Die Casting Design Specification Guide 2017
Die Casting Design Specification Guide 2017
Disclaimer
Every effort has been made to assure the accuracy of
the data presented in this Design and Specification
Guide, but Chicago White Metal Casting cannot be
responsible for results obtained with this data. CWM
disclaims any liability arising out of the use of this
material. No warranties, express or implied, are given
in connection with this publication.
Design & Specification Guide Introduction
The guidelines presented in this publication are intended
to aid OEM product design engineers in designing and
specifying parts for cost-effective die casting production—in
aluminum, magnesium, zinc and ZA-8 alloys.
1
Anatomy of a CWM Die Set and Die Cast Part
Automatic moveable slides Precision shut-offs, Oil heating & cooling Special surface treatment Premium tool steel,
can produce all holes and vacuum systems, as lines are used in is used on all CWM die used to build all
features as-cast. The well as advanced both halves of the cavities to help prevent CWM die cavities,
ejector half of this die runner and overflow die set for precise premature die wear, improve assures maximum die
casting die set is at left. design, help minimize temperature control casting surface finish, life and performance.
any porosity in the during very rapid minimize distortion, etc.
final cast part. casting cycles. The
cover, or stationary,
half is at the right.
2
1 Matching Material Properties
Die casting alloys are generally several times as strong as and many times more rigid than plastics, and their mechanical properties
compare favorably with powdered iron, brass, and screw-machined steel.
Designing for proper strength in a product depends on two main factors: strength of the material selected and configuration of the part.
Die casting alloys offer a wide range of as-cast material strengths, ranging as high as 54 psi (372 MPa) ultimate tensile. The designer
can usually develop sufficient strength in critical features simply by providing adequate wall thickness. Where additional strength is
required, reinforcing features (such as ribs, flanges and locally thickened sections) can be accurately computed and precisely cast. (See
Guidelines G-6-2-2015 and G-6-3-2015 in NADCA Standards.)
The die casting process allows the product designer freedom to create extremely intricate geometries. CWM offers the designer
material choices in all of the major non-ferrous alloy categories: aluminum, magnesium and zinc.
AZ91D is the most widely used magnesium die casting alloy, offering high purity with excellent corrosion resistance, strength, and castability.
Part Size Range .75” x .75” .75” x .75” .75” x .75” Minuscule
to 18” x 18” to 18” x 18” to 18” x 18” to 4” x 4” x 1”
Part Weight Range .5 oz. .25 oz. .5 oz. 1/14 oz. (2g)
to 10 lbs. to 10 lbs. to 8 lbs. to 3/4 lb. (337g)
Machine Tonnage Range 200-800 tons 80-650 tons 80-500 tons 4-Slide Miniature
Table values are approximations. Part sizes shown, in some cases, will require center gating of a part, not always practical with particular part designs.
For a discussion of the hot and cold chamber die casting processes, consult the Product Design for Die Casting Manual,
published by NADCA and available from CWM Die Cast Design Center (DC²) at no cost.
See Table 3a for approximate production part size and weight ranges, and machine tonnages, offered by CWM for each alloy category.
3
MATERIAL PROPERTIES & NOMINAL CHEMISTRY
Table 1 Typical Material Properties: Die Casting Alloys & Selected Plastics
Typical alloy values based on “as-cast” characteristics for separately die cast specimens, not specimens cut from production die
castings. (2015 NADCA Standards. Sec. 3)
MECHANICAL PROPERTIES
Ultimate Tensile
psi x 103 47 34 41 54 8 22
(MPa) (324) (234) (283) (374) (55) (151)
Yield Strength
psi x 103 24 23 32 42 6.5 19
(MPa) (165) (159) (221) (290) (48) (131)
Elongation
% in 2 in. 3 3 10 8 -- 7
Young’s Modulus
psi x 10 10.3 6.5 ≥12.4 12.4 1.0 1.5
6
Torsional Modulus
psi x 106 3.9 2.4 ≥4.8 4.8 -- --
(MPa x 103) (26.9) (16.5) (≥33.1) (33.1)
Shear Strength
psi x 103 27 20 31 40 -- --
(MPa) (186) (138) (214) (275)
Hardness
(Brinell) 80 63 82 103 -- --
Impact Strength
ft-lb 3 2.7 43 31 -- --
(J) (4) (3.7) (58) (42)
PHYSICAL PROPERTIES
Density
lb/in3 0.098 0.066 0.240 0.227 0.0376 0.048
(g/cm ) (2.7) (1.8) (6.6) (6.3) (1.0) (1.4)
3
Melting Range
°F 1000-1100 875-1105 718-728 707-759 221 431
(°C) (538-593) (468-596) (381-387) (375-404) (105) (221)
Electrical Conductivity
% IACS 27.0 11.5 27.0 27.7 -- --
Thermal Conductivity
BTU/ft hr °F 55.6 41.8 65.3 66.3 -- --
(W/m°K) (96.2) (72.3) (113.0) (114.7)
Pattern Shrinkage
in/in or mm/mm 0.006 N/A 0.006 0.007 -- --
4
2 Die Construction
The two die halves shown on page 2 are an example of a single cavity die with both fixed cores and moving core slides, which
produce additional as-cast features in the part. The use of core slides can totally eliminate or significantly reduce secondary machining
requirements.
