State of Indian Healthcare Indian Cities Through The Lens of Healthcare 2 EToaEJd
State of Indian Healthcare Indian Cities Through The Lens of Healthcare 2 EToaEJd
• Pune 19
• Ahmedabad 20
• Bengaluru 21
• Mumbai 22
• Hyderabad 23
• Chennai 24
• Kolkata 25
• Delhi NCR 26
Healthcare – the linchpin
of economic growth
Health is not only the absence of illness but also Considering the substantial role of health in
one’s ability to develop one’s physical, mental and economic growth and an individual’s development,
emotional potential during their entire lives. It is an an entire ecosystem including healthcare providers,
asset which an individual possesses that has both pharmaceuticals, medical finance services, care
intrinsic and instrumental value. Instrumental in the management, and many more have developed with
sense that the health of people influences the partaking of governments and international
economic growth in varied ways. For example, the agencies such as WHO and private players.
workers' ill-health directly affects productivity, by
increasing absenteeism rates and the economic
burden of the illnesses. It was found in the United
Housing -a mainstay of
Kingdom (UK) that close to 131 million working a healthy population
days were lost to sickness absence every year. 1
While a World Health Organisation (WHO) study Over the years, the global economic landscape has
observed that loss of productivity due to mental undergone profound changes. Industrialisation and
health problems costs the global economy USD 1 urbanisation have changed the way we live by
trillion each year. The most recent example of a heavily altering the degree of access to resources,
health crisis affecting countries’ economies is the varying as per countries and regions. While health
on-going COVID-19 pandemic, that has brought the status is dependent on many factors such as the
world economies to a screeching halt. access to resources, healthcare, health
In 2020, economies across the globe experienced infrastructure, affordability, and socioeconomic and
severe headwinds due to the COVID-19 pandemic, environmental conditions, housing is at the centre
more than 3.1 million deaths till date. During this As also recognised by WHO3, housing is one of the
exceptional year, the pandemic made us realise the mainstays of a healthy population. Its quality,
importance of health infrastructure and its location and environmental context are critical in
ramifications on the economy and the society. reducing health risks and improving access to the
While the countries around the globe are trying to healthcare facilities. Not only has the on-going
flatten the curve, India has been hit by the second global health crisis strongly reinforced the
wave of this black swan pandemic, overwhelming importance of access to healthcare, the ensuing
its health infrastructure and economy. lockdowns to control the virus spread restricted
people to stay at home, demonstrating the deep
1
Health matters: health and work, Government of the United Kingdom, 2019
General Health Care, WHO
2
01
connection between health and housing. The The everchanging demographics and altering needs
lockdown, lack of access to quality living conditions for the services, the comparative trends of major
and healthcare facilities, have further exacerbated world economies show that countries face different
the impact of the pandemic. set of challenges in delivery of equitable,
affordable, and quality healthcare services
depending up on the level of economic
As the world will look to rebuild and recover development. The growing population is altering
from the COVID-19 pandemic, healthcare and the demand for services everywhere and is
its underpinning services have and will take constantly putting pressure on the social and
centre-stage in the future narratives of physical infrastructure in any region. Nearly 68
economic growth across the globe. percent (6.7 billion) of the world population
is projected to live in urban areas by 2050.4
Maximise healthy
life years
HEALTH ECONOMIC
DRIVES GROWTH
4
United Nations
02
Global picture
Healthcare across the globe is highly dependent on Developing countries such as Brazil, China, and
the demography and socio-economic development India face their own set of challenges, including
which leads to varying degrees of success inequitable access to healthcare, lower public
in delivery and experience. The differences healthcare spending, and inadequate infrastructure.
in healthcare experience offered by countries For instance, compared to developed countries,
are reflected in the parameters such as India and China spent a mere 3.5 percent and 5.4
health expenditure, number of hospital beds and percent, respectively, of their Gross Domestic
doctors, life expectancy, and mortality rates. Product (GDP) on healthcare. It is to be noted that
this expenditure includes both public expenditure
Developed countries such as the United States, the
and out-of-pocket expenses on healthcare.
UK, Japan, Germany, and Canada expend nearly
10–18 percent of their Gross Domestic Product The gaps in the delivery of healthcare through
(GDP) on healthcare. Some of the key drivers public sources manifest themselves in the
behind higher spending on healthcare in developed high out-of-pocket expenses (OOPE). Such
economies include the ageing population, rising expenses range between 45–70 percent in
incomes and innovative technologies.5 The countries such as Brazil, China and India,
widened access to quality healthcare and compared to 15–30 percent spent in other major
improving lifestyles have led to higher life developed economies from the total expenditure
expectancy in these major economies. on health.
5
Health Care Spending Issues In Advanced Economies, International Monetary Fund
03
India sits at the bottom - lowest spending on
healthcare
India spends the least on its healthcare and has the lowest number of beds (public hospitals)
per 1,000 population (0.5). This means that only half a bed is available for 1,000 people in a
public hospital in India.
