Butadiene Plant P&ID Control Systems
Butadiene Plant P&ID Control Systems
1 Introduction
The P&ID of butadiene plant is mainly focus on the piping system and control system,
such as level control, temperature control, pressure control and composition control. This
diagram is purposely used to detail out the control system of equipment required. Most of the
main control valves will have their own by-pass valve calibration or alternative.
Table 4.1: Letter Code for Instrument Symbols (Based on BS 1646: 1979)
(SINNORT, 1993)
Indicating Recording
First Indicating Recording Controlling
Property measured and and
letter only only only
controlling controlling
Flow-rate F FI FR FC FIC FRC
Level L LI LR LC LIC LRC
Pressure P PI PR PC PIC PRC
Quality, Analysis Q QI QR QC QIC QRC
Radiation R RI RR RC RIC RRC
Temperature T TI TR TC TIC TRC
Weight W WI WR WC WIC WRC
Any other property X XI XR XC XIC XRC
(specified in a
note)
Notes:
(1) The letter A may be added to indicate an alarm; with H or L placed next to the
instrument circle to indicate high or low.
(2) D is used to show difference or differential; for example, PD for pressure
differential.
2
4.1.4 Proportional Control
The key concepts behind proportional control are the following:
1. The controller gain, KC can be adjusted (“tuned”) to make the controller output
(manipulated variable) changes as sensitive as desired to deviations between set point
and controlled variable.
2. The sign of KC can be chosen to make the controller output (manipulated variable,
p(t)) increase(or decrease) as the error signal increases.
The advantages of the proportional control are theoretically simple and easy to tune
which a single parameter is needed, KC while the disadvantage is cannot remove off-set
because the off-set is enforced by the controlled variables.
Table 4.2 : Differences between P, PI, and PID control (E-Seborg et al., 2004)
P Control PI Control PID Control
Simplest controller to More complicated to tune Most complicated to tune
tune (KC) (KC, I). (KC, I, D).
Off set with sustained Better performance than P Better performance than PI
disturbance or set-point No offset No offset
change Most popular FB controller Derivative action may be
affected by noise
3
4.1.7 Feedback Control
One of the simplest process control schemes. A feedback loop measures a process
variable and sends the measurement to a controller for comparison to set point. If the process
variable is not at set point, control action is taken to return the process variable to set point.
The advantage of this control scheme is that it is simple using single transmitter and also
directly controls the desired process variable. This control scheme does not take into
consideration any of the other variables in the process. It is important to make a distinction
between negative feedback and positive feedback. Negative feedback is desirable situation
where the corrective action taken by controller forces the controlled variable toward the set
point. Positive feedback which controller makes things worse by forcing the controlled
variables farther away from the set point (E-Seborg et al., 2004). Figure 4.1 shows the
schematic diagram of feedback control.
4
disadvantages for the feeback and feedforward control system. Figure 4.2 shows the
schematic diagram of ratio control.
Table 4.3: Advantages and disadvantages for the feeback and feedforward control system
Feedforward Feedback
Advantages Compensates for a disturbance Provides zero steady-state offset.
before the process output is Effective for all disturbances.
affected.
Does not affect the stability of the
control system.
Disadvantages Cannot eliminate steady-state offset Does not take control action until
Requires a sensor and model for the process output variable has
each disturbance deviated from its set point.
Affects the stability of the closed-
loop control system.
5
4.1.9 Ratio Control
Ratio control is used to ensure that two or more flows are kept at the same ratio even
if the flows are changing. Application for the ratio control are blending two or more flows to
produce a mixture with specified composition, blending two or more flows to produce a
mixture with specified physical properties and maintaining correct air and fuel mixture to
combustion (E-Seborg et al., 2004). Figure 4.3 shows the schematic diagram of ratio control.
6
Figure 4.4: Schematic diagram of cascade control
4.2 SENSORS
A sensor is a device that measures a physical quantity and converts it into a signal
which can be read by an observer or by an instrument.
7
4.2.2 Temperature Control
Temperature control is important to ensure the product achieves the desired
composition or specification. Besides that, temperature control also can minimize the energy
required by reboiler as well as consumed by heat exchanger through controlling the flow of
steam and input stream exchanger. The life span of the equipment can be preserved as long as
the temperature deviation is small.
Therefore, thermocouple sensor is chosen in this plant regarding on the wide range of
operating temperature and lower price. It used in temperature control and located at boiler H-
101 and H-102, reactor R-101, heat exchanger E-101 and E-103, condenser E-102, reboiler
E-105 and quench tower V-103.
