2019 Annual Report: Inclusive Bangladesh Project
2019 Annual Report: Inclusive Bangladesh Project
Project Information 3
Executive Summary 5
Bangladesh in 2019: Trends 8
Project Overview 10
Summary Of Project Strategy 11
Challenges in 2019 13
ANNEX
Project Financial Report 2019 38
Progress of Result Indicators 39
PROJECT INFORMATION
TARGET
Country: Bangladesh
2019 was the year the Partnerships for a Tolerant, Inclusive Bangladesh Project began to truly deliver on its
potential. New initiatives, coupled with thoughtful and evidence-driven changes to existing activities, gave the
project new reach and momentum. New partnerships, whether with new international supporters, domestic
government stakeholders, civil society partners, or internal team members, prompted new ideas and improved
execution. Insightful new research repeatedly shifted the perspective of the project team and its network,
leading to imaginative engagement activities which met a real and pressing need.
2019 Achievements: UNDP’s Partnerships for a Tolerant, Inclusive Bangladesh project works to promote peace
and tolerance by preventing violence, hate speech and extremism in Bangladesh. In 2019, the project both
strengthened additional initiatives, and launched new ones:
02 Following a successful mid-term evaluation in February, additional data and graphics specialists
were hired, data quality procedures overhauled, and Bangla-language versions of reports
published;
05 Five youth dialogues at universities allowed the Dhaka Metropolitan Police’s Counter-terrorism
and Transnational Crime (CTTC) unit to refine its prevention of violent extremism policy, leading to
the launch of its new strategy in December 2019.
01 Building on the online network the project has cultivated through the Digital Khichuri Challenges,
the project expanded its online presence into a full portfolio of creative online activities which
promote digital literacy and tolerance. New activities include:
• Peace Talk Café Series: An interactive discussion series which gives youth the chance to
directly interact and ask questions of prominent cultural, academic and social leaders on
issues of peace and tolerance;
• Quizzes for Peace: Online tests for youth on subjects related to diversity, peace and critical
thinking;
03 Supporting a new way for technical partners to share their insights into this challenging and
sensitive field;
Male migrant workers discuss challenges facing Bangladeshi migrants abroad with Digital Khichuri Challenge participants,
December 2019
All data available in the Bangladesh Peace Observatory’s annual report for 2019,
available at: http://peaceobservatory-cgs.org/#/peace_report
Research Facility:
Improve knowledge, understanding, and provide insight into the drivers of violence in
Bangladesh;
Citizen Engagement:
Enhance inclusivity and tolerance though social engagement activities, both on and offline,
with a focus on youth, women, migrant workers, religious leadership and marginalized
communities;
Government Engagement:
Sensitize government agencies to emerging global best practices when developing policies
that promote social inclusion and tolerance.
International Agreements:
This project responds to the UN Secretary General’s 2015 call for every country to develop a coherent and
contextual strategy for the prevention of violent extremism (PVE), while reaffirming the need for inclusive
institutions, transparent politics, and a commitment to fundamental human rights.
After the conclusion of a fruitful annual board meeting at the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, the PTIB-UNDP team bids farewell to
Ms. Nahida Sobhab, DG UN, Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Ms. Shahanara Monica, Director - UN, Ministry of Foreign Affairs
and thanks them for for their valuable support.
Transgender dance group, "Essence of Soul" left more than 600 audiences mesmerized with their performance at Boichitrer
Oikotan, a dance program organized on 28 February 2020 to inspire and uplift the transgender community of Bangladesh.
Youth express their concerns and questions directly to Dhaka Metropolitan Police in youth dialogues supported by UNDP.
• The Secretary General’s Strategy and Plan of Action on Hate Speech (2019):
This plan focuses on the need to reduce incitement of all kinds, recognizing hate speech to be a
precondition for violence;
A snippet from the Bangladesh Peace Observatory (BPO), an Open Access Data platform collecting different streams of publicly
available data, regularly updating the platform with newer incidents, conducting research and providing education opportunities
to better understand the state of violence and promote peace.
RESEARCH
FACILITY
BANGLADESH
PEACE OBSERVATORY
The Bangladesh Peace Observatory (BPO):
The BPO catalogues, aggregates, maps and visualizes nationwide statistics on violent incidents using a
combination of open data and media reports. Based at the University of Dhaka and supported by UNDP, the
BPO produces targeted analyses and updates, identifying new avenues for research. A variety of qualitative
(micronarrative) and quantitative methods (media monitoring) are used to help identify violent trends.
