Discussions Samples
Discussions Samples
Adrian Wallwork
(author of Discussions AZ, Cambridge University Press)
tefldiscussions.com
Copyrighted Material
You ....................................................................................................................................................................................... 16
Applications ......................................................................................................................................................................... 21
Sex ....................................................................................................................................................................................... 26
Exercises .............................................................................................................................................................................. 34
DISCUSSIONS One-to-One.......................................................................................................................................................... 37
Exercises .............................................................................................................................................................................. 41
tefldiscussions.com 2
Discussions Volume 1-3 Adrian Wallwork & others
DISCUSSIONS Volume 3
tefldiscussions.com 3
Discussions Samples Adrian Wallwork & others
Teacher’s Guide
Below is a very brief guide to this book. Details on how to use this book and the others in the series can be found in
the Teacher's Book, which can be downloaded for free at: tefldiscussions.com.
2 Choosing exercises
Before choosing a particular exercise/topic, decide whether it would be suitable for your students. In Vols 2 and 3,
potentially controversial exercises are marked with a in the Table of Contents. Such exercises are not suitable for the
following types of students, those who:
you do not know very well
do not know each other very well
are in a multinational group with cultures or countries that tend to clash with each other
tefldiscussions.com 4
Discussions Volume 1-3 Adrian Wallwork & others
A simple solution for your first lesson is to ask students to look at the index and to mark those items that they
would:
• be particularly interested in talking about
• prefer NOT to talk about
Whatever exercise you use, always have a back-up in case your chosen exercise does not go as planned.
3 Preparation
In Discussions Volume 1 and Volume 2 only the exercises with a clock ) in the Table of Contents require preparation on
your part. Preparation is needed in order for you to digest the meaning of a text or to think about the implications of the
questions. In a few cases, preparation might also involve looking at the key to the exercise. Note that in the Table of
Contents all those exercises with a key are marked .
If you are a reasonably experienced teacher, the other exercises require no preparation on your part. You can simply hand
out the exercise to students, and then read the texts and questions at the same time as the students are reading. If you are
relatively new to EFL / ESL teaching, then clearly you should look at the exercises before going into class! You will also need
to decide how long your class might take to complete the exercise.
In Discussions Volume 3 the exercises are 'heavier' than in the other two volumes. Unless you class is truly up for anything,
it would be wise to read the exercises before handing them out to students.
If you are planning to use an exercise for a full discussion (rather than just as a warm up), then ask students to prepare for it
in advance. Tell them the exercise they are going to be doing next lesson, ask them to read the text and look up any
unknown words, and finally ask them to think about how they would answer the questions (and what vocabulary and
grammar they might need to enable them to answer the questions).
This approach is outlined in Section 1 of the Students Introduction. Such preparation will help students to feel more
confident in having the discussion and you massively increase the chances of them having something to say.
Not all groups of students will need to see (and prepare) the exercise in advance. Those that are used to having discussions
in the classroom (and in their regular lives) will probably have no problem jumping in to a new topic.
Clearly, however, if you do have time to prepare the exercises, the more likely they are to be effective. Things you might
like to think about are:
• Is a discussion of this type suitable for my students? Will they have much to say? Might some students have an
issue with the subject matter?
• How long is the discussion likely to last? Would it work better as a warm up or a full discussion? [In Volumes 1 and
2, those exercises that I think also work well as warm ups are marked ]
• Do my students actually need to read the text? If I am short of time, could I get them simply to discuss the
questions?
• Do my students need to answer all the questions? Might some of the questions be intellectually too demanding for
them, or simply not part of their realm of experience? If so, should I tell them which questions to answer, or simply
say, for example, 'choose three questions that you would like to discuss'?
tefldiscussions.com 5
Discussions Samples Adrian Wallwork & others
• What other questions would I like my students to answer? (i.e. you might want to change / add questions)
• Could I increase the length of the discussion by combining more than one exercise together (for instance, by doing
two consecutive exercises, e.g. C1 followed by C2; or non consecutive exercises e.g. C1 + R4)?
• Can I tie in the discussion to what we did in a previous lesson or to a unit in the regular coursebook my students
are following?
Note: The exercises are designed for pairwork or groupwork.
Below are the typical activities. A single activity may occupy the whole page, or more frequently, may be found in
combination with other activities.
• Facts / Quotations: Students read the facts / quotations and discuss them directly. Alternatively, ask students to
write down a question in relation to the fact or quotation. They then ask the question to their partner. This is
designed to be a 2-3 minute activity.