8
4.2.3 Pressure Control
Pressure is crucial for system consist of gas or vapor. It must be maintain at the
specific value especially in reactor and distillation so that the equipment can function and
reaction can happen. Besides the pressure also cannot be too high as it might cause failure to
the equipment or worse cause explosion. This control method depends to the nature of
process, for instance, pressure is control via manipulating the flow from or to equipment.
Table 4.6 shows type of the sensors for pressure control that used in the process plant for
pressure control.
High Spatial Resolution Distributed Fiber-Optic and strain gauge are two types of
pressure sensors that have been develop in industrial plant. Fiber-optic is normally applied to
measure pressure in high temperature environment up to 800 . This sensor has good
resistant to harsh environments, high temperature up to 800 and high pressure up to 2500
psi (Chen, 2016). Thus, this sensor is suitable to be used in reactor since the temperature of
the reactor is up to 650 Table 4.6 shows the sensors for Pressure control of the strain
gauge.
9
Table 4.6 : Sensors for Pressure control
(High Spatial Resolution Distributed Fiber-Optic) (Chen, 2016)
10
4.2.4 Level Control
Level control is important in equipment with interface existence. It is to maintain the
interface level so that the system may not overflow or dry out during the process. Typically
level control is incorporated in the design with the flow out from equipment. Table 4.8 shows
type of the sensors for level control that used in the process plant for level control.
Since continuous level measurement is necessary in this plant, there are several types
of the sensors that can be used such as ultrasonic and radar sensor. The working principle of
ultrasonic transmitters is by sending sound waves from a piezoelectric transducer to the
process material surface that being measured. The function transmitter is measure time taken
for the reflected sound wave to return towards transducer. A successful measurement depends
on the wave, reflected from the process material and moving in a straight line back to the
transducer. However, the returning signal of this sensor can be affected by dust, heavy
vapors, tank obstructions, surface turbulence, foam, and even surface angles. Besides,
maximum operating temperature of 60°C and varying process temperatures may generate
inaccurate level readings. Thus, this sensor cannot be chosen for this process as most of the
process required high temperature.
Next, Guided-wave radar (GWR) is one of the radar based sensor. GWR is a
contacting level measurement which uses a probe to guide high-frequency electromagnetic
waves from a transmitter to the media based on the principle of time domain reflectometry
(TDR). A low-energy electromagnetic pulse is guided along a probe. When the pulse reaches
the surface of the medium being measured, the pulse energy is reflected up the probe to
circuitry and then measure the fluid level based on the time difference between the sent pulse
and the received reflected pulse. This sensor has more benefit over ultrasonic sensor such as
not affected by environmental and application conditions and high temperatures and
pressures do not affect device performance (Grumney, 2011).
Hence, radar sensor is chosen for this plant and used in n-butene storage tank TK-101,
quench tower V-101, condenser E-102 and E-104, hydrocarbon absorption column V-102
and butadiene storage tank for level control.
11
Table 4.8: Sensors for Level control
Types of Sensors Specification and Constraint
Radar Level Transmitter Specification
Radar level measurement has been used Power:
widely in all industries such as be it in - AC: 115 VAC, 60 Hz (± 20%) or 230
simple storage tanks, in corrosive or VAC, 50 Hz (± 20%), 1.7 VA
aggressive media or high accuracy tank - DC: 12 to 30 VDC, 0.07 Amps max. @
gauging applications. This is due to non- 24 VDC
contact radar with simple commissioning, Output:
trouble-free operation saves time and - Signal: 4-20 mA, 6.1 uA resolution;
money. For usage in a wide range of 750 ohms
applications ("WL900 RADAR LEVEL Accuracy: ±0.25%
TRANSMITTERS," 2015). Frequency: 6.3 GHz
Dimension: 4 inch diameter x 18 inch long
(10cm dia. x 45.7cm long)
Features:
- Accurate, non-contact measurement
- Works in conditions where ultrasonic is
not acceptable
- Simple push-button calibration
- Standard 4-20mA signal output
Constraint
Measurement Range: 10 inch to 50 ft (0.254
to 15.2 m)
Operation Temperature: -40°C to 60°C
Operating Pressure: 150 psi max
12
4.2.5 Flow Control
Flow control is usually associated with inventory control in a storage tank or other
equipment. There must be a reservoir to take up the changes in flow-rate. Table 4.9 shows the
sensors for the flow control that used in the process plant.
There are three types of common technology flow sensor that have been used. First,
pitot tubes which compare the pressure in a small diameter tube to the static pressure around
the tube. However, the disadvantages of this sensor are can clog from mineralization and
harsh in a landfill gas application, binding fluids yielding false readings and poor accuracy
when flows under 20 scfm. Hence, pitot tubes sensors cannot be chosen for this plant due to
non-user friendly characteristics ("The Advantages and Disadvantages of Traditional Flow
Measurement Devices," 2017).