10 2.5 2.8
Sr. No Country Total health GDP Estimated Mortality rate Ageing Life expectancy
expenditure in (USD Population (per 1,000 population% — age in years
GDP (% of GDP) trillion) (in millions) people) above 65 years (2015—2020)
2018 2018 2019 2019 (2019)
After the inclusion of private hospitals, the India has the lowest number of doctors (0.9
estimated total number of hospital beds (1.4) per per 1,000 population) compared to other
1,000 population still does not meet the major economies where the doctor to
benchmarks set by the major economies. Similarly, population ratio ranges between 2–4 doctors
with only 0.86 doctors per 1,000 people, India has per 1,000 population.
the lowest number of healthcare providers
compared to other major economies where the
As a country which is home to nearly 18 percent (1.3
doctor to population ratio ranges between 2–4
billion) of the world ’s population, Ind ia faces a
doctors for every 1,000 people. Despite being on
massive challenge in build ing its healthcare
the lower end in terms of important indicators, India
infrastructure and has to take long strid es in
has the lowest mortality rate, concurring with the
red ucing the d ichotomy of curative versus
fact that it has the lowest percentage of ageing
preventive and urban versus rural, in the delivery of
population (above 65 years) among the top
healthcare services.
economies.
1.0
0.9
0.9
0.9
0.2
0.9
0.9
11.0%
10.0%
11.4%
11.3%
0.7
0.7
10.8%
0.6
9.5%
8.7%
5.4%
3.5%
India
China
Italy
Brazil
UK
Canada
Japan
France
Germany
US
India
China
Brazil
Italy
Japan
Canada
France
US
UK
Germany
Number of doctors per 1,000 population Number of beds per 1,000 population **
13.0
4.3
4.0
3.3
2.8
2.8
8.0
2.6
2.5
2.2
2.0
5.9
4.3
3.1
2.9
0.9
2.6
2.5
2.1
0.5
India
Brazil
UK
Canada
US
Italy
China
France
Germany
Japan
India
China
Brazil
Japan
US
Canada
UK
France
Italy
Germany
6
Human Development Index is an index developed by the United Nations which measures the achievement in three basic dimensions of human development—a long
and healthy life, knowledge and a decent standard of living incorporating the parameters like life expectancy, education, and purchase power parity, indicating the
gaps in current social and physical infrastructure.
05
The daunting India story
Inception
The foundation of India’s public healthcare system The economic liberalisation, which began in 1991,
is based on the recommend ations of the ‘Health further gave a fillip to the private players providing
Survey and Development Committee’, also known quality healthcare services in India, driving focus
as ‘Bhore Committee’ from 1946. As specified in the away from public services. Moreover, the public
report, the public healthcare service in Ind ia is expenditure on healthcare has been in the doldrums
tiered -based – primary, second ary, and tertiary, until recent years. Its share from total GDP, which
d ivid ed as per population and the list of services was 1.0 percent in 2015, has reached 1.6 percent in
become more comprehensive as per hierarchy. Over 2019, showing a mere increase of 0.6 percent in the
the years, large hospital systems both public and last four years, leading to no significant
private providing curative care have come up in the improvement in outcomes such as the number of
bigger cities, vis-à-vis preventive services provided beds, mortality rates or life expectancy. It is to be
in the rural areas through d isease control noted that the total expenditure on healthcare
programmes. in India including OOPE was 3.5 percent in 2018,
which is significantly low than major economies
None of the larger states today have reached
like the US, the UK and France, among others.
the global average of 3.2 beds per 1,000
population or even the 2 beds per 1,000
population standard in public healthcare
delivery, as mentioned in the National Health
Policy (2017).
Source: Ministry of Health and Family Welfare, Census of India, National Health Profile (2019), World Bank, Housing Research
Note: Excludes out-of-pocket expenditure 06
Glaring paucity of hospital beds in India
INDIA
Public Hospitals
0.5 3.5
SHORTFALL
MN
HOSPITAL BEDS PER HOSPITAL BEDS
1,000 POPULATION
1.4 2.4
SHORTFALL
MN
HOSPITAL BEDS PER HOSPITAL BEDS
1,000 POPULATION
Source: Key Indicators of Social Consumption in India: Health, NSS Round 75th, National Health Profile 2019, Population Projection for India and States – Census of India, 2019,
Housing Research
*Average calculated based on data of hospital beds available for 173 countries in the World Bank database. Refer to Annexure 2 for list of countries.
