Positive Behaviour Support Guide
Positive Behaviour Support Guide
November, 1999
This is one of many publications available through the Bureau of
Instructional Support and Community Service, Florida Department of
Education, designed to assist school districts, state agencies which
support educational programs, and parents in the provision of special
programs. For additional information on this publication, or for a list of
available publications, contact the Clearinghouse Information Center,
Bureau of Instructional Support and Community Services, Division of
Public Schools and Community Education, Florida Department of
Education, Room 628 Turlington Building, Tallahassee, Florida 32399-
0400 (Telephone: (850) 488-1879; FAX: (850) 487-2679; Suncom 278-
1879; email: [email protected]).
Facilitator’s Guide
Positive Behavioral Support
Copyright
State of Florida
Department of State
1999
Positive Behavioral Support Project: Team Training & Technical Assistance vii
Introduction
Background
Behavior problems of students with disabilities can pose risks to
safety, result in loss of instructional time, and lead to physical or
educational exclusion. There has been growing dissatisfaction with
many common intervention methods because they are often too
narrowly defined, focused exclusively on consequences, unacceptably
intrusive, inappropriate for integrated settings, and/or ineffective in
producing meaningful changes in student behavior. In response to
these concerns, current approaches are individualized and better suited
to various educational environments.
Positive Positive behavioral support is an approach to intervention that integrates
Behavioral Support technical features of applied behavior analysis with person-centered
values. It offers a process for designing individualized approaches to
is a process for designing
individualized behavioral
support students experiencing behavioral difficulties in school, home,
intervention plans based on and community environments (Bambara, Mitchell-Kvacky, & Iacobelli,
understanding relationships 1994; Bishop & Jubala, 1995; Horner et al., 1990; Koegel, Koegel, &
between a student’s behavior and Dunlap, 1996). Positive behavioral support incorporates functional
aspects of his or her environment behavioral assessment and leads to behavioral intervention plans that are
(i.e., acquired through a
functional behavioral
positive (i.e., proactive, educative, and functional) in nature.
assessment). Plans include: Recent mandates including the reauthorization of the Individuals with
• modifications to the Disabilities Education Act (Public Law 105-17, 1997) and
environment corresponding regulations support positive, assessment-based
• teaching skills to replace approaches to student behavior problems. The IDEA amendments
problem behaviors require that functional behavioral assessments be conducted and
• effective management of intervention plans be developed when disciplinary sanctions result in
consequences
extended removal (i.e., 10 days or more) of students from
• promotion of positive educational settings. The amendments further encourage the use of
life-style changes
“positive behavioral interventions, strategies, and supports” when
addressing the needs of students whose behavior impedes their
learning or the learning of others.
Facilitator Competencies
Facilitator’s Role. This guide is intended to be used by
facilitators as they guide teams through a process of
positive behavioral support. Facilitators should have
training and experience in functional behavioral assessment
and intervention. They might represent a variety of
disciplines and roles in education (e.g., teachers, behavior
specialists, school psychologist, administrators) or another
Identifying Goals
Goals
The first step in the positive behavioral support process is
to determine the goals of intervention. Preliminary work
should include developing a profile of the student’s
strengths and needs, identifying the team members who
will be involved in behavioral support, and targeting
specific settings and situations which require intervention.
Awareness of a student’s strengths and needs will help the
team determine intervention goals and support the student.
STUDENT:
Consider:
• Have all environments in which the student interacts been considered?
• Have all people who know the student well been considered?
• Have key persons involved in possible supports and/or resources been
considered?
Ground Rules
Rule 1:
Rule 2:
Rule 3:
Rule 4:
Rule 5:
Questions to Consider:
• What would increase or strengthen the student’s
friendships and social support?
• How can participation and inclusion in the student’s
home, school, and community be increased?
• What would increase the student’s opportunity to
exercise appropriate choice making and control aspects
of his or her life?
• How can the student’s self esteem and confidence be
strengthened?
• What barriers might interfere with the student’s progress?
Questions to Consider
What would increase or strengthen the studentÕs friendships and social support?
How can participation and inclusion in the student's home, school, and community
be increased?
What would increase the studentÕs opportunity to exercise appropriate choice making
Does it result in
property or material kicking over chairs angry, hostile, resentful
damage?
completing tasks paying attention
• Does the problem
behavior prohibit or
limit the student from
participation in The team should establish goals for behavior change and
integrated activities? criteria for determining the success of the intervention
• Is the educational based on estimates of the frequency, duration, or severity
progress of the student of the behaviors that are currently occurring. If teams are
and/or others being
affected? unable to provide confident estimates, observations should
be conducted to gather baseline data for target behaviors.