Data Visualization:
The BPO team received training every week on how to better create charts and graphs, and
how to support tell a more compelling story using the available data. 5 additional research and
data analysts were hired to support the BPO, contributing to an increase in quality and
timeliness. The improved accuracy and accessibility of the Peacegraphics have made the
BPO’s website more intuitive and attractive, and have also been a major factor in the BPO’s
increasing media coverage.
Engagement:
Over 2000 people from 10 countries visited the BPO platform online in 2019.
(BPO Continued)
Weekly Reports:
CARU’s publications received such intense interest from partners that the project continued
to produce a significantly greater volume of reports than originally planned – the project
shifted quickly from bimonthly to monthly and then to weekly report production, which it
continued throughout 2019. The data suggest that single email signatures sent to partners
are sometimes opened dozens of times, suggesting that the reports are being circulated
widely within international partner organizations and reopened for useful data and review.
(OUTCOME 1)
Support to Partners:
CARU has also responded to specific requests for additional information by government,
diplomatic and NGO partners on the ground;
Early-Warning:
CARU runs a whatsapp group for UN partners which provides them with essential
information as it develops. Though this group was started as a communication side-option, it
has evolved into a useful tool which is widely used by humanitarian partners.
CARU organised consultation meeting for the Norwegian mission with five Rohingya CSOs in the camps in April 2019.
Immediate past Norwegian Ambassador Sidsel Bleken was part of the Norwegian delegation.
CARU team visiting Rohingya CSO leaders for data collection in December 2019.
Broader Circulation:
These monthly reports have been circulated to a range of international and domestic
partners, including Bangladesh Government counterparts.
• Only 11% of male migrants and 4% of female migrants had exposure to social media before they left
Bangladesh;
• 65% of migrant men and 35% of women used social media while abroad. Of these, 60% admitted that
they did not verify the legitimacy of news stories online before sharing, while 28% did not know how to
verify online information they encountered.
CITIZEN
ENGAGEMENT
DIGITAL PEACE MOVEMENT &
DIGITAL KHICHURI CHALLENGES
Participants and judges at the closing ceremony of the Sylhet 2019 Digital Khichuri Challenge.
• Recruitment Campaign:
UNDP supported a broad campaign encouraging youth to apply. UNDP and its implementing partner,
Bitopi, met more than 10k students at 5 different universities during the Call to Action campaign. The
most promising 7 teams were ultimately selected from 123 applications;
• Elite Mentorship:
The mentorship period after the event was led by specialists with SBYA Global, a leader in promoting
social entrepreneurship;
• Winning Idea:
The winning idea was to gamify the process of digital literacy, to produce a digital game called ‘Digital
Vaccine’ that would help promote the concept of fake news and the need for critical thinking online;
2
Like Bangladesh itself, khichuri is a traditional Bangladeshi rice dish that is a mixture of many different ingredients.
Female migrant workers at the Idea Lab of the Digital Khichuri Challenge, sharing their experience of the challenges facing
migrant workers abroad.
• Theme:
The theme of this DKC was selected following UNDP research suggesting that Bangladeshi migrant
workers are especially vulnerable to fake news and incitement when abroad (for more details, see
“migrant workers research” section above).
• Direct Mentorship:
Male and female migrant workers joined the DKC to help mentor youth directly on the types of online
platforms which could appeal to Bangladeshis abroad. Migrants shared their experiences in vivid detail,
prompting many DKC participants to radically rethink their initial ideas. Additional mentorship and
support from government agencies, including those responsible for migrant skills development and the
Ministry of Foreign Affairs, helped to further ground the participants and strengthen their ideas.
• Winning Ideas:
4 winning teams were selected, from 2 categories: One set of teams were all-new platforms, the other
consisted of existing startups wanting to refine their business model.
• Total Reach:
Online and offline messaging associated with the DKC event itself reached 741,663 people with
268,910 engagements online. (Platforms produced by the winning teams later went on to reach over 18
million Bangladeshis in 2020).
Digital Khichuri Challenge Dhaka cohort winners on stage during the closing moments alongside guests, judges and
organizers.
Participants and mentors in brief discussion during Digital Khichuri Challenge Dhaka bootcamp.
