Perspectives in Human Geography
Perspectives in Human Geography
Regional Synthesis
In one line:
Regional Synthesis =study (spatial, temporal, human)
An American Geographer, J.L Berry, explains the regional synthesis through the geographical
matrix.
In Geographical Matrix, there are three dimensions:
Ist: Rows represent attributes
2nd: Columns represent locations
3rd: Time
In this matrix, each cell has a geographical fact.
The following diagram shows the basic features of Berry geographical matrix of Delhi Region
(in this matrix we considered matura location is part of Delhi region).
As per Berry geographical matrix, there are ten approaches to do regional analysis and same
are listed below:
Cells within row show the spatial distributions of geographical features. In the above
geographical matrix, the first geographical feature is temperature.
1. Cells within the column show the localized geographical features. In the above
geographical matrix, New Delhi localized regional analysis variables are temperature,
rainfall, and humidity.
2. Spatial variation can be studied by comparing two rows
3. Areal differentiation can be studied by comparing two column
4. Study of sub-matrix
5. Study of spatial variation by comparing the same row through time which is temporal-
spatial covariation. Example caparison of the present-day temperature of New Delhi with
100 years ago temperature.
6. We can get sequence occupancy of a particular location by comparing the same column
through time.
7. Comparing a row with another row across the time dimension
8. Comparing a column with other columns across the time dimension.
9. The comparison and study of sub-matrix across the time dimension
Importance of Regional Synthesis is the current time:
Global temperature rise is not a sudden phenomenon and it is not uniform worldwide. By
using regional synthesis analysis one can easily get a trend of temperature rise in
region wise.
It helps to study of sequence occupance of region
Regional Synthesis help to analyze the regional disparity within and with another region
by comparing the economic variable across the temporal analysis.
3) Dichotomy(विरोधाभास) and Dualism(द्वै तवाद ) in
Geography
The literal meaning of dualism is two opposite views/aspects of the same subject. Dichotomy
happened when two views emerged on the same subject.
There are five dichotomies and dualisms in geography:
1. Contemporary vs Historical geography
2. Physical vs Human geography
3. Deterministic approach vs possibilistic approach
4. Regional vs System approach
5. Functional vs formal approach
Contemporary vs Historical geography:
Some geographers emphasized the importance of historical geography, as it deals with past
geographical features. Because of the following reason, the study of the historical aspect of
geography is needed:
We get the information about the physical and cultural landscape evolution
Evolution of settlement pattern through time, from unplanned settlements to planned city
planning
Past hazardous data. example submergence and the emergence of the island, tsunami, and
earthquake destruction, etc.
Geographical changes through time, for example, peneplain, plateau, the evolution of
mountain, etc
Some geographer emphasized the importance of the study of contemporary geography, as need
of people has evolved, as geographer do not want to waste the energy and time to study historical
data.
Because of the following reasons, the study of contemporary geography is important:
Due to climate change, there is a need for a sustainable way of planning.
Solid waste management, plastic, pollutions are contemporary issues
Due to technological advancement, now humans can create an artificial environment,
artificial minerals, many more.
Physical vs Human geography
Physical geography school of thought emphasized the study of geography as a separate entity
where the influence of man is neglected.
Under Physical geography, we study the physical features of the earth.
Study of landform, climate, vegetation, mountain building, etc, comes under physical
geography.
Environment role
Human geography school of thought emphasized the role of humans, culture, language, society,
etc, in geography. Under this:
Give more importance to man and environment relations. In physical geography,
humanly considered passive elements, but in human geography, man is active, passive, or
both. The same applied to the environment also, nature can be active, passive, or both.
Under this, we study, cultural geography, language, demographic, economic growth and
development, model theory related to industry and economy development, social study.
Human role in Human geography
• Behaviouralism in Geography
Why Behaviouralism developed?
Because of the following reasons:
It developed due to the reaction of the quantitative and positivist approach, As the
quantitative revolution considered humans as economic rationality, however the same is
not true as per behaviouralism.
As per Wolpert's study, optimal farming practice is not done by Swedish farmers
although having very fertile and productive land, they were satisfied with 60 %
productivity.
Indian farmers also used excess fertilizer that reduces the long-run productivity of
the land.