Multiple-cavity dies can be used to increase production rates substantially, and lower piece costs.
CWM unit dies employ standardized unit die holders into which replaceable die cavity “units” can be inserted. These replaceable units
can be removed from or placed into a unit die holder without removing the unit frame from the die casting machine. CWM unit dies
can significantly reduce die construction costs. They are available in single and double unit holders.
Unit dies have some limitations. They generally can only accommodate the production of smaller-sized parts, and they restrict the use
of moving core slides, water cooling, and gating. Therefore, unit dies are most appropriate for less complex product designs and for
products with lower annual volumes.
Core slides, also called moving die components, can be activated in various ways. Two of the most common are angle pins and hydraulic
cylinders.
The angle pin is a mechanical source of motion that is activated by the opening and closing of the die. Its advantages are that it does
not require hydraulics or limit switches, and is generally more economical to manufacture. Its limitations are that it can be used only
for short slide travel, and there is no control over the cycle of the slide pull.
The hydraulic method of slide motion permits a choice of cycles, allows the placement of slides on any side of the die, and avoids
interference when removing the casting from the die.
The choice is dependent upon factors such as production volume, the size of die, the length of travel of the slide, the size of area being
cored out, and the specific configuration of the part.
CWM will always make the most cost-effective recommendation for the particular core slide to achieve the desired result.
If there is no cosmetic surface requirement, the casting can be oriented in the two die halves to suit the most favorable overall casting
conditions.
In the case of a part that must have a cosmetic surface finish, the cover die half will generally be used to produce a specified cosmetic
surface. This permits the ejector die half to contain the required ejector pins—which assist in ejecting the part cleanly from the die after
each casting shot— as well as any engraved lettering or identification to be cast into the part.
With parts requiring a cosmetic surface, it is critical that this be discussed in detail during the earliest review meeting. Location
of the casting’s parting line, as well as the gate, overflows, and vents, must not affect any of the part’s designated cosmetic surfaces.
5
Assuring Longer Die Life
The number of parts that can be produced from a die casting die is dependent on factors such as the quality of the die steel, the alloy
specified, the specific design of part features, the cosmetic surface requirements for the part, and the number of die setups over the
life of the tool.
While CWM utilizes the highest quality premium tool steel in all of its die casting die construction, as well as a proven die surface
treatment to optimize die life, design features that can drastically shorten die life must be taken into consideration.
Sharp internal or external corners should be avoided. Specifying highly cosmetic as-cast surfaces can result in shorter die life and
greater tool maintenance costs.
Minimizing porosity begins with early planning in the design of the die cast part and
communication with CWM engineering. If porosity in specific areas will be detrimental
to product function, this should be clearly outlined before die design and construction
begins, since zero porosity is virtually impossible to achieve in a die casting.
Acceptable modifications in part designs can often be suggested that will greatly
reduce potential porosity problems. Once this important step has been taken, CWM
can utilize mold flow simulation, optimized gating and overflow design, die design,
special management of the heating and cooling lines in the die, vacuum systems, and
sophisticated process control and monitoring to limit porosity to non-critical areas of the
part.
When 100% pressure tightness is essential in a die cast part, early CWM consultation
becomes even more important. If the specific configuration of a component dictates
that it cannot be cast pressure-tight, impregnation may be required. (Refer to Pressure
Tightness, Sec. 6, NADCA Standards).
The die casting process offers the product engineer the added advantage of great
flexibility in housing and heat transfer design. An optimized heat sink can be incorporated
into virtually any die cast housing design.
Unlike a plastic molded housing and extruded heat sink combination, EMI/RFI shielding is
a built-in function of a thermally optimized die cast housing.
6
All forms of extended surfaces for heat transfer can be die cast: straight fins, “S” shapes and round pins etc. in all diameters, are easily
optimized for width, length and thickness in a die cast design and readily cast in place with the rest of a housing design.
