Caribbean Studies Final Document Brittania Simpson
Caribbean Studies Final Document Brittania Simpson
Internal Assessment
Topic: An investigation into the effectiveness of modern medicine versus traditional (herbs)
medicine on the physical health of students’ /family members of students at Central high school
Hypothesis: Modern medicine is more effective than traditional medicine for the health of
Candidate #:1000721610
Teacher: Mrs.Batchelor
Territory: Jamaica
1|Page
TABLE OF CONTENTS
(iv) Methodology…………………………………………………………………15-16
(x) Appendices…………………………………………………………………………..41-44
2|Page
Acknowledgement
I would like to thank the almighty for helping the researcher with this SBA. I would also like to
thank my respondents for helping the researcher with answering the questionnaire.
3|Page
Introduction
4|Page
Introduction
Background of study
Central High School is located in the center of May Pen at exactly 58 Sevens Road. It
caters for about 2024 students. The health system of the school is very poor because it lacks a
stable school nurse. Also in the event if a serious health issue occurs with a student the student
has to be rushed to a neighboring hospital ‘May Pen hospital’. The students’ physical health is
very important because it contributes to the social and academic behaviours. It is upon seeing
this problem it has pushed the researcher into wanting to find out if students were diagnosed at
home using traditional medicine would it be more effective than using modern medicine in
which the health care giver provides at the clinic or pharmacy. The researcher has also been
wondering if most illness that affects the students and their families, which medicine is more
“The greatest assets of a country are healthy people.” The researcher realizes that most
persons know so little about traditional medicine and in order to educate the minds and get the
people to be healthier tradional medicine should be learned about and promoted within the
school.
5|Page
Relevance of topic
Medicine has evolved due to the advance in knowledge and advent of technology which
increases the effectiveness of modern medicine but regardless of this development many
countries or area of these countries have still been using traditional medicine and for this reason
New technologies have always been the driving forces for major developments in
understanding the genomic and molecular origins of life and the reasons for disease; they are
also transforming evolutionary biology into a new, precise, molecular science that has enormous
Central High School is a rural high school of virtually 2024 students most of which are
growing up in rural families. This school is located in May Pen Clarendon at 58 Sevens Road.
The school contains several different family backgrounds which will help in getting different
opinions towards the problem statement “The effectiveness of modern medicine versus
traditional (herbs) medicine on the families of students in a rural high school in Jamaica and the
impact of using these either medicine.” And also to test the hypothesis “: Modern medicine is
more effective than traditional medicine for the health of Central High school students and their
families.”
6|Page
Purpose of Research
To find out why families prefer to use pharmaceuticals instead of herbs even though herbs are
widely available, has a lower cost, suitable for most chronic diseases and has proven to have
little or no side effect. The researcher also want find out which type of medicines is more
effective which is modern versus traditional and the impact of using the medicines. The
researcher specifically has chosen youths as an audience to find out if the drugs that are used
contributes to mental and physical health .It is important to study the medicine taken because it
can be traced back to ones behaviour and ones behaviour is liked to their actions. Youth violence
Research Questions
1. Why are persons turning away from modern medicine to aid in their physical health?
3. How can students/people become educated about traditional medicine and the benefits it
offers?
7|Page
Educational Value
The research conducted will give insights to the families of these students on which
medicines are best suited for certain illnesses. These families will spend less money and may
handle the event of sickness within the family more quickly and more effectively.
in some way.
Modern- Pertaining to a current or recent time and space and or style; not ancient.
Herbs- any plant with leaves, seeds, or flowers used for flavoring, medicine or perfume.
