Agma 929 A06 Calculation of Bevel Gear Top Land and Guidance On Cutter Edge Radius
Agma 929 A06 Calculation of Bevel Gear Top Land and Guidance On Cutter Edge Radius
ii
AMERICAN GEAR MANUFACTURERS ASSOCIATION AGMA 929--A06
Contents
Page
Foreword . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . iv
1 Scope . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1
2 Symbols, terminology and definitions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1
3 Input data . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5
4 Calculations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8
Bibliography . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 38
Annexes
A Additional equations from ANSI/AGMA 2005--D03 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 18
B Stock allowance and standard cutter specifications . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 23
C Spiral bevel example problem . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 24
D Hypoid example problem . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 31
Tables
1 Symbols and terms . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1
2 Input variables . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6
3 Symbols and terms from ANSI/AGMA 2005--D03, table 9 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7
4 Gear rotation factor, kE . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7
5 Suggested defaults for input data . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7
Foreword
[The foreword, footnotes and annexes, if any, in this document are provided for
informational purposes only and are not to be construed as a part of AGMA Information
Sheet 929--A06, Calculation of Bevel Gear Top Land and Guidance on Cutter Edge Radius.]
The Bevel Gearing Committee recognized the need for additional equations to aid in the
design of bevel gears. The equations for geometry factors found in the annex of
ANSI/AGMA 2003--B97 require detailed information on the proposed cutting tool before a
proper calculation can be performed. In addition, the minimum top land thickness is
required to aid in determining the maximum case depth allowed on carburized bevel gears.
The equations required for these values were not published in AGMA documentation, but
could be found, for some cases, in the publications listed in the bibliography of this
information sheet. AGMA 929--A06 expands on those equations to include gears
manufactured with the face hobbing cutting method.
In the case of non--generated gears, the equations in this document may yield different
values for pinion top land thicknesses and gear tooth depth at the toe and heel than obtained
on some well known commercial software. The pinion top land thickness is reduced by
curvature added to the pinion, a natural consequence of the non--generated gear member
having no profile curvature on the teeth. For the gear member, the non--generating process
cuts a rootline tangent to the gear root cone, a rootline which does not wrap around the root
cone as in the generated case. This leaves the toe and heel ends of the tooth slots shallow
compared to the generated gear case, and the gear tooth space at the ends of the teeth
narrower. The non--generated gear is the imaginary generating gear for the pinion. So the
pinion teeth, which fit in the non--generated gear tooth slots, are thinner at the ends than
their generated gear counterparts.
The cutter edge radii calculated in this document are based on the geometrical conditions
present and include a manufacturing gauging flat. Individual blade manufacturers have
standard blade edge radii and manufacturing tolerances for their products which should be
considered when sourcing non--standard radii. It is recommended to work closely with the
blade supplier to ensure design specifications and sourced product specifications are
consistent.
The first draft of AGMA 929--A06 was made in February, 1999. It was approved by the
AGMA Technical Division Executive Committee in August, 2006.
Suggestions for improvement of this document will be welcome. They should be sent to the
American Gear Manufacturers Association, 500 Montgomery Street, Suite 350, Alexandria,
Virginia 22314.
