Environmental River Engineering
Environmental River Engineering
Two-stage channels are equally inappropriate in spacings appropriate to the natural regime width o f
upland rivers, as they are likely to be rapidly the river. Their size and shape are also important.
modified by over-berm deposition and lateral since riffles are generally diagonal to the flow and
channel migration. pools are rarely the full width of the channel. Lt is
necessary to ensure that patterns of flow conver-
Lowland Rivers gence and divergence are maintained so that the
O n lowland rivers, which do not transport signifi- retained pools are self-cleansing and riffles are
cant amounts of bed material load even under flood preserved.
conditions, more options are available. Schemes Dredging, either locally to create pools or on a
involving the construction of flood banks are pre- reach basis to lower summer water levels and
ferred on both stability and conservation grounds, increase flood capacity, can lead to serious bank-
although it is recognized that space restriction may stability problems which could be identified in
not always allow them to be adopted. Two-stage advance. Surveys to assess natural failure mech-
channels are also appropriate, particularly as anisms and the nature of the bank material need to
instream habitats are not destroyed. However, in be carried out. This will enable assessment of the
rural areas flood capacities can be seriously impaired stability of the bank, consequent upon dredging, to
by uncontrolled vegetation growth o n the berm. be made, which would prevent costly failures.
High groundwater levcls can reduce the bearing Tree preservation is also vital with regard to bank
strength of the berm surface and thereby preclude protection and stabilization, and for shading of the
grazing by animals. Berm maintenance in urban river. Water temperatures are particularly respon-
areas would be easier, particularly if the scheme sive to the degree o f shading, which affects fisheries,
were integrated within a riverside park. while seasonal macrophyte growth can bc: limited by
Resectioning and straightening is a more feasible the provision of shade. Trees and shrubs also
option for lowland rivers from a stability standpoint provide cover for fish, while organic debris in the
provided that weirs are used, where appropriate, to river is vital for invertebrates.
prevent erosion of the bed material. These rivers The practice of limiting machine operations to
principally transport sands, silts, clays, and organic one bank is generally regarded as being important,
material in suspension. In straightened reaches this as it maintains natural vegetative growth on one o f
will probably be transmitted downstream, but in the banks. If the river is prone to bank erosion, this
those which have been widened and dredged deposi- could result in rapid erosion of the cleared bank. It
tion can result. This will cover the natural substrate, is therefore preferable to clear vegetation selectively
rendering it less suitable for colonization by inverte- on both banks, leaving sufficient protection in key
brates, and encourage reed encroachment. If depo- sections to prevent bank erosion. Aesthetically it
sition does occur, a regular heavy maintenance maintains a more pleasing riverscape.
prograninie can sustain its design capacity; but at a Meander cut-offs are also regarded as important
cost. features that require protection, and various
approaches have been advocated3. The key require-
Environmental Implications ment is the preservation of the original channel
Environmentally, such schemes can be tempered slope in the cut-off channel through the construction
as a result of river corridor surveys. These identify of a weir. If this is located at the head of the cut-off
key conservation elements within the river corridor it will create a pool which, via a pipe, can maintain
which require preservation, for example pools, some flow in the former meander bend. The weir
riffles, vertical banks, meander features, trees, and could be constructed in such a way that a pool is
macrophytes. It is then a question of designing a created downstream. The River Witham at West-
scheme which will retain thcse key conservation borough has been modified in this way. and the
features. This may require compromises if the resulting habitat has been successfully colonized by
requirement for flood capacity cannot be reconciled aquatic plants, insects, invertebrates anti fish.
with preservation of conservation features. Audit
surveys, in which engineered reaches are reassessed RIWKRIISIOKAI‘ION
to evaluate the design performance of the scheme, Over the years many rivers have been controlled
are revealing in this context”. In some instances for a variety of reasons. Until the introduction of
pools have been obliterated by silt and organic environmentally-sensitive schemes, trapezoidal
debris and riffles have been eroded or become channels were generally adopted. This removed the
imbricated, :is the gravel framework is infilled with natural morphological variability of the river, and if
silt, meander cut-offs are rapidly lost through reed sediment transport capacity was reduced it could
encroachment, and vertical banks are not main- lead to siltation and loss of natural sorting o f the bed
tained by undercutting. sediment vital for invertebrate communities. Effect-
Clearly. the arbitrary preservation of some key ively it produces a biologically-sterile river which is
conservation features does not necessxrily guarnntee aesthetically unattractive. Many rivers are still in
their survival. Pools and riffles need to be at this state.
