 2009 saw the world in recession with economic growth slowing
down in most countries. Analysts felt that the global slump was so harsh that even no-
frills dining would feel the pinch if conditions did not recover. In such a scenario, when
most companies were either cutting costs or reducing employee numbers, McDonald's in
India planned to increase its headcount by 2000 people for its restaurant operations in
2009. McDonald’s runs 160 restaurants1 with 6,500 crew members and 650 store
managers in India (2008 figures) 2. The fast-food retailer even avoided increasing prices
in spite of mounting pressure on input costs in 2008. Its same store sales saw double
digit growth for the last five years. In 2009, McDonald’s India plans to open around 40
restaurants3. How does the company see value in expansion in a market ridden with
troubles?
“This is a great time for retailers mainly because the real estate prices have come to a
level wherein they are negotiable. Even high street locations have become affordable,”
says Amit Jatia, JV partner & MD. In the last quarter, from October to December 2008,
while exclusive restaurants saw a drop in business, McDonald’s grew 14 per cent. The
chain’s global sales exceeded analysts’ estimates and grew 7.1 per cent in January
2009. It’s revenue in Asia, the West Asia and Africa surged by 10 per cent. One of the
key factors was its initiative to improve sales, without stretching the infrastructure too
much.
Tim Fenton, McDonald’s president for Asia, the Middle East and Africa, even remarked
in an interview4 - “It’s a time to gain market share, we will not cut back on anything, we
will accelerate if anything.” This case study discusses how McDonald's managed to buck
the trend, its early years and business strategy to get more out of its stores in India. The
1
Barring two, they are all company owned.
2
McDonald’s on a hiring spree in India, Swetha Kannan, 05 March , 2009, Business Line, Sify.com
3
McDonald’s opened 30 restaurants in 2008 and 20 in 2007. The company invests Rs 100-120 crore year-
on-year on expansion plans.
4
McDonald's may accelerate Asia expansion, Bloomberg / Beijing February 13, 2009.
2.2. The Indian Market – Top 10 per cent of the busiest markets globally
The Indian industry is fragmented, with a few sizable national chains, hundreds of small
regional players and thousands of mom-and-pop operations. In India, McDonald’s began
operations over 12 years ago in 1996. India ranks amongst the top 10 per cent of the
busiest markets globally for McDonald’s. Each of the 155 stores has an average of 2,750
walk-ins and in all the stores serves 180 million customers every year. In 2006, the
company announced plans to invest roughly Rs 400 crore in expanding into the eastern
parts of the country alongside setting up 25 outlets in places such as Benaras, Amritsar,
Patiala, and Kolkata among other tier-II cities. In 2007, the company announced plans to
invest Rs400 crore in next three years to increase presence in the smaller towns and
cities and was looking at doubling its sales every three years. McDonald's also planned
to introduce the McCafes concept in India in 2007.
Two key initial challenges facing the company in India were how it could avoid hurting
religious sentiments and political confrontation. Typically, McDonald’s has been a target
for anti-Americanism7. Foreign-based fast food chains like KFC had faced trouble earlier
(in 1996) with politically organized agitations8. In 2001, analysts feared that McDonald's
chain of 30 restaurants (which occupied prime space in the main cities of Bombay and
Delhi) could be vulnerable to protestors seeking to vent their anger on the United States
over war in Afghanistan. McDonald’s had to come up with a politically correct strategy if
it had to be successful. Beef and pork had to be avoided as India’s majority Hindus (80%
of India’s population) revered cows and 150 million of Indian Muslims do not eat pork. An
additional challenge was suiting to the Indian consumers’ taste. Other U.S. companies
5
Amit Jatia and Vikram Bakshi - They invested about Rs 4.0 billion in the first 30 restaurants.
6
For its back-end supply-chain, the company has tied up with French company McCain for french fries,
besides Vista Processed Foods and Dynamix Dairy for buns and dairy products.
7
McDonald’s has become a target for anti-American sentiment around the world from a culture perspective.
There have been incidents of bombs being thrown at restaurants in Paris, Mumbai (formerly Bombay) and
Indonesia (in 2002).
