Chapter 13 Financial Management by Cabrera
Chapter 13 Financial Management by Cabrera
ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE
.ANDJNVENTORY I •
MANAGEMENT
~f.Mrni"j ()ufco,n11 .
1' . 3. Explain the nature of credit policy and understand its · '
elements.
' . '
••••
CHAP TER 13
INTRODUCTION
Althou_gh some sales are made for cash, today the vast majority of sales· are on
credit. Thus in typical ·si~uation, goods are shipped, inventories are reduced and an
·account receivable is created.
Accounts receivable consists of money owed to a firm for goods and services sold
on credit. This type of credit basically takes two forms:
OBJECTIVES. OF ACCOUN
. TS RECEIVABLE MANAGEMENT ·
The goal of accoun~s receivable management is to ensure that the firm's investment
. in accounts receivable is appropriate and contributes to shareholder wealth.
maximization. It is therefore the responsibility of the finance officer to evaluate
the pertinent co~s and benefits related to credit extension, to finance the firm's
investment in accounts receivable, implement the firm's credit policy and to
en~orce collection. ·
• CREDIT POLICY
Credit policy is
a set of guidelines for ·extending credit to c~stomers. The success
or failure of a business depends primarily on the demand for its producfs - as a
rule, the higher its sales·, the larger its profits ~d the higher ~e Value of its st~ck.
Sales, in turn, d_epend on a number of factors, .some exogenous but others under
the control of the firm. Tp~ major controllable variables which affect demand are
sales prices, product quality, advertising and the firm's credit policy.
310 Chapter /3
I
.-
Credit policy generally covers the following variables:
1. Credit Standards
• I
I
'◄
Accounl.f Receivable and Inventory Managemdit 311
Credit tenns involve both the.length of the credit period and the discount given.
Credit period is tlJe l~gth of time buyers are given to pay for their purchases.
Discounts are p_rice reductions for early payment. The discqunt specifies what
the percentage reduction is and when payment must be made to be eligible for ..
the.discount. The terms "2/l 0, net 30" mean that a 2% discount is given if the
bill is paid on or·before the tenth day after ~e date of invoice; payme}lt is due
by the thirtieth day: The credit _period, then, is thirty days. Although the
customs of the industry frequently dictate the terms given, the credit perioq if
lengthened generally results to _an increased product demand and vice versa.
3. Collection Policy
!
'· Collection policy refers.to the procedures the firm follows to co11ect past-due
accounts. For example, a letter may be sent to customers when a bill is 10 days
. \ past due; a more severe letter, followed by a telephone call, may_be used_if
• I
payment is not received within 30 days; and the account may be turned over
to a· collection agency after 90 days. Credit analysis is instrumental in
determining the amount of credit risk to be accept~. In tum, the amount of
risk accepted affects the slowness of receivables and the resulting investment·
in receivables, as well as the amount of bad-debt losses. Collection procedures
affect these factors. Within a reasonable range, the greater the relative amount
of
spent on collection procedures, the.lower the proportion bad-debt losses and
· t~e shorte·r the average collection period, all other things remaining the san1e.
So a balance ·must be struck between the costs and benefits of different
collection policies.
Whatever credit policies a bu~iness firm may adopt, there will be some·
customers who will delay and others who will default entirely, thereby
increasing the total accounts receivable costs. Again, the optimal credit policy
that should be adopted is-the one \hat provides the greatest marginal benefit.
r
y
~3~12~iC?!:_n~ap~t~er~l!J3~_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
COSTS ASSOCIATED WITH -INVESTMENT IN ACCOUNTS
_:_~---~~==~~-
RECEIVABLE .
.
I . Credit analysis, accounting and collection costs
Once the tinn extends credit, it must· raise funds in order to·finance it. The ·
interest to be paid if the funds are -borrowed or the opportunity cost of e9uity
capital will constitute the cost of funds that ~ill be tied up in the receivables.
.
3. Delinquency costs
. • I
These co~ are iricurre~ when tf:te customer is late in paying. This delay adds
collection costs above those associated with a normal'collection. Delinquency
also creates an opportunity cost for any additional time the funds are tied up
after the normal collection period. · · ·.