• List of questions: This is most basic type of exercise. Ask students to read all the questions and choose 4-5
questions (or more) to discuss together.
• Quizzes: These are in the form either of: i) personality quizzes, typically asking students what they would do in
certain situations; ii) general knowledge quizzes (the answers are in the key at the end of the book); iii) true/false
statements (again, answers in the key)
• Short texts: The reading exercises are authentic texts of around 100-150 words, and can be read in between one to
three minutes. Students only need to understand the general gist.
• Questions on the preceding text: The texts are not designed to be a standard reading comprehension exercise, but
a springboard to conversation via the questions that follow the text. In some cases, the questions are factual (the
answers are in the key at the end of the book).
Proceed as follows:
• Put students into pairs or groups.
• Inform students which activity you wish them to do.
• If students haven't done any pre-preparation (see Sect 1. page 6), then they can do it now. However, in many
cases, they can simply launch straight into the exercise.
• Go around groups encouraging students and noting down their difficulties (vocabulary, pronunciation, repeated
grammar mistakes etc.).
tefldiscussions.com 6
Discussions Volume 1-3 Adrian Wallwork & others
• When the time you have allocated is up or when around half the class appear to be winding down their
conversation, either elicit general feedback or move on to the next activity.
At the end of the lesson or the beginning of the next, go over the points you noted down while you were going round the
groups (step 4 above).
With experience you will learn which exercises work best in which situations, with which groups, and for how long. The
secret is always to have a Plan B: - i) for a discussion that dries up too quickly you need to have back up materials (don't
force students to continue the discussion), ii) for a warm-up where the discussion actually takes off you need to assess
whether it might be better to abandon your original lesson plan and just see where the discussion goes and what students
might get out of it.
The index is designed to help you i) find exercises that you think might be suitable for your class, ii) to locate exercises that
you have done previously. The fact that an item is listed in the index does not always mean that there is a full discussion of
it in the related exercise, it may simply be referred to.
So I would welcome any improvements to my exercises (texts, questions) and also any new exercises that you like might like
to send me either to replace ones in the current books, or for use in future books in the series.
Although these books have been edited by experienced ELT teachers, they have not been subjected to the rigorous editing
skills of a professional ELT publisher.
If you find any mistakes or have comments to make please contact me: [email protected]
tefldiscussions.com 7
Discussions Samples Adrian Wallwork & others
1 2 3
Volume 1 Volume 2 Volume 3
The letters and numbers refer to the unit and exercise number. For example,
1 2
risks R1, R2, R3, R4, D2, D3
means that the topic of risks and risk taking is dealt with in unit R ('Risks') of Volume 1 in exercises 1-4, and in unit
D ('Dangers’) of Volume 2 in exercises 2 and 3
2 1 3
origines P4 alcoholism H3 atheism R4
3 3 2
abortion L4 aliens A2 Australia P4
2 3 3 3
actors M3, A1 alt-right M4 average G3
2 1 1
addiction - techno I2 Amazon B3 battery hens V4