Second, venturi meter in which the flow measurements are taken before and at the
mid-point of a constriction, then the flow rate is calculated from the difference of the two
measurements. This type of sensor also cannot be chosen for this plant because it can have a
significant pressure drop at high flows, expensive and bulky, it occupies considerable space,
relatively complex in construction and not suitable for flow measurement of highly viscous
slurries.
Last, Orifice meter are a famous flow measurement technology that has been widely
used. Orifice meter is a sensor used for measuring the rate of flow of a fluid through a pipe.
The working principle of the orifice meter is same as venturi meter. However, this sensor has
more benefits compared to venture meter such as orifice is cheaper and easy to install
compare to venturi meter, has greater flexibility and orifice meter can show higher
manometer reading at a given velocity compared to venturi meter.
In this butadiene production plant, orifice meter sensor is chosen for the flow control
loop due to its advantages such as high efficiency, easy to measure flow rate as it produces
considerable pressure drop across the orifice, cheap and simple construction. The sensor is
built in most of the equipment process such as mixer M-101, reactor R-101, heat exchanger
E-101 and E-103, quench tower V-101, condenser E-102 and E-104, hydrocarbon absorption
column V-102
13
Table 4.9 : Sensors for Flow control
Types of Sensors Specification and Constraint
Orifice Meter Specification
an orifice sensor is a circular plate Accuracy: varies with flow rate, from 1 to
inserted between flanges of a pipe with 3%
a round or other shape hole bored in Very cost-effective for measuring flows in
the plate center, matching system flow larger ones (over 6" diameter)
range and characteristics (E-Seborg et very cheap and easy method to measure flow
al., 2004) rate
Constraint
Dynamic range: limited to about 4:1
Range down : Up to 200:1 (14:1 flow
turndown)
Measurement Range :
Up to 1000 inH2O (2,48 bar) differential,
Up to 3626 psia (250,00 bar) absolute,
Up to 3626 psig (250,00 bar) gage
4.2.6 Transmitters
Transmitter is a device that converts the sensor output to a signal level appropriate for
input to controller. It generally designed to be direct acting which output signal increases as
the measured variables increase. It also designed to drive the transmission lines connecting
the two which are sensor and controller.
14
4.2.7 Transducer
Transducer is a device that used to convert the magnitude of a process variable into a
signal that can be sent directly to the controller.
Input Output
Manipulated Controlled
Other Other
15
4.2.10 Manipulated Variables (MVs)
Manipulated variables are the process input that adjusted dynamically to maintain the
controlled variables at set points.
4.2.13 Constraint
Constraint can be defined as the value that a constraint parameter must not exceed for
proper operation of the process.
4.3 VALVES
Mechanical devices specifically designed to direct, start, stop, mix or regulate the
flow, pressure or temperature of a process fluid which manufactured from various materials,
mostly made from steel, iron, plastic, brass, bronze and special alloys.
16
4.3.2 Types of valves
There are two broad classes depends on the primary functions that can be used in the
plant. Table 4.11 shows types of valves that used in the process plant.
17
Drain Valve V-56, V-57 used to drain off material that has
(Fully Closed) separated from a fluid or gas stream, or
one used to empty a process line, vessel,
or storage tank
A valve at the bottom of a combustion
chamber. When the engine shuts down,
these valves open and prevent an
accumulation of fuel in the combustion
chamber.
Check Valve V-59 safety valves that allows gases and liquids
(Fully Closed) to flow in only one direction
prevent process flow from reversing in the
system which could damage equipment or
upset the process
applied in process systems that have
varying pressures, which must be kept
separate
Used for protecting pumps in liquid
applications or compressors in gas
systems where backflow could cause the
pump or compressor to shut down.
18
4.4 Control Design
The starting point for control system design and analysis is preliminary process
design, perhaps with some initial control loops, along with specifications of the desired
process performance.
In the storage tank, butadiene will be stored in the liquid phase at the desired
temperature and pressure. However, the storage tank need to be monitor to ensure there is no
spilling or leakage due to the exceeding of storing the product (butadiene). Hence, the level
of the product in the storage tank is measured using radar sensors to detect the butadiene level
and control the out flow of the butadiene by manipulating the flow rate through V-54. Thus,
the optimum safety level storage of the product in this storage tank is achieved. Therefore, in
this system, feedback control system is implied with a PID controller to provide an
immediate action on controlling the final control element, V-54. Radar will detect the level of
the liquid in the storage tank and the transmitter (LT) will detect any changes of the level and
transmit the signal to level indicator controller (LIC) where it alter the control valve to either
open or close before the liquid exceeding the allowable level that can be stored in the tank.
