Lifting+Matters+Q3+2021 210930 WEB LR
Lifting+Matters+Q3+2021 210930 WEB LR
JIB SAFETY
liftingmatters.com.au
From the Editor
Q3, July - September, 2021
Welcome to the Q3 2021 edition of Lifting Please get in touch with us! You can
Matters. visit us on Facebook, LinkedIn, or
This edition we focus on safely erecting, drop us an email any time. If you have
using and removing fly jib extensions. an incident report, ideas about safer
CICA walk us through the industry best and more efficient ways of working,
practice of jib extension attachment and widespread issues, valuable reminders,
removal; and we bring you a Training or anything else safety related, we want
Toolbox on how to erect and stow a to hear from you. We look forward to
bi-fold boom extension. This edition working together to protect our people
highlights multiple incidents where and save lives in the crane industry. Any
jib safety has been compromised, at contributions for our next edition are
times with fatal consequences, due to due by Friday 10 December 2021.
equipment failure and human error. If you prefer printed glossy copies
We speak with Jack Burling about his for your crane cabs, cribs, mess hall,
experiences in our Operator’s Opinion, or reception, please send your postal
and profile Patrick Silver, Project and address and the number of copies you
Heavy Lift Manager at Universal Cranes. require to [email protected].
You can also read about Slew SafeTM, an Lifting Matters is available to view at
industry innovation turning the corner www.liftingmatters.com.au or you can
on pick and carry crane operator safety. subscribe to receive an email copy each
quarter.
It’s as important now, as it has ever
been, to check in with one another – Stay safe and see you next edition!
that’s why we’re supporting Workplace
Health and Safety QLD’s Safe Work
Month and Mental Health Week 2021. Thank you
Take a look at their upcoming events;
DASHELLE BAILEY, EDITOR
read the latest MATES in Construction
[email protected]
article; and make it a priority to check in
with your family, friends, and colleagues.
EDITORIAL 4
FEATURE ARTICLE
Industry Best Practice of Jib Extension Attachment and Removal 6
INCIDENT REVIEW
Jamestown, South Australia 10
Miami and Fort Lauderdale, Florida 13
INCIDENT GALLERY
Christchurch, New Zealand 16
Charlottesville, Virginia 17
Brooklyn, New York 18
Liverpool, England 18
New York, New York 19
TRAINING TOOLBOX
Erecting and Stowing the Bi-Fold Boom Extension 20
INDUSTRY INNOVATION
Slew Safe™ Safety Feature Preventing Crane Rollovers 24
OPERATOR’S OPINION
Jack Burling 28
PEOPLE PROFILE
Patrick Silver 30
If the hoist rope that you will be using for the fly
2.
jib is already on the main boom, pay out enough
rope to install on the fly jib before disconnecting
the rope from the boom head.
3.
The main boom should be set to manufacturer’s
specifications for angle and extension.
4.
Unpin the fly jib stowage pins and attach the pivot
point of the fly jib to the main boom head.
6.
Swing the fly jib into position and attach the can act like a saw
connecting pin to the other side of the boom head. blade on boom
sections or laces if
Place the wire rope correctly over the sheaves
7. and ensure all guide pins and retaining clips are
reinstalled.
reeved improperly.
8.
Reconnect all electronic sensors including moving
the anemometer from the main boom to the fly.
9.
The boom may have to be raised to a certain angle
before the hook block is lifted off the ground.
10.
Check the Anti-2 block sensor on the fly jib is
working.
It is important that the reeving of the wire can rotate freely when the connecting pin
rope is correct, to be sure it is retained by is released. Once the fly jib is secured the
the guide pins and that retaining clips are crane can travel to the next job.
secure on the guide pins. The wire rope can
act like a saw blade on boom sections or Underslung fly jibs follow a similar
laces if reeved improperly. procedure, but do not have the main
boom horizontal during installation and
When disassembling the fly jib ensure that disassembly. The hoist rope is used with
the boom is retracted to the position so luffing up of the main boom to unfold the
it can be stowed correctly on the support fly jib and bring it into position. Once it is
ramp and aligns with the stowage pins. in position, the fly jib angle is set.