ACTIVE MEMBERS
Table 1 (continued)
Symbol Term Units Where first
used
D, d Pitch diameter, gear or pinion inch Eq 140, Eq 139
FG, FP Face width of gear or pinion inch Eq 25, Eq 2
FiP Hypoid pinion face width from calculation point to inside inch Eq 1
FoP Hypoid pinion face width from calculation point to outside inch Eq 3
FxG Distance from mean cone to cone distance at involute inch Eq 38
curvature
kE Gear rotation factor -- -- Eq 52
N, n Number of teeth, gear or pinion -- -- Eq 79, Eq 79
pm Mean circular pitch inch Eq 27
pn Mean normal circular pitch inch Eq 27
Q Intermediate factor inch Eq 35
q Generating angle at mean degrees Eq 9
qi Generating angle at inside degrees Eq 13
qo Generating angle at outside degrees Eq 11
qx Generating angle at involute curvature degrees Eq 39
RbNG1, RbNP2 Mean normal base radius, convex, gear or pinion inch Eq 143, Eq 142
RbNG2, RbNP1 Mean normal base radius, concave, gear or pinion inch Eq 144, Eq 141
RibVG, RibVP Inner base radius -- concave, gear or pinion inch Eq 90, Eq 87
RibXG, RibXP Inner base radius -- convex, gear or pinion inch Eq 89, Eq 88
RiG, RiP Original inner pitch radius, gear or pinion inch Eq 76, Eq 75
RioG, RioP Inner outside radius, gear or pinion inch Eq 86, Eq 85
RNG, RNP Mean normal pitch radius, gear or pinion inch Eq 140, Eq 139
RoNG, RoNP Mean normal outside radius, gear or pinion inch Eq 146, Eq 145
R′bNG1, Outer normal base radius, convex, gear or pinion inch Eq 160, Eq 159
R′bNP2
R′bNG2, Outer normal base radius, concave, gear or pinion inch Eq 161, Eq 158
R′bNP1
R′iG, R′iP New inner pitch radius, gear or pinion inch Eq 84, Eq 83
R′NG, R′NP Outer normal pitch radius, gear or pinion inch Eq 157, Eq 156
R′oNG, R′oNP Outer normal outside radius, gear or pinion inch Eq 163, Eq 162
R′′bNG1, Inner normal base radius, convex, gear or pinion inch Eq 179, Eq 178
R′′bNP2
R′′bNG2, Inner normal base radius, concave, gear or pinion inch Eq 180, Eq 177
R′′bNP1
R′′NG, R′′NP Inner mean normal pitch radius, gear or pinion inch Eq 176, Eq 175
R′′oNG, R′′oNP Inner normal outside radius, gear or pinion inch Eq 182, Eq 181
rc Cutter radius inch Eq 9
rTG, rTP Maximum blade edge radius, gear or pinion inch Eq 74, Eq 73
r1G, r1P Maximum blade edge radius for no running interference, inch Eq 74, Eq 73
gear or pinion
r1VG, r1VP Maximum blade edge radius for no running interference inch Eq 106, Eq 103
concave, gear or pinion
r1XG, r1XP Maximum blade edge radius for no running interference inch Eq 105, Eq 104
convex, gear or pinion
r2G, r2P Maximum blade edge radius that can be manufactured, inch Eq 74, Eq 73
gear or pinion
r2RG, r2RP Roughing cutter edge radius, gear or pinion inch Eq 113, Eq 114
(continued)
Table 1 (continued)
Symbol Term Units Where first
used
r3G, r3P Maximum blade edge radius to avoid mutilation, gear or inch Eq 74, Eq 73
pinion
r3VG, r3VP Maximum blade edge radius to avoid mutilation concave, inch Eq 136, Eq 133
gear or pinion
r3XG, r3XP Maximum blade edge radius to avoid mutilation convex, inch Eq 135, Eq 134
gear or pinion
r′2RG, r′2RP Maximum roughing blade edge radius which can be inch Eq 111, Eq 112
manufactured, gear or pinion
r′2VG, r′2VP Maximum finishing blade edge radius concave, defined by inch Eq 118, Eq 115