19
LT
10506
LIC
TK-102 10506
I/P
31 Butadiene
V-54
V-56
V-55
20
4.4.2 Boiler (H-101, H-102, E-105)
Function: To boil the feed (butene)
Heating of the feed in the boiler requires energy. The various parts of the total process
thus are interconnected in a manner that makes the dynamics very complex, usually leading
to positive feedback and sometimes to problems with stability. Therefore, automatic control
is absolutely necessary. In this boiler, the fuel is used to heat up the feed gases to the desired
temperature. Hence, the temperature of the output feed gases is measured to control the
temperature inside the boiler in order to achieve the maximum desired temperature of the
feed gas. As the feed gas temperature is under standard condition, when the fuel inflow is
insufficient, the heating effect reduces and it would affect the final product of this process.
Therefore, in this system, feedback control system is implied with a PI controller to provide
an immediate action on controlling the final control element, V-05. The fuel will be
automatically added into the system to ensure the feed gas temperature can be achieved at
their required condition. Thermocouple will detect the temperature of the fluid in the boiler
and the transmitter (TT) will detect any changes of the temperature and transmit the signal to
temperature indicator controller (TIC) where it alter the control valve to either open or close
to allow the coil to heat up the feed to the desired temperature.
21
10001
TAH
V-04 TT
10001
1 H-101 2
V-03
V-06
V-05
Fuel 3
I/P
22
4.4.3. Mixer (M-101) and Oxidative Dehydrogenation Fixed Bed Reactor (R-101)
Mixer
Function: Mix all the output from H-101(boiler), C-101(blower) and H-102 (boiler) before
entering R-101
Before entering the reactor, the raw material which is n-butene, air and water must
undergo mixing process in order to obtain a desired mixture at an equilibrium temperature.
N-butene which is the raw material, air and water are flow into the mixer from boiler H-101,
blower C-101 and boiler H-102 respectively. Hence, flow control is applied in order to
control the output flow rate of the mixer by adjusting the inlet flow rates. Cascade control
system and PI controller are responsible to make an action on air-to-close valve when a
deviation from the set point occurs. The sensor chosen for this loop is orifice meter under
specific ratio constraint.
23
Oxidative Dehydrogenation Fixed Bed Reactor
Function: To produce butadiene from n-butene by using oxidative dehydrogenation process
In reactor, the output flow rate is essential to make sure the inlet flow rates of the
mixture are under a right ratio condition. As stated in the mixer, the flow rate ratio is air : n-
butene : water is 2.6 : 1 : 10. Therefore, flow control is applied to control the outlet flow rate
with feedback and cascade loop. The control structure of this loop is PID controller. All of
the feedback and cascade control system and PID controller responsible to make any
corrective action on air-to-close valve. Additionally, orifice meter is the chosen flow sensor
while maximum flow rate at fully opened valve is 1200 ton/hr is the constraint.
24
Control System: Temperature control
Tagging Label TIC10203
Objective of To reach and maintain the temperature in the reactor at 540 in order
Control to achieve the desired product composition
Measurements Temperature
Manipulated Inlet flow rate of coolant
Variables
Constraints 500-650
Disturbances Inlet temperature of the coolant
Controller PID
Control Structure Cascade control system
Additional Control valve (fail opened)
Considerations Hand manual valve (fully closed)
During the reaction process in the reactor, a desired product composition can be
obtained at 540 of temperature operating condition. Hence, temperature loop is necessary
to reach and maintain the temperature in the reactor at 540 . This objective can be achieved
by manipulating the inlet flow of coolant. Cascade control system with PID controller is
applied to reduce any error when the deviations occurred. For example, when the temperature
in the reactor which detected by thermocouple sensor is higher than the set point, the air-to-
close valve, V-18 will open to allow more coolant enter. Hence, temperature in the reactor
can be reduce and reach the set point.