From the above two examples, we can say humans are not profit maximizers but
merely satisficers.
The decision of humans is subjective in nature, can not be quantified as per the
quantitative tool.
As the quantitative revolution reject the role of human values, belief, culture, etc in
decision making, but the reality is different, the contribution of values, culture, religion in
the human decision can be seen in daily life. Example, temple visit is a totally religious
decision, not an economic decision, and vary person to person and this decision can be
subjective in nature.
Mental Map:
Each person has their own perception of the environment and the same is depended on
his moral, pre-knowledge, culture, social, and economic background, an environmental
image is created in the human mind in each individual, is also called Mental Map. Each
people have their own Mental Map, for example,
Each people have route map from home to office and that will vary person to
person
Work planning and prioritizing for the day is also a mental map.
There are high bonding on a mental map and actual decision making. People make
decisions based on their mental map, for example, route selection from office to home
vary person to person, the selection is based on his mental map.
Basic Concept in Behaviouralism:
The following diagram shows the basic concept of behaviouralism:
Geographical knowledge:
Each people and animal have their own mental map of the environment based on
geographical knowledge of the particular location. Examples,
Mental map of tribal people, they know the location of herbs, trees, water
storage, etc.
Animals in the forest have a mental map, they returned home after day-
long grazing.
Animal know where to hide while raining
Animal or men fear to go some particular place as they know it dangerous
to go.
Migratory bird such as Siberian cranes has a mental map which helps them
to find the route to migrate.
Territory and place:
Some animals like dogs, tiger defend their territory.
Some animal such as man becomes sentimental to his birthplace( we all do),
people are attached to his/her birthplace not because of economic reason because
of the sentiment.
Crowding and privacy:
Some people feel more secure in a crowded area, for example, recently in Hong
Kong, large crowded protesters protested in the airport of Hong Kong as they fear
suppression from the Chinese government, they feel more secure to protest on
CCTV areas in the airport.
Crowding creates more tension in the geographical region.
Privacy also affects the thinking process, alone and stress-free people are more
innovative than stress full people
Livelihood and economics:
The main purpose of human activities is for livelihood and social prospects.
Humanism geography differentiates the difference between livelihood and
destroyed, for example, the liquor ban in Bihar
Religion:
Religion is the way to bind people strongly by belief, faith, religious activities.
In India,
the meat business is done by generally Muslim
Jains are generally traders
Criticism
Man is not considered a rational person
It considered humanism is separate geography and supported to study physical geography
and human geography separately, in reality, the same is not true, man and environment
are interrelated.
This method is more subjective than objective, it is like social science.
We do not know the humanistic explanation is true because can not be objectified.
• Welfare approaches
The welfare approach in geography was developed against quantitative and locational analysis.
As quantitative and location analysis is similar to the capitalist policy, it created many social and
economic problems, and welfare approach is developed to make positive changes of common
men, and it deals with social and economic justice such as:
Inequality
Poverty
Gender discrimination
Women inferiority
Crime
Education and health care facilities.
Welfare for all
Environment control & Sustainable planning
For example, the main victim of inflation would be poor people, development should be focus
to reduce inflation at an optimum level.
Approaches in welfare geography
There are two approaches to welfare geography.
Discriptive approach
Process oriented approach
Descriptive approach:
The descriptive approach is used to identify injustice & inequality in a particular population in a
particular area. For example, identifying the beneficiary of toilet construction, fertilizer subsidy.
The descriptive approach is based on the following principles, it is shown in the diagram.
Welfare approaches
Who?
Identifying the subgroup of the population to whom should give preferential
treatment or give overburden, for example, for the welfare of the society, the poor
should get the subsidy and rich should pay tax.
What?
Who gets what, what should be given to the targeted population? it can be:
Cloth, Food grains, House
Water, roads, LPG
Education, health, social justice, etc
Where?
Who gets where it deals with identifying the region of the target and welfare
should be based on the region-specific. Livelihood and requirement of the
different region are different, for example,
city planning model cant be implemented in the village
Plain area development not suited in the hilly area
Designing of houses in the city is not fitted for the village.
How?
