Citrix Cloud Services Total Economic Benefits Assessment Guide
Citrix Cloud Services Total Economic Benefits Assessment Guide
Contents
1 Executive Summary .......................................................................................................... 2
2 Citrix Cloud – A Brief Overview ........................................................................................ 3
3 Citrix Licensing Options – A Perspective ........................................................................... 5
3.1 Perpetual Licensing Economics ............................................................................................... 5
3.2 Subscription Based SaaS Delivery ............................................................................................ 6
3.3 Comparing Perpetual vs. SaaS ................................................................................................. 6
4 Estimating Cost Avoidances When Using Citrix Cloud Services .......................................... 7
4.1 Hard Cost Avoidances ............................................................................................................. 7
4.1.1 Reduced Maintenance and Support Costs ............................................................................. 7
4.1.2 Automatic software upgrading and patching ......................................................................... 7
4.1.3 Reduced Time-to-Value, Time-to-Production ......................................................................... 8
4.1.4 Automation with Smart Tool Management ............................................................................ 9
4.1.5 Reduced Installation and Management infrastructure ........................................................ 10
4.2 Soft Cost Avoidances ............................................................................................................ 12
4.2.1 Providing Flexible On-Ramp Options for Any Cloud ............................................................. 12
4.2.2 Security and Compliance Advantages ................................................................................... 13
4.2.3 Minimized Downtime Cost ................................................................................................... 14
4.2.4 Shifting Expenses from CapEx to OpEx ................................................................................. 14
4.2.5 Enable Disaster Recovery and Business Continuity options ................................................. 15
5 Conclusion ...................................................................................................................... 16
Citrix Cloud Servcies: Total Economic Benefits Assessment Guide
1 Executive Summary
Citrix Cloud services represent the fastest, simplest, and most flexible approach to delivering integrated
digital workspaces available today. Services are provided either as full Software-as-a-Service (SaaS), or
other cases, as hybrid cloud services where Citrix provides cloud-based management, while customers
determine where workloads are located. All services are sold in the form of 1- 2- and 3-year subscriptions
which include service activation, support, and constant SaaS-based updates during the lifetime of the
subscription.
This paper provides guidance to customers wanting to draw economic comparisons between perpetually
licensed Citrix software, and the newer Citrix Cloud service equivalents.
Compared to purchasing, installing, and maintaining traditional perpetually licensed software, the new
SaaS/Subscription approach offers unique technical, financial, and capability benefits. Some of the main
benefits and often cost avoidances that Citrix Cloud services bring to customers in this paper include:
Citrix Cloud also brings several intrinsic “soft” benefits to customers beyond cost avoidance; these
benefits should be evaluated holistically as customers consider cloud services versus software
implementation. This paper also provides insights and data intended to help Citrix Cloud services
customers create a framework from which they can quantify their own unique economic and net-new
capability benefits.
citrix.com/cloud
2
Citrix Cloud Servcies: Total Economic Benefits Assessment Guide
The Citrix Cloud platform can be thought of as a management plane spanning multiple services. The core
cloud services are operated and maintained by Citrix, and contain all management functions that
customers would otherwise have to install and provision themselves. By seamlessly managing the
infrastructure related operational tasks such as software version updates, maintenance and support,
services integration, etc. on behalf of the customer, Citrix Cloud enables its customers to better focus on
their core business rather than on maintaining Citrix infrastructure.
citrix.com/cloud
3
Citrix Cloud Servcies: Total Economic Benefits Assessment Guide
One of the critical values that Citrix Cloud services bring to customers is that they are easier and faster to
integrate than traditional software, and are ready to be consumed with minimal effort. In many cases, all
customers need to do is activate, configure, and onboard users to the services. Maintenance and support
tasks such as periodic installation of software version upgrades, patches, etc. is Citrix’s responsibility.
In a few cases (such as with the XenApp and XenDesktop service) management of certain software and
networking components is explicitly placed under customer management, ensuring that customers are in
complete control of proprietary data and workloads. For example, Virtual Delivery Agents** (VDAs) in
Resource Locations are explicitly under customer control/management, while all other XenApp and
XenDesktop components are cloud-based.
