Level of Misconception Regarding Common Scientific Principles of The Senior High School Students of Sta. Catalina National High School
Level of Misconception Regarding Common Scientific Principles of The Senior High School Students of Sta. Catalina National High School
By:
Amparado, Jorem
Cameon, Glydeliza
Flores, Roldan
Pagaran, Liezel
Patrocinio, Lyndon
Tabujara, Edward
October 2018
CHAPTER I
RATIONALE
in science. When Student go to school they already carry some sets of beliefs on how
things works, and have assumptions based on their past experiences which enable
them to predict some future events. Science teacher who were affected by this
conceptual development of students have used different terms to describe the situation
in which students’ ideas differ from those of scientists about a concept, like student’s
(Blosser, 1987).
because they already acquired some knowledge in their early years of schooling or in
their elementary years up to the present year of their education, they come with their
happening around them, however, the concept that they have constructed are not
complete or what we call ashalf truths. These are what we call as misconceptions. It’s
not just kids that have this different misconception. (Gardner, 1991) says many highly
educated adults rely on the “models, beliefs, and theories” they developed as
preschoolers. Thesewrong ideas may come from strong word association, confusion,
developing learners because they restrict the learning of the students when the students
use them to interpret new ideas and students may get emotionally and intellectually
attached to their misconceptions, because they have constructed them with their own
knowledge. So when students give up their misconception it might cause harmful effect
on the learning of the student, if he/she has a strong unwillingness to give it up.
. The researchers conducted this study because we are concerned with the
acquired knowledge of the senior high students which are now one or two steps away
from the tertiary level of education, we need to make more knowledgeable individuals
with the right ideas because many highly educated adults rely on their belief and
theories that they have learned in their preschool years of education (Gardner,1991),
misconception as (Cho, Hee-Hyung, 1985) found that high school biology text books as
misconceptions and related learning problems associated with genetics. That’s why we
need to know the present acquired knowledge of the learners so that we can determine
the correctness of their knowledge, because cases like textbook containing wrong
concept might have been tough to the learners because we are using textbook as one
This study determines the level of misconception regarding common scientific principles
of the senior high students in the two national high schools that was selected for the
study.
1. What is the level of misconception in the different areas regarding science of the
1.1 Astronomy
1.5 Space
High School?
Learners
The result of this study will determine the student’s knowledge and perception on
This study will help the government in determining which school have done an
Teachers
This study will assist the teachers on where shouldthey put more attention in
teaching different areas on science so that they could correct the misconception of the
students.
Future Researchers
This would serve as a basis for future researchers for more evaluation regarding
This study used the survey method for determining the level of common
of fluid, Magnets and Magnetism and Space. The respondents of this study are the
The study was conducted in Sta. Catalina National High School which has a
higher standard of teaching and learning compare to the neighbouring high schools in
DEFINITION OF TERMS
nature of true scientific texts
explanation is in question.
Senior High School Students refers to Grades 11 and 12, the last two years
THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK
This study is anchored on The One Fallacy theory, misconception is due to some
Misconception
CONCEPTUAL FRAMEWORK
This study was conducted to determine the level of misconception of the learners
in Sta. Catalina Nation High School. We have the input which is the incorrect knowledge
Input
Survey
Output
Misconception
The term „tabula rasa‟, which shows that children are blank slates and teachers
need to fill them in with knowledge, ideas and information’s, is not generally accepted
anymore (Pine, Messer, John, 2001). It’s because children’s ideas are formed from
previous experiences and such experiences exist from the day of birth of the child. Such
experiences become one of the children’s learning and come from various
environments in and around their homes (Bradley, 1996). Children’s scientific views are
a result of personal experiences, which can include typical everyday activities and
Piaget and Inhelder analyzed children’s thinking about probability into the usual
stages (pre-operational, concrete, operational, etc.). The child is not able to distinguish
clearly between chance and necessary phenomena. That distinction appears during the
The concept of probability, develops only during the formal operational stage and it
represents a synthesis between necessary and the possible (Piaget and Inhelder,
1951).
Fischbein (1991) have suggested that the concept of “possible” may develop
before the concept of “certainty”. According to results of his study, some children
develop mathematically mature language for certain and impossible events before they
secondary school without achieving the level of formal operations. According to him, the
reasoning ability was the main significant factor associated with students’ level of
understanding, explaining 44 percent of variance. This means that the student ability to
reason out to form conclusion without any formal knowledge about an idea can lead
misconception.