07
Karnataka has maximum number of
hospital beds; Bihar the least
Karnataka,
Telangana,
Kerala
Have maximum number of
hospital beds (public+private)
Bihar,
Odisha,
Chhattisgarh
Have the least number of
hospital beds (public+private)
Source: Key Indicators of Social Consumption in India: Health, NSS Round 75th, National Health Profile 2019, Population Projection for India and States – Census of India, 2019,
Housing Research
08
Private dominance Centre versus state
The reckoning of available public hospital bed s Constitutionally, the central government oversees
suggests that Ind ia is still far from the global d efining of the healthcare policies, provid ing
average7 of 3.2 bed s per 1,000 population, falling financial resources and med ical ed ucation in the
short of nearly 3.5 million bed s. Although well country, the states are responsible for the delivery
below the average, the shortfall red uces to 2.4 of these services to the people through various
million with inclusion of private bed s, highlighting channels. This decentralisation has its pros and cons
the overarching presence of private healthcare and d oes cause incongruity in the quality and
services in India. coverage of healthcare services amongst the states.
The prevalence of private healthcare in provid ing For instance, larger states such as Karnataka,
quality services is congruent with the high share of Telangana and Kerala had the maximum number of
out-of-pocket expend iture. As per the National public and private bed s per 1,000 population in
Health Profile (NHP) 2018, Ind ia is among the 2019. However, the NITI Aayog’s Health Index (2019)
countries with the least public health spending and which takes into account the quality and delivery of
high out-of-pocket expend iture (OOPE). Also, the services, as well as the health outcomes, had the
health financing profile (2017) by WHO shows states of Kerala, Andhra Pradesh, and Maharashtra
nearly 67 percent of total expenditure on health in ranked on top, thus emphasising the importance of
Ind ia was paid out of pocket, while the world both quality and reach of healthcare services.
average is just 18.2 percent. The flow of resources
and services in case of public healthcare is also
responsible for wid ening gaps and inequitable
access to healthcare services.
Source: Key Indicators of Social Consumption in India: Health, NSS Round 75th, National Health Profile 2019, Housing Research
World Bank (refer Annexure 2 for list of countries considered for estimating the global average)
7
Source: Ministry of health and family welfare, Census of India, National Health Profile (2019), World Bank 09
Only half a bed is available for every
1,000 people in public hospitals
State-wise number of public beds per 1,000 population (2019)
0.5 INDIA
0.6
0.4
1.7
0.8
0.5 Public hospital
beds per 1,000
population
1.2
1.6
2.3
0.6 0.3 0.5 0.9
0.1 1.4
0.5
0.3
0.4
0.4
0.6
Highest*
Himachal Pradesh: 1.7
2.0
Kerala: 1.1
1.1 0.4
Karnataka: 1.1
Lowest*
Bihar: 0.1
1.0 Jharkhand: 0.3
1.1 Gujarat: 0.3
Source: Key Indicators of Social Consumption in India: Health, NSS Round 75th, National Health Profile 2019, Population Projection for India
and States – Census of India, 2019, Housing Research
*Only states with population more than 50 lakhs are considered for assessing the highest and lowest ranks.
10
Even with the addition of private hospital
beds, India remains in deficit
State-wise number of public + private hospital beds per 1,000 population (2019)
INDIA
1.4
0.7
Public + private
2.3 hospital beds per
1,000 population
2.0
2.7
1.4
2.0
1.7
3.3
1.2 1.3 0.8 1.5
0.3 2.4
0.6
0.7
0.7
2.2
2.9
Highest*
Karnataka: 5.3
2.9
Telengana: 2.9
5.3 1.5
Kerala: 2.9
Lowest*
Bihar: 0.3
2.1 Odisha: 0.7
2.9 Chattisgarh: 0.7
Source: Key Indicators of Social Consumption in India: Health, NSS Round 75th, National Health Profile 2019, Population Projection for
India and States – Census of India, 2019, Housing Research
*Only states with population more than 50 lakhs are considered for assessing the highest and lowest ranks.
11
Healthcare only an urban privilege
State-wise share of public + private hospital beds in urban area from total beds (2019)
INDIA
69%
86%
of total hospital
beds in India are
56% concentrated in
urban areas
68%
74%
55%
100% 11%
85%
74% 53% 48% 76%
57% 73%
53%
50% 58%
58% 69% 79% 75%
58%
72%
82%
71%
Highest*
Maharashtra: 82%
63% Karnataka: 81%
81% 68%
West Bengal: 79%
Lowest*
Assam: 48%
56% Jharkhand: 50%
58% Uttar Pradesh: 53%
Source: Key Indicators of Social Consumption in India: Health, NSS Round 75th, National Health Profile 2019, Population Projection for
India and States – Census of India, 2019, Housing Research
*Only states with population more than 50 lakhs are considered for assessing the highest and lowest ranks.
