0 ratings0% found this document useful (0 votes) 340 views16 pagesCh3.Strategic Communications Planning For Public Relations and Marketing WILSON LAURIE
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content,
claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF or read online on Scribd
CHAPTER ie
COMMUNICATIONS RESEARCH METHODS
“... digital media collectively provide searchable access to a wealth of experiences and
insights, the quantity and diversity of which seems likely to increase substantially.”
— Jonathan M. Levitt
CconrnsB070R 70 THs JOURNAL OF BlCHRAL INFORMATION
PCN ud eg46 cuapren} Communications research methods
GRP RESEARCH
Gathering and using
information to clarity
an issue and solve a
problem,
[hts tse research inthe ommanteions fd has enploded Before his
time, it was often considered an unaffordable luxury. Now we seer to abound in
data, so much so that we sometimes drown in it. The key, now, is to sort through
and synthesize data into usable information to help us make wise decisions.
Not only do most successful organizations now do research, but there are @
plethora of specialized consultants and research firms which have taken market,
social media, environmental, communications and organizational research to ev.
els of sophistication never before dreamed, Whereas in the past, communications
practitioners found themselves begging for a pittance to find out what their pub-
lics thought, they now have executives whose first question is, “What does the
research say?”
{As a result, our challenge is no longer to convince practitioners to do research.
At this point in your education or career, you have learned the value of research
and measurement and how to do it or how to buy it, Further, there are now doz-
ens of texts and handbooks a5 well as online resources for conducting research.
‘The challenge is to provide the basic framework for thinking about and organizing
research and analysis, and then, in the next chapter, t0 appiy it in the strategic:
planning process.
The role of research in
communication
Research is only as good as its application to the problem-solving process. To be
research-oriented means gathering and basing decisions on information as part of
your daly routine, To be effective in communicating with an organization's publics,
‘we must be constantly listening and scanning the environment for information. We
should establish good communication channels s0 information is constantly flow.
Ing tous — resulting in adjustments and refinements of our efforts as plans proceed.
Research helps us to
Save time and money.
Undersiand our publies
Make sound decisions.
Avoid mistakes.
Discover new ideas.
Identify potential publics.
Identify communication channels.
Justify plans.
Connect with communities
As professional communicators we should be wary of “gut reactions,” knowing
‘what we know about how peaple perceive and misperceive. Always test the infor
mation that leads to conelusions, and especially to key decisions. The next chapter
provides checks afthe information you need to meet the various challenges of an
‘organization and to pian strategically to seize opportunities. In this chapter, we iden-
tify some of the best sources of taformation and the methodologies used to obtain it.CcHAPTER 3 Communications research methods 47
Research methods and the
diversity of tools
Research methods are often categorized as formal and informal, quantitative and
qualitative, and primary and secondary. Nevertheless, these categorizations are not
poallel, For exemple, formal research is not necessarily quantitative research, nor
is it always primary research. A fewr definitions regarding research will help to
avoid confusion.
Formal and informal research, Formal teseerch implies @ structured study, It
is governed by rules of research that include previously identifying what
you hope to learn, how and from whom, Because it follows universal rules
of research, the findings are more accurate and reliable. Informal research.
is less structured and more exploratory. It does not follow specific rules,
Nevertheless, it often provides valuable insight to lead us in directions of
more formal discovery.
Quantitative and qualitative research. Quantitative research gathers statistical
data for analysis. Qualitative research is focused on individuals and groups
not statistically representative of 2 given population. While qualitative re
search may be supported by some statistical data analysis, itis not governed
by laws of probability. It may, however, be governed by rules of research,
Focus groups, for example, are a qualitative tool. They may be informal
discussions, but are more often formal research yielding important insights
into a publi’s perceptions, attitudes and motivations. Now that focus group
methodology has actually become a dominant method of market research,
the rules of research governing this methodology are meticulously followed
to ensure accurate insights. Although the method is classified as formal re-
search because it follows rules and structure, itis stil typicelly a qualitative
approach that yields in-depth understanding but no statistical data
Primary and secondary research. Primary research implies gathering the infor-
mation firsthand fora specifically identified purpose. It doesn't necessarily
refer to survey research. Personal interviews as well as mail and telephone
analysis also yield primary information, Primary research is research that
‘you implement yourself or contract out fora particular purpose. Secondary
research is primary research data originally collected for a different pur-
pose that is now being drawn upon for a new use. Typically itis cheaper
and faster to use secondary research, In this era of omnipresent data, you
should exhaust secondary sources before embarking on any costly primary
research efforts,
Given these definitions, the research tools become more difficult to categorize
Focus groups may be formal or informal. They are typically qualitative, but ifenough
soups are conducted, some quantitative data analysis may be done on the results,
Results are primary research when you organize and condutt them for the immedi
ate purpose, but reviewing transcripts and analyses of focus groups conducted for
‘other purposes is secondary research that may shed light on the problem you are
‘ying to solve.