Who gets how it deals with the process involved in welfare geography, such as
Top-down approach
Bottom to Up approach
what cost they are going to pay to get a particular service
How much they are working to get basic service.
Process-oriented approach:
It deals with how social and economic injustice existed in society.
Why the richer segment of the population is getting richer day by day and poorer are
getting poor day by day.
Contribution of geographer in welfare geography:
The following are:
Pareto Optimality:
Poor people can not be sustained or get better without at expense of rich people.
Someone must be compromised for better of for others.
Pareto supported the special treatment of poor people for welfare, for example,
subsidies scheme for the poor.
Smith & Knox :
Smith was the first geographer who coined the welfare geography, and he has
written a book "welfare geography". He stated that:
A quantitative tool such as GDP & GNP is not necessarily a direct measurement
of quality of life.
There should be a qualitative tool such as happiness index, HDI (both later
developed) to measure the welfare of society
The main focus in geography should be the focus on the welfare of people.
7) Language, Religions and secularisation
• Language
Language is the expression of ideas through speech sound combined into words. The following
are the importance of language:
Languages are the main source of culture consideration
Culture practice, moral values, literature, etc pass on generation to generation through language.
Language is one of the variables in the demarcation of regions, for example, most of the Indian
states are created based on language.
Dialect:
It is a particular form of language that is limited to the geographical or social region.
Language of the world:
• Religion
Communities of the same supernatural belief and moral values that bind people together is
religion.
Why the study of religion is needed in geography?
Religious festivals, food, and ceremonies are shaped by the physical environment.
It helps the study the religion & environment relation
Religion supports Sustainable development, environment conservation, and improve the
welfare of the population.
Diffusion of religion
The Major religion of the world was originated in a small area but spread to a large part of the
world by:
Invasion, for example, Islam
Conquering
Missionary, for example, Buddhism, Christianity
Politically imperialism
Expansion of political boundaries
Migration of population
Secularization
Secularization is the process to make :
People logical
Improve a scientific study
Remove the dominance of religious institutions and symbols from society.
To separate religion from state.
Cultural shifts in society and make the society free from superstition
Communal harmony
• What is Culture?
Culture is the way of the life of people. For example, the way of life of Indian people such as
food, cloth, moral values, are different from European people hence culture is different. Based on
the geographical influences, the following two types of culture are:
Culture type
Folk culture :
It changes region to region, for example, Indian culture is different from European or Latin
culture.
Popular culture:
It is spread across the world, for example, as of now wearing jeans is popular culture.
Each culture has some geographical area of influence and this area is called realms of that
culture. The following are the major cultural realms of the world:
North America
Latin America
European Realm
Soviet Russia
Arab Realm
Black Africa
South Asia or the Indian realm
Japan
8) Human Development Index
As in welfare and radical approaches emphasized to focus on the wellbeing of people rather than
a quantitative measure. HDI is one of the indexes that measure the quality of life of the
population. HDI is a comparative measurement tool that measures life expectancy, literacy, and
standard of living worldwide.
The following are included to measure the wellbeing of people:
Real freedom of people
Freedom to choose the profession, education, politics, etc
Economic opportunities
Free from any type of discrimination such as gender, race, caste, etc.
The standard of life includes access to basic amenities such as food, clean water, toilet,
basic infrastructure, house, school, hospital, etc.
It was developed by Pakistani economics Mr. Mahbub ul Haq and later Indian economics Mr.
Amartya Sen work on capabilities and functioning of the HDI.
The human development index is the geometric mean of the three normalized indices.
HDI =geometric mean of ( Life expectancy index, education index, income index)
As of now, HDI is being published by the UNDP ( United Nations Development Programme). In
2018, HDI Ranking are:
1st: Norway
2nd: Switzerland
3rd: Australia
130: India, HDI values: 0.640
India performance in HDI
HDI values in India are not uniformly in all-region. The following characteristics are:
Kerala rank first in Indian state having 0.784 HDI values which are higher than Mexican
HDI values.
Bihar rank last in Indian state having 0.566 which is equivalent to Pakistani HDI values.
Limitation of HDI
It does not include the women empowerment
Public Security and Crime not included
Gender discrimination, racial discrimination, etc not included