Perception of An Urban Public Place: A Case Study of Martyrs' Square, Trivandrum
Perception of An Urban Public Place: A Case Study of Martyrs' Square, Trivandrum
Abstract: Now a days, every city develops at a very fast One of the most important features of urban life today is
rate. Many factors contribute to this huge development. complex social relationships. Part of the relationships are
Many parts of the city have various forms and physical in the work environment, but much of them take place in
structures. Urban places and its different forms have a big the form of social interaction in the urban place concept.
influence and effect on the people using it. Urban places in So, urban place plays an important role in the social
current scenario are important due to different reasons. So development of citizens. Social interactions are formed in
it is necessary to analyse if an urban square is working these places. A social zone is defined and also the
good today. Only by evaluation can we identify the issues mechanisms of collective life are experienced. Thus the
affecting its performance. This dissertation aims at absence of a suitable urban place can cause social ills in
understanding Martyrs’ Square, Trivandrum. Martyrs’ cities. Squares are one of the most important urban areas
Square is a very important urban place in Trivandrum, and have long been the context of formation of social life.
India. Many political and other activities are held here. The impacts of quick changing monetary and social
The Martyrs’ square at Palayam Trivandrum, a 64 year conditions have progressively become notable on how
old urban space, which was originally placed as landmark individuals use and shape their surroundings. The urban
for the region, was used for several gatherings and populace has been drastically expanding overall and hence
occasions. The immediate surrounding areas saw huge physical structure of the urban areas changes always, for
development in the eventual years. Martyrs’ Square the most part in negative ways. As the populace expands,
became an isolated spot in the midst of all the newer the interest for infrastructure and equipment becomes
developments and buildings around it. The gatherings and greater. Privatization and decentralization are the two
ceremonies started happening in a confined fenced area noteworthy worries on the eventual fate of the urban areas
with the commemorative tower in the middle of a traffic and open spaces.
intensive urban area. In spite of the area limitation,
gatherings and public events continue to be held there. When it comes to urban space, public space and urban
This study is an attempt to explore how Martyrs’ square square, many scholars have different opinions. Some have
has evolved as an urban space and how to understand its identified urban spaces with a number of different
behaviour in the current scenario. This study also draws perspectives (Krier, 1979, p.15). Also having a physical
down to different methods of improving the performance of approach of urban space, identifies space as the form
Martyr’s square as an urban public square. (without imposing aesthetic criteria). 1Subsequently, Rob
Krier characterizes urban space as the “external space”,
Keywords: About four key words or phrases in “all types of space between buildings in towns and other
alphabetical order, separated by commas. localities.” The concept of urban space needs to take into
consideration the physical, social and symbolic aspects at
1 INTRODUCTION the same time. Urban spaces are important segment of
daily lives (Francis, 1987, p. 23). Such activities of daily
1.1 Background life take place both in public spheres and private spheres.
India is in a rapid phase of development. The development Public spaces also depict a crucial and essential part of the
occurs in various phases and in certain areas. Usually a ‘democratic’ community life, particularly urban squares, a
settlement pattern rises along the core area of growth. The public property that serves as a site with the expectation of
spaces and its functions changes according to the period complimentary discourse and free judgment of chose
and planning of the area. Spatial organization of today is authorities in full perspective of others. Public spaces are
more chaotic and dense. There is a geometrical irregularity important components of daily lives. The public space
but it goes on with harmony with the humans. A state of concept covers an extensive variety of roles and capacities
disorder can be seen in various public spaces. Hence, these in a variety of physical setting such as streets, squares,
spaces should be designed with respect to functions and plazas, market places and parks. This study aims to focus
their connections with the surrounding environment. The on the public urban spaces such as squares.
public spaces should be in correspondence with the culture,
traditions, history and sentiments of the people of the 1
Importance of Urban Squares as Public Space in Social
particular area.