PRIMARY
RESEARCH
Firsthand information
gathered specifically for
your current purpose,
INFORMAL,
RESEARCH
Less-structured
exploratory information
gathering,
ee
tat pronae dene
significance,
SECONDARY Ry
RESEARCH
Information previously
assimilated for other
purposes that can be
adapted for your needs,48 cnaeten 3 Canmunicsions esearch mesos
Similarly, personal interviews may be informal and qualitative resesech. They
ray be one of your “listening” techniques. Os, given more structure and an 3p-
propriate design, they may be formal and quantitative, allowing statistical analysis
with a high degree of confidence. They would be a primary research tool if con-
ducted for the project at hand, yet may be useful as secondary data in subsequent,
programs.
Whether the research you do is formal or Informal, quantitative or qualitative,
primary or secondary, depends largely on what you need and how you structure it.
You should determine your purpose (what you are hoping to accomplish with the
research) and what you are trying to find out from whom, before you decide on the
best tools to use and how to structure the effort
Secondary research
Organizational research
‘The frst place to begin in gathering information is within the organization itself
Many kinds of research tools are available to help gather and assess the information
available to you, A communication audit examines all of the organization's commu-
nication to see if t supports the organization's mission and message. Environmental
scanning within an organization monitors the mood and feelings that exist among
the workers, customers, investors, suppliers and many other publies of the organiza
tion. Online, mail and telephone analysis helps you track whit issues cause concern
among your publies. Social inedia analytics help to monitor your reach and relation
ships. Certainly customer service and complaint sites help you track opinion trends,
and potential problems.
Important background information about your company or your client is found
in the publications andl websites of the organization. Employee publications, blogs,
digital communications, annual reports, brochures and marketing materials, policy
and procedates manuals, organizational charts, sles and accounting records, histo:
ries and any other material available from the organization, either in hard copy or
electronically, ean be valuable information, Keep in mind that such material usually
possesses an inherent bias, and you need to loak outside the organization as well as
inside to make sure you have the complete picture. Organizations do not often open
thelr elosets to display the skeletons through their
‘own printed and electronic material. You will get
rich information about the organization theough its
‘material, ut you will not usually get the bad news,
And, not knowing the bad news may sabotage your
communication efforts, While the organization itself
js the place to start your research, it should never be
your only source.
‘he organization may also have data from past
surveys or research. You may need some primary
research to determine the mood and opinion of
‘employees, Most organizations would benefit by
taking a searching look inside before focusing re
search efforts externally,Ccomnrren 3 Communications research methods
Internet and library research
{nformation technology and the computer revolution have given us acces to incted
ible resources for research. Information that would take weeks or months to find
fom original sources is now readily avaiable a our fingertips. The communication
professional of today and of the future must understand how to get good data from
the Internet to compete in this new environment,
‘Online research has, in most cases, replaced @ personal visit to the library. It
gives the researcher access to the collections held by thousands of libraries and or-
ganizations and to databases full of information and references, Nevertheless, much
is availadle in library documents that may be difficult to find or expensive to secure
elsewhere. Most of us underestimate the value of the data available in our local col-
lege and public libraries. And unless you actually take the time to investigate, to talk
to a resource librarian or to just explore the collection, you will not appreciate the
vast amount of information at your fingertips
Remember the latest census? It's available on the Internet. In that census, some
people received a more in-depth questionnaire than the rest of us, and the psycho-
graphic data are accessible as well. Further, the census is continually updated with
Interim studies. Also accessible isa host of government documents and studies pub:
lished every year, along with many private research studies. You can find national
and local newspapers and magezines that date back years, sometimes to the begin.
ning of publication. Often the results of opinion polls can be found and rich eco-
nomuic data on local, state, national and international markets.