1 2 3 3
advice B3, K3, B4 Americans A2 beauty E1, G2, K3
3 1 2 3
affairs - extra marital A4, S1 animals A1, A2, A3, A4, V4, beliefs A2
3
3 K4, N1, T3 3
age S2 Bible H4
2
3 annoying habits Y2 2
agony aunts I4 Black English L4
2
3 apps A1, A3, A4 3
AIDs O4 blasphemy T4
2
3 art E3 2
alcohol R2 blogs B1, B3
3
artificial insemination E1
tefldiscussions.com 8
Discussions Volume 1-3 Adrian Wallwork & others
1 2 3
body building S2 cinema M1, M2, M3, M4 cultural differences H2, I1, K1,
W4
3 2
body G2 civil liberties S4
2
cultural heritage C1, E3
1 3 2
books B1, B2, Q2 civilization - a new C2, C3
1
cultural traits I3, P3, R4, W4, Z1
3 3
boycotting P2 claims for damages J4, K4
1
cultures B4, C4, P3, R4, W4
3 2
breast implants E1 climate change D4
2
cultures C4, Q1, P4, T4
2 3
bribing Y3 cloning G4
2
dangers - assessing D2
2 3 1
British U4, I1 comfort zone Z3
3
dating D1, D2, D3, D4, S1
1 2
bucket list Y1 compass T4
2
daydreaming Z3
3 3
burkinis U2 conspiracy theories C1, C2, C4
1 3
death O3, R2, Y1, L2
3 3
burqas H4 conversation - safe topics T1
1
debunking M1
2 1 3 2
business A2, G4, E3, B3 cool / uncool W2
1
definitions N4
3 1
cannibalism E3 countries B4, C1, C2, C3, H3, I3,
3
R4 diceman X1
3
capital punishment V2
3 3
creation myth R3, U1 dietary laws T3
1
cars A4
3 2
creationists U1 disciplinary procedure J2
3
Catholicism N4, R3, W2, Z2, Z3
3 3
crime J1, J2, J3, J4 discoveries U3
3
censorship Q2
1 3
crime J2, J4 dishonesty M2
1 2
chances O3, O3
1 2
cryonics O4 dreams Z2, Z4
2
children H2
2 2 1 3
cults W3 drugs O4, H3, R2
3
Christianity T3, U1, U2, Z3
tefldiscussions.com 9
Discussions Samples Adrian Wallwork & others
2 2 1 2
dubbing M2 Esperanto G3 future F1, F2, F4, D4, H4, I2,
3
1 1 O2, R4, T1, F1, F2, F3, F4, O4
e-commerce E3 ethics H3
1
1 1 future tenses F3
e-piracy E1 etiquette B4
3
2 1 3 gambling R2
economics F3, W4 euthanasia E3
1 3
2 1 1 game shows X2, X2
education E1, E2, E3, E4, U1 exams Q3, U3
2
3 3 games consoles X3
Egypt K1 extreme measures X4
3
1 3 Garos W1
elections G1 extremes O2, X1
1
1 3 2 gas E4
electricity E4, Y1 Facebook S2
1 3
1 3 2 gender L2, M3, G1
email E2, U2, H3 fake news N1
tefldiscussions.com 10
Discussions Volume 1-3 Adrian Wallwork & others
3 3 1 3
guns V1, V4 infant mortality E3 juries A3, J1, J2, J3
2 1 1 3
habits H1, H4, Y2 Instagram I4 justice A3, J2, J1, J2, J3, J4,
V3
1 1
happiness K4 insults N2
2
knowledge K1
2 1 2
headlines X4 intelligence D3, D4, X4, E2
2 1
language L1, L2, K1
1 3 2
health H1, H2, S2, E1, E3, G2, internet - dangers D1
3
L3, U3, Y1 law (an eye for an eye) J4
2
introductions Q1
3 3
heaven R4 laws (as in Murphy's Law) N2
1 3
inventions I1, I3, I4, T1, T3,
2 1 3
hobbies H3, L4, S1 C2 leisure time in the future F2
1 2 3 3
holidays C2, T2, V1, V2 Islam H4, J4, R2, U2, X3 lex talionis J4
3 2 3 3
Holocaust C4 Israel E4, P4 LGBT S4
3 3 3
homosexuality N4, O4, S4 Jain monks Z3 life after death L2
1 1 3
horse manure A4 James Bond Q1 life L1
1 3 3
household jobs W1 Jehovah's Witnesses U2, Z4 life on other planets A2
3 3 1
human nature N3 Jews C4, Z2 lifestyle K4, L1
3 1 1
humour D2, H1, H2, H3, H4 jobs Q1 lists B2
3 3 1 3
ideal (man / woman) W4 jokes D2, H2, H3, L4 live to be 100 L1
3 1 3
identity I1, I2 Joneses I2 Lorde P2
1 1 3
image - self I1, I2, I4 judging yourself J3 love D1, D3, D4
1 2 3
incompetence D1, D2, D3, D4 junk J1 lying M2
tefldiscussions.com 11
Discussions Samples Adrian Wallwork & others
3 3 2 3
machines F4 North Korea Z1 pets K4, K4
3 3 2
man on moon conspiracy C1 Nostradamus F3 phones P1, P2, P3, P4
1 2 3 3
maths B1, X4, X2 obsessions O1 plagiarism M2
