Apr 23 Capriccio
Apr 23 Capriccio
Capriccio
LIGHTING DESIGNER
Duane Schuler
The production of Capriccio was made possible
CHOREOGRAPHER by generous gifts from an anonymous donor
Val Caniparoli and Bill Rollnick and Nancy Ellison Rollnick.
STAGE DIRECTOR
Peter McClintock
GENERAL MANAGER
Peter Gelb
MUSIC DIRECTOR
James Levine
2010–11 Season
Richard Strauss’s
Capriccio
This performance
is being broadcast Conductor
live over The Andrew Davis
Toll Brothers–
Metropolitan in order of vocal appearance
Opera
International Flamand, a composer Servants
Radio Network, Joseph Kaiser Ronald Naldi
sponsored by Paul Corona
Toll Brothers, Olivier, a poet Steven Goldstein
America’s luxury Russell Braun Christopher Schaldenbrand*
®
homebuilder , Grant Youngblood
with generous La Roche, Scott Scully
long-term a theater director Brian Frutiger
support from Peter Rose Kyle Pfortmiller
The Annenberg
Foundation, the The Countess, Major-Domo
Vincent A. Stabile a young widow Michael Devlin
Endowment for Renée Fleming
Monsieur Taupe, a prompter
Broadcast Media,
The Count, her brother Bernard Fitch
and contributions
Morten Frank Larsen
from listeners
solo dancers
worldwide. Clairon, an actress Laura Feig
Sarah Connolly Eric Otto
This performance is
also being broadcast Italian Singers musicians
live on Metropolitan Olga Makarina David Chan, violin
Opera Radio on Barry Banks Rafael Figueroa, cello
SIRIUS channel 78 Dennis Giauque, harpsichord
and XM channel 79.
* Graduate of the
Lindemann Young Artist
Met Titles
Development Program To activate, press the red button to the right of the screen in front of
your seat and follow the instructions provided. To turn off the display,
press the red button once again. If you have questions please ask an
Visit metopera.org usher at intermission.
Synopsis
La Roche and his protégés return and Clairon arrives for the rehearsal. She and
the count read a scene from Olivier’s play that ends with the count reciting a
passionate sonnet. La Roche leads them both off to rehearsal, leaving Flamand
and Olivier alone with the countess. Olivier declares that the sonnet was written
for her and recites it again, which inspires Flamand to rush off to set it to music.
Olivier seizes the opportunity to declare his love to the countess, who still
hesitates between poetry and music. Flamand triumphantly returns to sing the
sonnet he has just composed. The countess reflects on the synthesis of words
and music, while Olivier, though moved, feels that his work has been ruined.
The two men argue about the true authorship of the sonnet, and the countess
decides the issue: it is now hers.
When La Roche takes Olivier away to rehearsal, Flamand in turn declares his
love to the countess. He asks her to decide: music or poetry, him or Olivier?
She promises that he shall have the answer the next morning at eleven o’clock.
Flamand leaves in great excitement.
The rehearsal over, the participants return. Flamand and Olivier resume their
argument of words versus music and the others join in. The count ridicules opera
in general. La Roche introduces a pair of Italian singers who perform a duet.
Then he announces his plans for an epic, mythological spectacle, to be given for
the count’s birthday. When the others make fun of his grandiose ideas, La Roche
eloquently attacks them, expressing his theatrical creed: instead of the feeble
34
attempts of modern writers, he wants drama to show human beings in all their
complexity, as creatures of flesh and blood. He challenges Flamand and Olivier
to create new works that will speak for their time. His listeners are moved and a
new plan emerges: Flamand and Olivier are to write an opera together. Possible
subjects are discussed, until the count suggests that the events of this very day
should be the subject, with the people present as its characters—it is the opera
we have been watching. The ending is yet to be decided by the countess.
The company breaks up and the guests leave for Paris, accompanied by the count.
Servants enter to tidy up the room, commenting on the events of the afternoon
from their point of view—isn’t everybody just playing theater? Monsieur Taupe,
the prompter, who had fallen asleep during the rehearsal, unexpectedly appears.
He explains to the major-domo that, in fact, it is he who is the most important
person in the theater because without him the show couldn’t go on. The major-
domo, after listening patiently, arranges for his transport home.
It is evening. The countess enters and learns from the major-domo that Olivier
will call the next morning at eleven to hear from her the ending of the opera.
She tells herself that since the reading of the sonnet, the composer and the poet
seem inseparable—now they even expect to meet her the following morning at
the same time. She begins singing the sonnet to herself, trying to make up her
mind: which of the two men does she love? Looking at herself in the mirror, she
realizes she can’t make a choice. When the major-domo announces that dinner
is served, she smiles at her reflection and slowly walks out of the room.