Objectives may involve eliminating or reducing problem
behaviors to acceptable levels, increasing alternative or
desirable behaviors, and/or teaching the student to tell
when certain behaviors are appropriate. Teams should keep
in mind the broad goals of intervention. These will guide
the team in not only targeting behaviors for reduction, but
in identifying skills that contribute to the overall quality of
the individual’s life (e.g., engaging in new activities,
developing friendships).
TARGET BEHAVIORS
Intervention Settings: In what settings will the assessment and intervention be conducted?
____ Student is engaging in behavior that places the student or others at risk of harm and/or results in substantial property damage.
____ Behavior is resulting in exclusion from participation in activities or settings with peers.
____ Current intervention involves excessively intrusive procedures (e.g., restraint, isolation).
____ Behavioral difficulties persist despite consistently implemented behavior management strategies based on a less
comprehensive or systematic assessment.
____ Other:
Sample Format - Page 2
Student Profile: What are the studentÕs greatest strengths and challenges?
Target Behaviors: What are the specific behaviors identified for increase or decrease?
Broad Goals: What are the student's social and educational goals (e.g., increased participation in inclusive settings, development of
Gathering Information
Gathering
Information
Effective intervention is based on a comprehensive
understanding of the focus individual and environmental
circumstances influencing his or her behavior. A variety of
data collection methods, ranging from highly precise and
systematic to relatively informal, have been developed to
obtain this information. Teams implementing functional
behavioral assessments will need to decide which tools and
methods will be most useful given the nature of the
student’s behavior, sources of relevant information,
circumstances in which data must be collected, and time
and resources available. In general, it is important to
gather information from multiple perspectives and across a
range of settings, activities, and situations. Gathering data
should be conducted as a collaborative process and is not
necessarily the responsibility of one team member (e.g., a
teacher or behavior specialist). It may be beneficial to
develop an action plan with specific timelines and
responsibilities to guide information gathering.
General History
Psychological Evaluations
Social Histories
Intervention History
Other
Tips:
• avoid judgement and unnecessary interpretation
• ask clear open-ended questions; avoid leading
• actively listen and reflect on important points to allow
the interviewee to expand his or her point of view
Student: Interviewer:
Respondent: Relationship:
Date:
7. Under what circumstances do these behaviors occur most frequently?
Interviews should be conducted with individuals who know the student well and interact with
With whom (who)?
him or her in a variety of settings and situations (e.g., parents, teachers). In order to get useful
information from the interview, questions may need to be repeated and clarified for some
In what settings (where)?
respondents. Probing should be done to encourage thoughtful, open communication in a
nonjudgmental, unhurried way. It may be necessary to record some responses on the back or on a
What times of the day (when)?
separate page.
2. What are the studentÕs challenges and areas of greatest difficulty? 9. Do you think there are medical reasons for these behaviors?
3. What people, things, and activities does the student like most?
10. Are there situations in which the behaviors never or rarely occur? What are those situations?
4. What people, things, and activities does the student like least?
11. Does the student have better and more appropriate ways to:
5. What are the studentÕs problem behaviors? deal with difficult situations?
How would you describe these behaviors? communicate wants and needs?
6. What do you think causes (motivates) the behavior (i.e., why does the student do it)?
13. How do you react or respond to the studentÕs:
problem behavior?
positive behavior?
14. Does the studentÕs behavior allow him or her to get things? If so, what?
15. Does the studentÕs behavior allow her or him to avoid things? If so, what?
Scatter Plot
Student: John
Target Behavior:
Observer: Ms. Lewis (teacher)
Leaving seat without
Dates: 3/2 through 3/13
permission
Dates
3/2 3/3 3/4 3/5 3/6 3/9 3/10 3/11 3/12 3/13
Time Activity
7:30 Arrival
8:00 Writing
9:00 Reading
NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA
9:30 P.E.
NA
10:00 Science
NA
10:30 Crafts
NA
11:00 Mathematics
NA
11:30 Lunch
NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA
12:00 Recess
12:30 Projects
1:00 Music
1:30 Reading
2:00 Mathematics
NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA
2:30 Dismissal
Behavior occurred
NA
Did not observe
Scatter Plot
Observer:
Dates: through
Using a scatter plot involves recording the times of the day (and/or activities) in which the
behavior does occur and does not occur to identify patterns that occur over days or weeks.
Dates
Time Activity
Behavior occurred
NA
Did not observe
ABC recording involves documenting the studentÕs behavior and the events that immediately precede and
follow it. The more specific and precise the description, the more useful the data will be.