2 2 3
media N1, N2, N3 odd balls O4 poems K3, N1
1 1 2 3
men M3, Q2, W3 odd one out O2, O2 political correctness T4
3 1 2 1 2
mental blocks M1 odds O3, O3 politics G1, G2, G3, G4, N4,
3
3 2 U3, G1, K2, M4, P1, P2, P3,
MeToo W3 office issues J3
P4, S1, Z1
3 1
miracles Z3 origins P1 3
polygamy K3
3 3
moon C1 paedophilia N4 3
Polynesia O3
2 3
movies M1, M2, M3, M4 Palestine P4, X3 3
pornography S3
3 2
Murphy's Law N2 Paris syndrome V2 1 2
predictions A4, F1, F3, F4,
2 2 3
music - black L4 Parthenon marbles E3 D4, I2, O2, R4, T1, F1, F2, F3,
F4, O4
3 1 2
Muslims H4, J4, R2, U2, X3 past habits P4, H1
3
preferences Y3, T2
1 1
myths (modern) M1 people P1, P3, P4, Y2
2
privacy online S4
1 1
names N1 performance Z4
3
private life A1
3 2
nationalities H2 personal questions Q2, Y2
3
professors H3
3 1
New Zealand P4 personal zones Z1
3
prostitution M3
2 1
news N1, N2, N3, X4 personality P1, Y2
3
Protestants Z2
2 3
nightmares Z4 personality traits G3
tefldiscussions.com 12
Discussions Volume 1-3 Adrian Wallwork & others
1 2 1 1
qualifications Q1 science A3, E3, R1, R2, R3, spy Q1
3
1 Q1, Q4, T2, U3 1
qualities K2 statistics P4
2
2 security S4 1 3
questions Q1, Q2, Q3, Q4, W4 stereotypes L2, V3, I1
2
1 selfies P3 2
quizzes / questionnaires B3, G3, strange people O4
3 3
H1, O1, O2, P2, P4, Q4, A1, sex Q1, S1, S2, S3, S4 3
strange powers A2, Y1
E2 G3, N3 O1, U4, Y3, Y4
3
Sikhs U2 1
2 3 stupidity D1, D2, D3, D4
Quora Q3, Q3
3
sin N4 2
2 3 subjects at university E2
racism E3, J4, E3, H2
3
Singapore K1 2
2 subtitling M2
rap L4
2
sleep Z1, Z2 3
3 suing J4, K4
reincarnation L2
1
soccer S4 3
3 supernatural A2, Y1
religion (in general) R1, R2, R3,
3
R4, U1, Z2, Z4 social constructs Y2 3
surrogate mothers W3
2 2
research R1, R3 social media S1, S2, S3 3
swearing T4
1 1
responsibility R3 social scientist Q4 1
syndromes C2, H4
3 1
rich B4 society L3, Q4 3
Tagalog K2
1 2 2
risks R1, R2, R3, R4, D2, D3 South Africans U4 3
taste T2
1 3
rules of thumb B3 South Korea O2 1
technology E4, F1, I2, I4, Q1, T1,
3 2
T3, T4
Russia P1, P2 space (outer) R4
3
3 2
teenagers Q3
scams B2 spare time H3
2
2 1
telepathy P4
school E1 sport S1, S2, S3
tefldiscussions.com 13
Discussions Samples Adrian Wallwork & others
2 3 2
telephones P1, P2, P3, P4 urban tales C3 which is worse Y4
1 1 1 3
Tesla A4 urban tales M2 Wikipedia M4, R3
1 2 1 1
time O4, Z2 USA O1, U1, U3, U4, H3 women M3, W1, W2, W3, W4,
2 3
1 2 N3, R2, U4, H4, I3, K3, L4,
tolerance L3 useless information J2, J3
M3, S3, W1, W2, W3, W4
1 2
tomatoes V1 vacations O3, T2, V1, V2 1
word generator O2
3 1
torture V2, X2 values R4 2
X box X3
1 1
tourism C2 vegans V3 1
X factor X2
1 3 1
toys L2, V4 vegetarianism V1, V2, V3, V4 2
X Files X1
2 2
translation G3 video game consoles X3 3
yes man X1
2 3
transport T3 violence V1, V2, V3, V4 2
YouTube Y1
2 2
travel T1, T2, T3 wack W2 3
zealots Z1
2 2
trolling B3 warning labels U2 1
zones Z1, Z2, Z3, Z4
3 3
truth C4, M2 wealth B4
1 2
TV X2 weekends V4
2 2
Twitter S3 Western identity P4
3 2
Uganda K3 whacky W1, W3, W4
1 1 3
UK Q4 what would you do? P2, E2,
U4
1 2
university U1, U3, U4, E4
2
WhatsApp A2
2 3
unpleasant people K2, B1, B3
tefldiscussions.com 14
Discussions Volume 1-3 Adrian Wallwork & others
DISCU
SSIONS
Volume
1
tefldiscussions.com 15
Adrian Wallwork & others Discussions Samples
YOU
Y1: Bucket list
A bucket list is a list of things that you would like to do within a certain time period (the original bucket list
was for things to do before you die). Choose five or more of the items below to put on your own bucket list.