As with any special part feature, consultation with CWM engineering is urged well before final product designs are agreed upon.
7
Standard & Precision Dimensional Tolerances (Table 3b)
QUICK GUIDE TO COORDINATE DIMENSIONING
Die Casting Alloy: Aluminum Magnesium Zinc/ZA-8
WALL THICKNESSES
Nominal wall thicknesses that can be die cast are heavily dependent on part geometry. With small castings, wall thicknesses of 0.030 in. (.762 mm)
may be attained with an optimized part design and alloy selection.
For projected area of die casting over 300 in² (1935.5 cm²), consult CWM.
For projected area of a moving die casting component over 100 in² (645.2 cm²), consult CWM.
Add’l tolerance, in. (25.4 mm) for ea. add’l in. (25.4 mm)
8
6 Tolerancing Guidelines
The extent to which the dimensioning guidelines shown here can be achieved in production
for a given die cast part design is highly dependent on part size and configuration, shrink
factors, and the precise feature in which the dimension is planned.
Caution: Both standard and precision tolerances are shown. The design engineer should
understand that requiring precision dimensions for every feature of a part is not possible in
production. Precision tolerances should only be specified in agreed upon critical areas, since
assuring these tolerances nearly always involves extra precision in die construction and/or special
controls in processing, with additional costs often involved. Consultation with CWM engineering
in the final part design stage is important to cost-effective production and part quality assurance.
Note, in some cases and on specific features, even closer dimensions than those shown can
be held by repeated sampling and re-cutting of the die casting die cavity, in combination with
capability studies. Such procedures will incur added costs and timing.
For example, Section 5 of the NADCA manual provides guidelines on “parting line die shift,”
which can result in dimensional variations based on a mismatch between two die halves.
In the case of Flatness Tolerances, the NADCA manual provides design guidelines to aid in
specifying part flatness requirements.
Precision tolerances for cored holes, such as cast holes planned for tapping, are provided in NADCA
Standards, in terms of diameter, thread depth, and hole depth requirements.
An introductory discussion, as applied to die cast part drawings, appears in NADCA Standards, together with more detailed GD&T
references.
Removed
Within 0.060” Within 0.030” Within 0.015”
After Commercial Trimming* within 0.010” Not Removed
(1.59 mm) (0.76 mm) (0.38 mm)
(0.25 mm)
Extension Remaining
* “Commercially trimmed” does not include hand filing, sanding or polishing to remove sharp edges or loose material. Very small parts can often be
trimmed closer than these standards would indicate. Shave trimming may be possible in cored holes and on certain features (G-6-5-15).
9
7 Metal Extension (Flash) Guidelines
An extension of metal (or flash) is normally formed on a die casting at
the parting line of the two die halves and where moving die components
operate. A seam of extended metal may also occur where separate die parts
cast a part feature.
Table 4 is the NADCA guide to the types of flash which occur in typical
die castings and the amount of flash material that remains after trimming.
These NADCA guidelines represent normal production practice. Precision
trimming, closer than standard commercial trimming, or complete removal
of all flash may entail additional operations and should be specified only
when requirements justify the additional cost. Generally, it is assumed that
unless specified, parting line flash or gate vestige remaining on the part is
treated separately and is in addition to the print tolerance of a feature.
Note that in some instances, depending upon the part geometry and the
surface finish requirements, the most economic methods of de-gating and
metal extension removal may include a tumbling or vibratory deburring
operation, or hand cleaning.
The NADCA surface finishing guidelines presented in Table 5 classify as-cast surface finishes for die castings into a series of five grades
so that the type of cast finish required may be defined early in the product planning stage and well in advance of die casting die design.
These guidelines should be used for general type classification purposes only, not to take the place of specific discussion with CWM
regarding the steps necessary to assure satisfying as-cast product finishing specifications. Such specifications should be agreed upon
with CWM prior to die design to assure cost-effective production. Note that important steps can be taken in the planning of part
design features enabling an optimum surface to be produced in specified areas. For exacting cosmetic finishes, extra steps in die
design, die construction and casting production are required, and additional cost may be involved. Selection of the lowest finishing
grade, commensurate, of course, with the die cast part application, will yield the lowest die and part costs.
A detailed discussion of the factors that relate to success in designing dies for highly cosmetic, thin wall die cast parts, specifically as
they relate to magnesium die castings, appears in an article by Chicago White Metal Casting, titled Designing Dies for Thin Wall, Highly
Cosmetic Mg Die Castings. It is available on request from CWM.