Cho, Hee-Hyung et al. (1985) found high school biology text books as sources of
misconceptions and related learning problems associated with genetics. Book are also
one of the reasons why misconception exist because it’s the traditional and commonly
Despite teacher’s best efforts, students do not grasp fundamental ideas covered
in class. Some of the best students give the right answers but are only using memorized
words. When questioned more closely, these students show their failure to understand
completely the underlying concepts. Students are often able to use algorithms to solve
(Mazur, 1996) reports that students in his physics class had memorized equations and
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
Research Design
This study used the survey method, for we will be gathering data about the
Questionnaires were distributed to all the senior high students in Sta. Catalina National
High School.
Research Environment
Sta. Catalina National High School was selected in conducting this study it is
Research Instrument
Senior high students of Sta. Catalina National High School were surveyed in this
study. This study used questionnaires in a form of a checklist as the primary instrument
negative statement or the misconceptions to test the knowledge of the respondent, the
respondents will choose either they Strongly Disagree, Disagree, Agree or Strongly
to the statement, this shows that the respondent is aware of that idea, and if the
respondent Strongly Agreed to the statement this tells us that he/she has viewed the
idea differently. The scales of misconception are Very Low, Low, High, Very High, so if
respondent Strongly Disagreed to the statement it means that they have a very low
misconception rate in that area and if they Strongly Agreed to the statement it means
that they have a very high misconception in that area. The purpose of the survey and all
CHAPTER II
This chapter presents the interpretation and analysis of the gathered data to
answer the main and specific problem of the study. The findings were shown in tabular
form followed by discussion and analysis. The presentation of findings follows the
Grade 11 Wx Verbal
Description
Astronomy
Common Misconception Right Concept
The sun rises exactly in the east and sets The sun does not rises
exactly in the west every day. exactly in the east and sets
2.16 Agree exactly in the west.
The moon can only be seen during the The moon can also be seen
night. 2.63 Disagree during the morning.
Meteors are falling stars. Meteors are debris in outer
2.41 Agree space
All the stars are the same distance from Some stars are the same
the earth. Strongly distance from the earth and
3.41 Disagree some are not.
Force of Motion
If an object is at rest, no forces are acting If an object is at rest, there is
on the object. a forces are acting on the
object which is the normal
2.39 Agree force.
Large objects exert a greater force than The amount of force does not
small objects. depend on the size of the
object it depends on the force
2.26 Agree which is applied to the object
Force is a property of an object. An object An object will stop moving
has force and when it runs out of force it because of the force of
stops moving. 2.35 Disagree friction.
Frictional forces are due to irregularities in 2.55 Disagree Friction is the force resisting
surfaces moving past each other. the relative motion of solid
surfaces, fluid layers, and
Negros Oriental State University Bayawan-Sta. Catalina Campus
College of Education
15
Space
The sun disappears at night. The sun does not disappear
it’s just at the other side of
the earth because the earth
is rotating and revolving
2.41 Agree around it. .
Gravity increases with height. Gravity decreases as you go
2.59 Disagree higher
The sun will never burn out. The sun will eventually burn
out when it burns all the
hydrogen that it has in its
2.40 Agree core.
Negros Oriental State University Bayawan-Sta. Catalina Campus
College of Education
16
Based on table 1.0a, grade 11 students of Sta. Catalina have low rate of misconception.
Most of their responds are Disagree on the misconception statements. However the
group Agreed to the statement, The sun rises exactly in the east and sets exactly in the
west every day which is a misconception because it does not exactly rises in the east
and it also does not exactly sets in the west because the earth is rotating and revolving,
and the group also Agreed to the statement,The sun disappears at night which is clearly
a misconception because the sun does not disappears, it just disappears from your
sight at night because it’s at the other side of the earth, because the earth is rotating
and revolving around the sun. The group Strongly Disagreed to the statements, All the
stars are the same distance from the earth, which is good because the statement is a
misconception, because stars distance from earth are not all equal. And the group also
Strongly Disagreed to the statement, The sun is not a star, which is also good because
it shows that they are aware that the sun is a star.
Grade 12 Wx Verbal
Description
Astronomy
Common Misconception Right Concept
The sun rises exactly in the east and sets The sun does not rises exactly in
exactly in the west every day. the east and sets exactly in the
2.29 Agree west.
The moon can only be seen during the The moon can also be seen
night. 2.76 Disagree during the morning.