Life- Master Thesis in Sustainable Urban Planning by
Armin Abbasian
2
Every society has its own particulars for such urban public places. One of which is the urban square. Urban squares
open spaces, every one of these terms addresses a typical are open public spaces which reflect the cities’ identity and
point which is: ‘the open space for public use’ concept of the communities’ cultural background. They are where
urban square. In this respect urban squares have a social people of the community gather and “urban life” takes
angle in appreciation of its public dimension and a spatial place since the ancient times. As the fundamental
facet because of its physical organization. Urban Square component of the city structure, urban squares contribute
frequently has been an image of social communication and to the image and prestige of the city. The urban area
majority rules system. According to Kevin Lynch, an urban evolves with time and it can have both positive and
square is the “activity focus” in the centre of dense urban negative effects. It also plays a major role in influencing
areas. He states that “. . . it will be paved, enclosed by high the people in terms of various aspects. Hence, it is essential
density structures, and surrounded by streets, or in contact to know various aspects of an urban square and what all
with them. It contains features meant to attract groups of characteristics contribute to a perfect well-functioning
people and to facilitate meetings” (Lynch, 1981, p. 443)2. urban public square.
As a result, I think that an urban square is one sort of urban
open public space that focuses on the public space system, 1.3 Aim of the study
providing a forum for interchange, both social and
financial, and a focus for civic pride and community
To understand urban spaces and to evaluate the
expression.
performance of Martyrs’ Square Trivandrum as an Urban
Square.
In urban planning, public space has generally been
characterized as “open space”, which means the streets,
parks and amusement regions, squares and other freely 1.4 Objectives
possessed and oversaw outside spaces, in contrast with the
private area of lodging and work. Despite that, the late The primary intention of the study is to identify certain
advancements of the types of urban settlement and the parameters that are characteristic of well-designed urban
increasing number and assortment of semi-open spaces squares and to evaluate whether Martyr’s Square satisfies
oversaw by private-open or totally private organizations the identified parameters, and if so how does how is it
addresses this thought acquired from a legitimate point of perceived as suitable urban space by its users.
view. Nowadays, public places should be understood as not
quite the same as people in the general area of the state and [i] To understand urban squares, its typologies,
its subdivisions, but instead as a place available to the characteristics and functions.
general population. Urban public squares are assumed to
be a key part in the urban structure and city life, turning [ii] To understand and analyse the Urban theories
into an advantaged component keeping in mind the end pertaining to urban spaces of Roger Trancik, Kevin Lynch.
goal to advance regional attachment.
[iii] To identify various forms and planning of urban
The performance of urban spaces gradually evolves with squares and undertake an comparative analysis
time, developmental pressures, outlook of the people etc. It
can change for good or for bad. No matter what the integral
attributes of a good urban space has to be retained in spite [iv] To evaluate the performance and behaviour of
of all development activities if the space has to be relevant Martyrs’ Square, Palayam, Trivandrum as an urban square
to urban users. This is usually not the case in many places. and its behaviour
This dissertation tries to understand about the idle
attributes of a good urban space. Further it tries to 1.5 Research Questions
understand through an example how the evolution of an
urban space over period has changed the behavioural • What are the various parameters for analysing the
pattern of the urban space. It tries to analyse if the changes quality of an urban square?
prove good for the current users or not. Martyrs’ Square
Trivandrum, has been chosen as a Case study to explore
• Does the performance and behaviour of urban
the above aspect in this study. spaces change with time, if so how do the user adapt
themselves to it?
1.2 Need of the study
1.6 Scope
The fast changing social and economic conditions have a
huge effect on how people use and shape their space and
• This study evaluates various urban squares and its
environment. The urban structure today has significantly characteristics through secondary sources. Trivandrum has
increased worldwide and as a result the social and physical
so many urban spaces. This study restricts itself to studying
structure of the cities changes accordingly. As the
Martyrs’ Square alone. Further it only evaluates the current
population increases the demand for spaces also increases. performance of the delineated space of Martyrs’ Square, it
Privatization and decentralization are the future of cities
does not analyse the reasons for the various developments
and open public places. There are various types of public
around the Square.
are different types of urban spaces, however this study 2.2 Urban Square
focuses only on Urban Squares.
According to Lynch, an urban square is the “activity focus”
1.7 Limitations in the centre of dense urban areas. He states that “. . . it will
be paved, enclosed by high density structures, and
• The pandemic situation prevalent in India from surrounded by streets, or in contact with them. It contains
March 2020 onwards posed a lot of challenges and features meant to attract groups of people and to facilitate
restrictions. This study to a certain extent has been affected meetings” (Lynch, 1981, p. 443). There are various types
due to the same. of Urban Squares based on various factors.