The firm incurs default costs when the.customer fails to pay at all. In addition
to ~he collection 'costs, capitarcosts· and delinquency costs incurred up to this.
po1~t, the firm loses the cost of goods sold not_paid for. It nas to write off the ·
entire sales once it decides the ~elinquent account has defaulted and is no
longer collectible. '
Accounts Receivab/ d
e an Inventory Management 313
SUMMARY OF TRADE-OFFS IN CRE
POUC ES : on AND COLLECllON !..,
Trade-offs
Benefit
I. Relaxation of Cost
a. Increase in sales and
credit total contribution a. Increase in credit
standard.s margin. processing costs.
b. Increase. in collection
costs.
c. Higher default costs
(bad debts). ·
d. ijigher capital costs
2. Lengthening·of a. increase in sales (opportunity costs).
and a. Highei capital costs
credit period total contribution. (QJjportunity cost of
margin. higher investment in ·
~ivabl es).
3. Granting·cash . a. Increase ii:- sales and I '
then be indifferent to
Incremental profit Incremental
3) = cost
the chang e in credit
contribution policy
ABC Corpo ration 's products sells for PJO a unit of which P7 repres ents variab
le
are
costs before taxes including credit department cost. Current annual credit sales
P2.4 miJJion. The firm is considering a more liberal extension of credit ,'whic h will
s.
result in a slowi ng in the average collection ·perrod froln one month to two month
·
The relaxation in credit standards is expected to produce a 25% increase in sales.-
Assum e that the firm's required rate of return on investment is 20% before taxes.
Bad debts losses ·will be 5% of incremental sales and -~o11ection expen ses will
increa se by P20,0 00.
d
Accounts Receivable and Inventory Management, 31S
Solution:
_.. ,.
Incr eme ntal_contribution margin from
addi tion al unit s (60,000 x P3) -
Les~: Bad debt s (P600,000 x 5%) P18 0,00 0
Coll ectio n expe nses · 30,0 00
Tota l 20,0 00
Net incr eme ntal profit P 50,0 00
-.· P130,000.
Req uire d retu rn on additional investment:
Pres ent level of receivables
(P2. 4 mill ion/ 12 mos.)
P20 0,00 0
Lev el of receivables after change in
. cred it poli cy (P3 million"/ 6 mos.)
500, 000
Add ition al receivables
Add ition al investment in-receivables P300,000
(P30 0,00 0 x 70% )
P21 0,00 0
Mul tiply by: Required return 20°/c,
Req uire d retu rn on additional investment
·p 42,000 • I
Conclusion:
· ·
In as muc h as the profit on additional sale s of
P13 0,00 0, exce eds the
requ ired retu rn on the additional investment of P42
,000 , the firm wou ld b~
well -adv ised to rela x i~ cred it standards.
REQ~IRED: Sho uld the com ~any chan ge its term s from
n/2~ to 2/10, n/30 ?
\
316 Chapter /3 · -
Solution: Present Proposed
Opportunity cost .
(Return on investment x
Average Receivables)
Pt60,000
Present ( J2% x P J.~33 M) PI06,667 ·
Proposed ( J2% x P0.888M)
Sales discount . , I
· 96,000
(P8M x· 60% x 2%)
Total _ PI60,000 P202,66Z . I.
•.
, l -
Conclusion: . .
The company would be better•off by main~ining the pr~sent ~redit terms
and policy of not granting c~h discount becal!se of the lesser costs
involved as shown above. ·
INVENTORY MANAGEMENT
INTRODUCTION
Inventories are an essential part of virtually all business operations and must be
acquire4 ahead of sales. The main.classifications of inve~tories are:
\·
r Accounts Receivable and Inventory Management 317
FUNCTIONS OF INVENTORIES
Jnv~ntories, ~ t~ey in the fonn of raw materials, parts and components, work in
process, or fimshed goods may appr~priately He considered as the life-blood of the
prod~cti?n_ - distribut_ion s~st~m. Within this system of l)roduction and
distnbut1on, the followmg functions and use~ of inventories can be identified:
INVENTORY PLANNING
lri using the Inventory_Economic Order Quantity, the following formulas are
followed: . ~ . ·
·Annual Costs
J. Economic Order 2 x demand x 'per
Quantity (EOQ) in units order
Carrying costs per unit
Total Total
a) Total inventory costs -
.Ordering + Canying
Costs Costs
b) Annual derna d · ·ts · 0rdering
Total ordering costs _ --==~__;_:-=:.:n=..:m:.:..=u.::.n::•:. x C ts per
EOQ or order size :~der
--
Accounts Receivable and Inventory Management 319
' a. Determine the economic order quantity for the sets of . '
wine glasses.