Visit metopera.org 35
In Focus
Richard Strauss
Capriccio
The Setting
Strauss imagined his work set at a chateau near Paris, with its own private
theater. (Indeed, the air of luxury is an integral aspect of the story.) The opera
was originally set in the second half of the 18th century, a time when debates
about the merits of various genres of music theater triggered elaborate wars of
words in and around the French capital. However, the issues at hand—the role
of music in opera, the need for plausible drama, the function of dance, design,
36
and stagecraft—are not specific to that era. The present production places the
opera within the glamorous ambience of the interwar period of the 1920s.
The Creators
Richard Strauss (1864–1949) composed an impressive body of orchestral works
and songs before turning to opera. After two early failures, Salome (1905)
caused a theatrical sensation, and the balance of his long career was largely
dedicated to the stage, with most of his works through the 1920s written in
collaboration with Hugo von Hofmannsthal. The idea for Capriccio originated
with Stefan Zweig, an Austrian writer of novels, plays, and non-fiction who had
written the libretto to Strauss’s Die schweigsame Frau (1935). Zweig’s Jewish
background made further collaboration impossible, and the composer turned
to his friend and colleague Clemens Krauss (1893–1954), an Austrian impresario
and conductor who also led Capriccio’s premiere performance.
The Music
In keeping with the general tone of Capriccio, the score is refined and more
complex than it appears on first hearing. Musical forms from the 18th century
are discernible, especially in the brief dance interludes. The large orchestra is
used in a very light-handed manner, rarely employing its full force and instead
creating the effect of a chamber ensemble. The opera’s overture, for example,
is a sextet for strings—and, in keeping with the narrative of the story, forms part
of the action. The vocal writing mostly keeps a conversational flow (with a few
notable exceptions), ranging from actual spoken lines to “Sprechstimme” (a sort
of musicalized speech) to several complex ensembles. Vocal and instrumental
writing interact playfully throughout the opera. The bass’s extended monologue
celebrating the art of theater represents one of the few opportunities for solo
singing. The apex of the score is the final scene, a combination of a rapturous
orchestral passage (the “Moonlight Music”) followed by the countess’s
monologue, widely considered a supreme example of Strauss’s many superb
showcases for the soprano voice.
Visit metopera.org 37
The 2011–12 Season
Featuring the first new
complete Ring cycle in more
than 20 years, conducted
by James Levine.
New Productions
Anna Bolena
DON GIOVANNI
SIEGFRIED
FAUST
THE ENCHANTED ISLAND
GÖTTERDÄMMERUNG
MANON
Repertory Productions
AIDA
IL BARBIERE DI SIVIGLIA
BILLY BUDD
LA BOHÈME
L’ELISIR D’AMORE
ERNANI
LA FILLE DU RÉGIMENT
HANSEL AND GRETEL
KHOVANSHCHINA
MACBETH
MADAMA BUTTERFLY
THE MAKROPULOS CASE
NABUCCO
Das Rheingold
RODELINDA
SATYAGRAHA
TOSCA
LA TRAVIATA
die walküre
L
ong famous—indeed notorious—as a composer who exploited opera’s
full potential for the grandiose and the ferocious, the 78-year-old Richard
Strauss said farewell to the public stage in 1942 with Capriccio, a serene
score of almost anti-operatic intimacy. Labeled variously by the composer as a
“conversation piece” or “theatrical fugue,” Capriccio is perhaps not so much the
last of Strauss’s 15 music-dramas as his loving epilogue to a completed operatic
career. It is a dramatized aesthetic debate, warmed by music at once sharp-
tongued and humane. Each of its allegorical characters represents one of the
many individual elements that combine into the crazy-quilt art form of opera: a
composer, a poet, a producer–director, an actress, a would-be actor, an Italian
soprano–tenor team, a ballerina, even a prompter—and, above all, a muse,
portrayed by Strauss’s leading soprano.
Realizing that he must alert listeners to the work’s abstract design, Strauss
discarded two provisional titles connected with the dramatic action (Words
or Notes and A Sonnet for the Countess) and chose the generic musical term
Capriccio (akin to the abstract “sonata” or “fugue”). In an instrumental capriccio,
the composer leavens a strict formal design with quirkiness and fantasy,
delighting in the forbidden; Strauss here departs from operatic convention with
equal relish.