Some universities have separate libraries for ther business schools. In that case,
the business library probably contains detailed market analysis and other such valu-
able information. While most of this information may be available electronically,
there are volumes of information that can only be accessed by visiting a library in
person. The more current the information, the more likely you will be able to get it
via the Internet, Nevertheless, there may be significant risks in ignoring the deeper
background that older documents contain.
Organizational information is also readily available on the Internet, And in-
creasingly, you will find many independent websites, blogs and other Internet
sites that contain valuable information, Be careful of the source of the informa-
tion, and seek secondary confirmation when possible. The information may be
credible, such as that from an industry analyst with a professional responsibility
to provide such information, or it may be a site constructed by a disgruntled cus:
tomer or employee containing extremely biased or inaccurate information, rumor
and innuendo.
External organizations
‘Our tax dollars support local, state and national government offices that have a
charge to operate in the public interest. Providing public information is often an in
tegral part of that responsibility. Much of the informnation is now available over the
Internet, but some ofthe valuable information you seek may only be available upon
request, or by digging through studies and papers. Sometimes the bureaucracy can
be difficult, and getting information can take weeks or even months, Nevertheless,
the information available is often critical.
“Most cities and states have economic development offices of some kind that cal
lect invaluable information on industries and markets. State, and sometimes local,
governments have information on population, wages, education, unemployment,
4950 cHarreR3 Commamicaons rscrch methads
Q._, DEMOGRAPHIC
oP pata
Information used
to segment publics
according to tangible
characteristics such
25 age, gender and
socioeconomic status
health and just about everything else you can imagine, Environmental data is read:
ily available from area chambers of commerce and travel councils. Be persistent;
the information you want may be part of something else. You will have to do most
of the searching, so start specific but be ready to broaden your search until you
find documents and reports that will provide the information you need. You have
to ask broad and searching questions to get to the right documents and studies.
For example, asking a clerk for any studies on how much college students spend on
e-books might not get you the information you want, But studies of online se or
income and expenditures of 18- to 24-year-olds or the costs ofa college education
would all contain information on e-book expenditures.
Inherent in the missions of associations, advocacy groups or professional sock
tes is gathering and disseminating information. One of the most valuable benefits
‘of membership may be access to the research they gather. You may be able to access
the information you want from them through their publications or resource librar-
ies. You may have to pay a search or use fee to access the material. In some cases, you
may need to get the materia through an association member. But the data available
is generally very rich, current and valuable.
‘A word of caution: When you receive data from these kinds of organizations,
especially from activist groups, check the souzces and methodologies used. Be aware
that any information published by an imerest group of any kind will be inherently
biased to some degree, Make sure you understand and allow for that bias, and seek
confirming and/or disputing information from other sources, or carefully examine
the research methodology used and adjust for distortion,
Media research
“Media research straddles the line between secondary and primary research. Depend-
ingon the purpose, itcould be either. Nevertheless, itis erucial in today's media envi
ronment. A number of publishing houses produce Internet-accessible media guides
and services that provide current and valuable information about media throughout
the nation by category: newspapers, magazines, radio stations, television stations,
cable stations and so on. Media services such as PR Newswire, CisionPoint, which is,
based on Bacon's media database, and BurrellsLuce media monitoring track editors
and reporters by assignment, how to submit pieces aa what is typicelly accepted.
The guides also indicate readership, wiewership or listenership and will sometimes
provide additional demographic information that stay be of help in profiling key
publics, They at least provide a way to contact the media organization to request
more detailed information. Most media organizations can provide detailed viewer,
listener or reader profiles because they sell advertising, And, advertisers want to
know who they're buying access to.