Answer:
. '
EOQ - J 2 x 800 x P2S
Pl.SO
' I
= ~244.95
• r
,, .
' I
320 Chapter J3
-===---=~-~~ --__:__::...:_ __:__;__----- --.:..---
Dlustrative Case IV. EOQ, Reorder point Determinatif;m
The following inventory infonnation and relationships for the Baguio Corporation
are available:
Solution:
J
EOQ -
J 2 x 300,000 x PS0
IO x 0.3'0
' .
- , 3. 16~ un~ts bu_t since . orders must be placed in
multiples of J00 units, the effectfve EOQ becomes
3,200.
- (300,000
·so . X
2) + J,000
- lJ,000 units
I
d
Accounts Receivable and Inventory Mahagement 321
Illustrative Case V. Costs associated with Safety Stoc
k , I •
Units
· Safety Stock · Stockout Probability ·
200 0 0%
·100 100 15
1
0 100 15
0 200 12
What is the tot~I cos fof safety stoc~ on an an~ual basi
s with a safety sto~k level
of 100 units?
Solution:
• •
I
Annual carrying cost (100 x PlO). Pl ,000
Annul stockout cost [( 100 x 15%) (S) ( 1O)] 750
Total -Pl,750
• I
~3~22~~C;.!}_h~ap~t~er~/~J~----.- - - - - - - - - - - - - - : -
LEVEL MO~ITORING AND INVENTORY CONTROL SYSTEMS '
Another approach used in determining the reorder point i~ by addi~g the ',
average demand during lead time and buffer ~tock.
\ I •
Questions ' I ,
2. Why does ,float exist and what e,ffect would elec!ronic ·funds transfer
· systems have on float?
3. Ho~ can a firm operate with a negative cash balance on its ·corpor~te
books?
5. What are three quantitative measures that can be aP,plied to the collection ·
policy o~the firm? ,
6. In what form is trade credit most commoniy offered? What is the credit ,
\
I
,7. What costs· are associated with carrying receivables? What costs are
associated with not granting credit? What d() we call the sum of the costs _
for different levels of receivables?
· 9. What are some of the factors that determine the length of the credit period?
Why is the length of the buyer,s operating cycle o~en considered an upper
bound on the length of the credit period?
10~ .In each of the following pairings, indicate which-firm would probably have I •
a longer credi~ period and explain your reasoning. ·
a. F~nn A sells ~ ~ira~le cure for baldness; Firm B sells toupees.
b. Finn A spectaltzes m products for landlords· Firm B specializes -.
in products for renters. '
c. F!rm A sells to customers with an inventory turnover of IO times;-
F~nn B sells to customers with an inventory turnover of 20 times. ,
d. F~rm A sells fres~ fruit; Firm B sells canned fruit. .
e. Finn A sells and installs carpeting; Firm 8 sells rugs.
Accounts Receivable and /nv~ntory Management 325
, 11. What are the d_ifferent inventory types? How do the types differ? Why are
some types said to have dependent demand whereas other types are said
· . to have mdependent- demand?
12. If a comp~ ny, moves to a JIT inventory management system, what ~ill
: . . . happe~ !o inventory turnover? What will happen to total asset turnov er?
What wall happen t~ return on equity (ROE)?
I •
.,-• • > ""
13. If a compa ny's inventory carrying costs are PS million per year and its
-fixed order costs are P8 million per year, do you think the firm keeps too
much i~ventocy on. hand or too little? Why?
14. At least part of Apple' s corporate profits can be traced to 'its inventory
manag ement. Using just-in-time inventory, Apple typically maintains aw
invento ry of three to four days' sales. Competitors such as Hewlett- · ·
P~ckar d and IBM haye attempted to match Apple' s inventory polici~s, but
I • lag far behind . In an industry where the price of PC compo nents continu es
to decline , Ap_ple clearly has a competitive advantage. Why would you say
that it 'is to Apple' s· advantage t<;> have ~uch a short inventory period? If
doing this is· valuable,' why don't all other PC manufacturers switch t9
Apple 's approa ch?
Problems
ProblemI 1
Davis Compa ny sells ori terms of net 45. Its annual credit sales are P912,5 00 and
·its accoun ts receiva ble average ·IS days overdue. Assume a 365-da y year': What is
Davis' investm ent in receivables?