8|Page
Literature
Review
9|Page
Literature Review
2015, they argue that “Modern medicine has extended our lives and we can now treat disease and
illnesses with more ease. Traditional medicine involved herbs and plants which were not always
effective because persons still died of simple illnesses such as chicken pox and even common
cold.” Furthermore the article states that “Some traditional treatments work well but modern
medicine just takes these traditional treatments and makes them more effective. Modern
medicine can have side effects, but if taken with regulation and not in overdose, modern
George Town University 1993, in his book The Virtues In Medical Practice implies that
“modern medicines are like fertilizers which are good at first but slowly shows their side effects,
Furthermore, Physiologist, Dr. Kennel Fenton 2008, argues that “Modern medicine can
treat long-term diseases much quicker and with less side effects as opposed to traditional.” With
modern medicine you can store it and have it in household whereas traditional medicine is not
However ,In an article published by the BBC of the year 2013, which states “traditional
medicine are less effective and have high risk due to inexperienced practitioners while on the
other hand modern medicine has been clinically tested and trialed and its effectiveness proven to
surpass traditional medicine by more than 65%.” In other words traditional medicine has many
different chemicals which may be harmful, while modern medicine chemical content is more
10 | P a g e
Moreover, Dr. Earnest Baldwin in an article written in March of the year 2000 and
published by Springer, he stipulates that “modern medicine is ineffective, in that it makes you
more ill with all of its debilitating and dangerous side effects which causes people to make other
visits to doctor's office, only to prescribe more drugs.” Modern medicine is an endless cycle of
However, Herbal medicine according to an article posted by Dr. David Winston, “It is
deemed important to recognize that most of these medical systems also see herbs as more than
their “active constituents". In Cherokee medicine, plants has a personality which when
appropriately matched with an ill patient gently stimulates the patient back to wholeness
(homeostasis). This vital force affects not only the physical body, but the mind and spirit as well
According to Modern medicine vs. alternative medicine article posted by WHO on,
August 8, 2008 it states that an “international herbal medicine research, several practical
pharmaceutical development, a step-wise process of drug testing occurs. They often come into
Accordingly, in clinical herbal medicine research there is rarely a strong preclinical basis
for dosing, and there are significant looming questions about product purity, quality, chemical
stability and active constituents at the time herbal medicine trials are proposed.” Furthermore,
“In recent years there has been a growing interest in traditional medicine and their relevance to
He later on in the article spoke of the advantage of traditional medicine. ”This is due to
factors such has diversity, easy accessibility, broad continuity, relative low cost, low levels of
11 | P a g e
technological input, relatively low side effects and growing economic importance are some of
the positive features of traditional medicine. In this context, there is a critical need to mainstream
traditional medicine practice into public health care to achieve the objective of improved access
In concluding, According to a book called Traditional and Modern medicine which was
published on July 28, 2014,” It states that Traditional and modern systems of medicine were
diseases and causes of diseases in different ways. These differences bring different approaches to
health and diseases. However, both systems deal with the same subject – human being. The old
12 | P a g e
Data Collection Sources
13 | P a g e
Data Collection Sources
In the quest of ascertaining knowledge and understanding from the problem statement
which is “The effectiveness of modern medicine versus traditional medicine on the physical
health of students’ /family member at a rural high school in Jamaica.” An assessment was done
from a sample of students mixed from every grade. The research done was a quantitative one
therefore a combination of primary and secondary sources were utilized to collect the relevant
information needed. The primary source used was questionnaires, which is a list of questions
usually printed and issued to a sample population in order to gather information on a particular
topic. A total of 89 questionnaires were issued to different students. The secondary sources were
the internet and books. Articles, blogs, debate and books were the materials written by the
secondary sources found on the internet. The persons who wrote the books and articles are
experts in the field of studies or have conducted the research themselves which makes the
researchers use of sources credible and reliable. The primary sources used contributed to the
research in every way because the questionnaire gave insights to my sample group and the
14 | P a g e
Methodology
15 | P a g e
Methodology
Eighty -nine questionnaires were given out upon which only six the researcher did not get
back on the day by which the researcher was collecting the questionnaires. The data was
collected within the middle part of October at any given time the researcher tried to find out if
the respondent was finish with the questionnaire. The data was collected from student from grade
nine to upper six. Questionnaires were hard and soft documents …hard copy for the small
children and soft copy (online questionnaire) to the older set if students.
