ECT Classical Methods
ECT Classical Methods
net/publication/360777599
CITATIONS READS
0 147
1 author:
Rupesh Gautam
Khwopa College of Engineering
10 PUBLICATIONS 0 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Rupesh Gautam on 22 May 2022.
-Rupesh Gautam
Khwopa College of Engineering
1 Introduction
Classical method means, solving the electric circuits containing R, L and C by using
differential equations. The general types of differential equation are studied here.
In general the required differential equations for transient analysis are of three types.
They can be listed as:
The first order differential equation can be written as shown in equation 1.1.
dV (t)
+ p V (t) = 0 (1.1)
dt
Where, p is any constant & V (t) is output response of voltage dependent on time t
in any circuit
This equation can be simplified as shown below:
dV (t)
= −p dt
V (t)
On integrating,
ln V (t) = −p t + ln K
2
Figure 1: RL series circuit
dIo
L + I0 R = 0 (1.3)
dt
Since, equation 1.3 is differential equation of first order homogeneous form so, R L
circuit can be considered as first order circuit. This equation can be further simplified
as:
dIo R
+ I0 = 0
dt L
R
On comparing the latest equation with equation 1.1, we can write p = , so the
L
general solution of equation 1.3 can be shown as in equation 1.4 (because the general
solution of equation 1.1 is shown in equation 1.2).
R
t− (1.4)
I0 = K e L
The equation 1.4 shows the nature of current of the first order R L circuit for dis-
charging case. The current nature shows that, it is decaying exponentially. The
graph of discharging current for R = 10 Ω and L = 10 mH is shown in figure 2.
In figure 2 the value of K was assumed to be 1 considering that the fully energized
inductor have 1 A current before discharging.
3
Figure 2: Transient response of RL circuit for discharging case
The nature of graph is similar to discharging case of R L series circuit for discharging
case. In figure 2 the maximum value can change below or above 1 A.
(Note: Same as R − L circuit, R − C circuit can also be considered as first order
circuit)
dV (t)
+ P V (t) = Q (1.5)
dt
Where, p is any constant, V (t) is output response of voltage dependent on time t in
any circuit and Q may be any constant or time dependent variable
Now let us multiply equation 1.5 by ep t , i.e.
dV (t)
eP t + eP t P V (t) = eP t Q
dt
d h i
or, V (t) eP t = Q eP t
dt
On integrating,
h i Z
V (t) e P t = Q eP t dt + K
4
Where, K is any constant determined using initial condition
Z
or, V (t) = K e −P t +e−P t Q eP t dt (1.6)
The equation 1.6 shows the general solution of first order non homogeneous equation.
Here, the constant after integration of Q eP t dt is already accounted in K, so
R
addition of extra constant is not needed. Basically we can demonstrate the first
order non-homogeneous equation in electric circuit in two ways.
5
V
R R R
− t − t t
or, i(t) = K e L + e L e L L
R
L
So, the general solution (i.e. response of current in the circuit) can be written
as shown in equation 1.8.
R
− t V
i(t) = K e L + (1.8)
R
Figure 4 clearly shows that, the current through inductor rises exponentially.
This shows the transient behaviour of the R L series circuit.
6
Figure 5: Series R-L circuit with exponential excitation
di(t)
V (t) − L − i(t) R = 0 (1.9)
dt
di(t) R 1
+ i(t) = e−a t (1.10)
dt L L
R 1
Comparing equation 1.10 with equation 1.5, we get P = & Q = e−a t so,
L L
the general solution as taken reference form equation 1.6 is shown in equation
just below:
R R Z R
− t − t t 1 −at
i(t) = Ke L + e L eL e dt
L
on integrating:
R ! R R
− t 1 1 − t t
or, i(t) = Ke L + e L e L e−at
R
L L
−a
Simplified equation i.e. the general solution of current for given R − L series
circuit excited by exponential source is shown in equation 1.11
R
− t
1
i(t) = Ke L + e−at (1.11)
R − La
The transient
response for current of figure 5 wih R = 10 Ω, L = 10 mH, a = 5
1
and K = − is shown in figure 6
R − La
7
Figure 6: Transient response of RL series circuit with exponential excitation
(Note: The same thing can be studied for R − C circuit and for time dependent
sources, sinusoidal signal can be used to study.)
Second order differential equation can be categories into two categories, namely :
second order homogeneous and non homogeneous.
Am2 + Bm + C = 0
8
The general solution depends on roots of auxiliary equation.The solution of
A.E is shown in equation 1.13.
√
−B ± B2 − 4 × A × C
m1 m2 = (1.13)
2A
d2 V (t) dV (t)
+ A + B V (t) = Q(t) (1.20)
dt2 dt
9
Where Q(t) may be constant or any time dependent quantity
The general solution the this types of differential equation is represented in
equation 1.21
V (t) = VCF (t) + VP I (t) (1.21)
Where, VCF (t) is the complementary function and VP I (t) is the particular inte-
gral of the solution.
Complementary function implies transient behaviour of the circuit whereas par-
ticular integral gives the steady state nature of the circuit. The method of
determining CF and P I are listed below:
Method to determine CF
The complementary function of second order non homogeneous equation de-
pends on auxiliary equation of differential equation. The auxiliary equation of
equation 1.21 is shown in equation 1.22
m2 + A m + B = 0 (1.22)
10
Case III: Roots are complex conjugate
If roots are complex conjugate then the value of m1 , m2 can be represented as
shown in equation 1.27.
m1 , m2 = −α ± j β (1.27)
Method to determine P I
To determine P I of equation 1.20, the differential equation can be modified as
shown in equation 1.29.
f (D) V (t) = Q(t) (1.29)
d
Where, f (D) = (D2 + A D + C) and D =
dt
Then P I of differential equation 1.20 depends upon the types of excitation.