Meteors are falling stars. 2.52 Disagree Meteors are debris in outer space
All the stars are the same distance from Some stars are the same
the earth. distance from the earth and some
3.04 Disagree are not.
Force of Motion
If an object is at rest, no forces are acting If an object is at rest, there is a
on the object. forces are acting on the object
2.30 Agree which is the normal force.
Large objects exert a greater force than The amount of force does not
small objects. depend on the size of the object it
depends on the force which is
2.39 Agree applied to the object
Force is a property of an object. An object An object will stop moving
has force and when it runs out of force it because of the force of friction.
stops moving. 2.38 Agree
Frictional forces are due to irregularities in Friction is the force resisting the
surfaces moving past each other. relative motion of solid surfaces,
fluid layers, and material
elements sliding against each
2.54 Disagree other.
Forces of Fluid
Objects float in water because they are Things float when they are
lighter than water. positively buoyant, or less dense
than the fluid in which they are
sitting. This does not mean that
an object has to be lighter than
the fluid, as in the case of a
boat; objects just need to have a
greater ratio of empty space to
2.41 Agree mass than the fluid.
Weight is the same with Mass and they Weight is the force of gravity
are always equal. acting on an object, while Mass is
the amount of matter contained in
2.51 Agree an object.
All objects containing air float. Object should be less dense than
2.64 Disagree water in order for it to float
Negros Oriental State University Bayawan-Sta. Catalina Campus
College of Education
18
Based on the table 1.0b, grade 12 students have high rate of misconception especially
in the field of Magnets and Magnetism, the group Agreed to the four statements which is
a misconception which shows that they have misconception in that field of science. Also
in the field of Forces of Motion which they also Agreed to three of the statement which is
a misconception which they should have not Agreed because it’s a misconception.
However, the group did show much better result in the field of Astronomy and Space,
they Disagreed to three statements in both field of science which show that they have a
better learning in the field of Astronomy and Space.
Grade 11 Wx Verbal
Description
Astronomy
Common Misconception Right concept
The sun rises exactly in the east and sets The sun does not rises
exactly in the west every day. exactly in the east and sets
2.16 Agree exactly in the west.
The moon can only be seen during the The moon can also be
night. 2.63 Disagree seen during the morning.
Meteors are falling stars. Meteors are debris in outer
2.41 Agree space
All the stars are the same distance from Some stars are the same
the earth. Strongly distance from the earth and
3.41 Disagree some are not.
Grade 12 Wx Verbal
Description
Astronomy
The sun rises exactly in the east and sets 2.29 Agree The sun does not rises
exactly in the west every day. exactly in the east and sets
exactly in the west.
The moon can only be seen during the 2.76 Disagree The moon can also be seen
night. during the morning.
Meteors are falling stars. 2.52 Disagree Meteors are debris in outer
space
All the stars are the same distance from 3.04 Disagree Some stars are the same
the earth. distance from the earth and
some are not.
Based on the table 2.0a, grade 11 and 12 students have different views on the
statement, Meteors are falling Stars; the grade 11 students Agreed to the statement
while the grade 12 students Disagreed to it, also in the same field the statement, All the
stars are the same distance from the earth; the grade 11 students Strongly Disagreed to
the statement while the grade 12 students Disagreed to it.
Grade 11
Space
The sun disappears at night. The sun does not disappear
it’s just at the other side of
the earth because the earth
is rotating and revolving
2.41 Agree around it. .
Gravity increases with height. Gravity decreases as you go
2.59 Disagree higher
The sun will never burn out. The sun will eventually burn
out when it burns all the
hydrogen that it has in its
2.40 Agree core.
The sun is not a star. Strongly The sun is a star which the
3.48 Disagree earth orbits.
Grade 12
Space
The sun disappears at night. The sun does not disappear
it’s just at the other side of
the earth because the earth is
rotating and revolving around
2.18 Agree it.
Gravity increases with height. Gravity decreases as you go
2.62 Disagree higher
The sun will never burn out. The sun will eventually burn
out when it burns all the
hydrogen that it has in its
2.56 Disagree core.
The sun is not a star. The sun is a star which the
2.92 Disagree earth orbits.
Base on the table 2.0b, grade 11 and 12 students also have a different point of views in
the field of Space; grade 11 students Agreed to statement which is The sun will never
burn out while the grade 12 students Disagreed to it, grade 11 students Strongly
Disagreed to the statement The sun is not a star while the grade 12 students Disagreed
to the statement which is clearly a misconception.