12
Karnataka, Telangana and Kerala have the glaring gaps are openly highlighted in the
maximum number of beds per 1,000 current dire times, with India having the second
population (of public and private hospitals), highest COVID-19 caseload in the world. In the
but in terms of quality, delivery of services and face of this adversity and ensuing large-scale
health outcomes, Kerala, Andhra Pradesh, and vaccination drive, the estimated budget outlay in
Maharashtra top the NITI Aayog’s National
FY 2021 for health and well-being has been
Health Index (2019).
increased 137 percent compared to previous
year — INR 94,452 crore (USD 1.2 billion) to INR
None of the larger states today have even reached
the 2 bed per 1,000 population standards in public 2,23,846 crore (USD 3 billion).
8
Population Projection for India and States – Census of India, 2019
13
Pune outranks other cities on health
parameters; Delhi NCR sits at the bottom
1 st
PUNE
8 th
DELHI NCR
ranks the lowest, as inadequate number
of hospital bed s, poor air quality and low
score on the livability ind ex pulls d own the
city’s ranking.
14
Water scarcity looms large for Chennai;
inadequate hospital beds concerns Mumbai
4th
Rank Mumbai number of hospital beds, air quality and livability index
pull down the financial capital’s ranking
6th POOR
Rank Chennai
MODERATE
topped in air quality, looming water scarcity pulls VERY POOR
15
Indian cities
through the lens of healthcare
Cities are the engines of growth for any country. Abuzz with However, buckling under the pressure of growing
economic activity, urban populace, the cities tell a story of a population, the infrastructure in the major cities is constantly
country’s growth trajectory. In India, maximum being tested leading to increase in problems related to air
socio-economic activity is concentrated in the top eight cities quality, water supply, sanitation, waste management,
of Ahmedabad, Bengaluru, Chennai, Delhi NCR, Hyderabad, etc. affecting the quality of life and consequently the
Kolkata, Mumbai (MMR), and Pune. health of its citizens. Moreover, with the healthcare
scenario primarily dominated by private players, the OOPE in
As of 2020, 101 million lived in the top eight cities, these cities is also very high for the public.
which had an average density of 3,000 persons per
sq km, which meant only 4 sq ft space per person. We looked at our top eight cities through the lens
of healthcare to understand the livability in our metros that
As per the Census of India projections, as of 2020, it is are engines of economic growth for our country, not only
estimated that nearly a quarter of the total urban population for real estate but across sectors. Gauging the city from a
was concentrated in these top eight cities. With the healthcare perspective a ‘Housing.com City Health Card’ has
burgeoning office and commercial activity, the population in been prepared by benchmarking the top eight
these major urban areas is only expected to grow and in fact, cities against important parameters such as number of
cities such as New Delhi, Mumbai, Hyderabad, and Pune are hospital beds, air quality, water quality, sanitation,
among the top 50 cities expected to see maximum livability index, among others.
population growth till 2030.9 Although, it is to be noted that most of the private hospitals
In response to the growing population and gaps in public as well as tertiary public healthcare services are
services, many private hospitals, both small and big, have concentrated in these major urban centres. This pushes
proliferated these cities. Over time, the quality healthcare the average of number of beds significantly higher as
provided by private players has seen even the regional compared to the national average in these cities —
again
population being dependent on these services. Excellent highlighting the grave lopsided health infrastructure.
Oxford Economics
9
16
What is Housing.com’s Housing.com City
City Health Card? Health Card summary
Housing.com’s City Health Card is a comparative assessment As per Housing.com’s City Health Card, Pune is ranked on the
of the top eight cities of Ahmedabad, Bengaluru, Chennai, top amongst all the cities, scoring significantly high on
Delhi NCR, Hyderabad, Kolkata, Mumbai and Pune, parameters such as the number of beds, ease of living, water
considering several parameters such as the number of quality and also performance and sustainable initiatives taken
hospital beds, air quality, water quality, ease of living, by its local government. On the other hand, Delhi NCR, which
sanitation, waste management, performance and sustainable is an agglomeration of NCT of Delhi and the cities of
initiatives taken by the local government which influence Gurugram, Faridabad, Noida, Greater Noida and Ghaziabad,
the health scenario, and hence, the basic livability was ranked the lowest. The main reasons for Delhi NCR to
conditions of a city. be at the bottom of the list are deteriorating air quality,
especially during winters, water quality and inadequate
Each parameter is assigned a substantial weight depending
water supply. In fact, the cities of Ghaziabad, Noida, Greater
upon the criticality of the parameter. The final arrived scores
Noida and Delhi NCT were ranked amongst the top 10 most
are used to determine the rank of a city.
polluted cities in the world.10
Why is it important?
region, which is also the largest residential real estate market
in the country with a transactional value of USD 2.5 billion in
The need for the health card arises from limited or segregated the first quarter of 2021, was ranked fourth on
information on the important health parameters of a city that the Housing.com City Health Card. Parameters such
make it ideal for living and mirrors its socio-economic growth. as the number of beds, air quality, and livability pulled
Currently, there is a glaring disconnect between down the city’s overall score. Similarly, Bengaluru is ranked
the socio-economic growth and the basic livability third despite a high number of hospital beds per 1,000
parameters of our top cities. population and the top rank in ease of living index. The
city scored low on air quality, water quality, sanitation
and performance of the municipal body.