16 | P a g e
Presentation of data
17 | P a g e
50% Age of students of the sample group at Central high
45% 45%
40%
35% 35%
age of students
30%
25%
Percentage
20% 20%
15%
10%
5%
0%
12 to 13 15 to17 17-21
According to the line graph above twenty percent of the junior students are ages twelve to
thirteen, thirty-five percent of the senior students range from the ages fifteen to seventeen and
also forty-five percent of the students at the six form level ranges from ages seventeen to twenty-
one.
18 | P a g e
Types of families which are present among the sample
population
16%
21%
nuclear family
single parent family
entended family
63%
Figure 2: Pie chart showing the types of families to which are present among the sample
population of students attending the Central high school. According to the pie chart above fifteen
percent of the population sample are from nuclear families, sixty percent are a part of a single
19 | P a g e
Health status of students /family member rate of illness
Seldom 30%
Often 45%
Figure 3: Bar chart showing the health status of students along with their family member
frequency of illness. Thirty percent of the students’ state that they get sick often, twenty-five
percent of the students state that they get sick very often and forty-five percent of the students
20 | P a g e
Have you ever tried using traditional medicine to help
with illness ?
40%
60%
Figure 4: Pie chart showing the amount of students who uses traditional medicine to help
with illness.
According to the pie chart above sixty percent of the students stated that they don’t use
traditional medicine and another forty percent said yes they use traditional medicine to help with
illness.
21 | P a g e
The effectiveness of traditional medicine
60%
50%
40%
60%
30%
40%
20%
10% 0%
0%
Very effective Barely effective Not effective
Axis Title
According to the students forty percent stated that it is very effective while another sixty percent
22 | P a g e
The Type of Medicine Used by Families to Counter Illnesses
Series 1
Axis Title
Figure 7: Bar chart showing the type of medicine used by families to counter health issues.
According to the chart above fourteen percent of the respondents uses both modern and
traditional medicine another sixteen percent stated that they use traditional medicine and seventy
23 | P a g e
The best way to promote traditi onal medicines
benefi ts
5%
15%
50%
30%
Figure 8: Pie chart showing the best way to promote the benefits of traditional medicine.
According to the chart above 50% of the students stated that herbal television show is the best
medium to promote the benefits of (herbs) which is majority, 5% of the respondents stated that
herbalist should be invited into the schools, 15% of the students stated that school health
campaigns and another 30% stated that annual health campaigns is the best medium to promote
24 | P a g e
Discussion of Findings
25 | P a g e
Discussion of Findings
The researcher interest was driven to investigate “The effectiveness of modern medicine versus
traditional (herbs) medicine on the physical health of students’/ family members who are at
Central high school between the ages 12-21 years old. A statement which most persons agreed
that modern medicine has a negative effect on their physical health or family member while a
minority did not think so. About three –quarter of the respondents stated that they or a family
member get sick often, Majority of the respondents stated that traditional medicine has less side
effects on their physical health, When the students where asked how long illness last whenever
they use traditional medicine majority stated that illness take a longer time to go away than
According to Cherokee medicine blog, each plant has a personality which when
appropriately matched with an ill patient gently stimulates the patient back to wholeness
(homeostasis). This vital force affects not only the physical body, but the mind and spirit as well
Based on a statement to which most persons stated that modern medicine is more
effective than traditional medicine based on majority of the respondents while others differ in
According to Debate.org which gave a valid and credible insight to this controversial
issue. They stated that which coincides with the research results that we can now treat diseases
with more ease and that traditional medicine is less effective than modern medicine. However
conversely to this, Edmund D. Pellegrino professor of medicine implies that modern medicine
26 | P a g e
effectiveness decreases over time. The truth to this statement was proven because when students
were asked if the effectiveness of modern medicine decreased after persistent use, 80% of the
students stated that that its effectiveness decreased while the others stated it works all the time.