Do not stand under the jib or on the side These steps apply to boom mounted fly jibs
of the jib in the area it will pivot, as the jib on All Terrain, Hydraulic Truck Crane and
Rough Terrain cranes. This brief overview position is that this activity does not need
is an oversimplification for fly jibs that are to be completed by an intermediate rigger
installed on large capacity hydraulic or but needs to be completed under the
lattice boom cranes. guidance of the crane operator following
the manufacturer’s recommendations in
CICA Position Paper, CICA-PA-0005-A, the operation manual. CICA Members have
discusses who can assist the crane operator access to all guidance notes and position
when changing the reeving arrangement or papers, go to www.cica.com.au to learn
installing a fly jib. Some WHS regulators more about CICA membership.
interpret the Intermediate Rigger HRWL
definition to include the installation of
swing away and underslung fly jibs as
rigging and derigging the crane. CICA’s
February 2007
Jamestown, South Australia
Cranes: Liebherr LG-1550 with 63m main boom and 28m luffing fly
Damage to strut
September 2017
Miami and Fort Lauderdale, Florida
Tower top and counterjib after the incident Tower top and counterjib after the incident
at the first failure site at the second failure site
In September 2017, Hurricane Irma hit remained intact. The cause of the failure was
the west coast of Florida, USA. The tropical the same in all three cases: the detachment
storm conditions across Miami and Fort of the crane jib from its turntable due
Lauderdale caused the collapse of three to turbulent wind loads. Once the jib
SK-315 hammerhead tower cranes that started falling, the two jib pendants were
had been put out of service and allowed to released. The forces on the tower top apex
weathervane. from the jib pendants decreased from the
maximum to zero in a short amount of time.
In all three crane failures, only the jibs,
The two tower top columns toward the
counterjibs, and the tower top collapsed.
counterjib failed because of the transient
The crane masts, ties and foundations
load change on the tower top.
On coastal areas with tall buildings and locations prone to frequent turbulent
winds, local governing bodies should consider asking engineers to conduct
simulations based on dynamic analysis to get a more realistic wind evaluation
than quasi-static analysis. Instead of conducting cost-prohibitive wind tunnel
tests, engineers could conduct a Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD)
analysis, which has become affordable due to the rapid advance of software
and computing technology.
The jibs in all three cranes were suspended by single pendants. In the event that
the jib begins to sway to the sides, the single pendants could not be expected to
secure the stability of the jib. It is, therefore, recommended that two symmetric
pendants or cables be considered in the design of the tower cranes. Terex should
consider adding pendants to the existing SK- 315 models.
Incident Gallery
April 2021
Christchurch,
New Zealand
OUTCOME:
CRUSH INJURY
January 2019
Charlottesville, Virginia
OUTCOME:
INJURY AND
BUILDING DAMAGE
NBC29 News
February 2021
Brooklyn, New York
OUTCOME:
NEAR MISS
NY Post
The jib of a Potain luffing tower crane when the crane's boom experienced a
dropped in February 2021 due to a failed partial collapse.” It is estimated the portion
luffing mechanism. The crane was located of the crane that collapsed measured 175
at the site of a 31-storey luxury high-rise feet (approx. 53m).
development in Brooklyn, New York.
The jib was facing away from the building
According to the New York’s Department when it collapsed against itself, causing
of Buildings preliminary investigation, no damage to the tower construction
“technicians were on site performing project. Thankfully there were no injuries
maintenance work on the tower crane to workers or passersby.
OUTCOME: The crane had been working on its main boom with
a fixed fly jib extension. A second crane was being
FATALITY
used to add an extra 6m lattice section of fixed fly jib
to the tip of the telescopic boom when the incident
occurred. As the existing fixed fly jib configuration
was dismantled and pins were removed, two boom
sections – weighing 2.4t and 1.6t – collapsed.
February 2016
New York, New York
OUTCOME:
FATALITY AND
MULTIPLE INJURIES
MAIN STEPS
ERECTING
3.
If extended, fully retract all the boom section (0° boom or it will run away
when it swings)
4.
Lower the boom to minimum elevation to permit ease of installation of pins
and access to the boom nose
5.
Rig either the main hoist or optional auxiliary hoist cable for single part line
with nothing but the wedge socket on the end of the cable.
6. Extend the boom enough to disengage the spring loaded boom stop block
7.
Pull down on the rubber hook to disengage the spring loaded boom stop block.
Place the end of the rubber jook in the retainer plate. Fully retract the boom.
Remove the retainer clips from the attachment pins stowed in the base of the
8.
boom extension and insert the attachment pins through the attachment and
anchor fittings on the right side of the boom nose. Install the retainer clips in
the attachment pins.
9.
Remove the retainer clip from base to fly attachment pin and remove
attachment pin from base section to fly section attachment fittings.
10. Stow the pin in the opposite attach fitting or the stowage lug.
11.