‘Media and Internet analysis and clips are @ critieal part of communications
research and evaluation, Whether in-house or a contracted service, tracking such
coverage is essential, Nevertheless, because of the time it takes to be thorough,
you will usually get more comprehensive and cost-effective clipping and analysis,
if you contract a clipping service. Clipping services may do as little as simply clip
anything (print, bro2dcast and other electronic media) that mentions the com.
pany oF an issue of interest to the company, At the other end of the spectrum,
they may engage io extensive analysis and evaluate the positive or negative int
pact of the pieces that discuss the organization and its competitors or any of thecurren 3 Communications rscerch metho — 51
issues faced by the industry. You can specify the level of service you want and pay
accordingly
Monitoring the Internet is particularly important to organizations today. And
the methodology has become more sophisticated as tracking tools have been devel-
‘oped and refined. Most organizations have given up teying to monitor al the online
conversations, but a selective approach to online listening related to Issues of con-
cer to yout organization isimperative.
Primary research
Focus groups
Focus group research has become an important and reliable source of data to under
stand our publics. & focus group is a moderator-led discussion with four to 14 per
ticipants. The moderator asks open-ended questions to garner qualitative responses
oon attitudes and behavior. The moderator must be careful not to bias the discussion
by injecting personal opinion or information into the group. He/she should encour
age participation from all members ofthe group and probe for in-depth understand:
ing, The moderator must also ereatean atmosphere of openness, honesty, safety and
confidentiality in order to engender free and open discussion. With the permission
and knowledge of the participants, he session is usually recorded (audio or video),
and the discussion transcribed for further evaluation and data tabulation.
Focus group research is generaly easier to conduct than survey cesearch
and provides rapid results along with depth of opinion and attitudes within the
group. The discussion nature of focts groups shapes, refines and crystallizes
opinions and attitudes (see Figure 3), Further, while not always less expensive
than other kinds of research, it is often more cost-effective. Focus groups used
to be conducted in communications ané marketing research primarily as discus
sion forums for advisory committees or idea panels to supplement quantitative
research, The information was often used as a precursor to survey research to
assist in developing a questionnaire that adequately probed attitudes and opin
ions. In today’s research-oriented marketplace, many practitioners recogni
that, while survey research is becoming less credible as an accurate representa
tion of publies, focus groups provide the kind of information needed to immedi-
ately address and resolve problems.
{As discussed in the previous chapter, people do not behave in isolation, The dis-
cussion and refinement of opinions and attitudes which occur in focus groups often
provide problem-solving behavioral information that surveys cannot. The example
cited in the previous chapter of the introduction of new Coke is a case in point.
Both research techniques were used, yielding opposite results. Yet because of the
reputation for validity of survey research over focus-group responses, the company
chose to rely on predictions of behavior based on attitudes expressed! in isolation
‘They should have more carefully considered the g:oup behavior that emerged from
the focus groups.
Further, focus group research can demonstrate the process of opinion forma:
tion, While not representative, the group isa social microcosm of a larger public.
The analysis of how attitudes and opinions change based on the flow of the dis
FOCUS GROUP
RESEARCH
Moderatorled
discussions with fewer
than 15 participants
providing in-depth
information on attitudes
and behaviors.
°
aotS52 CHAPTER 3 Communications research methods
gy Figure 3.1
© “Uses and abuses of focus group research
Uses Abuses
Immediate results. Weak moderator.
Comfort in numbers.
Dominant moderator.
Flexible and response-orlented.
‘Not homogenous.
Gauge of group behavior.
Too few groups.
Issues oxplored and opinions crystallized.
Generalizing to a population.
‘Sensitive issues addressed.
Attitudes of activists Included.
{ssues and jargon identified.‘cuAarTeR 3 Commuviaion research meade 53
cussion can help us know what information people need to
make sound decisions and what appeals will be most effec-
tive in the larger arena. Innovations in focus group research,
now allow quantification of results if certain conditions are
met. Conducting large numbers of groups and employing
some content analysis techniques can make the data statist
cally reliable.
The Internet provides an interesting resource for tea
ditional focus group research. Scheduled online chats can
produce similar results without the geographic restrictions.
Nevertheless, care must be taken that participants are invited
and known, Otherwise, the data may not be useful for the re
searcher’s purpose. Face-to-face group discussion is still preferable but can be simu
lated using tools such as Skype.
© LD Potshunesockcom
Copy and product testing
One classic use of focus groups is for copy and/or product testing, But this is
not the only method by which to test. Copy testing simply selects individuals
within your target publies and requests their review of copy, whether survey
copy or communication copy (brochures, advertising and the like). In product
testing, individuals are asked to examine and use a product and provide feedback
on everything from packaging and sales methods to product quality. Product
tests may be done individually by personal interview, by mail, in focus groups
or online
Honest responses in copy snd product testing help avoid costly mistakes.