Participation:
Assembled an anthropologist, popular musician, and founder of an online learning platform to
discuss how to help amplify cultural messages of peace and tolerance;
Preparation:
To maximize participation, the event was organized in Dhaka’s central Dhanmondi District,
and elimanated opening and closing speeches to be much more conversational;
Reach:
The pilot Peace Talk Café was a resounding success, engaging 6,606,546 people over social
media;
Peace Talk Café attendees pose with Ayman Sadiq, panelist during the first Peace Talk Café on August 28, 2019
Theme:
Held during UN Women’s “16 Days of Action against Violence Against Women”, this
discussion assembled a popular columnist, female social media celebrities, and female
entrepreneurs to discuss organized online harassment of women in Bangladesh;
Reach:
The second iteration of the Peace Talk Café reached 1,586,369 people over social media;
Peace Talk Cafe attendees and PTIB-UNDP team smile for the camera after the successful conclusion of the first Peace Talk
Cafe.
–Bappa Mazumder
Musician and songwriter
Peace Quizzes:
Many of the project’s most successful initiatives have taken-off because they engage youth and other target
demographics in a fun or unorthodox way. Peace quizzes are consciously designed to be enjoyable and
engaging, spreading positive ideas more easily and naturally. The Peace Quiz series engaged Bangladeshis to
test their knowledge of relevant issues throughout the year – two of these quizzes were issued in 2019, with
several more following in 2020. The two themes included:
Expressions of Interest:
The application process for Diversity for Peace asked for expressions of interest in either
Bangla or English, which allowed more grassroots organizations to compete with larger, more
established NGOs for UNDP support. The project received over 400 total applications from
across Bangladesh, proposing to integrate PVE or diversity programming into an aspect of
their existing activities.
Coaching:
Instead of immediately selecting the best ideas from the expressions of interest, the PTIB
project then coached and helped promising candidates to refine their proposals through a
series of orientation workshops in Chattogram, Rangpur and Dhaka. This provided additional
training for dozens of local NGOs and non-traditional partners for how to set realistic
budgeting and operational benchmarks, and how to integrate PVE principles into their
anticipated activities. The applicants then rewrote and re-submitted their applications for final
review.
Selection:
Nine finalists were then selected for funding, and given further training on project
implementation, financial reporting, and other essentials during a 2-day workshop in Dhaka in
November. Through this process, dozens of organizations were pushed to link their ongoing
activities to diversity and to digital literacy – far more than the nine ultimately selected for
UNDP funding.
A practical session helping religious leaders to promote peace through social media.
Results:
Many participants in this year’s training are now active in their own Facebook and Youtube channels,
disseminating messages supportive of tolerance and coexistence in their sermons.
GOVERNMENT
ENGAGEMENT
GOVERNMENT
ENGAGEMENT
Bangladesh Minister of State for Information and Communication Technology at the Closing Ceremony of a Digital Khichuri
Challenge
Bangladesh Parliament Speaker Dr Shirin Sharmin Chaudhury, International Affairs Advisor to the Prime Minister Dr Gowher
Rizvi, UN Resident Coordinator Mia Seppo, U.S. Ambassador to Bangladesh Earl Miller and CTTC Chief Monirul Islam
inaugurating National P/CVE Conference.
Prevention of Violent Extremism and Prevention of Hate Speech are both Peacebuilding:
While UNDP internally applies the Prevention of Violent Extremism label to this work, in 2019 the project
came to realize how adaptable this model is to addressing issues of hate speech being raised by the UN
Secretary General. Though the means and manner of hate speech may be different, the dynamics and the
implications are similar to that of extremist rhetoric.
BUDGET EXPENDITURE
ACTIVITY % OF EXP.
(USD) (USD)
Outcome 1: Research Facility; Improved knowledge, understanding, and insights into the drivers of conflict, violence, and extremism in Bangladesh, and inform public policy
1.1. Total Number of 3 (2017) 55 36 23 PTIB’s research components SecDev, & CARU are prolific
Research Publications Produced producers of weekly, monthly, and quarterly reports. Due
to the sensitivity of contents of the publications, it took the
project time to agree with the government and UN/UNDP
management on the distribution process. Therefore it
remained behind the target.
1.2 Total Citations for Research Products 0 (2017) 60 25 NA This indicator was held off considering the confidentiality
and restricted circulation of research products.