For each item, give a specific example (e.g. animal to see - leopard, book to read - War and Peace).
tefldiscussions.com 16
Discussions Volume 1 Adrian Wallwork & others
• Like to gossip.
• Vote for a political candidate on the basis of unimportant characteristics (appearance, name, accent).
• Tell the truth even when they know they would be better off lying.
• Speak with conviction about a topic which they know very little about (but are not actually aware that they know
very little about it).
• Make little attempt to question their own principles and ethical stances.
tefldiscussions.com 17
Discussions Samples Adrian Wallwork & others
Y3: Preferences
Which do you think is better:
• being the worst in a group of highly proficient people?
• being the best in a group of less proficient people?
Pat Metheny, the jazz guitarist, was once asked in an interview: Did you have a guitar teacher when you were
starting out? His reply was:
Well, I'm from this little town in Missouri called Lee's Summit, and unfortunately, we didn't exactly have any
teachers out there. But when I was around 14, I started playing in Kansas City with the best players in town.
They weren't guitar players - they were piano players, trumpets and drums, but those guys were really my
teachers. I was fortunate to learn from playing with great older musicians. Whenever young guys ask me
what they should do to get better, I always say try to be the worst guy in whatever band you're in. That's the
secret.
Contrary to what Pat Metheny says, research has shown that being a big fish in a small pond enables many people to
perform much better than being a small fish in a big bond. Top students in classes with other top students tend to
get discouraged if they're not doing comparatively as well as they were used to doing and may drop out. Students in
classes with less capable students tend to gain confidence and consequently perform better.
• the world expert in one area or someone very knowledgeable (but not an expert) in many areas
tefldiscussions.com 18
Discussions Volume 1 Adrian Wallwork & others
tefldiscussions.com 19
Adrian Wallwork & others Discussions Samples
DISCUSSIONS Volume 2
tefldiscussions.com 20
Discussions Volume 2 Adrian Wallwork & others
APPLICATIONS
A1: Killer Apps
Look at the ten apps below. Which seven do you think were actually put on the market and sold?
• Anti Mosquito: Emits ultrasonic waves to repel mosquitoes.
• CrossClass: Allows you to merge head shots of classmates and friends with photos of blown-up heads of strange
(but real) insects and lizard-like creatures.
• Dreme: When sleeping with earphones, video-records your dreams.
• Ghost Radar: Detects paranormal activity by identifying words said by ghosts.
• iBeer: Simulates a beer can that empties itself as you tilt it.
• Pocket Fan: Triggers a rotating fan on the screen (obviously no air comes out!).
• QLESS: Scans for mobile numbers of those in front of you in the queue and then proceeds to call them with fake
emergencies that will force them to sacrifice their place in the queue.
• Toilet Sound Machine Extreme: Plays a toilet sound.
• Lookalike: This dating app has a feature that allows you to find a celebrity who looks like you.
• Drnk Pay: If you get drunk, the app blocks your bank card until you a sufficiently sober again.
tefldiscussions.com 21
Discussions Samples Adrian Wallwork & others
DESIGNER OF FACTORY FARMS: analysing the least amount of space for an animal to live in while being the most
productive possible.
CONTRACTOR FOR FOREST CLEARING: on behalf of the government, clearing huge expanses of forests where
indigenous people currently live. The aim is to provide more room for planting crops or grazing livestock (both
the crops and the meat from the livestock are then sold to the West).
FINANCIAL LAWYER: helping the mega-rich minimize the tax they pay. This deprives governments from money for
public projects for all citizens.
LOBBYIST FOR PRIVATE PRISON: lobbying the government to imprison more people for longer, even ones that pose
little threat to the public.
LOW-LEVEL HUMAN RESOURCES EMPLOYEE AT WEAPONS MANUFACTURER: reviewing CVs for a company that designs toys
that explode on impact and are designed to maim children.
PART OF MARKETING TEAM OF A BANK: stipulating contracts for large loans with people who it is clear will have
difficulty ever paying the loan back.
RESEARCHER FOR ONLINE GAMBLING COMPANY: analysing the compulsive behaviours that make certain types of people
addicted to gambling, thus enabling the company to carry out targeted marketing.
SOFTWARE DEVELOPER FOR MASSIVE TECH FIRM: developing tools that can be used to aid the surveillance, detention
and deportation of immigrants.
tefldiscussions.com 22
Discussions Volume 2 Adrian Wallwork & others
Now look again at numbers 7-10. How would you set up some scientific experiments to prove or disprove these
statements?
tefldiscussions.com 23
Discussions Samples Adrian Wallwork & others
• The English language frequently abbreviates long words into shorter ones. Do you know what the long forms are of
these words: brill, info, prob, typo, uni?