Problem 2
Tyron Inc., has credit sales of P600,000 and 'an avera~ e collect ion period of 25
days. The fimi; s •variabl e cost ratio is 80 percent. The opportunity cost of funds
·invest ed in accounts-receivable is 15 percent. Assume.a 365--day year. ·
Required:
a. What is the accoun ts receivabl~ tu~ove r for Tyron Inc.? . .
b. What is the averag e investmen~ in a~coun~ receiva ble for Tyron Inc.? .·
l.
~3~26~-: _iC~n ~ap~ t'!!_e r~/~J ~----- ------ ~-~-- ----
Problem 3
n credit and amount to P750,000 a year.
8 II O
Butterfly Company's current saJes are
000 and variable costs o
f 85 f
~ercent ·o sales.
The fi nn has fi1xed costs of PI 00, · . ·• d J w1·thout
sa es
·ty hich would penmt 1t to expan t red" ·
Butterf1y has excess capact ,w .. I · t
· add"mon
·mcurnng · aJ fi1xed costs.· One means of expand mg sa
.· es ts o
• ~ c 1t of
.
.
th
net 90 days to applicants who h·ave been turned d<?wn. m e past The .~red1t
manager has prepared sev~ral estimates for each of three risk.classes of appl 1cants.
Required:
a. What are the marginal pretax profits for each risk·class?
b. Which risk classes, if any, should B_utterfly accept as new credit customers?
Problem 4
Jazz Auto Supply is not satisfied with its present credit policy. A proposal under
consideration is to change the credit terms from _1/J 0, net 30 to 2/10, net _30. The
firm's current average collection period is 42.days but it is expected to decline to _ ~
38 days. The percentage of credit customers who take the discount is expected to
increase from 45 percent- to 60 percent under the new policy. Credit sales are
anticipated to remain P400,000 with a contribution margin of 25 percent. The bad
debt losses are forecasted to decrease from 3.0 percent of~redit sales to 2~5 percent.
The finn 's opportunity co_st for investing in additional receivables is I8 perceot.
Should Jaz.z adopt th is change in policy? · ·
Problem 5
Dairy IceCrea~ sells J2,000 gallons of ice cream each month ·from its central
storage facility. Monthly carrying costs ·are PO.JO per gallon and ordering costs are
PSO per order. Ignore potential stockout co_sts and assume a 30-day month.
Required·
. '
a. ~hat is the economic order quantity (EOQ) for the ice cream?
b. What is the average inventory? , ' ,
c. .What is the total inventory cost for the month?
Accounts Receivab/~ and JnvenJory Management 327
problem 6
Fruitcake Specialists sells 36,000 fruit cakes annually. Annual carrying costi, are
PS per fruit cake and the ordering costs are P 100 per order., The firm has decided
to maintain a safety stock of one month's sales or 3,000 fruitcakes. The delivery
time per order is 5 days. Ass.ume a 365-day year.
Required:
a. What is the economic order quantity (EOQ)?
b. What is the average inventory?
c. How many orders should be placed each year?
d. What is the total inventory cost?
.. e. What is the r~rder ·point?
Problem 7
Problem 8
Heidi Company is in the _process of considering a change in its terms of sale_. The
current policy is cash only; the new policy will involve o~e period's credit. Sales
are 40,0qo units per period at ~ p~ice of PS 10 per unit. If credit is offered, the new
price will be P537. Unit sales are not expected to change and all c~stomers are
expected to take the credit. Heidi estimates that 3 ~rcent of credit sales will be
uncollectible. If the required return i6 2.5 percent per period, is the change a good
idea? · · · ·
328 Chapter 13
Problem 9 / I ,
1 • f running shoes per month at a cash price
O
Happy Feet C:ompany sel~s 3,30~ pa~rs olic that involves 30 days' credit
of P90 per pair. The firm 1s considermg a n~w p ereYd.tI ·sales • The cash price w·111
. . . p91 84 per pair on The
an d an mcrease m prrce to . . . d affect the. quantity sold.
remain at P90, and the new polrcy ,s ~ot expecte to. per. .month.