Entire class is working on a Sally says ÒNOÓ and moves closer Teacher tells Sally that she did
cooking project. Two students next to the students who are frosting. frosting last week and that she will
to Sally are frosting cookies. have to let other students have a
Teacher asks Sally to be a cutter. turn.
Teacher praises students who are Sally grabs the knife from one of Student slaps Sally and begins to
working and then looks at Sally. the two students frosting. cry. Teacher scolds Sally loudly
and returns the knife to the other
student.
Student resumes frosting and Sally sits down at the table and Teacher goes to Sally and tells her
teacher begins to assist some other puts her head between her hands. that she knows that she is upset and
students. She cries softly. that Sally is a Ògood frosterÓ.
One of the students frosting asks to Sally picks up the knife and looks Teacher says ÒOkay, you can frost
go to the bathroom and puts down at the teacher. for a little whileÓ.
knife.
Teacher resumes helping other Sally begins frosting and, while Student next to her says ÒickÓ softly.
students with her back to Sally. the teacher is focused elsewhere, Teacher does not appear to hear it.
licks the knife.
Date : ______________________
ABC recording involves documenting the studentÕs behavior and the events that immediately precede and
follow it. The more specific and precise the description, the more useful the data will be.
Developing Hypotheses
Antecedents (Contexts)
• In what settings does the behavior occur?
• What times of day does the behavior occur?
• Does the behavior occur in the presence of a certain
person(s)?
• In what activities is the behavior most likely to occur?
• In what activities is the behavior least likely to occur?
Consequences (Functions)
• What happens to the student after the behavior?
• Do the surroundings in the environment change as a
result of the behavior?
• What is gained or lost?
• How do others respond to the behavior?
Interview
Results from Interview with the Teacher
Questions Answers
What are the studentÕs challenges Completing classwork, reading
and areas of greatest difficulty?
Under what circumstances do these All of his teachers have noticed this
behaviors occur most frequently? during independent activities
With whom (who)?
Dates: 3/1 through 3/12 Putting his head down for more
than 30 seconds, closing books,
Using a scatter plot involves recording the times and refusing to respond.
of the day (and/or activities) in which the
behavior does occur and does not occur to identify
patterns that occur over days or weeks. Pattern Analysis
Dates
Time Activity 3/1 3/2 3/3 3/4 3/5 3/8 3/9 3/10 3/11 3/12 • Circumstances in
8:00 Language Arts which behavior is
8:30 Language Arts
9:00 Reading
most likely:
9:30 Reading independent
10:00 Science tasks and oral
10:30 Science
reading assignments
Behavior did not occur
follow it. The more specific and precise the description, the more useful the data will be.
Reading 9:00 Closes book when it is his turn. After several teacher prompts,
Reading 9:30 Puts head down without Teacher asks other student the
question.
Analyzing Patterns
Circumstances in which the behavior is most likely:
Examples:
1. When the teacher’s attention is withdrawn
or focused on another student,
2. Lisa makes noises;
3. this results in the teacher scolding and
moving closer to her.
Hypothesis Statement
to get/to avoid...
(describe consequences)
Examples:
1. Medical concerns (e.g., failing to take regularly delivered
medication increases the probability that Johnny will
shout in class; when Susie has physical discomfort
associated with sitting for long periods of time it
increases the likelihood she will throw down her books
and cry)
2. Activity patterns (when the curriculum offers little
variety and mostly repetitive tasks this increases the
likelihood that Margaret will get out of her seat, wander
around the room, and tease peers; Michael will attempt
to pull out his hair especially when his schedule is
disrupted due to a special activity)
3. Relationships with others (Kevin is more likely to put
his head down and close his book when he was
reprimanded by a teacher earlier in the day; Darrel is
more likely to use profanities when a friend or peer
group is present)
Setting Events
Medical issues:
Activity patterns:
Functional Analysis
In a limited number of cases (e.g., when there has been a
history of unsuccessful intervention based on imprecise
assessment), it may be necessary to conduct more rigorous
testing under highly controlled conditions (i.e., to perform
a functional or experimental analysis). Functional analysis
involves systematically manipulating antecedents or
consequences to verify their impact on behavior. This type
of testing requires extensive resources and staff with
expertise in behavior analysis. This may not be feasible or
necessary in most circumstances. (A number of research
articles are provided in the references list to offer examples
of functional analysis.)
Support Plans
The development of summary statements is a significant
accomplishment because it signals that the team is ready to
move from functional assessment to intervention. Well
developed hypotheses provide the foundation for positive
and effective individualized behavioral support plans. Plans
should include components that promote positive behavior
and deter problem behavior. Such components are based
on the understanding reflected in the hypotheses.