Dr. Kennel Fenton stated that “modern medicine has less side effects than traditional medicine
and can treat diseases with more ease” this statement was not agreed to when the question asked
by the researcher; Most of the students stated that Traditional medicine has less side effects than
that the student prefer modern medicine over traditional ,this was discovered by virtue of the
question “If you had an illness which medicine would you use to assist you?”
To the question “which medicine is more safely administered?” All of the students stated
that modern is more safely administered and also when they were asked to comment majority
stated that using traditional medicine has high risks. They also stated that modern medicine are
distributed by persons who are highly qualified in the health care sector. This supports the BBC's
claim that “traditional medicine has high risk due to untrained practitioners.” Students were also
asked to give a reason for their selection which all stated that modern medicine is designed and
has been tested, similar to what the BBC has said “modern medicine has been clinically tested
and trialed.”
Supporting Dr. Earnest Baldwin's claim that “modern medicine makes you more ill with its
debilitating and dangerous side effects which causes patients to visit the doctor’s office again
27 | P a g e
“Do you think modern medicine industries are more about making money than actually saving
lives?” Majority stated that modern medicine industries are more about making money than
actually saving lives and a follow up question was asked majority of the respondent stated they
on, August 8,2008 it states that an “international herbal medicine research, several practical
pharmaceutical development, a step-wise process of drug testing occurs. They often come into
use by a process of trial and error, or over centuries.” However, when the question was asked
most of the respondents do not take both Traditional and modern medicine together they took it
separate and most of them prefer modern medicine. They also claimed it is more effective.
He later on in the article spoke of the advantage of traditional medicine. ”This is due to
factors such has diversity, easy accessibility, broad continuity, relative low cost, low levels of
technological input, relatively low side effects and growing economic importance are some of
the positive features of traditional medicine. In this context, there is a critical need to mainstream
traditional medicine practice into public health care to achieve the objective of improved access
to health care facilities.” However, when the question was asked “Why do you think modern
The urgency of the issues is by far been not examined or properly noticed. It is very
important to know which medicine is better for the health of students due to the fact that
these children will grow up to be the future generation. The students will contribute to
making Jamaica a place to live, work and raise family. There are several implications of
using modern medicine due to the many side effects of using it, taking into consideration
28 | P a g e
both physical and mental effect on the person using the drug. Traditional medicine has
implication also such as herb not given for the correct illness, slow recovery, over dosage etc.
There are so many more implication that has not being mentioned for both traditional and
The Ministry of Health should educate the population on the effects of modern medicine and
Traditional medicine should be promoted more by the media, this is a way to reach the
audiences because both the young and the old utilizes the services offered by the media. This
will not just strengthen the medical system it will activate our history that we have long
forgotten. This will work because it is a modern world and almost everyone have access to a
Precautionary measure:
The wider population should consult a medical doctor before consuming traditional medicine
29 | P a g e
30 | P a g e
Analysis of Findings
31 | P a g e
Analysis of findings
The effectiveness of modern medicine verses traditional medicine on the physical health
of students at Central High school was investigated. Based on the findings of study, it can be
deduced that Central high School sample population twenty percent of the junior students were
ages twelve to thirteen, thirty-five percent of the senior students range from the ages fifteen to
seventeen and also forty-five percent of the pre-university students ranges from ages seventeen
to twenty-one who answered the questionnaires. See figure 1. The bulk of the information was
collected from the mature set of students therefore the data collected would have been a credible
one.
To the question asked, to ascertain the type of medicine the student's families used to
counter the illnesses, 70% of the students stated they used modern medicine while 16% stated
they used traditional medicine and 14% stated they used both medicines see figure 7.