. . d w1.11 be 15 .days. The •required
· return 1s I percent
.
d1scount per10
Require d:
a. How would the new credit tenns be quoted? I '
Problem 10
Require d.·
I
. a. a
Ir'there is . 20· percent"chance of default, should Silicon fill the order? The.
required return is 2 percent per month. This is a one-time sale and the customer
will not buy if credit is not extended .
b. What is the break-even probability in (a)?
c. In ge~eral t~s, how do you think you~ answer to (a) will be affected if th~ • I
customer will purchase the merchandise for cash if the credit is refused? The
c~h price is PI ,090 per unit.
A~counts Receivable and /nven{ory Management 329
problem 11
/
The higher eost-per unit reflects the expense.associated with credit orders, and the
higher price per unit reflects .the existence of a cash discount. The ci:edit period
will be 90 days, ancl the cQst of debt is .75 percent permon th. -
Require d:
a. Based on this i'nformation, should credit be granted?
b. ·In (a), what does·the credit p1:ice per unit have to be a break even?
-c. In (a), suppose we can obtain a credit report for Pl .50 per custome r. Assumi ng
that each custome r buys one uhit and that the credit report correctl y identifie s
all ·custom ers who will not pay, should credit be extende d?
3. Genes1s· o·st
1 r·b
1 utors. sells to retail store
. s·. on credit terms of 2/lO
. , .net
30. Daily sales average 1SO units at a pric e of P300 each .. Assun11ng _
that all sales are on credit and 60% of customers take the
dascoun~ and
pay on day Io while the rest of the customers pay on day
30, the amount
of Genesis' accounts receivable is · ,
a. . Pl ,350,000.. · c. P900,000.
b. P990,000. d. P8 I0,000.
4. A change in credit policy has caused an increase in _sa~es
, an increase
in discounts taken, a .decrease in the amount of bad
debts, and a
decrease in the investment in accounts receivable. Bas
ed upon this
information, the company's
a. Average collection period has decreased.
b. _Percentage discount offered has decreased.
c. Accounts receivable turnover has d~reased ..
d. Working ~J>•tal has increased.
,/
/
111111"'
Account, Receivable and Inventory Managemenl 331
6. .A company p~s to tighten its credit policy. The new policy will
decrease the average number of days in collection from 75 to'50 days
and will reduce the ratio of credit sales to total revenue from 700/o to
60%. The company estimates that projected sales will be 5% less if the
proposed new credit policy is implemented . If projected sales for the
coming years are PSO million, calculate the peso impact on accounts
receivable of this proposed change in credit policy. Assume a 360-day
year.
a. PJ,819,445 decrease. c. P3~)3,334 decrease.
b. P6,500,~0 decrease. d. Pl 8,749,778 inc_rease.
7. A ·company with P4.8 million in credit sales per year plans to relax its
credit · s~ndards, projecting that this will increase credit sales by
P720,000. The company' s average collection per:od for new
customers is expected to be 75 days, and the payment behavior of the.
e~isting custome~-is not expected to change: Variable costs are 80%
of sales. The firm's opportunity cost is 200/o before taxes. Assuming
a 360-day year,' what is-the company' s benefit (loss) on the planned
change in credit terms?
a. PO c. P144,000
b. P28,800 · d. P120,000
8. Which of the .following represenfs a finn:s average gross receivables
balance?
a. I on·ly. c. II only.
b. I and II only. d. U and III only.
1111
332 Chapter J3'
.IO. The high cost of Short-term fi_n~ricing has r~cently caused a.com pan
---
· ,to reevaluate
, the terms
. of credit 1t e_xtends tob its customers.
t h The
. . . cu rrentY
policy. is J/10, net 60: · lf'customers can orrow a t e pnme rat
I ..
· ·what prime rate must the ccimj'.lany c~ange its _terms of <;redit in o:dat
lo avoid an undesirable extension in 1ts-eollect1on of receivables? er
a, 2°/o ;
I .c, 7%
b. 5% ~ . .. ·d. - ·8%
- .
Whic~ one o_f ~e following ·woU Id· not be considered a carrying cost
11.
associated with mventory? . ·
a. Insurance costs. ·
b. . Co~t of capital irlvested in ·the inventory .. . ·
c: · · Cost of obsolescence. · , · ·· . ·
d. Shipping costs:· .· ··. ·, .. ·
, \ . ' I • - I
b. · Quantity discounts·lost. ··
c. Handli~g costs. -
d. Spoilage. , ·
. ''
\
• I
I I
I• • '.