CHAPTER III
This chapter presents the brief presentation of the result of the study and also the
SUMMARY OF FINDINGS
1. Grade 11 student performance to the survey was good because most of the
group’s response were Disagree and in some area they Strongly Disagreed to
statement which shows that they have a strong body of knowledge in that area
and this reveal that they group have low rate of misconception. Grade 11
students are more into conceptual understanding rather than memorization alone
which is a good start for students because memorization is just a short term
knowledge of an idea while knowing the concept and how it works is the true
form of learning which is a teachers goal. This shows that most grade 11
ability, they have stronger ideas in some areas because they have scientific
reasons to that concept which we can see in the field Astronomy and Space.
They showed better understanding because they have developed the concept of
certainty in that field. Most of the grade 11 students are certain and have a
strong view in the statement All the stars are the same distance from the earth
and The sun is not a star because it’s clearly a wrong idea if scientific knowledge
about it.
2. Most response of the grade 12 student is Agree to most of the statement which
means that the students have high rate of misconception regarding common
scientific principles. Grade 12 learners are more into their reasoning ability rather
when he concluded that many high educated adults rely on the “models, beliefs,
and theories” that they have developed as preschoolers. Wrong concept that this
learners have acquired during their elementary schooling have really affected the
students, conflicting ideas will affect the students knowledge because he/she has
to choose on who’s right and who’s wrong, which can never be answer if you
that they have no strong knowledge about any of the concept of common
3. Grade 11 and 12 students of Sta. Catalina National High School showed that
they have different views in some field of common misconception about science
especially on a concept in Astronomy; All the stars are the same distance from
earth, and The sun is not a star, which the grade 11 Strongly Disagreed with
Meteors are falling stars, most of the grade 11 students Agreed while the grade
The sun will never burn out, and The sun is not a Star, which shows that there
are some concept that the student has knowledge and in some they have
CONCLUSION
The result of the study was very surprising, it showed that grade 11
students have low rate of misconception, most of their response are Disagree
which shows that they have some scientific knowledge and conceptual
understanding in the field of science. While the grade 12 showed that they have
high misconception rate, they are more into their reasoning ability, most of them
that they lack scientific explanation to some concept of science. Grade 11 and 12
students showed that there are some concepts in science that student has
scientific knowledge and in some they have misconception in the same area or
field of science.
RECOMMENDATION
Teachers are the ones who will incorporate learners the knowledge that
they need to live to this ever changing world that we live in. High school textbooks may
always examine and analyse ideas of their instructional materials especially the books
that they are using when they teach it to the students to avoid misconceptions.
sources of misconception in the mind of the students in order to find ways to avoid or
REFERENCES
American Institute of Physics. (1998). Children’s misconceptions about science.
available: http://amasci.com/miscon/opphys.html
Blosser, Patricia,(1987).Science misconceptions: research and some implications for
theteaching of science to elementary school students, ERIC/SMEAC, Science
Education Digest No. 1
Cho, Hee-Hyung (1985). An investigation of high school biology text books as sources
of misconceptions and difficulties in genetics and some suggestions for teaching
genetics, Science Education, 69(5), 707-719.
Fischbein, E., Nello, M.S. & Marino, M.S. (1991) Factors Affecting Probabilistic
Judgments in Children and Adolescents. Educational Studies in Mathematics, 22,
523-549.
Gardner, Howard. (1991). The unschooled mind: how children think and schools should
teach, New York: Basic Books.
Green, D.R. (1983). A Survey of 3000 Pupils aged 11-16 Years. In D.R Grey, V.
Barnett& G.M. Constable (Eds.), The Proceedings of the Second International
Conference on Teaching Statistics, (pp. 766-783) Sheffield, U.K: Teaching
Statistics Trust.
Nakhleh, M. B. 1992. Why some students don't learn chemistry. J. Chem. Educ.
69(3):191-196.
Piaget, J. &Inhelder, B. (1951). La genèse de l’idée de hasard chez l’enfant[ The Origin
of the Idea of Chance in Child]. Paris: Presses Universitaires de France.
Pine, K., Messer, D. and John, K.S. (2001). “Children‟s Misconceptions in Primary
Science: A survey of Teachers‟ Views” in Research in Science & Technological
Education, 19 (1): 79-96.