25
Control System: Pressure control
Tagging Label PIC10001
Objective of To maintain the pressure in the reactor at 1atm by controlling the inlet
Control flow rate
Measurements Pressure
Manipulated Inlet flow rate of coolant
Variables
Constraints 1-1.5 atm
Unwell mixing
Disturbances
Temperature drop at stream 9 might occur
Controller PID
Control Structure Feedback control system
Control valve (fail opened)
Additional Hand manual valve (fully closed)
Considerations Pressure alarm high to alert the operator about the overpressure
condition
The purpose of pressure control in the reactor is to maintain the pressure in the reactor
at 1atm by controlling the inlet flow rate. The pressure must be control to avoid overpressure
vessel conditions and safety precautions. In this case, feedback control system and PID
controller is applied. The constraint for this control is 1-1.5 atm. If the pressure output signal
deviates from the set point, the controller will make an immediate corrective action to reduce
the error. For example, when the pressure above the constraint, pressure alarm high will ring
to alert the operator about the overpressure condition, then controller immediately do any
necessary corrective action to reduce the error.
26
27
4.4.4. Heat Exchanger (E-101)
Function: To cool down the outlet stream of the reactor from 500 to 100 before enter the
Quench tower.
In the heat exchanger, the coolant water is used in order to cool down the temperature
from 500 to 100 , so that the plant operates safely and can achieve maximum energy
recovery. Hence, the temperature is measured in order to control the inlet stream of the heat
exchanger in the shell side to achieve the aim of changes of temperature from 500 to 100 .
In this system, the cascade control loop is implied with the PID controller in order to provide
an immediate action on controlling the final control element, V-27. For temperature sensor,
the thermocouple will detect the amount of the heat flow in the heat exchanger, and the
transmitter (TT) will detect any changes of the temperature and transmit the signal to
temperature indicator controller (TIC) where it alter the control valve to either open or close
to allow the inlet stream of the heat exchanger.
28
Control System: Flow control
Tagging Label FIC10404
Objective of To maintain the flow of the coolant in the heat exchanger in a stable
Control or required condition.
Measurements To measure the inlet flow of coolant
Manipulated The amount of the coolant inlet stream into the heat exchanger
Variables
Constraints Flow rate at inlet and outlet stream
- 13.81 kg/s
Disturbances Outlet stream of coolant
Controller PID
Control Structure Cascade Control Loop
Additional Control valve is fail to opened
Considerations Hand manual valve is fully closed
The flow of coolant water that enters the heat exchanger is measured in order to
control the amount of the coolant inlet stream at 13.81 kg/s. In this system, the cascade
control loop is implied with the PID controller in order to provide an immediate action on
controlling the final control element, V-27. For flow sensor, the orifice meter will detect the
amount of coolant flow rate in the inlet stream of the coolant at heat exchanger, and
transmitter (FT) will detect any changes of the flow rate and then transmit the signal to flow
indicator controller (FIC) where it alters the control valve to either open or close to allow the
inlet stream of the heat exchanger.
29
30
4.4.5. Quench Tower (V-101) and Condenser (E-102)
Quench Tower
Function: To lower the temperature of product gases and to remove the water content.
In the quench tower, water is used to cool down the product gases down to condense
steam into water. Hence, the flow rate of the input product gases is measured to control the
input flow rate of the water in order to achieve the aim of changes of steam from gaseous
phase to liquid water. As the boiling temperature of water is about 100 under standard
condition, when the water inflow is insufficient, the cooling effect reduces and less steam
would able to condense into water. Therefore, in this system, feedback control system is
implied with a PID controller to provide an immediate action on controlling the final control
element, V-22. However, there are still some constraints as stated in the table above. For
example, the decreases in efficiency of pump P-101 due to failure. When the pumped output
flow rate of water is larger than the desired flow rate, the excessive water can be returned
back to P-101 via the recycling stream to avoid overpressure towards valve V-22.
31
Control System: Level control
Tagging Label LIC10102
Objective of To control the water level in vessel V-101
Control
Measurements Water Level
Manipulated Outlet flow rate of waste water
Variables
Constraints Maximum flow rate at fully opened valve is 1200 ton/ hr
Disturbances Channeling of water on vessel wall
Controller PI
Control structure Feedback control
Additional Recycle stream back to pump P-101
Considerations
As the steam content in the product gases would be condensed into water, the water
temporary stored at the bottom of the vessel V-101 and eventually removed via V-13.
However, the water level in the vessel required control system to avoid overflow in the
vessel. Thus, the water level in the vessel is measured using radar sensors to detect the water
level and control the removal of water by manipulating the flow rate through V-13. In this
case, a feedback control system with PI controller is installed to monitor the deviation of
water level beyond it set point and take action on controlling V-13 by increasing the opening
of valve. Since the high water level gives insignificant effect to the main aims of the
quenching process other than overflowing, additional considerations are eliminated to cut
cost.