338 J . I W E M , 1990, 4, August
ENVIRONMENTAL RIVER ENGINEERING
BANK FA,. URE
If a natural-type channel is to be totally re-
created, regime type design procedures would be
necessary to determine the required cross-sectional,
longitudinal. and plan geometry of the river. This
requires information on flow, sediment loads,
calibre of the bed and bank material, and valley
slope for the reach in question. Alternatively, the
geometry of an adjacent natural stable reach could
be copied'.
However, if it is a question of re-creating natural
features within a canalized river, it would be
necessary to determine the location, nature, and Id)
extent of any pools and riffles which had developed. a) F u l l - w i d t n weir - perpendtculai
It would also be necessary to consider the location of bl Full-Width w e i r V - l n g downstream
bankside trees, as these will determine where pools C) Wing deflector
d) Submerged vanes Symmetiical V upstream
could be located without danger of excessive bank 0) Submerged vanes - asymmetrical V
8%
1ng u p s t r e a m
erosion. Given this information, pools could be 1) wing Yane
established at appropriate spacings in harmony with
the meander geometry of the river. In straight Fig. 4. River restoration using structural
channels, pools and bars need to be located on measures
alternate sides of the river. flow pattern. The advantage with the structural
Restoration will generally be restricted to lowland approach is that the river is encouraged to be self-
rivers, as in upland areas the channel will be self- cleansing, whereas with dredging there is a strong
adjusting. It can be achieved either by structural or possibility that the pool will refill. This type of
non-structural means. Non-structural approaches approach has been adopted on a reach of the River
refer to dredging and gravel dumping to re-create Wensum at Fakenham in Norfolk, where it was
the desired bed topography. This is only appropriate necessary to desilt a pool adjacent to a group of
if the natural range of flows does not destroy the willow trees as a part of a trout management
imposed condition. Alternatively, structures can be programme. T h e structure causes slight ponding
installed in the river to promote local scour and fill. upstream at low flow and creates a disturbed water
Structures are introduced to generate secondary surface across and downstream from the vanes,
circulation in the flow. Flow convergence, either in which provides cover for the trout.
total or of surface flows, will result in scour, with
deposition in areas of flow expansion or surface flow RIVER GEOMORPHOLOGLCAL SURVEYS
divergence. Wing structures, placed on alternate
banks, need to be of the correct dimensions and This brief review illustrates how geomorphological
shape to produce the required constriction in flow principles can be applied to various aspects of river
for pool generation. Weirs, sometimes with notches, management. Different perspectives can assist in
have also been used to create ponding upstream or identifying problems, devising potential solutions,
scour downstream. These can be perpendicular to assessing likely impacts and developing natural,
the tlow or 'v'-ing downstream. The latter tends to stable-channel, design procedures. Baseline geo-
produce scour holes adjacent to both banks and a morphological surveys are an essential prerequisite,
central gravel bar. Over a period of time the and these can be made in parallel with standard
structure could be underpinned if bank collapse engineering and river corridor surveys.
occurs. The type of survey carried out depends on the
An alternative approach is to install submerged nature of the management problem. As consider-
vanes 'v'-ing upstream, with gaps in the centre ation needs to be given to a range of possible
between the vanes and the banks to allow for the solutions, from doing nothing to treating the cause
passage of bed material load (Fig. 4). Provided that of the problem rather than the symptoms, the survey
the angle of attack of the vanes is of the correct has to be tailored accordingly. Surveys could include
magnitude (approximately thirty degrees to the one or more of the following:
Row), a scour hole is produced downstream from the
vanes. The vanes are generally located in a reiatively (i) Establish the morphology of the reach (cross
uniform reach of channel and are constructed so that section, profile and plan shape) and identify natural
they are completely submerged during the lowest control features, such as rock ledgeslbars as well as
artificial structures such as weirs. It is important that
flow. Scour occurs because the structure creates two cross sections are taken at pools and riffles so that
spiral secondary flows with surface-flow conver- the natural variability of the reach is determined;
gence. Slower, near-bed flow is directed outwards ( i i ) Establish nature of the bed and hank sediment,
towards the banks, while faster-flowing surface flow textural characteristics of the bank material and its
spills over the angled vanes to produce a convergent stratigraphy t o a depth below the level of the