8
In January 1996, farmer activists attacked and damaged a Kentucky Fried Chicken store in Bangalore,
saying KFC represented western food habits which are not needed in India. A bottling plant owned by the
worlds No 1 soft drinks company, Coca-Cola Co, was bombed in Andhra Pradesh in 2001.
“We made a commitment far back in 1995 about no beef or pork. We have a nice
vegetarian menu and we don't even use eggs in ice cream or mayonnaise.”
- Amit Jatia, MD, McDonald’s India in 2001.
“We understand Indian culture because we were born in it. Physical separation of
vegetarian and non-vegetarian products is maintained right from the farm to the
customer”
- Vikram Bakshi, MD, McDonald's India (North and East).
McDonald’s introduced a menu which completely excluded beef or pork. The menu
(approx. 75%) was Indianized and specifically designed to woo Indian customers.
Instead of the flagship beef-based Big Mac (popular elsewhere), McDonald’s introduced
a mutton-based “Maharaja Mac” in India. For the middle class, the menu included
McAloo Tikki Burger (breaded potato and pea pattie).
(Refer Exhibit II – ‘The Menu at McDonald’s India’ on page 13 and 14)
The menu McDonald's developed also included vegetarian selections to suit Indian
tasted and culture. Some of the operations were re-engineered to address the unique
requirements of a vegetarian menu. Some key features are listed below:
[In May 2001, a right-wing Hindu group attacked a McDonald's outlet in Bombay after an
ethnic Indian lawyer sued the company in the United States for selling French fries
flavoured with beef tallow. McDonalds said it used beef tallow in the United States but
denied using beef in any of its products in India10. The company has reaped success in
India despite not selling a single beefburger. McDonald's responded with signs outside
all its Indian outlets saying ''No beef or beef products sold here,'' but the public relations
injury took a while to heal.]
9
Tastes of India in U.S. Wrappers, Saritha Rai, April 29, 2003, The New York Times.
10
McDonald's India plans expansion despite war fears, November 7, 2001, Rediff.com
Fresh food
Fast service
11
Store located in Vasant Vihar, an affluent residential colony in India’s capital,
12
Mostly in the northern and western part of India
“Our clear strategy is to bring the customers in initially and provide a range of entry-level
products so that they can try new items and graduate to the higher rungs. Thus, if a
customer starts with a McAloo Tikki Burger (breaded potato and pea pattie), what he
graduates to finally is a vegetarian burger. Or, if a customer starts with a Chicken Kabab
burger, what he graduates finally to is the McChicken.”
- Vikram Bakshi, McDonald’s managing director of the Northern region in India
McDonald’s has followed “purchasing power pricing” strategy13. Even though India ranks
as among the top 10 per cent of the busiest markets for McDonald’s globally, it ranks low
in terms of earnings. This is because a quarter of the sales are at the lowest price point
of Rs 2014. McDonald’s strategy has been to increase sales volume of its products by
making its products available at an affordable price. The reason McDonald’s brought
down its prices is because even though McDonald’s was able to get a larger share of
rich and upper-middleclass population, it was not that successful at effectively tapping
the middle-class and lower middle-class segments. This has prompted some analysts to
say that McDonald’s has fallen into the Rs-20 trap. In earlier years, McDonald’s had
launched quite a few campaigns emphasizing this price. Going back on this price could
attract negative feedback from customers. However, from another perspective, the low
prices could result in a boon in times of economic recession as customers want more
value for money, even in food as well.
McDonald’s recognized the need of customers who were in a hurry. A customer who
only wants an ice-cream or a beverage does not have to wait in a regular queue.
Accordingly, McDonald’s opened its first dessert kiosk at its Faridabad15 store in 2003.
The kiosks are at the entrance. McDonald’s has since started ice-cream and beverage
kiosks at 23 stores. These kiosks have added 10 per cent to the sales of the stores. The
enhanced cost works out to 10-12 per cent of the total cost16.