The composer first planned Capriccio while scoring his opera Die
Schweigsame Frau (1934–35), based on Stefan Zweig’s adaptation of a Ben
Jonson comedy. Working with euphoric ease and rapidity, Strauss could scarcely
believe his luck in finding Zweig. After the death of his longtime librettist
Hugo von Hofmannsthal in 1929, the composer had despaired of procuring a
successor even remotely as capable; now in Zweig he had a partner whose style
and dramaturgy excited him as Hofmannsthal’s had—and who was much easier
to work with on a personal level. Before he had finished Die Schweigsame Frau,
Strauss was already bombarding Zweig with requests for dramatic ideas, and
the pair rapidly drew up an agenda of four operatic projects.
Strauss considered combining two of these into a hybrid piece reminiscent
of his earlier Ariadne auf Naxos. As in Ariadne, a comic backstage prologue
(the germ that eventually grew into Capriccio) would precede a highly stylized
neo-Classical opera based on timeless Greek myth. The prologue would be
developed from an 18th-century buffo libretto Zweig had unearthed: Giovanni
Casti’s Prima la Musica, Poi le Parole (“First the Music, Then the Words”). Casti’s
text—once set by Salieri for performance in a famous Viennese court double-
bill with Mozart’s Impresario—was now hopelessly dated; but Zweig planned to
explore the perennial operatic question at its core: “Which is more important,
the music or the drama?” The evening would close with Strauss’s “answer” to
Casti’s conundrum: a one-act opera on the mythological subject of Daphne.
What tickled Strauss about this plan was that it echoed musical history: what
39
Program Note CONTINUED
40
1777 did not exist (André Chénier came a bit later), Swarowsky went back two
centuries to Pierre Ronsard. Strauss was delighted by Swarowsky’s German
rendering and finished setting the sonnet on November 23, 1939. The first music
in Capriccio to be composed, it is particularly important because it is repeated
in key scenes.
As late as June 1940, Strauss still intended to close the evening with his
already completed Daphne (1937), to be presented as an opera by Flamand and
Olivier (the pairing would have lasted over four hours). Fortunately, he found a
far more ingenious solution—toward the end, the audience learns that what
they have been watching is the Flamand–Olivier opera, Capriccio! With the
book still incomplete but well along, Strauss began composing the introduction
and first scene in July 1940. Receiving the last of the libretto in mid-January 1941,
he finished the entire short score on February 24 and the full orchestration on
August 3.
Inspired by the composer’s love of paradox and intellectual argument, the
music of Capriccio represents a rejuvenated Strauss, notably fresher and more
imaginative than in his spotty scores for Friedenstag (1936) and Die Liebe der
Danae (1940). From the outset, Strauss changes all the rules, beginning with
an “overture” wholly un-operatic in sound, scored for string sextet. We soon
discover that this sonatina-form movement with its seraphic opening and stormy
central portion has been composed by Flamand in homage to Madeleine. For
the sonnet, Strauss crafts a lovely melody, drawing most discretely on late
Verdi—Otello (“Ave Maria”) at the opening, Falstaff (the Nannetta–Fenton
duet) at the first melodic climax. Complex ensembles crackle with invention: the
central fugue (labeled “Discussion about Words or Notes”) and the “Laughing”
and “Argument” Octets, in which the director La Roche’s stage-spectacles are
held up to ridicule. La Roche’s ensuing defense is a highlight, its length justified
by its musical majesty. Here, Strauss presents a thoroughly convincing warts-
and-all picture of a vain but undeniably great man.
But of course he saves his greatest eloquence for Madeleine’s final
monologue. To introduce the scene, he resurrects a noble horn melody that
he had squandered 20 years before on a libelous song-cycle written specifically
to break a publishing contract. Even in old age, Strauss was still inspired to
lyric rapture by a heroine’s quest for self-knowledge, as Madeleine sings the
sonnet accompanying herself on the harp and searches her own image in the
mirror, faced with a question that has no answer. So long as opera survives—and
human brains perceive and integrate the way they do—the choice “words or
music” is literally meaningless. Their coexistence in song, fraught with epiphany
and vexation, remains an ever-wondrous mystery. —Benjamin Folkman
Visit metopera.org 41
Capriccio in a Twenties Setting
T
he central issue in Capriccio, happily, can never be resolved. The superiority
of music over poetry, or vice versa, must always be a matter of personal
preference. The countess, not wishing to sacrifice one by choosing the other,
proposes opera as a way to possess both. But this compromise, far from being a
solution, sharpens a mere topic of conversation into a vexed confrontation—for
in opera the conflict of priorities between words and music is enacted with every
performance. Those of us who work in opera are inevitably caught up in the battle.