Using the information from the summary statements, one
recommended strategy is to begin intervention planning
by using the competing behaviors model (O’Neill et al.,
1997). This model uses summary statement information
(setting events, antecedents, behaviors, and maintaining
consequences) to identify specific replacement skills and
other desired behaviors.
or focused on another student, Lisa makes extended periods, ÒI'm helping ____ now.Ó
noises; this results in the teacher scolding Teach Lisa to raise her hand when she
schedule occur, Ben throws his materials; refer to it throughout the day. Prepare Ben
having to pick them up delays the transition for changes, noting them on the schedule.
When Donna finishes her work before the Give Donna something to do when her
other students, she scribbles on her desk; work is finished (e.g., coloring, teacher
this alleviates her boredom. helper). Teach her to ask for activities
Crisis Plan
When the student:
Generalization and
Maintenance
ü Use a variety of examples
ü Teach flexible sequences
ü Vary aspects of environments
ü Diminish prompts and cues
ü Use natural contingencies
ü Reduce reinforcement over time
Contextual Fit
In addition to behavioral support plan elements being
consistent with the hypotheses and principles of human
behavior, they must also fit in the context. Some questions
teams should consider include the following:
• How does the plan align with the goals of the student
and support providers?
• Do the people implementing the plan have the capacity
and commitment to do so?
• Are the resources needed for the plan available?
Monitoring
Outcomes
Once the behavioral intervention plan has been developed,
it must be consistently implemented in order to be
effective. Teams may need to use additional resources to
implement the plan and train personnel and other support
providers. Implementation may require reevaluating
existing systems and providing opportunities for staff
development.
A good support plan will fit naturally within the routine and
structures of the environment in which it is implemented
(e.g., the classroom or home). The plan must be “doable” and
team members must be committed to its implementation.
Action Planning
What needs to be done? When will it be done? Who will do it?
(timelines)
Other
(lifestyle changes)
FUNCTIONAL ASSESSMENT
POSITIVE INTERVENTIONS
10
Bambara, L.M. & Knoster, T.P. (1995). Guidelines: Effective behavioral support.
Pennsylvania Department of Education: Bureau of Special Education.
Bambara, L.M., Mitchell-Kvacky, A.A., & Iacobelli, S. (1994). Positive behavioral support
for students with severe disabilities: An emerging multicomponent approach for addressing
challenging behavior. School Psychology Review, 23, 263-278.
Bishop, K.D. & Jubala, K.D. (1995). Positive behavioral support strategies. In M.S.
Falvey (Ed.), Inclusive and heterogeneous schooling: Assessment, curriculum, and instruction (pp.
159-186). Baltimore: Paul H. Brookes.
Carr, E.G., Levin, L., McConnachie, G., Carlson, J.I., Kemp, D.C., & Smith, C.E.
(1994). Communication-based intervention for problem behavior: A user’s guide for producing
positive change. Baltimore: Paul H. Brookes.
Dunst, C.J., Trivette, C.M., & Johanson, C. (1994). Parent-professional collaboration and
partnerships. In C. Dunst, C. Trivette, & A. Deal (Eds.), Supporting and strengthening families
(Volume 1): Methods, strategies, and practices (pp. 197-211). Cambridge, MA: Brookline Books.
Demchak, M. & Bossert, K.W. (1996). Assessing problem behaviors. Innovations (No. 4).
Washington, D.C.: American Association on Mental Retardation.
Durand, V.M. & Crimmins, D.B. (1988). Identifying variables maintaining self-injurious
behavior. Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders, 18, 99-117.
Blank Forms
Intervention Settings: In what settings will the assessment and intervention be conducted?
____ Student is engaging in behavior that places the student or others at risk of harm and/or results in substantial property damage.
____ Behavior is resulting in exclusion from participation in activities or settings with peers.
____ Educational support team is considering a more restrictive placement due to behavior.
____ Current intervention involves excessively intrusive procedures (e.g., restraint, isolation).
____ Behavioral difficulties persist despite consistently implemented behavior management strategies based on a less
comprehensive or systematic assessment.
____ Other:
Records: What records were reviewed? academic records child study notes What relevant information was obtained?
(cumulative)
anecdotals/home notes
discipline records
evaluations (e.g., social
previous interventions work, psychological)
Conducted by: other:
Interviews: What interviews were conducted? student parent(s) What relevant information was obtained?
ESE teacher administrator
Tools used: general education teacher related services
other:
Conducted by:
Observations: What direct observations occurred? Location Date/Time What relevant information was obtained?
Tools used:
Conducted by:
Other Assessments: What, if any, other assessments were conducted (e.g., ecological or classroom management inventories, reinforcer surveys, academic assessments)
?