10
World Air Quality Report (2019), IQAir – technology partner of UNEP and United Nations
17
Housing.com City Health Card
Water
City No. of hospital Sanitation & Ease of Municipal
Air quality Sustainable
health City beds/1,000 solid waste Living Index Performance
quality and initiatives
rank population management (2020) Index (2020)
availability
1 Pune
2 Ahmedabad
3 Bengaluru
4 Mumbai
5 Hyderabad
6 Chennai
7 Kolkata
8 Delhi NCR
Low High
18
PUNE RANK 1 v Pune, a well-known IT and education hub of India, ranks the
highest on the City Health Card as it has the edge over other
Hospital beds v In response to the growing number of residents and global tech
(Public + Private)** companies, many leading private hospital services have come up
(2020) in Pune. Not only this, but the city is also becoming a hub for
No. of beds / health tech startups due to the presence of a talent pool from
3.5
1,000 population high-quality medical and engineering institutes.
State average 2.2 v Having said that, however, the city still struggles with public
healthcare delivery, as is highlighted by the fact that Pune is one of
Total beds 18,000–20,000
the cities with high COVID-19 caseload.
Unsold inventory***
v
Currently, the city’s healthcare facilities are concentrated in
(2020) central areas and eastern areas. Although, the northern regions,
such as the IT hub of Hinjewadi and Ravet, see significant
1,31,870 residential traction, very few hospitals are located here.
Source: Housing Research (Refer Annexure 1 for methodology)
*Metropolitan area
**The additional bed infrastructure currently being augmented on a daily basis for COVID-19 have not been considered.
***Unsold inventory for apartment and villas available as of December 2020
RAVET
PIMPRI -CHINCHWAD
PUNE CENTRAL
HINJEWADI
KHARADI
LEGEND HADAPSAR
Unsold inventory
(Size of circle represents the number of units)
Total beds 21,000–23,000 Naroda and Vatva, which are also prominent residential
hubs.
Unsold inventory***
(2020)
38,610
Source: Housing Research (Refer Annexure 1 for methodology)
*Includes area under Ahmedabad Urban Development Authority and Gandhinagar Development Authority
**The additional bed infrastructure currently being augmented on a daily basis for COVID-19 have not been considered.
***Unsold inventory for apartment and villas available as of December 2020
Low density of hospitals in the prominent localities of north and south Ahmedabad
GANDHINAGAR
CHANDKHEDA
NAVA NARODA
SG HIGHWAY
BOPAL
LEGEND
CENTRAL AHMEDABAD
Unsold inventory
(Size of circle represents the number of units)
VATVA
SHELA
Hospital > 100 beds
Population aligning with the overall scenario of the state of Karnataka having
the maximum number of beds vis-à-vis the state’s population.
2020 9.5 million
• Over the years, the city has attracted a large-scale white collar
2030E 10.2 million
migrant population with high spending propensity, leading to
many prominent private healthcare providers setting up hospitals
Area (sq km)* with world-class services. The city has also developed into a
• Although the city has recently topped the charts in the Ease of
Hospital beds Living Index (2020), the burgeoning population, over the years,
(Public + Private)** has led to significant pressure on the water supply, environment,
(2020) and transport infrastructure of the city.
No. of beds / 3.6 • Currently, healthcare facilities are concentrated in the central and
1,000 population key IT hubs of western localities, with very few healthcare facilities
in the north and south regions. Contrary to this, most of the
State average 5.3
residential stock is available in the northern and southern micro
Total beds 33,000–35,000 markets.
Unsold inventory***
(2020)
71,200
Source: Housing Research (Refer Annexure 1 for methodology)
*Metropolitan area
**The additional bed infrastructure currently being augmented on a daily basis for COVID-19 have not been considered.
***Unsold inventory for apartment and villas available as of December 2020
Healthcare services sparse in the prominent housing clusters in north and south Bengaluru
BENGALURU NORTH
BENGALURU CENTRAL
WHITEFIELD
VARTHUR
LEGEND
Unsold inventory BENGALURU SOUTH
(Size of circle represents the number of units)
Unsold inventory***
(2020)
2,63,990
MIRA BHAYANDAR
MUMBAI
NAVI MUMBAI
LEGEND
Unsold inventory
(Size of circle represents the number of units)
• Hyderabad is ranked sixth in the City Health Card and the 24th
best city to live in among 111 cities from the country, as per the
State average 2.9 • In terms of healthcare, most of the city's health infrastructure
follows the residential footprints, with prominent services
Total beds 24,000 – 26,000
concentrated in the western and central suburbs.