maximum roughing blade edge radius and minimum stock
allowance, gear or pinion
r′2XG, r′2XP Maximum finishing blade edge radius convex, defined by inch Eq 117, Eq 116
maximum roughing blade edge radius and minimum stock
allowance, gear or pinion
r′′2VG, r′′2VP Maximum finishing blade edge radius concave, gear or inch Eq 122, Eq 119
pinion
r′′2XG, r′′2XP Maximum finishing blade edge radius convex, gear or inch Eq 121, Eq 120
pinion
SAG, SAP Stock allowance, gear or pinion inch Eq 65, Eq 66
S1 Crown gear to cutter center distance inch Eq 34
Tmn, tmn Mean normal circular thickness at pitch line, gear or inch Eq 47, Eq 48
pinion
Tn Gear mean normal circular thickness without backlash inch Eq 47
tiNG, tiNP Inner normal circular thickness at pitch line, gear or pinion inch Eq 189, Eq 188
tLiNG, tLiNP Inner normal top land, gear or pinion inch Eq 192, Eq 190
tLNG, tLNP Mean normal top land, gear or pinion inch Eq 154, Eq 152
tLoNG, tLoNP Outer normal top land, gear or pinion inch Eq 173, Eq 171
tmP Mean pinion transverse circular thickness inch Eq 49
toNG, toNP Outer normal circular thickness at pitch line, gear or inch Eq 170, Eq 169
pinion
W Finishing point width gear (Unitool and single sided) inch Table 2
WBG, WBP Finishing blade point, gear or pinion inch Eq 69, Eq 70
WBRG, WBRP Roughing blade point, gear or pinion inch Eq 67, Eq 68
W′e Effective gear point width inch Eq 52
WiG, WiP Inner slot width, gear or pinion inch Eq 59, Eq 60
WLG, WLP Minimum slot width, gear or pinion inch Eq 61, Eq 62
WMG, WMP Maximum slot width, gear or pinion inch Eq 63, Eq 64
WmG, WmP Mean slot width, gear or pinion inch Eq 50, Eq 51
WoG, WoP Outer slot width, gear or pinion inch Eq 55, Eq 56
WRG, WRP Roughing point width, gear or pinion inch Eq 65, Eq 66
WxG, WxP Slot width at AxG (maximum gear or pinion slot) inch Eq 57, Eq 58
xiVG, xiVP Limit tooth height for interference concave, gear or pinion inch Eq 102, Eq 97
xiXG, xiXP Limit tooth height for interference convex, gear or pinion inch Eq 101, Eq 99
y Amount of fillet mutilation permitted inch Eq 129
Γ, γ Pitch angle, gear or pinion degrees Eq 76, Eq 75
ΓR Gear root angle degrees Eq 17
ΔaG, ΔaP Change in inner addendum, gear or pinion inch Eq 80, Eq 79
(continued)
Table 1 (continued)
Equivalent symbol
from ANSI/AGMA
Symbol 2005--D03 Term
AmG Am Gear mean cone distance
AmP Am Pinion mean cone distance
AoG Ao Gear outer cone distance
AoP Ao Pinion outer cone distance
FG F Gear face width
FP F Pinion face width
φ1 φ Pressure angle -- drive side
φ2 φ Pressure angle -- coast side, set φ2 to --φ1
ψG ψ Gear mean spiral angle
ψoG ψo Outer gear spiral angle
ψP ψ Pinion mean spiral angle
q o = arctan r c cos ψ oG
A oG − r c sin ψ oG
(11)
Inner pinion dedendum
b iP = b oP − F P tan δ P (24)
Inner gear dedendum For the third and subsequent trials iterate.
Non--generated gear If AiG < AxG < AoG, calculate FxG, qx, Δqx, ΔbxG, bxP
and Σbx; otherwise, set these items to zero.
b iG = b′ oG − F G tan δ G − Δb iG (25)
Distance from mean cone to cone distance at
Generated gear
involute curvature
b iG = b oG − F G tan δ G (26)
F xG = A xG − A mG (38)
Mean normal circular pitch Generating angle at involute curvature