Survey research instruments should always be tested before being implemented.
‘Testing copy helps ensure that the messages are coming across in such @ way as
to produce the desired result. Marketers test promotional campaigns or products,
in areas representative of the overall market. Sometimes, two or three different
versions of a product or 2 campaign will be tested in similar areas to determine
which will be the most effective to roll out nationwide. Copy and product test
ing is one of the most valuable kinds of research available to the practitioner.
Its greatest value lies in its ability to prevent mistakes — saving money, effort
and time.
Psychographic studies
Values and Lifestyles Segmenting, developed by SRI International in 1978, is re
search methodology that classifies publics not just by demographies, but also by
psychographics or atitudes, beliefs and lifestyles. Found to be far more effective
in segmenting publics than demographies alone, psychographie studies help us 10
know what motivates individuals within a particular public. The VALS categories —
achievers, survivors, sustainers, belongers and so on — have been used extensively
in advertising and marketing to segment and tailor messages to specific target pub-
lies, They provide the same valuable segmentation for communication with all the
‘organization's publics. Communicators should know the VALS eategories, both the
original and the more recently revised segmentations, and understand the motiva
tions tied to the differences in attitedes and lifestyles.$4 cunnreny Communication rssh methods
Cag PSYCHOGRAPHIC
oP Dara
Information used
to segment publics
according to values,
attitudes and lifestyles.
Other market research firms have subsequently developed similar categoriza-
tions. In the 19905, Claritas developed PRIZM, segmenting American consumers
into 14 groups with 66 demographically and behaviorally distinct types like “Cosmo-
politans” and “Kids & Cul-de-Sacs.” PRIZM was subsequently purchased by Nielsen,
the company known for rating what people watch on television.
Oftentimes, local media and other similar organizations will have segmented
and profiled their own target audiences using a combination of demographic and
psychographie data, Whereas some will be unwilling to disclose the information,
‘which is quite costly to compile, others may be persuaded to share the data, especially
ifthe request comes from a nonprofit organization or is for a charitable purpose.
Another valuable tool for understanding key publics is Values in Strategy Assess
ment, a process developed by Wirthlin Worldwide and purchased uy Harris Interac-
tive, which has now also joined forces with Nielsen, This tools premise is that values
are the fundamental determinant of an individuals behavior and decisions, Under
standing the fandamental values of a public provides the strategy to motivate action.
Social media analytics
‘A new reallty of today’s communication environment is pervasive social media.
With the range of networks available today, organizations must carefully choose
those with which they will engage ~ those most appropriate for building relation-
ships with key publics. Facebook was perhaps the first to became an essential pres
ence for the organization. Now Twitter, Pinterest, Instagram, Snapchat and a host
of ather social media networks have become channels through which we interact
with our publiss, Since the effort to build and manage a social media presence is so
costly and time-consuming, itis critical that organizations employ research methods
to ensure the effectiveness of their social media efforts in delivering the messages of
the organization, building relationships with key publics and providing the interse
tions key publics desire
Quite simply, social media analytics are the tools used to measure, analyze and
interpret the interactions and relationships with our key publics. I, in large part's
essentially “online listening” to help us better meet the needs of publics. The East
rman Kodak Company used online listening several years ago to determine what
features consumers wanted in a digital camera. They discovered through theit re
search that no existing camera offered the combination of features consumers were
bbuzzing about on Facebook. Kodak engineers quickly went to work and within a
few manths were able to bring a new product to market that contained all of the
features people wanted most at an affordable price. The new camera sold extremely
well, but unfortunately wasn’t enough to save the struggling company from bank
ruptey in 2072
‘This kind of measurement is so important that many of the social media net
‘works, like Facebook and Google, have imbedded their own monitoring and ana
Iytical tools to track sociat media efforts. In addition, a host of external tools — some
fee, some for a fee — integrate measurement of all social media efforts, It is essen
tial, nevertheless, that you are careful about what you are measuring. Measuring the
number of “ikes" or “Friends” or “followers” doesn't measure whether publics are
actually retaining and acting on your message. Don't confuse coverage with success.