32
Condenser
Function: To condense portion of top product from quench tower V-101
Condenser E-102 is used to condense portion of top product from quench tower V-
101. First and foremost, the temperature of the top product must be reduced before undergo
condensation process. Hence, temperature control becomes very effective in order to reduce
the temperature at outlet stream from 80 -38 . This objective can be achieved by
manipulating the inlet flow of cold water. Cascade control system with PID controller is
applied to reduce any error when the deviations occurred. For example, when the outlet
temperature which detected by thermocouple sensor is higher than the set point, the air-to-
close valve, V-27 will open to allow more coolant enter. Hence, outlet temperature can be
reduce and reach the set point.
33
Control System: Level Control
Tagging Label LIC10203
Objective of To make sure the level of waste water always at the safe level
Control
Measurements Level
Manipulated The final control element which is air-to-close (fail open) valve
Variables
Constraints Maximum level at fully opened valve is 1200 ton/hr
Disturbances Flow rate inlet and outlet of waste water
Controller PI
Control Structure Feedback loop
Control valve (fail opened)
Additional Hand manual valve (fully closed)
Considerations
Level alarm high to alert operator about the excessive level
After the outlet temperature has been reduced, the top product is then undergoes
condensation process in order to remove waste water from the top product. Hence, to make
sure the level of waste water always at the safe level, level control is applied. The variable
that must be adjusted to achieve the objective is the final control element which is air-to-close
(fail open) valve. For this case, feedback control system and PI controller is applied. Both
feedback control system and PI controller are responsible to take any action in order to
reduce the error. In this loop, the constraint in this loop is maximum level at fully opened
valve is 1200 ton/hr while the sensor is orifice meter. For example, when level above the
constraint, level alarm high will ring to alert the operator about the excessive level conditions.
After that, the control valve V-29 is open to allow more waste water flow out.
34
Control System: Pressure Control
Tagging Label PT10102
Objective of To maintain the pressure in the reactor at 1atm by controlling the output
Control flow rate
Measurements Pressure
Manipulated Inlet flow rate
Variables
Constraints 1-1.5 atm
Disturbances Input flow rate
Controller PI
Control Structure Feedback loop
The purpose of pressure control in the condenser is to maintain the pressure in the
reactor at 1atm by controlling the inlet flow rate. The pressure must be controlled for the
safety purpose. In this case, feedback control system and PID controller is applied. Basically,
the constraint for this control is 1-1.5 atm. If the pressure output signal deviates from the set
point, the controller will make an immediate corrective action to reduce the error. For
example, when the pressure deviates from the set point, controller immediately do any
necessary corrective action to reduce the error.
35
Cold Water
33
FT FIC
10404 10404
TT TIC
10505 10505
16 PT
10102 10102
E-102 18
12
LT
10203
LAH
17
15 I/P
V-22 V-29 V-30
Water 14
Driver V-23
11
Motor P-101 V-101
Waste
Water
FIC
10303
FT
10303 LTLT
10102
LIC
10102
V-25
V-26 I/P
13
Waste Water
36
4.4.6. Hydrocarbon Absorption Tower (V-102) and Stripping Tower (V-103)
Hydrocarbon Absorption Tower
Function: To remove the flue gases from the product gases mixture by absorbing butadiene
using oil.
To control the effectiveness of the absorption of butadiene by oil from the product
gases, the ratio between the oil and the gas plays an important role and hence, the input flow
rate of the product gas is measured to manipulate the input flow rate of oil at the fixed ratio.
Hence, ratio control loop with feedback PID controller is applied in the control to provide to
maintain the input of both oil and butadiene at desired ratio and flow rate. Similarly, the
disturbance such as unstable pump efficiency can be adjusted by the additional or safety
consideration which a recycling stream is installed to avoid overpressure at valve V-50.
37
Control System: Pressure control
Tagging Label PIC10304
Objective of To prevent overpressure in the vessel
Control
Measurements Pressure
Manipulated Outlet flow rate of butadiene gas
Variables
Constraints 1atm - 2atm
Disturbances Temperature in the vessel
Controller PID
Control Structure Feedback Control
Additional Relief valve
Considerations
This separation process can be carried out under relatively low pressure at the
atmospheric pressure. However, the process might build up pressure in the process due to it is
a closed vessel even it is insignificant at slightly higher than 1 atm, a safety measure is still
essential. The pressure inside the vessel will be detected by the strain gauge pressure sensor
installed, transmitting the information to electrical signal to the controller and thus transducer
carry out the job of adjusting the pneumatic valve as discussed in section 4.2.3. The outlet
flow rate of the flue gas from the top of V-102 is manipulated to control the pressure in the
vessel as pressure built up. For example, when the pressure in the vessel built up due to the
increase in oil level or temperature, the opening of the valve V-34 would open wider,
allowing waste gas to flow to the downstream and prevent overpressure. For safety
consideration, relief angle valve is located at the top of the vessel to release pressure when
necessary.