1.3 Number of Times research products are 2 (2017) 38 20 9 The number of PVE conferences the project attended was
presented at PVE conferences lower than expected. In total project attended 4
international and 4 national conferences and presented
their findings there.
1.4 Number of instances media organizations 0 (2017) 40 25 8 BPO bi montly and annual peace report findings covered by
reference Research Facility data in reporting media.
1.1.1 Number of months’ data on various forms of 43 72 67 60 BPO has been consistent in collecting, validation and
violence available on the “Bangladesh Peace uploading of current data. However, reexamining of
Observatory” website previous years' data validation delayed the target meeting.
1.1.3 Number of online citations of BPO data 0 26 11 8 National news media outlets in their online versions
referred data of BPO bi monthly and annual peace reports.
1.2.1 Scale: Research conducted on identified 4/4 76/4 48/4 10/4 Higher priority was given to having the database in order.
areas, and research findings shared BPO conducted 4 micronarratives, 1 studies under
to relevant audiences fellowship program, and 5 joint studies with CTTC. All
these reports were shared with relevant audience (see
footnote)
1.2.2 Number of citations for research products 0 26 11 8 While the number of research products was lower than
planned, data and findings of BPO peace reports were
referred in different media.
Scale from 0 to 4: (a) 1st point- research area identified (b) 2nd point- research done (c) 3rd point- report developed (4) 4th point- report shared to relevant audience
1.2.3 Number of times research papers are 0 500 200 850 Peace Reports were downloaded 850 times from the BPO
downloaded online website
1.3.1 Percentage of attendees who felt N/A 80% 80% N/A Merged with output 3.2 TRAINING for government officials
the training was ‘useful’ or ‘very useful’ once on PVE
the training session completed
1.3.2 Percentage improvement in scores from N/A 60% 60% N/A Merged with output 3.2 TRAINING for government officials
a test administered at the start of training when on PVE
compared to a test administered at the end
Output 1.4: LEARNING LAB (Independent M&E, Skills Training for UNDP)
1.4.1 Number of lessons learned and applied N/A 40 25 7 Project staff attended 4 international conferences and took
from conferences lessons on challenges of interfaith engagement, more
effective use of Facebook for counter-narrative, and
applied PVE research.
1.4.2 Number of recommendations implemented N/A 23 13 15 Independent M&E- included (1) BPO review, (2) monitoring
from independent monitoring or mission by project’s Technical Advisor (PVE), and mapping
evaluation reports of PVE research in Bangladesh. Recommendations were
taken further including measures to improve BPO database
and communications, increase project’s focus on digital
drivers of VE, blend social entrepreneurship approach in
hackathons, and link academics with security agencies in
PVE research.
1.5.1 Number of bi-monthly updates on 0 (2018) 15 6 1 bi-monthly, 12 CARU produced monthly, and weekly reports, instead of
Monitoring Drivers of Social Tensions monthly and 73 bi-weekly reports due to the growing demand for
weekly reports information.
1.5.2 Number of quarterly perception surveys to 0 (2018) 10 4 0 The procurement of the survey firm was delayed.
map and track perceptions among Rohingya and
host communities, to understand possible shifts
on issues of importance to social cohesion
Outcome 2: Citizen Engagement: Enhanced inclusivity and tolerance of Bangladeshi society through social engagement activities, both on and offline
2.1. Total number of civil society organizations 0 25 13 13 PTIB has made consistent efforts to engage civil society
adding a PVE element (including diversity, peace, organizations in PVE orientated activities. A component of
and tolerance) to existing programming, with Diversity for Peace has been introduced to achieve the
support of UNDP grants, training, target by end of project.
or information materials
2.2 Percentage improvement in scores from a test N/A 60% 60% 90% Citizen training was conducted on CSO capacity building
administered at the start of training when on addressing diversity, and social media usage for faith
compared to a test administered at the end leaders.
2.3 Total number of beneficiaries who have N/A 18m 10m 12m Over 12 million audiences were reached with Digital Peace
come into contact with campaigns Movement messages of promoting peace, social cohesion,
and improved critical thinking.