Some of the most commonly used excitation are listed below:
Case I: Calculation of PI if Q(t) = λ e±at
For exponential excitation λ e±at (Where, λ and a are any real constant), the
P I of differential equation shown in equation 1.20 can be represented as shown
in equation 1.30.
1 ±at
VP I (t) = λ e , f (a) ̸= 0 (1.30)
f (D)
D=a
If f (a) = 0 then in that case,
1
e±at , f ′ (a) ̸= 0
VP I (t) = t λ ′
f (D) D=a
Similarly, if f ′ (D) = 0 then,
1 ±at , f ′′ (a) ̸= 0
2
VP I (t) = t λ ′′ e
f (D)
D=a
And so on...
NOTE: This exponential case can be used to calculate P I of differential equa-
tion if Q(t) = constant(ϕ). This can be done by considering Q(t) = ϕ e0 t ,
considering ′ a′ as zero.
Case II: Calculation of PI if Q(t) = λ g(t) {Where, g(t) = sin at or, cos at}
11
For sinusoidal excitation λ g(t) (Where,g(t) = sin at or, cos at & λ and a are
any real constant), the P I of differential equation shown in equation 1.20 can
be represented as shown in equation 1.31.
1
VP I (t) = λ g(t) , f (a) ̸= 0 (1.31)
f (D) D2 = −a2
If f (a) = 0 then in that case,
1
, f ′ (a) ̸= 0
VP I (t) = t λ ′ g(t)
f (D) 2
D = −a 2
And so on...
12
Differentiating equation 1.32 with respect to ′ t′ we get equation 1.33,
This equation 1.33 is the second order homogeneous equation, so its general solution
is given by A.E. It’s A.E is shown in equation 1.34:
1
Lm2 + Rm + =0 (1.34)
C
The general solution of current shown in figure 7 can be determined by roots of A.E.
The roots of A.E are shown below:
p
R2 − 4 L/C
−R ±
m1 m2 =
2L
r
−R R 1
or, m1 m2 = ± ( )2 −
2L 2L LC
The nature of current response depends on the value of R, L&C. To demonstrate
three different types of response of current, we assume three cases.
di(0+ ) v
Now, using initial value of current {i(0+ ) = 0 and = }, the transient
dt L
response can be represented as shown in figure 8. This case is known as the
R 1
under damped oscillation (being is less than √ ).
2L LC
√
• Case II: Let R = 40 5 Ω, L = 10 mH ,C = 5 µF & V = 10 V
For this case, the calculated roots are approximately −4.472×103 , −4.472×103 ,
so the general solution of equation 1.33 can be represented as shown in equation
1.36.
i(t) = e−4472t [A + B t] (1.36)
di(0+ ) v
Similarly, using initial value of current {i(0+ ) = 0 and = }, the
dt L
transient response can be represented as shown in figure 9. This case is known
R 1
as the critically damped oscillation (being is equal to √ ).
2L LC
13
Figure 8: Response of current for under damped oscillation
14
equation 1.37.
i(t) = A e−2763t + Be−7236t (1.37)
di(0+ ) v
As in above cases, using initial value of current {i(0+ ) = 0 and = },
dt L
the transient response can be represented as shown in figure 10. This case is
R 1
known as the critically damped oscillation (being is greater than √ ).
2L LC
Let us consider the RLC series circuit excited by exponential source Keat , as shown
in figure 11. Using KVL in the circuit shown in figure 11, we get the equation 1.38.
The equation was determined by considering no any initial energies and charges in
inductor and capacitor respectively.
Z
di(t) 1
Keat − L − i(t)R − i(t)dt = 0 (1.38)
dt C
d2 i(t) di(t) 1
L 2
+R + i(t) = aKeat
dt dt C
d2 i(t) R di(t) 1 λ
2
+ + i(t) = eat (1.39)
dt L dt LC L
15
Figure 11: Series RLC circuit excited by exponential source
R 1
m2 + m+ =0 (1.41)
L LC
16
√
• Case II: Let R = 40 5 Ω, L = 10 mH & C = 5 µF
For this case, the calculated roots are approximately −4.472×103 , −4.472×103 ,
so the complementary function of equation 1.39 can be represented as shown
in equation 1.44.
iCF (t) = e−4472t [A + B t] (1.44)
R 1 λ λ
(D2 + D+ )i(t) = eat =⇒ f (D) × i(t) = eat (1.46)
L LC L L
Now, the general solution of differential equation 1.39 can be shown for three different
cases.
i(t) = e−1000t [A cos (4358.9 t) + B sin (4358.9 t)] + 0.003 e0.8t (1.48)
The graph for this case can be shown as shown in figure 12. To draw the
d K
response the initial values of current are taken as i(0+ ) = 0 and i(0+ ) = .
dt L
The response of current as shown in figure 12 has same nature like under
damped oscillation shown in figure 8, where the oscillation dies out after certain
time.
17
Figure 12: Response of RLC circuit excited by exponential source (Case-I)
√
• Case II: Let R = 40 5 Ω, L = 10 mH, C = 5 µF , k = 750 & a = 0.8
For this case, the general solution of differential equation 1.39 can be shown as
in equation 1.49.
The graph for this case can be shown as shown in figure 13. As in previous
case, to draw the response the initial values of current are taken as i(0+ ) = 0
d K
and i(0+ ) = .
dt L
18
The response of current as shown in figure 13 has same nature like critical
oscillation shown in figure 9.
The graph for this case can be shown as shown in figure 14. As above, to
draw the response the initial values of current are taken as i(0+ ) = 0 and
d + K
i(0 ) = .
dt L
The response of current as shown in figure 14 has same nature like over damped
oscillation shown in figure 10.
19