• Acronyms are a very common form of abbreviation. What do these acronyms stand for: aka, atb, asap, btw, imho,
fyi, lol, omg?
• Sometimes vowels are removed to create a short form of words e.g. msg = message. What do the following stand
for: pls, rgds, wknd, yr?
• Native English speakers like to contract words, e.g. wanna = want to. Are you familiar with these contractions:
gimme, gotta, hiya, kinda?
• Another method of abbreviation is merging two words, e.g. drailing = drunk emailing. Do you know what the
following words are merges of: brunch, motel, smog, vlog?
• Before the advent of predictive texting, a common form of abbreviations in text messages was to use the sounds
of letters + numbers, e.g. cul8er = see you later. Can you guess what the following mean: som1, 2nite, ru32nite, b4,
w8in4u?
What kinds of words do you abbreviate in your language (e.g. people's names)?
Can you play with your language in the same way as English can be played with?
tefldiscussions.com 24
Discussions Volume 2 Adrian Wallwork & others
DISCUSSIONS Volume 3
tefldiscussions.com 25
Discussions Samples Adrian Wallwork & others
SEX
S1: Sex and politics
Who do you think is more likely to cheat on their wife? Those with more or less:
i) sexually conservative values; ii) restricted sex education; iii) money; iv) left-wing leanings
Read the text, check your answers, and then answer the questions.
Ashley Madison is an online dating service aimed at married people to help them find an extra-
marital relationship. In July 2015 hackers stole all of the company's customer data (names, addresses,
sexual fantasies, credit card info, etc). The hackers threatened to release all the information if the
company did not shut its website down. In August 2015, the hackers began publishing the data. In
2018 researchers in the US analysed the customer data and found that Democrats (traditionally more
left-wing) used Ashley Madison's services less than Republicans (right-wing). In their article for the
journal Archives for Sexual Behaviour the researchers concluded that: “Our results are perhaps the
strongest evidence yet that people with more sexually conservative values, although they claim to act
accordingly, are more sexually deviant in practice than their more sexually liberal peers”.
There are various theories as to why Republicans are more likely to have affairs than Democrats:
• Right wing people tend to be less well-informed about sex and sexuality.
• In order to deflect suspicion, people who are more interested in taboo activities declare
themselves Republicans, and profess to have stricter attitudes, .
• Ashley Madison's services are expensive, and since Republicans tend to be wealthier than
Democrats, they are more likely to be able to afford such services.
1. Are you surprised by any of the results? In your country, is there a tendency for there to be more
sexual scandals amongst a particular political party?
2. Is there any link between a male politician cheating on his wife and being dishonest with voters? Is
there a clear relationship between one's private and public life?
3. Ashley Madison's tagline was originally "Life is Short. Have an Affair." To what extent do you agree
with this statement? Or do you think that agencies like Ashley Madison be banned?
4. How do you think those husbands who were found out managed to deal with the situation?
5. How concerned are you about your online life and data being made public?
tefldiscussions.com 26
Discussions You’ve Never Had Adrian Wallwork & others
• Shave.
• Start dating.
• Get married.
• Have a child.
tefldiscussions.com 27
Discussions Samples Adrian Wallwork & others
Several feminist groups are trying to free women from humiliating representations that consider
them only as sexual objects, as usually happens in mainstream pornography. The solution
suggested by this “third wave” of feminist activists is not to ban pornography, but to produce
“feminist pornography” directed by women that takes account of their sexuality and expresses it
appropriately.
In Italy there is a feminist union called Le Ragazze del Porno (the Porn Girls), an all-women group
made up of film directors, writers, artists and performers which has launched a crowd-funding
campaign to produce a series of feminist pornographic films. The aim of the project is for women
to become sexual subjects of representation, rather than merely objects.
• What movies have you seen recently that represent women as sex objects?
• What do you think about the Ragazze del Porno's project?
• Where do you draw the line between the erotic and the pornographic?
• Do you think pornography in any form should be banned?
• What are the dangers of watching porn for i) teenage boys, ii) teenage girls iii) adults?
• How easy is it to become addicted to pornography? With what consequences?
tefldiscussions.com 28
Discussions You’ve Never Had Adrian Wallwork & others
• homosexuals
• transvestites
• transsexuals
• intersexuals
•
Read the text below and answer the questions. How offensive do you find Pence's support of this 'therapy'?