Ensure the pin attaching the fly section to the boom base section rear
stowage bracket is in place.
12.
At fly section sheave end (see picture - E) push in on the spring loaded latch
hook to release latch, allowing the base to separate from the fly
CAUTION
Raise the boom to horizontal and extend the boom just enough to clear the
1. extension stowage lugs from the guide ramps and stowage pins on the front
and rear stowage brackets.
Remove the hitch pin and clip pin securing the boom extension alignment
2. device in the stowed position. Pull the push bar assembly out to the working
position and secure it in place with the hitch pin and clip pin.
DANGER
1.
When erecting the boom extension, ensure that all personnel and equipment
are kept clear of the swing path.
Slightly raise and/or lower the boom to help control the extension. Using
2.
the rope attached to the tip of the extension, swing the extension into place
ahead of the boom nose, engaging the anchor fittings with the attachment
fittings on the left side of the boom nose.
3.
Install the attachment pin into the upper anchor and attachment fitting on
the left side of the boom nose. Install retainer clip in attachment pin.
If the boom extension alignment device does not properly align the anchor
4. and attachment fittings to allow installation of the last attachment pin, refer
to the Service Manual and adjust the boom extension alignment device.
Fully retract the boom until the bottom extension anchor fittings is against
5.
the boom extension alignment device and install the attachment pin in the
lower anchor and attachment fittings on the left side of the boom nose,
install the retainer clip in the attachment pin.
6. Lower the boom and remove the rope from the tip of the extension base section.
Remove the hitch pin and clip pin securing the boom extension alignment
7. device in the working position. Push the push bar assembly back to the
stowed position and secure it in place with the hitch pin and clip pin.
Background
The 2015 paper by RMIT, Causes of Fatal
Since their inception in 1980, articulated Accidents Involving Cranes in the Australian
pick and carry cranes have become a staple Construction Industry, stated 9% of all crane
part of operations across a wide range of incidents in 2001-2013 were caused by plant
industries. With unique characteristics overturning. This figure has recently been
differentiating pick and carries from slewing reported as 6% for Q1 2020 alone, according
cranes, careful consideration needs to be to data compiled in a collaboration between
given for their safe use (CICA). CICA and WorkSafe.
•
Operating on surfaces that cannot support the weight of the crane
and suspended load
•
failure to derate the crane's lifting capacity as per manufacturer's
requirements
•
changing direction (articulating) or manoeuvring around
obstructions
• under-inflated tyres.
Risk increases significantly if more than one of the above factors is present.
Nearly 75-80% of pick and carry cranes may result in an incident, TRT instigated
currently operating in Australia can pick up the development of Slew Safe as a leading
a load over the front on firm level ground, safety-system to minimise crane rollovers.
slew through many charts, and drive across
various side slopes and terrain without any Slew Safe was designed to save lives and
de-rating for pitch and roll. This results in improve driver safety when operating TIDD
the crane becoming unstable and increases PC28 cranes. It is now a standard safety
the potential for an accident, without feature on all new TIDD PC28’s and it is able
any warning to the operator or other to be retrofitted onto all TIDD PC25's.
stakeholders nearby.
How Slew Safe Works
Of the 4,000 pick and carry cranes currently
When the crane is operated in the GREEN
operating in Australia, only the machines
and AMBER areas of the lifting chart, Slew
manufactured after 2013 or having had
Safe will remain inactive. When the crane in
Dynamic LMI’s subsequently fitted, provide
operation moves from green and amber to
operator alarms when operating on side
RED, this is an overload notification based
slopes, meaning all others can easily go off
on the lifting chart which will activate Slew
the chart without any warning to the crane
Safe.
operator.
Once Slew Safe is activated it will do the
Solution following:
As the manufacturer of the TIDD Crane,
TRT’s primary focus has been safety, from • Show a visible warning on the ECU
the first prototype of the PC25 in March 2014
to the newer PC28 launched in May 2019. Reduce the speed of the power
• steering to 15% in the unsafe
direction
It was recognised there was growing
concern in the construction and Makes steering harder with instant
infrastructure sectors towards
the number of incidents – often
• feedback through the steering
wheel to operator
unpublished – involving articulating
•
The engine will “load up” making an
cranes causing serious harm to people. audible sound change for operator
“Working with Tier One clients, we are obviously aware of the focus
on Pick and Carries in general and the concerns around their safety
specifically. One of the biggest drivers around the TIDD purchase is
the fact that you can take the machine to Tier One customers and
demonstrate the risk mitigation features of the PC28”.
