Introduction to Decision Analysis, BITS Pilani
BITS Pilani
Pilani Campus
Decision Analysis ZG535
The premise
Lecture 2
Introduction to Decision Analysis, BITS Pilani
Myths
• Decisions are made in boardrooms - Tacit knowledge
• Decision making follows a linear pattern - Know what you don’t know
• We make good decisions when we are not influenced by emotions -
Phineas P. Gage case
• Smart people make good decisions - Brilliant Blunders
2
Introduction to Decision Analysis, BITS Pilani
The way we decide The way we think we
should decide
Descriptive Normative
Introduction to Decision Analysis, BITS Pilani
1
Thought 4 Action 3
2
Introduction to Decision Analysis, BITS Pilani
Personality 1. Speed
Preferences
2. Comfort
External factors 3. Cost
1. Rush
2. Traffic
Decision
Alternatives Values,
Resources
1. Public transport
2. Bike
3. Car
Introduction to Decision Analysis, BITS Pilani
A decision can be defined as a ‘choice’ between two or
more ‘alternatives’ that involves an ‘irrevocable’
allocation of ‘resources’ A mental commitment or
intention is not a decision
Resource Decision
Intent
commit
Introduction to Decision Analysis, BITS Pilani
A decision that gets the expected outcome is a good decision – Statistician's
1
world.
A decision that gets the highest favourable outcome is a good decision –
2
Politician’s world.
A decision that beats the competition and helps lead the market is a good
3
decision – Strategists’ world.
4 A decision that is rationally taken is a good decision – Westerners’ world.
5 There is nothing called good or bad – A scientist’s world.
6 Sorry, I am confused – An engineer’s world.
I have written a best selling book that is794 pages, please read it – A
7
philosopher’s world.
Introduction to Decision Analysis, BITS Pilani
Reach home He is
Stay back
safe fortunate
Quality of
Decision Quality of
Drive under MeetOutcome
with an
influence accident Bad luck
Introduction to Decision Analysis, BITS Pilani
Is this not counter intuitive?
Should we not be looking at the result
while making a decision?
Have you or others judged
your decision based on its outcome?