**VDA Definition: A VDA enables connections to applications and desktops. The VDA is installed on the
machine that runs the applications or virtual desktops for the user. It enables the machines to register
with Delivery Controllers and manage the High Definition eXperience (HDX) connection to a user device.
citrix.com/cloud
4
Citrix Cloud Servcies: Total Economic Benefits Assessment Guide
$120.00
$525.00
In the above example, the first year (i.e. Y0) cost includes the license cost (typically recorded as a capital
investment) plus the support and maintenance cost ($525 + $120). For Y1 - Y4, the customer pays just
support and maintenance cost ($120) for the subsequent years until the version of the software reaches
“End of Life” (EOL). Of course, the yearly support and maintenance fee is not mandatory and the
customer could potentially choose to discontinue paying this fee at any point in time. However, without
this fee, the customer will lose access to future upgrades, software support and patch releases. In the
scenario where upgrades and patches become available, it is the responsibility of the customer to install
these updates themselves.
It is also important to realize that in order to successfully deploy a software offering, there are other
significant costs including hardware, labor, datacenter heating and cooling, supporting infrastructure (e.g.
database, load balancer), etc. that need to be considered to establish a complete economic snapshot of
the associated cost structure.
citrix.com/cloud
5
Citrix Cloud Servcies: Total Economic Benefits Assessment Guide
$300
$250
$200
$150
$240 $240 $240 $240 $240
$100
$50
$-
Y0 Y1 Y2 Y3 Y4
As shown in the above graph, a typical Citrix Cloud service cost structure is constant and predictable,
often with lower (or no) infrastructure costs, and significantly less software and support, labor, and
datacenter-related investments. Most important, updates/patches are automatically tested and applied.
Lastly, as a subscription, accounting rules typically allow treatment of the cost as an operational (not
capital) expense.
citrix.com/cloud
6
Citrix Cloud Servcies: Total Economic Benefits Assessment Guide
Savings Estimation: Per Gartner Research, Inc., Software is either the first or second largest cost
in the IT budget; software support/maintenance accounts for between 50% - 60% of that overall
software cost.
In contrast, leveraging Citrix Cloud services helps eliminate most if not all of these typical
maintenance and support costs; besides the service subscription itself, there are no additional
requires maintenance costs.
citrix.com/cloud
7
Citrix Cloud Servcies: Total Economic Benefits Assessment Guide
Benefits Framework: Due to the complexity involved, enterprises tend to delay pushing software
upgrades out, sometimes indefinitely, as they want to avoid business disruption and associated
downtime. This effort is postponed until the enterprises hit a road block in the form of security
vulnerability, cyber-attack, software incompliance, or end of support for a software version.
With Citrix Cloud services, Citrix is responsible for the maintenance and support of the management
infrastructure including software version upgrades. This ensures customers are always on the latest
version of the software, and are compliant and protected against security vulnerabilities. (A current
exception is that management and support of XenApp and XenDesktop VDAs in customer-determined
resource locations are intentionally not updated automatically)
Savings Estimation: According to Gartner, enterprise software upgrades can cost up to 30%
of the original software installation price, can take more than a year to complete and require
companies to revamp their technology infrastructures and business practices. Direct upgrade
costs can include
• Installation
• Data migration
• Staging/test
• Roll-out & potential conversion downtime
The Citrix Cloud service delivery model eliminates any future need to patch or upgrade Citrix
technologies.
citrix.com/cloud
8
Citrix Cloud Servcies: Total Economic Benefits Assessment Guide
Savings Estimation: A typical 5,000 user XenDesktop traditional deployment may take 3-9 weeks to
1
stage, configure, deploy and move the core components into production including back-end resources and
necessary networking components.
In contrast, using the Citrix Cloud model, the customer is only responsible for the deployment and
maintenance of the VDAs and integration with the local Active Directory (AD). The remaining infrastructure
is deployed, configured and managed by Citrix. This could translate into a significantly shorter
implementation and test time for the customers thereby reducing time to production.