4
Paul Zucker: Town and Square( New York, Columbia
University Press 1959)-pp.8-17
4
They are a point of reference which is external. They are Connaught Place is one of the largest financial,
usually simply defined physical objects such as buildings commercial and business centers in New Delhi. It is often
or monuments, mountain etc... abbreviated to CP. It was developed as a showpiece of
Lutyen’s Delhi with a prominent Central Business District.
Other urban square performance parameters:- It is located at the center of the city, near Karol Bagh. The
Inner Circle of Connaught Place is Rajiv Chowk while the
Accessibility Outer Circle became Indira Chowk. Prior to the
construction of Connaught Place, the area was a ridge,
5
The name "Cantonment" is not much in use for the area, At present Palayam Martyr’s Square is used as a space for
though that name is still associated with the police station holding political meetings and other strikes. A crossway is
near the Secretariat, "Cantonment Police Station". At provided in front of Martyr’s Square and many people use
present, "Cantonment House" serves as the official it. Martyr’s Square acts as a central core form the Palayam
residence of the Leader of the Opposition. area. An underground passage goes below the Martyr’s
Square.
4.2 Martyrs’ Square, Palayam, Trivandrum- An
Introduction 4.5 Context Analysis and Activity Analysis
India. Many political as well as non-political protests and • Improvement of the surrounding context
meetings are held here which also states the importance of
the place as an urban square. The buildings and areas surrounding Martyr’s Square do
not have a certain form nor any special visually appealing
5.2 Martyr’s Square and Urban Square performance appearance. Changes can be brought in terms of design to
Analysis incorporate the area as a whole and not restricted to a
particular building or area. A sense of uniformity can be
• Analysing with respect to urban square created to gain an aesthetically appealing appearance.
perspectives of urban theorist Rob Krier, Kevin Lynch and
other urban square performance parameters identified. • Adapting certain measures to create a more people
friendly and eco-friendly place
FIG 5 MENTAL MAP OF MARTYRS’ SQUARE Certain design changes can be adopted to make the urban
area more user friendly. By comparison to other case
Source: Author studies, Martyrs Square is less pedestrian friendly. Design
changes can be adopted to make it a more user friendly
space.
5.3 Comparison of Martyr’s Square and other Case studies
• Provide visually appealing views
Comparing Martyrs’ Square with other case studies and
deriving conclusions.
Visually appealing areas can be created by adopting design
changes
5.4 Identifying potentials for improving the performance of
Martyr’s Square
6 QUESTIONAIRES
The case studies studied includes Times Square, New York
which is a famous urban public place in New York, a 1. Are you familiar with Palayam Martyr’s Square?
commercial and economic hub of the city. Manek Chowk
is a urban place in Ahmedabad which is a very busy place Option 1- yes
in India which includes various activities and is very dense
and crowded. Then there is Connaught Place which is a Option 2 - no
well-designed urban area in Delhi. Martyr’s Square is an
urban area which is developed mainly on its own due to the 2. Do you find the area as easily accessible?
changes in its context. In comparison we can understand
that in certain areas Martyr’s Square has certain limitations
compared with other urban public squares. These may be Option 1- yes
in terms of spatial organization, site features etc… But all
these can also contribute to the function of the area as a Option 2 - no
whole. The people have adapted themselves to go on with
the current context and use the urban area actively. 3. Do you find the area to be a very crowded place?
But this can be made better by incorporating certain design Option 1- yes
changes an addition to the existing scenario of Martyr’s
Square. Some changes which can be adapted for better
Option 2 - no
functioning of Martyr’s Square in terms of its performance
are:-
7
4. Do you find the place aesthetically appealing and does value as an urban space and the current development
this place provide all the requirements of an urban area? activities happening around it, it is important that both of
them coexist in a well-balanced manner. Even though
Option 1- yes Martyrs’ Square functionally works as a decent urban
space, theoretically there is scope for a lot of improvement
so that the overall spatial quality of the locality is elevated.
Option 2 - no