60% of the respondents who used modern medicine are a part of single parent families, while
15% nuclear families and 20% extended families see figure3. 90% of the 16% who stated they
used traditional medicine are a part of extended families. The students were asked to comment
on how long the illnesses persist while taking modern and/or traditional medicine. 70% stated
while taking both medicine the illnesses took a short period of time to subside while 16% stated
while using traditional medicine the illnesses didn’t persist too long and 14% stated the same for
modern medicine. 90% of the respondents said they think modern medicine is more effective
than traditional medicine, most of which stated this was due to modern medicine being highly
specific. The remaining 10% stated that traditional medicine is more effective which was due to
it having less side effects compared to modern medicine whose side effects made one feel more
ill.
32 | P a g e
Majority of the respondents were apart of both single and extended families while
minority was a part of the nuclear families. This implies that some students who are from the
extended families would have been using traditional medicine more than modern medicine.
Hence, the extended families would most likely be introduced to traditional medicine by their
grandparents and other generations before theirs. The single parent family is a family that will
more likely to face severe challenges regarding their financial aid .This therefore makes them
more successible to health issues. Thirty percent (45%) of the respondents stated that they got
sick often and the remaining forty percent (30%) stated that they got sick randomly and twenty-
It can be deduced that the respondents think modern medicine is more effective than
traditional medicine even though they all claimed that it had a lot of side effects. Majority of the
respondents stated that they use modern medicine and minority stated that they use traditional
medicine. See figure7. When the students were asked “Does modern medicine affects the
physical health of you or a family member?” 75% of the respondents said yes and 25% of the
respondents said no. On examining this question it can clearly show that the side effect of these
drugs have been doing harm to a large amount of respondents or their family. When the
respondents were asked “Have you ever consider taking traditional medicine to help your
condition?” majority said no. follow up question was asked “If you had a choice which medicine
would you choose to assist with your illness?” all of the respondents said modern medicine . This
implies that the respondents prefers modern medicine because they think it is safer and is a more
drug meaning over the counter . Traditional medicine on the other hand is widely available over
33 | P a g e
“Do you think modern medicine industries are more about making money than actually
saving lives?” 88% percent stated that modern medicine industries are more about making
money than actually saving lives and furthermore when respondents. This is so due to the fact
that when people buy a medicine to treat one health issues they end up have to buy more drugs to
get rid of the problems created by the side effects. In cases where the side effects are not intense
the drug is normally followed up because it does not get rid of the illness.
100% of the respondents stated that modern medicine is more safely administered than compared
to traditional medicine. This was the result of the question “Which medicine is more safely
administered and why?” The respondents claimed that Modern medicine works better and faster
Based on all the researcher has gathered people prefer modern medicine because they know more
about it the researcher thinks that if they are made aware of it they would have a different
response because it cheaper and easier to get because it can be find anywhere in nature. The
researcher personally believes that modern medicine does more bad to health and makes its
patient’s drug dependent. Most modern drug is made with theses natural ingredients however are
processed too much with chemicals so instead patient consume more unnatural chemicals that
As a nation moving forward towards healing the world and building our culture we should
promote mother earths healing wonders “Traditional medicine.” 50% of the students stated that
herbal television show is the best medium to promote the benefits of (herbs) which is majority
and another 30% stated that annual health campaigns is the best medium to promote the benefits
34 | P a g e
Conclusion, limitations and
Recommendation
35 | P a g e
Conclusion, limitation and Recommendation
After the data was collected and analyzed from both primary and secondary sources such
as questionnaires, online journals, articles and blogs. It can therefore be concluded that modern
medicine is more effective than traditional medicine. Modern medicine has several draw backs
because it is known to give a lot of side effects, therefore in my views traditional medicine is
better for the students mental and physical health even though healing process may take a longer
time.
can use to get detailed information from a large audience and also it allows the respondent to
86 questionnaires were issued to some sixth formers and the other questionnaires were
done by the students using the schools computer .There were several issues because not all the
students got the chance to do the questionnaire that’s about half of the student population and not
the view of all the student. Some questionnaires were unreturned, out of 86 only 72 were
returned. It can therefore be seeing that the accuracy of the research on this sample
population may not be as reliable as it should. The researcher could not give questionnaires to all
students due to financial circumstances. This will definitely affect the results obtained from this
research.