In the case of other Citrix Cloud services (i.e. Secure Browser, ShareFile, XenMobile Services, NetScaler
Gateway Service, NetScaler MAS and others) zero additional software or hardware or software provisioning
is required – services are simply activated and configured.
citrix.com/cloud
9
Citrix Cloud Servcies: Total Economic Benefits Assessment Guide
- Load and schedule-based scaling: Keeps a minimum number of machines powered on at time
periods the customer defines while accommodating the current level of demand for sessions.
Savings Estimation: In a hypothetical example with the Citrix Cloud XenApp and XenDesktop
Service, with VDAs deployed into a public cloud, Citrix Smart Scale can be used to control a
3,000 VM Delivery Group:
Assumptions
Number of VMs 3,000
Total hours/week VMs run 100% capacity 40
Total hours/week VMs run 50% capacity 16
Total hours/week VMs run 10% capacity 112
Hourly cost per VM $0.07
Annual Costs
citrix.com/cloud
10
Citrix Cloud Servcies: Total Economic Benefits Assessment Guide
Traditional Deployment Citrix Cloud Deployment
Figure 6: XenApp and XenDesktop Infrastructure Reduction with Citrix Cloud Implementation
Benefits Framework: Avoiding provisioning and maintaining hardware to support Citrix management is
the goal. Note
Hardware maintenance costs rise over time, and performance lags behind more current server offerings.
Energy efficiency is not as advanced in older server models, leading to increasing power/cooling costs in
the latter years of the server’s usable life cycle
Applications software and systems software fall behind the current versions available in the marketplace,
and security may require frequent updates. If the application or the system software is declared End-Of-
Life (EOL), security patches may no longer be provided, leaving the system vulnerable to cyber threats.
Savings Estimation: To illustrate the infrastructure reduction provided by Citrix Cloud, assume a
typical 1,000-user XenDesktop on-premises software environment. Per Citrix best-practices, between
4-10 servers may be required to support Delivery Controllers, Databases, Studio, Director, etc.,
(depending on performance, redundancy, etc.). This does not include the workload VDAs.
Where Citrix Cloud is applied, this hardware cost is completely avoided, as all services are provided
via the Citrix Cloud control plane.
Following industry statistics, a physical server’s initial capital cost may represent only 20%-50% of its
total cost of ownership (TCO) over a 3-5 year financial lifetime.
In the case of other Citrix Cloud services (i.e. Secure Browser, ShareFile, XenMobile Services,
NetScaler Gateway Service, NetScaler MAS and others) zero hardware provisioning is required –
services are simply activated and configured.
citrix.com/cloud
11
Citrix Cloud Servcies: Total Economic Benefits Assessment Guide
Benefits Estimation: The true hybrid nature of Citrix Cloud brings the following benefit to its
customers:
a. Lower cloud adoption cost: Thanks to its hybrid characteristics, Citrix Cloud helps lower adoption
cost and transition risk. For VDA workloads, customers have the freedom of leveraging their
existing infrastructure investments and have the flexibility to choose any public cloud they prefer
to deploy into. No “fork-lift” migration is necessary. For existing Citrix perpetual software
customers, promotional transition licensing is available that includes “hybrid rights” allowing them
to simultaneously operate both on-premises and in-the-cloud implementations.
b. Minimize cloud lock-in risk: One of the biggest concerns customers have with migrating to the
public cloud is that it becomes difficult to move workloads elsewhere. Citrix Cloud is completely
cloud-agnostic in nature, and allows for workloads to be moved to another cloud or to any on-
premises environment. In fact, customers can run and manage multiple Citrix workloads in
multiple clouds, simultaneously.
citrix.com/cloud
12
Citrix Cloud Servcies: Total Economic Benefits Assessment Guide
Benefits Estimation:
a) Data location flexibility: From a compliance standpoint, Citrix Cloud significantly facilitates security,
compliance and data sovereignty requirements by allowing customers to locate desktops and
sensitive data in the location(s) of their choice, while managing those multiple locations all from a
single management plane. Customers need only deploy VDAs in required locations and manage
the corresponding data as per local or regional compliance needs (as shown in Figure 7).
citrix.com/cloud
13
Citrix Cloud Servcies: Total Economic Benefits Assessment Guide
Benefits Estimation:
a) Fully-managed platform: Citrix Cloud is monitored on a 24x7x365, and services run on a highly-
available and globally-distributed infrastructure. This minimizes the customer’s downtime risk for the
components that Citrix manages, and alleviates much of customer needs to design for availability
(customers are still responsible for the VDAs and their availability).