- Michael Yates, Crew NSW
Operator’s
Opinion
Jack Burling
JACK BURLING
LIFTING CONSULTANT
– AUCKLAND CRANES
Jack, how did you come to be in Given your experience, have you
your current role? Perhaps you personally been involved in any
could you give us a summary of your incidents involving crane jibs / jib
professional journey so far… extensions?
I started on the ground with a crane crew I have - the Operator telescoped out with
on the west coast of New Zealand’s South the computer in fly erection mode. The
Island (Holcim Cement Works). I never auxiliary hook became jammed against the
looked back, slowly working my way from fly head sheave (applicable to this model
the man cage to the seat in the crane. I as this was the procedure for releasing
obtained national certification along the pendant bars to change fly jib rake angle).
way, and all the associated heavy traffic The Operator was under the impression
licences. When family responsibilities they were winching down, and unaware
increased, I was happy to move my feet that they were actually telescoping out.
under the desk and work as a Lifting Before anyone could call a stop to the
Consultant for Auckland Cranes. proceedings, the Operator had pulled the
People Profile
Patrick Silver
Positive reinforcement
and responsibility at all
levels certainly helps foster
that culture. What keeps
you motivated in your
role from day-to-day?
MATES in Construction
Article republished with permission from Workplace Health and Safety Queensland
MATES in Construction targets suicide “We know that each year more than 195
prevention in the construction, energy and construction workers in Australia die by
mining industries – and the not for profit suicide and many more are permanently
organisation’s efforts have been recognised incapacitated following suicide attempts.
by the World Health Organisation. Construction workers are six times more
MATES has been helping workers for likely to die by suicide than an accident at
more than 13 years and recently reached work.
a milestone as it clocked up 200,000 “A five-year review of MATES conducted
workers provided with general awareness in 2016 showed that suicide rates in the
training. That figure has now grown to industry had fallen by almost 8 per cent after
more than 230,000, as well as 21,000 the introduction of MATES in Construction.
people CONNECTOR trained and nearly
“We are unbelievably proud that the
11,000 cases managed, which has helped
World Health Organisation chose a small
the program to be recognised on the
Australian program such as MATES to
international stage.
demonstrate what can be achieved in suicide
A World Health Organisation guide details prevention by engaging worksites.”
six key pillars to nation-based suicide
prevention and showcases MATES in
Construction as an example of world’s best MATES also has information on the
practice in multisectoral capacity building. mental health issues raised by COVID,
MATES in Construction acting CEO John including tips for coping with stress
Brady said LIVE LIFE: An Implementation and resources for work sites.
Guide for Suicide Prevention in Countries
outlines a range of practical tips and
The Queensland Government supports
considerations to support effective
MATES in Construction by providing $1
whole-of-society responses that enhance
million annually to fund suicide prevention
community resilience.
services in the construction industry, and
“When MATES started in 2008, suicide was regional Queensland and small business,
seen almost entirely as a health problem with an emphasis on young construction
requiring health responses. Programs such workers. In July 2020, the Queensland
as MATES have shown that we achieve Government renewed its commitment to
much more when we engage all of the MATES by signing an agreement to provide
community,” Mr Brady said. $1 million per annum from 2020 to 2025.
Safe Work Month and Mental Health Week raise community and industry awareness
about the importance of work health and safety, and the benefits of mentally healthy
workplaces. Everyone has the right to come home safe and healthy at the end of each
working day.
Upcoming Events:
You'll find out:
• how a healthy diet can keep you full and energised
for your workday as well as providing you with many
long-term health benefits
October 14
In this highly interactive workshop, Dr Fisher provides
Creating mentally practical tips on reframing how we define accomplishment
safe workplaces beyond the performance appraisal and builds your
understanding of the importance of belongingness and
Strategies for promoting
mental wellbeing accomplishment as mental health fundamentals - and the
role it plays in mentally healthy workplaces.
1.00 - 2.30pm
Disclaimer – This newsletter is not an exhaustive list of all safety matters that need to be considered. Whilst care
is taken in the preparation of this material, Lifting Matters does not guarantee the accuracy and completeness
of this information and how it applies to your situation. Lifting Matters will not be responsible for any loss, dam-
age or costs incurred as a result of errors or omissions in relation to the material in our publication or for any
possible actions ensuing from information contained in our publication.
Any views or opinions represented in this publication are personal and belong solely to the author and do not
represent those of people, institutions or organisations that the publisher may or may not be associated with in
a professional or personal capacity unless explicitly stated.