Output 2.1: RESEARCH into online extremist narratives (This output was shifted under Outcome 1: Research Facility)
2.1.1 Scale: Research conducted on identified 4 48 28 NA This indicator was aligned with Outcome indicator 1.1
areas, and research findings shared to
relevant audiences
Scale from 0 to 4: (a) 1st point- research area identified (b) 2nd point- research done (c) 3rd point- report developed (4) 4th point- report shared to relevant audience
2.2.1 Number of Applicants, per event, 350 700 700 834 DKC gained more attention than expected.
for Digital Khichuri Challenges
2.2.3 Number of Facebook likes for 0 25,500 10,500 37,200 As a result of improved social media campaigning DKC
Digital Khichuri page gained more attention than expected. Especially activities
like the peace talk café has increased the the number of
followers significantly.
2.2.4 Number of visitors to Challenge winners’ 0 12,000 5,000 NA Considering not all winners were running websites and
websites and platforms after 6 months platforms, this indicator was not tracked.
2.2.5 Low viewer bounce/exit rate from websites 0 10% 10% NA Same as 2.2.4
produced as a result of Digital Khichuri
Revised/added indicator 0 113,500 900,500 2.8 million PTIB activities as part of its Digital Peace Movement have
proved adept at reaching online audiences with new and
2.2.6 Number of viewers reached online through innovative content that contains messages of inclusivity
Digital Khichuri Challenge/Digital Peace and tolerance.
Movement campaign
2.3.1 Percentage of women who felt training N/A 80% 80% N/A Project analyzed that instead of limiting to training on PVE
was ‘useful’ or ‘very useful’ once and gender, a more comprehensive approach would be
training session completed required. Instead of training, PVE and Gender are
addressed in the Diversity for Peace Low-Value Grants
initiative in support of CSOs.
2.3.3 number of female beneficiaries attending N/A 1800 600 N/A Same as 2.3.1
training sessions or discussions
2.4.1 Percentage of migrants surveyed after a N/A 80% 80% N/A Study into vulnerability of migrant workers has shows that a
workshop who felt the training was ‘useful’ more comprehensive approach is required to support
or ‘very useful’ once completed Migrant workers. Instead of training migrant workers, a
hackathon (DKC) was organized, and 3 organizations
selected/supported to build digital literacy among migrant
workers
2.4.2 Percentage improvement in scores from a N/A 80% 60% N/A Same as 2.4.1
test administered at the start of training when
compared to a test administered at the end
2.4.3 number of workers given training or N/A 9000 3000 N/A Same as 2.4.1
materials to recognize and defend against
extremist recruitment tactics
2.5.1 number of youth organizations adding N/A 25 10 N/A This indicator was aligned with output indicator 2.2.7
a PVE or digital literacy element to
existing programming
2.5.3 number of youth trainers in N/A 240 80 N/A Related activities were not carried out/repurposed.
digital literacy trained
2.6.1 number of religious organizations adding N/A 25 10 N/A The project could not identify appropriate organizations to
a PVE or digital literacy element to support, therefore it trained religious leaders as individuals.
existing programming
2.6.2 number of religious leaders given training N/A 9000 3000 150 Since project could not work through organizations but it
or materials to recognize and defend against had to work direct with individuals, the scale was lower
extremist narratives in their communities than planned. 100 religious leaders attended in the
interfaith workshop, and 50 participated in a social media
training.
Output 3: Government Engagement: Enhanced sensitization of the government to international best practices that promote social inclusion and tolerance.
3.1. Number of government agencies adding a 0 10 3 3 (CTTC, PTIB has essential relationships with CTTC on youth, ICT
PVE element to existing programming as a result ICT Division, Division on promoting digital innovation, and MOFA on the
of all engagement activities MOFA) “culture for peace” agenda.
3.2 Total number of policymakers (civil servants, 20 370 100 40 BPO provided training to a total 40 govt. officials, including
military, politicians) who participated in CTTC (17), Police (1) DGFI (4), military (6), MOFA (7), and
PVE training or engagement activities BIISS (5). Since PVE has not become a high priority for the
Government of Bangladesh, there were limited agencies to
work with, hence less people to train.
3.2.1 Percentage improvement in scores from a N/A 80% 80% N/A The training was conducted by BPO. Participants were not
test administered at the start of training when tested.
compared to a test administered at the end
3.2.2 number of government agencies adding a N/A 10 3 N/A Government agencies participating were already involved in
PVE element to existing programming PVE Since PVE has not become a high priority for the
as a result of training Government of Bangladesh, there were limited agencies to
work with.
3.3.1. Share and discussion on 0 3 1 1 PTIB supported National PVE Conference where the
National PVE strategy: 2 sharing meeting (December National PVE Strategy was presented and discussed.
2018)