• Although the city fares better than other metros in terms of air
Unsold inventory***
(2020) quality, sanitation and waste management, however, the rapid
influx of population has added stress over the water supply, with
39,300 demand exceeding the supply leading to water shortage.
BACHUPALLY
SECUNDARABAD
HYDERABAD CENTRAL
KOKAPET
LEGEND HYDERABAD
WEST
Unsold inventory
(Size of circle represents the number of units)
Population parameters placed the city in the sixth spot, due to poor
sanitation, solid waste management and water supply.
2020 9.6 million
2030E 10.4 million • The city, albeit only once, had reached ‘Day Zero’ – a state where
no water is left in the main reservoirs, in 2019, and is still suffering
from acute water shortage.
Area (sq km)*
• However, it is to be noted that Chennai currently has nearly three
1189 beds per 1,000 people, well above the national average of 1.4
beds.
Hospital beds • Over the years, Chennai has seen significant growth in the
(Public + Private)** automobile and service sector, especially IT, amassing the
(2020) working population from all over the country.
No. of beds / 3.0
• It is also base for many prominent healthcare service providers
1,000 population
and coupled with international connectivity; the city has become
State average 2.1 a desired place for medical tourism.
Total beds 28,000–30,000 • Currently, most of the hospitals are located in the eastern suburbs.
However, southern and western suburbs with dynamic IT,
Unsold inventory*** commercial and residential activity still fall short when it comes to
(2020) multispecialty and super specialty healthcare services.
36,610
Source: Housing Research (Refer Annexure 1 for methodology)
*Metropolitan area
**The additional bed infrastructure currently being augmented on a daily basis for COVID-19 have not been considered.
***Unsold inventory for apartment and villas available as of December 2020
Low concentration of healthcare facilities in prominent residential localities of OMR and GST
CHENNAI NORTH
CHENNAI
WEST
CHENNAI CENTRAL
GST
Unsold inventory***
(2020)
30,210
Source: Housing Research (Refer Annexure 1 for methodology)
*Metropolitan area
**The additional bed infrastructure currently being augmented on a daily basis for COVID-19 have not been considered.
***Unsold inventory for apartment and villas available as of December 2020
Healthcare services are mainly located in the central, eastern and southern suburbs in Kolkata
BARRACKPORE
HOWRAH
RAJARHAT
Unsold inventory
(Size of circle represents the number of units)
BEHALA
Hospital > 100 beds
JOKA
Population the All India Institute of Medical Sciences (AIIMS). It is also a major
hub of medical tourism due to leading super specialty and
2020 24.3 million multispecialty private hospitals.
2030E 26.3 million
• However, Delhi (NCT & NCR) is ranked the lowest among the top
eight cities of India as per our City Health Card due to factors such
Area (sq km)* as deteriorating air quality, water supply, and poor solid waste
No. of beds / • Even in Gurugram, Faridabad and Noida, the healthcare services
2.0
1,000 population mainly belong to the private sector, as public healthcare remains
1.5 a straggler.
State average
• In terms of residential market, all the cities of Delhi NCR,
Total beds 48,000–50,000
except Faridabad, hold almost equivalent volume of units.
Unsold inventory***
(2020)
1,06,690
Source: Housing Research (Refer Annexure 1 for methodology)
*Area includes Delhi NCT, Noida, Greater Noida, Ghaziabad, Gurugram and Faridabad
**The additional bed infrastructure currently being augmented on a daily basis for COVID-19 have not been considered.
State average includes average bed density for Delhi NCT, Uttar Pradesh and Haryana
***Unsold inventory for apartment and villas available as of December 2020
Note: NCR includes Noida, Greater Noida, Ghaziabad, Gurugram and Faridabad
GHAZIABAD
DELHI
NOIDA
LEGEND
FARIDABAD
Unsold inventory
(Size of circle represents the number of units)
LARGER HOMES
Work-from-home altering the homebuyer’s preference
TOWNSHIPS ONLINE
SENIOR LIVING
TIE-UPs HOMETOWNS
between RWAs, hospitals and remote working to make smaller cities
pharmacies more attractive
OFFICE
HYBRID FLEXIBLE
MODEL Spaces to offtake over traditional formats
DOWNWARD
RETHINKING
DESIGN HEALTH of employees to
more focus on design of office spaces & SAFETY be paramount
to accommodate standards and norms
27
Trends in real estate in post-
pandemic future
RETAIL
OMNI-CHANNEL
Retailers to shift to hybrid format of online and brick-and-mortar stores
FOCUS on
DIGITAL ‘SAFE’ RETAILING
safety considerations to motivate home-bound
EXPERIENCE consumers
RELOOK at
PRODUCT MIX
MALLS
to become
EXPERIENTIAL
CONTACTLESS
TRANSACTIONS
WAREHOUSING
E-COMMERCE PUSH
Robust development to meet sudden rise in e-commerce
AUTOMATION
to reduce human dependency
DECENTRALISE
to enhance last-mile connectivity
INCREASE EXPAND
CAPACITY
to keep up with the
FOOTPRINT
to SMALLER CITIES to meet the demand
increasing demand
28
Key takeaways
Global benchmarks Struggling cities
� Advanced countries such as the United States, the UK, Japan, � 101 million people lived in the top eight cities in 2020, which had
Germany, and Canada spent nearly 10–18 percent of their GDP an average density of 3,000 persons per sq km, which meant
on healthcare in 2019. only 4 sq ft space per person.