Remember that behavior — or action — is the final evaluation. Itdoesa’t matter how
‘many “followers” you have ifthey don't actually perform the action that will satisfy
‘yout objectives.cuarren 3 Communications rsuch mattods 35
Survey research and opinion sampling
‘A popular quantitative research method is survey research, although its credibility
hhas declined somewhat in recent years because of the difficulty in securing a truly
random sample. Several events have affected the ability of researchers to secure
truly random and representative samples, Mail surveys have always been extremely
unreliable, not only because of low response rates but also because of skewing. Only
certain kinds of people will take the time to respond to a mail survey, making it any-
thing but representative.
‘Telephone surveys have also declined in eredibility for the same reason. And
the “do not call” registry has mage telephone surveying more difficult than ever.
Although telephone surveys are not prohibited by the registry, the very existence of
“do not call” list seems to have given people the courage to refuse calls they would
have previously endured.
"Nevertheless, survey research has been 9 popular research technique in com
munications and will probably continue to be in some form or another. For exam
ple, researchers may find the personal drop-off method to still be effective because
of the personal contact involved in dropping off and/or picking up a survey. Its not
as easy to turn down someone face to face as it isto say “no” over the telephone.
Online programs like Qualtries make surveying easier but still face the challenge of
securing representative samples. Professional research firms have developed other
techniques that ean also improve response rates.
Survey research is a difficult and exacting approach. It requires meticulous at
tention to detail at every step ofthe process: questionnaire design, sample selection,
survey implementation, data processing and data analysis. A mistake or misjudg-
‘ment at any point will skew the results, often without the researcher knowing the
data is skewed,
To be valid and reliable, survey research must follow strict rules of research.
‘The idea behind survey research is to take a sample from a population, or universe
we follow good statistical procedures, we should be able to make that sample
relatively representative of the universe, although we can never be absolutely sure
of our accuracy unless we survey every individual in the population (a census). The
total number of individuals surveyed in the population and the way they are selected
‘will determine how accurately the results reflect the universe
Statistical research on very critical issues, or in close political campaigns, needs
to have a high level of confidence and a low sampling error, also known as margin
of error. The confidence level reflects the researcher's percentage of certainty that
the results would be the same (within the margin of error) upon replication of the
survey. The margin of error reflects the percentage points thatthe semple results, on
any given question, may vary from the population asa whole, Increasing the sample
size increases the confidence level and decreases the margin of error. The only way
to be 100 percent confident and eliminate the margin of error would be to survey
the entire population or take a census. Research regarding an organization's publics
generally requires at least a 95 percent confidence level and @ margin of error of
5 percent or less. Further, the more important or controversial the issue, the greater
the need for a lower margin of erro.
“There are two basic kinds of survey sampling: probability and nonprobabil-
ity. Probability sampling is scientifically random; every individual in the popula
tion has an equal chance of being selected, Nonprobability samples survey who-
ever is available, for example, intercepting students during the lunch hour as they
SAMPLING ERROR GL,
Meesured os moran of
tron nda the
oossble percentage
‘eration of sop
dataromthe whole
oonulton
CONFIDENCE
LEVEL
The percentage of
certainty that the results
of a survey would be the
same if replicated.56
CCHAFTER 3 Connumicatanseierch nerds
TIPS FROM
THE PROS
Beyond sampling error
Dee Allsop, Ph.D., CEO of Heart+ Mind Strategies and former president
of Harris Interactive Solutions Groups — producers of the Harris Poll —
tips you off on understanding key factors in survey accuracy.
With the current emphasis on “big data® for critical decision-making,
survey and sampling science are all about accurately measuring a small
number of people to understand the attitudes and predict the behay-
jor of an entire group. Accuracy in survey research is the direct result of
‘tentifying. eliminating or correcting for aif types of error or bias that can
enter into research. While “sampling error” is the most visible indicator of
survey accuracy reported in the media, your success depends on under-
standing both sampling and nonsampling errors.
SAMPLING ERROR
‘Sampling error is the statistical estimate of variation that will occur
when using a small number of people (a sample) to approximate a
result from a much larger population. One way to think of sampling er-
ror is the range of results that would occur if you were to repeat your
survey hundreds of times. For example, many surveys report a sampling
erfor of plus or minus 3 percent at the 95 percent confidence interval.