38
Control System: Level control
Tagging Label LIC10304
Objective of To prevent overflow
Control
Measurements Oil level in the vessel
Manipulated Output flow of the oil to V-102
Variables
Constraints Maximum flow rate at fully opened valve is 1200 ton/ hr
Disturbances Channeling on the wall of the vessel
Controller PI
Control Structure Feedback Control
Additional Bypass valve
Considerations
In V-102, oil is flow from the top of the vessel, in contact with the product gases,
absorbing the hydrocarbon butadiene and flow out from the vessel. Hence, there is definitely
oil assembled at the bottom of the vessel before flowing out via stream 21 to downstream V-
102. It is important to monitor and control the flow rate of the oil to the downstream as
overflow in the vessel leads to inefficient absorbing effect which causes loss and less
production. A radar level sensor used here to continuously detect the level of the oil in the
vessel to manipulate the opening of valve V-36 to the downstream stripping tower. A PI
controller is used in a feedback control loop to monitor the level and when exceeding the
safety level, control action will be taken on controlling the outlet of oil via valve V-36 to the
downstream equipment, the stripping tower (V-103). To be safe, a hand actuated bypass
valve, V-37 is installed to enable manual handling of the process to control the level.
39
Stripping Tower (V-103)
Function: To separate butadiene from oil
To optimize the separating process of butadiene from the oil, temperature is the main
concern to be controlled. In this temperature control loop, the temperature in the vessel V-103
is detected and controlled by manipulating the flow rate or amount of fuel used in E-105 for
refluxing the oil. The high temperature is maintained aiming to separate as much as possible
of the butadiene gas from the liquid oil. Therefore, the fuel input representing the amount of
heat energy input at E-101 to further rise the temperature up to desired set point. In this case,
PID controller is installed in the feedback control loop to take immediate action as the
temperature varies from set point.
40
20 Waste gas Cold Water
35
V-35 V-34 I/P FT FIC
10707 10707
TIC
PIC V-41 V-40 I/P 10708
PT
10203 10304
V-58 TT
10707
I/P
PIC
22 10405
PT
30
Hot Water 10405
V-52
LT
10405
PT PIC
10304 10304
V36 LIC
10405
V-43
19
LT V-42
29
FT
FT
10304
10505
LIC
10304
FIC I/P
10505
V-103
TT TIC
10808 10708
I/P
RC
10102
V-36
28 21
V-37 25
I/P
TT TIC
10909 10809
Cold E-105
Water
V-50
FT
10606
23
34
V-51 FIC
10606 V-45
24
P-102 V-44
Fuel I/P
TIC TT
10506 10606
V-46
E-103
I/P
Hot
wat
er
41
4.4.7. Heat Exchanger (E-103)
Function: To cool down the outlet stream of the stripping tower from 130 to 38 before
enter pump.
In the heat exchanger, the coolant water is used in order to cool down the temperature
from 130 to 38 , so that the plant operates safely and can achieve maximum energy
recovery. Hence, the temperature is measured in order to control the inlet stream of the heat
exchanger in the shell side to achieve the aim of changes of temperature 130 to 38 . In
this system, the cascade control loop is implied with the PID controller in order to provide an
immediate action on controlling the final control element, V-48. For temperature sensor, the
thermocouple will detect the amount of the heat flow in the heat exchanger, and the
transmitter (TT) will detect any changes of the temperature and transmit the signal to
temperature indicator controller (TIC) where it alter the control valve to either open or close
to allow the inlet stream of the heat exchanger.
42
Control System: Flow control
Tagging Label FIC10606
Objective of To maintain the flow of the coolant in the heat exchanger in a stable
Control or required condition.
Measurements To measure the inlet of coolant flow
Manipulated The amount of the coolant inlet stream into the heat exchanger
Variables
Constraints Flow rate at inlet and outlet stream
- 2.52 kg/s
Disturbances Outlet stream of coolant
Controller PID
Control Structure Cascade Control Loop
Additional Control valve is fail to opened
Considerations Hand manual valve is fully closed
The flow of coolant water that enters the heat exchanger is measured in order to
control the amount of the coolant inlet stream at 2.52 kg/s. In this system, the cascade control
loop is implied with the PID controller in order to provide an immediate action on controlling
the final control element, V-48. For flow sensor, the orifice meter will detect the amount of
coolant flow rate in the inlet stream of the coolant at heat exchanger, and transmitter (FT)
will detect any changes of the flow rate and then transmit the signal to flow indicator
controller (FIC) where it alters the control valve to either open or close to allow the inlet
stream of the heat exchanger.