W oG = W′ e A cos ψ oG
1 − oG
A
+ oG
W iG = W′ e 1 −
A iG cos ψ iG
A mG cos ψ G
A
+ iG
A mG
A mG cos ψ G A mG
A iG cos ψ iG
A cos ψ oG × t mP cos ψ iG − b
A mG cos ψ G G
× t mP cos ψ oG − oG
A mG cos ψ G
A iG cos ψ iG
× tan φ 1 − tan φ 2 +
B A oG cos ψ oG
× b Gtan φ 1 − tan φ 2 +
cos
Σφ
2 × B + A mG − A iG
cos
Σφ
2
+ A mG − A oGtan φ 1 − tan φ 2 tan ξ
(55) × tan φ 1 − tan φ 2 tan ξ (59)
The cutter edge radius for a bevel gear should not R ioP = R iP + a iP (85)
exceed the radius that would cause any of the Inner gear outside radius
following conditions: R ioG = R iG + a iG (86)
-- running interference, see 4.3.1; Inner pinion base radius
-- unable to manufacture radius on blade, see Concave
4.3.2; R ibVP = R iP cos φ 1 (87)
-- fillet mutilation, see 4.3.3. Convex
Maximum pinion blade edge radius R ibXP = R iP cos φ 2 (88)
R iP =
A iP tan γ
(75)
φ iV = arccos
R ibVP
R′ iP
(91)
cos2 ψ iP
Convex
Original inner gear pitch radius
R iG =
A iG tan Γ φ iX = arccos
R ibXP
R′ iP
(92)
cos 2 ψ iG (76)
Inner pinion profile radius of curvature
Pinion inner addendum
Concave
a iP = b iG − c (77)
à iVP = R′ iP sin φ iV − R2ioG − R2ibXG + R′iG sin φiV
Gear inner addendum
(93)
a iG = b iP − c (78) Convex
Change in inner pinion addendum
à iXP = R′ iP sin φ iX − R2ioG − R2ibVG + R′iG sin φiX
Δa P = Δc G n cos Γ (79) (94)
n cos Γ + N cos γ
Change in inner gear addendum Inner gear profile radius of curvature
N cos γ Convex
Δa G = Δc P (80)
n cos Γ + N cos γ Ã iXG = R′ iG sin φ iV − R2ioP − R2ibVP + R′iP sin φiV
Adjusted inner pinion addendum
(95)
a′ iP = a iP + Δa P (81)
Concave
Adjusted inner gear addendum
à iVG = R′ iG sin φ iX − R2ioP − R2ibXP + R′iP sin φiX
a′ iG = a iG + Δa G (82)
(96)
New inner pinion pitch radius Limit tooth height for interference, pinion, concave
R′ iP = R iP − Δa P (83) Generated gear
New inner gear pitch radius x iVP = R ibVP cos φ 1 + Ã iVP sin φ 1 − R iP + b iP
R′ iG = R iG − Δa G (84) (97)
otherwise, Convex
r 1P = r 1XP (108) S AG
r′ 2XG = + r 2RG (117)
Maximum blade edge radius for no running 2 sec φ 1 − tan φ 1
interference on gear tooth Concave
if, r1VG < r1XG S AG
r′ 2VG = + r 2RG (118)
r 1G = r 1VG (109) 2 sec φ 2 + tan φ 2
The following four r′′ calculations are as defined by If any of the following Ω values are negative, reduce
the finishing cutter: WBP or WBG accordingly:
The values of r′′ are never negative; if necessary Pinion intermediate blade mutilation value
reduce Δf:
Concave
Maximum pinion finishing blade edge radius
Ω VP = y 2 + 2y ΔW′ P sec φ 1 − tan φ 1 (129)
Concave
Convex
W BP − Δf
r″ 2VP =
sec φ 1 − tan φ 1
(119) Ω XP = y 2 + 2y ΔW′ P sec φ 2 + tan φ 2 (130)
Difference between pinion minimum slot width and Therefore, maximum pinion blade edge radius to
finishing blade point avoid mutilation
Difference between gear minimum slot width and Therefore, maximum gear blade edge radius to
finishing blade point avoid mutilation
ΔW′ G = W LG − W BG (128) r 3G = minimum of r 3VG, or r 3XG (138)
R NG = 0.5 D A mG
cos Γ cos ψ G A oG
2 (140)
− invφ 2TP R oNP (152)
NOTE: “inv” is the mathematical function involute. It is
Mean normal pinion base radius the tangent of the angle minus the angle in radians.