Proactive: What environmental adjustments will be used to Educative: What behaviors (skills) will be taught to replace Functional: How will consequences be managed to insure
make the studentÕs problem behavior unnecessary? (meet the same function as) the studentÕs problem behavior the student receives reinforcers for positive, not problem,
and improve his or her ability to function more effectively? behavior?
Crisis Management: Are crisis management procedures needed to insure safety and de-escalation of the studentÕs behavior in emergency situations?
____ yes ____ no If so, describe strategies:
Generalization and Maintenance: What strategies (e.g., natural cues and contingencies) will be used to insure that behavior changes transfer acros
s environments?
STUDENT:
Rule 2:
Rule 3:
Rule 4:
Rule 5:
What would increase or strengthen the studentÕs friendships and social support?
How can participation and inclusion in the student's home, school, and community
be increased?
What would increase the studentÕs opportunity to exercise appropriate choice making
100 Positive Behavioral Support Project: Team Training & Technical Assistance
TARGET BEHAVIORS
Positive Behavioral Support Project: Team Training & Technical Assistance 101
Record Review Form
Summarize historical information, data from evaluations, and intervention methods that may be
relevant in interpreting the individual’s behavior.
General History
Psychological Evaluations
Social Histories
Intervention History
Other
102 Positive Behavioral Support Project: Team Training & Technical Assistance
Interview Guide for Functional Assessment
Student: Interviewer:
Respondent: Relationship:
Date:
Interviews should be conducted with individuals who know the student well and interact with
him or her in a variety of settings and situations (e.g., parents, teachers). In order to get useful
information from the interview, questions may need to be repeated and clarified for some
respondents. Probing should be done to encourage thoughtful, open communication in a
nonjudgmental, unhurried way. It may be necessary to record some responses on the back or on a
separate page.
3. What people, things, and activities does the student like most?
4. What people, things, and activities does the student like least?
6. What do you think causes (motivates) the behavior (i.e., why does the student do it)?
Positive Behavioral Support Project: Team Training & Technical Assistance 103
7. Under what circumstances do these behaviors occur most frequently?
8. Can you tell when the student is going to behave this way? How can you tell?
10. Are there situations in which the behaviors never or rarely occur? What are those situations?
11. Does the student have better and more appropriate ways to:
12. What skills does the student lack that might help his or her behavior?
problem behavior?
positive behavior?
14. Does the studentÕs behavior allow him or her to get things? If so, what?
15. Does the studentÕs behavior allow her or him to avoid things? If so, what?
104 Positive Behavioral Support Project: Team Training & Technical Assistance
Scatter Plot
Observer:
Dates: through
Using a scatter plot involves recording the times of the day (and/or activities) in which the
behavior does occur and does not occur to identify patterns that occur over days or weeks.
Dates
Time Activity
Behavior occurred
NA
Did not observe
Positive Behavioral Support Project: Team Training & Technical Assistance 105
ABC Recording Form
Date : ______________________
ABC recording involves documenting the studentÕs behavior and the events that immediately precede and
follow it. The more specific and precise the description, the more useful the data will be.
106 Positive Behavioral Support Project: Team Training & Technical Assistance
Analyzing Patterns
Circumstances in which the behavior is most likely:
Positive Behavioral Support Project: Team Training & Technical Assistance 107
Hypothesis Statements
To get/to avoid...
(describe consequences)
To get/to avoid...
(describe consequences)
To get/to avoid...
(describe consequences)
108 Positive Behavioral Support Project: Team Training & Technical Assistance
Setting Events
Medical issues:
Activity patterns:
Positive Behavioral Support Project: Team Training & Technical Assistance 109
110 Positive Behavioral Support Project: Team Training & Technical Assistance
Behavioral Intervention Plan Components
Positive Behavioral Support Project: Team Training & Technical Assistance 111
Crisis Plan
When the student:
112 Positive Behavioral Support Project: Team Training & Technical Assistance
Generalization and Maintenance
Yes No
Teaches skills relevant to context
Strategies can be used in natural environment
Modifications to environment promote independence
Natural cues and reinforcers are utilized
Student is responsible for his or her own behavior
Positive Behavioral Support Project: Team Training & Technical Assistance 113
Action Planning
What needs to be done? When will it be done? Who will do it?
(timelines)
114 Positive Behavioral Support Project: Team Training & Technical Assistance
Monitoring Plan for Intervention Outcomes
Other
(lifestyle changes)
Positive Behavioral Support Project: Team Training & Technical Assistance 115
116 Positive Behavioral Support Project: Team Training & Technical Assistance
Tom Gallagher, Commissioner
ESE 310667