Capriccio is a conversation piece, concerned with ideas. Given that the issues
embodied in these ideas are as alive today as they ever were, and that by performing
the opera at all we are contributing to the argument, I wanted to find a way of doing
it that would stress how contemporary it is. In a piece that is of necessity rather
static, the 18th-century convention of paniered skirts and powdered wigs could
easily lend to the proceedings an air of the museum. So often with Capriccio, one
gets the impression of a group of silk and satin dilettantes idling their way affectedly
through a vacuous afternoon, whereas the essence of the situation is a number of
professional artists discussing their work with their patrons.
However, unlike the ideas, the social circumstances embodied in Capriccio are
not of the present. Where now do we find an elite wealthy and cultivated enough to
patronize artists as extravagantly as the countess and her brother do? The task was
thus to find a time that would be true to the dramatic content of the opera.
Paris in the decade after World War I had all that we needed. Patronesses like the
Princesse de Polignac commissioned works from Stravinsky, Cocteau, the composers
of Les Six, and others for private consumption. All of them were concerned with
problems of form, many with finding new ways of combining words and music for the
theater. Diaghilev and Reinhardt bestrode the theatrical scene.
Most of all, the relaxation of social behavior found in the post-war period, with
its ingenious emphasis on comfort that is not yet at the expense of elegance, seems
to look back to the 18th century and forward to our own. It releases to the performer
a rich vocabulary of gesture, posture, and moment-to-moment activity that is more
accessible to both audience and actors, being much closer to their own, and that,
therefore, can only assist in pointing the relevance of the conversation to us as we
watch and listen.
Those who find problematic the references within our text to 18th-century
composers and writers should reflect that every age has its reformers and traditionalists.
Names change but issues remain. Strauss, by claiming in his preface to Capriccio that
he himself was the direct heir of Gluck’s reforms, cleared the way for an exposition in
words and music of his own compositional concerns. (As if to leave us in no doubt at
all of this musical self-portrait, he even quotes frequently from his own work.) In short,
everything Strauss represents was as true during his working life as it was in Gluck’s—
most notably in the wholly 20th-century figure of the producer La Roche.
La Roche is anxious to people the stage with “creatures of flesh and blood,”
“people like ourselves with whom we can identify.” This interpretation of Capriccio is
an attempt to please him. —John Cox
42 Visit metopera.org
The Cast
Andrew Davis
conductor (hertfordshire, england)
this season Capriccio at the Met, Peter Grimes at Covent Garden, Rusalka and Thaïs at the
Glyndebourne Festival, Ariadne auf Naxos with the Canadian Opera Company, and The
Mikado, Lohengrin, and La Fanciulla del West at Lyric Opera of Chicago.
met appearances Salome (debut, 1981), Ariadne auf Naxos, Il Barbiere di Siviglia, Don
Giovanni, Hansel and Gretel, The Merry Widow, Der Rosenkavalier, Rusalka, and Die
Walküre with the company on tour in Japan.
career highlights He has been music director and principal conductor of Lyric Opera of
Chicago since 2000, is conductor laureate of the Toronto Symphony and BBC Symphony
Orchestra, and was music director of the Glyndebourne Festival Opera. He has conducted
all of the major orchestras of the world, from the Chicago Symphony Orchestra to the
Berlin Philharmonic and the Royal Concertgebouw, as well as at opera houses and festivals
throughout the world, including La Scala and the Bayreuth Festival.
Robert Perdziola
costume designer & interior décor (pennsylvania )
43
The Cast CONTINUED
Sarah Connolly
mezzo - soprano (middlesborough, england)
this season Clairon in Capriccio at the Met and Sesto in La Clemenza di Tito at the
Aix-en-Provence Festival.
met appearances The Composer in Ariadne auf Naxos and Annio in La Clemenza di Tito
(debut, 2005).
career highlights Dido in Purcell’s Dido and Aeneas at Covent Garden and La Scala, the
title role of Giulio Cesare and Brangäne in Tristan und Isolde at the Glyndebourne Festival,
Orfeo in Orfeo ed Euridice and Lucretia in The Rape of Lucretia at Munich’s Bavarian
State Opera, Nerone in L’Incoronazione di Poppea at Barcelona’s Liceu and Florence’s
Maggio Musicale, Octavian in Der Rosenkavalier at the Scottish Opera and for English
National Opera, the title role of Maria Stuarda and Romeo in I Capuleti e i Montecchi for
Opera North, and Romeo and the title role of Ariodante with New York City Opera. Future
engagements include Fricka in Das Rheingold and Die Walküre at Covent Garden, Orfeo
in Montpellier, Octavian at English National Opera, and return engagements at the Liceu,
Paris Opera, and Glyndebourne Festival.