The first four as-cast surface finish classifications listed in Table 5 relate to cosmetic surfaces. Class Five, “Superior Grade,” relates to
the surface specification required over a very selective area for special applications.
10
9 Further Design Assistance
As emphasized throughout this guide, product
design details—based on sound die casting part
design principles—can greatly influence the
costs of both tooling and production parts.
CWM sales engineers and the CWM engineering staff are available to ensure your early design decisions are the correct ones for
product success.
The Magmasoft high-pressure die casting process simulation software system is acknowledged
as the most advanced approach to computerized metal flow trouble-shooting at the preplanning
stage. CWM utilizes this software on all new tool builds.
The initial die casting die cavity design can now be based on the die designer’s experience plus
the results of this invaluable early metal flow data. For more information on the Magmasoft
system, download Tech Brief 23 in the OEM Solutions/Tech Brief section of the CWM Design
Center.
11
11 Prototyping
Because high quality production die casting dies represent a significant capital investment, prototyping of a part prior to production
tool build is a prudent course for a new product design.
Beyond 3D modeling on the computer, a variety of prototyping alternatives are being used, including machining from stock (hog-outs),
gravity casting, or prototype die casting.
All prototyping strategies based on alternative process for eventual die casting production are approximations to the final performance
of a die cast part, and the strengths and limitations of each must be weighed against the designer’s most important prototyping criteria.
3D Printing
The technology of 3D printing enables the production of rapid prototypes in durable
ABS plastic, directly from STL design files. Fused Deposition Modeling (FDM) parts are
built and bonded, extruded layer by layer, from 3D computer data.
Because of the strength of the ABS plastic part, it can be evaluated rigorously for form
and fit and used in many functional tests.
Most 3D printed processes have difficulty reproducing very tight toleranced features,
such as sections containing ribs, bosses and holes; CNC machining can be performed
on the strong FDM ABS part to the required critical specifications.
FDM prototypes are generated on every new die casting project to expedite production and shorten total lead times by providing
models in advance to all departments involved; these multiple FDM models help assure that die designs result in first-piece success and
aid in the simultaneous construction of die cast tooling, trim dies, machining fixtures, finishing masks, and any required subassembly
gauges or fixtures. See Collaborative Engineering discussion in Section 13.
CWM’s in-house FDM prototyping capability can work quickly with customer CAD files to expedite die casting projects.
Efforts are underway to develop the ability to 3D print metal parts, and CWM is working on several projects where this approach is
employed, either to produce a prototype part, or to produce tooling or tooling components. Stay tuned… as this is a rapidly developing
technology.
Machined Prototypes
Product designers have long specified accurately machined
prototypes as test models for eventual die casting. Developments
in 3D CAD, CAM and CNC programming have made the machining
alternative increasingly desirable.
For Al 380 die castings, Al 6061-T6 aluminum plate is generally used for CNC prototypes. For Mg AZ91D die castings, AZ31 Mg plate
is recommended. Zamak 3 stock is available to prototype Zamak No. 3 zinc die castings.
Secondary coatings and finishes can be applied to machined hog-outs to closely approximate the appearance of the proposed die
casting. CWM is one of the few North American custom die casters with in-house hog-out capabilities.
12
Gravity Cast Prototypes
Sand casting, investment casting, and rubber plaster-mold castings are some of the gravity cast processes that can be used to
prototype a die casting design. Because of the longer solidification times, alloys specific to those processes, combined with various
heat treatments, are used in order to approximate the properties of a high pressure die casting. Also, compared to high pressure die
casting, these processes usually require thicker walls and larger tolerances, so machine stock often has to be added and more features
will need to be machined than with a die casting. These processes use lower cost tooling than high pressure die casting, but have
much higher piece prices. All of these design, property, and cost tradeoffs have to be considered when evaluating the best prototype
approach.
Prototype die casting dies can be produced in shorter lead times and at less cost
because they can utilize standardized components (such as an existing die base), and
pre-hardened, uncoated tool steels. The tool will not last as long and the die will not
run as efficiently as a typical production die, but this is a non-issue when you only
need a small quantity of parts (1,000 or less). Design changes can be made faster
and at less cost with a prototype die than would be the case on a custom, hardened/
coated production die. Parts made from the prototype die are generally hand cleaned
of flash, avoiding the lead time and cost of a trim die.
12 Post-Casting Operations
At the same time, post-casting machining of die castings is a more complex production
process than machining directly from billet stock. A higher level of experience in
CNC pre-planning and machining center fixture design is critical to economical CNC
machining of die cast parts.