Heavy traffic and parking woes are common in India and put off customers from visiting
the stores directly. While most other quick-service restaurants in India offered home
delivery (and some even offered it for free), McDonald’s did not have this service for
customers. This was an opportunity for McDonald’s to increase its revenues at an
incremental cost by leveraging its stores to deliver food in the vicinity. Typically, stores
13
Purchasing power pricing or the customer’s ability to pay - called so by Amit Jatia, the company’s
managing director in the Western region.
14
In 1997, the company cut prices on its vegetable nuggets from Rs 29 to Rs 19, and the soft service ice
cream cone from Rs 15 to Rs 7. In September 2001, McDonald’s offered its enormously popular shudh
shakahari (pure vegetarian) Veg Surprise (a veggie burger) for Rs 17. In March 2004, McDonald’s launched
a Happy Price menu under which it sells four of its burger products at Rs20 each.
15
City in the outskirts of Delhi.
16
How McDonald's is trying to get more out of its stores.
In 1973, McDonald's lead the way with breakfast fast food with the introduction of the
Egg McMuffin. Subsequently, McDonald’s had good results with breakfast offerings
globally. A full breakfast line was added to the menu in about five years time. By 1987
one-fourth of all breakfasts eaten out in the United States came from McDonald's
restaurants. In Europe17, it accounts for 25 per cent of its turnover. In South East Asia,
breakfast fetches McDonald’s 12-15 per cent of its total revenue.
A research on breakfast habits carried out in large Indian cities in 2008 by McDonald’s
indicated that 18 per cent people in cities preferred eating out of home, driven by
convenience and variety. The research also revealed that out-of-home breakfast in
Mumbai was high during the whole week and in Delhi it peaked during weekends.
In December 2008, McDonald’s ran a pilot at some of its stores in Delhi and Mumbai
offering breakfast. It already had an international breakfast menu that could be brought
to India. But, it had to be adapted to Indian tastes. Some of its offerings like the
vegetarian wedge and non-vegetarian wedge were suited to Indian taste. It came out
with a special egg and cheese sandwiches18. Customary Indian items like paratha and
samosa were intentionally kept out of the menu as the company felt that the company
felt that the customers would not want Indian stuff. The price of the breakfast menu was
thus set between Rs 20 and Rs 99 which the Indian consumers could easily afford.
“The efficient supply chain that we have put in place is the backbone of the whole
business. We had to ensure the right ingredients at the right quality and at the right time.
And the key challenge is to ensure that none of these ingredients runs out of stock in
any of our outlets at any point of time.”
- Abhijit Upadhye, Director - Supply Chain, Menu Management & New Business Channels,
McDonald’s India.
The most important reason for McDonald’s pricing flexibility is its well-established supply
chain. Before setting up the first restaurant in Delhi in 1996, the company spent almost
six years and Rs 500 crore along with its Indian supplier partners on establishing a
supply chain which ensures efficiency and speed in distribution.
17
In Europe, McDonald’s began offering breakfast in the 1980s.
18
80 per cent of McDonald’s sale in India is sandwiches
McDonald’s India sources almost 200 ingredients from over 40 suppliers spread all over
the country. In a year, McDonald’s consumes a minimum of 4.6 crore buns, 17 lakh
bottles of sauce, 1,200 tonnes of iceberg lettuce, six crore patties and hundreds of
tonnes of dairy products and other ingredients. The huge increases in volume sales and
food processing technology have been helping the company to offset its cost.
With a unique cold chain19, the company has been able to cut down on its operational
wastage as well as maintain the freshness and nutritional value of raw and processed
food products. This includes procurement, warehousing, transportation and retailing of
perishable food products, all under controlled temperature. The setting up of this
extensive cold chain distribution system was possible thanks to the cooperation from
international suppliers in transferring technology, and in some cases, investing to form
joint venture companies which today are an integral part of the McDonald’s cold chain.20
19
A cold chain refers to the warehousing, transportation and retailing of products under controlled
temperatures. Such a chain is necessary for ice creams, frozen vegetables, processed meats, dairy and
bakery products. While frozen foods need sub-zero temperatures up to -20°C, products like butter, which
require chilling, need about 0-4°C.