Benefits Estimation:
a) Avoiding cost-of-capital hurdles: By shifting from a CapEx to an OpEx model, customers can potentially
eliminate risk and unpredictability associated with large hardware/software investments. IT SaaS infrastructure
can become a regular, predictable, and often consumption-based operational expense – often preferred by
finance departments. This avoids cost-of-capital expenses as well as return-on-capital requirements.
citrix.com/cloud
14
Citrix Cloud Servcies: Total Economic Benefits Assessment Guide
Benefits Estimation:
a) Simplifies recovery location creation/management: Citrix Cloud can easily manage multiple Resource
Locations across data centers or clouds or a hybrid of both – making it easier to establish and
maintain primary and secondary availability locations. This helps avoid the cost of duplicate Citrix
management facilities.
b) Facilitates Disaster Recovery: Citrix Cloud simplifies how Delivery Groups of VDAs are created,
allowing administrators to create duplicate Delivery Groups in recovery locations. In the event of an
unforeseen outage in a primary location, the Citrix Cloud console can be used to activate Delivery
Groups in a recovery location(s) – helping avoid the redundant cost of establishing duplicate Citrix
management facilities.
Further References and Data Points:
1) IDC Survey: Downtime Costs Large Company Billions
a. http://devopsdigest.com/idc-survey-appdynamics-devops-application-performance
2) Disaster Recovery Is Not Business Continuity
b. http://www.datacenterknowledge.com/archives/2013/01/04/disaster-recovery-is-not-business-
continuity/
3) Citrix Cloud Business Continuity Advantage (Blog)
c. https://www.citrix.com/blogs/2017/04/05/citrix-cloud-business-continuity-advantage/
citrix.com/cloud
15
Citrix Cloud Servcies: Total Economic Benefits Assessment Guide
5 Conclusion
Compared to the traditional purchasing, installing, and maintaining of traditional perpetually licensed
software, Citrix Cloud’s SaaS/Subscription approach offers unique technical, financial, and capability
benefits.
Considering the additional value, convenience, speed and reliability of SaaS-style delivery, Citrix Cloud
services provide a superior economic and strategic option to purchasing and maintaining a traditional
Citrix environment.
Purchasing evaluations based upon sole comparisons of cash outflows for perpetual licensing versus
SaaS-style subscription access may fail to take into account hard- and soft-cost avoidances, as well as
net-new value and capabilities.
When building an economic model for Citrix Cloud services, Citrix recommends customers factoring-in the
value of net-new capabilities, as well as using industry benchmarks to estimate direct and indirect savings
of infrastructure, updating, time, labor, and implementation risk.
To learn more about Citrix Cloud services, please visit https://www.citrix.com/cloud
About Citrix
Citrix (NASDAQ: CTXS) aims to power a world where people, organizations and things are securely connected and accessible to
make the extraordinary possible. Its technology makes the world’s apps and data secure and easy to access, empowering people to
work anywhere and at any time. Citrix provides a complete and integrated portfolio of secure digital workspace, application delivery,
virtualization, mobility, network delivery and file sharing solutions that enables IT to ensure critical systems are securely available to
users via the cloud or on-premises and across any device or platform. With annual revenue in 2016 of $3.42 billion, Citrix solutions
are in use by more than 400,000 organizations and 100 million users globally. Learn more at www .citrix.com.
Copyright © 2017 Citrix Systems Inc. All rights reserved. Citrix, Citrix XenApp and XenDesktop, other marks appearing herein are
trademarks of Citrix Systems, Inc. and/or one or more of its subsidiaries, and may be registered in the U.S. Patent and Trademark
Office and in other countries. All other trademarks and registered trademarks are property of their respective owners.
Revised July 2017.
citrix.com/cloud
16