Conversion therapy, which is advocated by Mike Pence (vice president under Trump) is a psychological
treatment or spiritual counselling aimed at changing a person's sexual orientation from homosexual or
bisexual to heterosexual. Until 1981 techniques used included 'ice-pick lobotomies', chemical castration
with hormonal treatment, electric shocks to the hands and/or genitals, nausea-inducing drugs
and masturbatory reconditioning. More recent clinical techniques have been limited to counselling,
visualization, social skills training, psychoanalytic therapy, and spiritual interventions such as prayer and
group support and pressure.
tefldiscussions.com 29
Discussions Samples Adrian Wallwork & others
tefldiscussions.com 30
Discussions You’ve Never Had Adrian Wallwork & others
Teacher’s Guide
8. What makes this book different?
This book provides a refreshing and effective alternative to the traditional discussion formula.
Source: http://iteslj.org/questions/news.html
If you propose one topic (e.g. news or honesty or politics) to your students, the effectiveness of the ensuing discussion
very much depends on the students being interested in that topic and having something to say about it. The above
questions on the news may generate a good discussion and the exercise will certainly practise news-related vocabulary.
But there is a chance that some students won’t have any particular opinions and/or are not interested in the topic.
If the discussion is multi-topic (news and honesty and politics and annoying habits and the supernatural and supermarket
shopping and x and y and z), and students are given the opportunity to choose their own topic, then you already have a
much greater chance of success. If additionally you let students go off-topic, then you get even more discussion.
The exercises do not explicitly draw directly from students' personal experiences, nor are students required to have any
specific knowledge of a topic.
tefldiscussions.com 31
Discussions Samples Adrian Wallwork & others
Instead the exercises are based on getting a spontaneous reaction to something that students have probably never even
thought about before, and then building upon this reaction.
This puts students on the same level with regard to their experience base and knowledge base, and so is more likely to give
all students a chance to express themselves.
Once I had got the formula I thought it would be useful to devise questions with someone much younger than me and also
female. So I enlisted the services of Lizzie Hoeppner, then 24, who provided a nicely different slant to some of the
questions.
Controversial topics tend to be avoided by the big publishers. They market their books all over the world and try to have a
one-size-fits-all approach. This means they can only stick to ‘safe’ topics in order to avoid any legal issues and so as not to
offend anyone of any religion or culture.
tefldiscussions.com 32
Discussions You’ve Never Had Adrian Wallwork & others
If you are interested in discussions that are more controversial, then try another book in this series: Discussions Volume 3.
11. I find that traditional discussion activities often do not work. Why is
this?
Many discussions in EFL classrooms fail. This may be for several reasons:
• the topics proposed are simply not interesting and thus generate no discussion
• the topics are too banal or have been overexploited in previous lessons / coursebooks
• they require students to already have opinions on the topic, which either students do not have or which they are not
willing to share or which they are not able to express easily in English
• they make students lose face in front of their companions because they force students to reveal that they know
nothing about a particular topic
• they require students to give away personal information that they may be reluctant to share with the rest of the class
Another key reason why discussions can fail is that they may be dominated by one or two students. To address this problem
see Section 17.
tefldiscussions.com 33
Discussions Samples Adrian Wallwork & others
Exercises
1. How much difference would it make if
1. Latin
2. make up
3. ornaments
4. pets
5. picture frames
6. social networks
7. thanking
8. wind
9. worrying
10. yawning
1. homework
2. insomnia
3. late dinner guests
4. partner’s infidelity
5. people who talk too much
6. shouting bosses / teachers
7. sibling rivalry
8. spam
9. stress
10. travel by low cost airlines
tefldiscussions.com 34
Discussions You’ve Never Had Adrian Wallwork & others
6. Which is 'better'
tefldiscussions.com 35
Discussions Samples Adrian Wallwork & others
1. uninteresting subject
2. unanswerable question
3. unusual idea
4. uncontrollable urge
5. unexpected event
6. boring person
7. hopeless situation
8. pointless conversation
9. wasted afternoon
10. ugly face
tefldiscussions.com 36
Discussions Samples Adrian Wallwork & others
DISCUSSIONS One-to-One
tefldiscussions.com 37
Discussions Samples Adrian Wallwork & others
Teacher’s Guide
1. What makes 1-1 lessons different?
There are some key differences between group classes and individual lessons:
• Students who opt for 1-1 lessons tend to be more motivated as they are probably willing to pay much more than
the cost of doing the lesson in a group. Their motivation is also likely to motivate you too. However, despite their
enthusiasm, they may not know exactly what they need from your lessons. This book is designed to cater for those
students who wish to improve their oral skills, and thereby improve their vocabulary and grammar. Before
embarking on the exercises, check that your students want to focus on oral skills.