20
Excerpted from ‘Behind the big bite’, The Hindu Businessline, April 03, 2008
(Source: http://www.rediff.com/business/1999/apr/29mac5.jpg)
McVeggie
The McVeggie sandwich starts with the oh-
so-familiar sesame seed bun. In between
the bread, you'll find a vegetarian patty that
is made from peas, carrots, green beans,
red bell pepper, potatoes, onions, rice, and
seasoning. This vegetarian burger is
garnished with lettuce, and has
mayonnaise made without eggs spread
thickly on the bread.
McAloo Tikki
Potatoes (aloo in Hindi) are a popular filling
food item in India. McDonald's in India's
McAloo Tikki sandwich includes a patty
made out of potatoes, peas, and spices. It
also includes tomato slices, onions, and
vegetarian mayonnaise.
Crispy Chinese
McDonald's in India's Crispy Chinese sandwich is crispy, but very China. It's more an
Indianized Chinese. Nevertheless, this vegetarian patty is topped with a creamy Schezwan
sauce and lettuce which makes it a nice addition to the Indian vegetarian menu.
Pizza McPuff
The vegetarian Pizza McPuff also starts with a rectangular shaped crust, but instead of a
creamy sauce is flavored with a tomato-based sauce and then is topped with carrots, beans,
bell peppers, onions, peas and mozzarella cheese.
* partial list
(Source: What You Can and Can't Get at McDonalds India..., by Noreen, February 26, 2009, Indiamarks)
McChicken
The McChicken in India is almost the same as its
cousin by the same name in other McDonalds
around the world. It contains one breaded and fried
chicken patty and is topped with lettuce and
vegetarian mayonnaise. It is similar in size (but not
taste) to the spicy chicken sandwich on the dollar
menu at McDonalds restaurants in the U.S.
Filet-O-Fish
The Filet-O-Fish sandwich at McDonalds in India is
the only sandwich item on the menu that is exactly
the same as the Filet-O-Fish sandwich you might eat
at a McDonalds in the U.S.
Chicken McGrill
Year Event
1948 The first McDonald's restaurant opens in California. (Richard and Maurice McDonald)
1954 Ray Kroc gains the rights to set up McDonald's restaurants in most of the country.
1955 Kroc opens his first McDonald's restaurant in Illinois
1955 McDonald's Corporation is incorporated
1958 34 restaurants
1959 More than 100 restaurants
1961 Kroc buys out the McDonald brothers for $2.7 million.
1965 McDonald's goes public.
1967 First foreign restaurant in British Columbia, Canada.
1968 The Big Mac is born
1972 More than $1 billion in annual sales
1973 Breakfast items introduced on the menu, with the debut of the Egg McMuffin.
1975 The first McDonald's drive-thru window
1976 McDonald's had served 20 billion hamburgers with sales exceeding $3 billion.
1979 Children's Happy Meal (a combo meal for children featuring a toy) is introduced
1985 One of the 30 companies that make up the Dow Jones Industrial Average.
1991 Number of countries with McDonald's outlets - 59
1991 9,000 McDonald’s units in U.S.
1996 McDonald’s enter India
1997 12,500 McDonald’s units in U.S.
1998 Number of countries with McDonald's outlets - 114
2002 First quarterly loss since going public.
(Source: Compiled from various sources)
(Source: McPrinciples to supersize business success, Harvey Schachter, March 4, 2009, The Globe and Mail -
Ideas from the book, ‘Everything I Know About Business I Learned At McDonald's’, written with journalist Adina Genn, Mr.
Facella takes us inside the organization to look at the heart, soul and principles that have made it an international hit.)
1. McDonalds has become the poster brand for recession-resilient business. What
is McDonald’s doing right in India? What elements of its business strategy are
working for it and how does it manage to get more out of its stores?
2. Does local adaptation contribute to business growth in a country? Explain
McDonald’s efforts to adapt to the local culture in India. What challenges did
McDonald’s face in India?
3. Have you ever visited a McDonald’s store? Compare and contrast your
experience with another quick-service restaurant or fast-food joint you visited
earlier. How can McDonald’s improve? Should it alter its strategy?