Concave Non--generated
R bNP1 = R NP cos φ 1
Convex
(141)
t LNP = Rt mn
NP
+ invφ 1 − invφ 1TP + inv− φ 2
Concave Non--generated
R′ bNG2 = R′ NG cos φ 2 (161)
Outer normal pinion outside radius
t LoNP = t oNP
R′ NP
+ invφ 1 − invφ′ 1TP + inv−φ 2
R′ oNG = R′ NG − a oP (164)
Pressure angle at tip of pinion tooth (outer)
− invφ′ 2TG R′ oNG (172)
R′ bNP2
φ′ 2TP = arccos
R′ oNP
(166)
− invφ′ 2TG R′ oNG
(173)
Pressure angle at tip of gear tooth (outer) Non--generated
Convex t LoNG = t oNG − a oGtan φ 1 − tan φ 2 (174)
R′
φ′ 1TG = arccos bNG1 (167)
R′ oNG
4.4.3 Inner top lands
Concave
Inner mean normal pinion pitch radius
R′
φ′ 2TG = arccos bNG2 (168) 0.5 d A iP
R′ oNG R″ NP =
cos γ cos ψ iP A oP
2 (175)
Outer normal pinion circular thickness at pitch line
Inner mean normal gear pitch radius
t oNP = b oG tan φ 1 − tan φ 2 + W oG A iG
R″ NG = 0.5 D
− B cos Γ cos 2 ψ iG A oG (176)
cos
Σφ
2
(169)
Inner normal pinion base radius
Inner normal gear outside radius Inner normal gear thickness at pitch line
A iG
Generated t iNG = b iPtan φ 1 − tan φ 2 + W iP −
A oG
R″ oNG = R″ NG + a iG (182) cos ψ iG B
×
Non--generated
cos ψ oG
cos
Σφ
2
(189)
Concave
t LiNP = t iNP
R″ NP
+ invφ 1 − invφ″ 1TP + inv−φ 2
Convex Non--generated
Convex − t
iNG + a iP tan φ 1 − tan φ 2
Annex A
(informative)
Additional equations from ANSI/AGMA 2005--D03
[This annex is provided for informational purposes only and should not be construed as a part of AGMA 929--A06,
Calculation of Bevel Gear Top Land and Guidance on Cutter Edge Radius.]
A.1 Purpose
This annex is to provide the user additional equa- 2005--D03. The additional symbols used in the
tions that are in or derived from those in ANSI/AGMA equations are defined in table A.1. Also see table 1.
ψ iG = arcsin 2A mG r c sin ψ G − A 2
2A iG r c
mG
+ A2
iG
η o = arccos A 2 + S 21 − r 2c
oG
(A.6)
2 A oG S 1
(A.2)
intermediate variable (face hobbing) outer gear spiral angle (face hobbing)
S1
Q=
N
1+ S
Nc
(A.3) ψ oG = arctan A oG − Q cos η o
Q sin η o
(A.7)
η i = arccos A 2 + S 21 − r 2c
iG
2A iG S 1
(A.4)
cos η 1 =
A mG cos ψ G
S1 Nc
N c + N S (A.8)
ζ i = arctan E tan ΔΣ cos Γ
A iG − Z cos Γ
(A.12) outer pinion pitch angle
γ oo = arcsinsin ΔΣ sin Γ + cos ΔΣ cos Γ cos ε o
pinion inner offset angle in axial plane
(A.20)
ε i + ζ i = arcsin
E cos ζ i sin Γ
A iG − Z cos Γ
(A.13) pinion offset angle in pitch plane at outer end
sin ε
ε′ i = arcsin cos γi
i
(A.15)
pinion dedendum angle
δP = γ − γR (A.23)
Annex B
(informative)
Stock allowance and standard cutter specifications
[This annex is provided for informational purposes only and should not be construed as a part of AGMA 929--A06,
Calculation of Bevel Gear Top Land and Guidance on Cutter Edge Radius.]
Annex C
(informative)
Spiral bevel example problem
[This annex is provided for informational purposes only and should not be construed as a part of AGMA 929--A06,
Calculation of Bevel Gear Top Land and Guidance on Cutter Edge Radius.]
Annex D
(informative)
Hypoid example problem
[This annex is provided for informational purposes only and should not be construed as a part of AGMA 929--A06,
Calculation of Bevel Gear Top Land and Guidance on Cutter Edge Radius.]
Bibliography
The following documents are either referenced in the text of AGMA 929--A06, Calculation of Bevel Gear Top
Land and Guidance on Cutter Edge Radius, or indicated for additional information.
Gleason Bevel & Hypoid Gear Terminology, Publication No. SD 4053A--1971--C&T, Gleason Works.
Formulas for Cutter Specifications and Tooth Thickness Measurements for Spiral Bevel and Hypoid Gears, SD
3124B, Jan 1982, Gleason Works.