36 | P a g e
Based on the results obtained from the sample population, the following
The Ministry of Health should educate the population on the effects of modern medicine and
Traditional medicine should be promoted more by the media ,this is a way to reach the
audiences because both the young and the old utilizes the services offered by the media .This
will not just strengthen the medical system it will activate our history that we have long
forgotten.
The wider population should consult a medical doctor before consuming traditional medicine
There should be a special day to highlight the uses of herbs in our country inoder to carve the
minds of the young this will in return help the economy and save more lives while building
More research and also more local programs should be implemented. This should be done
investigate our local herb so that the useful chemicals that the plants have can be extracted
All traditional medical dealers should obtain at list Senior school certificate (WAEC) in order
37 | P a g e
Professional development and conferencing of healers/elders through accessing universities,
health facilities and stakeholders of traditional medicine that support the elders/healers desire
to enhance their skills learn from one another and develop solid networks.
All traditional medicine has to fulfill the same uniform standards, tests and trails before being
More resources and infrastructure need to be committed and promote the use of safe and
There is a need for a campaign that raises awareness of the rights of patients to adequate care,
It is vital that the traditional healing profession be regulated and be brought into the ambit of
current legislation.
38 | P a g e
Reference
Modern medicine vs. alternative medicine, August 8, 2008 retrieved from http://www.
digitalcommons.unl.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=3062&context=libphilprac
Modern medicine is better than traditional medicine, 06/05/2015 retrieved from http://www.
omicsonline.org/blog/2015/05/06/11216-Is-Modern-Medicine-Better-than-Traditional-Medicine.html
Mother Bee v1.0 Development supported by Life Form Inc, 2015 retrieved from
SteadyHealth.com http://
bbc.co.uk/bitesize/ks3/history/uk_through_time/medicine_through_time/revision/3/ on October
15, 2016.
39 | P a g e
Edmund D. Pellegrino and David C. Thomasma, (July 28, 1998-2017) Virtue in medical
practice (205 pp). New York, Oxford University Press, ISBN: 0-19-508289-3.
40 | P a g e
Appendix
This questionnaire is for an internal assessment and all information given will be kept
confidential. The researcher is appreciative of your valuable time and effort in the completion of
this questionnaire.
*Instruction: Please read all questions carefully and answer all questions by indicating a tick in
the box provided and answer on the lines provided for the option others.
1. Gender
□ Male
□ Female
2. How long have you been attending Central High School?
□ 1-3 years
□ 3-5 years
□ 5-7 years
3. What type of family are you apart of?
□ Nuclear family
□ Single parent
□ Extended family
□ Sibling family
4. How old are you?
□ 12-13 years
□ 15-17 years
□ 17-21 years
5. Does modern medicine affects the physical health of you or a family member?
□ Yes
□ No
6. Have you ever consider taking traditional medicine to help any condition?
□ Yes
□ No
41 | P a g e
If yes state
why:__________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________
□ Often
□ Very often
□ Seldom
Comment on how long do the illnesses persist with each of the medicine whether traditional and
or modern
□ Modern
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
42 | P a g e
□ Traditional
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
□ Both
__________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
12. Why do you think modern medicine is used more than traditionally or traditional than
modern?
□ Modern is cheaper
□ Traditional cheaper
□ Modern
□ Modern Medicine
□ Traditional Medicine
□ Modern
43 | P a g e
□ Traditional
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
15. Do you think modern medicine industries are more about money making, than actually
saving lives?
□ Making Money
□ Saving lives
16. How do you think traditional medicine’s benefits can be promoted in other to heal the world
and build our culture? (Question is entitled to more than one option of choice)
□ Consult a herbalist
□ School health fair
□ Grandparents
□ Annual health campaign
□ Herbal television show
Others__________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________
44 | P a g e