‘This simply means that if you were to repeat this study 100 tires,
95 percent of the time your results would fall within a range of
6 percantage points.
NONSAMPLING ERROR
‘Sampling error is inherent in ail surveys. We understand it well and can
predict it, Other sources of error are more elusive, yet far more important
to accuracy and utility of survey results,
‘Sample frame. Make sure the sample was taken from the group of people
that matter. For example, if the survey is about who will be elected pre
dent, the sample should come from people who can actually vote for
presiclent: registered voters.
Nonresponse error, Several factors influence a respondent's likelihood to
respond (e.g., mode effects, interviewer effects and sensitivity effects),
Rather than sampling error, | would much prefer to know the response
rate for a survey. & law response rate indicates the survey Is less likely to
reflect the population in question.CHAPTER 3 Commamications reeurch methods 57
Construct validity. Questions can be worded or constructed to gener-
ate just about any result desired. Always read the questions that were
asked before interpreting the results. Biased wording will produce biased
resutts,
Institutional reputation. Always check to see who conducted the survey
‘and who paid for it. Reputable companies invest significant time and re-
sources to produce objective findings and eliminate nonsampling errors.
‘Take a lesson from marketing and survey research companies. Instead of
worrying about “sampling error,” focus on understanding how to reduce
nonsampling error through goad survey design, questionnaire construc-
tion, interviewing execution and data processing and correction,
Copvigh ¢ Kendo Hunt Ua ComoRTY
enter the student center or interviewing people at a grocery store on Saturday
afternoon.
‘There are also two kinds of errors: sampling and nonsampling, Sampling error
is inherent because we are surveying a portion of the population and not the entire
population, It is the percentage of possible variance in the sample's answers from
the population, We decrease sampling error by increasing sample size; the closer
‘we get to surveying the whole population, the smaller the sampling error. Sampling
error is unavoidable in survey research (unless we take a census) and is measured as
margin of error
Nonsampling error is all other types of errors introduced into the process
Misvakes made in questionnaire consteuction, saraple selection, survey implement
tion, data entry and tabulation are all nonsampling errors. Great care must be taken
in selecting the sample as well as in designing and implementing the questionnaire.
Question-and-answer categories must be designed to avoid the introduction of bias
so that answers accurately reflect the information the researcher needs.
Bias can also be introduced in the implementation of the survey. Ensuring strict
confidentiality of responses can lessen courtesy bias. Training interviewers to ask
‘questions without injecting value inflection or personal comments, explanation or
other dias is also critical. Further, great care must be taken in coding the surveys
and entering the data. Data processing converts the observations ané responses into
statistics for interpretation. Data analysis manipulates the data to make logical in
ferences. For the inferences to be reliable, the data must be accurately entered and.
processed.
Finally, the inferences made must be fully supportable by the dataset. few years
au, 2 ballot measure in Utah proposed a ligt ral transportation system to be fand-
ced by a small tax increase. When the measure was soundly defeated, many analysts
concluded it was a vote against light rail. In reality, it was more likely a vote against
the fanding method, not the light rail system itself. When we deal with statistics and
NONSAMPLING O55,
ERROR ~
Mistakes made
in designing and
implementing
a questionnaire
that may include
efinitional aifferences,
misunderstandings and
misrepresentations as
well as coding errors
and/or a failure to
represent all populationsSB cuarren s Communications estarch merhoas
Sap purposive
SAMPLING
Identifying and surveying
opinion leaders to
determine attitudes and
behaviors,
CRP STRATIFIED
SAMPLING
Selecting the sample to
‘ensure proportionate
representation of
segments within the
°
(BP panes stupy
Respondents who hove
repestedly 0 track
opinion ar tte
make inferences from data, we must be very cateful thet the data support the eon
clusions. Otherwise, we have established « faulty foundation far decision-making,
In addition to the types of survey research discussed above, other variations
have specific purposes and benefits. The following short cescriptions will provide
4 basis upon which tos westigate the techniques for any given research situation
Purposive sampling, Based on Katz avd Lazarsield’s two-step flow theory,
purposive sampling identifies and surveys opinion leaders to determine
attitudes and behaviors, The researcher must devise a procedure that se-
lects the target publics influentials (or eauses them to self select) and then
surveys opinion and behavior. It is also helpful to know a litle bit about
opinion leaders, such as where they get their information about certain
issues. Understanding opinion leaders helps us understand how they will
influence others, The Edelman Trust Barometer is an example of purposive
sampling
Stratified sampling. Truly random sampling should yield a cross section of
the population representative of the characteristics within the population
Ge, proportionate numbers of women and men and so on). Whenever we
skew the randomness of the sample by using techniques that make it easier
for us to complete the research, like surveying every “nth” number in the
local telephone directory, we risk jeopardizing the representativeness of
our sample, Ifabtaining a tray proportionate representation is critical, the
research sample should be stratified so that it includes appropriate propor
tions of the key segments of the overall popultion.