• You will be able to give the student your full attention and concentrate on their specific needs. 1-1 lessons are very
useful for those students who have pronunciation problems, or who are very shy and would be reluctant to talk in
a group lesson.
• Given that there is just one teacher and one student, you both have to take responsibility for making the lesson a
success. In a conversation lesson, this entails you having a lot of questions up your sleeve that you can ask your
student. You'll soon find that you are constantly feeding them new questions, so you always need to be one
question ahead!
• Your relationship with the student will be much more intense than a typical classroom relationship. You may well
end up becoming friends or becoming their amateur therapist!
Note: Although this book was written specifically for 1-1 lessons, most of the exercises can also be done with small
groups of students who know each other reasonably well.
Exercise 1 is dedicated to a needs analysis and should also help you set some ground rules. If your student is relatively low
level, then you might like to ask these questions in their language (if you speak it).
These needs analysis questions are followed by a discussion on names (Ex 2), as a gentle introduction to get the student
talking about him/herself.
Exercises 3-20 are organized by general theme (school, work, hobbies etc) and tend to be questions that you and your
student will be familiar with.
tefldiscussions.com 38
Discussions One-to-One Adrian Wallwork & others
These exercises contain questions about students' attitudes to various topics along with a number of hypothetical
questions. Each set of topics begins with a question (e.g. When was the last time you ... Have you ever ... How would you
react if ... Do you tend to ...). Many of the questions are typical of those found in personality tests. The questions are
personal, but are not intrusive and are unlikely to cause any embarrassment .
These exercises are similar to the ones given in the companion book, Discussions You've Never Had. They cover areas that it
is unlikely that you or your student have discussed before in an English language lesson.
• Are you going to charge them if they cancel at the last minute?
• Where are you going to do the lessons? Your place or theirs? Will the price change accordingly? [Having the
lessons at your house saves on travel time, affects you much less if there are last minute cancelations, gives you a
feeling of safety particular if you are a female teacher with a male student]
To get the main part of the lesson going, I suggest that you start with your own tried-and-tested first lesson questions.
Alternatively you can begin the questions in Part 1 (Ex 2-20) - these regard the student's family and work situations, without
getting too personal.
In any case, let the student choose the topics and questions, rather than imposing them yourself. As lessons progress, the
key is only to use those topics/questions within an exercise that you feel your student will be comfortable with.
Clearly, it is useful for the student's listening skills if he / she listens to you talking. However, given that many students think
that they are getting value for money if they do all the talking, it is a good idea for you to explain to them at the beginning
of the 'course' that there are clear benefits for them of you talking: not just to improve their listening skills but to give them
a break from talking themselves (see Section 8).
tefldiscussions.com 39
Discussions Samples Adrian Wallwork & others
1) Dictate (or message / email) those items in the exercise that you think would be suitable.
2) Ask your student to read through the items and choose one or two that they would like to talk about.
3) Get the conversation started by asking the student a related question. For example, imagine the item to be discussed is
whether the student eats junk food.
Your student begins talking about junk food and your role is to:
5) Be prepared for the fact that even though the student may have chosen the topic, they may not actually have much to
say about it. This means you always need to be one step ahead, i.e. you need to have the next question (and the one after)
ready.
6) Get the student to ask you a few questions (see Section 8).
tefldiscussions.com 40
Discussions Samples Adrian Wallwork & others
Exercises
1. Movies and TV
2. Are you on Netflix / Amazon / Sky? When did you first pay a subscription?
11. Who are some of the famous actors and musicians in your country?
15. When did you last go to the movies? Where’s your nearest cinema?
tefldiscussions.com 41
Discussions Samples Adrian Wallwork & others
1. animal
2. car
3. colour
4. flower
5. newspaper or magazine
6. painting
7. place
8. season
9. time of day
10. topic of conversation
tefldiscussions.com 42
Discussions One-to-One Adrian Wallwork & others
1. do press ups
2. be completely naked in a public place
3. listen to a baby crying
4. tread water
5. wash your hands
6. skip
7. peel onions
8. run on treadmill
9. drill a hole
10. talk in English
1. a cleaner
2. a first date
3. a laugh
4. access to a beach / sea
5. books
6. education
7. priority queue at an airport gate
8. second-hand clothes
9. taxis
10. the right to roam (countryside)
tefldiscussions.com 43
Discussions Samples Adrian Wallwork & others
tefldiscussions.com 44