� In comparison, developing countries such as India and China � The concentration of private hospitals and tertiary public
expended only 3.5 percent and 5.4 percent, respectively, from the healthcare centres in major urban areas has pushed its
total GDP on healthcare. This includes both the public hospital bed tally higher than the national average.
and out-of-pocket expenditure.
� In urban areas, 65 percent of the total hospitalisation cases
� The gaps in health infrastructure have manifested into high OOPE belong to private hospitals, thus creating significant pressure
in developed countries, such as Brazil, India and China, as on the healthcare infrastructure.
expenses ranged between 45–70 percent in these countries
compared to 15–30 percent spent in other major economies.
v The global average density of hospital beds is 3.2 beds per 1,000
people.
Housing.com City Health Card results
Daunting India story • Pune ranks the highest on the City Health Card, with the city
scoring high on parameters such as the number of beds, ease of
� On average, India has spent only 1.3 percent of its total GDP on living index, water quality, and performance and sustainable
public healthcare between 2014 to 2019. Even after including initiatives taken by its local government.
OOPE, the total expenditure, which was 3.5 percent in 2018, still • Delhi NCR ranks the lowest due to deteriorating air quality,
stands at the lowest end as compared to other major economies. especially during winters, water quality and inadequate water
• The National Health Policy (2017) recommends a standard of 2 supply.
beds per 1,000 population for public health services. • Mumbai, India’s financial capital and the largest residential
• India has an abysmally low 0.5 public hospital beds per 1,000 market, was ranked fourth with parameters such as the number of
population and mere 1.4 beds, including public and private beds, air quality, and livability pulling down the city’s score.
hospital beds per 1,000 persons. • Although Bengaluru was ranked the highest in the Ease of Living
Index (2020) and has a high number of hospital beds, the city
• The healthcare services in India face a shortfall of 3.5 million
secured the third rank due to low air quality, water quality,
hospital beds in terms of public hospitals. The shortfall is reduced
sanitation, and poor performance of the municipal body.
to 2.4 million beds with the inclusion of private hospitals.
• Ahmedabad secured second place in the City Health Card and
• The southern states of Karnataka, Telangana and Kerala have the
had significantly higher scores for the number of hospital beds,
maximum number of beds per 1,000 population (of public and
sanitation, ease of living and sustainable initiatives.
private hospitals).
• Hyderabad, which has a low number of hospital beds, was ranked
• On the other hand, states such as Bihar, Odisha, Chhattisgarh and fifth, although the city fared well in air quality, sanitation and solid
Jharkhand lag behind and rank the lowest in hospital beds. waste management.
• Whereas in terms of quality, delivery of services and health • Ranked sixth, Chennai scored lower due to poor quality of water
outcomes, Kerala, Andhra Pradesh, and Maharashtra top the NITI and inadequate water supply, as well as poor sanitation and solid
Aayog’s National Health Index (2019). waste management.
29
Annexure 1
City Health Card methodology
• The cities have been ranked among themselves as per • Water quality has been assessed by scoring cities as per
weighted scores for parameters like the number of beds weighted average as per the Bureau of Indian Standards
(public + private) / 1,000 population, air quality, water rankings (2019) and Water Stress Index (2019) by Versik
quality, sanitation and waste management, ease of living Maplecroft.
rank, municipal performance indicator and sustainable • Sanitation and waste management has been assessed as
initiatives. per the Swacch Sarvekshan Ranking of 2019.
• Hospitals with more than 100 beds have been considered. • The sustainable initiatives have been ranked as per point
The data available for each hospital has been taken from system for each initiative, which includes healthcare
government sources and/or official hospital websites. It has expenditure as per city budgets, open green space, waste
been assumed that 80 percent of data is covered for cities management and inclusive transport.
with the list of hospitals available for public/private
• Weights have been considered for calculating the final
hospitals through government sources. In case of cities
rank for individual cities for the City Health Card.
where data was tabulated from municipal websites,
medical tourism websit, official hospital websites • The population for each city has been projected as per the
and others relevant sources, it has been assumed Census of India (2011).
that 60 percent data is covered. It is to be noted that, the
additional bed infrastructure currently being augmented
on a daily basis for COVID-19 have not been considered.