Internet surveys. § growing area of survey research is conducting surveys over
the Internet and through social media. While there is inherent bias because
of the nature of accessible respondents, ahis data can be extremely valu
able i the purpose is consistent with the population semple. Increasingly,
‘organizations use this method to survey their members, employees or cus:
tomers. Commerelal firms with access to email lists may further facilitate
this method. The low-cost nature, ease of conducting and rapid feedback of
Internet surveys have fueled their popularity
Personal interviews. Very sensitive issues and research that requires deep
probing for attitudes and behaviors are best addressed through personal
interviews, The personal interview ensures greater control over the sample
and the data, But not only is this method costly, it requires alot of tine and
well-trained interviewers, Nevertheless, in certain circumstances, its the
only viable method to secure reliable and useful information.
Benchmark surveys. This type of survey is simply @ periodic reexamination of|
attitudes and opinions within the population, An initial survey is done to
set a benchmark against which subsequent survey results are compared,
Benchmark surveys are good tools for measuring change as well 25 for eval:
usting the success of a program.
Panel studies. Sometitnes you will want to study attitudes and opinions on a vat
‘ety of issues over a period of time. Panel studies vet respondents who will
be available for follow-up surveys at least once and often several times, ForCHAPTER) Communcavions rescorch methods — 59
example, a newspaper will select individuals from its readership to follow
a specific issue or election and respond to queries at specific points in the
campaign. Behavioral studies are also sometimes conducted by a panel to as
sess whether a change in behavior is temporary and what motivates perma
nent change.
‘Omnibus surveys. One of the easiest and least expensive methods of obtaining OMNIBUS SURVEY
survey data isto add a few questions to an omnibus survey being prepared An ongoing, open survey
by a professional research company. These surveys, sometimes called tay to which a company
fon surveys, usually have multiple research clients that share the costs and vt organization may
the common demographic data collected. Specific data gathered from the add a few proprietary
questions each client adds remains proprietary. The advantages are the cost questions at a
saving shared by multiple clients and the currency of the data because the reasonable cost
surveys are ongoing and conducted regularly, in addition, the reliability of
the data is high as the sample size is usually large.
Summary
(Our environment has changed. CEOs require “big data” to make decisions, and they.
expect your recommendations to be logically based on reliable information. To se-
tes cnsantflw of tend of eration you hed to make decor, met
thalenges and plan sategicaton, You mst inthe ight combintlonofcontine
‘ous research techniques. The purpose of the research and the kind of information
desired drive the selection of methodology. Otherwise your research will be useless
because it is inaccurate or because it doesn't provide the information you need to
design pesusve camel
Exercises
4. Volunteer to conduct focus groups for a nonprofit organization. Subse:
quently, design and implement a short survey to gather opinions, attitudes
and demographics on some of its key publics.
2, Visi the local library and talk with the reference librarian to discover the
range of resoutees, databases, search engines and other references avail-
able. Search through some of the material to discover the kinds of informa:
tion accessible, not just online, but in the library itself.
3. Look up the most recent U.S. Census and write down at least a dozen cat
cegories of information available through this rich resoure.
4. Compile list of “go to” sources to quickly find continually updated infor:
‘mation on issues, publics and communication channels,60.
ccuarren 5
Communicains sear serods
References and additional
readings
bebo hepato a aed Delman, CA Waawerh Pubaiag
pine Df. enim mrs: One for ended atone, me
‘engagenient, and key relationships. Duthamn, NH: Paine Publishing,
ene
sicusonte