43
44
4.5 Control Action
Control action is the pathways of each control loop designed for the equipment.
Since the fluid flow in this plant is mainly in gaseous phase, orifices are the sensors
that mainly used in this production plant due to the reasons as stated in section 4.2.5. The
orifice measure the pressure drops and thus determine the fluid flow rate in a stream. The
flow rate measurement is thus transmitted to a controller by a transmitter. The electric signal
is sent from the transmitter to the flow indication controller which mounted on board where
the measurement readings are shown to ease the monitoring operators. At the same time, the
flow controller takes action to adjust the final control element, mostly is a pneumatic
diaphragm valve. The electric signal converted into pneumatic signal which control the
opening of the valve to manipulate the flow rate.
In this plant, the ratio of the input flow rates of n-butene, air and steam for the process
at mixer M-101 and reactor R-101 is important to produce the product gases at desired
composition. Therefore, feedback controls loop with a ratio controller. By measuring the
input flow rate of n-butene, the input flow rate of air and steam can be manipulated to the
ratio n-butene, air, steam of 1:2.6:10 for the oxidative dehydrogenation process producing n-
butadiene in the fixed bed reactor. In the case of low inflow of n-butene, the PID controller
takes action to control the inflow of both the air and steam into the amount at the fixed ratio
to the n-butene input by manipulating valve V-11 and V-13 simultaneously. Similarly, this
feedback ratio control is also applied in this in V-102.
The field mounted radar sensor is installed for a continuous liquid level control. When
the sensor detected the reflection of radar, the feedback is transmitted into electric signal and
send to a board mounted level indicating controller to display the measurements and take
control action by sending the electric signal to the current-pneumatic (I/P) transducer. The
I/P transducer is then convert the electric into pneumatic signal to control the final control
element of the system, which is mainly the auto-actuated pneumatic diaphragm valve.
45
For example, n-butene storage tank T-101 in this production plant utilised the level
control system to control the level of the liquid n-butene in the tank. By adjusting the opening
of the valve according to the signals from the sensor to the controller and from the controller
to the transducer, the flow rate of the input n-butene at stream 1 can be controlled. This is to
maintain the level of n-butene in the tank which representing the amount of raw materials for
the production, either to avoid overflow or in this case is to avoid shorts in raw material for
the production. Similar level control action is applied on the process unit V-101, E-102, V-
102, V-103, E-104 for the purpose of level controlling to avoid overflow.
To control pressure, the pressure sensor such as strain gauge is one of the most
commonly used in production plant. This sensor detect the pressure, transmitter transmits the
information into electric signal and send to the pressure controller. A pressure indicating
controller thus takes action in manipulating the other variables such as output flow in a
process unit to control the pressure at desired safety level. The electric signal is converted
into pneumatic signal to control the opening of the automated diaphragm valve by air flow.
In hydrocarbon absorption tower, V-102, absorption of butadiene gas into oil can
occurs under relatively low pressure of 1 atm. However, when the vessel is loaded with oil
and gases, the pressure inside the tank may increases and hence a pressure control system is
required to prevent overpressure. In this plant, a PI controller is used in the feedback control
loop to regulate the pressure back to 1 atm by manipulating the output flow rate of the waste
flue gas. The feedback pressure control is located at the process unit R-101, V-101, E-101, V-
102, V-103 and E-104.
46
4.5.4. Temperature Control System
Taking heat exchanger E-101 as an example, the temperature of the output stream 11
of the heat exchanger is measured using thermocouple. As if the temperature of stream 11 is
above the set point, this means that the heat exchanger did not hit the desired target to lower
the temperature of the product gas to that point. Therefore, the PID controller in the cascade
loop in this case would take immediate action on correcting the error by manipulating the
input flow of cold water into the heat exchanger. When the temperature in stream 11 is
beyond the set point, the controller adjusts the opening of the valve to allow higher flow rate
of water, more heat is able to be transferred by the cold water cooling system in the heat
exchanger and eventually, the temperature drops to the desired one. In this plant, condenser
E-102 and E-104 also utilized the similar principle in temperature controlling.
47
References
Chen, K. P. ( 2016). High Spatial Resolution Distributed Fiber-Optic Sensor Networks for
Reactors and Fuel Cycle Nuclear Energy.
E-Seborg, D., F.Edgar, T., and A.Mellichamp, D. (2004). Process Dynamic and Control
(second edition ed.): John Wiley & sons, Inc.
48