30
Annexure 2
List of countries considered for estimating global
average for number of beds per 1,000 people
1 Afghanistan 44 Dominica 87 Korea, South 130 Russia
2 Albania 45 Dominican Republic 88 Kuwait 131 Saint Kitts and Nevis
3 Algeria 46 Ecuador 89 Kyrgyzstan 132 Saint Lucia
4 Andorra 47 Egypt 90 Laos 133 Saint Vincent and the Grenadines
5 Antigua and Barbuda 48 El Salvador 91 Latvia 134 San Marino
6 Argentina 49 Equatorial Guinea 92 Lebanon 135 Sao Tome and Principe
7 Armenia 50 Eritrea 93 Liberia 136 Saudi Arabia
8 Australia 51 Estonia 94 Libya 137 Senegal
9 Austria 52 Ethiopia 95 Lithuania 138 Serbia
10 Azerbaijan 53 Fiji 96 Luxembourg 139 Seychelles
11 Bahamas, The 54 Finland 97 Macedonia 140 Singapore
12 Bahrain 55 France 98 Madagascar 141 Slovakia
13 Bangladesh 56 Gabon 99 Malawi 142 Slovenia
14 Barbados 57 Gambia, The 100 Malaysia 143 Solomon Islands
15 Belarus 58 Georgia 101 Mali 144 Somalia
16 Belgium 59 Germany 102 Malta 145 South Africa
17 Belize 60 Ghana 103 Mauritius 146 Spain
18 Benin 61 Greece 104 Mexico 147 Sri Lanka
19 Bhutan 62 Greenland 105 Moldova 148 Sudan
20 Bolivia 63 Grenada 106 Monaco 149 Suriname
21 Bosnia and Herzegovina 64 Guatemala 107 Mongolia 150 Swaziland
22 Botswana 65 Guinea 108 Montenegro 151 Sweden
23 Brazil 66 Guinea-Bissau 109 Morocco 152 Switzerland
24 Brunei 67 Guyana 110 Mozambique 153 Syria
25 Bulgaria 68 Haiti 111 Namibia 154 Tajikistan
26 Burkina Faso 69 Honduras 112 Nauru 155 Tanzania
27 Burma 70 Hong Kong 113 Nepal 156 Thailand
28 Burundi 71 Hungary 114 Netherlands 157 Togo
29 Cambodia 72 Iceland 115 New Zealand 158 Tonga
30 Cameroon 73 India 116 Nicaragua 159 Trinidad and Tobago
31 Canada 74 Indonesia 117 Niger 160 Tunisia
32 Cape Verde 75 Iran 118 Norway 161 Turkey
33 Central African Republic 76 Iraq 119 Oman 162 Turkmenistan
34 Chile 77 Ireland 120 Pakistan 163 Uganda
35 China 78 Israel 121 Palau 164 Ukraine
36 Colombia 79 Italy 122 Panama 165 United Arab Emirates
37 Comoros 80 Jamaica 123 Paraguay 166 United Kingdom
38 Costa Rica 81 Japan 124 Peru 167 Uruguay
39 Croatia 82 Jordan 125 Philippines 168 Uzbekistan
40 Cuba 83 Kazakhstan 126 Poland 169 Venezuela
41 Czech Republic 84 Kenya 127 Portugal 170 Vietnam
42 Denmark 85 Kiribati 128 Qatar 171 Yemen
43 Djibouti 86 Korea, North 129 Romania 172 Zambia
173 Zimbabwe
31
HOUSING RESEARCH
Housing Research is part of Housing.com which is owned by Singapore-based Elara Technologies, which also owns Makaan.com
and PropTiger.com. The Group advises clients ranging from individual owners and buyers to major developers. Backed by strong
research and analytics, our experts provide comprehensive real estate services that cover advertising, marketing, mandating business
solutions for real estate stakeholders, negotiations, home loans, consulting and post-sales service. Headquartered in Gurugram, Haryana,
we have 14 offices across India. For further details about the Company, please visit www.housing.com.
Important Notice: This report is published for general information only and not to be relied upon in any way.
Download our reports and presentations
Although high standards have been used in the preparation of the information, analysis, views and projections
at housing.com/research-reports
presented in this report, no responsibility or liability whatsoever can be accepted by Housing.com for any loss or
OR damage resultant from any use of, reliance on or reference to the contents of this document. As a general report, this
For more insights and trends reach material does not necessarily represent the views of Housing.com in relation to particular properties or projects.
out to [email protected] Reproduction of this report in whole or in part is not allowed without prior written approval of Housing.com
to the form and content within which it appears.
Head office: Echelon Square, Plot No-25, Sector - 32, Gurugram-122001 (Haryana) India 0124-4866700
FOLLOW US ON