While state-of-the-art machining centers and equipment usually provide the greatest
cost advantages, more conventional machining units and cells may prove cost-
effective. As outlined in section 5 of this guide, die caster engineer consultation
and careful preplanning in the product design stage is critical to quality post-casting
machining results. It is essential that all of the specific machining requirements to be
executed after the part has been die cast must be made clear before a design goes
forward: prior to any CAD metal flow simulations, prototyping, or the development of
die design drawings.
These surface treatment systems can be used to (1) provide a decorative finish, (2) form a protective
barrier against environmental or galvanic corrosion, (3) achieve pressure tightness if interconnected
subsurface porosity cannot be eliminated, or (4) improve a product’s resistance to wear. Non-toxic
coatings are available to meet U.S. & European Union environmental mandates.
13
Even when a die casting requires no further surface
treatment for decoration, protection or improved
performance, a deburring operation is usually
recommended. This step removes the metal flash and
any burrs, sharp or ragged edges that might remain after
trimming, to facilitate handling and any further finishing
treatment.
CWM has procedures in place to meet objectives beyond these basic expectations and assure more rapid time to market. By adhering
to the collaborative engineering model described herein, CWM maximizes the customer’s opportunity to reduce unit costs, improve
part quality, and accelerate lead time.
Customer-CWM Interaction
Successful collaborative engineering hinges on the timely and
accurate exchange of information on the part of all persons
responsible for the conception, design, development, evaluation,
production, quality, sales, delivery, servicing, and eventual disposal
of the final product. This requires close coordination of functions
between the customer and CWM.
Responses during these meetings help assure that CWM will be in a position to raise all critical design-for-manufacturing issues at
the earliest point in the component development cycle. This approach will prevent costly changes that may occur, and quality and
performance improvements can be introduced at little or no cost. These focused customer responses should cover all aspects of
component requirements and quality planning which can be expected to influence the final engineered die cast product.
14
Magmasoft® Software Simulation & Part Design
Once the appropriate drawings, specifications, and part model files are exchanged,
CWM can proceed with initial Design for Manufacturing (DFM) evaluation of the
component design followed by Magmasoft® process simulation.
CWM’s use of advanced Magmasoft® metal flow simulations and thermal analysis,
prior to die design, can flag possible casting problems and call for minor product
feature modifications. These simulations will aid in optimizing die gating, runner and
venting configurations in the final die design to assure proper metal flow and die fill.
For more on this simulation software in use, see section 10.
Sampling
Once the die build is complete, the tool is set into the appropriate machine and
sampled. Raw castings are sent to CWM’s Quality Assurance (QA) lab for an initial First
Article Inspection (FAI) report and for cosmetic evaluation. Typically, samples are also
submitted for initial customer approval, but Chicago White Metal will accommodate
individual customer requirements. If there are any issues, a CWM Engineering Project
Manager will coordinate production, tool room, and process teams to find a solution. Once all tooling and process adjustments are made,
sample runs on the specified production die casting machine, together with capability studies, will confirm the process parameters to
be used in full production. The samples will serve as the basis for finalizing control plans and inspection documents.
When customer approval of the FAI report is received, all succeeding production elements will be established and uninterrupted,
continuous piece-part production – through any required CNC machining, finishing and assembly – can begin.
Customer Responsibilities
A tightened production timeline places additional responsibility on the customer
to confirm that all product and design requirements have been signed off on by all
relevant company departments before die design begins. This also ensures that a
timely communications channel is in place between CWM and the key company team
leaders.
15
14 Design File Transfer Options
The engineering department works with a range of media, software
and hardware for convenient, rapid OEM design file transfer. CWM
can accept customer digital design files for die casting production
evaluation and for die design development in virtually every popular
format. Design files can be transferred by email attachment (sales@
cwmtl.com) or CWM can access the Customer’s Internet server for
secure FTP retrieval or arrange a download via a secure web link.
15 Contract Manufacturing
With most end products, a die cast
part is a component of a larger
assembly, precision-mated to other
custom and stock manufactured parts.
CWM subassembly projects make use of customized manufacturing cells, specially designed CWM fixtures and experienced materials
management. Well-supervised personnel operate in a clean, 16,000 sq. ft. air conditioned space.
16
Chicago White
Metal Casting, Inc.
Aluminum, Magnesium and Zinc Die Castings
www.cwmdiecast.com
EXCELLENCE IS EXPECTED.
649 IL Route 83, Bensenville, Illinois 60106-1340 U.S.A.
Phone: +1 (630) 595-4424 Fax: +1 (630) 595-9160
Email: [email protected]