Renée Fleming
soprano (indiana , pennsylvania )
this season The title role of Armida and the Countess in Capriccio at the Met, Desdemona
in Otello at the Paris Opera, and concert engagements with the BBC Symphony Orchestra,
Pittsburgh Symphony, National Symphony, St. Louis Symphony, Munich Philharmonic,
Danish National Symphony, Aarhus Symphony, Royal Stockholm Symphony, Staatskapelle
Dresden, and Berliner Philharmoniker, among others.
met appearances The title roles of Thaïs, Rusalka, Manon, Rodelinda, Arabella, and
Susannah, the Marschallin in Der Rosenkavalier, Violetta in La Traviata, Desdemona,
Tatiana in Eugene Onegin, the Countess in Le Nozze di Figaro (debut, 1991), Donna Anna
in Don Giovanni, Rosina in the world premiere of The Ghosts of Versailles, Imogene in
Il Pirata, Ellen Orford in Peter Grimes, Fiordiligi in Così fan tutte, and Marguerite in Faust.
career highlights She has appeared in all the world’s leading opera houses, is the recipient
of three Grammy Awards, and was awarded the titles Chevalier de la Légion d’Honneur
and Commandeur de l’Ordre des Arts et des Lettres by the French government. She was
a 1988 winner of the Met’s National Council Auditions.
44
Russell Braun
baritone (frankfurt, germany)
this season Chou En-lai in Nixon in China and Olivier in Capriccio at the Met, Lescaut in
Manon on tour in Japan with London’s Royal Opera (Covent Garden), and Mercutio in
Roméo et Juliette at La Scala.
met appearances Silvio in Pagliacci, Figaro in Il Barbiere di Siviglia, Dr. Falke in Die
Fledermaus (debut, 1995), and Mercutio in Roméo et Juliette.
career highlights Recent performances include the Traveller in Death in Venice at Vienna’s
Theater an der Wien, Valentin in Faust at Covent Garden, Pelléas in Pelléas et Mélisande
at La Scala, Oreste in Iphigénie en Tauride with the Paris Opera, the title role of Eugene
Onegin with the San Francisco Opera, and the title role of Billy Budd, Prince Andrei in
War and Peace, and Enrico in Lucia di Lammermoor with the Canadian Opera Company.
Joseph Kaiser
tenor (montreal , canada )
this season Flamand in Capriccio at the Met, Lenski in Eugene Onegin for his debut at
°
the Paris Opera, Tamino in Die Zauberflöte at Covent Garden, Števa in Jenufa at Munich’s
Bavarian State Opera, and Don Ottavio in Don Giovanni at the Munich Festival.
met appearances Narraboth in Salome, Roméo in Roméo et Juliette (debut, 2007), and
Tamino.
career highlights Recent debuts include the title role of Faust at Lyric Opera of Chicago,
the title role of Messanger’s Fortunio at Paris’s Opéra Comique, Don Ottavio at the
Salzburg Festival, and Admète in Gluck’s Alceste at the Aix-en-Provence Festival. He also
recently sang Tamino with Los Angeles Opera, Lenski at the Salzburg Festival, Narraboth
at Covent Garden, and Jonas in Saariaho’s Adriana Mater at Santa Fe Opera. He starred
as Tamino in Kenneth Branagh’s film adaptation of The Magic Flute and appeared on
Broadway as Schaunard in the Baz Luhrmann production of La Bohème.
45
The Cast CONTINUED
Peter Rose
bass (canterbury, england)
this season La Roche in Capriccio at the Met, Baron Ochs in Der Rosenkavalier with
Munich’s Bavarian State Opera, Bottom in A Midsummer Night’s Dream with Lyric Opera
of Chicago, Gurnemanz in Parsifal in Hamburg, and Claggart in Billy Budd with the Vienna
State Opera.
met appearances Don Basilio in Il Barbiere di Siviglia, Bottom (debut, 1996), Ramfis in Aida,
Baron Ochs, and Daland in Der Fliegende Höllander.
career highlights Among his recent performances are Falstaff with Seattle Opera, Osmin
in Die Entführung aus dem Serail with the San Francisco Opera and Bavarian State Opera,
and Baron Ochs at the Vienna State Opera, Covent Garden, and in Barcelona. He has
also sung King Marke in Tristan und Isolde and Gurnemanz at the Vienna State Opera,
Kecal in The Bartered Bride at Covent Garden and in Chicago, Mustafa in L’Italiana in
Algeri in Amsterdam and Dresden, Dosifei in Khovanshchina in Hamburg, Leporello in
Don Giovanni in Cologne, Rocco in Fidelio in Vienna, and Boris Godunov with English
National Opera. This October he will sing Baron Ochs at La Scala.
46 Visit metopera.org